Oktay Eksi
Transcript of Oktay Eksi
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
1/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>
0? Fjab 9?>9 Pnh
IYK@ E]VYVB
Nhbn Pnn}a7 >>+9
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
2/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 79
Mncn ekyn( fjekebaj ieqv}hny( eqnh tf pajehegaj ieqv}hny( vhvhnynyn ahajahfya qnka a tf
m inhnk}hny tf fk ek ehnynj bfmqn+
hjfbawmf mfbejynaqf bmncnhf fmfk i}k iv yfhfymf nyn}yhbn lfyfjfk
inhjhnybw ivkhny+ Pawak( Jebaqekvbvwn( iayjn nh} jebaqek nqk nkmn mntf}akawa vqlvk
lym+ Cfb ivhvkmvvkvw jekvbhny a}ainyqhn cfb mncn k`fja mnyifhfy mf+++ ]fj iay nh}
jebaqek mntf} fmaqey tf }fj iay nh} jebaqekvk mntf}haa ehnynj ivhvkniahaqeyvkvw nbn
mafy }b yfhfyhf ahlaha ivynqn mntf} fmahmakaw+
Cfy fqmfk k`f( mntf}abawa jnivh f}}aakaw tf ivynmn ivhvkmvvkvw aak ej
}ffjjy fmaqeyvw+Jebaqek }ephnk}bw( k`fhajhf( mntf} f}}aabaw jekvjhnybwk iv jekvmn qnka awnc
f}}aabaw iv fyftf meyvh}vvkmn cfycnkla iay mffyhfkmaybf( vkvb qnpbnj a}fbfhfya
mvyvbvkmn jfkmahfyakf qayba mnjajnhj iay yf tfyaqeyvw+ Lfya jnhnk wnbnk eyv"`ftnp
fjhakmf( bahhf}tfjahhfyabawak ebv} eyvhnykn lfaqeyvw+
Jfkmakawa tf w lfbaakawa }nk}nynj inhnbnkw ya`n fmaqeyvw mffyhfkmaybf
qnpbnj a}fbfkaw mvyvbvkmn+
Pawf w tfybfmfk k`f ifk v nkmn ivynmn ivhvknk bahhf}tfjahhfyabawa awhfyf}nk}bnj a}aqeyvb7 Pehvbmn Qnny Jnynqfh Ifq( NJ _NY] Jnqfya Bahhf}tfjaha tf 93 vin}
Nh} Jebaqek Injnk: mya ncak Ifq Jebaqekvbvwvk Pw`( NJ _NY] nkjy
Bahhf}tfjaha: Fktfy Qhbnw Ifq NJ _NY] }nkivh Bahhf}tfjaha tf >14? tf bvc}ynk
jnpnqnk Nh} Jebaqek Injnk: @fklaw Qntahaehv Ifq NJ _NY] Fywvyvb Bahhf}tfjaha tf
>14? "qakf nqk"Nh} Jebaqekv qfa: w`nk Qfkafya Ifq NJ Bahhaqf}a Cnyfjf} _ny}aa v
nkmn nmf`f NJ _NY]hahfy ivynmn ivhvkvqey( ej wy mahfyab" Nkjnyn Bahhf}tfjaha tf >14?
tf Bvc}yn Nh} Jebaqekv qfa+
Ivqvyvk h}dfk( w awak Pnqk Fja+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Pnqk Injnkb( k`f( h}dfmap ifka mf nymkw aak
}ffjjy fmfyab+ Ivkv fyfdha iay lyft ehnynj jnivh f}}aaba mf pfakfk iahlakawf vkbnj
a}fyab+
Ifkmfkaw( qnb a}ainyqhn >14? mcah( 9< Bnq ehnq mcah( }b iv yfhfya
qnnmb+ Cn}}n ivkhnyk }nbnbkmn mn lnwf}f`a dn} }nqnynj ivhvkmvb+ E kfmfkhf(
ehniahmaak`f( jekvbvbvk awak tfymaa hmf lwhfbhfbf nkb ehmv+
k`f jfkma w lfbaabhf ahlaha jn iay iahla vknqb awf+ Wn}fk iv nw k`f nyw
f}}aab cvv mn iay pnynk adnmf f}}a+ < Nynhj >109mfk ifya mkqnmn ivhvknk iay ]yj
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
3/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 70
tn}nkmnqb+ >169 qhkmnk "3 E`nj }nyacakmfk a}ainyfk" 0? Fjab 9?>? }nyacakf jnmny ehnk
yf( njfyhaj tf vdnj inw dnyjh lyfthfy cnya }nbnbfk lnwf}f`ahaj}f lf}a+ E mn wn}fk iv
awak mfakmaakaw jekvhnymn lwhfbhfbf qncv} ifhayha hmf jqkmn( jfknykmn ivhvkbn
abjkk tfyma inkn+
Cvjvj dnjh}fa bfwvkvqvb tf lnwf}f`ahaj}fk injn mn qnnbb ieqvk`n( e lfa`a
ehnynj aakmf ivhvkmvvb yfhfy cnya( cfycnkla iay lyfthf bflvh ehbnmb+ Nynmn(
nmf`f( >130 qhkmn jvyvhbv ehnk "PEMF_" Peqnh Mfbejyna _ny}aakak jvyv`vhny nynkn
laymab+ Ek ivvj nq yfqhf aqnf}}f ivhvkmvb dnjn} dnyjh }nyac}f tf jevhhnyb vqlvk
mfahjfk aqnf}f laymaaba np}nqk`n mkfbmfja pny}a injnkkmnk awak nhnynj aqnf}ftfmn f}}ab+ Pekyn }fjyny bfhfabf mkmb+ E nynmn( 4 E`nj >14> }nyacakmf jvyvhbv ehnk
Jvyv`v Bf`haf inwhnykk wackakmf ehnk tf wnbnk wnbnk mn adnmf f}}aa cvvvk cahndkn
lawha eqhn qnphb fabhfyhf Nkjnynmnja ink bfkvphny }nyndkmnk qnphnk fabhf"
ink bfkvphnyk }fbah fmfk qf ehnynj jn}hmb+ ej mn f}ak iay fabmfk w fmaqeyvb(
ekv mn pnynk}fw aakmf iahlakawf vknqb+
Ek ivvj nq mn eynmn( >14> Nknqnnk qnpnk Jvyv`v Bf`ha}f Injnkhj
Matnkkmn j}ap qf tf qf ehnynj }niaa( lyft qnp}b+ Ivkv mn bfhfabak tf jfkma wfhqnnbbk iay fyfd pnqfa ehnynj mn jnqmf}}aaba iahlakawf vkbnj}nk bv}hvhvj mvqvqeyvb+
Fthaqab( 9 e`vvb tny+ klahaw`f iahmaaba mkqeyvb+ Cvjvj dnjh}fa bfwvkv
ehmvvbv iahlakawf vkmvb+ Pnkqeyvb ja jfkmabhf ahlaha ehnynj cvwvyvkvwn lf}ayfiahf`fab
}fbfh iahlahfy ivkhny+
9< Bnq >14?}n qfmfj vinq }fbfkmab+ Qnka 9< Bnq mnyifa( ac}ahnha( akjhni(
cnklaaka }fy`ac fmfyfkaw ekv aw h}dfk qhf jnivh ivqvyvk( e ehnqmn iay qfmfj vinq amab tf
lnwf}f`ahaj}fk daahfk vwnj}b+ Wn}fk( nhkmn( vwnj ehbnb aak injn fifp mf tnym+
Lffkhfymf cvwvyvkvwmn iay bfhfj}nbk cn}}n fja }nyachfymf pn}yekhvvbv
qnpb ehnk iay me}vbvk adnmf f}}aa iay cvv inkn qnkm+ Ekn mfakbfj ac}aqn`k
mvqvqeyvb iv tfahfqhf+ 9< Bnq}n qnphnk qnqkhny aakmf( e }nyac}f( ifkab qfmfj vinq
ehbnb kfmfkaqhf daahfk vwnj}n ehmvvb "nbn nhkmn Mkqn lnwf}fakak Nkjnyn ]fbah`aa
dn}k }nqeymvb" e ynmn bfycvb @fhnh Inqny cnjjkmn lfyfj}fk ]yj ink }nyaca
nkmnk cfyjf aak "iv inkk bfkviv ehnk cfyjf aak" v}nk tfya`a ehmvvkv
mkmb iay cnify qnqkhnkb}y( e mn bnnhffd Mkqn lnwf}fakmf qnqkhnkb}y+
Cvwvyvkvwmn e jekvqn mfakfk me}vb "tf e }nyac}fja pn}yekvb maqfiahayab kj daahfk e
qnpqeymv pn}yekhvv( nh pn}yek Dnhac Ydj N}nqm" Ifmaa Dnaj Ifqak e cnifya ifkab
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
4/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7=
tfymaaba adnmf f}}aaka lnwf}fhfymf ejvmvb+ Jfkmaakak mf iahlaakf vkn`nj fjahmf
jnbveqvkmn }fjwap f}}ab nbn ivyn jnqmn lff`fj yfb iay qfy ehmvv aak }fjyny f}bfj}f
qnyny lyqeyvb+ Ifk > E`nj >161 qhkmn njfyf la}}ab( 0? Cnwaynk >14? }nyacakmf mf }fyca
ehmvb+ E kfmfkhf( 9< Bnq}n( nw k`f nyw f}}aab laia( }fbfk dn} }nqnk iay ]yj njfya
amab+ E }nyac}f Bahh Pntvkbn Injnkh B}fny Eylfkfynh Pnhac @ejvk ama+ Fa Nhaqf
@ejvk Cnkbfdfkma Mfbejyn} _ny}akak Bahhf}tfjahaqma+ ]yjaqfmf aqna lfyahabak qjfj
ehmvv lkhfya qnnmbw aak ifkab laia( bvcnhad iay lnwf}fkak Nkjnyn }fbah`ahaakmfk
njfyf lamfk }fbfkak mf lwnh}kmn }v}vhbn Mncn meyvv lwnh} mfbfj}f bnjnmb
fq( qnka wlyhb }ncma}fmfk iay fqmfk w f}baqeyvb( awhfkbfa lfyfj}aakf mnay iay}nhabn} lfhba+
INJNK Daah iay bncfmf mvyvbv+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ftf}( ftf}+ whfkbfj}f ehmvvb+ Ivynmn jvynqhn Lfya
abma injn iay fq( Fyfd Njk` Lnykawekv mfkaqey lnhain( Bnbnj}n 93+ ]bfkmf ama
njfyhajhfyab qnka jvynmn eynqn la}ba}ab+ Eynmn iay me}vb cnify tfyma ja whfkaqeyvk(
cnifyak ehvk+ Kaqf5 }f( fk Mkqn lnwf}fakak }fbah`aa ehmvvk aak( ivynmn mn cnka
babhfkba iay jaaak( cnifyak ehvk+ mfma+ Ekmnk mn ia haqeymvb+Kfqf( vwn}bnj a}fbfmaab iay cvvn laymaj+ Daahfk tf cvjvjfk lnwf}f`ahaj
qnpbnb bbjk mfahma+ E qwmfk mf Ifmaa Ifqak cndwnkmnja aw( nkqeyvb( ekv nhmn}nk
iay aw+ Ifkab e cnifya qnwmb adnmf f}ba}a ja cvjvjfk( daahfk( wn}fk ehnqmn qncv} cnifymf
caiay fjahmf yehb qej}v+ Ivkv mn qfya lfhmaa aak iahlakawf vkbnj a}fyab+
Mfbfj a}fmaab( 9< Bnq}nk iv }nyacf jnmny( e mkfb mcah( aw nqbnmkw nbn
nhkmn 99 vin} >149 tnymy( 9> Bnq >140 tnymy( 1 Bny} >1 tnymy qnka ahnbnnhhnc
}nyacabaw iaynw mncn mfyakf lamfyfj( Pvh}nk Nimvhnwawak cnhhakmfk iv }nyndn jnmny fpfq
ifkwfya cajqfhfya qnnbhnyk }nyacamay+ Qnka a}fyfkaw Cnhnjy Wnia}nk Lyvivkv mn( 90
E`nj >1>0 }nyacha Ininha injkk mn nqbnj nkqeyvb ja iv mawaqa }nbnbhnbnj nkmnk
lfyfjhamay nbn ifkab lyfiahmaab( >14?}nk iv }nyndn ehnk+ Ekhnyhn ahlaha ifkab awf nyw
fmf`fab( pfakfk( cvvhny ivkhny+ Cnkla jekvmn( cnkla eyv tny af yfkbfj nkmnk
jfkmahfyakf qnk}hnyk vkniahf`fab( cfpakf cnwyb+
Ifkab whfyab iv jnmny+ ]ffjjyhfyaba tf nqlhnyb vkvqeyvb }b Jebaqek
qfhfyakf+
wfhhajhf mf iay fqa ek `bhf ehnynj( bnnmfkawhf( iahlakawf vkbnj a}fyab+
Jebaqekvk( }niaa( lyft fyftfaka Lfkfh Jvyvh }nqak f}}a dnjn} iqhf iay jebaqekvk
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
5/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 76
jvyvhbv ehbnkk tf iv bffhfkak fkakf ieqvkn( fk nwkmnk yfbfk jnq}hnyn
lfbfakak( i}k iahfkhfy }nyndkmnk iahlahfyakak ey}nqn mjhbfj vyf}aqhf yfb iahlahfy
nynkn i}k e mkfbhfyak laybfakak lfhf`fj jvnjhny nkmnk mn( mfbejynabaw
nkmnk mn( cfpabawak ey}nj mffyhfya nkmnk mn ej mffyha tf qnynyh ehmvvkv
mkqeyvb+ E kfmfkhf mf Jebaqekn inny mahfjhfyaba vkbnj a}fyab+
Pn ehvk+
INJNK ]fjyny ej }ffjjy fmaqeyvw Pnqk Fja+
]ephnk}bwn jn}hnk mafy bahhf}tfjahhfyabawa mf awf }nk}bnj a}aqeyvb( }nkqey
ehbnkwn ynbfk+ Bfcbf} fjfy Ifq @vbcvyaqf} Cnhj _ny}aa Lnwank}fp Bahhf}tfjaha( 93vin} Nh} Jebaqek qfa: Nha Ywn w}yj Ifq @vbcvyaqf} Cnhj _ny}aa Bfyak Bahhf}tfjaha+
Mffyha bahhf}tfjahhfyabawak eyv }nhfphfyaqhf iayhaj}f( ivqvyvk h}dfk+
Fktfy Qhbnw Ifq( ivqvyvk+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Ce lfhmakaw+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ ]ffjjyhfy+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Ifkab eybnj a}fmaab eyvkvk iay }nkfakf aw `ftnp
tfymakaw+ Ifmaa Dnaj Njk Ifqak @fhnh Inqnyhn ahlaha nkjnqnmn Injnkhny Jvyvhv }ephnk}kmfah( Nkjnyn Ynmqe nkn}hny fhaakmf nw hfba qnp}kn mnay qnwkk nkn n}d awf na}}a+
