Objectives of Cash Management - GFOAT | Government · PDF file ·...
Transcript of Objectives of Cash Management - GFOAT | Government · PDF file ·...
Objectives of Cash Management
Cash management may be defined as all activities undertaken to ensure maximum cash
availability and maximum investment yield on a government's idle cash. Cash management is
concerned with the efficient management of cash from the time revenue is earned to the time a
check or disbursement clears the bank.
Cash management activities include the following functions:
1) Receipt and deposit of cash and negotiable payments
2) Physical custody of monies and securities
3) Disbursements of funds upon proper authorization
4) Investing excess cash
5) Cash budgeting and forecasting
6) Short-term borrowing
7) Cash reporting
In its simplest form, the cash management function has three elements:
1) Cash mobilization: get the cash in as quickly as possible.
2) Controlled disbursement: release cash at the last possible moment.
3) Investment program: make the cash work in the meantime.
The constraints under which a cash manager must operate and the inherent conflicts between
investment yield and risk dictate that the cash manager strive to meet the following subsidiary
objectives as well.
1) The cash management system should support the operations of the government.
2) The cash management system must protect the assets of the government at all times.
3) The cash management system must provide adequate liquidity to meet all expected
and unexpected obligations.
4) The cash management system must be well-documented and accountable.
In recent years, cash management has grown in importance and is considered a key element of
the financial management process. Establishing and maintaining a cash management system that
maximizes both availability of cash and investment yield is a task that challenges financial
managers in all governments.
Controls and Organization for Government
Because of the risk inherent in handling cash and investments, internal controls are an important
consideration. An adequate internal control environment is essential for the reliability of
financial statements.
While the configuration of an internal control environment varies widely, internal controls are
established to meet five objectives.
1. To provide reliable data for management. Transactions that represent economic events
are recorded in accordance with prescribed procedures in the right accounts in the correct
amounts on a timely basis.
2. To safeguard assets and records. Access to assets and related documentation should be
restricted to authorized personnel. Furthermore, the accounting records are maintained so
that they continue to reflect the operation of the government.
3. To establish accountability. Responsibility for assets and other resources should be well
defined. Timely verification and follow-up procedures are essential.
4. To promote operational efficiency. Internal controls should reduce unnecessary
duplication of effort and deter inefficient use of government resources.
5. To facilitate financial reports. The system should assure that transactions are recorded to
permit preparation of financial statements in conformity with generally accepted
accounting principles (GAAP).
Internal controls need only provide reasonable, not absolute, assurance that these objectives will
be accomplished. Guarantee of these goals is probably impossible and is usually financially
unsound in smaller governments since they may lack the resources to provide for the necessary
increased division of responsibilities among staff. Augmented internal controls come at a cost,
and that cost should not exceed the benefits expected to be derived. Good internal control
procedures can help to reduce audit fees by allowing the auditors to rely on those controls,
thereby permitting a reduction in the extent of their audit tests.
The control environment in an organization permeates all aspects of operations, not just the
finance function. One of the most important elements of the control environment is personnel
policies and procedures. To ensure a good internal control system, management must hire
competent personnel with integrity and then train them so that they understand their duties.
The segregation of functions is one of the most powerful aspects of internal control. The
overriding principle is no one person should ever be placed in a situation to carry out or conceal
an error or irregularity without timely detection by others in the normal course of carrying out
their responsibilities.
Recommended Internal Control Practices
Authorizations:
Develop procedures and policies to specify how the department will comply with the
organization’s objectives and departmental expectations.
Supervisors and Managers should verify cash deposits, voided transactions, and overages
and shortages.
Segregation of Duties:
Establish a chain of custody and accountability immediately upon initial receipt of funds.
Individual accountability should be maintained at all times. Transfers of custody
between individuals should be jointly verified and documented.
Cashiers should prepare independent records of receipts and maintain individual cash
drawers.
Different employees should be responsible for:
– Receiving and recording collections of deposits.
– Balancing and reconciling daily deposits to departmental recordings.
– Verifying the deposit amounts reflect correctly in the general ledger and
departmental reporting.
Safeguarding:
Separate lockable cash drawers should be available to all individuals collecting money.
Checks should be restrictively endorsed upon receipt.
Cash counting areas should be secured and free from interruptions.
If deposits must be kept overnight, they must be kept in a safe or locked location.
Deposits should be deposited in the bank daily.
Safe combinations should be changed regularly.
Recording and Depositing:
Deposits should be presented intact.
All cash receipts should be recorded on a cash receipt form, cash register, or a properly
controlled computer system at the time of receipt.
Checks should be made payable to the organization.
Reconciliation and Review:
All receipt numbers should be accounted for.
All detailed organizational records should match the bank deposit records.
Cash Accounting and Reporting Systems
The ability to maintain an adequate cash flow and properly invest available cash is the most
important function of a cash manager. Cash reporting systems facilitate the performance of this
function and have the following components, each of which interact and rely on the other:
1) a cash accounting system;
2) an investment and interest apportionment accounting system; and
3) a reporting system of cash and investments consisting of bank reconciliations and
treasurer's reports.
The Cash Accounting System
The cash accounting system is required to maintain the daily receipts and disbursements that
occur in all jurisdictions. These activities are maintained by fund and account designation, and
the resulting data are used to provide information for management. The cash accounting system
is the foundation on which all other systems are built. A good cash accounting system does five
things:
1) provides accurate and current data, resulting in improved controls over cash invested and
balances in bank accounts;
2) allows interest to be allocated by fund based on daily cash balances;
3) permits comparison of budgeted with actual cash on hand;
4) provides some of the information needed to perform reconciliations;
5) supplies the cash balance information required to invest available cash in compliance
with investment guidelines.
Accounting for Investments and Interest
In fund accounting, each fund has its own cash account. In the past, treasurers maintained
separate checking accounts that corresponded with these separate cash fund balances. This
method can be very cumbersome. For example, a temporary overdraft in one account would have
to be covered by a transfer from another account with excess funds. Moreover, with several
accounts, bank service fees are higher because of the difficulty of maintaining a minimum
compensating balance in each account.
A more modern approach is to pool all cash, regardless of fund classification, into one bank
account. Not only can this reduce bank service charges, it also facilitates the investing of idle
cash funds by centralizing all banking activity into one account. This enables the cash manager
to more easily identify cash resources and match them with current and anticipated demands on
cash.
Apportionment of Interest.
Pooling has no effect on the segregation of cash by fund for accounting purposes, interest
allocation and reporting. Of course, pooling cash in this manner makes reconciling the bank
balance more difficult when compared to the individual account approach, but this
inconvenience is more than offset by the aforementioned gains.
The pooling method produces complications in bank reconciliation in that interest earned is no
longer income to a particular fund but rather results from the pooling of cash of all funds. An
interest allocation system must be established to properly credit individual funds for the pro rata
share of the interest earnings.
