Political Cartoon & FDR
description
Transcript of Political Cartoon & FDR
![Page 1: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
The Political Cartoon: A Unique Perspective on the Presidency of FDR
Michael W. Jackson 5/3/2000
![Page 2: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
JACKSON
2
The political cartoon, a tool of democracy, has been a cornerstone of American
politics since the inception of this nation. The political cartoon, however, did not
experience its coming of age until the presidency of Franklin Delano Roosevelt. The ink
flowed freely during the four consecutive terms of FDR and with this deluge of ink came
a portrait of an American President. The nation itself would grow closer to their
President unlike any previous generation. The focus of these political cartoons can be
separated into four distinct categories. The knowledge that is embodied in these political
cartoons ranges from Roosevelt's character and personality, Roosevelt's relationship
with the people, the effect of the New Deal on American life, and the controversial side
of FDR. These four subdivisions depict an American President that took America from
the depths of depression to the heights of economic recovery.
The first significant snapshot of FDR resides within the interpretation of political
cartoons that depict Roosevelt as the guiding force of the nation. Roosevelt himself is
depicted as "The Man of the Hour"1 and the leader of the pack. The nation was at the
depths of economic insecurity during the 1932 presidential campaign and the
inadequacies of Hoover left a void in the palette of the American people for a leader that
would act to bring an end to the Great Depression. Roosevelt was the son of a
prosperous family and had grown up in luxury. This experience itself would often be
called an irony of the Great Depression, as Hoover was a self-made man. The product
of this childhood, however, was not a snobbish aristocrat but a man who knew that
America needed emergency relief immediately. The pride of Hoover was his weakness
and it was the charity of Roosevelt that contributed to his understanding of direct
economic assistance to a public in need. The character of Roosevelt was further
fortified through the experience of polio that enabled him to view life with a disadvantage
1 Seibel, Fred O. Richmond Times Dispatch. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33031403.gif
![Page 3: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
JACKSON
3
and make him one with America. A worker once said, " Mr. Roosevelt is the only man
we ever had in the White House who would understand that my boss is a son of a
bitch."2 This character to be one with the American people allowed Roosevelt to gain
the trust of a nation in need of a savior. This position is supported through 7 distinct
political cartoons that display the character of Roosevelt. The first significant cartoon
(footnote 1) portrays Roosevelt as the man of the hour who is pushing away the
darkness of depression and replacing it with the sunshine of prosperity while upholding
the American ideals captured by the American Flag. "Still a Hero"3 is a cartoon depicting
three statues, two which have crumbled and one which is still standing proud and tall.
The two collapsed statues are of Hoover and Mellon who through their trickle down
economic theory and do nothing approach gained the ill favor of the nation. The statue
of Roosevelt however is still standing and it displays a man proud of himself and his
convictions. " Confidence in Your Doctor is Half the Battle"4 depicts Roosevelt as the
doctor of Uncle Sam. The bedside manner depicted in the cartoon conveys a sense of
security and confidence as well as trust in a man that will bring an end to America's
troubles. "Looks as if the New Leadership was really going to Lead"5 displays an active
Roosevelt full of energy ready to move the nation down the road to emergency
legislation and an end to the Depression. This cartoon captures the passion of a new
President and his desire to maintain his promises to America in accordance with the
sarcastic statement of the title that states that the nation did not expect the President to
lead the nation. " The March 4th Reception Committee"6 captures the quick nature by
which Roosevelt was introduced to the problems of the Nation as he approaches the
2 Henretta, James A. America's History pg 788 3 Brown, Webb. Akron Beacon Journal. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/fdr_100/small/33031302.GIF 4 Kaiser. Houston Post. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/fdr_100/small/33031001.GIF 5 Ray, S.J. Kansas City (MO) Star. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33030703.gif 6 Morris. Brooklyn Citizen. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33011001.gif
![Page 4: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
JACKSON
4
White House for the first time. Roosevelt is depicted as a normal man who walks up to
the White House with his own luggage and in turn conveys a sense of equality with the
American people. " Hail and Farewell"7 proceeds to continue the depiction of
Roosevelt's arrival at the capital and his subsequent actions by entering the Oval Office
while Hoover quickly leaves in disgrace. Roosevelt is shown to be jovial and ready to
attack the problems of society neatly organized. "Sweeping Changes are Expected After
March 4th"8 displays Roosevelt receiving the broom of reorganization to sweep away the
fat of the nation in order to save the economy. The situation is one of joy and it captures
the belief of the nation Roosevelt would bring and end to the depression as Uncle Sam
looks on. The man depicted by these seven varied portraits is one that is trust worthy,
energetic, and ready to lead America towards prosperity.
