p}°' .I H TH E SUPRE ME COURTOF T HE STAT£ DF F LORIDA

ARb LE£ ELLtdoobPertTioMEk Skktda.:

Y. bCh ., Ljò j$-L|||

DCA ! Nhl& Ll354THE STATE OF Fla®A LT. o.: ia-oross9cr og

REPoND£tar / LT No 12- ol500KF1D Acc O

PETIT10N FoR W RIT OF W AREAs coRf%

CoMes Novo, Ricuned Les E ttcoood, Pe_rtTioueg ,

ase- A»b Moves ms HoMoenat SuPrett Cover

or PtoatoA, ½R rssu¾NCE oF A R/T OF//ASEAS

doR Pos OR caHER £xrRA ORb iNARN Weir~ BE£NEb

APPRDRRiâTE PREDtCATEb UPoN wit etAIM SET FORTI-l

1-lEREld Aub tu vuRTHERAMCE. 71/ERE.oF C000LD STAT£

THL FOLLOLulM6

Ti41s CouRTs TuRisbicTlo s r9vorsb PoRsuAMT

To A RTicLE1 , Secmop 3 c) F -it floRlÞA CoAlsTl707/oA/

ANb F.S.A. '77.01 w#retAs THE ctA portr/as

ÑEUEF BEAR upon GoVeRAMeMT MI5 doMbOCT doMTRARV

To 'TN E. Due. �570RoCeSS C--L AU5e_ oF THE floRIMblT0flod,

.HlSTOfM

915 ACTtou ARt.S£5 FRoM THE SEVElJTETATH

-Jubici AL C- tRtu tT C_o0RT l u Aub voR 8RotoaRB

CouNw/, FLoelDA . Tubate rs Reusegen oo Tae

bey or OcToseR,20l3 g»d se»Tesoces

IMfbseb THE. sAme. DATE ,

�254S�254W �254Re_TOeC,oTl AT£b PL�254A.sic oorH cAses

DINTLN |M THAT THE PETITloMER to0Lb MoT /|ccePT

& PleA OF MO yeARS TbTAL lid c_Ase.. gangeg

13-D10589 C-F i b A U M LeSS W e_ A LSo AtteprgD 7pg

O ye6R coMcoRReMT PteA ip case gomsg /2-O/500

W FIOA . One PteA woutb yor wogg g>,7poor -jpg

OTHER . fuR PURPOSes OF ÞPPeAL THey HAvg geen

consoubwrtb sy rat fouery bisraer (mew A pire-,

h No breect get was weò

Fiesr 3.Er50 nario» was vite. os/is/poiy nunC23

»EMtED o,à 07 / to /acN.

3.1 Nortce- 09 APæAt Fited og Dt/cg/ao/V MD bew/ad

on D2 /13|a0/5 B¥ 71/t P" b.C.A.

D Secoub 3.ír60 Fiteb oo D1/27 /AO/6 AND beA//£ò

o» 08 /Ol /20/6 .

cric.e- or A PPeAL FiLeb 09 \ Ö / R3 /20/6 A Mb

DENttb wiTH A T14ReAT OF 8eflGC, SA MC.T|oü£b wm

A BAR oN l tof£ F/uN65

Bl T-og PuRfbse or APPeAt. , 9ErmoMcR Ftteb TD WAVE

c.Ass. NomBeAs 12-Dl5DD'ICF10A Aub 13-D/0689dF/CA

CONSoub8TEb ¡N 17/RT TH£ Alesorid7sb Pien wgs one.

AMb THE SRMe- . DMe- cootn soT Be.. RttePTtb tAl%dT

TWE oTHER oMt Be.14 6 AccePrtb

GiTRIE.MENT Bf CLAIM

Tuo P£rmoMER Ho THE PResear cAses Bem6 @war

GCPOR�254THIS Most Howoea ste. or Cooars Tat FtoeidA

SU?REM£ CoueT WtTH HIs WrrioM FOR NflIT oP ||AWAS

cpus osotN A bbResses oue- issue. TNar is A d.teAR[ 3]

hMD ÜNREFUTRBl.e_. , PROOF fostTIVE, ON 7}/E F4ce oF

'fM£_ RecoRb R»b IopbAMedTALLy 1Ltecat sy Tu(

V�254RHMoRbS WR/TIDO of 71}L LeAb beTECnV�254R/AA)

