Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of...

35
Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop Spin Physics Workshop 24-28 June 2012, Gatchina, RUSSIA 1

Transcript of Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of...

Page 1: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

Dmitriy ToporkovDmitriy Toporkov

Budker Institute of Nuclear PhysicsBudker Institute of Nuclear Physics

Novosibirsk, RussiaNovosibirsk, Russia

Spin Physics Workshop Spin Physics Workshop 24-28 June 2012, Gatchina, RUSSIA

1

Page 2: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

2

• Introduction• Intensity limitation in ABS • Source of polarized molecules• High directivity capillary source of molecules• Separating magnet for molecules• Conclusion

CONTENTS

Page 3: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

3

M.Stancary et al.

Intensities achieved from different ABS

Page 4: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

4

0( ) ( 1)cos

2nQdI n

d

n )-1

= I0cosn

Ifoc.= I0 max2 T (1-Att )

atomic fraction

T – transmission factor1 – Att – attenuation due to residual gas scatteringmax

2 – maximum accepted solid angle

Beam intensity from ABS

Page 5: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

5

Factors limiting the intensity from ABS

• Increasing a size of the source of atoms with increasing throughput • Intra-beam scattering• Pressure bump in the ABS• Attenuation by the residual gas

Page 6: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

6

Intensity of the H2 molecular beam ( free beam )

T.Wise et al. NIMA 336(1993) 410

Page 7: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Possibility to obtain a polarized molecular hydrogen target

7

Shielding by the skimmer

Two effect which may to providesaturation of the intensity

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

7

Page 8: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Possibility to obtain a polarized molecular hydrogen target

8Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

8

Page 9: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Possibility to obtain a polarized molecular hydrogen target

9Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

9

Green – calculationBlack – flow 0.2mbar*l/secRed - flow 2mbar*l/sec

Page 10: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

10

v/vmax 0.25 vmax 2*105 cm/sec

1.5*10-14cm-2 this is from attenuation atomicbeam by 300K residual gas

For 20K beam temperature should be largerFor given cm*secImax = 1/(*X) ~ 5*1017 at/cm2

For parallel beam and v being the velocity spread

Intra-beam scattering

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

10Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

Page 11: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

11

Attenuation of the beam by residual gas - well understood process

I(p) = I0*exp( -x*p/p0 )

Relative velocitiesof particles correspond roomtemperature

Page 12: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

12

INJECTION OF BACKGROUND GAS AT DIFFERENT POSITION

ATTENUATION OF THE BEAM ISDEPENDENT FROM THE POSITIONOF THE GAS INJECTIOJN

NOT MANY EXPERIMENTAL DATAAVAILABLE

Page 13: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

13Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

13Possibility to increase intensity of

polarized hydrogen target

Page 14: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

14

Page 15: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

15

Magnetic properties of H2 molecule

Magnetic properties of D2 molecule

Total spin S = 2, 0 L = 0, 2 … even S = 1 L = 1, 3 … odd

Magnetic moment of molecule is dependent on S and L.Magnetic moment of o-D2 molecule for m = -2, F= 2 equals ~n , five time less than for o-H2 molecule

Orthohydrogen S = 1 L = 1, 3 … oddParahydrogen S = 0 L= 0, 2 … evenAt room temperature concentration ratio in normal hydrogen C o-H2 /Cp-H2 = 3:1

Magnetic moment of molecule is dependent on S and L.Magnetic moment of o-H2 molecule for m= -2, F= 2 equals 5n = 5*0.5*10-23 CGS=2.5*10-

3B

Page 16: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

16

Energy dependence of H2 and D2 molecule vs the magnetic field if 4 upper substates will be collected

Pz=0.5 and Pzz=0.25 is expected

if 3 upper substates will be collected Pz=1 is expected

Page 17: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

17

First (to my knowledge) spatial separation of o-H2 molecules in inhomogeneous magnetic field have been done by Frisch R. and Stern О. [F r i s c h R. und S t e r n О., Ztschr. f. Phys., 85, 4, 1933].

