Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS...

43
A Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union By Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles Instructor: Dr. Modarres Quarter: Spring 2010

Transcript of Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS...

Page 1: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

A Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union

By

Dore Burry

CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES

Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles Instructor: Dr. Modarres

Quarter: Spring 2010

Page 2: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 2

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TITLE PAGE ...........................................................................................................................1 TABLE OF CONTENTS .........................................................................................................2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .....................................................................................................3 INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................................4 LOCATION? LOCATION! BORDERS? .............................................................................5

Community plan ...........................................................................................................5 Byzantine-Latino Quarter ............................................................................................6 Other data fuzziness .....................................................................................................6

SETTLEMENT AND EARLY DEMOGRAPHIC SUMMARY ............................................7 CURRENT DEMOGRAPHICS ..............................................................................................9

Ethnicity, gender, and age composition .......................................................................10 Housing, education, and language ..............................................................................11 Income ..........................................................................................................................12

PRESERVATION OVERVIEW .............................................................................................12 Historic-Cultural Monument Designations .................................................................13 Historic Preservation Overlay Zone (HPOZ) ..............................................................14 Community Redevelopment Agency efforts ..................................................................14 Community Involvement ...............................................................................................15 Open Space, Green Space, and Public Art ..................................................................16

MAPPING AND PHOTOGRAPHING THE HCMS ..............................................................16 DISCUSSION ..........................................................................................................................17 REFERENCES ..............................................................................................................Attached TABLES ........................................................................................................................Attached FIGURES .......................................................................................................................Attached

MAPS Map 1 –Byzantine-Latino Quarter Map Map 2 –Pico-Union 1 and 2 Redevelopment Project Area Map (CRA) Map 3 – Pico-Union Historic Preservation Overlay Zone (HPOZ) Map

ATTACHMENTS Attachment 1 – Mapping project of Designated Historic-Cultural Monuments within

Pico-Union Attachment 2 – Los Angeles Department of City Planning, Historic-Cultural Monument

(HCM) Report, Planning Community: Westlake Attachment 3 – List of HCM properties in Pico-Union (extracted from Attachment 2)

Page 3: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 3

Executive Summary

Overview

A spatial biography (essentially a placed-based descriptive journey of its past through its present, incorporating the histories of its built form, economy, demography, politics, and other aspects) while complex to perform, can provide rich and interesting insights of the present and future of a community. The different components of a spatial biography are not mutually exclusive, but rather interwoven and interconnected, often with “the economy dependent on society and the environment while human existence and society depend on, and within the environment” (Giddings, Hopwood, & O’Brien, 2002, p. 187). By attempting to assemble spatial biographies at the community level, we can gain a better understanding of the individual puzzle pieces that comprise the great city of neighborhoods that is Los Angeles. This brief spatial biography will examine Pico-Union, one of the oldest, most diverse, densely populated, and economically disadvantaged inner-city communities within the City of Los Angeles. Information Sources Many journal articles were reviewed, in an attempt to find a process of assembling an organized spatial biography and for historical information. Several UCLA studies and papers were enormously valuable in providing a social historical perspective of Pico-Union, and the neighboring Byzantine-Latino Corridor. Publications by Los Angeles Conservancy provided much of the included detail of the historical character of Pico-Union’s built environment, including descriptions of historically significant Pico-Union structures. Census datasets were obtained from American Fact Finder for six Pico-Union census tracts. The City of Los Angeles Planning Department and the Office of Historical Resources provided parcel level information that was included in the ArcMap created by the researcher. Field work (mostly photographing) was performed to gain an increased sense of the historical character of Pico-Union’s built environment.

Page 4: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 4

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union

It is certainly no exaggeration to say that all of the current 88 incorporated cities (and

unincorporated areas) that comprise Los Angeles County have undergone enormous change over

the last 150 years. Many Los Angeles communities simply did not exist 150 years ago. The

conversion of the sparsely settled Los Angeles desert landscape to its current form was largely

due to two large development booms, both driven by profit-motivated wealthy development

interests, waves of oil reserve exploitation, transportation infrastructure improvements, real

estate speculation, and manifest destiny. After the two booms (generally in the 1880s and

1920s), older, original settlement areas of Los Angeles did their best to survive the outwards

suburban leap-frogging of new community creation, the waxing and waning of federal

government priority shifts, often schizophrenic immigration policies, and poorly coordinated

local and regional development plans.

More recently (within the last 40 years), many urban areas within Los Angeles County,

have experienced significant urban decay and/or have remained stagnant. Curiously however,

some cities and communities have been able to redefine themselves significantly over relatively

short periods of time; since the 1990s. Glendale, Pasadena, West Hollywood, for example, as

well as the huge expansions of Santa Clarita, Palmdale, and Corona (as well as nearly every city

in the San Gabriel Valley) have redefined themselves and reshaped the urban context of Los

Angeles. Within the City of Los Angeles, the communities of Silver Lake, Los Feliz, Sunset

Junction, Echo Park, Eagle Rock, Miracle Mile, Culver City, Venice Beach, portions of

Hollywood, and especially downtown Los Angeles hardly look and feel like they did a decade or

two ago.

Page 5: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 5

Whether “due” for growth spurts, are the result of concerted efforts by constituents, or

politically assisted through targeted programs (such as Community Redevelopment Agency

assistance), spatial biographies of single communities can provide valuable insight into

community changes (or lack thereof). In a larger context, performing spatial biographies are a

crucial exercise in connecting and linking together the history of the “sum of the parts” to better

explain Los Angeles’ existence as a whole.

This paper, albeit through brief summary, attempted to link different aspects of the

history of Pico-Union with its present conditions. The intention was to provide an abbreviated

spatial biography from which understanding issues related Pico-Union’s future may be learned.

Location? Location! Borders?

One of the significant challenges involved in assembling a spatial biography of an area

within Los Angeles is to understand the specific boundaries of the community being explored.

Due to Los Angeles’s sprawling development patterns, it is often difficult to discern where one

community begins and ends. Furthermore, obtaining data and reviewing prior studies of a

specific community, such as Pico-Union, is complicated by differences of perceived borders,

which results in incongruities of place-based history and data.

Community Plan

Much of the City of Los Angeles data for Pico-Union, including key planning

components, are included in the Westlake Community Plan. The community of Westlake is

Pico-Union’s neighbor, a sister community in many senses, north of Olympic Boulevard.

Page 6: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 6

However similar, Pico-Union and Westlake are quite different (historically and presently), have

very different challenges to their future, and should have mutually exclusive community plans.