Koents ix weirt»s AND is sæctw To 8e THE TRUTH

UNDER TitE. PENAL7y op �040grJO Ry q ¿3 coppess fog 79

ThE VF.e( SE/MOUS OF AcT5 (CRimes) T///rT A 60V�254Rh}-

M�254CMLOFPltt&L CAM PORTRRY OPoo A CIT/-2.ed oF

THE UNITEb S7ATEs eT Ameeica n»n Tat Geerr STa,t

or FLdRlbA ToR WE SoUe. PuRfb5L OF 08FAINIMC-, A

conutcTion (se-e- NTrscritb ExHos1TD geizew AbbResse

As EXlftBir --E TelAT is Ao oFFicí A t 79eibeh!T RePoRT

WITH NARRATwE FRom THE. C.oRAL SFWINGS Rute Desk

Aub werrreo sw DerscT/rs Bg/4M KoEN/6,D. W6

Aub swoRu -ro A»b sue,6tRietb To Beroee Ssr. C,Aev

ScHttTz., Lt S SW ou T/ic #Y* Bay or Iow 20l3 av

b9: /3 o'CLodI< wHeRetr) . eTECTiv£ Bein» Koe»is usven

His towvesSlo4 To THE VEtw -ILLEGAL use- oF

GoveRumeNT owpeb ELtcTRceic_ Eau emeoT ( A

RRW Ab AMS btc,tTRL A C.QoIRe_ STAT1oO ) To

TAKe. Au ELECTRoMtt MAit MessR6e Taar wAs

DISTRIBUTEL By ELEcrRoalt meAròS (htso CALLeb

E-MMLh R pb ELECTRONltnLLY TORiù THAT E -HAlL

iloTb FRRubuteATTLY FALs\Fl£D DoCOMe47,5 OseB

BY THE ASStSTRNT STRTE ÆlTbEMeY TD c6TßlM

ILL�254GALCordVtCT(oUS A6AltùS7 W PET/77ml£ oF

TI-ÚS P277T/a) FOR \A/flir op //d&s4S CoRR)5 . |-|hb Til£

PETITloOER I<OooùM TflAT Mo ORistpAL Geøoloe,

AMD AoTHEMic. LETTElls ExtSTEb He. toootb weg

t½ve. PteAb GuitTy To & Mec:oT1AT£D PleA AMD

1400Lb HAVE Go Mt To TRt AL. THcee is no

OR\ CNhl G eOU tü t_ Arab f;uTHisNit. Et/(bDJce.

LN) LOR\TER GM THE. PET1T) oOER t M THE R$$esSlo

OF AMM C¬cueRMmeOT AL OFFicl8L tao g |-IAs wcet

EV'ER BeER SMM Sotl4 EVt berdc�254ANb THE SMTL

ATroRNEY C.AMMoT PRobote a boc.omedeb cHAlù oF

0-OSTobM £_ITHER . THs. STAw Arromey ans eMty

E sl

RAUDVle>JTLN FALSiFi ED E Vi beMCe_ t9 T11eift

Possesstor0. Tae_ eeTrnoceR ms RAtseb Tats tssoe_

ee A MoTIce Poa 9:>sT- Coovemog Reu £F 3 MO As

A Disco/EfW V t otr+Tl o M oMLY Tb Ge -173..D Gy TNE

STATT. ATTbgxief ià -n4EIR FI/tsT ReS/645�254THAT

(QudDMÒ " Trie_ RLteGRTIoM oE THE bePeaba47 or

A o AlleGeh DISCO|/EiN VloLAT)od 1S LeUILLY

^I©SUPP tC.\eñT, GeCAUSE He_ FA/LS 7b All@GE. A Öd756R.

SKTUbice . ($te GIW71T[ & ,Q src7m 3

IS PeTTTlooeR WAS LeAD To Ge-LIEVE 77/4T BY

US IN G TME C,UtbE ttME LAN odf oF A GLANK 3.y60

THAT THE eov/2T vòodLD klGeRALLY coMSTRU£. HLs ELAIM

AMD 'IMVEST16&TE t r, MoT t4oLD W l M TD T14E Sa%

STAMbhRBS y & R O_Rtrm µg(TRie t katoyeg agcguse

ae- t¾b ReAn Tue. cases or UncrtbSTr+Tes V.

