7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

1/11

!"#$"%&'()*$+%*&$,-*(.-"%*(-/(01,#-2-314(-/(!"#$"%+(&*5(67,-#-84(9:;??@(A?BC?(DE)@(?>';FG9=H?>?IJK>??K>>?9K9(

A?(

!"#$%'())&*+$,-,.$,/#'(".$)0/$,("#(1#$%!$%&)2#3()#+"#4"+*5$,/+*#4"$,678&/$+/0*+)#9"$&)/0*$0)+*,.:;##?5@)A5#B0CD/.#+"E#?05#F&G()EH#

#L,"2+33+(DM6NN6(

O&P"#$4(-/(Q5"P&$,-*R(S*,H+%2,$T(5+8#,(U$"5,(5,(O-88,&(V,&(6%3,(?AAR(G??>>(O-88,&(

8,"2+33+'5&**&W"*,*&',$(!

6X2$%&P$'()*($1,2(3&3+%()(Y-"#5(#,Z+($-(5+[-*2$%&$+($1&$( $1+(\2-P,+$4(-/(23+P$&P#+](*-$&X#4(,*/#"+*P+2(-"%(,5+&(-/($1+(-$1+%(&*5(-"%(,*$+%P"#$"%($1-"81$(&*5(3%&P$,P+'()*($1,2(Y&4($1+(,[&8,*&$,-*(,2(*-$(&(/%++(P%+&$,H+(P&3&X,#,$4(-/(&(1"[&*(X+,*8R(X"$(&(3-#,$,P(&*5(2-P,(,*2$%"[+*$(-/(3-Y+%(-/($1+(2-P,+$4(-/(23+P$&P#+'(^+4Y-%52@(,[&8,*&$,-*R(P-%%+#&$,H,2[R(,5+*$,$4R(,[&8+R(,*$+%P"#$"%,2[((

_+/-%+(8+$$,*8(,*$-($1+(1+&%$(-/([4(2"X`+P$(,$(,2(*+P+22&%4($-(2$&$+(&(1,2K$-%,P( 1+%[+*+"$,P( +73#&*&$,-*( -/( $1+( P-*P+3$"( 5+H,P+2( $1&$( Y,##( X+("2+5(,*($1+(P-"%2+(-/([4(%+/#+P$,-*'(O-%(\P-%%+#&$,H,2[]()(&22"[+(1+%+($1+( 5+/,*,$,-*( $1&$( N,P-#&,( a&%$[&**( +73#,P&$+2( ,*( $1+( $+7$( "#$!%$#&'()*#&*!')$!+&,-(-*.)!-/(?IJAR(Y1+%+(1+(Y%,$+2@(U-(H+%2P1,+5+*+( ^b3/+( Y,+( N&$-%3R( !&22,%+%R( c,PZ+%$R( a"22+%#R( a+,5+88+%( 2,*5( ,*(

5,+2+%(a,*2,P1$(5+[2+#X+*()%%$"[(+%#+8+*'(d,$(5+[(024P1-#-8,2["2(&X+%R(5+*(2,+(X+Ze[/$+*R(,2$(5+*(#-8,2P1+*(f1+-%,+*(5,+(V+%Z+**"*8(5+2(f%&*2g+*5+*gH+%1e#$*,2K2+2( ,[( Q%Z+**$*,231e*-[+*( 8+[+,*2&['( hij(a,*$+%( 5,+2+%( 0%-X#+[H+%Z+***"*8(2$+PZ$(&X+%(*-P1(+,*+(kX+%#+8"*8R(5,+(H,+#(e#$+%(,2$("*5(5,+((O+1#+%l"+##+(Y+,$8+K1+*5+%(^-*2+l"+*g+*(&"P1(5,+(^%,$,Z(5+%(%+,*+*(V+%*"*/$(X+1+%%2P1$'(d&*(Z&**(2,+(5&2(\Z-%%+#&$,H,2$,P1+(6%8"[+*$](*+**+*'(Q2(8,X$(Z+,*(Q%Z+**$*,2-X`+Z$(-1*+(Q%ZK+**$*,22"X`+Z$R( 2&8$( 5,+2+2( 6%8"[+*$m( [&*( Z&**( 5+*( L+8+*2$&*5( *,P1$( H-[( _+KY"n$2+,*($%+**+*R(+%( ,2$(oX+%1&"3$(*"%(L+8+*2$&*5p(\/o%\( 5&2(_+Y"22$2+,*'(:a&%$K[&**R(?IJA@(?F