The second issue addressed by the political cartoons is Roosevelt's relationship
to the American people. Roosevelt through his battle with polio had developed an
understanding of the disabled and discriminated masses and it was this new found belief
in the needs of a crippled nation that drew FDR closer to his citizens. "Economic Peril"9
displays a man representing the citizens of the nation crying out for help in a time of
need and first on the list of names is Roosevelt. This cartoon displays the confidence of
the citizen in Roosevelt to solve the economic problems while maintaining a lookout for
help on all avenues. " On the Course as Charted"10 Roosevelt returns as the captain of
the National Welfare ready to survive the storm ahead in full rain gear. Roosevelt then is
portrayed as the savior of the American people from their peril at sea as the captain
guiding citizens to safe harbor. This cartoon depicts the relation of Roosevelt to
7 Clubb. Rochester Times Union. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33030401.gif 8 Morris. Hoboken Observer. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33022101.gif 9 White Plains Republican. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/roadto/rtgifs/large/32051701.GIF 10 Sykes. Philadelphia Public Ledger. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37010601.gif
![Page 5: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
JACKSON
5
Americans as their levelheaded captain. "The New Chauffeur"11 displays Roosevelt now
as the repairman of the broken US economy. Roosevelt is captured rolling up his
sleeves and preparing to fix the American economy. Roosevelt here is presented as the
servant of Uncle Sam (American people) and it is his duty to fix any inconvenience.
Hoover is caught fleeing from the wrecked car but Roosevelt is ready to help. "A Clear
Track"12 now places Roosevelt at the head of a mighty locomotive ready to end the fears
of the depression and lead society to economic recovery. A nation's confidence is
emblazoned on the train and shows FDR leaving behind the blues of the depression. "
His Stamp of Approval"13 depicts the clear and concise nature of Roosevelt's link to the
people as he will maintain honesty and try his best, but if he fails he will accept defeat
and try again. It is this try and try again attitude which gained great admiration of the
American people. " Whoa"14 is a significant display of Roosevelt's relation to his
constituents as he decides that the congress may not go on recess until the matters of
the nation are solved. Roosevelt himself is depicted as a champion of the public and a
man who will give aide in a time of need. "Hotel America"15 the final piece displaying
Roosevelt's relation to America depicts a President who will not allow US funds to leave
the country without the benefit of Americans. Roosevelt himself will not give the gold to
Mrs. Trubble (Germany) as he is listening to the taxpayer and feels that the nation
should not deplete its gold supply in a time of economic crisis. These seven images
capture Roosevelt's devotion and bond with his nation as he prepares to pull America
out of the depression by being a leader and a great motivator.
11 Shanks, Bruce. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33030501.gif 12 Hungerford. New York Star Eagle. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33031402.gif 13 Doyle, Jerry. Philadelphia Record. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/roadto/rtgifs/large/32052402.GIF 14 Gibson, Bolt. Camden Post. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/fdr_farm/33031602.GIF 15 Power, T.E. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33030701.gif
![Page 6: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
JACKSON
6
The third avenue of inspection is the significance of the New Deal programs on
America. The New Deal itself provided a means to rebuild a plagued economy and a
way to find a job in a time where men felt worthless. America had a black eye and it now
was time to recover from its blow. "An Unfortunate Wait"16 utilizes the metaphor of a
train station to display the interim period between the Hoover and Roosevelt
administrations. In the train depot are the solutions to the Great Depression, however
because the Hoover train is sidetracked these new proposals will not arrive until
Roosevelt's term in office. "Keeping His Nose on the Grindstone"17 displays the hand of
the President pressuring the Congress to produce a solution to the problems of a nation.
Roosevelt here allies himself with the American people and vows to keep the
government hard at work to solve the problems of the nation. "On the Fire"18 displays
the solution to the economic problems of America and Roosevelt as the Chef is
preparing these remedies as fast as he can always announcing there imminent success.
The public is captured as well in this cartoon as it depicts the interest in Americans to try
these New Deal programs. "It IS a New Deal"19 begins to show the final outcome of the
first New Deal on society as Roosevelt has prepared the remedy and now awaits the
effects on the new move towards direct aid to America. "A Couple of Convincing
Testimonials"20 shows the outcome of the remedies prescribed by Roosevelt. The banks
and National Stability are improving and it is now time to bring relief to the farms.
"Farm Relief"21 is a clear presentation of the relationship of the New Deal to the
American farmer. Roosevelt has turned his attention away from the banks and national
stability to work on the infrastructure of our nation, the yeoman farmer. The farmer
16 Clubb. Plainfield News. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33012401.gif 17 Byck, S.S. Brooklyn Times. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33030603.gif 18 Munhall. Lynn Item. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/fdr_100/small/33030901.GIF 19 Talburt. Pittsburgh Press. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/wait_for_fdr/33031101.gif 20 Carlsile. Rome Sentinel. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/fdr_farm/33031803.GIF 21 Talburt. Washington News. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/fdr_farm/33031804.GIF
![Page 7: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
JACKSON
7
depicted is elated with the news that someone is finally trying to solve the farm problem
during the depression. "Foiled"22 is the pinnacle of the farm relief movement as the
financial troubles of the farmer are set aside so that the farmer can return to providing
the American people with food. The effect of the New Deal upon the American people is
echoed in these drawings as the nation proceeds toward newfound prosperity. The
nation once in toil is now protected and able to fight off the financial problems with aide
of a President.
The final area of concern embodied in these cartoons is the controversial side of
FDR, who is said to have been the best remedy for America yet challenged by his
actions involving the Supreme Court and the expansion of the power of the Executive
branch. Roosevelt is often criticized as well for his lack of planning in dealing with
America's economic troubles. "There's many a slip"23 is the first in a sequence of
cartoons that criticize the moves of Roosevelt to pack the Supreme Court in hopes of
maintaining his New Deal initiatives. Roosevelt hoped that he could add to the Supreme
Court a new justice for each justice over seventy that would increase the number of
justices from nine to fifteen. The cartoon "Wonder if the result of the election would have
been the same"24 further denotes the public rage when it appears that Roosevelt is
saying half-truths to the American Public. In one scene the President is stating his
hopes for the future and then in a second scene it depicts what Roosevelt really was
saying with an angry voter. "Mr. President"25 further supports the nation's frustration
during the second term of Roosevelt. The cartoon depicts the enormous size of
Roosevelt to a small representation of the people. "Oliver Twist"26 represents the fear of
22 Talburt. Washington News. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/fdr_farm/33040602.GIF 23 Evans. Columbus Dispatch. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37022508.gif 24 Orr. Chicago Tribune. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37021610.gif 25 Seibel. Richmond Times Dispatch. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37020704.gif 26 Parrish. Chicago Tribune. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37011603.gif
![Page 8: Political Cartoon & FDR](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022020105/546716caaf795974338b54a2/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
JACKSON
8
the American people that Roosevelt is trying to overstep the bounds of the executive
branch and move in on the power of congress. Roosevelt is asking for more power, yet
his size is able to gain him whatever he desires. "What Happens when he finishes
shuffling them around"27 is the question asked by the public as President Roosevelt
appears to be devising a way to have dictatorial power over the branches of the
government and the people. The public of course is caught off guard and can not
understand why Roosevelt would do this to his friends (Americans). "The Blank Page"28
is the transition between the errors of packing the Supreme Court and now the lack of
guidance when deciding what was best for a nation in crisis. Roosevelt is depicted as
knowing that things needed to be done however he did not know exactly what needed to
be done in America. It was only through assistance that FDR came to his plans for the
New Deal. In "The Master Wheel Forgotten"29 Roosevelt is finally depicted as a child
fooling with the nation's problems who solves the problem but leaves a crucial design out
of the solution. The process of reconstructing a clock symbolizes the lack of foresight of
Roosevelt and his presidency.
Roosevelt is a man who, captured in the inkwells of a journalist, is both a savior
of the nation and as well an uneducated child playing with a system he does not
understand. The review of Roosevelt in the context of the cartoon interpretation of his
actions has yielded a President with both beneficial and detrimental qualities. This
duality of good and bad traits is one which balanced in Roosevelt was able to pull a
nation from the depths of despair and return the American people to a state of
prosperity.
27 Parrish. Chicago Tribune. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/1937/37_scgifs/large/37022301.gif 28 Boston Hearld. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/roadto/rtgifs/large/32042001.GIF 29 Clubb. Utica Dispatch. http://www.nisk.k12.ny.us/fdr/roadto/rtgifs/large/32041502.GIF