CJtopic_ , 9 6b U.S. 698, t04 S.G. 203Ci 20 4.U. 41

661 Ú%D ; Noeran V Swre , Tr51 so2d (ba (nr

2* b CA acc8) nun Haeces V Regaeg, Jo / US.5/�041

L 63

91 S. Cr. 594 , 30 L EJ Act 662 úm) atso wt_

DIRfCTio4 s 7b THE GLAOR FORm HL OBTAleth F/Rom

THE bAttTroeMT OF Corutecn04S LND L181?AEy

T%T STPTEb '. Ctwón»c,½ * CpRourob Det! SumeRrze_

TE 0-LAlm WIThooT ttTir¾ AMM CMELbALU AS

Cot�2541Se.LNAS Vou cAR.

AR60M£MT / CoA>cuKinAl

boV£RMme/dTAL Mis co/GbucT 13 Alò¼Timt. AM

A C,EMT O F IN boVERtùmerJTAL ItC,eJGC_M CReATes ,

PRODUCe_S, OR MRMUFACTURe3 FRAubVLe#Jr

E.V IDeMC�254-USP_D Solf-LM TD 0%l2 A CoMVlCDutù-

Itt£- McPA FACT T1Wr TM£. AssisTaor STATE_

ktroroce-t PReseaTEB THs_ Pottc-e_. MaeUFacroRe,e

PRAUBUte sr LeTrtas w Twt. Courcr Aub Tut.

Permo»ER eN weH OF Lisn»6 Teem motTiete Times

t o weR bistc*ç;ty Exttiair (see- ExHierr2II seæ,Ò

cousTiTorts vanon oa»a Tat cauar Arab Ao

UNREFUTABLt.. VIOLAT/oA.) OF TME 9eTlTroide£S

D3

38 bb \'im AmembmeMTs on THe- ܻtwb STATes

consri Tort où be e_ �060cess Ruwrs . THE FRcr

THRT THt Asstsraer S a t ATreasex x»eta Tsar

He Fr>ssessen c c>ec,mat, ceooiot, Aub Acmeuit

LeTre£s is Reveessut ERRort, WL H6b To Km-O

RtAose_ ir is µ¡S DUW TO KMou3 WHPFr ÍS là

His Fices Ar Act T7mes, wHerHER WE FILes f¾e.

i» t4is íbssessica ott THE_ (bssessloa 01: A6e rs

OF THE bV6RMMeMT. THis c.ourtT Ne2D »oT cc

A»N FuRTHER THa» tis ocòe Ruu»6s. h STmE V

BRuroc, 314 So 2J 1% CFtA. \976) ; BocHe£

STATE., 603 So2ct 787 ( FU¼ , \9%Ñ w He£et d TÉS

cauaT aetb t Faaub upoa Tas Courr c,oes To ut

VERM C_oRe ce coev o seaeve

ResfbNSI 8te, FOR DePRWIM6 A DeFeMD4MT o F

Liaeary og Peon,y

ws eerrrione£ sas e en w caco,r e

�523Tut Seve»TeeeTa I c caecorr ao neC63

bARD CouAfrY , LottIDA AMb THE foue7h D/ST£lCT

d.auttr op Á P9°AL To goth nu Evibeæ«w fleAtuus

Ve7 ru£ P£77 rfonc£s cA/£s For Jos-nce Facts upof0

besW EMLs , h STs,1V· CAMoon, 5 7 So 3d ff92 Ô¼.

DCA 20lb CtuoTlM6 THE WORDS OF 7NIS |lopoKA6t�254

CooeT E CoovtsvneAT H tscou b ucT ,HiTr YlotArts A

DeFedb4NT3 Due. ÊltoEtSS Rl9&T.5 UMDf4 u)£iTIS

Co»sTirurtou ReQuoees bisiwssilt of desirvaAL ÔMeses ,"

AMbERsoo STATt , 579 & JJ 87, 92 (FM. 89 Ò .