Ifmaa Ifq iqhf iay Ekv mwfh}}akaw+ Ekvkhn ahlaha
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Qe( qe( e mfah+ Ifkab qhfmaab }nbnbfk injn iay fq+
E( wk f}}aakaw( >166 qhkk kank nqkmn nkjnqnmn qnphnk iay nw hfba ehnqmy+ E
nqy+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Ekv eynhb e wnbnk7 nkjnqnmn Injnkhny Jvyvhv
}ephnk} mfah( Nkjnyn Ynmqev nkn}hny fhaakmf nw hfba qnphmkn mnay qnw+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Nkhn}nqb awak tfyayfkaw+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Ivqvyvk+
abma( fdfkmab( e }nyac}f iaw Nkjnyn lnwf}f`ahfya mncn ej njnbhny nhymj+ Pekyn
}fjkehega mfa}ajf( jevhhny mfa}ajf lnwf}fhfy njnb nn} if}f( nh}mn i}k lkk
}nbnbhny chf lfhmahfy+ hntf iahlahfy ekyn lnwf}fhfyf layfy ehmv+ Iaw e }nyac}f( nw k`f nyw
f}}aab laia( iyehnybw njnbhny mncn ej dnnh ehvymv tf cnifyhfya ehniahmaa jnmny( a}f(
lkk ekvkmn iayiayabawmfk kf tnyhny eynynj( tfnayf( tfnayf( iaynw mn pnqhnbnj
vyf}aqhf lkk cnifyhfyaka }epnyhny( }nkivhn }fhfdekhn qnwmyymj kj mncn mn injn iay
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
6/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 74
abjk qej}v+ Mncn ekyn lfya }fhfj layma mftyfqf nbn iv( awf( iahlakawf vkmvvb }nyac
iqhfqma+
E njnb yfkmaj ja nkjnqnmn ej kfbha iay }ephnk} tny+ @vbcvyinjnkkk
injnkhkmn Injnkhny Jvyvhv }ephnkqeybv+ Ifkmfkaw mf }niaa( Mkqn lnwf}fakak Nkjnyn
}fbah`aa dn}qhn( 9"0 nyjnmnbw tny iyemn( iv ehnqk }kf m}j+ Ehniahmaa jnmny(
kfmay afyaa( ivhbnqn nh}j+ Injnkhnyk fthfyaka nynmj( a}f( inwhny mfma ja7 Ftf}( Pnqk
@vbcvyinjnkkk ny wfyakf fab la}}a+ tfnayf tfnayf+ E lkk kfbha ehnqhny kfhfy(
ekhny jfkma nynbwmn }ny}p N`nin ivkhny b lyqeyhny5 maqf mkqeyvw+
Pekv ehnynj( a}f( }ncbakf mnqnh ehbnj jnqmqhn( Injnkhny Jvyvhv }ephnk}kmn "@vbcvyinjnk }nyndkmnk nyhb ehbn wn}fk kfbaka l}fyaqey ehnqk" vkhny vkhny
lyhf`fj( maqf }ncbak fmahaqey+ maqf cnifyhfyabawa tfymaj+ Nynmnk wnbnk lf}a( nn}
nkqeyvb" mejvw ivvj( ek qnka 9>+0?"99+?? vhnyqm+ Ifkab jvwfkab mncn ekyn ivynmn
vwvk qhhny ]yjaqf Iqj Bahhf} Bf`haakmf Injnk Tfjahhaa qnp}( Bfbmvc Fja( fa aqa iay
lfk ama tf ynmqe mkqnkn cn}}n f nkn} ehbnj aak mf knthnyn dahnk mn layma+ E(
ynmqe mkqnkk ehnqhnykn qnjk ehmvv aak e njnb ynmqemn iay pyelynb awhfbfqf la}ba+
Inkn mfma ja( }fhfdek f}}a7 Ej}nq( nkjnqnmn iay fq ba tny5 Kf tny5 mfmab+ Iawabivynmn( ifk ynmqemn jekfya awhfmab dnjn} cfbfk nyjnkmnk nkjnqn Jjkmfk iayaa
lfhma( i}k nw tf f nkn} cnkbhny "nh}k awfyfj" Jjf nymhny+ mfma+ Qej mfmab
nkjnqnmn Injnkhny Jvyvhv }ephnk} tny ej}n kfbha iaw qhf iay cnify tfymaj+ Ifkab
lwbk kkmf ehmv+ mfma iv( qnka Lfhmahfy ynmqe ftakmfk( Jjk nyninhny cnkb
nkn}hnyk( nw nkn}hnyk nhm la}}ahfy Jjf+ Ekvk wfyakf mfmab ivkv awhfbfj hnwb+
Bfycvb Cfqak Fwfy tnym de}e bvcniaya ekv nynmb ftakmfk( mfmab ja7 Cfqak Nnifq
kfbha iay fq tny( iaw fkakhf ifhha iay qfymf ivhvvp mfmaab qfyf lamf`faw "ivkv mn iqhf
qhfbfbak fifia( Cfqak Fwfyak injn lnwf}fhfyhf inhnk} tny cnify eynqn jnbnk"
ivhv}vj nkjnqn Jjkk nkn jnp tny "kawnbaqf jnp" ekvk cfbfk nh}kmnja qehvk "ja
ivhtnyk abaka abma cn}yhnqnbnmb" inkmn abma lnhain Gnpek fdnyf}a ehnk iaknkk
kkmf iaw nyninqhn ifjhfbfqf inhnmj+ Pnn} 9?79= vhnykn meyv e kawnbaqf jnpkk
i}k jnphny nhm( nyninhny akbfqf inhnmhny qvjnymnk nnqn ifk ehniahmaa jnmny
}nkmb jaahfymfk nyninhnyk aakmfk qnkbwmnk lffyjfk jabhfy tnym ekhny ke} nhbnqn
nhqeyvb( Cfqak Fwfy de}eyndhnyk fjaqey qnkbwmnk lffk nyninhnyk+ Nkhnmj ja
cnjajn}fk Injnkhny Jvyvhv mfah iay nw tfqn f tfqncv} jekfy ivkn ifkwfy iay fq
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
7/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
8/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 73
tfqn cnjnyf} iay fq ifjhaqeyvb lfh lfh e}vy vynqn mfma e}vymvb+ Ifk fkak nnifqakak
nyjnmnqb mfma+ qa( }nbnb+ Kaqf iqhf qnpqeyvkvw5 mfma+ Kfqa qnpqeyvw fdfkmab5
Kaqf lamaqeyvkvw nkjnqn Jjkf Lnwf}f`aqaw+ Ehvy bv iqhf fq5 @vbcvyinjnk(
jeje`n `vbcvyinjnk Fdfkmab( lnwf}f`aqaw iaw( iawab iay fq qnp}bw qej+
Vwn}bnqnqb iawa nkjnqn Jnynjehvkmn abma qjhm e qfyhfy" eynmn nn} mymf jnmny iawa
nhjeqmvhny+ j}j ekyn yfkmaj ja Nh}nk qbfk ahf Nqmk Jjfy tnym "e mn yncbf}ha ehmv"
ekv mn iay injn nyninmn ivhbvhny ekv mn iayak`a vifqf l}ybhfy eynmn cnjnyf}
f}bahfy( ekhny mnqnj qfbfba( ekhny Cajbf} ]nkhjnk jnmny nkw mfahma+ Ekhnymn( eynmnk
e fjahmf jbhny+Iaw fy}fa lk iay ink }ephnk} qnp}j "iqhf iay eyv jnybn jn`nk iahfqmab
Kf| qeyj ]abfmn jnk cnifya lf}ayaymab cvwvyvkvwn" je`nbnk iay cnify Kf| Qeyj
]abfmn qnqkhnkm ]yjaqfmf lnwf}f`ahfy jnynjehn n}hqey mnqnj qaqeyhny+ maqf Kf| Qeyj
]abfmn v ieqmn iay cnify+ Qnka pnynk}fw aakmf iahlakawf vknqb7 E( ]yjaqfqa
majjn}akawf vkvqeyvb( iv ]yjaqfqa mf h}dfk cndwnkwmnk( ifk ivkhny nkhn}yjfk lfayak
}ntaqf fmfyab maqeyvb+ Iawab jnynjehn n}hbnbw Kf| Qeyj ]abfmn cnify ehmv+ ]niaa( a}f(
iawf( qakf nkjnqn Jjkf la}bahfy `vbcvyinjnkk addf}a cnyfbakf jnmny }f`ntwf}bfqf jnhjbhny( iv jnmny fmfpawhaj ehvy bv5 Tfnayf tfnayf+ Iv }y fqhfyf fpfq
bvcn}np ehmvj whfyf bwhfyf cn}}n inw lnwf}fhfymf qnqkhnymn ehmv Mfbejyn} _ny}aqa
}v}nk Wndfy lnwf}fa tfnayf mf nbn ehnq iv ama+ Mncn ekyn ekvk iay dn}vynkifk iay injn
tfahfqhf >163 qhkmn qnka aja fkf ekyn }yfkmf iay bahhf}tfjaha vyn}bn }ejn} n}bnj vyf}aqhf
dn}vynq iay mf eynmnk jnym+ Iqhf`f mfbfqa qnp}j fdfkmab+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Ftf}+
Injnkb mftnb fmfiahay baqab5
INJNK Ivqvyvk+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Iaw }nkivhmn Mehbnincfmf Ifmaa Dnaj Ifqa
makhfba}aj fpfq yfkjha iay jaahaa tny+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ftf} qhfmay+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Pawakhf qhhny`n bfna nyjnmnhkw qnp}+ Ekn mn
eymvj eynmn dnjn} eybnmnk qhf iay layawlc qnp} jfkmaa7 Jvyv`v Bf`ha maqf iay fq
jvyvhmv 4? ekyn( pfj ej jabfqf Dnhac Ydj Ifq mf inkn mn }fjhad lfhma+ Iqhf iay fq
qnpbnqw mfmaj+ Iaw Ej}nq Fja Nkjnyn bvcniayabawma e wnbnk ekv lkmfymaj( ekv nhk
mfmaj nhmhny mn ka}fjab+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
9/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 71
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Jfkmaa vqmvybv ekv( jvvyn injbnk nbn ca nhnjn
qej+ Ifk }nhap ehmvb( jntlnqn laymab Yncbf}ha Cnnk Nha Q`fh }nhap}a( Yncbf}ha Kacn} Fyab
}nhap}a nqmb aabhfy Cnnk Nha Q`fha ekyn Hftfk} Fbfy maqf iay nyjnmnbw tnym la}}a
ajkn f}ba inkn lfhma mfma ja7 Ifk Cnnk Nha Q`fh Ifq tnwlfbfqf ajkn f}}ab ej}n
kfbha iay ynjap( nbnk n eh aqa f}baak nkbw ny}ymk iv nqfmf+ Kacn} Fyab }nhap}a nbn
ekyn fabf laybfj}fk tnwlf}a( kaqf ehmvvkv iahfbaqeyvb+ Yncbf}ha F`tf} Lyfak }nhap}a(
yncbf}ha Bfcbf} Jfbnh Jvyvkehv }nhap}a mncn ej tny( qnka ej `amma iay jntlnq iaw fab
jntlnk qnnmj+
wak tfyayfkaw adnmf fmfqab tahnqf}}fk nhmbw "ifk e wnbnk Lnwf}f`ahfy@fbaqf}akak Lfkfh Pfjyf}fyaqab" ha}f "bfhfj jvyvhvhnykk qkf}ab jvyvhhny lawha eqhn
qnpqeyhnym( iay nynqn lfhf`fjhfy lawha eqhn fab qnpn`njhnym" nhmb ha}fmf bffy Ppey
Qnwnyhnykk Mfykfakak aba qejbv( intvymvhny Qjfj Pfab Jvyvhv fababawa iewmv
Paw ivkhny nhbnbkw fab eqhnbnkn maqf mfmaj ja7 Tahnqf}ak tfymaa ha}f iv acbnh
f}ba tahnqf} mfmahfy+ Nbn iv fabak kf}a`faka f}jahfqfiahf`fj iay mvyvb }fjyny
qnpn`njkw faba+ mfmahfy+ = E`nj >14> lk }fjyny fab qnpbnqn bf`ivy ehmvj tf
}fjyny fahmaj+ Qnka( Ifmaa Ifqak mncn ekyn ifkab pn}yekvb tfnayf maqf Jvyv`v Bf`haqfa ajfk la}}ab }nkivhn( jfkmahfyakf nqlb adnmf fmfyfj "wn}fk nqyhb}k Mkqn
lnwf}fakmfk" qhf iay jekvbnbw ehmv+ Caiay fjahmf Ifmaa Ifqak ifka lkmfybfj}a
tfnayf maqf cfycnkla iay yeh ehmvvkv Cndwn lnhain jfkmaaka nhmn}b caiay fjahmf
lfyfjhf nhnjn qej}vy+
Ivqvyvk+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! Pawak mncn ekyn Hekmynqn fhahaj j}aia ehnynj
lkmfyahbfkaw tny+ E yf keybnh iay yf ba5 Qnka e knh ehmv( ekv iay nkhn}y bkw5
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Cfbfk nkhn}nqb+ Ifk mfkaw e }nyac}f lfya Mkqn lnwf}fa
Nkjnyn }fb`aa ehnynj qhf7 >1 qnkmn lnwf}f`ahaf inhnmb( 9>"99 qnkmn mn ifhja mf
90}y }fbah`aa ehmvb+ kfbha iay jekvbmv dnjn} jfkmaba haf bfwvkv ehnynj qf}fyha
caf}baqeymvb( fjajhfyab ehmvvkvk dnyjkmnqmb( katfya}fqa bv}hnj vyf}}f ia}aybfb
lfyfj}aaka tf fk nw iay mah yfkbfb lfyfj}aaka mkqeymvb+
I}k ivkhnyhn Jvyv`v Bf`ha mkfba mf lfyamf jnhmj}nk ekyn e }nyac}f "qfya mf iv
ynhnymn iaynw }fnmd ehmv" iay lk fbf tf fahbf qn ahf ahlaha jekv Jvyv`v Bf`ha}fk
lyhyjfk( ifk mfkaw fahbf qnkk 96( fbf qnkk >3 ehbn lfyfj}af ahajak
kfylf tfymab "Jvyv`v Bf`ha wni}hny }nkj}y iv mfmajhfyabf" e nynmn Ihfk} F`fta} yncbf}ha
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
10/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>?