Reconciliation Reports: Purposes and Procedures
A good accounting system produces accurate and timely records of cash on hand and cash
investments. Various types of reconciliations are useful for maintaining proper control over cash:
bank reconciliations, proofs of cash, and various treasurer's reports.
A bank reconciliation is a schedule indicating and explaining differences between the bank's
record of a government cash account and the government's record. The general form of a bank
reconciliation is known as a bank to books reconciliation, since it starts with the balance obtained
from a bank statement as of a certain date and ends with the book cash balance on that same date.
A second type of control schedule is a four-column reconciliation, known as a proof of cash.
This statement reconciles an entire month's activity.
A treasurer's reconciliation report is used to track daily activity in each accounting cash fund and
every cash and investment account owned by the government. Many states, including Texas,
require an investment report that lists all investments monthly or quarterly as well as an annual
position statement on investment policy.
External documents are needed to reconcile bank accounts and to calculate resultant journal
entries. These consist of bank statements from the jurisdiction's servicing bank; confirmations
from dealers, brokers or institutions verifying the purchase, maturity or interest instruments; and
safekeeping receipts and trust department safekeeping reports.
Financial Reporting for Deposits and Investments
The basic disclosure requirements of GASB Statement No. 3 have been replaced with GASB 40.
Summary of Statement No. 40 Deposit and Investment Risk Disclosures—an amendment of
GASB Statement No. 3 (Issued 3/03)
The deposits and investments of state and local governments are exposed to risks that have the
potential to result in losses. This Statement addresses common deposit and investment risks
related to credit risk, concentration of credit risk, interest rate risk, and foreign currency risk. As
an element of interest rate risk, this Statement requires certain disclosures of investments that
have fair values that are highly sensitive to changes in interest rates. Deposit and investment
policies related to the risks identified in this Statement also should be disclosed.
Types of Banking Services
The first step in selecting the best mix of financial services is to define the available services.
They include:
1) collection services;
2) disbursement services;
3) investment services; and
4) credit services.
Collection Services
Collection services have the objective of accelerating the rate at which receivables become
available for investment. This is achieved by reducing collection float, which refers to the normal
processing of cash receipts through the mail and the government's internal procedures for
recording, reconciling, and investing collections. By utilizing various collection services, a
government can increase funds available for investment purposes. Electronic wire transfers and
lock box systems are two popular services used by local governments.
Governments collect revenue in five ways:
1) payment for services;
2) tax payments dictated by law;
3) miscellaneous fees and charges;
4) fines and court costs; and
5) grants from state and federal sources.
Payment for service is generally made upon delivery of the service or after the service is
provided. Compared to the other three types of collections, payments for services require a large
investment in staff time and effort, to prepare billings, maintain records, process payments and
collect past due amounts. One typical problem that governments face is the cyclical nature of
activity surrounding billing and processing. Cycle billing can alleviate the alternate periods of
high and low activity level. Under such a system, a portion of the billing is completed each week
during the month or accounting period, thus spreading the workload evenly through the period.
The interval of time between billing and the deposit of payments into a bank account is known as
float. There are three types of float that need to be managed (minimized). The first is mail float,
or the time a payment is in the mail system before the government has possession of the check.
This can be minimized by using post office boxes for payments so that they do not have to be
sorted from other mail. Collecting checks periodically (even several times each day) from these
boxes will minimize the time before staff processes payments.
Administrative float is the time needed to process the payment. Collection float is the time
necessary to get funds deposited into a bank account. One of the most useful methods of
minimizing float is the lock box. A lock box is a post office box used solely for payments. Bank
personnel are authorized by the government to collect the payments for immediate processing.
The cost of this service must be considered and compared to the savings that result from timely
deposit of funds. Arrangements should be made with the bank for processing checks not
accompanied by payment slips and those that do not match the payment due amount.
Disbursement Services
Disbursement services have the primary objectives of decelerating cash disbursements by
lengthening the disbursement float and minimizing idle cash held in a non-interest bearing bank
account. Techniques and communication methods range from a daily phone call to the more
complicated concentration/zero balance account structure.
The concentration/zero balance structure consists of a main bank account (concentration
account) that contains the government’s funds. The zero balance accounts are used for
disbursement with funds transferred each day from the concentration account to cover disbursed
amounts. Having all funds in a single account allows greater investment opportunity and
eliminates the need to determine how much to have deposited in multiple accounts. The
concentration account provides the compensating balance that pays for banking services.
Wire and automated clearing house transfer technology allows governments to delay payments
until the due date. This maximizes terms of payments for purchases and contractual obligations.
Of course, payors making payments to governments are also taking advantage of this technology.
Investment and Credit Services
Investment services and specific investment techniques are available to governments to assist
them in their investment programs. Investment services offered by a bank will depend on a
bank's location and size, and may include the offering of several money market instruments,
including certificates of deposit; investment advice; traditional time deposits; and, pension fund
investment advice as well as safekeeping and custody services. Credit services are available to
governments that borrow money for short- or long-term purposes. Services can range from direct
loans (subject to statutory limitations) to support functions relating to paying agent and registrar
on a government's bond issue to participation in local community or economic development
projects.
Typical Cash Management Services
Account Reconcilement Services: Balancing a checkbook can be a difficult process for
large entities. It can take a lot of human monitoring to understand which checks have not
cleared and therefore what the current account balances are. Banks have developed a
system which allows companies to upload a list of all the checks that they issue on a daily
basis, so that at the end of the month the bank statement will show not only which checks
have cleared, but also which have not. In addition, banks have used this system to
prevent checks from being fraudulently cashed if they are not on the list, a process known
as positive pay.
Advanced Web Services: Most banks have Internet-based systems. This enables
managers to create and authorize special internal logon credentials, allowing employees
to send wires and access other cash management features remotely and quickly.
Armored Car Services (Cash Collection Services): Large entities who collect a great
deal of cash and collections may have the bank pick up these deposits via an armored car
company, instead of asking its employees or staff to make trips to the bank.
Automated Clearing House: An electronic system used to transfer funds between banks.
Entities use this to pay others, such as employee’s payroll (this is how direct deposit
works). Certain entities also use it to collect funds from customers (this is generally how
automatic payment plans work). This system is criticized by some consumers, because
under this system banks assume that the company initiating the debit (payment) is correct
until proven otherwise.
Balance Reporting Services: Entities who actively manage their cash balances usually
subscribe to secure web-based reporting of their account and transaction information at
their lead bank. They include information on cash positions as well as 'float' (e.g., checks
in the process of collection). Finally, they offer transaction-specific details on all forms of
payment activity, including deposits, checks, wire transfers, ACH (automated
clearinghouse debits and credits), investments, etc.
Cash Concentration Services: Entities open bank accounts at various local banks in the
area. To prevent funds in these accounts from being idle and not earning sufficient
interest, entities have an agreement set with their primary bank, whereby their primary
bank uses the Automated Clearing House to electronically "pull" the money from these
banks into a single interest-bearing bank account.
