ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+...

544
Z D w L £ ? » z ´ # _ e Z ¸ g < Z + ; Z D w Z » 0 ˛ y 1 Q g z x ˘ ø ·

Transcript of ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+...

Page 1: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDw è £?»

ózÂ#_·

eZËg<Z−+;×

ZDwZ»�ò0Îy

1Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 2: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]£tôp

*Ñ:ZDwZ»�ò0Îy

0ÎyÔziZg�pÄ( è )Ó#Ö�2wÔZ-ZyZDwÔÑ�g

Tel: [+92-42] 36314-510 [+92-42] 99203-573Fax: [+92-42] 3631-4496

Email: [email protected]: www.allamaiqbal.com

ISBN 978-969-416-420-5

9BâÞ2891Y TZÍw:1002Y T�zx:0102Y : )ÃUãZzgZŸ¯VÆ‚B( TÎx005 ®Z�:XB054Bgz9 7:Ñ•6ì6öÔÑ�g -:

zeÔÑ�gÔy:41275373 g û�Ûz|:611Ô.ge

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^2

Page 3: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�Z�Z%jx

¬Ý�á{ŒÛ7)x:3B�y9691Y(

Åc�~

3Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 4: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ð

º[-ãzg;Ñ�gäZk£á6¸³Ã1891Y~

8ZÝe~Åe¤~«ÅX£!eZËz©ŒÛ7ÅgZ{úð~�kH�åÔZzg

6zW~*BWiZ�ZzgeZËÒZ−+œjÛzãð¸Xð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^4

Page 5: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

FK31 gæ�{V ¼* ð

51 Îx¸³ T: �âp ð

32 �zx¸³ T: �âp ð

13 âpTZÍw¸³ � : w½M¸i ð

73 Qg�z¯xÆù´ : ![198 :ÃgϯxÆù´ ![2312 :kKÆù´ ![3382 :x�~£? ![4923 :ºt�~ù´ ![5383 :�ª]Æù´ ![6704 :ZDwÅ%û�gÏÂÁ ![7334 < Á

305 ÂÒ] Á

515 Z�ágt Á

5Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 6: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^6

Page 7: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

,Z1Z[1DQg�z¯xÆù´

83 Qg�z~ÄÍð )Z³(25 Qg�z¯xÆù´: )[(25 �gZÔ3m4291Y è !895 !Á�sÔ�g~5391Y56 ¢�æÔ�Ñð6391Y86 ZgèÈsi)Qg�z(ÿâÞ8391Yþ17 à�ZDwÔQg�z )`(

2DÃgϯxÆù´09 ZDwÅÃgÏÍð )Z³(201 ÃgϯxÆù´: )[(201 ZuZ§p�~Ô21m5191Y021 gñ¯"p�~Ô01Z6s8191Y521 ZuZgzgñi)�(Ô3291Y841 \xætÔ5D9#3291Y361 i1§YÔ�y7291Y071 Yzh*)Ô�Ûzg~2391Y671 )�ÛÔ4391Y871 �~:p!h™�Z}ZZxÑtÔZÆ'6391Y081 �~:p!h™�DDDì)�ÛÔ6391Y281 ZgèÈsiÿâÞ8391Yþ

7,Z1Z[

Page 8: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

581 à�ZDwÔÃgÏ )`(

3DkKÆù´412 ZDwÅèoâ+ )Z³(122 kKÆxù´ )[(122 �á�ZDwÔ2491Y522 ZDw¯x�á�Ô6891Y522 ZDw*)ÔZzwÿ4491Yþ332 ZDw*)Ô�zxÔ1591Y932 ZDw*)ÿq¢~Z�á®þ042 ZDw¯x{y·*iZ−+{V%jxÔ4591YÔ6891YÔ5991YÔ6002Y è kK342 ZDwÔm7591Y ¯!�742 ZâZ§ZDwÔâga7691Y552 ZDw¯x¤ZòÔZ6s9691Y è kK752 è¹ZDwÔ6791Y062 è¹ZDw¯xH¤ZòÔ�g~8791Y262 ZDw:�È�vÔ6891Y362 ¯!�ZDw¯xa�O~·@Ô8991Y362 Ô3491Y Letters of Iqbal to Jinnah562 Ô�Ûzg~7491Y Iqbal's Letters to Attiya Begum662 ÔâÞ7691Y Letters and Writings of Iqbal862 Ô8791Y Letters of Iqbal

ZDwXZDw*óX è )gzbkK �Zg~ù´372 u·ZDw¯x¦Ñy0z~X´)ZDwÆ101�á�gèo( è kK672 ZDw è à�kK )`(082 ZDw)¡@'ã( è à�kK

4Dx�~£?482 ZDwÅ�â+ )Z³(192 �~£? )[(192 DZÑO�ÿâÞ4091Yþ303 Ô8091Y The Development of Metaphysics in Persia

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^8

Page 9: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

413 Ô#0391Y Six Lectures023 Ô#4391Y The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam

423 âè �~£?ÅDz+ )`(

5Dºt�~ù´033 ZDwÅ*yâ+ )Z³(233 �~ù´ )[(333 ZDwÔ3491Y è p}733 £Ñ�ZDwÔ#3691Y443 ZDwÆ�~Z°gÔâga7791Y253 %§ZDwÔ�g~9691Y553 ZâZ§ZDwÔâga7691Y653 Ô)�áC(âga5491Y Speeches and Statements of Iqbal063 Ô7791Y Speeches, Writings and Statements of Iqbal363 Ô#4691Y Thoughts and Reflections of Iqbal663 Ô)Z}Mg¤gt(7791Y Speeches and Statements of Iqbal763 Ô5791Y Mementos of Iqbal863 Ô9791Y Discourses of Iqbal 073 Ô�y1691Y Stray Reflections 473 @gõ¦sÔ5891Y573 Ô8891Y Bedil in the Light of Bergson

773 âè ºt�0gzVÅDz+ )`(

6D�ª]Æù´483 �ª�ZDw )Z³(883 �ª]Æù´ )[(883 ZDwÆ�gÔ�Ñð1791Y983 �ª]ÿZDwþÔZÍw:kyX�zx9491YÔÎx:7791Y593 ZDwmZ°9*îGÆP�ZCÙgm}Ô7491Y693 gziǧMÔÿZzwþÔ0591Y893 gziǧMÔ�zxÔ4691Y

9,Z1Z[

Page 10: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

993 ZDwÆëSÿ7791Yþ993 ZDwÆëd104 ZDw è WÖ304 âè �ª�ZDwÅDz+ )`(

7DZDwÅ%"0î GOE�gÏÂÁ804 yè ZDw¨ )Z³(114 �gÏÂÁ )[(114 Qg�zÃgkÔ�)®Æa214 Qg�zÃgkÔ‚Â,)®Æa314 Qg�zÃgkÔM^,)®Æa514 Qg�zÃgkÔ0v,)®Æa714 McYÔ7291Y914 yÔ3191Y è @gõ

< /

434 )1(£?ZDwÆÂÒCÃZ674 )2(Zôm~Z�ágZ]l�âpLL\xætóó)Zq),·�k(184 )Zq*c[*y»åQ( The Muslim Community )3(

ÂÒ] /

505 Z³DÂÁ115 [Dg‚bzZ¶gZ]315 Òu4è E

G N `Dz�Z]Zzg415 �D),·èoZzgc��ZÇz){415 zD),·ó£á515 Z�ágt /

aÝw /

45 �gZóóÔTZzw è 1DaçLzgtLL!8011 2DaçLzgtLLZuZ§p�~óóÔT�zx234 ¯[¯xgZáZ�)!{�çE(Zzg[¯xñß~™Ô·)bz~!{�çE( 3D492 4DaçLzgtLLDZÑO�óóÔTZzw

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^01

Page 11: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

803Ô903 Æ�z¶VÆuzgt Development 5D134 6DaçLzgtLLZDw*)óóZÍw414 7DaçLzgtLLQg�zÃgkÔ0v,)®Æaóó424 ( $g@î

EE0Z»�ò 8DaçLzgt@gõy)624 ( $g@î

EE0ñe 9DaçLzgt@gõy)724 ( $g@î

EE0¡7g 01DaçLzgt@gõy)924 History of India 11DaçLzgt

/ý/ý/

11,Z1Z[

Page 12: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¼* ç

¯�gæ�{V)ZqZ½k(

™r!~äW\ÅZkÂ[ÃYΙZzgÃ)™ZiZÍw@Wy7JZzg˧bÆØÆ%t²n™@�V�ZЊ§ZÍw»»x0cXW\äb×]6T§bÂzKzwÅìZzgZke~TZÈxÃÅpg3ìÔZ[z{Ác[ìXZq{m!]tÌìÿ�þQÆ».ÞÆe~W\äZ5Æ0]67g~§bÂzÅìXZzgÿtþUZ(ì�R[JøzÄÂzg;ìXT�h{gm~Zzg!gq|Æ‚BW\

äZqZqÂÔZqZqwsZzggñ¯Zz‡s6ÃeZàìÔz{ZqVwÅwÐ7Æð� zg Z ñ KYäƇ.ÞìXVwÆîg6�43ÿikÃZec~�46Ô56þ6ð ZŸ¯V6T§bW\äÃg¿ìÔz{ZKVwW\ìXzZ§tì�@ñZzg@

~¹(Zs~�ÛtìTŧs¬xW�òÅÂzÀ�Kzw7�0C)¹ÐpZm»Ì¸ZjZwì(c}�94ÿikÃZec~�97þ6Z5Ð0�cÅ

Æ7"ÅqìÔc}�15ÿikÃZec~�18þ6X "54èGEGE 'ç �ìÔz{øg}

gKgKb×]Ŷy��Å�ì)}LL*0ZZgóóZzgLL*0hZgóóc�gzZi{Zzg�gzZi}(Z²7Bc} è ZyÅwTŠgZëìÔZÏŠgßvZyÐ*WÙ�ZzgZyÇ.Þ

ÆZZexV»T§b»©_·H�ìZzgZqZqwsZzgw• ]��]�æ�Úç�

Zzg´#Ö»çH�ìÔZkÅVwW\ÅZkÂ[Ь=Â}Q7c}DwóóZzgLL·ZDwóóÆ*iu�ÛtÃÅpg3X Z å �832ÿikÃZec~�642þ6LL·

¾n�W\ÅtÂ[Dz+Æ¥Æa{mwgBì)ZD1]Æ

31¼*

Page 13: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

fí}~ZŸ†Âí34-ö XGJÿ˜Zþ(X~Z¤ZkÂ[Æ_¬ÐøzxgLÂ=(ZZ\k�@XZÏ6&òGŠì�Z[JYV7ZÐ7|eåZzgW\»�g{mNy�V�W\Å™x�Ûâðä=ZkÆ_¬»ñµõX

=W\ÅZk?mÐåZ·tì�m572ÿikÃZec~m972þ6W\»È{Zk»xÃZ�x�bI™}Ç!óZzg ÉÏî � ä7ÅìpZk~—ì�ÃðZ

Dz´»x-V̹ZiZ[7�0gì�XZka�TZìuÅ¢zg]�CìÔZyÆaÔz{y��ìXßvLLMZWœóó�DYgì�ZzgïÑuÃJw™C7XQ̲ՙDgxecÔ�áhWYñÃðW¨0X

gæ�{V ¯xg<Z−+;×��Ô02Bâga4891Y

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^41

Page 14: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�âp)TÎx('k¬»gƒZåX)@gõ�âpT�zx:41B�Ñð �k ikÃÂ[»�zuZZec

'ÎV~ñçq �k 0002YÔ“Z�á®:1002YÔ1ntZ~2002Y~©¬x6Wc(XikcÆe~�¼7găðÔfs~![zZgZk»¿f™HYg;ì:

1Ô2DQg�zZzgÃgϯxÆù´�zxÆ�âd~�å�ÄZDwÆLL£¾Z�á®ÆôpóóƒäÅ è ëäT

Åâq´qZ�áoVŽâgìX Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(]ö…�æ 0È~»ƒäÆÔZ[!iZg~»Zqc[W[ Ò×n^l WJ‚wƲá~gCgCZk½âg~ZŸ†ƒ@ŠZzgZ[Qg�z

q ìXc[Åi�~WäzZàCÙÚLLc[i�{óóƒYCìOçZDwÆZyâq´Q»qw$2g�ìXZ%ZDwZ»�ò0Îyуg»�áù™�{Zec è ~¡ Ò×n^l

7002Y9F+ìXZkÅ‚Â,Z�á®Ô4002Y~�75&37Åt$2gñ��¶X&953Å« ÅZÍAZ�ᮄÐoÔ¬Wg„ìXm53 e^Ùôqf†mØ ZqZzgt

S~LLâÞóóÆO}LL03BZÆ'óó9ìXZ[Zy�zâVZÝoÅoƒìXÆK~ëäZLZq*yLL¯ÄZDwÅDz+óó)�!: Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù]ö…�æ

Ôуgÿ5002Yþ(~�¦Zg�á]7Å�Ôz{‡.Þg�XZk ]Îf^Ön^lViË`nÜæirˆmä

Æ‚B„»[gæ�{V»*yLL¯ÄZDwÅDz+óóÌÂzeLìXZ,Vä¯ÄZDw»ZqóZec%A™äÆh~.eziã�Ñb�b�XZy»t

*yÁz�51'k¬ÖåZzgZZ,VäCkH�ZyÅWzZiœZ$|?ç EZU"ƒðìÂñßsäeZËÜZÜÅ?mz’q6p�Z(ZqóZec%A™ä»

51�âp

Page 15: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»g™1XëäXi{óZecż¬]Ìð™à è ÚZQVcZzggZ¶ÃÌÑq�ZV)âÞ(ÑzqƒD„n»x»W¸iƒYñÇ1ë è �Xìwå�5002Y»ñÌ

x~VaZƒZ@Wè62B�Ûzg~6002YÃ{V™r » C1 ¡Wh}WðÔ è �zâVÅyZ!‚¹ú0Xp ÇÐYAZzgøgZtµ/�O}»�OZg{Š:WVŠbãzWV è {Û

zËZvZp=X ___ eZËÜZÜ$2gpZ;V��~Zkµ"ÃZ�x�zVÆ*xЂt ÚÓÛØ e^Þ-ô�…] Zk²á~ZqÐz¾dZzg*ëww•

ìX Wðì&ËaZ£ä%AHZzg�*XÅ��ä�áù™ä»LL»g*)óóZ�x�c~�áï e^Þ-�…] aZ£äHtì�4291YJ´)ZDw»‚gZázu¯x

Å)ZDwŇì™�{(FKÃ$weZÑìXZkw•Æfg)Z,V e^Þ-ô�…] ™ÆÃLLåóó™�cì&ZyÆìw~ZDwLLZ�ðg~óógh‰ e^Þ-ô�…] ä)øp÷

¸Xtázu¯xZ¹‚g}»‚gZÔ!ª]¯ÄZDwÆùúVSî™'³gz~%jxлg”{ïŠ)tù·ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyуgÐ Ò×n^lôe^În^lô�Æô]Îf^Ù Æ%û

Z�á®5kƒäƈ��Ð̾[ì(X´)ZDwäZL¯x»¼z�áù™Dz‰Ü¹‚�áù”{¯xÌi�™�c e^Þ-ô�…] �™�cåZzg4291Y~

Zg»ÃKÆadîg6ÂÆ 6 åXZkázu¯xÃZµÐ�áù™*ZDwÆfƒYì1ZÐŒZzw¯x~�z!g{5™LLåóóZDwÃ7™*Z•ð$fz¹ìXtZ(„ì�nxÆe�ÐïáƒñÈÐÔgzhzVZzgèßÃ�z!g{ZÏe�~5�cYñZzgZ´yHYñ�ëänxÆe�ÃLLåóó™�cìX

�Ó�áaZ£™räHìÔZ¤ëZLdZzgZ�!fí}ÃZϧbLL%AóóZzgLLåóó™*Ñzq™�,‚gZZ�[LL¹VÅZ•¹V»gzhZÔ¸yää_�hZóó

Æ]ZtLLaVaV»%/óó0™g{YñÇXZDwÆázu¯xÃZyÆZݯxÆ8g*î FI0™°~5*Zq*ëww•ì

e^Ùôqf†mØ Zzgt)ZDwÅgÎZðÆáZ�sìX}ZÔaZ£™rÃÂ=:�}�z{

ÚÓ^ing…�n‚uŠà Zkż,gZ¶Æ*xgæ�{VƼ�èV~QìXtèo 1D*Ñ:Z�Ò]уgÔ9002YX ÆÄZyÐÂ!ßg]~�áùƒ`�X ]Ö‚màa^�Ûo ì^7eßÝ…ÊnÄ

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^61

Page 16: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

z){ÌZϧbLLåóó™Æ�áù™,X •†hôÒ×nÜ Zzg»Ãð�zuZZecÔ@qw‚t7WcXÝxZZec¤ZV Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(Ê^…‰o

7ìZzgZk»wZzgB#ÖÌic�{ìXZ¤Ãð*ÑZÏy~ÿ'xyz0Îy~�áù™}Â:Üs0Îyɸg]Æ)a Ò×n^l gZòþ&âZzgZ5~ÃgÏ

)Z»�ò Ò×n^l²�AõFÃgÏ(‡gMÅ¢zg]Ì7g~ƒÏZzgz{*ââkZ5~T”{ZkZã

6g~7"ÅúÐ$Yä6WÎ�ÏCk™,ÐX è ZecÔ»A:Z÷�(Ã&éEM%

3DkKÆù´»q¢~Zec)%A:Ug ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä Zk²á~�z&q,‚tWð�ÔZÍw:

»*Zec ]Îf^ÙÞÚ1 »*Zec)%A:†Zv�á{;×(Îx: ÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ &�(�zx:)%A:eZËZÜtZW(XZyÐVÂ1V»¬gsÔ�}![~ZLû6�cYg;ìX

ikÃÂ[Æ�â<îF0T�zx~ëäè¹ZDwÅóDz+»f™HåÔ!z��MZkz‰ÜZDwÆ�~áyŃÐ=wÂ[ìÔèÃg{!Ñ Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ù

Æñ��{)ZEyj£gFKzDz+Æ7ÃÔ Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing ¢zg]!¹ìÉÅ : Zk¢zg]ÅZÌ�zPƒìXt»xfz¾ïgpzZáËZDwÙk»³ì

ZuW¨0zZ�)%æFN{g~Wñ)%A:±¡@'ã(6¬g°â^ÔZÏ�}![Æ Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ù

282(5±ÙX D2 08 Wy~)mZk§bZDwƺtèo{à®Z�~‚tWñ�Xg‚bzZZ~�áù”{

Z,),·èoÅù¦®Z�Zqô}ÐIziƒÏX'×h'WVèoZDwƉZëfí}Ì‚tWñ��ZÂ1V~�áï�Ô}:

Ô …mçmç ]Îf^Ù ¦OZ£Æ�gcÄ™�{fíÒkK~‚]èo�áï�) ZÍw:©gW!��ÁÔ�g~4891Y(XZy~Zº©g~Æ*x3èoZkZ±gÐZë��Zy»

�Zg ñçqZDwÆ(}dWë[ZDw�XWë[ŠgCîg6åZKzZ−{ƧsgìÔXÐZDwÆ©]Zi7¸pZyèVЫ!gtZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�zZ−

71�âp

Page 17: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Æ‚BWë[ZDw»ZCgztÌu�gz*oƒZzg1�{åZzgZkäZKwÆVÐnÆèoqg;Zzg�¼ nasty ZfeàðXZDwë��z{� 6 ZDwùf

z»zl(z{ZkÅ z{™@ì)Wë[ZDwÔuZº©g~ÐâàZ¬-Æ�wÆaÃÒÔm45(2B�Ûzg~7391YÆâ~ ]Îf^ÙÞòoivÏnÐ »zìX) black mailing scheme

a ���Zy'ÎV~Zk»gztZkŠg1�{g;�~Òy7™YXz{÷}a)Zqx�g�u¯(g;ìX)ZsÔm55(ZkfíÒkK constant source of pain

75(X - )m55 ]Îf^Ön^ioq^ñˆc Šg}׬gsÆa�&ÀŸ/õ GG:gZ¶»û{�g Æ)5891Y(~301ÔZ,èo�áï��ZDw Ú¿×çÝ]Îf^Ù �zx:�ZÚiZ£Å"

äZ�ÛZ�{0Zy)�âg·Ô�«·Ô�ZÚiZ£Zzg�UgZ£(Æ*x�¸X�ZÚiZ£äZ¹¢zg~ÜZ0VÆ‚B%1ozÚZ0Zi~%A™Æ7HìXic�{Fèogzi%{i0ÏÆQñgzç5]Ð0�@ë‰èoÐZDwÅ,Ô

èoä} è f‚ZzgIÆwÆ!g}~ZyÅgYá»Z0Zi{ƒ@ìX%AÆèo Ú¿×çÝ]Îf^Ù }‰ZÖpvs™�b�XÎZ¤Z±gÐtfí{ZëìX)

51( - Ôm41 Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 5891Y »×-¬gsÔ�&ÀŸ/õ GGgZ¶ÅÂ[:Îx:eZËGZº�gZãäZDwÅðkRéZZzw*†Æ72)Zôm~=01

)5891Y(~�áùK¸XÂ[Æ ]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6 Zzgð=71(èoZKÂ[kZzgZyÅ �zu}Zec)9991Y(~èVÃ'×h4Z0Zi~ZzgZDwÆ�„â“‘½ð

w°ÃQg�zF3Æ‚B�áùHŠìXZy»iâU’kZÆ'7091YÐ3391YJ» èÜì111BZÆ'9191YƈÐ41BZÆ'1391YJÆ�gxã²á»Ãðâñ��7ìXZDwÅ,ÔZyÅ;]Zzggzââ~Zë�TÃKÆatèoZqã�~â~Åwgn�X¥xƒ@ì�zw*†ZzgZkÆjZáÐ*Åc�ZyÆ

41(X - Ôm11 Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h f‚ÐL":ƒmX)'×h,�&ÀŸ/õ GG:5891YÔZ�Zg{pÄ Þç]�… Xgx:†Z+mâßZe{)x:82B�g~1791Y(»fíÒkK)

ZsðÔуgÔ5891Y(91Qg�zZzgZôm~èVZzg0õ�úCgu]6�ìXtZkâßZe{ Z±gÐZëì�ZDwÔâßZe{ÃZLLL4+�z2Vóó~Ñg™DZzgZyÆ�w6

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^81

Page 18: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

gzZ*Å !b Æ%æFNïmèV»Ô�Zîñ��åXZyèVÐ�zâVÆ"$¹Ò¨é GE:Ôm57(X Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h â΂tWCìX)'×h�A:5891Y

)z„ZDwúö:ÚTyуgÔ2891Y(~eZË;Zd)Zzg Þç]�…]l Q:eZ˱†Z�(Æ*xÔZDwÆPZë�„â“èo�áï�X

çÜ+ )©gW!��ÁÔZ6s6002Y(~ZDwƉ©gW!�~ ]Îf^Ù…mçmç ¼:)´)†Zvq�~ÔZ1;†ZßZuÔÝx��gæZzgeZ˦†Z�(Æ*x,·Zzg

),·kK��áùK‰�XZy'ÎV~ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÆQg�zÝ~´)Ƽ�),·èo�áùƒDgì�X ]Îf^Ön^l

Ò^ ),·èo�gcăñ¸X),�A:6891Y 9 5891Y~ZDwÆ32(Zϧb'×h21),·èVÅ�gcÄÅ,Æa - Ôm81 ]Îf^Ön^io]�h

82(X - 9891YÔm72 - 7891Y ]Îf^Ön^io]�hÒ1inà‰^Ù �&ÀŸ/õ GG:eZË™'³gz~*¸&�;ÇVÐZDwÆ)æÍyèoÃ�™ÆZq*

ù·�áù™ä»³xKƒñ¸XZ,Vä�å:LLgZ¶Z�zs̽ã7ä�zœLmÔnóó( ÔmL ]�^…mäÚÓ^ing]ÎfÙ èo6�Zq*ù”î0kK%A™g;ìXóó)�âp:

Z\kìz{22Bâga8002YÃZÙw™‰ZzgZy»tµ/$k0î GIE0�g{ŠX

![4:x�~£?Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ËÂ[»5Ô4ZzgóDz+Æ‚BÃð*Zec‚t7WcX

ÅóDz+�gZqd¢zg]$2g!¹ìX Development ZzgeZËfÆ£á

![5:ºt�~ù´Zk Stray Reflections (g¿~WðÔZ% è ‰ùúVÅ)šFçzZŸ†(Z�á®

²á~&!gZŸ¯VÔp=VZzg5FKzDz+Æ‚B�ìXikÃZec~Zyƒ»f™ÔZLû6™�cŠìX

91�âp

Page 19: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

![6:�ª]Æù´)2002Y( Úr^Ö‹ô]Îf^Ù Zk²á~�áù”{6zWQ�a»%û�ªCù·

�ªCeÅZqZzgš~ìT»f™ÔZLû6HYg;ìXZϧbâIÆ�zi’^ÞnÌô )5891Y(»Y{ ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜÞ�nà )7791Y(Zzg Îf^ÙÒ1aÜ‘Ën† ùúVZ

Æ‚.Zec)1002Y(~�áï7ƒeåÔikÃZ�á®~�zâVùúV» ]Îf^Ù

E™{Ì�áïHŠìXÆ´z{ÔZk²á~Zg‚bzZZ~�ªCp}�áù Úr^Ö‹ô]Îf^Ù

ƒñ�Xc��Z¤V6F•gZ]Zzg¼�ª]‰W\áVÆfg)©¬x6Wñ�XZkâqÅ’k,ÔZDwÅ,ZzgZyÅ„ÃKÆa{mZÌgB�ÔZka�ª�ZDw6ïZzgQy»‹cC_·Ô$2gÂzÔìX

![7:ZDwÅ%û�gÏÂÁÆ$g@îEE0ñeÆ*³Zsy i^…mîaß‚ Zke~ZqZë�gcÄZDwÐ�[

ZzgˆZiZVå°ÅìÔX»Z)àf™![7~HYg;ìXZkÅ,>Zy)ZDwZ»�òуg ]Îf^Ön^lViË`nÜæirˆmä LL@gõy:P¥%]óó�!gZ¶ÅÂ[

ÿ5002Yþ(~7ňìXP™{*y~$g@îEE0ñe*³Zsy»f™åÔpl¬Ð

z„ ˆZiZV$g@î EE0ñeÔåßg]~�ø[ƒŠXZke~ZkZec»uZr³m�ohâZi{V)ciðÔIZS(äÎcX$g@î EE0ñe)å(»t*c[Z/�á{�ã™rÅ!ìÔZÏÐZ.�{HŠìX~Zy�zâV|Z]»]¦ZgƒVX

'×hÅ¢zg]ìZzgë%æFNZy�� è ¨ù¦ZDwÅ%û�gÏÂ1V6ïwÆ>ZD1]ÔL:LÔË:Ëñµ6cË�Æa„�ÔZkZë»x

ŧsázƒVÐXT�zxÆ�âd~gZ¶ä²nHå�:

1DLL£?ZDw6ïZqzWñçqìXTg!Ñ~�¼¹ŠìZkÅ

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^02

Page 20: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

(óóz LL w�PZ�ágZ]ÅìZzgz{Ì�áh*åXóó)m'|ì(Î;Ègzbì�91Ô02'k¬ F 2DLLgZ¶Z�zsÆatZ�k)�

ZDwÅX!VŶy�„Ŷz{áyZ-!VÉ$2g¾gì áÈ(óóiDz LL �Xóó)m:

W`â'kˆ=ZLqgz!ÑÒ*]~Ëp~Å¢zg]Ck7ƒCXßg�qÑ]'ŒÛZgZzg$2gìXZ¤pÄZDwƉ*Ñ+)ZzgZy~ZDwZ»�ò0Îyуg77ì(ÃÒ™D��*Zec�áù™Dz‰ÜQÅ¥xZÝo

¯ÄZDwäT°)ÝxZZec3791Y(Ãã� è �g„™àYNp9*Ñ+¯cÔZk~XZÝoŶy�„'ÎV¬Å¶Ô9Z[Ì$2gñ���XZkÐ

è ÃZDwÆÃgÏZzgQg�z¯x~Z[Ì}:}ÃðZ(£x‚tWY@ì�ï ès'×hZzg�g|ÃgÏZzgQg�z¯xÆóZexVÅ¢zg]»Z�k@i{™@ìX

ikÃZeczÂ"67HYg;ìXÃUã~ÔZkñµ6Q~}}FZçň�Zzgnz�}PZŸ±ÌX

â�Å¢zg] è |Âtì�ikÃÂ[Ɖ{W`ÿ92‚wˆþZiuCkƒCìXZk!]»‡bƒäÆ!z���»gÔSîï»gÃ@�ÄWyZLñçqÐ:æENH}gxecÔZzg‡gMÃñçq6@i{F+¥â]zî]ÐWÇ{

è gecX‰z�{ÐZ[÷}aZ(e7Oç~t»xwÆ>zZ|ì�z{:ÜsZkïÃWÐ(JNÐÉgZ¶ è ZD1]Æ4�™@ƒVXZy

ÅikÃ*Óx»zlÃÔ}ic�{4Zzg'F£g6Z�x5k™äÅÃÒ™,ÐX

ikÃZecÅ»g~Æe~$4è MG¹Ð�z2VZzg³mzV»]¦ZgƒV2Väz»¯»‰!VZzgñVŧsÂz�ÑðZzg‰än¬zÈd�ÛZë

�ÛZ¹ ™ÆZk»xÃW‚y¯cXZy~»[gæ�{V%jxÔohâZi{VÔ6zWd

12�âp

Page 21: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZzgeZËGZº�gZã�áï�X·�á@ðäZk£áÃ(~'g]ÐìiHXX Wy~6zVÅ»g~~æ�ÅàðZzgÂ[»Z�ágtÌ»gH �á¤�³m‡Ìú�Z£ä

$4è MGZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÆ]»g6�ZiZy»Ì3k¦ZgƒVXt»xZyƬzyS®�Ûc è Z»�ò»[·¢/™rÔ*ò è Æ%Z�x5kƒ*e:åX!<m*ò

Zp=X ÉÏî Š �Z*w™rZzg’)Ïî0Ã{:XzËZg<Z−+;×

[email protected] 12Bm0102Y

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^22

Page 22: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�âp)T�zx(

ZDw»ikËt�y0891Y~%AHŠåXZhJð'kˆ9BâÞ è £?2891YÃZkÅZ�ᮿ~MðX91Ô02'ÎV~LLøVÆnй‚0ã!îEM[

ìóóZzg‡šZD1]ZLgZ5ŹÏ2Bð™[ìÔZkÆ!z��Zk‹bÅ(g»�Ziñ��ìX è ZÃ�eZzgZkÅZ�á®

QZzgó è ZDwÆK~Tã�~b)¡ è gZ¶äikËb~£?Dz+(6izg�cåÔZk²á~ZD1Cï»gzVż:¼ÂzZk§sKzwƒð

ìX)t�úò7�tÂz¡gZ¶Å"»³ìX(ZzgZÄ~ùúVƼ� Ò×n^l ä'ÎV~´)ZDwÆQg�zZzgÃgÏ

áy‚tMñXZôm~ZzgQg�z�ƹÐ6ù´%AƒñÔPùúVÅóDz+Ì¿~MðZzg‰ùúVÆ´z{Ô‚—,¬]ÆÍ*ÍVZecÌ

�VZyƒ»-Y{e7ìX)t»xZϧbÆZqZzg DDDD �áùƒñ�ó£á»ñçqì(Xu�„Zk²á~ƒäzZáPúcVZzgZë»ñVÔ2

ñ��{ßg�qwÆ!g}~Ô![zZgPZ�ág}Zzg¥%]7ÅYg„�:²á :¯xZDwÅZ�á®ÆK~Zk Ê^…‰oÒ¡ÝÒ1ÚrÛçÂ1 ]ö…�æ]æ… 1Ô2X

ÅZq(~Zë7gÄtì�12BZ6s8891YÃ)ZDwÅ�Î,'Ï6(»8gZVZlÅgzЯxZDwÆLL£tZ�á®ôpóóÅ0È~»ƒˆÂ¼�*Ñ+ä

ZzgQg�zÆZÄ~ù´�áù™*Ñzq™�bXgC)“ÅzzÐ Ò×n^l Qg�ztù´×ZgiZV76�ø[ƒäÑX¯xZDwÅzWFZ�á®Æ$©�î EG0ÃÐ

32�âp

Page 23: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

tZqplMÒZ%å1Zkßg�qw»ZqtUÌ‚tMc�‰)f)�Zg Âe^Þ- *Ñ+ä¯xZDw~ðâã’d]™eZBXZq*ÑäÂ(Z0eJcX

�âpZhZ�cÔ¯xZDwÅFK$weZàÔZ�zZgÅuÈ~»™�~ÔÑ6zZðÅZ•t » �…]]Îf^Ön^io]�hÒ1inà Ðvs™�cX),Æa�&ÀŸ/õ GG: Ò×n^l]ö…�æ �x»¼z

:m43Ô53(X ‰^Ù

Zk²á~¯xZDwÆTŠg°�áùƒñÔZy~ÐZDwZ»�ò0ÎyQzZ5Ålzg è »»gZzg�áù™�{à])=$g@î

EE0Z»�ò(ÃëZzg4ìYèZk~¡½ÃÒňìX@qwZk~QÅÜsZqt»DƒeìX�75B37ÅMy~S~LL�ÛZtZ0óóÆO}LL�ÛZtMöóó�g„ìX�gZÝtt�ÝxZZecÅìX$g@îEE0Z»�òÅZ�á®�zx)4991Y(6LLúZòZecóóZzgLLZÝoÐ0uÆLLZÖp�g`�XZ�á®Îx)5991Y(~̸ßg]'ŒÛZgì1Xgx)7991Y(ÐLLúZòZecóóZzgLLZÝoÐ0uóóÆZÖpvs™�b‰�Ô@ë�75B37Åt$2gñ��ìX$g@î

EE0Z»�ò»ªSàZec)&e~GZec»*xÌ�cŠì(ƒÐ¬�áùHŠåX

Z»�òÅ&Z§bÅZ�áÈ¿~MN:1DúZòZec4991YÔ5991YÔ7991YZzg0002Y2DSà)e~G(Zec0991Y3D4e~GZec4991YZyZ�áoVÆ_54èEGE~¼"‡°ÏZzgZ{îìZzg¬x‡g~6ZY@ìXZy

ÆZ’Zð,]~F!gp´VÅI),Æa�&ÀŸ/õ GG:gZ¶»*yLL¯xZDwi‚æmà!ivÏnÐ]æ… ÔуgÔZDw�2991YÔ2�!: ‰n^…å ÅDz+óó6Z+gZuóó,·

Zigæ�{VÔ��9991Y(X¾qwZyÐVZ�áoV~0991Y»SàZec …æ]mkg~ .e@Zzg�h{idìXgæ�{VÆ–w:LLZkÆ,]ÆjZÙÔZ+É»ƒóóX Zzgg8Mö~Ð'×+��¼�kÆaÂCkƒ@ì��M\VÅgzÝ(|

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^42

Page 24: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

g¶äÅìZzgg3zplú7åEMQËwfzZ3gZ£Å»g™�{ àk $g@îEE0Z»�òÅæï

ìX¯xZDw»Z(�h{idZecL�áù7ƒZXDz+ÆK~ZqplMÒÆM¸i~àâ]Zzg�v�Ñ]Åz2V» ]…ÚÇ^áur^‡ Zzg e^Ùqf†mØ !]tì�

¯xÅz{ZÝßg] è Z‹Zn!]tì�$g@îEE0Z»�ò~ÔFK è ZŸ†™�cŠìÔ1‡.Þ

bw7ƒm�p�|]´)ä‡ìŶX¸�Zka�$g@îEE0Z»�òÅ»g~~ÝxZ

Zec7Ãg;ÔT~«!g��ZDwÃLLg!È]óóÆ��™äÅ$®Z(gňX$g@î

EE0Z»�ò~ZqZzg¶Z�ágbÅìXZ¤pCcŠì�Z�ágbZzgjZÙÃZqx¢Åßg]�~ˆì1@qwt¢�áù7ƒðX)Z�áùƒÏÔAÌ

ÐÝZ�ágbZzgjZÙŃ$ËìX( Ò×n^l ZkZµ¢ÅZÃ�ez{:ƒÏ�Zzg •†hÒ×nÜ »¯×ëìÔZ� e^Ùqf†mØ Zzg e^Þ-�…] $g@î

EE0Z»�ò~ZKû*³Ð!ÑFìX ï ×£~Â"K‰�XZkÅÅê L ]…ÚÇ^áur^‡

Æe~GZzg Ò×n^l Æ�z)wZzg�h{iR~ZŸ†ƒ@XÃgÏ Ò×n^l 7Vƒ@Â4e~GZexVÅÂ"ZkZyÆ*ñgæoZ÷�ÅìXtQ|�Â"uZuZkZãìZzg'x)@�÷Ô0ÎyZzg¸g](Æ9ÃgχgMÆa*ââkZzgZbìZzgQW~2™@ìXZkÂx~êMzZi,7�Zzgc}czsz!wZzgzZÌczsz!wÅ&gzZ7g¿ˆÔTÅzzÐÜsczsMzZi,g{ˆ�X)'×h,Æa�&ÀŸ/õ GG:$g@î

EE0Z»�ò6»[gæ�{V»*yZzgZk6gZ¶»Z+gZuÔ»ƒÐ Ò×n^l]ö…�æ "!!Ñ(X$g@î EE0Z»�òZK‰ñVÆ!z��¡QÆÒpÐ

xZzgZEyj¯ìXZ¤p!iZg~¯xZDwÆâq´q¶VZzgZ�áoVŽâgì1LL�Z‹Zs™¢ec�ZDwù¼â+Æ!z��ZyƯx»Ãð

óZecZ[J%A7ƒ0cìóóX)gæ�{V(:Zk²á~ZDwÆèVÆFù´|�Ô ÚÓ^ingÒ1ÚrÛçÂ1 3D

%û:·�ÛhZ/)™ZcÔ3891Y(c ]Îf^ÙVq`^á�m,† �:ñÑ*gZáZ�Æ*xèoZÆ' ‘vnËä Zzg �^�]Îf^Ù %û:·†ZvŒÛ7)уgÔ6891Y(T~ ]Îf^Ùeß^Ý�^�

3791Y~,·èoÃ�™ÆZ¹Ziuâ%AHŠìXpV6)Zzg‰)

52�âp

Page 25: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

,·(èo‰Zô[Å»zØVЂtMñ�XƒÐZëZŸ†ZqÂeZËGZº�gZãäZzg�zuZU�%äHXðkRZZzw*†Æ*xÔZDwÆðZzgZôm~èoÔðâ�·Zâyƒ1ƒxÅAs~¸q�gZã™r(~

]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6 »zlzœÐQg�zF3ZzgjZÙÆ‚Bæzy™Æ‚tÑñ�X)T�zxÔ9991Y(a�O~·@Æ*x62Qg�z+ZqZôm~=72),·èoZDw»ZqZëfí{ÔZyÆ7DU�%äZLZ*Z}Qg�zÆ£á)4891Y(Æ

Æ*xÐ�áù ÚÓjçe^l]Îf^Ùeß^Ý2ç�â†pÚvÛ‚uŠnà fg)¢HXZ[tfí{ƒŠì)уgÔ8991Y(ÿ1ù·Üs02èV6�ìÔ7îsâ�áï7K

‰þXèo6czïÆe~eZËÝx@fzZ3g™rÔeZË™'³gz~Ô] eZËd�ÛZ¹ÔeZËZÜtZWÔeZËZºg×ãÔâ7ZºÔ¾wZ£œjZzgeZËz©‚

z){Æ£Ñ]ZzgÂÁZÌgB�X�©gM!�~ZzgNy�{VÆ*xèo6]Îf^ÙÒo cä¹îw5Zzg6Ð6ï]‚tMñ)jZßVÆa�&ÀŸ/õ GG:

ZiidZûYÔZDwZ»�ò0ÎyуgÔ7991Y( ]ö…�æÞ%†

è¹ZDwÆK~ZqplMÒZ%tì�¯xZDwÆ'@ÔèoZDwÅZzwÅóDz+Åì ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä óDz+6{àÂz�~ˆìXeZËd�ÛZ¹ä

)tZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÐkd�áùƒÇ(X'×h'MVZ*…ZD1]Æøfsó£Ñ]Å~Ìèo6Æ»xƒZì:

Ô3991YÔZi†Zv�á{;× ÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ùeß^Ýì^áÞn^‡]Ö‚màì^7ViÃ×nÏ^læuç]�o 1DÔ7991YZi·œ&;ÿsi~þ ViÃ×nÏ^læuç]�o ]Îf^Ùq`^á�m,† 2D

8991YZiidZûY Eì_ç½Ii†ingæiv�näD ]Þç]…]Îf^Ù 3DZy£ßVÃDz+èoÆK~Zh7gÄŒÛZg�cYYìX

ÅZqYìDz+Å?m7Å Ò×n^lÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ù gZ¶Z�zsä6791Y~Ôm62(XQikËb)0891YÔ2891Y(~(g²nHå�èo ì_ç½]Îf^Ù ¶)

ÃÆ‚B%A è ZDw»txZ�yfí{à]kKZDwÅ~ic�{ÂzZzg�¢ïGOGzæzyKYä»Z`ìZzgZkK~PˆzmÌ7Å�)m172@672(XF

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^62

Page 26: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

eg Ò×n^lÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ù 'kˆ¦¡@'ãäZk»x»ÚZZVcÔZzgZ[ZyÅ%û]Îf^ÙV2ß‚Þò1 ¢zV~�áùƒ_ìX)�~¢6eZËd�ÛZ¹»û{�!

”]Æ‚BèoZDwÅóDz+Å¢zg]»Z�k�Ñ@ìX Úf^u&

:6zW·G�äZDwÅZôm~�ÅÂF+ ÚŠjÏØÞ%†pi’^ÞnÌ 4DÃ'ÎVŜƈZq‡.Þg— (Reconstruction) Â[ªZôm~h]

£g6%AHì)6891Y(XQÅ¡ÔjZßVÅ�lzoÔZ½‚]Å�ÔZÃgÅÃлx1ìÔ è CóZzgjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]Æ»x~Z,VäÜ�h{gm~Zzg�‰Üz+œz»zlZDwÆËZzgQÅDz+67ňXtZq£g~zVàóZec

Ò^ 6891Y ìÔ&ZD1]ÆDz´»ñV~¶ÈgZ{¯cYYì)-Y{�&ÀŸ/õ GG:m32@72(X ]Îf^Ön^io]�h(

ÆZÝ!iðO�}Å!icÄeZËGZº�¨Zã Development ZDwÆó£áäÅìX)Z,VäZk£áÅZqåÜâÞ3891Y~º[-ãzg;уgÅ�zu~¬@ZDw»ôkÆñµ6eZËYzhZDw™rÆfg)ZDwñi*уgÃ�~

¶(XèÃg{ZzA!iðO�}~ÔˆZiZVZDwäPp´VXZzg£áÅZ�á®Æñµ6ZkƼ{vs™�bXeZË�gZãäZkQÅFZçZzg÷zÃ]6Zq

T�zx9991Y(X ]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6 §qÝ*y~gzÝeZàìX)�&ÀŸ/õ GG:Bedil in the Light of ZqZzgZhDz+ÔZDwÆZqâ�gcÄZôm~*y

Åßg]~‚tMð)6891Y(XeZËd�ÛZ¹äZDwñi*ÐZk) Bergson

,·£á»�„â“!iðO�{�l™Æ�¢ïGOGLÃÐZÐ7JÔQQÃQg�zF3ÔÆ*xÐ�áù Ú_^ÖÃäÿen‚Ù(e†+Š^7ÒoÞ¿†Ún6 jZÙZzgZq¬Ó:lóÆ‚B

Æ*xÐZqîs The Problem of Time in Muslim Philosophy ™�cX´)ä*y�åÔZkÆnzxQ»ÜsZq„zgt�ø[ƒZÔZÐÌ�ÛZ¹™rä

{m�42(X ‰n^…å F3ZzgÂí]Æ‚B7891Y~�áùHX)ZDwÅñú�{"LL@gõ¦sóóÆ�zZ1Z[»z�{™'³gz~Ã�ø[ƒZÔ

Æ*xЉjZÙÆ‚B%A™Æ5891Y~�áùHX i^…mîôi’çÍ &Z,Vä

72�âp

Page 27: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Þ,^…�^lô]Îf^Ù :ZDwÆ)æzy�0gzV»Zqù· ÚjˆÑÞ%†pÚrÛçÂ1 5D)%ûidZûY(3991Y~�áùƒZXZDwÆ�~fí}ÅóDz+Æe~

+Ëj^…]Îf^ÙV ZqZhZzg»x[ÃÒZºZûYÆZ*…ZD1]Æó£á>Zy)6991Y(~ÃMCìX�vùúV6ÌZÏZ0Zi~ïÅ ÚjàÒ^ivÏnÏoÚ_^ÖÃä

¢zg]ìX:ZDwÆLL�ª]óóZyÆ�¦QÆfs~MD Ú×Ëç¾^lÒ1ÚrÛçÂ1 6D

�XZk²á~ZDw6‰ÎZ¤Â1V~ZyÆ�ª]6�{™ñZ��ƒ™‚tMcìXg‚bzZZ~ÌpV�ªCp}ZzgZÚz-�áùƒDgìXZ,

Æ*xÐ%AHå ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜÞ�nà �ªCp}»Zq�{ù·™'³gz~ä)5891Y(X�ª]ÆóZzg‹cC_¬ÅZqÃÒ¤@ZÑsäZ*…

)3991Y(Åßg]~Åì1t Ú×Ëç¾^l]Îf^ÙVivÏnÐæirˆmä Æó£á>Zyñçq7g~§bZyŤÄ~7MeX�ª]6ïÅ¢zg]@qw!¹ìX

:eZËo�ZºäZkñçq6¼'×h ]Îf^ÙÒoÚ†ifä�…‰oÒj^en6 7D¥â]�ÛZëÅ�ZzgZq*y~gZ¶Å�ÛZë™�{¥â]6‰Z‹ZŸ]K¸

]Îf^Ù]mÔivÏnÏoÚ_^ÖÃä( ÔуgÔZ6s3891YXt*yZyÆù·p}: Ú^åÞç )уgÔ8891Y~Ì�áïìX(gZ¶ä�Z6ZLzŸ�*y:LLZDwÅ%û�gÏ

уgÔZ~3891Y(~¢zg~Âí]Zzg¥%]7XX·a Ú^åÞç ÂÁóó)¡Úä a�O~ä4991Y~�gÏÂ1VÆ‹b6Z*…»ó£!%AHÔ>Zy:

X ]Îf^ÙÒoÚ†ifäÞ’^eoÒjgV]mÔirˆmä

DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDZDw6ïZqzWñçqìXTg!Ñ~�¼¹ŠÔZkÅw� è £?

PZ�ágZ]ÅìZzgz{Ì�áh*åXZD1]Æikc�~�7găðìÔ)id ]Îf^ÙÒo]ö…�æÞ%† ZkÐ�pgpzZá‡gMÃ'×h¥â]ZzgjZßVÆa

RTUMðÒ^ Ô QTUMðÒ^]Îf^Ön^io]�h ZûYÔуg7991Y(Æ´z{gZ¶Å‰@c]:Æ´{�Úe454è XGGX ]Îf^Ön^io]�hÒ1inà‰^Ù Zzg ]Îf^Ön^ioq^ñˆc Ô ]Îf^Ön^io]�h

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^82

Page 28: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

уgÔ ( e†Ò^lô]Îf^Ù ÅZ�á®óó) Ò×n^l '×h'MVeZË·gcnÆ*yLLZDwÆQg�zÃgÏÔ ‰n^…å ZDw»Z�á�£góó) è 3891YÔm742@352(ZzggZ¶ÆZq*y:LL£?

уgXZDw�2991Y(»_·ÌƃÇXgZ¶Z�zsÆatZ�k)�F'|ì(Î;ygzbì�91Ô02'k¬

áyZDwÅX!VŶy�„ŶÔz{áyZ[ÌZ-!VÉ$2g¾gì�X

Zk�zgZy~Z·C�ÝxZZecÅPZq'×hZÝo÷}D~MNXÆ Ò×n^lÊ^…‰o ÅZÝoÆaLL¥%]óó)m345(~�6�&ÀŸ/õ GGX Ò×n^l]ö…�æ

K~PVB5±ƒV:9 ß S �zg)zZîÔg}( �g 6 321

)ttTZzwЬMg„ìX(7 &4øFEI 2 215¡òz!mhò ¡ñz!mhñ 3 309

)rqZec(Æ�âd)>Zy:LLZnZgóó(~HxYzhZDw Ò×n^l]ö…�æ

™räCcì�Â"»My~%³Zzg¡¯xÅLLƒÐÌ2wóóñÑ*$Å~P�NLL�VóóQ�Ô}: Ò×n^l]ö…�æ LLgÉðóó~Z�x0ðXZkÆ!z��

)m671(»Zq^qì: e^Þ-�…]

¾~f}K~ìÑZ�èZiÚ_^Ög LL¾~óóÂ"Åtì) X $™rë�:LL¾}f}Kóó�g„ì

X Ôm522(1�ÝxZZecÅ6zspZã~Z,Vät�g47Å e^Þ-�…]

)m59(»tq: e^Ùqf†mØGƵZ[Ð$™*î EE0@g§]

TZzwÐZϧb¾g;ìX$™r�ÛâD�:LLÆóó»AÅtì

92�âp

Page 29: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ôm911(16zspZã~Z,VäZktÅo7ÅX Ú_^Öge^Ùqf†mØ ))m02(»tq: e^Ùqf†mØ

™�}ZÐZ[e0ŸgzV~ÃÈTZzwÐZϧb¾g;ìX$™rÆ4�qLLÅóóÂ"Åtì

�ÝxZ~Z,VäZÐ�g„7HX Ò×n^l Ôm03(1 Ú_^Öge^Ùqf†mØ ))m421(~Zq^qì: ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡�áhZi− ;k5é GXGV'pg~

Ƭ�Zecÿ3291YþÐZϧb¾g;ìX$ ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ tq™r��:LL ;k5é GXGy»Aäß�ìX�V²;k5é XGVóóƒ*ec�ÃÚy»&B©ýEO

Ô ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ Ú_^Ög ìX ;k5é GXGyÔyZ‚y»´‘ìÔZÐ−ÐÃðo97óóX)~Z,VättÌ�g„7ÅX Ò×n^lÊ^…‰o m032Ô132(1

Z,¼�Zñg@qwïÔ�XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

=Z‹Zs™*ec�TZzw~íÐPÃl�Vui�ƒNX‰ZÝoˆZiZV�gcăNXikÃÔT�zx~Z+!VÅoÅÃÒňìX‰ZëZñgÅoz¥ô�3456ÅYg„ìXZkÆ!z��ÔeìZ[ÌÔ‰ZÝo!¹ƒVX‡gMÐZùkì�¶y�„™ÆNy�ÛâNX

gZ¶ÃZL»ñVÆ*ÓxZzg*³ƒä»åZ�kg;ìZzgt»zlÌZkX ]Ö�ÃoÚßoæ]�iÛ^ÝÚà]Ö×#ä Z‹ZsÆ‚B7ì�:»§�*£Óx:™�DDDDD

g<Z−+;לg£Qg�z 41�Ñð0002Y

-ãzg;Zzg@»ÒÔуg

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^03

Page 30: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

w½W¸i)�âpÔTZÍw(

Qg�zZ�[~ÔLLZD1]óóÅZ�b×5ìX´)ZDwÆÄ~Zzg�~ùÔZyÅ,ZzgÎZöÐ0ÂÁÔZyÆ„~z/Zg»ÔZyÆ(ÏzèIZzg�:

Ä Ãc]ÆózW~_¬ZzgZyÅÄz�ÆÂ#z=m�-V6FÂÁÔZN!�z�Ô©�g‚bzZZÆZDw�'tƒLLZD1]óóÆi%}~Ñg�D�X

ZkzWZzg$43ðGEOqfí}Ã�zzZã�V~�HYYì:Äz�X è ZDwÅ£? 1D

ZDwÆ!g}~ÎZ¤ÔóÔW~Zzg=mÃz£Ñ]X 2DLLZD1]óó~ZÍwZ™Åwã�~Zzg¸yZ™ÅâÎUâ~ìXUâ~

âÎÅ�k,"uz�[�ZzgZyÅlZggziZ‚ÛzVìÔ²ZDwÅZK�kzV�vÔZDw»QAZzg Äz�Ô!Öº (~ZŸ†e7XQy»¯Ä Works by Iqbal)

6¼ìÔLLZD1]óóÆã�~â~Æîg6!¹gìÇXikãá~ÔLLZD1]óóÆZÏã�~â~ª´)ZDwÅÄz�»óZzg

Åã�6º[-ãzg;äZkñçq (Synopsis) Â#_·7HŠìXT{ÆD�ñzZãHŠ ™ é� »g»ç 6ïÅZYi]�~¶ÔQk~£áÅâÎZzguz�

Â[WÌÅYñÏÔ è ZDw6¨ è å�:LLtY{óÔW~ZzgÂ#�ÇX£?1ZDwÅ�á²~ZzgZ°g6WÔ£áÆ�Z]}~�áï7óóDDDOçZ-uz�ÆZ0ggT�ñÔZk£á~:

]Ä~Zzg�~ùúVÆ!g}~ã�~¥â]�ÛZëň�ÔªCÙ : ZÍw

13w½M¸i

Page 31: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Z�á®Zzg è ZÍwÅ@gõ è ù´»¿:©ÔZkÅFKz»g~ÔÂ"zS®ÔTˆÅ é� �k̳ è â�Z�áoVÅ,X'×h'WV�àâ]Zzg�0gzVÅ@gõ

ìXLLZD1]óóÆYzV~ZkâÎÅÃð%1oó»zlñ��7XZk£á~��ë«!g©¬x6Wñ�ÔZzgFZñgÔ�LLt;}p}óóÅwZ(g™`ÔZyÅo�ìX

QÆó_¬~ZùúVÅZÍAZ�áoVÆ�Ô�zu}Zzg : �zxZÃg~¼*z@íÅ, è �}ZexV~ÅYäzZàFZçÔ÷zÃ]Ô2FK

Zg»ÃK~ZkÐæ�AÏX 6 7ňìXQyìZDwÆ�zg/�zgfÂ"zZ5Æ‚B‚B Q6SàÂz�ï�ñÔCÙù´ÅZݹ è¡: Îx

ÃÆ!ÔZDwÆÄ~ è Æ� "54èGEGE 'ç Qy¥Ã]Ŷy��Ì™�~ˆìÔ��

ñZ�ZsÌgzZ7Ô è z�~Q~gZ{0‰�XgZ¶Æ4�qZDwÆZÝQÐucógz��-Zg¼óó»u7 W YèQÐZ�ZsÆ�ÔÅYäzZàïzW:LL@

™}ÏX:ZDwÅ��kzVÆ!g}~¼�ßxVÚ�ZgZzgÜ�gÜÆ Xgx

:LL0�ëóóÅwZ(g™�Ô}t�:Islam as a Moral and Political ¡6Zq/ZãÃóó8�0î E

E0Z¥|>Zy è LLI )Z³(ìX The Muslim Community »Qg�zFÀì'qÑè8�0î E

E0èÃg{»ÄZy Ideal

Qg�z ÄÆ!3¸ç EOÅw~óóZq è LL»[g‚ª–[å»Z�!û{óócLLgÎwåÔ® )[(ìÔ�´)ZDwÐ�gpZ„™Æ�ZcŠÔqÑèZÝ*yZôm~~åX *y

Our Prophet's Criticism of Contemporary Arabian Poetry Zk»ÄZyå:Islam and ~�áù”{*y»ÄZy Sociological Review ßyÆC: )`(

XPolitical Thought in Islam åÔqÑè*y»ÄZyå: Khilafat

ãá~ZkâÎż�ß�VÅo™D�ñZkãuJÔZDwÅ è ik9�kzV»9(tzòtzZãHŠìX

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^23

Page 32: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwźt�kzVÅ�lz[Zzg¦zFKÆË~Z[Jµn�z :Q�gXgL(}Qg�zZzgZôm~ù´æÍyKY`�XZkÆ!z��ZDwż�

ÅÃzVÐZzÍg�ZzgËù´~�áï:�ÃX´z{Zi, "54èGEGE 'ç ,·�k,

ãá~¼�)æÍyZzg),·ZÃgÔèo è ��k,@qw6�ÒØ~�ÔikZDwÅ�ÅY+ è Zzgºt�kzVŶy��™�~ˆìXZk§bt_Å�î0Äz�

'×hZqŠxìXÔ ]Îf^Ù è Þç]�… Ô …Êjä è ‰†æ� Ô ]Îf^Ù è e^În^l tzŸs¢zg~ì�ázu¯xÆùúV)

(ÃZk_¬~�áï7HŠXZk{Å@g]ZÌ ]Îf^Ù è ]‘¡u^l Ô ]Îf^Ù è if†Ò^lÐZïg7Ô1´)ZDwäZÐZLxQÐ{g`™�cåXZ%�Åßg]

ZìXx�~£?ÐsÃÔZDwÅi0Ï~QyÆËù�î0�ÅzZ�á®Åâ"7WðÔÍcZ¹ZK�ÆZN[»ñµ75XZ¤t%³7 � FK

�ÃÌZN[~�áï: W@ÔÂeå�z{ázuàâ]ŧbZK�óg�á�ZDwÆËÌ{ÃLLázuóóŒÛZg�be è ™DÔ1Z(7�ZXZ[øg}a�

7ÔOç�~WUgTŠgÌ�ø[�nÔ/Óxz¾wÔikcWñ�Xûzl»Zqxz{LL�gc©óóÌ�ÔX»×E™{ZZ1Z[~ZLû è ik

6�¬YYìX@ëPZ)àZ�ág}�VÌ*oƒ:�VÐ:»ZÝZzgå The Muslim Community ZDwÆZq),·Zzg*c[*y )1(

QÔ&Z[Jnzx¦gHY@åX´)ZDwÆ0kÌZkÅÜôp:¶Xt1191Y»8�0î E

E0Z¥|ìX)e:3�&À�/õ GG(»�âp�ŠX)e:2( µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ (XÅã�6 Notes z{Zôm~Z�ágZ]) )2(

]ö…�æÒç…Œ( �Z£¼qÆZ·ZuÐÔ´)ZDwÅ%ûZq�gÏÂ[: )3(Zk Ô ÔT»f™ZDwÆËE™}ÔÎZöcÂÒ]~7M µ^Þ3çm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1

»¬gsÔWy~![~�áïìX)e:1( X é� Ä~ùúVZzg�~£?ÅZÍAZ�áoV»ÔZkãuJîç )4(

Å« Reconstruction Zzg µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ Ô �…] è e^Þ- Ô e1ìç�p è …Úç‡ Ô ìç�p è ]‰†]… )5(

33w½M¸i

Page 33: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zç Z�áoVÆ�Ô�zu}Zzg�ßgÂV~�}ZexVÆQ~ÅYäzZàF~ñ��ìÔ ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ÆK~Zq*ÓxÏ, ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ z÷zÃ]Å,X

ÅFZçŶy��«!gÅYg�ìX Reconstruction Zzg �…] è e^Þ- ( µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ 1ZDwÃZÝZzgåF^~ÑäÅDZÛÆK~«ó è Zºnt£!ÔÄz�

»zlìÔTÐLLZD1]óóÅZq�FZ‚k½�YäŵÅY$ËìXZk£áÅæ�ÐZDwÆåfíÒÄz�ÃïÅgzÝ~7g~¡zYöÆ‚B

ÍyHYnÇZzgZDw»åZzg£g~Q‚tWYäÐZD1CïzW æ z é�%AÅ��g„™äZzg9F}òZ~™ä~{§pZ{æ�ïnÏX

Zk£áÅ»g~z�Z*f~eZËz©ŒÛ7ÅôZã~�ðXQyÅóNgÏä¹ÐÂZzgiÔ)bÃW‚y¯cX°Z"t»xZyÅgZ{úðZzg@NzÂz�Ð0��ÃàXZDà)gÍVaZ£eZg%jxÔ�·ZÑs%jxÔ±2k*i~%jxÔeZË·�Zv,ðÔ·�ZvŒÛ7Ô"Z£ÑzZãZzg�*iZ£™xyä¼�!S�5‡ÂV~Ô2&g=%Zv�Ë¥â]�ÛZëXXZϧbHxeZËZ�gZ£œjÔeZËpZz·i™cÔ»[ÀpZzÔeZ˱¥Z°ÝÔeZËWë[ZûÔeZËZâg‡hÔeZËGZº�gZãZzgeZË·gcn™xyäÌÆtg}«KX�ðZÖpz�gZ]Å�Hx·»ò™rÆfg)e�ðXZ%Zi~'Z�gxeZËpgægç~™r»!U¬zyqÝg;X

ÃzßZi)~´)ZDwñi*ÔZDwZ»�òÑ$k~Ôº[-ãzg; è �ÛZbÑ$k~Ô?zg-ãzg;Ñ$k~Zzgg^a΂ÌWs0ÎyÑ$k~Æ´z{Ñ�gZzg

ZgZy: Ñ�gÅZ»ÒÑ$k-VÐæ�BX{mîg6ZÍwZ™&Z�ZgzVÆf)� ÛzÈ™rZzgÕgç~™rä�ÛZc�Ñ:¬zy &�ZdÅ7™rÔeZË·dZ−+

HX)gÍZgxa@+™rZzg'Z�gx‡èZahŒÛÙä�*�g¶VÐZ.�}ÅZYi]�~X�Zx[SîeZË¥Z−+FÔÃgztZºÎÔ�Z(g

Ã~iØQVðXWy~%µ~ �á™Ô™'³gz~ÔZºgZ�Zzg�ZDÃgztä�¶ºtZñgÅZ�x��~a�O~·Z'Z�™rÔÃgztZW™rÔ�Zv�á{ÔÝxÑÔ

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^43

Page 34: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

‚]aZzg�ÛsÇä;BJcX��vZô[Ì'ZÓgZ„c!ßZôZk»xÅ�~çzyU"�ñX

Zk£áÅS®.e¾²á~å�ðXZkK~eZ]ËZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÿeZËz©ŒÛ7þÅSàÂzÆ‚B‚BÔZ»�òÆÿ*òS®þ�Ûc�Z*w™rZzg×eZsx6öÆ=xV·©[™rZzgìig·Z'Z�™rÅ)¦Ã{m�4ìX~ZyƒZô[ZzgZ�ZgzV»!îGL�wÐ3k¦Zg�VXZvQ¹bZ}í�}X

÷}�Z�Z%jx.e(ÑZzg�#èGOEZy¸XZyÅ.z�Æ‚B‚BÔ~ZyÅgzq+ÐÌo�ZXZkÂ[»Z[Q-Æ*xìX}Z

gØ™}X è Q¹¾&

g<Z−+;×£Qg�z 4BâÞ2891Y

-ãzg;Zzg@»ÒÑ�g

è Hx±%g¶»]tzZZìXÂ[ÿTZÍwþÅ%ãZzgÁz+ÔZÍwÆplâö)c�Z?(Å q^æm‚Þ^Úä Z1Z[ZyÆ�k™�{�X

¶y��ÌQ,VäÅXc�Z?%jxÆZqë))gvZzgplâö™r(X »[ÁeZvzZgOäZkŤ&Åì)1‚¦ÃgztZºÎ

53w½M¸i

Page 35: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

´â]zgñi)ÑzZã( Speeches Speeches, Writings and Statements of Iqbal

)ZÍw( Speeches Speeches and Statements of Iqbal

)%û:�áCÔ4491Y()�zx( Speeches Speeches and Statements of Iqbal

)%û:�áCÔ8491Y()¤gt( Speeches Speeches and Statements of Iqbal

)%û:Z}Wg¤gt(Thoughts Thoughts and Reflections of Iqbal

Letters to Atiya Iqbal's Letters to Attiya Begum

Letters Letters and Writings of Iqbal

Development The Development of Metaphysics in Persia

Reconstruction The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam

]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ ô ÚÓ^ing ZDw¯x{y·*iZ−+{V%jx è kK�ÝxZZhÜÑ�grq

Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing à�kKZDw)¡@'ã(

áZ�Ã]¡ÕäGOÎ ÿþßZi) ñZ� (Matter)

w° èÜ Transliteration

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^63

Page 36: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

![:1

Qg�z¯xÆù´

�ý�ý�ý�

73Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 37: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Qg�z~ÄÍð ( Z³ )

W¸izø»]Z·tp&ì�Qy» è ´)ZDwÆW!zZ]Z�ò~'aÔptŒ

©'6.3ð XEVÅZk�ácÐMìÔTäòÆCÙ�w³m!��á{Îyi+ �MZ°$+²s%�á{)1241YD9641Y(Æ�zg~ÃgÏ-ZzgZsòExŧsáz

°!z ƒðXŠ*'agzZc]ÐZkLLZ�ZsóóÅzzÐò~'6.3ð XEVäZ¹ZigZÓC1 $LL4zóó)ª�ƒÐ¬7−Ñzq™}(»Ä�cX

eÔ4z{0Zy~ƒÐ¬ZsxÑñXQ,Vä!!¾Z−+Æ7ÒªîG0 !!ßÁz�gz7 L C2 ZgZ�]~�Z4ƒ™Lz�gz7Z(gÅZzgòÆ�gxY~ÑgƒñX

Zzggzq+»tg8ÔZDwƼ�Z]Z�Æ;Vñ��åXQyÆZq7åEOÔ�·gpyDwÆzZ−�âg·n${ð GOsÐÎ�gn Z C3 äÃgϦs6¼�ÂÁ@;XX

:9191Y(Ð x ¸Xz{WzZyÑp)I|Z]Ôº[(ÆZq)gv‡èÎyú�)C4 ÅgÃãÂzZ−äZ¹Ì‡è™rг™Z�cX è ³¸XZDwÍ

z{ZZz‡]~|]Âx BZzgZz1ÐZDwÃåZqÍ:o]g„X ßZ−+Zz1Zzg|]&CåEO�Z³UãÆ£'6q¢ƒDgìX

5±Ù: 1D:m67 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù )Z³(

:m01Ô432 ]�en^lôÊ^…‰oÚn6aß‚æ¨7Ò^u’ä )[(ÔZDw�ÔZÍwÔZÆ'3791Y:m4 ‘vnËä 2D

ÿZÍwþm01 ‡Þ‚å…æ� :m323XfZ! Ò�Ûn† ô i^…mî]Îç]Ý 3DÔуgÔZ6s5691Y:m44 �ñnßä 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^83

Page 38: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¦sZzggzq+»ÔZyÆZˆ‚]"ÐŒÛRmìÔOçZDwƈ‚] ZzgZyÅgzq+ZzgLÔZDwÅfZ]~Zd_!]Zzg"Z W!zZ]Z�»${ð GOs

Åßg]~oƒZX�âg·ä!‡°{½70ð¶Ô1ßBZzgfÅÄäZyÅË)±÷ŒÐ ´ é� ZV è ~Zq…gZzg°aZ™�~¶X²!ÔÃgÏZzg�´ExÆÃåZDwÌQyÆ ZyÅ�~�z4¶X�âg·Qg�zZzgÃgÏÅÂÁ7|fÔ¯Ä

C1 _·gLXÄÐZ¹¡~gɶZzgLrgp�ÌĶî M1™D¸X ikZDwñ¸„ÐÄz�á²~Ð8o9¶XZyÅñizV8Æ!g}~

�«·ÅZâgZz~��z{gZ]Æz‰Ü!iZgÐàx¢zõ GOÑ™y~¢Ð‹c™D¸XZÒZz‡]¢~î GO7_7_ZK§sÐÌÃðL{)^q(Zk~a

Xìwgì ï� �ïXZy»tk0Z(p[ßg]Zzg%æFNZWƒ@�ƒßv"‚��Z�C2 �Qkz‰ÜQyÅ/o�k!g{‚w¶X

ZDwƱ¸Æ�z„±i�á{»Òyì�Zq!gëä½Fyh}ÂZDwäZkpÙ~&ëGNÈ~ŶX±i�á{äqgzfs0õ^ÜK�:

�w~Wð�iÆÔ½F0á¦ÑÑÆKÑwÔCÙ}ÔtÐáZy~Z,���PzVÆQhäzZá

}� Z[tìqw�W@�}Ô0îV3C 0îVÆnÔ:¥xÔi~ì�7

t!ÇñizV^´�ÔZ¹LL&ëGNÈ~óó7ŒÛZg�cYYXQkiâä~ZDwÔ

�ZÚiZ£»Òyì�zZ−ÒZDwÅzÃ]6Q,Vä�zBV~�k!g{ÄÈ™Zñ 1DÔ�zx:m612(X …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† ZzgÃð^qÌziyÐ{g`:åX)

:m01 ]Îf^Ù�…æáôì^Þä :m93X)[( ]Îf^Ù ô …æ]m^l )Z³( 2Dm86Ô : )2k*i~(TZÍw �]Þ^c…]‡ ''×h�&À�/õ GG: ÔZDw�7791YÔ�2:m11 ]Öˆen† 3D

*i~™räÜsZqÄ�cìÔz{-Vì:Y~Wð�iÆÔ½F0áÃð»ÑÔÃðZéìÔ�ztÐá

93Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 39: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�mç]áô ��÷ŒÃ 1C ˆè{~�áï¸XZyƼ��á¤�gZz~ ´)÷ŒÆI"uI¸XQg�zÔÃgÏÔ Î’^ñ‚ô†Êo Zzg ‰Óß‚…Þ^ÚäÞ¿^Úo Ô Ú%ßçpÚçŸÞ^…æÝ Ô u^ÊÀ

²!Zzgº!ÆDÙZgzVÄQyÆâ¿i!y¸X!]!]6Ä7"Ŭ�]¶XZyÆZ0Z¯Dgö~t!]Zë¶�²!7JDÂñçqÅo9ÐÃgÏZzgQg�z

ÆZÃg‹DXZL�á¤�zV~ZDw6QyÅ{m an†æ]…'�^å Z‚E{ÆZÃgZzgÂz¶X¢uÆZJyÆÂQy»9z‰Ü�á{™rÆ;V*g@ÔyYDƒñ

Ô� é�’ ¿t�÷ŒÅ,ÔZyÅÄZzgQyÐ ___ _¬ÆaÂÁáYDZDwÆZ�!ZzgÄ~fztÅ�zúÆa.eÆU"ƒZXZyÅ8ñizVÍðäÔ�Z’Z~Ôàx®7|™‹ä~gZÓZÖg0Cg„ÔZ[!‡°{ÄÍð»gZ3Z(gH

’ZðwÆ�âV~Q,V Z C2 OçZÌjw~ik½¸�Äz�á²~™äÑXC3 ä‰çßV6´)÷ŒÐZ&bàX

ÄÆ%æFNZuZgZzgë{¿Æ!g}~ZÃc]7K‰�XZDw èðßZ[¥xƒ@ìTä�á²Ã è „»ÃtŒÛ+ è ÅÄÍðÆK~Qk‰

LL”Z°Ýóó¹ìXZDwÆ!Åg~�á²~»z]ZãZzgZAòjZ!ã�~ZÌg�ìXQyÆ4�qéÈZÞZqW�ã¾ìTů6LL�á²Z:ËóógpzZÑZq

¿Äì66gƒ@ìXúZx~ZDwÅ=qzà]»(Z:Qy»Qg�z¯xå1ZyÅLL�á²Z:Ëóó

Qg�zÅÚÃgÏŧsic�{âbg„X2391YJÃgÏÆ0õùúVÆ£«~(�áùƒZåXŠgCîg6Qg�z¯xÆ�w�Z�ÇyÃDe �…] ô e^Þ- Qg�z»ÜsZqù·)

aZƒðXZQyйŠ�:LLÃgÏ~rOÔ1Qg�z»ÌÂW\6håóó'ÂXIt comes to me in Persian

C4 Q,VäZK6g~ªCÙ™Dƒñ¹:

:m62Ô55Ô06 ]Îf^Ù ô …æ]m^l 1D:m01 �…] ô e^Þ- �âp 2D:m31 ]Îf^Ù ô …æ]m^l 3D

Ôm54 ]Îf^ÙÒo�í’nk]æ…�^†p gzZe6zWqZ£{V: D4

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^04

Page 40: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

XZk � Zq%æFNZuZgªÅ¤Ä~ Ck™D�z{p� 4zÁÄÆñµ6z{»Z0Zi{ZyƉÒ*]ÐÎcYYì:

Zí6ÄìŪ¤g~ƒCìÂí6¶¯ñZzge|eyñÄ )1(QFä”�Zzg~Z¹‚Ü™©ƒVX!g;Z(ƒZ�~äZyZÃg~ÃðFç

™*e„Ôp÷~FçZÝZzgZ’Zð*iw”{ÄÆ£«~!LjÃWðZzg~1C äÄÃ�V»ÂV'ŒÛZgg3X

¨gz„Æfg)KZzg þ Äà ÿ Ä~Š"Æ�zgZy~Ô~äZÒZÐ )2(¤Ä~hÅÃÒÅìÔp�„~ZKª»‹tÑzq™@ƒVÔz{gzZãZzg

C2 ZAx»Ÿ{ƒY@ìX��éÈZÞÔ &åGO ZDw64zÁÄÐ0Zk§bż�gzZc]zzZu]¸

Ä»ZëF+&?çOuìX è ZDwÆ;VðZ£¼q C3 ´)ZDwäZq!gZ£¼q0�áйå:LL?Zzg÷~�á²~ë/ƒóóX

äZC‚ÁzÑ�]2131|Ccì�{~“4981D5981YÆ_.ìXZkZ±gÐpu†ZØ�g»tÒyic�{9¥x Ô W¸iŒÛZg�bec 4981YÃZDwÅ�á²~»‚Á

C4 ñizVi!yÐåÎX ƒ@ì�ZÌjw~7_¸�Ä4981Y~¢u»ZJy�}™z{jwÐgÁƒ`¸XÍc1981Yc2981Y

W¸iŒÛZg�b9FƒÇX4981Y~ÔQyƯx~ZâéW_¶ ÃZyÅÄÍð»‚Át1 C5 3981Y~ƒZ »W¸i ��é� �z{Z�!g‚ßV~àѸX�ZrÐZDwÆM’

:m542 ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù 1DÔZDw�0791YÔm441D541 Ú^åôÞç gzZe·�+@|: 2D

:m791 ìç7e`^ 3Dm01 : �…] è e^Þ- �âp 4D

gZ¶äZ’Z~ZLeZËfÆ£á~�å:LLÃðZ+Þ�]$4lç GO7Tů6î 5D“ÑzqƒZXZ%QyÅ3981YÅZqçw),·: � é� $›4è

GGOEƒn��ZrÐZDw»M’

:m341D441(~zZãîg6�Zr»g8úcVìX …Êjä è ‰†æ� ��ÔâÞ3981YfZ!: ‡e^á)�WÒ{Ô6( ZkiâäÅZqZzgçw»t\:

14Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 41: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

²znZzgEx6gqÝ™`Ô è g;XZDwD ŸZq�z'kÐic�{Yg~7»� é�’ k§bQyÐ Z C1 Oç�Zrä¹¢¶î M�c�x~Z&bÅRö¹ÁìX

ZDw Z‚ÛZðÔ ®Åtj, Ÿ»ƒŠÔQkz‰Üz{ZÚzf~ik½¸X�ZrZ,Z*£�â&�á²ÆaZq)©à!]¶ÔTäZ¹ZL®6ic�{ZO�õX

5981Y~уgV™ÔZDwÍg»Ò~!Z}~�Z4ƒñX¬¼²�Z0gzy¸K�}gìÔ6981Y~»ÒÆÃZegy)qwZDw(ƒ9Æ#{�1~QJ

9981YJÔZQ,VäZ*Z},HÔD}gìXƒ9»t&‚!ªxÔ Zzg WñQyÅi0Ï~{mZÌg�ìXZy»#{Ô¹¢Ä~zZ�!fztgpzZá¥Å

Ä»�{fzt è ÂzZzg>WgZð»%œ0ŠXZDwƉ�z„Ô�ᲃäÆ‚B×ZDw Ìgn¸XÝx�.8ÃZDwÅfZ]~LLw»¸óóÃWcZzgQ,Vä¯Ä

2C EV KÆZg»~ƒ9Å"$¹Ò¨é GE:Ä~zZ�! æzôp™*Ñzq™�cXZDwÆèZ¾7HYYXPâ{ÆZ0gz{‰�z2VÆZÜZg6ÔуgÅZ�!EVZzg ÃZ0Zi Ã

x²zV~ÑqƒäÑÔ˜V‰*ñgÄZZzgZ�[�z„Zô[¦ƒD¸X)�*�(

¤xë6Lƒ@ì�z{"ÔZDw|‹�ZrÆZÃg‹�ï�

ÆZ‹Zs(êCÙ™@ � é� gZ„ZWZ])ZzgZqZ±gÐQyÆ’ ÌZDw6�ZrÆ'ZÓìóóX)m:6(1ˆ~gZ¶Ãu†ZØ�gÅZqÞ�]ïˆXz{ZL*yLLZDwóó),·:

#2091Y(~��:LLZJyZÚ÷0k™äƈZDwä»[âZ[ Þ¿† è ì‚Þ-¹Z<âZ[%iZ{V™r�Zr��~ÔZ*�—gÂx�ÁºZv�ÔÐ&g=âÂ"

Ï‚wZDwÅi0Ï �ZrÐZ&bh»ŸÑzqƒZÔS ÅIZð'T‚w|‹ � é�’: ]Îf^Ùq^�æ+†ôaß‚pÞ0]� ~ZqZzgzZ§7Wc'ªQyÅ�á�~ƒóóX)fZ!:

m041(XZDwäZÚ÷»ZJy3981Y~0kHZzgZÏ'kQyÅ�á�~ƒðXZk§b�Zr»‚w)3981Y(îîg6³ƒY@ìX � é�Ð’

:m11 �…] ô e^Þ- �âp 1DÔZÆ'7591YX ]Îf^Ù ,Æa5±Ù:Ýx�.8»*y:C 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^24

Page 42: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwуgWñÂQÏ'k�¼qZÉåO+·äLLQg�z)Äx²{óóÅã�g¿X�cƒñZzgZKçw6 C1 5981Y~Â{Ô)xÆ�zu}x²}~ZDw«!gÑq

�Z›K0ðXZ¤pZkz‰ÜJÔpVçBìÆÔQyÆZ0gZK�á²Z:&6VÃ^ÐуgWäƈËêx²}~tZyÅ � 6ZO�aZƒ[åX@ë(w

k~%iZZg”ÍgÇãZ,Z*£®äQyÆZkÄÃ"uuZ;: Z C2 ZÍAÑ•¶XñC�Æ�áÈ™aä8èFNEa¢}�¸%}²¾ZgwÆ

Zkj,Z‚ÛZðÐZDwÔÄÍð~Zzgic�{%æFNZO�ƒ‰XZkiâä~уgÅZëF+LLQg�z)Äx²{óóÆ´z{‰gKZ�̇ì

ZDwZy  �X�¼qZ−+·ÆZÙw)6981Y(6�zu~Z�ic�{u¤xƒIZIVÆx²zV~ÑqƒäÑXZy~Áz�Zq΂¥¦ƒYDXt

yêx²zVÃZDwÅÄÍð~¹ Z C3 ƒ½cCZzg!fzt|Z]ƒD¸XZ��óóÆx²zVÃtS¤qÝì�Zy~Ô8981Y è �4ìXZy~ÐLLZ³

ƵnÔZñç¬]zÄZ*]6ÄÍð»ŸYg~ƒZZzgZDwʼn>}ø!Ô�g›GÔñ•�gcÔZyZzg)ÄŠg]z){LLx²ÒZ��óó„ÆikZWèIXZy

è x²zV~ZDwÆ´z{‰Z,ÄZÌÑqƒDÔ�Ëiâä~Z³º[ è º[Æx²zV~Ñqƒ™¼�àâ]7|`¸Xx²ÒZ��6Z³

ÆZWZ]»Z0Zi{Zk!]ÐÌÎcYYì�2091Y~Z³Å¶‹U6Æñµ6C4 º[Ðic�{!gzÞóó™�¶»³xªCÙHŠX è ZÐLL%jxZ³

)m:691(~ZÐZL“zÑ�])4981Y(»zZ§ŒÛZg�cì ìç7e`^ �Z£¼qä 1D7691Y:m01(X �801Ôm ÞÏç� )1QyÅZqZzgÔˆÅÔ’kÐZkÅF�hƒCì)�&À�/õ GG:

Ãì�:LLZDw¬U6981YÆËx²}~ÑqƒñóóX è ·†ZvŒÛ7»tÒyû 2DÔZÆ'4591YÔm04(6�Qz6f™ƒZÔZDwä«%û�c5981Y~!iZg ]Îf^Ù )C

�801Ôm7691YÔm01(X ÞÏç� ¦VÆ�zu}LLQg�z)xx²{óó~Ñ•Å):m161 ]Îf^Ù è …æ]m^l 3D

ÔZÆ'5591Y:m47D08 ]Îf^Ù C 4D

34Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 43: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zk�zg~уgÅÄ~EV~*ò@©~Zzg%iZZg”ÍgÇãÆ�á¤�zVZ��Æx²zV~ÌZkÆ è Zzg$åOZjVÆ�gxyçÜZ:îYg~¶XZ³

ÆjZáÐZDwÔ~Å � é�’ Z¤p%iZ�ZrÐM C1 bCÙ}�Ú~WD¸X@ëQ,VätÈ™: C2 Ú��Ðic�{ŒÛd¸X

ZDw~ÐÔ:�àÐì¾n¾wÆ è i³ è ëÂZ§�n

p�Ã�zâV¤zƒVÅâuÑ7дu{g3ZzgtZq(Ãw¶XZ¤z{Zkî~�áïƒYD©eZzg��eÅ—ãõfWgZð~Ô}å�w~ZyÆ

X( æ� Ä~Zk*]ÃüLLQg�z)Äx²{ó󻟻ƒZÂ�×i�+Å�~CÙgzi�áxü�

!fztZôƒ„zÃÔZ�!zÄZZzgZ‚E{zf¦ƒäÑXZDwåÐZkâqÅWÖÆ�−Z�{ÔZkaz{!‡°ÏÆ‚B!iZg¦VÅZyBV~ÑqƒDXZyEV~�Z}Z−+Ô�×i�+Ôu†ZØ�gÔuÞ[Z−+ÔpZzg°

jÔpZz™*jÔpZzZ÷jÔÑÂxZ−+Ô�†[�+Ôñß~Z£�+ÔñÑ*@ ±ZŒgZ−+Ô{yZ£ †ZÔ¯âg~Ôñß~·ŒYßO~Ô?·†ZvIéÔM

ƒD¸X�Z}Z−+ Ò·�+¯tÔñÑ*ZûZgzkZzg±·�á{zV�áï {VÔ

,Æa5±Ù: 1D)уgÆx²}ZzgZDw(m�zxÔC ·†ZvŒÛ7»*y:LL§‹ZDwÅË”{šcVóó

ZÆ'5591Y:m27D79 ]Îf^Ùуg~Ô%iZZg”ÍgÇãÔ�{È��Æu¤z{¸X¹Y@ì�уgWä6ZDwÃZg”Ð 2D

ƒZÔ1¼�âVˆ�ZrÆ!‡°{�á¤�ƒ‰XÑ!u~gZxÔ†ZØ�guzg~Ô·†ZvŒÛ7 � é�’ÅÃðçÜÞ�]�ø[ � é�’ Z�[ÌZÏß.»Dg�X1Zg”Ð è v¸gð Zzg‰�

7XeZËz©ŒÛ7äZkZ6×cƈt³Z~Hì��ZrÐZ&bhÅÅ� é�’ 0È~4981Y~ªÑƒgWäÐI„ÔYCg„¶ZkaуgV™Zg”ÍgÇãÐ

ZDw�ÔZ6s …]æp „7X)LLzÑ�‹ZDwÆeÅZq@G~�?óó: !]�g4791Y:m48(

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^44

Page 44: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

.e!fztZyZzg�¬Ý¸X�×i�+p��ᲸZzgZKD�z4ZzgZ�[âZi~ÅZ�á®'ŒÛZgg¿Xu†ZØ�gplfztZ�dÔˆ �ç…ôÚv�† Æ:ÔQ,Vä

Æfg)Q,VäQg�zi!yzZ�[Æa*‡.Þ�ÛZñl}â]Z�x�,X Úíˆá ~»àxº!FÀ¹=wƒZXj'Z�gZyÆLÑ` ÚŠ‚ùŒôu^Öo uÞ[Z−+»

)zZµDÆcV¸(cVÔ!iZg¦V(~²d�gZiJdWÖ[g�XzÑeЉ†+„�kô]ÖË^Á ß~Z£�+zVä ñ C1 qƒñX zZ36ZDwÌF'kJZy~Ñ

ÌèX{yZ£@{VÔуgÅZ�!�* ]Îf^Ù ZzgˆZiZVÔZDwÅ�á²~6«Â[YßO~Ô ÆækgìXñß~·Œ �f^hô]ö…�æ ZzgˆZiZV �ç…ôÚv�† ÅZë,¸X

~Zzg?·†ZvIéZL�zgÆÝfZzg‡.ÞZ‚E{~иX g ñÑ*†ZÔ¯â?™rÆ*ÂZV�~LLDza»ZÚfí{å�Ãi}~�gcȃäÅéZy

5Æ ÃgÏÆ´z{²znÔ0ù$ZùZzgS è ~ÔLL¸Z° g Ñ*†ZÔ¯â ñ C2 6™�tWCìóóXá÷6Fg‚ßVÆ'¸X�áxÅ<V~ZyÆ#¥ic�{FZDwƒDZzg

y5V~ÑqP™{!ÑZô[Æ´z{Ô Z C3 Äz�á²~ÆZ�!õÍ6W™DóóXÒpwÆâ´¸XZDwÆfz¾ÄÅ è ÌdzZ�!Z±gЇ.Þ !¹|Z]

P™{!ÑZô[Æ!g} X F�~ZyZ�!gVÆZWZ]ÃÃZ0Zi7HYY~�Z£¼q���Zkiâä~ZDwZC¯x¬Zy)gÍVËDZzgQZÐ

�g�óóÜczs>ÔZ³ è ÏóóZzgLL¦k ¬x~7_XLL*Èî0dóóÔLLhÁ è Ë>C4 ×eZsxÆ5V~‹äЬÔZ-ßÍVÆ‚t7SIX

9981Y~Z*Z}»ZJy0k™ÆZDwä(i0ÏÃí!�¹Zzgƒ9ghZ·tÐZ-�âV)Z6s~(QyÆÀZ*�6zWWg&Óå EHäZzg@»Ò è �cXŒ

gig уgƇì£x6±»£eÑXPgzi31B#ÃZÏ»Ò~.e²æ

Ô†g~9691Y:m54 ]Îf^Ù…mçmç 1D��zxÔ�c7791Y:m855 ZDw ÞÏç� 2D

Ô�801Ôm7691Y:m21 ÞÏç� 3D:m991D002 ìç7e`^ 4D

54Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 45: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ƒŠX 6Qy»7ÒªîG0Zx[ŠgCîg6ZzgÌzW Zk%µ C1 ÅwÐZDw»½gƒŠXZDwÆX�z2V»¬f™W[ìÔZyÆ´z{Ò8[¬ÝÔ*�g»Ãgz~ZzgÒ

uZ`Z−+ÌZyÆ7ÒªîG0Zx[~ZÌgn¸XÎZògZx¾BлÒÆiâä„ÐQyÅ�z4¶XZDwäQyЩ]7SZzgˆ~ZÏzZWÐy~Zzgy*ã�V»_·HX

ZyÅÄÍðäÔ�ƒ9~�z2VÅ)xWgZÇVZzg!iZg¦VÅÄ~EV1Zq�á²Åw Jöz�¶ÔZ[ZLZÖgÆa6Q¬Å§sŠx(JñX

9981YÐ5091YJi k~czs7ƒñ¸X Å5éEO ÐZkz‰ÜJZDwÔúZxZXZÍw:Z³ ƒC¬ˆ 'ÎV~ÔZDwÅ�á²~�zzZTVÐÔúZxÆ‚t�gs

X Úíˆá ×eZsxÆ‚Ñ:HX�zx:g‚!�,œ~Å«aåð~Z³×eZsxуgÆZnÐQ,Vä¼�

>7³1Z’Z~»g6�ZiZÈZ³ÌZyÅ�á²Z:wZzgZyÅ�á²~ÅŠgz~«!gZDw 2C ¸XZ³ÆGgð,‚Ñ:H)41�Ûzg~0091Y( WÇ{: 2ªÐ

äLL*Èî0dóó‹ðXœ§Z°ke÷2kZ£��~äZk»zlÃZyZÖp~uZ;:~äZy»âVÐZ/Zzg�ÛÆ%#/õIG•1T0ñÅÄW`G~WðZzg�ZW

C3 Zkä÷}�w6HÔz{ZkЬL:ƒZåXtzZ§ZDwÅo�à]Æa$©�î EG0W¸iU"ƒZXWg{F'ÎVJQ,Vä

Z³Æ‚Ñ:5V~ZKàâ]‹™úZxzpZmÐ"C{yZ`d0cXZkÅZq�zu}t�z{CÙ ßg]ÂtƒC¶�‚¥ÔZDwÅ>Í™�wÅw™P{�ïX

Æñµ6Ôàâ‹ZDwÆ,·¶VZzg),·ÝwäZVŠggxÆún.e H

Ôº[-ãzg;уgÔ�Ñð7791Y@ Journal of Research eZËÝx@fzZ3g: 1D†g~8791Y:m68D78

: ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 :m81(ZzgeZË·†Zv,ð) ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù †ZØ‚´) 2Dm32(ä�ì�LL*Èî0dóó9981YÆ‚Ñ:H~7Sˆ1t�g„7ìX

:m07 ]Îf^Ù]æ…]ÞrÛàuÛ^mk]‰¡Ý 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^64

Page 46: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

6�l§jÐ;ðV;BfXXZ»'ÐZDwÃZyƯx6�Z�BÔQy~e÷2kZ£ÔñÑ*qàÔñÑ*(ÔpZzŒÂòZzgu·fzZ3gZ{VÆ*xúcV�X32B�Ûzg~2091YÃœ§Z°kxVÂxZ−+ƒQgZzf~äZDwÃLLoZÈZYóó

VZ³Æ5VÆfg)ZDwÅà]»�Z]{zWƒ@ŠX - C1 ŒÛZg�cXZ³×eZsxуgÔº[Æ�âV»(ZzgçZ�Zg{åÔ®ZZkÆP

ÃgxÐgŠZzggzZî�á²~Æ'@¸òZzgçàâ]„7ÅYC�XZDwÌ�á²~ŧsâbzázƒD‰XQ,VäZ³Æ‚Ñ:5V~�> çZy~L*Èî0dó)0091Y(Ld»æ[hwÏÐó)1091Y(ÔLZsð»Ò»æ[ 7³

�g�ó)4091Y(L“{ó)1191Y( è ÍCÙ!gc�Ûc›Z#Öó)3091Y(L¦k è º[Ðó)2091Y(LZ'Zsxó)3291Y(¸òÔçZzgZsò gZ{ó)2291Y(Lƒ» è LÓz�á²ó)2191Y(Lå

ñç¬]Ð0�XZkâqÅÄóg~~ic�{FZ³Æ»çVZzgZDwÆç_!]zZˆ‚]Ã�4åXçwÅgŠ�á²~Ãí!�¶î M™Zq5gzlZ(g™*ÔZDw

¶X ÅZqZ¿�~»zlƬÑg} Úíˆá -VÂZDwż�çBÔZ¶gZ]zZZ~¾_�1

)Z6s1091Y(~LLø!óóÅZ�á®ÐLL6Z0ZiÅVZzgçßVÅZ�á®»Ÿø!óóÅZ�á®â&�á²ÅÄÍðÅ�á0Zg�U"ƒðXZôm~ LL C2 Yg~ƒŠóóX

½ÑzqƒZåÔZ[Íg»Ò~Zôm~Æ ÄzZ�[Æ_¬»ŸÔ�zgZÈZe¾6zWHgƒñÂZk_¬~zÝZzg¾aZƒZÔTäQyÅ�á²~6!±§

ìÑ]Zzg!±§®Ô�zâV§b�ZZWeZÑXZk�zgż�>Ë:Ëw~‰Å¹Ï �…] ô e^Þ- C3 f!ÄZ}�ÍÔÑ8SÔZ\ÍZzgz@Ã6z){Ðâpf�X

:m002 …æm‚]�‰j†âç]7‰^ŸÞäq׊ä]ÞrÛàuÛ^mk]‰¡Ý 1Dm9 Ô :`3 ]ö…�æ�]ñ†åÚÃ^…Íô]‰¡Únä 2D

ZDwÆfZCfíÒÃ~Ô�ˆ~Zsð»ÒуgÃv™�cŠÔzgeizgBÔ�ÍÔ 3DZÞ,œ~Æ 9 ÔZy~Ð � åé¤}z){ÆÄ~ùñ�� Zzg 'Z�)Ôh

ªkì��zgZȽzDgöÔtƒQyÆik_·gìƒVÐX è ,·�XŒÛ+

74Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 47: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¸V6ÔLLâpfóóÅÜZsñ��71ÀVÔZ7gzVZzgFZIÆ´z{ZLÐ zgeizgB Q|ƒ„zÒyÆÒpÐÌÔtZôm~�á²~ÐMW¥xƒC�X

ZDwÅZW5k~»Z0Zi{ZyÆZkZ‹ZsÐÎcYYì:þWordsworthÿ saved me from atheism in my student days.

1C

Æ Úíˆá z{ C2 ZÏabCÙ¡]ÃZDwÆ�z§ZÍwÅ�á²~~{mZÌqÝìX>óóÉ�¶ x�zZßV~иZzgQ,Väu†ZØ�gÐMLL6g8Å

Æ£œz'×Z`Æ7ÃZ¤pQ,Vä Úíˆá »z°{HåXf!Z�[Æ_¬Zzgf!ÄZÐZWZ]JwKÔ@ëæEÅgzbÔZDwÆ;Vå¸g„X

ÆaZDw µßräÿÊçŸ� Ò·�+¯tÔZDwƳm�z„¸Xz{ÌZLZ¶gÆ7ÒªîG0Z�á®~zÝ µßräÿÊçŸ� �z4Æ‚BÔ è Ð@i{¯xÅ�Ûâö™äÑXh

»ìw̯tÆf‚~ñ��ƒÇX‰�v6dÌ@i{¯xqÝ™äÆa~ Úíˆá Ã�áVƒñXZDwƒÅ�ÛâUVÅzЇܸÔ@ëQy»@i{¯x

~¯ÄZDwÆ‚BZÒ Úíˆá �áùƒ@åX » ~z»¯ µßräÿÊçŸ� ZÒz9ZzgäZDwÃZq]hÄÍÅ Úíˆá u†ZØ�gƬg°â^Ì�áïƒDXZk§b

º[Å]h�á²~Å’qÃÔ è wÐ�gs™Zä~¸W™�ZgZ�ZHX-VZ³ƒZÔYèàâ‹ZDwZL„~¾Zzg qÝ ZDwÅÄÍðÐÔZq4R6�Ûzr

º[ÅŠ*àâ]Ð×ic�{£g~ZzgY0Zg�X¾ è )1CŒÅ$zªZ³�zZx«ÅX ‹ Ãà w äZD x£ Z�! 0Æ Úíˆá qwZ³×eZsxÆúZònZzg

m5091Y~ZDwZd½Æa-g\−‰XÄÍðÆe~Qk�zg»ƒÐZëzZ§tì�u†ZØ�gÅÀ:Ã@VZzgWg&Óå EHÆ�ZøqZ:Ÿä

Zzg ™�,XZkiâä~-g\Åc sp C3 ZDwÃ6gH�z{F¿Ä»ZCLLZgZ�Òfóó:m45 Stray Reflections 1D

Þ¿Üô ¡]64ÅZqVwóó˜! : ×cÆa5±ƒ:eZËzikW¸»*yLLZDw 2D:m13D04 q‚m‚ÒoÒ†æ:n6

:m51 �…] ô e^Þ- �âp 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^84

Page 48: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zz[Ð�zegHX 6 �RzpDZŠZgÆ'Z{gZ„ZzgŒÛR_¬äZDwÃZqfZkZz[»ZëF+UÔQyÆx6*:ìÑ]~p~åXtp~LLf[Å]:

%ƒÈ5¶XçÑCZzg Å C1 ó i0ÏZzgxz±Åã�6kz]wÆÜsg›¿ódâjwÔ;àw'vÅ"ØWÖÔð Æ Ô‰` } -g8çÑ 6 ER6

X-g\ ZWZ]%AK ZDwÆ»zf‚6µ ä pZ&Zzg¾HÐdItÍZgZWeZÑXZk�zgÅ>®Z� � Æp[ßg]ŠgCoøäZyÅË6.epl

~ic�{7Ô1ªÄ-g\ÆZWZ]ÐZyV~ÔZDwÅËÆ®Z:Zzg�:¥cÅJVQ�X

8091Y~-g\ÐzZ36ÔP}Â�ÆÔZDwäуg~z»ªÑzqwÅ C2 ÅXZkzsйÁz‰ÜÇåXZ³ò~�*yƾwóR~

ÐÌZ¹¼�ÛZøZ�x�¶7D¸X@ëZyÅË6ªÄ-g\»g›¿ÔZÏ�zgZCZ[ZzgZˆµËðÅÝ] Z0gzã ~‚tWcZzgz{ËŠgZf�ÏÔwâVóÔ

Ä»øuU"ƒNXtZDwÅ, è Ð�zegƒñXtÝ]ÌZDwÆað»ZÚiå�ZyÅËänÃðt¥cZ(g7HXQy»{™z‰Ü"Ø�z2V

Æ‚B>WgZð~¬ƒ@Xic�{F>WgZðÉÐöOÑ`ÔZ0gzy¸K�gzZi{~ƒCÔTÑ`Å ÉÐö LO C3 ~ZDwÆZÒZx[ÑqƒDZzgZDwQyÐ�Z›¯xzßw™DX

Æx EVÆ´z{ZDwƼ��z„ÔQyÆkyzZµZ*gÔ6ÌWc™DX'Z´VÐZ¹{]�Ûâñßwƒ'1z{Z¹7gZ™äЇܸXZ%

ZsxÆ5V~ÄÍð»�ŸÔ-g\Yä6{ƒŠåÔ�z!g{Ñzq è Z³×eƒZZzgZ³ÆZnÐ1191Y~LL“{óóZzg2191Y~LLÓz�á²óó7SIX

Zk�zg~ÔZDwZLZx[~ƒÐic�{ñÑ*¤ZòÐ!5éGMWznƒñXÆ ë'×Z`zZµƒñ¸XZуgWDÂMZDw Z±gÐz{ZDwÆ ‰

:m24 µ^ÒŠj^áÒoÞ¿†m^ioeßn^�m6 eZËz©ŒÛ7: 1DZDw�Ô�zg¼ÔÑg{42:m991 ]�eo�Þn^ ò~�*y: è ZDwZzgZ³ 2D

Ô†g~9691Y:m84 ]Îf^Ù…mçmç pZz†Zß©: 3D

94Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 49: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

;Vªx™DX‘zgzi�zâV~dWgSÔÄ~gñizï]6cƒCÔZq�zu}ÆZÃg×zZÙ�ÅãK66ÇYDÔ!bÄÍðZzgI1VÅZyBV~ZDwZzg¤ZòFFgziçgTX¿t�¤ZòÅ,ZzgÄÌÔZDwÅÄ~ðZzgZy

]‰†]…ô Æ�á²Z:Zg»~ZÌgBìX¸z{iâ:åZz{ZKc�WgZÃgÏ£?Å@;zFK~'w¸XZk ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Zzg µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ìç�p(…Úç‡ôe1ìç�p(

iâä~ZDwä±Ñy0z~ÔñÑ*ÔZ°ÝÑzZãZzg†ZÓ]�gc!�~ÐÌpi!yzõzg}Å!gÃVZzgÄ~¨ZëÆe~z{Ô¤ZòÅgZñà H C1 tg{

C2 ic�{™TB¸XZ[ZDwÅ�á²~Zk%µJWâ¶�Z¹Ëj,Z‚ÛZðc�Z�zdÅ

ÅCÙÕÐ"*iƒ`¸X *xËg~ ¢zg]:¶XZq�á²ÅwÐz{à]zFßÐ7−½ãFu™`¸XÄ‹äÅ�ÛâöÀ˜Nw�ïXZk�zg~ÔQy

�á²~Ð è Æ;V(}ÂZFZzgöÆ‚BtZÖgMì�~�ᲃVZzg:=®Ãð�pìXz{èIZzgZܹ£œÃZÍAZÌ�¶ÑZzg�á²~Uâ~wZ(g™X‡gMÆìÑ]~Zz[aZ™*ÔZDwÅKÍð»ÑIZX׈Æ

ÒyŶ»“{HŠÔÂ�Ûâc: è �zg~ÔQyƯx~�á²Z:ÇZzgg#��x~�beLƒVÔz{Z[÷}a!ÇzZナìX~²!�á²~Ågzl6

C3 !Ç™s™sZzg¦S¦S!'¶î Mg;ƒVXSî/ Zg�cXZ[ZDwÆa ŒÛ C4 ÇÄÍðÃQ,VäZLaZqLLoóó

(Zø¿Äz{Îiz‚iÔz@[Ô�g�q~ZzgƒÐ(| ƒÐ ÆWy~'ÎV~Ô¼q: TÐZDw»�wz�ârÔM�zegg;X–w�Z£ ™z{_!îE0ZCZ[åÔ

ÔZÍw:,]5Ô68D79Ô101Ô301D901Ô721Ô632 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1DÚÓ^ingô ZDwp�ZkZ%Æ2s¸X¤ZòÐtgzVÆ!g}~-c5±Ù: 2D

:m17D18 ]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo:m67 ]Îf^ÙÒo�í’nk]æ…�^†p gzZeÝxgÎw$: 3D

~ì: ‡eç…ôÂrÜ 4D)m641( :|íÔZiZV%›�Ûz�„)m641( ÄzKn è �'ðo

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^05

Page 50: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�, ZyÆn}6ZÒ„zFœ�ÆWUgÃWDZzgLLÔZyWUg~Zk�g�z™[Å�~C1 Ì�3ð�¶Ð�Ôqz{ZLñz‚ÐZLë6V6ªCÙ:™*eT¸X

ZDwÆLL�âVÅŠóóZzgLLÒVÆ¢Zióóžnz¸eZÏZqb6%ÃiƒHYñÔ�QyÅ�á²~ÅZ‚k gé ¶�5±Æf~VÃQyZz[Z0ìÑ]Ðë

�X�z„Zx[Æ‚BÀWgZðZ[̃C¶ÔZyEV~Äz�á²~Æ´z{(ÏzçÑC)bikcWDZzgød:pl-Ṽ'1ZLzW Zzg dzZ�!