Byzantine-Latino Corridor

Hutchinson (1999) and other studies examine Pico-Union with, or rather within, the

context of the Byzantine-Latino Quarter (BLQ), which begins in the south-western portion of

Pico-Union, and continues westward along Pico Boulevard to Normandie Avenue (and also

includes several blocks north and south of Pico Boulevard (Map 1). The BLQ (a LANI

neighborhood since 1997, formerly known as Pico-Heights), as it crosses Vermont Avenue going

westward, is still very similar demographically to Pico-Union, but the two are very different in

terms of built form. Even the Pico-Union Neighborhood Council, and the relatively new Los

Angeles Times neighborhood mapping project include areas west of Hoover Street (to

Normandie Avenue) as within Pico-Union. Those areas however become what many consider to

be Koreatown, which, perhaps moreso than Pico-Union, has no distinct spatial boundaries.

Other Border Fuzziness

Unfortunately, portions of Pico-Union are also sometimes grouped within the Figueroa

corridor or South Park. Until the recent real estate collapse, Pico-Union seemed helplessly

poised to be merged, absorbed, or even consumed, by the staples center, L.A. Live, Nokia

Center, Convention Center, and other encroaching downtown developments. Hardly needing to

be stated, Pico-Union looks nothing like, and shares virtually nothing in common (besides

location) with their encroaching neighbors across the 110 freeway.

Page 7: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 7

For most purposes of this paper, the boundaries of Pico-Union are identical to the

Community Redevelopment Agency’s (CRA) Pico-Union 1 and 2 project areas, which are bound

by Olympic Boulevard on the north, the 10 freeway on the south, the 110 freeway on the east,

and Hoover Street on the west (Map 2).

Settlement and Early Demographic Summary

In a time without freeways and major avenues, Pico-Union “lies within the original

boundary of El Pueblo de Los Angeles, founded in 1781,” and, “by the 1880s, the new railroads

were bringing thousands of new residents each year, from across the nation and around the

world, initiating a pattern of migration and settlement that has shaped Pico-Union throughout its

history” (Los Angeles Conservancy, 2010). Early settlers of Pico-Union were a diverse group of

Europeans, including middle and upper-income “Greeks, Norwegians, Swedes, Welsh, and

Russian Jews” (Loukaitou-Sideris, 2000, p. 17).

Pico-Union was initially developed as an early suburb (1880 to 1900) to the business

activities of downtown Los Angeles, which was essentially 1-mile away to the north and

northeast. As the Los Angeles economy grew and the development boom of the 1880s hit full

stride, the center of Los Angeles grew, and Pico-Union was well on its way of being transformed

into the inner-city residential character that exists today. The new suburbs moved outwards,

including westward along the BLQ, to accommodate a bulging population through inefficient,

space wasting, suburban-like development models. From 1860 through 1920, the Los Angeles

population grew from approximately 11,000 to 1 million (Modarres, 1998, p. 136).

As Los Angeles continued to grow outwards and the suburbs became more

infrastructurally and economically capable, dependency on the downtown area decreased,

Page 8: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 8

leading to decay. Within Pico-Union, this period (approximately 1930s-1950s) included the

flight of most of their remaining affluent residents, which were replaced by the working class,

typically immigrants. The 1940s brought large industrial interests to Los Angeles (essentially

south of downtown) and many more recent immigrants that sought work found Pico-Union

convenient due to location, social familiarity, and cheaper cost of living.

Urban renewal and redevelopment of downtown Los Angeles during the 1950s and 1960s

“eliminated much of the low-cost housing serving ethnic communities in the city’s core,” which,

“pushed Asian and Latino communities into neighborhoods immediately surrounding the central

city, including the Pico-Union area” (UCLA, 1998). During this time, “Housing became run

down, as landlords kept subdividing the units and renting them out to accommodate ever-larger

numbers of immigrant families” (Hutchinson & Sideris, 2001, p. 297). This period was

especially difficult as Pico-Union’s infrastructure quickly deteriorated, complicated by its rich

ethnic diversity, a recurring theme through Pico-Union’s history. Hutchinson (1999) explained

that Pico-Union is an example of a diverse inner city, experiencing continual shifts in its very

high population density, which has lead to “Propinquity Without Community,” as “overstressed

infrastructure exacerbates the problems of living in a majority stranger population” (Hutchinson,

1999, p. 1). However, Hutchinson also noted that while many cities have had voids in their

decaying urban cores, Pico-Union didn’t follow that pattern. Pico-Union’s single and multi-

family dwellings were often over-crowded (as is still the case presently) with immigrant families

striving to survive, bringing with them “a store of energy, work experience, and the willingness

to bear hardship to create a better life” (Hutchinson, 1999, p. 7).

In 1970, the name Pico-Union was officially adopted by the CRA (named for its central

intersection) and the CRA Pico-Union 1 project area was created. Shortly after, large influxes of

Page 9: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 9

Central Americans, especially Salvadorian and Guatemalan immigrants, found residence (and

refuge from civil war) in Pico-Union; a trend that has continued until today, and has expanded to

include many ethnic groups, including Cuban, Korean, a diversity of Mexican backgrounds, and

a variety of immigrants from many Central American countries.

Current (2000) Demographics

Pico-Union’s demographic characteristics, in comparison with the City of Los Angeles as

a whole, and the United States, are markedly different in virtually all basic categories. Summary

information pertaining to Pico-Union’s ethnic composition (Table 1) and income (Table 2), are

provided in-text, Tables 3 and 4 are more comprehensive and are provided in the Tables section

of this paper.

Lastly, as mentioned previously, there are large discrepancies across sources regarding

the statistics of Pico-Union, due to different boundary definitions. The total population (in 2000)

of the six Pico Union census tracts was reported as 17,498, but many sources include areas west

of Hoover Street area as Pico-Union, which increases the population to over 40,000. An

interesting article by well-known writer and scholar, Joel Kotkin, in 1997 even stated that the

Pico-Union’s population was “roughly 120,000” (Kotkin, 1997, p. 1). Kotkin must have been

including all of Westlake, the BLQ, and portions of Koreatown. Admittedly, a small portion of

Westlake and a sliver portion eastwards of the 110 (to Figueroa) are included in the six census

tracts considered for this paper (due to census tract boundaries, Figure 2 in tables section).

Page 10: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 10

Ethnicity, Gender, and Age Composition

In 2000, ethnically speaking, Pico-Union was significantly less White and Black then the

City of Los Angeles and the United States, and it had almost double the percentage of Hispanic

or Latino as reported citywide (and over 7 times as reported nationwide) (Table 1). The

reporting for the category of “Some Other Race” within Pico-Union was the majority response

(56.5%) which indicated the enormous diversity of the area (largely from Central American

countries). The Pico-Union reporting for Some Other Race was more than twice the citywide

percentage and over 10 times the nationwide reporting.