7tft Ifdttbe>Jr REPoRT (£×Rt8rr2.) HAs Fece

AGEAEIES ANb SK Tubtvlbvat PeoPle. FoR A

-ToTAL OF T90 MISSifùG N6Mes FR.oM TH£. STATÉ

hstov'eRN Ex½t ßtT (ExH18FF 111.) THFIT be poT

A9PEAR ðQ Tat A Lisr , B usr soa C usr of

10ITXIeSSe S i:.aHo HAVe.- D)Fotin6non TM RT SnoOLb 8t

LJST�254¤wt7Win 7)f£ DiscovEet Í×HISIT Mfr// Nf15 TWE

Po7wTIAL TO LOO/4 AS ZF THE Srn,t Arria»ev

AlevEtt IstroJb£b FoR. 7hE. Tex.:bepT Re8oRT r4rB/r

C93

TD GP- AckæL£bGeß B¼ TML PETrnoMex.

TÉts Í O lTs setF CMts Post T+lt Per/noue(s

NeGoTIA7tb Ptees 7b Ge- V6cWTeb , ~Ttte perrrMøe(

HRS A Co STrrori ounc.- Id /6HT 70 Pinxe 4 bl£i5/04

To ACCEPT A AleGoT187th Paa 77/AT |5 Bassb æbr)

TRUTHFUL INR>ett#Tiori seiac, paw ne ey mg_

STATE ATroRMeN u)H(c>f t4 e- W AS teT A FFORbED IM

~Titese cases in viourriox) op iiis G

bb M'" /kevnearm be &cess or 7»t hth

STmss Con3Teromoc.

tl6R�254Fbt , THE. PETTTl oNER PtSK THÆr THIS

MoRABU2, OF COURTs T+1t SveResne Couer o e

LDÈlb & , DSv�254.fTS LdRIT o F A sees cc pas

Có'RACl9 G THe. PET17t orde( A L L ReuBF #e /5 Enr/ 72e 6

Tò , TMcLobia6 VActTr/N6 /Às JubGMem¯S AMh

Se»Te^3CeS A»b Seiv bt»6 7?tese cAses ßRcM ro ni£

T(ttAL Cou «T FOR. TR I AL or THese. cAses w InicoT

Tf/E IR�2546ALLé7Ts2S Behv6 P£es&JTsb t» 77tr CauctC 103

bbVeôOlYleßTAL ts COMDUCT CAdtd c5T ge PeRJntTEéb TD

c o oraResotveb 89 Turs Hosr Naaoreae &ar.

RicllMD A�254eELLuladh Obb(1||

AMO9 / Ú_�254fEOPICA7EOF OG/lC�254.

HlWIU6 genh THE Poe�060aC»STMTEmeurs caJ®ueh u) TNis

PETITioAlf I SweAIC OMb2/L PeN4LTY oir R£Tußt Att ST47£b

I.S TRu £. Rab cattltscr, ?væMT TD Fa fMtf916Ñ;Q ,'

swt V. s HeAcee, 62r so M Ho2 (rc4. m3), Aub cemw 4

TKut aéò coatteer coPY oF THfS PETIT/oA) //)5 BEEA/ Fe/Mis/KD

BS D.S. Mait To omce or ,wt Amu/ev 6eveuc, beé

oe Lesu AFFRites , IS/SÑ Ñ&el be. �540virt �570O, hiesY

Pnn Besce, R. 3340I T S bav oF T 901b

©cHARD LEe- ELLwab Ob6v/l

TeFF£ILSQD c.T . Ak109 e

1660 ßlG Tot ß©AbMcWricetto Flov/>A 323'l¥

Ct 1 Springs Police DepartmerG 3 Rep.: 07/te,20 3

. Incident Report cao s 01. 3a5s7

I Case # Report Occurred From Occurred To Report TypeN 01-13.004587 07/19I2013 11:51 SUPPLEMENTC Dept. Classification Case Status case Status Datel MURDER ATTEMPTED CLEARED BY ARREST (FEL 07/15/2013

Common Navne .E CORAL SPRINGS, FL (BROWARD County)

Incident Type : FELONY Total Stolen Property Value : $0.00Total Damaged Property Value : 50.00 Total Recovered Property Value : $0.00

N Topic SUPPLERAENTAR THIS CASE WAS FORWARDED TO THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE FLORIDAR REGIONAL FUGITIVE TASK FORCE FOR ASSISTANCE IN LOCATING AND APPREHENDINGA ELLWOOD.T

INFORMATION WAS OBTAINED THAT ELLWOOD WAS POSSIBLY STAYING IN AN ABANDONEDE HOUSE THAT HE PREVIOUSLY OWNED AT 17790 NW 48TH COURT NORTH IN LOXAHATCHEE

FL. A CHECK OF THAT RESIDENCE WAS NEGATIVE.