7ÒªîG0Zx[ÔZKÓxFà]z=qZzg)©à³]zZ™ZxÆ!z��ÔZqZˆµËð~t&éGMW ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ äQ¹å„ÔSî/ÆWy~'ÎV~Ô"ug3X

ZˆkÔÎizZCZ[ZzgZˆµËðÔZDwÆWy~ ç ic�{”]Æ‚Bñ��ìXt�zg~QyÅÄÍð»ZqZëøug;X

Zzg 6 Lèo~z{f Z C2 ZLë)zV~ZDwÃÔZºÆ§¯ZˆkäOWHX„~îg6ZºZ[W!�~Æ‚Bu�gzŒÛdzëW}ÃWD�XËZzgë)Æ‚B

uöÃ7WCXZ’Zð�zg~Zq¿²áÆ ZzgÃcC ZDwÅZ+„~q3aQ,VäZºÆQ|[»âÌHÔ1ZÐñizV:0™¢Fu™�cX@ëZDwÅ

qàÅ�g�q~ZzgÑe X �á²~ÔZº„Æ0g‹„»Zq¤{Zzg×rîìäÌZDwÃ!5éGMWH@ëqàÅZf�ÏZzgËŠgâ-ÏÆ'@ÔZDwÆ;VgYðL¸ìXZk§btI"Y:ƒÇ�f[ÆÜsZqµg›¿ZzgZsò¶‹U6ÅWgizÔi0ÏÆCÙ�zg~ÔZDwÅÄÍð»ƒÐ(Zøug„X

ÄÆø»]ZzgÄÍð»�:©ÔQz6ÅTg~ÒyHŠìÔZy èðø»]ZzgZk:©~ZDwÅ�á²~T§bZg»5kƒðÔZkÆË~Qg�z¯x

( ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ (ZzgZqÛÄ~ù·) Ò×nÜ ô •†h Ô e^Ùôqf†mØ Ô �…] ô e^Þ- Æ&å)QÆ è »gƒZXWÒ{,]~ZyQg�zùúVÅFKzDz+ÔS®zZ�á®Zzg¡

ZU�V»Y{1YñÇXÔ�801Ôm7691Y:m02 ÞÏç� 1D

(»»x inspiration eZËÝx@fzZ3g��:LLZº»¯x7g¶ÌZDwÆaø¿„) 2Dm7D85 V ]Òf†]æ…]Îf^Ù �êåXóó'×h,Æa5±Ù:

ðýýðýýð

15Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 51: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Qg�z¯xÆù´ ([)

�gZ è !8 /

Æfg) Úíˆá ,]~f™W[ì�Z³×eZsxÆ5VZzg *¸~#XZkÆË~�á@ÔZL 7g}'x ZDwÅ�á²Z:à]Ôpl10™

¯x»ìwaZƒZÔ1£¾ è ¼�Zô[ÃZ�á® C1 ZLîg6ÔZy»¯x¦™äÑXZqÂt� : kż�z�{� Z C2 Z�á®ÆçA~ZDw{™J$©�î EG0Ãgn¸X

–ÁZDw:LLßvˆgCZ¾ZnÃÅpgn�ZzgZk!]ÅÇ6zZ7™D�Äß�zu}t�´)ZDwZL¯xÅ(gZ�á®Ð¬Zk6ÃUã 3C Öìc9?óó

Sî Ô ¢zg~B¸X�}t�ZyÅ*gZz‡]»ZqZëfg=Â1VÅgZ¦å¯xÅZYi]7�~Y$˶X è kaCÙ�z)ÃZ�á® Z 4C Ô Wy~‚ßV~

5±Ù: 1DÔTZÍw:m5Ô7 e^În^lô]Îf^Ù )Z³(Ô�zx:m512 …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† )[()†ZßZug(:m07 ÞÏ�ô]Îf^Ù )`(

·�+¯tÃZq!g�:LLZ¤Ãð÷Z¯x÷~ZYi]Æ%Y9ÂZk6�úò™�cYñXóó 2D:m36(†ZØ‚´äšZYi]ZDwÅÄ�áùÅÂZ¹‡âãâF��cX ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ):m23D33('×h'WV�ZÚiZ£Æ�z„”t™rÃQg�z¯x»ù· m^…]áôÒ`à )

Ô�zx:m812(X …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† �áù™äÅZYi]7BX):m36 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 3D

71D6191YÐzÃ]JÔZDwÃ�ù¦WæãƒðÔZkÆ‹bÐ¥xƒ@ì�z»ªÆ 4DÔZy»ƒÐ(Zfg$œî G0WæãÂ1VÅgZ¦åXtg¶)D&76926gz9(z»ªÐWæãÅg¶ÆÛÐËŠgiZZìX,Æa5±Ù:(gú�»*yLL´)ZDw»

ZDw�ÔzZÍwÔZÆ'3791Y:m31@15(X ‘vnËä ÍØZgÒWæãóó:

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^25

Page 52: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¢zÑe−‰X 1 C1 ZÃg»ìw3091Y„ÐZyÆf‚~ñ��åÔ è FKÅFK …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p ZzgˆZiZV ]‰†]…ôìç�p zZ36Dg+Zzg‡âãxÁ~ÔQ

~zsgìXZk²á~Qg�z¯xÅZ�á®ÆaZDwÆZx[Zzg�á@»ZÜZgYg~g;X¾ëÆ*x7BZ6s0191YƯ[~��:

I have been receiving letters from various parts of the country to bring

out my poems in book form. C2

è ¯xÆe~i7gÄ:ƒmXtZ%ÌÔËuJÔ! è @ëZq²áJFK291Y~ZDw¤ÏÐQg�z¯xÅFKŧs 1 C3 @íƒZ�Qg�z¯xÅlZgÁ¶X

zg�Ûzg~4291Y~ Z C4 ázƒñX!iðO�}ÅDz+~a�O~·@ä¹;BJcXC5 !iðO�{»AÆjZá™�cŠX

Â[~F è ¯xÅÂ"Â�Ñð~åƒÔ1�âdÅÂ"ZzgS® èQ¬x6WcX�Vt è© C8 »ªZec �…] è e^Þ- à C7 !sy3Bm4291Y C6 ƒ‰X s wç M�

Æuzgt» �…] è e^Þ- ~Iqbal in Pictures zŸsoƒƒÏ�M±z©Z−+äXt Title page of First Edition of 'Bang-i-Dara' @�cìÔZkÆn�ì: �

uzgt�}gì� è !]�g„7ìXZkß.ÆZiZáÆaëTZÍw»@)�&À�/õ GGWÒ{�(X

ÔZÍw:m12 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1Dm86 :Letters to Atiya 2D

ÔZÍw:m12 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D:m921 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 4D:m94 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 5D

ƒèÃg:m05 6D: +�jä ]æ…]Ñô+Ü xVÂxZ−+Ã7™�{°6LL·ZDw3m4291Yóó�gì)fZ!: 7DÊÓ† m831(6zWWg&Óå EHÃ7™�{°6̸@gõ�g`ì)gzZe:Zu�ZgQ~�g:

%û¬Ýp0÷~Ôo+Ô©gW!�Ô7791YÔm66( ]Îf^Ù{Ô6( ZÍwóóÆZÖp�g`7ZkatªCÙ)�WÒ è ¬ZecÅ6.Ñí~LLZ�á® 8D

35Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 53: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

TZÍw»@ e^Þ-ô�…]

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^45

Page 54: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

èY 1C ÅDz+Æñµ6ÔZDwÆ0kZC7gZ¯xôpzñ��7å �…] ô e^Þ-gkgegÔQyÆa{™ÂåX,·¯xÆ´z{¹‚),·¯xÔQyÆ

ÅZ�á® �…] ô e^Þ- çZx[ÅÒçVÐæ�àˆX O C2 Zx[Zzg�á@Æ0kåX¾™W¶T~Qg�z¯x»5/z�áïåX ]Îf^٠Ьñß~Z£�+Å"

ZDwäZÐI7HOçZ£�+™räÂ[Ÿù™�~X4291Y~©gW!��áùÅXZkšZYi]Zzg)‡âãZ�á® Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù �ÁÐñß~†Z°iZtgZ”ä

Z�á®ÑÍ:ƒ@ è ÆÜs‡âãeg{�ðW‚y:¶Yè�Á~'¤â~‡âÈDC3 åX!syuZº©g~ƉÐÂ[Å�Ûz|Ô�ÁJöz�™�~ˆX

Å9>ZzgçBÔZ¶gZ]zg‚b~�áùƒ_�XVÆ �…] ô e^Þ-Z’ZðQÐ¥xƒ@ì�ZDwäFKÂ[Æz‰Ü{àFçz;лx1XF

091YÐ 1 C4 úVZzgZÃgÃ4¯cX¼�È{g`KZzg‰6ÈzV»ZŸ†HX~�áï7ÅXic�{FFçzZ&b8091YJƯx~ �…] è e^Þ- çw c ¬ÅÃðÄ

ňXZL�}�zgƯx~ZDwä×ÁFçÅìXFçzZ&b»tŸÅFKЬ„Ñzq™�cåXLL“{óó,·%[Zàуg �…] è e^Þ- Q,Vä

Æ°»QÔSkÄÆZÍAQÐZìXuzgt6zŸs�g`ì�t

)�*�(I^ ¬Zec»ì'Zk»»½Ôz‰ÜÆ‚B)ƒ[ìZzg!îGM™äÐ 7ƒ@�tÔ

Rose Brand - Manufactured by Allah Y@ìXZkÆZ0gzZRâgu~t„g]ÃWCì:XTZÍwÆÂÒCÃZÆa5±Ù:e�1 Diya and Sons, Lahore and Delhi

:m921 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù )Z³( 1D:m8 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ )[(

ÔTZÍw:m5 e^În^lô]Îf^Ù )Z³( 2DÔ�zx:m512 …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† )[(

,Æa5±Ù: 3D:m13D23 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù )Z³(

:m56D48 ÞÏ�ô]Îf^Ù Åu*“Zi†ZßZugÔ!: Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù )[(Zi·aZ/�’~X ]‘¡u^lô]Îf^Ù ×_¬Æa�&À�/õ GG: 4D

55Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 55: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

LL'ñßsÅÃUãóóƈY0ŠìXZk~�z&£â]Z,�Ô˜V%A™Dz‰ÜQFçÅXtƒFZçzZ&q]ÔZDwÆW~ �…] è e^Þ- ZDwä

C1 ÅgZzgZN!f‚6�Ѫ™C�XÒ×n^lô]Îf^Ù ¬ZecÆuzgt6LL]£tìhFÀôpóóÆZÖp�g`�X

Å �…] è e^Þ- )�Á(Æ¢{/õGE

GÆ:©~tZÖpZë�X�âpÔu†ZØ�gä�Yèzgt!]0191Y„ÐZy Z C2 �âpâ+ÆaÔZDwZ-ÃÐic�{ñizVB¸

}: Ô ~Â"cZ5ż�ZÝoñ��� èZÍw �á® Z C3 Æf‚~ñ��¶X9 ß S �'×g» '×g”î0 3 450ÆÔa 0c 8 87F~ ¾~ 3 221

TÇx T»x 7 131^›å Nò Ä~ 7 041

ÆÔa�wÂä c�wÂä 7 481WÍ WN 5 881WÍ WN 3 981i!V i!y 5 642�âÕZV!Ä �âÕZVcÄ 4 772

¬~YLÅ?mƒðXeZËfZ™@ä5291Y~ èâà �…] è e^Þ- �zu~!gÃu è %A™Dz‰ÜZDwäZL¯x~�Fçz;ÅìÔZkÆ7 �…] è e^Þ- 1D

†ZØ�gÅtgZ}XÐ@ì�:LL´)ä¸Å§bZ�á®ÆaZL¯x»ZN[ÔTZÍw:m7(X e^În^lô]Îf^Ù 7HåóóX)

:m74 2ß‚m^�m6(2ß‚iø$†]l gzZe¬Ô@Jß~: 2D¾HÆ*x7BZ6s0191YÆâ~ZkZ%ŧszZãZ�ág{MìX 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^65

Page 56: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»Z(„YL»ZgZ�{ �…] è e^Þ- »!3©øEGOIZec�áù™äƈ Æ^Ög è �mç]á 'ÞÐ

ªCÙHÔ1ZDw»fztÔ&ì6ŒÛ!y™äÆa»g:åÔZkat?mgzÑ:ZkÆQ~qgz C2X �z'kÔm6291Y~�zuZZec&„~�áùƒZ C1 WmX

fs£â]6FZçQ�:Z�á®�zx Z�á®ZÍw S �F~@gqgZÂV~lZ¸V' z×lZ¸V' g ë� F~Ì~Ô~ 4 76

pz;V"6�{' è Å5ÐöG ªtbz;V"6�{' 1 09K Z}˜VW!�ÔZ}uâ›)Ä Kè ZI è W{ÔZ}"3ïEGGNZ�Zxè<Ø 1 19

W{Ô{à�ZrÐ' ª{à�ZrÐ' 2 19�»' è e0�ßg]¤ ¬Ý»' è t‡�*ò 3 361

êj!D' êÎäÅD' 3 163pZË{' è« pZË{' è¬ 21 412

1¡]F~Z¢45å EGE{Zzg' 1¡]F~g+{Zzg' 01 472Â"�VÅÂV ¯x~m642ÅtÅZ&bƒìÔ!¹ÓxZݹ èQ

ñ���X'×h'WVqgzfs5™VÌgz5kƒ�:9 ß S �

¤ !}43ïEGG 3 66è‹ 9.š3ïGG 01 672

�ZZeceg‚wÆzMÐ0391Y~�áùƒZXZk!gZDwäQ~Ëp~Å¢zg]Ck7ÅÔÜs�âd~Ô´)÷ŒÆ!g}~Ôqd/õ IG~Zk

ÎxÆ è „g]»ZŸ†HŠì:LL52Bm9291YÃ|]»z™wƒŠìóóXZ�á®

:m4 ]Îf^Ù è ÚÓjçe^l 1DÂ[ЬԴ)ZDwÅZq¦kÌÎðˆìX¬ è ZkZec~�âdƈZzgQ 2D

ZecÆ'@ZkZec»»½¢oZzg0ZZgìXÂÒCÃZÆae�15±ÙX

75Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 57: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�zxÅFy]ÃÃZ0Zi™�c è e~ƒÐic�{ÀZ0!]tì�Zk~ÔZ�ᮊXQÆNg_¬Ðt³Z~HYYì��}ZecÅÂ"Æa

™ZÆ âöÃÔ�zu}ZecÆO}ªZec�}�cŠZzgZÐ�V»ÂVÂ" � plY\�cŠX�}ZecÅ»g~ZzgS®Æñµ6Ô�zu}ZecÅFZç:¥x

Îx~ è P™{!ÑWJFZçÔZ�á® �zxÅ è QyÆf‚ÐYV"ƒIX¾qwZ�á®Ì$2gñ���Xm131Åt Ã7W'X¬Zzg�zu}ZecÅ9ZݹÂ"

�g„™�~ˆìÔ1&5ZÝogzúƒ�:9 ß S �3ƒV ôƒV 6 55˜VW!� ˜yW!� 01 98yâÕZVcÄ yâÕZV!Ä 3 772

´)ZDwÅzÃ]ƈQyÆÄ~ùúVÅZ�á®zS®a�O~·@»aåZec�y9391Y~a�O~™r �…] ô e^Þ- Z}ÅikôZãƒäÐXOç Z*

zg Z C1 ÅôZã~�áùƒZXtZecZkZ±gÐZëì�ZÏZecŲôp™àIXÆÓxZecZ-.VÐ �…] ô e^Þ- )�Ûzg~3791Y(ÅZ�á®Ð¬ Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù

Y9‰XXgx~�zu~Z�á®»QZ(gHŠXOç�~Z�á® è pl¬ÐZ�á®

Æñµ6Ô�WJFZçÃZ0Ziƒ�Ôa¸Zec~ÔQyÅã�6ÔQ9ßg]~�zxÅFç)F~Z¢45å EGE{Zzg'(ÃZ(g7 è �áùƒZ'ÎZ}Zq£xÆÔ˜VZ�á®

HŠÉ¬Zec„ÆQ)F~g+{Zzg'(Ãg��cŠ'}ZYäYV?ñ�� 'ZkZec~,]45Ô55Ô87Ô98Ô221Ô481Ô881Ô981Zzg642Å™V$2g

�X�041Zzg772ÅZÝo�g„™�~ˆ�1�2016Zq5tgz5kƒìX

ZkÒpÐeZËYzhZDw»tÒy�:LL¯xZDwÆZ[JæZec�áùƒñÔz{ƒ 1DƃZ-.VÐTƒDgì�Ôq|]´)%jxäp�ZKôZã~»g™zZc

:�5(ß.6FìX Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù åóó)�âp

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^85

Page 58: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß SU�z�zI U��zI 3

ˆÅZ�áoV~ZÏa¸ZecÅ.VÃø¢zg]�‚i~ÆÔT~9491Y C1 ÃðZû%û�X �…] ô e^Þ- ZEwHY@g;X9391YÐ2791YJ

JÅZ�áÈÔa�O~·@™rÅôZã~ƒNÔ1ZݹÂ"ŧsËä1Ô481Ô881Ô981Zzg642Å"!!ÑZÝoÔˆÆ 2 Âz7�~ÔOç,]:87Ô98Ô2

è ZexV~Ì$2gñ���XZ%�N!]tì�‰Zz‡]Ë�‚iä)øt�g„™äÅÃÒÅìÔOç�3826LLW"0î JE0¬gnóó)9( q Z p÷ÔÂ"Å

ÃLLWc¬gnóó)ß(¯�cŠX¸�¡ZkªkÅã�6�ÔZkÄ~0õ‚](LLWsóóìÂ�VÌLLW¤óóÆOñLLWsóóƒ*ecX

!Á�s /

ÅZ�á®)4291Y(ÆÔÚF'kJÔZDwÅic�{FÂzÃgÏÅ �]… ô e^Þ-Æ ~Z�á®5kƒ™Qg�z‡gM 3C !g!gM®Z� �…] ô e^Þ- Zk�zgZy~ C2 §sg„X

fzt»‚ây�ÛZë™Cg„Ô@ë�á@Ô6ù´ÅZ�á®ÆaÚ è aúIZi,9291Y X ÃZDwä*Qg�zù·%A™1 è ÏZÜZgÆ7 Z C4 ^Zzg³gìX

* »�ZZec-Ye¯Zsð��~TƒZåXZ[YezZá µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ~Ä~ù·ÌYCeT¸XZDwZk6gŸq¸XQ,Vä±2k*i~ Qg�z

ˆÅZ�áoVÆÂÒCÃZÆa5±Ù:e�1 1DPˆ�v}ÃgÏÆegÄ~ù´�áùƒñ: 2D

:7291YX ‡eç…ôÂrÜ )1(:2391YX q^æm‚Þ^Úä )2(

:4391YX ÚŠ^ʆ )3(:6391YX Ú%ßçpµ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� )4(

«&Z�áoVƶVÅ®Z�:ZVg{DÙZgX 3D:m361Ô781 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 4D

95Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 59: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�c�z{*ÑÐçnð™BXZkZz~9Bm4391YÃQg�zù´Å C1 Z(g ™rÃÂ"ÑzqƒX

mƒZZzg!iðO�}Æuzgt6̸*x�Š ? C2 Þ�^áôÚ߈٠6Qg�zù´»*xic�{ñizVìÔOçQ,Vä!iðO�}6 e^Ùôqf†mØ 1ˆ~ZDwäCkH�

'Z�á®Æe~Ye¯ÐÂçn C3 É�c e^Ùôqf†mØ Ãi�™Æ Þ�^áôÚ߈Ùð:ƒeÔZ%@`vуgÐç@{ƒŠX¬ìwå�ù·4391Y„~¾YñÇÔZka!iðO�}Å6.Ñí~LLZ�á®ZÍw:4391YóóÆZÖpX�Ô1n

®Z›Z�á®Æ!g}~ C4 ¬x6WðX è© Â[Ô†g~5391YƬ‚}~�}~ZDwÅ’k~LL0õDÙZgóóÆZÖp�g`�ÔQËä0õƤ�Ô�Z]{¯™ éz

6�TZÍw6ÜZsñ��ìÔÂ[�kDÙZgÅ®Z�~Y8ˆX 1 C5 &É�cÔÔ%Ë�Æ�áùƒðX¸�ZDwäCkH� e^Ùôqf†mØ Æ'@ �…] ô e^Þ-

ZyÅ�á²~Ô„z®ÆZk£gz%µJV_ì�Z[6ù´ÆW¸i~ËƈÆËÌ e^Ùôqf†mØ :©Ô¬gsc±Ţzg]7X�áh¸zzì�

Ä~ù´~Ãð�~�âpc�ñ��7X¬ZecÅÂ"{mZÈxЙZðˆX@ëZk~Â"ÅqgzfsZÝo

ÃWC�:9 ß S ��s ~s 9 8

:m351Ô781 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 1DƒèÃg:m781 2D

&z:ZDwñi*ÔуgX A/M-1977-88� e^Ùôqf†mØ 5±Ù:uzgtN!iðO�{ 3De^Ùqf†mØ �� m442X9B†g~5391YÆâ~2k*i~Z:q�ï ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 4D

¾™�áùƒìX)ZsÔTZÍwÔm242(XH™/È0wÃ7™�{°682B†g~m32( ZiZÜtZWÔ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 5391YÅ@gõ�gìX)

&z:ZDwñi*ÔуgX A/M-1977-88� e^Ùôqf†mØ 5±Ù:uzgtN!iðO�{ 5D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^06

Page 60: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �ÆäMRSÈî WM ÑSÈî RM 3 91

%} ÷} 3 72À'Â À'â 6 33

ŒÛWV ŒÛWy 11 33�Û‡V �ÛÃV 8 14gzgzÆ gzgzƒÆ 3 45ÆäRMSÈî WM ÆäMSÈî RM 11 86sS[SÆä �Zv ÆäQZÈî RMZÆäMZv 5 96%~ ÷~ 3 67W¤ Ws 4 49%} ÷} 21 79sZ[ ÆäMSÈî RM 7 99sZ[ ÆäMSÈî RM 2 111�, �+ 9 431

v ÉÓÏî 1 161]Zy ]Zyz²zâ] qí 902

�736«çwÆ�~â^~ZDwä�ì:LLâÞ3391Y~'ÃC1 ZÆ'3391Y»ìX B �‹ðçâ~òÆ'×Z§lkÅicg]�ƒðóóqÑètzZ§03

¯x~¢zg‹Ä~Æ è Q,Väc��Z“лxfƒñâÞÉ�cX�9026QC2X �ZDwäLL²zâ]óó!0JZzgqd/õ IG~̸É�c

:m611D921 ‰n†ô]ÊÇ^ÞŠj^á 1D6( )�WÒ{Ô pXZ»g~»áyì�ZDwä!�ç NO~»_·Zôm~cð~HƒÇZzgZk§bÂ[Æ 2D

16Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 61: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÔZDw»ªù·åÔ��kDÙZgÅ®Z�~�áùƒZXZyÅo�à] e^Ùôqf†mØƬ„ZecÅ e^Ùôqf†mØ ÃÔ è ż�Z�áoVÆ7 �…] ô e^Þ- Zzg¬Qg�zù´

ZÍwÅ�Ûz|Æe~Zë!]t è M®Z�~Z�á®ÔZqoƒêåXZ�ᮃð��IguZÆO}tÂ[@`vÃ�~ˆX¸�Ñbz~·z]Æ:

Pâ{Ì:*g}¸�ZDw C1 Z(ƒZ1@`vÐç5]plQ|!Ð:^nXc´)Ô Í C2 {Â1VÆÎwZÐ0M�X Ò ä2k*i~ÃÉ�c�QyÆ�z„ÔW

@`vÐçnð™Æt:¸X»¸Zec�áùƒeX�zuZZecÔZyÅzÃ]Æ e^Ùôqf†mØ ZDwÅi0Ï~Ô

#1491Y~a�O~·@ÅôZã~�áùƒZXZkÅÂ"×£ìXT�zx~Æ,]8Ô33Ô14Ô45Ô431Zzg902ÅZÝo�g„™�~IÔ1,]91Ô èZÍw Z�á®

72Ô86Ô67Ô96Ô49Ô79Ô99Ô111Zzg161ÅZÝo$2gñ���X'×h'WVZkZec~5™VÌ¥z5kƒ�: èfs ø

9 ß S �33Y 33| 3 73� !©ûG 2 011�e[ �E[ 2 131ŒÛ\» �Û\» qí 631

)�*�(:m511(Xt ]Îf^ÙÒoi¡�Ún6 *xÆ9ÈZzgZ5)²zx](Ð*WÙgìƒVÐ)

áy�Zq"ã�ªkWgZðìXZDwä²!i!yzZ�[»zW_·HåZzge7�²zx]Æ9ÈÐ*zZ�ƒVX

e^Ùô gZ¶ÆZ§g6±2k*i~ÔeZË·†Zv,ðZzg�*iZ£™xyäCc�¸� 1DÆÎwZÐä-Ђi!i™ÆÔÂ[ic�{®Z�~VZà¶Zzg¸Z%yZëEL qf†mØ

©]»:¯XzZvZD!Å{ð OZ[X:m912 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^26

Page 62: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �zp zÅ5½èG 3 141

DÔ+B5ÿEE

G+B5ÿEE

GèD 6 551W�âV W�ßV 1 961

¬ZecŧbÔZkZec~Ìgñ¯Zz‡sZzgZ²Z[»ZÈx7HŠX�7316ÄÆ�~â^~LLï6ÆZqZzgxZyóóÆZÖpÃLLï6ÆZqxZyóó

Ðps™�cŠìXgZ¶Æ4�qtp~�g„7ìXàÔï6)„ÆZq0@1(äï6»ZMZg êZe(»xZyåXï6ÆLLZqZzgxZyóó)-Š

qÝ™äƈàÃ8k™�cåXZ¤�VÐLLZzgóóïw�cYñÂ|xtÀì�à)ï6ÆËê»7É(Ãð)ïâ~!��á{åÔ&LLï6ÆZqxZyóóä

zÃ]ÆÔZ�á®»ZÈx™ä {™�cåX�~â^~P™{p~Ô´)ZDwÅzZßVäZKßZ[�h6ÅÔ¸�a�O~·@äX¾qwtp~�g„7ìX

Ô e^Ùôqf†mØ �zu}ZecŲôp™àIZzgW^,Zec)�y1591Y(J�‚i~~Ã@„Æ:ÔˆÆZexV~}} Ô Z-.VÐTÅYCg„

yQh‰ZzgZÝo¥z5kƒ�X}TÞ~:9 ß S �� £ 3 96:ƒ :Î 6 27zp zÅ5½èG 3 141

â™ZðˆX,]Å®Z�ÔÄZ*]Zzg è â,Zec)âÞ4591Y(ÅÂ"ZiuÃg;ÔZ%Šg}£ìXtÂ" è QÆZ0Zi~�zuZZec„7 è Â"

6z,g¶ÅìXZk~gñ¯Zz‡sÅ{xVÌ�Ô1ù¦îg6Ô¬Zzg�zu} è Z0Zz‡sZzgS²Z[»4ZÈxHŠìX ZecÆ£«~ÔikÃZec~gñ¯

ÃZec~,]96Ô011Ô131Ô631Ô �zu}Zec~ÔÂ"Å�ZÝoñ���Ôik

36Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 63: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

141Zzg961Å™V�g„™�~ˆ�1,]91Ô72Ô73Ô86Ô67Ô49Ô79Ô99Ô111Ô551Zzg161ÅZÝo$2gñ���XZkZec~qgzfs5ZÝo¥z5kƒ�:

9 ß S �$h4è GWG $øGW 8 14ÆäMRSÈî MQ ÑS[ 9 05

%vÔ§‹"Ñs %À§]"Ñs 9 06ÆäMRSÈî MQ ÆäMS[ 01 08•çEMEZà •çELEZà 2 38R§ë

EQ R¦"öELQ 1 19²¤u ¾¤u 4 101W¤ Wc 6 111H²w HÇæ OEw 5 741

GV …5Òhé EV 9 151Zw ZZw 6 951iZgzi1V gZizi1V 3 081

è ¸e è Ãe 7 681pZ„Zg pZ„Zi 9 712

F/V»S5 ÔZϧb ZkZec~‰´â]»ZŸ†HŠZzg‰~$¸ç GOs$w�cŠìÔ}:

âZVZec �zuZZec S �"54hé EGHI $‹pî EI qí 28Z‡ñZÉÐ:ö OX Z‡ZÉÐ:ö OWX 8 388h4èGEP @ñ 4 39

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^46

Page 64: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âZVZec �zuZZec S �Zg °æO ðè©g ©g°æOZg 11 39

7Ò5ÕäE

GíP 7Ò5ÕäE

GV 11 3018h4èGEP @ñ 11 251

¡òz!mhò ¡z!mh 51 451ß± Îó 2 261

tZÈxÔÂ"ÅÔ×4ßg]êCÙ™@ìÔ1@Zzg©g6LLñóóÅ´#ÖÃps™*ÔgZ¶Æ4�q�g„7XtZq§bÅ’pìT»hÔ:»AÃì

ZkZecÅ.VÃôp™Æ2791YJZ-лx1Y@g;X©�3791Y X Zzg:*ÑÃ)3791Y(zZàÂ"Ð�áùHŠZzg@qw Ò×n^l »ßZVZecÔ e^Ùôqf†mØ ~

Â[ÔS-.Vоg„ìX

¢ƒæ /

ÅZ�á®)†g~5391Y(ÆPâ{ˆ„ÔZkŠgQg�z¯x¦ƒŠ� e^Ùôqf†mØ´)ZDwäLLߧZuZ>óóÆ*xÐ�}Qg�zù´Å»g~Ñzq™�~X6391Y

ô •†h ÆO} ÆZzZb~ù·%AƒZÔÂñçqÅo9ÐZÐLLߧZuZ>óón�ÑðÆ 1 1C »*x�cŠX¬ìwå�ù·Z6s6391Y~�áùƒYñÇÔ Ò×nÜ

tZDw»ªù·ìTÆuzgt6Q,VäÂ[Æ C2X Wy~�âV~Z(eƒe*xZzgñçqÅzŸsÆaÂ#ZÖp)LLZ´Èk�z§q¢ÆÜsóó(�g`K

ÉZq¿ÐZkÅ'×h=ôÌÅXqf†mØ ó e^Ùô ZÍw6ÔS®»â{z‚w�g7ìXZkÅÂ" è ÅZ�á® Ò×nÜ ô •†h

»½6qgzfsLLß*)óóY\™QРƬZecŧbŠg}ëìXZq´u{

Ô�zx:m99 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D:m262XH™/È0wzàÇPZ�~¬${ÎyZzgeZˆZ]‰Ã7™�{¶V ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 2D

( 53D63 m ÔTÎxÔ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 6ZDwÆ�+VÆ‚BJZ~6391YÅ@gõ�gìX)

56Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 65: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

p}ЬÔZ0gzãuzgtÅ16ðVHŠì: è z„9 ß �ƒ:nÇ :ƒnÇ 2gZ³ %³ 44

¾Á†V ¾wz†V 54FZ ¾Z 46

¤¿ ¶÷ 28ì Ð 491ñ -} 911

÷iZ %iZ 121>{ > 2215 ã 321

»xz�‚ èm z»x�‚ m 531Ô}: 1¬Zec~ÔÂ"Å'×h¹ÏZÝoÌñ���9 ß S �>ìF} >ì¾} 11 01i1ZP i1ZñP 3 11

ky kV 21 31ñ. ñÏ 5 84YZ �Z 1 55�áGi~ ×i~ 6 88W"0î JE0 è Ws 01 19F~ ¾~ 6 301

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^66

Page 66: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S ��* �* 01 711Z+ Z, 9 9117s &éEMs 9 721

æZÉÐ:ö �X æZÉÐ:ö RX 3 531hZÉÐ:ö �X hZÉÐ:ö X 7 771

> ¢ 11 971ZkZec6plâö»*x�g`7Ô1Q|ƒÂ"ÐtZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�tÂ"

6z,g¶ÆO}ËZzgplâöäÅXZkŤ&ZkZ%Ð̃Cì�:‰ZÖpÆZ5~«!g¡»ìwg3Šì}:�)m81(¶î MQ )Z³(

Æ Ò×nÜ ô •†h )m84(X6z,g¶!ÑoZxLL¢©->î EGGXóóZzgLLÈóó�Ô©�

�zu}Zec~Q,VäZyZÖpÅQÐßÂ"™�~X²!Q)Wc]zFZIz){(ÅÂ"&~ìX6z,g¶Ô²!Q )[(

å¬~��XZkZec~(~®Z�~Â"ÅZÝoQ�X6z,g¶ÆÂ"”{ÔË )`(Zec~ZÝoÅZâÒ]7X

âÂ"™ZðˆXÂ[6plâö»*x�g`7 è �zu}Zec†g~1491YÅZiu1zZãîg6tÂ"6z,g¶ÅìX,]Å®Z�Zzgàâ]ÆW¸izZ!x~Ô¬ZecÆ,]�»âHŠìXZkZecÅ»g~ZzgS®a�O~·@ÆikôZã¿~WðX¬ZecÅZÒZÝo�g„™�~IÔ@ë,]55Ô19Ô301Ô531Ô171Zzg771ÅZÝo$2gñ���X'×h'WVZq5tÌÃWCì:

9 ß S �¢Zi~ *Zg~ 5 27

Â"×£ì'ZÏZecŲôp™ÆˆÆZecY9YDgìX

76Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 67: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

7ƒmXm5116ZqQhYäÐ'×hZqt%�Zgƒ: o �27ÅtÅ9 ß

? Ó�á è0 t Ó�á è0)3791Y(zZàÂ"ÐY0ŠZzg Ò×n^l ,ðZVZec)Z~4791Y(

ZiZV¸ŸYg~ìX

)8~î0Qg�z( ZgèÈsi /

6391YÆz‰~�áùƒðZzgZ6s8391Y~´)ZDw»ZÙw Ò×nÜ ô •†hƒŠXzÃ]ÐIÔZ¹ZL7ä�z'kƯxÃ%A™Æ�áù™ä»ñµ75XlZ§¯xÌZâ:¶�Zqåù·%Aƒ@XzÃ]ƈÃgÏZzgQg�z)æÍy

ZDwÅzÃ]ƈ X Æ*xÐY\�cŠ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ ¯x¦™ÆâÞ8391Y~]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Zka Ô ôZã�áùƒäѸ ik QyÆÄ~ù´a�O~·@Å

ÅFKzDz+ÌQ,VäZ�x�~ZzgÂ"ÌZ-ÅôZã~ƒðX»!iðO�{Â"Æa»g™DÔZka ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ ZDwÃZâú7B�z{

tÂ[ËÆ*xÌsy7ňXZ[Æe~�«YZv��:åÔ ÌâZ[™rÿÈ0wþ„Å2g™ä»ZgZ�{™1 ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Z,VäZKÂ[

TÅZ:qQ,Väu±gZk&�Ã�~¶XugZk&�ÔZDwЬ¯]ƒ‰ÔZDwÅzÃ]ƈ�áùƒðXZk§bZDwÅZkpZézz°{»Ô ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Zzg

Í:z¤»¬g�ìÔËÃD:ƒZ'ÿZ[þQyìZDwÅZkpZéÅ �Z[ZqC1 YñÏX zÅ

ZkÅz7ƒmZzgƒCÌù?�«YZväZDwÅZkpZé»ÃðjZ!7 1�cXZDwä�!]gZk&�нÔ�«YZvþfg)ÐZkÅZ:qB?

âZ[È0wÆ!g}~ZDwäF(_!‹N+»ZÖgHìÔZkaZk™rÈ0wÆ*x!š3ð NMEQMy™* âZ[ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Zkyìîg6Âg�7HYY�z{

ÔZÍw:mLLróó ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^86

Page 68: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

eTƒVÔ@ëËzZãÞ�]Å°xñ��Ï~ÔZÐZDwÅLLz¤óóŒÛZg7�c»Z[ÌâZ[È0wÆ*xì Ò×nÜ ô •†h YYÔT6¿�gWæŵg¿YñX

Zzgt¼Ð‚4ì�ZqÆÔ�zuZù”î0¯xÌZ-Й[™�cYñXÃ� è »½ã�zäðzÃgϯx6�ìX°Z߉Üøg}7 ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡

102Ð082J»Qg�zzìXÃgÏzÔ�zu}![~ikcWñÇX»ªZecÔ6�Qz6f™ƒZÔâÞ8391Y~�áùƒZXÂ"6z, ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡

g¶ÅìZzgZDwÆÄ~ùúVÅÚŠg}£ìZzgic�{ZôoZzgZÈxÐňz™VQ�: � ìÔZÏaZk{~Â"Å

wx è :� 9 wx è :3 ß m:252S:Z:WÇñ 9 :Wǃ ß m:322S:0Z

�zu}Zec)Z~4491Y(Æñµ6¸�¬ZecÅ‚g~²ôp:g{ÃZka‰”VÅÂ"Ziuâ™ZðˆXWy~»8)m372D082(ÅÂ"¬„

u}Zec~Â"»‚— ZecÆ_.ìÔ!¹Qg�z{Å‚g~Â"5ìX�zQ|[Z(gHŠìÔZk~TZÍwÅZqt)m252(�g„™�~ˆìXm8726

XˆÆÓxZexV~ZÏ�zu} Å´#Ö¯*�g„7ì óó å� ó6LL ó å LL@Z£72D082(Å�P¬ZecÐ ZecŲZEwÅIXZ%Wy~»8)m3

ôp¬Wg„¶Ôz{�}ZecÆñµ6ŸùƒZzgZÐZiuâÂ"™ZcŠX-VÐQg�z{ÅÂ"5ƒX¬ZecÅ«»8: 1C �}Zec)âÞ6491Y(

Z0gzãuzgtÂ[ Zq��á® Z TZzg®Z› Zq�

z„p} egÔ)Z³D[D`D�({à �zÔ

6�¶X¸�ZkÅPôo:g{mXZ�á®�zxÆñµ6ZkÅZiuâÂ"»Fœ�*u ZÃg)—§h(ÐÑzqƒD�XZkZ\k è 7HŠÔOçˆÆÓxZecÔQ

»ÃðZ(75ÔT6TÎxÅÜZsñ��ƒXZ%ZqZecZ( ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ gZ¶Ã 1D�ø[ƒZÔT6‚ÁS®Zzg:-»Z0gZ`ìX~äZЄ�ZZec¦gHìX

96Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 69: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¯ÄZDwÆza�O~·@Zzg:ËZzgÅÂzX è {òŧsZ�á®�8726LL@Z£óóÆikÄZy&ZÃg»ZqÃgÏ«ìÔTÆ!g}

~´)ZDwƉŒÛR‚¹V)pZz†Zß©ZzgeZË·†Zv,ð(»ìwì�Z�‰�vZô[Å C1 ZDwp�%A�ÛâDÔÂt«�áï:™DÔ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Z¤

gZ}ZkÆ'@ìXP™{ÃgÏ¿ÅÔÂ[ÆÃgÏ{ÆO}Qg�z{ÆWy~ËqÐáiƒ@ì�a�O~·@ÌÔZkçA~¬Âáœ�gìÔpˆ~Ô¿Ã�áï™ä»êHŠX

ðýýðýýð

Z¤|]´) ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ P™{¿Æ!g}~pZz†Zß©��:LL÷Zìwì� 1DÔ†g~9691Y:m76( ]Îf^Ù…mçmç mZ°¶Åi0Ï~ÕÂtÄZk~�áï:ƒCóóX)

Ô%ApZz†Z°Ý ]Îf^Ön^lôìç]qä ZÏK~pZz†Zß©»*yLLôD$�c„óó)˜!:_·ìÔT~z{��:LLZyPZô[~ÐÔ�%jxÆ è ¤gtm801D111(ÌÑë

»gÔ‰Zk!]»ZŒÛZg™D��)%jx»ZgZ�{ÔZy è Wy~Zcħ]~ZyÆg=%A™äzZßV~ÐË¿ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ :åX ¦CÙ ZÃgÃZLù·x~�áù™ä»

Ôm111(eZË·†Zv,ð»ìwì�: ]Îf^Ön^lôìç]qä ÅÑZg]I~ÐZ(ƒZìXóó)LLZÐ�áù™ÆZY7HXÃtZYìÔÎZ}ZkÆ�@Z£»*xWcìóó)gZ¶Z�zs

ÐZqWÔ9B�y9791Y(XZke~6zW/§]g~»*y�&À�/õ GG:LLZDwÅZqуgÔZÆ'ÔâÞ4891YÔm471D971( ‰n^…å Ä:@Z£»ó_·óó)

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^07

Page 70: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Qg�z ‹ZDwÔ à (`)Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù ¯ÄZDwÅ5Â"»�Zi7™DƒñÔeZËYzhZDwÔ

)уgÔ3791Y(ÆW¸i~LLZnZgóóÆikÄZy��:¯ÄZDwÆZ[JæZec�áùƒñÔz{ƒÆƒZ-.VÐTƒDgìÔq|]´)%jxäp�ZKôZã~»g™zZcåXZkÒpÐt²|‹´)Æ�zu}r»]ŧbÔ³]z:æ N#Ö»£xgB�XZ¤pÒ‹ZEwÆ!ZyÅqªZFƒìXZ¹Fu™ä»j,7ƒ@åXCÙ�iZ¹�‚i~

Ƹi}Ð'×#èGOE™Æ»x1Y@g;XpZ[ZyÅqªtƒì��‚i~ÌZ¹Zk‡.Þ7¯$Ë�'×hS®ÆaZEwÅYÃÔZkaZkÆÎZÃð

C1 eg{:g;�ZiaçLâÂ"™zZÆ5²»gÅYNXZDwÅi0Ï~: Ô tÒy¡ÔìX˜VJQg�zùúV»mì

Æ&Zec)4291YÔ6291YZzg0391Y~(�áùƒñXa¸ZecÅ �…] ô e^Þ- )1(Z�á®´)ÅzÃ]ÆÔ‚w½ˆÔ�y9391Y~ƒðXZkÅÂ"QyÅzÃ]

ЈÅìZzgZÏÂ"Å.VÃôp™ÆÔˆÆZecY9YDgìXà]»92zZVZecÖÔZkÅÂ"�y9391Y„Å �…] ô e^Þ- ÅZÍAZ�á®ÐIÔ

Å.VÃÔZDwÆLL*.çGEOuóó �…] ô e^Þ- ìXªCÙìZkÂ"ÃZzg:Zkлg”{YYìX ~ÑgH

Â" ´)ZDwÅi0Ï~�áùƒZX5 )†g~5391Y( »ÜsªZec eÙôqf†mØ )2(J )�y1591Y( Å�²»gƒNÔz{W^,Zec )#1491Y( Ð�zu}Zec

Â"™ZðˆX Ziuâ ZEwƒCg�Xâ,Zec)âÞ4591Y(Æa:m5 Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(]ö…�æ 1D

17Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 71: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»81zZVZec)Z6s2791Y(âÞ4591YÅ e^Ùôqf†mØ ÅZÍAZ�á®ÐIÔ Ò×n^l

.VÐTƒZX»ÌÜsZqZec)�Ñð6391Y(´)Åi0Ï~ÖX5 Ò×nÜ ô •†h )3(

ZEw è ÅZ�á®Jik Ò×n^l Â"Ð�zu}Zec)1491Y(Å»g”{²Ôg�XªCÙìt²LL´)äp�ZKôZã~»góó7™Zð�X

ÅÂ"zS®Â|‹´)ÅzÃ]ƈƒðX ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ )4(®ZZDwÅi0Ï~�áù”{QyÆËQg�zù´ÆËZecŲôp:g{

ìZzg ß.6F ÃXZkaZynzxLL!2.çGEOu.Vóóų]zw#ÖÅ!]¡�Ûzg~3791YЬԡZkzzÐÔZy.VÃFu:™ä»�Zi7áXZkÆ

S®ZzgZq]h£g~Z�á®»Ô: �{ !z��Ô¯ÄZDwÅ5p[ßg]Â"Ô×Üs»ï�Ziñ��åÔÉZkÅZ”¢zg]̶X

Å^~Z�á®Ð0Ô�*i Ò×n^l ZDwÆQg�zZzgÃgÏÄ~ùúVÅÔZ£gZz~�:

Zke~¼�™8ïENZ°Z}Zô[ÐgZ}àˆXZy~ñÑ*ÝxgÎw$Ô6zWqZ£{VÔñÑ*qæZ{VÔeZËYzhZDwZzg%iZ;�~ZázZíFZ!z){�áï�XZyƒZô[ÆZ°køg}yƒDZzgZ)bikcWD'¼�Zñgðƒñ'Z5ÆZ6(~cƒðXWytð0c�Ë»�Z5Ô´)

™rä�ÔQÐ'ŒÛZgg3YñÔZ%%jxqZ£{VÆZÜZg6ÂLLWfgóó˜VÌC1 WcÔQÐLLWigóó~ps™�cŠX!¹ê¸å�Z5Ô�ìÔz,„g��cYñX

eZËYzhZDwäÂ"Æe~ñÑ*$ÅgÉðZzg‰£â]Åo~C2 QyƬzy»f™HìX

ñ��{ÔÂ" è ÅZ�á®Æa{™ZÈxHŠZzg~ Ò×n^l Zk~d->î IEX7�ÅŒ»g~ÔS®Å0ÀÏZzg΄ÆÒpÐZÐÔZq£g~Zec¹YYìX

gZ¶Z�zsÐWXуgÔJ�Ñð9791YX 1D:�LLzóóX Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^27

Page 72: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

@ëQÅ¡ÔFKzDz+ZzgZ5ÆZ±gÐPZñgÂzÔ�:»�k ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ »a�{S~Zzg •†hôÒ×nÜ »4!g{S~Ô e^Ùôqf†mØ Zzg e^Þ-ô�…] )1(ic�{ ÆaÎ!S~)7V(4Z(gHŠXZk§bZqÔ6 Ò×n^l S~åX

ZÃgÅRöaZƒZzgegzVùúVÆÀ628,]Æ£«~‚gZQg�z¯xÔÆ476,]~ƒŠÔ1ZkÐFZqÕ÷aZƒ‰Ô}: Ò×n^l

~ÄLLÓ �…] ô e^Þ- ZZexVÆ,]Å7+»ƒXVwÆîg6 )Z³(~ÄLLï6óó e^Ùôqf†mØ ~�381ÐX Ò×n^l z�á²óó�102ÐÑzqƒCìÔ1

ÅZ�á®Ð¬ÔÄc Ò×n^l Æ�301D4016X e^Ùôqf†mØ ~Ô Ò×n^l �0416ìÂZÃg»jZ!�ïz‰ÜÔÂ[ÆZecŶy�„¢zg~:¶Ô1Z[jZá~ZecZzg‚ÁZ�á®»ZoZx¢zg~ƒŠX

Ò×n^l ‰àâ]Zzgç1]ÆWy~�g`Ô ; Ƽ��] e^Ùôqf†mØ )[(~Z¹Zq6ÄZyLLg!È]óóÆ�¦™�cŠìX)t*ÄZy‡ì™*O}p�

×Æ4�qZDwÆ9�]ÃLLg!È]óó~Ñg7HYYX( è Z‹ZnìYV�ZI è ‡.ÞZzg}Zy»ûps™�cŠìXZkZ)wÅzŸsÔøfsVßVЃÏ:

LLç1]óóÆWyÆ9�])cg!È](»ûps™�cŠìX 1DÄLLï6óóÆWy~�g`�zÄzV)AYD�'Š*Zec 2D

m141(ÃâILLg!È]óóÆ{~áYcŠìXÄLLÑÈî0õZóóÆÔ�g`�zšÄZyÄzV)ZDwäÀ'Š*m 3D

561(6LL«óó»p�‚�ÄZyΙQ¹ÄLL�¬óóЬ�g`™�cŠìX)rqZecm09(

ÄLLgz—Zgè'óó)Š*m871D971(ÆWy»«)¡]%~ 4Dâ#'(Â[Æ!ÇWy~Ô)rqm071(6áYcŠìX

LLcz%hóóÆWyÆ�zÄzV)FZ@gzbÐ'ÔŠ*Ôm191(»n�! 5D™ÆQ¹ÌLLg!È]óóÅâá~�}�cŠìX

LL�szZ+óóÆWy»«)ÀZL%hzV'Š*Ôm491(Â[ 6D

37Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 73: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÆWy~Ô)rqÔm071(6áYcŠìXÅxzgCwä´)ÆZ5Ã�V Ò×n^l è ¯x$wˆìXFK è Zk§bFK

¯x~tp~ùÍZgZ™à?-VÌtLLg!È]óó è »ÂV'ŒÛZggp6Z·tHÔ1FK7Ô�]�X

Æuzgt)m364(6Â[»:ÄZy'LLªZ´È Ò×nÜ ô •†h ~ Ò×n^l )2(kÔ�z§q¢ÆÜs'óóZzgtZÃgñ��7�:

WiZ� è 7£xÅp¤ËƒZ}§ÔVÁ²aZ™

gZ{ÐYL è DÙZg*ÔF}�p�~~ez[Æ¢ƒæaZ™

ÅÂ"~Z0gzã Ò×n^l :ÄZyZzgZÃgÔÂ[ÆÜsÛzãuzgt6�g¸XuzgtÐÂ"ÑzqňÔZkaÛzãuzgtÆZ0gZY]ÔÃzVÐZz̓‰X

Zzg e^Ùôqf†mØ ÅxzgCwZzg:ñÑ*$ÅÂzZkZ%ŧsˆ� Ò×n^l )3(~ Ò×n^l ÆW¸i~Ôàâ]Ôç1]Zzg�]z){Åz„ñ��7X ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡

LLz„p}óó%A™Æ�áï™*Â:åÔ1t�Ûz*Z“$2gñ��g„Xz„ÅWCìX °xñ��ÏÐË{mÄcçwňl~{à�‰Ü7

~ÔQÅ¡Æ!g}~eZËYzhZDw��:LL!g!gÅ Ò×n^l )4(‚i~Æ!¼™V¥z5kƒ�ÔqZÍA¶VУ¨™Æ ��

,V䉣â]ÅoÆK~ÔñÑ*$ÅgÉð»Ìf™H Q C1 ó HŠXó �g„ÅÂ"Åoz){$™räÅZzg™�tZ Ò×n^l ìX�*iZ£Æ_.:LL

ЬÆZexVÅqgzfsZÝoÅ Ò×n^l Oç C2 �Ñzg~äÌZk~;BJcóóÔoƒìX

ZÍA¶VÐÔtBïGLQ~ZquJæ�ï$Ëì1z{ ___ ÔQg�z:mLLzóó Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù 1DLL£g~°óó¾qw7�XgZ¶Z�zsÐW:уgÔJ�Ñð9791YX 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^47

Page 74: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 S »� Ò×n^l ß S �e^Þ-ô�…]

�hØ 31 31 �h� 8 ~'×gq 11 16 '×g”î0 4 45

3 11 26 ô 6 55Ò!È 31 57 "5é EGO!È 7 27

0ÆÔa 01 08 0c 8 87Å5ÐöGLp 9 98 bp 1 09WÍ 7 271 WN 3 981

è u*“ 7 181 è u¦“ 9 991è« 6 491 è¬ 21 412

i!V 3 022 i!y 5 642Z¢45å EGE{ 8 342 g+{ 01 472W"0î JE0 3 151 Wc 3 382

e^Ùqf†mØ�s 9 992 ~s 9 83391Y 2 413 33| 3 73%vÔ§‹"Ñs 31 133 %À§]"Ñs 9 06R§"öEL 7 453 ï Z§ã 1 19W¤ 41 553 Ws 7 49²¤u 51 163 ¾¤u 4 101

57Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 75: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 S »� Ò×n^l ß S �W"0î JE0 51 963 Wc 6 111H²w 9 004 HÇæ OEw 5 741

GV 9 304 …5Òhé EV 9 151‡wzZw 31 904 ‡wzZZw 7 951

1V iz iZg 3 624 gZizi1V 3 081è ¸e 5 134 è Ãe 7 681

Zg 5 654 Zi 9 712•†hôÒ×nÜ

YZ 3 025 �Z 1 55W"0î JE0 21 555 Wc 01 19

æZÉÐ:ö X� 5 695 æZÉÐ:ö RX 3 531

Ã: Ò×n^l Zz6ëäÔeZËYzhZDw»tÒyÜHì�QÅoÆe~ÔLLZÍA¶VУ™Æ�g„HŠóóXZÍA¶VÐñZiä~Ãðw`7Ô1Z¹£g¯*Zkaßì�Qy~ÌÔM®Z�~Â"ZzgZ5ÅZÝoñ���XZkÆÎZÔZDwäZKÂ1VƬZexV~FZçÌXX-VÌQßÁïÅ¥zÐÔZ¤'Åi0Ï~ËÂ[Ƽ�Zec|ƒVÂÔ¬7ÉWy~Zec

5 ~qgzfs Ò×n^l ÆQãg~tHYñÇX¾qwZkŠgZôoÆ!z��™Vgz5kƒ�:

ß S �» Ò×nl 9 S �e^Þ-ô�…]

:Yñ 9 25 Yñ 9 24

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^67

Page 76: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ß S �» Ò×nl 9 S �7Cì 21 56 7Cƒ 8 95

�y 4 302 �V 1 622e^Ùôqf†mØ

’,çE

Ò 5 303 `Ò 4 51¢©->îEGGX 2 223 � 5 74]ZƒV 41 233 ]Zƒ 4 26"fz¾%›i0ÏÔñ]

01 543 "fz¾%�i0ÏÔñ]

3 97

9.è FNE 7 153 m 11 68%~ 5 753 ÷~ 1 59

� 5 093 � 1 331¯‹‰h{ 61 193 ¯‹‰h 4 531

~tZÖp Ò×n^l ÿ÷zs�þ

844 Z1ZY!�çO~²!i!y»�g�á²

01 902

•†hôÒ×nÜ3 8 384 4 11 31$ìV 7 225 $ìy 7 75

LÅÝò 2 055 LÅÓò 5 78�y 6 765 �V 6 301)Áiâð 01 585 )wziâð 4 221

]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡'.5é GEOzV 5 746 '.5é GEOîV 5 312

77Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 77: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~‰6ZãZÝoÅ¡ Ò×n^l QÔZ5ZzgÂ"Åqgz!Ñ5ZÝoÆ´z{Ô7ƒmX‰™V�VÅÂV'ŒÛZgg�cQy~Z+p~ň�tÅßg]

}: Ô $wˆÔ1t�zg7ƒm9 ß S à]»� ß S �

e^Þ-ô�…]zI z� U� U��zI 31 99 Iz� U� 3 201

WÍ WN 9 171 WN 5 881e^Ùôqf†mØ

%}»x ÷}»x 3 903 ÷}»x 3 72ÆäMRSÈî MQ ÑS[ 5 423 ÑS[ 8 05

DÔ+B5ÿEE

GL"¥¥ ‘ÐêL+B5ÿEE

G"g¥ 6 604+B5ÿEE

G"g¥ èD 6 551X m 2 054 m 6 012

•†hôÒ×nÜÓ�á? è0 8gê F

ILÓ˜t 5 975 Ó�át è0 01 511

YZ �Z 8 906 �Z 6 941Zz6ÅTg~XQñgŶy�„ňìÔZy~Ð9»mDz+ZzgZݹ

Â"ÐìX|Âtì�¹ÏZݹÂ"Ô¡Z5Zzg/VÅ�z^~ßóg~»™Ö�X

Z5»X /

ÆZkY}~Z5»XÌÂzÔìX9F¹cCi!âVÆ Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù

ßg]³7ƒmXZk|ÐZïg™*Âì�Qg�zZ5 £g~ '@ÔQg�zZ5ÅZÌJ"Ÿ$ŒÀö E

YZzgZ_g»DgìX¹ÐZÖp»ßZ5gZòìÔ¼�/VÅZq

¯Å è *xËgZI X ÐiZZ�z›^g„�ZzgZ²Z[z°óg~»ÂíÔf™„HXZg�zZIVZzgZ�ZgzVÅ"Â?ì�ZKÂ1VZzg 7Z ’k,ÌZyÛ[Ð(.çEO

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^87

Page 78: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

g‚ßV~ÌZL„ZßÁZ5Å0È~7™DX»tVÃ?�ì�Z5~z{ZKZ5ÐZg�zZ�ZgzVÅ è ßZ[�h»WiZ�Z:ZEw™,ZzgWÅZÏ�ÛZc�àZzg¡

Ñ6zZðÆ:ÔQg�zZ5ZÌJßóg~ÅeZ„Ð�]70mXi!yzÒyZzggzi%{zõzg{Æ´z{ÔZ‚E{»¯xÔZkZ±gÐÌ�§Vwz

Z÷�7HY@ì�QyÆ;VË{m»Z5Hì?CÙP�‰qpV~ZÐÎZ5~æ�¢zgQìXZka è °œ9^ŒÛZg�b�g„7ƒ@Ô@ëZkС

Z56ÌÂz�b.e¢zg~ è Z‚E{ƯxÅDz+zÂ"~QÅoÆ‚B¡è Å‚&4-ö

JEH¡ëELßg]³™äZzg k ìXt»x¢zgì1Qg�zi!yÅF¹ÔZù¦Qg�zÆwÆ$©�î EG0ÃÐÔÂI~ÆZk{giZgФmÔ�ZøqZ:§¯¿:ƒÇX

´)ZDwÆ�zg~Qg�zZ5_5éGOwqª~åX¼�ZÖpÅŠ*Z5ðßg'gZò�ÔZ%‰ZÖpÔßg]$w™5^Z(g™`¸X‰ë)ÄZzZ�!ŧb

ZDwÆ;VÌÔZ5~"Ÿ$ŒÀö EY

Zzg"‡°ÏÅVBQ�XQ,VäZL¯xÅ~иÔ1 C1 Â"Æa†ZØ6z,g¶»ZN[H�ZL�zgÆ4+»tV

Z5Æ$©�î EG0ÃÐ"µ»Dgg;ÔYèiâäŬxgzl¸ è ¯xZDw»QÔ¡¶X6z,g¶ÆÂ"”{‚g}ùúV~Z5ðZ_gÃW@ìXSyÔ6ZäZexV

Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù ~ÂÔZ5Åßóg~ÐܽÃHYYìÔ1Z\k*u!]tì�)уgÔ3791Y(ÌÔTÅLL]hÂ"zS®óópléZzgªCÙ~Œ»g~»Zd%:

�c ætƯxÆ�ácÈ�áyóóŒÛZg è ìZzgZÏaeZËYzhZDwäZÐLL�á²Zzg tZecÔZqVà S5ÆÒpÐ*³ìX¯IW?Æfg)T”{ è ìÔ¡

ZDwZqâ~��:LL†ZØ»AÌÿ˜ZþÔ÷}4�qуg~ƒÐ4ìóóX 1D:m16(X@ë´)Й[tw"ã�ì�:LL6z, ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ùeß^Ýen,Ü+†]Úo )

уgÔJ qß- g¶÷}ZÃgÅÂ"7™,ÐÂ~�á²~Fu™�zVÇóóX)gzi*)ZÆ'1891Y:m32(X

97Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 79: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

{'k;'kJÔZÐjZữ g zgW Z C1 £g~°ÅwÐ7ZzggZòHŠìZ5»SàZÈx¢zg~åXZkÆa� è ¦gHYñÇXZkaZk°~¡Æ,]ZkÐ{àÃWD�ZzgtƒZk Ò×n^l �h{gm~Zzg»zl£[¶Ô

ì�: Æ!z��oÆaeZËYzhZDwä{àu¤�ZãÅX )Z³(¡zo»»xñÑ*ÝxgÎw$ÅôZãZzggZ{úð~Z�x0cX )[(

{VÔ � Z5ÆZ6xzgCw)T~ñÑ*$Ô6zWqZ£{VÔñÑ*qæZ )`(%iZ;�~ZázZíZzgeZËYzhZDw�áï¸(äp[gzpnHXgZ¶Æìw~xzgCwä¯ÄZDw~ÔZ5ÆZZzgZkÅ4Z•zZÌ

)3791Y(ÆZ5~xzgCwÆ Ò×n^l »7g~§bS�gZu7HXtÂf™W[ì�ZkŸÅ0È~7ň�:ZZÖp»Z5LL�ìÔz,„g��cYñóóÔÉZ5

]ÐZ5Åßg]�g„Zzg4ƒì1‰ à ~¼�$¸ç GOÃ]K‰�X9$¸ç GOZ5ð¥Ã]ÆË~9Z5Ã߯�cŠìcZ5Å4ßg]ÃFu™�cŠìÔ}:

&C½ðE)TZÍwÔm02S1:íÃ( m:43S:31*0ZZg~ 41 S: 132 �:¢©->îEGGX 2 2230'»[ 6 823

ZyZÖpÅ4�z^-Vƒãec:íÃX*0hZg~X�X0/g»[XLL£ÄZ5óóÐLLW‚V¦gäóóÆË~FyZÒVaZƒ�XZkK~P

Âz�: è UÑë

Qy] Ô 6FÔZqZec�áùHŠì Ò×n^l 5791Y~Z¥|)¸g](ÐÔikc 1D~ñ���Ô1ZkÅZq'×hp!tì�CÙÔÆ Ò×n^l pçVZzg{ñVÆ‚BÔ�

z){(»*xÌ�g`HŠìX ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Ô e^Ùôqf†mØ Ô e^Þ-ô�…] Qz6´Â[)

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^08

Page 80: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ÿ�VÅ0È~ zz 䥽Z5Æe~Ãð‡°{çzä7HÔ:'çO "54èGEGE 'ç )1(

ÅìÔTлAZzgôZyÅ"ZôïªCÙƒCìXZkÆË~Z5~7+aZ7ƒmÔ}:

:m834(~ps™�c Ò×n^l ZßÁZâ!Æ�Oîg6*g{Ã*g}) D Z³:m971Ô Ò×n^l ŠÔ1}ZÏZßwÃÃZ0Zi™Dƒñfg{Ãfg}7¯cŠX)

:m653(qÑè Ò×n^l :m872(Zzg‡š$2g‡š) Ò×n^l S8(B$2gB)�Vfg}ÔJZzg‡¶»ûåX

m931(~$w�cŠZzg}ZkÆ Ò×n^lV LL&C½ðEóóÃOîg6LLíÃóó) D[m89(¯cŠpZkÆ'@ Ò×n^lV m:43S31(*0ZZgÃ*0hZg) Ò×n^lV '@)

:m213(Zzg Ò×n^l m132(~psHŠX0„Ã:�„) Ò×n^lV *0hZg~Ã*0ZZg~):m213(~psHŠ1}ZkÆ'@0/g»[Ã0'»[ Ò×n^l i}Ã/y})

m823(™�cŠX Ò×n^lV )Zq„ÂcZq�ZÖpÆ�zZZ5ð%äX�X}:"!u D `

)m:523(Zzgyu)m:753Æz)m:92(ZzgI™)m:23(eð&|)m:401(Zzgeð&)m:701(z){X

âwä?mHå�:LLÃgÏÂ/Ô:ÔpÔ�Ô" è Qg�zÅZ&—gÌ è Z³F¹ D�z){�p�ÃgÏ~ÌL�zu}ÂÐ5™ZzgLZµ‘YD�ÔQg�z„g]~

~t}Zµ‘‰�)/�wÔm601(Zzg}5™ Ò×n^l 1 C1 Zµ‘YNóóX)$„Ôm701Ô�m961(¸qw‚–VZzgÑ£V»ì}ƒl)m982(Ôá)m562(ÔÔ[)m171(Ôç¦ZV)m082(Ôƒ')m482(ÔZkÆ'@"n)m521(Ô"!u)m523(z){X

~tÂCÙ Ò×n^l LL%zVóó~âyêZhZ�cŠìXto�g„ìXZ[ )2(جiZZ ˆZq (-Vì:LL%zVóóÔQßÁÂ"Å¥zÐZk~LL~óóÆ

:m264X ]ö…�æ]Ú¡ Ô†g~4491YXfZ! ]ö…�æ g‚! 1D

18Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 81: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ìXZk»9Z5-Vƒ*ec:ôzVXZ5Æe~W`ë‰!ÂVéà�™ÃZDwÅtßg]�âãYñÏÔZkaZk~ZqØÚ» è Z0Zi™�ï�Ô1ÀQ

Ì�Ût7ƒ*ecX~ÔËuJÔ Ò×n^l Z5~ZÌgn�X è )3(gñ¯Zz‡sZzgS²Z[Ô¡

ÃZq£g~¯ZÏz‰ÜŒÛZg�cYY Ò×n^l »ZÈxHŠìÔ1 gñ¯Zz‡s S²Z[zÈÐêZzgÀò(zd£g è ìÔZS²Z[zZz‡s»7gZZÈxHYñX¡¢zg~ìXPVB: Zi' ZÈx » ÃÔ‰£â]6Z²Z[ è ÆÝwÆ7

£/ßg] à]»Z5 S �'±h4ð YNGZV '±h4ð YGZV 1 862§‹"Ñs §]"Ñs 31 133

îg è �g| �g|îg 2 233¤çGN…0î NE ŒÛ\ 1 583

ßg‹c ßg]c 1 393�ÔCÙiâV �OiâV 2 393

( $$$ )4(czs§iì�Z�}c†)Z¾mÔ£â]ZzgÃz){(ÆQz6�)Zke~”h§�Zzg Ò×n^l (¯D�X ����� ÎðYCìZzgÄZÆk6t#Ö)

ÎgÂVÔxZâVÔÂ1VÔ Å 0u Ά�á Z_g»DgìXkÅ´#ÖÔÄZÆ‚B‚B£â]Zzg‰Z»'Æ*ñV©�‰ZÖp6̯�~ˆìX1ZkLLQßwóóÅ7g~§b

(Ðøzx�Zzg}k ' k) è 0È~Ì7ňX‰£â]6ÄZÆkÔ´#Ö(Î�~ˆìXoƒå�7V§iZ(gHY@X $$$ 6�)

)5(‰£â]6Z�}c†£Ð‘‰�),]:826Ô936Ô146Ô666(19£â]6ZyÆa¬xZEwHŠìXZ�}c†¬x„Ðr

X ¤s X �à X \g X -g\ :� oƒìZ%Qy6Zq�¯�~YñX

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^28

Page 82: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)6(¹ÐZÖpÆZ5~;}�oZzg;}“p»ZqÐigzZ7g3ŠqÑèŠ*§¯óglÆ'@ÔZ[;}�oZzg;}“p~zZãZqÐiÃZq0‡°}Å

~Z,ZÖp:y�zÔ&¡çzzÃÔOZzwÔ\¡çI

Ô%îÔ}gZÔyw Ò×n^l wq݃_ìXz){ÃZk§brec:h�zÔ$zzÃÔCÙZzwÔàÔ%ëÔøgZÔhwz){X

Z�ágt /

ÆWy~ZVg{,]»ZqZ�ágtÌ�áïìXËÌZë�~cÄ~ Ò×n^l

ù´~Z�ágbÅ¢zg]zZÃ�eZ•Òy7ÔÉZ[ÂCÙÂ[Æ‚BZ�ágt*¦kƒ@Yg;ìÔ1Z�ágbŸeHƒãec?ZkÆ£œHƒV?ZzgZÐÁ

ZÃ�e è QßßVZzgçZ*ÅgzÝ~%AHYñ?@�z{ÇsV~!%ÔÃðÌZ�ágtÔ:¬x‡gMZzg:ï™äzZßVÆ Æ é� ZyZñgÆç ƒnX

aÎ�qƒYìXik_·Z�ágtFZ±gÐJ*³ìZzgZ�ágbÅ » Ò×n^l Z\kì�

~Ô gz ZÃ�ezseÃ7gZ™äЇÜìXZkÅã�~{òtì�Zk~{àgzZ"ZôïZzguu~6лx1ŠìX¨ù¦tÔ¡zZ÷�ZzgïzD±ÆÁÐÁ£/£gÐÌ�ÛzFìX‰£â]6Â%AÔD%æEOzù]Å©à&¢

C1 Ð̬g~ÃW@ìXPU5±Ù:‚ióó èè )1(Z�ágt‚iÔ/VÆpz|xÐ*zZ�ìÔ}LL�su

LLpÈZuZLWY@ìWy�l~óó m701(Ðou»jZ!Z~HŠìX Ò×n^lV )LL�§6óó)m561(ZzgLL(|Æ6Ðì )m162(ÐoZuZL»jZ!Z~HŠìX

tc¶î0�+zzíóó)m653(Ð�gÒ6»jZ!Z~HŠìXLLªZVì1ZÔ�~Wc¹VЃVóó)m044(»jZ!1Z#ÆO}1Z¹gÆ��cŠìXÂYzh

ÆZkY}~6zW·-÷‹]Æó*yLLZ�ágt;}¯xZDwóó Ò×n^l Z�ág› 1DÔZDw�7791Y:m024D144(ÐÌZ.�{HŠìX e†.ô+Ø )

38Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 83: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)794±å(»jZ!YzhZDwÆ��g`HŠìXF»È¢ã)m253(»jZ!|]¢yñÆ��g`HŠìX

m7966ÄZyLLZâÁóóÆ‚B¯~ÂLL�óó�ŠìX Ò×n^lV )2(С�´%Z�¢!Ç*¹ìX'×hÀ»!ì�%Aä�gc�V ZâÁ

)gZz~ÔIÔtVÔ�ÛZ]Ô��[(NhzV)ZæÔø!(àzV)]{ÔckÔÆÔæÜÔŒÛ\ÔZ¥|(qgZ])gcn2wÔêû(Zzg(Z�ZgzV)‰`-ãzg;ÔÍg»Ò

è уg(ÆjZáÌLL�óóÅfs~�g`K�XŒÛ\Æ�ÔàŒÛ\ZzgKŒÛ\ÆjZáqY�g`K‰�X

ZÓãZzgzik~Ã�]Æ��g`HŠìqÑèZÓãÔ*cð!°}»áZ�sìZzgzik~Zq\»*xìX�àÆic�{FjZá�àÆ�1PLLZq˜VW!�óóÆ��g`K‰�X

Z�ágtógä‰Z�Æ‚BÔQyÅwc£xz%¥ÅÜZsÆ )3(aÔzZz+~Â#ZÖpÉ�b�Ô}:

èZ�)"6„( D12D]45å HEHw)Zôm(3D�)à»*x(4D"54hé EGHI)*»�g�á²z�(

Zy~ЉzŸ¬ '×h'WV X tÂí]ÔZ�ágtógÆ�ÛZø~�áï7�áÑâg: X ZkÆ'@˜VzŸs£[¶)}ŒÛ\:àcK X )�1Ô2Ô3(ß�

!rcDZzg´‘(z;V±7ňXZ,�zc�zÐiZZZ�Ã)�Zq„¿Ô£xÔqcªÃªCÙ™D�Ô )4(

ñ.ÔæX@ÔYX�Û�zkÔ¼Ô0XñðÔ�yX�á�Ô×iXWë[ÔÎgX }ƒäe454è XGGXZ%Wy~ z){(¦™�cŠìÔt�g„7ìXCÙ*xÆjZáZµZµ

:ñ.Æ�,]Æ »Ìf™ƒ*ec:} (cross references) �ðjZßV

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^48

Page 84: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

��}™Wy~�Yñ:'×h�&À�/õ GG:æXZϧbæÆ�,]Æ��}™Wy~�Yñ:'×h�&À�/õ GG:ñ.X

„CÙXRZÖpÆjZßVÃqY™�cŠìÔqÑèZyÅâÎZq )5(�zu}ÐZìXZy~ЉZ�}c†Ô‰Z�}fZ]Ô‰Z�}ø½

kVÔ‰Z�}ªZzg‰Z�}¦�Ô}:˜$Ô˜$~X5äÔ5ä~XFuÔFÅXÝxÔÝòX�áxÔ�áòXGÔ¬@XzíÔzƒ43ïEGGX"ìENGÔ"ìENG—{XuâtÔuât�ZgX

454è XGG ¦sÔß°X�ÔoÔCKÔÓ#ÖXZk§bÆjZáZµZµ�g`ƒäeYèZy~Љ�]Æ�WNÐÔ�:˜$Ô5äX‰ñç¬]Æ�WNÐÔ�:¦sÔ5ä~ÔCKÔzƒ43ïEGGZzg‰ZâÁÆ��:�áxÔFÅX

¼�Zë�]Æ*xÔÄZyÅz„~�áï7K‰Ô}:Ð)¢ã )6(m504(gZx)m77XÄ»ñçq„gZxÅ,ìXZ�ágb~ Ò×n^lV �ÛâVgzZX

gZxÆ‚BzZz+~gZxPgYÌrecX(")m081XzZz+~»ª~Å(X 83 0 ÜZs™ãecX(-)m

Úíˆá Ãg3ìÔ|xcp6g7HXæk è )7(%AäÜsªCÙ~ZÖpÃ7"Ç)m056(Ã{ è "+CÐö

GEOZzg[ è )m621(²[Æzg)631(csy)081(æ

Á)m67(6g™ÆZ¹ZZnK�†ZØ�gÔW8gåÔ|]©[Ô»gwâg¾Zzg�Û;�Æ�ÔZkÜZsÆ‚B�g`™*ecå�tFZIP™{�]Æa�X

‰ÄZ*]ÔZ�ágb~ñ���1ZyÆFjZág^‰�}:p�~: )8(m153Ô495Ô826Xå:m701XZuZ>:m033Ô595XFu:281Xª#Ö:m225X³õ MQ:m775X3È:m46Ô86Ô201Ô971Ô612Ô414X˜�:m412X

‰Z�zZÖpÆ‚BZ,,]��g`K‰�ÔX6Zy»*xz¶y )9(²:69X }:æ:134Ô126Xgzx:261Xsi:536Xp�~:203Ô943Ô344Ô636Ô086X ñ��7

ik_·Z�ágb»�Zz>ZyLLñçqóóƒÐic�{*³ìX%A )01(

58Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 85: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ä‰ñç¬]É™a�Zzg‰gh�b�XZkFuzZ(g»£gHì?�%AÅßZ[�hXZq§sÂLLsÄf[óóZzgLLziexWs�~ZÆóó�ñçq)��g

|ñçqBäÆ�7(‡ìK‰�X�zu~§s"p�~Ôiâ:Ô¹gÔ¡]Ô†VÔ°wZzg)wZ,Zëñç¬]ÃÃZ0Zi™�cŠìXZk{~ZDwÆÄ~ùúVÆjZá�b‰�ÔqÑè´,]6Qy»f™¨LLÂ[óóWc

Æ��g`”{ijZßV~Ð0õjZá �…] ô e^Þ- ìÔ:�LLñçqóóXÆO} �…] ô e^Þ- )m:35Ô521Ô951Ô071Ô602(¬ß�ÔYèZy»mÂ[

�gZóóƽ~pLLpÅWzZióóÐìX è LL!8ÔZZ‡qÕ÷Zzg{ñVÐ%æFNìXZkÆÛ[» Ò×n^l ¿t�Z�ág›

÷ZÔZÃ�eÆUÐic�{ziãìXZkZ�ágbÅ¡zoÅÚÔZq*Z�ágtÆ Ò×n^l F'kÐ *¸ Z\k*u!]tì�tZ�ágt X %A™*Ôic�{W‚yƒÇ

‚B¾g;ìÔ1ËÃ)øw*ÑÔÎwZÐÔ%AZzgf}ZD1](tZˆk7ìX „g hQ �ÛzÈoøg}dZzgó£gÅH¼

Å Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù ÐZµ™�becX Ò×n^l øg}ìw~ZkZ�ágbðZ|gÔZ�ágt‚i~Æa¡/2ÐzZ/»°7ÔZkÆaZD1]ÆDÆ‚B‚Bðh~Ïù]Ì�g»gìXt»xf}ZD1]ÅôZã~ƒ*ecÔ�Z�ágb

‚BÔZk»7gZuSîñç¬]Åz„Ô%A™}XQt»x Æ é� Æ£œÆçZ�x�}X ÃðŠ/»gZzgDqZ�ágtóg

~Z5ZzgZk Ò×n^l ÐtZ0Zi{Î*Â7� 1C ÆZk¿ÐY} Ò×n^l

ÒpЯxZDwà Ð0]U�V»XZ_gZzg§�Z]»DgìXZ�!Zzg/»�gzqÝì)Zzgz‰Ü¦gäÆ‚BÔZDwÅ�LƒCYñÏX(´) S÷�

ZDwÐo]z�ZzgZyƯxÅ�wÉÆ:ÔZyÆZÃgÔQg�zƬx‡g~Ãg;ìXQg�zZzgÃgÏZ5Æ9)bÂ�u�Ô‰ºm è7 Ò×n^l �VÜsQg�z 1D

Z1Z[~ÅYñÏX g{ ÃgÏZÖpÆZ5Ð0Zñg6cÔW

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^68

Page 86: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ô¯ÄZDwÆæÌ°=ÐÔZy~Ô»zlz�Ð g{ Æzg›i!y�XW1C „%ä»»x�}ÇZzgZÏÅÇÅYñÏX Ò×n^l %AHYäzZÑikc$g@î EE0

Zka.e¢zg~ì�QyÓxZñgÃÔXŶy�„Zz6ÅTg~ÅY_ìÔ¤ÏÐik¨gÑ™Dz+zZ5Æî¸Z°zQßw%AzEKYNZzgZyÅ

Zzg9¯»g™}Ô& »ZqR Ò×n^l]ö…�æ gzÝ~f}ZD1]»Zq1geÔ£g~ŒÛZg�}™gZòHYñZzg!¹Óx°ázuŒÛZg�}�bYNX

]Îf^Ön^lViË`nÜæ gZ¶ÆZq*yLL¯ÄZDwÅ£g~Dz+zZ�á®óó)˜!ÔZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔуgÿ5002Yþ(ÐikcZÅ'×hzŸsƒCìZzg irˆmä

Ü™D�: �V ë ZqcZ ´ ¼6ï]‚tWD�XèÃg{*yÐËyZ!ÅZ&b'z‰Ü:ÅYñÂZkÐ'×hyZÒVÀg�XgZ¶ä2891Y~¯rq~ÔFK¯x~’pÔZ5ÔÂ"Zzg�!VŶy�„ŶX1*ÑÅ"*i~Ô"Z²ðZzg³…p[ì�ZÌJQyÅZ&bŧsÂz7�~ˆX

1FK¯xÃ$% 0991YÆZDwZ»�ò~Z5ÔÂ"Zzg�ZÝoÂ�g„™�~IÅ�$®Ô«!grq~Z(gŶÔZ»�ò~ÌZkÅcz~ňX$g@î

EE0Å�záVÃoƒ£â]6v e^Ùôqf†mØ Æló~¹Šì�ëä Z»�ò

™�c'qÑètLZÙwó¯rq„~ƒ[åÔW\äÂÜsZkÅcz~ÅìXL£g~ Q¹Šì�LZk![~ëä£g~gzZ`ÃFß�~óXÎZwtì�rqù

gzZ`óƒŠ?ZzgH´)ZDwŇì™�{FK¯x6L£g~gzZ`ólxì?)m672(

ÆaZec�áù™gì�X0Îã*Ñ+äÌ Ò×n^l }¸g]~Z*Ñ+ZÏ 1D�áùK�Ô©�ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÆ�áù Ò×n^l ZÏ)rq(ZecÆ_.„¼�

ÅFK~ÌZÏ)rq(ZecÅÇňìXÿ-VgZ¶ä Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(]…�æ ™�{0891YZzg2891Y~T}Ú»ZÖgHåÔ0991Y~z{n‚tWŠXþ@ëZ»�òZec

ÆZÍw@Wy e^Þ-ô�…] )6�ë�âd~f™™`�(!±§Q9¯ìXZk~]ZexVÅZqtÃZDwÅZqÒnÅæ�Ð�g„™�cŠìXÄLL'ÅÍ�~©�N™óóÆ0v,Ä~LLCóó�g„ìÔ:�LLm|óóX

ðýýðýýð

78Qg�z¯xÆù´

Page 87: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

[:2 !

ÃgϯxÆù´

�ý�ý�ý�

98ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 88: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwÅÃgÏÍð ( Z³ )ZyÅ IZi,tf™W[ì�ZDwÅÀòà]ÅãŠÔZyÅQgŠz�á²~¶Ô@ë

ù¦ÃeZBÔÂHzªÔŠzâVZ±gÐZDw»ÃgϯxÔZyÆQgŠz¯x �á²~6C1 6qz~ìX

ÔZyÆ;VÃgÏÍð»gDy ÆZ0g ZDwÅ�á²~»W¸iQgŠz~ƒZÔ1P‚wÅ (Æ£«~ÃgÏ �…] ô e^Þ- 91YJÔQgŠzÆZqù´) 34 ZkŠgF¹™Š�( ÚŠ^ʆ Zzg q^æm‚Þ^Úä Ô ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Ô µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ Ô …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p Ô ]‰†]…ôìç�p iÂÁ)

�áùƒ_�XÃgÏZDwÅâŠg~i!y¶Zzg:±i!yÔZkÆ!z�ŠÃgÏÍðŧsQyÆ)©à~yÅz�{H�?ZyÅÃgÏÍð»W¸i“ƒZ?ZzgQZyÆZk‘Zzg~y~YV™ZŸ†ƒ@Š?tZñgËŠgcÔ�X

ì�ªÄZàyÆiâä~Zq!gÔ¼Šz2VäZDw 2C �†ZØŠg»ÒyÐÃgÏZÃg‹äÅ�ÛâöÅXZDwämg]Å�Q,VäZqWŠ|ÄÆÎZÔLÃgÏ~¼ìÅÃÒ7ÅÔ1¸!]ÔZDwÆaÃgÏÍð»&?çOu0ˆZzgQ,V

ä äŠz2VÅèÃg{>ÐzZ:W™ggÃgÏ~ŠzçB¶î MeZBX�†ZØŠgZkzZîÐ�³)LLZDwÅÃgÏÍðÅZ’Zóó(Z~HìÔz{ËZ±gÐÌ™T

7ìXZDwÅt!]�Q,VäZqWŠ|ÄÆÎZLÃgÏ~ÄìÅÃÒ7ZàyÆiâäJÔZyÆÃgÏZÃg~ÐÁZi ªx ÅÔ¡Zy»ØZzgZÎgåX

‚y7ìX W é‰ �XŠg|ZyÅÃgÏÍðÆ$©�î EG0W¸i»îç 3C ÁZqÎ~iôp

:m004 ]Îf^Ù(‰gÒ1Ön1 1D:m61 �…] ô e^Þ- ŠâpÔ 2D

:m51 ]Îf^Ù]æ…Ê^…‰o�Æ] D3

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^09

Page 89: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwÅÃgÏÍð~Ô¹ÐZñgÊ4ì:ZDwäZ’Zð½gzZî§iÅŠ*ŠgkǃV~qÝŶXZy»icŠ{z‰Ü

ñß~÷ŒÆ�~¦gZÔ�ñß~Z'Z�÷(ÈKÆ–w:LL²!ÃgÏi!yŠgkÇ{¶X÷ŒÃgÏÆ85å EGO¬Ý¸ZzgÃgÏÄzZŠ[»geƒZfztgn Å C1 ó ŠZãó

Ô �mç]á ¸XZyÆZq�ᤊeZËÂZgZg»Òyì�:fZCîg6Z¹pZzqƒ»Z¹DÙZgzV C2 Zzg²°ÆŸZicŠ{I¸X ‰Óß‚…Þ^Úä ÔÂò» Ú%ßçp ñÑ*gzxÅ

Zzg � C3 ZÃgâ¿i!yÔ!]!]6Ä7_ZzgŠzgZyDgö'ûZÃg‹DXjwÆZz‡]ÆÌÔZDw»icŠ{Fz‰Ü÷ŒÅÄ~¦g@åÔ2Vä

C4 ZDwÅË~ÃgÏ�á²~»fzt¢™ŠcXZDwZyÐZõƒ;Æ2s�XZDwÆ�ÆZqŠz„LLŠeóó»Òyì:

: eç‰j^á z +׊j^á ZDwÃÃgÏi!yйicŠ{Šw8o-ö FF¶X!g{‚wÅ/~ZkäÜsZi'™à�ÔÉz{�ZK¸‹qCÅ$zªÃgÏÅZyŠzâVÂ1VÐ$

C5 7Jc™@å'ZDw�QgŠzZzgÃgÏÅ>ÑxÑx™‹c™@åXZkâjw~ÔZDwäÃgÏ~'g]aZ™äÆaJœÅXZy»ZC

Òyì:ßÍVÃÀƒ@ì�ZDwÃÃgÏYV™WˆÔZ�ZkäZjwc»Ò~ti!y77S?Z¹t¥x7�~äÃgÏi!yÅÆaZjw„Æiâä~¾

C6 ŠgœZVðZzgÄZ‚E{ÐZ.Š{HX

:m391 ]Îf^Ù ô …æ]m^l 1D:m55 Zs 2D:m06 Zs 3D�á§ægZÏÆ*xZqâ~��:ñß~±÷ŒLL(})gv¬ÝZzgÄû�X~ 4D

:m37( ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù äZ-ÐZõƒ;HìXóó)91YX 94 Ô22BZ6s ]Ú†æ‡ 5D

m343 : ÔZÍw ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä gzZe:Z‡MãÔ D6

19ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 90: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwÆZ’ZðZÃg„~ZkœÆWUgñ�Š�XŠz§¤dÅÄLL#—¸xóó)6981Y(~Ãg8ÆZ’ZðWUgÃWD�XLL*Èî0dóó)0091Y(ÔLLd»æ[Ô

~tZWicŠ{�ZƒŠìXu†ZØŠgà 1C hwÏÐóó)1091Y(ZzgLLZ]ëILpVóó)1191Y(†g~1091YÅÄLLø!óóÆXŠzúcVUƒV»ZˆkƒZÔZy~ÐZqZëUÔÄÅ

XZyQgŠzV~¼ŠÃgÏ^´Zzg‰(7g}Æ7g} å 2C LLÃgÏÈ/óó�XZzZb2091YÅÄLLZsð»Ò»æ[›âVÐóó~zZãîg6 ñ�Š ÃgÏÄ

Zˆkƒ@ì�ZDwÆ;VÃgÏÍð»gDy!~ÐF¹™g;ìXZkÄÆCÙÈ»Wy~ÄZzgŠg{ZÃg6�Wy~7gZÈÃgÏ~ìXZÏiâäÅÔÒuZ`Z−+Ã

ÆÎ!ZÃgÃgÏ~�Zzg�‚]QgŠzZÃg6ÌÃg8» 3C %ÏÔ32ZÃgÅZqÄ„ìX¼-VCkƒ@ì�iZÃg�ÆÔQgŠzÔZÖ§ìwz_!]~âú

ƒä»Z´yHÔZk 4C ƒðÔ®Z‚Â,Ä~�á²ä‡B$w™LLÃgÏ~ÏpZVóóÆQgŠzÅÚÃgÏ~icŠ{LLÑ—œgóóÆ‚BZÖ§_!]HŠìX

Z¤pZDwÅà]»!ZyÅQgŠzàâ]�Ô@ëZyÆÃgϯxÆŠwŠZŠÇyÌM®ZŠ~ñ�ŠÔOç43ZÃgÅÃgÏÄLL3k»[Z÷óó�áù™D

äZDwÆÃgϯxÆaLLZx[Æ»çVóóZzg 5C )†g~5091Y( Úíˆá ƒñLLZx[ÆZÜZgóó»f™HXZàyYäЬżŠQgŠzV~S»™»ÃgÏ

øgZìw È/ZzgF^Zzg¨ù¦¢ÃgÏg8ñ�ŠìX ZÃgÔ´ÔÃgÏ,]�ZZnK8Ô9Ô81Zzg381 V ‰†æ�ô…Êjä egzVV»Q5±Ù: 1D

:m31 �…] ô e^Þ- ŠâpÔ 2DÔZÍw:m61@91 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D

q:ƒV/p&ÿGL¸Z°ÔÃgÏ~ÏpZV 4D»â^:LLfsÅÄŠg`™ÆW`ëZyZx[Æ»çVÐ%ŠzlƒD�Ô� Úíˆá 5D

6zWZDw™rÆÃgϯxÆaZÒŠiZ$tªCÙH™D�XÃgÏ>À˜ƒ'Ô@ëZx[ÆZÜZgÐëZÐ@›*ø+™D�óóX)m74( 7 ~Šg` Úíˆá

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^29

Page 91: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zk~y~ÔñÑ*¤ZòÐ5‡ÂVZzgQyÅgVÆZWZ] ì�ÃgÏŧsìeC1 ¹ZÌgn�X3091Y~ZDwÆ;V¤ZòƪxÅÞŠ]ñ�ŠìÔ

©]ZzgÌŠ*ƒVZzg>WgZðƒCƒXÆe~Q,Vä�Ã|ÅÔZk C2 ªÄZàyÆŠzgZy~ÔZL£á

C3 ÐZDw»ÃgÏfztZzgÌ¢ƒŠXÐá\÷

IOì�z{ÃgÏ~ÄìÑÔ@ët 4C ¾HÃ'ç NÏÔZqÃgÏçw¢zgì�ZÌÅg~îg6Zzg¤ÏÆ‚Bz{ÃgÏÍðŧsáz7ƒñ¸Zzg

QÏgzifgZÏÂz 1 C5 ZÏaQ,VäZx[Æ‚tÃgÏZÃgÐmzg~ªCÙÅÔÐQ,VäÃgÏ~ŠzçB¶î MeZBZzgÃgÏÍðÆaZyÆZ0gZOŠ(JX-g\ÐzZ36ÔLrgƒâg7g~ÔÃgÏƇŠgZæx�á²ÔñÑ*¤ZòÐÄÍðÅ

…'0ƒC�Xu†ZØŠgÅèÃg{!ÑÔŠz2VÅ>ÆÔtŠzuZñµå�ZDwÆŠw~ÃgÏÄÍðÅpZéaZƒðX†Z+mâßZe{»Òyì�Zqx²}

LL=eZË ÆZ!x6ÔT~ñÑ*¤ZòäÃgÏZzgZDwäQgŠzZÃg‹ñ¸:÷± C6 ÃgÏ~ÄìÑzq™ŠzVóóX ™rä¹:�’Ô~eLƒV�~Ì

g\~ ÔÃgϯZŠ[Å!‡°{ZzgQ- ‰ 鉒 ŒZ,ÃgÏÆ85å EGO¬ÝÐZDwÆZDw ²!ZzgÃgÏÆŠ*EĦsz,Æ_¬Æ:©~ÔÃgÏÍðŧs: ÅgÉÃZyÅÄÍðÆZg»ÅZqš~'ecXxV†Z+mâßZe{ë�

ÔZÍw:m9 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1DDevelopment 2D:m61 �…] ô e^Þ- ŠâpÔ 3D

Zkçw»ªÄì: D4Z}Éi{§WgizWiZŠag¦ø0L

âŠyø0L è Âëi{¿Z,mâ#m31( :Letters to Atiya)

:m61 �…] ô e^Þ- ŠâpÔ 5Dm126 : ÔŠc7791Y ÔZDw�2 ÞÏç� D6

39ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 92: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

eZË™rÃgÏ~¶î M™÷}0k�Šc™,ÐZzg~Zk { WytðƒZ�WÒ¯xäZò™rÅZ&bÆÔZyÃzZ:™Šc™zVÇ'Zk§b&%ûZDwƯx6¤Zò™rä�Z&bŠ~Ôz{~äeZË™rÃуgzZ:™Š~X«Ši'¤Zò™rä¹å:�ÔtÃgÏ~Ìp[¾ÇXŠzu~ŠiìÑ:¹

�{X�~ŠiQ,Vä¹:W\ZyÃK�Z[÷}0kz{ZC¯x:CÔpŠ„ÃC1 Uã™1™,X

]‰†]…ôìç�p '2C rÑzqÅ ]‰†]…ôìç�p ZÏiâä)11D0191Y(~´)ZDwä191Y(~QgŠzÍð»ŸÌYg~g;Ô1Zk~ÃgÏ»ZW¹úcVìX 0 1D 5 ÆŠzg)

ÃgÏ�á²zVÆúVZzgÄzV6$|)43ðGE

GEV»Úƒ(k Zzg 7g}7g}ÃgÏZÃg1 C3 LL4}góóÐvÅS™gì¸Ô è ~Ôz{qƒ ]‰†]…ôìç�p ŠXZq§s

Šzu~§sQgŠzàâ]~ËÌŠzu}ÃgÏ�á²Æ£«~qƒÆÄzVZzg�áhZka�F‚w¬ÔªÄZàyÆŠzgZy Ô úV6×icŠ{$|)454è

GEGEG™gì¸

k™`¸X C C4 ~ZDwÔgz—qƒÃZKÄ~,~Öw™@ZDwÆZòƒÃgÏÍðÆK~ÔP™{!ÑZñgÆ´z{ÔZkZ%ÃÌúcV

Š4ìÔ�LL"5½5é GEYE}QgŠzóóÔZyÆZ°gz_!]Å37ƒ$˶XZq!gÔZkÎZwÆ�Z[~�:LLÃgÏ~�»ìwW\þ§bWcóó?ìÑ:LL~䊬å�

]‰†]…ôìç�p tÞŠ]Ìñ�Šì� Q C5 ÃgÏ~÷}ìÑ]Zh§bZŠZƒM�óóXm126D226 ÔŠc7791Y: ÔZDw�2 ÞÏç� 1D

:m052 +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù 2D4}g è ƒâgZiqƒ 3DâtŠZg u ZV è YêZiiCÙ

m66( Ô :TZÍw ]‰†]…ôìç�p ):m473(Ðt™äƒZ�ZDw ÊÓ†ô]Îf^Ù eZË-Š@{VÃцZÔÆZqãÒy) 4D

:m21(XŠg|t!]ZDwäZq u^ÊÀ]æ…]Îf^Ù ät!]Ñ™rн¶X)m51X :Letters to Atiya 5‡]ÆŠzgZy~Ô¾Hн¶XŠ&ÀŸ/õ GG:

:m05 �$^…ô]Îf^Ù 5D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^49

Page 93: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¬UQgŠz~�ÑzqŶÔ1Šà_ªCÙ™ä~Â7WðÔZkaÃgÏDwÅÀòà]QgŠz�á²Å¶X¸�ZkZˆkÆ�Ô�ZyÅZÍAÄ~ Z C1 Z(gÅX

Â[ÃgÏ~ŠN™Ô�á@zƒVÐÔZDwäZKÃgÏÍðÅtÂä7Å:§¯%§Šg~è,FZ„

Zkè´»ZqZëUtì�Š±ìÑ]ÆZÖgÆaÔQgŠzÅÚÔÃgÏ»uâ›ZÖp}icŠ{ìZzg–ÁZDw:LLÃgÏ~FL}Zzg¿‚‘~e|ƒñ

t!]Z¤pZDwä C2 Z,X�ÔXÆ_.QgŠz~L}eJ%W‚y7óóX6¤ZòÃè¶�:LLÃgÏŧsicŠ{~yƒ@Y@ì ÅŠ)âÞ4191Y( ]‰†]…ôìç�p

ëF‚w¬ÌÔt!]ZÏŠg9¶X Ô@C3 Zzgzztì�Šw»ggQgŠz~ïw7YóóÆ´z{ÔÃgÏÆzW7ÒªîG0ZW»ìwÌÔZDwÆf‚~ 7‚ãF− ìÑ]Å

C4 Æ´z{ÌtLLŠ*ƹДV~ªYC¶óóX x åÔYè'Zz6f™W[ì�†Z+mâßZe{ƉÐÔZDwäñÑ*¤ZòÃÃgÏZÃg

Š3ñXZkLLtgÒKóóäWÐ^™!bZ.Š{zZõ[Å×zWßg]Z(g™àX¤ZòÔZÌуgWDÂZDwÆ;VªxgLÔÄÍðƒCZzgÄ~gñizï]6czIƒÌXZDwÔñÑ*¤ZòÅÃgÏŠZãZzg‡ŠgZæòƇb¸ZzgZÏa

�Ñð B ZòÆ*x31 ¤C5 èV~ÌZ¹!g!gZL¯x6û{zWÅŠú]ŠïX»f™™Dƒñ��: ]‰†]…ôìç�p 4191YÆâ~ZDw

t�~!Ç5ìÔpW\Ð5‡]ƒÂW\ÃZkÆZÃg‹ƒVX=¢ìÔW\ZÐÍ™plƒVÐXvÔZŠOW仓Jpì?~Zq²áÐW\»³

6C ó ƒVX}ZgZ¢W�ÔƒÐ(Z»xÂtì�W™÷~�~%ZzgZk~tg{ŠØXó:m651 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 1D:m05 �$^…ô]Îf^Ù 2D

:m99 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 3D:m61 �…] ô e^Þ- ŠâpÔ 4D

:m721Ô491Ô991z){X ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 5D:m89 Zs D6

59ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 94: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZKàâ]ZzgÄ~£?ÃWy~^ŠïƒñÔZDwä¤ZòÆ´z{‰ÆtgzVZzg C2 ÑzZã V ZzgÔZ°Ý{ C1 DçÜ+}±Ñy0z~ è Šzu}ZI

Zy»ZC_·Ì.ezWZzgW~Åg¹¢åXZÖpz X WzVÐÌÃZ{ZVcõzgZ]ZzgFZIÆZEwZzgZyÅïÆe~Š*Z‚E{Ưxc¹Ð

C3 ÃgS¶X è Å�$åO e`^…ôÂrÜ ZPŠ™DX¹~!kxZDwäÃgÏÄzZŠ[ÆzW_¬ÐÔ�!�ZWZ]JwKÔZkÆ

'×h'WVÃgÏ�á²~Æ C4 ~½ã,ÆŒÛdÄZÔZyƯx~èÃg�X ËúVZzgÄzV6$|)43ð

GEGEVÔFZWZzgŠv@WZ]Jw™äÆÒpÐÔZDwÓxQgŠzÄZÃgÏ�á²~ÐZDwÅ!�ZW5k~~qƒZzggzòÆ*xƒ C5 z„�X è ~u

ÐúcV�X~ZDwäqƒ6”hWŶ:LLYèZyÅ�á²~ä›âV ]‰†]…ôìç�p

/Z±gÐz{qƒÃ�0t�á²B 1 C6 ÆZzo~Ô�gZqKÆÔ»xHìóóÔ)TZÍw(~Q,VäLLƒâg ]‰†]…ôìç�p zgpŠZyÆ�á²Z:HÆZ§¸X Z C7¸X

4}góóÐW¸i™DƒñÔqƒ6�š~WÅÔZk~Ìz{qƒÆcZ› è ZiqƒÒyÆYŠzÐMWƒñ%:g{nXZy»tq:LLZiŠzYxWÇ”Š*§Zzóóqƒ

ì: C8 ÆqgzfsÄÐâpfuplZi,Š„�¼™Š¯{ è ß°

$zYÄŠ¤WÇØŠŠ*glÔZÍw:m58 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D

:m7 Zs 2D:m98@79 Zs 3D

:m22 ]Îf^Ù]æ…Ê^…‰o�Æ] 4D:m04 Zs 5D

:m371 ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù 6D:m661 Zs 7D

:m31 u^ÊÀ]æ…]Îf^Ù 8D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^69

Page 95: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwÆÃgϯx6ù¦wÐÃeZBÔÂt|WDgƒCì�qƒÆZË-Š e C1 W}»ZW´)ZDw6Óx/g;X èŒ FIZzg èŒ ZºZqÔ è ÒyÔŒ èŒ

@{V��:Z¤pÑzq~ZDwäqƒ6WŶÔpˆ~ZkäCkH�ZKÑeÃ

¸W¯äÆaqƒ»cZ›ÒyZ(g™*¢zg~ìÔOçZkäqƒÆC2 zQ|[»Åg~îg6âHX ‰ §i

è y~ÃÃZ0Zi™ÆÔÇ è &43üGGEOÅg~ƒc)Åg~ÔtZ%!hÐêOì�ZDwä%

²Z¹Åcz~Z(gÅZzgZyÆQ|[z®6qƒÆZWZ]ÐZïge è qƒ~Ô%qƒÆ„~UÛâVÆa¢gg‚VKÆ!z�ŠÔZqZd è 7XZDwÄ

C3 gìX ŠgZÆ�á²ÅwÐÔZyÅÑÆ2sZzgZyÅ°p~g¥ZuyÅŠzŠgXÐiZZë§bZzgëi}çßVZzgù¦îg6ZDw ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Zzg µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

ÅçßV~qƒÆg8zW}ÔZyÆgñizìZzgZyÆZ7gzVZzg)-VÊBÂZDwÅZk!]~¼icŠ{I¾Ck7ƒ@�:

¾~f}K~ìÑZƒèZi~ŠZ4 �mç]áôu^ÊÀ цZÔ��:LLZDwÅÃgÏçBZ+��Z¤ZyÃ

Zk!]ÃI¾ C4 ™ŠcYñÂ7"zZáqƒÆ¯xÐZk»ZqÐi:™ÃÐóóX−ÔAÌ6zW·ëgÆ_.Ô´)ZDwÆŠg†VZÃgÆK~Z(I

C5 !ÇŠg„ƒÇX

:m7 ¡Úä]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰oƈ٠6zW·ëgÔ 1D:m7 u^ÊÀ]æ…]Îf^Ù 2D

5±Ù: 3D:m081 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo )Z³(

:m371 ÚÏ^Ÿl]Îf^Ù )[(:m911 Stray Reflections )`(

:m473 ÊÓ†]Îf^Ù 4D:m67 ¡Úä]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰oƈ٠5D

79ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 96: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

gzx è ÃÔ„~Z±gÐZDw6ƒÐicŠ{ZWc è ®ÔQ|[Zzg�á²Z:UÐs»ìXtf™W[ì�gzòÅ�~Ô´)÷ŒÅ&Ih{Â1V~�áï¶Xgzò

ZqãŠ~KìXZqz‰ÜZ(ÌWc�Q,V ‰ 鉒РÐZDwÆ„~m~÷Œ¸: ~ÌZ¹ŒÛWã_ÃWD Ú%ßçp özŠ™1X J C1 Ú%ßçp Zzg Ά�á äZC_·;

Ã/w½U~ŒÛWVâ“Zz{§]z»Ñ]Åë{SVÅÕ[¤ð™D�ÂZuZ§§]ÆZÏs»ZZL%”ÔgzòÆu!0_�:

ZizWñ»ZuZ§YVð~Zy»Ôgzò„ÅgZ{úð~ðƒ@ìZzgWy~YzhÃÌZyŸ q^æm‚Þ^Úä

Ãì�:gZ{‚i è gzògZg= ècC2 @}Z+Bhå EEIFZÎiz¢Zi

I¾Wöì:  ±zikZd¬$~ÅtgZ}ŒÛWyzugÆçë

EL¬DÌZDwäãŠ~îg6Ôgzò„ƉÐa�ÔÉ

f[~ÌZ¹˜V}ÃðNZ(MìÔ�ŸÈî0ñðÆ�ÃW@ìÔQÐ èÕC3 z{gzòŤ&z@GÐJw™D�X

s~Å°p~åg¥ZuygìXh]~ è @ëZk~d->î IEX7�ZDwÔ%”��:

The world of to-day needs a Rumi to create an attitude of hope and to kindle

the fire of enthusiasm for life.4C

Æ gZi]hóó è ¢-öEEOZW5k~J’ŠXLL+ Zzg„~uzVÐ(|™Ô 6f ˆZiZVtZ.Š{Ô

~qƒÆZWZ] µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ Åd~�XLL ÚÃßçp Ú%ßçpô ÎZÔZDwÅÓx�cVÔÔŠzx:m72D82 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D:m802 q^æm‚Þ^Úä 2D

:m61D71 Ú%ßçp…æÚoÚn6 Ô ]Îf^ÙÒ1�ÆpÚ^ì„ 3D97 :m Reconstruction 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^89