w a}fma ifkmfk "nh w cnjj ifkabma" mfmab ja7 Ihfk} Ifq jekvvk e mn bffy nqk
fqa kfyf`fjba( ekyn ifk jekv}vb( jekvvyjfk mfmab ja7 Ifk bfhfabf mkf`fab(
jfkmabhf ahlaha iay kfya tfyaqeyvb mk`fa wacakhfyakawmf mebnk maqf in}nk adnmf
fmaqeyvb( Jvyv`v Bf`ha ia}ak`f ifk bfhfabf mkf`fab mfmab( mkmb+
Vhv lnwf}fakmf a}acinyn} fda ehmvb Ihfk} Ifq }fjhad f}}a+ Dnjn} pny}a lnwf}fakmf nhbnj
iay lnwf}f`a aak ej wey( j} iay fqmay+ kj pny}ahahfy cfyjf jfkmaakmfk mncn iqj iayaa
ehbnmk mkmjhfya aak nwhnykmnk jnk cfy hndk bncw" cnjajn} ehmvvkmnk fbak
ehmvjhny aak( fy}fa lk lnwf}fmf jj l}fyahayf jwnyhny( ehbnwn jwnyhny tfnayf
tfnayf+ qhf iay ey}nbmn aak }nm ehbnmk majjn}f nhnynj qvy} mkn la}bfqf tffjajhfyaba }nbnbhnbnqn kaqf}hfkmab+ Kf qnpniahayaw( knh qnpniahayaw5 Iay lk abma
fbfjhaqf nqyhm Qvymnjvh Dak`nk`ehv maqf iay bvcniay nyjnmnbw tnym+ Lfhma mfma ja
Ej}nq inj fk qvy} mkn la}bfj a}aqeymvk @vbcvyaqf} lnwf}fakmf Menk ]nkqfy tny(
Menk ]nkqfy Nnifqabaw iawab+ Menk nnifq ifka nym( Hekmynqn lamf`fjba nbn
ej jwb Bf}ak ]ejfyf mf ny hndhny fmfyfj jfkmaakf kfyahfk aa yfmmf}ba+ Kfqba5
Mfmab7 Menk ]nkqfyak fa yncn}wb( Bf}ak ]ejfyf mfba ja7 Ifkab abjkhnyb bna}
mfah( qvy} mkmn }fmnta f}}ayfiahf`fab nbn inkn iay nyf ivhniahay baakaw5 Bf}ak ]ejfy mfmfba ja7 Tnhhnca ifk iay fq qnpnbnb nbn bf} _nnqhn iay jekvnqb+ bf} _nnqn
qhfba( bf} _nnIninjnk+ E mn mfba ja Bf}ak ]ejfyf ekv}n Tnhhnca eynmn fhahaj}f
iay qfy( iay a }fbak fmfiahayhfyf jekv mn cnhhfmahak+ Bncnhha j}aphaj }fjhad f}bahfy( bnn 4?
klahaw hayn( ivlkj pnynqhn kf fmfy5 >6? mehny fmfy ba5 F}bfw+ Iqhf iay fq+ 4? klahaw
hayn+ Menk ]nkqfy mfba ja Bf}ak ]ejfyf Ifkabhf nhnq b fmaqeyvkvw5 Ifk iv faba 4?
haynqhn l}yfb jabf }fmnta f}}ayayab( knh }fmnta f}}ayayab5 Yfmmf}ba ny iay bfj}vphn+
Menk ]nkqfy ivkv Qvymnjvhn qhfba( Qvymnjvh mn jfkmaa mf ftha( e`vjhv ehmvv aak
inkn mfma ja7 Ej}nq( fkak iqhf iay kaqf}ak tnym( ifk mf lamfbfb( lamfiahay baak5 Tnhhnca
lamfyab mfhmab( ifk ifjy iay nmnbb( 4? hayn mn ifkab pfjh aaba wfy+ Kf qnpnyw5
]vycnk Dfqwaehv e wnbnk yncbf}ha Ininjnk Qnymb`( ]vycnk Dfqwaehvkn mfmaj ja7
lamfhab( ynkmftv a}fqfhab( jekvnhb+ La}}aj ajabaw( mfmaj ja7 Iawab qvy} mkmn ejvbnj tf
iqhf iqhf jfkmabawa lfha}aybfj laia iay mfymabaw tny+ bjk nyqeyvw( iawf iqhf iay fq
j}( qnymb f}bfj a}fy baakaw5 Cn( ehvy( fhif}}f( inkn mfka qnpnyb+ mfma dnjn} ]vycnk
Ifq iay nq( aja nq vkv}}v ivkv+ 9= Fqhh >149 lk bf} _nnkk mevb qh mkb tny+
Ivhtny _nhn maqf iay e}fh tny+ Ivhtny _nhn}n iaw bf} _nnkk mevb qh mkb
mehnqqhn lnwf}f`ahfy( a}f( aqnahfy lfhaqey( cnify( la}}aj+ ]vycnk Dfqwaehv jnpmnk afya
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
11/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>>
layfyjfk ifka lym+ Nn( fk ch ivynmn bk5 mfma+ Ivynmnqb+ mfmab+ Cnka
jekvbv}vj5 mfma+ Ff( aw( jekv}vvbvw eynmn jnhm( iay fq qnpbnmkw ja+ mfmab+
Nbnk( qnyk inkn lfh+ mfma+ Fy}fa lk la}}ab ]vycnk Dfqwaehvkn( mfma ja7 Kfqma iv5
Mfmab7 }f( ifk iqhf iay fq Cfbfk mfma7 Ifk wn}fk Mahfya Injnkkn tfjhf}
fmaqeyvb( abma( iv aa cnhhfmfyaw+ Knbj Qehln( Vbvba J}ap( ekn }fhfdek f}}a( iayahfyaka
nym( mfyjfk mfmahfy ja7 Injekehehvj}n bncnhh j}aphaj tny "qnka e k`fja
jekvbnqn mnqnh ehnynj qhf iay fq tny" a}fyfkaw( fbyfmfyfkaw iv jvhhnkhniahay+
]nbnb+ Pnkn vqlvk bv5 Vqlvk( ifkab nbmnk 4? klahaw hayn qf}fy( ifjy iay yfk`a
cnqn}kn qf}f`fj iay pnyn+ Ifkab mf dnwhn iay ammanb qej( bnjnmb kj v7 ]vycnk Ifqqhfma( iayahfyakf iay fq qnphm( a}f( cnify lkmfyak dahnk ehmv( ekv ehnynj bncnhh j}aphaj(
Hekmyn Injekehehvvkmn 4? klahaw hayn bnnh bncnhhj}aphaf ifk }nhap ehmvb( la}}ab(
eynmn ivvj fkf iv dn}hn( iv lyfthf jnhmb( ehnq ivmvy+
INJNK Pnqk Fja( ej }ffjjy fmaqeyvw+
Jj iay vqny( cn}yhn}bn ehnynj nkhnynkw ej bfbkvk ehvyvb( bbjk ehmvv
jnmny mncn jn `ftnphny tfyayfkaw wnbnk aqa jvhhnkbnj nmkn+ ej eyvv tny nyjnmnhnyk
tf iayjn nh} jebaqek nqk nkmn awf eyvhny qkfh}f`fj+EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Pnqk Injnk( majjn} fmfyab( ehvy fdfkmab+
INJNK @fklaw Qntahaehv Ifq( ivqvyvk h}dfk+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb!Ce lfhmakaw Pnqk Fja+
Fdfkmab( ifk >14? tf Nh} Jebaqekvkmnqb+ abma( inkk mnyifhfymf iay
}v}vbv tny( mnyifhfy k`fakmf tf mnyifhfy ekynkmn iay }v}vbv tny+ >14? mnyifa
k`fakmf jnk cnifyhfy tny( ekynkmn jnk cnifyhfy tny+ Cn}}n iay qvtnyhnj bnn
}ephnk}hny tny( Bahh Iayhaj Mfjhnynqekv fjhakmf iay qvtnyhnj bnn }ephnk}+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Cnklaa( nkhnqnbnmb ekv fdfkmab+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Iv 9< Bnq}n( 9< Bnq ekynkmn cfbfk(
qvtnyhnj bnn }ephnk}hny+ Iv qvtnyhnj bnn }ephnk}hnykmn aqna pny}ahfy }ephnkqey( Bahh
Iayhaj Jeba}fakak peha}ajnhnyk qnpn`n ahfyf bvcnhfdf} f}bfbfhfya iay( ajak`aa( mnyif
ekyn qnphnk ahfyf bvcnhfdf} f}bfbfhfya( mnyifqa mf fhf}aybfbfhfya qkkmf ej jnin`n
"cnjwhj f}bfqfqab" iqhf iay nkhnbn qnphqey+ Ivkvk njniakmf mf ink nkhnbn
qnphqey( Nknmehvmnk ink bfkvphny( wbay( Nkjnyn( }nkivh ink bfkvphny mn
}ephnkqey( e qvtnyhnj bnnmnk jnk ekvhnyn majjn} fmahbfa( ivkhnyk nhfqcakf mf qnw
qnwbnbnhny a}fkaqey+ abma( }niaa( mncn ekyn mn iqj eynkmn iv nhnkqey+ ]niaa(
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
12/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>9
mnyifkak "46}fk ekyn dnyjh fqhfy mf tny" dnjn} k`fakf mf inj}bwmn jnk cnifyhfyak(
mnyif fknkmn( ekynkmn qnwhnk cnifyhfyak ej mn meyv ehbnm Pekynkmn iaw
ivkv Ifmaa Dnajf mf eybv}vj( e mn Cnifyhfya ej dnwhn jek}yeh fmfbaqeymvj e mkfbmf+
cn}}n ifhja qhf mf qhfkfiahay qnka Lfhfk cnifyhfya jek}yeh f}bf l`bw b tnym5
fjhakmf( qhf nkhnhniahf`fj fqhfy qhfma+ Bffhn ivkhny afyaakmf mfpehnymn ej dnwhn
ahnc ivhvkmvv( iay y aknkk( yfk`akak hmyhm tfnayf iv }ap cnifyhfy qnphqey+
Cn}}n iay cnify tny ja a}f( Nymncnkk Yvhnyn }fjhad fmahmaa laia Bfkmfyf }nyndkmnk( iv }ap
cnifyhfy mf tny+ Njniakmf mf }niaa( nbn nhnkqey+ Iaw mf iahaqeyvw ja( mnyif k`fakmf
bbjk ehmvvk`n aj}amny qpyn}hqey qnka a}ainywhn}yhqey( ekynkmn mn jny qehvknjfy bmncnhf ehmvv fjhakmf iay nhl qnyn}hqey( ivkn wfbak cnwyhnkqey+ E wfbakak iay
pnyn ehmvv lwjqey+
kj cfbfk njniakmf mf bffhn Cyyaqf} lnwf}fakmf Jvy}vhv Inqynb j
c}ahnhabaw Bahh kjhnp jqey bffhn+ j c}ahnhabaw f}ak Nh}nk( Pnqk Nh}nk iqhf iay qnw
qnwqey+ Ieqkv Ijjhfy laia tvy fkfakf( nh fjbfaka nkhnk ]yj bahhf}akak
vqvvjhvvkmnk iaymfk ahjakap i}k e injq tfnayf n}}kn mnay cnifyhfy jqey+ Cn}}n
mncn mn ahfya ykfjhfy tny( ifk ivkhny nkhn}bnqnqb dnjn} ifkwfy mvyvbv lfhaqeyvw 93vin}}n mn lyqeyvw+ 93 vin}}n mn iay iyadakl tfyahaqey ">? Cnwaynk >11
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
13/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>0
mnyif ekynhnykmnk cfp atah nhnk mf}fjhfqa`a eq tfyaqey( lhfkmayaqey eynq+ Ivkn mncn
injn fjahmf qakf injqeyvw( bfmqn Ntyvpn Iayhaakmfja bfmqnqn ltfkak qnykn ncap