ON97/10/2013, I WAS CONTACTED BY DETECTIVE BRIAN CHRISTIE OF THE BROWARDSHERIFPS OFFICE. DETECTIVE CHRISTIE INFORMED ME OF A RESIDENTIALBURGLARY/GRANDTHEFT AUTO CASE THAT HAD OCCURRED NEAR THE AREA OFELLWOOD'S PREVIOUS RESIDENCE IN LOXAHATCHEE ON 06/26/2013. DETECTIVE CHRISTIEINFORMED ME THAT DETECTIVE HUMAN OF THE PALM BEACH SHERRIFPS OFFICE WASINVESTIGATING THE CASE (PBSO CASE #13-090031). . -

I CONTACTED DETECTIVE HUMAN WHO INFORMED ME THAT THE VICTIM OF THERESIDENTIAL BURGLARY HAD INFORMED HIM THAT A WALLET STOLEN DURING THEBURGLARY HAD BEEN RETURNED TO THE VICTIM AFTER BEING FOUND BY A STATETROOPER IN TENNESSEE. DETECTIVE HUMAN FURTHER ADVISED THAT THE VICTIM'SSTOLEN VEHICLE HAD A SUNPASS INSIDE THE VEHICLE AT THE TIME OF THE THEFT.

I THEN CONTACTED JENNFIER NATTER, THE NORTH BROWARD REGIONAL INVESTIGATORNITH THE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION AND ASKED HER TO CHECK TOLL PLAZACAMERAS FOR THE STOLEN VEHICLE (GRAY HYUNDAI, FL TAG E18 2KV). NATTER LATERSENT ME AN EMAIL WITH SEVERAL PHOTOGRAPHS TAKEN FROM TOLL PLAZAS BEVNEENPALM BEACH COUNTYAND LEESBURG FLORIDA ON 06/26/2013, DEPICTING THE STOLENVEHICLE AND THE DRIVER OF THE VEHICLE, WHO WAS RICHARD ELLWOOD. I FORWARDEDTHE EMAIL WITH THE PHOTOGRAPHS TO DETECTIVE HUMAN.

ON 07/15/2013, SPECIAL AGENT LOUIS KUYKENDALL OF THE TENNESSEE BUREAU OFINVESTIGATIONS ALONG WITH OTHER MEMBERS OF THE USMS MIDDLE TENNESSEEFUGITIVE TASK FORCE AND THE MACON COUNTY SHERIFPS OFFICE, LOCATED ANDARRESTED RICHARD ELLWOOD AT HIS MOTHER'S RESIDENCE AT 1982 HANESTOWN ROADIN A RURAL AREA NEAR WESTMORELAND, TENNESSEE. AT THE TIME OF THE ARREST, THE .PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED STOLEN VEHICLE WAS ALSO RECOVERED AT THE SAME

Ofßcor se arting signed and hereby sworn to Urdt Report Status:DET BRIA 4 KOENIG (786) CIU ApprovedVerifying 1mploV88 Data/Tline ..

Sworn to and subscribed before me Unit Dato /TlineSGT GARY SCHEETZ (544) . Clu 07/24/2013 Olt13 c

EXHIBir T ' "'IJ1

Ce 1 Springs Police Departmeri R.port omeaa 3Incident Report case e os.1s-co4ss7

LOCATION. láLLWOOD WAS REAU MlHANDA HK3HIB BY KUYKENDALLAT THE TIME OF HISARREST. ELLWOOD STATED THAT HE UNDERSTOOD AND WAIVED HIS RIGHTS. POSTMIRANDA, ELLWOOD TURNED OVER THREE HAND WRITTEN LETTERS THAT WEREADDRESSED TO STEPHANIE BALME. KUYKENDALL PHOTOGRAPHED THESE LETTERS ANDEMAILED THE PHOTOGRAPHS TO ME. I SAVED THE PHOTOGRAPHS AND ACQUIRED THEMAS ASSETS AND STORED THEM AS EVIDENCE USING A FORAY ADAMS DIGITAL ACQUIRESTATION. IN THE LETTERS, ELLWOOD CONFESSED TO FIRING A GUN AT THE VICTIM, BUTALLEGED HE ACCIDENTALLY FIRED THE WEAPON.