Lockbox: Entities which receive a large number of payments via checks in the mail have
the bank set up a post office box for them, open their mail, and deposit any checks
deposited. This is referred to as a "lockbox" service.
Positive Pay: Positive pay is a service whereby the entity electronically shares its check
register of all written checks with the bank. The bank therefore will only pay checks
listed in that register, with exactly the same specifications as listed in the register
(amount, payee, serial number, etc.). This system dramatically reduces check fraud.
Reverse Positive Pay: Reverse positive pay is similar to positive pay, but the process is
reversed, with the entity, not the bank, maintaining the list of checks issued. When checks
are presented for payment and clear through the Federal Reserve System, the Federal
Reserve prepares a file of the checks' account numbers, serial numbers, and dollar
amounts and sends the file to the bank. In reverse positive pay, the bank sends that file to
the company, where the company compares the information to its internal records. The
company lets the bank know which checks match its internal information, and the bank
pays those items. The bank then researches the checks that do not match, corrects any
misreads or encoding errors, and determines if any items are fraudulent. The bank pays
only "true" exceptions, that is, those that can be reconciled with the company's files.
Sweep accounts: Typically offered by the cash management division of a bank. Under
this system, excess funds from a company's bank accounts are automatically moved into
a money market mutual fund overnight, and then moved back the next morning. This
allows them to earn interest overnight. This is the primary use of money market mutual
funds.
Zero Balance Accounting: Entities with large numbers of locations can very often be
confused if all those locations are depositing into a single bank account. Traditionally, it
would be impossible to know which deposits were from which locations without seeking
to view images of those deposits. To help correct this problem, banks developed a system
where each location is given their own bank account, but all the money deposited into the
individual store accounts are automatically moved or swept into the entity’s main bank
account. This allows the entity to look at individual statements for each location. U.S.
banks are almost all converting their systems so that entities can tell which location
made a particular deposit, even if these deposits are all deposited into a single account.
Therefore, zero balance accounting is being used less frequently.
Wire Transfer: A wire transfer is an electronic transfer of funds. Wire transfers can be
done by a simple bank account transfer, or by a transfer of cash at a cash office. Bank
wire transfers are often the most expedient method for transferring funds between bank
accounts. A bank wire transfer is a message to the receiving bank requesting them to
effect payment in accordance with the instructions given. The message also includes
settlement instructions. The actual wire transfer itself is virtually instantaneous, requiring
no longer for transmission than a telephone call.
Controlled Disbursement: This is another product offered by banks under Cash
Management Services. The bank provides a daily report, typically early in the day, that
provides the amount of disbursements that will be charged to the customer's account.
This early knowledge of daily funds requirement allows the customer to invest any
surplus in intraday investment opportunities, typically money market investments. This is
different from delayed disbursements, where payments are issued through a remote
branch of a bank and customer is able to delay the payment due to increased float time.
Cash management services can be costly but usually the cost to an entity is outweighed by the
benefits: cost savings, accuracy, efficiencies, etc.
Obtaining Banking Services
Competitive bidding for banking services with competition among banks is recommended and
may be legally required. Competitive bidding usually will prove beneficial to government units.
Benefits that can be obtained through competition are:
1) additional interest earnings resulting from improved yields if investments are divorced
from routine banking services;
2) additional interest earnings resulting from an overall increase in amounts available for
investment through better use of a bank's collection services;
3) additional bank services available for the same service charges or compensating balances;
4) reduced bank service charges or compensating balances;
5) increased efficiency in cash management operations.
Competitive selection can be achieved through a written request for application (RFA) for
banking services. The RFA format can be flexible but should include requests for information to
facilitate the evaluation of facilities and specifications of depository and investment services
needed. The format of the RFA should allow the responding institutions a chance to describe
their services, costs and credit worthiness. Development of the RFA should include a review of
legal requirements for the selection of banking services. Some statutes specify the maximum
contract length, define the selection process, and may even name the basis for contract award.
FDIC Deposit Insurance for Accounts held by Government
Depositors (Date Sensitive Information)
http://www.fdic.gov/deposit/deposits/FactSheet.html
Section 330.15 of the FDIC’s regulations (12 C.F.R. 330.15) governs the insurance coverage of
public unit accounts. For deposit insurance purposes, the term "public unit" includes a state,
county, municipality, or "political subdivision" thereof. Under section 330.15, the "official
custodian" of the funds belonging to the public unit – rather than the public unit itself – is
insured as the depositor.
Permanent Rule The insurance coverage of public unit accounts depends upon the type of
deposit and the location of the insured depository institution.
All time and savings deposits (Interest Bearing) owned by a public unit and held by the
same official custodian in an insured depository institution within the State in which the
public unit is located are added together and insured up to $250,000.
Separately, all demand deposits (Non‐Interest Bearing) owned by a public unit and held
by the same official custodian in an insured depository institution within the State in
which the public unit is located are added together and insured up to $250,000.
For the purpose of these rules, the term ‘savings deposits’ includes NOW accounts, money
market deposit accounts and interest bearing demand deposit accounts. The term ‘demand
deposits’ means deposits payable on demand and for which the depository institution does not
reserve the right to require advance notice of an intended withdrawal.
The insurance coverage of accounts held by government depositors is different if the depository
institution is located outside the State in which the public unit is located.
In that case, all deposits owned by the public unit and held by the same official custodian
are added together and insured up to $250,000.
Time and savings deposits are not insured separately from demand deposits.
As mentioned above, a political subdivision (through its official custodian) is entitled to its own
insurance coverage. The term "political subdivision" is defined to include drainage, irrigation,
navigation, improvement, levee, sanitary, school or power districts, and bridge or port authorities
and other special districts created by state statute or compacts between the states. The term
"political subdivision" also includes any subdivision or principal department of a public unit
(state, county, or municipality) if the subdivision or department meets the following tests:
The creation of the subdivision or department has been expressly authorized by the law of
such public unit;
Some functions of government have been delegated to the subdivision or department by
such law; and
The subdivision or department is empowered to exercise exclusive control over funds for
its exclusive use.
The term "political subdivision" does not include subordinated or non-autonomous divisions,
agencies, or boards within subdivisions or principal departments.
Again, a public unit (including a political subdivision) is insured through its official custodian. If
the same individual is an official custodian for more than one public unit, he or she is separately
insured for the deposits belonging to each public unit. On the other hand, two or more
individuals are treated as one official custodian if action or consent by all of these individuals is
required for the exercise of control over the funds of a single public unit.
An official custodian is an officer, employee, or agent of a public unit having official custody of
public funds and lawfully depositing the funds in an insured institution. In order to qualify as an
official custodian, a person must have plenary authority – including control – over the funds.
Control of public funds includes possession as well as the authority to establish accounts in
insured depository institutions and to make deposits, withdrawals and disbursements.