Page 97: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~gzòÅÍô׸~ìXZDwÅZyëi}Zzgë§bçßV ‡eç…ôÂrÜ ¸�1~gzòÆz ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Zzg µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ Æ´z{Ô�gzòÅçßVÆâ~½IÔ

ŸÐ�zçßVÅ®ZŠÌ{àìXZDwägzòÆikZW„‚Š{ÒãZzguy~Ågm{»g~ZzgëÏÆ'@ÔZDwZLÜô è Z0ZiZ(gHXÄZ}%

q^æm‚Þ^Úä wÅÃgÏÍð»�á‚g DZ C1 F�X gz×Q|[ÅzzÐgzòÐŒÛd ZzgÚ%ßçpÚçŸÞ^ tÂ[ZDwÆZLZÖp~:LL C2ìX »g8zgz\g� Ú%ßçpÚÃßçp

C3 ŧi6èˆìóóX …æÝ

ZDwÅÃgÏÍð6ƒÐicŠ{ZWZ]ÂqƒZzggzò„Æ�Ô@ëZyÆ;Vn~ÔËwÔ¸Ô²°Ô!!jãÔZ÷ÆzÔ!!¤CÙ²cVÔYòÔ«gÔÄ~Zzg¹Ð

Ë:Ë^~ïYC�XÃgÏÍÄZÆ Ì Šzu}ÄZÆ„zQ|[ÅJVC4 ‚BZDwÆ�á²Z:SgnoÆK~,ÐÌiZZÄZÅz„%AƒCìX

ZDwäZKÃgÏÍðÆZ’ZðŠzg~ÃgÏ�á²~ůgzZc]»&43üGGEOHZzg

Zzg ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ Zk~ÌZyÅÂz�~ZzgçwÅ×=Á¬xZ0sŧsg„XƒÇ »ZqzÔ�ZzgQ|[ÔŠzâVZ±gÐ{µ¯�á²~~Ñg µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñµn^Ýô z�Ñë

ELTä�zQ|[Æ6Š!]»W¸iHX ] 1ÖˆZDwÅ7åEO

si( ó)$™*î EE0‚g!È ~ ‘@[óÔL7å N è ZÜóÔL™î ·góÔLuz› è żŠ>}L` Ú�†Ñ

q^æm‚ ZzgLMó454-ö XGJGŠ1VÆZ±gÐZyÆS$Z¦f‚Å?k�XLL$™*î EE0ïóó)~ÌYg~ì'ZDwf! ÂrÜ è ‡eç… ß]zW}»Zq*Š/ìXtŸ ( Þ^Úä

:m82 ÚvÛ‚]Îf^Ù 1D:m254 ]Îf^Ù(‰gÒ1Ön1 2D

ÔZÍw:m612 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D×_¬Æa5±Ù: 4D

Zi6zW·ëgX ¡Úä]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰oƈ٠)Z³(Zi†Z,gZŒX ]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰o�^†pÒ^ißÏn‚pq^ñˆå )[(

ZieZË·gcnX ]Îf^Ù]æ…Ê^…‰o�Æ] )`(

99ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 98: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:©ZDw»f!ZŠÒ] 6 ÐÌ�~zZ/gn¸XeìÔZyŠ!]»f ZŠ[»zW_·ƒXZkZEVÆatZ$Z¬]¾qw6¸XeZˆZ,gZŒ��:

µn^Ýô ZkZyÅ]h�á²~~�Æ66Š"ƒñ�Ô1Zy»iâ:¬xîg6C1 ÅS®Ðˆ»ìX ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Zzg Ú�†Ñ

„CÙçßV»ù·ìÔ1Zk~ÌZDwÅ8]]ZzgZºZ¦f‚ä ‡eç…ôÂrÜQ,V伊5 C2 Zq*g8Š3cìXz{gzZîçwÆ'@!kx\7�X

FZIðXXgzZîçwÆ�ZzwZÖpÆçã~ÂWÆ‚BZ¹6¢�gHZzg6Zãg'×Ã* ë) DÐ Z óL Ì«KX–w6zW·ëg:L6ZäZ�ág}Ã6xg

%ñiŠcX‚B„¼5Z�ágeÌZºZqÅX¼*y6Zä„gìÔ1ZÖg»cZt*6Z�zZâÁ}�ÛZ%iÔ˜VŠz„Zzg%¼+z){ZDwÅ�Š‹T6 ‰ C3 ƒŠóóX

ŠÑª™D�X6zWWg'~Ô´)ZDwÅÃgÏ�á²~ÆZ-UƒVŧsZ�ág{™Dƒñ��:

Iqbal accepted the ghazal as he found it, with all its age-long rigidity ofform and matter; and with the true touch of genius. He took it one stageforward. While remaining absolutely true to both pattern and image, hegave the form a new meaning by making it express his individualmessage. The ghazal had been put to a variety of derived uses by the oldmasters; the panegyrists had taken the love-motive and directed it to thepatron-flattery; the mystics has used the language of human passion toexpress their devotion to God. Now for the first time the ancient formwas made to clothe the body of a new philosophy. C4

tZkaeƒeå�ÃgÏExZzgÄzZŠ[Ð�zZõ[ÆTe»:m984 ]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰o�^†pÒ^ißÏn‚pq^ñˆå 1D

:m461XLL\�ŬŠ]„7óóX ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 2D:m331 ¡Úä]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰oƈ٠3D

Persian Psalms Šâp: 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^001

Page 99: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ã^~ñß~ÝxŒ™rÆ�ЃZåÔz{jwZzg»ÒÅ!3›Ð+öGO

‰ W¸iÔ(wZzg@»ÒÅâÔªÄ-g\ZzgQZDwÅ&zgZ:Zzggzi%{z5]ÆZcx~ÌYg~g;ÔÉgzi'ziZkÅuzŠzÝ5kƒCg�Ô©�ZyŇŠgZæòZzg'g‹

U"ƒðÔÉZ3ÿXLZkZyÌZk6zƒñXÝx 1Cõè i!yÔ:ÜsZJVÆa!@™ÄAö´ò��:

çãz$]zZ7gZ‹"Z*Š~z'g]ZipŠ è Zz0gÏtŠ{@puŠg è i!ÈZ-C2 ¶yŠZŠ{Z„�Íði!yâŠg~Zz0gÏZ„X

|tì�ÃgÏ�á²~~ZDwÅ5WzZi»ŠZzg�iìX‚ŠÏz‚Š{ÒãZzg¯gzZc]Å0kŠZg~Æ!z�ŠÔZyÆ"!uZz!ŸÔÇÅg#Zzg�ÑãÔ

ZDwÃÔÃgÏ è „~ZzgQ|!S$Z¬]Ô�ZzgFZ0ÌZºZ¬]ÔæáZzgegZâáäÄ�á²~Å@gõ~ZqZ(£x«Hì�Z¹gzZîZ0ZiÆ—ãZzgÄ~Š{âV

~ÐËZqÆ‚BºmzÝ7™MXZkZyÆczs¬ÝZzgŠZøËgeZË@8Œ4-öE

GE»ìwì�:LLZ,�á²Zºm/pŠŠZ“��áhoƒ!”ÔWVgZ¯ÄC3 ZDwlZ4óóX è �á²%

Ë�á²ÆaZq)i!y~ZÖ§ÒyÅZ+Šg]z'g]Åà¢Ô�Z3ÿXLi!yÃÌZ‹Zs™D„¶ÔZq)©à!]ìZzg:ÜsÃgÏZŠ[Å@gõÔ

ɬ@ZŠÒ]~ÌtZq*ŠgVwìX,]~ëZDwÆÃgÏùúVÅZZ�áoV6óÃeZBÐX {ÒW

ðýýðýýð

:m53 u^ÊÀ]æ…]Îf^Ù 1D:m31D41 +Ø è mÔ2Ûà 2D:m551 …æÚoôÂ’† 3D

101ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 100: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÃgϯxÆù´ ([)

ZuZ§pŠ~ /

�Ñð1191YƯ[~Ô´)ZDwg¶§Zi�: B ¾HÆ*x7Father has asked me to write a Masnavi in Persian after Bu Ali Qalander's and

inspite of the difficulty of the task, I have undertaken to do so .1C

¢6»)@ƒZèZi{Ô è Ô� 2C 1¡ZâÏ!]�~»øu:¶X�‚!ªÄ-g\™[zZCZ[Ô�Ëu 6 Zsð»ÀòizZwzZzoZzgZyƒÆË~z{f èI

JLL“{óóZzgLLÓz�á²óóÜVZzgZkiâäÆèo)�§{mkK¯xZºZ[»ZÝøuìXzZÉåLZDwÅ?mÃZ%¯g~øuŒÛZg ]‰†]…ôìç�p (~ªCÙƒZÔ C3 W!Š~

ìÔzg:'gZY¨6�áŠ�áŠÆ*xZqâ~´)ZDwCD��Q,Vä ŠcYY'tZ�ág{ìZkZ%ÅY+ 4C �~ZipŠ7èÔÉZ¹LLZkÃ�Å@Zeƒðìóó

»W¸i“H?ZkÅ ]‰†]…ôìç�p �Z¹Ô�~�6Šg]äâñgHìXZDwäZÍAZzgŠ*F+ÞŠ]¾HÆ*xZDwÆP™{!ѯ[)¸gQ:7�Ñð1191Y(

~Ð ÆPZÃgŠg`K�XZy ]‰†]…ôìç�p ~ñ�ŠìXZkâ~Q,VäZqÄ�V»ÂVZzgŠzZÃgËŠgFçÆ‚BÔ�~ÆZ’Zð{~ñ�Š�X

¯[¯x¾H»�Z½kZz6ÜHŠìÔZkÆWy~¿:I have undertaken to do so.

m37 :Letters to Atiya 1Dz©Z£Æ*xZqâ~��:LL|tì�-g\ÅW[zƒZä=›y™ŠcóóX 2D

:m671 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^ÙÔŠzx:m43D77 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3DÔZDw�ÔZÍw3791Y:m861 ‘vnËä 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^201

Page 101: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ðáiƒ@ì�W¸¯»güicŠ{Šy:¦g}¸ÐeìXW¸iÔ�yÔ�Ñð~�Ñð1191YЬÔË’kcâ~�~»E™{7MX¯',t!]D B X7 ƒ ƒZ

C1 ¥xƒCìÔ�Z¤ë¼úÌáÂÔ�~»W¸i1191YÆÛZÍw~ƒZƒÇX¸�Z’Zðz�ÆÔ�~â+»ŸV»DgƒŠZzgel|Šz‚wÆzMÆ

�Ñð4191YƯ[~� B Ôz{ZiaçLâ�~ŧsázƒñXñÑ*¤ZòÃ31�VLLÑzq™äóóÐÔ¸%ZŠ C2 ‚wZq�~ÔÃgÏ~�ÑzqŶóóX *¸ �:LL

â�~ŧsázƒñXOçZk»icŠ{Fz3191Y è ¢ec�3191Y~ZDwÔZiuC4 9B�Ûzg~5191YÃðX Š C3 Zzg4191Y~–ŠX

è ÖˆÔ9BâÞÃzZ−ÒZDwÅgÔ»qŠX7WcXQŠc~UgHÐ-Ë&ƒZ�Z�á®ÐI è Å^z5]g�X´z{Zi,ÔtZ%Ì: )U¬(

C6 ƒäÆaÔñÑ*¤ZòÐtg}ÆpZ;V¸X 5C ÐCÙ§bLLtóó z{�~¸�ZyZcx~ñÑ*¤Zòуg:WnXpZz³m©~ÃÌ�~Š3*eT¸Ô1

C7 YnX ~:

eZË·gcn��:LLZkÆW¸i»â{z‚w�¥x7Ô1ŒÛZíCD��«kx 1D: é‰ :m93(¹»ç ]Îf^Ù]æ…Ê^…‰o�Æ] ÆÑzqƒäÐIÔZk»W¸iƒ[åXóó)

Dîg6eì'ZϧbeZˆZ?xpgæ»tÒyÌŠg„7�: Â é‰ �Ô‚w»ç:m421( ‰†+„�kô]Îf^Ù Å’k~zsóóX) ]‰†]…ôìç�p LL3191YÐZDw

:m89X¸�Zϯ6eZˆZ?xpgæÃP™{!Ñ™äƒZX ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 2DÔZÍw:m22 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D

(~ÔZDwä�~»�uzgt¯cìÔZk6 A/M. 1977. 201 �~ÅZqÒn)� 4DLL9B�Ûzg~51YSÓxcÄóóÆZÖpŠg`�X32BâÞ3191YÆZqâ¯x�áŠ~tZÖpX

ÔZDw�ÔZÍwÔ3791Y:m231(X„CÙŠzâVÒ*] ‘vnËä �:ÃgÏ�~»ƒìóóX)~§Š¥xƒ@ì1øgZìwì��~»(Zz3191Y~»ƒŠZzg4191Y~ZDwZk6ÃUã™DgìX

ÔZDw�ÔZÍwÔ3791Y:m231 ‘vnËä 5Dm89D99 +†]ÚoV ô ]Îf^Ùeß^Ý ô ÚÓ^ing 6D

Zs:m501 7D

301ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 102: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

C1 ÅZ�á®)5191Y(ÐIÔZkÆF{ÔZZZ~�áùƒDgìX ]‰†]…ôìç�pZy”VƼŠZÃg»QÔTZÍwÐ{™ZìÔTÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�ZDw

�~6ÃUã™DƒñpŠZLZÃgÅZ&b™DgìXñÑ*¤ZòÐâÂ"Yg~ J 3C UãZzgFçzZ&b»tŸ�Ûzg~5191Y à C2 Æfg)Ôtg{̃@g;X

g;XZDwä�~»!iðOŠ{F!g»g™ZcX�~~!g!gZzg{]ÅYäzZàFZç»ÆZy&N¶VZzg!iðOŠzVÐHYYìÔ�ZDwñi* ]‰†]…ôìç�p ¼Z0Zi{Ô~»*xZÌð:ƒZåX�†ZØŠg伊*x:ZuZ§§]Ô � C4 уg~ôp�X

â?mKX*xÆe~ZDwäpZzŒÂòÃÌT è Ô\ÄâZzgWM \ÄætÆ*xÐñÎxƒðX¸� ìç�p è ]‰†]… !sytZÍAÄ~" C5 WiâðÅŠú]Š~X

t*xÔ�~ÆZk^´ÐZ~HŠ:5±Ù: 1D

Ô÷JÔJZ~3191YX içun‚ )Z³(8gzi{m37 :Letters to Atiya )[(

)`(ñÑ*¤ZòÃZqâ~ZDwä�~ÆZ’ZðZÃgÉǸX5±Ù::m501 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo:501 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 2D

ÔŠzx:m863 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3DÆZyN¶VZzg!iðOŠzVÅ,Zk§bì: ]‰†]…ôìç�p 4D

XtƒÐª!iðOŠ{¥xƒ@ìX{à».Y.ňìX A/M-1977-198 )Z³(�Zk~¹ÐázuZÃgZzgFç”{ZÃgÌñ�Š�XLLei~móóÆikÄZyÜs

Gg{ZÃgŠg`�XXt!iðOŠ{Ëplâöä–ìXQZk~ZDwäFZçz A/M-1977-203 )[(�

ZŸ±K�XázuZÃgÂÁ�Ô1Fç”{ZzgZŸ†”{ZÃgÅ®ZŠ{àìXtTZÍwÅZqZ’Zðßg]¥xƒCìX)`(�}!iðOŠ}6jZ!�Šg`7XÀ601,]�XZk!iðOŠ}~Ì{à».Y.ňìXei~mÆ‚BtzŸsŠg`ì:LL!ZYi]»ƒ@zbóóX

»*xZy»?m™Š{ìX ]‰†]…ìç�p ÔŠzx:m863XpZzŒÂò»Šúòì� ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 5DZÍwÔm322( ‡Þ‚å…æ� Ô�y0591YDfZ! Úß^�p )

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^401

Page 103: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

1C CÙpò|iZuZ§pŠ~Z„Pâ{Â"Ô»kVÅoZzgS®z){Æ%Zi~¦g}Zzg21m g{ W

ÅZÍAZ�ᮿ~WðX ]‰†]…ôìç�p à 2C 5191YpZV 8 Zë›Tů6Ô�~ÅÂ"zS®Æ �á²Z: &zgZ:zsZzg

ð™*ÔZDwÆa¹ÂåÔOçt»x�M·²ÂòÅôZãZzgZÈxÃè Zk}ÚÆ7 C4 ÉZkÆZyZY]Ì�™rä'ŠZ“KX C3 Z�x0cÔ ~

ž®ZŠ~VZcŠX 6C ZÐ0õÎ 5C �Ôeì�~~icŠ{ßvŠp:BÔZgZŠmxÔ ‰ ÒaZÞ%[g¶ÅÂ"Šg}£ìX4iS~ìZzg‚21<51k

ZÃg»W¸iƒ@ìXŠz è ŠâdÆ,]�»ÑgZ³ÐwJHŠX��1ÐQ»g8 (Border) góuzgtÔ»kVÐZµY0ŠXYwZzgÂVÅâzZáqd/õ IG

ucìÔ²uzgtÅ„g]!g8~ìXƒÐWy~Ô)Wy~uzgt(6t„g]Šg`ì:

:m21 ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ 1Dm5191YƯƒZDw~�~»Ãðf™7ÔQZkâÆ�Z[»ZOgK B �áŠÆ*x9 2D

%)21Bm5191YÃ(Z¹ZqZzgâ�ƒñÔZDw�~Zg‚w™ä»f™™D�XÍctâ¡ZÏa–��~QÏgzi-лgƒ™WðXZ¤Â[01c11BmûgƒYCªCÙ

ì01c11BmÃâ�XZk¯6ëä@gõZ�á®21Bm³ÅìXZkÅ@GÔZDwñi*уg~ôoÔTZÍwÆZk?°ÐƒCìÔT6ZDwÆŠ\ì@gõ

]‰†]…ô ¸�Šz&gziÂ[Æ?ƒä~ÑX´)äWg&Óå EHà X 5191Y(�� )51Bm)ZÍw(»�7HÔZk6ZDwÆŠ+VÆ‚B51Bm5191YÅ@gõŠg`ìX ìç�p

t‰`-ãzg;Ñ$k~)jZ!�1D29e~638Zö(~ôpìXZk»@Š&ÀŸ/õ GG:m273X : TŠzx9991Y Ô ]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6

:m58 ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù 3D:m74 ]ÞrÛà 4D

:m56D66 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 5DTZÍwX Ô ]‰†]…ôìç�p uzgt 6D

501ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 104: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Z:q)®ZZl4191Y»8gZVêt�Ûzg~4191Y(�~3åXWEZÆ]£tôp�X®ZÃð

T:™,X è ™rp'Z¤pZkiâäƬxZ�á�£gÆ_.¶Ô@ëZDwÔ�~Æ ]‰†]…ôìç�p

ZÍw~Z5ZzgÂ"ÅqgzfsZÝoñ�Š�: T C1 £§S®Ð¼icŠ{t:¸X9 ß S �T¤Šh T™Šh Wy~ uzgt

� !gBþ 01 `)õFM0 )õFM 2 01

« ¬ 2 61ÛzV @zV 4 61

§]zë] §‹ë] 4 02

è, è+ 4 22

6zZ:; ^qZzw:6zZ. 5 22

6zZ:; ^»Uã:6zZ. 5 22

�{; �; 1 62

@ƒ% @[% 2 62

ñ\öL ñÏ 6 82

zZ âz âƒZz 2 65

Zip÷ Zij÷ 4 65

ÔZDw�ÔZÍw3791Y:m351 ‘vnËä 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^601

Page 105: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �pVW�áx pyW�áx 5 65+BøEM

K Ÿ 6 65zyDÆZy zVDÆZV 1 85Šzª è Šzª 1 87

v âYz âz… 2 87ÑSÈî M ÑS[ 3 87

ó]Wñizzí ó]Wñizí 6 97ZÞ ZÅ:ö

RX 1 18Ñ"5Ðö GEW Ñ"5Ðö GE 3 18

õZzŠ“ õZƒŠ“ 4 411Wig Wfg 4 511ZigxZ„ Zigx„ 5 611

�ì :ì 1 911W’ W¶î Y0 1 031

Ï;} $™+<éEE

Xñ 4 231Yzh� Yzh� 5 341!Ñz !у 6 841Z+zWV Z,zWV 2 551Wigl Wfgl 5 551

Z#îyZzgqƒ6ZDwä�WŶÔZk6¹Ðßv2nƒñXZ¶gZ]zZZ~IƒÑzqƒŠXZDwäÌZLñ�ÅzŸsÆa¼Šp}‘X

701ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 106: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:åÔ 2C IXZDwÃZLÝÅ¡6d->î IEX è 1C ÆgŠ~¼Š�cV ìç�p ]‰†]…ôÆ ]‰†]…ôìç�p Q,Vä C3 â]»ŠwgpÆaÔ è ÑÅ{§Zzg¼zZ− è !,!¼Âg«

C4X ‰{vs™ä»ê™1èZÍwÂ�~Üs Y C5 �~»ªZecÔZq‚wÐÌÁ²á~»ƒŠÔ

OçgU„ C6 0õÎÅ®ZŠ~Y8¶ÔŠzu}tÌicŠ{FÔZx[~„ƒX@ëZkÅ C8 XZ6s8191Y~t»g~Yg~¶X 7C Šzu}ZecÅ»g~Ñzqƒ

~WðX ¿9C Z�á®8191YÆÛWy~

ÆgŠ~èYäzZà‰�cVt�: ]‰†]…ôìç�p 1DZi{y·ŠgciZŠ{¡Z£ŒÛ7œj&~WùÔ*Ñ:a@ …]‡ôe1ìç�p )Z³(

-šàŠ‹Ô8191YÔm:61+211ZiñÑ*�9ziZ−+Z£&ZðZ%<~Ô*Ñ:ÒñÑjVÔZ%<Ô ÖŠ^á]ÖÇng )[(

kXyÔm13ÔZDw�ÔZÍw3791Y: ‘vnËä ZixVo·‡Šg~aZgÔyfZ!: Ê^…‰oÚ%ßçp )`(

m342D542,·™ZcÔ2691Y:m48+49+281 Ô ZieZË¥Z−+Õ Ú%ßçp‰ô†%]Ÿ‰†]… )Š(

:m211 ]Îf^ÙÒ1ÚÛ‚æ|Â×Û^ 2DÔŠzx:m461 …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† 3D

ÔZÆ' ]Îf^Ù óó:C ]‰†]…ôìç�p ,Æa5±Ù:·†ZvŒÛ7»*y:LLc¶î0 4D3591YZzgZ6s4591YX

:m56 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 5D:m931 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 6D

m6191YƯ[~��:LL¬{ÅŠzu~Zec»»½À B *iZ−+{VÆ*x11 7D:m5 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ yh1ìXóó

ÔZÍw:m08 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä D8ÔZÍw:m35D75(ÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�ŠzuZZec ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ZºZ[W!Š~Æ*xZqâ) D9

11B�y8191YJ:ÖåX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^801

Page 107: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

TŠzxÆqgY‹uzgt~ÌFçňìXÂ[Æ*xÆ‚BLLª›ëÔ6Š&ÀŸ/õ GG(X {Ò §‹�ÛŠtóóÆZÖp(JŠb‰�X)Zkuzgt»@W

]‰†]…ôìç�p ZkZec»ƒÐZëUz{÷zÃ]zZŸÃ]�Ô�´)ZDwäì: fs è 6ûzVZzgWzVÅgzÝ~KX‰FZçÌÅIÔZyÅ,ø

)Z³(÷zÃ]:]ôá$Úôàø]Ö�ÆôÖvÓÛè t~å: è uzgt:%ã6qg`ug )1(

C1 !g{,]»ŠâpX )2(X 8)¬5ÔZzgWy~3(ZÃg Ãg~Ð Z C2 7¿ïgu±ZZâxÆQ/ )3(

ZqÄ:gz—âò�hZ�Ä@ )4(3C ²i ê

GN�ZÚ¯KÔTZÍw:m71( ]‰†]…ôìç�p )

ZqÄ: )5(i0ÏœiZ�ºpŠ~Z„»@ZipZƒpŠ~.z}ia

)TZÍw:m72(

Šzx)m44D25(~�áïìX …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† )m351D951(Zzg ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù tŠâp 1DÆQ~¼ŠZÝoñ�Š�X ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù

Åt!]Šg„7 ‰†æ�ô…Êjä è "54èGEGE 'ç )m86D96( ‰†æ�ô…Êjä Z/ZÃg»Q5±Ù: 2D

�tƒQ/ZÃgŠzu}Zec~vs™Šb‰X†ZØ‚´ÌZÏß.»Dg:m59(XŠgZÝ÷zsÄÜs8�X!¹Šg{ÄzV»û$wŠc ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù ƒñ�)

ŠìXtLL�óóÆ{~ÔP,]WÐ^™Ä:LL'¤¢-êEG

6Š{')TŠzx:m51(ƈ�áï�XÄ3ÆŠzu}^´~LLŠzgÒpVóóÃLL¤Š¶pVóóÐ$wŠcŠXtŠg{ZÃgÔâˆZ�áoV~Ìñ�Š�X

:m452(~tÄÔ�áïƒä ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ñÑ*$Å%A™Š{z„LLvs”{ZÃgóó) 3DÐg{ŠìX

901ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 108: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

TŠzx»@ ]‰†]…ôìç�p

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^011

Page 109: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

53ZÃgÔªÄtì: 1C qƒÆ!g}~ )6(}g 4 è ƒâgZiqƒ

ZVuâtŠZg è YêiiCÙ)TZÍw:m66D27(

egZÃg: )7(µgZ¤pŠÁØ~ ßg‹ )1(

¨h!ÑFZiWNØ~µgÎ| è *VŠí ί )2(

�{g�zO»îgÎ|gÄZi@gz—¤ŠzV@¯Qz )3(ZiZV[:â0WzZ¯Qz

È{ZlŠgaÍcð0h )4(2C u'zVZi¢Òpø>

)TZÍw:m601D701(ZqÄ: )8(

–zpŠWÇ{” é;U}šZv” è i“

)TZÍw:m111(ZqÄ:

*!”Šg¹�ƒ45åFGŠgw*r{ñÙ¦h

)TZÍw:m42(

QÆa5±Ù: 1D:m07D27 ‰†æ�ô…Êjä )Z³(:m413D613 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù )[(

~LLpø7½5å FGóóŠg„7X)m452( ‰†æ�ô…Êjä 2D

111ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 110: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)[(ZŸÃ]:uzgtÅ%ã6LL687óóX )1(

ÆZÖpÆLLª›ë§‹�ÛŠtóóX ]‰†]…ôìç�p uzgt6�~ )2(C1 TŠzx»*ŠâpX )3(

gzòÆ&ZÃg: )4(:m4X Ò×n^lô]Îf^ÙÊ^…‰o Š~�!lZr')TŠzx:m2(

W¸¯�~ÐIÔlÐZz6ÅS~:LL—ð NMóó )5()TŠzx:m5(

n~»Ä: )6(:m5( Ò×n^l ')TŠzx:m5Ô Fz �ŠgÈ

Šg{ZÃg: )7(4h4-êXGG' è ZiÄ�1:1Šî

m01D11(X Ò×n^lV @Ä�2:¢{@ë0›')TŠzx:m51D61ÔZqÄ: )8(

m51( Ò×n^lV aVpŠ~WgŠ')TŠzx:m32ÔÄzZ&—ZŠÒ‹ZsðóóìjZÙ)TŠzx: è å![>Zy:LLŠg| )9(

m43D93(X Ò×n^lV m55D46Ô0õZÃgDZiÄ�1:¤:‚iŠ'@Ä�5:Šg˜VÕZV')TŠzx:m18Ô )01(

m94( Ò×n^lVm16( Ò×n^lV ñÑ*gzx»ZqÄ/pZÖpìqí:ŠgŠgzß�')TŠzx:m101Ô )11(

ZqÄìqí: )21(m27(X Ò×n^lV @—Šggziz‘')TŠzx:m221Ô

ZqÄ: )31(m67( Ò×n^lV Ã{W>&Á')TŠzx:m921Ô

)m391(~®wìÔ1Zk~¼ŠZÝoñ�Š�X ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^211

Page 111: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZqÄ: )41(m67( Ò×n^lV øV')TŠzx:m921Ô 'gZ â !i

]jZÙÎZ}Šz£â]Æ: )51(m84Ôqí�1( Ò×n^lV )1()TŠzx:m97Ôm76Ôqí�1( Ò×n^lV )2(TŠzxm211Ô

Wy~Ô6»8gZVÐ0LLZ´yóóÆWy~Ô'ÆŠ\/wzs )61(Zôm~ìLLÛ7ZfÑYуgóóX

)`(FZç:Šzu}Zec~F§bÅFZçň�:

)m842D352(~¹ÐZ,£â]Å ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ñÑ*ÝxgÎw$ä )1(ÆTŠzx~FZçXÔ@ëFZç ]‰†]…ôìç�p ¶yŠ„ÅìÔ˜VZDwä

Å{à®ZŠ$™rÐÃZ0ZiƒXQ$™rÆFZç*ó~TŠzxTg~ g{ ZzgTÎxÅFZç‘oƒ�ZzgZk~¼ŠZÝoÌ�')W

ñµZyŶyŠ„ÅYñÏ(fs~z{ÓxZÃgzrg#Šg`K èøŠzxÆñµ6Z&bňX´#ÖLLxóóÐ%ZŠz{FZç è YD�ÔX~ÔT

�XŶyŠ„$™r™`�X

311ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 112: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÔT�zx ]‰†]…ìç�p � ÔTZzw ]‰†]…ìç�p � �à] Fç�ÓÎiZV@|'6zZ:Zx Å 21 Ó;Vg6'6zZ:Zx Å 41 9 1!�{;Vg6'e:Zx Å !�{-gl™�'e:Zx Å 2¤�lZiâzZx��Yxó Å 12 RZiâzZx��Yxó Å 52 41 3

x C1 �gcØ� è �Ò è �{Õ Å 22 �gcØ� -g¶ è �{Õ Å 52 41 4x �yZip÷cÄ !{aV@� Å 22 %Zip÷cÄ !{aV@� Å 62 41 5x ä'zVZiUVW!�” Å 52 p÷ è ä¤ÄZiUVWM Å 03 61 6x ZzWiZ�” ÏZii0ZÈ Å p÷ è� Ïi�Zi¯� Å 7x @iWñEx 74iï FGGgZ¯ Å 62 Ex ZºZ¬� 74iï FGGgZ¯ Å 03 61 8

plFziâFz8[F Å 92 �V8[F Zi�È Å 53 91 9x �ºugZaVÑ"6�{�h Å 13 �VÑ�ºpgZ"'�{�h Å 83 02 01x ð �JxWgZÄ è �g&45å GFG Å 33 ð µWgZÄ è �g&45å GFG Å 04 12 11x 8k5¼-<é

EGYGXñÂZi*�Zg~Z„ Å 63 ÂZi*�Zg~Z„ ]ZbÄ Å 34 21x Â�Fg~Z„ �g� è ZÝ Å A;�Fg~Z„ è ZÝ Å 32 31x p÷ Z°§ è ¨©iyZ0g* Å 14 p÷ Z°§ ¾tZ0g−Ä Å 05 62 41

:m842Ôqí�3(qÑV�t�zu}ZecÅFçìX'×h'WV$™rÆ ‰†æ�ô…Êjä $™räZÐ�}ZecÅZ&bCcì) 1D_.¬Zec~ÂLL�ÒóóåÔ&�zu}Zec~LL-glóó¯�cŠÔ1ZÝßg]ZkÆ'@ìÔ6�ëäZz6¶y��ÅìX

*%î0WVÈÒh�é{ Å 34 h�é{ *%î0WVß° Å 15 62 51

411

Page 113: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

*%î0WVÈÒh�é{ Å 34 h�é{ *%î0WVß° Å 15 62 51x W�ÛgÍA 2C pñ¤Ï Å 64 ]4�3ï EGOG5k�ÍA è g8 Å 65 92 61x Wë"'pg~ ⧠@§ Å 84 *.çEGO}@!VØ~ è @¯; Å 85 03 81x îèZiJÃÙ)1� Å 94 èZiìø)1� ¸Ä Å 95 03 91x @64h1� �w&z¾ Å Z,Zsh1� �w&z¾ Å 02x pZ[WzgI è WælZ,G Å 94 pZ[WzgI è WælZ,z÷ Å 95 13 12x pg�Zi{ò\ÈÍA Å Zi¯ÄÍA 3C ��g Å 22

'4Z0ggÀZzpÈQz Å 76 g³cZ�ggÀZzpÈQz Å 57 14 32Ziuz�½ÛzV%z Å 86 Ziuz�i0ÏÛzV%z Å 67 14 42

x :/ίZ,�V‚i*â Å 67 :7ÑÄ�V‚i*â Å 78 64 52WzZg{Zx æ� �gì!øa1 Å 77 �ggc¸Zza1WzZg{Zx Å 88 74 62

x 0ÃgzͶ*ÛZZiz Å 87 �h{Z�+ö WͶ*ÛZZiz Å 98 84 72x %�íg�Zi°æOZg~Z„ Å 97 �g�VCÙìZi°æOZg~Z„ Å 09 84 82x ÍCÙlgZW'zp��Zg~Z„ Å Z'zñ%�Zip��Zg~Z„ Å 92x �g¿7æ{*ȧ] Å 08 �g¿�Z„*ȧ] Å 29 94 03

:m152(��g„7X ‰†æ�ô…Êjä $™räZkÂÃLL¤òóó�ì) 2D:m151(��g„7X ‰†æ�ô…Êjä $™räZkÂÃLL"góó�ì) 3D

511Ãgϯx

Æù´

Page 114: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

iz§p�gZZi¶�x Å 286)4øXGIgZZi¶�x Å 39 94 23

x 榤ât�ZgZi¢ðGO]Z„ Å 48 ¸]1� è 榤™r Å 59 05 33x �ú)Zz"*i9BïEOGZ„ Å �ú÷ÅZi9BïEOG1� Å 43x ¯Òo/õ IE�g{�²-ê

E Å 68 −ó�g¢Ò�²-êE Å 89 25 53x 1�z°x è u�ÛzZ0g* Å 69 ¨©pZ§−x1�z°x Å 211 85 63x W>ZiX'�y è ëad Å 001 œÑZgZi¹{gZ'h Å 611 06 73x ZiÂ−x¤�îÃV+ Å 201 ZiÂ−x‚bîÃVØ� Å 911 16 83x �ZâV+ �{;Zi; Å �ZâVØ� ; è �{Õ Å 93

Z�gZuÎ| è �wyð è W> Å 311 Z�gZuÎ| è Z�[�wl Å 231 76 04^�Ïî I0�Zg�VÁjZ!u� Å 611 jZ!u� >;ñZzVÁ Å 631 96 14

âZi�{;WgZ3 è) Å 421 âœ�{;WgZ„Z„ è) Å 641 47 24Zi½§0ñâ'{3 Å 0ñâ'{„Z„ Zi½§ Å 34â6.V�g�VaVZº* Å 821 â6.VaVWÄZº* Å 941 67 44

x Zz¤�zV£x Wë[Ziί Å 031 Zz¤�zV£x è Wë[Zi; Å 251 77 54x ZzæZx '¤Z0gîZ½ Å ZzæZx îZ½ è '¤" Å 64x

&B¨Ñõ EË0 �gxÈ Å 231 ¬ãË0 �gWÄ Å 451 87 74

611

Page 115: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZÃgzrg#~¼*z@íňì: è ‰£â]6FK )2()Z³(TZÍw)m42(~tÄ:

m31( Ò×n^lV 0') Z &ŠZkÈ»Wy~ÄåXTŠzx)m02(~ZÐñ�Š{(ÑcŠX

C1 )[(ŠzZÃg:gŠÁpŠ' Š Zg Wgiz

m61( Ò×n^lV Zzg:WgizYȘV')TZÍw)m23(~Zk![ÆWy~ÄÔTŠzx)m43(~Z¹Ô![»Ä�3Zzg�4¯ŠcŠX)`(TZÍw)m98(~ZkÄ:

Qz@È{‚ è âZi$ èð {¿º[ZiŠÄZzi0{‚m25( Ò×n^lV )

Šzx)m68(~tFK è ÆúVÅFKÔñ�Š{ßg]Æ'@¶XTňX ‡ìZÍw)m26(~ZqÄZyÅZ’Zðßg]t¶: èT )3(ŠgÒyZ�Z#îÈ-*ãzqƒèZi~�¦szZŠÒ‹ZZÄZsð{‹Z.V

ÍA~gCZ0zZiZ.VZ�ZizZZZ„X è C'Ý kx5 è ZWm23(TZÍw~Â"Å Ò×n^l TŠzx)m15(~ZÐñ�Š{ßg]Š~ˆ)

¼ŠZÝoñ�Š�XTŠzx~ÔuzgtÅ„g]~FçƒXŠâpÌvs™ŠcŠXTZÍwÅ!¹ZÝo~ÐqgzfsÅoƒ:

$™rZyZÃgÆ!g}~��:LLtÄŠzu}ZecÆz‰Ü@i{¾‰Ô¬~ 1D:m942Ôqí�1(�V$™rÃœƒZìXtŠzâVZÃgT ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ñ�Š:óó)

ZÍw~Ìñ�Š�)m23(TŠzx~Z¹úáYcŠìX

711ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 116: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

T�zx)9( S � TZÍw)ß( S �)õF0 2 9 )õFM 2 01ŠhÒ 6 01 Š$Ò 2 21

ÛzV 8 31 kzV 4 61è, 7 91 è+ 4 226zZ:; 8 91 6zZ. 5 22�{; 3 22 �; 1 62!ð N\ö ML 8 42 !ð NÏ 6 82Zip÷ 6 64 Zij÷ 4 65

ÆZy 7 74 ÆZV 1 85gxZ„ 8 99 gx„ 5 611

� 6 221 � 5 341Z+zWV 1 331 Z,zWV 2 551

@ëTZÍwÅqgzfsZÝoTŠzx~Ì$2gñ�Š�:T�zx)ß( S � TZÍw)ß( S �è¬ 6 31 è¬ 2 61zZ âî 4 64 zZ âî 2 65pyW�áx 7 64 pyW�áx 5 65

ºŸ 8 64 ºŸ 6 65zV 7 74 zV 1 85è Šzª 2 96 è Šzª 1 87

âî… 3 96 âî… 2 87ÑS[ 4 96 ÑS[ 3 87

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^811

Page 117: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

T�zx)ß( S � TZÍw)ß( S �ó]Wñizí 5 07 ó]Wñizí 6 97ZÅ�öR

5 17 ZÅ:öRX 1 18

Ñ"5Ðö GE 1 27 Ñ"5Ðö GE 3 18õZ 2 89 õZ 4 411Wfg 8 89 Wfg 4 511:ì 1 201 :ì 1 911W¶î Y0� 5 111 W¶î Y0 1 031$™+<éEE

Xñ 7 311 $™+<éEE

Xñ 4 231!Ñî 6 721 !Ñî 6 841Wfgl 4 331 Wfgl 5 551

ZkŠzu}Zec~qgzfs5ZÝoÌgz5kƒ�:9 ß S �

0gz Z} }Zîg0 3 2!îENQ : 6 61yŠÒ yŠ{ 8 71YȘy YȘV 6 426zZi 6zZg 2 52èÔ Ô 5 52i0ZÈ i0ZV 3 24

™Šy ™ŠV 6 64p/™0k p–0k 2 46i0ZÈÿ N

i0ZVÿ N2 76

911ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 118: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �ZyZ}>#-:ö

GEXWùZŧBhéEIY ZÅ}Òð>#-:ö

GEXWùZŧBhéEIY qí 07

ÚßZZË.çEO ÚßZ_ qí 17xZV xZy 2 27Ñ"5Ðö GEW Ñ"5Ðö GE qí 27

u v 6 97âè FI Âè FI 5 18

âYz… âYzv 7 78!h42.ç GEG !k2.çGGE 5 59!{u '{u 1 89

ð Z'Z� Z'Z�ñ 8 89ZzÑ Zz! qí�1 411

ïf è 8ø N 4 611uZ è‘ cgZ è‘ 3 231

]‰†]…æ ÆŠzu}ZecÆ‚B5™ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p »�ZZecÔ ]‰†]…ôìç�p)CÙŠzŠ( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ )Š(Åßg]~�áùƒZXZkaZk»f™WÐ^™ …Úç‡

ÆTZÍwÆY}~ƒÇX

gñ¯"pŠ~ /

5191Y(„Æ ÅŠ�Ûzg~5191YZzgˆZiZVZkÅZ�á®)21Bm ]‰†]…ôìç�pÉZkÆñç¬]zp}ZyÆf‚~ 1C iâäÐÔZDwÃzŠzx�»ìwåÔ

6†Z°ÝLg~ ]‰†]…ôìç�p Й[¬Ô@Jß~»tw�:' ZDw C2 ñ�Š¸XÔZDw�ÔZÍwÔ3791Y:m351 ‘vnËä 1D

ÔZÍw:m32 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^021

Page 119: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

kaßì� Z C1 »–Y*"u¢zg~ìóóX …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p »*y7|™=ZˆkƒZ�Æik Iqbal - His Persian Masnavis 67ÔÉ ]‰†]…ôìç�p Lg~äÜs�~

Z6s8191Y( B ÅZ�á®)01 …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p ÄZyŠzâV�-V6cŶZzgt*yC2 ~�áùƒZåX )�Ñð8191Y( East and West Æ&â{ˆg‚!

„ÅÂW¶ZzgZÏ» ]‰†]…ôìç�p Ãð*µ/:åÔÉ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p Šg|»f™HÔ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p ìwÔZÏaZDwäZx[Æ*xèo~˜VÌ èö

C3 »zŠzxŒÛZgŠcX ]‰†]…ôìç�p ZлW¸i5191YÆWy~Zcxc6191YÆZ’ZðŠâV~ƒZXZÒ{ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p

âÞÆŠgxy(X B ZzgŠâÞ7191Y~ƒð)31Zzg72 4C 6191YZzg7191Y~‘‰ZiZV‡âã»çVÃ7gZ™äÆa¦ÆFÊ3ðˆX�!iðOŠ{¦Æa5 ˆŠÔz{ZDwñi*Ôуg~ôpìZzgZkÆCÙÔ6¦™äzZáZfÆÃ

C5: ñ�Š�XWy~Ô67g}Š\ì@gõZk§bŠg`� (initials) Š\6C

AbdulAziz25.12.17

:m74 2ß‚m^�m6(2ß‚iª$†]l 1D)m741D ð�á@ · A: Ô% Tributes to Iqbal Lg~Æ*y»Q5±Ù: 2Dm401( V ]mÔÚ_^ÖÃä D ]Îf^Ù 551(XZkK~ZqÒyY'Z±»ì�&CÿLOÃìX)

5±Ù: 3D:m3Zzg84 �^�]Îf^Ù )Z³(ÔZÍw:m32Zzg97 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä )[(ÔŠzx:m35 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä )`(ÔZDw�ÔZÍw3791Y:m351 ‘vnËä )Š(

ÉgìÔâÂ"Æfg)ñÑ*¤ZòÐ'Z'tg{ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p XŠâV~ZDw 4D:,]011Ô411Ô611Ô811Ô911Ô321Ô ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo fgìX5±Ù:

31X 3 521Ô621Ô131Zzg&z:ZDwñi*уgX A/M 1977-199 :� …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p 5±Ù:!iðOŠ{ 5D

¸XZiZVZ³×eZsxÆW3k~óR~ officer -in-charge †Z+mÔ6ö'Zõ~ 6Dm651 un^lô]Îf^ÙÒo+Ü�‚åÒ<m^7V gìX'×hŠB

121ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 120: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

„CÙ¸4ì�Y¦äÃðÄ7»NXZ%‰ZÃgÔ¥xƒ@ìÔˆ~pŠZDwä¡Ð,ç

GEŠ™ŠbXZ¤¦zZáÃðÄ»3ÂZx[Æ*xèo~Ô˜Vz{�~Å’kz"ÔŠzZ!xZzgÂ"zS®z){Æ!g}~@i{F+ßg‹qwÅZ:qÅàDgTÔZÃgÆ¡Ð,ç

GEŠƒYä»f™Ì™DX…Úç‡ôe1 ~tZÃg C1 ñÑ*¤Zòä�g½oPZÃgÉÇÔ1ZDwÆìw

…Úç‡ôe1ìç�p ÆaicŠ{oƒ¸Xµ¶�¤Zò ]‰†]…ôìç�p ÅÚ ìç�p¤Zò'z‰Ü½o:ÉnX 1 C2 Æa5½oKÐZzgZkÆaZDw³Ìgì

ZÏZz)ŠcÆWy~Zcx(~�~Â"ÆaŠ}Š~ˆX½ã&â{Â"zS®Æ%Zi~¦g‰Ô©�Z6s8191YƬ‚}~Â[¾™»g

zgZ6sÆz‰~ÔZx[ÃQkÆ°gzZ:K‰X Z C3 ƒXÅZÍAZ�á®»ZÈxÌ�M·™r²ÂòäHX …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p

Åâucg8~ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p uzgtZzgWy~ÔÅâ»emZíÌz„ìÔ@ëTňìXuzgt6�~»7gZ*xZk§bŠg`ì:

4C ªZuZ§§]Zsðóó …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p LL�~Wy~Ô6ÔucâÆZ0gt„g]ñ�Šì:

Z:q®ZZl4191Y»8gZVêt�Ûzg~4191Y�~3åXWEZÆ]£tôp�X

)'(ŠâdÆaŠ{S~4ÆŠz,]6��»Ñg7HŠXZŒi,]

Zsð(ÃZ³[`Š{zÐÑgHŠìX�~��1ÐÑzq è )7¿ïgI

:m631 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 1D:m11 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 2D

:m28 �^�]Îf^Ù 3D~�áïìX Iqbal in Pictures TZÍwÆuzgt»@ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^221

Page 121: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ƒ™��9316»ƒCìX!ÇWy~�{àìXt´)ZDwÅ«Â[ìÔ&: †ZØÿ6z,g¶þäÂ"HXTZÍw~Â"ZzgZ5ÅqgzfsZÝoñ�Š�

9 ß S �ZZxŧ] ZZxƧ] 5 Šâpm1

¢o !{3ðE

Go 4 Šâpm2ŠzâV ŠzÂV 5 Šâpm2ck c9öOz 3 50g{;ñ 0g;ñ 5 9]Ö†$uûÛFàô ]Ö†uûÛFàø þ qí ÿ8 21Z06; Z0$g<é GIX 6 41

*;ñ 8g+<é FIXñ 3 81œ&ñgZœ& œ&ñgZœ&ñ 6 81é‰»Î é‰ »ZÎ qí 92Ò� Ò�~ 3 43møûÚö†ö ï møûÚö†öÒöÜ qí�2 83aöçø]Ö×#ä aöçø]Ö×#äö 7 14@i{Zir @i{Zgr 5 44

]øÖøÜûiø†ø]ôÖøo]Ö$„ômûàø WtÑf»9Qtì:eø‚$Ööçû]ÞôÃûÛøkø]Ö×#äôÒöËû†÷]æ$]øuø×%çû]ÎøçûÚøãöÜû�ø]…ø

o eôòû‹ø]ÖûÏø†ø]…ö æø ½ mø’û×øçûÞøãø^ t qøãøß$Üø oŸ ]Öûføçø]…ô

qí 84

g9*îGNÉÒ›é OÅ)4èG g9*îGNZÉÒ›é OÅ)4èG 7 95ÊøjøÏø_$Ãöçû�ý‡öeö†÷] ÊøjøÏø_$Ãöçû]ý‡öeû†]÷ qí�1 16]Ö‚ù]ÅôýÞ%Óö†õ ]Ö‚]ïôýÞÓ†] qí�2

321ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 122: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �gZi~ gZi~ñ 6 36

ÖjÓçÞç] ÖjÓçÞç qí�1 78é‰ âå é‰ zâå qí�3 78

p$h4è GIGE!i p$h4è GIGEâi 2 89

Öf^ŒºÖùÓöÜ Öf^‰ÓÜ qí�1 301

Òø^áø]øeöçûeøÓû†ö‘ø‚ôùmÐöÚôàø]Öß$fôo@ÚøÓø^áø]ûÖøçô‡mû†öÊøÓø^áømø�ø^æ…øåöÊôoû ß:qøÛônûÄô]öÚöç…ôåæøÒø^áø$ø^ÞônöäXÊôoû]Ÿô‰û¡øÝôæø$ø^ÞônûäXÊôo]ÖÇø^…ôæøÒø^áø$^ÞnöäX

Êôo]ÖûÃø†ômû�ômøçûÝøeø‚û…õæÒø^áø$ø^ÞnûäXÊôo]ÖÏøfû†æøÖøÜûæømøÓöàû…ø‰öçûÙö]Ö×#äö

)¸wGZ0"( 5o ‘ø×ùo]Ö×#äöÂø×ønûäôæø‰ø×$ÜmÏ‚ÝÂ×nä]øuø‚÷]

Xå Òø^áø]øeöçûeøÓû†ôáô]Ö’ôù‚ôùmÐöÚôàø]Öß$fôoôùÚøÓø^áø]Öûçø‡ômû†ôÊøÓø^áømö�ø^æô… 9:X Êôo]ÖÇø^…ôæøÒø^áø$ø^Þônøä X Êôo]Ÿô‰¡øÝôæ$ø^Þônøä X ÊôoûqøÛônûÄô]öÚöçû…ôåæøÒø^áø$ø^Þônøä

Êôo]ÖÏøfû†ôæøÖøÜûmøÓöàû…ø‰öçûÙö]Ö×#äô‘ø×$o X Êôo]ÖûÃø†ômû�ômøçûÝøeø‚û…õæøÒø^áø$ø^Þônøä

)¸wGZ0"( 5o ]Ö×#äöÂø×ønûäôæø‰ø×$ÜømöÏø‚ôùÝöÂø×ønûäô]øuø‚÷]

qí�1 411

/Zv !v 6 611

Úø^‡ø]Éø]Öûfø’ø† ]Öûfø’ø†ô Ú^‡ø]Éö 8 121

ŸøiøvûøÞöçæøŸøiøôßöçû]]øÞûjöÜ]ŸûøÂû×øçûá ß:æøŸøiøôßöçû]æøŸøiøvûøÞöç]æø]øÞûjöÜö]ŸûøÂû×øçûáø 9:

qí 821

o] Vo 8 231&À;/õ EXG &À;/õ E

YXG 8 331

Wig Wfg 4 731

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^421

Page 123: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»ZqÄZk§bì: …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p

©Zi'Z„ è hgZg'× è ZI�Z„ ]iFo]Ö†$uûÛFàøÂøf‚] Šg

0u)Îg{%*:39(Ðâpf Ά�á ^qUã~²!FIÔ)TZÍw:m21(ìÔ1ZDwät$¸ç GOsHì�ÂLLZë

GWóó–ì�ziy67gZ7QF@Xziy~

(ÐZ iôo ó Fó óóŠzâVßg'ŒÛWyÆQ)Z iôo óóKcLLR iFo óóW@ìX¾qwLLZ ]øiôo LL…Úç‡ôe1 �XZk§b�Vñ�Š{Â"pƒ™g{ŠtÄÅZë{òìXZDwä

ŠÔZÍw3291Y(~¹ÏFZçXÔ1Àì�Zk ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ÆTŠzx) ìç�pZë�Ûz*Z“6Z¹&40î GEEO7ƒeÔTÆË~ZqZët!¹g{ˆX

ÅZ�á®ÆÔ´)ZDwZk»�ZzÌ�»ZgZŠ{gn …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p!gQ,VäZkÆW¸iŸŠïƒñCc�LLtZqnÅ5yZÅ�.çG qZ C1 ¸X

mHåÔ1tñúŠ{�~LT ? 3C k»*xQ,VäLL§‹!h4©5ÏîGGE0Zsðóó ZzgZ 2C ƒÏ

ƒ™!3~î E0áŠ6:WmÔeìZkƼZÃgÉ™�™Šb‰ƒVX)CÙŠzŠ(TZÍw�áùƒZX ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ »ŠzuZZec�g …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p

)Š( ZuZgzgñi /»ªZec»ƒä6ŠzâV�-V …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p »ŠzuZZecZzg ]‰†]…ôìç�p

Æ6ZexVÅZ�á®»XŠg7ƒZÔ´)ZDwäŠzâVÅŠZ�á®»êHXZkñµ6Q,VäŠzâV�-V6ÃUã™Æ‰ZÃg~FZçXZzgFZÃg»ZŸ†ÌHX

)Š(ÆTZÍw6‚ÁZ�ᮊg`7Ô@ëZkÅZ�á®»‚w ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ÅZ�ᮊzxìX …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p ÅZ�á®ÎxZzg ]‰†]…ôìç�p t C4ìX 3291Y

ÔŠzx:m57 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D:m421 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 2D

:m97 �^�]Îf^Ù 3DÔ6( Ò{ W ZkŠzgʼnÂ1VÆÃZZk§b�:)� 4D

521ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 124: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

uzgtÆ��36PS~¿ŠâpìXtŠâp´)ZDwÆË�~ù´~�áï7ÔZkaZÐ�VÜHY@ì:

Šâp…Úç‡ôe1 Zzg ìç�p è ]‰†]… ZkZec~*ø+ÅœªÆaŠzâV�cVª

Š�áùÅYC�X©à�FçÆ´z{Ô_Å'×h=ôÆa‰ ìç�p(ZÃg»ÌZŸ†ìÔXÅù¦®ZŠÎZ΃ÏXZqŠz(6ÄZẏìK‰�Ô1Â[ÅFK~Ãð�Ût7X

·ZDw)Š(~¼ŠZÃgvs™Šb‰ÔF”V~FçňZzg ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

‰ZÃg»ZŸ†ÌƒZX,Zk§bì:)�*�(

6.Ñí Â[Šg-™azZµÑƒg!Èx÷Z÷jT¤Šh TZÍw3291Y µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

Zs ÔŠ ]‰†]…æ…Ú燙a6öуg4ŠÃÂZàŠ*!Èx÷Šg]Zv6Ú�X TZÍw4291Y e^Þ-ô�…]

÷Z÷j™r%jxÆ™a6öуg~!Èx÷Šg]Zv6Ú�

TŠzx4291Y µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

TZÍw µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ŠÅ6.ÑíZq„ìX ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ÔTZÍwZzg µn^ÝôÚ�†ÑÌZÏ‚w3291Y~� ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ªkì� è 3291Y~�áùƒðÔZkZ±gÐŒÛ+

µn^Ýô TZÍwZzg �…] ô e^Þ- ƒÏÔYèZ¤tZŒ'k)4291Y(~ÕÂZkÅ6.Ñí̵n^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ¸�÷Z÷j3291YÆWy~) X TŠzxÅ6.ÑíÆ_.ƒC Ú�†Ñ

ÔŠÅZ�á®Æˆ(¯]ƒ‰XZka4291Y~�áùƒäzZà ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ZÍwZzgczsZŠdZzg[ÀpZz )÷Z÷j X ŠzâVÂ1VÅ6.Ñí~p~™Š~ˆ

÷Šg]ZvZyÆâñVXZq!gpZz™rägZ¶ÃCc�÷ )x:5002Y(Æ**¸ZzgŠg]Zv¼²�™a6öÃ`DgìÔQZ,Vä6öÁeZv™rÃ�Ûz|™ŠcåXQ,Vä¼²áˆ6ö»‚iz‚âyÖŠcÔZk§b™a6ö»ƒŠX(

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^621

Page 125: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

÷zÃ]: )Z(TŠzx Ô ]‰†]…ôìç�p

uzgt6Â#ÄZy:LL›ë§‹�ÛŠtóó 1D1C Šâp 2D

W¸¯�~ЬÔÔÅ%ã6Â:LL—ð NQóó D3m75»tÄ: D4

Zz'âŠæ è §†Z\Vî{)ZlÃì®ñò±håI

m4316£¾Z�á®Ð0LLZ´yóó)ZÐ*,]~ÜHY[ì(X D5: …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p

mZ³»tÄ: D6�{;ñp÷gZ$k5é EIE�)x( Z}/GŠvZVŠw!�

m42»tÄ: D7pVZiŠhÒŠwò�)x( è Z— 2C Zzò£ è YßZi¤ò

m79Æ&ZÃg: D8p$h4è GIGEgZ!iŠgâŠgH âŠgòpgŠ è ÙZiŠ„aVÉZi!›Hig�ŠZz '×›gzbh4è IGEiâŠg�ŠZz

)x( É4øEICÙŠxÎZáò� iZ 0ZzCÙ9'Zâ�m411Æqd/õ IG~qg`GZ0"»Zqw)twm4216ÜHY[ì(X D9m681»tÄ: D 01

)m391(~®wQ~¼ŠZÝoñ�Š�X ÚÏ^Ÿl]Îf^Ù 1D‰†æ�ô ZkÄÆ!g}~ñÑ*$ÅtzŸs:LLZq£x6tÄ–åÔQiŠ™Šcóó) D2

:m652(ãìXQ,VäZkÄÃLLFç”{óóÆikÄZyŠg`HìÔ1t7 …Êjä]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ zZãH�ZkÅZ’Zðßg]H¶X|~tÄTZÍw~ñ�ŠåÔ1

)Š(~ZÐvs™ŠcŠX

721ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 126: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

p÷Z0Z|Z„ è g8 C1 @ѺZÙ]gZ)Z#‚|Z„

Wy~Ô6£¾Z�á®Ð0LLZ´yóó)t„g]*¸,]~ÜÅ 1D 1Y_ì(X

)[(ZŸÃ]:Šâp)*,]~ÜHY[ì(X 1D

~![LLZ߉ܢóóƬÈƈZVg{ZÃg»ZqåÈÔ ]‰†]…ôìç�p 2DT»ƒÐªÄì:

†z:æ N ZqЯ @ÙÏ &½0î EG0òÍ'.ï JGgz×a™gZzgWy~Ä:

¨©ŠgŠwiy�|gZ¯z‰Ü $™*îEE0{ñlŠZgŠ‚¯z‰Ü

m27D47( Ò×n^lV )(6ñÑ*gzx»tÄ: …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p m29) 3D

m08( Ò×n^lV 4ÁŠg')m111»ÄZy: 4D

m79( Ò×n^lV LLõzg{¾zc')m911D0216Zq6ÄZy: 5D

·túz@ªwez)zZ]zZp‹µ è Z,�°Šg‚ª è LLŠgpm301D401( Ò×n^lV â»WŠxZ„óóÆ�Z’ZðÎ!ZÃg')

9'(ÔÄ�5)Šgz÷'(Ôm031 è :m921»Ä�4)7 ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ 6DÆŠg{ZÃg)Zi:WV£ê'@›Z4'(Zzgm131ÆŠzZÃg)ò

m211D311(X Ò×n^lV &¼-CåEYE

E'Zzg:Šw$„Wzg'(ÀGg{ZÃg)m211D311( Ò×n^lV m921Ô031ÆjZÙ) 7D

m331ȀZy: 8D

:m852(1TZÍw~LLѺóóì)ZÍw:m021(X ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ) ñÑ*$äLLÑèóó–ì 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^821

Page 127: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

m511(X Ò×n^lV LLŠgpZ,�zíZ‚µI�óó): 341D4416Zq6ÄZy 9D

Z,�ŠgiâUZzoÇZiZ¿ŠRz\FZ„óóÆ�Ä�2))ÄZZx è LLŠgpm421D521( Ò×n^lV @'(@Ä61)Z}6.VÀ'(ÀGg{ZÃgX)

m2516ŠzZÃg: 01Dgzò' è Ä�5:%”

m131D231(X Ò×n^lV Zzg:Ä�6:$½hÿY

Zi»Z°Ë'){ÄÂ'(@�21)‚¯ è m551»Ä�2:)¤ÃŠZg~'(Zzg�6)„ 11D

m431( Ò×n^lV pZË{'(m651»Ä�1)ŠJxÂ'(ÀâÔZÃg)m441( Ò×n^lV m761»Wy~Ä:¢Òœ') 21D

(Ô�2)aVï'(Zzg�4)wsaV ' m861»Ä�1:)aV$gc 31Dm441( Ò×n^lV ¤]'()

m441( Ò×n^lV m861»qí�1) 41Dm781ÆWy~ŠzZÃg: 51D

)1(aVÊg6Š{;ñ'm161( Ò×n^lV )2(Šg˜Véx[')

m091ÆŠzZÃg: 61DZz' è Zzé è )1(Z#Ö

m361( Ò×n^lV ') ¾ Z )2(â§hg)`(FZç:

)Š(~‰ZÃgzrg#ÃFçÆfg)Ô5ßg]Š~ˆXZk ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ÅzŸsfsÆÍØZg}ЃÏXXFZçŶyŠ„ñÑ*ÝxgÎw$äÅÔZyÆ‚t´#ÖLLxóóŠg`ìX

Ô6( {Ò )ÍØZg{W

921ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 128: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � Ô�zx ]‰†]…ìç�p � �à] Fç�x ÏZxZiiÀ"6zZ0 Å 5 "*iZiͶZ%ziWæx Å 7 6 1x �ÛŠZ0 è ðâZ}�á² Å �ÛŠZ0 è ðœZ}�á² Å 2x pVŠh{Zx )¤Š¶ ŠggÀ Å 01 Šggv)ŠzgÒpVŠh{Zx Å 5 01 3

1C &ŠÔZ0ŠÔ6ŠÔ@$Ôgæ Å 31 &ŠÔZ0ŠÔ�Ô@$ÔŠæ Å 02 31 4x ÎiŠÔZ�ÛziŠÔ±håIÔ÷ŠÔŠæ Å ÎiŠÔZ�ÛziŠÔyZæÔ6i0 Å 5x Š„zŠ0ZyzŠârz0zÍl Å 71 |zŠ„zŠârz0zÍl Å 62 71 6x è;ZiíuÛzViŠ0 Å 03 è;Zi&4pî EGI0u'iŠ0 Å 54 82 7x %æENEZV;ViŠ0 'BiZ§ Å ÍAZV@745å EGE 'y§ Å 8x 2C ŠkÜZ#îV� è gZ<Ø Å 43 ZÍw#îÈ� è gZ<Ø Å 15 23 9x 3C !g�ògzŠ è ^ik Å 54 gZ“z‚âyz�ó'Š Å 66 04 01x ¡]pVØŠ è T*VÈ Å 15 ¡]/;ŠgpV£ èT Å 57 54 11

:m842( ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ñÑ*$äZk^´ÅFç”{ßg]Ì�z�ÉŠ~ìÔ�Z�Zðßg]¶) 1D:m47( ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo tp~ÔñÑ*¤ZòÆÂzŠÑä6ň) 2D

Šzx è TZÍw)m47(ZzgT ]‰†]…ôìç�p :m052(1 ‰†æ�ô…Êjä }Ã!VÎ}2wó'ŠX) 0Å ñÑ*$äZkÄÆqŠzxÃZk§b–ì: 3D)m66(ŠzâV~LLògzŠóóìX

ÖÃäÚ_^

•nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^

031

Page 129: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � Ô�zx ]‰†]…ìç�p � �à] Fç�x ÒZi±©0î YEG0$Õä NO‚ÛzŠ ί Å 57 $ÕäOÒgZ7åO]‚ÛzŠ w½ Å 311 76 21

!iâgZ'øV}#Öág Å 78 !iâgZ'øV}#Ö¦Zg Å 921 67 31x ZZx™Š è Z}FZh{? Å 39 Z}FZhi$ÒZZx™Š Å Z³ 18 41x 'ÂCÙW¸igZZ�x™Š Å »'ŠzgÒZcx™Š Å ÿgñiÔ

Zzwþ51

x ¤5ŠâŠxò� 'ŠÁ Å 59r-AêEaMò� è 'É Å Š 28 61

x @i{•Ñ!iZgWh3h Å 69 @i{•Ñ!iZg}'Šæ Å z 48 71x ZiŠ#Ö!Š·gWh3h Å Ï;ñsuÛzVi0 Å 81

�ÛŠz¸xWcqŠvZ0 Å 89 �ÛŠz¸xWcqŠvZ0 Å 2 68x yzÍCÙKyzZºZ0 Å 0Z ëìwzëdz� Å 91

aViï]p÷gZÛzVŠ@ Å 001 aViï]p÷gZÛzV±håI Å 5 78 02x Ãiw±Ší}Z5+ Å 201 œjä$�*î EE0Z¶+ Å 8 98 12x â gZlèZiÒZ°§ Å 601 â 6Š{ÈZi^�Ïî I0Z°§ Å 31 29 22x ZzZiÆäM+Bý

GMEMQ�ØŠ è» Å 901 p÷ZiÆäM+BýGMEMQ�+ è» Å 91 59 32

131Ãgϯx

Æù´

Page 130: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � Ô�zx ]‰†]…ìç�p � �à] Fç��øiøíøÌû]ôÞùÔ]øÞûkø]�ûøÂû×Fo 1C ÎöØû qí�3 901 mFÛöçû�Fo�øiøíøÌû]ôÞôùo�ømøíø^ÍöÖø�øp$]ÖûÛö�û�ø×öçûáø qí�2 91 59 42

Š“ c.çIGL@Wæ3hZi§½ Å 411 ÈÒiŠè}ZiŠZâyŠ“ Å 52 99 52x Zz†°i0{� Ziyz¶ Å Š“zŠgZi3454ø XGE

GI°i0{� Å 62x Šwi)Zv�V'+ Å 811 ›Zif}h4±håI Å 23 201 72

ÈÒ©gñâZ}1fgñZ„ Å 221 $�*îEE0¢VñâZ}1fgñZ„ Å 53 601 82

i0Ï�Š!,‡âVm] Å 421 i0Ï�ŠiZ,‡âVm] Å 83 92è<Ø¤Ä è @(„µ Å 331 è<Ø¤Ä è @Ó#Öµ Å 94 611 03

C2 ¯ÑC4èFGpVØŠ è {ZiŠ„ Å 531¯ÑC4èFGpVØŠ è {ZiŠ„ Å 25 711 13

x 1ÛzVgzŠ è Zimâ# Å �ZimÛzV±håI è g| Å 23x �aVgÄZiœZ¨¸5 Å 041 aV6.V”œZ¨¸5 Å 85 121 33x 'áÈ*¤ŠŠ"ç Å 741 *¤ŠŠ"ç ZiìÁ Å 66 721 43

@¼'íglWæwZx Å 741 3C @¼ŠgíglWæwZx Å 66 721 53

')Îg{È:86( Î×ß^�iíÌ 0u»9QZk§bì: Ά�á 1D:m652(�Šg„7ìX ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ñÑ*$äLLpV”óó–ì) 2D

:m011( ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo LLb-gl'Šc§ZzwZxóó) Å TZÍwÅZ�á®ÐIZk^´Å!ÇZ�Zðßg]t¶: 3D

ÖÃäÚ_^

•nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^

231

Page 131: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � Ô�zx ]‰†]…ìç�p � �à] Fç�x õZ¤Ä F�Zi¤ò Å 841 õZ¤Ä � F�Zi7åO Å 86 821 63x Ã=?ò@['¤ŠzÈp÷ Å 351 uDaZÁZ0gpÈp÷ Å 57 231 73

CkòpZ@' è %œ Å 451 �ŠrZ@' è ÄZy:%œ 77 331 83

x p÷ ^�Ïî I0Zz6Š{ZiŠz� Å 551 p÷ ^�Ïî I0ZzY)!sZiŠz� Å 77 431 93x ZzŠxl÷Z0g> è W> Å 551 ZzŠxl÷Z0g±håI è W> 87 431 04x Ñ!¤Šhzi�á/'Šy Å ÑÈî0¤ŠŠi�á/'Šæ 14x X5 è æ¬÷� Å 061 X5 è� ZiìÁ Å 38 731 24x Zz„ iZâZ`Z']Z0ZÄ Å 161 Zz„ ZâZ`Z']Z0ZÄ Å 58 831 34x ¥VŠ è h�VgZë Å 561 h�VgZzg!îI0¥VŠ Å 29 241 44

¬Å.5éG[� è @(Zipgæ Å 761 ¬Å.5éG[� è Zipgæ ] 7åO Å 49 341 54x Zâ'Š è @�ZiÕ Å 761 ZâØŠ è @¸~ZiÕ Å 49 341 64

!iÎ}p$h4è GIGEòWgŠl Å 071 @q}p$h4è GIGE!iWgŠl Å 89 641 74

331Ãgϯx

Æù´

Page 132: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � Ô�zx ]‰†]…ìç�p � �à] Fç�x ZsxV;gzVgæ è ‡Z Å 481 �óŠZã�;gzyZ°æ Å 811 951 84

Â{ñl� {¿ 1C Zi$o-.øE

GI Å 681 Â{ñl� Zi�Zø{¿ Å 021 061 94gzc~Ñ™*åÃZC�g�{ è 'Tä¬Ý

ZÕ(�cX�gåä ]Úài�Ò�qn�]áe�p�×Ü )ZkÆA~pl�ù~ÃZKeŠg'

591 qí�2'TÃÑ™*íä�}ÆA~ZKeŠg'

431 761 05

@�i&éEOg„RU Å 891 è "{U @�iî) Å 813 071 15)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � ÔZzw …Úç‡e1ìç�p � �à] Fç�YV@Šg�V' è ZkÄ:g|

ÐÔWyJÆ8zõ OÃZqȯŠcŠìX

691 ![:LL²nqw''óóTZÍw~ÑzqÐWyJZqÚÈÅ~åX

631 861

:m952(�Šg„7ìX ‰†æ�ô…Êjä $™räZÐLLéóó–ì) 1D

ÖÃäÚ_^

•nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^

431

Page 133: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)Š(¼*z@í)Š(~‰£â]6FKZÃgzrg#~¼*z@íňìX ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � Ô�zx ]‰†]…ìç�p � �à]FKZ«Š~ˆ:)1(ZiÎZÁWÇ')2(ZiÎZÁZ#k'

42 ŠzZÃgÅFKZk§b¶:)1(ZiÎZÁZ#k')2(ZiÎZÁWÇ'

73 32

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ � ÔZÍw …Úç‡e1ìç�p �ZkÄÃ![»�ZįŠcŠìX 39 tÄ:

F' è Z}Ã'ŒFKÆZ±gÐZk![»Ù

ÄìX

[

úVÃQ«ŠcŠì:@i{Z0Z¯ÃaZ+

IVŠgŠ“zŠgaZ+

301 ZkÄÅtßg]ì:IVŠgŠ“zŠgaZ+@i{Z0Z¯ÃaZ+

9

Z,�Šg è Šzu}ÄÃ![:LLŠgpiâUZzoóó»ZÍBįŠcŠX

341 ZÃgÅFKZk§b¶:)1(„�áVg$hå G'

q¢�' è )2(Ç

36

Šzu}ÄÃZk![»,ƒZVįŠcŠX

441 ZÃgÅFKt¶:)1(Z}�ZiZuZ§Š,')2(î'Šw'

36D46

531ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 134: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Šzu}ÄÃ![LLŠgpZ,�§‹%œóó'»‚ÂZVįŠcŠX

551 ZÃgÅFKZk§b¶:$ðEN' è )1(¤péxl÷' Š Zz è é)2(W>

87

¬ÄÃZkÈ»aåįŠcŠX 681 ZÃgÅFKZk§b¶: 121 - 021)1(Zi�Zø{¿Â'

)Wñ!' è )2(D…Úç‡ôe1 )TŠzx(Zzg ]‰†]…ôìç�p ìZec~ ik )Š(Æ ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

)TZÍw(ÅqgzfsZÝoŠg„™Š~ˆ�: ìç�p

)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ Ô�zx ]‰†]…ôìç�p

9 S � ß S �!îEN� 2 11 !îE� 6 61yŠÒ 21 11 yŠ{ 8 71YÈ˜È 5 61 YȘV 2 426zZi 01 61 6zZg 2 52$§öEEL 1 71 Ô 5 52i0ZÈ 2 82 i0ZV 3 24

zZ âz 2 13 âîZz 4 64™Šy 4 13 ™ŠV 6 64pVW�áx 5 13 pyW�áx 7

zy 2 23 zV 7 74Šzª 2 74 è Šzª 2 96]á]Ö’ù×çFéißFoÂà]ÖËv�^ð qí�1 74 ]Ö’×çéiß`oÂà]ÖËv�^ð qí�1 07

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^631

Page 135: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 S � ß S �ó]Wñizzí 2 84 ó]Wñizí 5 07ZÞ 9 84 ]Ö?o 5 17Ÿmf×oF 1 94 Ÿmf×o 1 27Ÿmf×oF qí�1 94 mf×oô Ÿ qí

u 1 45 v 6 97âè FI 3 55 Âè FI 5 18

âYz… 4 95 âî… 7 78!h42.ç GEG 7 46 !k2.çGGE 5 59!{u 5 66 '{u 1 89

ð Z'Z� 21 66 Z'Z�ñ 8 89f 9 77 è 8ø N 4 611

uZ è‘ 7 98 cgZ è‘ 3 231)�( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ÔZÍw …Úç‡e1ìç�p

9 S � ß S �cŠì Š s™ v„ Šâp ZZxƧ] 5 Šâpm1

Zs !{3ðE

Go 4 Šâpm2Zs ŠzÂV 5 Šâpm2

m«uøo% 11 59 c9ö Oz 3 5@i{Zir 01 821 @i{Zgr 5 44]Ö‚]Åô qí�2 241 ]Ö‚]ï qí�2 16Ú^‡ø]Éø 21 681 Ú^‡ø]Éö 8 121

o] 9 491 o] 8 231

731ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 136: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)Š(~$2gñ�Š�: ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ 1qgzfsZÝoÔ)�( Úç‡ … æ ]‰†]… Ô�zx ]‰†]…ôìç�p

ß S � ß S �}Zîg0 9 2 }Zîg0 3 2

è¬ 2 9 è¬ 6 31

§‹$›45é GGOE‹ 2 21 §‹$›45é GGOE‹ 2 81+BøE

ƒ 6 13+BøE

ƒ 8 64

p–0µ 1 43 p–0µ 2 46

ÿ'×htt� è i0ZVÉLLwóóÃ�g™Šcþ

8 54 i0ZVÉ 2 76

âî… 3 74 âî… 3 96

ÑS[ 4 74 ÑS[ 4 96

ÚßZ_ qí�2 84 ÚßZ_ qí 17

xZy 2 94 xZy 2 27

õZ 6 66 õZ 2 89

Wfg 21 66 Wfg 8 89

:ì 11 86 :ì 1 201

Wˆ)tÌßì( 8 47 W¶î Y0� 5 111$™+<éEE

Xñ 11 57 $™+<éEE

Xñ 7 311

Zz! qí�1 67 Zz! qí�1 411

!Ñî 6 68 !Ñî 6 721

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^831

Page 137: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

WŠgl)ªZkÂ~tÅßg]$wˆìXLLWfglóóZzgLLWŠglóóŠzâV

ß�X9LLWiglóóìX(

4 09 Wfgl 4 331

)�( Úç‡ … æ ]‰†]… ÔZÍw …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p

ß S � ß S �0g;ñ 4 301 0g;ñ 5 9]Ö†uûÛFàø qí 501 ]Ö†uûÛFàø 8qí 21Z0$g<é GIX 11 601 Z0$g<é GIX 6 418g+<é FIXñ 9 801 8g+<é FIXñ 3 81

œ&ñgZœ&ñ 3 901 œ&ñgZœ&ñ 6 81»ZÉÒ3ï OGI qí�2 611 »ZÉÒ3ï OGI qí�1 92}Z„ 4 811 }Z„ 8 13Ò�ñ)tÌßì( 8 121 Ò�~ 3 43

ï mø^Úö†öÒöÜ qí�2 421 ï mø^Úö†öÒöÜ qí�2 83WtÑf»Q$2gßì qí 331 WtÑf»Qßì qí 84g9*îGZÉÒ›é OÅ)4èG 11 041 g9*îGZrÅ)4èG 7 95$2gß qí�1 241 ÊøjøÏø_$Ãöçû]ý‡öeû†]÷ qí�1 16ÞÓ†] qí ÞÓ†] qígZi~ñ 3 541 gZi~ñ 6 36ÖjÓçÞç qí�3 261 ÖjÓçÞç qí�1 78

é‰ zâå qí�3 261 é‰ zâå qí�3 78Öf^‰ÓÜ qí 371 Öf^‰ÓÜ qí�1 301

931ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 138: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ß S � ß S �!v 6 381 !v 6 611

ÿLLgóó6ikÅ ]Éö]Öfø’ø†ø ‡ø(i'¯ðˆì1tÌßìXþ

21 681 ]Éö]Öfø’ø†ô ‡ø 8 121

)Š(~qgzfs5ZÝo¥z5kƒ�: ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

9 ß S �gzò gz~ 21 01ñ\öL ñ\öWL 7 61ÍCÙè~ ÍCÙ~ 4 33

Ws è �CÙ WÜ è �CÙ 6 33ŠAzË ŠAî¢-<é GEX 9 33

‚ÛzŠ �ÛzŠ 01 33&Š 2Š 11 738k0î EG0â )zâ 4 04

qd/õ IG»Wy~zLL—ìÔW›ŒÛWãŧsóóg^ŠìX

qí�1 54

aZ 3Z 5 54gDÙy gDÙV 5 35

Z+zWV)Šzu}Zec~ZktÅZ&b™Š~¶Ô1ikÃZec~ttŠz!g{gz5kƒìX(

Z,zWV 1 09

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^041

Page 139: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S ��ÛΊ �ÛñŠ 3 490gÜ 0g"0î EE 7 59ªCÙlZix x¸ ªCÙlZg 8 89ŠgÒïGpŠgZ ŠgÒïGgZpŠ 11 90100zÎy 00îÎy 5 911

72 mŠZV mŠZV 11 721æ!�øÝø æ]¤�Ý qí 031

1C ²;k5é XGV  ;k5é GXGV 01 441Z·ÎZg c.çINGÎZg 7 841

ŠgZ ŠZ 01 051BZz Zz èB 21 651�ZgŠl �Zgl 4 071

tÂZkÄ~Wcì: 1D ;k5é GXGV'pg~ è �áhZi−

!iŠgW¶îÃV6zg~ÝxgÎw$äLL ;k5é GXGVóóûAÅtŒÛZgŠïƒñ–ì�:LL�V²;k5é XGVƒ*ecÔ

:032D132( Ú_^Ög]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ Yè ;k5é GXGy)yZ‚y(Ã−ÐÃðo97X))3291Y( ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ÂzìÔ@ëtt»AÅ7XtÄ«!g è ñÑ*$ÅZ&b‡.Þ

ÔÃgÏ Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù ~�áïHŠåXZk~ZzgˆÆÓxZexV~LL ;k5é GXGyóóìX)уgÔ3791Y(ÅÂ"ñÑ*$ÅgZÉðZzgôZã~ƒðÔZk~ÌLL ;k5é GXGVóóìXZk

e~eZ˱†Zv»ìwì�:LL´)ä²;k5é XGVà;k5é GXGVÉ™ZLŸZzgfztÅ{gZ:m41(Šg|�VLL ;k5é GXGVóó»û7Ô ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù Ô I~»o]ŠcìXóó)l)

3291Y~«!gLL²;k5é XGVóóÆO}tÐLL ;k5é GXGVóó¾ŠX´)ZDwÅi0Ï~3291Y»Wy~ZecåÔˆ~ZkÂÅo7ƒmXeìÔpŠ´) ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ~,·Ôt

ZDwäzŠ}~LL ;k5é GXGVóó–ƒZzg³~t!]*e7XZ¤Z(ìAÌttZ+zZãì�ZÐps™*¢zg~ìÔZÏaëäZÐߌÛZgŠcìX

141ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 140: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÔTÎx(× …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p ÔTXgxZzg ]‰†]…ôìç�p ŠzuZZec) » 1C ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡C2 Šg`HŠìX 1928 (~Æ6�áùƒZXuzgt6�ÎäzZàáЂÁZ�á®

!kxÔÄ~ùúVÅÂ"Ô†ZØ6z,g¶H™DÔ1ZkZecÅÂ")7291Y(Å ‡eç…ôÂrÜ LL·ŒpÛöauäуgóóäÅìXZÏiâä~,·

Â"ÌZqZzgplâö)·œ&(äÅXË)©à:ÐÔÂ"6z,g¶ÆO}·ŒZzg·œ&ЙZðˆXeìZyZcx~Ò†ZØÔуg~ñ�Š:

x(‚.ZecЊg}(~ì1 ‰ ÆZkZecÅÆ)91<41k ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ƒVXS~4'ŒÛZgg3ŠìXZZ1Z[ÆW¸izZ!xZzgZÃgzjZÙÅFKz){~ !g{

‚.ìÔ1uzgtÆZ0gÔuzgtÆ è ‚—Zec»SnqHŠìXuzgtÅ„g]ø��2Њâpvs™ŠcŠìZzgZk(!§Z�á®ÅzŸsZk§bňì:

Xgx è :Z�á® ]‰†]…ôìç�pÎx è :Z�á® …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p

ÅZ&b 8291YÆZkZec~TZÍw)ŠÔ3291Y(Æøfs,]�þ %ZŠì��Zzg2Ð%ZŠìS� 9Ð ~ 9

2 ÿzŸs: ƒðìX942 Ô 84

qí�2 Ô 545 Ô 441 Ô 7311 Ô 3301 Ô 339 Ô 336 Ô 334 Ô 0121

611qí

�290111

9013

Ô 60111 Ô 401

9 Ô 898 Ô 598 Ô 493 Ô 091 Ô 777 Ô 47

8 Ô 355

68121 Ô 071

4 Ô 261qí�2 Ô 261

qí�1Ô 65121 Ô 051

01 Ô 8417 Ô 241

qí�2 Ô 241qí�1 Ô 121

8

Ô 8911

Ô 5914

Ô 4919

Ô 191qí�1 )LLgóóÅi'UŠ~ìXZ[ZÐ*x7JYYì(

)Š(%ZŠ1YñÇXóó ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ÐLL ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ Tg~ { WÒ 1DZÃ{âV~ZkZecÆ�°ÔgZ¶Z�zsÅÃЦg}ÔZyƒ6Zϧb 2D

Ô �ÎäzZàáЂÁZ�ᮊg`ìX¸�S®Æz‰Ü‚ÁZ�á®:–YeZkaˆ~t§iZ(gHŠX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^241

Page 141: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

@ëTZÍw)ŠÔ3291Y(Æqgzfs,]ÅZÝo)XÅ׶yŠ„*,]~ÅY_ì(8291YÆZkZec~Ì$2gñ�Š�:

94qí�1 Ô 74

4Ô 743Ô 548Ô 044

Ô 136 Ô ì( )tÅßg]$wˆ 61

7Ô 212

Ô24

Ô 67qí�1 Ô 57

11Ô 8611Ô 6621Ô 666Ô )qd/õ IG»Wy~z:LLW›ŒÛWãŧsóóg^Šì(

Ô 421qí�2 Ô 911

5Ô 8114

Ô 8019Ô 501

qí Ô 5012

Ô 3014 Ô )WfglÌßì( 09

4Ô 686

04111 Ô )WtÑf»tQÌßì( 331

qí Ô )zWŠxÌßì( 031qí Ô 721

11

X 79101Ô )/vÌßì( 381

6Ô 371

qí Ô 8612 qí� Ô 541

3Ô 4412Ô 241

qí�1 )tÅâÎÔ $wˆì(

ÆZkZec)8291Y(~¼5ZÝoÌ¥z5kƒ�: ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

9 ß S �*“ ª^q:¦“ 01 5)õF0 #/õ FMJ 2 6ñ\öL ñ\ö WL 7 61"+CÐöGEO "x 01 42èŒ f 9 73izgt Šzgt qí 44ZkV Zky 5 15‚i* Îi* 2 25»ÄŠw ÇÄŠw 7 16*i‚âÈ *gz‚âíL 11 7685å ENE~ 745å ENEG~ qí�2 57

341ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 142: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �*Zg ¦Zg qí�6 57!5ÿIL é 4 18”~ Ø~ 5q2 18@§:æ N *§:æ N 4 38gÁ}Zz gÁñ 2 1516Z„ 6„ 4 661Z+zWV Z,zWV 1 071

zZ 0ZiŠ Z z 'ŠZgŠ 'ŠZgŠZ0ZiŠZiz 7 171u*“ u¦“ 7 171u*“ ^qUã:u¦“ 9 171u*“ u¦“ 01 171

» ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ P™{!ÑZecÔ´)ZDwÅi0Ï~Z�á®5kƒäzZÑÔ)Š(» ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ Wy~ZecåXZ†Zec!g{'kÆzMÐ0491Y~ÖXt

�ZZecåX¬ZzgŠzu}Zec~uzgtÅ%ã6lÆäcZQ~Z°ZŠLL687óóŠg`K‰ÔZkZec~ÔZ¹¸�*ŠZ·îg6ÔFu™ŠcŠXZDwÅzÃ]ÆÔ�áùƒäzZáZk¬Zec6£¾Z�á®Ð0t]«!gŠg`

HŠ:LL]£tìhFÀeYzhZDwîZ»t´)eZËu·ZDwmZ°õôp�óóXŠg}£ì@ëZ1Z[ÆW¸izZ!x6ÔZÃgzjZÙÅFKz){~‚—Zec)8291Y(„7Ãg;ìX

0491YÆZkZec~ÔTŠzx)ŠÔ8291Y(Æqgzfs,]ÅZÝoÅoƒì:

Ô 271

Ô 7611

Ô 666

Ô 167

Ô 155

Ô 44qí Ô 73

9Ô 4201

Ô 617

Ô62

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^441

Page 143: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ô 371qí Ô 071

1Ô 1512

Ô 9115

Ô 384

Ô 185

Ô 184

Ô 576

@ëTŠzx)ŠÔ8291Y(Æqgzfs,]ÅZÝo)XÅ׶yŠ„*,]~ÅY_ì(0491YÆZkZec~Ì$2gñ�Š�:

Ô 57qí Ô 86

11Ô 6621

Ô 252

Ô 74qí

�1Ô 744

Ô 743

Ô 548

Ô 044

Ô 136

Ô 212

Ô501Ô24

Ô 031qí Ô 521

11Ô 421

qí�2 Ô 8114

Ô 8019

Ô 501qí Ô 501

2Ô 3014

Ô 094Ô 686Ô 185Ô 67

qí�1 Ô 5711

X 79101

Ô 17101

Ô 1719

)ŠzZÝo(Ô 1717

Ô 861qí�2 Ô 661

4Ô 6414Ô 5413Ô 04111Ô 331qí

0491YÆZkZec~P5ZÝo¥z5kƒ�:9 ß S �g|!i C1 *i è g| 9 5

*“ ^qUã:¦“ 01 5Q Å5ÑõG qí�1 9*Zg ¦Zg 6 57

ŧs21þt Êô×ônûà Ÿ]öug%]Ÿ6 qí»!¹zÿ qí�2 67ÐvsƒŠìX

ps ps 3 111

ŸÞøfôoû Þøfô$o Ÿ 4 811

pZ@ pZ0 3 841

BZzgZ6zg* ¹Zz6zg* 21 651

:m24 ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ô Ú_^Ög ÝxgÎw$Ô 1D

541ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 144: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

tZÝoÔ®ZŠ~Ô‚—Z�áoVÆ£«~{àÁ�XTÐtZ0Zi{ÎcŠZzgZôoлx1X Š YYì�plâöZzgôZÈZ�á®ä×icŠ{F

…Úç‡ôe1 Zzg ]‰†]…ôìç�p Z�á®8491Y~¿~WðXt {Ò ÅW ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡Åa¶ŠZ�᮶XZkZec~uzgtÆZÖpps™Šb‰XZ[ZkÅ ìç�p

ßg]tì:]£tôp

ZuZgzgñiZDw

uzgtÆZ0g)16(Â[Æ!§Z�á®Ð0qgzfsÃZŠg`�:!gŠzì0491Y ZuZgzgñi)CÙŠzŠ( )ikôZã!gÎì8491Y ZuZgzgñi)CÙŠzŠ( aŠO~·@

)0õDÙZg( Z*Z}()CÙŠzŠ(ÅZZ�áoVÆ!g}~ ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ t¥â]Šg„7�X

9ßg‹qwZk§bì:Š!gZÍw:3291YÔZuZ§pŠ~Z�á®ÎxÔgñ¯"pŠ~Z�ᮊzx

Z�á®Îx ZsÔ Š!gŠzx:8291YÔZsÔZ�á®XgxÔZ�á®Xgx ZsÔ Z�á®QÔ ZsÔ Š!gÎx:0491YÔ

Z�á®Q ZsÔ Z�á®¼Ô ZsÔ Š!gXgx:8491YÔÅo ,]Å!V ZkZec)8491Y(~‚—Zec)0491Y(Åqgzfs

: ēX 1113

Ô 501qí Ô 501

2Ô 185

Ô 576

Ô 743

Ô 044

Ô 136

@ëqgzfs,]ÅZÝo$2gñ�Š�:

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^641

Page 145: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ô 252

Ô 94qí�1 Ô 74

4Ô 548Ô 325Ô 617Ô 212Ô 9

qí�1 Ô)^qZÍwZzgqUã( 59Ô24

Ô ŠzZÝo 8114

Ô 8119

Ô 8019

Ô 3014

Ô 094

Ô 686

Ô 672 qí� Ô 67

qí�1 Ô 5711Ô 8611Ô 6621

Ô 6614

Ô )ŠzZÝo( 65121

Ô 84111

Ô 8413

Ô 41 53

Ô 41 011

Ô 331qí�1 Ô 031

qí Ô 72111

Ô 421qí�2

X 79101

Ô 17101

Ô 1719

Ô )ŠzZÝo( 1717

Ô 861qí�2

ZkZec)8491Y(~qgzfs5ZÝo¥z5kƒ�:9 ß S �LLgZê�~:Ïzuzgóó qí�1÷zsì: 7 4LL*Äðóó qí�1÷zsì: 1 5LLð:bÆ\»*xóó qí�1÷zsì: 8 9

upl upŠ 3 54ÁV�Š Á�Š 3 05

W X 01 55�v �v 11 67Z+zWV Z,zWV 9 18ìø×øÐø ìø×øÐû qí�1 58{r›4èE

G {r›4èGE 8 68XW!îGG ÞßùÙ XWt ißùˆÙ qí�2 68Ky KV 2 89

]øiûÏFÓöÜû ]iøÏûÓöÜû qí�1 021è *zW è *zX 9 221

*ÂZÈ *ÂZV 8 321

741ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 146: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �í‰ Šú} Šú} 5 421

&B¨ÒøEI &B¨Òø

E7 241

è+ è, 21 651]Öûfø’ø†ö ]Öûfø’ø†ø 21 681+Bk5å EEIGø�0 .ø�0 9 691

Z-.VÐTÅ ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ZkZecÅ.VÃôp™1ŠZzg1791YJYCg„)ZyZexVÅÂÒC,Ôe�1~5±Ù(X

OçZyƒZexV~Ô8491YÆZecÅÓxZÝoñ�Š�XZ%{]S®ÐÔZy.V~yZ!Æ:ÔZyZexV~}}5ZÝogzúƒ�Ô}:

9 ß S �Z±g Z745é EGEg 9 97

| #-ö EG 2 48»gê »gl 11 78Ší} Šá} 11 201!Z!ïOG !Z„ 4 031

ƈ ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ 2791Y~ÔÓxÄ~ùúVÅÂ"ZiaçLâ™ZðˆÔOçÆZec)6791Yzâˆ(ZÏ5Â")ZiúŠZvœj(ÐTK‰�XZy

ÆK~cƒÏX Ò×n^lô]Îf^ÙÊ^…‰o ,]~ {Ò ZexVÆõÍzçT6ÔW

\Äæt /

ìç�p ]‰†]…ô ÅŠzS®)01Z6s8191Y(Zzg!›é Sˆ …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p ´)ZDwÆŠzu}ZecÅ»g~ÐÃgrƒñÂÃgÏÍðŧsZy»~yizgzV6åX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^841

Page 147: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ï%ÆaQgŠzÆ 1C Z¤pÇìÇìÔz{QgŠz~ÌĶî Mf¸Ô1LLŠw»ggóó2C ÅZqçwQ,Vä5191Y µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ £«~ÃgÏÃicŠ{ñizV0D¸X-Vµn^Ýô ~½¶ZzgeìÔ‰Švç1]ZÏŠzg~ÔcQkÐ̬½ƒVÔ@ë

ÔTŠzxŊƈ„ÔKzwÅX ]‰†]…ôìç�p ŧs7g~ÂzÔQ,Vä Ú�†Ñ

ù·»g™1Yñ)ZÆ' qZ C3 Z’Z~Zy»ìwå�QgŠzZzgÃgÏàâ]Ã5™9191Y(Ô1ˆ~QgŠz¯xÃXi{ù´~�áï™ä»ZgZŠ{Fu™ŠcXZk§bŠ-Zy

‚hñ&'kÔ ã½ C4 ÃgÏÅB#ÖXi{ù´Æ¡ZqäðÆ'Z'k¶XÅZ�á®»ezweZÑŠXZDweT¸�ZyÆf‚ µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ 3291YÆZzZb~Ô

~�'×hLLP¢zg~óó>ñ�Š�Ôz{ÌČۤk6vƒYNÔAù·�áùH„ C6 Oç�Ûzg~ C5 (x»ZÜZgå�Aƒ[ìÔZÐ�áù™ŠcYñX è YñÔ1ZyÆzZ−

¦g‰X ~ C7 ÐZ�á®Å»g~ÑzqƒÔâgaZzgZ6sÂ"zS®Æ%Zizg7¿ Z C8 Â[)ªÑÈî0îgÐWyJÔm�1@002(ÅÂ"ƒðÔŠâp è ¬Q

C9X Æ,])Z³@q(ˆ~‘‰

:m99 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 1D:m99@001 Zs 2D

ÔZÍw:m701 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3DÔŠzx:m951 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 4DÔZÍw:m432ÿZkâ»9‚Á’k3291YìXþ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä D5ÔZÍw:m124D224 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä D6

ÆZ�á�%ZiÐWÇ{™DgìX µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ Zk²á~ÔZDwZLŠz2Và 7D:m931(X �^�]Îf^Ù m722D : ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo )

ZDwñi*уg~ôpZqNÒn~ÔZDwÅZK’k~z{Z’Zðï]X�ÔTÅ 8D»Šâp–XtŠ„â“ï]Zôm~~�XZk),· µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ãŠ6Q,Vä

’kÆa5±Ù:e�2X:m271 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù D9

941ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 148: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

'gZY¨6�áŠ�áŠÃ81B#3291YƯ[~��:LLŠz‹ÐjƒVÔÅZ�ᮃðÔ~äDÃZqZg‚w™ä»¬„ µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ´ª~ è qª#ÆËgzi¾™»gƒðXZkZz~�áŠÃÂ[ï_ B cÂ[4 Í C1 Ég3åóóX

Æ!g}~ZKgZ}»ZÖg µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ¶XQ,VäZDwÆ*x41B#Æâ~#ÃÔÂуgÐ8c9ÃgzZ:ňƒÏX B HXZ¤�áŠÃtÂ[Šzgzi̬BƒÔª21

gzi-о™WðX Ë C2 #ÆŠgxy B ÍcÂ[5Ð9ÆŠzu}ZecÅŠzS®)8191Y(ƈ ]‰†]…ôìç�p Zz6f™W[ì�

»icŠ{Fz µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ŧs;ðÆ‚BázƒñXÍc µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ „ÔZDw8191YZzg3291YÆŠgxy–ŠXZDwñi*уg~ôpÔZDwÅNÒçVÐÌ

żŠàâ]Æ‚BZy»iâU’k µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ZkÅ@GƒCìXZyÒçV~}: 3C Šg`ìÔ

8191Y Ä1}É 952 m: µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

#2291Y �á�zâ„ 682�Ñð8191Y çw)¾z‹Vzá'( 623z‰Z6s9191Y \x 753

:m741 �^�]Îf^Ù 1DZ�á®Æ!g}~qgzfsÒ*]oÔ�: è Å@gõ µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ZkZ±gÐ 2D

:m96( +†]Úo ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^ÙeßÝ ÅZ�á®»ìóóX) µnÝôÚ�†Ñ )1(·†ZvŒÛ7:LL2291Y't‚w]Îf^ÙÒ^ƒaßo Z6s3291YÆWy~�áùƒðóóX) µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ )2(eZËÝx@fzZ3g:

:m411(X ]…iÏ^:m121(X ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù �áùƒóóX) µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ )3(†ZØ‚´:LLJ#ÿ3291YþÃ

:m381(X ‰†+„�kô]Îf^Ù ¬x6WðX) è© )4(eZˆZ?xpgæ:LLtÂ[J#3291YÉZ�ágZ]ÐFVÆ:©6ÌgzÝ7Cì}:´)ZDwä�563ÅÄ D3

LL,z(„óóƬÄÆŠzu}´6¶y¯™qd/õ IG~Zôm~»t]ŠgHì:Bradley's defination of metaphysics which suggested this half verse.

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^051

Page 149: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

g!¦�841@151Æ‚Btâ^Šg`ì:LLg!È‹!ÑŠgâ·gHâ”óóXZ~2291YÆâ6£Ä’kLLHâ·góóŠg`ìXÍct B ñÑ*Ñy0z~Æ*x3

g!È]Z~2291Y~èIXÅÂ"†ZØ)6z,g¶(äÅXQ»4!g{S~ZzgŠâd µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

)�Z³@b=8,](»ZRS~ìXg!È])ÑÈî0îg(»4WJS~)°�:p}7Š~ˆX è Šzg!È](ìXƒÐ(~{òtÃWCì�W¸i~z„

'×h'WVZk~qgzfsZÝoÌñ�Š�:9 ß S �ZY: ZYU 41 [1ey 1Šy 91 ŠÎZ

1CÎZñ 02 {

Wig Wfg 3 41Gz Gƒ 2 02� È 7 47Wigx Wfgx 01 58

« ¬ 9 98²;hé Xg Ãög 9 301Ñ!i{u ÑÈî0{u 8 411

^» ^”î0L 4 711v ÉÓÏî LŠ 5 911� ¢©->î

EGGX 9 721

gzÈ ŠzÈ qí 031

eìÔzZãîg6ZÐLLtóót:HYñ1tLLÎZ}óó»ûÔ¾qw7ìX 1D

151ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 150: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �è� ¢©->î

EGGX 8 341

$©3ð EEG) $©3ð E

EGñ 9 341iŠ ig 1 851ŠgW ŠgZ 01 361YxWæ YxWzgŠ 4 781'z 'Š 1 291

zø é‰èñ ƒÿEOLøƒ 6 291

'*zc '*ƒc 1 791Zk) C1 ©¬x6WD„ÔŠz‹ÆZ0gÛÆŒÛd�Ûz|ƒX µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

ÃZDwä3291YÅu‹¤â„~ŠzuZZec%A™*Ñzq è7 ©à=qƪZec2B�Ûzg~ 2C ™Šc)TÆ!g}~Zy»ìwå�:LL¸�*~TƒÏóó(X

ZkZz~ŠzuZZec%Aƒ™Â"ƒ[åXOç�Ûzg~4291Y 3C ƒŠÔ 4291YJ»C5 gaƬ‹~©¬x6WcX Zzgâ 4C „~tZecS®Æa6ö�ŠcŠ

¬Zec~'×hFLL¢zg~óóàâ]Ì�áï™*eT ZDw tf™W[ì�¸Ô1�âg·ÆZÜZg6ÔÂ[ÔZŸ¯VÆ%„Ô¢�áù™ã7~XZ[Šzu}

:m54 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 1D:m591ÿeìtìw´)ZDwÃZkaWcƒ�ZÏiâä~ZyÆQgŠz¯x» ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 2D

:m4þ ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù ù·Ô-»zcã'ÞÐYLÅ?m‚tWð¶XÔŠzx:m661 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D

:m94 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 4D]æ…]Ñô âga4291YÅ@gõŠg`ì)fZ!: B ZDwäxVÂxZ−+Ã�@tHÔZk672 5D

âga4291YÅ@gõŠg`ìX@ B :m931(X6zW'ZîyÃ7™Š{°601 +Ü+�jäTŠzx9991YÔm373 ]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6 Š&ÀŸ/õ GG:

µn^Ýô Ô ZÍw : Å�Ûz|Æ!g}~†ZØ‚´ÆŠz�ŠÒ*]X� µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ÿH¤ZòÆ*x Ô m321(XŠzx : ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù »ªZecWJââ{Åæ]~»ƒŠ) Ú�†Ñ

»ªZec�ZqDÙZg)�WÒ{Ô6( µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ 51B�Ûzg~5291YÆâ~��:

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^251

Page 151: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zec~ÔZ,VäZh@:,]»ZŸ†HX¼ŠZÃgZzgjZÙvs™ŠbZzg¬Zec6ûzVZzg‰Zx[ÆtgzVÅgzÝ~FZÃg~FZçÌXÔXÅ,tì:

)Z³(÷zÃ]:�Û8óó(ÆtŠzZÃg: è 741>ZyLLÕ D ZÍwÔm011ÅÄLL©eóó)TŠzx:m641 T )1(Ši0{ŠZ0$y l �pŠgZ /§¯â~'±håIYVi@

/@gZ•Y.ØŠ!T pgŠ¤ZŠ[g%vZi�Û8C1 TZÍwÔm911ÅÄLL—yZuZº%jxóóX )2(

TZÍwm51»«: )3(záZip$h4è GIGE*WÙð ŠZgŠg‚ð è ŠzV„

i~+CÑõEE

'Wð è �Ziik P'pŠ¤aVŠZ:`��81ÆtZÃg)�03(: )4(

z�Šx è iÉgmŠ}Zî 'a�gZgzi}ppl„i1Šl1Šò™ŠŠtŠx &ŠZß�±ñ0ZgŠ

pŠgZ‚ÛzŠx è ·}K záZi¯ÿ LFZæxV×)�*�(

Z[J»7ƒZÔqÑè‚wel|‚wÅ$åO]ÔZkÅS®6¦gXóó åÔ Å®ZŠ~Ö:m46(tÒyŠg„7ìXgZ¶Æìw~‚´Ã ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ùeß^Ýen,Ü+†]Úo )

Å=qZzg�Ûz|Æ �mç]áô+†]Úo ZkßÒãÅLL¢zg]óóZka7Wð�H¤ZòÔ!g}~Ëß.~:g�þX

m932(~tÄñ�Šì1: Ô )TÎx e^În^lô]Îf^Ù )m391(Zzg ‰†æ�ô…Êjä 1D)Z³(Ä»ÄZyLL%�ZºZ[W!Š~óóìX)[(tÄ�TZÍw~Ä»�ZÄåÔñ�Š7ì:

·g} è “¤›ZzaZ'Zr5ÑõG è “çÒZza$

)`(Ä�5~LL¥!gÒóóÅ(LL'ZzÒóóZzgLLO.óóÅ(LLiâ.óóìX

351ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 152: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

��46Åg!¦�22: )5($Z}eg{¤Z,^›Ïî I074iï FGGÔ�ŠgpßgzZVâ#W[Z„ôŠg[ÔYV*›yŠªZyzŠwŠgz@[Z„

m753(ÆqgzfsŠzZÃg: Ò×n^lV ��761@861ÅÄLL\xóó) )6(DzÕZ¤lpñp!iŠ@

ŠZ*iŠzZVpZgFZ„ è WŠòiZŠÒHZ„Z¤'ç NE›Ýx è pZzgZ7

È{WiZŠFzpZz¤ëgZ„qgzfsjZÙ: )7(

)2(ƒgDÎg`)3(¸iD’ TZÍwÔ��011::m692Ô0$i�ç E�6( Ò×n^l )

1DŠzÈXÕ[X ��031m513Ô0$i�ç E�21( Ò×n^lV )

1Dg{z£xñuÅZ�²�X ��841:m923Ô0$i�ç E�5( Ò×n^lV )

1DÍ,»ëzízë)�á²åX ��961:m892Ô0$i�ç E�6( Ò×n^lV )

1D�gzczsð…X ��771:m173Ô0$i�ç E�1( Ò×n^lV )

2Dð…¬X ��871:m273Ô0$i�ç E�1( Ò×n^lV )

1DñÑ*°wZ−+gzòX ��281:m673Ô0$i�ç E�3( Ò×n^lV )

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^451

Page 153: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)[(ZŸÃ]:TŠzx~Šz,]ÅLLz„_óó)ŠzâV,]»Ñg7HŠ(X )1(

ŠzxóóÄZyÆ�qgzfsŠâp: è LLZ�á® )2(LLŠzu~Z�á®~¼ŠVÔçßVZzgg!È]»ZŸ†ìX‰‰(�FçÌ

ù¦z„ìÔ�¬¶óóX è ìXÂ[ÅFK¨ZDw)m:LLyóó(

qgzfs>: )3(m862 Ò×n^lV TŠzxÔm211Ô uz›ZÜ

m172 V ZsÔm611ÔZs ²ðm272 V ZsÔm711ÔZs "5åFEL!i!+@î EF0p÷m372 V ZsÔm911ÔZs ™ÄÂ!m472 V ZsÔm021ÔZs ºz*im672 V ZsÔm221ÔZs ™$ëL‘@[m972 V ZsÔm521ÔZs u~m282 V ZsÔm031ÔZs ¢ÒW[m882 V ZsÔm631ÔZs Ëðm292 V ZsÔm241ÔZs Gm692 V ZsÔm741ÔZs jgz�á²m992 V ZsÔm151ÔZs �}W[

qgzfsg!È]: )4(m102 Ò×n^lV �81:·Zi;ñ' g!¦

ZsÔm301 �42:gìŠg¹'ZsÔm502 �03:'zVZi'

551ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 154: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

m022 Ò×n^lV �67:B}pŠ'ZsÔm532 �221:/‚ñ'ZsÔm342 �441:yŠ™0k'ZsÔm642 �451:tây'ZsÔm642 �551:˜Èg8z1'ZsÔm742 �651:ÂòÍð�'ZsÔm742 �751:Îì{àZi'ZsÔm842 �951:dsZ0g$~'ZsÔm842 �061:¾ŠwG'ZsÔm842 'è �161:~iZiÈ

qgzfsZÃg: )5(m982(LL'Ñ!7½5å FGxóó6»ƒC Ò×n^lV TZÍw)m001D101(~ÄLLMóó)

ìX!¹ZÃgÔTŠzx~ZmZŠK‰Xm613 Ò×n^lV ZqÄ:guy'm613 ZsÔ ZqÄ:ipŠgy{'m923 ZsÔ W' è ZqÄ:o

ZqÄ:ŠZøZ0z�'363 - m853 ZsÔ ÐÄÆZ!xJ14ZÃg»ZŸ†

m143D453(»ZŸ†/Z]��3ÆZ’Zð Ò×n^lV ç1]ZiίK) )6(ZÃg:

TZÍw)m002(ÆWy~šÄZyŠzZÃgÃTŠzx)m852(~LLWiZŠ)dóó )7(m783(X Ò×n^lV »ÄZyŠcŠ)

)`(FZç:

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^651

Page 155: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

T�zx S � TZzw S �æ¹g8»ƒÐic�{=w�á² 3 o ƒÐic�{=wæ¹g8»�á² 11D21 5

‘@[óó»ÄZy�}™LL�á�zâ„óóZzgLLu~óóÆ�gxy�g`H�X è �81Æ�qg`ZÃgÃLL™î 41

‘@[óóZzgLLu~óóÆ�gxy�g`H�X è �67Æ�qg`ZÃgÃLL|óó»ÄZy�}™LL™î 14�!â§p�~�}ZgZ Å 4 57 �Ziâ§p�~�}ZgZ Å 4 76�VgZ@óÓð0hZ„ Å 4 09 �VgZZióÓð0hZ„ Å 4 47iZV*i3�Èi0ö¤�{Z0 ÅWìZ„c�Çg�1*x�Z�{Z0 Å

1D2 201 i0Z6�Èi0ö¤�{Z0 ÅWì*Z“Z„�1*x�Z�{Z0 Å

1D2 09

�È¿ 4 441 �*ñ¿ 1 801

�Û8 èÕ 641 ©e 1 011ÄLLi0Ïz¿óóWJúV)4ZÃg(6�ìXT�zx)m051(~ÔZ¹Zk§b��ì�eg´)�zZÃg(¥xƒD�XZkZ0Zi~:

Zë�{�¤psi$o-ê GG è ‚iˆ:¥x”W{�ð74o-ê FGG

´)ZDwÅZqNÒn~ÌZkÄÃWJúV)egZÃg(Å„~��ìXT�zx~ñ��{ßg]¯ð�X

961

751Ãgϯx

Æù´

Page 156: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

â^:"54hé EGHIä\¡Òiªî EE0ZÜt6i'�„úHìZk»�ârZkzZW»�ÛìX

qí 142 2D"54hé EGHIä¾Z+6Z(i'�„úHì�tè<ØZkúÐoY΃nÇX"54hé EGHIÅ"3©5å GEGGL¾Z+{ØZsò$©�î EG0ìwÐìX3DZk»�ârZkzZW»�ÛìX

qí 771

â^:N�ZÈ' qí 642 2DN�Zy' qí 281YxZzgz×FZiWcZ\gZ„ Å 3 842 YxZzgz×FZiYxWzZ\gZ„ Å 3 481zg:�g&B¨ÿELÉÑ!·YxWæ Å 4 153 zg:�g&B¨ÿELÉÑ!·YxWzg� Å 4 781

ÖÃäÚ_^

�nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^

851

Page 157: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)Š(¼*z@í:fsì: è TŠzx~¼ŠZÃgzrg#ÅFKps™Š~ˆÔZkÅ,ø

)1(g!¦�99ÆúVÃZk§bpsHŠ:T�zx:m06 TZÍw:m25åViZhÕŠgŠÁâ? â? è åV²-B5å

YEEGŠwZ0gÉåVÎiŠlZ¼2wâ? åViZhÕŠgŠÁâ?