ELLWOOD WAS TRANSPORTED TO THE MACON COUNTY SHERIFPS OFFICE PENDINGEXTRADITION TO BROWARD COUNTY. THIS CASE IS CLEARED BY ARREST AT THIS TIME.

knd of Nanahve: i

Omcor reporung signed and hereby sworn to Unit Report Status:DET BRIAN KOENIG (786) Clu ApprovedVerifying Empicyee DatafTime

Swom to and subscribed befose me Unit Date ITimeSGT GARY SCHEETZ (544) Clu o7124/2013 09:13

2 W 2

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OFTHE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIALCIRCUIT IN AND FORBROWARD COUNTY, ELORIDA

STATE OF FLORIDA ) CASE NO. : 13-10589 CF10A

)

) JUDGE: BACKMANv.

RICHARD LEE ELLWOOD )

Defendant _)

RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT' S MOTION FOR

POST-CONVICTION RELIEF

COMES NOW, the State of Florida, by and through the

undersigned Assistant State Attorney, and responds to the

Defendant' s Motion for Post-Conviction Relief, pursuant to

Fla. R. Crim. P. 3. 850, and the Order of this Honorable Court, as

follows:

1. The allegations of the defendant that he was coerced into

entering the plea in this matter is refuted by the record. The

change of plea transcript (Exhibit I) reflects that the Court asked

the defendant if anyone threatened the defendant into entering his

change of plea, and the defendant stated that no one had threatened

him to change his plea (Exhibit I, pp. 13-14). The defendant was

also indicated that he felt that accepting the plea bargain

E Bil

is what he wanted to do, was in his best interest, and that

no one was "twisting his arm" to accept the plea

( Exhibit I, p. . 9) . Additionally, the plea form ( Exhibit I I ) , which

was adopted and ratified during the change of plea (Exhibit I, pp.

6-8, 17-18), reflects that no one coerced the defendant into

changing his plea. Since the record conclusively refutes the

allegation of the defendant, relief must be summarily denied.

Alfred v. State, 7} So.3d 138 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011); Scheele v.

State, 953 So.2d 782 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007).

2. The allegation of the defendant that he was on psychotropic

medication at the time of the plea is without merit. This.Court

asked the defendant if he was on medication, and the defendant

stated that he was not (Exhibit I, p. 8) . Additionally, the change

of plea transcript refutes the allegation of the defendant that he

did not understand the procceedings (Exhibit I) . Since the record

conclusively refutes the allegations of the defendant, relief must

be summarily denied. Ezer v. State, 10 So.3d 1175 (Fla. 4th DCA

2009); Iacono v. State, 930 So.2d 829 (Fla. 4th DCA 2006).

3. The allegation of the defendant of an alleged discovery

violation is legally insufficient, because he fails to allege a

material prejudice. Duggan v. State, 588 So.2d 1054 (Fla. 1st DCA

1991) . Regardless, the transcript of the change of plea reflects

that the defendant knew and understood that there would be no

further pretrial discovery proceedings nor would there be a jury

2

trial by changing his plea (Exhibit I, pp. 12-13, 15-17) .

4. Although not perfectly pled, it appears that the defendant

is alleging that the sentencing order in this matter and it case

number 12-15004 CF should be running concurrently. The plea forms

in both matters reflect that the sentences on all cases and counts

are to run concurrently (Exhibits II and III) . The sentencing

orders, however do not reflect that the sentences are running

concurrently, which means that the defendant is serving consecutive

sentences (Exhibits IV and V). F.S. § 921.16. The plea transcript

notes that the plea form reflects the understanding of the

defendant as to the length of the sentences (Exhibit I, pp. 17-18) .

The fact that the sentencing transcript does not reflect that the

sentences in this matter and 12-15004 CF are not running

concurrently seems to be an oversight. Consequently the State

agrees that the sentencing orders in this matter and 12-15004 CF

should be corrected to reflect that the sentences are running

concurrently.

WHEREFORE, the State of Florida:

1. Respectfully requests that the Motion for Post-Conviction

Relief should be denied.

2. That the sentencing order in this matter and in case number

12-15004 CF be corrrected to reflect that the sentences as to both

matters are running concurrently.