Magnetic separation of the beam of H2

mm

Cross sectionof the magnet system

Page 18: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

18

Diaphragm

Oven slit

Magnet

Beam receiver

Schematic view of the arrangement.

Page 19: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

19

|В|=В0*(r/rmag)N/

2-1

Focusing properties of multipole magnets

0 5 10 R(cm)

Page 20: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

20

Suggested source of polarized molecules

D=20 cm

Page 21: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

21

Molecular flow through the long tube

~ L >> d

Intensity in forward direction is the same as fromthe orifice, but total flow is less by a factor 3L/4d

For further estimation L/d = 100, d=0.1m

Page 22: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

22

Regular microporous membrane with pores of 0.3 m in diameter and 30 m thickness have a geometrical transperancy of about 70% could be fabricated by the method of deep X-ray lithography [G.N.Kulipanov et al. Nucl. Instr. And Meth. A359, 404(1995)]

Capillary ring array D = 20cm, width = 0.5cm

Page 23: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

23

The total area of the source is about 30 cm2. Assuming geometrical transparency of 50% this area should contain 2*1011capillaries. If we set a flux through a single capillary 1*1010mol/sec the density of the molecules before a capillary should be in the range of1*1018mol/cm3. Total flux of molecules 2*1021mol/sec

Page 24: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

24

Monte Carlo simulation of flow through the cylindrical channel

degree

L/d=100

Page 25: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

Radial density distribution at 100 cm distance from the capillary with d m

L/d=100

Page 26: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

26

Number of poletips – 32Magnetic poletip field 4 T

Page 27: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

27

Spatial distribution of molecules at the exit of the separating magnet from a single capillary

Page 28: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

28

Monte-Carlo simulation has shown that the fraction of molecules from a single capillary that reached an entrance aperture of the magnet and focused to its axis has a value of 2.3*10-3. The fraction of the focusing molecules in the flow is ¼ ( ¼ is p-H2molecules, ¼ is defocused and ¼ has a magnetic moment close to zero).Estimated fraction of the focusing molecules is about 0.6*10-3 of the total flux or 1*1018 mol/sec

Results of simulation

Page 29: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

29

Formation of the molecular beam with highest directivity

Realization of huge pumping system

Preservation of the nucleon polarization during the transportation of molecules

Key points

Page 30: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

30

We have some superconducting sextupole magnets installed in cryogenic Atomic Beam Source

Nearest plans

Page 31: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

31

Some spare magnets can be used to test the idea to focus hydrogen molecules

Nearest plans

Page 32: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

32

Pumping speed of cryosurface at given temperatureis different for hydrogen and deuterium gas

Attenuation of hydrogen beamsby the rest gas

Pressure, bar

Temperature, K

Page 33: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

33

A magnetically focused molecular beam of ortho-water

p.319

The 0.3 m long, 1 mm internal radius magnet achieves a polepiece tip field of 1.1 T using NdFeB permanent magnets and Permendur 49 polepieces.

T. Kravchuk et al.,

Page 34: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

34

Intensity measurement

Page 35: Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target Dmitriy Toporkov Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics Novosibirsk, Russia Spin Physics Workshop.

Dmitriy Toporkov, Gatchina, 24-28.06.2012

Possibility to increase intensity of polarized hydrogen target

35

Conclusion• Intensities of polarized beams from the Atomic

Beam sources seems have reached it’s limit of about

1017at/sec.

• Proposed source of polarized ortho-hydrogen (o-H2 )

molecules probably will provide intensity by order of

magnitude higher. For deuterium gas situation is harder du

to the smaller magnetic moment of the molecule.

• An opening questions are preservation of polarization

of molecules under injection into the storage cell and

realization of huge differential pumping system needed

to get good vacuum condition.