Table 1 Ethnicity Comparisons by Category

Category Pico-Union Los Angeles United States

One race 94.0% 94.8% 97.6%

White 29.8% 46.9% 75.1%

Black or African American 3.6% 11.2% 12.3%

American Indian and Alaska Native 1.4% 0.8% 0.9%

Asian 2.8% 10.0% 3.6%

Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander 0.1% 0.2% 0.1%

Some other race 56.5% 25.7% 5.5%

Two or more races 6.0% 5.2% 2.4%

Hispanic or Latino (of any race) 90.4% 46.5% 12.5%

Note. Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Not surprising of working class immigrant communities, the percentage of males in Pico-

Union was higher than females by 1.6% when compared citywide, and 2.3% nationwide (Table

3). The imbalance towards males is likely caused by gender issues relating to availability and

types of work (often labor) for immigrants. The median age reported in Pico-Union was 27.6

years, 4 years younger than median age citywide, and 7.7 years younger than reported

nationwide.

Page 11: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 11

Housing, Education, and Language

In 2000, Pico-Union was overwhelmingly a renter community (reported as 91.7% renter-

occupied, Figure 1). Many reasons contribute to the high rate of renters within Pico-Union, but

most simply, the housing stock lends itself, almost perfectly, to renters (high percentage of multi-

family housing).

Perhaps not surprising for a community comprised of recent immigrants (but very tell-

tale of the current quality of life and future outlook for many residents of Pico-Union) the

percentage of High School graduates (27.8%) was less than half that of citywide reporting

(66.6%) and almost one third of national reporting (80.4%) (Figure 1). Reporting of those with

Bachelor’s degree or higher was also significantly lower than citywide and nationwide reporting.

The majority (64.1%) of Pico-Union reporting was Foreign born (more than 5 times the

nationwide reporting) and 89% reported speaking a language other than English at home.

Census 2000 Demographic Comparisons

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Renter-occupiedhousing units

High schoolgraduate or higher

Bachelor's degreeor higher

Foreign born Speak a languageother than English at

home

Families belowpoverty level

Individuals belowpoverty level

Census Category

Perc

enta

ge

Pico-UnionCity of L.A.U.S.

Figure 1. Selected Pico-Union Community Characteristics. Note. Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Page 12: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 12

Income

The Pico-Union median household income ($16,419) reported in 2000, was less than half

of citywide reporting, and less than one-third of the nationwide median household income (Table

2). Perhaps most striking was the Pico-Union reporting of per-capita income ($9,136),

percentages of families below the poverty level (42.3%), and individuals below the poverty level

(43.8%). All three of these categories are significantly lower than reported citywide and

nationwide. This is a complicating disappointment, since the cost of living in Los Angeles is

much higher than most of the country (therefore actual poverty rates for Pico-Union residents,

after adjustments, are much higher).

Table 2 Income Comparisons

General Characteristics Pico-Union Los Angeles United States

Median household income in 1999 (dollars) $16,419 $36,687 $41,994

Median family income in 1999 (dollars) $18,032 $39,942 $50,046

Per capita income in 1999 (dollars) $9,136 $20,671 $21,587

Note. Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Preservation Overview

For a wide variety of reasons, Pico-Union contains an extraordinary assortment of

architecturally significant structures that remain from, or near, settlement days. This is due to a

variety of factors, including concerted efforts of long-time constituents and through

governmental policies. While there is still much more preservation work to be done, Pico-

Union, very fortunately, is very far ahead of the curve as large numbers of historic structures

(typically residential structures) remain.

Page 13: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 13

Historic-Cultural Monument Designation

Parcels and properties can be declared Historic-Cultural Monuments (HCMs) by three

levels of government; City, State, and Federal. Each level of government can declare HCM

status independently, while sometimes properties enjoy multiple declarations.

Regarding the City of Los Angeles designation process, the city, in 1962, enacted a

Cultural Heritage Ordinance that protects “resources that have a special aesthetic, architectural,

or engineering interest or value of a historic nature” (City of Los Angeles, 2010a). The Los

Angeles Department of City Planning and the Office of Historical Resources maintain an

inventory of HCM designated properties, as declared by all three levels of government. The

properties are organized by Planning Areas and Community Plans. The Pico-Union HCMs are

included in the Westlake Community Plan (Attachment 2) and 27 properties within Pico-Union

enjoy at least one declaration. Of the 27 properties (Attachment 3), the majority are residential,

built as single-family (but often converted to multi-family), multi-family, or mixed-use

(residential with commercial). Worth noting is that likely upwards of 75 additional properties

that have similar designers, built in the same period, and are very worthy of HCM status are not

listed, due to a variety of factors (process, limitations of HCM status, etc.).

In addition to single property designation, the Federal government has designated and

listed two Pico-Union districts in the National Register of Historical Places; the Alvarado

Terrace Historic District and the Bonnie Brae Historic District.

Page 14: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 14

Historic Preservation Overlay Zone (HPOZ)

The City of Los Angeles, in 1979, adopted the Historic Preservation Overlay Zone

(HPOZ) ordinance to help preserve and protect “neighborhoods with distinct architectural and

cultural resources” (City of Los Angeles, 2010b). As of 2010, 25 communities have been

protected by the ordinance, Pico-Union being the nineteenth approved HPOZ in 2006 (Map 3).

While the reasons for HPOZ protection varies greatly by community, the HPOZ goals for

Pico-Union were essentially to preserve its residential character “of architectural styles including

late 19th century Victorian-era cottages, early 20th century Craftsman and Mission Revival

bungalows and larger homes in Period Revival or Classical styles…designed by known

architects and builders of the period such as Frank Tyler, Hunt and Burns, Stiles O. Clements,

and Elmer Grey” (City of Los Angeles, 2010c). An expansive description of styles and periods

of architecturally significant structures can be found in the Pico-Union Preservation Plan.

Community Redevelopment Agency Efforts

In 1970, the Community Redevelopment Agency of Los Angeles had the foresight to

“preserve and expand affordable housing, encourage economic development,” and “improve the

community’s appearance by rehabilitating housing and businesses,” within a newly created Pico-

Union 1 Project Area (Map 3). In 1976, the adjacent Pico-Union 2 Project Area was created;

together, the two project areas completely overlay all of Pico-Union. The CRA has helped create

hundreds of low- to moderate-income housing opportunities and was instrumental in the HPOZ

designation process.

The recent Pico Boulevard improvements of sidewalk repair and replacement, street tree

replacement, bus shelter installations, street lighting improvements, trash receptacle installations,

Page 15: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 15

and textured decorative crosswalk patterns (photos included in Attachment 1) were part of the

CRA’s Pico Boulevard Streetscape Program. The program, which began at the 110 freeway and

stretched to westward to Hoover Street, helped improve the living conditions, pedestrianization,

and made a main artery of Pico-Union more socially conducive.