Deposit insurance coverage cannot be increased by dividing funds among several putative
official custodians who lack plenary authority over such funds. Likewise, coverage cannot be
increased by dividing funds among several accounts controlled by the same official custodian for
the same public unit.
Special Rule for Public Bonds A special rule applies to funds held by an officer, agent or
employee of a public unit under a law or bond indenture that requires the funds to be set aside to
discharge a debt owed to the holders of notes or bonds issued by the public unit. A deposit of
such funds in an insured depository institution is insured up to $250,000 for the beneficial
interest of each bondholder. This coverage is separate from the coverage for other deposits
owned by the public unit at the same institution. In order to obtain this special coverage,
however, the deposit account must satisfy certain disclosure requirements applicable to deposits
held by agents or fiduciaries. Specifically, the deposit account records of the insured depository
institution must disclose the existence of the fiduciary relationship or the fiduciary nature of the
deposit. In addition, the details of the fiduciary relationship and the interests of the bondholders
must be ascertainable from the records of the depository institution or the records of the
depositor maintained in good faith and in the regular course of business. See 12 C.F.R. 330.5(b).
The relevant section of the FDIC's deposit insurance regulations can be found at: 12 C.F.R.
330.15. If you have questions or comments about the insurance coverage of public unit
accounts, contact the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation by telephone at 1‐ 877‐ASK‐FDIC
or by mail at 550 17th Street, NW, Washington, DC 20429.
Cash Forecasting
Cash forecasts are projections of anticipated receipts, disbursements, and cash balances over a
certain period of time, typically a year. Accurate cash forecasting is an important cash
management tool because it can:
1) improve investment earnings by forecasting the amount of cash that will be available for
investment, and for what time period;
2) identify temporary cash deficits that require short-term debt financing and ensure
compliance with federal arbitrage regulations;
3) ensure liquidity by providing estimates of the amount of cash on hand for timely
disbursements;
4) enhance creditworthiness through improved cash management practices, thereby
reducing the cost of borrowing to debt issuers; and
5) warn of impending problems with the annual fiscal budget through the identification of
potential revenue shortfalls or unexpectedly large disbursements that could result in cash
deficits.
There are several types of cash forecasts as follows.
1) Annual cash forecasts provide monthly estimates of cash position, including the level of
positive and negative cash balances. They are useful in determining the amount of cash
available for investment in instruments with maturities of 30 days or more.
2) Monthly cash forecasts provide weekly estimates of cash position. They can be used to
monitor the accuracy of the annual forecast and are useful in making decisions involving
investment instruments in the 0-90 day range.
3) Weekly cash forecasts provide daily estimates of cash position. They can be used to
monitor the accuracy of the monthly forecast and can be used for investment decision
making involving instruments with maturities of fewer than seven days.
While the main objective of each type is to forecast cash position at some future point in time,
each has different purposes, benefits and costs. Approaches to cash forecasting range from the
informal to the sophisticated. At a minimum, investment officers should coordinate banking
services that assist in the development and reporting of cash forecasts as well as utilizing
spreadsheet and databases applications to automate much of the forecasting process.
Investment Policies and Strategies
Governments should have and, in some states such as Texas1, may be required by law to have a
written investment policy. A formal policy protects not only the assets of the organization (which
belong to the public), but also the elected official and management staff. The three objectives
that should direct any investment policy are:
Safety
Liquidity
Yield.
Safety is listed first. Because public investment officials have a fiduciary responsibility with
regard to the monies that they manage, safety, or the preservation of capital, must be their
primary concern. Treasurers must manage investments in such a way as to minimize risk. The
various types of risk that require attention are described below.
1) Credit Risk – risk that the issuer of a security may default. Credit risk is gauged by
quality rating assigned by commercial rating companies, such as Moody’s Investors
Services, Standard and Poor’s, and Dominion Bond Rating Service.
2) Liquidity Risk – involves the ease at which the security can be sold. In an active
secondary market for a security-type, there are always buyers available. One key to the
secondary market activity is the spread between the bid price and the offer price. In active
markets, such as Treasury Bills, the difference in the bid and offer may only be a basis
point or two. For inactive markets, the spread may be several basis points.
3) Market Risk – the price of the typical security will move in the opposite direction of
interest rates. As interest rates rise (fall), the price of a fixed income security will rally
(rise). For an investor who plans to hold a fixed income security to maturity, the change
in its price prior to maturity is not of concern; however, for an investor who may need to
sell the security prior to maturity, an increase in interest rates will mean the realization of
a capital loss.
4) Volatility Risk – risk that the price of a security will be more violently affected by
changes in interest rates. Certain attributes of a security, such as a long-term maturity
date, an embedded option (such as a call feature), will cause the security to exaggerate
the effects of market changes. For example, when interest rates increase slightly, a
Treasury Bill will be affected only slightly. In the same environment, a mortgage-backed
security’s value may plummet.
5) Extension Risk – risk that a change in interest rates will cause the anticipated maturity of
a security to extend. An example would be a mortgage-backed security that has been
historically paying off faster than the absolute maturity date of the issue as homeowners
refinance, upgrade, etc. In such a case, investors typically assume this accelerated
payment will continue and will calculate the “average life” of the investment to be shorter
that the absolute. When interest rates rise, however, homeowners may cease to refinance,
upgrade, etc. and the average life of the security will return to the absolute maturity date.
6) Re-investment Risk – risk that the cash flows generated by a security will be reinvested
at a lower rate than the prevailing interest rate levels. This risk becomes a much more
critical consideration for callable securities. If an issuer holds the right to call the security
when interest rates fall, the investor is faced with having to reinvest the proceeds in a
lower rate environment.
7) Collateral Risk – risk that the market value of the collateral an investor receives against
his investment will not be adequate to cover the investment plus interest accrual in the
case of a counterparty default. It can also be applied to the degree of “perfected interest”
that the investor contractually holds in ownership of the security. For example, the
collateral should be held at a third party institution in the account name of the investor.
Repurchase agreements should always be governed by an executed PSA Master
Repurchase Agreement between the investor and the dealer.
8) Event Risk – risk that an unforeseen event or accident could negatively affect the value
of a security. An example would be the Orange County bankruptcy and the impact that
this had on the participants in the investment pool managed by that county. Not only were
the participants’ funds withheld, but their credit ratings were adversely affected by their
lack of liquidity. Investors who held bonds issued by these governments saw the value of
their securities decline.
The key is to remember that all the various risks are ongoing all the time and to determine the
acceptable level of risk and to ensure that the risks are monitored on an ongoing basis.
Liquidity, the speed with which an investment can be converted to cash, is also important.
Invested funds must be available when the government needs to make expenditures.
Yield, or the rate of return -- the income which is derived from investments -- is the third
objective. While additional income from investments is important, it must never become the
prime consideration in the investment of public funds and must be tempered by acceptable risk.