iawmf+ Iawmf qnka mafy jvyvb( jvyvhvhnyn( Cjbf}f ltfk ekynk jn}fmaqeyvb+ }f(
fhabmf iay nyn}ybn ekv`v tny( qnjhnj qwmf 6?hfyf qnjk Ntyvpnmn inkn ltfk( iawmf
qwmf 96hfy `atnykmn+ Iqhf mf iay ekv tny+ Qnka ink mnyif k`fakmf( ynkmn tf
ekynkmn mnyif`ahfyhf knh iay ahaja jvyvqey5
]ffjjy fmaqeyvb Pnqk Fja+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ifk mf }ffjjy fmfyab+
k`f awak tfyayfkaw v ltfk bffhfakf mfakfqab mf ekmnk ekyn mafyhfyakfPnqk Injnkk mn adnmf f}}ajhfya laia ehniahmaak`f jn qnk} tfybfqf nhnqb+
Iv ltfk jekvhv nkjf}hfy( qejhnbnhny( nhkmn yfbak e nkjf}a qnpnkk vqlvhnm
bf}emn tf eyvhnykn lyf ev jfw nk`nj qnyk l}fyay( e mafy qnyk l}fybfw qnka
ynjnbnh inw fqhfy jny ey}nqn nbn nh lfyfa l}fybfw+ Iay mfdn e jekvmn `awnkf
majjn}akawf vkbnqn mffy ivhmvvb cvv( dnwhn `ammaqf nhkbnbnkk mncn meyv ehmvv
fjhakmfmay+
jak`a cvv@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Pnqk Fja( nddfmfyakaw( ej wy mahaqeyvb+
Iv ltfk }f}hfyaka( jnbveqv nyn}ybnhnyk cfb vhvhnynyn nyn}ybnhnymnk cfb
iawab ]yjaqfmf qnphnk nyn}ybnhnymnk inj}b+ Qnjhnj ekvhny tny fdfkmab+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ifk mf Nbfyajnmnjahfy mf mcah ehbnj wfyf }nbnbk
jnpnqnk iay ly adnmf f}bfqf nh}b fdfkmab+ Iv nyn}ybnhnymn vbvbaqf}hf ink ahf
peha}ajn` qnk qnkn jny( inwfk iayaa ekmnk iay jnmfbf qvjnymnmy( inwfk iay jnmfbf }fja
qvjnymnmy+ Iv "}fjyny nyw fmaqeyvb" nca mffyhfkmaybfbf lyf ej kfbfkbfbfa
`awnkf nyw f}bfqf kaqf}ha ehmvvb iay cvv( ekv eynmn jffhab+
Pawak mfakmaakaw( qvtnyhnj bnn jekdfynk mfmaakaw cvv( wnkkfmaqeyvb ja( >6
Fjab >14> }nyacakmf qnphnk >14> fabakak nymkmnk( Bahhf} Bf`haakmf @vbcvyaqf} Cnhj
_ny}aakak nkmnhqfa dnwhnqm( @vbcvyaqf} Pfkn}evkmn Nmnhf} _ny}aa tf Qfka ]yjaqf
_ny}aakak iayhaj}f nkmnhqfa qakf dnwhnqm( e `amma iay lfyahab qnyn}}+ ]yj Pahnch Jvttf}hfy
Iayhaa maqf iay iayhaj ehv}vyvhmv+ Jfjf iv Jebaqek( jfjf iv Nyn}ybn Jebaqekv ]yj
Pahnch Jvttf}hfy Iayhaa bffhfakak mf aakf layf( e lfyfjhfya mf ey}nqn jnyn+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Injqeyvw ftf}( injqeyvw Pnqk Fja+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
14/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>=
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ ]yj Pahnch Jvttf}hfya Iayhaa >6 amnb( >6aka mf }nmaj
fmf`fjakaw+ maqf iv Bf`ha iaknk nym+ Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa qfhfya( pnwnyhjhn( }fcma}hfyf
nhmy f}bfqfyfj tfnayf ekv 0f akmayma+ Iqhf lfyfjhfya tny iv ]yjaqf,kak }nyacakak+ ]yj
Pahnch Jvttf}hfya Iayhaa aqna aj}amny atah e}eya}fqf tfybfqf jny ehnk njfyhfyak
"ivkhny j} nj ehnynj" pye}ejehhfy abwnhnqp in}nk ekn amnyfqf fh jeqbn jnynyhhk
ey}nqn jeqnk iay cnyfjf}}a+ }f( e ]yj Pahnch Jvttf}hfya Iayhaakak bmncnhfakf bnnmf
f}bfbfj aak @fbnh Lyfh "bfycvb" wb ehnynj aqna pny}ahfyak hamfyhfyaka iay nynqn
lf}ayfk iay qvtnyhnj bnn jekdfynk }ephnm+ Pwk f}}aakaw jekdfynk e ehbnj lfyfjay+
QNNY JNYNQFH #Jnqfya! Pnqk Fja( nddfmfyakaw( nynqn laybfj mfah mfaabhfkmayfiahayfkaw ffy cndwnkwmn tnyn jnq}hnyn laybfa nkmnk kfbhamay maqf
mvyvbv+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Iv Pahnch Jvttf}hfy Iayhaaqhf nhnjnh+
QNNY JNYNQFH #Jnqfya! Ekhny aabhfkmaybf abjkkw tnyn+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ ]niaa }niaa( nyw f}}aab laia iv Bf`ha J}pcnkfakmfja
jehfjaqekhnymn mn tny+ Cn}yhnmb ifkab @ftmf} Pvknqk abwn tnymy eynmn( jnyn
jvttf}hfya jebv}nkkk abwn tnymy( eynmn nhinqhnyn jnmny iay y( iayej "inhnqk qnkajbqey nkhnbkmn iay adnmf f}bfj a}fbaqeyvb( jabfqf nqlwhj f}bfb a}fbfb
nbn" pfj ej vinqk abwn tny( jehfjaqekhnymn tny ivynmn Bf`ha J}pcnkfakmf( cfpa
mvyvqey( nj( jn jfyf qnwhm+ Ekvk aak qnka ifk ]fj }fj v nkmn aab nqbnbn hwvb
qej( wn}fk jehfjaqekhny qhqey+ mfbfj a}aqeyvb+
Iv atah amnyfqf aj}amnyk mftyfmahbfaka fklfhhfbf nbnh e cnyfjf} ehvk`n Lyfh(
}niaa( bf} _nnkk mn mf}faka nhnynj atah e}eya}fqf mftya aak wb ivhbn nbn`qhn
wk f}}aakaw qvtnyhnj bnn jekdfynk maqf ifkab mf cn}ybmn jnhnk }ephnk}q
mwfkhfma+ Eynmnk iay bv}ninjn} bf}ka j}( e bv}ninjn} bf}ka nymkmnk awak wk
f}}aakaw laia ink mn cnka awlaqf e}vy}nhb }y iay }ephnk} qnphm maqeyvkvw(
cn}yhnbqeyvb( caiay dajyab qej+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Tf qnka iv tny( jnq}hnymn mn tny+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Caiay dajyab qej ifkab qnka cndwnbmnk mn jb ehniahay+
Iahbaqeyvb( qnphm mn iayahfya( pn}yekhny jn}hm( ehniahay( iahbaqeyvb+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa qfhfya }nyndkmnk qnphqey
Pnqk Fja iv+ ]niaa( mafyaqhf iv ehnq
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Fdfkmab( Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa ia}}a e }nyac}f+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
15/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>6
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Qej cnqy Pnqk Fja+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Fdfkmab( >6 Fjab >14> lk Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa ia}}a+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Iv }ephnk}kk qnphm }nyac}f
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Mncn ekyn e+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! Iv }ephnk} >< Nv}e}n qnphqey( incf}ba
ehmvvb }ephnk}( mncn ekynkmn mn Qakf( ivynmn( cn}}n Bahhaqf} lnwf}fakak >3 Nv}e
>14> }nyacha kcnkmn mn tny( eynmnk nhk} qnphnynj ivkv vkvqeyvb awf+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Iv ifkab iahbfmaab iay }ephnk} ehn`nj e wnbnk+
@FKLW QNTHEHV #Fywvyvb! kj eynmn ej kfbha iay }ephnk}( Qnnmnjnynyhnykk }ny}bn jekvv qnphbnbn laia iay fq mf jqey tf inkn mn Ivkv
qnpbnqk+ maqey+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ifkab iahmaab iay fqmfk w f}baqeyvkvw+ Ifkmfkaw e
ynmn Jvyv`v Bf`ha qfaqmab( inkk aakmf mfahmab( ivynmn Injnkhj Matnkkmn J}ap
qf ehnynj lyft qnpnk Jvyv`v Bf`haak qfaqmab+
Inkk iqhf iay }ephnk} qnpb ifk aakmf mfahab( iahbaqeyvb ehniahayab nbn ifkab
iahmaab >6 Fjab >14> fabakmfk ekyn ]yj Pahnch Jvttf}hfya Iayhaa mfmaab `vk}ncnyfjf}akak a}fmaakf fklfh ehvp yfgaba qfyakf( awlaakf e}vy}bn nbn`qhn qnphnk }ephnk}my+
Ekv( mafyaka ifk wn}fk ifk lnwf}f`a ehbnmb aak( qnka iahdaah lnwf}f`ahaj qnpbnmb aak e
}nyac}f( cfychmf iahbfmaab iay fqmfk w fmaqeyvkvw+
Qakf( ]yj Pahnch Jvttf}hfya iayhaakak e ynmnja yl}hfkba ehbnkmnk jnqknjhnknk
iay }ephnk}( iay qfymf qnphb af ekn iay fq maqfbfb+ Iahmaaba( ifk iahlakawf vkvqeyvb+ E
mafy mnyifhfy k`fakmf Bfmqn qhf qnqk qnpqey( iqhf qnqk qnpqey( iayahfya iawf }nhabn}
tfyaqey Ifk cnqn}b ieqvk`n inkn }nhabn} tfyfiahf`fj iay ininqaa}hf cfkw
jnyhnbnmb( ekv in}nk iahlakawf vknqb( pn}yekhnyb mncah iv jekvmn( ekv mn iahlakawf
vknqb+ Qnka( inkn( lyftaba ifk if`fyfiahmaab jnmny qnp}b( ifmfhaka mf mfmab+ Cfy
wnbnk ivkv iqhf qnp}b+ ]ntaqfmay( ya`nmy ekn ifkwfy fqhfy Ekvk mn aja }nkf ykfa
qfya lfhayf iahlakawf vknyb+ ]nhabn}caiay wnbnk Njfymfk bnjfymfk( atah e}eya}fmfk(
atah ehbnqnk e}eya}fmfk( vkmnk ivkmnk( yvcnkaakmfk( iahbfb kfakmfk( caiayakmfk iay
}nhabn} nhnynj( }b cnqn}b ieqvk`n lnwf}f`ahaj qnpbnmb+ Ekv in}nk majjn}akawf
vkvqeyvb+
Injnhny nhb bmy5 Iahbaqeyvb+ _n}yekhny mwfqakmf iay fq ehbv bvmvy5
Iahbaqeyvb+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
16/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>4
Ia}}a fdfkmab+
INJNK Ftf} }ffjjy fmfyab+
w`nk Qfkafya Ifq( ivqvyvk h}dfk+
W@NK QFKFY #Nkjnyn! Ftf}+
Pnqk Fja( }fjyny ce lfhmakaw+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Pn ehvk Ce`nb+
W@NK QFKFY #Nkjnyn! Paw }niaa( iv mnyifhfya iahdaah lwhfba( awhfba( jaba
wnbnk mn ekvhny a}ainyaqhf inw eylnkhnymn qfy nhb iay aknkkw+ Ekvk aak( awmfk iv
jekvmn ej kfbha jn}jhny ey}nqn jnyn`nbw ifk ncfk mkqeyvb+EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Pn ehvk fdfkmab+
W@NK QFKFY #Nkjnyn! Nbn abma( qnka iaw vkv qnpqeyvw lfkfhmf: }fjkaj
nkhnbmn kf ehmv5 E mkfb( v qnw kaqf qnwhm5 Qn mn a}f( ivkvk mnyif fmahfk yf`f
f}jaa kfmay5 fjhakmf eyvhny eyvhvqey+
Ifk vkv qhfqfqab7 ]yjaqfmf mnyifhfy jnmny qnkh nkhn}hb( nhjhnkb(
jv}nkb( thb( hnkf}hfkba( }nynd}ny ehvkbv tf jny jhb iay eqnh ehlv mncn qej
tf cfyjfak iay iaabmf( qn qnkkmn qn mn jnykmn ehmvv iqhf iay ehlvqv( }nyndw tflfyfjhfyf vqlvk iay iaabmf ey}nqn jeqbnkk cfy fqmfk ej mncn dnwhn wey ehmvvkv
mkqeyvb+
abma( ehnk ahf ehbn hnwb lfhfk( ehlv ahf nhl nynkmnja dnyjhhj iawa mnyif laia `nk
nh` iay eyvkv nhlhnbnj}n jk} qnyn}qey+ Mnyif tf bvc}yn( k`fakmf qn mn ekynkmn
jnk mjhbfa "k`fakmf( ynkmn tf ekynkmn" amnbhnyk ehbn( ehlvqv nkhnbnmn tf
nkhnbhnkmybnmn jk} qnyn}bnj}nmy+ Qnka( ekv}n evbnb qnynhny( chfk
njakhfbfba mvqlvhnyk tf makbfba djfhfyak f}jaa nh}kmn ehnk ia}fka njhnbnj ej
mncn wey+ Ekvk aak ifk qhf iay fqak wfhhajhf awmfk `ftnik nhbnqn nhn`nb7 abma(
>1=1=4mnja eqvkv }fjynyhnqn`njhny( aj}amny bvcnhfdf}f
iynjbnqn`njhny( ]yjaqf iqhf iay yfwnhf}f ajak`a mfdn nckf ehbnbnh( ivkn bnnmf
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
17/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
18/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>3
nmnb ehmvvkv wnkkf}baqeyvb+ >164( 6< tfqn ifjha mf 63 qhkmn }nyac mncn ej kf}
mfahab" Jvybnq Iakin Pnbf} Jvv }nyndkmnk "ahlahfyf maqfqab" yfba bnjnbhnyn iay
acinymn ivhvkvhmv7 Iay njfy `vk}n Mfbejyn} _ny}a aj}amnyk( Nmknk Ifqak Cjbf}aka
mnyifqhf akmaybfj nbn`qhn nhqey+ maqf+ Pnbf} Jvvkvk aciny wfyakf @fbnh Qhmyb
mncah "qnkh cn}yhnbqeynb" 1=4 fabakmf ivqvymvvkvw laia jayhahajhfy
tnymy nbn e mkfbak j}amny ivkmnk cfbfk mfy nhb}y+ bf} _nn( Bf`ha}fja( jak`a
Iqj Bahhf} Bf`haa tny qn( nkn iakn( ivkmnk k`fja( e iaknqn =4 fabakmfk ekyn qnphnk
@vbcvyinjnkh faba nymkmnk Bf`haak nh }yfkakmf jekvbn qnpbnj aak la}}aa
wnbnk Bf`haak nkn jnpkmnk layfbfma( nyjn jnpmnk layma+ Kaqf5 kj( fabhfymfja cahfqwkmfk( iayajfk }fpja qwkmfk iay yncn}whj mebnk maqf qhf iay }fmiayhf nhmhny+ Nbn
bf} _nn =4 fabhfyakak jayhahaakmfk ej iqj wmynp mvqmv( bvnwwfpf ej+ E qwmfk
fab a}fbaka iaynk k`f mwfh}bf tf aj}amny jnwnknk fhhfyf( }fbaw fabhf jnwnknk fhhfyf
}fhab f}bf }nhabn}k tfyfyfj Pfab Jnkvkvk jbnk nhnm+ >16? fabhfyakmfk cfbfk
k`fja jnkvkmnk w fmaqeyvb( fjfyaqf} a}fbaka tf lawha eq nj }nkad vhk lf}ayfk
qnnmnk w fmaqeyvb+ bf} _nnkk e }nyac}fja }nty ja iay kvbnynh aabma( mfbejyn}aj
a}fbf meyv ]yjaqfqa l}ybfqma+ Cn}}n( >16?ha qhhnymn iay lk( bf} _nnqn yncbf}ha
Nmknk Bfkmfyf jymfk( fk mj Bahh fd mfah baak5 Mkj dna} hamfy mfabhaak5
Bnknkmn ny iay hnd f}}aa wnbnk bf} _nn jnhj}( la}}a mfma ja Ifk e }nyac}fk iv hjfqa
mfbejynaqf lf}aymab( aw ivynmnk kfyfqf l}yqeyvkvw ekv cfnp fmak+ Lfyfj}fk
ehnqhnyk fqya ivmvy( e }nyac}f bf} _nnqn cfycnkla iay fjahmf E aj}amny tfybfw( ekv
aqna mfbejyn}aj a}fbak awlaakmf }v}nhb+ maqf iayaakak lamfiahf`faka tfqn e nbnhn
W@NK QFKFY #Nkjnyn! bf} _nnqn mfah( Dncya Ifhfk _nnqn
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Dncya _nnqn lamap mf ivkv }nhfp fmfiahf`fjhfyaka
nkbqeyvb+
W@NK QFKFY #Nkjnyn! abma( iv Nima pfja ahf bfy @enyk
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
19/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 7>1
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ bfy Pnba @enyk
W@NK QFKFY #NKJNYN! Ftf}( bfy Pnba @enyk ac}ahnhak Qw ja}nikmn
tny( iayej jnqknj}n mn tny+ Iv( fqhf eynmnk nia}( ekvk mn }fakmf wn}fk Fbak Nq}fjak mf
>1=1 qhkmn jfkmaakf ifkwfy iay }fjhad}f ivhvkmvvkv qhqey+ E mn maqey ja vin} nqkmn
=1vk ja Jvybnq Iakinkk ifka ifjhfmaaka lymb( qnkbn ejvhnynj Pfkakhf wfh
jekvbnj a}aqeyvw mfmahfy( lfkfh aqna mvyvbmnk incf}}ahfy( lfhf`fak jnynkhj ehmvvkv
bf} _nnkk 6? fabhfyakmf mf =4 ehnqhnyk }fjyny fmfyfj bahh aynmfkak }f`fhhaakf abjk
tfybfqf`faka qhfmahfy+ Mfbejyn} _ny}akak }v}vbvkv( qfka fabhfyhf fhmf fmf`fa kf}a`fqf
jeyvbn nwbaka ifhay}}ahfy+ Iv vyf}hf w( bfbhfjf}ak iay jnymf jntlnkn yjhfkf`fakej}nkn lf}aymahfy+ }f iv fjahmf( eymv qfka iay lkf tf eyvbhvhvj nh}kn laybfj}fqma tf
}v}vbn bnka ehn`nj iay cnwyhn inhnbnj wnbnk lfhba}a+ Jfkmahfya( eymv afyaakmf }fjahn}
jvybnj}nqmhny( ifka mfiv }fjahn}n nhbnq bknap lyqeyhnym+ maqey+ Qnka e wnbnk iqhf
iay cnwyhk Nkhn}qeyhny( ivkhnyk nkhn}}jhny kf jnmny meyv( qnkh jvjvvw }ny}hy
nbn vkv tvylvhnbnj aak adnmf f}}ab( qnka e mkfbmf bfqmnkn lfhfk cnmafhfy nkja iay
yf ekyn aj}amnyn jab lfhayf lfhak ekmnk ekyn lfhfkf jny mn nqk fjahmf qnphy+ Ekvk
aak mnyifhfy( iqhf iay pny}afh bnk}jhn mnyifhfya mffyhfkmaybfj qnkh}y( mnyifhfy bahh iayifhnmy( mfbejynakak ifhnmy( mfbejyna cn}nhmy maqfhab qnka ehlvkhnbnb
mfbejyna cn}nhmy tf mehnqqhn( qfya tf wnbnk lfhmaakmf cfyjff jny tf cfy jfabf
jny qnphqey+
jak`a eyvb fdfkmab( 9< Bnq}n awf lyf Nbfyajnkk f}jaa tf evj ny}hnyk
f}jaa tny bmy5 Tnyn iawf ebv} inw fqhfy qhfqfiahay baakaw5
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ce`nb( ej kf} iay iahlaqf ncap ehmvvbv qhfqfbfb+
Nbfyajn Iayhfaj Mfthf}hfyakak nj tfqn lawha mf}fa ehbnmnk ]yjaqfmf mnyif qnpbnkk
bbjk ehmvvkv wnkkf}baqeyvb nbn nqyk} iahbaqeyvb+ E lf`f( nn} fqyfj
lfaqeymv lnhain cn}yhnyb( yncbf}ha Nhpnyhnk ]yjfak fakmfk mnyifqhf ahlaha iahlahfya nhmj
ynmqemnk+ Ekvk ahj qhfmaa whfymfk iaya KN]Eqn( @FK]Eqn inhqw+ wmy+ Qnka e(
qf}fyak`f iahla tfyfiahf`fj jnmny nkqeyvb kfbha iay adnmfmay+ ]fjyny fmaqeyvb7 Nbfyajn
Iayhfaj Mfthf}hfyakak wbka tfqn nj fqa ehbnmnk( Iaw jnybnqw( qnpnyn qnpkhnyn fk
nwkmnk bna} iay }nty ehbnmnk ]yjaqfmf mnyif qnphniahf`faka wnkkf}baqeyvb( qnpnk
mn wn}fk nq ekyn iay injnqhn akmayayhfymaqf mkqeyvb+ Bnnhffd( ]yjaqf,kak aakmf
Nbfyajn Iayhfaj Mfthf}hfyakak fha dnwhnqhn tnymy( e kfmfkhf ivkn cnqy( ca nhnjn qej}vy
maqfbfb+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
20/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 79?
