October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for...

14
10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 Use chat to submit questions Yes, you’ll get the slides We’re recorded, so come back and listen again

Transcript of October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for...

Page 1: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

1

Structuring Exits for

Competitive Returns

October 14, 2015

• Use chat to submit

questions

• Yes, you’ll get the

slides

• We’re recorded, so

come back and listen

again

Page 2: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

2

• Mission: Fuel the success of angel groups and accredited individuals

active in in the early-stage landscape

• World’s largest trade group for angel investorso 220+ angel groups

o 13,000 accredited investors

o Voice of accredited individuals, portals, and family offices

• 50 US states + Canada

• Research/ education partner

MEMBER GROUPS & ACCREDITED PLATFORMS

New Dominion Angels

Page 3: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

3

ACA PARTNERSGOLD

OUR MODERATOR

Alexandra LaForge

Director of Strategic Programs, Investors’ Circle

• Evangelist for Impact Investing since 2009

• Co-chair, Young Women Social Entrepreneur,

San Francisco

• University of Notre Dame

Add Photo Here

Page 4: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

4

OUR SPEAKERS

David Gitlin

Co-leader of the Emerging Technology Practice and

Shareholder with Greenberg Traurig, LLP

• Recognized nationally as a leading M & A attorney

and a leading Venture Capital Attorney

• Internationally recognized for his work across

borders

• Philadelphia, PA and Tel Aviv, Israel

OUR SPEAKERS

Aner Ben Ami

Co Founder and Managing Director

Pi Investments

• Committed to investing 100% of its assets in support of a more sustainable and just economy, including investments in clean energy, sustainable food and global supply chain

• San Francisco Bay

Page 5: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

5

OUR SPEAKERS

Dave Bisson

CEO

Big City Farms, Inc.

• A Baltimore-based urban farming venture that

creates good jobs for worker-owners,

revitalizes urban landscapes, and produces

ultra-local, sustainably-grown food

• Baltimore MD

TOPICS WE’LL EXPLORE TODAY

• Why Structured Exits are Attractive to Angels

• Which Types of Businesses and Investors Benefit Most

• Standard Terms for Structured Exits

• Approaches to Consider

• Challenges and Opportunities

• From the Entrepreneur Perspective: Big City Farms, Inc.

Page 6: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

6

STRUCTURED EXITS DEFINED

Investment structures designed to achieve a

desired investment return without reliance on a

traditional exit.

11

• Suitable for:

o impact investments.

o revenue generators but not exit candidates.

o exit candidates but ownership interest in long term play.

o geographies with few exit options.

o traditional investments where parties view structure as win-win.

WIN/WIN

• Little or no dilution to entrepreneur when valuation is

low in exchange for growth capital.

• Safer return to investor without risks associated with the

need for a significant exit.

12

Page 7: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

7

TYPES OF STRUCTURES

• Redeemable Preferred

• Demand Dividend

• Cash Flow Loan

Coupled with Exit Warrant:

• pay now for nominal exercise price later.

• pay nothing now for today’s FMV price when exercised.

13

FLEXIBLE NATURE

• Flexibility is Key:

o Can be tied to immediate or future cash flows.

o Return can be partially fixed and partially variable based on cash

flow.

o The return multiple can be fixed or progressive – can be tied to x

times investment or IRR.

o Can be capped or uncapped.

o Can be equity or debt.

14

Page 8: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

8

Page 9: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

9

Page 10: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

10

Big City FarmsBaltimore, MD

Page 11: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

11

Big City Farms Value Proposition

• 3 full-year growing cyclesOperating track record

• 80-90% lower CAPEX per sq. foot vs. hydroponic greenhouses

• $3.25 / sq. ft. when built at scaleLow CAPEX hoophouses

• Local restaurants, institutions, online & physical grocers

• Strong and growing farmers’ market presence

Strong, diverse customer relationships

• $2.50 / sq. ft. when purchased

• Free or nearly free when leased from CityAccess to affordable inner-city land

• >45% gross marginSolid unit economics

• COO: 15 years exp. with specialty veg.; 6 yrs. exp. managing 3,000 acres of organic citrus

• Front-line team: between 2 and 4 years experience each in sustainable veg. productionExperienced grower team

• First “network farm” partnership formed in 2012 with ex-offender assistance org.

• Talent recruitment partnerships with workforce/career development groups

Strong community & NGO relationships

Page 12: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

12

AMOUNT DESCRIPTION

$150,000 SALES of produce per unit

$80,000 COGS per unit

$70,000 Gross profit per unit

46.7% Gross margin %

$64,350 CAPEX per unit

$3.25 CAPEX per square foot of growing area

0.92 Avg. years to payback of CAPEX ([Unit CAPEX] / [Unit Annual Gross Profit])

115.8% 5-year IRR per unit

Unit = 19,800 square feet inside hoophouse greenhouses (approx. 1/2 acre)

Big City Farms Unit Economics

Why should entrepreneurs care about structured / alternative exits?

1. Improve chances of finding well-aligned investors & getting capital you need to grow

2. Flexible terms and realistic expectations increase chances of financial success

3. Maintain focus on original mission and impact goals

Page 13: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

13

AUDIENCE RESOURCES

Alexandra LaForge – [email protected]

• Investors’ Circle - www.investorscircle.net

Dave Gitlin - [email protected]

• Greenberg Traurig Law -http://www.gtlaw.com/

• http://www.gtlaw.com/News-Events/Publications/Published-Articles/187859/Structured-Exits-A-New-Universe-of-Potential-Funding-for-Companies-in-Undeserved-Markets

Dave Bisson - [email protected]

• Big City Farms, Inc. http://www.bigcityfarms.com/

Aner Ben Ami - [email protected]

• http://www.transformfinance.org/blog/2015/7/26/square-peg-round-hole-innovating-finance-for-social-enterprises

Forbes.com -http://www.forbes.com/

THANK YOU!

UPCOMING

WEBINARS

November 4: DEMO of Seraf

Investor tool for angel investors

November 18: Best Practice Series:

The Key Points of Term Sheets

December 2: ACA Leadership Forum

& Angel News (Members Only)

December 16: Best Practice Series:

Valuation of Pre-Revenue Companies

Webinar programs archived

at:www.angelcapitalassociation.org/e

vents/webinars/

Audience

Questions

Page 14: October 14, 2015 - Angel Capital Association · 2015-10-16 · 10/16/2015 1 Structuring Exits for Competitive Returns October 14, 2015 •Use chat to submit questions •Yes, you’ll

10/16/2015

14

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

Marianne HudsonExecutive DirectorAngel Capital Association

Christopher MirabileManaging Director, Launchpad; Board Chair, Angel Capital Association

http://www.angelcapitalassociation.org/news-forbes/

http://www.angelcapitalassociation.org/news-inc/

UPCOMING ACA EVENTS

• October 21, 2015: New England Regional Meeting – Boston, MA

• October 23, 2015: Southwest Regional Meeting - Tucson, AZ

• November 9 – 10, 2015: Angel Insights Exchange, New Orleans, LA

• May 9 – 11, 2016: ACA Summit, Philadelphia, PA

• http://www.angelcapitalassociation.org/events/