â�ò�?p�? ó â�ò�?p� èóâ? è åV²-B5å

YEEGŠwZ0gÉ åVÎiŠlZ¼2Áâ?:m882( Ò×n^l )

)2(TZÍwÅg!¦�441ÿgÀ›'þÃTŠzx~g!¦�851¯ŠcŠX)3(ÄLLh¡]óóƬegÄzVÅFK~Zk§bgŠz$wHŠ:

T�zx:m79 TZÍw:m58)1(È{iŠ' )1(È{iŠ')2(¡]WÍ' )2(¸}gÄ')3(¸}gÄ' )3(Wgiz"')4(Wgiz"' )4(¡]WÍ'

» �Û8óó( è m592D692>ZyLLÕ Ò×n^lV )4(TZÍwÅÄLL©eóó)m011D111Ôñ�Š{Wy~Äÿ�Û„Z,'þZ’ZðFKÆ_.Ä»ÙÄåX

m443Ƭ&ZÃgÿZiAz@['þTZÍw)m361(~ Ò×n^lV )5(m043þƈŠg`�X Ò×n^lV çwÿŠg˜V'&

)6(ÄLLi0Ïz¿óóTZÍw)m961(~LL\xóóZzgLL‹ZÑZxóóÆŠgxy~¶Ô1TŠzx)m051(~ZÐLLjgz�á²óóZzgLLZ<vóóÆŠgxyáYcŠìX

)7(TZÍw)m002(ÆWy~ŠzZÃgÃTŠzx)m852(~LLyŠ{óóЬÑcŠ)ZzgLLWiZŠ)dóó»ÄZyŠcŠ(X

951ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 158: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)8(VÅFKZk§bps™Š~ˆ:õzg{DzGÔMÔÑ!ÔÕzÄX TZÍwÅFK:

ºz*i)TŠzxÅ5Ä(Ñ!ÔÕzÄ'ËðÔMÔGX TŠzxÅFK:: Šzu}Zec~ÔTZÍwÅqgzfsZÝoÅoƒì

T�zx)9( S � TZÍw)ß( S �ZY: 01 ` ZYU 41 [

� 7 28 È 7 47Ñ!i{u 4 551 ÑÈî0{u 8 411

^q 4 851 ^”î0 4 711qíÅ„g]÷zsì 071 ŠzÈ)9:gzÈ( qí 031

iŠ 11 891 ig 1 851YxWæ 4 152 YxWzgŠ 4 781

zc '* 1 162 '*îc 1 791@ëTZÍwÆ,]:

2916

Zzg 2911

Ô 36101Ô 3419Ô 3418

Ô 7219

Ô 9115Ô 3019Ô 989Ô 5801Ô 022

Ô 413

Ô{02ÔŠ91

Ô 7619

Ô 0517Ô 2319Ô 1019Ô 7901Ô 822Ô 223

Ôo11Ôb1

ÅZÝoTŠzx~ÌZZnK,]

6$2g�X 6526

Zzg 6521

Ô 80201

Ô 4812

Ô 4811

ZkZec~qgzfs5ZÝo¥z5kƒ�:9 ß S �vè ÉÓÏî LŠ 2 2!ÑzŠzl !уŠzl 2 9

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^061

Page 159: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �˜ä Ää 6 81â·gZV â¸gZy 7 82âuV âiÇy 6 89*zâl *ƒâl 6 411

i �Š Âi �z 6 711Wig~ Wfg~ 2 112Wig Wfg 6 142

Æ�}ZecÅÂ"ÑzqƒðXZÏZz µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ 9291YÆZ’ZðV~~-YeZsðŠ‹ÆzÔ·šÅŠgpZ„6´)ZDwäZ¹�ZZec

Š‹gzZ:™Š~IZzgÂ[Š‹~ C2 Š}Š~XÂ"”{»\V 1C �áù™äÅZYi]~Š~XZkÐ C3 Z~Ư[ B ¾ˆX844ÂÁуgîÅZ:qÔZDwä2

zZãì��ZZec�Ñð9291YÆWy~Z�á®5kƒZXTÎxÅÆÔTŠzxЊg}(~ìXuzgt6LL-YeZsðŠ‹óóÆ

ZÖpZzgWy~Ô6LLÂ[3åXWEZY»ØóóÆ��IguZ»èŠg`ìXZkZ´yÆÐÌZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�YeÅf)ŠZg~Ô¡ C4 ´z{Ô2k*i~Æ*x´)ÆZq¯[

S®JözŠ¶XTÎxÆ»½~zZRâgu~tZÖp7ñYM�:World Cream Laid 5316 Norway

t»½¬ZzgŠzu}ZecÆ»½Ð׊ܢzgì1ZyÐVZexV»»½ÔŒ7äÐI^Y@ìX

:m5 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 1DÔZDw�ÔZÍwÔZÆ' ‘vnËä 6z,g¶Ã�§Z‹Â"+ZqÎMgz9ZŠZK‰X) 2D

3791Y:m43(X:m21 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 3D

X Zs 4D

161ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 160: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

TÎxÅÂ"ÌÔ†ZØ6z,g¶äÅXZkZec)9291Y(~TŠzxÅøfsZÝoÅo™Š~ˆì:

X 0517

Ô 2319

Ô 7116

Ô 896

Ô 827

Ô 81 ,]:6@ëqgzfs™V$2gñ�Š�X,]:

Ô 80201Ô 8022Ô 4811Ô 7619

Ô 4116

Ô 1019Ô 7901Ô 822Ô 223Ô82Ôo11Ôb1Ô z„_( )2

2X 6522

Ô 6521

Ô 1426

Ô 1122

TÎx~qgzfs5ZÝogz5kƒ�:9 ß S �ñizV ñizy 7 Š'0 'c 01 Š

§] è g'× (] è g'× 4 2ið gð 8 3

8 z. 1 1ƒ.8 6 871oZix �Zgx 7 252

aåZec2491Y~aŠO~·@Z*Z}ÅôZã~�áùƒZX6z,g¶ÐZkâÂ"™ZðˆXplâöäFKz®Z›,]ZzgÄZ*]z){~�} è ÅZiu

Ãg3ìXtZkaÌ¢zg~å�)ÆZÙwÆÔZyÅÂ1V~ è ZecÃ7Ën»gœz$w*oƒìX

TXgx~Ô�}ZecÅqgzfsZÝoÅoƒì:

@ëZyZÝoÅo7ƒm: 6521Ô 2527

Ô 80201Ô 7116

Ô38

Ô24Ôb1ÔŠ01ÔŠ7

,]:

@ëÔqgzfs,]Å™VŠzg7ƒÃX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^261

Page 161: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ô 4811Ô 7816Ô 7619

Ô 4116

Ô 1019Ô 7901Ô 822Ô 223

Ô83

Ôo11

)z„_(Ô 2 ,]:2

X 6526 Ô 142

6 Ô 1122 9}i'»ZŸ†HŠìÔ1tZ5Ìßì( )Zq 481

2

TXgx~5tÜsZqìXz„_)m1ÔS5(~11@299ìÔ:�11@49X

ZecŲôp™àIZzg1791YJTƒäzZáÓxZecZ-.V ZkÐTKYDgìÔ@ëˆÆZexVÃNgŠÚÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�‰,]ŲŸùƒIÔZkaZy”VÅŠz!g{Â"™ZÆ5²»gÅIX,Zk§bì:

t,]$2gTXgxÅ.VÐTKYDgìX m�1@042Zzgm�942@652

âÂ"™ZðˆZzg5²»gƒNX è Zy,]ÅZiu »8Z³:m142@842»8[:m752@462

1TÞ)8491Y(ÅWy~»8)m752D462(T¼ÆO}TXgxÆ_.¥xƒCìX:¥xtYV™ƒZ?TQÆñµ6»8LL[óóŲ˃äÆ:ÔZkÅZiuâÂ"™Zð¶ÔeìTÞÆñµ6Ë”{PïYäÅzzЂÂZVZecZÏÐT™ä»êHŠƒÔ1ˆÆZexV~»8LL[óóÔ

XgxÐTň¥xƒCìX è Zq!gQT

i1§Y /

#3291Y(ÅZ�á®Æˆ»‚gZÃgϯxÔ´)ZDwä Ô )TZÍw µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

ÆŠzu}Zec)âga4291Y(~�ácåXZkZz~ÃgÏÍ𻟠µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

Dz+ Yg~g;X¢„Q,VäCkH�¼²áˆZq6ÃgÏù´ÅFKz

361ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 162: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZzgZ~4291Y~·GZ−+Q~ 1C *¦kƒÏX�Ñð4291Y~{y*iZ−+{yÆ*xÐ Æ*ñV ‡eç…ôq‚m‚ Zzg Songs of Modern David kK~Q,Vä 2C Æ*x

Æ*xÐñÎxƒðXZk§btIß ‡eç…ôÂrÜ TñúŠ{Â[»E™{HìÔz„ˆ~W¸i4291Y„~ƒŠåÔ1ZkÅŠÁz�ZhJð'kˆY™ƒðX » ‡eç…ôÂrÜ 7�

~t�áùƒð:LL.eä]Æ‚B‡gM ‡Únß‚]… 62B†g~7291YÆ!ÇåƒìZzg‹ ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Ãt(׊{‹cY@ì�´)ZDwÅ@i{" ™Zx

Y@ì�Šzeggzi~ZkÅÂ"ÑzqƒYñÏóóXñÑ*¤ZòÆ*x13B†g~»ƒìXZqŠzgziJ»A ‡eç…ôÂrÜ 7291YƯ[~��:LL÷~Â[

Â"ÐS®J 1 C3 ZzgGg{ŠyÆZ0gZ0g�áùƒYñÏóóÔ ~YñÏ Æ;B»%³ðƒä~Gg{ŠyÆO}Fâ{Üsƒ‰ZzgÂ[�yÆ�}‹

C4 ~Tƒ™©¬x6WðXÅÂ"ܽ©w6z,g¶ÆO}·œ&)ˆZiZVZÅ)Ò©ïGOE/LLZÓk TZÍw

Z5 è äÅXtÂ"×ëìXCÙÔ6XgÍâ1L¯ñ‰�X¡ g¶óó(Æ$©�î EG0ÃÐÔ·œ&Åplâ+ƉU¹Zi�Ô}:Q,VäzZÌÕ6Ä{)Y(Å´#Ö7¯ðÔc}ZŸÄ6ÌÄ{¯äÐZ�ZiHìÔLL�óóÃLL¢©->îEGGXóó7–ÔZ�6z,g¶¬xîg6ZktÆ%>ƒñ�X·œ&ä‰ZÖpÃ5™–ìÔ}:

4-C½øXGFÔ!5½hé GIV)m391(t*ââkZ0ZiìXt¢zgì�

ÅÂ"6¯EgBìX 6z,g¶ÅÂ"ù¦ŒZzgplúð~Ô·œ&:m05 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 1D

:m811 ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä 2D:m142 ÚÓ^ingôôô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 3D

~Ò¤CÙZ−+Å ]ÞÏ¡h TZÍw6â{z‚ÁS®Šg`7ìÔ112B�y7291YÆ 4D»ZqZ3g�áùƒZÔT~CcŠ�LL@i{"¾™»gƒ ‡eç…ôÂrÜ §sÐ

Z−+ ňÅZ�áoV~ÌLLTZÍw�y7291YóóŠgìXZDwäxVÂx ‡eç…ôÂrÜ ìóóX:m831(X ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä Ã�7HÔQk6LL·ZDw92�y72YóóŠg`ì)

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^461

Page 163: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÆZÖpzZãÃWD Super Fine TZÍw»»½×ŠÜìX»½ÆzZRâgu~1<9 3 �X'×h'WVZqLL@óó»¶yÌñ�ŠìXZk°Æjn»‚)‚hñ

(Ð×gNìX xk ìÔ�6z,g¶ÆÂ"”{¶VÆjn)71<11 x( ‰kƬZec~Â"ÅqgzfsZÝoñ�Š�: ‡eç…ôÂrÜ

9 ß S �è; è ¢3ú

EE 3 32

XÓ Xì 6 73w½ ܽ 7 34Wig~ Wfg~ 6 54$z) $zâ{ 3 071Z+ Z, 01 7916)4è XGE � 01 502' / 5 012iŠZø iŠZ× 6 312'zV 'zy 2 612óg0 ógZ0 1 812uât ñä uâ 4 022pÍyZ„ pÍVZ„ 3 822

gŠ W �Ûz �ÛzWŠg 5 922·D6)4è XGE ¸D� 7 2 03

áyDWy áVDWV 4 732Wig Wfg 1 752Wig~ Wfg~ 7 2 75

561ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 164: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

��04)zZÍw(6çw»9Ñg�32ìÔ:�33XtÑg�m68Jß„)66(¸ìÔ˜Vçw»Ñg�66Šg`HŠìXŠg|ÀçB65�X

eÉT C1 ªZecP'k~»ƒŠåXŠzuZZecÔ´)Åi0Ï~:¾ZÍwÆ7ä,{'kˆZ6s4491Y~aŠO~·@Z*Z}ÅôZã~�áùƒZX

(xk ZkZecÅÂ"6z,g¶äÅìX6�Zz6f™W[ìÔÔ»jn)71<11ZÃgz){!kxTZÍwÆ è Ð(ZìÔ@ëFK x( ‰ 1<9k 3 )‚hñ …3üELZÍwÆjn

_.ìX‰(ZqÄTZÍw~ZqÔ6ìÔÂTŠzx~ZŒÔ6XZk§b»�ÛtŠzâVZexVÆ,]01Ô11Ô41Ô51Ô02Ô12Ô22Ô32Ô42Ô52z){6ñ�ŠìX6z,

¬Š]c}ZŸÄZzgzZÌÕ6Ä{)Y(¯ŠcìÔ@ë�ÃQ,Vä‚ è g¶äøg�Šcì)m:081Ô332(Zzg¢©->î

EGGX7¯cìX

TŠzx~ZkÄ»ZŸ†HŠì:—"3«ç EGEEzŠz>ZiŠwg1Š W…Šg@Š è q¢7 èD

)m:452(Z TZÍw~tÄ»AÐ\Að XS ‡eç…ôÂrÜ ZzgZkÆ‚Bqd/õ IG~zŸsŠg`ì:LL

vsƒŠåX¥xZkz‰ÜƒZZÂ[Óx¾_ÔÜsZkÄÆaÂ[Æ‚Bß*)»�áù™*´)%jxäoƒ:�)·@(óóX

ì: TŠzx)Z6s4491Y(~ÔTZÍwÆqgzfs,]6ñ�Š!VÅoƒ

X 7324

Ô 0327

Ô 8223

Ô 0224

Ô 6122Ô 0125

Ô 50201Ô 79101Ô 347

Ô 736

Ô 323

fsËVÅZÝo$2gTŠzx~Ìñ�Š�: è @ëøX 7527

Ô 7521Ô 9225Ô 8121Ô 3126Ô 0713

Ô 546

ÅS®»ZOx ‡eç…ôÂrÜ 2k*i~Æ*x2B#5391YƯ[~´)ZDw��: 1DÚÓjçe^lô ÔZ[Æ›ÿ˜ZþQgŠzFÀ�áùƒX) ‡eç…ôÂrÜ ¯gUƒYìÔ1÷ZZgZŠ{ì

:m962D072(1´)Åi0Ï~Z(e:ƒeX ]Îf^Ù

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^661

Page 165: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zϧbç1]ÆßÑg�)m04@68(Ì$2gß�XŠzu}Zec~¼5ZÝogz5kƒ�:

9 ß S �»giZ§ »iZ§ 1 74—z —ƒÂ 3 05u%î0 u%î0 3 791g§V g§y 2 62 2

T6tÐLLm4491YóóŠg`ìX‚w Ô �ZZecm5491Y~�áùƒZS®ÆZ0gZ`~ttZkaGZqtì�ZÍwÂegâ{ƾ²á~T

ªk7XZDwÆËÌù´Æe è DÙZgegζV»�Ûz|ƒ*ÔŒÛ+ ZqÆ ŠzxZecZzgz{ÌÃgÏù·ÔZkª]Z0É ËÂ[»ŠzuZ ~ÃðZ+Vw7Q�

7Z:!~Ð�Ûz|ƒZƒXZ¤ZqxÆat�ÛnÌ™1Yñ�zZªZ(ƒZÂtâÂ" è Ãgì�TÎxÆ,]94@002ÅS®5.VЃðÔ�Ziu è Z%7

ƈ»gÅIX251,]ÅÂ"Ô»kVÅoÔQS®ÔˆZiZVÂ[Å©¬x6WæÔZyƒ%Zi»Zq.e¾z‰Ü~ðƒ*ÔŒÛdŒÛd*eìXìwgì

ÅTZÍwÆ!g}~†g~7291Y~´)䵪CÙŶ�Gg{gzi ‡eç…ôÂrÜ �nb‚]â{ˆ)�Ñð~(Z(eƒeXZkÒpÐtZ% 1 1C ƈÂ[»gƒÏ

Ém5491Y~�áùƒZ)Zk6LL4491Yóó\Að XL Ô Dì��ZZecm4491Y~7Â"ì(XZkƉ{ÂÔTŠzxÅ.VÐTK‰Ô1P”VÅÂ"5ìXZyÅ,Zk§bÐì:

TŠzxÅ.VÐS®ÅˆX ��1@�84Zzg��102@Wy:5Â"XtÂ"Ì6z,g¶ÅìX ��94@�002:

:m142 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 1D

761ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 166: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âè ¸�,]:94@002Å6Zã²yZ[ÔËcŸùƒIÔZkaZy,]ÅZiuÂ"™ZÆÔ5²»g™ZðIX

3126

Zzg 7913

TÎx)m5491Y(~TŠzxÅqgzfsZÝoÅoƒì:,]

'×h'WVçßVÆÑg�)m04@84ÔZzg85@46(ÅÌo™Š~ˆìX@ëqgzfs,]ÅZÝo$2gñ�Š�: Æ TŠzx

çßVÆ�Ñg X 2622

Zzg 7527

Ô 7521Ô 9225

Ô 8121Ô 0713

Ô 253

Ô 053Ô 741

Ô 546

(Ì$2gß�X 5Zzgm66@68 )m05@6aåZecm8491Y~�áùƒZXZk~��94Ð�65Zzg�56Ð�002

Zzg Ô JÅS®ÔTÎxÅ.VÐňÔ1!¹,])�1@84Zzg�75@�46âÂ"™ZðˆXtÂ"zZãîg66z,g¶ÆO}ËZzgpl è 102@Wy(ÅZiu

âöÅìXZkZec~ÌTÎx»â{z‚ÁS®m4491Y–ŠìÔ�Šg„Åoƒì: ,]Å!V 7XZkZec~ÔTÎxÆqgzfs

@ëqgzfs,]Å™VTXgx~Ì$2gñ�Š�: 9225

Ô 741

,]

X 2622

Zzg 7527

Ô 7521

Ô 8121

Ô 0713

Ô 253

Ô 053

Ô 546

ZϧbçßVÆÑg�)m05@65Zzg66@68(Ì$2gß�X'×h'WVm346Ìçw»�ÑgßìX

ZkZec~P5ZÝoÌgz5kƒ�XZyÅ,tì:9 ß S �!üE+@î EF0 !ü

E+@î EFO 3 23!z�iW> W>� ;z 4 73Z÷X6)4è XGE ZøX� 01 502

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^861

Page 167: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �£ó £á 7 802Šgz ŠgŠ 3 902

¸ ê 9 812)Î )Á 4 422åy åV 21 22 5

·Ô6)4è XGE ¸Ô� 7 032·ÔÍ ¸Ôª 11 332f

+A)4èGE

G 3 7320v,Zec»ÃðgZ¶ÃÔ�¶}gÆ!z�ŠÔ75X÷Zìwì�0vZVZec

z„ìÔ&tÐ…3üEL¼ÑgHŠìXt!]fsÆ»©ÍØZg}ÐzZãƒÏ:T¼6Z0gZ` TÎxzXgx6Z0gZ`TZÍw�y7291YŠzDÙZg TZÍw�y7291YŠzDÙZgTŠzx' TŠzxZ6s4491YZqDÙZgegÎ

Z6s4491YZqDÙZgegÎ TÎx TÎxm4491YŠzDÙZgTXgxm5491YŠzDÙZg TXgx8491Y0õDÙZgTQm8491Y0õDÙZgT¼�y8591YŠzDÙZg

TÎxZzgTXgx~Ô…3üELÎx»‚ÁS®ßîg6m4491YŠg`HY@g;XZ[TQÆñµ6ZkÅo™ÆÔZÐm5491Y¯ŠcŠÔ1ZÐ…3üELXgxŒÛZgŠcŠÔ

Å �$¸îg6ßìX)TXgx6â{z‚wS®m8491Y!ÇŠg„ìm5491YeZÑ Z�á®ÃLLXgxóóŒÛZgŠ¶ÆˆtXŠg7ƒZ�m8491YÅZ�á®Ã¾3D~ÅÔ QóóZºZq è Yñ?

&;-+êXG

L-cplâöäZkZÃLLióó™äÆaZqZzgLLZ�á®

961ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 168: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»ì1mo]ÔpŠ (discrepancy) &TXgxÆ‚ÁS®Ð�hŠcŠXZkÚ³TŠzx»ÍØZg{ìÔT~TŠzxÆ‚t‚ÁS®Zzg:®Z›ÃèˆìX

¾qwZk0v,Zec)�y8591Y(ÅÂ"zS®CÙZ±gÐTXgx)m8491Y(Æ_.ìXTXgxÅt²ôp™àIZzgW^,Zec)m0791Y(JÅS®Z-.VЃCg„XZyÓxZexV~Ôz{ƒZÝoñ�Š

�ÔXŶyŠ„…3üELXgxÆK~ÅY_ìX.V )Z~4791Y(úŠZvœjÅ5Â"лg”{ »âZVZec ‡eç…ôÂrÜ

ÆK~1YñÇX Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(Ê^…‰o ,]~ g{ ÐTHŠXZy»Y{WYzh*) /

ƒŠåÔ 1C ÅŠÆÖÔ7291Y„~ÔZDwÆZkµ"»W¸i ‡eç…ôÂrÜ

q^æm‚Þ^Úä ¸Xˆ~tÂ[ B2C &z{LLe-Zí»z~ŧbZqZsò»z~óóÐñÎxƒðXtÔZkZ±gÐZDwÅZëF+"ì�z{ZÐZKLLi0Ï»

"Æ Â C4 ÅŠZ6s1391Y~ƒðX q^æm‚Þ^Úä ¯äÆaÃ�áVgìX 3C â°óón1 C5 %µ~Fâ{¦g‰XZDwõ¶�Â[ZÆ'J�áùƒYñÏÔ

±2k*i~™r»Òyì�7291YÆñ̤â~Zz{eZˬ$@Åö~ 1D

´)Å}#Ö~q¢ƒñ´)äZKÒ¸ZÃgÐPLL�]‹ñÔ�WÐ^™:m33(ZkÅgzÝ~aŠO~· ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù »�Zi¶óóX) q^æm‚Þ^Úä /øzZŸ†Ô

]Îf^Ù(2ç�â†p ÑzqHóóX) r q^æm‚Þ^Úä ~ @»tÒy�ZDwä:LL9291YÅZ’Z¥xƒ@ìX ûà :m302( ÚvÛ‚uŠnàÒoÞ¿†Ún6

:m33 ÚÓjçe^l]Îf^Ù 2D»f™™Dƒñ·ÕÆ*xZqâ~–: q^æm‚Þ^Úä 3D

:m911( Letters of Iqbal) I hope to make [it] my life work.

ÔŠzx:m883 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 4D:m37 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 5D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^071

Page 169: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»Zq q^æm‚Þ^Úä ¬x6WðXZ’Z~´)ZDw è© ƒ™ T C1 �Ûzg~2391YÆZzZb~ÆŠz ‡eç…ôÂrÜ �»ZgZŠ{gn¸Ô1tZgZŠ{gzÑ:WeZzg Ì C2 LLŠNŠâpóó

ZÃgÊâdÅßg]Š}Š~ˆ:

ŠâpìÁð��áñW�V1ŠZ„$z¶â{z7¨¶KV1ŠZ„

â„ è áVÞ��{—ZVé�CÙ*g{˜yZ„c˜V1ŠZ„

ZDw…3üELZÍwÅÆZzg4z){z„ìÔ�ZDwäZKÄ~£?Æ q^æm‚Þ^Úä

aZq§bÐMHg™1åXÂ"c†Z?ÅìX�‚iÝx[Z−+¸XZy»*x®)7^(~Šg`ìXTZÍw»»½ŠÜZzg0ZZgìXWy~Zq´u{»½6qgzfsLLß*)óó�áïHŠì:

9 ß �Ñg �Šhy | Ä2ÔqUã 41

`[ ¡] Ä3ÔqZÍw 44Z, Z} Ä3ÔqZÍw 181

%Š %› Ä5ÔqZÍw 581L q Ä9ÔqUã 102‡š ‡&Ïî G Ä3ÔqUã 032@Š ÅgBðEŠ Ä9ÔqZÍw 532

ÛzãuzgtÆ,]»ÑgÌÔ�gZ³[HŠìXÔŠzx:m793 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 6DÔZÍw:m612 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 7D

171ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 170: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�LL`óó6Z0gzãuzgtìXz„p}�LL{óóÐÑzqƒ™�LL~óó6»ÆŠzÄzV6�ìX ‡eç…ôÂrÜ ƒCìXLLŠâpóó)m:o(

P™{!ÑZÝo*ó~X!VŶyŠ„ňìÔZyÆ´z{ÌTZÍw~qgzfsZÝoñ�Š�:

9 ß S �p3 p2 02 i5a 5q 3 01/ó{ X{ 5 52ÃgZVXZ0gZV ÃgZyXZ0gZy 8 238ðEN¤ pŠ¤ 1 73qb qs 4 83

æZÉÐ:ö ŠX æZÉÐ:ö X 5 45í‰ Ÿ} ŸZ} 4 85

²;k5é XGV ²;k5é XGy 3 46Z, Z+ 8 97

Îi}Š¤ ίŠ¤ 6 88¾[zÑt Ñtz¾[ 2 19uÒð W] +Z] 9 301Šg)õF0 Šg9 21 501

käŠv} kÈŠv} 3 511'iây 'iâV 6 611

vXi~ uXi} 21 811

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^271

Page 171: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �Šg˜y Šg˜V 8 911!K iZK 4 521

Zz+~r¢zg~åX z ^»Uãà 01 531�g &¾æE

YEg 11 051$›Ð.ð GV $›Ð.ð Gy 01 961

jZk ƒZk 6 681

Z, ^qZÍw:Z+ 3 222)õF0 9 5 422uÒð W‹ +Z‹ 11 432uÒð W] +Z] 5 532

è ¤` è ¤p 9 042Wè WZ0ZI è ZI Xè XZ0ZI è ZI 8 342

»ŠzuZZecÔaŠO~·@ÅikôZã7491Y~�áùƒZXZk6 q^æm‚Þ^Úä

»A»*xŠg`7Ô1Z0Z¯Â"6z,g¶»ìX4ZzgZÃgzàâ]ÅFKz){Ãg3ŠìXƒÐZëFçtň�ŠzZÃg6�Šâpvs è ~TZÍwÃ7

™ŠcŠXŠzuZZecaŠO~·@™rÅôZã~ÖÔZkatp~Z-ÆZZ6ƒðƒÏX„CÙZkÅÃðÂä7ÅY$ËXgZ¶Æìw~tF笚�ZiìX

TZÍw~ÛzãuzgtÆŠz,]»Ñg�gZ³[HŠåÔ1TŠzx~Z¹Ñg7HŠÔOçZ[�Z³ÔZ0gzãuzgt0ŠìÔZzg[`Š{à�Xz„

p}{ÔzÔiÔb6Šg`ìXTZÍwÆ‚B´u{»½6Ô�LLß*)óóÎcŠåÔTŠzx~ZyZÝoÅo™Š~

371ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 172: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ˆìXZkZec~TZÍwÆqgzfs,]ÅZÝoÌŠg„™Š~ˆ�:

Ô 192Ô 886Ô 978Ô 463

Ô 854

Ô 455

Ô 834

Ô 731Ô 3311Ô 238

Ô 525

Ô 619

Ô 013

Ôi02

X 2223

Ô 2816

Ô 9118

Ô 81121Ô 6116

Ô 5113

@ëqgzfs,]Å!VÅo7ƒmì:

X 3428

Zzg 0429

Ô 5325

Ô 43211

Ô 96101

Ô 05111

Ô 53101

Ô 50121

Ô 3019

ÆŠzu}Zec~qgzfs5ZÝogz5kƒ�: q^æm‚Þ^Úä

9 ß S �@/| @:| 11 64Zi)õF0 Zi[ 7 801¢¬.çGEGE:@Ñ[ < qí 331i©g*ñ i©g'êGP 1 731Wè&WV� Wl 01 151

TŠzxŲôp™àIZzgm4791YJÓxZecZ-.VÐTKYDgìÔOç�}ZecZzgˆÆÓxZexV~TŠzxÅZÝoñ�Š�XZ%m151

ÅtŠg„™Š~ˆìX…3üELŠzx~z„p}Æ,]Å9FK){XzXiXb(ÆO}ÔS®c¢È~~tÆ:ÔtFKÃWCì:iXbX{XzXTXgx~tFKŠg„ìÔ1Z0gzãuzgt�`6`ŠìX,]Z³Zzg[{à�XTQÔ¼ZzgÞ~̸ßg]ìX

»WZV)m4791Y(ZzgâZVZec)�y8791Y(úŠZvœjÅ q^æm‚Þ^Úä

Ò×n^lô]Îf^ÙÊ^…‰o {,]~ Ò Â"лg”{.VÐTK‰XZy»Y{WÆK~WñÇX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^471

Page 173: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

TZÍw»a q^æm‚Þ^Úä 2891Y~ZDwZ»Šò0Îyä72<22kxÅÆ6Zec�áùHX&LLT{móóLL{mZ�á®óóZzgLLe~GZecóóÆ*xŠb‰XZ»ŠòÆ*òz©ŒÛ7äŠâd~Z�á®»¬gsÔ2TZÍwÅ(gZ�á®»�Zi

7™Dƒñ–:TZÍwÅwâZŠg~ÐìXtZec¹Ác[ìXZЊz!g{�áù™ä»ÑsZDwZ»ŠòqÝ™g„ì'QÂ[¯IW?Æfg)TZÍwÐY0ŠìX¹ÐZÖpzwzs7Šg}»½ZzgS�Z›iâ:Æ:YOÐâ07‰¸

qg~+B5ë HFEYÐQYw™Šz!g{bwHŠì'Â[ÆWy~ß*)åÔZÐÌ

�áïQ™ŠcìX‰Šzu~ZÝoÃÌ�»AŠg„™ŠcìXÆ]oø q^æm‚Þ^Úä tZ�á®qgìXZbäeZËYzhZDwÅZ‡#ÖÇ{6

ZDwZOòÅÂz»%œµ (Mural) ÅtŠ-Zg~¦kÉ q^æm‚Þ^Úä Š-Zg6îK¸XZzgZDwZOòäµ"Æ�ZkŠ-Zg~©*óÅg3£zk»g™ZNZzgQZk

~Љ{É™ÆRZ¤$n.ç EGE~v™ZñX

ZN[£zk»Zë�Û9eZËYzhZDwäZ�xŠcXZ[t53£zkZkZ�á®{m~�áï�X)Šâp(*,]~ëäTZÍwÅ92BZÝoŶyŠ„ÅìXikÃZec~Zy

92BZÝo~ÐÜseg!VÊg„HŠìÔ!¹�VÅÂVñ�Š�XZkZec»»½¹�{Ô0hZgZzgŠÜìXzz¸�tì�ZkÅS®÷zZ]ZÆZŠZg}zZ]‘Ô.çGE�уgÆ-~ƒðX

ÆŠzZÃg6�Šâp�áïå�ˆÆÓxZexV~ ‡eç…ôÂrÜ TZÍw~vsƒŠ)Šâd~�ßg‹qwCðˆìz{Šg„7ìX(TZÍw»tÄ~ŠâpikÃZec~Ì�áï™1ŠìXZ’Zð61,]ÆÑg�Šg`7K

¯xaÃg¯g3qd/õ IG è uzgtZzgŠâpz){ÅÂ"ÕŒÛ7àkg¶ÅìXQ ‰XÐ'×+ìX

571ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 174: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

1C )�Û /

)12BZÆ'@2âÞ3391Y(ÐzZ36 2C Zjjy è Zk�~»W¸i´)ZDwÆ^ƒZÔ1ZkÅŠ~Fâ{Üsƒ‰XZ~4391Y~Â"»%³ðƒZXZkiâä

ÅZ�á®Æe~-YeZsðŠ‹Ð!]’ƒg„ ÚŠ^ʆ Zzg e^Ùôqf†mØ ~ZqDÙZgcGg{ÎÅ®ZŠ~Y8YñZzgŠk°{m ÚŠ^ʆ ´)»ZgZŠ{å� ¶X

Å 4C ƒVÔ1YezZßVÐÃðçnð:ƒeÔZka�~Üs0õÎ 3C »½6T®ZŠ~ŠÜWg^Ä6Y8ˆX±2k*i~Æ_.�~ÅözŠ®ZŠÔZx[~

‚hñ81<21kxìXÂ" ZÍwÅÆܽ©w T C5 ÆaTŶX „Zzg4!g{S~ìXuzgtÆqgY]Zk§b�: 6z,g¶Å

)�Û$š/õ GEPgzi{Zjjy è (s)ZÆ'33Y(

4391YC7 !3�ç EEL¬x6WcX ~ 6C »ªZecâÞ4391Y ÚŠ^ʆ

è ˆ~ìÔ1ëFK ÚŠ^ʆ ¬Zzg µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� ñ�Š{¶V~FKÆZ±gÐ 1D»f™¬™,ÐX ÚŠ^ʆ Ãè iâãÆ7

,Æa5±Ù: 2DZi±Ñy0z~X ‰n†ô]ÊÇ^ÞŠj^á )1(

уgÔ†g~6791Y(X Ô ]Îf^Ù…mçmç ZjjyZiZºgZ„X) è )2(´)ZDw»^:m091 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù D3

ÔTŠzx:m2 ÚŠ^ʆ D4:m481Ô191 ÚÓjçe^l]Îf^Ù D5

·ÕÆ*x6BŠc4391YÆâ~��: D6m421( :Letters of Iqbal)Musafir was published about a month or so ago

ÆTitle Page of First Edition of 'MUSAFIR'~Iqbal in Pictures M±z©Z−+ä D77ÄZyÔ�@ŠcìÔz{Z0gzãuzgt»@ìÔ:�Ûzãuzgt»X

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^671

Page 175: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ƬZec~qgzfsZÝoñ�Š�: ÚŠ^ʆ

9 ß S �[] +Z‹ 2 8’,ç MQz / 11 11

Wig Wfg 7 41

ZÅ}Òð OW] ZÅ}Òð OZ] 5 02

'*zc '*ƒc 3 15•çEŠ} •çEO} 21 45r3œî LEQEMGMZv r3œî LEQEMGNZv 01 75

ecÔ£"3ýEGLZDwÅ%zzÆ)12<71kx(66391Y~�áùHŠÔ1Zk Z ŠzuZ»4!g{S~ÆO}ŠkS~ìXÂ"×ëìZzgZ�á®»ZÈx±2k

ZkZec~TZÍwÅqgzfsZÝo X *i~)Ã{:ƒqZsxуg(äHŠg„™Š~I:

T�zx TZÍw9 S � ß S �[‹ 6 6 +Z‹ 2 8

ZÅ}Òð OW] 6 51 ZÅ}Òð OZ‹ 5 02

ÅZÝoTŠzx~ÌZZnK,] 7501zg Z 4521Ô 153Ô417Ô 1111

@ëTZÍwÆ,]

6$2g�X 347

Zzg 143

Ô 8301

Ô 113

Ô93

771ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 176: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

TŠzx~qgzfs5ZÝogz5kƒ�:9 ß S �'Wg 'Zg 5 82

¨ ¨V 2 83©y ©V 7 93

µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�]c]Îç]Ýô »tŠzuZZec6391Y~ÖÔZÏ'k�~ ÚŠ^ʆ»ªZecÌ�áùƒZXZyŠzâV�-VÅ´u{´u{Z�á®)Zzg¸�¼ �†Ñ

µ‹2äe^m‚ ²áÆa�Ûz|(ÆÔŠzâVÊ?™ÆÔ¢6tÄZyÉŠcŠ:XZiZVŠzâV�-VÅ7VÂ"™ZðˆÔŠzâVÆ Ò†�]c]Îç]Ýô�†ÑÚÄÚŠ^ʆ

,]»´u{´u{ÑgHŠÔ@ëŠzâV�-VÃLLZqÂ[óóÆîg6�áù™ÆÆ�}Zec»Y{ZÏŠ ÚŠ^ʆ �Ûz|HY@g;ZzgZyÅZµZµw»ƒX

)¬(ZecÆîg61YñÇX

�~:p!h™ŠZ}ZZÄÑt /

´)ZDwÔugZk&ŠÆ*x92B�y6391YƯ[~��:3BZ6sÅ‘ÃÔZ~È0w~åÔ~ä'+£é

Gg}ŠZŠZg9*îGZvmÃpZ[~

Š¬XíÃ�Ûâc�ZK´ªÆ0—§g‚ª–[åÅ}#Ö~²n™X~ZÏz‰ÜËZgƒŠZzg¼Ä²nŠZ“Æîg6ÃgÏi!y~‘ÔÀ‚JăñXуgW™ìwƒZ�tgKÏÄìÔZ¤ËicŠ{(~�~»Wy~zƒYñÔÂp[ìXZ:v�t�~ÌZ[»ƒìXíÃZk�~»áyÌ:åÔ¾qwZk»*xƒÇ:

C1 óóX µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�]c]Îç]Ýô�†Ñ2<71kx(6уgÐ�áùƒðX401 1 ) ~(~Æ C2 t�~WyZÆ'6391Y

:m362 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 1D]Îf^Ù �áDÙZŠ~¬${Î:ÃZDwä�7HÔQk662BZÆ'6391YÅ@gõŠg`ìX) 2D

:m42(XâZ[fzZ;gk‚ÑgÃ7™Š{°6Ì62BZÆ'63YÅ@gõŠgì ]æ…eãçµ^Ù™ZcX( eZË·dZÉåO+ÔZDwZ»Šò ]æ…Úß’çe1( Ò^…+]…p D ]Îf^Ù]Ò^�Úo Â^ ¬g° )@

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^871

Page 177: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÔTŠzx)6391Y(ZzgZk ÚŠ^ʆ S~ZzgÂ"Šg}ëìÔ»A»*xŠg`7Ô1ÅÂ"Zq„»AäÅZzgŠzâV»Z0Zi!Ç7VìXZk°»»½¢o0ZZgìX Zzg

�~ÆZkZec~qgzfsZÝoñ�Š�:9 ß S �§pgz §pgŠz 1 8i¨#èGEL i°#èGEL 4 9

iZ ¢«çEGLQz ¢«ç

EGLZiZz 3 431C R8jè QMEL¾* RŒZÅ3©ð GG* 2&qí 04

+A)4èGE

G f 8 04Z, Z,Z, 1 44%æENŠy 'zy 1 44‚iŠ ‚iz 7 64*h *$ 01 84Wig~ Wfg~ 4 05

2C Z¡Õä EMMQ"3�ç GMEQENóQÇ ¡éEMZ$�çEQENQ qí 75

Šy zy 6 85YZ �Z 2 95ŠgŠ} Šgz} 9 86ŠZgŠ ŠZgz 6 07

Îg>ZÅ54èGOGE:4 1D

Îg>Z¸í:71 2D

971ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 178: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�~ƬZecÅ´u{Z�á®Zzg¸�¼¶VÅ�Ûz|ÆÔ)6�Zz6ÌÆ‚BŠ?ßg]~7HŠX ÚŠ^ʆ CcY[ì(ZÐ

�~:p!h™ŠZ}ZZxÑtì)�Û /

Å´u{ µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�]c]Îç]Ýô�†Ñ Zzg ÚŠ^ʆ Qz6f™W[ì�6391Y~´u{Â"ÔS®ZzgZ�á®Æ¼²�ÔŠzâVÊ¢™ÆZqÂ[Åßg]

'Å«Z�᮶X4491Y~6z, µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� ÅŠzu~Zzg ÚŠ^ʆ Š~¶Xt‚. è g¶ÐŠzâV�-VÅZiaçLâÂ"™ZðˆXtÂ"Šg}£ìÔ14ø

'Æ,]»ÑgZiaçLâ µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� Æ44,]ƈ ÚŠ^ʆ !g{S~ìX�ZqÐÑzqHŠìX4491YÆZkZecÃLLTŠzxóóŒÛZgŠcŠìXŠg|t

'»ŠzuZZecìX4491YÅZ�á®ÃLLTŠzxóó µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� »�ZZzg ÚŠ^ʆÜsZkßg]~tHYYì�ŠzâV�-VÅ6391YzZàZ�áoVëŠZ�á®�ÛnHYñÔzg:ZÝ~ÂikÃ4491YzZáZecЊzâV�-VÊH

ÆTZÍw)4391Y(ÆK~ ÚŠ^ʆ ŠZzgtŠTZÍwìX4491YÆZkZec6ÃðzŸsñ�Š7ìÔqÑègkgeŠg„gpÆat¢zg~åXaŠO~·@Z*Z}ÅikôZã�áùƒäzZáZkZec~qgzfsp´Vň�:

)Z³(6391YÆZecЊzâV�-VÆuzgt7åENZ7åENZ¸X4491YÆZkZec~«!gZ0gzã7åENZuzgVÆ´z{ÔŠzâV�-V»ZqZµœ�uzgtÌ

ÎcŠÔT6Â[»ÄZyZk§bŠcŠì:

�~:p!h™ŠZ}ZZxÑt

ì)�Û

™Š' µ‹2äe^m‚ )�Û¬ìZzg�~ Ú%ßçp )[(‚—FKÆ'@ÔZ[iâãÆ&4øFGILÃtp~:ÜsoƒÔÉ¢zg~̶X è ˆ~XFK

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^081

Page 179: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)`()�ÛTZÍwZzgTŠzxÆuzgtÅ„g])&Qz6ÜHY[ì(Ãvs™ŠcŠìXZ[uzgt6ÜsLL�~)�ÛÔZDwóóÆZÖpg{‰�Xtp~Ôš�ZiZzg*oƒìXøg}ìw~'äaçLzgt6�ZÖpŠg`KÔZ¹�V»

TZÍwÆK~Šg`™`�X( ÚŠ^ʆ ÂVgecåX)tZÖpë)Š()�ÛTŠzx6«ŠzâVZ�áoVÆ‚ÁZ�á®Zzg®Z›Â[Ð0

ÃZŠg`Ôñ�Š{°~QyÃvs™ŠcŠìXŠzâV�-VÅZiaçLâŠFKÆñµ6ZkZ%6Âz7Š~ˆ�:)1()�ÛÆW¸i~z„ÄZ*]ñ�Š7XôZÈZ�á®ZzgzäZzg¼Š

FZçXÔ1z„»ZŸ†7HX)2(ZŠzâV�-VÃMŠ™ŠcŠÔÂQŠzâVÆ,]´u{´u{Ñg

™*Ô*‡&ÿELûìX,]»ÑgÚƒ*ecåX™ŠÅz„p}ÃÑzq~áW*ecåX µ‹2äe^m‚ )3(�~

4491YÆZkZec~6391YÆZecÅqgzfsZÝoŠg„™Š~ˆ�:

X 143

Ô39 ,] V ÚŠ^ʆ7

X 076Ô 8601Ô 856Ô 8401Ô 647

)ŠzZÝo( 441

Ô 433

Ô94

Ô8 ,] V µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�1 4

@ëqgzfs,]ÅZÝo$2gñ�Š�:

X 347

Ô 8301

Ô 832

Ô 825

Ô 113

Ô93

,] V ڊ^ʆ

X 952

Ô 75qí Ô 05

4Ô 04qí Ô 04

2,] µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�V

181ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 180: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZkZec~P5ZÝogz5kƒ�:: ÚŠ^ʆ

9 ß S �Íhl Íhl 3 62—Z„Ô6Z„ —„Ô6„ 1 53

V µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�

� ¢©->îEGGX 2 31

4491YÆZecÅt²ôp™àIZzgTÞ)2791Y(JÓxZecZ-.VÐTKYDgìXZyZexV~Ìz{ÓxZÝoñ�Š�ÔX»E™{4491YÆZecÆK~W[ìÔZ%T¼6691YЊzâV�-VÅFKQQ«Š~

ˆ~XWZVZec)7791Y(úŠZv ÚŠ^ʆ ¬Zzg µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� ˆìÔªÆK Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(Ê^…‰o œjÅÂ"лg”{.VÐTHŠXZk»Y{

~1YñÇX

ZgèÈsi /

ÅFKzZ�á®»f™ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ ZDwÆQgŠzÄ~ùúV6cÆK~W[ìÔ8~î0QgŠzÆQ»Y{Ì1Y[ìÔ�VÃgÏ{»Y{7HY@ìX

»ÃgÏz��1Ð012J”ìXTZÍw)âÞ8391Y(~ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡

qgzfsZÝoñ�Š�:9 ß S �@› @Š} 8 11

1C aç Nz› aç Nz§ 1 41

Ô†g~9691Y: ]Îf^Ù…mçmç ÅZqg!¦óó) ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ ñÑ*$äZL*y:LL 1DgóóX z ŠóóìÔ:�LLaç N z m14D44(~Zkt6×cƈU"Hì�9ÂLLaç N

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^281

Page 181: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �Wig~ Wfg~ 7 431

�802JÔˆÆÓxZecTZÍwÅ.VÐY9YDgìX,]902Zzg012zQgŠzÅZk»8»zÔ�TŠzxÆñµ6ZiaçLâ�Zð¶ÔZkaTŠzxZzgZkƈÆZexV~ZyŠz,]Å5Â"ìX

ÔZDwÅzÃ]ƈaŠO~·@ä%AzæÍyÅX8~î0QgŠz ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡

~�áï¿>ZyLL@Z£óóÆ!g}~![ZÍwÆWy~{~‰Zô[ÆpŠ%A�ÛâDÂt«�áï:™DX ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Zkªk»f™ƒ[ì�Z¤ZDwÔ

ZkÆ'@ikcÃgÏ{~Zqg!¦�áïƒäÐg{ìX±2k*i~gZz~��22�Ûzg~8391YÃZDwäZKZq@i{g!¦Æ¬Šz

^ps™ZŠbX*i~™räÜsP™{ŠzÜK�Zzg–ì�:~t«cg!¦cèÃg{ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Ô1 1C ~ñ�Šìóó ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ LL7gZ«cg!¦

Šz7XXZ%ZDwÆWy~*yLL'Z5ðuzŠZzg›yóó~Ô)T»iâU2C: ’kz„ìÔZikcg!¦½ˆ(tg!¦èÃgì

£Ã½iŠoz©gZ²[gZ è :ŠZ0&½0î EG0Š+

Z¤¸xZizí1Š}·å:ŠZŠ}Šú‹Š,1�gZ

äZDwÆ!¹â0{¯xÅFKzDz+~£/ZôozFœŠ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ è %Aлx71ÔTÆË~tg!¦ù´~�áïƒäÐg{ˆX

:m232 ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç… 1D)TÎx:m606(~ÜÅˆÔ e^În^lô]Îf^Ù m081@691Xˆ~ : Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ˜! 2D

1Zk»Q97ìX

381ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 182: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

´)ZDwÆZqczsÄ»czsQtì:¶È%›ñð!ÂÍ*

1C Zz„ è a%vWh+']…ÚÇ^áô Ô1 C2 ñÑ*$ä7âga8391Yô)Åi!ãtÄÔZÏßg]~‹å

~tÄZk§bŠg`ì: ur^‡¶È%›hŠvpÍ*

3C a%vWh+'ÅïELZz„¸ªkì�tÔÄÅZ’Zðßg]¶Ôˆ~ZDwäFçÅZzg7Bâga

8391YÃ$™rÅñ�ŠÏ~ÄÃZÍwZ™czs~7JXZDwÅzÃ]ƈ�áùƒðZzgZkÅFKzDz+ÌQy ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ ¾qw

µ‹ )6391Y(Zzg Ò×nÜ ô •†h ÃÐY{¢¢zg~ì�Wc è Š‰Ü X Æ;ðV7ƒð~æÍyƒ[ì? ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ )6391Y(ƈ»‚gZQgŠzZzgÃgϯx 2äe^m‚Ò†�

Z¤¼)æÍyZÃgŠø[ƒYNÂZ¹Ìù´~�áï™1YñXZϧbt~QyÅ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ ZEyÌ™¢ec�ZDwäXZÃgzg!È]~FçÅÔ

Fç”{ßg]ìÔ:�Z’ZðQÔ�áïìX

ðýýðýýð

ZDwÆ;VÔ¸ìwZ’ZðŠzgÅZqçw)6981Y(~Zk§bMì: 1D%›ñðŶãÃðíÐ7iñ]ZWñÏQkÃÔÂz{çZVƒÇ

)%û:lZrŒ‹](:m96 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä D2:m611B899 ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ D3

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^481

Page 183: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÃgÏ ‹ZDwÔ à (`))�Ûzg~3791Y(ÆW¸i~ÌLLZnZgóóÆikÄZyeZË Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(Ê^…‰o

cW[ìX ik ÆY}~ Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(]ö…�æ âp�áïìÔ� z„Š YzhZDw»ZkcÐëät³Z~Hå�:LLZDwÅi0Ï~�áù”{ÔQyÆËQgŠz

ù´ÆËZecŲôp:g{ÃÔZkaQynzxLL�u.Vóóų]zw#ÖÅ!]¡I¾ìXóó)![ZÍw:m24('ÃgÏùúV»Y{BÂßg‹qw¼ZÃ7WCX

ÅZÍAZ�á®ÐI: Ê^…‰o Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù

»ŠÎZVZec�áùƒZÔ�ZDwÅzÃ]ÆŠk‚wˆ8491Y ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ )1(~»g”{.VÐTHŠåX

»¾ðZVZec�áùƒZÔ�ZDwÅzÃ]Æeg'kˆÔ µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ )2(2491Y~5Â"лg”{.VÐTHŠÔɉ”VÅÂ"Â4491Y

™ZðˆX ~ec�áùƒZÔ�ZDwÅzÃ]ÆŠk'kˆ8491Y Z C1 »WZV ‡eç…ôÂrÜ )3(

~5Â"лg”{.VÐT™ZcŠXùƒZÔ�ZDwÅzÃ]Æâ'kÔ7491Y �á C2 »‚ÂZVZec q^æm‚Þ^Úä )4(

~5Â"лg”{.VÐTHŠX»‚ÂZVZec�áùƒZÔ� Ú%ßçpµ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�]c]Îç]Ýô�†ÑÚÄÚŠ^ʆ )5(

ZDwÅzÃ]Æi'kÔ4491Y~5Â"лg”{.VÐTHŠXŠ&ÀŸ/õ GG:e�1~ÂÒCÃZX 1D

sZ 2D

581ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 184: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÅÂ"zS®ZDwÅzÃ]ƈƒðX ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ )6(ZkÐt!]ßU"ƒYCì�:LL¯ÄZDwÆZ[JæZec�áù

ƒñÔz{ƒÆƒZ-.VÐTƒDgì�Ôq|]´)%jxäpŠZKC1 ôZã~»g™zZcåX

QÔFKzDz+ZzgZ5ÅXZÝoÔ è ÆY}~ëä¡ Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(]ö…�æ~ÌÁz�z„ßg‹qwñ�ŠìX Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o {ñVZzgÕ÷»f™HåÔikÃ

fs~PÂzÔZñgŶyŠ„ÅYCì:~ÆÔ4ÔÂ"ÆÔZ0ZiZzgHMz){~7+ Ò×n^l )1(QgŠzZzgÃgÏ

ïÄZDwÆZyùúVÃZqp[ßg]�hZ)Ã(ŒÛZgŠcYY è ÆZÈxÆ7ìX]ÃgÏùúVÆÀ2231,]Æ£«~‚gZÃgϯx8+8201,]~

ƒWcìÔ@ëZkÐZZexVÆ,]Å7+»ƒZzgËÄcÄ»jZ!ŠïƒñÔZecZzg‚ÁZ�á®»f™¢zg~ƒŠÔqÑè¬ZkÅ¢zg]:¶X

~ÌZ5ÃÔ�V»ÂV'ŒÛZggpÆŸ Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o ŧb Ò×n^lô]ö…�æ )2(Tg~WñÏ(X { Å0È~7ňX)ZkÅ,WÒ

)3(ZµZµùúVÆW¸i~ÔQyÆTZÍwZzgâˆZ�áoVÆ‚ÁZ�ᮊg`7K‰X

]‰†]…æ ÅxzgCwÔñÑ*$Zzg:zÂ"c*Ñ䊬� Ò×n^l )4(ÆW¸i~z„p}ñ�Š7ÔTÅzz ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Zzg ÚŠ^ʆ Ô ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Ô …Úç‡

ÐZyùúVÅZàâ]Ô�]Zzgç1]Å�l~Ôzgt¤ŠZã™DƒñÔZY{™z‰ÜŸùƒ@ìXZiaçLâDz+Æñµ6CÙù´ÆÑzq~z„ÄZ*]Šg`™*¼Â:åX

,] Ê�áùHY@g;Ô1ŠzâVÆ ÚŠ^ʆ Zzg µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� IZi, )5(~Z ~,]»ÑgÚìXøg}ìw Ò×n^l »Ñg´u{´u{ƒ@åX

ÔmLL{óóX Ê^…‰o Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù YzhZDw: 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^681

Page 185: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÅZy�-VÅw´u{´u{Â[ÅìÔZkaZyÆ,]»ÑgÌ âδu{´u{ƒ*ecåX

è Ô6391Y~�XF"3ïGGELiâãÆ7 µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� 4391Y~Zzg ÚŠ^ʆ )6(~ZyÅFKÌZϧbƒãec¶X Ò×n^l Ã

)7(ZùúVÆ�ZecÔZDwÅzÃ]ƈ�áùƒñÔQy~FKzDz+Ð0‰Õ÷gZ{0‰Ô}:

ÔTŠzx)7491Y(~TZÍw~ñ�ŠŠzZÃg6�Šâp q^æm‚Þ^Úä )Z³(~ZktÅZ&b™DƒñŠâ<îF0èÃgÃ�á$ÿLÂ[ Ò×n^l vs™ŠcŠåÔ

™¢ecåXÔTZÍw)4391Y(Æuzgt6ñ�ŠZÖpÃ4491YÆZec~vs ÚŠ^ʆ )[(

~ZyZÖpÃbw™ŠbecåX Ò×n^l ™ŠcŠåÔm45&0586LLz^ïGLp}óó»ZŸ†oƒƒÇX ÚŠ^ʆ )8(�~

Z1Z[ЬÔZkÅ9(6 è )m735Zzg175(~lÃÁz+ ‡eç…ôÂrÜ (9)ÉŠcŠìXlÅt¼*ÔoƒZzgŠg„ìX

1C Qz¯xÅLLÌ2wóó è ÆŠâd~Ô¡ Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o eZËYzhZDwäÔÒ×n^lô ~¼ŠZÝoŶyŠ„ŶÔZ\kì� Ò×n^lô]ö…�æ Xëä »f™Hì

Ô6zspZVZzg*Ñ+z){Æa°ZßZµLLÌ2wóóU" è "54èGEGE% ÔZkÆ Ê^…‰o

Æ£«~{™icŠ{ìÔÉ Ò×n^lô]ö…�æ ~ZÝo»ÚƒÔ Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o ƒðXÐIZ�á®5kƒäzZáËÌ°~ÔZÝoÅz{Ò]Ã7 Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o

¢ìX Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o WCÔTÐ~Ô‚—ZexV~ñ�ŠÔXZÝoÅo™Š~ˆìÔZyÅ Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o

,tì:

:mLLzóóX Ê^…‰o Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù 1D

781ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 186: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 S »� Ò×n^l ß S �]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

}Zzg0 4 4 }Zîg0 4 2qíñ�Šì 6 qíñ�Š7ì 7 4qíñ�Šì 6 && 1 5g|!i 5 7 *g è g| 9 5

*“ 6 7 ^qZÍw:¦“ 01 5

*“ 6 7 ^qUã:¦“ 01 5qíñ�Šì 01 qíñ�Š7ì 8 9§]z$›45é GGOE] 5 21 §‹$›45é GGOE] 2 21ÁV� 4 54 Á� 3 05

W 1 05 X 01 55Wig 21 95 Wfg 11 66

�ì 5 16 :ì 21 86�v 61 76 �v 11 67Z±g 11 07 Z745é EGEg)Üs9591YZec( 9 97Z+zWV 6 27 Z,zWV 6 18

| 2 47 #-ö EG)Üs9591YZec( 2 48

ìø×øÐø qí 47 ìø×øÐû

qí�1

58

»gê 41 67 »gl)Üs9591YZec( 11 78

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^881

Page 187: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 S »� Ò×n^l ß S �Wigl 31 87 Wfgl 4 09Ší} 31 98 Ší})Üs9591YZec( 11 2010g{;ñ 4 09 0g0ñ 4 301

*;ñ 9 49 0;ñ 9 801

}ZZ„ 01 201 }Z„ 4 811é‰IèW 6 601 é‰IèX 9 211

*ÂZy 7 701 *ÂZV 8 321Šúò 31 701 Šú} 5 421KŠx qí 311 WŠx qí 031!Z!ï OG 5 311 !Z„)Üs9591YZec( 4 031&B¨ÒøEI 6 321

&B¨ÒøE

7 241pZ@ 4 821 pZ0 3 841è+ 8 531 è, 21 651KšÃ qí2 441 WŠx qí2 861Wig 8 961 Wfg 01 791

µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

,]�psƒä6oƒì 49 5 z„_Wig 7 202 Wfg 3 22

« 4 952 ¬ 9 101Wig~ 2 643 Wfg~ 2 112

981ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 188: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 S »� Ò×n^l ß S �‡eç…ôÂrÜ

!š-@îEEF0 3 514 !ü

E+@î EFO 3 23Wig~ 41 424 Wfg~ 6 54Z÷X6)4è XGE 5 935 ZøX� 01 502

£ó 4 145 £á 7 802Šgz 21 145 ŠgŠ 3 902

)Î 1 355 )Á 4 422åy 5 455 åV 21 522

·X6)4è XGE 31 755 ¸X� 7 032· 6 065 ¸ 11 332f 21 265

+A)4èGE

G 7 732Wig 21 085 Wfg 1 752Wig~ 2 185 Wfg~ 7 752

çßVÆßÑg�Ì9™Šb‰�Xq^æm‚Þ^Úä

zZz+Ίb‰ 4 507 ^qzZz+~7ì 01 531

Wè&WV� 7 817 Wè 01 151

¤` 5 297 ¤p 9 042'×h'WVLLWfgóóÃÓx£â]6LLWigóóÐ$wŠcŠìX

ZIWZ0ZIW 1 597 IX Z ZIXZ0 8 342

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^091

Page 189: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�9 S »� Ò×n^l ß S �Wig~ 1 438 Wfg~ 4 05]øÊø¡ømøßû¿ö†öæûáø qí 938 Êû]öÞ¿û† qí 75

YZ 3 148 �Z 2 95Íhl 3 968 Íhl 3 62

ڊ^ʆ'Wg 11 078 'Zg 5 82Wig 31 658 Wfg 3 11

]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡

æ‰uz› 9 498 æ‰uz§ 1 41Wig~ 8 779 Wfg~ 7 431

@ëZ5ZzgÂ"ŹÏZ+ZÝoÅ¡7ƒmÔ�Š*¶V~ñ�Š�ÔÔ65±™,: g{ ´z{Zi,‰ZÝoÅßg]$wˆìX,W

191ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 190: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×n^l ß S �]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

ñ\öL ñ� 4 61 ñ. 7 61¬@ ¬@? 2 22 ¬@? 5 32upl up� 9 04 up� 3 54i0ZÈÉ i0ZVÿL 5 14 g0ZVÿL 8 54sSÈî M ÑZ! 4 24 ÑZ[ 4 74

qd/õ IG»Wy~z:LL�W�ŒÛWãŧsóó¸TìX qí1: 94�i* Îi* 21 64 Îi* 2 25

Ï;ñ $�+<éEE

Xñ 9 76 $�+<éEE

Xñ 11 571C qí1:qd/õ IGÅ�g]$2gZ�ðg~ìX 86 qd/õ IGÅ�g]Z�ðg~ì qí2: 67

ZzÑ Zz! qí2: 76 Zz! qí1: 67!Ñz !Ñî 21 57 !Ñî 6 68

äZ�Zð¶VÃ!ÑK[7�¬Ô "54èGEGE Æ% Ò×n^l ZkÐtZ0Zi{�@ì� 1D

YV�Z�Zð¶V~tqíåìX

ÖÃäÚ_^

�nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^

291

Page 191: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×n^l ß S �{r�4èE

G {j 6 67 {j 8 68C2 ÞößøôùÙöý�mè÷ *.çGEOEw qí1: 67 *.çGEOEw'Wt qí2: 68

Ky KV 2 68 KV 2 893C ]øiûÏFÓöÜ Z»Á qí 401 Z$¨Àê

GNGqí 021

&éGM'ç NN mø^Úö†öÒöÜû qí 801 mø^Úø†öÒöÜû qí2: 42127 m�ZV m�ZV 1 111 m�ZV 11 721

$2gßì qí 511 WtÑfßì qí1: 331

ÿLLwóóЬLLZ³óóiZZ …øuûÛøèºÖù×Ã^ÖÛn6åÔz{Âvs��1LLyóó»iZZìþ

…øuûÛøèöÖ×Ãù^ÖÛnà 3 221 …uÛè]Ö×Ã^ÖÛnà@ 11 041

4C ÊøjøÏø_$Ãöçû� ÊøjøÏø_$Ãöçû] qí 321 Êøj_$Ãöçû] qí1 241

Îg>ZÈZ:4 2DŒÛWã�gZ]zZÖp»Z5Ì�ŒÛWyÆ_.�*¢zg~ìXŒÛWy0u~Zk»Z5ZϧbìX)Îg>ZÆZ]:311( 3DÎg>Z>ëy:35 4D

391Ãgϯx

Æù´

Page 192: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×n^l ß S �gZi~ gZi~ñ 21 821 gZi~ñ 3 541

zg* 6Zg BZz ¹Zzg6zg* 8 531 ¹Zz6zg* 21 6516Z� 6� 21 241 6� 4 661u*� u¦� 2 741 u¦� 7 171

zZ 0Zi� Z z '�Zg� i� Z 0Zi� Z '�Zg� 2 741 0Zi�Ziz Z '�Zg� 7 171u*� ^q1:u¦� 4 741 ^q1:u¦� 9 171u*� ^q2:u¦� 4 741 ^q2:u¦� 9 171u*� u¦� 5 741 u¦� 01 171]Öûfø’ø†ö ]Öûfø’ø†ø 31 061 ]Öûfø’ø†ø 21 681+Bk5å EEIGø� .ø0� 11 861 ^q1Ô2.ø�0 9 691

µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

ÉÏî LŠ ÉÓÏî LŠ 81 471 ÉÏî LŠ 2z�_

ÖÃäÚ_^

�nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^

491

Page 193: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÎZ ÎZñ 5 181 ÎZñ 11 o

zl z� !Ñ zl � !Ñî 01 091 !Ñî�gl 2 8

Gz Gî 6 602 Gî 2 82

Wigx Wfgx 01 552 Wfgx 01 79

l zâ * lâ *î 61 962 lâ *î 6 411

� ¢©->îEG

GX 8 313 ¢©->îEGGX 9 761

1z.8 1î.8 8 123 1î.8 6 871

� ¢©->îEG

GX 7 523 ¢©->îEGGX 1 481

$©3ð EEG} $©3ð E

EGûWL 8 523 $©3ð EEGñ 2 481

Wig Wfg 6 173 Wfg 6 142

øz øî 9 583 øî 6 052

‡eç…ôÂrÜ!z�iW> !z�W> 4 914 !z�W> 4 72

591Ãgϯx

Æù´

Page 194: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

z �  �î 3 724 F�î 3 05

$z) $zâ{ 3 315 $zâ{ 3 071

ógÄ ógZ0 5 845 ógZ0 1 812

¸ ê 31 845 ê 9 812

Í ª 6 065 ª 11 332

g§V g§y 2 585 g§y 2 262

q^æm‚Þ^Úä@/| @:| 4 336 @:| 11 64

[]&[> +Z] 4 086 +Z] 9 301

�g9 �g[ 3 286 �g[ 21 501

Zi9 Zi[ 5 486 Zi[ 7 801¢¬.çGEGE=@Ñ[ $2g÷zsì qí 307 tÐvs�� qí 331

g*© i ð g*©i 4 607 ð g* ©i 1 731�g &¾æE

YEg 9 717 &¾æEYEg 11 051

ÖÃäÚ_^

�nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^

691

Page 195: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

møÃû×øÛöçû7 møÃû×øÛöçûáø 41 237 mÃ×Ûçá 01 961[]&[> +Z] 7 887 +Z] 11 432[]&[> +Z] 31 887 +Z] 5 532

µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†�� ¢©->î

EGGX 2 128 ¢©->î

EGGX 2 13

5C ]øuûŠøàôiøÏûçmÜ ]øuûŠøàö]ÖjøÏûçmÜ 8 728 ]øuûŠøà]ÖjÏçmÜ qí2: 04ÚŠ^ʆ

�,ç MQz / 9 558 / 3 9�Z�X6Z� ��X6� 9 578 ��X6� 1 53¨ ¨V 01 878 ¨V 2 83zc '* '*îc 2 978 '*îc 01 83

6C ‘ôfÇèø]Ö×#ä ‘ôfûÇøèö]Ö×#ä 1 288 ‘ôfûÇøèö]Ö×#ä 7 34]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡

@� @�} 4 398 @�} 8 11

Îg>ZÅ54èGGE:4 5D

Îg>ZÂ{:831 6D

791Ãgϯx

Æù´

Page 196: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~‰5ZÝogz5kƒ�X%iZ;Š~ZázZíFZ! Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o

ÆikÄZyÔ¹ÏZÝoŶyŠ„Å 1C ~Â"Å™Vóó Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù äÔäÂzŠÑðìÔ@ëZÝoÅåz„} 2C ìXPZÝoŧseZË·gcn

icŠ{îsìXfs~ëÓxZÝoÃqYŠg`™gì�XeZË·gcnZzgzZíFZ!äÔXZÝoŶyŠ„ÅìÔQyÆ‚tZZnKLLxXgóóZzgLLzX]óóÆ&B©¨é EEE]Šg`�:

9 ß � »� Ò×n^l

]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

úVÆŠgxy´#ÖLLtóóŠg`ƒäÐg{ˆìX 4 7Z%æEL·g Z*.çEEL·g 11 7$§öEEL Ô 9 61^©0î NEGzD] s 21 12

9FKtì: ZÃgÅFKßì 9Ô01 32)1(ZiÎZwZ#k' )Z(ZiÎZwWÇ')2(ZiÎZwWÇ' )2(ZiÎZwZ#k'Þøvû‹õ Þøvû‹º 21 92

[} 8o-BðEG

Eñ 5 03izgt igzt qí 04

Íg ͧ 6 54

ÔŠc8791Y:m962@671 ]ö…�æJ]ñrŠ8 1D¯[¯xgZ¶Z�zs:51�Ñð7791YX 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^891

Page 197: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß � »� Ò×n^l

*ZgŠ ¢ZiŠ 01 16eô^‰ûÜô eôô‰ûÜô qí 47

zD] «4 «Ï 7 87!iôo !io 6 19Ò^Ö×ùn&ô Ò^Ö×ùn&ö qí 01 1uåO&ñ œ& 01 101æø]ŸûôuûŠø^á æø]ŸûôuûŠø^áø 4 801ZÑ][ V ZÑ] qí 801

zD] 1C ƒôexõ ƒøeûxº 3 011‚âV ‚ây 31 011�ø]…ø �ø]…º 01 511

zD] ÒöËû†]÷ ÒöËö†]÷ 31 511Ÿo �ø]…ø �ø]…ö 51 511�76ƒ*ecåX ZŒÄ LL)03(óó qd/õ IG»°Š 6 611

âè 'u âèuè' 01 911WN WM 3 121Rz\ Qz\ 1 421æ$‰ø_÷^�öø‚ø�ðø

æ%‰û_÷^ý

�öø‚ø�ðö

5151

931931

2gzh6„ 2§h6„ 8 051

Îg>ZÅ{©ï WOEŠG:701X 1D

991ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 198: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß � »� Ò×nlZsxV Zsxy 4 951

ð} }å 9 951]Öûfø’ø†ö ]Öûfø’ø†ø qí 061

Öô×#äô]ÖÛø�û†ôÑöæø]ÖÛøÇû†ôhö æøÖô×#äô]ÖÛø�û†Ñôæø]ÖûÛøÇû†ôhô

µn^ÝÚ�†Ñuzgt

ÆÑzq~LLzóó»ZŸ†š¢zg]„ Ö×#ä]ÖÛ�†Ñæ]ÖÛdžh~Zq(tZÖpzZzÆ‚B Ά�áôuÓnÜ 7Ôš�ZiÌìX

Wñ�)ZÂ{:511(ZzgŠzu~(zZzÆ%)ZÂ{:241(XZDwÅi0Ï~,·ÐVZexV~ÐË~ÌzZz7Zzg:

‡ßìX ~zZz(J* Ò×n^l ˆÆËZec~ÔZka

uzgt

ÐVæ¹i!âV ÐVi!âV 31 0811C ZZxÆSù ZZxÅSù 9 7812C ZZÄæt ZZÄÑt 41 281

WiZg WzZi 2 402igk=‰~ < qí 112

_ZgZi[ _Zg[ 6 612Ñb ub 2 932*h *æ 11 652

i!yZzgZ°ÅgzÐÂLLZZxÅSùóóß7Ô1ZDwÆZÖpLLZZxÆSùóó~ è¡ D1ÌZ+ÃðyZ!7�ZÐpsHYñXZDwäŠzu}Zzg�}Zec~ÌZÐ

ZÐ$%ÆWi7ƒMX Ò×n^l è 'ŒÛZgg3ÔZ[%AZK(LLZZÄÑtóóÅFIŠg„ìÔ1ZDwäLLZZÄætóó–åÔZkaZÐLLZZÄ D2

Ñtóó~ps™*ßìX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^002

Page 199: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×nl

¢k=*Ó < qí 852ÈV ÈÈ 3 362

zD] !W²} 7²} 4 762$§:.5åEEXG{ ŧ:.5å

EXG{ 1 472Z0g Z2g 6 392

zD] W¤ Ws 9 992YV Yy 1 203Z!/õ OG Z!/õ OG 3 803

4C ZZmøŠûËôÔö]Öô‚ùÚø^XXæøZZìø’ônܺÚ%fôn6XXzD]

mŠËÔö]Öô‚ùÚø^ìø’nܺÚ%fôn6 41 013

6zZ:òWð 6zZ:ògm~ 41 343ŠZŠ=ŠZî < qí 063W¤ Ws 6 063

zD] ä 6 01 163g§V g§y 1 663

zD] ƒZ÷ ƒZY÷ 8 873g4 g3 8 973

zD] W¤ Ws 6 183‚ª ‚¢5é GF 01 483

ZDwñi*уg~ñ�ŠÔ!iðOŠ}~zZãîg6LLzóóñ�ŠìX 4D

102ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 200: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×nlWy~Äƈ�Yw¯cŠÔz{Šg„7ÔYèZkÔ»Wy~ÄZzgZŒÔ»ªÄûƒ‰�ÔZ�tŠzâVëgŠpzë‡B�ZzgŠ*¶V~µ‘‰

�XZ¹ZµZµ™*ßìX

983

»^gZ�ÛÍ »É45å EEgZz6:ö XX 1 093‡eç…ôÂrÜ

\V \y 7 904¤ŠŠ �Š 41 0243¦y F¦y 7 924�áV �áy 9 684

zD] ŠZg~ ŠZg„ 8 894*# *Ò 2 315

zD] � ¢©->îEGGX 3 915

zD] Z, Z, 5 725*d-êIG

¦d-êIG

01 925�VŠg;l �È;l 31 245

zD] !h42.ç GEG !h42.ç GGGE 01 345ìX ZzgŠzu}úVÆŠgxyLLtóó»¶yŠgƒäÐg{Š ¬ 21D31 445

)õF0 9 21 655zD] � ¢©->î

EGGX 31 955

�ZV �Zy 8 465

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^202

Page 201: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×nl²ÃV ²Ãy 8 565'zV 'zy 6 975

pŠ è† pŠ èÇ 1 385q^æm‚Þ^Úä

¸ · 1 226zD] ⧠âg} 9 226

Z{ g ¤Š {g °æYLŠ 11 526

� � 6 146ZikV Ziky 1 076i+Z°$,ò i+Z°$+ñ 3 676

xDg zu Š Šg ŠzŠzu 4 996¢¬.çGEGE=@Ñ[ < qí 307

zD] g9*îGrÅ)4/õGE g9*îGZrÅ)4/õGE 2 417i, i+ 8 717

zD] q} C} 6 337zD] 5kŠ 8kŠ 2 437zD] uz§ uzg} 01 147

mŠZV mŠZy 8 747ì!V ì!y 31 057y*V yz*V 3 357

xDg ÎV èL LzÎV 7 067

302ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 202: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×nl»§Zz„ ^qUã:»§Z„ 6 967

xDg ò™Š~ yZã 01 177Wèw½ØtZÕª—guzg»Ñ]ŠgqUãZ�ág{ZazgZ�ŠgG"0î EGGZÑsx

< qí 477

ŒÛd ŒÛ"ìGEƒ 3 087zD] $ÕäOcy $Õä NOcÈ 41 987

YV Yy 21 597ï ]øÖûøÜ%Þô’ûÌö]Öûø†øÝ ]Ö×ù`ÜÞ’Ì]Ö`†]Ý qí1 697

Ú%ßçpµ‹2äe^m‚zD] Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ÖFä 7 018

âV ây 4 318Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ÖFä 4 318

„ Z iŠ iŠ„ 1 518Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 1 518

zD] � ¢©->îEGGX 4 128

Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 3 228zD] Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 01 328

møßû¿ö†ö møßû¿ô† 2 628+A)4èGE

G f 41 728Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿ?ø]ôÖFä 31 238

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^402

Page 203: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×nl*$ *h 3 338¶!fã=ªQJ÷}¬Ð < qí 648

ÚŠ^ʆŸø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 7 158Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 3 168Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 61 568

5C ìô†ûÎøjø^á ì†øÎûjø^á 3 378Öôoûìô†ûÎøjø^áô]øÖûËøÏû†öæø]Öûrôãø^�ö Öôoûìø†øÎûjø^áö]ÖûËøÏû†öæø]Öûrôø^�ô qí2 378

æ Zv ë Zv 2 778¤{ \B5å EG{ 9 978%Zv /)Zv 11 978%Šy %ŠÈ 51 088

]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡i "Î "Ί 9 929

xDg '+õ E� ^qUã:’+õE

� 6 039

Š, Š+ 3 139%Zv /)Zv 11 139Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 6 439Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 3 349Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 6 159

CðìÔ�Šg„7ìX ìø†ûÎøjø^á zZíFZ!äZkÅßg] 5D

502ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 204: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S »� Ò×nlo Ö%Çöçûhõ o ÖøÇöçûhõ qí 359

zD] ˜m ˜m 01 559Š*V Š*y 21 769

ª Í 8 869pl pk 01 189Ÿø?]ôÖøä Ÿø?]ôÖFä 5 389

xDgÔzD]8g.øFII 8g.ø

II 8 9101Å}Òï OG Z ZÅ}ÑBïG 31 1301

zD] »Ñ] »b] 2 6001]hZkZãZŠÒ]~ŸÅp~äZkZyÆÃgÏZ5~‰ãŠ~p´VaZ

™Š~�XŠ*¯Zzg'x)¸g]Ô0ÎyZzg@Š÷(ÆŸÆ'@ÔW`ÀZkZy~czsZzg!wWzZizV~ZqÐigzZ7g3Y@Xz;Vây“0î EEOÅWzZiÌ»

%ÍzÃgÏZ5Æ_.�áùK‰�Ô1 1C Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù ƒ_ìÔOçZkZy~,·'x~WzZizVÅ&ZzgZkÆË~Z%½óglZ[Ìñ�ŠìX®Z�VÔgæŒ{VÆ–w:LLZ5ZzgÈÔŠzâV~Ôczsz!wZzg“0î EEOWzZizV»Z5Åpg3YñÇZzgZ¤Ãð¿ÃgÏ]hÅÇ~ÔZkÆÜs™}ÇÔÂt§iQßÁDz+

»ƒÐplWÒUtì�Zk~¯ Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o kà i C2 ƇÜsƒÇóóX7_ƒñÔZq Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o ÃgÏƧ¯Z5Ã'ŒÛZgg3ŠìÔzg:ZkZy~,·

Q{zZzgZ_g»DgƒY@ìX 6 ‡g~ÔSî'x»‡g~ÔfZ_g ŧbZ5ð Ò×nlô]ö…�æ ÔŠZ½îg6 Ò×nlôÊ^…‰o UÐsÃÔ 1ZkplWÒ

~ ÔZ5ðZ_gZ]z§ŠZ]ÔZ²Z[z°óg~Æe Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o »DgìÔÉ

Ôz){X %û:Z£uzlÔ,·éZyÔTZÍw:3691YÔTŠzx:2791Y 1D:m565 ]ö…�æ]ôÚ¡ 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^602

Page 205: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÐÌ(JƒZìX Ò×n^lô]ö…�æ "µZzgZ5Åù¦"Ÿ$ŒÀö EY

ZzgÛ[ÆZ±gЃÐ(~{òtì�Z5Æe~ÃðŸ‚cQßwzä7HŠÔplâöÅfZCßZ[Šh„ZÝQßwìÔOçplâöäZqÂÃ6e;ÔÉŠcÔŠzu~(ZkÅ

qZec ‰ –z^$wŠ~Zzg�~(QÐ!Ç5ßg]jŠ~XeZËYzhZDwärd->î IEX ÅLL]hÂ"óóÃLL�á²ætóóƯxÆ�ácÈ�áyŒÛZgŠcìXš Ò×n^l ÆŠâd~g] ÅÂ"Ô¹p[ß Ò×n^l ŠzâV QgŠzZzgÃgÏ ªCÙ~Œ»g~ZzgplúðÆZ±gÐ

ìÔ1Z5Å¡z7+Æ$©�î EG0ÃÐtplâ+£g~7ìXzZíFZ!��:ÃÔ�)gv6zsgigxWñÔz{ÃgÏ Ò×n^l tŠN™"uœ)ƒZ�)agÆZk

¸ Z‰é‰ ÔZ°Ð!ÇÞ Z‰é‰ ÐuZu"¾{ÔSî¸Z‘åLÃgÏЇ*£Ô²znÐ8cC1 ZzgQyÅÃÌFšcC)Rh(7¶X

Zzg ZVp Z5»UÔôZÈÂ"Ô6zs è tgZ}¹JìÔ1t¢zgZˆkƒ@ì�¡ÅˆÔZkÐ}icŠ{Šh{gm~Zzg Zãp ÎÂzÐ6zs X *ÑÅóƒVÐZzÍg;

~:Üst�ZÝoŽâgìÔÉZ5Å"‡°ŠV Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o »zl£[¶ÔÌMZzg�q�Ô}:

Ò×n^lô )Z³(Zq„ÂcZq�ZÖpÆŠzZ%äŠ&ÀŸ/õ GG)¸¯~Æ,]�Šg`�X( Ê^…‰o

)904(0g{ g{ ›"3þJG)081(›ë)181(XzZñ)527(zZ})527(X0)776(X)õE0)36(6)163(X/zÑï)204('zZ#/õ JG)214(XÍ*)433(X

)195(Wiâ÷)636(X&4èEGE)146(/@)256(X Íì)713(WiâöPZ,ZÖpZzgZy 2C )[(‰ZÖp»Z5zZãîg6ßìXëfs~�g%:

~Zk§bÆßZ5ÅÒ]ì: Ò×n^l Å9ßg]Šg`™gì�ÔÔâÞ8791Y:m961 ]ö…�æJ]ñrŠ8 1D

Z5ÅZ+ßßgÂVÃgZ¶äZÝoèÂ"Åz„~�áïzÑg7HÔYèt)Åg~ß D2–z^ZqÒpÐZ5»%zz§iìXZ¤Z(HY@ÂZÝoÅ®ZŠôzVÐ(|™DÙZgzVJVYCX

702ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 206: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

£/9ßg] »ßZ5 Ò×n^l �!a !$iï JG 5310hZg} 0ZZg} 444�g{ �Ò{ 064pZË{ pZËÒ 206ó w 436W�V; W�. 496Š{V; Š{. 496

)`(ÃgÏÂ/Ô�Ô"Ô:Ôpz){LŠzu}ÂÐï™ZzgLZµ‘YD~̸ßg]ìÔ1}ZµricŠ{gZS¥xƒ@ìÔZk§bt Ò×n^l �X

~)m924(3¦yÃtÐF¦y¯ŠcŠìÔZ¤Zk Ò×n^l »ZÈw7gLÔ}:Åßg]:LL:g¦yóóƒCÂZkt»Zky¹�ƒ@XZϧb:LL¾Âóó)m285(ÃLL/CÙÂóóLL1]óó)m946(ÃLL/z]óóZzgLL!kZyóó)m396(ÃLL/ZkZyóó–Y@Â4åX

] ¬~S²Z[»ZÈx׃@ìX&Z(g™ä~ÔZkÅ) )Š(ZVäÐsÃÔƒÐ(ZÃZ{¸ì�Zk~ZÈÄZ²Z[¹W‚yìZzgZk

§b’kÃgzZãZzg×!gëg~Ð7JYYìXS²Z[Åñ�ŠÏ~ÃÃ}g»z7ƒCÔZ�šS²Z[’k~ÔŠg}R�zCkƒ@ìX

~S²Z[óg~»ZÈx7HŠÔZkÅzzÐF£â]6 Ò×n^l Z\kì�S£kaZƒ@ìXfsÅPVßVÐS²Z[Å¢zg]»Z0Zi{ƒÇ:

£/4ßg] »Z5 Ò×n^l �¯8çXM:æENEÌ iCÙbÌ 9

›gÌ ¯ izg› 34$ðENMáQ 1Š 44

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^802

Page 207: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

£/4ßg] »Z5 Ò×n^l �ôQR $ðGMQ ÂZx 54™®é OÈ Š»y 96¡åGLx Šx 531!îEL / 151

'} R ¯ iZ'} 282%îLQz )Zz 665

8�Û iZ iŠh ™/ Zg Qz 8�Û iŠhZi $Zg Zz 896Zi$gê GM

IQ Zi1 167){(Z�}c†Ã}£ЖŠìZzg}¬xÐÔZkK~:Â

7g~§bŠ*¶VÅÇňìZzg:ËZzgŸÆÅXplâöä®Ó45éGOGSZKßZ[Šh)m745(ŠzâV Ò×n^l )m712(Zzg ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Ð»x1ìÔ}:LL�Û8óóZzgLLBkóó

)m835( Ò×n^l )m402(£ÐÔ1 ‡eç…ôÂrÜ (£Ð�XLLrmóóZzgLL5äóó~¬xÐ�X)Q‰£â]6Z�}ð{ZzgZ�}Ì]Ạ̃ЖŠ

m701(Zq„Â}£ÐìZzg}ëÐ(X Ò×n^lV ìÔ}:LL�óó)Z�}c†)Z¾mÔ£â]ÔÃz){(ÊvZÖpZzgZdwÐ&-.çGOE™ä (z)

(r»§iÔŠ*§iZ5ÅZqczsßg]ìX ___ ÆaQyÆQz6Zqâ)~!ÇWiZŠZ: Ò×n^l (¯ðYCìXikc

__ ZϧbÄZÆZ�6kÅ´#Ö)gzlZ(gňìÔÉicŠ{9sV~tIec�Ãð!3›4è G

GOEgzlì„7Ô}:ÆZz6â5ŠƒÔ}Z�}ð{6kÅ´#Ö ï ‘Ðê MMè ~�áh„ËZÌ ]‰†]…æ…Úç‡

)m201Ô301(Ô}Z�}c†6kÅ´#Ö)m333Ô713Ô068(Zzg}kÅ´#ÖÅO}â)m633(XZq„Â6}â5Š)1Z:m568(Zzg}â

75Š)1Z:m52Ô62(Ô}â!Ç„š�ZiZzgßì)$h45é EIGEV:m088(X

902ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 208: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

‰£â]ÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�plâöÔZÖpÆzzÝÐ"¾{ìÔZóó'�VLzóZzgLió~zÝZzgLióZzgLzóÆŠgxy g izŠ z }:m0626ì'LL¬ÝŠk

ZóóX g zŠ − z ßìÔ9ßg]~ZÐ-Vƒ*ecå:LL¬ÅêLŠk~LLWfgóóÃOîg6 Ò×n^l ÃŶÆ:ƒZìX è tƒ¼ZôoÔÂzZzgŠ‰Ü

LLWigóóÐ$wŠcŠìÔ1°xÂzÐ}}tp~7ƒmÔ}:LLWfgóó$2gLLWfgóó)m173(ZzgLLWfgxóó$2gLLWfgxóó)m552(ìXZ5ÆK~Zy§ŠZ]zZ_gZ]Zzg"‡°7VÅzzÐÔgZ¶ZK!]ŠCÙZä66gì�:LLDz+zZ5Æî

Ò×n^lô ¸Z°zQßw%AzEKYNZzgZyÅgzÝ~f}ZD1]»Zq1geÔC1 »ZqRZzg9¯»g™}Ô&£g~ŒÛZgŠ}™gZòHYñóóX ]Îf^Ù

ÆWy~ZVK,]»ZqLLZ�ágtóó�áïìXtÌZÏâqÅ Ò×n^lôÊ^…‰o

ÆZ�ágb6cÆK~ Ò×n^lô]ö…�æ {]ZÝoÐ%æFNìÔX»uu~‚E™{ƒ[ì)5±ÙÔ![ZÍw:m35D65(Ô}:

WŠòÔZxZ2[ÔYxWZzg5ä~ÆÄZ*]ÃLL�]óóÆ�Zzg )Z³(fzZ¥îxÃLLZâÁóóÆ�Šg`HŠìX

)[(¡)m087(Ð%ZŠ¢ãxZyìÔ1Zk»jZ!pZz¥Z−+²Ô*.çFGL¡Æ�ŠcŠìX

)`(LLWfg~óóÃLLWigóóÆjZßV~£ç™ŠcŠÔqÑè�VWfg~Ð%ZŠì:’ƹÐ0ÔZk»WigÐÃðm7ìX 2C )m757(

)Š(LL¡óó)m846Ô309(Æ‚BLL¾wZ−+¡~óóßîg6–ŠìÔ¸yZ™ÔZqZµ,�X

]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ ){(LL4mZ?xóó)m57(»jZ!ƒÐicŠ{5&ìÔZÐâóóÐZ~HŠìX ð z;gz4 ð ÆZk^´:LLzZg“ñ.

