Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS...

47
WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Permafrost carbon and its role in future carbon emissions D Carlson Director, WCRP

Transcript of Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS...

Page 1: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon and its role in future carbon emissions

D CarlsonDirector, WCRP

Page 2: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Week CenturyDecadeSeason

Observations

Models

CMIP

Page 3: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Week CenturyDecadeSeason

Climate Grand Challenges

Page 4: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrostcarbon

Week CenturyDecadeSeason

Climate Grand Challenges

Page 5: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrostcarbon

Week CenturyDecadeSeason

Climate Grand Challenges

Page 6: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrostcarbon

Week CenturyDecadeSeason

Climate Grand Challenges

Page 7: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrostcarbon

Week CenturyDecadeSeason

Climate Grand Challenges

Page 8: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

Schaefer et al. 2014Env. Res. Lett.

Page 9: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

Schaefer et al. 2014Env. Res. Lett.

Page 10: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

Schaefer et al. 2014Env. Res. Lett.

Page 11: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

Schaefer et al. 2014Env. Res. Lett.

Accumulated for 1000’s of

years

No decay while frozen

Page 12: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

0-3 m

Page 13: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

0-3 m

1,035 + 150 GtC!

Hugelius et al. 2013, ESSD

Page 14: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

0-3 m

1,035 + 150 GtC!

(1,035 GtC = 485 ppm in atmosphere)

Hugelius et al. 2013, ESSD

Page 15: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Thermokarst lakes (TKL), Alaska

Permafrost land morphology

Page 16: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Alaska: Active Layer Detachment (ALD); Surface Erosion (GTK);

Retrogressive Thaw Slump (RTS)

Permafrost land morphology

Page 17: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Alaska: Active Layer Detachment (ALD); Surface Erosion (GTK);

Retrogressive Thaw Slump (RTS)

Permafrost land morphology

Page 18: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Schuur et al. 2015 Nature

Page 19: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Schuur et al. 2015 Nature Drill

3 m

Page 20: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

(1,035 GtC = 485 ppm in atmosphere)

• Where will this carbon go? • As CO2 or as CH4? • How much, how fast?

Page 21: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

Schuur et al. 2015

Nature

Page 22: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

Schuur et al. 2015

Nature

Dry & aerobic leads to

CO2

Page 23: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon feedback

Schuur et al. 2015

Nature

Wet & anaerobic leads to CH4 & CO2

Dry & aerobic leads to

CO2

Page 24: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Schädel et al. 2016Nature Climate

Permafrost incubations

21 Studies

Compare 15oC to

5oC

Page 25: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Schädel et al. 2016Nature Climate

Permafrost incubations

21 Studies

Compare 15oC to

5oC

Increase by factor of 2

Page 26: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Lawrence et al. 2015Env. Res. Lett.

Model permafrost drying

NCAR Community Land Model, RCP 8.5

Page 27: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Model permafrost carbon loss

Lawrence et al. 2015Env. Res. Lett.

NCAR Community Land Model, RCP 8.5

Page 28: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Measure atmospheric CH4

Sweeney et al. 2016GRL

Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of continuous CH4 measurements (NOAA), months with wind from land sector

(July to December)

Page 29: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Sweeney et al. 2016GRL

Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of continuous CH4 measurements (NOAA), months with wind from land sector

(July to December)

Slight winter increase?

Measure atmospheric CH4

Page 30: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Sweeney et al. 2016GRL

Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of continuous CH4 measurements (NOAA), months with wind from land sector

(July to December)

Slight winter increase?

???

Measure atmospheric CH4

Page 31: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Sweeney et al. 2016GRL

Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of continuous CH4 measurements (NOAA), months with wind from land sector

(July to December)

Slight winter increase?

???Increase by 6oC!

Measure atmospheric CH4

Page 32: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon - best estimates

Schuur et al. 2015 Nature

Page 33: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Permafrost carbon - best estimates

Schuur et al. 2015 Nature

Approximately 100 GtC by 2100

Page 34: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

• Where will this carbon go?

• As CO2 or as CH4?

• How much, how fast?

Page 35: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

• Where will this carbon go?

• As CO2 or as CH4?

• How much, how fast?

Biology -> atmosphere

Page 36: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

• Where will this carbon go?

• As CO2 or as CH4?

• How much, how fast?

Biology -> atmosphere Erosion -> ocean

Page 37: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

• Where will this carbon go?

• As CO2 or as CH4?

• How much, how fast?

Biology -> atmosphere Erosion -> ocean

If dry -> CO2

Page 38: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

• Where will this carbon go?

• As CO2 or as CH4?

• How much, how fast?

Biology -> atmosphere Erosion -> ocean

If dry -> CO2 If wet -> CH4 (?)

Page 39: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

• Where will this carbon go?

• As CO2 or as CH4?

• How much, how fast?

Biology -> atmosphere Erosion -> ocean

If dry -> CO2 If wet -> CH4 (?)

100 GtC by 2100, 370 GtCO2 by 2100 (8 decades)

Page 40: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Upper 3 metres of terrestrial permafrost contain 1,035 + 150 GtC!

• Where will this carbon go?

• As CO2 or as CH4?

• How much, how fast?

Biology -> atmosphere Erosion -> ocean

If dry -> CO2 If wet -> CH4 (?)

100 GtC by 2100, 370 GtCO2 by 2100 (8 decades)estimate 46 GtCO2 per decade, or 140 GtCO2 by 2050

additional 18 (7 to 25) ppm by 2050.

Page 41: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

CMIP6 Scenarios - Preliminary

Very preli

minary!

Conc

entra

tion C

O2, p

pm

Riahi et al. submittedGlobal Env. Change

400 ppm in 2016?

From AR5

Page 42: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

CMIP6 Scenarios - Preliminary

Carbon from permafrost adds ~18 ppm CO2 by 2050 …

Page 43: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

CMIP6 Scenarios - Preliminary

If dry -> CO2Carbon from permafrost adds

~18 ppm CO2 by 2050 …

Page 44: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

CMIP6 Scenarios - Preliminary

If dry -> CO2

If 5% wet -> CH4

Carbon from permafrost adds ~18 ppm CO2 by 2050 …

Page 45: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

One of the urgent

questions on our planet

Page 46: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Climate challenges the human spirit

Page 47: Permafrost carbon and its role in futurebcc.ncc-cma.net/upload/userfiles/WCRP4ISCS Permafrost.pdf · WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15 Sweeney et al. 2016 GRL Barrow, Alaska (USA) - 29 years of

WCRP ISCS 2016.07.15

Huselius et al. 2013. TheNorthernCircumpolarSoilCarbonDatabase:spatially distributed datasets of soil coverage and soil carbon storage in the northern permafrost regions. Earth Syst. Sci. Data 5, 3–13.

Lawrence et al. 2015. Permafrost thaw and resulting soil moisture changes regulate projected high-latitude CO2 and CH4 emissions. doi:10.1088/1748-9326/10/9/094011

Schädel et al. 2106. Potential carbon emissions dominated by carbon dioxide from thawed permafrost soils. DOI: 10.1038/NCLIMATE3054

Schaefer et al. 2014. The impact of the permafrost carbon feedback on global climate. doi:10.1088/1748-9326/9/8/085003

Schuur et al. 2015. Climate change and the permafrost carbon feedback. doi:10.1038/nature14338

Sweeney et al. 2016. No significant increase in long-term CH4 emissions on North Slope of Alaska despite significant increase in air temperature. DOI: 10.1002/2016GL069292

Papers referenced in this talk: