Octavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 (BIA Mar. 13, 2014)

8/12/2019 Octavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 (BIA Mar. 13, 2014)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/octavio-ugarte-delgado-a205-829-687-bia-mar-13-2014 1/6



U.S Department of usticeExecutive Oce r Immaon Revew

Decson of he Board of Immgraon Appeals

Fl Cur, Vn 20530

Fle: A205 82

68 Plaineld

In r e: O CTA VO UGARTE ELGADO

IN REMOVAL PRO CEINGS

PEAL

ON BEHALF OF SPOEN Pro se

at:

ON BEAL OF DH Krstin nsley ssistnt Chief Counsl

MAR 1 3 204

In an oral ecsion atd ovmber 25, 2013, an migation Judg un th rspondntreovable; etened tat e di not deonsate elgbiit elie om emoval; anorded im removed om the Unite Stats to Mxico he espondent appeald om tatdecison. Te recod w be emane

Te now 36year-o respondnt was un rmovabl on both charged namissibiitygounds, as convicted of a crim inolving oral turitue ( CIMT") under section212a)(2)(A)(i)() of t migration and Nationalt ct, 8 .SC§ 8(a)()()()(I), an aspresent wtout being admitted o parole uner section 2(a)(6)(A)(i) of th Act Assubstatat by coniction documets, e has a Marc 6, 203, coniction upon a guilty plea rsnthetic intity decption" undr Ind Coe § 35-4353.8(a)(3). Fo such crime, h wassntenc to imprsonment o 2 s, wt iositon of 8 months o tat sntnc sspenddsubject to comltion of pobation. S Ex2 He arrivd in t United tates in about 18S IJ. at 3; Trat 34 8

Te Imiraton udge d te respondent remoable der section 2(a)2)(A)(i)(I ote Act bse on hs 203 Indina conviction r snthetic identity dception" n additon, thImmiation udge note tat, in view of suc conviction, the respondent was ineligibe rcacellation of rmoval. S sctions 40A{b)( )(B), 8 UC § 2bb)()(B) s sosection (3) o te Act, 8 UC§ 0((3); J. at 2.

Ths ord revews n mmigaton Jge's ndings of ct, incudin ndngs as to thecredibility of testimony, uder te clearly erroneous" stndard S 8 CR. § 1003()(3)(i);Mr ofR-S-H- 23 & c6 (BA 003); M o SH, 23 I& Dec. 46 (BIA 2002).We view questions o law, discretion n udent, nd all othr issus d ovo. S 8 CFR§ 03) o--B, & ec 008

The statut unr wich e responent was conicted, n Code § 3543-5-38(a)(3),povids, A erson wo knowingly or intentionaly obtains, possesss, anss, or usse synthetic inting imationwt intent to roess to b aother peson . commitssnthetic dentity dceton . " Fur, In Coe § 5--5- provdes, It is not adense n a proscution dr subsecton (a) or ( tt no eson was am o eud."

Cite as: Octavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 (BIA Mar. 13, 2014)



A05 829 687

t is we-estbishe tht oeses inoig u n the constiue Is. See, e.g,Mater of Pinzon, 6 &N Dec 189 19-95 (B 01 (owgy n willy ming aymterl lse ctiious or uulent stement o ot a nited Stes psspo atter ofJurado, 24 &N Dec. 9 (BA 2006 (reti he; ater of Alarcon, 20 &N ec. 557 559-60 (BA 1992) (pety he an mil u ater of Adetiba, 20 &N Dec 506 507-08 (BA1992) (mi u); Matter of Correa-Garces, 20 I&N Dec 451 454 (BA 192) (au); Mtter

of Esfndiary, 16 IN ec. 659 660-61 (BIA 1979) (micious esss with inent to commitpeti arceny; Matter o houinard, 11 IN Dec. 89 840-41 (BIA 1996 (simle rceny ileg use of creit c