![ZÍw:m85 1D~ZkÔ»Ñg�ß)857(Šg`ìX Ò×n^l 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^012

Page 209: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZZxóó»ìÔ è ZZxóóÐňìXZÝjZ!LL> è )z(ZZÄ�{ÅzŸsLL>XtjZ!ZÏÄZyÐW*ecåÔ:�LLZZÄ�{óó League of Nations TÐ%ZŠì:

»áZŠsìZzg�VZk»ÃðûÌ7ìX United Nations ÆÄZyÐ�)i(ZDwÅ£?Zzg‰ŠvÂ1VÆ*ñVÃLLñçqóóÆ�Šg`HŠ

ìÔ�ßìX)b(‰XRZÖpÆjZßVÊŠg`HŠìÔ}:�á²Ô�á²~ÔçwÔ

ÄXLÔMXDÔ¬ÝX»�ÛÔ¬X›Ô›yÔñðXxÔèXzíÔzƒ43ïEGGXÑÔ‚XqÑèZyƒÅâÎ]Z]ZìX ___ }ZÔmŠZVXkÔ˜ŠX${ð GOsÔß°

ZÝo%AÅYñ®ZŠôzVJãÏXZyôzV è ikÃZ�ágbÅz„Æ‚B�áùƒg;ìZzgZkÅ Ò×n^l ZÝoÉÔtZ�ágt*¸73'kÐèÃg{

Z&bcps™ä»ìwËÃ7WcX¿U¸¹YYì�tZ�ágt*‡&ÿELZ&bìÔZkÅ(Zq*Z�ágt%A™*icŠ{W‚yƒÇX

Ê^…‰o Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù ikÃÂ[Æ�71Zzg526ZDwZ»Šò0ÎyÆ�áù™Š{)e~GZec0991YÔ4e~GZec4991Y(»f™M[ìXZ÷…ÆZkZãZ|ƒ

'xÆ9ÃgχgMÆa*ââkZzgZb ( Ò×n^l Â"~�áù”{èÃg{µn^Ýô ~¼ZzgÕ÷ÌÃMD�Ô} Ò×n^l ÃÔZk è ìXZ|ƒÂ"Ðs

иTìÔZ%Zk»ÃgÏFÀŠcŠìX)ZDwä Ò×n^l »QgŠzŠâp Ú�†Ñ~ Ò×n^l ŠâpÃgÏ~7–åX(F3Æ‚BQgŠzQÌŠb¢zg~åXZk

ZqZzgp~tÃMCì�‰Z�ÛZŠÆZÝ*ñVÆO}ZyÆÃgÏáZŠÃ]ŠZ4™Šb‰��Í,ÆO}ÍMc"54fõ E

GHIÆO}—cMí6íÆO}Z&4k54è GEIGGE

¯ä)c—hä(»h k ZzgN&ðÆO}ÂÅh4ðG~Xøg}ìw~Z�}c†Ã!«çEOËÃqÝ7ìX–wgæŒ{V:èZ¾ZkZãÅcz~~*ñVÃ'~§b*H

k§bÅp=V)’d]?(»Ÿç*uìXZkK~Š&ÀŸ/õ GG:)1(gZ¶ Z C1 ŠìX»*yLL¯ÄZDwÅ£g~Dz+zZ�á®óóX2gæŒ{V»*yLL¯ÄZDwÅ

�X ~�áï ]Îf^Ön^lViË`nÜæirˆmä tŠzâVp}gZ¶ÅÂ[ Dz+óó)2(:m46 ÚÓ^ingô…�n‚uŠàì^7eß^Ý…ÊnÄ]Ö‚màa^�Ûo 1D

112ÃgϯxÆù´

Page 210: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:3 ![

kKÆù´

�ý�ý�ý�

312kKÆù´

Page 211: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

DwÅèoâ+ Z ( Z³ )´)ZDwÔ{y·*iZ−+{VÆ*x91BZÆ'9191YÆâ~��:=tÍ™ÀƒZ�W\÷}èoôpgn�XpZzŒÂòÌZ(„™D�X¼²�ƒZÔZQ,Vä÷}‰èoZqÂ[~�áù™�bÔÂ=¹6.ãƒðÔYèèoå³~�YD�ZzgZyÅZ�á®°�7ƒCX°*ZÁ:’k~ZqZ(Z0ZiaZ™�îìÔTÃ6ZÇfèo~çs™M�Ô1Z�á®Ô

C1 ZyÅÃUãÆ%:ƒãecXZDw»tZˆµ¡÷ÀZ07XèoÔ!kx'�Z¸Zzg³~�YD

�ÔZkaZÒx‹äI7H�QyÆCÙâqZzgCÙ§bÆèo�áùKYNÔ1Zë!]tì�ÎZz‡]¸èox‹Å�]Æ_¬~ZëF+â~

�XZDwÆèoÌZyÅ,Ô2ZyÆZ°gZzg�á²~Ń~ã~ U"ƒDZÌgn�X

ùÔZZDÅ54èGGEÅfZC�wVZzg»zØV»³�Xt �¼ ZDwÆ è kKƒÔZDwÅzÃ]ƈz²Vz²VÐ�áùƒñZzgªCÙìQyÅÃUãZzgZYi]

Æ£« ZkaZ¹ZDwÅ!‡°{LL£?óóŒÛZg7�cYYXÄ~£? Æ%;~QyÅw¾qwUâ~ìÔ@ëZD1]~ZyÅw!hÐ*î OìX

Ã^ÐуgWñZzgÍg»Òуg~!Z}Å)® � 5981Y~ZDw(w~�Z4ƒñXQyÆazZ−+Ð]Zƒ™ÔyÐ�zgLL6�öóó~g�»tªñµ

s :Ü åX&À.5ÿG

GL½ÆÌуg~}gìX5091Y~Zd½Æa-g\‰ÔÂM6 zÑeÐzZ3 yzZßVÐ�zg~(|ÔÉ�z„Zx[ÐÌ]Zƒ‰X

:m42 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^412

Page 212: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

уg~}ƒ‰Xz5]Æ‚B‚BQyÅà]~ÌZŸ†ƒ@ŠXZDwÆÃâr¢zg~åZzg�zu~§sZL�z2VZzg { aZq§sÂZLzZ−+ZzgZ•çEO

¸»2Ô�ÛZø X $åOZjVÆZ§gZ]»�Z[rÔ�z4»»ŸåZzgZܹ�ÛnÌZzg6gcVZDwÅèoóg~»:©�X

ZDwÔã�~îg6�á²Z:Tgn¸XZyÆ;VÚ~Zzg+?çGOuÆO}™I

Zzg§�¸åÔZzgz{0È-VZzgŸ�VÐ<ÍZD¸X–wÝxgÎw$:LL´)%jx{−nß°��: C1 ÅËÔZ’Z„Ðgz„ZzgZìuzZ¢Ztŧsâb¶óóX

�Z�{¸X z{¡m™II¸Xeg0ð64�gZicÇ�¤ÐfÎñÆg�Æ(}�wC2 Hg{6)ƒ@ÔÂZ¹å�kƒYCX è z‰ÜÅ0È~QyÆa¶XZ¤}z‰Ü

iâU¤d„ÐZyÅZë›T¶XÍg»Òуgƃ9~Qy»#{ÄzZ�[»Z(%œåÔ˜V•[V'0g�XZyÆë�gk÷Ýx�.8ÆZÖp~:LLZDwÅË~ZÏz‰ÜÐZqÍ:¢Œ43ï GEGOG¶Zzgz{LLÚZiY&

»g~5i#ÖФmÌÔWiZ�{gz~ÆZÏgDy»ZqUåX u C3 745å EEEóó»]Zt¸XZDwÆŒÛRg=u†ZØ�g»Òyì�ªÄßyÆiâä~ZDwZqÂÁWö¸

»z°{™D¸ZzgQë¸:�ÃyYñXZk äY �zu}:»IXLLz{F�iË(ÃÔëZ¹çÐ è z‰ÜÂÀ}Üc!CÙYäÃY7eLXóóQyÆ™IÆ7

C4 LLÚZiY&745å EEEóóŹz]‹c™D¸X™IÔ§�Zzg"‡°ÏÔZ¤Zë›T»zƒÔÂèoóg~~Ú~ÔVZzg

!‡°Ïŵ…ìXp�N!]ì�´)ZDwÔ¬xi0Ï~™Zóg~Æ'@Ô[óg~~¹ÚZzg!‡°{¸XeZË·†Zv,ð��:

ZDw»�2gtå�Z�OeZHâ�}™Y@åZzgQ�Oz{ZL}#ÖÇgZjÃgU¯�Zy:ÿZÍwþÔ7ÂÔm22 ]Îf^Ù�…æáôì^Þä 1D

Ôm32 Zs 2DÔZÆ'7591Y:m5 ]Îf^Ù C 3D

89 :m Þ„…ô]Îf^Ù 4D

512kKÆù´

Page 213: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zzg»½Z]»e&éEOÑäÅ@Ze�ÛâD¸XQ¯gU�Z[�¸ZzgQÏz‰ÜZjÆC1 jZá�ÛâD¸�{…~eZwWñX

¸zzì�ZDwÆèV~Zk§bÆ¿{]X�:LLZÌZq�¬W\»âàóóXLLW\»âZil*)ZÌZÌñßwƒZóóX

Your letter which I received a moment ago. Your letter which reached me a moment ago.

kKÆfí}6ó{eZ%ÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�PZq×èoÃgh™ÔZDwäCÙ�Z[~ZkãZ"gлx1ìXâÆ�Z[~VÔÚ~ZzgZ"g

Æ�gxy�Zg*ñ��ìXZke~ëä�å:ZDwů[óg~~L!‡°ÏóZqi'�„Zˆkf)�Zg~»³ƒäÆ!z��ÔZyÅ

™Zóg~Zzg"*i~ÆgDyÅ�4Z0Zi~Ð7$mXkK»Z"gZÏ�4Z0Zi~»³ìXZq§sZ�ZëJL�ÛnÔ�Z[»»Ÿ™CìZzg�zu~§sgDÈTÆ;ðV6g��ZkØZzg0È~Т�]AÔOçkKÆÎZkgZk�

Å¡™s�@Y$ËìXLâ6@gõÉ�~ÔLÈw‰ÔìwWŠÂWy~É�~Ôzg:š@gõ„âgzZ:™�c;L@gõZzg¶É�cZzg“0Zg�;Lâ»™äÅ¢~

ZˆZzgLLic�{ ~ZÖpg^‰;Zˆµ�ÛnÆ‚BârÑzqHÔ1¢„ËH²n™zVóón»L{ə⻙�cXtL{ZDwäZLèVÆWy~Ò]

C2 Ð�CÙZcìXâТÖgZ0äÆgDyÃZDwÅg~îg6ÌCk™D¸XeZËÝx@fzZ3gÆ4�qZDwÆèoÔZyÆÄ~Z°gűԄ~:

C3 ©ZzgZg»ZzgÎZ¤ÒpÐZë�XZDwÆfíÒkK»"3�ç EEELr_·™,ÂZD1]~ZyÅZÃ�eZzgÌzZãƒYCìX

:m074 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 1D:m74@94 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 2DÔ¢ZÍwÔÑg{1D2:m92 Úr×äÿivÏnÐ 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^612

Page 214: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

èo~Zq‡g~p�ÃZDwƹŒÛdCk™@ìXZDw�LzæÔ�gz7z¤®Ô"zZÎg»(ÃWD�Ô�zu~§sz{ŒÛWyÔugZzg}6�~ÃÆ‚B�*z~Ex»ÌzW_·gn�XZ¹½FzVÐÌgÉìZzgèo~"

z{øpz('×Z`�Zzg C1 ØZx[ÐZkñçq6Á™n�Èî0ìw™D�XC2 èV~ZyÅ8øL'×ZbúcVìX

ZDwäZq(�ì:LL�á²Æßk~Zzg6ZÇfèoÐZkƯx6gzÝy»twÔËZzgÐic�{Ôp�QyÆkK6™�tW@ìX'×h'WVÔ Q C3X 7Cìóó

øXèo è èoÐZDwƉQydµ1V»è¸ìÔ�w~QyÆ7C4 Åæ�ÐÁZiÁ�k!g{Z+Â1VŶy�„ÅY$ËìÔ�ZDwreT¸X

ZDw»ZqUtÌì�: è kK‰âWñi�á²(~Ò]ÐZKÄ~»z/Z&bÅ{§QyÅ}#Ö~5™D¸XZ&—ÄŹÏVBZyÆèV~Q�XLz{ZÖpÅï~

áňl~u¤�ZVXQë)oVÐdÔZ�! Ã�áVÃWD�ZzgLËjZZDwÔZyÆŧïzWZzg è ZzgÄ~)b6n�Èî0ìwƒ@gLå'OçkK

_·»Ì è D�ÔÉZkÐQyÆ#-?ç GEOdZzgzÝ Ä~zZ�!$©�î EG0ÃÅzŸs™C5 è¸ìX

¯'�Z¸„�'z{�áhZq%ûâÉ™ –w2k*i~:ZDwLLZÌâ�ÔÅ a‰Zz‡]ÃðwscÂg^Y@åXèo~Zk§b Zk C6 7_Ì7óóÔ

~X ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ ic�{F 1D~ZkÅ{]VBQ�X ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 2D

:m11 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 3DÔZDw�2:m741@561 ÞÏç� 4D

:m06 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 5DÔmLLióóX ÚÓjçe^l]Îf^Ù 2k*i~: 6D

712kKÆù´

Page 215: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

pVVBïYC�Xfs~ZDwÆèVÐP¿ÜKYgì�X¸¯~�b‰ZÖpÔZDwÅZk’k~ñ��7Ôª¢~~g^‰¸:

:m37 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù LLZ(g™äÿÃþƒVóóX:m981 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù LLZyßÍVÿÅþ�gpZZ'óóÔ�zx:m173 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä LL_!]aZ™*eTÿ�þóó

‰Zz‡]¢~~ZÖpßÌ�YDÔ}:�ZÚiZ£Æ*x3âgaâЪCÙì�tâуg è LL{s;îkуgóó�g`ìÔqÑèQ ~ 1C 0291YÆâ

Ð7Ô��Ð�ìXZDwÆZôm~èoÆ@�ÚÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�ZigÓZ"gÔ‰ZÖpÃ

&B©ýEEO¯™��Ô}:

jZ! ZDw»Z5 ZÝÂm581 Letters of Iqbal Asstt Sec. Assistant Secretary

Zsm581 red. received

Zsm581 Aug. August

Zsm891 T.B. Text Book

Oriental College Magazine

ZDw�7791YÔm692Shd. Should

Zsm992 Coll. College

�gìÔ1ˆ Md.cMohd. ÑzqÑzq~Âz{ZL*x»ªbzÌ¿™Æ(Å´#Ö å� ZϧbQg�z~·ÆQz6) �X Mohammad ~ZÐFu™Æ!ÑoZx

Æ*xÆ‚B¯ãecÔ1tZoZxÔ å (ÜsgÎÁ0u å� ̯DXQßiÂt´#Ö)W\åÐZDwŸe�gzZzgZ�ZxêCÙ™@ìXZϧbâÆW¸icZ�x

XIqbal in Pictures èÃg{âÆ@Æa5±Ù: 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^812

Page 216: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

6@gõ�»ÌZÈx™DXZ,èo¹ÁƒVÐÔX6@gõ�g`:ňƒXQg�zZzgZôm~�zâVi!âV~W\»â¹¢åÔ@ë!~Æ‚B�Æ:}}ZÖp7"~�‰ÜƒCìX

è¹ZDwÅic�{F®Z�Qg�zZzgZôm~~ìÔ@ëPèoÃgÏZzgðZzgði!y~,{âiâä 2C Ô²!i!y~Zq 1C XÃgÏ~�z X� i!âV~Ì

72â�áùK� Å�S�Ðôpg{‰�XGZº�gZãäézw*†Æ*xð~�YäzZáT×â»f™Ô ði!y~�X {, Zy~Ь

C3 èV~�áïìX 27 eZËGZº�gZãäHìÔz{Z-ZDwÆZ’Zð�zgÆèoôp7XŠ*F+�ø[âñÑ*ZŒâgCÙz~Æ

y~â91BZ6s W C4 �Ûzg~9981YÃ�ŠX B *xìÔ�Íg»Òуgƃ9Ð82Æ*x�ŠXWy~'ÎV~ršý ELwg]Æ:“ C5 8391Y»ì�NyŒ{V

X p��Z[�Ї܃‰ÔÂZ5™ZÆ�\™�ïÔ‰èoš�\„{Z�ïè¹ZDwÆ»�~Ò¤CÙZ−+ÔxV·ÃÔeZË·†Zv,ðÔ±2k*i~Ô

�áï�X�iŒ��: C6 ezgkZ£ZzgYzhZDw H)Iqbal was a most scrupulous correspondent and I know of nobodywhoever wrote him a letter without getting a reply 7C .

eZË·†Zv,ð»Òyì:

:m092D192 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 1Dm582 : ì_ç½]Îf^Ù 2D

m881 : ÔT�zx ]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6 3DÔZÍw:m3D4 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 4D

Ôm533 Zs 5D:m021 Ú×Ëç¾^l 6D

XLetters �âp: 7D

912kKÆù´

Page 217: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âÅZܹqªZzgâÆ*yÅZÌÆ´z{ÔfZCqÑ]Ã è ¬xîg6ßv»A$åLOÃgÄ™�Z[�¶c:�¶»ê™D�X‰Zz‡]°*ZÁ:ZzgKãúZgn

�g{m�Z[�~âúƒD�Ô1|]´)äÔ!z��KãúZgnÔd_¬C1 ~Z¢ZtZzg°*ZÁ:ÆÔL�Z[�Фm7�ÛâcX

ZqZzg(��:C2 ÷}ìw~W`JËÃtDe7ƒð�ZDwŧsÐz{�ZƒâÐøzxg;X

ZyÒ*]Ðt³Z~™*ß:ƒÇ�ZDwäZKi0Ï~DÙZgzVâ�ƒVZDwÅ ÐÔ1Zy~Ðôpz�ø[èVÅ®Z�½ãGg{ÎkìXGè¹ôpzñ�� eìÔ¹ÐèoÔZ[Ì}:} Ð C3ìX 5!îE�®Z�Ÿùƒ

¬x6WäÅÃðßg]aZƒYñX è ƒVZzgz‰Ü¦gäÆ‚BZyÆ©´)ZDwÅzÃ]ƈP'ÎVÆZ0g„ZyÆkKƦzFKZzgZy

ZDwÆZùúV»Zq è {,]~ëkK Ò ÅZ�á®»»xÑzqƒŠåXWY{7™,ÐX

ðýýðýýð

:m174 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 1DZDw�Ô2591Y:m24 Ô Þçm‚ô‘fx 2D

Ôèo�ÔZÍw:m954 ÞÏç� 5±Ù:)Z³( 3DÔZÍw:mLLnóó ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä )[(

Zi¾H:m5 Iqbal )`(™ZcÔ7#2891Y qß- )�(

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^022

Page 218: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

KÆxù´ k ([)

�á�ZDw /

ÆÓxFèo'gZY¨6�á��á�Æ*x�‰XZkÆ%AÔeZË �^�]Îf^ÙZ−+‡�g~izgù´Æló~��:LLZkù´~�èo�áùK �[

��á C1 Ygì�Ôz{'gZYÅzÃ]Ð�z&‚wI„�Z�á®ñßwƒñóóXtèoÔZ¤�z‚wIÌeZËizgÆ4�K‰ƒVÔÂÌZy C2 »ZÙw9391Y~ƒZX

ÅFKzDz+ZzgZ�á®»ezw7391Y~ÔªZDwÅzÃ]оqwFâ{¬ÔeZÑŠƒÇÔ@ëù´Å»g~ZzgS®Æ%Zi~F‚w¦g‰Zzgù·2491Y~

C3 ¬x6WcX è© ¾™Ô´)ZDwÆÄ~ùúVÆÀòZzg%zÆ6�áù �^�]Îf^Ù tZ%p&ì�

ňXeZËizgäM,]Æ×�âd~�á�ZzgZDwÅ5‡ÂVZzg©]6gzÝeZàìXQ�zâVÅ£zkZzg�zâVÆZqZq¯[»@�cŠìXƒZDw

Ôm351D451(XùÂ]”V~„ �^�]Îf^Ù »@*åìX)�&ÀŸ/õ GGZÝâ:HŠìXèoÅÀ®Z�ZqÎZqìXZy~Ð94èoZDwÆZzg25èoÔ�á�Æ�XÓxèoÃ@gõzZgFK�cŠìXªâZDw»ìÔZkÆ�Z[~�zuZâ�á�»Ô�ZZDw»Zzgaå�á�»ÔWyJ¸ßg]ìXZkÐÂ[ÅB#Ö(|ìÔ@ë�á�Æ�Z!èVм�=ôÔZñgzZãƒYD�X

:m63 �^�]Îf^Ù 1D:m14 Ú`^…]q^‰†Ò�െ�^��^�(un^l]æ…]�eoì‚Ú^l 2D

Ác[ìXgZ¶ÆDÅuJуgÆËêÃ{ä~Zk»ñ�� �^�]Îf^Ù 3D7X¯',ëZkù´»×׬gs™Zgì�XÂÒCÃZÔ<~�áï�X

122kKÆù´

Page 219: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

%Aäló~Cc�èoÅLLFKZzgÜÆe~'™ñZ�{÷·ZZ*Z} {VoÔ™ñZ�{÷ZÑsZ{V™r!Z}�ZgZzggæŒÛ7™r

ÈèoÃNg�ÚÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�ZÝèoÃ7"Zzg á C1 Ð{mîg6æ�BóóXÃ�g»g¶ÔZk è �‰Ü QZ¹Zôoz¡Æ‚BÜ™äÆaT¸e�gZÅ

~¼¶g„XgZ¶Ã»[ÀpZzÅz‚¦Ð‰èoÅaÝw�ø[ƒNÔZyÅ

gzÝ~Z0Zi{ƒ@ì�QpZã~{à™Zóg~лx1ŠÔ}:)9( ZÝâ )ß( �^�]Îf^Ù S �

z;V6¢zg] z;V¢zg] 6 66Y ZY 9 66a=©gW!� a©gW!� 51 66¹²áÐ ¹gziÐ 21 96‰�ÔZq ‰Ô~äZq 51 48HZzg HåZzg 61 487|™ Í™ 4 58

tÜs&èVÅZÝo�XZ¤7g}94èocZyÅaÝw�ø[ƒYNÔÂê7�ZÝoÅ®Z�pVJãX

ƉèoÅ@gu97Zzg‰ZÖp»Z5zZãîg6ß �^�]Îf^Ù '×h'WVìXeì�Zy~м™VÔ»AÐui�ƒðƒVX¾qwfs~‰ZÝoŶy�„ÅYCì:

9 ß S �v ÉÓÏî Š 2 79ZhÁ Z&¾æGEÁ 6 111Z:v Z:ÉÓÏî Š 41 111

:m63 �^�]Îf^Ù 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^222

Page 220: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �2291Y 3291Y 2 511zZÑÓx zZÓx 3 551æÖFÓôàû æŸÒà 7 36192�c 9ec 11 361

ï ]ôÞ$Ûø^]øÚûçø]ÖöÓöÜûæø]øæûŸø�öÒöÜ ]ôÞÓöÜ]øÚçø]ÖÓöÜæø]ø�Ÿø�øÒöÜ 71 071[Z<ZCx Z<ZCx 6 171v ÉÓÏî Š 6 171

‰èo6@guß�g`ň�Ô}:â�1Å9@gõJZÆ'ìÔ:�âÞ)�&ÀŸ/õ GGÔâ�2:LLW\»âñgQJZÆ'=5óóX(Zϧbâ�5Å9@gõ

�cXLLÀ�²9�åóóX(â�67 B �cX)�&ÀŸ/õ GG:â�7Ôøg{:6 B 5B�cìÔ:�4�cì:� B 6ÜsLL�cóó�ìÔt2291Y»’k™�{ìXâ�69Å9@gõ92

�c)�&ÀŸ/õ GGâ�59Ôøg{:22B�cÔTÆ�Z[~tâ�69�Š(X B9�^� óó¯D¸Ô å ZDwZL*xÆbz)·(6ZigZÓZ�[zZ�Zxå´#ÖLL7 ~tZoZx7'@ŠXZϧb�cÃec),]96Ô111Ô721Ô371(Z~ÃZ ]Îf^Ù

),]95Ô16Ô36(ZÆ'ÃZÍ')m711(�ŠìÔ²ZDwå�cÔZ~ZzgZÆ'�™D¸XÜâöcplâöÅ"µZkÐÌzZãì�Â[~P™{

ÔZÆ'ZzgZÍ'X 7 !ÑÐVZÖpÆ�z�zZ5ñ���Ôª�cZzgecÔZ~ZzgZZDwÆkKÔZL_ÆZ±gÐ!kxzZãƒD�Ô1�á�Æ*x

ZDwÆZyèo~F£â]{áLL%æFNZuZgóó¥xƒD�Ô}:C1X 'LLScu�ÂÃa™‰XZ[²lÆŒÛdƒVÐÔcz;VJV‰ƒVÐóóC2 %Z�ÆÇóóX èø 'LL8¯y»�Yg~ìZzgFZ§Zs~}Zÿäþe;Âî

!ÂV»ÃðzZã|xZ~™*øg}aÂìX +Z !bgZi�Zg~Å

:m65 �^�]Îf^Ù 1DZs:m931 2D

322kKÆù´

Page 221: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

‰£â]6¼ZÖpc„gZ]vs™�~ˆ�X),]:91Ô23Ô211Ô321Ô521Ô621Ô631(%Aät7Cc�÷zsZÖpz„gZ]g�g`7K‰ÔcZ¹7J

7YeXZ¤p�á�Æ�Z!èoÐFZñgzZãƒYD�ÔZkÆ!z��Q6jZÙÅ¢zg]¶Xù´Æ%AeZËizgÆaÂ#jZÙ�g`™*TŠgW‚yåÔW`04'kQÏŠgƒŠìX

ÆT�zxÅâ"7WmX �^�]Îf^Ù

eZË[Z−+‡�g~izgÃZDw)Zzg�á�(Æ�kK½K‰¸Ôz{èoÅ��: C1Ô ZÝ®Z�»¡Zqz¸Ô1'×hˆlÆ!z��Z¹Ãð*â:ïe

ZÍ'2291YÆ�gxãiâäªeJð‚wÐic�{ B ec9191YZzg11 B LLZ\kì�91l¬ÐP™{æ]Æ4èoZzg3191YZzg6191YÆ p C2 æ]Æèo�ÛZë:ƒnóóX

Æ64èoP‚wI�ø[ƒ‰XZDwZ»�ò0ÎyäZÝèo ²á �gxãZzg·†ZvŒÛ7äZy�kèoÃZq×lóZzg C3 yh™ZL;Vôp™a

ÆZDw�ÔZÍwÔZÆ'3791Y~�áù ‘vnËä jZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]Æ‚B%A™Æ

™Z�cXZ¹5™�á�Æ*xZDwÆèoÅ®Z�94+05=99kìXt�kèoÔ~Zq*yÆîg6�áùƒñ�ZzgZ¹ZqÂ[cù·7¹ ‘vnËä Z¤p

Ðñç¦o9 �^�]Îf^Ù (ìZzg extention ÅZqËÂW) �^�]Îf^Ù YYÔ@ëtÆ:ÔZy»_·z‹tZÏ(oƒ¥xƒ@ìX

ZyèoÅÜâ+~Ì»ï�gzZôo7ƒmÔ}:8âga6191YÆâÆÔZDw�ÔZÆ'3791Y: ‘vnËä ™ZcÔ32Z6s2791Y(ZzgQ) qß- @),·

m361D461(»ñZi:™,ÔÂZq„â~ÔQÅ�z™VQ�:

:m73 �^�]Îf^Ù 1DZs:m511 2D

ÔZDw�ÔZÆ'3791Y:m99 ‘vnËä 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^422

Page 222: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

®w�g] ZÝ�g] SÌìZzgz{t ÌìÔz{t 9u»gÆ u‚ÑgÆ 11

óÅ ó å ó6eZËizgŧbÔŒÛ7™räÌLL ó å QZDwÆ*xÆbzLL·´#Ö7¯ðX

Zyèo~ÌFãZzg6ZuZg£â]ñ���Ô}:'LL‚Ng[ÃW\»�xà�cåÔÑ$©3‹ð GGEZ�ÛâD¸X)m131('LLZvZºZkz‰Ü=pgn�ZzgíÐ÷}ZqÄ»|x�gcÄ™gì�óóX)m171('LLZ¤p8¯yyZ[ìZzgQ�O�áÈ"*i~ìÔ@ë�Z[ŵìóóX)m681(

ZDwƼ��®áÝlÃ$›Ò3¨é GGG]Ðgz×HìÔ1 è ·†ZvŒÛ7äkK

P™{!ÑnÆã£â]Å=ôzz{Ì7™nX�N!]tì� X �á�Æ*xZDwÆZy99èo»iâ:Ô¾{'ÎV6�ì

"$¹Ò¨é GE:%ZÌÆ!z��ZDwä�á�ÃåZq„Ä)u»gzZÑcu»gzZÑng(ÐZºZ[W!�~ zg Z 1C æ[HX´)ZDwä¤ZòÆ*x09èoÔ±Ñy0z~Æ*x17

Æ*x61èo�1ZØ[zW�Z[ÅZ+7+Zzg}7QXtÔkK¯x�á�{mìX ZqЯ »

ZDw¯x�á� /

Æ*xÐÂ!ßg]~æÍy™�c ]Îf^Ùeß^Ý�^� ·†ZvŒÛ7äèÃg{99èVÃ13X - m82 : Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h ìX))xZDwуgÔ�y6891Y(Zk6-û{�&ÀŸ/õ GG:6891Y

ZÍw ZDw*)Ô /

ZDwÅ�ÛZb´)ZDwÆZÙwƽãZq'kˆ è �«YZväkKZ6s3591Y Ê^…]á ZÍw~�áï�X'×hZqâ)øg{:91B#7391Y( ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ,èo 1D

~�áùƒZXtâ@qwËxù”î0kK~�áï7ìX

522kKÆù´

Page 223: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

„ÐÑzq™�~¶Ô@ëFKzDz+Ð0i»x»W¸i�Ûzg~3491Y~ƒZXÅœÆÔù”î0kK»gƒŠXZk6“Z�á®�g`7XZkÅ@G 1C el|'k

ÔZÍw»ZqìÔ�÷zàZvZPW!�~ÃÔZyÆ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ?zg-ãzg;Ñ$k~~�z„�Z£ä7HåXZk6�Z£Æ�+VÆ‚B4B�c4491YÅ@gõ�g`

kZ±gÐDì�tù·4491YÆWy~�áùƒZXaZ£eZgä“Z�á® Z C2ìXÔZÍw ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä «YZvä'ÎV¡c��Z“ů6É�c� � C3X 4491Y„�ì

ªCÙì�t�g„7X C4 5491Y~ÖåÔ´)ZDwÐ%AÅo]q~Zkù´ÅDz+»ã�~øuµX�Zv��:LLZ¤pZDwÆkKÅ�ÛZbzZ�á®Ð°�ZquJZy�ZCÙ � «Y

ÅZ�á®Ð÷ZƒÐZëÑ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 0gzVÃ�S›iâ:Ðôp™¢ìÔp§]ógÆa‰)bZzgp�ZDwÅi0Ï6ZDwÅ’k~Þ�'½ g{ ZDwÆW

™*ìóóXOço]q~Æ‚BÅYäzZàZk»zlÆË~k"3ïGGELZDw»ZqZ(ù·�ÛZ냊Ô�®Z›kKÆZ±gÐW`ÌZDw»ƒÐ(Zù”î0

Zy~ C6 èoìX%AÆÑg�Æ_.À®Z�762ìÔ1ZÝ®Z�642ìXÆ@Ì�áï�X V ÆQg�zFZW�X�kQg�zè V ¼�kKÔZôm~è

X� zg Z ,]`Ôb : ÔZÍw ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �âpÔ 1D�&ÀŸ/õ GGX ™134 tZ:q6zW™'³gz~Ž™�{ìXèÃg{°Æuzgt»@ 2D

XLetters of Iqbal �âp: D3m8 : Ô�zx ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 4DÔZÍw:mLLbóó ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �âp: 5D

ZÝ®Z�ÔÀ®Z�ÐqgzfsâÎÆèou™Æïàˆì: 6DZ,Zôm~èoÆQg�zFZWÔX»ZÝQËZôm~ù”î0kK~�áïì)aèQg�z )Z³(FÀZÝZôm~QÆ£«~¾qwUâ~wg‚ìÔZka�VZ,Qg�zFZWÃ

2ÌÐ{g`™�cŠìXZ%z{Qg�zFZWÑg~�áï�ÔXÆZôm~áyËù´~7X(XZ,Qg�zèo��V*åßg]~�Ô1ËZzgù”î0èo~Zy»9ZzgåQ�áïìX )[(

Ñg�502)m043(ÃÌ2Ì~�áï7HŠÔYV�tZqÄìX )`(

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^622

Page 224: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�«YZvätzŸs7Å�!ÓxZÝèoÔQ,Vä&Z‹p�5±KZzgQZyÅÝw»gXc™ZN?cZZô[äèoÅ�Ýw½XÔZ¹š¤&„�V»ÂVJw™Æù´~�áï™1Š?%AÃTŠgZÝèo�ÛZëƒnÔ¥x7ÔZ¹ôp™1Šc7?tÎZÑ]ZkaaZƒD��áÈkK

kK~ è ìX¸�%AÃZ0Zi{:å�Dz+ WC à ~ZZ‡qZÝoÅ{à®Z�QÅHZÌìÔZkaÜâ+~©à¶�ÃY�ŠÔ�: è¡

~tZÈx ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ¯D¸Ô óó å� ZDwZL*xÆbzLL·óó6å´#ÖLL )Z³(7HŠX�\ЬÔâÆ{86ñ��ÂLLzZ?xóóÜâöä¬xîg6vs™�cìX )[(ZDwä˜VÔ}:23Yc12Y�ìÔÜâöä2391Yc1291Y¯�cìZzgt )`(

p~{]ňìX�zuzVŽ™�{ÝwÐsÃÌ™BÔÂZ,èo~ZݹQÅÃðÂä

~�áï�Ô}:eZË„kZ{V�Æ*xâ�7 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 7ƒ$ËÔXÆ@)m172(Æ@ZzgZkÐÜ™�{Q6»©ÃeZBÔÂÜâ+~"Zôï»Z0Zi{ƒnÇ:

»Q ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ZÝâ»Q S2391Y 23Y 1

j � 4

Qyì� Qy� 5

< zZ?x 6

4·ZDw Dw Zå· 7~˜!¼�kKÆ�@�ø[ƒñ�ÔQyÅgzÝ~ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �

~QÅpVZÝoñ���X™414:S6Ô7ÅZk„g]:LL÷~WçQÏ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä

722kKÆù´

Page 225: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

C1 z‰ÜÁˆZzgZk²n�Z“ÆPÄ�R[îsƒìÔ÷~i!y6Yg~ƒóóXЙsªCÙì�ÜâöÅtÐLLPÄóóÆÔ¼„g]g^ˆìXeZË·�+@|äikcù´Æ‰ÓVÿX~:LLZ.�{qÝ™*óó®wìþ

Zg�cìXøg~gZ}~LLZ.�{qÝ™*óó ŒÛ 2C Åã�6�Æ9èoÃLLzsóó»AÅßóg~»™ÖƒYìÔZka¡Zkã�6�Æ*xèoÃPczsŒÛZg

!,!ëeZË@|ÅZkgZ}Ð7g~§b5��: C3 �}™g�7HYYXkK~†ZßZug»Òyì�� Z C4 Zvä¶Ð»x71óóX � LL¸³�«Y

C5 Z�á®~vs™�cYñÇóóÔ {Ò «YZvtê™`��Zy~ÐZÒèoÃWg™räZkLLŸóó»ÃðjZ!7�cX¸�Ug&�™räZÏš� 1

ÿŠþÐZqÆÎZ�Æ*xƒèovs™�bX ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä LLêóóÆ:

µ‹2äe^m‚ Z�ág{ìZk²n�Z“ŧs�LL�g—gg‚ª–[åóóÆÄZyÐ�~ 1D')m84(~�áïìXZkzZî»f™gZk&�Æ*x92B�y6391YÆâ~ Ò†�

:m362(X ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù ÌMìX):m711 ]Îf^ÙÒ^ÊÓ†æÊà 2D

†ZßZug»tÒyI¾Wöì�:LLeZË@|¬îg6U"™`��ZÒz{èoÔX 3D:m481( ÞÏ�ô]Îf^Ù Æ0¹Y@ì�z{ZDwäeZËßâÿ�þÃ�ÔP�óóX)

eZË@|ÆZkZ‹ZnÅã�¡t•Zì:LLZ.�{qÝ™*óóZzg6�ëäQz6²nHÔ7gZZÈwñ��ì�tt*�c»AŃX‰rZIäÌZkLLtóó»Zg‚[H

ìÔ}:LL-g\Ɖ*xËgÄZæ¹�á²zVƯxÐZ[JZ.�{qÝ™DDwä Z DD �IguZуgÔ3091YÔm382( ( m^�+^…Æ^Ög : �Xóó)Z®s@qà

: ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ºÔÛÔfZzgæ'+ÐZ.�{qÝHXóó)·�+¯t: LLZàyÆ�vD m641(D Ô Î†�á]æ…]Îf^Ù LL!mîg6�¼Z.�{ZyÃq݃ZXóó)Z1·�: D m28(D

mLL�óó(X Ô Ô�Ye��Ô3591Y ÞÏ‚]Îf^Ù LLZ.�{qÝ™ä»ñµ5Xóó)oZºW!�~:ÔZ³F¹Qg�zyÔ ÖÇ^lô…æ‡Ú†å ÒZ°ÝÃgz¹ÌLLZ.�{qÝ™*óóÃß7BX)

��Ô3002YÔm63D83(®Z@|ÆZkd-?õ IEXÃLL¬o]óó7ŒÛZg�cYYX:m711 ]Îf^ÙÒ^ÊÓ†æÊà 4D

:m481 ÞÏ�ô]Îf^Ù 5D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^822

Page 226: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

1C ƒZìXZºgZ„ "ZôﻜzgèVÅ@guZzgâ{z‚wÜ™ä~Ì’kÅoÅìXZkÆ!z�� è ä¾{èoÅÂZgõ 2C äZqÔZzgeZËÝx@fzZ3g

Z[̼�kKÅ@guß�Ô}:�Ñð2291Y�g„7XZÏâƬ B ¯[�62¯xÑy0z~Å@gõ5 O

ÔZÍw:m911þЪCÙ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ~�ìóóX ÚÃ^…Í 6�âW\ä µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ¿:ÿLL)�y3291Y( ÚÃ^…Í ÅZ�á®)#3291YÔ�&ÀŸ/õ GG:m051(Zzg µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ì�tâ

�Ñð3291YìX B ~Zk6â^àÆ�ŠÔZkaâÅ9@gõÜq5ZÆ'3391Y B ZÆ'3391YZzg91 B ¯[�15Zzg25¯xÑy0z~Å@gu51 O

zg41BZÆ'Ã�‰XQZy Z �g„7ÔYèÖˆegèo�35@65ZZnK11Ô31ZÆ'3391Y�X B ÆQÐÌzZãì�9@gu5Zzg9

ZÆ'3391Y�g„7ÔYè[� B ¯[�75¯xÑy0z~Å@gõ8 O65Ô41BZÆ'Ã�ŠX'×h'WVZkâÆZ’Zð{:ÿLLW\»@gÀ5ÔTÐ¥x

ÔZÍw:m671þЪCÙì�9 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ZÆ'JW\Ã07g7ïeóóX B ƒZ�71pœÔ»A»ƒc*�»Ô Ô ZÆ'3391YìX¸�tZÝoÔ\Að XLÂ"»³� B @gõ81

%AÃ'~Z¯)ŒÛZg7�cYYX%Aä9Zôm~èoÆQg�zF§VÆ‚BÂLLZôm~óóÉ�cìÔQÌ

F(tzŸs7ƒmÔ}:¯[¯xÆ·G{V)m642(c¯[¯xugZk&�)m153(X‰Zôm~èoÆQg�zFZW*³�Ô}ZkZôm~¿:

I hope you won't mind replying to this letter by the return of post .3C

ó�g„7ìXZÏâ~Zôm~ ó 4C »Qg�zFÀ:LL�Z[zZ3eZuÐ�Ø»Qg�zFÀu}Ð�c„7ŠXugZk&�Æ*xZôm~ yours ever ZÖp:

:m131 ]Îf^Ù(‰nù‚‰×nÛ^áÞ‚æpÒoÞ¿†Ún6 1Dm04@54 Ô ¢ZÍwÔÑg{{m:1Ô2 Ô Úr×äÿivÏnÐ 2D

:m69 Letters of Iqbal 3DÔZÍw:m153 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 4D

922kKÆù´

Page 227: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÆQg�zF§V~ZkÆ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1 C1 �Ô yours ever èVÆWy~ZDw��wZÖp}7�‰X

@824(X %Aäèo�452@652»¯[ZD‚]g×ãÃŒÛZg�cì)m524Ôуg�Ñð2691Y~�áù™Zñ ]Îf^Ù…mçmç F'kˆZºZ{V²ÙiZ�{ätèo

��Æ{m�5391Y)m73D83(ÆjZáÐCc�tèoz©Z£Ô Þn†Þ,Šj^á Zzg~ZkZ%Å 2C Ã�‰Xˆ~z©Z£ä·†ZvŒÛ7Æ*xZqâ ÞÏng æk

¤&™�~Xâ�32)m85D95(Ư[ZD¼gZ−+{g7Ô·�+¯t�XZÝâZDwñi*уg~ôpìX

‰£â]6QÅZÝ„g]vs™ÆZk(yÎ�b‰Ô}:,]013Ô063XQÅ„gZ]Ãvs™*QßißìÔ@ëZ¤Ë6g~cÅů6t*¦kåÔÂqd/õ IG~ZkÅzŸs¢zg~¶ÔZq£x6ÂyÎä»ØÌ7

�y7391YƯ[¯xgZk&�)m783(м„g]vs™�~ˆ B HŠX01ZzgyÌ7Îñ‰X

â»9Q ZÍw Ô ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä�ZÚiZ£÷Z(Z�ìX.e™ÔW�ò

ìX ìÔ1Z\k��´�ZÅ¥zЇ�cã�ZÚiZ£÷Z�ìÔ.e™ÔW�òìÔpz{p�¹Èw�Zgì'

?Ã¥xì�‡�cEVÆo}Æ_.Óx�y»�Û�XZkzZWtZ%

`ì�WcZ(o{gpzZÑW�ò�yƒYìc7?ZkÆ guardian ”V»

3C ´z{z{p�¹Èw�Zgì'vsňìÔ ugZk&�Æ*x13B#5391YƯ[)m163(Ð�„g]

m69@101 :Letter of Iqbal D1:m371 ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä D2

TÎxÔ6002Y:m812 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 D3

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^032

Page 228: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZkÆñçq»Z0Zi{Î*¼Â7ÔZkЬâ)�7(~t]Mì:LL=QyìW\Zd|]Å}#Ö~ZkZÃ7™�,ÐóóX)m063(÷zs„g]zZÑâZkÆZqß�ŠXZkâ~ZDwäâZ[È0wŧsÐáµzf»

þ m06( ìX ÔT6002Y~¾Š ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 Zkâ»7gZQ ÿ f™HƒÇXZqÃ�BÂ(tzòtÐt à 1C gZk&�Æ*xZkÐâIZzgâˆèo

³Z~™*Â7�÷zs„g]»mâZ[È0wÆzfЃÇX62BZ6sÆ™* Ά�á â~ZkZ%»ZÖgHìÔ�Z¤ZkçA)ZZ}zn(~»x!ƒYñÂ

2B#Æâ~ÌLL}#Ö 3 C2 6’<å XLq¢ÆZ°gÅgzÝ~ZLâF»g™zVÇX�Ð0ZL Ά�á 1B#Æâ~÷zs„g]ÆÖˆ 3 C3ìX Z�x�¶óó»f™

5C ¸�Zk(ZDwäzZãîg6zfÅ!]ÅƒÏ C4 Z°gÈ™äÅ}#Ö»f™ìXZzg%Aägt„g]vs™�~X÷zs„g]zZÑâ4�eZu™`¸�QÏgzi

ÃZqZzgâ�ZzgZL�} T6ZDwäZÏz‰ÜgZk&� ZZ}znÅZ:qB

ZDwÔZLèo~ugZk&�ÃZ�ág})ñ~!g!gZZ}znŧsáz™D� 1DÔZÍw:m353ÔTg:1Ô2Ô41Ô51+m453ÔTg:1D2+m753ÔTg7 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä )5±Ù:

@51+m853ÔTg1@6+m953ÔTg:4D5+m063Tg:7@01X�Z6gZk&�Z¹¢�ÑD��ë�zâV)&�ZzgâZ[È0w(Ð(|™ZzgÃð'+£é

GgZípZ{7ÔZZ}zn

Æaë'Z'Ã�áV�Xóó)5±Ù:LLèogZk&�¯xZDwóóÔ%û:YŠzZðD,·:™ZcÔZ6s5791Y:m5@11( ÎçÚo‡e^áZÍw:m753 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

Wy]Ь¼:¼}#ÖZ�x�¶»ÕðìX=QyìW\Zd è ��:LL^ 3DÔZÍw:m063(X ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ZŠk~ZkZÃ7™,ÐXóó) è |]Å}#Ö

m163D263 ZsÔ 4DZkŤ&Ôikcâ»åQ‚tWYäЃìXZkâ»åQÔ6002Y~ 5D

~�áïìXâÅ9@gõ03B#7Ô31B# ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 È0wÐ�áùƒäzZáù´Ô6þ Ò{ W ÔZÍwÐøfs„g]vsŶ:ÿ� ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ìX

132kKÆù´

Page 229: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

1C _!‹N+»ZÖg™Dƒñ@ZeÅ�t²9Zd|]Ë�ØXZDwÆZÖpЙsªCÙì�ZZ}zn6]tZ�Z™gì�XZkŤ&ZDwÅZåLÃb)‚Á(:63D5391Y(~�g`”{Zk„g]ЃCì:

The assessee is getting Rs. 500/- p.m. from Bhopal State from June 1935 .2C

ZÍwÔS® ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä øg}ìw~÷zs„g]zZѸz{âìTů6¬x6:WeX¬tåâ�á$ÿLÂ[HŠåÔˆ~Â[ è© ÆÔZq²áJ

ÅS® ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ÆZyZzgZtÃïw™ÔZkâÆW¸iÅ„g]vs™ã7~XtZ%Ô�Ñð9791Y B zZ�á®Å@gõ»ZqzìXù´Æ*Ñ�·ZÑs™rä5

ÃZq5‡]~gZ¶ÃCc�:ÅZ�á®gÃZä»rtì�Zk~ZqâågZk&�Æ*xÔT~ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä

b§ ZDwä�å�ZJYzhŽå7ƒCÔZkÆaSYg~gìXtZqÅ�gpZ„¶Xa�O~·@Zkiâä~6ö'ZõÆ4·.¸ZzgÄNz°ÌXZkz‰Ü»½6NzwåÔT»Èå�*Ñ+Ågzbz{H™M�Xa�O~

ìÔZÐ�áï:HYñÔ1Â[¾_¶Ô¢,0 damaging ™rä¹tâ�XZy»Iå�ZÐÖ~Ðïw�zÔ1~ätI:HZzgÂ[gzu™gÄ

LL~äW\ÃÀâ�åZzgÀÆâÆö~tâÉg;ƒVÔYè~Zq¹Zë!]rÈwŠåX~&ƒV�W\Y…��~äp�Â�{i0ϦZg*21ìX

$!ã ÷~¢zgc]¹ic�{7�X~ÎøƒV�Zqðh~ÏS÷}a»°ƒÏXÔ6002Y:m061(X Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 ] ™Æt:Îv�=ëÆaDÙZgzVÅ¢zg]ìXóó)

gZk&�Æ*xâ�gcÄ”{â)21B#5391Y(~ÌZDwä¸!]èì:LL÷~:m451(X ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 pZéì�Zd|]p�=ZKgc„ÐSàg™�,óóX)

ZÖpt¸:LL~¾i!yÐZd|]»]tZ�Z™zVXQ,VäZ,z‰Ü~÷~ 1D�~�ÛâðÔZ�egzV§sÐ~WÑxzrT~gåX}Z¬\ZyÅ/z �„

m771( : Ô6002Y ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 �zª~'•�}Xóó)ÔZDw�ÔZÍwÔZÆ'3791Y:m34 ‘vnËä 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^232

Page 230: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

C1 �~Ô�Ûz|È™�~X»°²�ZOgHXÿQþ~äz{âÂ[~Ðïw�cX~èoÅù¦FK¹ZhìXZq£x6èoÅiâãFK ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä

)m921D131(Ô 'ŒÛZg7g„X±Ñy0z~Æ*x[�46B23ñgQ41B#2291Y2291Y B# ñgQ92 75B52 Æ™�8116¯[� ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä iâãFKÆZ±gÐ

Ь�g`ƒ*ecåX�zx ZDw*)Ô /

zZÍwÆ�âd~�«YZvä�å:LLZÌ»°ZzgZëñZ�èoÅßg]~Ô�á® Z ÷}0kñ��ìXlz[Yg~ìX=µì�'~¢Zi¢z�zxÅ

Oç48+893,]6�z�zx1591Y~�áù C2 Æ�ÛnÐ%�zlƒjVóóÿÇþXìXz C3 211 ZÝèoÅ®Z� HŠXzZÍwÆ642èoÆ£«~Ôz�zxÆ

× �zxZKFKÔZ0Z¯Â"Zzg‚z){ÆZ±gÐÔzZÍwÆ_.ìÔZ%Zk»»½ì: tÐÑZzg$zgìXzZÍwŧbZkÆuzgtÅ$iï FNIG6Ì*ÑŧsÐtZy�g

]£t죾FÀôp�Ãð™rbzUc®Õä NS¢}å GLT:™,·ZÑs

W¸i~%A»Zqîs�âp)m7@38(�áïìXZ’Zð48,]�+·~6öуg~TƒñXZkÆ,]»ÑgZiaçLâƒ@ìXÂ[»t!¹z™�2Å6.ÑíÆ_.ÃW6W6ì6öÔzí¤8уg~ÖX

¥xƒ@ìÔz�zxÆa%AÆ0k¼ic�{èo¦7ƒnÔZkaZk~¼,·èoZzg¹ÐZôm~èoÆF3Ì�áï™a‰X,·èo

]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ZkÒyÅgzÝ~eZˆZ?xpgæ»tÒy�g„7�a�O~·@ä 1DÔZDw�:m732( ‰n^…å Å‚g~¢,‹™Z�,X)

ZÍw:mLLpóóX ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2Dèo»Ñg�781JHŠìXZÝ®Z�)211(QÏÃgñáÆ�³ÅˆìÔT» 3D

2Æqí�1~ƒ[ìX 26 f™™�

332kKÆù´

Page 231: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ð;�á§ægZÏÔ±iZzg2k*i~Æ*x �^�]Îf^Ù èo 1C ~Ð'gZY�á�Æ*xÐZzg*i Þç]ñ1æÎk Z6s9491YÐ;ZjÆ*xâ B ZDw�Ô22 ]Ú†æ‡ kK

Ða‰�X·Z»bZzg¾ëÆ*xZôm~èo �Ê^Ñ Z−+{VÆ*xèoz�zx~),·Zzg6èo»{™fí{ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä QyÆxùúVÐX!,!

ù¦Ôz�zx~Ìz„{xVñ���ÔXŶy�„z è �ÛZë™�cŠìX¨ZÍw6cÆK~ÅY_ìX

*�ZzgplâöÅ"Zôïм�èoÅ@guß�g`ƒIXeZËÝxäoÅì�â�88)m332(Å9@gõ’k91B†g~5391YìÔ C2 @fzZ3g

:�91B†g~5291YXZϧbâ�46)m271(Å9@gõJZÆ'6191YìÔ:�JâÞ6191YXeZËÝx@fzZ3gäš@gõÆZqâ)�95Ôm261(»iâU’kZ6s#2291Y³HìXøgZìwì��«YZvZ¤ðh~ÏZôoZzg¶Ð»x

f¹Ï!VÐ$M¸Xfs~ëP'×hZÝoŶy�„™gì�:C3X )1(m352:â�79Å9@gõ3B†g~9191Yì:�3B†g~6291Y

)2(m752:â�101Å@gõ’k31Bâga5391Y�g`ìX$4èGELâÐ¥xƒ@ì�QyZ&éGOx~ñÑ*Zâg�á{™rZ³}ZxZ−+Æ‚Ñ:H~Ñ•Æ

* aуg=pÑñ¸XZkâ~eZË·†Zv,ð»f™ìZzgQyÆ_.Zk 4C '×h'WVñÑ*Zâg�á{92B#3391YÃ]ƒ`¸X C4 âga5291Y~ƒZåX

aZkâÅ9@gõ31âga5291YìÔ:�31âga5391YXC6 )3(m003:â�911Å9@gõ42�Ûzg~ìÔ:�22�Ûzg~X

ÐZ~K‰�ÔZ%â�91Zzg02)m802D012(Zkz‰Ü �^�]Îf^Ù �á�Æ*x81èo 1D~�áï�X �^�]Îf^Ù J),·ÔZ[t·†ZvŒÛ7Æ%ûù´

m64D84 : ¢ZÍwÔÑg{1Ô2 Ô Úr×ùäÿivÏnÐ D2Ô†g~Ô�Ûzg~5791YX Islamic Education fZ![3åXWEZ,· D3

:m621 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 D4:m14 ]Îf^ÙÒ1ÚÛ‚æ|Â×Û^ D5

:22BZ6s9491YX ]Ú†æ‡ D6

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^432

Page 232: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

C6 )4(m603:â�221Å9@gõ42BmìÔ:�22BmXìÔ:�92B#2391YX 7C )5(m803:â�321Å9@gõ92Bm2391YìÔ:�41B†g~3291Y 1C )6(m813:â�721Å9@gõ41B†g~2291YìÔ:�41BZ6s9191YX 2C )7(m023:â�821Å9@gõ41BZÆ'9191Y

C3 )8(m333:â�141Å9@gõ03BZ6sìÔ:�02BZ6sX@g:VÆ´z{QpZãZzgÜâ+~̹ϙVƒð�X,]

46Ô56Ô982Ô9136‰ZÖp77ñYnX‰£â]6¼�ZÖptÐg{‰�Ô}:m3036S2~ZqÂZzgWÐ^™7gZÄ�g`ƒäÐg{ŠX

Ô�zx~�áï‰kKÆ�@�ø[�ÔQyÅgzÝ~QÅ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä1 Q~"ZôïÆ:ui�ƒN è ôzVZ+!VŶy�„ÅY$ËìÔ�Ü

Zyƒ»ÑgÔ)©àîZª»:ƒÇXë�VÜs�z&VB7™D�:)1(¯[¯xgZáZŒ)m152D252(~âZÝoZzg&¥Ã]0ñYD�:

@â ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä SÐQZq¸Å ÐCÙZqbzÅ 1£œz){à £œÃ 2™á ™} 4h} hzV 8gz—Zss gzbZsè 8’qÆ£œ ’qZzg£œ 01ÆZbZ »bz 11

Z6s9491YX B 22 Ô ]Ú†æ‡ 6D:m38 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 7D

:m04 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 1Ô2D:m503 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 3D

532kKÆù´

Page 233: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

@â ZDw*) S< zZ?x 31·å · 51

â»@�ÚÐZ0Zi{ƒÇ�%Aä$¨ÿEG

LQ~P™{!ÑZÝoÆ´z{ÔâÅFK~&§bÆ¥Ã]™�b�XZÍw:ZÝâ~*cZ¤ZsÔ�:LLW\Å’q'óóÐÑzqƒg;ìÔQÐQz6ÅSÐ5�cìX�zx:£xZzg@gõ’k�âÆWy~�g`ÔZ¹Z’Z~É�cXÎx:13YÃ1391Y¯�cXs~Z±gÐÂeìZy¥Ã]ÅZ̼:ƒÔ1ZkÐZzgP™{!ÑZݹQÐÌÔt¢zgU"ƒ@ì

™2346�&ÀŸ/õ GG( ÃZzgZôoлx71X)â»@ è �%Aä{§pZ{�‰Ü»@�ÚÐ¥xƒ@ì�âÆ )m073D273( )2(¯[¯xñß~™Ô·

Wy~{Åt„g]!Çgh�~ˆì:LLpZz™rÅ}#Ö~÷~§sÐsx)â»bz~@™2346�&ÀŸ/õ GG( %yà�X~QyÆ{0ZyЛg‚ƒVXóó

C1 )3(¯[¯xñß~†Z/)m58(ÅZqîs„g]÷zsìXÔ ]Ú†æ‡ )4(�á§ægZÏÆ*xâ�4)m603D703(»ÔZݯ[Æ@)

22BZ6s9491Y(ÐñZi:™,ÂqgzfsZÝoÃWC�:9 ß S �

ZÚiG ZÚih 51 603,zè<ØÆ›ëÐ_mìX ,=¢ì�Zq�y 2 703=¢ì�Z3ÿXL�w�ÛâcW\ �ÛâcìW\ 4 703ZÌJ�áù ZÌ�áù 6 703

ZݹQÆ´z{ÔZkù´~‰�vâÎÅZÝoÌñ���Ô}:âЪCÙì�â è )1(‰èoƯ[ZÊ-:êGXß�Ô}:)Z³(m001:Q

]Îf^Ù Zi�iŒ)m05(~5±ÙX ]Îf^Ù]æ…Âf‚]ÖvÐ P™{â»@ZzgåQ 1DÔ�zx~�áïkK¯xñß~†Z/~ÐËZq»QÌ7g~§b97ìX Þ^Úä

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^632

Page 234: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Æ Ê׊ËäÿÂrÜ ÆáW)÷ŒZ−+(Æ*x�ŠX¤t@@` Ê׊ËäÿÂrÜ*ѸX)[(m822:tâñß~¤Ù·Æ*x7ÔÉu�ZgZ*!Z£Ô�ZåL�

C2 )`(m562:tâ·�+¯tÃ7ÔÉñß~Z¶YZv{VÃ�ŠX C1 Ã�ŠXC3 )�(m153:tâZºèZãÆ*x7ÔÉQyÆzZ−6zWú�èZãÆ*xìX

)2(Zôm~èoÆFZW~Ì"ZôïèìÔ}:)Z³(»bÆ*x�zâV»FÀLLÙgZióóHŠìÔ Strictly Confidential Zzg Confidential èo~

qÑèF3~¼�ÛtgzZg¢zg~åX)[(m452:âÆWy~ZÝZÖp�:k»FÀLL*iqóóZkâÆ(tzòt~˧b�g„7X)`( Z C4XYours truly

Zk»FÀLLyz*ã*Š+óó C5XLucknow critics m552:S3XZÝâÆZÖp�:ËZ±gÐÌ�g„7X)�(m552:â�89ZÝZôm~âÆWy~ZqZôm~¿:

As to disreg you have done me nothing of the kind.6C

»FÀu}иTìX){(m212D222:™ñZ�{Wë[Z£{VÆ*xZÝâZôm~~ìÔ1�VÜZs7ňXZÝâÆW¸i~:

Sialkot City4th June, 1925

ZzgWy~:

:m841 Letters of Iqbal D1~å ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù Ô�zx~tâ*åìX ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä :m39)'×h'WV ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù D2

â�áïìXm39@301(Zkâ6@gõ�g`7Ô1$4èGELâÆZk¿:LL~À».ÞYg;ƒVóóÐZkÅ@g+÷ GEL’k D3

ÔZÍw:m671(t ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ZÆ'ÅðуgÐgzZ:ƒñ) B ³™*Â7XZDwÔ02ZÆ'3391YÃ�ŠXeZˆZv,ðÆÒy B âZkÐZqgzi¬»ìÔZkaG91

:m673(X ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 ÐZkŤ&ƒCì):m231 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù D4

Zs:m431 D6Ô5

732kKÆù´

Page 235: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Yours SincerelyMohammad Iqbal

ÆZÖpñ���Ô1Zy»FÀ7�cŠX�c1191YÆWy~{ÃÔZqZµâ B )3(m251:¾HÆ*x¯[øg{41

C1 ¯™7HŠÔqÑè[�9Zzg�01)Ú�35Zzg45(�gZÝZq„âìXzZÍwŧbz�zx~ÌáÈèoƉZÖpZzg„gZ]vsň�Ô

}:m05Ô25Ô76X·Zº¡Æ*xâ�2)m651(Ð�ÅegÂ1VZzgâ�4)m261(Ð�Å&Â1VÆ*xvs™�b‰�Xt"g×:vs.e*oƒ!]ìXZyÂ1VÐZDwÆIh{\VZzgµ3ïGEL,Æ!g}~Ë

Ô�zx~Z+ZÝoÌÃWC�Ô�{µÂ"Å ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ¥â]q݃$Ë�X™VÑgƒVÏÔ}:

9 ß S �zZÅhÕä Ox ZÅhÕä Ox 41 232ã� Ò� 4 152Z�õ Z�ï 7 173*!ÔWìÔjä *!zW{zjä 21 013

P™{!ÑÓxFZÝoZzg{ñVÆ!z��Ô�«YZvÅZk)©à»zlÅZÌÁ7ƒCXk"3ïGGELZDw»tËfí{æÍy:ƒ@ÔÂÐeì�Zk»Zq5/z

èoÅ®Z�ÆZ±gÐÔ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ¤�¶ZcxÅ�„%æEN�»Dgƒ™nzxƒ[ƒ@XkKÆÓxùúV~açLz„ìX%A»ZgZ�{å��ÛZ6+ö XLèo»»xYg~g3YñZzg:ÜsèoÆ'×hù´æÍyKYNÔÉè¹ZDwÆFZWZôm~Ô

ñßsÅ'×hÃð»zl‚t:WmX 1 C2 ÃgÏZzg²!~Ì�áùKYNÔ

:m57D77 Letters to Atiya �&ÀŸ/õ GGZkZôm~¯[»@: D1Ô�zx:m28D38 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �âpÔ D2

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^832

Page 236: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÿq¢~Z�á®þ ZDw*) /

ÅLLozFç”{q¢~óó ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 5002Y~ÿ»[Ug&�Æ%ûþÔT~–w%A:LLeZËd�ÛZ¹ÅïzoQÃã�¯cŠìóó ‚tWð Z�á®

1tÒy�g„7ìX�ÛZ¹™rÆ%ûQÃZk¢~Z(g7HYeX�zâV”V~kKÅFK$2gìÔZ%t!]*‡.Þûì�zZÍwÆ

�âdÿøg{Z0ZiUÔm4491YþÃ<ÅYV�~ˆìZzgz�zxÆ�âdÿøg{:÷zs JBâga1591YþÃzZÍwÆÑzq~YVÎcŠìXTZÍwƉZ0gZY]u64 LLik �Ô}:âZ[œgcgk»l)Ô²*ÑÔZ[»™ÔmLLóóÅ„g]:

z){X u†ZØ�góóÔmLLóólÔ�Æ*xÓxèoâÎZÔZqZzg¼�èoÆ@zg Z LLoQóóÆ´z{ÔPZŸ±K‰�:u!5ÓÀê GeZg#»¯[¯x�«YZv

8iï FFZzg¥â] �«YZv»¯[¯x‡ZZWXZ�ágb»ZŸ†ÌZëìÔ1ZëFÔ�w]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3åXWEZÿUg&�þäCcì� è Z�á® è Z‚ÛZ’kLL:©óóìT~»ƒ%A

Å�z¢zVÃæÍy™ä~LL%Aÿ�«YZvþ6H¦g~Xµ/È~H¶ZzgH1úIJáJZ¹ËQV*7ZX¹V¹Vоw¤�{�àÐZyÅZæZ�ňZzgÁ

Á%Zi6Z¹*plÍZgŠ!]»‚o™*7ZXóó)m946(ZkLL:©óóÃ7_ƒñÔ}}Zk6LLdàmÔW\móó»áyƒä4ìX¾qwZk~¼�ñç¬]z�]6¥â]Z‚ÛZï]W‰�XZ¥|ÔgZk&�ÔZDwƯ[ZD

ZDw¯x�ÔgZk è (kK ÒØÚàÂ×n`^Ê^á Zô[Æ�Z!èo)XÅE˃X&�Æ*x11B�c5391YZzg01B�y7391YÆèVÆ÷zs{XikÃZec~�Æ*xZDw»ÜsZqâ�áïìÔ‰z�{Ð!¹Óxâvs™�b‰�X

]Îf^Ù %AäOîg6‰Qñg)øwkK¯x�(Ã>Æ4�™�cìX)ZÜtZW(ÆTÎxÔ6002YÅgzÝ~eì»[Ug&�LL:©óó~'×h Þ^Ú1

Âí]z¥%]Å¢zg]Ck™,X

932kKÆù´

Page 237: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

%Aä}}¯gzu1ì:LLt!]÷}D~ì1~ZÐÒy7»tZec¸³Åµ/È~ÆÐ_. ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä LL ™zVÇXóó)m666(O�

ìóó'1LL�zï]6¿™*g{ŠìZqZôm~Q»�áïHY*Zzg�zuZ�]»¬gsóó)m766(

ÅDz+ÆK~�zâV»x.eZë�XZôm~èo»à] ZDw è kKÆjZÙ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ¸�ZDwZ»�òÆikZÈx»gZzg�áùƒÇZzg�]Ƭgs�g

Æ%µ~�X �á® Z z$›Ò3¨éG

GG]ZieZËd�ÛZ¹ÔZDwZ»�ò„~

ZDwÔ¯x{y·*iZ−+{V%jx è kK /

NU Q*ÏkK6�ÔikÃù·ÔZDwÆÄ~ùúVÆ%Í`‚6!gq~THŠX‚ÁS®�g7Ô1ZöZ}g×yÅ�~Tg>Zy:LL¤&óó68B�Ñð

�Zø 4591YÅ@gõ�g`ìÔTЂÁZ�á®»çHYYìXtÓxèoÔ™ñZ�zV qZV)YßO(ÆgK{y·*iZ−+{V%jxÆ*x�ÔqZyÆ�z

{yZ�gZ−+Z£Zzg{y%Z−+Z£äZ�á®Æa)ÄZDwуgÆ4�HåX*ÑŧsÐù´6tZ´y�g`ì:LLÄtzZYi]%Z−+Z£{VóóXáÈèoÆ!g}~ZöZ}gÝä¤&Åì�:LL~äZÝèo'�N

Ù1ìXèo!3åXWEZÅ è a�ZzgQy»£¨Zkù´Å˜!ÝwÐ/�‰ÜÚ¤&ÅYCì�z{ZÝèoÅ9Ýw�óóX

ù´~�zèoÆ@Ì�áï�ÔXÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�áÈèoZ¤pÌ®�ìÔ}: [ZÃè ZôoÐÜK‰�Ô@ë£/�‰Ü

m3:�}âÆWy~ZDwÅ’k~@gõZk§b�g`ì: )Z³(âga6191YÜHŠìX B LL31Bâga61Yóó&ù´~31

óÃLL·óóX ó å âÞ7191Yóó�ŠìZzgLL· B âÞ71YóóÃLL72 B m11:LL72 )[(âÐñZi:™ä6¥xƒ@ì�LL·åZDwуgóóà è m74:â�56»@ )`(

LL·ZDwóó�ŠìX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^042

Page 238: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zkù´~tZÈx'@Šì�ZDwä@gõÔâÆW¸i~èìÔÂW¸i„~�g`ňìÔZ¤ZÝâÆWy~ìÔÂZkÅ0È~ňìX‰�zu}ùúV~tZôoÃ7WCX}}‰ZÖp¸¯~�g`K‰�Ô}:m52Ô03Ô33Ô1tzŸs7ň�¯ÆZÖp�¯Æ‚BZÝèo~Ìñ���ÔcZÝâ~tZÖpZDwÐœUg^‰¸)6�¼��zu}èV~ƒZ(Zzg%AcÜâöäg*‡ì™äÆa¸¯~ZK§sÐZyZÖp»ZŸ†HìX

â�44)m43(~�k£â]6�kZô[Æ*xZzgZyÆÃZvsKZãp ‰�Ô@ëqd/õ IG~tzŸs�g`ì�gZ(HŠìXù´Å6zs

ZôoÐňìXWy~Ô6ÂLL4óótÐLLÅ.úóó¾ŠìXm9ÔS42:LLZ¡�óó7ÔLLZ¡góó�g„ìX

»[ZöZ}gÝù´ÆLL7Âóó~��:LLZk~Üs�zâZ,�áï~�áùƒ`�Ô!¹),·�óóX9ßg]qwtì�â�56 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �Ô�

¾[ìXZk§b,·èVÅ®Z�&k ~ 1C »@ÌÔù´Ð¬ËZ¶g¬x6WñXXЖwZöZ} è© ìX!¹ÓxèoÔZkù´Åßg]~«!g

gÝ:LLZD1]Æfí}~�·ZŸ†óóƒZXtÓxèoÚ�Zzg[ZDZq„¿ìÔZka‰=ôÔZñgÅzŸs!¹7gSÔQÌF£â]6jZÙÅ

ìX ù¦Z±gÐtù·LL’#Ö¾z$©-.ï EGGG4óóÅ�{Vw ___ ¢zg]CkƒCì»�zuZZec6891Y~ZDwZ»�ò0Îyуgä& ÚÓ^ingeß^ÝÞn^‡

Â"~øfsZŸ¯VÆ‚B�áùH:1DLL5¡]óó)�âp:T�zxZi6zW·ëg(2DñÑ*¤ZòÆ41èo¯x*i3Dù´»¬gsZi%Z−+Z£{V

(Æ;V�¬å1Z¶g»*xZzg@gõZ�á® ÞÏç� gZ¶äZk@»FZ�á·Ü%jx) 1D:ƒmX ¥x

142kKÆù´

Page 239: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

4D*iÆ¿qÑ‹i0Ï5DjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]Zi%Z−+Z£{VTZÍwŧbÔZk�á®»QÌ*³ìX�ZZec5991Y~)ÄZDwуgÐ�áùƒZÔ!Ÿ†ÔZÍw:�âpZieZËÝx

@fzZ3g)�6891YÆZ»�òZecÅZ�á®Ð"¸gTƒñ�ŠX(�zx:PZqjZázjZÙXÎx:Z�ágtX

†Zv�á{;×»%ûaåZec6002Y~ZDwZ»�ò0Îyä�áùHX%AäikÃZecÃ4Zzg£g~¯äÅlzg½ÃÒÅìXpl¬ÐZk%µ6Z¹èoÆ@�ø[ƒ‰ÔOçQÅ¡6SàÂz�~ˆìX%AäZL

ù´ ×ló~¯[ZDÆÎZ¤ÃZZzgZDwÐZyÆgzZ*Æ´z{ikÃÅZÌ6ÌgzÝeZàìZzgèo6ÆZzg¥â]Z‚ÛZjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]Ìg¶K�XZkZec~ZDwÆ�„â“ikKÆ@Ì�áï�X@�ÚÐ

Z0Zi{ƒ@ì�TZÍwÃ%Az�áù™DƒñQpZãÔTäÌÅÔ£/ZôoZzgÃ~лx71X=g×y™räÌgzZgz~~LL¤&óóÉ�~ìÔ � é�›‰Ü

~´)ZDwäŒÛWãWe»Zqbc��Z“ÐZk§b ( }:â54)01B�y0291Y�åZzg97ìX*�äWe»QŒÛWy0uÆ æqÃ×ßÓÜÎf^ñØÖjÃ^…Êç] É�c:

_.¯�cXšd->î IEX¯ÄZÞÃ�g„ßg]~r¢zg~ì1tZDw»QÂ7ìXâ~ZÐøfsZ0Zi~recå:

y�öÃöçûe÷^æ$wÎøfø^ñôØøÖôjøÃø^…øÊöçû]yMw ó Fó æøqøÃø×ûßÓöÜû

Zϧb62Bâga6191YÆâ~LL'×Z`íƒÇXóó)@(ÃLL'×Z•¤ZòíƒÇóó¯�cX8B�Ñð6191YÆâ~ÌLL'×Zóó)@(ÃLL'×Z`¤ZòóóÉ�cX12B†g~1291YÆâ

~LLFÀZôm~ƒZóó)@(ÃLLFÀZôm~~ƒZóó¯�cÔz){X†Zv�á{;×äZkâÎÅZݹQÅo™�~ìX@ëZq(QyÐÌauƒìÔ}3B�c0291Y

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^242

Page 240: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Æâ~LL¹îs�Z[ƒÇóó)@(ÃZ,VäLL¹îsƒÇóóÜHìXZDwÆZ5ÆK~�N!]tì�ÎZz‡]ZyÆ;VLLÅóóZzgLLÆóó»

Z5!Ç7VÃW@ìX†Zv�á{;×Æ%ûZkZec~ÔeìZk§bÆS»™»Æ]ùúVÃÔZÏ ZDw è kK ™õ]ZzgÌïYN@ëtì~w`7�

%äZzgZ0ZizQ|[Zzg£g6%A™äÅ¢zg]ìX

¯!‹ZDw /

±2k*i~»%ûtù”î0kK:LL�ZÑ#Ö|]´)ZDwÆQy¯!]»�Ñð2191Y»øg{)Zkù´»ƒ B Z%02 C1 ù·ì�z»¯»%AÆ*x�‰óóÔ

Ъ(â*i~™rÆzZ−±†ZD™rZzg82Bâga6391Y»øg{â*i~y~Ð Z C2 ™rÆ�z„s#ÖZv�á{™rÆ*xìXkKÅ®Z�281ìX

�zâZôm~~�),]82D92Zzg933(XZ’Z~�zèV»@�cŠìX&ÆZDw�Ô22BZ6s9491Y~¾[ìXWJ ]Ú†æ‡ èV»@ZkЬ

™ZcÆZDwZecZ6s4791Y~�áùň�X�zèo qß- ÅaÝw èoÔ�zx)m903D213(~Ì�áï�X@ëÂ#jZÙZzgc��Z¤VÆ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä

‚BZzg%AzEßg]~tkKÔ«!gm7591Y~ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔƒñX ™ZcÐ�áù

7 kK(6,]Æ��g` è Z’Zð!g{,])uzgtÔZ[Ôz„Zzg@�XQWJ,]Å�6,]»ÑgZ³@bHŠìXÂ[»Q)áÈèoZzgjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG](273,]6;ƒZìXWy~21,]»Z�ágt�á$ÿLÂ[ìXLL�óóÆikÄZy%AäZDwÅèoóg~ÔikÃèoÆ:©ZzgF"3ïGGEL

ÆuzgtÅ„g]X ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 1D2k*i~Æ*xZDw»Zq¯[)øg{:11B†g~1391Y(Zkù´~�áï7ìXƒ 2D

m51(ZkâÆ!g}~*i~™rä : ÔZDw�Ô�c7791Y Êßçá èÃgÆa�&ÀŸ/õ GG::m48(X ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù Ccå�ŸùƒŠX)

342kKÆù´

Page 241: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Â[Æ0¢zg~Zñg6gzÝeZàìX2k*i~äèoáF"3ïGGELiâãÆ_.%A™*„»°7�ÔÉZLÂ#Z�ágZ]Åæ�ÐèoÆ�gxyZqg*aZ™ÆÔºtèo6�ZkÂ[ÃZqZ»ð¯�cìX��:

~ätZoZxg3ì�ZÍwCÙ[Åg¬eЉZ+!ÂVÅÜZs™�~ìÔX»mZÝ*yÐåÔQ7gZ¯[Ü™�cÔpZ¤ÃðZ%ZkÆ!z��zŸs

Ôg{ŠÔÂZkÅQÐzŸs™�~ÔÉ¢zg~¥xƒZÂfs~¿ÐjZÙÌC1 (J�bX

Q,Vä‰ZñgÅzŸs™DƒñÔZDwÐ5‡ÂVZzgZyÆ—gBV~ƒäzZàW�VÃÌÜHXtËzŸ¬Ô˜VƒkK~çz-™C�Ôz;VO}p�Ô�ª‹ZDw»ËuâtÌ�XjZÙ}}ic�{îsƒ‰�Zzgp�%AÃZk»ZˆkìX��:LL=Z‹Zsì�t¥%]}

C2 }¢zg]Ðic�{îsƒ�óóX‰QñgZ[ÌzŸsÔ�Ô}:81Bm4391YÆâ~´)ZDwä�

å:LLZ¥|ÆqÑ]Zi7•YDóóX)m002(2k*i~™räZkÅzŸsZk§bÅì:LLZ¥|~Zkz‰Üzƒ43ïEGGZzgZ·ZKäZsèÆÜsZqi'�„õf‡ì™g3åóóX)m902(QWÐ^™Z¥|~‡ìƒäzZà

Z³»f™W@ìZzgt�Z³Âh�~ˆZzgZkÆáÃ-ãzg;Ð{g` Anti-God

™�cŠÔ12k*i~™räZÝzZu]7�Ô:tCcì�Z·ZKÆaÃyßv?èÃg{Z³“ÔùZzgÁßÍVÆ;ðV‡ìƒð?QZyZ`» u¤Ä¿

zZ§Hå?z){'ZÝ~*i~™rÎZz‡]ZÝñçqÐx™ìÑ]Å~�zgòYD�ÔZk§b!]¹îsƒYCìÔqÑèz„!]×Z"g z¦

Æ‚BÅY$ËìXZq£x6*i~™rÅc��Z“Ôè%»DgƒìX71âga3391YÆzZu]ÆK~*i~CD��Z~äZDwÃW`Å@i{

:mLL{óóX ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 1DZs:mLLbóóX 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^442

Page 242: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¯]ƒ‰(Âz{gzäÑXgZ¶»ìwì�tzZ§Ô0391YÆzZu] ‹ð)�Wg&Óå EH

~�g`ƒ*ecåtÐ3391Y~�g`ƒŠÔYè6zWWg&Óå EHÅ@gõzÃ]ìX 1C 9B�y0391Y

tù·Ô!±§_54èEGEÔFZ1Z[~ËìX“)Ã![»ÄZy¯™Zk(Æfs~z{úcVñç¬]zZñg:ÄZ*]Æîg6É�b�ÔX6Zk![~ccZÖ§ìwMìÔQZk‚wÆkKZzg=mZ�ágZ]�g`K‰�X&

èoÅÂ"×ëìXZ¤p�«YZvÆ%ûùúVÆ'@tù·ic�{Zôoz»zlZzgœÐ%AHŠÔQÌtZÝoÐ0u7ìX$4èGELèo~F§bÆÕ÷ÃWD�X�zu}*¡Ó4è

GGEŧb2k*i~ÌËÂcwsÃ�Ü7™DÔ

(�g`™ä» å ZDwóóÃLL·ZDwóóÜHìÔªLL·óó6´#Ö) å OçQ,VäLL·ZoZx7'@XZϧbLL33YóóÃLL3391Yóó)m22(ZzgLL53YóóÃLL5391Yóó¯�cXz{èo

’kÃâ è ÆZÝcZ¤ZsÌ'ŒÛZg7gnX‰Zz‡]âÆW¸i~qgz@gõZzg‰Zz‡]ZkÆ'@)m76ƒÐ¬â~t C2 ÆWy~É�ï�X

Ôm691(ZyÆÜ™�{Q~FZÝoñ���Ô}: ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ßg]ñ��ìX�&ÀŸ/õ GG:72Z6s0391YÆâ)m32(~Zq]ì:LLZkÅ¢È~6BZ6sJ»ƒYñÏóó�V6B#ƒ*ecXZϧbÔm261)S41(2B�yÆO}2B�Ñð9ìX

41(91BZÆ'ÆO}91Bm9ìXm532)S11(72BmÆO} m212)SìX}}ÂQ{™*³ìX 72B�c9

Ô¢03Ôm62ÿ×cÆa�&ÀŸ/õ GG:6zWœ& Dictionary of National Biography 1DÔZDw�Ô1891Y: ]æ…mß9ØÒ^ÖsÚn,ˆmà Yzh»*yLLZDwZzgZqzZuCè$óó,·:

m35D66(XZDwÆ^��)âga3391Y(Å@g:VÆK~Ì*i~™rЙäƒZX�&ÀŸ/õ GG:eZËZºg×ã»*yLLYeZsð~¸i~gîs0�áÆh]ÔZDw

ÔD�121Ôm0002Y( ì‚]eí�Ÿñf†m†pq†ÞØ ZzgZqzZuCè$óó)ÔZDwZecÔZ6s4791YX qß- ZÝèo»@5±Ù: 2D

542kKÆù´

Page 243: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÐñZi:HYñÂtZ%sà C1 â è 6BZ~4391YÆQ)m381(»@�: WD

@â ÚÓjçe^l]Îf^Ù ÅS ÚÓjçe^l

gZ]Å73ðXW`Ì' gZ]Ã73ðX~äÌ' 3ggW`7ƒZX gg=7ƒZD 4礙Z1ìX 礙Zcì 7

�™rÅ}#Ö~²n™, �™rвn™,�Z[gzqãZW' 9�W\ÆgzqãZW'

‰�vèo~ÌZk§bÅZÝoñ���X81BZ~4391YƯ[~�z(LL²n™�ØóóÃLL²n™�,óóZzgLLic�{CkF¹óóÃLLic�{F¹óó�ìZzgâÆ

1B�Ñð4391YÆâ~ZDw��:LLƒZ 6 C2 Wy~ZK§sÐуg»ZŸ†HìXpg~ÅÃÒ™zVÇÔ1ZkŬ�]7*ÂìXYèÓxy~LZ(7HóóX)m171(�VÂLLyóó‡.ÞgìX(tzòtÃ�BÂLL/óóƒ*ecÔLLyóó

Is Religion ¾qwßìÔeìtÂ"ÅtƒXm38)S21(6$4èGELâ~ÆZÖp�g`7ƒnX%A䉣â]6$4èGELèoЉ*xZzg Possible

„gZ]vs™�~�ÔYè:LLZyÅw.e¶óóX)�âp:mLL�óó(Xá™Ôù·�z!g{�áù ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔуgäZÆ'7791Y~TZÍw»@

HXT�zxÅB#Ö~eg,]Á�b‰XšÑgÆ!ÇZ’Zð,]!g{ÆO}WJ�X�zu}Zec»»½×4ìX

Ã9QZzg*i~™rÆ ÚÓjçe^l ZDwÆ�„â“èoÐñZi:™ÆjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]6ÃUãÔZzgø¢zg]ZŸ¯Vƈ�áù™äÅ¢zg]!¹ìX

ÔZDwZecÔZ6s4791Y qß- @5±Ù: 1DZs 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^642

Page 244: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZâZ§ZDw /

–w�iŒ:LLZDwÅ»goÔèoÔp}Zzg*�g¯x»tù·óóaZ£eZgä%A™Æâga7691Y~™ZcÐ�áùHÔZk»¸zZDwÆèo6�ìÔ

~ZDw ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ZkaëZk»Y{ù·;}kKÆK~7™gì�X)»¼*�g¯xZzg‰»gkzp}Ì�áï�ÔX6![�5~cƒÏ(X

¬Î!,])uzgtÔ7ÂÔ²nqwZzgqgY]Åz„(Æ$4èGELÂ[ÆW¸iÐZiaçLâ,]»ÑgHŠìÔ�613,]6;ƒZìXWy~62,]»Z�ágtÌ�áïÂ[ìXÂ[&~ì1m313@Wy¬NUZEwHŠìX

»½)©àîg6�ÜZzg¢oìXiâä~tù·%AƒZÔaZ£eZgZDwZ»�òÆeZ]˸XZ»�ò~¹ T

‚),·Zzg)æÍyñZ�ñ��åÔTÅFKzDz+ZqÒpÐQy»�Û>åXtz¯ù·Q,Vä{àœz»zlÐ%AzæÍyHX

~�áïZÝèoÅ®Z�571ìXZy~Ðic�{FèoÔZkÐ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù¬ZZ¶gZ]zg‚b~¾`Ô1Ëù”î0kK~�áï:¸X‰),·èoÌZkù´~�áïK‰�X�«·Æ*xZqâZzgZDwÆ�zèVÆ@Ì�b‰�X

ù·%A™Dz‰ÜÔaZ£eZgäÂ[ÅZqFK‡ì™äÅÃÒÅÔOçz„qgY]6ZqÃeZ%ÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�Ñ]ÃQyÅâÎÆZ±g

ÐZyÄZ*]Æ�„HŠì:1D»goZzgp}2Dèo3Dºtèo

ægZk è 4Dgz�Z›5D)xWy)»goÔèoÔp}ÔÒ*]ÔZDw»Z’Zð¯x(

742kKÆù´

Page 245: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

FZ±gÐù´ÅFK*³ìXWy~{>ZyLL)ÄWyóó~CÙâqÅ )1(’k,�áï�X%AäLLDz+ÅZk{òZzg*ûZg~óóÆamg]7™DƒñZk»:tCcì�Â"Æ�zgZy~'×h�ø[”{ñZ�Ô¬ñZ�ÐLLoƒZzg

%AäZ’ZðegÄZ*]Æ��’k,ŠÅ 1 C1 áZiyZ0Zi~Ý:ƒeXóó�ÔQy~ÌÃðs~FKÃ7WCÔ}:

)Z³(LL»goZzgp}óóÆikÄZyâkKÌ�áï�XZ¹�zu}c�}{~W*ecåXZÏ{~�áïLLZDwÐ�oÅ5‡]»qwóóÌ�VñizV7ÔZк‡]Æ��boƒåX

)[(�zuZZzg�ZÔ�zâV{èo6��X„CÙZ¹�zZµ{¯ä»Ãð�ZiÃ7W@X

)`(�zu}{>ZyLLèoóóÆ�¯tÅZq’k)qÑ‹ZDw(�~ˆìXZÐLLº‡]óó~W*ecåÔYèZkÅâÎZDwÐ0’kzVÅìX

)�(èo~Ãð�Z½FKÌñ��7X:ÂZ¹_54èEGEzZg%AHŠìZzg:ÅFKÐX *ñV Æ ¯[ZÊ-:êGX

7Xù´~¾{ å qgY]Ì è )2(FK~ZyÕ÷Æ´z{z„Z,kKñ���ÔX»f™z„~7ƒeÔ}:¯xŒÂò)m4(ÔUÜ

)m5(ÔpZzzàZ−+)m6(ÔØt�w~)m9(ÔqY·Z£)m11(Ô†ZÁ~ »zg~Ãã)m51(ÔÐDÙZgz~)m51(ÔZׄk)m61(Ôñß~™xZÞ)m61(ÔuZº

·Z�gö)m613(X Zzg ÝxZ£{g)m07(ÔÜZDgZx7g~)482( ©g~)m23(Ô~Zk» ]Þç]…ô]Îf^٠ã[¶Ô è )3(QpZãZzgÜâ+~�ZôoZzg�‰Ü

ìX‰èo»ZÝèoÐñZi:™ä6ÔaZ£eZgÆ;VÌÔ�«YZv hZyZôïÃWCìXfsÅPVßVÐZ0Zi{ƒnÇ: ÅÏ"

Z6s#3691Y(X Ô Ò†�]…ôÞç m681:xV†Z°æÆ*x�zuZâ)@,·: )Z³(

01 mV ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Ô ²qwZi%A 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^842

Page 246: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZÝâ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

W\ZzgW\Æ�z„ W\Æ�z„Æañßw Æazßw

5591Y(X 22BZ6s �‡]�Ò�Ûn† )@,·: m402:¯[¯xg[âZi{V )[(�Ñð03Y B 62 �y03Y B 62

Z: Z:v��Xic�{ ‚Û �i ƒñXZÉ

Ð�êŠ

ƒñXic�{ÔZ6s5591Y(X Ú^åôÞç )`(m012:¯[¯xpZz†Zß©)@,·:

~Zq¼ ~ZyƼ·å ·

Zk⻪]ì:LLZÌJ�Z[7)Wc(óóÔ�VÂLLWcóóZÝâ~ñ��~t¸¯~É�cŠìÔ1zŸs7Å ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 7ÔœUg^ŠìX

ˆ�¯~�cŠÂÔ$4èGELâ»zìÔc%AŧsÐ(JcŠìXt§iL~É�cY@ÂÇåXZk è QßÁDz+ÆÜsìXZ¤LLWcóó¡Õä GOÎc¸¯�X §b'×hVB,]25Ô081Ô681Ô191Zzg5916Q

m001D701:kK¯xÝxgÎw$)ZÝèoZDwñi*~ôp�(X )�(]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ZÝâ ™

Conference Another Unity Conference 001Mohammad Md. 001

Z~2391Y B 71 < 001< ßy 001Z¤A Z¤à 201

%Ëì�W\» Zg‚wì�W\à 701< Z~3291Y B 41 701

942kKÆù´

Page 247: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�c2391YZzgJ�Ûzg~3391YÆèo)m001D101(ZZnKßyZzgck B 92Ð�‰XZÝèoÅ%ã6ßyZzgck~ZDwÅY}ªxÌ�g`ìX�c2391YÆâ6tZÖp|ƒñ�: B 92

Queen Ann's MansionSt. James ParkLondon S.W.I.

ZzgJ�Ûzg~3391YÆâ6tèñ��ì:Hotel Luletia

43-Boulevard Raspail SquareDU Bon Marche

Paris

áÈèoÆ‚BZyêVÃ�g`™*ZkZ±gТzg~å�ZDwÆËÎZö-g\)l�~Íwö è ógÆ;Vt,7QÔZyÐZDwÆ�}^

»Ð÷(~ZyʼnªxǃV»Dƒ@ìX·�+¯tÆ*xZqâ)m25D35(6@gõ�g`7ìÔ1$4èGELâÅgzÝ~

Zk»‚Á’k³™*Â7XtâR‹»Ò‰`Ð�ŠÔT~ZDwäуgÐgzZ:ƒDz‰Ü¯tÐ5‡]:ƒä6Z\k»ZÖgHìXZkâ~¯tÆ

ŧsÌZ�ág{HŠìÔ�†g~6091Y~Yg~ƒZXZkÅgzÝ Ò�Ûn†pÚn,ˆmà~¹YYì�tâ�Ûzg~Ôâga6091Y~�ŠƒÇÔpZz†Zß©Æ*xâ

Ú^åôÞç �Ûzg~3391Y: B )m012(6@gõ�g`7XtâpZz™rƯ[)øg{72Z6s5591Y(Æ�Z[~Ô�Ûzg~3391YÆWy~�âVcâgaÅZ’Z~�ŠƒÇX

~�áï‰èVÅ@gu97�XáÈèoÅgzÝ~7‚ã ]Þç]…ô]Îf^ÙZyÅ¡ƒ$ËìX

Ú†ÎÄ )Z³(¯[¯xzÝìZò)m471(6@gõ�g`7XZkâ~èÃgÄÆZÍAÑg})†g~6291Y(~�áïìXÍcâ5291Y~�ŠƒÇX

�Ñð0391YÅ@gõZkaÜqß B )[(·�+@|Æ*xâ)m502(622

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^052

Page 248: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

6)�¶»f™ìÔ�0391Y~Ö„:åXâ~�ì q^æm‚Þ^Úä ì�Zkâ~�:LL~�VÈ0w~�´•'¹}ƒVóóZzgt�:LLâZ[È0wä=LL@§]0õÎgz9âƒZgÅßk~S«�ÛâðìXW\Ã�áhZk»DZ¶gzVÐ

�Ñð B ƒŠƒÇóóXS»ZZ�y5391YЃZX´`Æa�zu~!gÈ0w~71kaDîg6tâ22B�Ñð5391Y»�ƒZìX Z C1 Ð82BZ~5391YJ}gìÔ

)`(·GZ−+Q~Æ*xâ)m582(631BZ~2291YÅ@gõ�g`ìÔZzgZôm~~Zq× ‡eç…ôq‚m‚ ��g„7Xâ~ZDwZ:q�ï��Zy�âV

ik"ìX*iZ−+{VÆ*x The Idea of Ijtihad in the Law of Islam *y*ò Songs of A Modern David CD��Zy�âV ~ 2C �Ñð4291YÆZqâ B 31

Â[Ég;ƒVX~‰¨)bÆ!g} 3C Ñy0z~Æ*x81Zzg72BZ~4291YÆèo

~Z§gZ]K�XZkÐzZãì�·GZ−+Q~Æ*xZk⻂Á’kÌ4291YìX,] ~ 4C 4291YìÔ:�2291YXg°j�á�Æ®wQ

571D7716qg`�zèoЬtâ^�cŠì:)$Z-V(�Xtg‚!¬9191Y~Yg~ ÞÏng ZyèoƯ[ZD»[z©Z£æk

ÔzZÍw)™: ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ƒZZzg¼²áƈȃŠX1291Y~�z!g{Yg~ƒZX524D824(~¸èoÔ‚]g×ãÆ*xÐ�g`�Ôp–w¬$gŸËZg:tèo

Ô ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä z©Z£Ã�‰Ô6��}âÅWy~SЪCÙƒ@ì)�&ÀŸ/õ GG:ZÍwÔ™824(:¥x7Ãy‚ÄW\Æ0kZâ-ìÔ4ìY\�ØXZkâ^ÅgzÝ~ÔZkƈ�b‰èo6ÃeZBÔÂz{&7ÔÜs�z

~7MX ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù èo�X�îg6�ZâÔTÅWy~S�VÜňìÔ

:m09 ]Îf^Ù]æ…eãçµ^Ù 1D:m05 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 2D

ÔZÍw:m131D531 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D:m811 ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä 4D

152kKÆù´

Page 249: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÔZÍw)m524D824(Æ& ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä *¥xLL¸èoóóÐ%AÅH%Z�ì?]Þç]…ô Æikc�zèV)m571D771(Ð8Z�Xªkì� ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù èo

kâ^ÆÖˆÔZkƼZzgZtŸùƒ‰Ô »�z�{aZ£eZgä»gHåÔZ ]Îf^ÙÆ*x&â ÞÏng cÂ"”{ZzgZt}˃‰Ôqgz!Ñâ^ƈz©Z£æk

Z-ZzgZt~¸Ô!¹�zèog{‰Ô�m571D7716®w�X¬âÆZq¿�X ÞÏng Æa�z&ZÃgq¢�óóÐzZãì�[ZDz©Z£æk ÞÏng LL

™DƒñÔZºZ{VäzŸsÅì�tâñÑ*z© 7 1C �zu}èo»QÆ*xìX ÞÏng Z£æk

Zkù´~˜!·�+¯tÔÝxgÎw$ÔgæZ£œjÔ÷pgæZ£Ô×Æ ÞÏç� »‰ÔÒuZ`Z−+ZzgñÑ*·²Ãy{VÆ*x9kKÔIZi,

kK�)7591Y(~¾`�Ô1�zâVÆáy~)©àZ%Ã]�Ô}:Z~8091YÆâ~tZ%Ã]ñ���: B ¯tÆ*x2

]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ÞÏç��+~�»x!' �8ƒVÔZk~�»x!' Ò�Ûn†pÚn,mà¼:™jVÇÔYè!@‡âyÅÃ' ¼:ÉjVÇYè‡âãÃ'уg`Y�VÇZzgx' уgW™x'W\Ð5‡]ƒZ™}ÏX W\Ðp[p[5‡'ƒZ™,Ï

ò~Í]Æ0Ì' ÅF¹zZ�á®ÆaÌ' Ò�Ûn†pÚn,ˆmà@gZP™rÅ' @gZ)ÖZ}΂�ÛzlÔ���gzZi{(Å'

·�+¯tÆ*xZÝèo·†ZvŒÛ7Æ0k¸XèoÅÝwQ,Vä„»Q„x'ecX±†ZDÆ*x[)m291( ÞÏç� ýÅ�Ô®Z ÞÏç�)m7(~�áïìÔ1Q~�z(Z%sìX¾qw ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞ„m†Þn^‡p

AÔáÈèoÅZ&b è Zk§bÆZ%Ã]�N™-V4ìÔ�*¡Ó4èGGEäø

�ÛâðìÔcÝw»g™ä~u�gz"Zôïлx1ìX

»â~̸�¸ìX ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Ô�Ñð2691YX ]Îf^Ù…mçmç 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^252

Page 250: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~jZßVŶ%æEN~§bCìX%AäS»™»£â]ÆÎZ} ]Þç]…ô]Îf^ÙÅZk{òÅ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 7Cc�Ëâ»â~Hì?gZ¶äF'k¬aZ£eZgÃ

�c2791YÃ�Z6-VzŸsÅ: B §sázHÔÂQ,Vä02†ZßZug�ßv�zu} ˜VJâ~Z]Ŷ»çnìÔZkÅZq{mzz¶X

œ6eZ»eZ%Ƭ�~�ZzgQZkÃt™äÐÌ!5¾æ NEXZ¤W\!Án ßÍVÅ]ÞÏ¡h ÐÃðq(~œÐ¥x™Æ�áù™zZ�,Ô¼²áˆ¸q ]ÞÏ¡h

Å ÆjZáÐz{p�Ëù´~�áï™ÆÔÓxucgzðZLaºm™f�XQyZkw•ÐvÆa~ä�UQyÓxâ~Z]ÃWy~!iðO�}Ðvs™�cåXeZg™r»}�g„ìÔ1Qy»§¯„)dìXuºÆ}ÚÐjZ!

vs™*QßißìXZkÐÂ[Åp>ØêzbZzgZkÅZ÷�~w»ƒYC~!èoÔZZ¶gZ]zg‚bZzgÂ1VÐZ~K�X ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ìX%Aä

fs~ë‰èoÆâ~Z]Ŷy�„™gì�:â~ ¯[¯x �

Ôâga0691Y 2†]Éô…]å UÜ»y7g~ 5Ôèo� ÞÏç� )Z³( Z1ZMgx·†Z?xÐ 51ÔZDw�5691Y qß- )[(

ÔZ6s5691Y 2†]Éô…]å Zׄk 61ÔZ6s5691Y 2†]Éô…]å zÝìZò 371

Ô�Ñð2691Y ]Îf^Ù…mçmç z©Z£ 671Ôm5)aÜ( ‰†æ�ô…Êjä Ë®Zv{V 891

Ô22BZ6s5591Y �‡]�Ò�Ûn† u�Zgg[âZi{V 402)aÜ(

ÔZ6s5591Y)aÜ( Ú^åôÞç pZz†Zß© 012Z6s5791Y)a B Ô12 qß- âZ[·�gcgk 312

Ü(

352kKÆù´

Page 251: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

â~ ¯[¯x �ÔZ6s1591Y)aÜ( Úíˆá ŒuPøzx 622

#8391Y B Ô03 ]uŠ^á %Z£{Vo 292'×h'WV·�+¯tÆ*x,{èoÔ$Æ*xâÔ÷pgæZ£Æ*xiÔ×

»‰Æ*xegÔÒuZ`Z−+Æ*x&ÔgæZ£œjZzgñÑ*·²ÃyÆ*xZqÆkK�~¾`�X ÞÏç� ÅZ�á®Ð!g{'k¬ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Zqâ

Æ 1C ~�áï‰èoÔZDwñi*уg~ôp�Ô}:ÝxZ£{g ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù:m07(ÝxgÎw$Æ*x01B�Ñð1391YÔ71BZ~ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù *x21Bâga2291Y)

2391YÔ92B�c2391YÔJ�Ûzg~3391YÔ12Bâga3391YÔ41BZ~3391Y)m69Ô001Ô�«YZvÆ*x01BZ6s9091YZzgâZ[·�gcgkÆ*x41Bm3391Y 101Ô701(

)m312(ÆkKXÆ%Aä:LL@;Æz‰Ü7g~ÃÒÅ'�ÿZkù´~þÃðZ+ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

]Þç]…ô œU‰æÍyèoÌ 1 2C q�áï:ƒYñÔ�¬x,·ùúV~W_ìóóÔ�zx)m001(~; ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ~�á�X÷ŒZ−+Æ*xâ)m102( ]Îf^Ù

]Îf^Ù ;Z£œj)m712@022(Zzg·gpy)m322(Æ*xèoìaÝwÔÔ�zx ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ÔZÍw)!nKm503Zzg833(~Zzgú�èZãÆ*xâ)m882( Þ^Úä

)m153(~�áï�X%Aä¿jZÙ»ÌZÈxHìÔ1}}mCkƒCìX‰ZñgÅË

å?z){X H 3C UÜ»y7g~Æù”î0¯x)m5(»*x Šg'×h±¢zg~¶Ô}:t�»�zuZZec7791Y~TZÍw»@á™�áùHŠXZk~TZÍw ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

ÅÓxZÝoñ���XT�zx»»½×!gqìX~tâkK¯x·�+¯t~�g`ìÔ1·†vŒÛ7Æ_.ZkÆ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 1D

m482(X : …æ|ôÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ù ¯[ZDÝxZ£{g�):m8 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 2DX Új^Åô�…� 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^452

Page 252: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwÔ¯x¤Zò è kK /

m }èo6�tù·ÔñÑ*�Ýx‡�g¤ZòZzgZDwÆ!bg*z é ZDwÆâ»Zq�N%µìXZDwÆZÝèo�u�Zg·Æ‰ÐZDwZ»�òÃq݃ñ¸X·†ZvŒÛ7äZyèoÃZq§qÝló)m11@78(ZzgÆjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]Æ‚B%AzæÍyHZzgZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔ™ZcäZ6s9691Y~�áùHXƒ

†g~7291Y»X‚]èo6Ãð@gõc“ B âga0191Y»ìZzgWy~13 B Ъâ11�g`7Ô%AäqgY‹âÐZ0Zi{ΙÔQyƪςÁ’k³K�X

Z’ZðÎ!,])uzgtÔz„Ô7ÂZi�iŒ(Æ,]»ÑgZiaçLâHŠìXñÑ*ÝxgÎw$ä‚],]ÆLL�z¬gsóó~¤ZòÅ,ZzgZDwZzg¤ZòÆ!b©]6gzÝeZ%ÆÔ%AÅLL�h{gm~óóZzgLL�âr»z~óóÃCÙ

*öŒÛZg�cìTÆË~tù·LLZD1]Æe» è Z±gЇ&ÿELŠgZzg�Zq‡.ÞŠg%µóó0ŠìX%Aäló~¤ZòÆÎZöÔZyÅ,z�á²~ÔikÃèoZzgZyÆjZáÐZDwZzg¤ZòÆ!bgzZ*Å,½ÅìXèo@gõz“zZg�XCÙâÆ{86$›Ò3¨é G

GG]ÆikÄZyÔQkâÐ0±ÔZñg6¿Zzgîs•gZ]�g`K‰�XZy•gZ]~%Aä¤ZòÆ�Z!èo)¯xZDw(ÐÌæ�àìX·†ZvŒÛ7äZkLLZÝ»xóó»f™™Dƒñ�ì:

ZÝ»xtì�ZyèVÃ(tzòtZzg7©z:©Æ‚BZ,§jЇg~Æ‚tÑcYñ�Ãð¢zg~Z%ZkÐ�:gìXZ¤â~ËzZî»f™ìÔÂtzZ§7"zZáÃ¥xƒYñÔZ¤Ë,»*xWŠìÔÂZk,ÐzZ/Å

àðYñZzgZ¤ÃðZ�ág{ãìÂQÐzZã™�cYñXt»xfgZÂåÔp}ZäC1 W‚y™�cX

Zkù´~�áï‰kKIZi,ZùúV~¾`�Ô}:âÔZÍw)m21Ô31Ô41Ô51(~;â�2Ô3Ô81Ô12Ô24Ô34Ô06Zzg78 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �1Zzg83

Ôèo�ÔZÍw)m32Ô42Ô52Ô62Ô72Zzg82(~Xâ�61Zzg64ZDwñi* ÞÏç��X уg~ôp

:m1 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo ²nqwZi%AÔ 1D

552kKÆù´

Page 253: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

èoŧb è "54èGEGE% Q~Ô%Aä{àZôoлx1ìÔ@ë�v èÜ

Å´#Ö7¯ðÔqÑèZDwäåZk»ZoZxg3XZÏ (å� äLL·óó6) Q,V71YÃ7191Y¯�cì)m811(XLLZ*mgZâyóó)m732(�g„7ÔLLZ*ZD §b

gZâyóóƒ*ecXZkù´Æ‰èoÅ@gu�g„7Ô}¯[�26@gõ�g`7Ô

C1 %AäZkâÃLL0191YZzg2191YóóÆ�gxy»ŒÛZg�cìÔ�g|tW¸i2191Y»ìXZ6s2291YóóЃ@ìÔqÑèQЪCÙìÔ B Zϧb¯[�07»W¸iLLуgÔ42C2 �tâ−·äÐ3291Y~�ŠX

%AÆjZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]Ðèo~èÃgF�]ÔÃZzg)bzZñg6gzÝ

7CìÔ1F!'Z[ÌzŸsÔg{ˆ�Ô}:LLg-h~»]tóó)m422(ZzgLLâìg-h~ïŠìóó)m932(Ð:¥xH%Z�ì?'·†ZvŒÛ7Zq(�

Å"»ìóóX µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ �:LL2291Y~Qic�{®Z�èVÅÃWCìÔt‚wµn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ )m96(%Aä¸�t³42BZ6s2291YƯ[ÐZ~HìÔT~

qÑè C3 »f™™DƒñZDw��:LLZkÅZ�á®Ã�zßÐic�{7¦gZóóX)6�Qz6f™W[ì�(Zk⻂Á’k2291Y73291YìX%AƉ$›Ò3¨é G

GG]ic�{îZªZ(g™‰�Ô}:gZ¶Æìw~u†ZØ�g)m701D801(ÔâZ[fzZ3gZ{V)m801D901(ZzgZºZ[W!�~)m871(Ƭg°•gZ]׿ƒDÔÂ4åX61B#2291Y~LL8¸ç EELgZ{óó»f™WcìÔ%Aä$›Ò3¨é G

GG]~Ä6ZK,]ÐiZZ»ZqîsW~ »7 ÄÆ0ÝxgÎw$ ìwÆÔ §sÐZÖ§

T»�Vû:åX *yÜ™�cìÔ�y1891Y~ZDwZ»�ò0Îyуgätù·�z!g{�áùH�TZÍwÅa

H¤ZòÆ*x Z�á®ìXWy~LLZŸ£îE0T�zxóóÆ�¤ZòÆ*xZq6âZzgÔ¢ZÍwÔÑg{1Ô2:m84 Úr×ùäÿivÏnÐ Ô eZËÝx@fzZ3g 1D

Zs:m94 2D:m302 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^652

Page 254: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

%û:qZv�á{;×(»ZŸ†HŠ ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ùeß^Ýen,Ü+†]Úo ‚]èV)âpfZiìXZݹQ)�&ÀŸ/õ GG:m952D062(~ЉÂ�g„™�~ˆ�Ô1¼�ZÝoZ[Ìñ���X

è¹ZDw /

tù·ÔZDwÆZqΊg{Z,èo6�ìÔ�Ëù”î0kK~ñ��7ÔZ¤ñ���ÂQy»Q*³ÔQ�ðgZcßìXZy~Qg�zÆ19ÔZôm~Æ91Zzg²!»Zqâ�áïìX²!ZzgZôm~èo»ZÝQìFÀ�cŠìXù´~ZDwÆ9Qg�zZzgZôm~èoÅaÝwÌ�áï�XZDwÆ*xYeZiCÙÆ´)

½ZÔZ©Æ�Z!âÅaÜ̽ňìXQè 7ÂeZ˱†ZvÆÐìXLL²%AóóÆikÄZy%Aä¡

kKÔQpZã è "54èGEGE% ÅZÌ6izg�ïƒñZVßVÆfg)zŸsÅì�

: ~™I~Zzg"Zôï»Dgƒñ�XikÃù´Æe~%Aä�ì~äZÍwÂèoÅaÝw½™äÅÃÒÅZzgTŠgèVÅaÝwïÃÔZ¹‚tgÄ™ÔèoÆáyÜ™ä~‚ZÑky7g~Zôoлx1X�VJ

�|‹´)»ZÝZ5Ì�V»ÂV'ŒÛZgg3ìXZϧbZ¤@gõËâÆW¸i~�g`ìÔÂW¸i„~�g`ÅÔZ¤Wy~ìÂWy~Xâ~“LL61Yóó�ìÂZÐLL6191Yóó7¯cÔªÜâ+~ÜÅZÝÐ_“Ã'ŒÛZgg3ŠìXQX

èVÅaÝw�ø[7ƒÃÔ�zu}fgZùÐZkãuJÔZy»9Q�gcÄ™äÅ[ňX‰èVÆZqÐiZZáyA‡&ÿELFßQZ(g™ÆZ%Ã]Ŷy�„jZÙ~™�~ˆXZϧbZôm~èoÆF§V~Ì{àZôoлx1ìXTTZôm~â»Q�ø[ƒeÔz{Qg�zF3Æ‚B�g`

™�cŠìÔ@�‡gMF3»ñZi:ZÝQЙÃXF3ÆK~ZqzŸs¢zg~¥xƒCì�~äZôm~èoÆZØ[»Zôm~FÀ7HÔÉZ¹�V»ÂVg��cìYV�ZÍwÂZyZØ[»Z(oƒzñizVFÀ™*W‚y

7Ô�7g~§bZk|xÃZ�Z™}Ô�â�ƒñ´)ZDwÆf‚~ÔË{m

752kKÆù´

Page 255: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¯[ZDÆañ��åX�zu}:ekuÔâðekZºz){Z,ZØ[�Ô�|‹´)äZLQg�zèV~ÌF(ZEwK�ÔZkaZ,ZØ!]ÃQg�z~Ìdqh

C1 'ŒÛZggp~ÃðDs7XÆW¸i~k"3ïGGEL ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù ZkÐikÃù´Å7g~YzZãƒYCìX

ZDwÆZùúV»¿Y{7™DƒñÔZDwÆèoZzgZyÅèoâ+6ZqW~ÃeZàˆìXèoÅFK@gõz“zZgìÔZ%Zq¯[ZDÆ*x]

èoŠ„�b‰�XCÙâЬ¯[ZD»¿¬gsZzg⻿:©�g`âÆZ%Ã]Zzg‰�]z){Æ!g}~¬g° è ìX¿0zg¹$›Ò3¨é G

GG]~QZ�ágZ]ñ���XÂ[»�Zz)<:m292D803(áÈkKÐ0‰

�~zÄ~’kzV6�ìXa¸{>ZyLL–~óó~CÙâÆfg$œî G0”wÔIZi,ZkÅZ�á®Zzg‰Zôm~èoÆ*³F§VÐcňìXù´ÆWy~ÂÒ]ZzgZq×Z�ágtÌ�áïìX

~–weZËÝx@fzZ3g:LLQÅoÆ ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù Zk~d->î IEX7�@ëÝÁQ~p�%AÐÌ¹Ï C2 óóÔ ´z{‰@g:VÃÌ�g„HŠì

™Vui�ƒð�Ô}:9 ß S �m âÞ 9 301^©0î EG s 2 221�âz �âp 3 221g‚ƒ g‚ƒV 31 621*6z *6 3 131

1�ê 1 4 061

:m22Ô32 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 1DÔ¢ZÍwÔÑg{1Ô2:m53 Úr×ùäÿivÏnÐ 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^852

Page 256: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �¾Z−+ Z−+ 6 771~77 ~7 3 102~äÍ“ ~Í“ 2 902

†g~ B 42 �Ûzg~ B 42 21 112å\ åé 21 422Zz ZW 71 732

ÆÈ ÆÔ 5 942eìÔZy~ЉÔÂ"ÅZÝoƒVÔ@ë%AÅf)�Zg~Á7ƒCX

l)ÔjZÙZzgÂ#•gZ]~ÌF™VÃWC�Ô}:S �

ZÆ'ßX B ZÆ'9ìZzg91 B 41 71 73™229ìZzg43ßX 81 73˜i»*xCYßìX 6 67^»UãÅ9ßg]tì:¼AíÃÌZk�g!§ÍCÙ!gÐ 61 77Né�ÔZqR-wZÐì:�˜igZyvX qí�4 97

9:LL¼Â:¶óóX 51 39øzx6691Y~¯]ƒñX 3 4019*x:÷u�ZgZ£{VX 6 2213291Y9ìZzg2391YßX 6 1513291Y9ìZzg3691YßX 01 451LLYÄqàóó9ì:�LL*ÄqàóóX 61 832eZËgcnZdÔ™Zc-ãzg;~LZ*�7gìX 7D8 722âÞ4391Y9ìZzgâÞ6391YßX 51 162

952kKÆù´

Page 257: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

‰èoÅ@guZzg“Z&bÔ�Ô}¯[¯xYzhZDwÔ3391Y~�ŠÔ:�2391Y~)m222(X¯[¯x½ZÔZ©7391Y~�ŠÔ:�6391Y~)m412(X¯[¯xugxÔ�c3391Y~�ŠÔ:��c2391Y~)m151(X

:m012(X +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù ·yÆ*xâZÆ'7391Y»’k™�{ì)QŧsÂzKzwƒðZzg¹ è ZyZÝoÆ!z��ÔZkù´ÅzzС

m5091YÉ`Ð�Yä B Ðèo«!g9Zzgåßg]~‚tWñX52~Zk ì_ç½]Îf^Ù zZáZqîs¯[ÃÔZ[J·�+¯tÆ*xŒÛZg�cY@g;Ô

Zݯ[ZD)ñß~Z¶YZv{V(Ŷy�„ňì)m39(Zkù´~ ÆʼnZÝoÅoňìX¯[¯x�xZv ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ZÍwÔ�zxZzg ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä

C1 âÞ5391YìX B )m102(6@g+÷ GEL’k�g`7ÔZkÅ@gõ’k22ÅZqZzgZ�á® ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù ½ãZq‚wˆ7791Y~TZÍwÆ@6F

��п~WðXtZ�á®%AÅZYi]zZ:qÆ%ƒðÔZkaZkZec~ÔC2 TZÍwÆÓxÛ[zÕ÷ñ���X

è¹ZDw¯xH¤Zò /

»t¿ù·qZv�á{;×ä%A™Æ V HñÑ*¤ZòÆ*xZDwÆWJè†g~8791Y~ßW!�Ð�áùHåXñÑ*¤ZòÅzÃ]ÆÔH¤ZòQy»¯x%A™ÆVZ*eS�ÔZke~z{´)ZDwÐtg{zZ¬-ŤƒNXZDwÆtèo¯Ä¤ZòÅFKzDz+ZzgÂ"zS®ÆK~@Zc]6�

�XtèoñÑ*¤ZòÆzgUÐqÝ™Æ%AK‰�X%Aäù´ÆZ’Zð{~ñÑ*¤ZòZzgZDwÆ!b"$¹Ò¨é GE:gzZ*6

gzÝeZàìXZke~Q,VäZDwÆ,·kKÆ´z{Ô¤ZòÅ),·

:m031 ]Îf^Ù]æ…]ÞrÛàuÛ^mkô]‰¡Ý 1DÔZqW~Y{óó˜!: ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù '×h,Æa�&ÀŸ/õ GG:�ÛzrZ£»*yLL>Zy 2D

уgÔZDw�Ô�Ñð@ZÆ'7791YÔm712D432 Ô ]Îf^Ù…mçmç

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^062

Page 258: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»Q è¹ZDw c��Z¤VÐÌæ�àìÔQH¤Zò»¿¬gs™ZcìXZiZVèo�áï�X è �g`HìXWy~@

%A�âd~��:LLæèo�ø[ƒn�Ôz{šÁz»„�áùKYgì�óóX)m01(1áÈèoÜ™ä~%Aм�ZÝoui�ƒð�Ô}:

èo è@ è¹ZDw¯xH¤Zò S �81Y 8191Y 4 74

z‡Å7ƒð ‡7ƒñ èz 8 74Qy�W\ QyìW\ 9 74

�c71Y B8 �c7191Y B8 11 74ÉÏî LŠ Z: Z:ÉÓÏî Š 2 25ZkÆ Zk»xÆ 5 25

¬ÜsZy ¬Qy 7 25m72Y B 31 m7291Y B 31 41 25

:Â[ :�Â[ 4 35Z6s03Y B 52 Z6s0391Y B 02 8 35Ãð!]Z+ ÃðZ+!] 3 65

Ù� ÙÏ 5 65�y03Y B 11 �y0391Y B 11 8 65

‡&ÿELZO� ‡&ÿELZ±g 3 85³mÐcW\Ð~ä ³mÐ~ä 5 06W\À¯x W\‚gZ¯x 21 06!CÙg�zZá !CÙÐWäzZá 61 16:ƒ$Ë :ƒC 81 16â"„7 â"7 91 16

162kKÆù´

Page 259: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zkù´~ñÑ*¤ZòÆ*xÔZDw»Zq),·âÌ�áïìXù¦Z±gZDw~ZqÆZŸ†ìX·†ZvŒÛ7äZyÓxèoà è ÐÔtù·fíÒkK

Æ�zu}Zec~�áï™1ìX ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo

˜È�v D ZDw /

Zkù´ÃgZáZŒ)6091YD5791Y(Æ*x,·Zzg),·ù”î0kKgZá 3 îg67HŠì1À44kK~â�ZqZâg~HÆ*xìXâ3 Æ

ZŒÆ*x7ÔÉ6zW·œ&;si~ÅïÆ_.ZkƯ[ZDñÑ*gZáZŒÆ*xkKÅ®Z�24kìXCÙâÆ!W.ÞÔ V- 1CX Ã�Zî�~�

ZDw»�„â“@�cŠìXZôm~èo»FÀÌ�áïÂ[ìXWy~¯[ 6-*y q ZD»-¬gs�cŠìXLLZDwZOòóóÆÄZyÐgZáZŒ»Z

уgÆZDw�2391Y~ÖåX Þn†Þ-ìn^Ù Ì�áïì�ƒÐ¬çÔ(ÏZzgd_Zzgñç¬]ÆZ±gÐtâ¹Zë�XZykK»

²d’k#1391@m7391YìXtiâ:yz*ã((]ÔZsxÈyÃ�g7)bÔQyÆwZzgZDwÆ[Z[M!�ÆjZáÐ"uZëZzg*iuåXgZáZŒ

Æ*xikÃèV~ic�{F(ÏQñgz)bZzg�âVÆawÅgZ{¿6i}Zzgâ6Bâga è ZÖ§ìwMìX11B�c4391YÆâÐZDwÆÛ!