INJNK Ftf}+ Mftnb fmaqeyvkvw
W@NK QFKFY #NKJNYN! Pek ehnynj iay fq mf vkv eybnj a}aqeyvb7abma(
iv mnyifhfy}niaa aw wfhhajhf qnnmkw aak qhqeyvb" iqhf iay jekgekj}yfh fq awhaqey(
qnka mnyif iaabhfya+ abma( 9< Bnq >14? }nyacakmf ahnch( mncn k`fmfk phnkhnkb(
eylnkawf fmahba iay fjahmf qkf}abf fh jeqbn fjhakmf lfyfjhfba+ >9 Bny}( amfehegaj
nyhjh iay j}( >9 Bny}hnyk afyaakmfja ihkbf ekv a}ainyqhn jfkmaaka mfklfhfma( iay
lyvp mafyaka f}jaaw chf lf}ayma tf e mn iay bvc}ynqhn
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Paw qnpbnqk( iaw qnpnhb+ ehmv e+
W@NK QFKFY #NKJNYN! Ftf}( qhf ehmv+ >13?f lfhmaabawmf( 3?( }fjyny 9>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 79>
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ ]ffjjy fmfyab+
BFCBF] FJFY #Lnwank}fp! Tfymaakaw iahlahfy aak mf }ffjjy fmaqeyvw+
]niaa( ]yjaqfkak jnynkhj mkfbhfya mnyifhfy+ Qw qhmy iv hjf ivkhnyhn wnbnk
cny`qey+ @vbcvyaqf} mkfbakmf mf }niaa( iawab mnyif qnphm wnbnk nmf`f lw kkf
nhp( majjn}f nhmbw aak ivynmn }ny}qeyvw nbn ekvk mkmn( ayaha vdnjh( awak mf
incf}}aakaw laia cfy wnbnk jnhjbnhny ehbv}vy( bmncnhfhfy ehbv}vy+ }f( >6 }nkf
aknkk amnb fmahbfa aak Bf`haf inj qnphb}y( jnkvkhny jny}bnj aak inj
qnphb}y atah qn mn njfy pfj ej fjahmf ivkhny qnnkb}y+ Ivkhnyk cfpaka iahaqeyvw
nbn >16?ha qhhnyk inkmn Nhkmn fk iqj jk}bw mn vkv qhfbfj a}aqeyvb7Mkqnq fjekebaj tf eqepeha}aj nmnk aqa }nchah fmfbfmaabaw aak inbwn mn ivkhny
lfhaqey+ E mkfba aqa }nchah fmfbaqeyvw tf awak nmkwn iayahfya mf jp ej aqa }nchah fmaqey+
}f( e wnbnk ]yjaqfmf( cfbfk cn}yhnykw >16?ha qhhnymn jebkawbhf b`nmfhf
mfykfjhfya jvyvhvqey+ Jebkawbhf b`nmfhf mfykfjhfya >1
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
22/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 799
Qnyl( cfy wnbnk l`k qnkkmn ehbv}vy: ivkn jn}hy bkw5 Ivkv ej bfynj
fmaqeyvb+
Iay mf( awak fhakawmf iqhf iay iahla tny b5 >9 Fqhhmf 6 iak =?? jaa Mnkbn Bf`haa
qfa ehbnj aak intvybv ]yjaqfmf+ Ivkhnyk iay ha}fa tny bmy5 Jnq}hnykwmn tny b5
Lnwf}fkawmf tny b5 E wnbnk ivkhnyhn ahlaha ffy Jebaqekvbvwn lfhayf ej bfbkvk
ehvyvw ffy jnq}hnykwmn tnyn iv 6 iak =?? jaaqhf ahlaha+ Iaw Mnkbn Bf`haakmf lyft
nhbnj a}aqeyvw+ mfbahfymay+
Iay mf Pnddf} Pehnj abaka nkbny bkw5 Pnddf} Pehnj( jebkawbhf b`nmfhf
mfykfjhfyakak jvyv`vv( jvyv`v injnk tf mncn ekyn Bahh Kawnb _ny}aakak mf jvyv`vv+EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Cnqy( qnka abak qnink` lfhbfmaaka mkqeyvb nbn
iahmaaba qhfqf`fj jnmny wackabmf iayajab qej+
BFCBF] FJFY #Lnwank}fp! ]nkbqeyvkvw+
_fja( e wnbnk eyvbv }fjyny kf}hf}ayfqab7 E wnbnkja Jebkawbhf B`nmfhf
Mfykfa( ekyn >9 Fqhh mkfbakf lfhmaakmf( >9 Fqhhmfk k`f ]yjaqfmf qnphnk
fqhfbhfyf inj}kwmn( a}f jek}ylfyahhn( lhnmae( ]yjaqf Dajay Ngnk laia( B]ak iay iyev
ehmvv qhfkfk iv ngnkk( ivkhnyk yeh kfhfymay593 vin}n lfhmaabawmf dnaha bfcvh `aknqf}hfy tny+ ]yjaqfmf `amma fjahmf jk}hny
qnnkqey+ Qnka cfp ivkhny }fnmd b5 I}k ivkhny iay fh }nyndkmnk( iay eylnkawnqek
}nyndkmnk qnphnk fqhfy ba5 Ivynmn fk kfbhaa mf( bnnhffd iawab lymbw v7
Paqnahfyak mf a iayhaa tny+ Bnnhffd aqnahfymfk mfa iayhaa afyaakmf ehnkhny tny+ jinh aak
ehniahay( jeyjvqhn ehniahay( mfbejyna jh}ykk fjajhaakmfk ehniahay nbn ivkhny qnnkb tf
qnnkbnqn mn mftnb fmaqey+ Iv jekvmn dajyakawa nhbnj a}fmab+
]ffjjy fmfyab+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ ]ffjjy fmfyab Pnqk fjfy+
Pekmnk inhnqnqb: lfyfj}fk aqnahfyak wnbnk wnbnk iv jekvmn mf}fj tfymaa
Mncn kf mvyvqeyvkvw5 Wnbnk lfhbfma ba5 Mncn jn jaa hk5 }ykmfk iv mnyif
cftfhahfyakf }fhjakhfymf ivhvkmvv lfkfhhajhf iahakfk iay cvv}vy+ Ncbf}( Bfcbf}f qhfma+
maqf`fj jnmny ebv} iay ykfj tfyfbfb nbn iv( qnqlk iay fjahmf( jvhnj}nk jvhnn mvqvhnk
iay fqmay+ Cn}}n >13?( qnka >9 Fqhh >13?mfk k`f "Iv mn jnbveqvkn qnkm( nj iahla"
yncbf}ha iay iqjfhabaw "e ekyn aqnf} qnp}( ekyn iay nyn mn Mahfya Injnkh qnp}"
cnwyhnm nknqnn }nhnk jnbveqvqhn pnqhn}: qnka iay mnyifkak fqa
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
23/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 790
Qakf fja qhhnymn injnkhj qnpb iay iahab nmnbbw qnqkhnm mfylamf nknqnn
}nhnk qnqkhnm+ Qnka mnyifqa }nhfp fmfk nqmkbw( iahab nmnbbw( aqnf}abaw
ehbv}vy+ Iv( bnnhffd iay cnwak lfyfj}ay: iv iay+
ja: Mnkbn Bf`haa jekvvkmn 6 iak jvy intvyvkvk ehbv ehbn bbjk+
Ifkmfkaw jfkmabhf ahlaha iay cvvv iahlakawf vknqb+ E }nyac}f }nkivh Tnhaa ama Kftwn}
Nqnw+ Kftwn} Nqnw ifkmfkawf iay lk lybfj a}fmaaka qhfma+ Jekv}vj: Mnkbn
Bf`haakf qf ehbnb cvvvkmn iay }ntaqf qncv} }fjhad}f mncn meyv( nj adnmfqhf }fjhad}f
ivhvkbnj aak ly}k( lybf a}faka mahf lf}ayma+ Mfmab ja7 ej }ffjjy fmfyab+
Ifk aabmfk tf jekvbvbmnk bfbkvkvb+ ]n}bak ehvqeyvb aabmfk+ Mncn k`f mf Jvyv`vBf`ha qfhaa qnp}b+ Jnhm ja( Jvyv`v Bf`ha}f iaw fahfyfj lfhba}aj tf fqma( cfycnkla iay
njfy fha ehnk iay }nynd qej}v aak aakmf+ Ivkmn meyvmnk meyvqn Bahh Ltfkhaj Jekfqakak
ha}fakmfk awf aab lfhaqey: ifhhaqma e+ Mfmab ja Ifka bnwvy lyk( ifk laybfb+ Ekv e
vyf}hf( jfkmabhf ahlaha bffhfqa jnpn}}b+ Nbn iayej intvyvkvk ehmvvkn ahajak iahla ifkmf
mf tny: ynjnbnh iay iahlab tf ha}f qej+
Qnylkk ]yjaqfmf( }niaa yfgabmf tf cfpabawak qnnbkmn ej `amma f}jaa tny tf
mnyifhfy mkfbakmf mf iv f}ja ej ej( ej mncn dnwhn ny}qey: mfmaakaw ej meyvmvy+Bnnhffd ]yj aqnf}aakak inbw qnyl lfyfakf ynw ehbn ch bbjk ehbnm+
Paqnf} qnpbqeyvb ivynmn( nh}b qhhj lnwf}f`a ehnynj tf }b a}fkhaabhf jekvvqeyvb+
]yjaqfmf qnyl( 6? k`fakmfk mf inhnqnynj pak v`vkv aqna aj}amnyk fhakmf }v}bnj
meyv ehvy+ nkhnqkk flfbfk ehbn qwkmfk ja( e }nyac}f ivkvk ntvkv`vv yncbf}ha
Cnhah wqyj ama: ej mn }nkkb( iahakfk iay cvjvjvmvy+ Qnyl}nq >+ Injnk ama tf qnylkk
inbwh jekvvkmn jfkmaa fklfh }fjah f}}a maqf 6? k`fakmfk a}ainyfk ej mn
jknkb}y nbn ekyn Nmnhf} Injnkh qnp} Mfbejyn} _ny}a mkfbakmf+ Jn iay yfqnp}:
e ynmn( nkqeyvb qnp}kk qnkh ehmvvkv lym+ Jn qnp}( wn}fk nqyhm+
Mfbejyn} _ny}a mkfbakmf( ej wlkb ja( qnyl }nb iay inj nyn` ehnynj nbn v
nkhnbmn( aqna aj}amny jwmynk ehnqhnymn jvhhnkhm+ Lfkfh qnyl aak dnwhn iay fq
qhfqfbfb+ Lfya qnylkk inbwh( }fbakn} jekvv ej }ny}hm+ Yncbf}ha Ebnk
ftja afjmn tnym( bfycvb Nmknk Ifqak ej ftmaa iay Nmnhf} Injnkqm+ Ekvk w e
mkfbak nkhnqkn mnbln tvynk iay wm7 ]fbakn} tf inbwhj qnyl`k ta`mnkkmnmy+
mfma+ Iqhf iay pnhntyn ehbnw nbn yncbf}ha ivkv qhfma tf e mkfbmf mf iv nkja
lffyhaqba laia jekvvhmv+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
24/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 79=
Cn Mfbejyn} _ny}a mkfbakmf fk cnwak mkfb iay bfmfkaqf ce`n ehnk Cfqak
Ntka Lj}yj tf B}fny Cnma ]nk mkfbakmf qnnkm+ Qnyl bnctfmahma+
c}ahnh ehmv qncv} mnyif ehmv: cfy kfqf+ Jvyv`v Bf`haak qnpbnqn nh} fk kfbha
ahfymfk iaya( qnylkk inbwhk lfyfjhf}aybfj ama+ E ynmn Pyy N}nhnq Qnylq
}nbnbfk( qnyl mkqnk }nbnbfk fhmfk lfayfhab( iqj iay }ndaqf qnpnhb+ mfma+
INJNK Pnqk Fja( wkw jfbfj a}fbaqeyvb nbn
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ivqvyvk fdfkmab( wy mahfyab: vwn}}b b5
INJNK " Wnbnkbw ej j}h nbn la} lamf
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ _fja( wy mahfyab fdfkmab+INJNK Iay mf ifhja iay cvjvjv ehnynj ifk mf awf( bfhfj}nkw ehnynj ej
jw nbn qnylkk inbwh jnmny }nyndwh jntynbkk mn iayhaj}f jvhhnkhmk tf
kfbaw ehbnmk cn}yhn}bnj a}fyab+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ ]niaa( }niaa( cnjhkw+
INJNK ]epnyhnynkw( 93 vin}hn ahlaha mkfbfh eyvhnyn lfhf`faw+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Cnjhkw( qnylkk inbwh jnmny }nyndwh mn tny:
cnjhkw( meyvmvy+INJNK Inbwh jntynb }fj jvhhnkhbnw In} cvjvj a}fbhfyakmf: kj
nmf`f inbwhj( iniewvjhvj ehnynj nhlhnkniahay+ Nqk wnbnkmn qnkwh( }nyndwh
ahjfaqhf iayhaj}f mffyhfkmayahbfa lfyfjay maqf mkqeyvb+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Pnqk Injnk( cnjhkw: fjaaba }nbnbhnmkw+
INJNK Bmncnhf f}bfbfqf nhqeyvb nbn mncn eyvhny tny tf bnnhffd ek
if mnjajnbw tny+ Iay nk k`f }epnyhnbnkw ya`n fmf`fab+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Pnqk Injnkb( }epnyhnqnqb( wy mahfyab+
Cnjhkw( qnylkk inbw ehbn jnmny( }nyndw ehbn mn ej kfbha iay ahjfmay+
jaa iay nynmn ehbnwn bnnhffd cfy fq j}qf lamfy( }nbnbfk nh}kn abwn n}n`nb iay
vqnymn ivhvkmvkvw+
Bnnhffd >9 Fqhhmfk ekyn mncn j} ehmv+ wlkb ja( 4>"3? nynkmn( qnyl(
jfkmaakf }nkknk inbwh qf}fyak`f mffyhfkmayfbfma+ Nknqnnh cnjjk aqa jvhhnknbnm
tf bnnhffd >9 Fqhhmfk ekynja mkfbf laymaj+ Ivlkj }niheqv cfpabaw iahmaabaw aak
Paqnf} qnpqey mfyakaw maqf ekn laybaqeyvb+
NH YAWN W]YJ #Bfyak! Kaqf laybaqeyvkvw Pnqk Fja5 Ivlkj }niheqn mn
layak+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
25/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 796
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Ivlkj }niheqn mn layfqab e wnbnk+ Ivlk i}k
qnnkb mkfbhfyak fk tncabaka qnqeyvw+ maqfiahayab+ kj 4? ac}ahnhakmf( 4?