The investment policy may include specific reference to the prudent investor rule, which states
that persons should exercise the same level of care in managing the funds of others that they
would with their own funds.
Once policy is developed, it should be presented to the governing board for adoption by
ordinance or resolution. The policy should be implemented immediately and procedures
developed using the policy as a framework. The policy also can be used to monitor actual
investment activity. The policy and the strategy statements (discussed below) should be reviewed
at least annually and updated to include new investment legislation, personnel changes or other
issues that may arise.
Investment Strategies
The investment policy establishes the goals and objectives of the entity’s investment
management program. The investment strategy is the plan designed to achieve the goals and
objectives. The foundation of the plan is the entity’s cash forecast. Cash flow needs determine
investment selection by types and maturity. Whether the investment portfolio is large or small, or
whether the portfolio is managed internally or externally, a cash forecast will be required.
Written investment strategies in the investment policy must address:
(1) Suitability
(2) Preservation and safety of principal
(3) Liquidity
(4) Marketability
(5) Diversification
(6) Yield
With the cash forecast as the base, investment strategies should focus on safety of principal,
liquidity to meet unforeseen cash needs, suitability of the investment, and diversification of the
portfolio as a means to control risk, and finally yield. Investment suitability includes
consideration of management’s tolerance for risk, staff resources and time devoted to investment
management. For example, the cash forecast may indicate that an entity may safely invest a
portion of its investment portfolio for twelve months but may not have access to the market
information required to monitor the value of all security types available at this maturity. Staff
resources and time will also influence how actively the portfolio is managed.
Public investment officials should review their investment capabilities, constraints and objectives
to decide which investment strategy works best for them. In the final analysis, cash managers
should remember the "SLY" priority of investment objectives: safety and liquidity always come
before yield.
Investment Economics
A key concept for investment planning is the yield curve--the relationship between interest rates
and the time to maturity on investments. A yield curve is simply a graph plotting the yields on a
specified security (e.g. Treasury bills or bank certificates of deposit) on the vertical axis, with the
maturity of each instrument on the horizontal axis. Each point on the yield curve represents the
yield for a particular maturity of a security.
So what determines the shape of the yield curve? Most economists agree that two major factors
affect the slope of the yield curve: investors’ expectations of future interest rates and certain
“risk premiums” that investors require to hold longer maturity investments. Yield curves take
many shapes and do not remain stable. Most of the time,
the yield curve rises from the left to the right, as interest
rates are higher on longer-term maturities. Such an
upsweeping or ascending yield curve is called a normal
yield curve.
In periods of high interest rates usually associated with
periods of tight money, the yield curve may invert. When
this happens, short-term rates exceed long-term rates. This configuration reflects investors'
expectations that high interest rates will not last forever, and a slowdown will probably drive
interest rates lower. Such a downward sloping yield curve is called an inverted yield curve.
An inverted yield curve is often a foreshadow of a recessionary period. A positively sloped yield
curve often foreshadows inflationary growth.
The yield curve should be a smooth continuous line that flattens out
as maturities lengthen. Whenever a specific security lies above the
rest of the curve, it may represent a buying opportunity. Similarly,
when a security held in a portfolio lies below the curve, it may be
prudent to sell it.
Experienced public investors learn to study the yield curve and find
maturities that offer the best relative value. With flat yield curves
the general rule is to select shorter maturities; with steep curves,
longer maturities may offer better investment values.
Closely linked with analysis of the yield curve is the design of a government's portfolio. Of
particular concern should be the development of a policy of diversification to minimize risk. The
most common way that this is achieved is through limits on investments by type, maturity, and
financial institution.
Investment Instruments
The investment process involves systematic selection of securities and investment instruments
that meet a local government’s objectives and constraints. Investment instruments should always
be analyzed in the context of four criteria: legality, safety, liquidity and yield. Major forms of
investment instruments are as follows and are detailed in the Public Funds Investment Act of
Texas:
U.S. Treasury Bills (T-bills). These short-term obligations are issued at a discount from their
par maturity value. T-bills are considered risk free and very liquid instruments with the highest
degree of marketability. Their yields tend to be the lowest of all money market instruments.
Unsecured obligations of the U.S. Government.
Maturity of a year or less when issued.
Unlike longer-term Treasuries, T-Bills pay no coupons.
They make a single payment of par value at maturity.
They are issued at a discount to par, so an investor who holds a T-Bill to maturity earns
the difference between the par value and discounted value at which the instrument was
purchased.
Prices for T-Bills are quoted for USD 100 of par value.
T-Bills are also quoted as an actual/360 discount yield
The Department of Treasury auctions standard maturities of T-bills.
– These typically include 13, 26 and 52 week maturities.
– All T-bills mature on a Thursday (unless a holiday).
– Certain maturities may be suspended for periods of time.
– These instruments are issued through weekly auctions.
There is an active secondary market for T-bills.
Mechanics
– If you buy/sell, you will be quoted a dollar price as a bid and asked spread
• The bid is the dollar price at which the organization will buy your T-bill if
you are selling
• The asked is the dollar price at which it will sell if you want to buy
• The difference is the spread and it is the profit.
– Price = $10,000 – ($10,000 x asked discount x days to maturity) / 360
Treasury Notes and Bonds. In addition to the Treasury bill series, the U.S. Government also
issues coupon securities called notes and bonds. These instruments pay interest every six months
just like municipal bonds. Unlike Treasury bills, which are quoted on a discount basis, Treasury
bonds and notes are traded in the bond market with prices based on par equaling 100.
Have initial maturities greater than a year.
All pay semi-annual coupons, usually according to a schedule under which coupons are
paid on anniversaries of the security's first issuance date.
Calculate on Actual/Actual basis
Notes and bonds differ only in their initial maturities.
– Notes are issued with maturities up to ten years.
• 2, 3, 5 and 10 year notes
– Bonds have initial maturities greater than ten years.
• 15, 20, and 30 year bonds
By convention, note and bond prices are quoted based on a USD 100 par value.
– Prices can be confusing and expressed in decimal or hyphen form.
• For example USD 101.34 or 101.25 or 101-14.
– Quoting prices in 32nds of a USD is widely used.
• If a bond is quoted at 101-14, this means that the bond's price is 101 and
14/32, or USD 101.4375 per USD 100 of par value.
• A 64th can be added to the price with a plus sign, so 101-14+ means 101
and 14/32 and 1/64.
• Eighths of a 32nd can be added to the price by appending an additional
digit to the quote. For example, 101-143 indicates a price of 101 and 14/32
and 3/256.
• Often, a period replaces the hyphen in this notation, so don't assume that a
quote of 101.25 means 101 and 1/4 USD. It very likely means 101 and
25/32 USD.
{R + [(FV - PP)/M]}
Investment yield = ------------------------------
[(FV + PP)/2]
R = coupon rate FV = face value
PP = purchase price M = years to maturity
Treasury Bonds
– Have the longest maturity, from fifteen to thirty years.