4391YÐZDwÅLL0ÎyYóóÅzŸs̃CìXñç¬CZÌů6–w6zW;si~LLZyèoÅDz+SàÂzžè¶pZ\k�Zk»ìw:g3ŠZzgèo/³�áù™�b‰Xóó

ù´ÅƒÐ(~{òÂtì�QÃÜ™ä~¾8ªîGOZôo7ňXZqZzg(~¶tCkƒCì�Q6¢zg~jZÙZzgÂí]�áï7�XZk¶

q`^áô�m,†V D ]Îf^Ù 6zW·œ&;si~äZLZ*…ZD1]Æó£á Ã~!Œ§&7gZHìXèÃg{£á~QÅ�g4ÆaÌ iÃ×nÏ^læuç]�o

Ôm261D361 iÃ×nÏ^læuç]�o V q`^áô�m,† D ]Îf^Ù ),·£!Z*…ZD1]>Zy: 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^262

Page 260: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âZzgZ�á®ÅZ” è ‡.ÞŠg»zlňìXZk£áÅgzÝ~ikÃù´ÅDz+¢zg]ìX

¯!‹ZDw¯xa�O~·@ /

´)ZDwÆŒÛRg=ZzgZyÆ”VÆu6„a�O~·@Æ*xè¹ZDw»tù·[ZDÆ7DU�%ä�áùHìX4,]»�âpZzgP

�]6&,]».euu~¬gsÌ�áïìXäèo»Qì@�áïÂ[ìXtÓxèo7†»ge6’kK‰�X

�gZÝtz„èo��U�%ä4891Y~ZLZ*Z}Qg�zÆ£á~�áïK¸X)Zk6gZ¶»û{ E…æ]e¼D ¡Úä]Îf^Ù]æ…2ç�â†pÚvÛ‚uŠnà

Ôm45D55(èÃg{ó£á~¯[ZDÅeZ]~Ƽ{ ]Îf^Ön^ioq^ñˆc �&ÀŸ/õ GG:Ô:¥x 1Zy~Ð×iîsâikÃù´~�áï7K‰ Zzg62â�áï�

V»iâU’k3291YÐ6391Y YV?qÑèZkfí}~z„iâZëF�XZyèJìXÓxèoZDwÆ�„â“�X

LETTERS OF IQBAL TO JINNAH /

‡ZZW·Z»bÆ*xZDwƾ{èo6�tù·Ô¿ƒäÆ!z��Ôs~ZÌ»qïìXtèo·ÑpîÏûbÅfZCÑ$k~Ð�ø[ƒñX

C1 Q,VäèoÃNUHZzg@gõzZg%A™Æ¯[ZDÃZyÅZ�á®ÆaWâ�{HX»beT¸�ZDwÆ*xQyÆ�Z!èoÌ�áï™ÆÔùÃs~Z±gÐ

C2 ic�{åz%1o¯�cYñÔ1ZDwÆ;VлbÆ�Z!èo�ø[:ƒnÔOçQ,VäZk6Zq7»ZŸ†™Æù·Z�á®Æa�}�cX

ªZec&DÙZgÅ®Z�~Z6s3491Y~�áùƒZXˆÅZqZ�á®)8691Y(ÆZÖp%x�Ô1tZ0gZ`�g„7XxVaZ£»Òy First Edition 1942~

:m11 My Reminiscences 1D:m71 Quaid-i-Azam As Seen by His Contemporaries 2D

362kKÆù´

Page 261: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ì�†g~3491Y~‡ZZWäè¹»b¯xZDwˆl™zZäÅ@ZeÅX�Z6Zkßg]~2491Y~ C1 ~ä42B�Ûzg~3491YÃZ¹èoÅ°x�ø!ÐiHX

Æuzgt6tÂ#„g]�g`ì: èZÍw *eìXZ�á® èZÍw ù´ÅZ�á®A collection of Iqbal's Letters to the Quaid-i-Azam conveying his views on thePolitical Future of Muslim India.

ˆ~Zk„g]Ãps™Æ-V¯�cŠ:Allama Iqbal's views on the Political Future of Muslim India.

tù·Z[JF!g¾[ìZzgZkZ±gÐk"3ïGGELZDwÆùúV~ƒÐic�{àzZÑù·ìXÓxZ�áoV»Q7VìX

ZkùÃZiaçLâ%A™*ecXZk~ÔZÍw:´)ZDwZzg‡ZZWÆ!b©]Zzg(Ï]z4~�zâVÆZ·Zuz¬zy6gzÝeZ%Å¢zg]ìX�zx:Zyèo~èÃg(ÏZzg@g]ZjZwz)bÆ0Â#jZÙ»ZŸ†¢zg~ìÔSîZq¬x‡g~ÆaZyÅse{§pZ{§jÐZÏz‰ÜúcVƒCìÔZZ¹

¿�~•gZ]Zzg0zg¹jZÙÆfg)zZãHYñXÎx:aZ£eZgÆù´)m501D111(~ZqZ(â�áïìÔ�ÝxgÎwŧsÐZDwÅ@Ze6 Letters

)m495Zzg806(~ÌZkâqÆ�z ]Îf^ÙÒ1�ì†p�æ‰^Ù ·Z»bÃ�ŠXZg�á�71�Ûzg~Zzg7âga8391YÃÝx è %Z|V»Qg�zFÀ�áïìÔ�´)Æø

)Z6s1891Y( ÎçÚo‡e^á »Qg�zFÀ gÎwŧsлbÆ*xljX'×h�zèV~ÖìXZyƒÃikÃù´~�ge�áï™*ecX

~�áïHìX»b Letters of Iqbal aZ£eZgäZy¾{èVÃZLù´Æ*xZDwÆ�zèo˜$¬ÝZzgZq™'³gz~ä�gcÄHìX˜$¬Ýä91èV»Qg�zZec�áùHì1â�gcÄèVÆZÝZôm~áyZzgZyÆ$ó~

¢7KX wq@ Z,Vä

:m71 Quaid-i-Azam As Seen by His Contemporaries 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^462

Page 262: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

IQBAL'S LETTERS TO ATTIYA BEGUM /

6�tù·«!g�Ûzg~7491Y~�Ð�áù 1C ¾HÆ*xZDwÆâèo~Ì�áïìÔ1ikÃù·ZkaZÌ Letters of Iqbal ƒZXZ¤pZyèV»Q

g‚ì�Zk~«!gZÝkKÆ@�áùK‰XZöZ}gÝäZkÂ[ÃZg�cìÔ1Zkñâ¤ZsÅ‚g~ ŒÛ 2C

The Monograph of Attiya Begum on Iqbal

Iqbal's Letters qg]ZDwÆâèo6Z2ZgìXQÂ[Ƥ�7l6qg`ÄZyÐ̪CÙì�ZÐù”î0kKÅwÐ7HŠìXª to Attiya Begum

â‰`Ð42B†g~7091YZzgWy~уgÐ41B�c1191YÃ�ŠXZyèoÐÔZkœgZzgZCZ[»Z0Zi{Îä~æ�QìX 6 ²á~ZDwÆ_!CÌyÔf

Åc��Z¤VäèoÆ:©Zzg7©Ã'×hzZã™�cìXZkù´Å ¾H¬x6WcÔ è Z�á®Ð§‹ZDwÆZqZë![Ð0.eËZzg!Ç*ñZ�©

TÅã�6ZDwƉÕ�zVÃZyÅ_!Ci0ÏÆ0qíWgZð»ñµïŠXZk’k³ƒCìÔ è ~ZDwʼn¸VÆZ,@Ì�áï�ÔXÐZyÅ@gõ:m421Ô212Ô112(X e^Þ-ô�…] 13�c1191Y) Ôðè âh }:âZ}§Ô�c1191YX�¬Ô�c1191YXZzg

Ô1 �g`ì Iqbal's Letters to Attiya Begum Â[Ƥ�7l6ÂtÄZyJöz�g3ŠìXZ’Z~Wg^Ä6,·ÔâZ[ Iqbal Z0gzãuzgt6ÄZyÃÜs

Œcgk·�gZzgëg8-.èGEÅ£zk�áï�XNU!gqìXzZu]Åo9�~ˆ�:)1(±ZìZò Ì C3 ÐQÆ�gxy„gL‚~qgzfs£zk

Æ;VKÔ‰`)2(�ÛZ6zW‹y)3(�ÛZAJ�áw)4(ZDwZzg¾Ô&BðLW)5(K!¼�Û�zk)6(¾HÔÏ`Dƒñ)7(ZDwÔÏ`DƒñX

)áW:MYZ−+ ]Îf^Ù ¾HÆ*x�ÎZVZzgWy~âÔikcÂ[ÆQg�zF3>Zy 1DZ£'ãÔ™Zc6591Y(~�áïHŠXZÝÂ[~ñ��7ìX

ÔT�zxX Iqbal ¡Ò3ïE

GF: 2DÂ[»ikcªZecZkaÌZëì�t£zkT�zxcÂ[ÆËQg�zF3~ D3�áï7�X

562kKÆù´

Page 263: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�Ñð9091Y» B Z6s0191Y»âŠg{,];71 B ZDwÆtèo××�Ô7‚],]Zzg03âga0191Y»â0õ,]6�ìXZDwäZkŠgîs˜èo

¾HÆÎZZzgËÃ7�XZ6s9091YÆâÐÔ&Z£â]м{vsK‰�XZÏ B 71

Â[Æ�zu}Zec)уgÔ9691Y(~˜!@~âƬÔÆ�z÷zs¿�áï�:

(1) I too wish to see you and pour out my entire self before you.(2) Your letters to me have always kept in a safe chest; nobody can see them.

@ë�zu}ÔÐ�]vsHŠÔz{T�zxÆ@~Ìbw7ƒeXZq¬x‡g~ÆaZyèoÃgzZãÐ7−W‚y7XQÃNU~Ì�cY@ÔÂ4åX

�zuZZec9691Y~уgÐWsZ�[ä�áùHXZk»NUñNZzg»½�ÜZ6s9691Y(XÂ[»Q B ìX¡Ò3ï E

GFÅ„g]ZöZ}gÝÆÐìX)ñgQ:8�¬ZecÆ_.ìÔZ%‰àâ])�¬Ô%›ðZzgFÌ�ÂògZã'(Æ@Ô�¬Zec~Â[ÅÆÐ(}‚6TK‰ÔT�zx~!{�çEO™�b‰�X'×h'WVqgzfsq,vs™�~ˆ�:

XIqbal's Letters to Attiya Begum ¬ZecƤ�7l6�g`”{ÄZy: )1(âZ[ŒcgkZzgëg8-.èGEÅ£zkX )2(‚]£zk)X»f™Qz6W[ì(X )3(

ÔáW: ]Îf^Ù @ëtZ%À&ì�92#3391Y»øg{â)T»@«!gZ−+Z£'ã~�áùHŠå(�zu}Zec~�áï7ìX¤�7l6 MY

Monograph of Atiya Begum on Iqbal �g`fsZÖp»ZŸ†HŠì:�ZZec)WsZ�[ÔуgÔ7791Y(T�zxÅaZ�á®ìX

LETTERS AND WRITINGS OF IQBAL /

ZDw»tù·Ôã�~îg6ÔZqù”î0kK è âÞ7691Y~™ZcÐ,·Ô�

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^662

Page 264: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ìXZk~ZDwÅZzgZyÐ0’k,Ì�áï�Ô1QyÅ®Z�èoÆ£«~�áïK‰ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ~ÁìXIZi,ZDwƼ�Zôm~èoÆQg�zFZWÔ

¸ÔS»™»Zôm~âZ¶gZ]zg‚b~�áùƒDgìÔ1]�ø[Zôm~èoÂ!Zzgæzyßg]~ÔZkù´Æfg)«!g‚tWñX

CÙâЬ¯[ZD»¿¬gsZzgâ»:©ÒyHŠìÔ1tZÈx‚g}èVÆe~7HŠX‰£â]60zg¹jZÙÌ�g`�Ô1{áX

~QìXQ,V ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù QÅ¡ÆK~%A»gztz„ìÔTÅ¡)m511(XQ~ by pupils à by his pupils Zzg 1C ÜHì Attiya à Atiya ä

}}¸¯~Âí]�g`Å�)m33(1:Â�âd~Zzg:qd/õ IG~ÔZkZ%ÅzŸsňìXZDwä¹ÐèoZLgZáb6�ÔèoÃÜ™Dƒñt&¢zg~ì�,·ZÖp¹V»ƒD�Zzgâ»ZÝQ¹VÐÑzq

z7Ô1eZg™r » 2C ZÝâ Lahore ƒ@ìXm5116¯[¯xHWg&Óå EH~ƒЬâ¯xÆG·{y»Qg�z Æ®wQ~ZÐ8~î0QªCÙHŠìXZ,�ÔX»Zôm~QÔZkâ~ 3C ~�áïìÔ1F3~�z¿ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä FÀ

ñ��7ìXeZg™räZke~ÃðzŸsÌ7ÅX:¥xZôm~Q*³ìcQg�zF3~èÃg{�zÓV»ZŸ†áWäZK§sÐHì?'Zk»Zq(Z:tì�%AäCÙâÆâ~»f™7HX�âd~Q,Vä‰Zô[Æ*xrZñ�ÔXƉÐZ¹èo�ø[ƒñÔ1t�Zy~ÐCÙ

â¹VÐZzg¾ßg]~)ZÝÔ@cÜ?(q݃ZÔZk!g}~%AäSØлx1ìXikÃù´ÅZk{ò»Ãð�Zi7™*ÂìX

Zi¾HÔFÀZiMYZ−+'ã:m161 ]Îf^Ù â!: è@ 1DÔm09 ]Îf^Ù(mç…¸Ún6 ÔZDw�7791Y:m511;2: Êßçá âÔ è �&ÀŸ/õ GG@ 2D

LLãyz*y»Wy~�y3„åÔTÃy*yÆ�âVä¢�ÛZñl™�¶~ D3ÔZÍw:m642(X ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä (~*Z»°Ð»x1ìXóó)

762kKÆù´

Page 265: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

m3016¬Z½µâÃ1391YÅ’kCcŠìÔZk~'}VÐZDwÅ5‡]»f™ìÔt5‡]†g~3391Y~ƒð¶ÔZkaèÃg{Z½µâ3391YcZk

ƈ»ìXpZz†Zß©Æ*xâ)m7(6@gõ)62(Æ‚Bâ{z‚w�g`7ÔtoÅÀ®Z�34ìX26èo»Qg�zFÀIZi,�áù è C1 Z6s5391Y»âìX B 62

ƒ[ìXù´~�áï&èoåßg]~7ÔÉÜsZ½kÅ^~�X‰ÆZØ[zW�Z[�g`7K‰XZqâ)¯x»b:m501D111(ZDw»ZC7ÔÉQyÆóR~ÝxgÎw»’k™�{ìXm5016»bÆ*xâ7391Y~�ŠÔ:

~,·ƒ ]Öf¡É �4391Y~X[¯x�ZiCÙÔZDw»ZÝâ7Ôɲ!Z¶gZDwÆZqÜá6FìXèoÆK~Z}�ÆaZDw»’k™�{Zq

u"3©5½3ï HGEGGHÌ�áïìXZоqwâ7¹YYXZϧb,]73Ô83Ô04Ô146�~ˆ�gpZ2VÅâÎÔèoÐËŠgZìXZyZZ‡qkKÃ%A™Dz‰ÜZµZµ”V~Š™*ecåX

FKzDz+ÅZy{ñVÆ!z��ZDwÆZôm~èo»tZÍAù·ZÌg‚ìÔYèZkÆfg)Zôm~èo»QÔŠßg]~‚tÑcŠìX

~Letters of Iqbal %AäZkù´ÆÓxkKÔˆ~ZLYìFù´�áï™aXZkÒpÐZkù´Ã»³x'ecZzgZk~�áïkKÐZ.�}Æa%AÆ6ù´Ðg�q™*ecX

LETTERS OF IQBAL /

Æ*xÐ�ù· Letters and Writings of Iqbal aZ£eZgäâÞ7691Y~%AHåÔikÃù·ZkÅÂWZzgZŸ†”{ßg]ìXZkù´~%Aä¹

Ð6èo�áïK�Zzgºt’kzVÃ{g`™�cìXZ[ZkÅâÎ{µù”î0kKÅìXZqÎ&èV6�tù·×ic�{ÂzZzgœÐ%AHŠìXZk~&bz~èoÔZq*åâZzgeg�gpZZÌ�áï�Xù´Ãic�{Yì

ÔZDw�2:m614 ÞÏç� 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^862

Page 266: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Iqbal's Letters to Attiya ¯äÆaÔ%Aäè¹ZDwÆ�z×Á?ùúVªÃÌikÃù´~槙�cìXZk§b Letters of Iqbal to Jinnah Zzg Begum

Z[ZDwÆÓxZôm~èoŠƒ‰�XX¯[ZÊ-:êGXÆ*xÔZDwÆZqÐiZZèo�ø[�)}¾H:01X

Õ:7z){(ƒÐ¬ · ua@:4XgZk&�:7XeZËZöZ*Z™Zx:5X�g`HŠìÔˆZiZVZZ¾mÆ*xºtèoX ¹Q

%Aä¯[ZÊ-:êGXƬgsZzgèoƱԣâ]Æ!g}~!©}ÿEO

jZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]Zzg•gZ]��XkK¯x¾H6Zq×l)ZzgPZq<

Ì�áïK�Xù¦wÐZyÂí]Æfg)ƒèo~¹æ�QìZzgZkK~%AÅœ‡&ÿEL�Z�ìX@뉣â]6Sîºtèo~Âí]Q�ðg~Zzg�Xâ�021)m881(Ƭg°•g}~%AäZ‹ZnHì�

)31B�Ûzg~ The Pakistan Times äZkâÃ),·ŒÛZg�cìÔqÑèt ‘vnËä ækÂ*�Z·Zq,·âÃLL),·óóɉÔ1eZg ‘vnËä 9691Y(~¾[ìXæk

™räÂ�Z·ÔjZá�¶ÐZ�ZiHìXQ,VäZèoXÂ1VÐZ~K�ÔZyÅ�,�¥xƒmÔZk§bì:

ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù zggZk&�Æ*xâ�1 Z ºtèo�12Ô42Ô92Ô13Ô33Ô43Ô53ÔZDw�1 ÞÏç� Ð;ºtâ�72 Mementos of Iqbal Ð;ºtâ�22Zzg32

ÔZDw�Ô�zxÔ7791YÔ8791YÐZzg ‘vnËä m7791YÐ;ºtèo�64Zzg74ÔZDw»ôöуgÔ7791YÐX ÞÛ^m�Þ^Úä �gpZ„�84

áÈèoÐ0ÔqgzfsZñgÂzÔ�:’kÃr3û EEL’k~ÑDƒñ�Z·F¥Ã]K è@ )1(QpZã¨gÐ7ňX

¯�cìXZÏ Atiyya ��ÔeZg™räZÒ(ZkÂà Atiya ‰XZDw!kxDecember à Dec. )m82( March à Mar. )m71( Fayzee à Feyzee §bà Oct. )m851(Zzg August à Aug. )m63( Mohammad à Md. )m73(: )m402(ÜHŠìXƒÐic�{¥Ã]â�81)m581(~X� October

962kKÆù´

Page 267: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

eZg�r»Q S ZÝQAugust 2 Aug.

Maulve 3 Maulvie

received 4 recd.

Assistant Secretary 6 Asstt. Sec.

Muslim 6 <Round Table Conference 31D41 R.T.C.

October 41 Oct.

The Round Table Conference 61 R.T.C.C1to Maulve Mohammad Yaqub 12 <

ÔZDw»ôöуg7791Y~�&ÀŸ/õ GG(ʼn ÞÛ^m�Þ^Úä �gpZ„�84)@ÔZÝo5±ƒV:

January S51 m822 Jan.

ground 02 // grd.

against 02 // agt.

Examination 3 922 Consideration

Government 51 // Govt.

~Yours Sincerelyà Yours etc. )m791(ÆWy~ 2C â�72¯x��+·ps™�cŠìX

)2(QÅozŠZzgzŸsÆa%A丯~‰ZÖp»ZŸ†Hì)�&ÀŸ/õ GGm63Ô421Ô521Ô771Ô791@991Ô402Ô912(1tzŸsñ��7�¯ÆZÖpÔZÝQ»z7�X

)3(‰èoƼ{�g`ƒäÐg{‰�Ô„CÙZk»:%AÅ"ZôïìÔ}:

tâ)�81(™Zc-ãzg;~ôpìX 1DZDw�ÔZÍwÔ7791Y)m625(~¾[ìX ÞÏç� 9Q D2

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^072

Page 268: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

÷zsZÖpz�gZ] �m96(X ÔLetters to Atiya )@â�&ÀŸ/õ GG: 7th April 10 Wy~ 43

Qg�zÄÆWy~:LL·åZDwóóX)@â�&ÀŸ/õ GG:ZsÔm77(X 83P.S. Ali Bakhsh sends his respects to you and the Begum

1C 001P.S. My wife passed away at about 5.30.

2C 101Wy~:LL~ä�*Ó™rÐ��~Z!5ÿGÅ´ª»f™™�c

C3X åÔz{âÞ~��YNÔÂQyâzgq�3Nóó201

For reasons mentioned in my last letter.4C 581

I would like to see more Muslim teachers like him.5C 002

Æ�0õTg÷zs�XZy~ZDwäZL*y: P.S. Wy~Æ!g}~óóZ:q�~¶X)Qg�zF3 Mc Taggart's Philosophy

Ô�zx:m682(X ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä Æa�&ÀŸ/õ GG:

042

)4(¯[¯x�ZÚiZ£)m391(»W¸iLL{s;�k��óóЃ@ìXZÝ~LL{s;�kуgóóìÔZDwtÐ��ÆO}LLуgóóɉ�XeZg 6C â

ÃÔ:¸¯~�g`HZzg Delhi ™rätÅo™DƒñÂps™�c1Â:qd/õ IG~zŸsÅX

(QƉZÖpÔZÃgc„gÂV»FÀÔ$4èGELâÆZ0g„�g`HŠìX 5)m62Ô92Ô63Ô461Ô902Ô322(qÑètFZW0zg¹qd/õ IG~�boƒåÔQ}FÀ!Ç7�cŠ)}:m561(Zk§bÂ[~7+'ŒÛZg7g„X

T6002YÔm151Ô561 ( ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 Ôm91;2 Letters �&ÀŸ/õ GGåèo 1Ô2DÔm02 Letters �&ÀŸ/õ GG:åâ: 3D

ZÝâ%@gõÔ™Zc-ãzg;~ôpìX 4DÔm581 ì_ç½]Îf^Ù : �&ÀŸ/õ GGåâ 5D

Iqbal in Pictures â: è �&ÀŸ/õ GG@ 6D

172kKÆù´

Page 269: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ѓ@ìXZÏ%AÅ Dear Madam (›7ZHÅç{Æ*xâ»W¸i 6)~ZkâÆ‚BtÄñ��7?ZÏâƬg°â^~7ZH» Letters Â[

C1 Z~2091YÃ]ƒñX B ‚ÁzÃ]8091Y�g`ìÔqÑèz{3è Ѓ@ì)m312(Z�ZÝâ)@ Lahore (HWg&Óå EHÆ*xâ»W¸i 7)

»z7ìX DwÅ’k Z ~t :m09( Îf^ÙWmç…¸Ún6 ] â:~Zq» That you can for him ¯[¯x%iZ·G)m991(ÆWy~{ (8)

!Î~�b¢zg~åX Ãdo �V ÔThat you can do for him ZŸ†™ÆZÐ-V¯�cì:�Ô� zs ÷ ÆZÖp Bar-at-Law (m026Ô¾HÆ*xâ�2ÆWy~ 9)

m53@(~ñ���X :Letters to Atiya ZÝâ�&ÀŸ/õ GG:)(¾HÆ*xâ�7)m13D43(ƉZÖpÔZÝâ~â>{� 10)

(~�ì italics m26Ô36(%Aäâ>{”VÃFiNU) :Letters to Atiya)ZßitßìX”VÃâ>{„¯*oƒåX )m32()11(¯[¯xZ*Z*ÑpƬg°â^~CcŠì�)ätâÔ[ZD

72BZ~2291Y XZkZ±gÐZkÅ@gõ’k Æâøg{71B�Ûzg~6291YÆ�Z[~�å¬ßìXZ¤“Ô6291YƒÔAÌŒÛ+ªk7�´)ä�Ûzg~~ñß!â»�Z[iâ{ˆ)Z~~(�cƒX¯',ZkâÅ@g+÷ GEL’kuZuªÏìX

2(Å@gõ’k91Bm7391YìÔ:�91B�c 2 )21(¯[¯xgZáZŒ)m0ÆZÖpiZZ�X)@ yours sincerely ZzgWy~ Dear 7391YX'×h'WVZ’Z~

Ôm621( q`^áô�m,† D ]Îf^Ù â:ù´~S®ZzgNUż�ZÝoÌñ���Ô}:

9 ß �Partition Partitiou 73

é í 091

Ôm941 i^…mî]æ…mß9ØÒ^ÖsŸaç… 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^272

Page 270: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß �Z0g, Z0g+ 091ÖjÓçÞç]�ã‚]ð ÖjÓçÞç�ã‚]ð 902

9th June 1936 9th June 1939 142Zy{ñVÆ!z��ÔZDwÆfíÒkK~Zkù´ÅZÌtì�Zk~

Z[JÆ�ø[ÓxZôm~èo¦™�b‰�ÔZ%†ZÁ~ÃãÆ*xZôm~Ôm312(Zk~�áïƒäÐg{ŠX ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù â)

ƒZg~ù´ /

ƉZ,ùÌX�q ZDw è kK qgz!ÑxùúVÆ´z{LLƒZg~ùóóŒÛZg�cYYìXYèZy~ic�{FZ-èVŃZgì�x

ùúV~�áï�:~·†ZvŒÛ7äZDwÆ2321èVÆÉZ½‚] …æ|ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ù 1D

@gõzZg%AK�XZKZk»zlÆ!g}~z{��:LLCÙâÅÔZDw„ÆZÖp~3™ÆÍc�gcÃÃi}~c«gÃœs~È™�cìX!Öº�vèV»

7é1ìXóó)m72(1Ãå%Aä¨g7�Ûâc�èoЉ”VcÓVÆZN[Zzg‰ÆFuÃLL3óó7LLZN[óó}ÐX3ÂZLZÖp~ÅYCìXZkZ±gÐZkÂ[~è¹ZDwÆÉ”V)cÓV(Ã@gõzZg%AHŠìX%AäQÆÖÖ}}¸¯~zŸ‚ZÖpc¿Ì�áï™�b�XQßÁDz+zïÆZ±gÐZÍwÂ�âd~ZkÅzŸs™ãec¶X�zx:Â#ZÖpc¿!Îÿþ~�b¢zg~åXZqZzg{òtì�ZDwʼn’kzVÃ

12 Â[HŠìÔ}:â4Ô53Ô373Ô483Ô393Ô287Ô1221Ô22 è LLèoóó¯™�áïz){X‰’kzVÅwZDwÅ»goZzgMgZÅìÔèoÅCÙ¦7Xtù·ÂZgõZzgQÅZÝoÐÌÞZ7ìX

ìÔT~È0wÆjZáÐ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 2D�zuZƒZg~ù·eZËZÜtZW»

372kKÆù´

Page 271: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)ZÍwÔ�zx(Ðâpf�Ô1Zkù´ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä X9èo ‰ ZDwÆ17èo¦KÅZÌtì�Zk~·-ŒÛ7Æ*xZqZzgugZk&�Æ*x&),·èVÆ´z{ÔegZ,âÌ�áï�ÔX»åQ«!g‚tÑcŠìX%A6èo»@Ì�áù™�ïÂù·ic�{z¯ƒ@X)ZkÆTZÍw)1891Y(6gZ¶»-

уgÔ†g~3891Y~�áùƒZåX( ]Îf^Ù…mçmç û{®Z� 1 Æ�zu}Zec)È0wÔ0991Y(~kKÅt®Z�67ƒ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1

]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ÃÔZk~ZëZŸ†ZDwÆ�„â“èVÆ‘½ðk»ìX'×h'WV è ÐsÆ@Ì�b‰�ZzgZq§ Vè )%û:�«YZv(Æ’pZzg)’p”{

qÝl)Ì�áïìXZ0gzãuzgtÅ„g]tì:LLÈ0wZzgZ0zgÐ0ZDw002Y( Æ),·Ô,·kK»ù·óóX�~Z�á®)æX6�÷Qg�zZ»�aÈ0w6

~èVÅ®Z�78JVˆìXè¹ZDwÆ‚B¼LL0]óóÌ�áïÂ[�X~gZk&�ZzgâZ[È0wÆ�Z!èo)¯xZDw(Zzg‰èVÆ@×Zë�XgZk&�Æ�zèo)¸gQ72B#5391YZzg81B�y5391Y(È0wÐZDwÆZZ}zn6'×hgzÝeZs�XgZk&�»ZqZzgâ¯x?ZâZgZ/Ì�áïìX

Q6{mÂz�~ˆìXZ¤p�zuZZecÌ è �}Zec)6002Y(~¡Šg}4Z0Zi~�áùHŠåÔp�}Zec»£g'×hZEyjìXZk~Zq×�âdZzg{à®Z�~£zk»ZŸ†ÌHŠìXZÜtZWägZk&�Ô

ÆjZáÐXï]6cÅ ZDw è kK „kZ{V�ZzgNyŒ{VÆ*xìÔkKÆ‹-VÆK~Z¹ÃZ0Zi™*e:ƒÇX

‰èoUâ~$ó~Ða‰��21B�Ûzg~5391YÆQg�zZzgZôm~èo¯x�m,† ]Îf^ÙVq`^áô 4)'ã(ÐZ~HŠìXtèo Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing ·Ã�Zî�~q

(Ãã�¯D ]Îf^ÙVq`^áô�m,† ~ì@ñ���ÔZÜtZW™rZ¤ZkZÍAâ~)Â'ã™rÅZkt)Zôm~âÅ@gõ’k21B�Ûzg~ì:�12B�Ûzg~(Ð$M

ÔZyÐui�ƒðX 6 »QÜ™äÅ Ò×n^lÚÓ^ing ¸�

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^472

Page 272: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

è kK »tZecZqÆÃÒìZzg ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1 ù¦wЃZg~ùúV~'×hÆK~»[ZÜtZWÅZk»zlоqwæ�AÏX è 6ï ZDw

)2991Y(ZDwÆ07èo6 ÚÓ^ing‰†ÚvÛ‚]Îf^Ùeß^݉nù‚‰×nÛ^áÞ‚æp 3D~ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �ì&03�]ÆÎZ¤ÃZÆ‚B�áùHŠìXtèo

�áï�Zzg.gç~ÅikûzlÐIeZËZºgZ„Z¹¿jZÙÆ‚BZK)уg(~Ì�áù™`�X ‰nù‚‰×nÛ^áÞ‚æp]Îf^ÙÒoÞ¿†Ún6 Â[

)0002Y(Æ*xÐZq �^åÒ^…ì_ç½ 101 ¡Úä]Îf^ÙÒ1 4D†Z°[ŒÛ7äX ù·�áùHìXMy~èV~èÃg{�]»ZqZq�z�zS~¬gsÌ�cŠì

ðýýðýýð

572kKÆù´

Page 273: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDw è ]kK à (`)ZDwÆZùúV~æÍyèoÆ´z{Ô´)ZDwƼ�,·Zzg è kK

)уgÔ6791Y(Å ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù ),·èo)%AZzg)æÍyßg]~ñ���Xì_ç½]Îf^Ùeß^Ýen,Ü+†]Úo(]Îf^ÙVq`^áô�m,†( Z�á®ÆˆgL(}&egù´)

(�áùƒñÔpZ¯[ Letters of Iqbal Ô ÚÓjçe^l]Îf^Ùeß^Ý2ç�â†pÚvÛ‚uŠnà

¬x6M`�XZy~ZZzw è ZÊ-:êGXÆ*xÔ´)Æ�zÎƵn)æzykK©(Æ*xZzgfíÒOZ£ÔfíÒ Ú¿×çÝ]Îf^Ù *†ÔâßZe{ÔZzg´)ÆZ�ÛZ›{0Zy)˜!:

)©gW!��ÁÔ6002Y(ÆkKZë�X)�&ÀŸ/õ GG:m71D91Ô�âpTÎx( ]Îf^Ù…mçmç

ÐeìÔ‰Zô[Æ0kÔZDwÆ'×h),·èoÌñ��ƒV'~Z¤),·Zzg)æÍykKÃÌ�áï™1YñÔ´)ZDw 1C 6031,·èV

Æ�gcÄ”{èVÅ®Z�½ã51ÎJBìXóÃÐè¹ZDw6ó{eZBÔÂù¦tfí{˱FKÐøzxìX9èo»QÌ*³ìXèoÃÜ è

™ÆQ¹æÍy™ä~ËQßwÅcz~7ňÔÉCÙ%AäZK�1úÆ_.ÔT§boƒ�ÔèoÃFK�}™Y\�cXCÙP�kKÔ�zZ÷�

ZDw» è ÆZ±gÐÔZDwÅ�á²~Æ£«~Uâ~QÅwgn�ÔQÌ�ÃÆ‚B%AzæÍyKYä» è txZ�yfí{à]Å^~Ôic�{ÂzZzg�‰Ü

Å ZDw è kK Ãg6ecÔ& è Zi�iŒ7 ]Îf^Ù]æ…Âf‚]ÖvÐ Z`ìXZkK~ŒÛdŒÛdZqVàDz+¹YYìX

ƒÐ¬ÂQg�zÔZôm~ÔÃgÏÔðZzg²!èoÃZµ™�cYñÔQ!±§âÎZyÅ„Zk§bÅYñ:

ZùúV~�áïZÝèoZzg)æÍy,·èo»qݦX 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^672

Page 274: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZÍw:z{èoXÆZÝc@�ø[�X�zx:z{èoX»QRZzg!zNtjZßVÆfg)�ø[ƒZƒXÎx:z{èoXÆZqÐiZZQ�ø[ƒVXXgx:*åZzgbz~èoÔX»7gZQñ��7X

ÃÆ‚B7|™Qy»Q è )1(XèoÆZÝc@ñ��ƒVÔZ¹.e�‰ÜQ~X™õ]»Dgƒñ�ÔQyÐÈ è ÔÜ "54è

GEGE% ZDwÆ è ÜHYñXkK¢zg~ìXQ�ZÝâÆ_.ƒXZ%Z5~p~ÅY$ËìÔ}LL(Að FXõóóÃLLVóó;LLÉÀ;5é XEóóÃLLróó;LL$4/õGEóóÃLL~äóó;z){ÜHYñÔ1Zk§bÆZÖpÅZqz„¯™ÜZs™�~YñX£xz@g+÷ GEL’kâÆW¸i~ìÔÂW¸i~„gìÔWy~ìÂW¸i~:ÑcYñXZDwäZ¤31Y�ìÔÂQÐ3191Y:¯cYñÔZϧbZôm~QÆZôm~&B©¨é EEE]ÌdqhƒVXZ¤œUÃðÂg^Š

¾náÈèożözw#Ö'ŒÛZg X ƒÔÂ!Î~É™qd/õ IG~zŸs™�~YñgZi'¢zg~ìX

)2(z{èoXÆZÝc@ñ��:ƒVÔ1Zy»QRZzg!zNtfgZùÐ�ø[ƒÔQ¹Ng_¬ÆˆJw™1YñÔ@ëZkâqÆèo»ó_·

™Æt�9¢zg~ì�ZÖpZzg_Ô�zâVZ±gÐËâ~Ãð�Z½§�Â70cY@Ô}:LLâzÂ"óóÅ%z`ßFIÃZDwåLLâÂ"óó��Ô®ZZ¤Ë

,·â~LLâzÂ"óó�g`ƒÂQÐLLâÂ"óóÐps™�cYñÔZϧbËâ~s~ÒpÐÃðZ(|xñ��ƒÔ�ZDwÆù¦Z°gÐ_“:g‚ƒÔÂZkÅïÌ¢zg~ìX

)3(ZDwƉèoÆZqÐiZZQX�X�z£â]6®wÔZq„âÆQ~&4èEGOEZ%s0cY@ìÔZk§bÆPèot�:

ÔZÍw:m75 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D¯x·Zº�á{{VÎW!�~m21 V ]Îf^ÙÒ1�ì†p�æ‰^Ù

772kKÆù´

Page 275: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÔZÍw:m06D16 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ÔkK�:m603 ÞÏç� ¯xZ−+;× D2ÔZÍw:m452 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ÔkK�:m592 ÞÏç� 3D¯x·Z}iÛ~ÔZÍw:m124D224 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä :m44 ]Îf^Ù(ìç]inàÒoÞ¿†Ún6 4D¯xHø-V%iZ

m001 : 1C Ô�zx ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä :m102D202 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

ÔkK�:m703 ÞÏç�5D¯x÷ŒZ−+

Ô�c0691Y:m573D673 e†a^á :m4 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

:�Ñð2691Y ]Îf^Ù…mçmç

6D¯xŒÂò

:�Ñð2691Y:m28 ]Îf^Ù…mçmç :m524 2C ÔZÍw ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 7D¯xz©Z£ZkâqÆèoÅYõ6Ä™ÆÔZDwÆ;VZZÖpÆZEwZzgQyÆ

Q|ƒ’kÅgzÝ~×9Q³HYñXt»xZDwÙÎVÆ!bZzgzWFtg}Ѓ*ecX

)4(*åZzgbz~èoÃÐWy~´u{FK�cYñXkKÆK~kKZÊ-:êGXƬgsÔ±Ôï]ÆiZzg–~ è Dz+

ÆZñgÔSàÂzƤ�X‰ñ��{ùúV~Zy»ZÈxHŠìÔ1¬gszjZÙÅâÎZzgQyÅîZªzZ"gz){Æ!g}~ƒÐ¬¼QßwEƒäe454è XGGXZëF+!]¸ì�¬gÃ]z$›Ò3¨é

GGG]~Z"gzYö$åLOÃg¿

YñXt:ƒ�[ZDcË,Æ7g}ÎZö�g`™�bYNÔÉÜsZyÔkKÆ "54è

GEGE% Zñg»f™ƒX»mZDwÐc7ï[ÆËbЃX–~ÔZØ~gpƬ�~�ÔtZ%ˬÝc[Æ�ácÈ�áy7ìÔZkaCÙâ

¢zg]Zk6cÌ¢zg~ìX è Æâ~»:Üsf™ƒ*ecÔÉøÔ ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ýì^áÚvÛ‚Þn^‡]Ö‚màì^7 Ô �^�]Îf^Ù ñ��{ùúV~

ñç¦ùúVÅw à ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý+†]Úo Zzg ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞ„m†Þn^‡p

Ô�zx~ZФt@@`Æ*xCcŠìÔ��g„7X ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1DÔ�zx~ZЯx‚]g×ãCcŠìÔ��g„7X ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^872

Page 276: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

qÝìXZyùúVÃXi{à‹kKQg�zÆeg”VÆîg6�áï™1YñX�á�ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý ~ZzgH¤ZòÆ*xWJèo �^�]Îf^Ù Æ*x'×h�kèoÔ

~7KYNXZy”VƬgÃ]z$›Ò3¨éG

GG]6ÃUã™ÆZ¹'×hYì +†]Úo(Æ]èoà ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù Zzg ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Ô ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä p¿F¯cYñX!¹ùúV)

@gõzZgFK�cYñÔ1CÙ[ZDÆ*xèoŠƒVXXi{à]ÆZôm~{~̸FK'ŒÛZgg¿YñX

»Zqù·Z(Ì»gƒ*ecÔT~ZDwÆÓxèo@g+÷ GEL ZDw è kK’k)iâãFK(Æ_.%AK‰ƒV)cÁZiÁZqZ�ágt„%A™�cYñ(XZkйÐ�Nï]‚tWNÐÔ}t¥xƒÇ�i0ÏÆË

¾§bZèV~Q,VäZLZq„ {m�zg~ZDw»§¯„HåZzg~V Zˆk»ÔZq�ZÖp~ÂZFÆ‚BZÖgHÔ}:51B†g~4391YÆ�zè

ZDwÆìÑ]ZzgZyÆZÖgÅ7ã5±ƒ:¯xgZáZ� ¯x±Ñy0z~

�*Zkz‰ÜZq5úÅZ`ìÔ/ge+ƒg„ìÔuât�Zg~ÆÜsZq˜›xƒg;ìÔ�dzÕyÌZq�~2ìXZyqÑ]~W\Æìw~�*Å]hú~ZsxHæ�™Yì?

Ô81âga9791Y( qß- )

�*Zkz‰ÜÐ�~ìÔ/ge+ƒg„ì'uât�Zg~ÆÜsQZq˜›xƒg;ìX�dz

4q~ìÔ¾n è Õy'Ìqª�ÂĬÝZq5ú»Z`ìXZyqÑ]~W\Æìw~ZsxZk]hú»¹VJ@ƒYì?

ÔZÍw:m181( ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä )

ZDwÔrFïz_¬ÆÔZiaçLâDz+zFKƾè è ¿t�kK�Xt»xTŠgZëìÔQÏÒpÐœz&¢Zzgz‚bzfgZùeLìXeZËÝx

âÔÿËþZD1CZ�Zg}»»xìÔ è ZDwÅDz+ è @fzZ3gÆZÖp~:LLkK

972kKÆù´

Page 277: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

!, C1 YèZyÆ0kgkgeÌìZzgS®zZ�á®Åœ�Zzgëw¤ZRÌóóÔ!ZDwÆ[zÕ�ZKZÐZ�~w~ÌÔZkf)�Zg~Ð~'~Z¯)7ƒMX

ZDw è kK à‹ /

Dz+ ÅZiuâFKz ZDw è kK %A™DƒñgZ¶ä ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 6791Y~Ôm44Ô54(eg'kˆZL),· ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù ÆaPzm7Å�)l):

ó£á)0891YÔZzgikÃ�áù”{:2891Y(~Q²nHŠ��ZDw»txÃÆ‚B%AzæÍyKYä» � é� Å~ÂzZzg›‰Ü ZDw è kK Z�yfí{à‹

ÔTZÍwz�zx:m272@672( i’ÞnÌô]Îf^Ù Z`ìXøZZkK~PzmÌ7XX)@ëà‹kKÅ?mÃgzÑÑä»ZZq¸gCWðÏZöZf±¡@'ãÆuì2Vä]�ø[kKÃgZ¶„ÆXi{èo6��Ðeg¢zV~�áùH:

TZÍw9891Y ¢ZÍwTZÍw1991Y ¢�zxTZÍw3991Y ¢ÎxTZÍw8991Y ¢Xgx

Æ]xùúVÆÓxèoZzg¹Ð)æÍy ZDw è kK ~ Ò×n^l Zk,·Zzg),·èoZzgZôm~èoÆFZW�áïK‰�XZôm~èo6�ñú�{0v,¢@qw�áù7ƒmX

Óx ŧi6ìXZDwÆ�„â“ ì_ç½ô]ÎfÙ Zzg ]ÎfÙÞÚä ~èoÅFK Ò×nl

�X �ø[@ÔèoÆ‚B�áïK‰�X0zgt~¿jZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]Ì�b‰

ZDwÆ]�ø[kKÃqY™Æ�áù™*šd->î IEXZqÆZzg‡.ÞŠg»xìX

Ô¢ZÍwÔÑg{1Ô2:m05 Úr×äÿivÏnÐ 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^082

Page 278: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

'ã™r‰ZdÇzV6ÃgìXWy~z{Pˆ�v}ß/·gZzgCÙc:ÆÍg3gìXQy�™rwÔ!ZWZzg!z‚b¿Æaà‹kK%A™*c

0Îyм�ZDw�z2VZzgp�ZDwZ»�òäèoZzg C1 ™zZ¢¹Â7åXlzg ´¥â]Å�ÛZb~'ã™rÐ�ÛZc�àЬzyHXgZ¶äÌø

HìX ZyÅæ�ÅT»Z,Vä�âd~ZzggZ¶Æ*x‰èo~ÌZ‹Zs»tU Ò×n^l Dz+kK~QÅïZzg¡Ãã�~ZÌqÝìZk

Å«¢6û{™Dƒñ�å:LLZk Ò×n^l ƒÐ$zgìXZke~gZ¶äâÎÆ»xÆa¡z‚b»°7ÔÉZkÆaz{ófztZzgã[ì�

*Z}Qg�zÔº[ Z C2 ZqîswZzgñçq6¼z‰Ü»x™ä„ÐaZƒCìXóóÿˆZiZV Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(]ö…�æ ZDwZ»�òäZL�í)Qy�âVzZµE›Nîy(~ZL 1D

ñÎx/LL$g@îEE0Z»�òóóþ6ZqxzgCZ°kÂHåÔT~Ô˜VJ=c�7@ìÔ»[

�áyZ/SÔ»[ÀpZzÔeZËz©ŒÛ7ÔeZËpZz·i™cÔ»[·Z™Zx,ðÔeZËd�ÛZ¹ÔeZË™'³gz~ZzggZ¶Ñq¸XZ°kƈ9¶ygÁƒ‰Â*T

*òZ»�ò¢/ä»[ÀpZzÔd�ÛZ¹ZzggZ¶ÃZqLL¢zg~tg}óóÆaZL#}~æúHXPxS�OQ�OÅ!ÂVÆ¢™räZKöÆ�gZiÐZq?

ÔZÍw)%û:'ã(»z�{åÔQy Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ù !iðO�{ïw™øg}‚tg3XtäSÐ�9ÑzqHX¼�kˆpZz™rätëƒñƒÃaï�c:LLt ë ÆZZ6

jZÙÂ�gZ£Ãgz¹Æ�ƒñ�Xóó»[ZÚiJß~ÌZ·tÐz;Vñ��¸XZ,Väc�áhËZzgä¹:LLƒYìÔjZÙp�%Aä�ƒVZzgÃgz¹™räZ¹ÜsÜHƒXóópZz™rtÍ™—Z�bXtøg}D~å�eZË�gZ£Ãgz¹Pâ{¬

~šcZzg ÞÏç� YzhÜÆ;V}gì¸XZqgziZ,Vä=Ì�í »[ ™ уgWè¹ZDwňlz�ÛZbÆe~ZKZzg'ã™rŧsЬzyÆa¹XèÃg{!iðO�}~jZÙ)ZkÐsÃ�z{�gÃgz¹™rÆøg{z¯/¸(ëƒÅ

ÅZ�á® Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing ˆZiZV¥xƒZ�ZDwZ»�òä X gZ}~ZEyj:¸Ðmg]™àìX

Ôm03X ]Îf^Ön^io]�hÒ1inà‰^Ù 2D

182kKÆù´

Page 279: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~èÃg{à])`1( C1 ZiidZûY( ]Îf^ÙÒo]ö…�æÞ%† -ãzg;ÆZq£á)~¢6eZËd�ÛZ¹»Zq× � Å47BZÝoQŶy�„ňì)m512(X

èoÅ884ÔZÝoŶy�„ňìX)t×Ô�ÛZ¹™rÆ è _·ìT~Q è Ñë)ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyуgÔ7991Y~�áïìX( ]Îf^ÙV2ß‚Þò1Úf^u& ù”î0p}

Å)¢ZÍwƈ¢�zxÔ Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing ¾qwt�ÛZ¹™rÆZÏ\×»ZWå��z‚wÆzMÐWðÔ¢ÎxÌ�z‚wÆWð(1¢XgxÆ!3�ç EEL¬x6Wä~0õ'kµ‰XqÑ踳ä¢ÎxÆ�âd)%):82B�c2991Y(~tâh‹ð¶

³ LLa¶¢ÌZÏZd£g63991Y~�áùóóƒYñÏXZkßg‹qwÆ!z�� �C2 �Xóó :ÜsåÉRÌ èoZDwÔ »t�úò!Àì�:LLøg~Â[~!

Æ$›Ò3¨é GGG]~ Ò×n^l Dz+Q~jZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]ÅZÌ0ìXikÃÅï "54è

GEGE% ¸³äp�Ì»zlÅì1ic�{FZ,VäkKÆxùúVÆ„6‡HìZzgZÂ1VÐrc)rZzg�ø[zq¢¥â]Ü™�~�ÔZÏaZy~*ûZg~Zzg°xÂZiyÃW@ìX

�]ÆÎZ¤{ÆÂ[ÆWy~{~qY�b‰�Ô¼jZÙÂic�{„îs�Zzg‰ÂFF,]Æxp}ŒÛZg�bYM�XCÙ¢ÆWy~

´¯[ZÊ-:êGXƬgsÔÂÒ]ÅzZZzgZ�ágbÌ�áïK‰�XÅtegzV¢,Zq!z‚bÓäZ�Zg}Qg�zZ»�ò��ä�áùÅ�X Ò×n^l

Z¤Z�á�Dq~лx1Y@ÂZÍw:QŠg}ë~ƒ@Ô�zx:¯[ZÊ-:êGXZzg™ä �]ƬgsZzg$›Ò3¨é G

GG]ÅÂ"ÚƒC)O}CÙ=6ÔÐÑzqÆ(ZkÆË~Zy¢zVÅ�#ÖzB#ÖÌÁƒCZzgZy»_·ZzgZy»ZEwM‚yƒ@Xñ��{ßg]~CÙ¢!g{!g{ÎÐiZZ,]6�ìXa¶¢

ÆWy~ZqÎZq,]6�ZÝo*ó~egzV¢zVÅZÝoÅoňìXðýýðýýð

t£!ZDwZ»�ò0Îyуgä7991Y~�áù™�cåX 1DÔ`3Ôm13X Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^282

Page 280: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:4 ![

x�~£?

�ý�ý�ý�

382x�~£?

Page 281: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

DwÅ�â+ Z ( Z³ )´)ZDwã�~îg6Zq�á²�X�Q,Väè¢zgÔ1‰!©3{5é GGE

G]Æ�Ôc¼�ÛâUVÅ�ÆaXZyÅ�á²~ÂLLâZ}uzlóó¶ÔTÆaZ¹!kxËSà»zlÅ¢zg]7:WC¶Ô1�»çnZåX�á²~Zzg�Ã

ZnKLLWæóóZzgLLWzg�óó»*x�cYYìXQ,Vä¤ÏÆ‚B�óg~ŧs ZLÂz7�~XèVÆ�Z[z{'�Z¸�ÔLQg�zZzgLZôm~~Xk"3ïGGEL

ZDwÅâÎÔQy�0gzVÅ7Ô�ÎaXgÆÔ¤ÏÆ‚BZzgW™�YDC1X �áù™äÆh~:¸ ¹ �ÔZÏaZDwÔÃUãÆ%Q

(ZzgPºtp}ÔZôm~ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� èoÆ´z{ÔQg�z�ÅZqÂ[)t�ZDwÆ�~WUgXB#ÖZzgHÆ ; ~eZËf»£!Ôh]ZzgPp}

Z±gÐÂZDwÅ�ÔZyÆÄ~fí}Æ£«~²7Ô1�~Zzgs~Z±gÐZyÆâÄ~ù´ÔQyÅ�~’kzV6¯Egn�X

-VÂCÙâqÅZã&&}Zð¾�Ô1ÄÍð{µZqzI&¢ìXZ¤Ë¿ÆZ0gt&¢ñ��ƒÂÔZKœZzgÃÒÐÔZkÆa®Å�-VÃ

g¢ÐeìÔpÃð¿…3üELñizV„ÐøzxƒÔ¡œz»zlÐ�á²~7ÅY$ËXZkÆ'@�óg~×ZqÄ&¢ìX¸zzì��Ô/Ú�á²~Æic�{;ðÔœZzgÎeSìX��Æaic�{Zí¹TÔ!‡°ÏZzgZ4Á'×Z`Å¢zg]ìXZDwnZzg'×Z�ÔZyZz™sЬg~¸X8™IÔZq

Í:WiZ�{gz~Zzg�á²Z:'×Z`ZyÅ,6qz~g;X¸zzì�Qy»�~uât×ÁìXZDwÃi0ÏÆZZ�zZg~4+dzZ�!âjwxg;;ZL�zgÅ�0t

:m42 ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^482

Page 282: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Š*z]h Zzg doVÐZ.�}»ñµ5;Q,Vä-g\~Zd½qÝÅ67g~Šg]qÝ ZÖg Ex6oƒ�,kÅàðX_·zWåZzgâ°ZÅ|-.ç

EGÆ

¶XÂÐÂZzg�±Ð�±dZzg�:_Ã~$þGLZŒÒy™äÅ7g~&¢gnÔZkÆ!z��Qy»�~fí{YVÁì?Zk»�Z[ZyÆ�á²Z:'×Z`~ïYìX

ZzgZt~f™W[ì�QÞ,œ~ÆWy~ZcxZzg�,œ~ÆZzZb *¸Ð�gsƒñÔZÍw:Z³×"ìGGLZsxуgÆ k Å5éEO Z ~ÔZDw�zzZTVÐúZxÆ,]XZ³Æ5V~9981YÐ4091YJ Úíˆá ‚Ñ:5V»PÃgxÔ�zx:

ƇgMÐQy»¬gs Úíˆá z{CÙ‚wÃð:Ãð)*yc£!7(Ä7_¸XLLø!óóÆ�á²ÅwЃZZzgQ)�ÆS®é O�®é Op}Æ£«~(ZDwÅ

ÆCÙÑg}Åi“kg�X9�~p}ËZ0gzã Úíˆá àâ]zç1]_"ÅaZzZg7ÔÉ¢zgm��XÍcz{ZDw»!ZÖg7ÔÉ{gYúZï»

Ôm2091Y(TiZ�*y7ÔZqZôm~*y» Úíˆá Åg~gáLO¿�XLLi!ÈQg�zóó)ÔZÆ'3091Y( Úíˆá 6»gH�XLLQg�zi!yº[~óó) 1C Å�gpZ„ Úíˆá FÀìÔ�

Zq�Z!*yìÔ�Zq™rLL"3©5å GEGGL^g�óóŧsÐZDwZzg*øÅ�á²~6KƬ0õ‚w»Z�ágt�¬Yñ Úíˆá X YäzZáZ‹ZŸ]Æ�Ãq~��

tßg�qw‚tWCì:�0g} àâ] �w< 6 1091Y1 01 2091Y1 11 3091Y2 01 4091Y1 9 5091Y

Æa Úíˆá è LLøg~�gpZ„6øg}�z„�·ZDw™rZ*Z}'ZÐ*ø+ 1DÔm2091YÔm1( Úíˆá FÀ™Æ¬�Xóó)

582x�~£?

Page 283: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zk§b0õ‚ßV~Ôà:àâ]Æ£«~0õ�~’kzVů6tIß:ƒÇ��óg~ÐZDwÃ8o9:¶X

),·4091Y(ÌZÏiâäÅ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ZDwÅZÍAZzgzZuQg�z�~"c�ÇgìX6�ëWÐ^™×c™,ÐÔ˧b»_!CZˆkc!_/Zk»øu:åÔÉZkÆZò�@;~‰�v!©3{5é GGE

G]�áï¸XZôm~~¬!Z}ZzgQ8ZÝe~Æ(ZzgZJã»çV Development ZDwÅ«"

ZyÆ�~WUg~¹ Reconstruction Ãè�XZyÅ�zu~Zôm~Â[ è Æ7úcVÑgƒCìXZk~�áï‚]h]ZdZz‡]~ZzgZk¢zg]Æ�»gK��Z¹ZZ½¬]~7™*åXZDwÆ!¹�~uâñ~Ìic�{F

zÔ�Z!’kzV»ì)×E™{WÐW@ì(ÔOçZDwÅ�ÔZyÆÄ~WUgÆ£«~Uâ~wgBìXQg�zÆ�~Z�[~ZDwÅ�¾£xz%¥Åqïì?�VZkc»ûìZzg:ñµÔ@ëZkK~ZqbÅÜZs¢zg~ìX

eZ˱†Zv��: ZDwÆ!g}~‰Õ�zVÅWgZ5±ÙX è�Qg�z�~|]´)äZ¤pÁ�Ôpz{dQ|[»Zq»�g8Qg�z�Ã�}

Z0Zi{ì�ZDwZ¤�á²~:™DZzg�„�ÔÂÌz{Qg�z�~%iZÅ �'÷ZZCtC1 ghYD'�á²ZDwÔZq»�§i»�ógÌåX â#Zq{m�{yc�Çg

6zW·¢yë�:XZô[ä´)ZDwÅ�»Ng_·HìÔQyÆ�w~Zk�äÌz+„(

C2 aZ™àìÔ�ZkÐI^�ç ILZDwäaZŶXeZËÝx@fzZ3g»ìwì�:ZDwZ¤�~Z�[ŧsÂz™DÂGZkyZy~ÌZyÆZ�!»g*óZL

$ÖÝlghYDÔpZ�!ðÆZk�Z]}~z{ZqW�|¡�3™™s RyC3 ò��'ZDwZq™8ïEL§iQ|[óg�X

:m71@81 ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù 7ÂÔ 1D:m64 un^lô]Îf^ÙÒ^]mÔq„e^io�æ… 2D

Ô†g~6791Y:m03@04 Journal of Research ZDw»Q|�ógl:�! 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^682

Page 284: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

eZË„�]'w~��:ZDwäZgD*��ÆZâZ`ÐZLZ0Z¯�»‘Ñ»gHZzgP‚w~z{Zq

C1 ºmQ|��Åú~»x[ƒ�ÔTäZ¹Zq™8ïEL§iZ¶6�Zi¯�cXÝx�Œgæ»ìwì�:

C2 Qg�z~t§’k»�ªZKVwW\ìXZyZ½‚]~LLZ¤óóÐÑzqƒäzZà!]¡Zq*Óx‹]ìZzgZÖ§

ÕÅZqßg]ÔZkaPZV‡&ÿELÂz7ìÔ1ZyƒÒ*]~�uNtì��á²~„ŧbQg�z�~ÌZDwZq»�g8Æ™8ïEL§iZ¶6�Zi�XgZ¶Æìw~t!]{àI¾WöìXZz6ÅTg~�cÅ�ÔZkÐt³zZã

ZDwÆg8z è ì��á²~Æ£«~ZyÅ�Uâ~wgBìX˜VJ�W}»mìÔZDwÅŠg�Òy~¯x7Xz{ËËñçq6ZCâ°ZÅ|-.ç

EGZ�Z

™äÅ7g~7g~&¢gnÔ1ZyÆ]�~WUg‚tgOÔÂZk~F§bÆg8ÃWD�Ô}:Zqz{g8ì&eZ˱†ZvZzgÝx�Œgæä

TZÍwÆ�âdZzg e1ìç�p è …Úç‡ TZÍwZzg ]‰†]…ôìç�p ¦:Zzg¬Ó:�¹ìXÆe~zŸ‚Zzg�Z!p}ZDwÆZkg&ëEYL�ÅúÒÏ™D�X ]‰†]…ôìç�p

¸òi0Ï(~Ô„g]Å‚�ÏzgzZãZzg" c ‰p})}:”VŽzF�Zzg æ›à èu±ÆªÃWD�Xñß~Z¶YZv{VZiñ è $¹Ò¨é GE:Z0ZiÅzzÐZDwÔ�

~�,œ~ÆW¸iÅgzâã’qÆZWZ]¸ 3C Ò¤CÙ�+Æ*xîsèocVì' ú C4 ~–weZËÝx@fzZ3gZqÍ:.Zzgpª Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �X

Zk§bZDwÅù¦�ÂtgnƒñQ¹LL»�Zzg™8ïEL§iZ¶ógóóI�g„7¥xƒ@X

:m27 ]Îf^ÙÒo]ö…�æÞ%† 1D:mLLbóó Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù �âpÔ 2D

:m47D301Ô402D012 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù D3:†g~6791Y Journal of Research D4

782x�~£?

Page 285: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

èZDwÐ0ZqZzgN‡&ÿELÂzìX�~Q,VäQg�zZzgZôm~Ãfg$œî G0 è�ZÖg¯cXt¥xì�ZDwQg�zÆ6�lqò¸ZzgZkÅFzózF¹~�~�pgn¸Xñß~†Z/Æ*x4Bm6391YÆâ~�:LL÷~—ãÖÔ�´

Q82Bm7391YÃ�:LL»l~ZKi0ÏÆ!¹�yW\Æ C1 ÖÐÁ7óóX²~»Qg�zzÔ�~p}ÔÒ*]ZzgèoŹ �á C2 ‚Bg{™Qg�zÅ}#Ö™YXóó

Æ�zg Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� (~®Z�ÔQg�zi!yд)ZDwÅ�wÕZzg�w8o-ö FF»1�X)�,œ~ÆW¸i(~ÔZqdi!yÅwÐÔQg�z¼Z+F¹cC:¶Zzg

çâ]�‚³®6Qg�z~¼r{™ÂåÔQÌZDwätÂ[Qg�z~èX1Qg�zi!yÐZkÓxF�w8o-ö FFZzg›Æ!z��ÔZyÅ�»ic�{FzZôm~

(ÂQg�z~�ÅRö„:¶Ô Development ’kzV6�ìXeZËf»£!)ZÖg Q,VäQg�zÆO}Zôm~Ãfg$œî G0 ~Ì Reconstruction p×Zë"

¯cXh]Æ´z{QyŽkzVZzgÒ*]Ź(~®Z�Zôm~~ìXZqÎÆÓxF Stray Reflections ÆŒÛdèoÌZôm~~’kK��XeZ]~

•gZ]ÌZôm~~�XHZDwÔtƒQg�z~:ÉM?Qg�zÆ!g}~ZÖ§ Æ!z��Q,VäZq$+i!yà zZãLL—ãÖóógpZzgZk»ZÖg™ä

_»fg=YV¯c?'ZkÎZw»Ô2+2=4ŧbÔ�zIu�Z[W‚y7ìÔ@ëè¹ZDwÅgzÝ~Zôm~д)ÅZkgÉÅz�{�lÅY$Ë�X

†Z°[¼Æ*xZqâ~ZDw��:LLi!yÃÔ~Zq"¦g7™@cTLL—ã Í C3 TÅ6-ÅYñÔÉZÖ§_»ZqZãfg=ìw™@ƒVóóX

Öóó»Q,Väñß~†Z/Ðf™HÔz{ËnÅtÖcZ0S¡:¶ÔÉ9.3ïGGL¸òÅZq¶XQZDw'×hzŸs™D��i!yZÖ§_»ZqZãfg=ìXß°+Æ*xZqâ~��:LLíÃ!g;Zk»Š/ƒZì�Qg�z~W

Ô�zx:m87D97 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä D1:m28 Zs D2

ÔZÍw:m65 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^882

Page 286: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

t!]Z'çLzZ§7Ô¡ 1 C1 ™Dƒñ~ZLâ°ZÅ|-.çE

GÃZh§bZ�Z7™YóóÔZDw»ZqZˆkìXZÏ;CZˆkä¾e0™ÔZkìwÅZ(g™à�‰{mp}z_»ZÖgÔZôm~„~eìÔcÁZiÁQg�zÅÚZôm~~4ZÖgƒYìX

t¥xì�ZDwäZôm~jßVÔ»œVZzg-ãzg-V~ZK½åÅX'¤â~ÂĽÆZyZ�ZgzV~:Üsfg$œî G0½Zôm~åÔÉZôm~i!yzZ�[ÅDgöZqÑiò*yÅwЃC¶XÄzZ�[~8o9zgÉÆ

:ÔZDwäZôm~i!yzZ�[»×ic�{�w8o-ö FFZzgÂzÐ_·HXQÍgZ})oVÃZôm~i!yzZ�[ÅDgö »ÒуgÆiâUâ~ZÚzfZzg!

ÌQyÆfó¶XQyÆZq�á¤�Z*ZÅ»Òyì��á²~7JDƒñÔLLƒÐ¬ZÃgÅ=ôZk§b™DÔTÐQyZÃgÅ/pçV6ÌgzÝ7C¶ÔZk%µÆˆikcZôm~ZÃgŧsázƒDZzgZ,�wecZñ~Qy»ÈÒy™D�½ãå|xZzgÄ~4ZQzZãƒY'XtÓx¼Zôm~~ƒ@'QyÆ7J仧iZÚ�w¿å�¸�ZyÆ]~ÓxZ‚E{Æ£«~ic�{

¦gZÔ ZiZVZd½Æa-g\�ÔÂQy»ic�{Fz‰Ü‰`~ ˆ C2 gSóóX q¢~˜VdZzg(Z±gÐZ¹4+âjwxWcXZàyÐzZ36‡âã6?Æiâä~°ZpV~Ìz_5Ïî G0WZôm~åÔZk§bZzZ&ÿJL/~Zôm~i!yÐQy»�gZ‚‡ìƒZåÔz‰ÜÆ‚Bz{ic�{Q2ZgZzgLƒ@�XZkÆË~

8aZƒ�ÔÉz{Zk~CÙ§bÆÂ_ZzgZ�t è Zôm~i!yÐZqo9ä6̇�gƒ�XZôm~6Zk)©à�,käZDwÃZôm~�� ìÑ]Z�Z™

ŧsgZáHX{µdZzg�:_ÃÔQg�zÜ×5i!y~Òy™ä~�)]7WC�Ôz{Z�Òy7XZDwÆiâä~ÂÔt)]ZzgÌic�{�XQZq

ÔZÍw:m74 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D:m621 ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä 2D

982x�~£?

Page 287: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Z,¿ÆaÔT»‚gZd:©Zôm~ƒÔËdZzg�:ñçq6W™DƒñÔZLâ°ZÅ|-.ç

EGûx!ÐQg�z~zZã™*Ô*e7ÔÂZ•ð¢zgìX

Zk~t}Ìì�zŸ8ïGL|x~Ãð¶g{YñX‰Zôm~p}ÔSîh]ÆZôm~�k»¸�ZiìXÝx�.8Æ*xZqâ~ÔZDwäh]Ð0�zŸsÅìÔZkÐikcZ6¼ZzggzÝ7CìX��:

Zy)zVÆ#¥ic�{Fz{�y�Ô�f!�ÐMW�ZzgZk!]ÆpZéq��¡Òiªî EE0ZsxáÒiªî EE0]hÆZÖp~ÒyHYñÔZzgZ¤6Zä+B5Õä

GEGO]~

{xV�ÔÂQyÃg«HYñX÷Z»xic�{Fy~ìZzgZky~Ô~ä¡Òiªî EE0ZsxÅ4+gzZc]ÃÅp{§g3ìÔ1~ìw™@ƒV�Qg�zpZV�*Ã�áhZyÐÃZ{:ãÔYè¹Ï!ÂV»DÔ~ä�Ûn™1ì�7"zZácGzZáì

C1 ÐqÝìÔZkÆ%eg{:åXgZ¶Æìw~ZDwÅZkzŸsÆÔ'×h˱Ţzg]7gSXt

ÒyÔ�Sîh]~Zôm~Ãfg$œî G0ZÖg¯äÅ6g~Ô�ZiZzgQkÅÕÃl!ZY¤™@ìX/Z±gÐZDwÅZôm~�HwgBì?Zk»Y{Z3ÿXL×zÄ

g~ áM�Ô@ëZkK~�z!'¹zZã�;ZÍw:ZDwÃZôm~i!y67ñµ¬Ó:Zôm~�Zzg è �,kqݶÔ�zx:’kz½k~z{¹ZhÔ9Zzgø

1%6‡�g¸X

ðýýðýýð

ÔZÍw:m012D112 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^092

Page 288: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~£? � ([)

ZÑO� æD /

Z}™äÆ31#9981YÃZDwZzg@»Òуg~.e²ægigHg Z*ƒñXgig’Æ�ÛZ$ú

JEL>~@gõZzg7Å541¹ÿ GHGZ»âòÅDgöÆ´z{Zôm~c

»[ Political Economy (Å Fawcett Z�!£?»Qg�zFÀÌ�áïåXÆ)~�áï¶XZk§bZq§sÂz{ZO�c]6�gk�ïgìÔ�zu~§sQ,Vä

C1 Qg�zFÀ»gHX n» Political Economy (Å" Walker zZ™)ZyÅ!›Ð)é:i0ÏÆZ-xÁÆ:© Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ZDwÅZÍAQg�z"

Å@;ÃZDwÆgig’Æ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ~"Å�XeZËÝx@fzZ3gäŒÛZg�cìÔ1Q,Vägig’ƸZ‘åL5i#ÖÅgzÝ~.e C2 �ÛZøÐzZh

²ægigÆ�&>�ÛZøÿ)1(-ãzg;,¬]ÅS®~Z¬-)2(Zôm~þÒyK�ÔTiZ�"ÔZyÆ�Z]Ò»g~7 3C Dgö z²!Â1V»FÀ)3(

»]4ïEEL@;�Û>:åÔZ%teì�Zk Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� WCX¯',øgZìwì�§b»@d»x!›Ð)é:»g™�ÏÆîg6/$�ç EELZIy�¬Y@ƒZzgZDwÆf‚~t

Æ@dø»]~tZ%ÔZkaÌŒÛ#èGELªkì�Zzg@ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� !]ñ��ƒXº[-ãzg;rgzVZzgZzg@»ÒÅ‚Ñ:g7gIVÅã�6Ôt¥â]eZËz©ŒÛ7Zzg 1DeZËÝx@fzZ3gä½Å�)�&À�/õ GG:LL´)ZDwÅ(i0Ïʼn¬]óó�!:

Ôm503D623ZzgLLZDwZzgZzg@»Òóó:�!: Ò¡‰nÓo]�hÒ^ivÏnÏoÚ_^ÖÃäÔº[-ãzg;уgÔ�Ñð7791Yz†g~8791YÔm38D011(X Journal of Research

Ô†g~6791Y:m7 Journal of Research 2DÔ�Ñð7791Yz†g~8791Y:m201 Zs 3D

192x�~£?

Page 289: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

A new work Ã!,ZÖp: Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� »ÒÅ‚Ñ:g7g^1091YD2091Y~ik"ZyÅ‚Ñ:»g™�Ï~ÑgH�ìX 1C

of Political Economy in preparation

ZO�c]QyÆ X (i0Ï~ZDwÅÂz²!ÔZôm~Zzg�ŧsg„aZq*DåÔ1Dg+»çVÆ�Q,VäZk»ËŠgzW_·HƒÇZzge

(Ì»gKƒVXZÏZz~Ô6�z{�âd~� Study Notes ìÔï�_·)Òy Â[ŧsázHXWg&Óå EHÐZDwÅzZÕZ� è 6zWWg&Óå EHä@; ��

�»¯g~øuU"ƒZX¿t�ÔZÍw:‘ÐêL Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� 7ÔOçQy»Âz�Ñ*ZO�c]»@i{_·Ô�zx:Wg&Óå EHÅ’qZzgÎx:"»>»g™�Ï~Ñgƒ*'

�»ÚZZVcX Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ÃQ,Vä è ZyƒZñgÆ7Zz6f™W[ì�Zzg@»ÒÅ‚Ñ:g7g^)1091YD2091Y(~èÃgì��

·ZDw7Å541¹ÿ GHGZ»âò6Zq5Â[»g™gì�XZkÐt³Z~HYYì�091YJ 5 YÐ 9981 »W¸i1091YÆÛWycZzZb2091Y~ƒZƒÇX Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^�

2C ZDwÆZcÄ5i#ÖÅÂEZk§bì:Â}:42B�y9981Y( ½g�g.e²ægig) 31B#9981Y

‡ì£xZk6zWZôm~ÔÍg»ÒÔуg 4B†g~1091Y@13Bâga2091Y.e²ægigÔZzg@»ÒÔуg 1BZÆ'2091Y JBZ6s2091Y@7

‡ì£xZe¾6zWZôm~ÔÍg»ÒÔуg 81BZÆ'2091Y@13Bâga3091Y.e²ægigÔZzg@»ÒÔуg JBZ6s3091Y@13B#3091Y¬gèZk6zWÔÍg»ÒÔуg 3B�y3091Y@5091Y

Ò¡‰nÓo]�hÒ^ LL´)ZDwÅ(i0Ïʼn¬]óó�! : fZ!eZËz©ŒÛ7 1DÔm823 ivÏnÏoÚ_^ÖÃä

)�zx(Ô ]uç]Ùæ�$^…]Îf^Ù ) tÂEeZËz©ŒÛ7ÔeZËÝx@fzZ3gZzgeZË·!ŒÛ 2DŽ™�{¥â]ÅgzÝ~%AÅ�ìX m1@51Zôm~zX(

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^292

Page 290: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Æ@d�zg~Qy»ic�{Fz‰ÜÍg»Ò Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ZkÐzZãì�уg~¦gZXÍcÂ[ÆW¸i)1091Yc2091Y(ÐZkÅZ�á®)4091Y(Jeg‚w~ÔQ,Vä½ãââ{»¾²�Zzg@»Ò~¦ZgZX

ƬZec6‚ÁZ�á®�g`7ìXZkzzÐZkÆ‚Á Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^�Z�á®Æ!g}~ZDwÆÎZöógzVÆ;V��Ò*]X�XÒ·�+¯t

¤CÙ C2 ‚´äšjZ!tÆÒyÃ�CÙZ�cìX C1 HX 7 é� äÂ[Æ‚ÁZ�á®»çÆ;V‚ÁZ�á®»f™„7MXÂÒ]ógzV~ 4C ZzgeZˆZ?xpgæ 3C Ãgz¹

C8 Zz†Zß© p C7 Ô2kZ£ 6C Zzg†ZDzpZzâgZÞ 5C ЇèZ£xVZº�*¥Sä1091Yä3091YÃÂ[»‚ÁZ�á®CcìÔ1Zkß.ìx™ä~ C9 Zzgg<Z−+;×

T�zxÔ1691Y(ù�4ìÔT»W¸iZk Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �iŒÆZk�âd)ˆZiZVZÏT�zxÆ C10 3091Y~�áùƒð¶óóX Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ¿Ðƒ@ì:LLZDwÅ

Æ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ~TZÍwÆuzgtÆîg67H�X Iqbal in Pictures uzgtìZecÅÂ"&ŶÔ1T�zx»tuzgtNU~ìXZk6&~

Â×Ü ) LL3091YóóÉ�c�ìZzgZÏ@äP™{!Ñß.ÆaÍc¤&½ÅÔ65±ÙXZk6‚ÁZ�á®�g`7ì(X {Ò TZÍwÆuzgt»@W ]ŸÎj’^�

m18( : ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù èXóó)fZ! Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� æy6ZqÂ[¯x è ~(„ ¯t��:LLZÏiâä 1DÆ*x Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� („æy6ZqÂ[ è ‚´ÆZÖp�:LLZkiâä~´)äD 2D

:m24( ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù ÐQg�z~èXóó):m33 ‰n†lô]Îf^Ù 3D

:m34 ‰†+„�kô]Îf^Ù 4DÔ�Ñð@m1791YÔm78þ ]Îf^Ù ÿaZ£eZgäÌ1091Y�ì:C :m41 ]Îf^Ön^lÒ^ißÏn‚pq^ñˆå 5D

:m2 Bibliography of Iqbal 6D:m84 Ò×n‚ô]Îf^Ù 7D

:m31 A Bibliography of Iqbal 8D:m61 Òj^en^lô]Îf^Ù 9DÔT�zx:m1 Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� 01D

392x�~£?

Page 291: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^492

Page 292: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Æuzgt6'Æ*xÆ‚BLLZk6zWóóÍg»Ò Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^�уgóóÆZÖp�g`�XZzg@»ÒÐ3B�y3091YÐgÁá™ÔZDwät

ÆÑg{Z6s4091Y Úíˆá £eÑXÍcÔÂ[Zk@gõƈ„Ëz‰ÜåƒðX»Wy~zÔ>ZyLLW!�~óóZkâ^Æ‚BÖ:LLÂ[ikTìóóX ]ŸÎj’^� Â×Ü ~

)m1(XÍcÂ[4091YÆZzZb~åƒðZzgÂ"Æa�}�~�ZzgZq![~Z�á®Æa��c�X¸ªktì��Ûzg~ÆWy~câgaÆ Úíˆá

ÆÑg{Z6s~ Úíˆá Z’ZðZcx~�ƒðÔYèZÏßg]~Wy~![ÅËqeƒðX

eZËÝx@fzZ3g��:LLtÂ[3091Y~åƒ_¶ZzgZkz‰ÜZDw'*¸Tg~ëä C1 ó Íg»Ò~Ô�áhZkÅÂ"Ì3091Y~ƒ�ƒó

ZDwÆZcÄ5i#ÖÅ�ÂE%AÅìÔZkÅgzÝ~13Bâga3091YJÂÔZDwÍg»Ò~‡ì£xZe¾6zWgìÔJZ6sÐ13B#3091YJZ,VäZzg@»Ò~.e²ægigÆ�ÛZøZ�x�bZzg3B�yÃÍg»Ò~Zk

å:ƒð¶)zg:uzgt6z{LLZk Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� 6zWHgƒñXÍc3B�yÐIÂ6zWÔÍg»Òуgóó:�(XZ¤Â[3091YÆWy~Zcx~Ìåƒ�ƒCÔÂ

(Wy~![>Zy C2 )t¥xì�u†ZØ�gåZDwÆg¥��Æ|ÙgT¸XLLW!�~óóÔ†g~c�Ûzg~cic�{Ðic�{âga4091YÆÑg}~¾Y@XÑg{Z6s

~ZkÅZ�᮪CÙ™Cì�Â[»t![�Ûzg~âga4091Y~��ƒÇZzgt!]Â!Ç„êZiªkì�LL�áhZkÅÂ"Ì3091Y~ƒ�ƒóóXZ¤zZªZ(å

Úíˆá ÂQÂ"”{»kVÃ�zeg7Ô7g}�kâ{JgzÆgpÅH¸e¶?ÆZq![ÅZ�á®Æ‚BÂ[ÆikTƒäŸ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� Z6s4091Y~

~Zk!g}~ÃðZ:qcZ´y7MXÍcZyV Úíˆá �~�¶ÔâÞ4091YJÔ~tZ´y�áùƒZ: Úíˆá ~Â"zS®Æ%ZiðƒñÔ©��c4091YÆ

Ô�Ñð7791Y@†g~8791Y:m401 Journal of Research 1D:m35( ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ) ¯xt:LLÄì�LLp�ñizVƒY@ìÔu�†ZØ�gáYD�Xóó 2D

592x�~£?

Page 293: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~ Úíˆá ë*ø+Ã(~pÙÐtZ:q�ï��t‡&ÿELŠgÂ[T»Zq![C1 �áùƒ[ìÔ¾™»gƒ�ìX

» Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �cÆÑg}~�áù”{ZkZ´yÅgzÝ~tIß:ƒÇ�C2 ¬x6WcX è© ªZecâÞ4091Y~¾™

Æ�âd~��:LL(ˆãæÙ÷}]bÆ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ´)ZDwC3 ���Q,VäZkÂ[Ɖ”V~i!yÆ0‡&ÿELŠgZ&b�~óóX

~4091Y»Zq¤z\¯I�áïH� Iqbal in Pictures ¸�tZ6s4091Y»f™ìXìÔT~ZDwZzg(�zâVñ���XZkÅã�6¹YYì�4091Y~ZDwÔñÑ*(ÐAƒVÐX

Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� „CÙt!]ÐÏ@ì�”Á½ÆaZàyYDƒñÔZDwä»z�{ZL‚BáYä»ÂZÈxHÔ1Ãð,·:á�Xeì�zeg¢,

ÐzZãƒ@ì 4C á�ƒVZzg�z„Zx[Å2g™�~ƒVX¾HÆ*xZqâ»Ãðñ��:åÔ&z{¾Ã7™DX Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �Z6s7091Y~QyÆ0k

ZzgZDwäjZä»ZgZ�{ÌHÔ1¾H»Òyì�: ¶C5 y*y~Â[�ø[Iqbal presented his original M S of Political Economy to me.6C

t61B�Ñð7091Y»zZ§ìÔˆ~t!iðO�{6zWWg&Óå EHÃvƒ�X

Ô�c4091YX Úíˆá 1DÆÑg{�Ûzg~5091Y~6zWÕ�©gW!�~Æû}Ð4091YÅ@GƒC �Òà…mçmç 2D

уgÔÑg{ ÞÏç� ,· �Òà…mçmç ìDD�&À�/õ GG:eZËZº©g~»ª~»*y::m78(Zzg·Ú{Ãgz¹ä ‡Þ‚å…æ� �041ÿ2991YþXeZËYzhZDwä¡LL4091Yóó)

Ô†g~6791Y:m96( ]Îf^Ù…mçmç LL�c4091Yóó�ì)ÔTZÍw:m7 Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �âpÔ 3Dm21 :Letters to Atiya 4D

»Z3g�áùƒ@g;XWy~!g#8091YÆÑg} Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ~z²Vz²VÐ Úíˆá 5D~�áùƒZX

m91 :Letters to Atiya 6D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^692

Page 294: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�: âga7191YÃ6zWsbZ−+·Z1k'ãÆ*xZqâ~� ´)ZDw8Bï�¶'W\Å"Qg�zi!y6ZqZˆÈxìX=tì Òj^h]ÖÛÃn�k

C1 6t«Â[ìZzgCÙUлïX DZÑO� ~fgZÌ@ï7�Qg�zi!y~6Qg�z~ DZÑO� ½ã0õ�ˆ51BZ6s7191YÃ'gZY¨6�á��á�Ã�:LL

yÒ*]~§�ìX„CÙZk»:¸ì� Z C2 ƒÐ¬RÂ[~äèóóX8BâgaÆâ~ZDwäZigZ{zä�Zg~Ô'ãÅÂ[ÃLLQg�zi!y~DZÑO�6«ZzgCÙUлïÂ[óóŒÛZg�ïƒñZyÅj,Z‚ÛZðÅÔ1ZÏiâä~©gW!�;ðÃg^Å*ÆaZDw»*xÌikgåXZkK~¯[¯x�á�~ZLÎZ¤

�� ÅZkZqÐi~w»f™¢zg~ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ZzgAÃZÅ,�ƒñZkñçq6LLƒÐ¬RÂ[óóQ,VäèX

@;zZ�á®Ð¬DZÅ.›4iïGIG6Qg�zi!y Å Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� |tì�~ÁZiÁiÂÁ�áùƒ_�XZy~Ð0õÂZôm~Â1VÆFZW¸ÔZ%

)r:·ëg�á{{Vz·&��á{{V(WiZ�Z:gz�ÆÔ ÖäÂ×Ü]Þj¿^ÝÚ‚á …‰^

Ãçâ]6Qg�z~« Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ZkZ±gÐ C3 �gZqTiZ�"Æ��XÂ[ŒÛZg7�cYYX

Æ{�xZ³M6öуg~TƒZX µnŠä]ìf^… »ªZec Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^��gx:ìÔjZÙ×!gqÐ�ÔuzgtZzgZkÅ1Æ,]�Ñg7K

�X7¿)Z[(m16ìÔz„p}m26Zzgm3{àìX�âp)&ZDwóó�ì(m4@7Zzg$4èGELÂ[m8ÐÑzqƒ™m6126»ƒY@ z ä!ÑoZxLL�â

ìXÂ"p[ßg]ìÔ1¹ÐZÖpŠ*Z5Æ_.���Ô�R[ázuƒ[ìÔ}:7�)7"(Ô^˜õ)[(ÔrÏ):ƒÏ(Ô�y)�V(Ôsy)sV(Ô

ÔZÍw:m904 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D:m54 �^�]Îf^Ù 2D

óó�!: Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ,Æa5±ÙÀpZz»£!:LLZDw»ªd»g*)Ô 3DÔZDw�7791YÔm553D083 ]ö…�æ g‚!

792x�~£?

Page 295: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

(Að FXõ)V(Ô#y)#V(ÔYz})Yñ(Ôn�à)n�á(Ô(Y*)(|Y*(Ô\+A>î EX)�(ÔðV)qV(ÔZÍ)ZÌ(z){XÂ"ZôoÐÅ�ìÔQÌ}}Â"

ÅZÝoÃWC�Ô}:9 ß S �

¼ ´43ïEEH 61 7™D�ÔZ�Zi ™DXZ�Zi 71 9ÅgzÐ Ågz}Ð 41 11Ð ì 21 42ec eT 31 63@ u 8 65¦V DV 6 36¡ÆÜs ¡ÅÜs 4 46ÁƒÏ ÁƒV 7 57YZ YY 8 59

¿ ç 41 621ÃZñ “5åEEZñ 7 731ƒ*ì ƒ@ì 91 741

»f™™Dƒñ��:tÂ[ZKZ�á®Æ¼ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� 6zW·¢yÔC1 ²�ˆ!iZgЄ¸Tƒ�X

#8091YJÂDîg6�Ûz|Æa!iZg~ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� tf™W[ì�~Zk»Z3gÖå(eì�ZkÆÌ�ø[g„ Úíˆá ñ��¶)YèZÏâ{

ƒX¾qwâÞ4091YÐ#8091YJ‚hñ&'kƲááLL¼²�óóŒÛZgÔ†g~4691Y:m29 ]Îf^Ù…mçmç 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^892

Page 296: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�b�g„7ÔQ6zW·¢yä¬ZecÆ»ƒä»TZ0Zi~f™HìÔÿLL!iZgЄ¸Tƒ�óóþZkÐt@WMì�Â[˵"Æ�Zzg%æFNZuZg§jÐ!iZgиTÅ�ÔqÑè:ÂZkÅ¢zg]¶Zzg:wZ(ƒZX

t�g„ì�Â[»ƒä6ÔZDwä�zu}ZecÅ¢zg]Ck7ÅX�á²~Æ9ùúVÃQ,VäZKi0Ï~!g!gVZä»ZÈxHÔ1ZKZÍA

C1 "Å�z!g{Z�á®Å§sz{Láz7ƒñX»�zuZ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� «Z�á®Æ*zy‚wÔZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔ™Zcä

Zec�áùHXZk6‚ÁS®�g7Ô1�iŒÆ7ÂÅ@g+÷ GEL’k)01B�y1691Y(ÐZk»‚ÁZ�᮳™*Â7ìXuzgtZzgZkÅ1»�Ñg~7Ñc

�{àìX7Â)Zi�iŒÔm1@01( �Ôz„Ô,]Z³Ô[Ô`6�g`ìÔ�l))ZiZâgZDwŒÛ7Ôm11@91(7¿)Z[Zzg'Ôm12(Zzg�âp)Zi

âÑgƒ@ìX�zu}ZecÅ è Â[Ð,]»Ziu è 'Ôm32@62(ƈQƒÐZë!]ÔTZÍwÆQÅoìXuzgt6%A»*x�g`7Ô1�âd~

Æækçzy ]Îf^Ù…mçmç ÅoC �iŒäzŸsÅì�:LLñ��{°ÆQ»[pgæZ£™rÅÃ@VÅ%ƒÈ5ìóóX)m9(%AäFçzoÆe

fsâÎÅp´VcZŸ±K�: è ~øÂ[0õ”V~ËìXCÙ{ÆÑzq~ZqZqzgt»¡Ò3ï E

GF¯ )1(Z1Z[Å,�~�ì)ªzÜsZq![6� è ™Zk6´{ÆÁz+

ìÔ®ZZkÆ‚BLL![ZÍwóó)m3(�Å¢zg]:¶XTZÍw~ÌtZÖpñ��7�(X

ZDwÅzZu"ìÔ�Q,Väp�T™ZðZzgp�„�Ûz|™D¸ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� 1DÔ�c4091Y(1Zk Úíˆá )LLZkÂ[Å7ÜsZqgz\ìZzg'Ðï$ËìóóX

Â×Ü ÆˆZKÂÁZk§b�Ûz|™ä»ìQ,VäL70ÑXeìÅ�Ûz|»Š/âúg;ƒX ]ŸÎj’^�

992x�~£?

Page 297: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)2(çâ]ÅQg�zZ�q]ÆZôm~áZ�Ã]Ôqd/õ IG~�b��X)3(Â[ÆWy~LLZyçÙZ�q]»Zôm~FÀ�ZkÂ[~

ZEwƒð�óóÆikÄZy�k,]»Zqe�áïìX)4(%Aä0zg¹qd/õ IG~‰áZ�Ã]Ôçâ]Å{mZ�jVZzg

¢zg]¥ô™�~ìX)5±Ù:,]3Ô6Ô01Ô81Ô32Ô è )bÆ!g}~ø92Ô44Ô35Ô65Ô58Ô901Ô121z){(X

)5(Â"ÅZÝo�g„™�~��X}ÃðÂœUg{�åÂÉ�c�Zzgqd/õ IG~ZkÅÜZs™�~�XgZ¶Æìw~CÙ÷zsÂÆ!g}~!g!gqd/õ IG

~zŸsÐ4å�W¸i~Zq!g¥ô™�~YCZzggLƒñÂ!Îÿþ~�}�bYDÔ¾qwt‚g~FZçZzgZŸ±Âoƒ�ÔpFZçʼn�vâ¨gÔ�Ô}:

T�zx S � TZÍw S � �Ñg�Z[~ZÍwÂët' 5 4 �Z[~ZÍwÂt 1Ô2 9 1t̹YYìX 9 4 t¹YYì' 5 9 2ÂLL�zªóóFF(ZEwHìX

1 5 ÂLL�zªóó»ZEwF(HìX

91 9 3

£[Zâcz{ÓxZâ 5 5 £[cz{ÓxZâ 51 01 4uZ�x�êìX 12 5 uZ�x™@ì 41Ô51 01 5

76ic�{ZWrÇ 1 23 76¼ZWrÇX 9Ô01 33 6˸xŇ/ÔaZö�zªÆÒpÐZk¸x

Åi}'

1 75 aZö�zªÆÒpÐ˸xŇ/Zk¸xÅi}'

1Ô2Ô3 75 7

�1Ô2Zzg4Æ!g}~%AäzŸsÅì�Zy~ZZnKLLëóóLLÌóóZzgLLZâóóœUvsƒ�ÔZ(eìÔpøgZìwì�Z¤tœU÷zs:ƒñ

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^003

Page 298: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ƒVZzgZDwÅZÝ’kZϧbƒÔAÌ|x~ÃðñzZµ7ƒ@ÔZka�VyZÖp»ZŸ†™äÅ¢zg]:¶X�3Zzg7~‰ZÖpż*z@í»Xì ZZzgt�zZáÅßZ[�hZzgfzt6«ì�z{¾ÂìÑ@ìZzg¾Ãˆ~X

|x�zâV§bzZãìÔ®ZtFZçÌš¢zg]�X�5:tõzg}ÆZEw»XìXøg}ìw~LLuZ�x™*óóÌß7ÔZkaZkp~ÅÌ¢zg]:

FçZ%oƒìÔYè�V'»|xÂLLic�{óóÐzZãƒ@ìÔ ¶X�6:t:�LL¼óóÐX

ZyVßVÅgzÝ~Ô%AÅFZçzZ&q]»Y{BÔÂZy~Ð9š¢zg]ÃWC�XZyZ&q]ÐL}úƒ��Zzg„g]~ic�{gzZãZzgzŸsaZƒ�ìÔpZDw»ZÝQÔpsƒ�ìZzgoQÆtp7�

¢zg] èø ZÝQ~]hQ|[Ô—ã»çVc%z`gzi%{zõzg{Æ_.Ôp´Vc¥Ã]™�bYNÔOçT�zxŹÏFZçzp´VÔgZ¶Æìw~*£[�XZÝQ�V»ÂVgxecåÔic�{Ðic�{ÔjZÙ~ÜZs™�~YCX

Qóó»Z�gZu7HÔ¸zzì�Q~ è gZ¶Æìw~%AäLLw#ÖpV£â]6FçÅ�Ô1jZÙ~tÜZsÜsP£â]Jöz�ìX¹Ð¥Ã]Æ!g}~tf™7ƒZ�t%AÅZ&q]�Ô}:

T�zx S � TZÍw S � �ÑgñÎxHY@ìX 11Ô21 64 ñÎxH™D�X 2Ô3 05 1ÃÒÅì�tzZã™,�'

21 64 ÃÒÅì� 3 05 2

�ºgzVÅ{q~Zzg�zgZ07

82 95 �ºgzVÆ{�Zzg�zgZ07

7Ô8 46 3

ŒÛnf�X 62 56 ŒÛnZVD�X 4 07 4{uƒY@ìX 32 23 {u({ƒY@ìX 01 43 5

103x�~£?

Page 299: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZkâqÅVB,]04)ZÍw:m34(Ô24)ZÍw:m44(Ô64)ZÍw:m45(65)ZÍw:m06(Ô26)ZÍw:m66(Ô07)ZÍw:m27(Ô17)ZÍw:m47(Ô37)ZÍw:m67(Ô09)ZÍw:m39(Ô19)ZÍw:m49(Ô041)ZÍw:m641(Zzg¹Ð�v£â]6�@Y$Ë�X

TZÍw~F£â]6¼�„gZ]ZzgÓVÃúcV™äÆaZyÆnâ5�ì),]76Ô86Ô18Ô28Ô78Ô88Ô59Ô021Ô121Ô221Ô821z){(X1T�zx~Zy”VÃâ>{7¯c�Zzg:ZkÅ}zŸsQìÔqÑèt¢zg~åXT

óó„��XT z ZDw!kxLL�â ´) 'óó)m5(ìZzgt9ìX z ZÍw~LL�â~®wñÑ*YòÆ ]‰†]…ôìç�p ZÍwm6Zzg76ÌQ,VäLL�âZóó�ìX

óóì)m12(XZ[T�zx~ZkÂÃLL�âpóó¯�c�ìÔ� z ZqÄ~ÌLL�â�g„7X

TZÍw~LL�zxóóÃZq(LL�zìóó)m902(ZzgLLÎxóóÃ�z(LLÎìóó)m17Ô901(��ìXT�zx~ZkÅZ&bÆO}CÙ(Ô©�z„~ÌÔLL�zìóóZzgLLÎìóó™�c�ìX

ÅZÌÔZDwÅZÍA"ZzgZqc�ÇgÆîg6ìÔ:� Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� W`çâ]ÅZqÂ[ÅwÐXçÙÃc]ZzgQßßV~Zâ7gă_ì

»d%ûÑ$þJLZ²7g;Zzg:tÂ[]hçâ]Æ¥Æa Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �PZVÎ�qƒ$ËìX�V�Vz‰Ü¦g}ÇÔZkÅtwn¬YñÏÔ1ZDwÅ"Æîg6ZkÅZÌ$2g!¹gìÏXZkaZkÆQ~˧bÅ

¢zg]jZÙ»ZŸ†™ä~Ãðw`7X è p~c¥s*oƒìÔ@ëø»�ZZecуgÐ�áùƒZX*ÑÅwÐZk6 Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� 7791Y~

Z}sxWsZ�[уg»ìXZk ZDwZ»�ò0Îy»*x�g`ìÔ1LLZÈxóóZ*�}Zec6LL!gZÍwÔ7791YóóÆZÖpÔÂ[Æ*ÑZzgLLzóó�zâVÅ"µÆ

ZÍw~ è âi�XZec~8ûEL¬Ã8ûEL&~$w�c�ìXÂ"ÍZgZìÔTÃZec~Zk�Ût»ZÈxgzZ7g3�X è jZÙ»¯ÔQÐ×!gqåÔ1ik

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^203

Page 300: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

z„~tp~Å�ì�CÙ{Æf~ÄZ*]Æ‚B�g`”{![ZÍwÔ�zìÔÎìz){ÆZÖp�b��Zzg7ÂÐ<JCÙÄZyÃÚÑg™DƒñÔQkÆ‚B�É�cìXtZºZq¸�plâöÅìÔTÅ¢zg]¶Zzg:Ãð�ZiX

THE DEVELOPMENT OF METAPHYSICS IN PERSIA /

gziˆJZÆ'à Zzgi 1C ZDwZd½Æ”wÆa52m5091YÉ`ãÆ¢ÔZKï»W¸i™�cX 2C Æîg6�Z¼h advanced student R‹»Ò~

~ZDwäŒÂòЦsÐ0‰Z§gZ] 3C ZÆ'5091YÆâ B8KZzg‚B„¦sÆñçq6ŒÛWãWc]ÆjZá�l™ÆLL¹¢×�Z[óó

ZÆ'Æ�gxyÌÔz{ZÏe~ZqâÉ` B �Å@NÅXZkЬJZzg8ZDw �åXeZËå&¾æ H

Y^Ô ƒ é� ¸XZkÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�W¸¯»gÆ‚Bñçq»ç

z{! 4C (dissertation) QyÆkR¸Xtó£! (H. Sidgwick) ÆôZÈïZzgZÝùÌuÃQ,Vä£! ãel|‚wˆ7Bâga7091Y ½ C5X Z}Åe¤~Æa»g™gì¸

~Zkâ6LL52BâÞóó�g`ìÔ��g„7þX ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù Ôm301ÿ ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 1DßyÔ qß- eZËGZº�gZãäZL*yLL´)ZDwÅ@gõaZöÔP6iZzbóó) 2D

02Bm7791YÔm4(Æ‚BR‹»Ò‰`ÆgZ�Z¼ÐÔJZÆ'5091YÆZ0gZY]»advanced ÿ @�áù™ZcìÔTÐR‹»Ò~ZDwÆ�Z¾Å@gõZzgZkÅâÎ

@ìXZDwäÌZLZq*y~f™Hì�z{R‹»Ò~�g ƒ é� þ»ç student

ÔÑzZã:m341(X Speeches ik½gì) advanced student

Ô�zx:m353Ô453 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D_.gZ�Z¼R‹»Ò‰`X 4D

Z}Åe¤~hÅ!]�g„¥x7ƒCX eZËYzhZDw»ìwì�‰`Ð! 5DÔZÍw:m311(1Q,VäZÏÂ[~ÔP,]WÐ^™ÔZDw»twÜH ‡Þ‚å…æ� )

Z}™1óóX)m621(ZÝ!]tì�R‹»ÒÆgZ�Z¼ ì:LLZ~ä‰`Ð!ÅwÐ�Z¼1åÔZkw~Ô advanced student ÆZ0gZY]Æ_.ZDwä

Z}Ƭx¤Dŧb&‚wÅæ]7g~™Æ QyÆat0È~7¶�z{!(dissertation !‡°{ZJy~áZzgZJy0k™äÅÑo7g~™,XZ¹ÂZC£!)

7™*åX¸zzì�ZÏZz~Q,Vä6BâÞ5091YÃÅ5¿.ç EEESy~Ì�Z¼á1åZzgZÏe~ZÒßyWD¸X

303x�~£?