bmncnhfakmf qnylkk( aqna qnyl jvyvhmv+ Injkw( Iayak`a Bf`ha}fk ekyn }ajhnh
bncjfbfhfya jvyvhmv nbn cnhjk( lfkfh aknkk bflvh ehmvv lfkfh qnylqhn eqknkbnm+
Paqna bncjfbf( }ajhnh Bncjfbfa ama+ 9< Bnq( aqna bncjfbf ka}fhajha ehnk Qnnmnq
jvymv( lfkfh qnylqn mejvkbnm+ ej wlkb ja( aakmf ivhvkmvvbvw iv mkfb lfkfh
qnylkk fkdfj}f ehmvv iay mkfb tf fk tncab mkfbmay: iv jnmnyk qhfqfqab( jffqab+
INJNK 93 vin}hn jnyhn}ynynj iay mffyhfkmaybf qnpnynkw ej bfbkvk
ehvyvb bnmfb cvjvja iay mffyhfkmaybf a}fkma+EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ Pnqk Injnk( 93 vin}
INJNK 93 vin} mkfbakmf lfkfh qnylkk }v}vbv jekvvkmn mn iay
mffyhfkmaybf qnpk+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ qaqma mfbaqeyvb Pnqk Injnkb+
INJNK Knhm5
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ 93 vin} mkfbakmf njfy mehnqh iay fjahmf a}fbf fh
jeqmv+
JK@ E]VYVB
Nhbn Pnn}a7 >0+9=
INJNK7 Kabf} IN
"""""?"""""INJNK ]fjyny nyn tfymaj}fk ekyn qfkamfk }ephnk}bwn jnhmbw qfymfk tf
ia}ayf`fj( }nbnbhnqn`nj fjahmf mftnb f}bfj a}aqeyvb+
k`fhajhf iv jebaqekmn jebaqekvk lyfthfyaka tf fyftfaka awfyjfk wfhhajhf
i}k aqna pny}ahfyak ey}nj meyvh}vmn tfyba ehmvjhny kfylfqa ej kfbfmaaba adnmf
f}}ab+ Mnyifhfyf tf bvc}ynhnyn tfqn mfbejynaqa jfak}aqf vyn}nk yfhfyf cfy fqmfk
k`f cfp iayhaj}f aqna aynmf ehnynj ey}nj iay jny jeqv( jn}fleyaj iay mvyv fylahfbfbaw
lfyfj}aa jekvvkmn cfbdajayaw+ Ivynmn ]wj fyftfa meyvh}vvkmn jebaqekvbvwvk
ahj jvyvhmvv lkmfk iv lkf jnmny Injnk dn}qhn mfbejyn}aj iay ey}nb ehv}vyvp i}k
aqna pny}ahfyak jfkmahfyaka fk meyv fjahmf adnmf fmfiahf`fjhfya fjahmf fyftfaka awfyfj
tf i}k jnynyhny iayhaj}f nhnynj nhbn }njtababawa( nh} jebaqekhnybw( jvyvhv fjahhfyaka(
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
26/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 794
ak`fhfbf jekvhnyk( inhjhnyk ifhayhfmaj+ Pnkqeyvb bahhf}tfjahabaw iv }ephnk}hnymn
ivhvkbnm aak ivlk ]wj fyftfakmf tf nqjy iay qkf}ab }nyw fylahfmaaba adnmf
f}}a+ Cfy fqmfk k`f iv hvp iv _nyhnbfk}e n} nh}kn qnjnk iay hvp mfahmay+ Cfpabaw
cfy fqmfk k`f iayiayabawhf jekvvyjfk f }ekvbvwv nqnyhnbnj jekvvkmn ehvk iay
kfwnjf} tf cnnaqf} l}fybfbaw lfyfjay maqf mkqeyvb+
Ivynmn mffyhfkmaymaabaw jekvhny iawf Lfkfh Jvyvhvk tfymaa fyftfmfja
jekvhnymy+ Lfkfh aqnf}f qnkqn`nj cfy }yh }ny}bnkk `fyfqnk fmf`fa qfy Bf`ha
Lfkfh Jvyvhvmvy+ Bf`ha Lfkfh Jvyvhvkmn adnmf fmahbfa lfyfjfk bvcnhada whfyak tf
fhfyak ivynmn nhbnhnybwk a inybw iewn`nj fjahmf ak}ajnh f}}ayahbfaka cfy fqmfkk`f vqlvk ivhbvqeyvb tf iv }nywmn iay hvivk cfy fqmfk k`f aqnf}f qnjbnmk
adnmf f}bfj a}aqeyvb+
Ivynmn mahf lf}aymaabaw cvvhny tf mffyhfkmaybfhfyabaw fk fy} fjahmf ehn mnca
Ntyvpn knk Cnjhny Pwhfbfakak adnmf cyyaqf}a kyhnykk mn awmaa fyftfmf `nkbw
n`}n mn fhf}ayaqf cfpabaw qjfj mwfqmf }ncnbbhh ehbnhqw+ Iv( mfbejyn}aj iay
}v}vbmvy+ Ivkv cfy fqmfk k`f nmf`f aqna jabhaabhf mfah cvjvjv jabhaabhf mf
afhhf}ayba iay aknk ehmvvbv mkqeyvb+ Mehnqqhn ncbn ehnynj( ncbnqkhfkmayahba }b iv mffyhfkmaybfhfya mafy }b jebaqek qfhfyabaw }nyndkmnk
pnqhnhbqey ehbnk cfy fqmfk k`f iay jnwnkb ehnynj lyqeyvb+
Fhif}}f qnylqn ahajak mffyhfkmaybfhfyabawa qnpnyjfk( mkfbfh mffyhfkmaybfhfya
qnpnyjfk n}hnbnbnbw tf ifhja mf lw nym f}bfbfbaw lfyfjfk fk kfbha cvv iawab
ivynmn ak`fhfmaabaw mkfbhfy mnyif mkfbhfyakak cvjvj a}fbhfya tf ekn ahajak ifhayhfqa`a
vkvyhnymy+ Mnyif mkfbhfya mkmn mfbejyn}aj qehhnyhn fahba aqna aj}amnyhnyk mfkf}ab
bfjnkawbnhnykk cvjvjnh ehnynj mafyhfyakf lyf mncn dnyjh ahfmaaka cfpabaw iahaqeyvw+
Cfy fqmfk k`f ]yjaqf @vbcvyaqf}a Mfthf}a vhvhnynyn cvjvj a}fbakf fk}flyf ehbv iay
hjfmay( ftyfkfh cvjvj jvynhhnyk ifkabfba iay hjfmay+ hjfbawmf qy}hfk cfy }yh
qnylhnbn( ykfj ehnynj l}fyahfk Fylfkfjek mntn mn ivkn mncah ehbnj wfyf( Fylfkfjek
mntn nkjhnykk mn wnbnk wnbnk Ntyvpn knk Cnjhny Bncjfbfakf jfkmahfyaqhf ahlaha
mah qnylhnkbn ahjfa pyfkaia fyftfakmf intvymvjhnyk tf ekvhnyk iahaqeyvw+
hjfbaw a cvjvj a}fba afyaakmf cnjjk nynqnk dnjn} vvh ahfbhfyak nymkmnk
chfk mncn ftyfkfh cnjhny pyfkaia nkhnbkmn cnjhnykk achnh fmahmajhfyaka mkfkhfy ehvyn
ftyfkfh bncjfbfhfyak iayfqfh intvyv cnjhny ehmvvkv iahaqeyvw+ Iv iayfqfh intvyvhny
9??= qhkmn qnphnk mfaajhajhf qnylhnbnkk anmfa( a cvjvj}n meyvmnk vqlvhnkbn qf}jaa(
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
27/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 79
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
28/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 793
INJNK Iay fq ahntf f}bfj a}aqey+
MYP NCK #nkjy! ej wy mahaqeyvb Ej}nq Ifq( mfbak ej lwfh iay tvylv
qnpb}kw( iaw ekvk wnp}n lfbfa nmkn hjfbawmfja mnyifhfyak tf mnyifqf
}ffiihfyak ekvkvk lfhmaa jnknn}akmfqaw( ivkmnk ekyn ivkhnyn jnhjhbnqn`nk
vbvqeyvb+ mfmakaw( ivkn mnay mf iaw iay ke} nhmj( ivkvkhn nhnjnh mn ebv} ykfjhfy
tfyfiahayfkaw Iv jnkqn awa l}yfk lfhabfhfy kfhfy ehbv}vy( ivkmnk ekyn ehbnbn
aak kfhfy qnpbnhqw5 Ivkhny mn iv }epnyhnbn afyaakmf knjhfmfyfkaw cfb jnq}hnyn
lfba ehvy cfb mf iaw mf a}adnmf f}ba ehvyvw+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " ]ffjjy fmfyab+MYP NCK #nkjy! Ifk }ffjjy fmaqeyvb+
QNNY JNYNQFH #Jnqfya! " Iay fq mf ifk nyw fmfqab+ Qnny Jnynqfh ifkab
abab Jnqfya Bahhf}tfjahaqab+ Mncn k`f mfmakaw ja7 ]yj Pahnch Jvttf}hfy Iayhaa qnka 4?
c}ahnhaqhf ahlaha e mkfbmf amnbhnyhn ahlaha pnwnyhj qnphm( }v}nknjhny tny ivkhnyk+ mfmakaw+ Iv
}v}nknjhnyk afyaakmf iv nhnk 0 ininjnk tf 9 }nkf injnkkk }v}nknj}n aabhfya tny
bqm5
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " Pnqk Jnynqfh( ekv mn ahntf fmfyfj qnk} tfyfqab+QNNY JNYNQFH #Jnqfya! " Ftf} ivqvyvk fdfkmab+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " k`f awak tfyayfkaw mncn k`f ja njhnbnbmn
fjaj iynjhb aja kej}nq }nbnbhnqnqb( ekmnk ekyn mn cfb Pnqk ncakak cfb mf
wn}nhakawak eyvhnykn qnk} tfybfqf nhnqb+
Iayak`aa( Pnqk Qfkafya( w`nk Qfkafyakak eyvvkmn >1=4"6? nynkmn bf}
_nnkk cfycnkla iay fjahmf aj}amny iynjbnbn fahaba w jekvv ehvyn bffhfqf fh
jeqn`nj fjahmf Lfkfynh Dncya Ifhfkhf @fbnh Qhmyb nynkmn iay jekvbn lf}aakf ahajak
whfya tnym( ekyn jnqknj mn adnmf f}}a Fbak Nq}fjakmfk tfnayfmfk+ ]niaa( e mkfbmf
jabak kf qnp}k iahf`fj mvyvbmn mfahab( nmf`f jnknn}aba nyw f}}ab tf mfmab ja7 =4
ehnqkmnk bf} _nn ej nwnp mvqbv}vy tf 6?qf meyv mn ehniahmaa jnmny yfgaba
mfbejyn}aj a}fbak aqa ahfqf`fa fjahmf qfyakf e}vy}bnj nbnh nmbhny n}b}y( n}}yb}y+
fbf}}ak Lknh}nqk ininjnk ehbn ivkvk lfyfjhfyakmfk iayamay bffhn tf e }nyac}f lfk
bahhf}tfjahhfyakak( lfk peha}ajn`hnyk fbf}}ak Lknh}nq laia ej ny}j qnhnkb peha}ajn`kk
jniakfakf laybfaka nhnbn mn ekvk ekv`vmvy+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
29/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 791
vkv adnmf f}bfj a}aqeyvb7 >16?mf >= Bnq faba qnphm wnbnk cfb
Mfbejyn} _ny}a ahfya lfhfkhfya cfb mf lfkfh jnbveqv Mfbejyn} _ny}akak iay baj}ny
lhfkf`faka dnjn} @vbcvyaqf} Cnhj _ny}aakak aj}amnymn jnhn`nk mkqey tf ifjhaqeymv+
Ka}fjab e lf`f nkjnqn Jjkmf qnnknkhny mncn ekyn jnbveqvkn qnkm+ ej qnqlk
iay fjahmf adnmf fmahfk cvv vmvy( }niaa }nk mfahab( Nimvyyncbnk Kndaw Lybnk "e
}nyacak Lfkfhjvybnq Injnk" fab ekvhnykk ifhha ehmvvkv lyk`f qnka aj}amnyk ny}j
Mfbejyn} _ny}aqf jnqmk lyk`f @vbcvyinjnk bf} kkqf _nnb( bnnmf
fmfyfkaw ivkn iaw bmncnhf fmfhab nkhnbkmn }niaa jfhabfhfya ivhbnj tf nqkfk adnmf
f}bfj bbjk mfah( iay }nhfp tfqn iay nywmn ivhvkmvv ej qnqlk ehnynj adnmf fmahba}ay+Mncn ekyn Nimvyyncbnk Kndaw Lybnk Iqhf iay fq ehbnmk adnmf f}}a maqf
cn}yhqeyvb+ Dnjn} qnqlk jnk emvy ja bf} _nnqn iqhf iay }nhfp lfhba}ay( e mn7 Cnqy(
bahh aynmfkak lfyfa kfqf e qnphn`nj}y+ mfba}ay+ Ka}fjab >6 Bnq >16? lk cfbfk(
fab ekvhny njhnky njhnkbnw( ifhha ehvy ehbnw kk( ej kf} cn}yhqeyvb "e }nyac}f
haf yfk`aaqmab" nbn ej kf} cn}yhqeyvb Mfbejyn} _ny}a j}amnykn Cfbfk aj}amny(
cjbf}a mftyf}bfqf cnwy ehmvjhnyk jnbveqv kkmf ahnk f}}a+ Dnjn} Mfbejyn} _ny}a iay
cnd}n yf a}fma( iv aj}amny mftynhniahbfj aak+ Ka}fjab cn}yhnmb 99 Bnq dahnkmy(`vbcvyinjnk fahbfa tf cjbf}ak jvyvhbn+ Qnka e mkfbf ahajak yfba cn}yhnbnj
a}fqfkhfy( meyv awlahfyf injnyhnyn aqa ehvy maqf ivkv adnmf f}bfj lfyfaka mvqmvb+
jak`aa( Pnqk Injnkk nkqeyvb" qncv} Pnqk fjfyak whfyakmf tnym7
]ncjajn}k( wfhhajhf Fylfkfjek mntnkmnk ekynja mkfbmf }ncjajn}k lawhahaaka achnh
fmfk Pwhfyaba }nbnbhnbnj nbn`qhn qhqeyvb+ Iv( e jnmny ej ny achnhhfyf qeh n} ja
j}amnykw qnka Nmnhf} tf Jnhjkbn _ny}aa j}amny 0 kvbnynh }eyin qnnqhn nmha a}fba "iay
jnknn}f lyf mncn aqa ahfy chf lf}ayf`fa ahfya yhfk qnn ahf" e wk f}}aab ny
achnhhfymfk menk = iak jvy mntnq ey}nmnk jnhmyn`nj cjb jeqmv qnn }nnykn nk`nj
ekvkhn ey}nmnk jnhmyhniahma+ Iv( achnhhfyak kf jnmny qnqlk( kfjnmny ny ehmvvkv ey}nqn
jeqnk ykfj}ay maqf jnqmn lfak a}fmab+ Pnqk Injnkk adnmf f}}ajhfya laia meyvmvy( wnbnk
wnbnk cjb tfyahba ehnqhny mn tnymy( cnjhmy Pnqk Injnk nbn ej iqj evkhvj
bnnhffd jnbveqvkv aqna aj}amnyk( ivlkj aqna aj}amnyk nywv f}}aa meyvh}vmn
ehv}vybn nbnh tf bnjn}h qnqkhnymnk ainyf}}ay( e mn }ncjajn}k lawhahaa ahjfakak achnhakmfk
jnqknjhnky+ Ivkhny( Pnqk Injnk jnqmn lfak maqf nyw f}}ab+
INJNK Pnqk Fja( ej cwh iay fjahmf }nbnbhnynkw ek iay `bhfkawa nhnhb
h}dfk+
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
30/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 70?