– Have a coupon payment every six months like T-Notes, and are currently only
issued with a maturity of thirty years.
– The U.S. Federal government suspended issuing the well-known 30-year Treasury
bonds (often called long-bonds) for a four and a half year period starting October
31, 2001 and concluding February 2006.
– As the U.S. government used its budget surpluses to pay down the Federal debt in
the late 1990s, the 10-year Treasury note began to replace the 30-year Treasury
bond as the general, most-followed metric of the U.S. bond market.
– However, because of demand from pension funds and large, long-term
institutional investors, along with a need to diversify the Treasury's liabilities the
30-year Treasury bond was re-introduced in February 2006 and is now issued
quarterly. This brought the U.S. in line with Japan and European governments
issuing longer-dated maturities amid growing global demand from pension funds.
Zero-coupon Securities. A zero-coupon security is one that does not pay interest until its final
maturity. By stripping the coupons from a bond, it is possible to offer investors Treasury
obligations that pay principal or interest on future dates with the original investment priced at a
substantial discount from the maturity value. Zero-coupon securities also permit investors to
“lock in” a specific return.
Federal Agency Securities. In addition to the U.S. Treasury, numerous federal agencies and
government-sponsored corporations (instrumentalities) issue debt. Some of these obligations are
guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. Government, but most of them carry only a
“moral obligation” to protect investors. The securities are not as widely traded as treasury
obligations, and their lack of guarantees leads to higher yields. Because of federal involvement,
most states authorize these investments for their local governments.
TIPS
Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (or TIPS)
Inflation-indexed bonds issued by the U.S. Treasury.
The principal is adjusted to the Consumer Price Index (CPI), the commonly used measure
of inflation.
– When the CPI rises, the principal adjusts upward. If the index falls, the principal
adjusts downwards.
– The coupon rate is constant, but generates a different amount of interest when
multiplied by the inflation-adjusted principal, thus protecting the holder against
inflation.
TIPS are currently offered in 5-year, 10-year and 30-year maturities.
STRIPS
Separate Trading of Registered Interest and Principal Securities (or STRIPS)
T-Notes, T-Bonds and TIPS whose interest and principal portions of the security have
been separated, or "stripped“.
The name derives from the days before computerization, when paper bonds were
physically traded; traders would literally tear the interest coupons off of paper securities
for separate resale.
The government does not directly issue STRIPS; they are formed by investment banks or
brokerage firms, but the government does register STRIPS in its book-entry system.
They cannot be bought through TreasuryDirect, but only through a broker.
STRIPS are used by the Treasury and split into individual principal and interest
payments, which get resold in the form of zero-coupon bonds. Because they then pay no
interest, there is not any interest to re-invest, and so there is no reinvestment risk with
STRIPS.
Collateralized Mortgage Obligations
First introduced in 1983, the Tax Reform Act of 1986 allowed CMOs to be issued in the
form of real estate mortgage investment conduits (REMICs). Almost all CMOs are
REMICs.
CMOs are collateralized debt obligations (CDO) consisting of mortgage-backed
securities (MBS) that are separated and issued as different classes of mortgage pass-
through securities with different terms, interest rates, and risks.
CMOs are agency CMOs that are guaranteed by the Government National Mortgage
Association (Ginnie Mae), the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae), or
the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Association (Freddie Mac).
CMOs by private issuers, collectively referred to as non-agency CMOs, achieve a AAA
rating through the use of credit enhancements.
CMO bonds differ from corporate and government or agency bonds in that payments are
made monthly or quarterly instead of semi-annually, the payments may consist of both
principal and interest, and, although specific CMO bonds may have stated maturities, the
actual lifetime of the bond will depend on prepayment rates, and it could be longer or
shorter than the stated maturity date.
– 10 yr. or less stated final maturity date
– Cannot be either an Interest-Only or Principal-Only CMO
The following are not permitted:
– inverse floater CMO
– Principal only CMO
– Interest only CMO
– Maturity greater than 10 years
Depository Instruments. Banks and savings and loan associations offer short-term instruments.
Two instruments are noteworthy: the interest-bearing deposit account (NOW or MMDA) and the
certificate of deposit (CD).
Repurchase Agreements. A repurchase agreement is where an investor exchanges cash to
receive government securities for a specified period of time. This can be done overnight, for a
specific term (maturity), or on a indefinite (open) basis. The interest rate paid for the use of the
cash is determined by negotiation or bidding. Upon maturity, the investor returns the securities
and receives cash plus accumulated interest.
Commercial Paper. These are unsecured promissory notes of corporations maturing in less than
270 days. They carry no government guarantees or insurance and entail considerably higher
credit risks. Issued at a discount and carries a zero coupon.
PFIA Requirements:
– 270 days or fewer
– Rated not less than A-1 or P-1 by at least:
• Two credit rating agencies; or,
• One credit rating agency and an irrevocable bank letter of credit
Bankers’ Acceptances. To finance foreign trade transactions, large banks issue acceptances of
trade bills. These instruments are usually high-quality money market securities, and usually trade
in denominations of $1 million or $10 million. Most BAs trade on a discount basis with
maturities under 60 days.
PFIA Requirements:
– 270 days or fewer
– Liquidated in full at maturity
– Eligible Federal Reserve Bank collateral
– U.S. Bank rated not less than A-1 or P-1
Certificates of Deposit. A certificate of deposit or share certificate is an authorized investment
under PFIA if the certificate is issued by a depository institution that has its main office or a
branch office in this state and is:
guaranteed or insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation or its successor or the
National Credit Union Share Insurance Fund or its successor;
secured by obligations that are described by Section 2256.009(a), including mortgage backed
securities directly issued by a federal agency or instrumentality that have a market value of
not less than the principal amount of the certificates, but excluding those mortgage backed
securities of the nature described by Section 2256.009(b); or
secured in any other manner and amount provided by law for deposits of the investing entity.
(b) In addition to the authority to invest funds in certificates of deposit under Subsection (a),
an investment in certificates of deposit made in accordance with the following conditions is
an authorized investment under this subchapter:
the funds are invested by an investing entity through a depository institution that has its main
office or a branch office in this state and that is selected by the investing entity;
the depository institution selected by the investing entity under Subdivision (1) arranges for
the deposit of the funds in certificates of deposit in one or more federally insured depository
institutions, wherever located, for the account of the investing entity;
the full amount of the principal and accrued interest of each of the certificates of deposit is
insured by the United States or an instrumentality of the United States;
the depository institution selected by the investing entity under Subdivision (1) acts as
custodian for the investing entity with respect to the certificates of deposit issued for the
account of the investing entity; and
Brokered Certificates of Deposit. Brokered CDs are now allowed after the 2011 Legislative
session. The requirements are:
A broker that has its main office or a branch office in this state and is selected from a list
adopted by the investing entity as required by Section 2256.025; or
the broker or the depository institution selected by the investing entity under Subdivision (1)
arranges for the deposit of the funds in certificates of deposit in one or more federally insured
depository institutions, wherever located, for the account of the investing entity;
the investing entity appoints the depository institution selected by the investing entity under
Subdivision (1), an entity described by Section 2257.041(d), or a clearing broker‐dealer
registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission and operating pursuant to Securities
and Exchange Commission Rule 15c3‐3 (17 C.F.R. Section 240.15c3‐3) as custodian for the
investing entity with respect to the certificates of deposit issued for the account of the investing
entity.