We that ren s ecessy in his case Pursuant to Descamps v. United Sttes,_U.S. (201 the resonent cou be u remobe uer secion 212()(2(A)(i)( ofhe ct if coniction uer the din sue pertng to syhetic ienity ecepton"either s categoicly u or e oese or is iisie with u o he emonse bye coiction ocumets he Noember 201 orl ecisio incues the iion Juge'ssaemet that eity eception my be iisibe satute" bu such eciso oes not inictewhich conicion ocumes my he een consue ad does no contin etaie lysis

regring the ctegoricl modie caegorical proches. O rem the mmtion Juge shou reconsider his ecisio in lgh of Descams v Unted Stats, sura, n oericabe cae receent. Both the resondent n he Depme of Homen ecurity mysubmi y a l ailble reet eience s pproriate.

Accoringy we enter the llowg orer

ODER The record is remne to the Immiaion ou r fuher proceeigs a rthe ssunce of new eciso consstet wh his opnio.

1 For example on s ce he stute woul appear o py o erso who presenteddocumets eraning to anoer perso n oder to ga access to gcub or are n aiporresered r prerred rne cutomes wle wang epure.

Cite as: Octavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 (BIA Mar. 13, 2014)



/

NITD A DEARTMNT O JCXCTIVE OICE OR MMIGRATON REVIEW

NED TATS MIGRAO N CORCICAGO ILLNOI

ie A0589687 Novebe 25 203

n te Mae o

OCTAVIO GART DGADO

RSONDN

CHARG

ALCAION

ON HAL O RONDN RO S

ON EHAL O H CRITIN LNSLY

)))

)

N RMOVAL ROCDING

ORAL DECION O MMGRATION DGE

e esonen s a 36-yeao snge ae aen a nave and ctzen o Mexco

Resoent ast eteed e nie aes wtou section i aoxaey 998

He cae o e aenton o e Deamen o Hoelan ecuty because o s

cal eco e esondet as convcte n Mac o 03 n te ka CountyCou at Inana te oense o idetty eceton o ths oense te esodent

eceive a to yea sentence to confneent In ation te esonen eceve an

egt yea sentence alue to ay cl suo o to eo o cou

At a eoval eang coee on Novee 25 03 te esonen amie

1



the alegations contaned n te Notce to Appear. The Govement atoey presented

a copy of te respondent's convcton records. Based upon respondents testmony and

t Cos revw of e convction records I find removablity as been establised by

vidence whic is clear and covincng. Athoug dentty deception may be a vsbe

satte i is clear th conviction record at the respondent assumed t identty o

anoter person and sed tat ienty wout athorzaion. nd ta ths oense

constues crme nvovng oa turpitde and terefore te respondent s sbject to

remov rom te Unied States as caged in he Noce to Appear

Atough te rspondent as ved in the Uned Saes r pproxaely 5

years e os not qaiy o ean n the Uned Staes under any povison o te la

e respondens perod of ncarceration and cminal convcons make him inegible o

ppy for cncelaton of remova or any oher eef. s Cou would d respondent

does not mert vounta depure as a mater of dscretion even hen considering te

favorabe actors versus the navorabe actors. hereore the folowng order w be

entered.

ORDER

T IS ORDERED tat te respondent be depored and removed te Unted

States to Mexico on te charges conaned in the otice to Appear

A205-829-687

R D VKOORImgraton Judge

2 November 25, 2013



CRFA PAGE

I eey cefy t e tce poceeg bee UDG ROR D

NIKOOR e me of:

OCTAO GARE DELGADO

A205-829687

CHAO INOIS

ws e s ee ppeas a at s s te org tscrpt ereo te le o

te xecutve Oce fo mmgo Revew

LNDA DOCK (scrbe)

R SA RPORING lc2

ANUARY 19, 2014

(Compleo Dte)

Octavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 (BIA Mar. 13, 2014)

Documents

Transcript of Octavio Ugarte Delgado, A205 829 687 (BIA Mar. 13, 2014)