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! Pek iay Nyw fmaqeyvb+ Jn }v}bnqn
nhn`nb+
Pnqk ncak Mnyifhfy mkfba kaak ny}j lbhb}y5 maqf eymvhny+ Injkw(
Pvh}nk Nimhnwawmfk nhp ivlkf lfhfiahayakaw+ ]n e }nyac}fk a}ainyfk yf`f injnynkw
lamfyfj bf}e}hnyk mfabfj}f ehmvvkv tf qvbvnbnj}n ehmvvkv mn lyykw+ Iv kfqa
adnmf fmfy5 Iv( }ephvbvk ny}j mnyifhfyf }ncnbbhkk jnin( ny( inh}nqhn ehnqk }kf
layfy laia mnyif qnpbn lfhfkfakak }ephvbmnk }fpja lybfakak tf }ephvbmnja ehlvkhnbnkk
lf}aymaa iay ekv}vy+ Ka}fjab fk ek cn}yhnmbw jabakak mnyif mfmaa( jabakak fhfj}yekaj
mnyif mfmaa( f"mnyif mfmaa 9< Kankn lfhak`f injqeyvw ja ny}j k}fykf}f jnmny akba mnyifbf}emv+ Iv( wn}fk hbk lfhmaaka l}fyfk iay lfhabfmay( qnka mnyif`ahaak hmkk iay
ebv} ykfamay+ Ifk ivkv mncn ej }ephvbmnja lfhabfqf( ahf}aabak qnqlkhnbnkn tf
mfbejynakak cnjajn}fk ny}j jvnjhnyk ahajhfyakf( lfkhfyakf jnmny ahfba ehbnkn
inhqeyvb+ E kfmfkhf mnyifkak( mnyif`ahaak ny}j hmk mkqeyvb+
Pnqk Jnynqfhak iay eyvv tnym+
QNNY JNYNQFH #Jnqfya! " ]yj Pahnch Jvttf}hfya Iayhaa ahf qnphnk iv nkhnbn
tfqn bwnjfyfhfy ekvkmn qnka amnb fmahf`fjhfy ej}vEPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! Fdfkmab( ifk wni}}nk w f}bfmab+ Pnkqeyvb ja
nwbmnk wni} jfhabfa jbnm( qnka ivkn ahajak iay wni}}nk w f}bfmab+
QNNY JNYNQFH #Jnqfya! " Bv}ninjn}
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " Bvc}fbfhfk Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fakak lawha
wni}hnykmn iv ehniahay+ E( nj b mfah ba ekv iahfbaqeyvb nbn lawha wni}hnymn ehniahay
kj e }nyac}f Jvyv`v Bf`ha}f qhfqma "inwhny fap ntvyvqey >6 jaakak amnb jekvvkmn
iaw mf eq jvhhnkbw mn tfnayfqba tfnayfqba nhnjn qej" >6< nqh Qnn Qnnmn
Bncjfbfhfyakmfk tfyahf`fj jnynyhny nynkmn amnb jnyn ivkv eknqhnbn tfqn yfmmf}bf
qf}jaaka Bahha Iayhaj Jeba}fakf tfyba}a+ Iv( Jvyv`v Bf`haak }fjahakf ahajak >6< nqh Qnn+
E kfmfkhf wn}fk ]fbah`ahfy Bf`haa jnknmkk qnka ifkab qfa ehmvvb jnknmk ehnqhn
ahajaa qej}v+ Lfyaqf 90 qfha Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa jnhqeymv+ Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa mf }niaa iv
bffhfqa lawha e}vyvbvkmn }ny}}+ E qwmfk fhabmf iay wni} ehmvvkv( Pnqk Jnynqfh(
qhfbf nkkn ncap mfahab nbn iv qnqlk ehnynj iahakfk iay cvv}vy+ Iay mf cnjjk
}fhab f}bfj aak kj ifhha iay aqna lfhfkfj}fk lfhfkhfy( bf} _nnkk cnjjk qfbf
jekvvkmn ej a}nchhnymy( e qwmfk cnjjk }fhab f}bf ac}aqn`k wnbnk wnbnk mvqnyb+
mnbhny ehbnk maqf qy}km bf} _nn nbn mfymaka nkhn}nbnm+ Yncbf}ha Fjyfb N`vkfy
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
31/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 70>
bf} _nnq cvwvyvkmnk jetbv}vy+ Pw v7 Qnpbnqk( ivkmnk nmf`f jncynbnk
qnyn}ykw( yfgabf wnyny tfyayakaw( caiay fjahmf dnqmn qej}vy+ mnb f}bfqak( amnb
eknqhnbnqk+ mfbfj aak Fjyfb N`vkfyf E }nyac}f Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fakak Lfkfh Pfjyf}fya
dn}k }nqeymv( mkfyha iay a}fbhfya tnym+ Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa Lfkfh Pfjyf}fya Fjyfb
N`vkfy( _nnb( ny}j fkak aj}amnyk( mkfbak mfah( bnnmf fmfyfk iv ahfyf iaw jnyny
tfyf`faw( iv ahfyf aw jnybnqk+ maqfyfj lybfqa ia}ayba}ay+ Qnka _nnqn qnphnk
bvnbfhf cnjnyf} ka}fhaakmf ny iay bvnbfhfmay+ Mfbfj a}fmaab v7 Cnjjk qfbfbfj aak
jnq}hnyn lfak maqf nyw fmaqeyvb+ Ifkab awhfyf nyw fmf`fab ivmvy+ Pnqk Injnk(
niykw va}abnh f}abf inhnqk+FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! " Ej}nq Ifq( cndwnkwn ehnk }njmayf nqnkhb ifhay}bfj
a}fyab+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " ]ffjjy fmfyab+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! " Qnjhnj fhha( fhha if qh k`faka mkb ivlkb laia
yncn} iay fjahmf nkhn}niahaqeyvkvw+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " ]nyachfyaqhf qhfqfiahayab( meyvmvy+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! " Mnyif ekyn( 4? ekyn k` lnwf}fakmf "yncbf}haNhpnyhnk ]yjff qnjkhqhn iahakfk k` lnwf}fakmf mf" qnwhny qnwmkw qn mn kf jnmny
yfha qnwmkw5
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " Jn mnjajnkw tny Pnqk Qhbnw5
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! " ej vwvk ehbnbnj jnqmqhn+ E yf`a iay mffyhfkmayay
baakaw5 Ifk yfkmaabmf iaynw }vcndbn la}}a+ Iay mffyhfkmayayfkaw
Ivqvyvk+
EPBNK EJ]NQ FJ #}nkivh! " Cfbfk nkhn}nqb fdfkmab+
abma( ifk nw k`f nyw f}}ab+ Mfmab ja7 0? cnwaynk >14? lk ifk }fyca ehmvb(
qfmfj vinqb+ "dnjn} Nmknk Ifq mkfbakmf Mkqn lnwf}fakak Nkjnyn ]fbah`aaqab+ Iaw
ntny laia lnwf}f`ahaj qnpqeymvj( iv mn meyv iay fq mfahma+" ]fyca ehn`nb wnbnk
cnwaynk nqkk ek iay nqhj awkaba nhmb( la}}ab }nkivhn+ Ifmaa Dnaj Ifqf mfmab ja( >0
cnwaynk >14? lk( jfkmaakf mfmab ja7 Ifmaa Ifq( ny}j Nmknk Ifq qej( Mfbejyn} _ny}a la}}a+
Qfka iay mkfb inhqey( iaw mf lnwf}f`ahaj qnpnhb+ Kf mfbfj a}aqeyvk fk5 mfma+ Mfmab
ja7 Pntny laia qnp}j iv aa( iv( lnwf}f`ahaj mfahma( ifkab nkhnqbn( aabf akfk iay mkfb
mfahma+ Ekvk aak awak tfyak( iawab Nkjnyn iyevkvk inkmnqb ifk iayjn bvcniay nhnhb
mn aabawa nmnb laia meyv my} qnpnhb( ivkv nkhn}bnqn nhqeyvb+ La} la} jnymfab
-
7/30/2019 Oktay Eksi
32/32
] I B B
]v}nknj Cawbf}hfya Injnkh
Jebaqek 7 Mnyif #93 vin}! Laya 7 >>+0? ]nyac 7 0?%>?%9?>9 Lyvp 7 _fhak Pnqdn 709
jfkma iyekvk inkmnk( nkn jabf iay fq ba qhfma+ mfma+ Ekvk wfyakf a}adnb
fjyf}fya ]yjnk Cnkbn iynj}b( }yfkf n}hnmb( Nkjnynqn lfhmab+ awmab qnka >0
Cnwaynkmnk ekyn lnwf}f`ahajhf inb e nkhnbmn jfahba}a( ahf inb jfahba}a+ Nkjnyn
Lnwf}f`ahfy @fbaqf}akak e ynmn iay lfkfh jvyvhv ehmv( Lfkfh Pfjyf}fya ehmvb+ Nyjnkmnk
aaw ehmvvb mkfbmf ifk mf jfkmabf a nyqeyvb+ Mfmahfy ja yncbf}ha Waqn ]nkv "jn maqf
iay ngnk tnym( aj}anma cnifyhfy ngnk dahnk laia iay fq" e( iay lnwf}f jnyn`njb+ Waqn
]nkv( ej aqa iay nmnbb ekyn }nkmb nbn e }nyac}f nynbwmnja cha pfj mf qhf bnjivh
iay aab laia nhlhnkbnwm+ Ifk mfmab ja7 Ifka ahlahfkmaybfw+ dahnk+ Mfyjfk nynmnk wnbnk
lf}a( Waqn ]nkv ifka nynm tf a }fjhad f}}a Jfkmaakf }ffjjy f}}ab+ "iaynw mn jnin`nmntynkmb aak ch wlkbmy" nbn ekyn e yny fmak`f Qfka Cnify lnwf}fa maqf iay
lnwf}f jvybnj}n ehmvvkv yfkmab tf wn}fk aaw ehmvvb aak _fja+ mfmab( laymab+ Injn
nyjnmnhny mn iawf jn}hbnqn mntf} f}}aj( 93 lfk lnwf}f`a Waqn ]nkvkvk pn}yekhvvkmn
lnwf}fkak jvyvhbn nnbnkn lfhmaj+ E ynmn mvqmvj ja Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fakmf iay jntln
jb+ Jntlnmn kf ehbv5 Iaw ny}j qehn jbw( lnwf}fqa cnwyhqeyvw+ Bahh Iayhaj Jeba}fa
qfhfya Nhpnyhnk ]yjff mfbahfy ja7 Iaw ivynqn lfhmaj( lamf`faw+ Iv lnwf}fqhf kf aak tny
fkak( kaqf fk lnwf}f jnyqeyvk5 E( Ifk jny}bqeyvb+ mfba Cnqy( jny}qe yvkjny}bqeyvk mfyjfk( mfbahfy ja7 _fja( fkak fakak abakf ab}aqnwn nhkb( Bvnwwfw
Cnkbk abakf "Bvjnmmfy tfqn Bvnwwfw" ab}aqnwn nhkb iv kf5 Ekvk wfyakf iv( Waqn
]nkvqn mkb mfba ja Jnymfab: ifk qevb+ Qnp Jyfmakak jvyv`vv yncbf}ha Jnwb
]njfk} bffy ac}ahnhf mf}fj tfybfj aak 06? iak hayn jyfma nqyb( < cafqf ihb( iv
fhhafy iak haynq mn }fjahfyf qhfyab 06? iak haynqhn lnwf}fqa jvybnqn jnyny tfybahfy+ Ivkvk
wfyakf Nhpnyhnk ]yjf fjahak`f Waqn ]nkv mfma ja7Ifk( ny}j qevb+ Iaw mfmaj ja7 Iay
mnjajn( 93 nmnb j} qehn "cnma ifk aawmab nbn iayej nmnb mn a}adn f}}a lfhma" knh
qejvk ehbnw iqhf fq( jnyn`nw lnwf}fqa+ Ekvk wfyakf k` maqf iay ab}aqnw nhm(
k` lnwf}fa j}+ Iay yf ekyn Nhpnyhnk ]yjfhf nynhnykmn ahajakak mftnb f}}aaka dnyj
f}}aj iaw+ Ka}fjab abwnw qnwhny lfhaqeymv k` abwnh( iaw injqeyvw lnwf}fmf fy}fa lk
jb+ Ivkhnyn iaw bnka ehbnqn nh}j( nynmn ac}ahnd j}+ Ifk( nynhk ekvkmn Jvyv`v
Bf`ha fabhfyakf jn}hbnj aak a}adn f}}ab+ Lnwf}f 94 nv}e >14? lk j}+ 94 Nynhj
dahnk }nyacakmf mf ifk mfmab ja7 Iv a}f ifk qevb( nqyhqeyvb+ Ehnq iv+
FKTFY QAHBNW #}nkivh! ]nbnb( }ffjjy fmfyaw+
INJNK ej }ffjjy fmaqeyvw n ehvk+