Investment Pools. Many states have created investment pools in which localities can invest that
operate like commercial money market funds. These pools offer the advantage of daily liquidity,
economies of scale through combined purchasing, and diversification and professional
management.
PFIA Requirements:
– Governing body must authorize investment in pool
– Can only invest in obligations approved by the Act
– Provide an offering circular containing information required by the Act
– Provide investment transaction confirmations
– Provide a monthly report containing information required by the Act
– Pool created to function as a money market mutual fund must mark its portfolio to
market daily and stabilize at a $1 net asset value.
– Must have an advisory board as specified by the Act
– Rated not less than AAA or an equivalent rating by at least one nationally
recognized rating service.
Money Market Mutual Funds. Several states permit local governments to invest in money
market mutual funds. Like their retail counterparts, investment companies offer institutional
money market funds to governmental investors. These S.E.C.-regulated instruments employ an
independent custodian, and operate under a trust agreement.
No-Load Money Market Funds
PFIA Requirements:
– Registered with and regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission
– Provide a prospectus and other information required by the Securities Exchange
Act of 1934 or the Investment Company Act of 1940
– Must have a dollar-weighted average stated maturity of 90 days or less
– Must include in its objectives maintenance of a stable net asset value of $1
– Investing entity may not own more than 10% of the fund’s total assets
Mutual Funds
PFIA Requirements:
– Registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission
– Must have an average weighted maturity of less than two years
– Can only invest in obligations approved by the Act
– Rated not less than AAA or its equivalent by at least one nationally recognized
investment rating firm
– Comply with information and reporting requirements for investment pools as
described in the Act
– Amount limited to 15% of investing entity’s monthly average fund balance,
excluding bond proceeds, reserves, and debt service funds.
– Ineligible for investment of bond proceeds, reserves, and debt service funds
– Investing entity may not own more than 10% of the fund’s total assets
Investment Pools
PFIA Requirements
– Governing body must authorize investment in pool
– Can only invest in obligations approved by the Act
– Provide an offering circular containing information required by the Act
– Provide investment transaction confirmations
– Provide a monthly report containing information required by the Act
– Pool created to function as a money market mutual fund must mark its portfolio to
market daily and stabilize at a $1 net asset value.
– Must have an advisory board as specified by the Act
– Rated not less than AAA or an equivalent rating by at least one nationally
recognized rating service.
Below is a PFIA summary of the various requirements and limitations regarding pools and funds
Guaranteed Investment Contract or Flex-Repo
A fixed rate, fixed maturity contract similar to a bond.
Unlike a bond, a guaranteed investment contract is always valued at par (face) value.
– This occurs because the company issuing the guaranteed investment contract,
usually an insurance company, guarantees the investment by agreeing to pay the
difference between the market value and book value for the issue if the investor
decides to sell it.
A guaranteed investment contract may be structured in a manner similar to a flexible
repurchase agreement, whereby the investor is able to draw down the balance upon written
request throughout the life of the contract.
Authorized investment for bond proceeds
– Defined termination date
– Secured by Section 009(a)(1) of the PFIA
– Third party safekeeping
Term may not exceed 5 years from date of bond issuance, excluding reserves and debt
service funds
– To be eligible:
• Must specifically authorize when authorizing bonds
• Three bids
• Highest yield
• Drawdown schedule
• Reasonable administrative costs
No-Load Money Market Mutual
Fund
No-Load Mutual
Fund
Constant Dollar
Pool
Floating Net
Asset Value Pool
Restricted to Public Funds Inv. Act Authorized Investment
N
Y
Y
Y
Rating Required
N
Y
Y
Y
Weighted Average Maturity (WAM) Limit
90 days
2 years
90 days
None
Stable Net Asset Value (NAV) at $1
Y
N
Y
N
Requires Advisory Board
N
N
Y
Y
Investment Amount Limits (maximum)
None
15% of operating funds, excluding bond reserve and debt service funds
None
None
Investment Bond Proceeds
Y
N
Y
Y
Weighted Average Maturity (WAM) calculation using stated or reset dates
Reset
Stated
Stated
Stated
Public Funds Investment Act Disclosure Requirements
N
Y
Y
Y
Israeli Bonds. Debt securities issued by the Government of Israel.
In summary, the following are the only investments allowed by the Public Funds Investment Act:
– U.S. government obligations, including letters of credit.
– State of Texas direct obligations.
– Obligations of other states, agencies, counties, cities.
– Collateralized mortgage obligations.
– Bankers’ acceptances.
– Commercial paper.
– Repurchase agreements, including securities lending.
– Certificates of deposit.
– Share certificates.
– SEC-registered no-load money market mutual funds.
– SEC-registered no-load mutual funds.
– Local government investment pools.
– State of Israel bonds.
– Guaranteed investment contracts.
Investment Safekeeping
Prudent public investors minimize risks by arranging for their investment securities to be held by
an independent third party--somebody other than the depository bank, dealer or investment
company from whom the securities are purchased. The following general guidelines apply to
different investment instruments.
Government Securities. Ownership of U.S. Treasury securities and some federal agency
securities is recorded by computerized “book entry” on the records of a Federal Reserve Bank.
The government’s custodian bank usually will be listed on the Fed’s booked entry system, with
ownership shown as “customer account” or “trust account.” Local governments generally cannot
have their own name shown on the book-entry system. Therefore it is very important that
ownership be placed with an independent party--either a financial institution other than the one
acting as seller, or possibly in the trust department of a local bank (provided there is a written
trust agreement). A written safekeeping confirmation should be provided for each security held
by the custodian.
Repo Collateral. Securities purchased under a repurchase agreement should also be delivered to
an independent custodian or a bank trust department, subject to a written safekeeping/custodial
agreement. Governmental investors should avoid “hold in custody” repos, in which the dealer or
bank holds the collateral with no segregation and independent verification to protect the
customer.
Deposit Collateral. To protect public deposits, some states require each bank to segregate
government securities. Collateral usually can be transferred to a Federal Reserve Bank or to a
third-party bank, which protects the entity against financial failure.
Mutual Funds. Most mutual funds employ independent bank custodians for their portfolio
safekeeping. Before investing in a money market mutual fund or a short-term government bond
mutual fund, investors should verify (1) whether the portfolio is held by an independent
custodian, (2) whether the fund requires delivery vs. payment (DVP) in its portfolio transactions,
and (3) whether the fund purchases insurance against fraud, embezzlement and computer errors.