Page 301: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

™Æ�Z4™�cÔT6‰` å The Development of Metaphysics in Persia >Zy«ÅX 2C Z}Åe¤~ 7091YÃ! zg31B�y Z 1C #7091YÃZ¹Zq� B -ãzg;ä7

ZkZz~Û7~»ÃgkÌYg~åÔZDwä8ZÝe~™ä»ZgZ�{™1)Zk~ÔQyƉ`ÆZ‚E{Zzg6zWWg&Óå EHz){»�4ƒÇX(‰` äƒ §sáz

~Qy�âV8ZÝe~7ƒC¶)z;Vt�1291Y~Yg~ƒZ(ZzgeZËfÆah'WV '× C3 ¥!kx*YD¸XZDwÆ7ÒªîG0Zx[~FðÃå�áï¸X

Zq²!"ð6ïÆe~Ô6zWWg&Óå EHäÔZDwÃ*­Å?mÌ7ÅZCîg6z{ëVÆæZb¸ZzgQyŧs{™~ÈTgn¸X¾H f C4¶X

yƒúZïů6ÔZDw Z C5 óó äZDw»twÜHì:LLZ¤Dâ™*ƒÂ*Y�X™1�*Y™8ZÝe~ÅYñX 6C ä¢ZgZ�{

Qy�âVð-ãzg-V~8ZÝe~Æ¥ÆaÁZiÁel|'kÅq¢~Ñiò¶Zzg£!ðcÑHi!y~r7@åÔ@ëZDwÃZL‰`ÆZ‚E{Å

XIqbal in Pictures @5±Ù: 1Dm:93 Mementos of Iqbal2; y8791Y:m3 B� ÔßyÔ22 qß- fZ!eZËGZº�gZãÔ 2D

:m51 Letters to Atiya 3D:m71 Zs 4DZi¾H:m48 ]Îf^Ù 5D

eZËYzhZDw��:LL¥xƒ@ìZDwä̉`~g;öZ(g™äƯgUˆ 6DÔZÍw: ‡Þ‚å…æ� ZLñç»ïÆ0¢zg~g+Bn.ç GEHcñà-ãzg;~™zZ�~¶Xóó)

m21(1t!]�g„7YèZDwÆZqÒyÐzZãƒ@ì�‰`Ð!Z}™äƈQ,Vä8ZÝe~»ZgZ�{HZzg�«·™rÐ'×h¼g¶­Å�gpZ„Å

:m63(Qt!]̨gÔì�–wYzhZDw:Z¤ÔZDwä‰`Ð! �$^…ô]Îf^Ù )ÔZÍw:m311(ZzgÛ7~ÆaÅ5¿.ç EEESy~Ì�Z¼ág3åÔ ‡Þ‚å…æ� Z}7H)

èÃg(YV !jZ ‰`~¾aªx5k¸Zzgg^ae°ÅwÐR‹»Ò~�Z¼)zg; 1å?Z¹ßy~gxecåÔ�VZq§sÛ7~Å»g~™DZzg‚B‚Bñà-ã

Åg^aÌYg~gSX

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^403

Page 302: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Dw71ƈZzg12B�Ñð7091YЬËgzi Z C1 \gl6�zâVÑZ_~Z]ï�XC2 ZàyÐgzZ:ƒ™*−�X

¾H»Òyì�ZDwä:LLz{d£!Ì=õÔT6Q¹!Z}Åe¤~ª!iðO�{(�ìXeìtZÝ£áÅ ) 4C MS. Zzg(Q,Vä qZ C3 «ƒðóóX

܃cZÝ£!ƒZzgZkÅÜZDwäZL0kôp™àƒX*V™Q,VäÑzqÅZzgZkK~ðZ*EV)øwzw g~ Æe~'×h» !ãZJy i

*†ZzgJ(Ðn�Èî0ìwZzgczI}Æ‚B‚B*ƉÃ{âVÐÌZ.�{HX£áÆe~ZDwäX"¤]Ðæ�àÔQy~Ð&

ÌHƒX » 6C XeìQ,Vä-g\Ɖ�vàzV 5C 'ÞÅÑ$k~~¸Xz{ic�{F;àw'v~}gìÔ C7 g; ù¦îg6*~ZDw»ªx¹plÍZg

èg2w(~ ) C8 ˜VQyÅg;ö�gc}mÆ)g}Zq%æFNc(6zZµZqky{§Æ‚Bz{ði!y~ZK è ¶XZk§b.e‚iÇgâjw~Zzg�

Z¦Z�(JDgìX:m841 Letters of Iqbal 1D

Ô ‡Þ‚å…æ� eZËYzhZDwä�ì:LL¸��ÑðÆ�}�~;àw'v−�óóX) 2Dm911(GZº�gZã»ìwì�:LLßyÐ02B�Ñð7091YƵn*gzZ:ƒñóó ZÍw:ÔßyÔ22B�y8791Y:m3(XgZ¶Æìw~ZàyÐgzZ�Å@gõ81c91c02B�Ñð qß- )

Zi¾H:m48(*V™Q,Vä¾HÃ� ]Îf^Ù kìX61B�ÑðÃz{ßy~¸)81@ Ãg(XtZÏßg]~eì�ZDw è! z{¾ä32�ÑðÃ�z2VÃ7|™‹c)jZ â�Ô

02B�ÑðÃ)Ëgzi(*ãƒVZzgQÏgzicZŒgzi¾HÃâÉ�cƒXZi¾H:m48 ]Îf^Ù 3D

m91 :Letters to Atiya 4DXI ÔmDevelopment ¬gs: 5D

�y8791Y:m3(X B ÔßyÔ22 qß- }z~W*)eZËGZº�gZãÔ 6D:m68@89(ÐÎcYYìX ]Îf^Ù Zk»¼Z0Zi{¾HÅeZ]~ÆZ0gZY]) 7D

*~}P0ÎEVÅÂzZzg»zlÐ6691Y~ZkkyÅÛzã�-Zg6Zqc�Çg~ 8DÔ6( { ß·™�c�XgZ¶Ã7991Y~ZLøiZ�2;×ÅgZ{úð~ÔZkÅ)!¹WÒ

503x�~£?

Page 303: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

*~ªxÆ�zgZy~ÔQ,Väði!y6oƒuJ�,kÅàðÆ!g}~ZyÆZ‚E{»ìwå�:LLZDwä&¹~΢ð T C1¶Ô

i!ãZJyð~ƒZZzgñà-ã C2 i!y-ìÔZâ¢ÃðqÝÿ˜Zþ7™YóóXâÞ7091YÃZkd£á6ZDwÃ8ZÝe~Åe¤~«™�~X B zg;ä4

ZDw»tó£!ÔZDwƪÄZày„Æiâä~ßyÅßiZuZhv(äÂ!ßg]~�áùHåX‚ÁZ�á®8091Y�g`ìX'Ñ-ã Luzac & Co.)

þ6Ô�ZDwäZL�z„ SB741 (415231 zg;Ñ$k~~ñ��°ÿjZ!�:)�g`ìX 3C eÚåéÃ7HÔZDwÆ�+VÆ‚B3B�Ñð8091YÅ@gõ � Zp

ÍcÂ[8091YÅ«�„ÆWy~�âV~�áùƒðXZkÅS®Z~Z's(ÆikZÈxÑày);C(~ƒðX6zWWg&Óå EHÆ*xZ[Å E. J. Brill)

„g]ÐZLZ*�ÆaZDwÅ›zo]ÆZ•ð_!]ªCÙƒD�XÑzq~Zq¿‚ß*)Ì�áïìX

uzgtZzgZkÅ1ÆÔ»Ñg7H�ÔZ[Ôß*)Ôz„Zzg¬gsZiJ '!g{,]6��ZzgZy»ÑggzðyÎV~ìÔ$4èGELÂ[�ZÐ591~(transliteration) w° èÜ �ìXß*óÔz„Zzg0zg¹jZÙ»NU!gqìX

gZbZ¨S΂̻zä™�{§iZCc�ìX8jèELßg~ÆZ±gЬZecÅS®£g~ìXQ»NUgz×ZzgzZã

ìXgñ¯Zz‡s»{mZÈxÃW@ìX½ã�zœ,]ÆQ~Zq�gXÐÌÃZzg*ÑÆF��S®»Z0Zi{Î*Â7X¬ è ÁZÝoÐ6zspZVÅ�‰Ü

Zq ZecÅ�zSÈQ�:)1(S®LLZ³óó:Zk»-f™Zz6ÅTg~H�XZk»¸X)2;×Qy�âV ÷}ë^ Zk^~eZËd�ÛZ¹Ì icg]»ñµ5X )�*�(

*ÆZkz‰ÜÆ�ZgZ|#Ö1yÆ0Îã\g]{äÐݸX(:m841 Letters of Iqbal 1D

Zi¾H:m49 ]Îf^Ù 2D:m96Ô353 ]Îf^Ù(mç…¸Ún6 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^603

Page 304: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¯º[-ãzg;Ñ$k~~ñ��ìX)2(S®LL[óó:Zk»uzgtS®Z³ÆÆikÄZyZDwÆ¿qÑ]�áï Lebenslauf~ uzgtÐËŠgZìXZk

�Ô2Z’ZðWJ,]ÆZ0gZY]ÅFKÔS®Z³ÅFKÐZìX–w¡�:LLW`ÐGg{'k¬1y~}ÔZDwÆZqð¬ÔZzgZqZdu»g~5ixeZËñøä»[�iŒÅ�Ûâö68691Y~ZϬ°Æ�kg~6.

gZ¶ÃËg~6.»uZr7ïeX1891Y 1 C1 �áùKÔ�0ÎyÌÇ�óó~eZËGZº�gZãäâg'v-ãzg;Ñ$k~)*(~ZÏS®LL[óóÆZq

L�zgÒ Z C2 ~6.»g™ZñX § qÎ °»uZrÎcZzg6zWWg'Z.Åæ�ÐZkÆZ~Ð&°ÔQ,VäZDwñi*уgÔZDw уg)âÞ3891Y(Æñµ6Zy

Z»�ò0ÎyуgZzgÍg»ÒуgÅÑ$k-VÃ@tKXS®LLZ³óóZzgS®LL[óóÆZ’ZðWJ,]ÅFKZzgZ0gZY]Æ

Z%Ã]t�:S®:[ S®:Z³ ��&À�/õ GG 6 �zâVuzgVÆ@WÒ{,] uzgt< 3C 6.Ñí uzgtÅ$iï FNIG

ZDwÅ¿p�â“>Zy4C

Lebenslauf

6zWWg&Óå EHÆ*xZ[Å„g]

þIÿ

< < þIIÿÂ[»*x ZÝo*) þIIIÿ< < þIVÿ

ÔZDw�Ô¢2ÔÑg{11D21:m701 ]uŠ^Œ 1DÔâga2891YX ]ÊÓ^… 2D

Printed by: E.J. BRILL - LEIDEN (Holland) 3D~�áïìX Iqbal in Pictures Zk»@ 4D

703x�~£?

Page 305: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

@ëZ5ZzgÂ"ŹÏZ+ZÝoÅ¡7�mÔ�Š*¶V~ñ���Ô´z{Zi,�ZÝoÅßg]~$w�ìX,tì:LLp}ZDwóó»Q S � 9Q S �

)or 6 11 )o�r 91 2 ÔZÆ'2091 Úíˆá

ìÔF¹ 73 ìX:F¹ 31 63 Ôâga5091Y Úíˆá

øg}¸ÇV 6 73 øg}yz¸ÇV 71D81 63¬Ð� 2 83 ¬� 01 73rZg; 8 83 rzZg; 61 73uz§»Ñ]íÐ 1 67 uz§»Ñ]Ð 8 854 Ô8Z~7191Y ‰j^…åÿ‘fx

7791Y ZDw�1Ô ÞÏç� fZ!™zZð 1 67 ™Zð 9 584�4øE 61 67 �4øE 12 584pZ<îE0�z�Ví 31 77 pZz�z�V 01 684�ZkŠgÄÅ°p�Ûâð 31 77 �ŠgZkÄÅ�Ûâð 01D11 684!h42.ç GEGE 4 84 !k2.çGGE 3 Z³ TZzw ]‰†]…ôìç�p �âp

ÖÃäÚ_^

�nvoæiç

ivÏnÏoÒÙ

i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^

803

Page 306: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

LLp}ZDwóó»Q S � 9Q S �weZzg!Öº�v 71 94 wec!Öº�v 8D9 `$�4èE

GE¿ 71 94 $�54èG

GGEL¿ 2 �Zò[ 2 15 Zm] 01 zZ0Z{�Yì 9 15 Z0Zi{7�Y 8 i

903x�~

£?

Page 307: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

1C uzgt z„p} V

t„g]: 2 C2 6.ÑíXGenehmigt auf Antrag des Herrn

Professor Dr. Fr HOMMEL

< VI

!¹Óx,]ÅFKZzgQ7VìZzgZyÅS®~Zq„²ZEwÅ��XOçS®LLZ³óóÅÓxZÝoS®LL[óó~Ìñ���X

Z[ÎZwtì�Zq„‚w)8091Y(~Â[�z!g{YV�?)tÂŒÛdŒÛd*eì�P„â{~ªZec»ƒ�ƒZzgZÏ‚w�zuZZecYC7ZƒX)LLZ³óócLL[óó6TZÍwc�zxÅÃðÜZsÌ7Q(XZ¤Â[Zq„!g�ÔÂ

zZÑ Lebenslauf QZ’ZðWJ,]ÆZ0gZY]~�ÛtYVì?S®LLZ³óó~�YV�áï7?ZϧbS®LL[óó~Wg&Óå EHÆ*xZ[zZáÔÅ°xñ��Ï»:Hì?Zke~‰ŒÛZíÔ2eZËGZº�gZãÅ�ÛZë™�{¥â]ů6gZ¶ZkË6à�S®LL[óó¬¿~WðÔZkÆP°eZËfÅe¤~ÆaY9�Ô)eZËZ+÷~\)ÿ

IÆ_.eZËfÅe¤~ÆaÔQy

(ZkÆuzgtÅð„g]Ð̤&ƒCìÔ 3C �âV£!T™ZÆ7HY@å�g`ìÔ8ZÝe~»f™7ìXQkz‰Ü M.A. uzgt6'Æ*xÆ‚BÜs

JS®ÅZÝoÌ�gcÄ7ƒð�ÔZkaZkS®~LLZÝo*)óó�áï7H�XeZËfÅe¤~ï�ÂZ-.VÐÂ[Æ'×h°�áùK�Ô1Zk5Z�á®)LLZ³óó(ÆZ’Zð,]~‰FZçÅIXeZËfÅe¤~ï_¶Ô

Åð„gZ]ïw�~IÔZqÔÅ¿p�â“Ì [VI] ZkauzgtÔ2�vs™�~�ÔYèS®LLZ³óó~t̸�ZJã¢zg]Æ�„�áïÅ�

»ZŸ†H�ÔZϧbWg&Óå EHÆ*x Ph.D. (Munich) 'Æ*xÆ‚B ¶ÔZ!„g]Ì(Jð�XZkz‰ÜJS®Å‰ZÝo�gcă_�ÔZkaLLZÝo*)óóÌÎ�c�X-VS®LLZ³óó¿~WðX

_.qí3Ôm903 2D _.@*� 1DgzZeeZËGZº�gZãÔ¯[¯xg<Z−+;×Ô51âga0891Y@ëtÎZwQÌѦ 3D

ì�ñà-ãzg;~7091Y~�Z4™�{°68091YYV�g`ì?

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^013

Page 308: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

8tE™{�pÐ{à:ƒÇ�S®LLZ³óó»LLZÝo*)óóÌ!VÐ{àÅ( IIe-ness ƒ*ecXS9~ Bundadish Å( Buudadish 7XS1~

ƒ*ecXS01~èÃgtÔÂ[~ñ��7ìÔZ%ZÏ�)661ÔS12(6 I-ness

ƒ*ecåÔ1LLZÝo*)óó~ZkŶy�„7Å�'�zâV a Ь peaceÂ~�021Å(121Zzg121Å(051�g„ìX Contents SoVÆ

´)ZDwÅi0Ï~ÔZkÂ[»�zuZZec�áù7ƒZÔYèQ,VäZkÅ(g~L�w8o-ö FF7àX7191Y~Z©gW!�;ðÃg^~¨QQy è Z�á®

ƽg»ZkyaZƒZÔÂQ,Vä�á�Æ*xZqâ~ZKd1‰ÜÔ(ZqÐiZ]Zzg»f™™Dƒñ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� Dg+Š"Å,ÒyÅX"z@;ÆK~

Â[ÅZÐZ�~w»SyZÖp~f™H:LLQg�z~ƒÐ¬RÂ[~äpikcÂ[Æ!g}~Ô�-g\~QyÅ�z‚!dï»x¶Ô C1 èóóX

kÆ‚BÃðZ( Z C2 Q,VäÜst�:LLZq×g‚!¡Òiªî EE0ZkZy6Ì�ìóóXÂr3§öG

EÂc]7ìÔTЪCÙƒ�ZDwZkÂ[ÃZqZë"»�gz�ï�X

&'kÔ{y·*iZ−+{VÃ�:LLZkZyÆ�6~äZqÂ[è¶Ô¡7291Y~÷Œ C3 Zq{�åÔ&ˆ~%æFN™ä»påÔ1z‰Üä)°]:ÅóóX

Z−+äÔZkÆQg�zF3ÅZYi]ÔÅÔÂZ¹�:÷}4�qZk»FÀ¼Æ:ƒÇXtÂ[Z[ÐZVg{‚w¬è�¶ÔZkz‰ÜйÐ6Zñg»ZÏsƒZìZzgp�÷}ìÑ]~̹‚Zz[W[ìXði!y~çZàÔîÏz){6´u{ÂÁè��Ô�÷~’kÆz‰Üñ��:�X÷}ìw~ÔZ[ZkÂ[»ðhZ‚z!¹ìÔ�WÅi�Ð$nX÷~

C4 gZñ~FÀ™äÐ4t!]ì�W\p�Z+@gõKX:m54 �^�]Îf^Ù 1D

:m54Ô64 Zs 2D92 :m ÚÓ^ingô]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÞn^‡ 3D

:m102D202 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 4D

113x�~£?

Page 309: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ícz‰Ü¦gä6ZDwÅÃ~ÔQyÅZk"ÅdwzZÌ»ƒ_¶XZk»Zq:¸ì�ZDwÅZkZ’Zð»zlÆÔZkñçq6F¬Ó:Zzgz¯ÂÁèIÔ1ZKZk�:"ÐZDwÅ°x�w8o-ö FFZzg"ZEã~t

C1 NÌZëì��ÐQyÅ�p¹Áƒ�¶X~Zk»�zuZZec)xZDwуgä�áùHXZk»»½�ÜZzg0ZZg 2C 4591Y

ìXZ’Zða�{,])uzgtÔ7ÂZiZ*Z*ÑpÔZ[Ô¬gsZzgz„(Æ,]»ÑgZiaçLâƒ@ìXQm9416»ƒ@ìXm051{àìXZ�ágbÆWJ,]ZµÑgK��X¨ù¦ZkZecÅFKZzgqgY�QzjZÙÔ…3üELZÍwÆ_.�Ô@ëZk~‰FZçZzgZŸ±K��ÔZ¤pªCÙ~Zzg!mZ±gÐtPZVZÌÆqï7ÔQÌZyŶy�„¢zg~ì:

)1(¬Zec»‚‚hñ81kxFu™ÆÔ�zuZZec(~Æ42<‚hñ51kx6Y0�ìXZkp~ÅzzÐZ[Q»Zq�52ÅO}13SzV6�ìX

»‚—Zzg(Z‹�Å,vs™�~ Shaikh )2(uzgtÐ'Æ*xÐ�ìX

)3(uzgtÅ16ZyZÖp»ZŸ†H�ì:With the Kind Permission

of Messers. Luzac & Company

LONDON

)4(7Â)ZiZ*Z*Ñp(»ZŸ†H�ìÔT~Cc�ì�ZDwÅtZÍA�:"{ñVÐ(.çEOZ7ìX'×h'WVZkñçq6}ic�{YìZzg4

ÂÁ¾��Ô@ë_Åœî0æª]~ZkÅZÌÆ&4øFGILÃZzgC}ZD1]ÆZÃ�}ÆaÔÂ[»�zuZZec�áùHYg;ìX

Jm2291YÃciZ�{Z'Z�ðÃZqâ~�:LL~Zq²áÐ�»_·gh´ 1D:m442(X ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ƒVóóX)

�g`ìÔTÐ First Edition 1954 Zk6‚ÁS®�g`7Ô1ˆÅZ�áoV~ 2D³ƒY@ìX 4591Y S®»‚w

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^213

Page 310: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÅFKps™�~�ìXTZÍw~z„¬ Introduction )5(z„Zzgˆ~ìÔ�zu}Zec~FKZkÆ'@ìX Introduction Zzg

(ЬZqzgtΙQk6ÔQk{»ÄZy�g` Part )6(…3üEL�zx~CÙ{)H�ìÔ…3üELZÍw~tZÈx7MX…3üELZÍw~Zq![»ƒä6ÔQÏÔÐZ†![Ñzqƒ@ìZ�…3üEL�zx~CÙ![»W¸i6ÔЃ@ìX

X§II §I ÄZy�: ZÍw~Z1Z[Æ:ÄZ*]Zϧb�g�XZqS~ …3üEL )7(ZzgZkÆ 2Ô1 �zu~S~ÄZyÆZÖpÔ1T�zx~Zq„S~¬ÄZy�: Q

‚B„ÄZyÆZÖp���XÆ0QßßVÃÅp w° èÜ )8(TZÍw~²!zÃgÏZ�zZÖpÆgÌZ�~Z1Z[~tZÈx è ù¦ZkÅ0È~Å�ìÔ1Áz+ è g3�ìÔT�zx~¨

'ŒÛZg7g{eÔ}:T�zx � TZÍw �

MANI 11 M -an-I 21SUFIISM 67 Sufiism 69

QURANIC Q -u'r-anic

AL-ISHRAQI 49 Al-I _sh r -aq-I 121AL-JILI 611 Al-Jili 151

LLróó � _Gh )9(TZÍw~NUÆwzs7V�Ô1T�zx~‰wzs}LLlóóÅWzZiêCÙ™D�Ô×!gq�),]56Ô49Ô59z){( � _Sh ÅWzZiÃZzg

ZkÐÂ[Æßg~Œ~�ÛtzZµƒZìX)01(T�zx~WJ,]6�Z�zZ´xZzgñç¬]»ZqÆZ�ágtÌÂ[

ÆWy~Îc�ìX9591YZzg4691Y~ZZnK�ZZzgaåZecÌ)ÄZDwуgÆikZÈx

�áùƒZÔt�zâVZecCÙZ±gÐT�zxÆ_.�X

313x�~£?

Page 311: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

SIX LECTURES /ON THE RECONSTRUCTION OF RELIGIOUS THOUGHT IN ISLAM

»t]ZDwÆ (Nicholas P. Aghanides) „CÙZqf!'æÑk8Z‘45å EEGiZôm~h]»&½0î EG0W¸ic¯g~&?çOuU"ƒZ:

As regards the ijma' some Hanifites and the Mu'tazilites held that the ijma' canrepeal the Koran and the Sunnah.1C

4C 1ZæxWiZ� ZzgZ C3 JZzgZkK~Q,Vä±Ñy0z~ (C2 ZÐ7|™ZDw»®ÐZ§gHXp�ÌZkñçq6gzpn™DgìXZkZz~Q,Vä−·ä~?ÔZ°Ý−·â~Ôñß~·Z}−·â~Zzgуg~ñß~±³ÔñÑ*ZûZgzk

ÐÌZkñçq6n�Èî0ìwHX!sy4291Y~Q,VäZ¿�° 5C ZzgñÑ*Ýx%”Æñçq6Zôm~~Zq[»gHÔ�ËŠgFçZzgÃUãƈ¯;w 6C ZÑsx

» уg~Ôu†ZØ�gÅœZg]~Â{ÔZqZ°k~7J�XtzZ§31B�c4291YÔThe Principle of Movement in the Structure of Islam ”î0h]»Ù[ ù C7ìX

ZϽkÅFçzZŸ†”{ßg]ìX

:m19 Mohammedan Theories of Finance 1DZk»E™{F(MìÔ}: 2D

ÔTZÍw:242 Reconstruction )Z³(ÔZÍw:m131Ô231Ô531 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä )[(

:m003Ô103 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 )`(ÔZÍw:m131@631 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D

ZsÔm231 4D:m103Ô203X25±Ù:ñÑ*Ýx%”»*y>Zy:LL´) ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 5D

Ô†g~9791YÔm103@723 ÞÏç� ZDwg9*îGZvmÐX�]qZ:5‡'óó�!Ô·GZ−+Q~Æ*x31BZ~4291YÆâ~ZÏ\ŧsZ�ág{ìXZDw��: 6D

óó: The Idea of Ijtihad in the Law of Islam LL~Zq×*yZôm~~Ég;ƒV::m811(X ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä )

ÔÎxÔ![61X ‡Þ‚å…æ� 7D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^413

Page 312: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZÏZz~ægZkÅLL�Z�åZÁÏZcWs‡gyZ&cóóŧsÐZ¹Zsx6)�¶Å�ú]BXIZi,5291Y~±Ñy0z~Ô§�t~åÆZ

U�V6ÔWJ)�}`¸XZDwät�ú]Jw™Dƒñ&h]Ô’k~ßg]~»g™aX

The ZsxуgÆ24z,‚Ñ:H)61BZ6s7291Y(~Q,Vä è Z³×eC1 Æñçq6Zq½kÅÔˆZiZVZk»Qg�znÌ7HX Spirit of Muslim Culture

Zk½k~0v,\Ð0Fï]zZ�ágZ]X�XZkÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�h]Å»g~Z6s7291Y„ÐÑzqƒ_¶XÐZ-�âVZDwäeZˆZv

C2 ,ðÅz‚¦Ð·©[¿N&4iï JFHÃ�Zc@�h]Z5™ZñYNXægZk~ih]7™ä»ZgZ�{åÔ1o&\»gƒnZzgz{ÌZŒ

'kª8291YÆÛWy~XZke~ZDw&g=âÂ"±Ñy0z~мÂÁeZˆZv C3 ‰)b6n�Èî0ìw™DgìZzg‰ÂÁÌ|CX

B†g~9291Y 5 C5 B�c8291YJ&h]»gƒ�X 5 C4IX ,ðÅz‚¦Ð|ð‚t ÃZDwægZkãZzg5Ô6Zzg7B†g~Ãth]ÍA;w~ægZkÆZIDÆ

~¸\CgÔ�gZzg©gW!��ÁÆZ½¬]~Ì7ñ�X ˆ C1 7KX

)m001D311(~gz�Z�LLÒûZV‚Ñ: ]Îf^Ù]æ…]ÞrÛàuÛ^mk]‰¡Ý Zk»bz~Q 1D‡Únß‚]… )m52(~gzi*) +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù *Â{61BZ6s7291YóóÆjZáÐZzg

02BZ6s7291YÆjZáÐ�áïìXÔ�zx:m333ÿLL·©[−·ä»!°{åXz{;Zv{VZzgeZg#»¿Ì ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

åX©[Ð~äZOxHå�z{´)ÐZ51™}Zzg!‡°{NU™Æ´)Å}#Ö~7™}'ˆÆ&)iÆa´)äZµZOxHåóóX)¯[eZË

�Ûzg~7791YX( B †Zv,ð¯xg<Z−+;×Ô52ÔZÍw:m251@851 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3DÔ�zx:m433Ô533Ô733 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 4DÔZÍw:m114 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 5D

513x�~£?

Page 313: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zz6f™W[ì�Àih]»g™ä»ZgZ�{åÔOçz»ªZzg�vz5]ÆZDw!¹&ZVŧsázgìX·Õ{VÆ*x4BZ~9291YÆâ~�: !z��Ô

The courts are closed for summer vacations and I am writing down my

remaining three lectures which I hope to finish by the end of October .2C

Qkiâä~ZDwÆh�ægZk»leƒZÔÂZ¥|-ãzg;äZ¹�ú]�~�z{Z¥|W™Ye~h]7™,XZ[�&ZVÅ�ZzgÌ¢zg~ƒ�

âÞ9291YÃZ B 81 C3 ·Õ{VÃZ:q�~�h]åƒ`�X ¶X4BâÞ9291YÃÐ�áxiW72;w~h]»W¸iƒZXZk§biå\ âÞ B ¥|ãZzg91

�X Z¥|~7ñZDwÆZyh]Åi!yZôm~¶ZzgIt�:Ô®ZCÙ�z)ÆaZ¹'W‚y:åXZÏZˆkÆ�Q,Vä±2k*i~Ã�:LL=Zk~d->î IEXì�¬xßvZkÐoƒÃÐXf2Vä�»{mîg6_·HìÔz{÷Z

OçúZx:�ÔpZmÆa„h]ÅZ�ᮢzg~¶ZzgZk» C4 Ñ�ÃÐóóÔìwÔZDwÆf‚~�c8291Y„Ðñ��åX÷Ýx�.8Ã5B�c8291YÆ

�cÿ9291YþJtÓx)»gƒ™¾YNÐXZkz‰Ü~W\ â~�:LLWÒ{ægZk~ÌQ,VäZÏZgZ�}»ZÖgH:LLt C5 Å}#Ö~Zq»8�jVÇóóX

C6 )kdzg�Â[¾YNÐóóX†Z?xpgæ(ä X †Z?x0z~X†ZØ‚´ X ZDwÆZÒÎZöógzV)¤CÙÃgz¹ D1

ZÐ�c8291Y»zZ§�ìZzg)zVÅ®Z�iCðìXt�zâV!'�g„7X^ZDw ÞÏç� :m913@243X2 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 ægZkÅ,Æa5±Ù:

765 - �ÔZÍwÔ7791Y:m055:m911 Letters of Iqbal D2

Ôm121 Zs D3:m42 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù D4

ÔZÍw:m112 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä D5:m423 ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 D6

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^613

Page 314: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¸�Z¥|ÐzZ36Q,Väih]ÃÂ!ßg]~%A™�cåÔ1S®~Z:q�~�)51BZ6sJ 1C ~Fâ{Üsƒ�X2k*i~Ã4BZ6s0391YÆâ

~�:LLÂ[¾�ìÔZkÅ¢È~6 2C ¾YNÐÔQ72BZ6sÆâþJ»ƒYñÏóóX¥xƒ@ìPÂÁ#ÆW¸i„~»gƒ™WIX 3C ÿ#

}$¹ÒjèE

EÃ7™�{°65B#0391YZzguâ&45½ð EHGY

=Ã7™�{°66# Z 6zWWgZkÆn�gzŸs ÔìSix Lectures [»ZÝÄZy  C4 0391YÅ@gõ�g`ìXÆZÖp×ëNU~ on The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam

�g`�XZ’ZðWJ,])uzgtÔz„Ô�âpZzg¬\Æ¡Ò3ï EGF(ÆÔ¬

\ÆQÐ,]»Ñgƒ@ìXCÙ\ЬZqzgt»¡Ò3ï EGFÎc�ìXQ»

NUgz×ZzgzZãì²Z½‚]!gqNU~�XQ»�MS~ìXìi8Zzg6zsgi8{àZôoÐÅ�ìÔQÌNUŹÏZÝoñ���XW¸i~

ß*)Îc�ìÔT~!g{ZÝoŶy�„Å�ìÔ1ZÝoÅZÝ®Z�ZkÐic�{ìXfs~åz„�~Yg„ìXÂ[ÐÝß*ó~èÃgZÝoÆ

¯ð�ì: * ‚t´#Ö9 ß S �

Stimulate Simulate 61 7the he 33 61

camel cloud 03 71

:m22 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 1D:m32 Zs 2D

â~6BZ6sìÔ��g„7X èQ 3DZzgyZ™R‹»ÒÑ$k~Ô (13.7.C.90.3 ZÍwZ™‰`-ãzg;Ñ$k~~)jZ!� 4D

(ôpìXZyZ:¬]ÆagZ¶ÔeZËGZº Adv. C. 25.38 ‰`~)jZ!�:ÔT9991YÔm963Zzg473X ]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6 �Zã»NyìX�&À�/õ GG:

713x�~£?

Page 315: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �to fo 21 53

Teleological Teleogical 7D8 93Teleological teological 93 24

understand understend 01 44is how s how 1 36

purposes pruposes 03 96which whch 22 37

appreciative appreciate 62 28conception connection 22 09

* plurality plurity 6 29* quote boute 8 29* events event 12 801* whole hole 42 001* creational cretional 1 111* for of 7 621* his its 21 621* a single single 3 721* dogmatism dogmatisms 8 851

Nietzche's Nietche 6 161* Christian Christia 91 181

neck-vein neck-vain 61 881angels angles 81 091

unanalysable unanalyasable 11 612

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^813

Page 316: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

* inheritance inheriance 81 632hindrance hinderance 1 942

ìX�&À�/õ GG: (Nietsche) »Z5CÙ(ß Nietzche ‡&ÿELf™!]tì

X 06129

Ô 06116

Ô 95113

Ô 85126

Ô 85120

�:S:

ZDwäÓxh]~Wc�ŒÛWãÆjZá�b�ÔpZÝQÅ(Zôm~FÀ�g`HìÔF£â]6FZWÆ‚BWe»Ñg�ßìÔ}:

9 ß �44:38-39 44:38 31

3:189-190 3:186 3129:201 29:19 3195:4-5 95:4 41

84:17-19 84:17-20 516:98-100 6:95 7125:45-46 25:47 7132:7-9 32:6-8 0242:51 42:50 622:164 2:159 2625:63 255:63 2655:14 53:14 77

уgÐ�áùƒäzZáikcù”î0h]~ÔZDwÅZÍAZôm~"Æ0QßßVÅ0È~7Å�X w° èÜ ),·ßy8091Y(ŧb Development

)m941( Ibn-i-Khaldun: @ëZk~‰Z�}c†Ô»×9Z5Z(gH�ìÔ�(Ibn Rushd, Ibn Khaldun) )m5(tZ5ÔßyÅ,·"!!ÑÂ[ÆZ5 Ibn-i-Rushdc

ìX F9Ð

913x�~£?

Page 317: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

THE RECONSTRUCTION / OF RELIGIOUS THOUGHT IN ISLAM

ZàyÅ ~ C1 dòV~h]»{™leƒZXZ~2391YÆ�}�ZgT¤A΂Ìŧsд)ZDwÃ�ú]ñßwƒðT~ßyW™Ë�:

ñçq6)�¶Å�gpZ„Å�¶Xt�gpZ„Jw™DƒñÔQ,Väm2391YÆÄZyÐZqZzg[»gHXZ!Ä‚wÔZz{�~Íw Is Religion Possible?~

ö»Ð÷~Ñ•Æaßy�ÔÂt[èÃg{΂ÌÆZqZ½q~7JÍZgZWZ]%AƒñÔOçZDwÆZq � �XZàyÆdòV~Zk\Æpl

(ÆZZ6ÔZz±i«çEe-ãzg;6öäh]Å Lord Lothin '¤â~æZbÑgeß�+)» Is Religion Possible? (gZ�á®»ÚZZVcX�zu~Z�á®~‚Â,\>Zy:

ZŸ†H�X2k*i~Æ*x11Bm3391YÆâ~´)ZDw��:Â[ÅS®Zz±i«çEe-ãzg;äÑzq™�~ìZzg~ÛÆŒÛd6zs�N[ƒVXtª6zsìX��geÔz-ãzg;6öä=Z:q�~ì�Â[�Ûzg~

C3 ~¾™»gƒYñÏX1S®~Šg}@íƒ�Zzg,·ßg]~Â[Ô#4391YÆWy~Zcx~

ÔÍc�zu}ZecÅZ�á®#Ƭ�~¿~WðX â4C ZàyÐy*yÂ[Ð,]»Ñg è Z’ZðWJ,])uzgtÆ�zZzgZtÔ�âpZzgz„(ÆQ

ƒ@ìXCÙ[6ÔÐÑzqƒ@ìÔ1¬ZecÆ'@CÙ\Ь�g¡Ò3ï EGF

£«~ Zµzgt»ZÈx7H�X»½×�ÜìXQ»NUÔ¬ZecÆ!gqìXOçQ»�53SzV»ìX¬ZecÆjn‚hñ41<‚hñ9

xÆ£«~Zk»jn‚hñ61<7ä01kxìXZkzzЂ]ZV»Q �kÔZÍw:m022 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D

:m38 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 2DZsÔm711 3DZsÔm231 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^023

Page 318: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

,]~��ìÔZ�¬Zec~Üsih]942,]6�ƒñ 881¸ÔZkZec~:

ÆZÖpvs™�b��ÔZk§b Six Lectures on )Z³(Â[ÆÄZyÐThe Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam Z[Â[»ÄZy-Vƒ�:�X ZÖpvs™�b� ÆBarrister-at-Law, LahoreÐ 'Æ*x )[(

Wy~eg,]6�Z�zñç¬]ÆZqZ�ágb»ZŸ†H�ìX )`(NUÅZÝo�g„ƒ��ÔZ%m28Åt$2gñ��ìX )�(

ƒÐZëp~ÔQÅz{$|B-CéG

G]ÔFy]ZzgZŸ±�ÔX»f™ZDw ){(HìÔZyÅ,tì: ~ 1C ä¼�èo

T�zx S � TZÍw S �within itself the.. 7 6 within the... 8 8to our own.. 03 81 to my own... 41 52sub-conscious.. 11 52 sub-consciousness 41 43piece of... 31 04 slice of... 62 75from the centre 4 54 from centre... 4 46vision. God's life... is

self-revelation, not the

pursuit of an ideal to be

reached. The 'not yet'.

12 75 vision. The 'not

yet'...

32 18

is intensive. not extensive... 72 16 is intensive,... 02 09farther... 92 36 further... 81 39(A.D. 933) 6 46 (933 A.D.) 1 49(A.D. 1012) 8 46 (1012 A.D.) 4 49Nazzam... 43 56 they... 41 69

m512 : ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 2: ; :m711Ô564 ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù 1D

123x�~£?

Page 319: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

T�zx S � TZÍw S �according to him a... 1 66 according to these

thinkers, a...

91 69

Discussions. Razi... 01 Discussions, which saw

the light of publication

only a short time ago at

Hyderabad, Razi...

21 501

of t he cha rac t e r i s t i c

features of the mystic

levels of consciousness.

Not...

2Ô3 26 of its characteristic

features. Not...

02Ô12 531

which emerges the ego

of...

02 001 which emerge finite life

and consciousness of...

22 741

degree of co-ordination.... 22 001 degree of complexity... 52 741could not but raise... 3 201 could not raise... 1 051'I am time' (Muhammad)... 9 401 I am destiny, (Muawiya) 3 351The centres of this energy

are limited in number...

42 801 The number of the

centres of this energy is

limited...

91Ô02 951

connexion 1 011 connection... 51 161of their own... 2 651 of its own... 03 232looked at through... 33 761 looked through... 7 542today, is there anything... 03 961 today, there is

anything...

43 742

the Muslim of... 33 071 the Musalman of... 51 942

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^223

Page 320: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ecÔ�k'kÆ×îszMÆ4491Y~уgÐ�áùƒZÔZk~ Z Z�TZÍwÆm28Åt�g„™�~�XZ%m8116�zuZ^qZk§b¾�:

ÂÐfZ]òô~z�g&4g+öGE Å

Zk~LLzóóiZZìXtt4591YZzg0691YÅZ�áoV~Ìñ��ìXZ%5691YÆZec~ZkÅZ&bƒ�X1791YÆZec~Zq5tgz5kƒ�X

Xeffacting ìÔ:� effacing m62)S6(69Â�ZZec4491Y~�·ZÑs@ÃуgÆikZÈx�áùƒZåÔˆÆÓx

¬x6WñX è© Zec4591YÔ0691YÔ5691YÔ8691YÔ1791Yz){(ÌZ¹ÆZÈxÐ8891Y~LL£¾Z�á®ôpóóÅ0È~»ƒäƈÐÔ0ÎyZzg¸g]

Ƽ�*Ñ+h]�áù™gì�Ô1)6�ëT�zxÆ�âd~C`�(»Zq£g~zVàìÔ Reconstruction 6zW·G�»%ûZec)6891Y(k°Æ׬gsÆ Z___ &ZD1]ÆDz´»ñV~¶ÈgZ{¯cYYìX

Ôm32@72X Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 6891Y a�&À�/õ GG:

ðýýðýýð

323x�~£?

Page 321: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âè ~£?ÅDz+ � (`)´)ZDwÆZZ‡q�~fí}Ã&”V~�HYYì:1Dx£?2DèoZzg£Ñ]zp}3D»gkzÒ*]4Dº‡])�ª]z){(

Ô3D Development Ô2D Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ,]~ZDwÅX&£?ÿ1D *¸þÃikcÑc�ìÔQy»mZÍAâÎÐìXZy&Â1VÃt Reconstruction

ZqÐi~wqÝì�ÔZ¹ZDwä&Z�p�’kHÔp�„%AzæÍyHZzgZyÅZ�á®ZyÅi0Ï~ƒðXZkÆ'@èoÔ£Ñ]zp}Ôc»gkzÒ*]Zzg

�ª]ÆËùÃtwqÝ7ìXZDwÅx�~£?Z[JF!g¾_�Ôo~ZzgÛzÈoÌd

ìX B òV~ZyÂ1VÃzWeä65kZðZôm~h]ÆQg�zÔ1’~ÔXàÔº!Ô_ÔFÅÔðÔ²!ÔÃgÏÔ)²!

ÆDevelopment zg gÌZ�(ÃgÏ)§}Éë LgÌZ�(�ÛZúÔ¢k5é GIGß~Zzgïâ~FZWZÃgÏZzg�ÛZúFZW�áùƒ`�Ôz‰Ü Ôº!ÔFÅÔðÔ²!Ô �á)Z&z�( Qg�zÔ¸

Æ‚BÔZDwÅ£?ŧs¬@Âz(fYg„ìXâZzgZyÆ]hZexVÅ è Zk:©~ÔZDwÅx�~£?ÅDz+

Z�á®.e¢zg~ìXtZec:Üsßg~8jè NEÆZ±gÐVàƒäe454è XGGÉDz+ÔS®Zzg¡zZ÷�ÆÒpÐÌQy»£gÔZDw�x®Æ�ácÈ�áy

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^423

Page 322: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

QyÅZ�á®~ÃyÐZñgÅpgÇYN? g{ â¾Õ6ƒ?ZzgW è ƒÔ1ZyÅDz+Zke~Pï]$åLOÃg¢zg~�:

Â×Ü )1(oQ6SàÂz�~Yñ)Zôm~Â1V~ZÝoÁ�Ô1~ZyÅ®Z�Mì(�uZÖpÆ!g}~´Z3ÿXLDZzgZDwÙk ]ŸÎj’^�

|xÆa è ÃczŸs è Zô[Ðg�qHYñÔZ¤Q~¸Z‘åLi!yÆ7p~¢zg~ƒÔÂqd/õ IG~ZkÅÜZsÅYñÔZ¤ZDwÐÃðzZuCtui�ƒðìcÃðNzZã6ßìÔÂZkÅoÆaÌÔQ~p~ÆO}qd/õ IG~zŸsÅYñX

)2(ZDwäXWZzgÂ1VÆjZá�b�ÔZÝÂ1VÅgzÝ~�¬Z½kcjZá~ÃðtÂ7g{�?ZDwäZÒ£â]6jZßV» è Yñ�}Ü

~z{:Zq[qì'‰ÛÅgZ}tì' Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ZoZx7'@Ô}z){È™f!WÅWgZÒy™�ï�XZ,Väâ

Ê-�øG

ZzgâgÆìÑ]ÐƬԻªcZ¤Zs–wÀpZz Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� 'ZÓgZ„Z.�{HìX

Zôm~ C1 ƬÔƬcZ¤Zs»�FÀìX Principles of Economics

™\ÔYy h]~Q,Vä'RhgËÔÍ,ÔÃ$ÖÔz@8-,ç EGEÔ6zWÐz&Óå EHÔÃy'µZzgpV�zu}WÆZ°gÐcÅìX}*xá™Zzg}*xa

%XZDwä}´Â[»*xÉ�cìÔ1ZÒ,]��g`7KÔcQÂ[»*x„7�X�zu}\~²°Zzg*Üuy~»ZqZqÄZzg�}\~

0zg¹qd/õ IG~ZyWÆ9jZá)'Ô gzò»ZqÄÜHìX¢zg~ì�C2 YNX Â[ÔZecZzg,](�l™Æ�g`K

zugc Ά�á ~Zôm~Â1VÐZzgZôm~£?~ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� )3(

ÔZDw�Ô7791Y:m763@963 ]ö…�æ 1D

6�Zz6f™W[ìÔh]ÅuJZEyj!]tì�ÿøg~Zyzm)2891Y(Æ 2DÃVàZ0Zi~$åOzy™Æ6891Y~�áù™�cX Reconstruction ˆþ6zWG�ä

523x�~£?

Page 323: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¤]ЉZ½‚]Ôzg�FZWÜK��X " �v²!ÔÃgÏcQg�zÃz´£x6FZWЬZy»ZÝQÌ�g`HYñZzg%AŧsÐtÜZs™�~Yñ�ZÝ„gZ]zZ½‚]ˆ~(Jñ��X

»Z5Š*ZzgázuìÔZkaZÐ]hZ5Æ_.%AH Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� )4(YñÔ1tp~Ô!‡°{³QßßVÆ�¿~ÑðYñXZÖpÅŠ*Zzgñ��{

Ë ßgÂV»Zq»©ÍØZg{%A™ÆÔW¸¯Â[~Zkp~ÅzŸsÅYñXZ¤ÂÆZEwcFIÅ¡~Z]45é IGE{aZƒÂZDwÅ’kzVÐZ£Z[HYñX

¢zg]Yì1¿$›Ò3¨é GGG]»ZŸ†HYñZzg è )5(Âr-÷

EGL_ÆaÔøÆ�zu} Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� ˜V¢zg~ƒÔ@GzF�hÆa»©jZáÌ�bYNX

Zec~6zWpgæZ£ä�ÆjZÙ�áïK�ÔZ¹'×h4¯cYYìÔ1ZzgZôm~h]Å$›Ò3¨é G

GG] Development çâ]ÆâCÙZ‚E{„ZkÆZI�XZ,Z3ÿXLDÆ4�ƒãecÔ�]h-g8ExZzg�Æ‚B²!ZzgÃgÏ~Ì

1C 'g]gnƒVXÆ w° èÜ »X{mÂz»¤ìXZkz‰Ü w° èÜ )6(Zôm~Â1V~

)Ñày(» ]ÞŠ^ñoÒ×çµn;m^�Í]‰¡Ý ¼�§jgZò�Ô}:6zW$¹ÒjèE

E»§iÔ]…�æ�]ñ†åÚÃ^…Íô]‰¡Únä §iÔckZOò»§iZzgð>zf»§iZzg

º[-ãzg;уg»§iz){Xtƒ§jà:äzäK�X¢zg~7�ëW@È™ÆÔZ¹�V»ÂVJw™,X²!zÃgÏÆ'×Z`ZzgÈÆ_.

¢zg]Zy~FZçÅ¢zg]ìXëÔ�*§izä™,ÔZDwÅÓxZôm~ èø£?~7Vîg6Zk§jÅ0È~¢zg~ìXCÙÂ[ÆÑzq~ZkÅoƒÜZs™�~YñX

:Üs$›Ò3¨éG

GG]ÔÉQÅoZzgjZßVÅ�l66zWG�ä‡.ÞŠg»xHìXZy» 1D6Zy» Development æÍ:h]»¯6891YÐ!g!g¾g;ì)Zk»f™Qz6W[ì(X

Z(„HƒZ»xZÌ$k0î GIE0S®ìX

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^623

Page 324: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

,]~7™�{ÐVÂ1VÆ×Y}ÐZ0Zi{ÎcYYì� *¸@qwÔZDwÅikcx£?Æ!g}~ã�~¥â]Ì%A7ÅIX

“ZzgÁqÑ] Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �¥â]�ø[�Ôz{*åÔ*³Zzg)R�Ô}:~è�?ZkÅZÍAZ�ᮓ¿~Wð?ZDwÃeZËf»£!�Å’qùƒð?ZKï~‰`Zzg;àw'vÆZ3ÿXLDÐQ,Vä¾uJZzgùZ.�{H?£áÅ�Ôi!ãZJyÔ«}e¤~ÔQZkÅZÍAZ�á®Æ%ZiYV™

“��?¹V ðƒñ?ZϧbZôm~h]»×:©Hì?th]“Zzg Development ¹V7ñZzg7K�?QZ¹¾§b%A™Æ�áùH�?

Zôm~h]ÅZ�á®6'¤6ÆdZzgôDòV»g�¿Hå?¾uJZyÅ5kZðc#¿ƒð?¾nïÅgzÝ~ÐVÂ1VÅ×@gõc�Z*y%A™äÅ¢zg]ìÔ�ZyÂ1VÆ!g}~RZzgã�~¥â]ZzgZyÆå:©z

�ZDwÅt£?ÔZyÅÎZöÔ,ZzgZyÆ�Ð%1o¥x @ 7©6�ƒƒVXCÙÂ[Åt@gõÔZkÆXi{]hZecÆW¸i~�gl)�áïÅYñÔ@�‡gMÆalóÅgzÝ~Â[ZzgZkÆqgY]Ã'ic�{W‚yƒX

ðýýðýýð

723x�~£?

Page 325: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:5 ![

ºt�~ù´

�ý�ý�ý�

923ºt�~ù´

Page 326: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwÅ*yâ+ ( Z³ )Z1Z[~1Y[ì( *¸ èoZzg&x�~£?Æ´z{)X»Y{

´)ZDwÆ!¹�~WUgZZ‡q�XZy~ºt£Ñ]Ôp}Ôh]ÔÒ*]Ô»gkÔ�âdÔ»goÔr8/õE)ZÚz-(�â]ÔÂr3§öG

EZ‹�Zzg•gZ]z){�áï

�Ôq¼�Qg�zZzgZôm~ùúVÅßg]~%AzæÍy™Æ�áùHŠìX�~ùúVÅw%"5é GEO�âˆ)zÃ�ZDwƈ(ÅìXikÃ![~ ZyÓx

ÃìX è Z-ùúV»óZzgÂ#_·7ZÏiâä~ Ð C1 »W¸i1091YÆÛWycZzZb2091Y~ƒZX Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^�

ZDwäQg�z*yóg~ÑzqÅXZy»Š*F+�ø[Qg�z*yLL”VŽzt C2 ÆÑg{†g~2091Y~�áùƒZåXÍcZk»iâU’k�c1091YìX Úíˆá F�óóÔ

![~tcƒ_ì��óg~ÐZDwÃ8 *¸ ZDwÅ5i#Ö»Z’Zð�zgåXo9:¶X'×h'WVe:xÁZzgZ�!EV~!ÑoZxÑ•Æ:Z¹Zâ�Û›:¶�z{Zip�*yâ+ŧsázƒDX9p}z£Ñ]Ë�Ûâöc

OçZDw ‘‰Ô �gpZ„6’kK‰cËc~QVñ‰ï]Æ�Z[~Æxp}Å®Z�ic�{7X,Zk§bì:

†g~2091Y ÔуgÔ Úíˆá )1(”VŽzF�Å�gpZ„6þ Úíˆá m2091Yÿ ÔуgÔ Úíˆá )2(i!ÈQg�z)Zôm~ÐFÀ(

ZÆ'2091YÿZq�æZzg�Z!’kþ ÔуgÔ Úíˆá )3(Qg�zi!yº[~

X Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �&À�/õ GG:![4Ô:ÄZy: 1DeìQ,VäZkЬÌp}‘ƒVÔ1ZkÅÃðÞ�]x7XZke~ 2D6zW·¢y»tªk�g„7�:LLZy�0gzV'Å’k»�QyÅ�ZãÆiâä

:m641(X un^lô]Îf^ÙÒ^]mÔq„e^io�æ… )4091Y(ÐÑzqƒ@ìóó)

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^033

Page 327: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZÆ'4091YÔâga5091Y ÔуgÔ Úíˆá )4(¸òi0ÏÔZ%<5B†g~6191Y æÒnØ )5(ZuZ§p�~Zzg¦s

6 ]‰†]…ôìç�p �Ûzg~6191Yÿ B ÔZ%<9 æÒnØ

Z‹ZŸ]Æ�Z[~þ)6(açLZuZ§p�~

�c6191Y B ÔZ%<31 æÒnØ )7(¦sz��tÔZ%<82B�y6191Y æÒnØ )8(DªCÙzD!í

þ ñÑ*æãÆ�Z[~ Ôуg9Bâga8391Yÿ ]uŠ^á )9('Z5ðuz�Zzg�y’kzV~h]Ô»goZzg�âd�Ûâ›’k,�XZ�»gkÔÒ*]Zzg

(~7ƒ@X˜VJZDwÆ writings r~Vz){»ÑgZDwÅLL’kzVóó)The Doctrine of Absolute Unity Zôm~p}»mìXŠ*F+�ø[*y:

ÆÑg{ Indian Antiquary Ô�Æg‚á as Expounded by Abdul Karim Al-Jili

�:ÜsZôm~ÉZyÆQg�zZzgZôm~fíÒp}~ 1C m0091Y~�áùƒZåƒÐŠ*�ø[*yìXZôm~~ZDw»�~fí{ÔQg�zÆ£«~ic�{ìXºt�)»goÔÒ*]Ô»gkÔr~Vz){(ÐsÙ,ÔAÌgL(}

kìXZkÐøg}Zkñ�Å'×h@GƒCì 2C x’k~p}Å®Z�ZR�:´)ZDwäQg�zÅÚZôm~�×ic�{gÉÆ‚BèXOçQg�zi!yÐÓxF�w8o-ö FFZzg›Æ!z��ÔZyÅ�»9zZôm~’kzV6�ìXtÌzZãì�Qg�zÆ'@Zôm~{~�Ûâ›Zzg�Z!p}»ÚƒÁìX

xâÎÆp}z£Ñ]Æ´z{!¹�~fí}~CÙâqÅ’k,�áï�X¼Z¶g~r8/õEÔ‰îsèo)�ñç¦ZÌÆZ±gÐO}p�

‡ây‚i~â»gkÔZ¶g~Ò*]ÔZZ½¬]~Å è> p}Åwgn�(

ŠX H ~�áï Development ˆ~ËŠgFçÆ‚BZÐeZËfÆ£á 1D)ÑzZã(Åz„:zZÍwÆ�z\+z�zxÆ Speeches ,Æa5±Ù 2D

Gg{p}+zÎxÆegp})�1Ô�2Ô�4Zzg�5(X

133ºt�~ù´

Page 328: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ìç�p ó e1 è …Úç‡ Zzg ]‰†]…ôìç�p ˆ»gkÆÜá)�6ZäZ¶gZ]ÐÜK‰(ÔÆázu�âdÔ�vWÅÂ1V6»goÔgLgL¿lâ]z){X

ZDwÅÂzÄ~ùúVÅFKzDz+ZzgZ�ᮄ6%Ãig„)cQ�z!gZôm~h]�áùƒñ(XZK�ŦzFK~ZyÆaÃðzzæ:¶XtÌ

¾qw X ZÃgäZ¹Zâú:�~�z{FKè�Å„™D è ¹YYì�FK´)ZDwäZCÃð�~ù·%A7HÔ:QyÅi0Ï~Ë�zu}¿ÃZk»

X³t�ZyÅi0Ï~ÔZy»Ãð�~ù·�áù:ƒeX Wc ìw,]~ {Ò ÅZ�á®ÐƒZXW Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù �~ùúV»W¸iÔ3491Y~

´)ZDwÆZQg�zZzgZôm~�~ù´ikcWNÐX

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^233

Page 329: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~ù´ � ([)

ZDw è p} /

jV»ZqzWIaZƒŠåÔT Z ©gW!��Á~Z’Z„д)ZDwÆ$åOkZzg½cC6ÅZqM®Z�Æ´z{¹ÐWzÄZZzgZg!� Å5éEO ~úZxZ

Ó#ÖÌ�áï¸X´)ZDwÐZyƒÅ�w8o-ö FFÔo]ZzgÎz»(Z:¯ÄäZk�w8o-ö FFÃZzg(J�cÔOçZDwÅ Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù ZDwåXñß~†Z°iZtÅ%û

ZDwÅZ�á®~{à è Ãz;VÆ*ÑZÈÃä£? è Zk)©à=qÆ7» Development �w8o-ö FFàXZ£t6öƤt@@`äZDwÅi0Ï„~

åX�z'kÔQ,VäZDw �c )Zi÷ŒZ−+(�áù™ Ê׊ËäÿÂrÜ Qg�zFÀ>Zy�~p}ÅFKzZ�á®»ìw C1 ʼnV6��zÂa%A™ÆY9X

Æ*xÐ2631| Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ÌÔ¬U¤t@@`ÃWcXQy»%ûù·¬x6WcXtÂ[ZDwÆÄ~ùúVÅÆ6�áùňX4Z/ è© ÿ3491Yþ~

S~ìXuzgtZzgz„Æ�zZzgZtÑg7K‰X�âp)ZiÝx��gæÔ>Zy:%Z�óó(Æ�k,]»ÑgZ³[`�'ÐìX$4èGELp},]1@4026� è LLð

ÅZÌZzgZDwÆ�~ Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ì'6zWÝx��gæä�âd~Q|[6�á²Z:Z0Zi~gzÝeZàìXQ,VäZDwƧ’kÃLL»�ªW\ZK

Zg�ïƒñ�ì�Zyp}~LLi!yÅ»/ ŒÛ 2C Vw'.e¢Zzg%æFNØ•óóÔ8391Y:m51 Þ¿Ü]Îf^Ù(‰Ë†un‚…�e^��ÒàÚn6 )Z³( 1D

Ô8391Y:m51 ޿܉¶^Œqß^h]Ún†]æ…�扆pÞ¿Ûn6 )[(:mLLbóó Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù 2D

:mLLoóó Zs 3D

333ºt�~ù´

Page 330: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ô1ZkÅÃðVw7�~X 3C }}úcV�óó~ZDwÆÀa�{�0g}�áï�ÔZy~ÐÛZôm~ Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

p}ÆQg�zFZW�X,Zk§bì:)1(¡Òiªî EE0JÃÙ:eZË$¹Òjè

EEÆ*xZDwÆZqîs¯[ñgQ42B†g~1291Y

)m754D474(~Ì ZÍw ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä »Qg�zFÀì)ZilZrŒ‹](¸FÀC1 �áïìX

Our Prophet's Criticism of Contemporary »Z�!û{: å )2(»[g‚ª–[�Ñð7191Y( B )82 New Era ZÝ*y«!g~Æ »Qg�zFÀìX Arabian Poetry

ˆ~Zk»Qg�zFÀLLgÎwZv-ZvmzÅ¢èEELÄÆ�Åw~óó C2 ~�áùƒZX

C3 191Y(~ÖX 7 Z~B уg)8 ‰j^…åÿ‘fx gzi*)C4 »Qg�zFÀìX The Muslim Community ¡6Zq/ZãÃ: è )3(I

)4(8‹0î EE0œZg]WwZ&c�>0391Y:ZÝ[Zôm~~ìX2k*i~»

C5X Qg�zFÀÂaÅßg]~�áùƒZIslam »Qg�zFÀìXZÝ*y«!g Islam and Ahmadism )5(»t]:

C6X )22†g~6391Y(~�áùƒZZk§bZkù´~Qg�z� __ :ZÝ’kZôm~~ì Ú†ÎÄ2Çj^ño )6(�âp

Ôm141D741 Letters of Iqbal Zôm~Q�!: 1D)ÑzZã(Ôm421D621 Speeches Zôm~Q�!: 2D

LL»[g‚ª–[å»Z�!û{óóÆ‚B%AäáW»*x7�X¸�Q,VäZÐQg�z 3D:m991D202( ]Îf^ÙÒo]ö…�æÞ%† *y¦gHìÔeZË„�]'w~ÌZÏß.»Dg�)

Ææk;Z{V¸Xªkì�z„ZkÆáW�X ‰j^…åÿ‘fx)ÑzZã(Ôm301D701 Speeches åZôm~Q�&À�/õ GG:ikÃÂ[»e�3Xbz~Q�! 4D

)ÑzZã(Ôm3D61 Speeches Zôm~Q�!: 5Dm671D991 : Zs 6D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^433

Page 331: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

g{YCìZ�ZÝ®Z�}ic�{ìX%AÃÜsWJ 1C 0gzVÅ®Z�ÜsWJ’k,�ø[ƒÃX%AäWy~�zp}ÆÎZCÙ*yÆW¸i~â~»jZ!�c

~Zzg�zu~âga ~!Ñlo�áùƒZåX«mZÆ'4091Y Úíˆá ìXLL¸òi0Ïóó5091Y~Ô1%AäZk*y»â~ÜsZÆ'4091YCcìX

Q~%AäZôoZzgf)�Zg~»o]�cìXÓx�!p}�VÆ èÜXZk§bZ5ZzgÂ" ÂV�áïK‰�Ô@ë}}©à‚¥scg�z$wMì

ŹÏZ+ZÝoÅ¡7ƒmÔ�Š*¶V~ñ���Ô´z{Zi,‰ZÝoÅßg]Ì$wˆìX,tì:

Ú–^Únà]Îf^Ù S � 9Q)or 6 11 2C )o„rìÔF¹ 73 3C ìX:F¹øg}¸ÇV 6 73 4C øg}yz¸ÇV

¬Ð� 2 83 5C ¬�rZg; 8 83 6C rzZg;uz§»Ñ]íÐ 1 67 7C uz§»Ñ]ЙzZð 1 67 8C ™Zð

è …Úç‡ ZÍwÔ ]‰†]…ôìç�p i!ÈQg�zÔQg�zi!yº[~Ôòi0ÏÔ'Z5ðuz�Zzg�yÔ 1DÆ�âdZzg½kZ³Z�!».ÞX µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ ZÍwZzg e1ìç�p

ÔZÆ'2091YÔm2ÔS91 Úíˆá 2DZsÔâga5091YÔm63ÔS31 3D

3ÔS71Ô81 7 ZsÔm 4DZsÔm73ÔS01 5DZsÔm73 6D

ÔZDw�ZÍwÔm7791YÔm584ÔS8 ÞÏç� 8BZ~7191YÔfZ! Ô ‰j^…åÿ‘fx 7D9 ZsÔm584ÔS 8D

533ºt�~ù´

Page 332: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ú–^Únà]Îf^Ù S � 9Q"3ðEEO‘4øG 61 67 1C ‘4øE

pZ<îE0�z˜Ví 31 77 2C pZz�z˜V�ZkŠgÄÅ°p�Ûâð 31 77 3C �ŠgZkÄÅ�Ûâð!h42.ç GEGE 4 84 4C !h42.ç GEGweZzg!Öº�v 14 94 5C wec!Öº�v

ç¿ 71 94 6C $š54èG

GGEL¿Zò[ 2 15 7C Zm]Z0Zi{ƒYì 9 15 8C Z0Zi{7ƒY

Zy~ÐZqW�|ÂÂ"ÅtŒÛZg�~Y$ËìÔ1ZÒp´VZgZ�~ZzgÅg~�X‰Z,£â]6Ô˜Vg�z$wÅRöò$˶Ô%Aä¥s7HÔ}�9S66LLZknÅ£góóÃLLZkn»£góóZzg�9S86LL°x¡Å£góóÃLL°x¡»£góó¯cYYåÔYèLL£góó!Ñ·tè™ìX

�| Wc�ŒÛWã~ZݹÂ"ic�{�ÔSîLL'Z5ðuz�Zzg�yóó~èÃgZqWH ‰ZÖp»Š*Z5Z(g X )m881Ô981Ô091( ÆÎZÓxWc]~ZÝoQñ���ì: 7;Ô�&À<é GX)m83(z){X‰F¸V»Z5Zk§b ŠìÔ}:¦;)m23(Ô

12 ÔZDw�ZÍwÔm7791YÔm854ÔS ÞÏç� 8BZ~7191YfZ! ‰j^…åÿ‘fx( 1DZsÔm684ÔS01 2DZsÔm684ÔS01D11 3D

ÔTZÍwÔ�Z³ÔS2 ]‰†]…ôìç�p �âp D4ZsÔmLL`óóÔS8D9 5D

óÔS2 zó ZsÔmLL 6DóÔS01 zó ZsÔmLL 7DóÔS8 ió ZsÔmLL 8D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^633

Page 333: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]4--.ç FHE)m1(ÔZÍ')m8(Ôec)m701(¸��Á~VÆ*xZϧb‘YD~̸Z5MìX �^�]Îf^Ù ¸ÔYè

èZDw è Ô´)ZDwÅ�æz%A™äÅZqZ’ZðÏÃÒ¶X� Ú–^Únàô]Îf^ÙÅ 1C »9z%AÅóƒVÐZzÍg;ÔQÌ6Zäg‚bÐZDwÆWJp}

!icÄZzgZyÅDz+zZ�á®Ô%AÅZ+}#ÖìÔ&ÃZ0Zi7HYYXZDwÆZÍA�~ù´»Ñs¾qwZÐqÝgìÇXtù·ËS�¬Æ%7HŠ

QÆÒpÐtÔˆ~Z�á®5kƒä è ìXÍÔZk~p}Å®Z�ÁìÔ1¡6¯Eg�ìX ]Îf^ÙÒ1Þ%†p]ÊÓ^… Zzg ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù zZá�zâVùúV

£Ñ�ZDw /

ÅZ�á®Æä'kÔ3691Y~Ô±†ZßZug»%ûù”î0 Ú–^Únàô]Îf^ÙÆ*xÐ�áùƒZXuzgtÔzg¾Z[)¯x:YzhZzg¡{(Ô ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù p}Ô

p}Zzgl))>Zy:LL�g]óóZieZ˱·†ZvÔm7D81(ÆZVg{Ú è z„,]ƈ'Æ!g{,CLL7ÂóóÃZ³[`�'ÐÑgHŠìX$4èGEL

ìX Â[��1ÐÑzqƒ™742J�ìXWy~&,]»Zq¡*)�áïeZ˱†Zvä´)ZDwÅ�óg~»W~õ²*î™DƒñQyÆQ|�

�ÆZgùVŶy�„ÅìZzgt³Z~Hì�LL�á²ZDwZq»�§i»�ógAäZL7Â~´)ZDwÅ,Zzg„~QyÆ�~p}Å % C2 ÌåXóó

�XZiZV 3C ZÌ6cÅìXQyÆìw~tp}LLQg�zi!y»²-÷YEEL¤ZVâtóó

%AäLL7Âóó~�!£Ñ]ZzgZyÆâ~Z]»f™HìX

Qg�z’kzV»ù·ìÔZ¤pQg�z’kzVÅ®Z�WJ„ìX� Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ã�~îg6 1Dip}ÔZôm~’kzV»Qg�zFÀ�XZDwÆFZWÔZk£áÆ�Z]{cÐ{g`

ÏX ,]~ÔZôm~’kzVÆùúVÆK~ikcWN { �XZÝZôm~’k,WÒ:m71Ô81 ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù 2D

Zs:mLL`óó 3D

733ºt�~ù´

Page 334: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~�áï�0gzVÅ®Z�aäìXZy~&�0g})»[ ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^ÙZsð(ZDwÅZôm~’kzV è ¡6Zq/ZãÃXÜÄ è g‚ª–[»Z�!û{XI

è ÆK~W[ìXLLÜÄ Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ÆFZW�XZÍwZ™�zp}»E™{The Sociological »FÀìÔ�ßyÆg‚! Political Thought in Islam ZsðóóThe Hindustan Review )�Ñð8091YÔm942@162(~�áùƒZÔZiZV Review

(~ÌÖåX 2C )2291Y Muslim Outlook (ZzgQ 1C )Z[W!�Ô�c0191YZzg†g~1191YCcìÔ� 4C

"Islam and Khilafat"c3C †ZßZugäZk»ÄZyLLZsx~ÜÄóó�g„7ìXz{��:

The substance of article on "Islam and Khilafat" was incorporated by Iqbal in

"Political Thought in Islam", published later on in The Hindustan Review'5C

g™räLLZsxZhÜÄóóÃZqZµ*y�ìÔqÑèLLZsx~ÜÄóócLLZsxZhÜÄóóÆÄZyÐZDwäLÃð*y7�Ô�g|6�Qz6f™ƒZÔtZq„*yìÔ��z&!gZg‚b~TƒZXZk»Qg�zFÀ

L7Âóó L C6 ÂaÅ^~уgÐ�áùƒZX ì¡Êkô]‰¡Únä )Zia�O~·@(Islam: A Social and ë�:´)ä0191Y~t¼Z¥|~ g™r ~The Muslim 6�cåX)mLLsóó(tÒy�g„7XZ¥|)»ÄZy political Ideal

¡6Zq/ZãÃóóÆ è åÔT»Qg�zFÀ)ZiñÑ*;Z{V(LLI Community

ÄZyÐF(¾[ìXt¼1191Y~�cŠåX)ÑzZã(:m701 Speeches D1:m37 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù D2

:m88þ ]Îf^ÙÒo]ö…�æÞ%† ÿeZË„�]'w~äšïZktÃ�CÙZ�cìÔ p$4èGELZDw:mLL[óó D3A m4Zzg ÔBibliography of Iqba l X) "XIV" )zZu(TZÍw:m Thoughts 4D

ÌZÏß.»Dg�(X "54èGEGE% Ôm51Æ Bibliography of Iqbal

X Zs D5*Ñ:;'Z�gkÔуg3291YÔm13)Âa~tzŸs�g`ì�t½kÔZDwä8091Y 6D

~ZLªÄßyÆiâä~Ô0yZsî΂ÌÆikZÈxÂ{ZqH~Ŷ(X

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^833

Page 335: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

LL»[g‚ª–[å»Z�!û{óóÆ0ÌikÃù´Æ%A»ÒyoÔ~�*yñÑ*;Z{Vä ‰j^…åÿ‘fx ìXz{��:LLZÒZx[»ìwå�

�áùHåÔz{�áhZôm~*y»FÀìÔ1ZÞtì�tQg�z»*y´)äZk*yÆQg�zZzg C1 ÆaQg�z~�åóóX ‰j^…åÿ‘fx Å�gpZ„6 V ñÑ*;Z{

Zôm~áy»ñZi:HYñÔ™s¥xƒ@ì�t�zZµp}7ÉQg�zQÔOur ,]~ëZq(C`��ZÝZôm~*y *¸ Zôm~’k»FÀìXNew Era ÆÄZyÐ Prophet's Criticism of Contemporary Arabian Poetry

191Y(~�áùƒZåÔgÔ!]tì�Zk*yÅZ�á®ÆÖˆÔ 7 �Ñð B )82´)ZDwÐZÏñçq6Qg�z*yÉ�¶Å�gpZ„»�ZiHå?´)ZDwÅt

Ú~ÌêZiªkì�Q,Vä°Z|gZk�ÛâöÅz™�~Ô'×h'WVtÌ�NZ·tì�tQg�z*yÔZyÆZôm~*y»ƒÉFÀìXZÝ|tì

ƬÑg}~)¸�ZDwÅÃð5 ‰j^…åÿ‘fx �ñÑ*;Z{VäZL6Z¶g’k:Y6ZyÆ(Zôm~*y»Qg�zFÀ„�áù™�cX¸Zkyì�tFÀQ,Väp�„HƒÇX

ã�~îg6ÔZDwÅQg�z’kzV»ù· ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù P™{!ÑFZWÐsÃÔ0g}�áï�X ìXZk~p}Ô�âdÔ»goÔ»gkZzgr8/õEªCÙ§bÆ�

qZyÅâÎÆ_.Zk§b„HYYì:p}Å®Z�WJìX~Ðeg)i!ÈQg�zÔQg�zi!yº[~Ôò )1(

~�áï�X!¹egp} Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù i0ÏÔ'Z5ðuz�Zzg�y(Âz„�Ô�()æÍy�XQÆ»© 2C )i!ÈQg�zÔZuZ§p�~Zzg¦sÔaçLZuZ§p�~Ô${ð GOsz��t

_¬ÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�%AäZÝâ~ÆO}Uâ~fgZùÐQqÝHìXDìX t!]{mîg6ZÍwZ™p}Æ0

:mLLqóóX ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù 1DB†g~Ô9B�Ûzg~Zzg31B�c6191YX 5 æÒnØ m2091YÔ Úíˆá ZÍAZ�áÈ:ZZnK D2

933ºt�~ù´

Page 336: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Æ*xZDwÆ�zîsèo5091Y~ZyÆуgЉ`î æ›à )2(Ziñ»*xÿñß~Z¶YZv{Vþ7CcXWy~âÅ æ›à Ågz�Z�6��Ô%AäZiñ

m5091YƒãecX B âÞ5091Y�g`ìÔ�52 B @gõ52)3(ZDwз�+¯t»Zqr/>ZyLLZq�Nk?óóÔZk»ñçq

ÔZ~4191Y(X Ò�Ûn†p+ˆH ¦sìX)âpfZi)4(i»gktyZ�å»Ð÷1191Y;&B¨ÿEL~�Z#;Z°kZ³×eZsx;

ÏZ[2391YZzg*Z+A.èEEELZ�!».Þ3391YÆñZµ6ZDwÆ¿æ!]Åg7gIV6

ÐâpfìÔ1Zk» Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ��X¸yZ™¤t@@`Æù´ÄZyps™ÆLLZDwÅZq½k».Þ~óó™�cŠìX

Æ�âdX µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ Zzg e1ìç�p è …Úç‡ )TZÍwz�zx( ]‰†]…ôìç�p )5(Zzg u†mkô]‰¡Ý Ô ]Újv^áÚn6µ^ŒaçÞ1Ò^+ö† )6(·�+¯tÅ&£?)

(6ZDwÅ¿»goX Òç:o ‰ç]Þx¡ÚäÂf‚]ÖvÓn܉n^Ù

~�!Óx’kzVÆâ~Ŷy�„7ÅÔ@ë‰ ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù %AäÆWy~Qkg‚ácZ¶g»*xÉ�cÔ˜VÐ’kZ~ňXZy~ÐZÒóg�á]ZqÐiZZ!g¾_�XQÆNg»©_¬Ð¥xƒ@ì�%Aät’k,ZÍA$ó~ÐqÝ7XÔÉUâ~fgZùÐÜÅ�X�’k,ÔI

ÚÏ^Ÿlô ~�áï�Ôg™räz�ÐZ~Å�XOç Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù Zi,ÔTZÍwÔLL»[g‚ª–[å» ]‰†]…ôìç�p ~®wÔLL¸òi0ÏóóÔLL�âpóó�~ ]Îf^Ù

Z�!û{óóZzgLL'Z5ðuz�Zzg�yóóÆQ~Ìz„¥Ã]ZzgZÝoQ�Ô�~ñ���ÔZ�ZÍAâ~Zy¥Ã]ZzgZÝoÐ0u�X)�&À�/õ GGÔ Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

Æ,]:ZZnK ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù (ZzgñZiäÆa�&À�/õ GG: ZDw è [5:p} !Ô 98151

Ô 98141

Ô 88171

Ô 78141

Ô 2551

Ô 258

Ô 1531

Ô 157

Ô 226

�:S:

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^043

Page 337: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

4åÔ%AUâ~â~»jZ!�ïX 65151

Ô 6517

Ô 5512

Ô 45191Ô 3514

Æ%AÆuƒCX Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù @�ZyZÝoZzg¥Ã]Åf)�Zg~†ZßZugäZÝQ~p�̼�FZçzZ&q]Zzg¥Ã]K�XZ5

QÅPVB5±Ù: è Åp=VÐܽÙDƒñÔfs~p~»Q ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù S � ZÝQ S �

Ôm2091Y Úíˆá

3„XÃgzi%{ 21 21 3„gzi%{ 7 2Ât·t 81 21 ·t 31 2Z(§’kZ(gH 01 31 Z+§’kÃZ(gH 01 3

Åi!y6 02 31 Åi!âV6 5 30õÑÄ 4 51 55ÑÄ 12 4Zk!]Ã 51 51 ZkZ%Ã 31 5

ÆÓx½cC 7 61 ƽcC 6 6Zôm~Æ 7 71 Zôm~i!yÆ 5Ô6 6

ÁZzg 31 71 ÁÔ!qZzg 21 7ZÆ'6091Y Ô Úíˆá

®» 41 12 ®W» 6 72Qg�zYìK 9 22 Qg�zi!yYìK 2 62W\äZLZk 12 63 W\äZk 3 93

º!õzgZ] 1 83 º!ZÖpzõzgZ] 91 93T~Zkõzg}»9ZEwñ��ìX

7Ô8 83 X~Zkõzg{»9ZEwì

4 04

143ºt�~ù´

Page 338: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

»Q ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù S � ZÝQ S �F¹ 7 15 iF¹ 21 63¢zgc]7gZ 9 15 ¢zgc]Ã7gZ 31 63*ÂZV 21 15 ®z*ÂZV 61 63

�X;VZ%Z 7 25 �XZ%Z 9 73¬Ð� 8 25 ¬� 01 73j,ƒÂ 11 25 j,ƒÌ 31 73Z*� 41 25 ÙZ*� 51 73

lZggziZ‚ÛzV 12 25 lZgZy~gziZ‚ÛzV 12 73Z�ÛZ�Æ 1 85 Z�ÛZ�xÆ 7 24

‰wya 61 85 ‰wîg6ya 12 24�2gÆ 02 85 �2g.eÆ 3 24

g ‰p´VÂeZ{Á�Ô}:LLZk²[äZLÄ~ZkÅÍyÅ!]½¶óóÙräLLZk²[äZLÄ~Z+ÃyÏ!]½¶óó)m981(¯�cìXZϧb:LLZkÆìÑ]»7gZZ0Zi{ƒYìóóÃLLZkÆìÑ]»7gZZ0Zi{7ƒYóó)m651(

$wŠìX ~ps™�cìXQ~Zy¥Ã]ÆË~„g]»ZÝ|xZyVßVÐZ0Zi{Î*Â7�%AäQ~Ô"�g$Z&bÅìXë

äÜs�z£Ñ]Æ¡P¥Ã]Ŷy�„ÅìÔzg:¥Ã]Ååz„¹îsìXXp=V6ZݹÂ"»áyƒYìÔZ¹ÃZ0Zi™�cŠìXÂ[ÆWy~¡*)ÆikÄZyQ™kZÝoÅ�z„%AňìÔQÐu™ÆÌZÝoÅ®Z�šI¾ôzVJBìXnz�}PZÝoÂœ»³ƒ$Ë�Ô1CÙ

C1 Z•ðÑ6zZðÐňìX pZã Ô60õ0õiiZÝotªCÙ™C��6zs

ÔT�zxÆ ]‰†]…ôìç�p m31Zzg0260õ0õÔ2566Zzg9569BZÝoz¥Ã]ñ���X 1D�kS~�âd)m391(~&�V�X³äã�~â~ÐS²7HX

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^243

Page 339: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ñ6zZðZzg™IÆ:F£â]ÐQÅ7g~7g~S,¸T�Ô}:»Q ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù S � ZÝQ S �

Ôm2091Y Úíˆá'gÄa�Zzg' 12 51 'gÄa�X:Qg�z

æ äpÜszèÆy~ZÑÝìT~¼âgzZh~Zzgº!ZbZÌ�áï�Zzg'

91 5

ÔZÆ'2091Y Úíˆá'��VŠxŠx' 31Ô41 83 '�!<mZyßÍV

Ã�Z3ÿXLi!V7�ÔŠxŠx'

9 04

]Îf^Ù ô Ú–^Únà fZ! ]uŠ^á'Z6ÆËZzg' 12 322 Z6ÆQßwÅ

~ÃðEZL wè Z0g7g�Zzg�

Z½ÜZ6ÆËZzg'

41D51 881

'ƒÏZzg-g\' 31 522 ƒÏÔOç-g\» 'Š/�*Æ‚tìÔZ-g\Å�´zu]0g{0g{ƒZzg-g\Å'

5Ô6 481

¡6Zq è tTgÂœUvsƒIÔZq(el|S�Z·vsňì:LLI

343ºt�~ù´

Page 340: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

/ZãÃóó)m921ÔS3Ô4(ÆtZÖp:LLº[~Zsò§]»A%:Zk)®Å)m39(Zzg·†ZvŒÛ7 Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ^~ªCÙƒZìÔ&�Û£îG0‡�cãë�óóX

~Ìñ���Xg™rä�äYVZ¹vs™�cXŒÛWyz Q C1 Æ®wugZzg²!ZÃgÆQ»qwZkÐÌZFìXFWc]~Z²Z[7Îñ‰

Z¤Z²Z[�Âß)m142Ô642(X )m85Ô801Ô312Ô512Ô032Ô442Ô542Ô742(ÔZkù´Æ%AÔZDw6FQg�zZzgZôm~W~ùúVÆ'¸ZzgZDw

ÐîszZÕgn¸XZ¹ÔZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÐ>mů6Z»�òÆÃÚ–^Únàô]Îf^Ù {äZzg�vßZióÐ7‚ãZ.�}ÅœªÌqÝg„Ô'×h'WV

�áùƒðÔ6ZäZ¶gZ]zg‚bд)ZDwÅ ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù Æä‚wÔZ¹Ï�~’k,LL�gcÄóóÅY_�ÔZ,z‰Ü~ZzgZ,‚iÇgqÑ]~%"ìGEL

èZDwÆZqYìFZzgRù´Å£g~Dz+zZ�á®Åµ è Ð� ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^ÙÅßg]~³Z•ðâ-kÁìX¢zg~jZÙzÂí]»ZŸ†Â ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù ¶Ô1

QÐu�gzÑ6zZðZzgê'CˆìX®Z�ÆZ±gÐ è Zq§sg;Ô¡ÅWJQg�zóg�á]6¾{�0gzV»ZŸ†HŠìÔ156Zヒk, Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

ZÝoÐ%æFN�Xøg}dÝwÅZkÐic�{Z\k*uVwZzgHƒÏ�%Aätù·ZkS�¬Æ‚B7Hì:

/Ô�§gÓcg}™�x è qÝ)mLLuóó( p÷�»g}™�x è �á�xZii0ÏZݹQÔâ'×h’kzV»ZŸ† è ·†ZvŒÛ7äTZÍwÆ42p}6Ôš�g4

HX8891Y~tZecÌWsZ�[уg„ä�áùHX

ZDwÆ�~Z°g /

(Z¥| Þç]�…ô]Îf^Ù †ZBgOä´)ZDwÆázu¯x6�Zqù·)zq™�~¶Ô ÌÑ Ð�áùHåXZÏiâäÐQ,VäikÃù´Å»g~

)m01(TÆË~282,]ÅtÂ[âga7791Y~�‹Ð�áùƒðX:m48 ÎçÚo‡Þ‚+o]æ…Ú×kôen–^µ†]mÔÂÛ†]ÞoÞ¿† 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^443

Page 341: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

%Aä�âd)>Zy:²%A(~Zkù´Æ�ZiZzgZkÅLLZÌzZÐZ�eóó6gzÝeZàìÔ��:

¬x6W[ìZzgQyƯxƼ�ZecÌ'Z'ä è© ZDw»½ãÓxÄ~uâtgì�Ô1ZyÅ�~’kzV~{mîg6QyÆp}Ô�W`ÐæM'k¬

ÅZ�á®ÆˆZDwÆ*c[ Þç]�…ô]Îf^Ù �áùƒñÔZ[*c[zÁc[�'p}ňlz[Yg~g„ÔTÆË~=ZDwÆF*yZ,AÔqZ[JÂ!ßg]~�7HŠåXtp}X6Zäg‚ßV~�áùƒñÔz{

Ú–^Únàô Ãè Ì*c[�X_Åœî0ZDwÆe~Zyp}ÅZÌzZÃ�eÆ7Æ‚B‚Bt*ù·~äFK�cìÔT~ZDwÆ33*y«!g ]Îf^Ù

@g]FKÆ‚B7KYgì�'Z�OP‚wƒñÔZDwÆkKZzg¼ÌZÏeÅZq ]Îf^ÙÒ1Þ%†p]ÊÓ^… *c[’kzVÆPZzgù´‚tWñ�X

C1 Zëš~ì')T~(«!g´)ZDwÆZãp}�7KYgì�XÍcikÃù´»]4ïEEL@;tì�:ZDwÆ9�~p}*c[zå[�X 1D

ƈ(Ëù´~�áï7�X Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù t*c[zÁc[p}) 2DZkЬ´)ZDwÆZãp}Ëù´~�77K‰X 3Døg}ìw~Wy~:Â!Ç"ziyìXZ¤p}Åic�{Ðic�{®Z�Ã

�™*„°�åÔÂZkÐFkic�{B#ÖÆîsQg�zZzgZôm~kKZzgZôm~p}Zzg»gkñ���q)FÀ™Æ(ù´Ã}ic�{?ZzgYì¯cYYåÔZ%¬�zï]ÔLL]4ïEEL@;óó~ã�~ZÌgn�X

ZDwÆ´z{Z[J´)ZDwÆp}z£Ñ]Zzg»gkzÒ*]Æ è kKqgzfsù´�áùƒ`�:

3491Y Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù 1D3691Y ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù 2D

:m01 ]Îf^ÙÒ1Þ%†p]ÊÓ^… 1D

543ºt�~ù´

Page 342: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

7691Y ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 3D9691Y +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù 4D7791Y ]Îf^ÙÒ1Þ%†p]ÊÓ^… 5D

C1 Å"~ Zkù´Æ7ÂógZzgZ³F¹Qg�zyƾwóR~»[ÜZÜìX%Aä�âd~LLkKZzg¼*c[’kzVÆPZzgùóó À»!

~ÐË»*x71Xù´ +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù c ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Ô ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù Åã!]ÅìÔ1+Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù Zzg ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù »f™MìÔ1 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ~�ákzVÆqd/õ IG~

ÌèÃg7ÔTÐt&éGMWMì�%AZy�zâVùúVÆz��Ð"ìX }P™{!Ñ�zâVùúVZzg†ZBgOÆù´Æ�gxyZZnK�kZzgWJ'k»z9ìXZ•ð!“ïILÀZzg½ã*‡&ÿEL¢Z%ì�Ãð'ikïñçq6ZÏi!yZzgZÏ'x~a�{ZzgWJ'kI�áùƒäzZàÂ1VÐÑDg;ƒXDzïÅ�*~¥â]Ŷc"~Ãð±g70$ËZzgZkÑdů6Ãð'g¬e»

�7�YYXÆ%Aäù´~�áïÓx’kzVÆâ~Z]»jZ! ]Îf^ÙÒ1Þ%†p]ÊÓ^…

7�cÔfs~ZyÅ,7ÅYCì:�vù&Ã ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù

»�Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

»��0g{ Ñg�

1 __ ”VŽzF� 161 8 Qg�zi!yº[~ 211 1 i!ÈQg�z 3

3691Y Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� __ __ Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� �âp 493 52 ¸òi0Ï 5

:m62D13 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù__ __ ÃZÚz-þ ‡Ú^Þä Î�7’qÿ 6

ÆLL¸�Ãðù·�áù7ƒZóóX)m8( Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù LL7Âóó~eZËÜZÜ��� 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^643

Page 343: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�vù&Ã ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù

»�Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

»��0g{ Ñg�

Zsò-ãzg; 7:m872 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

__ �âV»ZJy 8Ô�zx: …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn†

m44D2535 84 ÔZÍw ]‰†]…ôìç�p �âp 9

061 __ Zzg¦s ]‰†]…ôìç�p 01: ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jäì_ç½ô m37D77Ô

:m411D911 ]Îf^Ù

__ __ » 1C 6Z‹ZŸ] ]‰†]…ôìç�p�Z[ÿ¯[þ

11

171 __ 2C ]‰†]…ôìç�p þ è ÿu 21281 __ ¦sz��t 31

:m862 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù__ __ DªCÙz!í 41781 57 ÄÆ�Å è gÎwåÔ®

w~51

__ 45 …Úç‡ôe1ìç�p �âpÔ 61Æ] µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ

Zec102 65 µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ �âpÔ 71

:m14Ô ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù__ __ è<ØZzg(„ 81

:m442 +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù

142 __ [ÏZ[ 91

QÆÄZy~LLZ‹Znóóì)m201(X 1D�Ô�ßìX ]‰†]…ìç�p %AäÄZy 2D

743ºt�~ù´

Page 344: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�vù&Ã ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù

»�Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

»��0g{ Ñg�

712 102 ½k:Z³Z�!Ô».Þ 02:m54 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

__ __ t])1( 12:m74 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

__ __ t])2( 22:m122 u†Íô]Îf^Ù __ __ £î�ZsòÅ

¢zg]32

Ô�zx:m262 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä __ __ Zsx]ÿZÝ:Zôm~¯[þ 42__ __ DZÑ[ 52591 __ ~�Z# 62

)�Á( Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ùm401D501

__ __ ZqÄÅ=ô 72

: u†Íô]Îf^Ùm222D522

__ __ ‚Áâ»�xÿZÝ:Zôm~þ 82

122 081 ZsxZzg¸èÿ'Z5ðuz�Zzg�yþ

92

ÂaÅßg]~Ì�ø[ìX

511 __ Zsð è ÜÄ 03

ÂaÅßg]~Ì�ø[ìX

__ 97 ¡6Zq/Zãà èI 13

:m742 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù__ __ Û}ZsxÆrF_¬

ÿÅþ�ú]23

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^843

Page 345: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�vù&Ã ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù

»�Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

»��0g{ Ñg�

ÔZÍw:m754 ]Îf^ÙÞÚä __ 46 ¡ÒiªîEE0JÃÙ 33

__ 791 Ú†ÎÄ2Çj^ño �âp 43

e:m711 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù

__ __ ]‰†]…ôìç�p &èol:m661D071 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù &èolÃ�è

Zk,ЪCÙì��7)Zsò-ãzg;(Zzg�52)DZÑ[(Æ´z{Óxóg�á]ñ��z�ø[ùúV~�áï�XZkÐ%AÅz{�zâV!'ßU"ƒYC�ÔXÅã�6tù·%AHŠ)�:ZÍwÔZkù´~�áï9�~

p}*c[zÁc[�Ô�zxÔt*c[zÁc[p}Ëù´~�áï7(Zk§bgZ¶Æìw~Zkù´ÅZ�á®»Ãð�Zi!¹7gLX

@ë%AäÔtù·ZZkS�‘é OÆ‚B7Hì�:LL~äZDwÅxˆl™Æ¸xÅ÷Z_ÔxJàäÅ[ÅìZzgZDw62VÆa ’kzVÃ

Zq*c[θ]óó)m51(�Zk§b:LLZDw6ï™äzZßVÃZyÆp}ƒZq(ïYNÐóó)m11(ÂZk»Y{¢¢zg~ìXSîZk$©�î EG0ÃÐ�Z÷�

QÆÒpÐZkLLθ]óóÅHwìZzgZ3ÿXLïZkйVJÃZ{ è Zzg¡QVM�X

%A»�úòì�t*c[p}6ZäZ¶gZ]zg‚bÐZ~K‰�Ô1zVÆ!g}~t!]97ìX¹Ï’k,%AäUâ~fgZùÐ Óx’k

TZÍw»�âpQ,VäÔZÝÂ[Ð7ÔÉ ]‰†]…ôìç�p Z~Å�Ô}ÐÜHì)1Zk»jZ!7�c(t!]QZzgZ5Æ»©_¬Ð Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù

zZãƒCì:

943ºt�~ù´

Page 346: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]Îf^ÙÒ1Þ%†p]ÊÓ^… S � Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù S � ZÍw Ô ]‰†]…ôìç�p �¿èç 71 78 ¿ç 71 94 �¿ �

zuZ−+ 31 88 zuZ−+ 51 05 ZzuZ−+ zZò[ 91 88 Zò[ 2 15 Zm] zZ0Zi{ƒYì 3Ô4 98 Z0Zi{ƒYì 9 15 Z0Zi{7ƒY iz‰Ü 5 09 z‰Ü 01 25 ¸] ~

)m222@522(ÐâpfìÔ1jZ!7�c u†Íô]Îf^Ù ZϧbLL‚Áâ»�xóó�ZÝo0ðYC�Ôz{Zkù´~Ì�VÅÂVñ�� Å 1C ~F3 u†Íô]Îf^Ù ŠX

»FÀ:LLYäHHóóHŠìÔ��g„7XZÏ heaven knows what else �Ô}»FÀ:LLpV have proved demons of bloodshed tyranny and oppression §b

ìX 2C gm~Ô\ÅZzgi'�„WiZ�~Æ�-@U"ƒñóóßtÂ[O~�ìÔeìt*ÑÅ6g~ƒÔ1Â"ÌËZiplâö

~ZzgÌÑ6zZð'Cˆì)É}}áyƒ@ì� pZã Ð7™ZðˆXQ6zs�¼»AäÉ�cÔQÐ�V»ÂVY\�cŠì(OçZݹÂ"zZ5ÅÒ]ìÔ}}ZÝQÅ7g~Tg¸T�Ô}:m781Ôk6Å„g]ÜsZâì:LLi0ÏZzgZkÆ’Æa¢zg~ìóóÔZ�9QZk§bƒ*ecå:LLi0ÏZzgZkÆZ°g~q3ZzgëW°ƒ$ËìÔ�ZqZ#ÖÅúZzgZkÆ’Æa

¢zg~ìóóXZÏ*yÆW¸iÐtZÖp¸T�:LL~äZL^q:uz�'açL��IZizíZ„óóX

QÐê»ZqZëUÔM®Z�~ÅYäzZàp´VZzg¥Ã]�Ô è¡qd/õ IG~%AäCcì�LLÃZk»Zôm~FÀÌÖóóªz{Zkß.»Dg�� 1DZÝ�xQg�z~åÔZ�ßg�qwZkÆ'@ìX

9FÀtƒÇ:LLpVgm~ó\ÅZzgZëZ�Æ*eU"ƒñóóX 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^053

Page 347: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

XÐÎZz‡]ZÝ|x„Z«ƒŠìÔ}:LLZ0Zi{7ƒYóóÃLLZ0Zi{ƒYìóó¯�cX)m98Ôk3Ô4(LL¸]óóÃLLz‰Üóó~$w�cìX)m09Ôk5(LLWÙ7óóÅ

(LLWÙ�óó™�cX)m9Ôk12(t&)Zzg'×heg(¥Ã]0õ,]Å’k)�âpÔTZÍw(~K‰�XZk’k~WJ£â]6ZÖpvs™�b‰ ]‰†]…ôìç�p

�ÔGg{ZݹÂ"ZzgZ5Åp´VZk6eZ��Xm556ZÝoZzg¥Ã]Å®Z��kÔm656WJZzgm5816‚]ìXm5416�zSÅŒÛWãWe~&�VZzg

m051D1516egS~ug~0õ�Vñ���Xm7716ZqÄ~&ZÝo)m431Ô531( e1ìç�p è …Úç‡ �Xm386Ý©&%û�ìZzgÐV!gßX�âp

ÅaäSzV~Î!ZÝoz¥Ã]X�X}„g]ÅcZ¤Z¢5ë EEY~ÔZÝQÆO}%AcplâöäfZCßZ[�hлx1ìXZk§bÒ�ZÝo~tù·ÔÓx‚—ùúV6!i~áŠìX

%AÅ¥â]Ì{à*³�XZôm~*yÆQg�zFZWÃz�zxÆ�Zµ�HŠìÔZ¤%AÃZk!]»Dƒ@�zZÍwÅ&’k,)£î�ZsòÅ¢zgc]ÔZsx]Ô‚Áâ»�x(ÌZôm~’kzVÆFZW�ÔÂGz{

ÔZÆ'4091YCcì)¸�Zk Úíˆá Z¹Ìz�zx~�áï™DXLL¸òi0Ïóó»â~~�zÇV~ÖåÔ Úíˆá ~ZÚ„jZ!ì(qÑèt*yÔ Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù a�

~ �$^…ô]Îf^Ù Zzg ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù Ô ]Þç]…ôÎf^Ù �zu~mâga5091Y~�áùƒðX%Aä®w‰’kzVÃLLÁc[óóCcì)m571Ô972(qÑèP™{ù´�ø[zñ���ZzgZyÆt�Ñ]Ëßg]ÌLLÁc[óóŒÛZg7�bYMX

%AäZkù´~�áïp}Å®Z�33Cðì)m01(Z�ZÝ®Z�„~Ôp}ÆÑg�92ƈ!¹p}à 53kìXttZkzzЃð�z

QÐ�82ÐÑgHŠìXÂ"ÅZktŧsÔ%AÔ*Ñc6zspZVËÅÃ7ˆZzgZk¯6Ãå%AÔZLù´~�áï�0gzVÅ9®Z�Ð"�X

%Aä�ì�Zkù´Å~ï™äzZßVÃtƒp}Zq(ïQŃCìZzgZkù´»ƒÐ è YNÐ)m11(Xï~ã�~ZÌÔ¡

153ºt�~ù´

Page 348: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ic�{$zgUZk»*³QìÔ®ZZkß]ÒûQÅã�6�ïƒÏÔZk»³ÆaZkÂ[ÅZÃ�e#ìÔÉgZ¶Æìw~¬x‡gMÆa > ¥xX

èQg�zy Ìtù·eZ{ÁìXZ\k*uZ%tì�ZÐˬx*ÑÆO}Z³F¹ä�áùHìX

%§ZDw /

·g=Za»%ûÔtù·èÃg{!ÑùúVÐËŠgZâλìXZk~´)ZDwÆ£Ñ]zp}ÆO}ZyÅ»gkZzg‰Ò*]æÍyK‰�Xù´»¬gs™ZDƒñÔ%A��:

ù”î0ikÃ~�ñZ�FK�cŠìÔz{ËZzgù·~�áï:åXtƒ»ƒÑƒgÅÜsQy¢zVÐ1ŠìÔ�g^aÎ‚Ì ]ÞÏ¡h Zzg ‡Únß‚]… Æ�zgzi*ñV

Ws0ÎyÅÑ$k~~ôp�X»gkÔÒ*]ÔkKz){»tù·@gõzZgFKC1X Zzg<ÆÔX»ñZ�ˆ~�ø[ƒZ gz�Z�zV �cŠìÔÎZ}WyÅ�z

Zkù´Æ�Ñ]Ãi”V~„HYYì:1DZdÔ(cpDZ½¬]Zzg(ÏzZN!5V~ÅYäzZà»gkX2DZ¶gZ]zg‚bÐr8/õEZzgZ¶g~úÒzVÆÎZÑ]Æ�Z!]X3DZë(ÏZzg@g]ñZµ6Yg~KYäzZáÒ*]XZy~ЉÒy

´)ZDwäZÐZ�~w~Yg~KZzg‰Ô�vZ»'Æ‚B���+VÐYg~K‰X

ÆækZyщX ]ÞÏ¡h c ‡Únß‚]… 4DèoÔ�‰ZñgÅzŸsÆa!kx)0391YD1391Y( 5DZDwä�zgÒ†!y)8291YD9291Y(Zzg�zgÒZàyZzgZOSàX {Ò ~,·Z¶g~g7g›Zzg!�ú ]ÞÏ¡h Ŭ]6�Ô

6Dº‡]Ô}:ZDwŧsÐYg~™�{ZÖÔ�â]ZzgZDwÐ5‡ÂVÅgz�Z�,z){X

:mLL{óóX +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù l)Ô 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^253

Page 349: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

À�0gzVÅ®Z�ZqÎ,{kìXCÙ�0g}ÆÑzq~Zq¿�~â^�cŠìX$4èGELÂ[m1Ð272J;ƒZìXZ’Zðä,])uzgtÔz„Zzgl)(ZkÆ´z{�XWy~Zq×Z�ágtÌ�cŠìX

¬NU~TňìXjZÙZzg�~¬gs*óËŠg!gqNU +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù~�XZk§bÂ[Åßg~ZzgªCÙ~wZEyjìÔ@ë»gkzÒ*]Æ

~,·Q ]ÞÏ¡h Zzg ‡Únß‚]… áyÜ™ä~7g~ZôoZzg»zlлx71ŠX)m8(; »Z5psHŠìÔ�:LL1ŸixóóÃLL!Ÿixóó)m7(;LLZk&óóÃLLZ»âòóó

¯�c LLÞóóÃLL¸fóó)m831(;LL§&óóÃLL§ióóZzgLLpóóÃLLYóó)m361(ŠXZ5ÅZ+p=VÆe~%AŧsÐzŸs¢zg~¶XZk§b˜V˜V¥Ã]K‰ZzgZ¶gÆQ~zZãZÝoÃ�g„HŠÔQyŶy�„Ì

Æ*x¯[)m6D8(~%AäZq( ‡Únß‚]… qd/õ IG~ƒãec¶XZeñ™*äZk¸]Ãoƒ Ά�á g!óóÆZÖpvs™�b�ÔZÝ]tå:LL è LLw#Ö

+Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù g!Zzgi2>z){»Âx?mHìóóX è uz�ÆZ0ggpÆa‡âÈ÷Z_Ôw#Ö‡âÈ ~Zk§b®wì:LLŒÛWy™*äZk¸]Ãoƒuz�ÆZ0ggpÆa

g!óóÅFI�Uvsň è ÷Z_Zzgi2>z){»Âx?mHìXóóZ¤�VLLw#ÖìÂtZq§bÅì-ì�zu}tR%%AÅ%ú!:f�Å´#ÖÌìX

Q~%AÐ{]ZÝoui�ƒð�ÔZyÅz„¹îsìX è܇Únß‚]… ÆÜs&,]»Ô +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù îZªÐZ�Zi™DƒñÔ%äÆîg6Ô

ÆQл©_·7HYg;ì: ]ÞÏ¡h Zzg+Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù S � Ô42�y3291Y( ‡Únß‚]… ZÝQ)uâtÅ] 11 7 uât�Zg~Å]oƒuz�ÆZ0ggÄ™' 21 7 oƒuz�ÆZ0ggìX-g\Zk

NÃÃZ0Zi™ÆW`WÑxzrT»DgìX÷~�àWgizì�µâqZyÅÓx¸'ZLZL�´~Z,¸Z2zä™,ÔX»ÑuâtŸ]Ãoƒuz�ÆZ0ggÄ™'

353ºt�~ù´

Page 350: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ô62BZÆ'2391 ]ÞÏ¡hZ¬�{F!g' 41 361 Z¬�{z{F!g'ZzgZkÆ‚B„]ZÇ:ZN['

32 361 Zzg‚B~ZkÆ]ZÇ:ZN['

÷~*³gZ}~' 42 361 ÷~gZ}*³~'æzoîg6gÄ™' 52 361 æzoîg6‡ìgÄ™']ZÇ:�Ã' 1 461 ]ZÇ:B�Ã'¨gHìÔ=Zk!]»' 2 461 ¨gHìX»ZWZkz‰Üæ¹ZZxÆ

((]6ƒg;ìÔ=Zk!]»'tì�ZÒe' 62 462 tì��y¾§bZKxç�

Ð�S�ZgƒYNXy~ZZxŢȻz‰ÜŒÛdWñÇZzg¢zgWñÇp¥xƒ@ì�ZÒe'

Zk»©Y}Ð%AÆ™IZzg°ÄZôo»Z0Zi{Î*Â7X&,]%A™ä~¼�£â]6ZÖpgh�¶Æ´z{&£â]6ZÝQż�Tgg^ˆ�X7g~Â[~Zk§bÆLLœóóÅÒ]ìZzg-V%A»®wQÔ½zÐÆÑë7g;X