Community Involvement

Various waves of community involvement have helped Pico-Union’s continually

transitioning population. The Pico-Union Housing Corporation (established in 1971) and the

Pico-Union Neighborhood Council (established in 1965) have helped steward Pico-Union in a

myriad of ways, including helping to improve and create low- to moderate income residential

options (affordable housing). Created in the 1970s, the Institute of Popular Education of

Southern California (IDEPSCA) helped Central American immigrants assimilate (and

incorporate) and, more recently, the Central American Resource Center (CARECEN) assists

with human and civil rights issues through economic justice based programs. Approximately

two dozen non-profit groups exist, providing these types of services.

Churches have played a big role in the stability of Pico-Union. The Iglesia Angelica

Lutheran (founded in 1888 by Swedish immigrants), in the heart of Pico-Union has “offered

religious services in English, Spanish, Korean, and Kanjobal, an indigenous language of Mexico

and Guatemala” (Watanabe, 2009). During the early 1980s the church became “Part of an anti-

war campaign protesting U.S. foreign policy in Central America, the Sanctuary Movement

started in the Southwest and grew into a network of hundreds of religious congregations that

provided shelter to refugees facing deportation” (Los Angeles Conservancy, 2010). The Central

Spanish Seventh-Day Adventist Church, originally built as the First Church of Christ Scientist in

1912 (designed by Elmer Grey) is also noted for its many humanitarian assistance efforts across

Page 16: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 16

ethnicities. Although no complete record of churches, or their historical and social contributions

within Pico-Union could be found, many churches exist in the range of 80-130 years old.

Open Space, Green Space, and Public Art

Pico-Union is approximately .6 square miles and has little open and green space. In total,

only five small parks or park-like opportunities are closely available (photos included in

Attachment 1) to the highly population density residents. The options are limited, both in size

and access, but are intensely used. The spaces are

• the Salvation Army’s Red Shield soccer field; • the Cesar Chavez Community Garden; • Pico-Union Park; • the Alvarado Terrace Park; and, • Toberman Park.

Public art, through murals and other means, has often been an opportunity for expression

within Pico-Union. Approximately a dozen murals grace its aging infrastructure, often with

connoting messages of recommitment to community. Along these lines, the CRA Pico

Boulevard Streetscape program attempted to accentuate Pico-Unions public spaces by using a

decorative crosswalk pattern at several busy intersections and by imprinting outlines of historic

structures into newly poured sidewalks (photos included in Attachment 1).

Mapping and Photographing Pico-Union’s HCMs

Using information from the City of Los Angeles, Office of Historical Resources, the

Planning Department, and the Westlake Community Plan, I extracted location data for all the

HCMs within Pico-Union (27 properties). I researched each property, by confirming address and

property details (including year built) using NavigateLA and parcel reports (Attachment 3).

Page 17: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 17

Within ArcMap, I used ESRI’s online worldwide street map, created an address locator,

and geocoded the locations (by importing the address and zip code data from an excel file). I

organized the HCMs from west to east, and north to south, and assigned IDs so the locations

could be cross-referenced. I created a map layout, added a second data frame to better show the

large grouping of HCMs on Alvarado Terrace and created the attached Designated Historic-

Cultural Monuments in Pico-Union map (Attachment 1). Additionally, over the course of four

days, I visited and photographed each property (also included in Attachment 1).

Discussion

Pico-Union largely complies with the old adage that the more things change

(demographics and surroundings) the more they stay the same (infrastructure and overall ethnic

diversity). Although its ethic composition has changed significantly over time, from its mixture

of early European settlers to today’s potpourri of international representation, ethnic diversity

seems to be been innate bound to the Pico-Union soil.

Unfortunately, the diversity in terms of income, and all the other factors that are related

to income and opportunity (including formal U.S. education), have been missing for over 50

years. With a median household income of approximately $17,000 and a per capital income of

less than $10,000, it becomes clear that Pico-Union’s incubator of labor to the City of Los

Angeles does not extent much past that. In that context, the extraordinary compromise and

suffering that has been endured by the continually replenishing supply of immigrated peoples

that make their way to and through Pico-Union is staggering. The over-crowded conditions, the

lack of open space, the countless obstacles towards integration, are just some of the major

challenges of current and future generations of those within Pico-Union. Concurrently, those

Page 18: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Brief Spatial Biography of Pico-Union 18

challenges will be complicated further by the pressures of gentrification as downtown expands

outwards.

In other contexts, the opportunities to immigrants, such as the rich social immigrant

network and the underground economy of Pico-Union, are not available in many other places in

Los Angeles. Across much of Los Angeles, the luxury of freeways have formed barely-

permeable community barriers; creating negative externalities such as social, ethnic, and

economic stratifications, quality of life differences, and divisions of place. In the case of Pico-

Union however, tucked deeply within a corner of the 10 and 110 freeway intersection, has been a

huge benefit, for its own survival and for Los Angeles as a whole. The freeways, directly

(through creating physical barriers) and indirectly (through making the real estate less desirable),

have fostered Pico-Union’s diversity, protected its rich assortment of historical structures

(through lack of private interest of redevelopment), and has provided sanctuary from the cultural

sterilization of gentrification. For these reasons, and many more, Pico-Union has been a

salvation, an incubator, and a never ending supply of culture, labor, and talent. Ironically, these

benefits provided by Pico-Union have been absorbed by a city that has a history of ignoring

communities like Pico-Union.

When describing Pico-Union, current Councilmember Ed Reyes stated, "The issue here is

how do we collaborate and share the space we have," and continued "That, to me, is the beauty

of this area: the coexistence of communities" (Watanabe, 2009). Reyes’ statements might be

best framed as to pertaining within Pico-Union (as there is a cohesive interplay of ethnicities).

Collaborating, sharing space, and “coexistence of communities” between Pico-Union and its

neighbors must be done in a manner that does not absorb nor displacing Pico-Unions innate,

unique, and valuable characteristics.

Page 19: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

References

City of Los Angeles, Office of Historical Resources (2010a). What makes a resource historically

significant. Retrieved from http://preservation.lacity.org/significant

City of Los Angeles, Office of Historical Resources (2010b). Historic Preservation Overlay

Zones (HPOZs). Retrieved from http://preservation.lacity.org/hpoz

City of Los Angeles, Office of Historical Resources (2010c). Historic Preservation Overlay

Zones (HPOZs): Pico-Union. Retrieved from

http://preservation.lacity.org/hpoz/la/pico-union

Giddings, B., Hopwood, B., & O’Brien, G. (2002). Environment, economy, and society: Fitting

them together into sustainable development. Sustainable Development, 10, 187-196.

Hutchinson, J. M. (1999). Propinquity without community : A study of social capital, survival

networks, and community building in the Pico Union area of Los Angeles (Doctoral

Dissertation). UCLA Libraries and Collections, Record ID: 4316015, UMI Number:

9939074.