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

2/11

L,"2+33+(DM6NN6(=(E*($1+(!-%%+#&$,H,2$,P(!-*2$%"P$,-*(-/($1+(E$1+%(

A;((

[&**'(f1+(a"*8&%,&*(31,#-2-31+%R(,*(/&P$R(,*($1+(/,%2$(3&%$(-/($1+(+&,-(-*/!-0!,1)!2-3.4(!5).&*(5+5,P&$+2($Y-(Y1-#+(P1&3$+%2($-(a&%$[&**R(&*5(*-$(X4(P1&*P+'(

q"ZrP2M( 2$&%$,*8( 3-,*$( ,2( -/( P-"%2+( d&%7,2[R( Y1,P1( ,*( ,$2( 8+*+$,PK[&$+%,,2$(P-*2$,$"$,-*(,2("2+5(&2($1+(5-P$%,*+(-/(\%+2,2$&*P+]($-($1+(*+Y(\2P,+*$,/,P]( 31,#-2-31,+2( :*+-K^&*$,&*,2[R( +[3,%,-KP%,$,P,2[( &*5( *+-K3-2,$,H,2[

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

3/11

!"#$"%&'()*$+%*&$,-*(.-"%*(-/(01,#-2-314(-/(!"#$"%+(&*5(67,-#-84(9:;??@(A?BC?(

AJ(

8&*,g&$,-*(/-%[2(*-$(-*#4($-(,[3%-H+(3%-5"P$,-*R(X"$(-($-(%+8"#&$+($1+(P&3,$,2$(P-*2"[+%'()$(21-"#5(*-$(X+(/-%8-$$+*($1&$($1+(P-[3#+$+(2"X[,22,-*($-(P&3,$,2$(,*K5"2$%4(-/(P-*2"[+%(8--52(:&*5(2+%H,P+2(-/(2-KP#+5

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

4/11

L,"2+33+(DM6NN6(=(E*($1+(!-%%+#&$,H,2$,P(!-*2$%"P$,-*(-/($1+(E$1+%(

AF((

$1+( &22"[3$,-*( $1&$( $1+( 5,22+[,*&$,-*R( "*5+%2$&*5,*8R( +$1,P( H-%,2&K$,-*R($1+(%-#+($1&$($1+2+(P-*P+3$2(3#&4(,*(2-P,(&*5(5&,#4(3%&P$,P+2(&*5($1&$(5+/,*+(X+1&H,-"%2(&*5($1-"81$2(&X-"$(P"#$"%(5,//+%+*P+(&*5(,5+*K

$,$4(P-*2$,$"$+($1+(5+H,P+2(5+2,8*+5(,*($1+(/-%8+(-/(&*(+*$,%+#4(P-%%+#&$,H,2K$,P(23+P$&P"#&%(Y-%#5R(&(Y-%#5(-/(,[&8+2(&X#+($-(5+/,*+(,$2+#/(&*5($-(5+/,*+($1+([+&*,*82(&*5($1+(1-%,g-*2(-/(2+*2+(-*(Y1,P1($1+([&*4(2-P,(&*5(3-#,$,P(@)(,4&2314##&*)&(&%+(P-*2$,$"$+5'(

)*(21-%$R($1+(,5+&(B(P+%$&,*#4(*-$(&(*+Y(-*+(B(,2(&2(/-##-Y2@([&*4(%+K/#+P$,-*2( -*( ,*$+%P"#$"%( 31,#-2-314( $&Z+( &( 2$&*5( ,*( /&H-"%( -/( &*( +*K1&*P+[+*$(-/($1+(,[&8,*&$,-*(:$1,*Z(-/($1+(5,23"$+(,*(3-#,$,P(31,#-2-K314(X+$Y++*(2"33-%$+%2(-/(^&*$,&*,2[(H2(N+-K6%,2$-$+#,&*?>

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

5/11

!"#$"%&'()*$+%*&$,-*(.-"%*(-/(01,#-2-314(-/(!"#$"%+(&*5(67,-#-84(9:;??@(A?BC?(

AA(

_"$(Y1&$(,2([+&*$(X4(3+%/-%[&*P+t(D+X-%5R(,*(G1)(=-3.),/!-0!,1)!=;)3,4H3()!,2(P#+&%(,*($1,2(%+8&%5@(\f1+(23+P$&P#+(,2(*-$(&(P-##+P$,-*(-/(,[&8+2R(X"$(&(2-P,(%+#&$,-*(&[-*8(3+-3#+([+5,&$+5(X4(,[&8+2](:D+X-%5R(?IG>@(F@(F

