Passivation BasicsYour Guide to the StePS, SPecificationS and SucceSS of thiS critical ProceSS

By Brian Sutton and Cheryl Larkin, Miraclean

hat i s commonly referred to as “passivat-ing” on a shop floor

is actually just enhancement of a naturally occurring process on most stainless steels. Typically used for applications where picture-perfect finish is critical and contamination may cause performance failure, the process provides a two-in-one: cosmetically pleasing surface and top-of-the-line performance. Medical device finishing (think implants and surgical tools) as well as aerospace components are top candidates, but so are everyday items like the stainless steel cutlery found in your kitchen.

When there’s a risk of contamina-tion on or corrosion of the stainless steel surface, the passivation pro-cess eliminates the risk by forming a chemically inert passive surface layer or film (thereby reducing the reactivity of the

steel), which occurs when the stain-less steel is exposed to an oxygen environment.

The success of this natural passive film formation can be compro-mised, however, by contaminants (dirt, oils, grease, compounds, scale) and by the presence of free iron on the part surface. So an organized shopfloor passivation process is designed to remove these contaminants and produce clean, corrosion-resistant stainless steel parts.

Minimizing the potential for con-tamination and corrosion on stain-less steel parts and devices can be critical for safety and performance and is often required in industries such as aerospace and medical

devices, among others.

the PaSSivation ProceSSIn all cases, cleaning is the first step in the passivation process, although in some shops the clean-ing may take place in a separate process line or cell. The type of cleaning required depends on the contaminants, the soil loading, the degree of cleanliness required, and the part geometry. Cleaning to remove deposited contaminants such as dirt and grease may involve swabbing, vapor degreasing, spray, or immersion with or without ultra-sonics and/or agitation. The clean-

ing chemistry or detergent should be appropriate for

W

the passivation process provides a two-in-one: cosmetically pleasing surface and top-

of-the-line performance.

Reprinted From: Products Finishing Magazine

the type of soil to be removed and should be handled in accordance with safety and environmental regulations. If descaling (removal of heavy oxide films from heat treating or welding, or heat tint) is necessary, pickling or electropolish-ing followed by thorough rinsing may be required, and subsequent passivation with nitric or citric acid may not be indicated (Need specifics? Refer to ASTM A380 and B254).

In a multiple station immersion passivation line, the process often begins with one or more cleaning tanks equipped with ultrasonics and filtration, possibly agitation or indexed rotation (if part geometry or soil loading suggests this would help), and a water-based clean-ing chemistry or detergent. Parts should be arranged in baskets, fixtures, racks or indexing equip-ment to optimize solution contact with all critical surfaces in each step, even in the case of complicated part geometries.

Immediately after the cleaning station, there are one or more rinse stations, which again, may be equipped with mechanical actions such as ultrasonics, agitation, index-ing, and/or spray off to facilitate good rinsing. Counter-flow rinsing techniques and automatic make- up devices help maximize water use, conservation and consistency.

nitric or citric?Following the cleaning steps,

the acid stage of the passivation process involves controlled contact between the cleaned stainless steel parts and the diluted nitric or citric acid according to one of several possible recipes defined in speci-fications such as ASTM A967 and AMS2700C. The purpose of this step is to remove any free iron and foreign contaminants that remain after completion of the previous cleaning and rinsing steps.

When possible, the passivation

in a multiple station immersion passivation line, the process often begins with one or more cleaning tanks equipped with ultrasonics and filtration, possibly agitation or indexed rotation.

Regardless of which acid is des-ignated, chemistry-appropriate equipment (both personal protec-tive and process) should be used during the process, and handling, storage, and disposal of the selected acid must be in accordance with fed-eral, state, and local regulations.

thorouGh rinSinGThe passivation bath is followed

immediately by one or more rinses—spray, immersion or a combination—depending on spec-ifications, part geometry and water conservation philosophy. Again, more rinses set up to counter-flow provide superior rinsing and, at the same time, conservation. Some-times a neutralization step (such as 5% sodium hydroxide) or a post-treatment step (typically sodium dichromate) may also be indicated, again followed immediately by rins-ing. The final rinse should be fed with “clean water,” with deionized (DI) or reverse osmosis (RO) water being good choices to prevent spot-ting. Rinsed parts are immediately dried. In scenarios where particle counts are critical, the dryer can be outfitted with a high efficiency

step involves full immersion of the parts in a passivation bath. The bath should be large enough to allow for solution movement around and throughout the load, which can be further enhanced with recircula-tion and/or ultrasonics. Make sure all equipment associated with the passivation step is compatible with the selected acid.

Acid concentration, bath tem-perature and contact time are all proportionate in the passivation recipes and are critical to suc-cessfully achieving specifications. These process parameters can be monitored either manually or automatically in systems that are so equipped, and long-term data storage is available.

Nitric acid has been the tra-ditional acid of choice for this passivation step, although both ASTM A967 and AMS2700C allow for the use of citric acid. In recent years, citric acid has gained ground because it’s friendlier than nitric acid in terms of safety and environ-mental considerations. It can also produce shorter cycle times. Citric acid passivation is generally consid-ered acceptable as long as it meets stipulated specifications and the buyer’s requirements, including successful passivation test results. Some shops are even expanding their capabilities by setting up pas-sivation lines that have both nitric and citric passivation tanks followed by dedicated rinses.

PaSSivation StandardS

For many types of parts and industries, including many military specifica-tions, ASTM standards A380 and A967 (astm.org) provide the guidelines for good passivation practice. These standards detail acceptable methods and/or recipes for passivating stainless steel and provide tests for measuring passivation success. AMS2700C (sae.org) establishes acceptable passiva-tion methods and/or recipes, practices, and test protocols for aerospace, and supersedes AMS-QQ-P-35 (cancelled in 2005 although sometimes still referenced by purchasers).

Passivation lines can be equipped with bar coding and data managment features.

Reprinted from PRODUCTS FINISHING Magazine April 2010 and Copyright © 2010 by Gardner Publications, Inc., 6915 Valley Ave., Cincinnati, Ohio 45244-3029

particulate air filter (HEPA), or the whole process can be conducted in an appropriate class clean room setting.

PaSSivation equiPmentThe optimum equipment for

batch immersion passivation is a manual or automated process line consisting of a continuous series of tanks. Lot volumes and throughput requirements influence tank size as well as the number of process stations recommended to meet production goals. The number of required processes also impacts the number of process stations. A continuous automated line, for example, may feature cleaning, pickling, and passivating in one line, each with dedicated rinses, with PLC controlled programs for each process and parallel or random operation as desired. A number of safeties includ-ing push-pull exhaust, enclosures, light curtains, and secondary contain-ment are also available, as well as statistical process control, bar coding, and data management.

PaSSivation SucceSSSuccessful passivation

is typically determined by inspection and test-ing. Once passivating is finished, and the parts are rinsed and dried, they should be completely free of surface defects. Pitting, etching, frosting and stain-ing would all be indicative of the possible presence of free iron. Post-passivation, parts can be tested for free iron as required by the specifications or purchaser

® Ashville, NY 14710Tel. 716.763.4343www.miraclean.com

• ultrasonic cleaning,• passivation (nitric or citric),• electropolish, and• automated liquid penetrantinspection systems

• and develops aqueouscleaners, corrosion inhibitors,and custom racks and fixturesfor a wide range of cleaningand passivating applications.

Miraclean® designs,builds & programs:

to verify passivation success. These tests can include water immersion, high humidity, salt spray, or copper sulfate, among others, performed in accordance with ASTM A967 and/or AMS2700C. n

For more information from Mira-clean, call 716-763-4343 or visit miraclean.com.