Hutchinson, J., & Loukaitou-Sideris, A. (2001). Choosing confrontation or consensus in the

inner city: Lessons from a Community–University partnership. Planning Theory & Practice,

2(3), 293-310. doi:10.1080/14649350120096839

Kotkin, J. (1997, September 28). Can Pico-Union become like N.Y.’s lower east side? The Los

Angeles Times. Retrieved from http://articles.latimes.com/1997/sep/28/opinion/op-37054

Page 20: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Los Angeles Conservancy, (2010). Los Angeles history – self guided walking tour. Retrieved

from http://www.laconservancy.org/initiatives/PicoUnion_Tour_new.pdf

Loukaitou-Sideris, A. (2000). In Byzantine-Latino Quarter: Creating community in Los Angeles’

inner city. DISP 140, 36(1), 16-22.

Modarres, A. (1998). Putting Los Angeles in its place. Cities, 15(3), 135-147.

UCLA, Department of Urban Planning (1998). The Byzantine-Latino Quarter: An urban

planning comprehensive project. Retrieved from http://www.sppsr.ucla.edu/blq/history.htm

Watanabe, T. (2009, March 22). Pico-Union tour traces historical immigration patterns. The Los

Angeles Times. Retrieved from http://articles.latimes.com/2009/mar/22/local/me-pico22

Page 21: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Figures

Census 2000 Demographic Comparisons

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Renter-occupiedhousing units

High schoolgraduate or higher

Bachelor's degreeor higher

Foreign born Speak a languageother than English at

home

Families belowpoverty level

Individuals belowpoverty level

Census Category

Perc

enta

ge

Pico-UnionCity of L.A.U.S.

Figure 1. Selected Pico-Union community characteristics. Note. Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Page 22: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Figures

Figure 2. Pico-Union census tracts (yellow shaded). Note. Map adapted from 2000 Census Tract Map (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Page 23: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Tables Table 1 Ethnicity Comparisons by Category Category Pico-Union Los Angeles United States

One race 94.0% 94.8% 97.6%

White 29.8% 46.9% 75.1%

Black or African American 3.6% 11.2% 12.3%

American Indian and Alaska Native 1.4% 0.8% 0.9%

Asian 2.8% 10.0% 3.6%

Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander 0.1% 0.2% 0.1%

Some other race 56.5% 25.7% 5.5%

Two or more races 6.0% 5.2% 2.4%

Hispanic or Latino (of any race) 90.4% 46.5% 12.5%

Note. Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Page 24: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Tables

Table 2 Income Comparisons General Characteristics Pico-Union Los Angeles United States

Median household income in 1999 (dollars) $16,419 $36,687 $41,994

Median family income in 1999 (dollars) $18,032 $39,942 $50,046

Per capita income in 1999 (dollars) $9,136 $20,671 $21,587

Note. Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Page 25: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Tables

Table 3 Complete Comparisons by Category General Characteristics Pico Union Los Angeles United States Total population 17498 3,694,820 Male 51.4% 49.8% 49.1% Female 48.6% 50.2% 50.9% Median age (years) 27.6 31.6 35.3 Under 5 years 10.1% 7.7% 6.8% 18 years and over 68.1% 73.4% 74.3% 65 years and over 6.9% 9.7% 12.4% One race 94.0% 94.8% 97.6% White 29.8% 46.9% 75.1% Black or African American 3.6% 11.2% 12.3% American Indian and Alaska Native 1.4% 0.8% 0.9% Asian 2.8% 10.0% 3.6% Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander 0.1% 0.2% 0.1% Some other race 56.5% 25.7% 5.5% Two or more races 6.0% 5.2% 2.4% Hispanic or Latino (of any race) 90.4% 46.5% 12.5% Household population 96.2% 97.8% 97.2% Group quarters population 3.8% 2.2% 2.8% Average household size 3.35 2.83 2.59 Average family size 3.94 3.56 3.14 Total housing units 5467 1,337,706 Occupied housing units 92.7% 95.3% 91.0% Owner-occupied housing units 8.4% 38.6% 66.2% Renter-occupied housing units 91.7% 61.4% 33.8% Vacant housing units 7.3% 4.7% 9.0% Population 25 years and over 9654 2,308,887 High school graduate or higher 27.8% 66.6% 80.4% Bachelor's degree or higher 5.1% 25.5% 24.4% Disability status 27.4% 21.7% 19.3% Foreign born 64.1% 40.9% 11.1% Speak a language other than English at home 89.0% 57.8% 17.9% In labor force (16 years and over) 54.3% 60.2% 63.9% Mean travel time to work in minutes 34.6 29.6 25.5 Median household income in 1999 (dollars) 16,419 36,687 41,994 Median family income in 1999 (dollars) 18,033 39,942 50,046 Per capita income in 1999 (dollars) 9,137 20,671 21,587 Families below poverty level 42.3% 18.3% 9.2% Individuals below poverty level 43.8% 22.1% 12.4% Single-family owner-occupied homes 187 412,804 Median value (dollars) 155,583 221,600 119,600 With a mortgage (dollars) 1,461 1598 1,088 Not mortgaged (dollars) 235 339 295

Note. Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Page 26: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Table 4

Complete Comparisons by Category (and Census Tract)

All 6 Los UnitedGeneral Characteristics Number Percent U.S. Number Percent U.S. Number Percent U.S. Number Percent U.S. Number Percent U.S. Number Percent U.S. Tracts Angeles StatesTotal population 2,585 2,708 3,607 3,067 2,238 3,293 17498 3,694,820

Male 1,342 51.9 49.1% 1,392 51.4 49.1% 1,839 51.0 49.1% 1,621 52.9 49.1% 1,157 51.7 49.1% 1,629 49.5 49.1% 51.4% 49.8% 49.1% Female 1,243 48.1 50.9% 1,316 48.6 50.9% 1,768 49.0 50.9% 1,446 47.1 50.9% 1,081 48.3 50.9% 1,664 50.5 50.9% 48.6% 50.2% 50.9% Median age (years) 29.6 35.3 27.0 35.3 27.7 35.3 27.8 35.3 26.6 35.3 26.7 35.3 27.6 31.6 35.3 Under 5 years 255 9.9 6.8% 273 10.1 6.8% 330 9.1 6.8% 275 9.0 6.8% 272 12.2 6.8% 339 10.3 6.8% 10.1% 7.7% 6.8% 18 years and over 1,824 70.6 74.3% 1,807 66.7 74.3% 2,457 68.1 74.3% 2,133 69.5 74.3% 1,489 66.5 74.3% 2,212 67.2 74.3% 68.1% 73.4% 74.3% 65 years and over 280 10.8 12.4% 147 5.4 12.4% 364 10.1 12.4% 138 4.5 12.4% 97 4.3 12.4% 213 6.5 12.4% 6.9% 9.7% 12.4% One race 2,436 94.2 97.6% 2,502 92.4 97.6% 3,410 94.5 97.6% 2,904 94.7 97.6% 2,101 93.9 97.6% 3,111 94.5 97.6% 94.0% 94.8% 97.6% White 825 31.9 75.1% 778 28.7 75.1% 1,179 32.7 75.1% 886 28.9 75.1% 671 30.0 75.1% 865 26.3 75.1% 29.8% 46.9% 75.1% Black or African American 175 6.8 12.3% 38 1.4 12.3% 83 2.3 12.3% 172 5.6 12.3% 58 2.6 12.3% 95 2.9 12.3% 3.6% 11.2% 12.3% American Indian and Alaska Native 17 0.7 0.9% 48 1.8 0.9% 56 1.6 0.9% 48 1.6 0.9% 32 1.4 0.9% 38 1.2 0.9% 1.4% 0.8% 0.9% Asian 40 1.5 3.6% 61 2.3 3.6% 286 7.9 3.6% 27 0.9 3.6% 46 2.1 3.6% 66 2.0 3.6% 2.8% 10.0% 3.6% Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander 5 0.2 0.1% 0 0.0 0.1% 2 0.1 0.1% 0 0.0 0.1% 0 0.0 0.1% 8 0.2 0.1% 0.1% 0.2% 0.1% Some other race 1,374 53.2 5.5% 1,577 58.2 5.5% 1,804 50.0 5.5% 1,771 57.7 5.5% 1,294 57.8 5.5% 2,039 61.9 5.5% 56.5% 25.7% 5.5% Two or more races 149 5.8 2.4% 206 7.6 2.4% 197 5.5 2.4% 163 5.3 2.4% 137 6.1 2.4% 182 5.5 2.4% 6.0% 5.2% 2.4% Hispanic or Latino (of any race) 2,199 85.1 12.5% 2,543 93.9 12.5% 3,150 87.3 12.5% 2,773 90.4 12.5% 2,057 91.9 12.5% 3,083 93.6 12.5% 90.4% 46.5% 12.5% Household population 2,265 87.6 97.2% 2,708 100.0 97.2% 3,607 100.0 97.2% 2,843 92.7 97.2% 2,172 97.1 97.2% 3,293 100.0 97.2% 96.2% 97.8% 97.2% Group quarters population 320 12.4 2.8% 0 0.0 2.8% 0 0.0 2.8% 224 7.3 2.8% 66 2.9 2.8% 0 0.0 2.8% 3.8% 2.2% 2.8% Average household size 3.24 2.59 3.45 2.59 3.20 2.59 3.28 2.59 3.63 2.59 3.30 2.59 3.35 2.83 2.59 Average family size 3.75 3.14 3.99 3.14 4.07 3.14 4.03 3.14 3.93 3.14 3.84 3.14 3.94 3.56 3.14

Total housing units 769 880 1,176 935 634 1,073 5467 1,337,706 Occupied housing units 699 90.9 91.0% 785 89.2 91.0% 1,126 95.7 91.0% 868 92.8 91.0% 599 94.5 91.0% 998 93.0 91.0% 92.7% 95.3% 91.0% Owner-occupied housing units 19 2.7 66.2% 63 8.0 66.2% 186 16.5 66.2% 78 9.0 66.2% 45 7.5 66.2% 64 6.4 66.2% 8.4% 38.6% 66.2% Renter-occupied housing units 680 97.3 33.8% 722 92.0 33.8% 940 83.5 33.8% 790 91.0 33.8% 554 92.5 33.8% 934 93.6 33.8% 91.7% 61.4% 33.8% Vacant housing units 70 9.1 9.0% 95 10.8 9.0% 50 4.3 9.0% 67 7.2 9.0% 35 5.5 9.0% 75 7.0 9.0% 7.3% 4.7% 9.0%

Population 25 years and over 1,569 1,461 1,973 1,721 1,192 1,738 9654 2,308,887 High school graduate or higher 435 27.7 80.4% 376 25.7 80.4% 581 29.4 80.4% 535 31.1 80.4% 276 23.2 80.4% 512 29.5 80.4% 27.8% 66.6% 80.4% Bachelor's degree or higher 26 1.7 24.4% 96 6.6 24.4% 135 6.8 24.4% 100 5.8 24.4% 68 5.7 24.4% 73 4.2 24.4% 5.1% 25.5% 24.4% Disability status 460 22.8 19.3% 614 25.3 19.3% 972 29.5 19.3% 695 27.1 19.3% 656 32.8 19.3% 786 27.1 19.3% 27.4% 21.7% 19.3% Foreign born 1,624 62.8 11.1% 1,715 63.3 11.1% 2,469 68.5 11.1% 1,848 60.3 11.1% 1,474 64.6 11.1% 2,120 65.3 11.1% 64.1% 40.9% 11.1% Speak a language other than English at home 1,908 82.0 17.9% 2,197 90.6 17.9% 3,031 91.9 17.9% 2,465 88.4 17.9% 1,830 91.6 17.9% 2,601 89.6 17.9% 89.0% 57.8% 17.9% In labor force (16 years and over) 978 51.6 63.9% 1,129 60.1 63.9% 1,316 50.8 63.9% 1,187 53.8 63.9% 832 53.7 63.9% 1,285 56.0 63.9% 54.3% 60.2% 63.9% Mean travel time to work in minutes 39.0 25.5 36.5 25.5 34.4 25.5 29.0 25.5 34.1 25.5 34.7 25.5 34.6 29.6 25.5 Median household income in 1999 (dollars) 16,335 41,994 13,792 41,994 16,938 41,994 17,820 41,994 17,594 41,994 16,036 41,994 16,419 36,687 41,994 Median family income in 1999 (dollars) 14,954 50,046 13,750 50,046 22,054 50,046 20,754 50,046 17,241 50,046 19,444 50,046 18,033 39,942 50,046 Per capita income in 1999 (dollars) 13,152 21,587 6,857 21,587 6,999 21,587 10,709 21,587 8,944 21,587 8,158 21,587 9,137 20,671 21,587 Families below poverty level 221 44.8 9.2% 307 54.0 9.2% 253 34.5 9.2% 209 35.7 9.2% 196 41.6 9.2% 305 43.1 9.2% 42.3% 18.3% 9.2% Individuals below poverty level 1,006 44.3 12.4% 1,385 51.2 12.4% 1,388 38.7 12.4% 1,090 38.5 12.4% 972 43.6 12.4% 1,508 46.4 12.4% 43.8% 22.1% 12.4%

Single-family owner-occupied homes 11 44 13 56 26 37 187 412,804 Median value (dollars) 162,500 119,600 159,100 119,600 79,300 119,600 164,100 119,600 152,800 119,600 215,700 119,600 155,583 221,600 119,600 With a mortgage (dollars) 1,375 1,088 694 1,088 2,250 1,088 1,042 1,088 2,111 1,088 1,292 1,088 1,461 1598 1,088 Not mortgaged (dollars) 175 295 275 295 99 295 510 295 350 295 0 295 235 339 295

Note . Data extracted from 2000 Census (http://factfinder.census.gov).