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

6/11

L,"2+33+(DM6NN6(=(E*($1+(!-%%+#&$,H,2$,P(!-*2$%"P$,-*(-/($1+(E$1+%(

AC((

P-%%+#&$,-*R($1&$(X+$Y++*(2"X`+P$(&*5(-X`+P$R(&*5($1+(&"$-K%+P-*2$%"P$,-*(-/(&(%+3%+2+*$&$,-*(-/(%+,$4(,*5+3+*5+*$(/%-[($1+(H,+Y+%(,$2+#/'(N-$(P-K,*P,5+*$#4(D+X-%5(P#+5(1,2(/,%2$(X--Z(-/($1+(=-3.),/!-0!,1)!=;)3,43()(\$1+(

P"#[,*&$,-*(-/(2+3&%&$,-*'](f1,2(2+3&%&$,-*(,2($1+(5,2$&*P+(X+$Y++*( $1+(H,+Y+%(&*5($1+(,[&8+(:$1+(%+3%+2+*$&$,-*

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

7/11

!"#$"%&'()*$+%*&$,-*(.-"%*(-/(01,#-2-314(-/(!"#$"%+(&*5(67,-#-84(9:;??@(A?BC?(

AG(

P-[["*,P&$,-*R( ,$( ,2( X+P&"2+( $1,2( uP-[["*,P&$,-*M( ,2( +22+*$,#4( #&.(4,H)$4(](:D+X-%5R(?IG>@(?FB?A

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

8/11

L,"2+33+(DM6NN6(=(E*($1+(!-%%+#&$,H,2$,P(!-*2$%"P$,-*(-/($1+(E$1+%(

A9((

,5+&(-/($1+(,5+*$,$4(-/($1+(c-[&*,&*(3+-3#+(&*5($1+(c-[&*,&*BH,-#+*P+(5",$4'(

c+8&%5#+22(-/($1+(3-#,$,P(/"*P$,-*(-/($1+([+5,&(&*5($1+(23+P$&P"#&%(

[+22&8+R(Y1&$(,2(,[3-%$&*$($-(*-$,P+(,2($1&$($1+(23+P$&P#+R($1+(\,H+](,[K&8+R(*-Y(X+P-[+2($1+($%"+(3#&P+(-/(+22+*$,,g&$,-*(-/(,5+*$,$4'(QH+%4K$1,*8( ,2( P-5+5( H+%4(Y+##( -(X4( U&,5( ,*( $1+( $,[+#+22( $+7$(+$.)&,4(.2:R(,*(Y1,P1(Y+(%+&5@(\E*+(&23+P$(-/($1+(+#+P$%-*,PR(3-2$[-5+%*(Y-%#5(,2($1&$($1+%+(1&2(X++*(&(%+,*/-%P+[+*$(-/($1+(2$+%+-$43+2(X4(Y1,P1($1+(E%,+*$(,2(H,+Y+5'( f+#+H,2,-*R( $1+( /,#[2R(&*5(#( $1+([+5,&M2(%+2-"%P+2(1&H+( /-%P+5(,*/-%[&$,-*(,*$-([-%+(&*5([-%+(2$&*5&%5,g+5([-#52](:U&,5R(?IGG@(;C

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

9/11

!"#$"%&'()*$+%*&$,-*(.-"%*(-/(01,#-2-314(-/(!"#$"%+(&*5(67,-#-84(9:;??@(A?BC?(

AI(

2$&X#+( 3-3"#&$,-*'(f1+( [,8%&*$2R( $1+*R(&%+(2-(/%,81$+*,*8(X+P&"2+( \$1+4(&%+( $--([&*4v](E*P+( &8&,*( $1+( 3-Y+%( -/( $1+( ,[&8+( ,2( 3&%*,*8@( -*P+(&8&,*( $1+( \/%&8[+*$]R( 23+P$&P"#&%#4( P-*2$%"P$+5R( X+P-[+2( $1+( Y1-#+'(

6*5(Y1+*($1+(/%&8[+*$(X+P-[+2($1+(Y1-#+($1+%+(,2(&(P-[3#+$+(Y&2$+(-/($,[+(&2(&*(1,2$-%,P(*&%%&$,H+(&*5R($1+%+/-%+R(#-22(-/(,5+*$,$4(2++*(&2($1+(3#&**,*8(-/($1+(5,//+%+*P+R(&2(l",$4($,[+(-/($1+(231+%+(-/(23+P,/,P,$4(&*5([-5,/,&X,#,$4'((

6X-"$(23+P$&P"#&%( -%(32+"5-KP4P#,P( $,[+(D+X-%5(Y%,$+2( $1&$( ,$( ,2(\&*(,*/,*,$+(&PP"["#&$,-*(-/(+l",H+*$(,*$+%H'()$(,2($1+(&X2$%&P$,-*(-/(,%%+KH+%2,X#+($,[+(Y1+%+(#($1+(2+8[+*$2(-/($1+(P1%-*-[+$+%(["2$(-*#4(3%-H+($1+,%([+%+#4(l"&*$,$&$,H+(+l",$4'(f1,2($,[+(,2(,*(%+,$4(+7&P$#4(Y1&$(,$(,2(,*(,$2()J314&*)45()!P1&%&P$+%](:D+X-%5R(?IG>@(9F

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

10/11

L,"2+33+(DM6NN6(=(E*($1+(!-%%+#&$,H,2$,P(!-*2$%"P$,-*(-/($1+(E$1+%(

C>((

23+P$&P"#&%($%&*23-2,$,-*(-/($1+(24[X-#,PR(,[&8,*&%4(&*5(%+3%+2+*$&$,-*R(&( $%&*23-2,$,-*( $1&$( -%,8,*&$+2( ,*( ,$2( P-%%+#&$,H,2$( /-%[2( &*5( P-*$+*$( -/(P-*P+,H&X,#,$4(-/(-$1+%*+22'(

QH+*([-%+(%&5,P(,2(&*-$1+%(O%+*P1($1,*Z+%R(.+&*(_&"5%,##&%5R(Y1-(,*($1+($+7$(G1)!K)$0)3,! ?$.:)! 2$&$+2( $1&$( $1+( ,5+*$,$4B5,//+%+*P+( 54&5( ,2( 5+K2,8*+5(/-%(&*(&%$,/,P,(24*$1+2,2(-/(-$1+%*+22'(f1+(%+(-$1+%*+22R(,*(/&P$R($1+(-*+(Y1,P1(%+2,2$2R($1&$(5-+2(*-$(-33-2+(,$2+#/(X+P&"2+(,$(,2(%&5,P#4(\-$1+%]( 1&2( X++*( 5+/+&$+5R( #,l",5&$+5( &*5( ["2$( X+( %+3%-5"P+5'( \f1+(-$1+%*+22(,2(#-2$(&*5(Y+(["2$(&X2-#"$+#4(3%-5"P+($1+(-$1+%(&2(&(5,//+%K+*P+R(,*2$+&5(-/(#,H,*8(-$1+%*+22(&2(5+2$,*4'](f1+(-$1+%R($1+*R(["2$(X+(%+5+2,8*+5( &2( &( 5,//+%+*P+( $-( X+( %+#&$+5( ,*( &( P-%%+#&$,H,2$,P( Y&4( $-( $1+(,5+*$,P'(E*#4($1,2(Y&4R(&2(&*(-33-2,$,-*(*+8-$,&$,-*R($1+(-$1+%*+22(,2(

P-*$%-##+5( ,*( $1+( H,%$"( Y-%#5R( 2,*P+( $1+( ["%5+%( -/( $1+( %+,$4R( -/( $1+(-$1+%R(1&2($-(#+&H+(*-($%&P+2R(Y1&$(P#&,[2($-(X+("*,l"+R(,*P-[3&%&X#+(&*5(Y1,P1( 3#&42( -"$2,5+( $1+( 8&[+( -/( 5,//+%+*P+R( ["2$( X+( +7$+%[,*&$+5(:_&"5%,##&%5R(?IIC@(?;J

7/29/2019 On the Correlativistic

11/11

!"#$"%&'()*$+%*&$,-*(.-"%*(-/(01,#-2-314(-/(!"#$"%+(&*5(67,-#-84(9:;??@(A?BC?(

C?(

D+X-%5R(L"4'(=-3.),/!-0!,1)!2;)3,43()'(D+$%-,$@(_#&PZ(w(c+5R(?IG>'(O+%%&%&R(6#+22&*5%-'( C4!0-$64!')((D)2):;.-N!L(!;4$4'.*:4!')(!*.#'.6.- '(d,#&*-@(O+#$%,*+##,R(

;>>I'(O-%*+$K_+$&*P-"%$'(c&y#'(f$4&20-$:43.O&!.&,)$3#(,#$4(!')!(4!0.(-2-0P4'(_,#X&-@(D+2P#z+(5+(

_%-"Y+%R(;>>?'(a&%$[&**R(N,P-#&,'("#$!%$#&'()*#&*!')$!+&,-(-*.)'(_+%#,*@(s$+%(D+(L%"4$+%R(?ICA'(^,[[+%#+R(a+,*g'( L&,)$F#(,#$)(()!K1.(-2-;1.)N!"#$!E.&0Q1$#&*'(a&[X"%8@(."*,"2(V+%#&8R(

;>>;'(q"ZrP2R(L4b%84'(+&,-(-*.4!')((D)22)$)!2-3.4()!R'(c-[&@(Q5,$-%,(c,"*,$,R(?IGC'(d#R(c&[(651&%'(K1.(-2-;1.)!.:!S)$*().31!')$!T#(,#$)&N!L&,)$F#(,#$)(()!K1.(-2-;1.)U!).&)!&)#)!+$.)&,.)$#&*'(D&%[2$&5$@(s,22+*2P1&/$#,P1+(_"P18+2+##2P1&/$R(?IIA'(

N"22X&"[R( d&%$1&( !'( A$-&,.)$2! -0! V#2,.3)U! W.245.(.,/X! Y4,.-&4(.,/X! =;)3.)2! Z):5)$21.;'(!&[X%,58+(d6@(a&%H&%5(S*,H+%2,$4(0%+22R(;>>C'(

N"22X&"[R(d&%$1&(!'(?#(,.>C'(f-5-%-HR(fgH+$&*'(G1)!3-&I#)2,!-0!9:)$.34N!N+Y(x-%Z@(a&%3+%(w(c-YR(?I9F'((s,[[+%R( O%&*g( d&%$,*'( L&,)$F#(,#$)(()! K1.(-2-;1.)N! E.&)! E.&0Q1$#&*'( s,+*@( 0&22&8+*(V+%#&8R(;>>F'((

N-$+2?(Q*8#,21($%&*2#&$,-*(X4(d&%,&(d&$%-*+'(;( a+%+( ,2( $1+( Q*8#,21( $%&*2#&$,-*@( \f1,*Z+%2( 2"P1( &2( N&$-%3R( !&22,%+%R( c,PZ+%$R(a"22+%#R(&*5(a+,5+88+%(2"PP"[X+5(,*($1,2(%+8&%5($-($1+(2&[+(+%%-%'(f1+4(-33-2+5($1+(2&[+(324P1-#-8,2[(Y1,P1(21&%+5(Y,$1($1+,%(#-8,P($1+-%,+2($1+([,2`"58,*8(-/($1+($%&*2P+*5+*P+(,*($1+(31+*-[+*-*(-/(P-8*,$,-*(i(_"$(X+1,*5($1,2(5+*,(-/($1+(3%-X#+[($1+%+(,2( 2$,##( &(["P1(-#5+%( P-*2,5+%&$,-*(Y1,P1(5-[,*&$+2(&2( &( 2-"%P+( -/(+%%-%(Y,$1(#&%8+(P-*2+l"+*P+2R(+H+*($1+(P%,$,l"+(-/(3"%+(%+&2-*'(x-"(P-"#5(P#(,$($1+(u!-%%+#&$,H,2$( &%8"[+*$']( )$( 2$&$+2( $1&$( $1+%+( ,2(&*( -X`+P$( -/(Z*-Y#+58+( Y,$1-"$( &(

2"X`+P$(-/(Z*-Y#+58+(&*5($1&$(4-"(P&**-$(2+3&%&$+($1+(-X`+P$(/%-[($1+(P-*2P,-"2K*+22m($1&$($1+(-X`+P$(,*(8+*+%(,2($1&$(-*#4(u$-M($1+(P-*2P,+*P+'](J(U+*M2(:?I9G(&*5(;>>C>C