3

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of the foregoing was furnished by

U.S. Mail to Richard Lee Ellwood, Defendant, Pro Se, CIS

#501403884, Broward County Jail, P.O. Box 9356, Fort Lauderdale,

Florida 33310, this 7th day of July, 2014.

MICHAEL J. SATZState Attorney

By:4dDEL SILVERSHEINAssistant State AttorneyFlorida Bar #608092Room 660201 S.E. 6th StreetFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301Telephone (954)831-7913courtdocs@sao17.state.fl.us

4

HENillERIXA 7 1 9. 7 4 ,

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT INAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA

CASE NO: 13010589CF10AJUDGE: PAUL L. BACKMAN

STATE OF FLORIDA

Plaintiff .:v. .

: STATE' S DISCOVERYRICHARD ELLWOOD : EXHIBIT

Defendant :

COMES NOW the State of Florida, by and through the undersignedAssistant State Attorney, and pursuant to the provisions of Rule3.220, Florida Rules of Critninal Procedure and in recognition ofthe Defendant' s election to participate in discovery, submitsthe following information:

1. The names. and addresses of all persons presently known tothe prosecutor to have information that may be relevantto any offense charged, or any defense thereto are:

A ALLEN, AMY 2801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVECORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065

A BALME, STEPHANIE 9635 NW 4TH ST

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 99999A BRANDT, JEFF 6346 MOONSTONE WAY

DELRAY BEACH, FL 33484A CABALLERO, RAFAEL 2801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVE .

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065A CAPPLIS, WILLIAM 2801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVE

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065A CAPRE, FRANCIS 2801 CORAL SPRINGS .DRIVE

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065- A COUPE, ROBERT 2801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVE

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065A CRUZ, MARIA 9641 NW 4TH ST

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33071A GRIMMER, LISA 9609. NW 4TH ST

2B

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33071A HOEHENBERGER, MICHAEL 9609 NW 4TH ST 2B

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33071A HORNE, JAMES 2801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVE

The State incorporates by reference any individual(s) listed in the police report(s), any witness statement(s) anddepositions(s) relevant to the offenses charged herein.

Rev 11/10 Original = Clerk Copy = Defense Counsel Copy=SAO File DCS

EX14 i R iT Ttt , ,,

STATE'S DISCOVERY ExtIIBIT rage 2 of 4STATE v. RICHARD ELLWOOD Case: 13010589CFI OA

A JOHNSON, KENNETH

A KOENIG, BRIAN

A KUYKENDALL, LOUIS

A MCCOMBS, MARCUS

A MICHAUD, ERIC

A MILETSKY, WILLIAM

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065

2801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVECORAL SPRINGS, FL 330652801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVECORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065901 R. F. GAFF BLVDTN BUREAU INVESTIGATIONSNASHVILLE, TN 372169641 NW 4TH STCORAL SPRINGS, FL 330719635 NW 4TH STCORAL SPRINGS, FL 999997670 NW 79TH AVEUNIT 0-4

A SULLIVAN, MARLA

A WALKER, BRIAN

A WHITTINGTON, CHAD

CORAL SPRINGS, FL 333212801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVECORAL SPRINGS, FL 330652801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVECORAL SPRINGS, FL 330652801 CORAL SPRINGS DRIVECORAL SPRINGS, FL 33065

2. The items and/or documents described on this and thefollowing pages are within the .State's possession orcontrol and [except information concerning subparagraph2. (e) ] are available for inspection, copying, testingand/or photographing at this office upon ,timely andreasonable notice.

(a) Statements of Defendant:

All written, recorded and/or oral statements of ·the

Defendant, if any, contained in the reports, records anddocuments enclosed herewith, and indepositions/statements taken.

Type: Written

Concerning / Indicating: Admission to the shooting andhis Intent. See letters.

(b) Statements of Co-Defendant (s) [provided if ajoint trial]: . .

All written, recorded and/or oral statements of the Co-

Defendant, if any, contained in the reports, records anddocuments enclosed herewith, and indepositions/statements taken.

Rev 11/10 Original = Clerk Copy = Defense Counsel Copy=SAO File DCS

STATE'S DISCOVERY EXHIBIT Page 3 of4STATE v. RICHARD ELLWOOD Case: 13010589CF10A

(c) Tangible papers or objects obtiained from or belongingto Defendant: (see paragraph 3. of this submission.)