Los Angeles County Census Tract2243.1 2243.22098.1 2098.2 2110.1 2242

Page 27: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Map 1

Source: http://www.sppsr.ucla.edu/blq/landuse.html

Page 28: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 29: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

200911

Structure DesignationContributing Feature

Non-Contributing Feature

Not Available

HPOZ Boundary

I

City of Los Angeles - Department of City Planning - S. Gail Goldberg, Director

0 250 500 750 1,000125 Feet

0 90 180 270 36045 Meters

Pico - UnionHistoric Preservation Overlay Zone

Ordinance 176,156Adoption Date: 08-03-2004Effective Date: 09-25-2004

CPC-2002-6297-HPOZCouncil File Index 00-1566-S2

WASHINGTON BLVD

VENICE

BLVD

PICO

BLVD

OLYMPIC

BLVD

HO

OVE

RST

ALVA

RADO

ST

18th

ST

17th

ST

18th ST

17th ST

BONN

IE B

RAE

BURL

ING

TON

UNIO

N

CONS

TANC

E

TOBE

RMAN

STTO

BERM

AN

VALE

NCIA

ALBA

NY

OAK

ST

OAK

ST

WRI

GHT

ST

BOND

S

TCH

ERRY

ST

ST

ST

ST

VALE

NCIA

ST

AVE

PLST

STPL

12th

STALVARADO TER

WESTLAKE

AVE

MAL

VERN

AVE

COUR

TLAN

D AV

E

BONN

IE B

RAE

ST

WES

TLAK

EAV

EW

ESTL

AKE

LAKE

12th

BURL

ING

TON

ST

11thG

RAND

VIE

W

ST

AVE

BONN

IE B

RAE

BEAC

ON

AVE

AVE

GRA

TTAN

ST

ST

AR

AP

AH

OE

ST

SANTA MONICA FWY.

HA

RB

OR

FW

Y

110

10

AVE

UNIO

NAV

E

ST

Includes Historic Context Statement

Page 30: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 31: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 32: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 33: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 34: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 35: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 36: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 37: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 38: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 39: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)
Page 40: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING

City of Los Angeles

HISTORIC-CULTURAL MONUMENT (HCM) REPORT

Planning Community: Westlake

Level of declaration determined by number series as follow:

0 - 999 Series = City declared monuments1000 - 1999 Series = State declared monuments

2000 - 2999 Series = Federal declared monuments

Note: Multiple listings are based on unique names and addresses as supplied by the Departments of Cultural Affairs and Building & Safety.

Last Updated: December 29, 2009

MonumentNo.

Date Adopted/Approved Monument Name Address Photo

11 01-04-1963 West Temple Apartments (The Rochester) 1012 W. Temple Street - Demolished:02-14-1979

39 06-15-1966 Residence 1425 Miramar Street

45 02-08-1967 Residence 818-822 S. Bonnie Brae Street

83 07-07-1971 Boyle - Barmore Residence 1311-1321 Alvarado Terrace

84 07-07-1971 Cohn Residence 1325 Alvarado Terrace

85 07-07-1971 Gilbert Residence 1333 Alvarado Terrace

86 07-07-1971 Powers Residence 1345 Alvarado Terrace

87 07-07-1971 Raphael Residence 1353 Alvarado Terrace

88 07-07-1971 Kinney - Everhardy House 1401 Alvarado Terrace

89 07-07-1971 Central Spanish Seventh Day Adventist Church 1366 Alvarado St & 1447-1459 Alvarado Ter

89 07-07-1971 Central Spanish Seventh Day Adventist Church 1447-1459 Alvarado Ter & 1366 Alvarado St

99 04-05-1972 Residence 1036-1038 S. Bonnie Brae Street

100 05-01-1972 General Douglas MacArthur Park (Formerly Westlake Park) 2100-2320 W. 6th Street

100 05-01-1972 General Douglas MacArthur Park (Formerly Westlake Park) 601-631 S. Alvarado Street

100 05-01-1972 General Douglas MacArthur Park (Formerly Westlake Park) 610-680 Park View Street

113 03-07-1973 Young's Market 701-709 Union Avenue

113 03-07-1973 Young's Market Building 1602-1614 W. 7th Street

129 06-19-1974 Residence 757-767 Garland Avenue

158 07-07-1976 Mary Andrews Clark Residence of the YWCA 306 Loma Drive

167 11-17-1976 Residence 826 S. Coronado Street

Monument Search Results Page http://cityplanning.lacity.org/complan/HCM/dsp_hcm_result.cfm?commun...

1 of 3 4/29/2010 10:20 AM

user
Typewritten Text
Attachment 2
Page 41: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

173 04-20-1977 Welsh Presbyterian Church 1153 S. Valencia Street

173 04-20-1977 Welsh Presbyterian Church 1501 W. 12th Street

208 01-17-1979 Residence and Carriage House 841-845 S. Lake Street

210 02-21-1979 Terrace Park and Powers Place Powers Place and 14th Street

238 04-09-1981 Granada Shopper & Studios Building 666-678 S. LaFayette Park Place

244 04-30-1981 Residence 1402 Malvern Avenue

244 04-30-1981 Residence 1866 W. 14th Street

267 06-24-1983 Park Plaza Hotel 2400-2416 W. 6th Street

267 06-24-1983 Park Plaza Hotel 603-607 Park View Street

268 06-24-1983 La Fonda Restaurant Building 2501-2511 Wilshire Boulevard

326 09-09-1987 McKinley Mansion (Former Site of) 310-312 S. LaFayette Park Place - Demolished:06-01-1994

327 09-22-1987 Thomas Potter Residence 1135-1141 S. Alvarado Street

328 09-22-1987 August Winstel Residence 1147 S. Alvarado Street

333 12-18-1987 Grieri - Musser House 403 S. Bonnie Brae Street

352 04-08-1988 Los Angeles Nurses Club 1405 Miramar Street

352 04-08-1988 Los Angeles Nurses Club 245 S. Lucas Avenue

431 05-05-1989 Residence 1851 W. 11th Street

432 05-05-1989 Doria Apartments 1600-1604 W. Pico Boulevard

433 05-05-1989 Alphonse J. Forget Residence 1047 S. Bonnie Brae Street

454 10-24-1989 Chouinard Institute of the Arts 2301 W. 8th Street

454 10-24-1989 Chouinard Institute of the Arts 737-747 Grand View Street

491 07-13-1990 Charles B. Booth Residence and Carriage House 824-826 S. Bonnie Brae Street

538 07-02-1991 David J. Witmer Family Houses and Compound 1422 W. 2nd Street & 208-210 1/2 Witmer St

538 07-02-1991 Davld J. Witmer Family Houses and Compound 208-210 1/2 Witmer Street & 1422 W. 2nd St

546 09-24-1991 Westlake Theater 634-642 S. Alvarado Street

555 03-18-1992 Mother Trust Superet Center 2506-2522 W. 3rd Street

651 05-05-1998 Filipino Christian Church 301 N. Union Avenue

653 09-18-1998 Bryson Apartments 2701 W. Wilshire Boulevard

719 10-01-2002 E.A.K. Hackett House 1317 S. Westlake Avenue

790 02-23-2005 Belmont Tunnel / Toluca Substation and Yard 1304 W 2nd St

934 09-25-2008 Park Wilshire Building 2424 Wilshire Boulevard

958 06-03-2009 Bob Baker Marionette Theater 1345 West First Street

2176 Crocker Bank 1926-1930 Wilshire Boulevard

2180 General Douglas MacArthur Park (Formerly Westlake Park) 2200 Wilshire Boulevard

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1311-1321 Alvarado Terrace

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1314 S. Bonnie Brae Street

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1317-1421 Alvarado Ter (Both Sides of St.)

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1325 Alvarado Terrace

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1333 Alvarado Terrace

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1345 Alvarado Terrace

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1353 Alvarado Terrace

Monument Search Results Page http://cityplanning.lacity.org/complan/HCM/dsp_hcm_result.cfm?commun...

2 of 3 4/29/2010 10:20 AM

Page 42: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1402 Malvern Avenue

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1866 W. 14th Street

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District Powers Place

2305 Alvarado Terrace Historic District Powers Place and 14th Street

2305 05-17-1984 Alvarado Terrace Historic District 1401 Alvarado Terrace

2312 South Bonnie Brae Tract Historic District 1023-1053 Bonnie Brae St/1819-51 W 11th St

2312 South Bonnie Brae Tract Historic District 1036-1038 S. Bonnie Brae Street

2312 South Bonnie Brae Tract Historic District 1047 S. Bonnie Brae Street

2312 South Bonnie Brae Tract Historic District 1819-1851 W. 11th Street (Both Sides of St)

2312 01-04-1988 South Bonnie Brae Tract Historic District 1851 W. 11th Street

2317 09-04-1979 Bernard and Susana Machado House and Barn 845 S. Lake Street

2337 11-20-1986 Granada Shopper & Studios Building 672 S. LaFayette Park Place

2356 06-03-1976 Frederick Mitchell Mooer's House 818 S. Bonnie Brae Street

2445 Royal Lake 2202-2220 W. 11th Street

2452 Marks Residence 1357-1359 Constance St/1709-1711 4th Street

2452 Marks Residence 1709-1711 4th St/1357-1359 Constance Street

2478 Willet Apartments 1426-1428 3/4 S. Bonnie Brae Street

2501 04-07-1983 Bryson Apartment Hotel 2701 Wilshire Boulevard

2511 05-11-1995 Los Angeles Nurses Club 245 S. Lucas Avenue

2519 Royal Lake 2200-2220 W. 11th Street

2520 Burch Residence 1805 W. 12th Place

2521 B. Bodwell Residence 926-928 W. 17th Street

2533 Cook Residence 1025 S. Westlake Avenue

2534 Wilshire - Westlake Professional Building 2001-2015 Wilshire Bl/639 S. Westlake Avenue

2534 Wilshire - Westlake Professional Building 639 S. Westlake Avenue/2001-2015 Wilshire Bl

HISTORIC-CULTURAL MONUMENT (HCM) REPORT BY PLANNING COMMUNITY

Monument Search Results Page http://cityplanning.lacity.org/complan/HCM/dsp_hcm_result.cfm?commun...

3 of 3 4/29/2010 10:20 AM

Page 43: Pico-Union - Brief Spatial Biography - Dore Burry · Dore Burry CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES Course: GEOG 432 – Metropolitan Los Angeles ... (as is still the case presently)

Attachment 3

MapID Ad Year Built Ci ST ZI PU Notes Adopted Notes1 2202 W. 11th Street 1925 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2445 Royal Lake2 1135 S. Alvarado Street 1908 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 327 9/22/1987 Thomas Potter Residence3 1147 S. Alvarado Street Los Angeles CA 90006 X 328 9/22/1987 August Winstel Residence4 1366 S. Alvarado Street 1950 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 89 7/7/1971 Central Spanish Seventh Day Adventist Church5 1025 S. Westlake Avenue 1898 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2533 Cook Residence6 1317 S. Westlake Avenue 1901 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 719 10/1/2002 E.A.K. Hackett House7 1023 S. Bonnie Brae Street 1900 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2312 1/4/1988 1023-1053 Bonnie Brae St/1819-51 W 11th St8 1036 S. Bonnie Brae Street 1895 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 99 4/5/1972 Residence9 1047 S. Bonnie Brae Street 1890 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2312 1/4/1988

10 1851 W. 11th Street 1890 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2312 1/4/1988 South Bonnie Brae Tract Historic District11 1819 W. 11th Street Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2312 1/4/1988 South Bonnie Brae Tract Historic District12 1311 Alvarado Terrace 1905 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2305 5/17/1984 Alvarado Terrace Historic District13 1317 Alvarado Terrace 1905 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2305 5/17/1984 Alvarado Terrace Historic District14 1325 Alvarado Terrace 1908 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2305 5/17/1984 Alvarado Terrace Historic District15 1333 Alvarado Terrace 1902 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2305 5/17/1984 Alvarado Terrace Historic District16 1345 Alvarado Terrace 1905 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2305 5/17/1984 Alvarado Terrace Historic District17 1353 Alvarado Terrace 1903 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2305 5/17/1984 Alvarado Terrace Historic District18 1401 Alvarado Terrace 1905 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 88 7/7/1971 Kinney - Everhardy House19 1447 Alvarado Terrace 1912 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 89 7/7/1971 Central Spanish Seventh Day Adventist Church20 1402 Malvern Avenue 1903 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 244 4/30/1981 Residence21 1314 S. Bonnie Brae Street 1907 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2305 5/17/198422 1426 S. Bonnie Brae Street 1925 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2478 Willet Apartments23 1805 W. 12th Place 1890 Los Angeles CA 90006 X 2520 Burch Residence24 1357 Constance St 1933 Los Angeles CA 90015 X 2452 Marks Residence25 1600 W. Pico Boulevard 1903 Los Angeles CA 90015 X 432 5/5/1989 Doria Apartments26 1153 S. Valencia Street 1909 Los Angeles CA 90015 X 173 4/20/1977 Welsh Presbyterian Church27 926 W. 17th Street 1880 Los Angeles CA 90015 X 2521 B. Bodwell Residence