These protections are offered by many mutual funds and should not be overlooked.
Short-Term Borrowing
Short-term borrowing, is frequently an important component of an effective cash management
program. It is generally used to finance temporary cash flow deficits and enable governments to
meet budgeted expenditures, such as payrolls, prior to the receipt of current revenues. Short-term
borrowing is also used as temporary financing for long-term capital improvement projects. In
some instances, borrowing has been used as a means to earn additional interest income for a
government through arbitrage investing.
The ability of governments to borrow in the short-term is restricted by law and by other factors,
such as local policies regarding debt issuance. State and local laws and local debt policies
generally specify who can borrow, how much can be borrowed, from whom money can be
borrowed, and what types of debt can be issued. Federal laws and regulations, such as those
governing the earning of arbitrage interest, also act as constraints upon a government's ability to
finance temporary cash deficits.
The ability of governments to engage in short-term borrowing is also dependent upon access to
the credit markets. Access depends on a number of factors, including:
1) The creditworthiness of the issuer;
2) A demonstrated record of performance in the credit markets based upon the prior
issuance of debt;
3) A favorable market environment, with stable interest rates; and
4) The ability and experience of management in implementing a financing plan.
Governments engaging in short-term borrowing must understand that too much short-term debt
can lead to fiscal problems. Therefore, when governments find it necessary to issue short-term
debt, it should be for a specified time period and only when the revenues to repay the debt are
assured. Furthermore, short-term debt, borrowing for operating purposes should always be repaid
by the end of the fiscal year which the funds were borrowed.
Investment Transactions
Control of risk in an investment management program includes policies and procedures for the
conduct of investment transactions. Vendors of investment products should be selected according
to established criteria and then reviewed periodically based on performance and other
appropriate standards approved by the governing body or the designated investment committee.
In addition to being sellers of instruments, banks are also facilitators of investment transactions.
The depository bank should be selected through a competitive bid process, and one of the
evaluation factors in that process should be the bank’s securities clearing and safekeeping
capability. All securities transactions should be conducted on a delivery vs. payment (DVP) basis
as required by Public Funds Investment Act 2256.005(b)(4)(E), and the bank’s procedures for
handling failed transactions should be clearly understood and documented.
Banks also offer many investment products to governments, including U.S. Government
securities, mutual funds, repurchase agreements, and interest-bearing accounts such as
certificates of deposit and FDIC products. A bank’s creditworthiness should be reviewed even
though all deposits may be fully collateralized. The government’s interest in the collateral must
be perfected according to requirements of state and federal law. Perfected meaning a security
interest in the collateral that is used to secure the performance of a debt that is protected from
third-party claims.
Local government investment pools and mutual funds should be evaluated for compliance with
state law and the government’s investment policy. For example, if the investment policy only
permits investment in money market mutual funds and investment pools functioning as money
market funds, then funds and pools with fluctuating share prices should not be considered.
Offering statements for investment pools should be read carefully. The pool’s performance
history should be studied and compared with other investment alternatives.
Portfolio maturity restrictions should be evaluated to determine potential market and credit risks.
The qualifications and experience of the portfolio manager should be evaluated in terms of both
the individual and organization fulfilling this function. Portfolio pricing practices, including any
designed to maintain a stable unit/share price, should be evaluated. Custodial policies should be
reviewed. All investors in mutual funds should read the prospectus. The size, depth, and history
of the investment organization should be evaluated. Fees should be investigated; the total
expense ratio should be determined. Earnings performance histories should be evaluated.
Both investment pools and mutual funds should be checked for compliance with any rating and
information disclosure requirements imposed by either state or federal laws. Procedures for
deposit and withdrawal of funds should be verified.
Governments also purchase investments from broker/dealers. There are different types of
broker/dealers and investment advisors offering similar services. A broker can be defined as one
who brings buyers and sellers together for a commission. By definition, brokers do not take a
position in the assets being exchanged. Their function is to provide a communications network
that brings market participants -- buyers and sellers -- together to exchange assets. A dealer
makes markets in money market instruments by quoting bid and asked prices at which they are
prepared to buy and sell. Dealers will buy and sell to each other, to issuers, and to investors.
A firm may operate as a broker/dealer by bringing buyers and sellers together in its function as a
broker and by taking a position of its own in selected securities in its function as a dealer. A
subcategory of dealer is a primary dealer. A primary dealer is one who makes a market in
government securities and has met certain minimum financial criteria set by the Market Reports
Division of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. The second tier of dealers generally includes
firms that meet certain market needs and attempt to position themselves in specific sectors of the
market. Often secondary dealers will seek to meet the needs of their clients by offering
instruments that match the cash flow needs of the government. Secondary dealers may operate
regionally or nationally.
Many public fund investors lack the resources necessary to search the money market properly or
on a timely basis and, therefore, look to brokers/dealers to find market opportunities for them.
Providing access to the money markets is a major function of the broker/dealer community.
Other important functions of the broker/dealers are market analysis, portfolio analysis, credit
research, securities analysis, and relative value analysis. These services represent the advantages
of using broker/dealers. The disadvantages of using broker/dealers arise mainly from lack of
monitoring the cost of investment transactions and lack of adherence to the government’s
approved investment policy. These disadvantages can be controlled by developing a selection
process for broker/dealers -- and other investment vendors -- and by monitoring the performance
of all firms involved in the government’s investment program.
Investment advisers offer investment advice to governments for a fee. Advisers differ in the size
of the firm, the range of services offered, and the amount of fee charged. Investment advisory
firms may be bank trust departments, national investment management firms, specialized
boutique firms, or small independent consultants. Some investment advisory firms offer
prepackaged investments, such as mutual funds or investment pools, while other firms offer
customized portfolio services that may include consulting activities for the cash management
function, such as cash flow forecasting. Investment advisors may also act as broker/dealers. If
this is the case, the investment advice offered may not be the sole objective since trading
securities generates income for the firm. Investment advisers may be given either discretionary
or non-discretionary authority in managing the government’s portfolio.
As with broker/dealers, there are advantages and disadvantages to using investment advisers. The
advantages include greater access to the capital markets than the government’s limited resources
would permit leading to wider diversification of the investments as allowed by the investment
policy. Some investment advisers have expertise in specific sectors of the market and can
enhance returns by developing investment strategies to make the most of market opportunities in
those sectors. Advisers may also be used to complement internal resources and to strengthen
internal controls. The disadvantages of investment advisers include the overall cost an adviser
may add to the investment management process. In some cases, investment advisers will be
unable to produce sufficiently high returns to offset the cost of the service. Public funds investors
must also remember the responsibility for the portfolio remains with them and cannot be
delegated to an adviser. The adviser should be selected through a request for proposal and
performance monitored according to standards established in an investment advisory agreement.