YES

(d) Material or information provided by confidentialInformant (s) : [If "yes", same will only be disclosedpursuant to Court Order]

NONE

(e) Electronic surveillance, including wiretapping, ofthe premises of the Defendant or of conversations towhich the Defendant was a party .(see also paragraph3. of this submission) :

(f) Search or seizure: (see paragraph 3. of thissubmission)

NONE

(9) Reports or statements of experts: [The curriculumvitae for any category B expert witness is availablefor inspection upon request]

3. The tangible papers and/or objects listed belo.w, whetheror not taken from or belonging to Defendant, which theState intends to use at hearing or trial, may beinspected, copied, photographed and/or tested, uponreasonable and timely notice to the agency shown:

Papers / Object (s) Agency /

bullet/fragments

letters written by defendant

Any/All Police Reports, Probable Cause CSPDAffidavit and Supplement (s) , Crash Reportand Uniform Traf f ic Citation (s) 01-13 -4587

Any and All Documents/Items mentioned inPolice/Lab Reports

Witness Statement (s)

Rev 1 1/10 Original = Clerk Copy = Defense Counsel Copy=SAO File DCS

STATE'S DISCOVERY EXHIBIT Page 4 of 4STATE v. RICHARD ELLWOOD Case: 13010589CF10A

Photographs

Arrest Warrant / Affidavit(s)

Property/Evidence Receipt (s) and all itemslisted therein

Arrest / Conviction Record (s) IncludingPhotographs and Fingerprints

Proposed / Tentative Sentencing GuidelinesScoresheet

911/Dispatch Recordings and Records

4. At this time the State is not aware of any materialinformation favorable to the defendant which is otherwisenot available through the exercise of reasonablediligence by the defendant in accordance with Brady v.Maryland , 373 U.S. 83, 83 S.Ct. 1194 (1963) and itsprogeny.

5. Having made this Discovery Exhibit under Rule 3.220FRCrP, and in light of Defendant's notice of intent toParticipate in discovery, the State hereby reminds theDefendant of his/her reciprocal disclosure obligations,and the time limits for same, under section (d) of saidRule.

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true copy hereof has been furnishedElectronically /U.S. Mail/Hand-Delivery/Fax this 21 day ofAugust, A.D. 2013, to

Bruce Raticoff, Esquire, 201 SE 6th Street, Suite 3872,Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301

MICHAEL J. SATZState Attorney

By:

PAUL VALCORE, ESQUIREAssistant State AttorneyFL Bar 0940461201 S.E. 6th StreetUnit CCUFt Lauderdale, FL 33301

_ (954) 831-8838

Rev 11/10 Original = Clerk Copy = Defense Counsel Copy=SAO File DCS

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDAFOURTH DISTRICT, 1525 PALM BEACH LAKES BLVD., WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33401

March 24, 2016

CASE NO.: 4D15-4165 and4D15-4354

L.T. No.: 13-10589 CF10A and12-15004 CF10A

RICHARD LEE ELLWOOD v. STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellant / Petitioner(s) Appellee / Respondent(s)

BYORDEROFTHECOURT:

ORDERED that appellant is warned against the filing of successive challenges to his

convictions and sentences in Broward County case numbers 12-15004CF10A and 13-

10589CF10A. Appellant is cautioned that abusive, repetitive, malicious, and/or other

frivolous filing may result in sanctions, such as a bar on pro se filing in this Court, and/or

referral to prison officials for disciplinary procedures. See State v. Spencer, 751 So. 2d 47

(Fla. 1999); § 944.279(1), Fla. Stat. (2016).

Served:

cc: Attorney General-W. P. B. Richard Lee Ellwood

Ic

FOURTH

LONN WEISSBLUM, Clerkfourth District Court of Appeal

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDAFOURTH DISTRICT, 1525 PALM BEACH LAKES BLVD., WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33401

May 20, 2016

CASE NO.: 4D15-4165, 4D15-4354L.T. No.: 13-10589CF10A,

12-15004 CF10A

RICHARD LEE ELLWOOD v. STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellant / Petitioner(s) Appellee / Respondent(s)

BYORDEROFTHECOURT:

ORDERED that the appellant's April 11, 2016 motion for rehearing en banc is denied.

Served:

cc: Attorney General-W. P. B. Richard Lee Ellwood *w*

ms

LONN WEISSBLUM, ClerkFourth District Court of Appeat

O p y