%AäÂ[Æló~Oîg6�ì:LLtñZ�:Üs´)ZDwÆRÎZöWiZ�~Å@gõÅFKÆa"u¢zg~ìóóX è §]�Æaɺ[Zzg’q

Åã� O}p�ZkßZió)ñZ�(ÅZÌOìÔ1%AÆÜ™�{*³Zzgß]ÒûQ1CX YñÏÔS±gzS÷�~Zk»0t$zgƒÇ 6�ÎZö§]c@gõè

)6991Y( +Ëj^…]Îf^ÙÒ^ivÏnÏoÚ_^ÖÃä ZºZûYäZLZ*…ZD1]Æó£á 1DÆQÐñZi:™Æ·g=ZaÆ%û*³Q6 ]ÞÏ¡h ÆQ» +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù ~

ìX ÃZzg,ÐY{1 è ¤ÄÅìZzgZyÅ!VÔ™õ]ZzgÑ6zZð»�¢ïGOG

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^453

Page 351: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZâZ§ZDw /

Åwù”î0kKÅìX![3~ÔkKÆZùúVÆ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^ÙY}~tÂ[­ikcW_ì@ëZkù´~kKÆ´z{´)ZDwÅ�v�~’k,Ì�áï�Xt’k,F§bÅ�:

~�áï7 ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù c Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù )1(ZDwÆZ,p}Zzg’k,Ô�Æe»ZqZë*yÔLLD ]‰†]…ôìç�p �XZy~LLt]óóÆikÄZy�z’k,Ô

ªCÙzD!íóóÔÃ%æJLZsxÆñçq6Zq’k>ZyLL�âV»ZJyóóZzgZqZôm~ï�X �á C1 *y»Qg�zFÀ>ZyLLÛ}ZsxÆrF_¬Å�ú]óó

C2X )2(уgÆ*¬x)03�c9191Y(~ZDwÅZq½kZzg�z¿Ò*]C3ìX ÆúÒ}ÐZqr/Ô�*å ‰ç…]qnä )3(

)4(ZWÅÂ1V6ZDwÅ»goZzgWgZX)5(´)ZDwÅ%"0î GOEgz�Z�º[6zzZ�å»Ð÷)Z6s1191Y(X)6(ZDwÅ%û‰�gÏÂ1VÆ�âdX)7(ZDwÐZq5‡]Ågz�Z�)Zi�o(ZzgQyÆ¿qÑ])Zit(X)8(ZDwÅYg~™�{ºtZ‹�X)9(ægZkÆ^~ZDwÃ7KYäzZá‰3k*óZzgZqZ3gX

~¦™�cŠìXIZi,t ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Íc%AÃZDwÐ0�¼5ÔZÐf™W[ì�!±§FKtù·*³ìXZq„âÎÅ’k,Z£â]6)~ƒð�Ô%Aä‰�Ñ]Æ–~Ì7CñÔjZÙ¿Zzg*»°�Ô}:´)

o ZDwÆqÑ�i0Ï)Zi·�+¯t(~¼�!'oÔ�Ôqd/õ IG~ZyÅ

Speeches »Qg�zFÀDZÝ*y A Plea for Deeper Study of the Muslim Scientists 1D)ÑzZã(~�áïìX

)m16(~ñ��ìX +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù ZqÒyÔåßg]~ 2D)m422@622(~ÜHŠìX +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù ××r/ 3D

553ºt�~ù´

Page 352: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¢zg~¶XLLt]óóÆikÄZy�z•gZ]Ɖ”V»@Ì�áùHŠìÔTÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�%Aä»t]Ð0ZDwÅ’kÐtzvs™�cì:

ZzgzZZZÅ©5ÿGG

X˜Z[ÃZϯ6OHŠÔqÑè6d~qìÔz{—gg‚ªC1 –[Åt]»]tåZzgZkÅZfZy~—gg‚ª–[Åt]Ť&¶'X

%AäZk(yÎ�b�XZDwÅZkzZãZzgzZ”s’kЇ�c+6a^7CìÔ%Aä¸�LLp½Y�»óóÆ:t8~î0’kvs™�cÔ1Qßit�g„7X

SPEECHES AND STATEMENTS OF IQBAL /

´)ZDwi(„Ðic�{F¤mZVgìÔYèi(„QyÅZë�TÆ_.:¶XQÌ�âVÆZqBZzg(ÏgZ{úÅwÐQy»ÑgZ»'

‡ây‚iÆMgì è ~ƒ@ìX&'k)6291YD9291Y(z{º[Å> oVZzgZkw~¼�»gkXXZ¹¼�!g‰´‡ðZzgÀy»Ð²VÐæ[

™äÅ�ú]�~ˆXWy~P'kz{º[�>ÆœggìX�z!gßy~Â{Íwö»Ð²V~ÑqƒñXQ½7gii0ÏÆW¸i)8091Y(ÐzÃ]

)8391Y(J¸òÔ(ÏZzgB@gõÐ0ZñZµ6ZzgZë)bzZñgÐ0ÔQ,Väz»¯»ZëÒ*]Yg~KXZ¶gZ]ä‰)b6Qy»ñ�¥x

™äÆaQyÐr8/õEKXLL�v�Z»'Æ‚B��ZÖYg~™*7,X´)ZDwÅZkâqÅ»gkZzgÒ*]z){Qg�zZzgZôm~Z¶gZ]~�áù

ikcW_ìÔT~ZDwʼn»gkZzg +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù ƒDgìX*¸ZzgZt~Ò*]¦™�b‰�X

ZDwÅic�{F»gkZôm~~�XQy�âVÒ*]Ì!kxZôm~„~Yg~KYD¸XZÏzzÐQg�zgzi*ñV~ZDwÅt»gkZzgÒ*]­Zzg{§pZ{

~�áïÒ*]Zzg»gk¿Zzgic�{F +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù §&Ð�áù7ƒnÔ¸zzì�

(Xt@¹!{�çE™Æ�cŠìX ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù ’k!W.Þ:m44) è ZDw»@ 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^653

Page 353: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

bz~�XQg�zZ¶gZ]Æ£«~Zôm~Z¶gZ]Æz‚bic�{ZzgZOâ]4~ZDwÅ»gkzÒ*]»× ‰çÙ]mß;Ú×9†p+ˆH ¸ÔOçZôm~Z¶gZ]Sî

×ZzgågkgeôpƒŠXz){( ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù Zzg Ú–^Únàô]Îf^Ù ,]~´)ZDwÆ�~ùúV) *¸

ÆK~QyÆQg�zp}»f™W[ìZzg‰Z+Zôm~’kzV»ÌÔXÆQg�zFZWèÃg{Qg�zùúV~�áï�XtZôm~’k,Ô‰dZzgó&CÒð EV~�áùƒCg�X&Z�p�´)ZDwÃÔcQyÆŒÛR7ÒªîG0Zx[~ÐËÃÌÔìw7Wc�Zk�~fí}æ™Æ%AHYñX"Z£ÑzZãäLL�áCóóÆN*xÐ4491Y~Zôm~’kzVÔ»gkZzgh]zÒ*]æ™ÆÂ!ßg]~æÍyHX

~уgÐ�áùƒZX%Aäló 1C tù·qgz!ÑÄZyЫ!gâga5491Yè ~Ccì�ZDwÆZôm~h]Zzg»gkÔgLgLºt”VZzg>

‡ây‚iº[Ågz�Z�zVZzgZ¶gZ]Æ6ZäÑgzV~)~ƒð�ÔZ¹ikÃù´Åßg]~%A™�cŠìÔ@�ZyÆŸùƒä»Z06:gìXWÐ^™Q,VäZDwÆ(ÏZ°g6cÅìZzgCcì�ZDwäZKZ™"ìEGL„Åã�6�+Zzg(„~&ÆÜsWzZi�ÅX

tù·&”V~ËìXZk„Æ_.:�z§bÅ»gk6�ì: zZÍw:ZDwÆ�zœZgC\)‚Ñ:Z°kÀy�>ÔZ[W!�Ô92B�c D Z³

0391YZzgÀy�»Ð÷уgÔ12Bâga2391Y(X‡ây‚iº[~ÅYäzZàWJ»gkX è>D[>ZyLLZsxZzg‡�c+óóÆ�t’k,�áï�: z�zx:Zq*y:LL‡�cãZzggZtZ·{�yóóX D Z³

ÆZ‹ZŸ]»�Z[X Ÿñ8 èÃg{*y6‡�cãZ¶g D[

TZÍw~‚ÁZ�á®�g`7Ô1T�zx6Ô¬ZecÅ@g+÷ GELZ�á®�g`ìX 1D

753ºt�~ù´

Page 354: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÆZ‹ZŸ]»�Z[X ‰9n9ŠÛnà èÃg{!Ñ*y6gzi*) D `‡�c+Æe~H]1zÆÎZÑ]»�Z[X D�

&§bÅq,¦Åˆ�: zÎx:Ày�>ÆóR~ÆÇ}ÐZ]4š§õ GD»âZzgu�ÛZ1jDÙ� D Z³

Æ*xZq¯[Ɖ{XZ(ÏZzgò)bÆ!g}~82Ò*]X D[‚wâ»gicð�x)J†g~8391Y(X D `

HŠìXZ,Väló~Zy %AŧsÐ}}¿jZÙ»ZŸ†Æù¦â~Z]»f™ÂHìÔ1CÙ’kÆ‚BZµZµjZ!�g`7HX> ’kzVÅ»gkÔ>Å,·gz�Z�zVÐàˆ�ÔœZgC\,·Â”VÐZzg ‡ây‚i

ÆZÑgzVÐXÒ*]~ƒÐWy~Òy ‰çÙ]mß;Ú×9†p+ˆH ZÒ*])9Bâga8391Y(ÐZ~HŠìXZÝÒyQg�z~åÔikcù´ ]uŠ^á gzi*)

~Zk»Zôm~FÀ�áïìXtÒyÂ[Åù¦YÆ�Z]}~7W@ÔYèÃè Z¹tÂ[Zôm~»gkzÒ*]»ù·ìÔ1ñçq)Xè(ÅZÌÆ7

ZzgZkaÌ�tZDwÅWy~×’kìÔ%AäZÐZLù´~�áï™*¢zg~�XZk*y~Wc�ŒÛWãƲ!QÆ‚B%AäZôm~F3»ZŸ†™�cìXm1326ŒÛWãWeÆ‚Bqgzfs�zWc]tÐvsƒ�:

æø]i$føÃûköÚô×$èø!eø«ñôo]ôeû�ø]aônûÜø )1(o÷ Êø^i$fôÃöçû]Úô×$èø]ôeû�ø]aônûÜøuøßônûË^ )2(

ÐV”VÅ’kzVÃiâãFKÐ%AHŠìX1’qòÆe~m3391YÆÒyÆW*ecåX‰’kzVÆ:© B 2BZÆ'3391Y»Òy91

ÅzŸsÆa�~Zzg¬g°Z�ágZ]Å¢zg]¶Ô}z�zx~‡�c+Ð0’kzV»Zq{m:©ìÔ%AŧsÐZk6¿gzÝeZàYCÔ¬x

‡gMÆaZy’kzVÃ'ic�{W‚yƒ@X

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^853

Page 355: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZkÂ[»�zuZZec‚hñ&'km8491Y~�áùƒZXPZŸ¯VÆÎZÔtZecCÙZ±gЬZecÆ_.ìXZk6�zâVZexVÅ@gu�g`™�~ˆ�Ô1Ëló»ZŸ†7HŠX¬ZecÅZ�á®ÆÔ%AÃZDwÅ�'×h’k,ZzgÒ*]�ø[ƒñÔZ¹ikÃZec~�áï™1ŠìX

Mc Taggart's z�zx~�zqzV»ZŸ†HìÔZÍw:Zq*y>Zy:)Zk»ñçq§]ˆZÅ+)é]ì(' 1C

Some Study Notes Ô�zx: Philosophy

mB �Ñð7391YZzg6 B zÎx~éÃgCÙÍÆ*x�zkK)ñgQ02tkKåßg]~7�ÔW¸izZ!xÐZØ[z){ X 7391Y(»ZŸ†ƒZì

÷zs�Ôe켿Ì�áï:K‰ƒVXZkù´~NUʼnZÝoñ���Ô}

9 ß S �non-spatial non-special 16 651

corporeal oorporeal 17 651is is(?) is 20 651

an and 7 061ÃgÏZzgQg�zZÃgÆQ~‰úcV�V�:

zë �î 8 151Wh W$ 13 151�zZx ��Zx 22 151ZiZV iZWy 26 151

g�áÆ �]Æ 4 251'p�'hy '�„'�y 5 51 2

The )ßy(2391YÆÑg{ZÍwZzg Indian Art and Letters tp}ZZnK 1DÔm2391Y~�áùƒñÔ%AäjZ!7�cX Muslim Revival

953ºt�~ù´

Page 356: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

9 ß S �Î| ÎÄ 2 651¢©0î EG

GL } 21 032£Ã ±fõ

Y� 6 632

ZÆ'3391YÆÒyÅ@gõtÐ B òóóÆe~2 è z„~LL’q22BZÆ'�g`ìÔttNUÅìX

ZŸ¯VÆ‚B6*x ¼� Zkù´»�ZZec%AÅÃUãZzg7791Y~�áùƒZX ÐSpeeches,Writings and Statements of Iqbal

SPEECHES, WRITINGS AND STATEMENTS OF IQBAL/

�zuZZec8491Y~�áùƒZåXZq²áJ�ZZec:¾eXZkZz~ÔZkù´Æ�Ñ]Êg}FçÆ‚BÔ‰�v|Z]ä6ùúVÅ

ZDwœ~)7791Y(Æñµ6%AäZLù´ÃZiaçLâ C1 ßg]~Y\1XFK�cXZk»*xÌ$w�cX'×h'WV:ZÍwÔ�zu}ZecÆ�Ñ]ÅQÐ7@wÅX�zxÔ¹Ï5qzV»ZŸ†HXÎxÔjZßVZzg¿0zg¹jZÙ»ZŸ†HX

,Zk§bì:

)Z³(ZŸÃ]‡ây‚i~81B�Ñð7291YŽk)l:ZzgZŸ°¤Z.(X è )1(>

ÆÄZyÐZqz:Zk~�zp}Âz{�Ô Religion and Philosophy )2(T�zx~(Jñ‰Ô1¾{6îsZzg¿xp}�áïK‰�X �

)3(LLZsxZzg‡�c+óó)�ÔZ[Â[»�Zzì(ÆikÄZy�z5qzV»ZŸ†)1(H]1zÆ*xZqâ)2(ZqzŸ‚ÒyX

%A:ZöXZ}zZuуgÔ#4691YX ÔThoughts and Reflections of Iqbal )Z³( 1D%A:Z}Wg¤gtуgÔZ6s3791YX ÔSpeeches and Statements of Iqbal )[(

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^063

Page 357: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ƬcZ¤ZsÆWy~t] Some Study Notes )4(z�zxÅZq’k(JcŠì:

I am sure this passage will interest the readers of the Muslim Revival.1C

Zk’k~‰Wc�ŒÛWãÆjZá�g`K‰�Zzg‰Wc]ÆÑg�zVÅoňìX

eÛfòoÒ†]ÞnÓØ )5(zXgx~�zqzV»ZŸ†:)1(Ç0SÆ*xZqâ)2(~,·ZÚz-X

)[(FZçIslam and Ahmadism T�zxÔz�zxÆa*y)m111(»ÄZy$w™ )1(

™�cŠìXgZ¯]hóóÆÃgÏZÃgÔ è ~èÃgLL+ Mc Taggart's Philosophy T�zx~ )2(

�áï¸XTÎx~ZÃg»Qïw™ÔZy»Zôm~FÀ�áïHŠìXCorporeal »ÄZyps™Æ Some Study Notes T�zx~�áïZq’k )3(

¯�cŠìXZk*yÆQ~qgzfsp´Vň�: Resurrection

TÎx S � T�zx S �the author refers 72 151 he refers 16 651more exact 2 251 more and more exact 1Ô02 9 651would even admit 01 251 would admit 8 751except what 02 251 except by what 51 751complete all his 5 351 complete his 51 851that life 62 351 that all life 6 951so that I may 92 351 so that may 01Ô11 951readers of the Muslim

Revival

73 351 readers 20 951

)ÑzZã(:m151 Speeches 1D

163ºt�~ù´

Page 358: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

TÎx S � T�zx S �as a unification to cultare 02 451 as a uniform culture 21 061

ù´~NUÅZÝoÌQ�Ô}:9 ßan a 72 251astonishing astounding 8 451unified unification 02 451

%A»ìwå�Zkù´~Üsz„q,�áïÅYNÔ�p�Q,VäVä , ZÝâ~ÐqÝÅ�Zzg��zu}RùúV~ñ��7ÔOçQ

)zZu(~�áïF’k,ÔZLù´~�áï7XÔZ%Wy~z‰Ü6 ThoughtsC1 ÐP’k,á™�áïÅIX Mementos of Iqbal *ÑÆZÜZg6

%Aäqd/õ IG~Zyg‚bzZ¶gZ]Æ*xZzg@g+÷ GELZ�á®�g`™�~�ÔW‚y $›4è

GGOE ˜VÐt’k,Z~ň�XZyjZßVÅæ�ÐCÙóglÅ@g+÷ GEL’k»

Mc Taggart's ìÔ-VZ¤ÃÒÅYCÔÂ'×hî@gu̳ÅY$Ë�Ô}:Æ!g}~ZDwä22#2391YÃéÃgCÙÍÃ�:LL~äW`ƒZð Philosophy

eZuÐ'¤â~2så"5¾æ HGY

^6Zq£!5ì'ZkÐ0t£!u�ÛZ1C2X jDÙ�Å�Ûâö6�ìóó

ZÆ'2391YÆÒy)m122( B jZÙÌ¿�XËŠg'×h,e¶Ô}:8)m061(~ñ�� +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù ~†ZØ�SÆ*xT@g»f™HŠìÔZk»Q

ìXZϧbm2226ZDwäX¼�@gzV»f™HìÔZyÆ�Z[~ZDwÆ)m061D161(~�AYM�XjZÙZzg»©jZßVÆZ0gZ` +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù �Z!]

LL¥%]óóX ic�{Æ0YåXTXgxÆe~Â[ÆWy~�&À�/õ GG: Ðù·Zzg

¯["Z£ÑzZã¯xg<Z−+;×Ô41�y9791Y)ÑzZã™rÆZÖp�:LLt~ 1DäZK%èÆÜsHåXóó(

Ô�zx:m682 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^263

Page 359: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ñ��{Ìt è Z¤pZkùÃ'×h4ZzgYì¯äÅRöñ��ìÔ@ëbªZDwÅZôm~óg�á]Zzg�~fí}»ƒÐRZzg9Fù·ìXtZÐZ�~»zl

Zzgz‚bÐ w8o-ö FFů6 � dìÔSîZkZ±gÐ�%Aät»xfZC è Ñë»xfƒñZqâqÆZD1C_"ÔÆ‚BZ�x�cìX

THOUGHTS AND REFLECTIONS OF IQBAL /

#4691Y~,·Ô±†ZßZu»%ûÔtù·eg”V~Ëì:!Kºt£Ñ]zp}ZzgœZgCh]Ô•gZ�„Zzg‰Â1V6»goz){X )1(ZsxZzg‡�c+6‚]’k,X )2(

>‡ây‚iº[ÅWJ»gkX )3((ÏZzgB)bÆ!g}~!g{Ò*]X )4(

)�zxÔ8491Y(Åã�6%AHŠìX�áCÆ Speeches tù·Ô�áCÅÂ[ù´~Z™kóg�á]�áï�ÔZ�ikÃù´~ZyÅ®Z��kìX%Aä�áCÆù´ÐZVg{Ò*]{g`)94D81=13(™ÆZ/5’kzV»ZŸ†)13+91=05(HZzg�áCÆù´ÃZq6*xÐY\�cXgZ¶Æìw~d

)�zx(»Zq Speeches �c-»»Ÿtå�±†ZßZuÔ�áCÅZYi]ÐÔZyÅÂ[C1X *Zec»g™DÔYè�zäðÐic�{’k,�áCŦz½™�{�

6ZLù´ 2C ƒäů Topical )�zx(ÅZVg{óg�á]à Speeches %Aä~�áï7HXtêW‚y7�ÃyÏ’kzzâÎÅìcËuòñçqÐ

Ãè 0ìÔcZkÅwxìX%AäZkK~Ë’kÅñç¦ZÌÃ7»ªZec±†ZßZugä%AHåÔ·†ZvŒÛ7ä�zu}Zzg e^În^lô]Îf^Ù 1D

�}Zec~½ã&kB#Ö»*ñZ��áïHÔ1ZÍA%AÅwб†ZßZu»*xÂ[Æuzgt6'ŒÛZgg3X±†ZßZuäÔikÃZôm~ù´~ÔZkÆ'@gztZ(gHÔT»Ãð�Zi7áX

X xiii ÔmThoughts ¬gs: 2D

363ºt�~ù´

Page 360: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

7g3ÔÉ¡ZKßZ[�hÃgZ{ú¯cìÔ}:LLñ9ZzZgeóóÆñçq6ZDw»ŠX 42BZ~2391Y»ÒyÂ�áï™1ŠÔ1ZÏñçq641B�Ñð3391Y»Òy�áï7H

X¦Ð072B�Ñð7391YÃYg~™�{ÒyÂ%AÆ4�qZëåÔ1Zk�Ñð7391Y(»øg{âÔ¯xéÃgCÙÍ%AÆ B ñçq6ZkÐZq߬)02

Z²7Xd3åXWEZZgkÔ÷zsÒ*]y*yÅ(ÏZzgB@gõÆ.e è 4�qÑëZëñç¬]Ð0�XgZ¶Æìw~ÔZyƒÃù´~�áïƒ*ecåX

XZ/�0gzV»ZŸ†HŠìÔQy~Ð9ZDwÅ’k,�XtZkÆikÄZy�b‰ºt•gZ]Ô&‚w Stray Thoughts ù´~ËZŸ†ìX

~�áï�Ô®ZZ¹�áï™äÅ¢zg]:¶ÔYè Stray Reflections ¬,·èÃg{ÄZyÐZDwÆ•gZ�„6�ZqxÂ[ñ��ìXZkù´»ƒ

ìXñÑ*;Z{VäZDwÆ8‹0î EE0Z¥| The Muslim Community ÐZëZŸ†

¡6Zq/ZãÃóóÆÄZyÐ�áùHåÔ1ZÝZôm~ è )1191Y(»Qg�zFÀLLIZ·tÐ%�xÑg~ÅZqg7g^)1191Y(~Zk\»Zqz èŒ C1X [*aƒŠ

¬x6áWñ�X�v è© ôpg{ŠåÔ%AtQÔèÃg{g7g^ÐZ~™ÆZŸ±ÌZë�X

‰p}ÆW¸i~ X %Aä‰óg�á]Æ‚Bf~qd/õ IG(Jñ�Speeches �~â^Ì�g`�X9’kzVÆâ~»jZ!�cŠìX%Aä

CcìÔ1t�úò&CÿLÃìX Civil and Military Gazette )�zx(ЮwñZ�»â~YèZ»gkzÒ*]ÆWy~Z¶gÆ´ÑgzVÅ@gõz,]»jZ!7�cŠX%Aä�áCÆ¿jZÙÃ!kx'ŒÛZgg3ìÔZ%Zq�z(qd/õ IGZhZ�b�Zzg

McTaggart's Zqqd/õ IG)m423(»ZŸ†HìÔTÅPZV¢zg]:¶X�áCÆ;VÆQ~ZÃg»ZÝQ�g`ìÔikÃù´~&ZÃgÃQyÆ Philosophy

Zôm~F3Ð$w�cŠìX‰WÅÂ1V6ZDwÅ»goÌù´

3X �ø[ƒZåX5±Ùe� *c[*yZDwñi*уgÐåßg]~ Z�zsÃt gZ¶ 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^463

Page 361: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

t¥â] X ~�áï�Ô1ZyÂ1VÆ£ÄZ�á®Zzg‚ÁZ�á®»¼è7¸C1 Ìqd/õ IG~�g`™�~Y'ÔÂ4åX

%AÆ4�qZDwÆqgzfsegp}»Q@qw�ø[7ƒe:(1) Islam and Khilafat.

(2) Islam as a Social and Political Ideal.

(3) Inner Synthesis of Life.

(4) Notes on "Qurratul Ain".

Islam and Khilafat 6cÆK~C`�� ÚÏŸlô]ÎfÙ ë*,]~ÆÄZyÐZDwäLÃð*y7�Zzg:½kÅXT½k»Qg�zFÀLLZsxZzg

ìX�zu} Political Thought in Islam ÜÄóóÆÄZyÐÖÔZk»ZÝÄZyìZzgt*yikÃù´ 2C

Islam as a Moral and Political Ideal *y»9ÄZy)m92@55(~�áïìX%AÅtzŸs�g„7�t[1191Y~Z¥|~

ìX�Z*yšd->î IEX The Muslim Community �cŠX8‹0î EE0Z¥|)1191Y(»ÄZy

ikÃù´ÅZ�á®)4691Y(J�ø[7ƒZåXˆ~"Z£ÑzZãä)ÑzZã(~�áï™1)m821(Ô Speeches �gcÄ™ÆÔZLù´Æ�}Zec

Z%a¶’k@qwnzxìX$4èGELp}~èÃgWc�ŒÛWã»Q97)m632Ô932(X

ÆZDw�Ô�c7791Y~�áù™ZcìXZ¹D:ƒe�¾{ Êßçá Z£âZioä¸Q 1D'k¬tQikÃù´~�áùƒ[ìX�w8iï FF!]tì�Z£âZioäZL

(»ZqZ½kÌÜHìX Thoughts *yÆW¸i~ÔZkù´)zZð;×ät*y¬gsÔjZÙZzg<Æ‚B%A™ÆÂ!ßg]~5591Y eZËZö D2

ÐEthicalà Moral ~уgÐ�áù™ZcXñßsäZÍwÂ*yÆÄZy~ÂÎx:QÃîsZzg)¢zg~jZÙÆË~Zk§b Ô $w�cÔ�zx:Q~‰¥Ã]K

(gƒðÔ¯t� è 0™g{ˆX7791Y~ZkÂ[ÅZ�á® Z «Z�Â[ZqÍgÄ�®(Åt editing ¬gÃ]zjZÙ~tf™}7M�*y“�ŠZzg¹VÖ?Dz+)

Zq%æEN~VwìX

563ºt�~ù´

Page 362: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Z¤p%Aä¹ÐÆjZÙ�g`K�Ô@ëF£â]6mCkƒCìX'×hÂzZzgœÐ±ÔZñgÅÜZsic�{Â:¶XƒÐ¬*y)m3D72(Æqd/õ IG~tzŸs¢zg~¶�ˆ~ZDwäLLZ�ãóóÃLLZ

ÄB5Ðö EGóó~Development Ð$w�cìZzg*yÊg}FçƈZLeZËfÆ£á

�áï™1Xm7926ZDwäZLTÿZ¥|þ)»f™HìÔ%AÃqd/õ IG~C*ecå�Zk)Ɖ{ikÃù´ÆWy~�áï�X

ZkÂ[»�zuZZecâ'k3791Y~�áùƒZXtZec�Ñ]ZzgB#Öz){CÙÒpÐTZÍwÆ_.ìX

SPEECHES AND STATEMENTS OF IQBAL ð

)�zx(Å(gZ�á®ìÔ&%A)Z}Wg Speeches ikÃÂ[�áCÆù´(Â[Åw Compiled ¤gt(ä¡ZL�âdÆZŸ±Æ‚BZK%A)

)�zx(Æ Speeches Ð7Zzg�áùHìXZkÆ�Ñ]Å®Z�ZzgQyÅFK‚_.ìXZkZ±gÐZkù´ÅwZqƒZg~ù´ÅìX

ikÃÂ[»�Zi7™DƒñÔ%A�âd~��:Long ago when I saw this book, I did't find its printing and get-up upto the

standard of its topic. Therefore, I revised it thoroughly'all the verses of Iqbal

in this book were without translation. Now I have translated them into

English'and have also given important foot-notes .

ZkZ½kÅgzÝ~ikÃù´Å@;Æ�zZò[�:�áCÆù´ÅS®Zzg¡Z\£g~7¶X )1(Zk~Qg�zZzgÃgÏZÃg»FÀ7�cŠåX )2(�zâVLL�Ñbóó:Üs$zgZzg1�}�ÔÉ5&Ì�XZ¤Z,„LL�ÑbóóÃ

uºÆaz<îELLL�Zióót™1YñÔÂQ�*ÆczsWÅ9£?Ô�¿eìZL*xÐY\YìÔYèLL£g~S®óóÂZqZŸ°!]ìXQ

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^663

Page 363: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÆZÖp� Copy-rights Reserved �w8iï FF!]tì�LL%AóóäZkù´6ÐÌ�g$7HX

»mìÔZy»ZŸ†,]612Ô922Ô important footnotes ˜VJ%AÆ�Óx 032Ô332Zzg6426HŠìXjZÙÅZyTgÅù¦®Z�ÜsZVg{kìX

â^�áCÆ�Ô1�zâVÆ�gxyÃð¸&‡ìgpÅiØÍZgZ7ňXZkzzÐÔZJ�áC»ù·ZzgikÃù·�zâV‚t:ƒVÔªCÙ~@W¸ƒ@ì�

æøâöÜûeô^�6ìô�øéô ‚g}jZÙZ}Wg¤gtä�áïK�Xm9326ŒÛWãWe»Zqz:(JcìX ZÝQ~�áï7ÔZ}Wg¤gtäZK§sÐ âöÜûÒFËô�öæûá

MEMENTOS OF IQBAL /g°j�á�Æ%ûikÃù´6‚wZ�á®�g`7Ô@ëÂ[Ƭgs

ikS®ìX'×h'WVikà 1C ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä ~%AäCcì�÷ZQg�zù·ÆÑg{†g~Ô�Ûzg~5791Y~�áùƒZX Islamic Education ù´»7gZßZi)«!g

ZkZ±gÐZkù´»‚wZ�á®5791YáìX%Aä�~Tg~Ccì�ÎZöZDwÆaßZióňlÆ�zgZy~Ô

Z¹ZDwʼnZ+Zë’k,�ø[ƒNÔ�Ë‚—Zôm~ù´~�áï:�ÔèZDw»ù·7ÔÉ è Z¹ikÃù´Åßg]~%AzæÍyHYg;ìXt{µ�

Zk»ZqäðzÔZDwÆ!g}~ZZ3ÿXL¯Æp}6�ìXù·&”V~Ëì:

Zk{ÃLLp}zÒ*]óó»ÄZy�cŠìÔ1Zk~ZZ‡q zZÍw: )1(’k,�áï�X�zp}Ôeg»gkÔ�zZÚz-ÔZq�ıeZzgZq��ZhD9

Æ6ZäÑgzVÐZ~ň�XZDwÅZÝ Light ’k,уgÆZôm~8gzi{»gkQg�z~�ÔZkÒpÐZkù´~�áïZôm~QÃÔFZWI�g„ƒÇXeg

)m611Ô241(~ñ��ìX +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù ~Ð�z»gk»ZÝQLLèoóóÆikÄZyWJèoÆ‚BeZË@|ÆaZqÂr3§öG

E z�zx: )2(

tù·Z6s5791Y~�áùƒZåX 1D

763ºt�~ù´

Page 364: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Letters of )6791Y(~ZzgQ ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù �Ì�áïìXtÓxkKˆZiZV)7791Y(~�áï™a‰X Iqbal

Šg{ºt�0gzV~ÐÜs�zóg�á])Zq’kZzgZq zÎx: )3(¯Æ�ÔX~ZDwÅ,ZzgÎZöÐ è ZI v� Òy(ZDwÅ�X�p}

0‰U�V6ÆgzÝeZàˆìXZk,ЪCÙì�%Aä�&ÄZ*]‡ìK�Ô�Ñ]Å„~Qy

Å0È~7ňXzZÍw~p}zÒ*]Æ´z{�vâÎÅ’k,Ì�áï�XQZqÒy)m95(º‡]Æfs~�cŠìÔqÑèZÐzZÍw~W*ecåX8~î0kKÆ‚BZqÂr3§öG

E�ÌÝ™�~ˆìXZkù´~ZÝo

ÅÒ]ìXi,]6�ß*ó~®Z�ZÝo812ìXÀ�0gzVÅ®Z�ZRìX%AäCÙ0g}ÆW¸i~¿¬g°â^�c

èZDw è ìÔT~(tzòtÆ´z{jZ!Ì�g`™�cŠì'tù·�!ª��tù·�z!g{L7�áùƒeX 1 ~ZqÆZŸ†ì

DISCOURSES OF IQBAL /

�á@@giZ¹»%"0î GOEtù·9791Y~�áùƒZXZkù´ÆW¸i~Ô%AÆ*x‡ZZW·Z»bÆZqâøg{9BZ~1491Y»@�cŠìÔT~Q,Vä´)ZDwÃyZ�o]7HìX‡ZZWä|�´)Æ!g}~ZLt@WZ]ÔgiZ¹™rÅ�gpZ„6Z¹ÉǸX

%Aä�âd~Ccì�ZDwÅQg�zZzgZôm~’k,¦™ä»»xÔQ,Vä1491Y~ÔZkz‰ÜÑzqHÔZz{©gW!��Á~}¸ZzgZk»x~Q,Vä·�gcgkZzg‹]ñ;ãÐÌæ�qÝÅX6491Y~´)ZDwÅQg�zZzgZôm~’kzV»ZqZqù·Z�á®Æa»gƒŠÔ17491YÆ%æFNWØ[qÑ]ZzgZiZV�ÁÐ0Îyó]Æ:!iðO�Z]Ÿùƒ‰X%ACD��Q,V

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^863

Page 365: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

äÈ:;g~ZzgZDwÅ’kzVÃ�z!g{¦™*Ñzq™�cÔ�VJ�Zôm~’kzV»!iðO�{0691YƵnZq!gQZ�á®Æa»gƒŠÔphÅ*g‚ð�&À�/õ GG�

Æ™I Zk!g*Ñÿ¸�ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔTÆ*òÔZkz‰Ü±†ZßZug¸(~ÂÐ0õ‚wÔ Zzg°x¬zyů6F'kJZkÅZ�á®Åâ":WmX

1C zZ:h~»x[ƒñZzgZ[ZÐ�áù™�cìX !iðO�{ %AikÃù´~´)ZDwÅ33Zôm~’k,Ô»gkZzgÒ*]�áï�XZq

)ÑzZã(~Ìñ���XÍctÌ Speeches Zzg Thoughts ’kÆ´z{ÔtÓx’k,ZqƒZg~ù·ìX�âd~ÃðZ(ŒÛÜ7ÔTÐZ0Zi{ƒn�z{"Z£

ÀìÔ��: è ÑzZãc±†ZßZuÆ%ûùúVÐ!¸�Zzgt!]!no serious effort has yet been made to compile, edit and publish a completecollection of his treatises, both in English and Urdu .

2C

WÐ^™ë�:The present collection is being published with the object that AllamaIqbal's prose writings may be brought before the public in a suitablebook-form.

C3

X ÐzZª"� 4C èZDwÆ‚—ùúV è� Ícz{%AÆ_.ÔQ,VäZDwÅZ’k,ZÍAo,ÐqÝÅ�X

ñµZyÆjZáÌ�b�X6�ëäZz6f™HÔZkù´Å è Q,VäøèZDwÆ è )m381@881(Z+ìÔ�� Basic Philosophy of Asrar-i-Khudi Zq’k

Ëù´~�áï7ìXt’kÔeZË$¹ÒjèE

EÑYäzZáZqâ^6FìZzgÐZ~ňìXCÙ’kÆW¸i~Â#Z�ágZ]�b‰�Ô Únˆ]á ©gW!��ÁÆC

TÐZk»(tzòtzZãƒ@ìX

�áùƒŠX Thoughts p&Z%ì�ZÏZz)3691Y(~±†ZßZuÿgþ»%ûù· 1DXxv :mDiscourses of Iqbal 2D

Xxvii Zs:m 3D)¤gt(X Speeches )`( Thoughts )[( )ÑzZã(X Speeches )Z³( 4D

963ºt�~ù´

Page 366: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

6491Y„~)ZZy’kzVë%û¦HŠå(tù·¾™‚tWY@ÔÂG%AÆatZ³Ziƒ@Ô1Ø&öLëÐZ(:ƒeXñ��{ßg�qw~Ô�

)ÑzZã( Speeches ÔThoughts èZDwƼ�ù´�áùƒ`�ÔikÃù´Ã è�)¤gt(ŃZg„¹YYìX Speeches Zzg

Zk~: Ô 3002Y~ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyäZk»�zuZZec�áùH»ZŸ† Bedil in the Light of Bergson ZÍw:TZÍwÅ33’kzV6Zq*y

HŠì&eZËd�ÛZ¹™räZDwñi*Ð�gcÄ™Æ8891Y~�áù,]~Wg;ìX(giZ¹™räd�ÛZ¹»æÍ: {Ò HåX)Zk»-f™W

Â[HìX è Ô�áï ( *y�V»ÂV)jZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]É

Å�gcÄ»f™*ZzgZt~W[ (The Muslim Community) �zx:8‹0î EE0Z¥|

ÆIslam's Peculiar Conception of Nationalism ìXikcù´ÆTZÍw~ikÄZyÔ8‹0î E

E0Z¥|ƉZ½‚]�áïÔZ[Z¹{g`™ÆèÃg{[åßg]~�á$ÿLÂ[HŠìX)Zk»9FQikÃÂ[Æe3~�&À�/õ GGX(

ìX Å ÅwÌZqƒZg~ù´„ Zec ÆZk Discourses ZyZŸ¯VÆ!z��STRAY REFLECTIONS /

Zq�á²Zzg®Åwд)ZDw»f‚ZzgZy»„ÚZg»5kg;X„~»ZqZzgUÔz{ *“ u6 Zg»ÅZq�wWzm¡ÂZyÅ�á²~~QìÔ1f

]�Ô��á²~Æ:6�{Ôik,ØzVÆîg6ñ��gìX�á²~c�~ZDw Y '.ð GOóó'Æ]ZtÔz{Zzg̹¼ së;�*&â0 LL : Å ä�¼¹ÔZkÆÎZÌ

IeTÔZk»Z0Zi{kKÆPZ½‚]ЃÇ:01BZÆ'9191Y:LL~ZL�wz�ârÅu*“Ì¿îg6reLƒVZzgtu*“

zgZ°g x6gzÝeZ%Æa.e¢zg~ìÔ=¢ì��ìÑ]Zkz‰Ü÷}xZ(1C 0z~ Æ0ßÍVÆ�ßV~�ÔZk’kÐQy~¹Zz[aZƒÇóóX)¯x±Ñy

ÔZÍw:m901 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^073

Page 367: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âÞ9191Y:LL÷~i0Ï~Ãð)©àzZ§7Ô�ZzgzVÆa$Wñi B 72ƒnÔ;VìÑ]»Dg�Zz[Z%$WñiƒYìÔZ¤L�Û›ƒÂ�VÇóóX

7m1291Y:LL'Zqîs�Z*yìÔL�Û›ƒðÂZL»ÅÓx (1C )¯xz©Z£(2C ¯È™zVÇÔTÐ=¢ÿìþ¹ßÍVÃÃZ{ƒÇXóó)¯xz©Z£ *“ u

ñú�{u*“Âr3û EEL’k~:WmÔ1ZDwÅi0ÏÆZq.eZë�zgÐ0QyÆP•gZ�„ÔZqeZ]~~ôpƒ‰X!ª��Æ¿Ô1s~ÒpÐ

)©àZÌÆqïÔZkùÃeZËYzhZDwä1691Y~�áùHXgKÆÅ’kÐ¥xƒ@ì�¬Ô è ZkÒn~ÀZqÎæZ0gZY]�XuzgtÆ@

ÐReflectionsà Thoughts ?mHåÔˆ~ Stray Thoughts ZDwäZk»*xps™�cXW¸i7BZ6s0191YÃZZzgÓxZ0gZY]ZÏ'kr3û EEL’k~WñX

’kÌ�b‰�ÔTЖwYzhZDw è ,·Òn~‰,]Æ@f4è XELZDwÅÂZ*ðZzg7Õä EO¹Å?σCìXt•gZ]™sZzgzZã’k~�X¹

Z$ZqÅ�á@�X 6 Á£â]6FZçň�ÔZzgtFZçÔZDwÆfF'kÔZDwÃZyÅZÃ�e»ZˆkƒZÔÂQ,Vä,{É•gZ]g‚!

Z6s7191Y(~�áù™ZñXZë!]tì�Z�á®Æñµ6Zy6 B )7 New Era

ÃUã™ÆZy~¼�FZçÅIXZyÅ,tì:New Era S. Reflections •g{�there are psychological reasons... there is a psychological reason.. 45an element of vagueness in

poetry, since the vague appear...

an element of obscurity and

vagueness in poetry; since the

vague and the obscure appear..

87

the thougt of Divine creation..

Faust is a...

the Divine thought of creation...

His Faust is a...

211

7X( ÔZÍwÆ_.ZkƯ[ZD‚]g×ã�Ô1t�g„ ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä m624) Zs: 1D:m671 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù 2D

173ºt�~ù´

Page 368: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

writer 'Azad'...

Literary criticism sometimes

precedes the creation of a great

literature. We find Lessing of the...

poet "Azad"

Literary criticism does not

necessarily follow the creation of

a literature. We find Lessing at the

611

says the poet, is a necessary... teaches the poet: is the necessary... 421~�áù”{•gZ]Ô¸�¬ÒnÐÜK‰ÔQQy~FZç New Era

’k~ZyÅz„ßg]ìÔ� è ™ÆZ�á®Æa��b‰ÔYèZDwÆ@,·Â[~�~ˆìX

Zzg„~u*“»ZqZëâ~�XtZ%‡&ÿEL¨gì�Ð 6 t•gZ]ÔZDwÅfZÏ�zg)Z6s0191YZzgâˆ(~kK¯x¾H~ZDw»_!CÌy²z`6åÔ1ikÕgZ]~ZDw»_!Cgzt¹æîÔÉŒÛdŒÛdnzxìZzg„~gzt¸

ìXeZËZ�gZ£œjÆìw~ZkÒn~ÔP™{èoÅÏ%�{�àZzgZf�{•gZ] ZDwäZkù”î0•gZ]»*xÌ?mHÔ$�ç EELUã~‰ ´) C1X }7Q 6f

~FçÅÔQ‰•gZ]�áù™�bÔÍcZyÅZ�á®~ZÃ�eñ��¶ÔZkZ±gèZDwÆQyÓxùúV è ÐZyÅZ�á®)Ít¹@íЃð1(¹¢zg~¶X�

~Ôq%"5é GOE�âˆ)zÃ�ZDwƈ(ÅwqÝìÔikÃÂ[ZK„~¾z$©-.ï EGGG4óóÅwgBìX è seů6LL’#Ö

(gZ�á®Æñµ6tZÈx¢zg~ì�;ZÍw:jZÙ~Zy£â]Ŷy�„è ™�~YñÔ˜VZDwä‰ZÖpz„gZ]~FçÅìX)Zk§bÅFZç@

’k11~t•g{É™»^�cŠ: è ’k5Ô6Ô7Ô8Ô9Ô01Ô21~ñ���(Ô}:@The psychologist swims on the surface and/ but the poet dives into the deep of

the human mind.C23CThe psychologist swims, the poet dives. ˆ~Zkätßg]Z(gÅ:

:m13 �„…]lôÊÓ†ô]Îf^Ù 1D:!W.Þm431 Stray Reflections 2D

ZsÔm731 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^273

Page 369: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Z¤‰•gZ]Ãåîg6i�™�cŠƒÔÂZ¹ÌjZÙ~�g`™*ecXÍ,ÐZDw»„~Zzgs~g*zmZDwÅ�á²~»ZqZëUìÔ1

C1 (‘�X Geothe ÆX!kxß) Goethe �N!]tì�ZDwä1691Y»ZÍAZec521•gZ]6�åX7891YÆZec~026•gZ]»

ZŸ†HŠÔZ¤pZy~Љ•gZ]Åw¿p}Åì�ºtZôm~~�áï�X Thoughts and Reflections of Iqbal ’kzVÆù´

�}Zec)ZDwZ»�ò0Îyуg2991Y(~'×hZq•g}»ZŸ†HŠZzgZDwÆ�„â“•gZ]Æ@Ì�áï™a‰�X

tZec×(~Æ6Zzg.eZÈxÐ�áùHŠì1Zk~FZq™õ]gZ{0‰�Ô}:m0516ZqZ½kg{ŠÔm6416²!Ä�g„7ÔZ0gzãuzgt6•gZ]Æ%A)YzhZDw(»*x7WeÔ«�zZ�áoV~ZDwÅZÏ)0191YÔciâUŒÛd(ÅZq¦k�áï¶Ô&ZkZec~iâUâˆ)¸�2391Yc3391Y(Å

¦kÐ$w�cŠìX«�zZ�áoV~•gZ]6�Ñg�g`qZkZ�á®~vs™�cŠìXZkZec~]•gZ]Æ@Ì�áï7�XZ�ágtÔ¸�T

‰Z�ÔZ�ágb~7WnÔ} ,! Z¾mJöz�ìÔ! �zxÅÇ~ÔÜsÿ†Z>þÑg)m151(ÔegÖZÍw)m851(z){X

yxZb»%ûaåZec6002YÌZDwZ»�ò0Îyуgä)©àZÈx�„ ZzgŒS®ÆZEyj£g6Zq6Z�ágbÆ‚B�áùHìXZDwÆ

The Orient â“•gZ]Æ@zZãZzg™s�ÔZzgZy6�ÑgÌ�g`�Xg‚!~�áù”{5291YÆ01•gZ]»ZŸ†HŠìÔ�ZahŒÛÙÅ�gcÄ�XeZËYzhZDw»7Â�gLL:ÂóóWy~�áïìX

%A䉕gZ]6ójZÙ‘�Xë�:˜VJ¥xƒeÔCäÅÃÒňì�Ãð•g{Šg}Zßg]~¹VÖìcz{¾*y»zìZzgZk~Hp´Vň�X

e:2X µn^ÝÚ�†Ñ ZsÔm63Zzg73Æ!W.Þ‘½øL’k5±ÙX2�&À�/õ GGÔZ�ágZ]m 1D

373ºt�~ù´

Page 370: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

@gõ¦s /

ÅZ�á®)5191Y(6¡Òiªî EE0p�~Å#¿ZzgZkÆ�Ãq~Zq ]‰†]…ìç�p

ZL Z+c)Nc�WgZð(»W¸iƒZT~p�ZDwÃÌSî¦sÆñçq6Ôñ�ÅzŸsÆa¼�p}�7}XOçZDwäZq§sÂpZzŒ

�zu~§s¦sÅ@gõrÑzqÅX{y Ô ÂòÆZ²Zâ]Æ�Ãq~ZVc*iZ−+{VÃ��:LL¦sÅ@gõÉg;ƒVÔ�z![É[ƒVªµg'`

Pâ{ˆ±¹Zv»‰Ã�: C1 JX0õeg![ZzgƒVÐóó)31B�Ûzg~6191Y(XâZîV � ŒÂòZzgQyÆë Z C2X LL¦sÆ0~p�Ég;ƒVóó)41B�Ñð6191Y(

ÐNc�WgZð»ƒðÂ@gõ¦s6ZDw»Ì¥uŠX½ã&‚wˆZÅïeZzg �ÑzqŶÔ1Z\k�)!: i^…mîi’çÍ ÞZ`7g~Ã��:LL$4è MGä

ÆZy�zZ1Z[ÃÌ i^…mîi’çÍ QZDwä C3X 9191( Zq�z![É™g{Šóó)71B#>�cX´)ZDwÆ�~!ª]»tZqZë�„â“!iðO�{E²áJ®Ò0îE0�ÛZñÙ

)7791Y(6Ô¹Ð�zu}»½Z]Zzg @WèZDwñi*ƪx Ô ~7Zôpg;´)ZDwÆNFÆÆ‚BtÌñi*Åi“¯X

Æ ´)ÅZk*�g’kû�™'³gz~äZq×lóZzgjZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]

Ë [Ƭ�zZ1Z[Âå�1�&Z1Z[  C4X ‚B%AzæÍy™Æ�áù™�c%1o’kÆO}�‰•gZ]ÔZ�ágZ]Ô²!Z½‚]ZzgÉÃgÏZÃg6

»t!iðO�{Ô´)ÆTzWzr_¬ÔZyÅÏZzg i^…mîi’çÍ ___ ��X³gz~™räZÐ�áù ___ ZyÆd'×Z`»1ìÔZkÅDz+z+7ƒmX

™ä~ËŠg³Ð»x1X{§pZ{Dz+ÆaÔZk6'×hœZzgz‰ÜÜs™äÅ¢zg]¶X

:m34 ÚÓ^ingeß^ÝÞn^‡ 1D:m821 ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 2DÔZÍw:m25 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D

�yZ+уgÔ5891YX(gaZ�á®Ì¿~WðX 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^473

Page 371: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZÐz„e°æÍy™Y p ÃZiuâæÍy™*ec i^…mîi’çÍ øg~gZ}~1úg�ƒÔ2Dz+ÆW�Z[ÐÌl!zZ�ƒX � ì�²!ZzgÃgÏÅoƒ

»gÅ è !iðO�}ÅDz+Ьt¢zg~ƒÇ�æÍyDz+ÆZyQßßVZzgZk§&æÍyƒÏXtÌoƒƒÇ�Â[~ i^…mîi’çÍ zŸs™}ÔXÅgzÝ~

ZDwÆ7g}N!iðO�}»@Ì�áï™�cYñXkÔ¸�ZÏZÌÆ:t�z!g0Îy ZDwÅ’ Ô�zu}: Zq:¦s»ñçq

âZD1CZ�ZgzVÅf) è ÅDz+ i^…mîi’çÍ C1 ÐZzg�z!g¸g]Ð�áùƒ_ìXD1]»»Ÿì�Zq*³Dz+Å!g!gZ�á®ÆO}ÔZq£g~ Z �Zg~ìX

Dz+Å»g~ZzgZ�á®»¢Zi¢ZÈxHYñX

BEDIL IN THE LIGHT OF BERGSON /

8891Y~eZËd�ÛZ¹äÄZÈ!Ñд)ZDw»ZqZëZôm~*yZq6891Y~èÃg{*y)ì C2 ¬g°zW~lóZzgjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]Æ‚B�áùHXl)zjZÙ(Zg�zF3Æ‚BÂ!ßg]~�áùHŠÔZk~83,]6�

Zg�z{»ÄZyì:LL_Åœî0ËwÔ C3 ZDwÆ�„â“!iðO�}ÅaÜÌ�áïìX___ „'}VÅgzÝ~óó

Ý ´)ZDw»tË*yeZË�ÛZ¹äÔ·¢/Ŷy�„6ZDwñi*ÐqdìX�ÛZ¹™rä è [ÅFKzDz+»£gÌZEyjZzgÑë  C4 HåX

¸g]ÐÔ0ÎãTZÍw5891YÅøfsaZ�áÈ¿~WN: 1DgZx7gÔ-8Ô9991YX ]ÖvŠß^l )Z³(�

)[(�Ûh,e7�‹Ô3002YXуgÔZÆ'@�c6891YX Iqbal Review 2D

*Ñ:-ãzg˅уgÔ8891YÔ6+83+64mX5991YZzg3002Y~ZDwZ»�ò0Îy 3DуgÐZkÅaZ�áÈ¿~WNXZDwZ»�òä0002Y~Zk»ÃgÏFÀÌ>Zy

)ZiZÒ](�áùHìX Ú_^ÖÃäen‚Ù�…µ†içô]Þ‚m�äâ^pe†+Šç7Ôm5 Ú_^ÖÃäen‚ÙÊÓ†e†+Š^7Òo…æ�ßoÚn6 4D

573ºt�~ù´

Page 372: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÃÐ7|™Ô%AHìXz{��: è ´)»Zq.eÂQ(~œZzg�‰ÜLLZÝZôm~!iðO�}~:ÜsWVÅP�VÃWC�ÉPZÖpÌ�g`ƒä

Ðg{‰�'~äZyP™õ]Zzg�Ûz*Z¤VÃ�zg™�cìXóóøg}ìw~tìÔz{ÁÐÁ£gT6ZDwÆ�~áyÃ%Aƒ*ecX

ZDw»tZë*yZg�zF3Æ‚B�gZqQg�zÂ[ÆÔ�áùHYg;ìXÔ [�Zôm~uzgtZ0g�cŠì Z ZÝ*yZôm~~ìÔ1Zk»ÛzãuzgtÔ0gZ�

.e¢zg~åYV�Z¹Ât´)ÅZôm~Â[ ¸¢6Ì�}�cY@�ÉtìFÀÂUâ~qìXt¼Ð‚4ì�ZÝN?¸TZzgF3»N?ñ��X

øg~?mì�ÜsZôm~{6�Zq´u{Ì�áùHYñXZg�zÐ*£Ô�*½ÆzWFZôm~pZV6ÆaÔñ��{Zg�z{Æ06,]¬ZŸ°)ZzgZq1ú(�X

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^673

Page 373: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âè t�0gzVÅDz+ º(`)z,ÂCÙ»gÆaÔZK&]Æ!iðO�Z]cZyÅÝwÃôpgp»ZÈx

*¦kìÔ1�ógÆ£«~Zq�á²ÆatZÈx×W‚yƒ@ìX´)ZDwLL4zÁóóZÃgÆñµ6ÔZC¯xËNÒn~ôp™f¸Xˆ~¢zg]ZyNÒçVÐàâ]zç1]Ü™ÆZ¶gZ]zg‚b~Z�á® èø

XQÄ~ùúVÅFKzDz+Æñµ6̸Òu4è EGÔ ��~YC� Æa

ã�~LLâ~óó»»x�î�XZqÄcçwÆ'@*yc£áÅÜ»g™*ZqñWiâZzg×»x

ìX´)ZDwã�~îg6Zq�ᲸZzg�â+ZyÆaUâ~wgB¶X¸zzì�ZyÅÄ~ÒçV~Qy»¯xW`Ì/Óxz¾wôpìX1ZyÅ�~’kzVÆZÝ!iðO�Z]½ãnzx�X£Ñ]zp}ÅÝwQ,Vä�áh„LÔ

èZDw è ZL0kôpg¿ƒVXtZÈxËZ�!çzyÆ%eÌ:åÔOçW`ë�ÅZÍA,·ßg]„ÃÔã�~QŒÛZg�¶66g�X

ÃÔZyÆ�~g¥�„Ì!g!gY9YD è ZDwÅà]z=qÆ7QóóÐ"~Æ:Q~F§bÅZÝogZ{0C è gìXZkÜ�gÜ~LLw#Ö

Æ¥Ã]ZzgplâÁVÅZ&q]ÐQ~§b§bÅp´V "54èGEGE% g�XQækZyz

¼�’kzV» ƒC¬IX³t�ZqZq*y~:ÜspVZÝoñ���ÔÉ7K‰ ZÝQÌZyZ&q]»Dgƒ™*ƒ[ìX*,]~�Y}

�ÔZyÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�™IZzgÑ6zZðÆË~ZDwÆ�~Q~F(ZÝ|x¹ƒŠìZzg‰£â]6Âs~§�zÚ³ÌaZƒŠìX

ZDw»�q�~fí{ZQg�zZzgZôm~ùúVÅßg]~�áùHŠìX

773ºt�~ù´

Page 374: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

äQÅ¡zw#Öг…Æ´z{ÔFKzDz+Æã�~ "54èGEGE% ZyùúVÆ

Zzg0QßßVÃÌÅp7g3XZÝ’k,ZzgFZWZq„ù´~�™�bX¬x‡g~Æa�zâV~¸&™*e7X‰Zz‡]¸è7¸�ZÝ’kQg�z

Ãg„Zzg:óg�á]à è ~è¶cZôm~~ÔQZyùúV~:Âñç¦FK7â¦Z±gÐæÍyHŠXZÒùúVÅwZqZ,LLCwóóÅìÔT~£Ñ]Ôp}Ô•gZ]ÔèoÔ»goÔÂr3§öG

EZ‹�Ô»gkÔh]ÔÒ*]Zzgr~Vz){

»ZqWö{‡gMÆ‚t7™�cŠìX‰’k,Q�ðg~Ôbz~Zzg*å�XZkz‰ÜZDwÅ)ºt(Qg�zZzgZôm~�Æegegù´X�ÔCÙù´~ƒZg

ìXÃðZqù·ÌZDwÆ7g}Qg�zcZôm~�~fí}»Zq©7™@ÔÉtèè ƒùï™ÌZDwźt�Ã�7XS®é O�®é OùúVТ‹ü

GLÃ:+B543ï EGIGGLù¦Ô�

QZzg£§Dz+�zâVZ±gÐ*³Zzg)£g~�X è ZDwÆtù´¡OçZDwÅx£?ŧbÔQyÆZZzg�qQg�zZzgZôm~!ª��

QZzgˆZiZVZkQÅZq5FKzDz+ZD1]»Zqã�~»ŸìX è ÅoâÆe~a¸![~gZ¶ä‰¢zg~ è ZDwÅx£?ÅDz+

Ãg*¦kìÔ è Z¤p!ª��ÅDz+~ÌZ¹7 C1 ï]ÅzŸsŶXâ{§pZ{§jÐZ�x è èZDwÅDz+ è� pPZ,ZñgÌ�ÔX6Âz�b%

70$ËX)1(nz�}P’kzVÆ´z{ÔZDwÅ9�~’kzVÆZÝ!iðO�Z]�ø[

ƒÐ ZkaZÍA,·Q„Ãã�~QŒÛZg�¶ÆÎZÃðeg{7X C2 7�Ô

(4 5±Ù:![4)`(Ôï]�)1(@) 1DThe Inner Synthesis of »ZÝ!iðO�{Dñi*™Zc~ôpìX Islam and Ahmadism 2D

)ÑzZã()!W.Þm82(~�áïìÔ1ZDwƹÐ!iðO�Z] Speeches »@ Life

iâäÅ�S�»Dgƒ‰�XeZËz©ŒÛ7äZq!ggZ¶ÃCc�a�O~·@%jxäZq!gZ¹Cc�)ZDwÅzÃ]ÆÔQyÆFÆйл½Z]z!iðO�Z]Ô$4è MGYzh

Ô6( { 2wÐZL�íáŠZzg™«ÆìwÐZ¹ZqZÓg~~w)�WÒ

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^873

Page 375: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¬´Z¶gZ]zg‚bÐZÍA,·QÅÝw»g™ZðYNZzgÂ"zZ5ÅZÝo�zg™ÆQÃ�g„HYñX‰»gkzÒ*]àz‰ÜFZ¶gZ]~�áùƒñÔZq„½kcÒyÅ]g7g›)ZZ¶gZ]Æáy(¦™ÆZqYì

Q»gHYñXZôm~ZzgQg�z�ÆZµZµùúV~]�~fí}Ãâ¦wÐ )2(”V~�HYñÔ}:)Z³(p}z£Ñ])[(èo)`(»gkz ´u{

(��ZÖ)i(»gozWgZ)b(º‡]X z h])�(Z¶g~Ò*]){(r8/õE)�Z½îg6CÙ{~iâãFKÅpg6ecX

)3(CÙ’kƬg°â^~’k»:©Zzg(tzòtzZãHYñÔ@�ÅseÌQY¤ƒnXZke~ZDwÅ k’ ‡gMÆaQŃW‚yƒZzg

ÎZö/-VZzgµ3ïGEL�ª]Æ´z{ë)Z¶gZ]ÅÃ�VÐæ�ï$ËìÔ}Qy»:©Ô@g+÷ GEL’kÔ»g~ZzgZ�á®Å,pZz Islam and Ahmadism Æ*y

ZDw�2Ô7791Y:m393@493Zzg ÞÏç� †Zß©Zzg2k*i~Ž™�{¥â])» Qadianis and Orthodox Muslims :m503@813(~ñ���X ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ù

C1 :©†Z°æ¤gtäzZãHìX)4(¿$›Ò3¨é G

GG]Æfg)QÆ=ôÔï]ÅzŸsÌ¢zg~ìXZkCÙ’kƈQkÐ0� : 0zg¹jZÙÆfg)X�zx : ZÍw Ô Å�zßg'�

$›Ò3¨éG

GG]X‡g~ÆaZÍAßg]ic�{ñizVgSìX)5(Zôm~ZzgQg�z�zâV¢zV~Zq×ñç¦Z�ágb»ZÈxZ”¢zg~

ì@�ZDw6»x™äzZßVÆaZq„ñçq6Zp}ÔèoZzg»gk~

™�cÔ¼²áˆZÓg~ÅàÂZ¹�]e^¶XZkŤ&xV )�*�(†ZØäÌÅì�a�O~·@Æ�í~ÔZyÆ‚B»x™D¸X)�&À�/õ GG:*y

ÔâÞ8791YÔm85@821(X ÎçÚoJ]ñrŠ8 LLZDwZzga�O~·@óó,·::m022 Ú×Ëç¾^l 1D

973ºt�~ù´

Page 376: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)}ƒñï]Jg‚ðZzgg�q~W‚ãƒÔÉZ¤ÔÆ0cÈ�Zð~»©jZßVÆîg6Ôñçq6ZëÃz£Ñ]Ŷy�„Ì™�~YñÔÂtZyXi{ùúVÅZŸ°p!ƒÏX

ZDw»9�~fí{P™{!ÑùúV~æÍyƒ[ìÔ1tù´ZDwÅQg�zZzgZôm~’kzV»´Zq©7™DX¹Ïåz*å»gkÔr8/õEZzgºt’k,

~ZDwÆ�zr8/õEÔ Letters g‚bzÃ~)~ƒð�XaZ£eZgÆ%ûù´ZDw�ZÍwÔZÆ'3791Y~ ‘vnËä �z»gkZzgeg¿Zzgîs’k,Ì�áï�X

ZahŒÛÙÔ·ð�á@Zzg·†ZvŒÛ7Æp}~ZDwÅZq�gXÐiZZZ+~ÌZk§bÅ ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä ’k,Q�Ô�Ë�~ù´~�áï7�X

)9âÞ7791Y(~Z*!ÍCÙ~Æ Údžeoµ^ÒŠj^á ºtóg�á]ñ���Xgzi*)aZDwÅZq�»@ÖåXP'kI·ð�á@ÔZDwÅ'×heg’k,©¬x

Ôуg8791Y(X ]Îf^Ù…mçmç 6ÑñX)P™{!Ñ¥xZzg�ø[�~fí}Æ´z{ÔZDwÅ'×h�~’kzVÅñ��Ï

{g`ZiZky7X½ãÛœ~IeZËYzhZDwäÔ´)ZDwÆFÆ~LLèoZzg),·p}óóÅñ��ÏŸ�ïƒñ�å:

My desire is to edit these papers gradually and to publish them.1C

ÃæÍy™Æ�áùHYñ? Papers HZÌz‰Ü7Wc�Z,´)ZDwä8091Y~ZàyÐpZzŒÂòÃ�:Zày~Ô~äZsòè<ØzÕy6)zV»Zq�ÑzqHìÔZq)ƒ[

ìÔ�zuZLZsò¦só6�Ûzg~Æ�}�~ƒÇÔ!¹)zVÆçãÿ˜ZþtƒVC2 Zãóz){X è ÐL�âV»ZW�d-g\6óÔLZsò/geóÔLZsxZzg=

]ÞÏ¡h Ô ‡Únß‚]… ,·c’k~ßg]~Zy)zV»uZr}7MÔ'×h'WV^ Zzg‰�vZ¶gZ]Æ6ZäÃ�V~ZDwÅ»gkzÒ*]»5/z)%A

xxx :T1691YÔm Stray Reflection 1DÔ�zx:m853 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ •nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i’^ÞnÌô]Îf^083

Page 377: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

C1 ~ôpìX,]~f™W[ì�´)ZDwƺt�0g}Qk�zgƉ *¸

Z¶gZ]ZzgZÃzZZ~)}ƒñ�X'×hˆlz»zlÅYñÂZ¶gZ]zZZÆ6ZäÑgzVд)ZDwÆ'×h!ª���gcăäŵìX

Zk§b»Óx¥xz*¥xZzg„CÙnzxßZi)ZD1CÌVZzgfÅÂz»äZq!gZ²ZxÎcå�‡�c+6ZDwʼn’k, ]ÖË–Ø ³ìX‡�cEVÆF)y

FÆÃï k§bÆLZ²Zâ]óÅ|zZã™äÆaÔZDwÆ�~ Z C2 P�XÅgzÝ~%AzæÍy™**¦kìÔOç�~fí}ÃYìF¯äÆa6ßZióÅ!icÄÔZkÅóDz+ZzgQZkÅ£g~S®zZ�á®Zi'¢zg~ìX

ðýýðýýð

ÆÜsQyÃ�VÐZ~HŠÔ�g^aÎ‚Ì ]ÞÏ¡h Zzg ‡Únß‚]… »ñZ� +Ëj^…ô]Îf^Ù 1D~»gkzÒ*]Źðh~lZg�áï ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Ws0ÎyÆÃ{ä~ôp�X

un^lô]Îf^ÙÒ12ß‚ ~�áù”{ZD1CßZi)�zÂ1V ]ÞÏ¡h ìX·Ú{Ãgz¹äßg] )ZsÔ2991Y(Å ]Îf^ÙÒ^‰n^‰o‰Ë† ))ÄZDwуgÔ8891Y(Zzg ÚíËo+ç�1

~�%A™�cìXZk~ZDwƉÒ*]Zzg»gkz){ZzgZyÐZzgZD1]Ð~,·ZD1CßZi)Z¶§ ‡Únß‚]… 0¹‚ËßZi)�áïìXeZËZºZûYä

èÃgÆÃ�VЦ™ÆæÍyHÔtkdZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÐ�áùƒÇXÔZDw�2Ô7791Y:m493 ÞÏç� fZ!Ô 2D

183ºt�~ù´

Page 378: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:6 ![

�ª]Æù´

�ý�ý�ý�

383�ª]Æù´

Page 379: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ª‹ZDw � ( Z³ )Z1Z[~´)ZDwÅ]Ä~z�~£?Æ´z{ZyÆ�Ûñ�Z]z *¸

Zg�á�Z]6�ùúV»Y{1Y[ìXt�Ûñ�Z]!kx°Z^t½kzVZzgr~VÃ{~´)ZDwÆ è Å^~�ZzgZDwÆ�¦QÅwgn�X7

�¦QÅŠg}ZâÎikcWñÏX½kzVZzgr~V~ÂñçqÔñµûZzg(tzòtÅuz�»¾qw0ȃ*7@ìÔ1!3›4è G

GOEñç¬]Ð0Zy�Ûñ�Z]ÐZµÔZDwÆ�¦Q»ZqZëZzgúcVzÔQyWîV6�ìÔ

q×"$¹Ò¨é GE:âjw~Zzgš¢5å GGLñçqÔWiZ�Z:ZÖ§ìwÅZqßg]¹YYÅìX Ú×Ëç¾^l ìX�¦QÅtâ“3ïGOG

±2k*i~��:|‹´)ÆZg�á�Z]Å�*zW¶ÔZâzW�ëQyÅ}#Ö~q¢�XÃð!]ÑzqƒðÔù?Zzg¹VÐ?Zkоn7Ô¾nìÂZkÐ�!]ÑzqƒðXë

�ÛâcÔ ä|‹´)»'×Z`7YÔc|‹´)äp�ZKË»qwÒyHXÃðZ§gZzg cËZ%ŧsZ�ág{ƒZZzg!]ì�©àЩà)bÔ©àЩàzZu]

uƒ6YˆX jZ�_ÐËËÔZsxÔ¬ÅêLZsxÔ@gõÔ')å GOyÔ(„ZzgZyz»Ñ]ÔDz=Ô„zz]ZyÔZ�[Zzg®ƒZkÅi�~�XZk6|‹´)»

ÒyÔ™sz‚�{Zzg�weZÖpÔbszšºÔ'\Zzg"‚$ÔÂzZzg èŒZZ]Ô.ZzgÂZäÔïmZzg�g�q~��Zg�á�ìÔ�w~QFg;ì;�!]ìf‚~Ög„ì;QQy»ZΧDÔ.Zzgi0{�à�S�¬ìÔ:$›Ðö

GOÔ:¾zgÔ:5;O-ÌìÔÂøZÄÅeÝÐ{à7;Z�Oë��uZ0Z�[ÔuZ0Z�ZxÔ|‹´)ÆZg�á�Z]Ígì�;%Ë5ÆÎZÑ]™gì;ÎZÑ]»�Z[�}gì�;›ëzçgsÅ�*‚tì;»zÃÆs[ZJgì�;�wz�âr»g8µ

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^483

Page 380: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

C1 g;ìXZvZº!H"${3üGEOWNZzgH"Ø…‰X

…ZzgZygV~ƒäzZàWNÔ�ª‹ZDw»â~zÈ�X´)ZDwÅgVÐnz;c[ƒäzZßV~F§bÆßv�áï

ƉçÜ+Zzg"Ø�z2V)�†ZØ�gÔ%iZ°wZ−+ÔÝx� y ¸XZ.8z){(ÃZzZbzW¸i„ÐZDwÅŒÛ"�ƒðX‰Ãz|~´)Åëg»!»ñµ5)a�O~·@ÔeZË·†Zv,ðÔÝxgÎw$Zzg±ZëZz){(X

¼Zô[ZDwÆWy~‚ßV~!ÑoZxZyÅ}#Ö~q¢ƒDgìX)±2k*i~ÔpZz†Zß©Ôa�O~·@ÔxV·Ã(@ëic�{F®Z�Z,*iqzVŶÔ�´)ÐZL_!îE0o]Ã@i{gpÆaz»¯»q¢ƒ™QyÆ�ª]Ð

c[ƒD)xVaZ£Ô·@²ÙÔÝxgÎw$Ô†ZØ‚´Ôïƒâg7g~Ô ;qZ£{VÔ·�+@|Ô†Z°æ¤gtÔZ*ZÅZzgpZz†Z?z)ë(X1tƒÔz{ßvÔ�Mуg~}Ô(~®Z�ZyßÍVŶÔ�ÛzÈуgcÛzyoÐWDZzgo]z›ÆZ•ð_!]Æ‚BÔ¤V¤VZDwÆ;VíÔÎZz‡]

[VZyÆZg�á�Z]FÔZkÆ!z��ZqmagÁƒDXZy~CÙ§bÆßv�áïƒD¸XxV·ÃÆ–w:LLeZË™rÆ5‡ZV~ñc�Æ

·[�ÛzlÐá™Zsò�VÆfZzgºZzg-g\Æà:JX�áïƒDC2X ¸ZzgeZË™rCÙZqÐZyÆøsÆ_.W�ÛâDóó

´)ZDwÅ�Ñ~¯x7XQyÆZg�á�Z]z�ª]ÅsezZÃ�eÌOìZzgZyÅ}#Ö~q¢~�¶zZßVÆ_!]ÌFZzg"0cV¸X´)ZDwÅÀ~–w@|:LLZ+˜VZ�ÛziWƒC¶�CÙ5‡]~F5ÂÁ

ZkìwZ0WÃ'CÙ�z)Æ'Å!]:¶Zzgq}Z 1 3C �»ñZ�ƒ@åóóätÂ=�¶ÔZy~йÁZ,†ÔqZy¦:�ª]Ãôp™ä»ìw

ÔZÍw:mLLzóóX ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç… 1D:m431 ¡Úä]Îf^Ù(]µßç7ÒoÞ¿†Ún6 2D

:m43 ]Îf^ÙÒ^ÊÓ†æÊà 3D

583�ª]Æù´

Page 381: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

WcƒZzgz{Zk~»x[ÌgìƒVX!,!�ª‹ZDw»ZY{™fí{’k~ßg]~Eƒ™ôpƒŠìX

�ª‹ZDw»tfí{QyÅ�á²~Zzg�~Z°g»#-*î GGOìX�ª]Љàâ]Zzg£?Æ:©6gzÝ7CìÔ‰ZÃgzp}»iâU’k³Zzg

Zϧb�ª]~‰ZÃgzï]Å=ôÔp�ZDwÅi!ã C1 tzZãƒ@ìÔ (tzòÑbz�Ð0�ª]»tU{™ZëìÔp�Ûñ�Z‹ZDw Å ZDw è QìÔZ¤p„

Ås"ìGOG»ZkÐÌic�{Zë¥ctì�Zk~ZDwÅÎZöÆaË{xßZi)ñ��ìX¹Ð�NzZu]ÔZDwÅi0ÏÆZZ�zZgÐ0‰qÑ]Ô6UÔZyƬ�Z]zZîZgÔ¬‹Ô¡Ô´`ç„Ô¿ƒñZcxZzg

(autobiography) 8iï FFLLp�â“óó wƳZìÔ¾n�ª]Åæ�ÐZDwÅZq�w%Aƒ$ËìX

èo~šd->î IEXZDwÅ,ƹÐ6Zzg*�gU‚tWD�1�ª]~¿Zzg,ÃÔëic�{ŒÛdÐZzgic�{�Zð~�NM�XQy»§¯„ÔZyÅÎaZzgQyÆC‚]»Z0ZiÔQyÅ�g�q~ZzgQy»¡Òï G

ELg±Ôtƒ¼�ª]~¹zZãìXxV·ÃÒy™D�:

y~»x™äzZà{'ZÌðÆaYzh2wWCÔÂZLdÃÔ�Yzh»ë/åÔZL‚BáWCXZJz{»x~zsgSÔt^Yzh2wÆö~S�OQ�OngLX¤ñVÆñÌ~Zq�yeZË™r'Wæ}~WgZx™ÏeZw™WgZx™gìÔÂQyÅó{�¢š5é EGS{Æa67~ÔQÐPÄBŠõ E�Úƈ�~WzZi

0g}ŧb ~�ÛâäÑ:LL~ZÌZkaÃ�8ƒVÔÂ÷Z�wZCZ[ÐÜs G\ZÞìZzg~ÎøƒV��`ÅiîzVÅzzÐt^i0Ï~

5±Ù: 1DÔZÍw:m94Ô351 ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç… )Z³(

@89Ô022Ô122 9 m86Ô6 : Ú×Ëç¾^l )[(ZDw�2:m393Ô493Ô604Ô044 ÞÏç� )`(

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^683

Page 382: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

{™z[0nÇÔqÑèZk~ZzgYzh~Ô˜VJZyƒä»mìÔÃð�Ût7XZ¤Yzhf;-~Zk±ÆÐÁ̃Ô¡ZkzzÐ�z{÷ZgìÔZk6

C1X F¹ÆgZ5Ag�ÐtgN‚zZ§ZzgZDwÆtP¿ÔZDwÆ¡Òï G

ELˆkÅÜF)ã™D�ZzgZk~7æ{Zãg�~Zzg�g�q~»�_/‚tÑD�ÔZkÅzŸsz=ô�áhZqîs£á~Ìe7X

̹¼�YñÇ1 g{ ZDwÅi0Ï6¼�p}ZzgÂÁèˆ�ÔWÎZöÅFKzDz+~�ª]ÃÃZ0Zi™*e7ÔÉZqã�~â~ÅwÐ�ª‹ZDwÅZÌå'ŒÛZggìÏX

]Îf^ÙÒ1 Zi±2k*i~Ô ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç… fíÒ�ª]6�¼�xÂ1V)Ô%A: Ú×Ëç¾^l ZipZz†Z?(Æ´z{�ªCp}ÆFù´) 2ß‚qç]a†…mˆcÔ%A: ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜÞ�nà ÔZÍwz�zxÔ%A:M±z©Z−+Ô …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† ú�ÂòÔ

Ô%A:Q�a(ZzgpVQg�zZzgZôm~p}�áï�X Úr^Ö‹ô]Îf^Ù ™'³gz~Ô,]~Zy»ZµZµY{7HYg;ìX {ÒW

ðýýðýýð

ÔZDw�2Ô�c7791YÔm654 ÞÏç� 1D

783�ª]Æù´

Page 383: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]Æù´ �ª ([)

ZDwÆ—g /

±2k*i~8191Y~«!g´)ZDwÐAÔˆZiZVZVg{'kJz»¯»QyÅ}#Ö~q¢ƒDgìX6391YÐMуg~}ƒä6!ÑoZx5‡]

Åßg]aZƒÔOçz{gziZ:„Yzh2wV™ÔFF]ÔZDwÅ}#Ö~q¢gTZzgQyÆZg�á�Z]ÐnƒDX*i~™r»©wå�ˆ~�ª‹ZDwÃZKÒ¸c��Z“~ôp™fX

´)ZDwÅzÃ]ƈ*i~™rätgzi*/%AHÔ1ZkÅZ�á®F'kÔ�Ñð1791Y~¿~WðX(~ÆZzg!gqNU~,·�ª‹ZDwÅikë¢Ô%AÆZݵ"»ZqbzìÔ�J†g~Ð12Bâga8391YJ

ÆZ0gZY]6�ìXgzi*ôÆ!¹{~iÔ$k0î GIE0�zS®�XZkK~)&c ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç… gZ¶äZq!g*i~™rÐZ§gHÂZ,Vä�Z6�:

egZzg{()1(Yzh2w~)2(63Y')3(73Y')4(83Y»�zuZzÔ¼t{ÔZyÅ 1 C1 %AÔ¼)%A7Zì'~p�„ZyÅZ�á®»ZÈx™g;ƒVÔ

¬x6WnX è© i0Ï~Ô:zÃ])2891Y(Æ@qw)ZÍw(Yzh2w~7Wæ{zZu]ÔoøZzgW�VÅZq ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç…

’k~™ìX*i~™r‘zgzi~{à�kYzh2w~ñ��gTÔZk²á~ÃyWc;ÃyŠ;HWƒð;ZDwÅËÔZy»'×Z`ÔZyÅÝ‹¡Ô�zZ�V»ZEwZzgZy»¿zg›¿'ZzgƒÐZëQyÆZ§gZ]z�ª]ZzgZx[Ð

Sq© Syz Óxz¾w n�Èî0ìÑ]X2k*i~äZyW�VÔSî´)Æ�ª]»/

¯[±2k*i~¯xg<Z−+;×X 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^883

Page 384: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

™äÅ[ÅìXgzi*ôÆZ’ZðZ0gZY]Ô6�!kxƒ@ìÔ¿¸p%A™Dz‰Ü�ª]Ã!5¯ÈHŠX7B�Ûzg~»Z0gZ`ZkÅ ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç…

è ~Üseg,]6�åÔ1bª 1C zZãVwìXgzi*ô»tzÔZ’Zðßg]QyegËVÅ,�kŠg{ËV6’ˆìÔ@ë�Zzg×�zâV’kzV 2C ñ��{

~Ô!±g|x¼�Ût7X%Aä$4èGEL�ª]Ð0Ô0zg¹jZßVZzgjZÙ»ÌZÈxHìXtjZÙ!kx¿�XÂ[ÅS®Yg~¶�%AÉc��Z¤VÆ

6ZbZ�ø[ƒ‰ÔZϧb‰Ò*]Ť&Ë{gYfg)Ѓ'Q‰Zñg×ic�{,Æ‚BzŸsÔÔ}:KLmÔZz‡s.ÞÔ>»

Z°kуgÔxоæÜÔZ£eÔ‡�c+z){XLLZ+ZguóóÆikÄZyÔÂ[ÆWy~QZzgjZÙÐ0ZyZñgÅ'×h¥ôz±ňìX

ƉZÃgÅî@g+÷ GEL’k»è¸ìÔ ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ �ª]ÆZkù´Ð82B†g~8391YÃZzgZkù´ÅWy~Ä 3C }:LL@Z£óóÆikÄZy&ZÃg

7B�Ûzg~8391YýˆXZϧbZqg!¦Æ¬�z´Z’Z~ 4C LL|‹ZyóóZk§b¸:

�Ugz¯gz×¾{‘gZ ²[gZ è 0Zã&½0î EG0�+22B�Ûzg~8391YÃ$�ç EELUã~Fç™ÆZ¹Zk§b¯cŠ:

²[gZ è 0Z0&½0î EG0�+ £Ã½i�oz©gZ

�ª] /

Zkù´ÅâÎËŠgZìXtÚgzi*ôc¡�ª]ÆO}ÔäZLx@Z] Gg{Z,p}»ù·ìÔX~‰�ª]Æ‚BÔ�zZßV

ÿlZrŒ‹]þ:m49@79 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä �!Ô 1DÔZÍw:m351@361 ]Îf^ÙÒ1u–ç… 2D:m196 ]ö…�æ Ô Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù 3D

Zs:m296 4D

983�ª]Æù´

Page 385: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZzgZDwÅ,Æ!g}~ZL@WZ‹o]ÃÈHìXtÓxp}уgÅZqZ�!Z³LL7ÒªîG0×zÃóóÅZBV~7ñ‰Ôˆ~ôÆóR~ú�

ÂòäZxƒIÅ?m6Z¹Â!ßg]~%A™Æ�áùHX�zZßV~u†ZØ�gÔxVaZ£Ô·@²ÙÔ%iZ°wZ−+Ô·�+@|Ô

qZ£{VÔpZz†Zß©Ô¬$Z¬$ÔåÑÔ†ZßZuZ*Z}Zzg†Z°æ¤gtz){�áï�Xƒp}ÔZDwÅzÃ]ÆŒÛR²á~‘‰ÔOç§zZ0z{Zzg‹]zøzòÅZqªZyƒ’kzV6¸ìX

ZDwÅ,ZzgQyÐ5‡ÂVÅc��Z¤VÐ0p}Ææù´Z[Ã:ÜsiâãZ±gÐZÍqqÝìÔÉ�! Ú×Ëç¾^l J�áùƒñ�XQy~

p}Æ£gzZ÷�ZzgßZióÅâÎzZÌÆÒpÐÌtù·ƒ6¯Eg�ìX™IgZz~!kxª‚]Åã�6gzZc]z�ª]ÆxZ�yqy™�ï�

äZkçA~ªkcZbÐZA[HìX‰p}Åã� Ú×Ëç¾^l 1gZzcÈgzZeógzV)}xVaZ£ÔpZz†Zß©Ô†Z°æ¤gt(Å’k~c��Z¤V6ìÔ@ë¡qzÅæ�ÐÈKYäzZá�ª]ÅgzZe~Ì{àZôo»o]�cŠìX�ª]ógzVÆZˆµf)�Zg~»Z0Zi{ZyÅZkgzlÐÎcYYì:

tÃÒňì�Ãð!]�QyÿZDwþÆ�ZÆÜsƒÔQyÆfóÎäÐC1 )·@²Ù(X Þø^ ó �øe$ßø^�øiöç*]ìô�ûÞø^]ôá$Þ$�ônûßø^]øæû]øìû_ø+ Z�ZiHYñÔ

ôzV!'ƒNÔpZ\k�qC~:ƒäÅzzÐZ¹�âr~ôp7gÄeC2 Zzg7eL�ÃðZ+!]�VÔ�7g~7g~�g„:ƒX)xVaZ£(X

gzZeógzVÅZôo»ZqUtì�Z¤Ë¿ÔÂ[cq»*xß—f‚ÐC3 "ƒŠÂQ,VäZkÆZ‹Zs~@ï7HX

�ª]Å{§ZDwƉZôm~ZÖpÔFZIZzg¿ è gzZeógzVä¡:m65 Ú×Ëç¾^l 1D

Zs:m23 2DZs:m24Ô45Ô65Ô27 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^093

Page 386: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

(ZDwƺ! F C1 VÜK�Ô@��Ûñ�Z‹ZDw»ZÝ|xzZãƒnX æ �VÆ¿®w�X

»£§Â"zS®oƒìÔZôm~ZÖpNU~�b‰�X Ú×Ëç¾^l}}ZݹÂ"ÃWC�Ô}:

9 ß S �°y »y 11 63Â×oFìÛ�õ Âø×øo]Öíø�û 01 93�Ò#F^ �øÒ$ø^ 51 44_541ºÎæ FGE ]4-)¾æ

IFGY

61 011$úELO¬ $©ú

EGL¬ 6 271

_541ºÎæ FGE ]45¾æIEGY

51Ô71 791&£â]Z,�˜VŒÛWãWc]ß܃ð�:

�~ZkâqÅ�zWc]�X)Z³( Ά�á ' Ên`^�øÖÇçæ�i^$nÜ )1(m471:�ømø�ûÛøÃöçûáøÊônûø^ÖøÇûç÷]æ$�øÒô�$]e÷^ )ZßZ§:52()[( �ømø�ûÛøÃûçáøÊônûø^ÖøÇûç÷]æ$�øiøû$ônûÛ÷^

)ZûY:53(�VÎg>ZßZ§ÅÃðWe%Z�ƒÏXiZZìX)ZÂ{:621( �ô�ûÎ÷^ )2(m94:WeÆWy~

)Z'Z�:5( æø�øÒôù�ûaöÜûeôøm$^Ýô]Ö×#äô Å9ßg]ì: �øÒø�ûeôømù^Ýô]Ö×#ä )3(m05:‰�ª]Ô§‹ZDwƼ�ZBZñgÃzZã™D�Ô}:{−nß°

Zg�ïƒñ�ì�tZqGz£ ŒÛ 2C äZDwÅZqWçŸùƒäÃLL"ã�Z¯Z{óó6 Ô1´)ZDwCD��:LL÷~�Z 3C ìÔ�gZÝQyÅLLWçÅÓð�Ð$zg¶óó

:m13Ô601Ô701Ô911Ô121Ô221Ô341Ô471Ô502Ô602 Ú×Ëç¾^l 1DÿZÍwþ:m591 ]Îf^Ù�…æáôì^Þä 2D

Zs:m491 3D

193�ª]Æù´

Page 387: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

WçÂÑzqÐZg¶'�z‚wÅ/~÷~tWçŸùƒ¶X=ZLƒl~C1X Çc�7�tWçÇ̶c7óó

@ëZqW�|£xZ(ìÔ˜V¥xƒ@ì�gzZeógÃZDw»|xK~ß.ƒðX±Z®sŒgZz~�:

Ëä7Y�Z¤Qg�z~úi7|àYñÔÂHw`ì?ìÑ:²!~úi!ǦS‚�~ìÔÃðÂZÖp7Ô®ZúiÆQg�zF3»ìw7aZƒ*ecÔz,Z¤ÃðíÐ7iÂ~¼VÇ�Qg�z~ÌÃðw`7Ô=c�ì÷~zZ−{™/²!ZÖp»È9:™$ˉԮZ÷}zZ−™rZ¹ZYi]�c™D¸�z{"

C2 —Qg�z~„úi7|1™,X„CÙ¢™äÃY7eL�zZ−ÒZDwÔ²!~úiZ�Z:™$˃VÔg;Qg�z~

úi»�Zi'Âtñ�ÔZDwÆqgzfsÒyÐÜqpÐì:My own belief is that the congregational prayer is the prayer conceived as a

world institution must necessarily be in Arabic' all the world over.C3

9491Y~�áùƒZ'Zk»‚ps™�cŠìÔ1Zë 4C ZkÂ[»�zuZZecù´ÅâÎÃ4îg6zZã™@ìX Ú×Ëç¾^lô]Îf^Ù p~ù´Æ*xÅìX**x

T�zxÆW¸i~LL�âpTUãóó)Zi6zWqZ£{V(Qg�zp}LL�ætóó)Zi·ŒŒÛÙ(ZzgLLZ!Yyóó)ZiYzhZDw(»ZŸ†HŠìXm44Zzg94ÅZÝoÅo

æø]Ö$�ômûàø ƒìX!¹ZÝo$2gñ���X'×h'WVZqZzgtgz5kƒìX¯�cŠìÔ��g„7X ø ]ôá$]Ö$�ômûà )m55(ûŠZZec7791Y~eZËZ1ZÎœjäLL%Aóó™Æ Ú×Ëç¾^lô]Îf^Ù

�áùHXZk~T�zxÆQ6�z§bÆZŸ±K‰XZÍw:×jZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]Ô

�zx:Q~‰�ªCp}»ZŸ†X

:)gzZeqZ£{V(m911D021 Ú×Ëç¾^l 1DZs:m571 2D

:m06 Mementos of Iqbal 3D‚ÁS®�g`71�âdÅ@g+÷ GEL’k82BZ6s9491YìX 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^293

Page 388: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

%Aä£,]6�LL7%góó~ÔZkù´Æñç¬]6cƈZDwÅQk¦kÃQY¤HìÔ�Zy�ª]Æ:©ÐQ½CìX

»�zuZZec6zWqZ£{V™rä Ú×Ëç¾^l %A»tÒyoÔì�:LL6zWñßsTUãÆ�âpógÔ:�%AX�zu}Zec6̨ C1 X %AHóó

%Aú�Âò„»*xñ��ìX¡�zp}ÆZŸ±Åã�6qZ£{VÃ�zu}Zec»%AŒÛZg7�cYYXQ,Väp�t�úò7HZzg:Zk»�ZiáìX

…æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† п�ª]Zzg ]Îf^Ù]æ…Âf‚]ÖvÐ ikÊ}ZecÆZŸ¯V~ЉÉ�ª]ìjZÙ�áï�XWy~ÂÒ]ZzgZq×Z�ágt�cŠìX

â:Üs¢zg~¶ÔÉCÙÒpÐ? è ÅZ�á® Ú×Ëç¾^lô]Îf^Ù ZVK'kÔTZ0Zi~Z�x�~ˆìÔZk 2C ]hÅÿtþ}#Öóó è ÌÔ1LLFKzDz+Z�á®

ÃikÃZecÃZq£g~ZecŒÛZg�bÂìXZk»(Z:Âtì� è Æ7%AäZK»zlzœÃ$4èGELÂ[6%Ãi™äÆO}‚g~ÂzjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]6ÜsÅìXQTZÍwÆK~ÔXZÝoŶy�„ňìÔm271)TZÍw(Å

tÆÎZÔ!¹ÓxZÝoZkZec~Ì$2gñ���Xczsf!'_541ºÎæ FGE»*xÐV(ßìX)_545¾æ FGE

YÔm24Ô]45Ó¾æ

IGEY

Ôm632zg]41ºÎæIGEÔm125(TÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì

�T�zxÆQÃ:Ng7JŠZzg:ZkÅoňXÂ[262 è ˜VJjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]»mìÔZyÅ)©àîZªp&ìXQ,]6�ìZzgZkÆjZÙ9426ÔªQZzgjZÙÅB#Ö~Üs31,]»�ÛtìX·@²Ù»*y72,]»ìÔ1$›Ò3¨é G

GG]17,]6�ƒñ�Xu†ZØ�gÆ8,]Æ*y641,]ZzgxVaZ£Æ71,]Æ*yƱ_Æa05,]ÆjZÙ(Jñ‰�XjZÙÅZk)©àîZª»

:tì�%Aä‰70Zë�{ñç¬]ÆaFFÔz�™�b�Ô}:)463@863(Ô :eg,] q^æm‚Þ^Úä ñÑ*gzx:ÎZ0õ,])953@463(Ô

ÔTÎx:m21 Ú×Ëç¾^lô]Îf^Ù 1DZs)7%gZi%A(:m52 2D

393�ª]Æù´

Page 389: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)wZ−+Zjã:b,])604@214(zdBZZgkDjZÙz$›Ò3¨é GGG]îsƒäÆ

´z{)áZiyÌ�X‰�]»¬gs¿)1»°(ìÔ}pZz�w·egS,)m892(ÔZg”ÍgÇã:‚]S,)m892(Ôß°+:âS,)m974(uzÂ*àz:bS,)m893(Ô´)†Zv-ŠZ:WJS,)m893(ÔZkÆ'@

‰¬gÃ]¹îs)Zzg)¢zg~(�Ô}:Çg‚V�@Ï:0õ,])723@233(Ô%iZ†ZØ�gËw:‚hñeg,])893@304(Ô)wZ−+Zjã:b

,])604@214(z){XZÒjZÙ~ã�~¥â]½™äÆO}û{z=ô»¬xZ0ZiZ(gHŠìÔ}:�]Ƭgs~@g+÷ GELzÑ�]zzÃ]J�g`7Å

I),]592Ô903Ô893z){(XDz+ÅúcV{òtì�Â[ÆZq{~Ô¬åQZzgˆZiZVå

jZÙ�g`K‰�Ô1�zu}{)>Zy:ZŸ£îE0Q(~QZzgjZÙÅtFK‡ì7g¿ˆÔÉQÆCÙ�}ƈZk6$›Ò3¨é G

GG]�g`K‰�XZk§bÂ[Æ�zâV”V~7+7g„Zzgñ��{ßg]~Â[ZqÀ¥x7ƒCXT�zx~YzhZDw»*yåßg]~ñ��åÔikÃZec~QÐ$4èGELÂ[дu{™ÆLLZŸ£îE0QóóÆ{~�áï™�cŠìÔ1¥stHì�7gZ*yåZzg%1oßg]~�¶ÆO}ZkƉ{ZµZµ�zVÅßg]~�b

�XCÙ�}ƈZkÐ0$›Ò3¨é GGG]�g`K‰�X

Å«�zâVZ�áoV6�§%Aú�Âò»*x�g`ìÔTÎx Ú×Ëç¾^lô]Îf^Ù~ÛzãZzgZ0gzãuzgtÐZy»*xvs™�cŠìXt!]*‡&ÿELûìXTÎx

»*ZecìXË'c Ú×Ëç¾^lô]Îf^Ù Æ%A2s��tÃð*ù·7É%AÅÂ[6jZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]ÆZŸ±ÐÔZkÆZÝ'c%AÅw‚�7ƒYCZzgËÌÂ[~PZŸ±ÔZkZ%»�Zi70M�ZÝ%A»*xQhZ�cYñXt§¿ÔZÝ%AÐ"Z»°ÆáZ�sìZzgZkÅÃðz@zs

c- 7ÅY$ËXeZËZ1ZÎœjÔQg�zZ�[~Zq(Z*xìÔ1ZyÅt»zld�Å0âàÅZ\k*uVwZzg*³Dz+»Zq‡]*u%:ìX

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^493

Page 390: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDwmZ°9*îGÆP�ZCÙgm} /

6zWpZz†Z?äZDwÐZK5‡ÂVÅc��Z¤V6�Zqîs*y~�áù™ZcåXˆZiZVt*y7491Y~уgÐZqÂaÅßg] 1C ÚÃ^…Í g‚!

~�áùƒZX´)ZDwÐ'Å5‡ÂV»�âÞ0291YÐ�c7391YJ;ƒZìX

z,Âz{ÇìÇì5‡]ÆaYc™DÔp4291YÐ7291YJQ¹CÙ�!ÑoZxq¢~»ñµ5XZDwÐ'ÅuöZzgŒÛ"»Z0Zi{ZkÐÎcYY

ì�Q,Vä'Ãtf)�Zg~Î,g¿¶�z{,Zzg¾w‚bÆ0@i{Zzg��: C2 £g~Â1V»_·™,ÔZiZVz{ÂÁ´)Å}#Ö~7™,X

eZË™rÅi!y;F)yÐ�DÙZg;�ZCÙgm})DgìÔZy~ÐPÃ)�Zy =AZzgX~ÃðZ+!]7Ô�ËÆa!§{§ƒ(~ä�V¦HìX

~Qy!ÂVÃ�g`7HìÔX~Bc(Ïç5]6-c¶ÔcX~,cfZ»]Ð ‚bÆ�±)b6c¶XZ+!ÂVÃÌFu™�cŠìÔX»m

C3 ìXZ+!'Ì.e%æFN¯Zzg$WñiƒC‰pZy»�áù™*oƒ7XÍcikÃÂÔ�ª‹ZDw»ZqÉù·ìÔ&'äZq{m£gÃ

æÃgnƒñ%AHìXøg}ìw~tZyÅ)¢zg~ZôoI~¶XÃðw`:åÔZ¤%AñßsLLBZzg(Ïç5]óóZzgLL,c‚bÆ�±)bóó6´)Æ�ª]Ì�áï™fXikÃ�ª]zzZu]820gzV)�zV(~Ë�XCÙ0g{

ËZqzZîcZqÜÅgz�Z�6�ìXtù·§‹ZDwÆZZ�zZg6�ìXm616Zqñß~™r»*xgvs™�cŠìX

zZu]z�ª]ÆÒy~{àZôoлx1ìXZkÅR %Aä

ÔZ~8391Y:m101@311 ÚÃ^…Í m�1: 1DÔm8391Y:m561@081 ÚÃ^…Í m�2:

:m8 ]Îf^ÙÒ12ß‚qç]a†…mˆc 2DZs:m8Ô9 3D

593�ª]Æù´

Page 391: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÉÎZöógzVƼÒ*]Zkù´Ðâpf�X´)ZDw6 wÆ7c�{FpZz†Z?ÅgzZc]„6Z2ZgìX i 1C †Z?x0z~»%ûÎZ¤{�

Zkù´ÅÂ"zS®£g~7ìX,]13Ô93Ô14Zzg646ZÃgzrg#»)¢zg~îg6£ìX!,!�ª‹ZDwÆùúV~tù·‡&ÿELf™ìXZkÆfg)§]ZDwÐ0¹ÐZ,zZu]Zzg‰�ª]‚tWD�Ô�ZDwÆÎZ¤fí}~èÃg7�X

ÔZÍw gziǧM /

¸X Æ%AM±z©Z−+ÆyZäÐZDwÆ%Z̹6Zä …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn†z{��:LLZDw%jxÐ�~=5‡]»Ñs�ƒZZzg%jxÅzÃ]Jt

X�]=�g„ÔZÐQyºt5‡ÂVÆ@WZ]~ZqZâ-ŧbZLikÃù´Å~tZâ-Q,Vä‡gMÃÎ,�~ìX 2C X �w~aQ@ƒVóó

Zkù´6‚wZ�á®�g`7Ô1%AÆLL7ÂóóZzg;Z£;ÆLL¬gsóóÅ@g:VÐZk»‚ÁZ�á®)0591Y(³ƒ@ìXÂ"zS®~)©à

ÖðÅ ZÈx'@ŠìXWg^Ä6¬¯!g8ŤZ�&TňÔZk6šuÅZD1]~uz„ŒÛZg�~Y$ËìX è ßg~ÆZ±gÐfíÒÃ èŒ …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† ˆX

tù·�z”V~ËìXLLѽ—góó)m33@301(~%AäZDwÐZK*iq~ÆW¸iÔˆZiZVZ5‡ÂVÔ{0Zã%ZÌÔ2´)ÐZLzZ−Å

5‡ÂVZzgºtW�V»f™%1oZzgÚZ0Zi~HìXLLw±iÉ4øEIï{ZxðóóÆ�‰zZu]Zzg�ª]ü�:ÄZ*]Æ��g`HìX

t¿ù·s~Z±gЊgz7»qïìX0591YƈÎZöZDw6�¼ÅZyc��Z¤VZzg�ª]ÆjZá{]Zzg"5¾æ EGZgX …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† �ŠÔZk~

�X„CÙZ(ÃðŒÛÜ7ÔTů6ËgzZeczZîÃ�uŒÛZg�cYnÔZ%Zq

:m1@24 ]Îf^ÙôÒ^ÚØ �! 1DÿZÍwþ:mLLzóóX …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^693

Page 392: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

(%AÃZ£kƒZìX!gCåELŒÛ\Åicg]»zZ§Òy™äƈ���LLZÏ^t�g„7ìX^ï6†g~3391Y»zZ§ìÔZ�zh C1X ~z{ZỎóó

Ð5‡]�zu~Íwö»Ð÷ÐzZ362391Y~ƒðX»*Zec»gHÔ&(~Æ6šuÐY0 …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† ¾{'kˆ%Aä

ŠXZk~qgzfsZŸ±K‰�:)Z³(W¸i~ñÑ*&bZ−+Z£Åz{’k�Q,VäZkù´6�gû{

gi-ÐíŶX)[(�á²ætÅi0ÏÆZëÍØVÐ0‰Z,zZu]Ôq%Aä

åX 2C TZÍwÆñµ6LLuu~�™ÃZ0Zi™�cóó)`(±ZëZZzg-ŠÐ²ÆgzZe™�{zZu]z�ª]X

¬gsX ZDwÆzZ−+Ô�«·Ô�ZÚiZ£Ôñß~÷ŒZzgYzhZDw»¿ )�(){(ZDwÅ@gõaZö6cX)�(§‹ZDwÅZëc��ZÇX)i(¼�£zk»ZŸ†X

ZÍwóó)m72@47(»QTZÍwÆ_. è ù´Æ�z{�:)1(LLîUãóó)m57@652(ZŸ¯V6 è ìXÜsS»™»jZÙZmZ�K‰�X)2(LLî

îUãóóƉZñgoÔ�Ô}: �ìXLLÆZkÄ: e1ìç�p è …Úç‡ )1(m18:

3C Wy, è âgZ}8 è F¿ �gxÈ»giZ§¬z�,»xgZDÔÎyã7ÉZzg8id¬KìX

312:ægZk~Üs&)�b‰Ô:�i'Zkz‰ÜJ zg Z )2(m031|‹´)Üs&)„»g™n¸X

ÿZÍwþ:m57 …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† 1DUãÔTZÍw:m9 è ZsÔî 2D

:m89 Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù(Ê^…‰o 3D

793�ª]Æù´

Page 393: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

åƒZåX ~7ÔÉ7091Y~ 8091Y Development m442:eZËf»£! )3()4(m542:gzx»3391Y~7Ô2391Y~ƒZX^ï6ZzgzhÐ

5‡]Æ0ÔTZÍwÅtZkZec~Ìñ��ìX)Zi‚´(ŹÏzZuC!VÅoÅìX ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù %Aä*xa%

ZkZecÅÂ"zS®~ÌÔ¬Zec»‚ZÈx'@ŠìÔ×ëìXƒ*ecX Ê’ç”]ÖvÓÜ Å( ì’ç”]ÖvÓÜ ÜsZq£x6Â"ÅtÃWðXm631:

1C '×h0õ!g )TZÍw:ZÆ'3691Y(»¸)©à=qÆ7à LLîUãóóY0ŠXtƒZecäpÂ"zS®ZzgQ7V�X

Ô�zx ziǧM g /Å¢�zx�áùƒðXLLZ¶OóóÆikÄZyÔ%Aä …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† âÞ4691Y~

Z Zkù´ÅLL�áÈ4zwóó»f™™Dƒñ�:LLZÂ[¾™©¬x6WðÔÂZˆkƒ�~ZKc��Z“~ôpFZëzZu]ÃÈ7™eZzg')gÍVÆô¥â]

Oçikâ~¹Ð6zZu] 2C óó Ð̹Ð�ZCÙgm}qÝKYMz�ª]»ZŸ†HŠìXic�{FgzZc]eZËgØZvŒÛ7Ô�iŒZzg�ZÚiZ£ÆjZáÐÒyƒð�X�zu}{~ZDw»Z(ázu¯x�HŠìÔ�!ª‹ZDwÆËù´~7MXŠZzZDwÅZzgQyÆ086£zk6�ìX

¢�zxƉÒ*]Z&bÔ�Ô}:)T ]…ÚÇ^áôur^‡ Åc~%AÃè$ƒZìX ‰†æ�ô…Êjä )1(m71D81:

ìX 3C ZÍw@Þ(~LLuzgóóì:�LLuz�óóX9ßg]uz�ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù ÔTZÍw»�âpF(¾[ìX ]‰†]…ôìç�p )2(m34:

)3691Y(~Ì�áïìX-ÃZe1~5±ÙX)Z[ZkÂ[ÆaZec¼�*Ñ+äY\a�X( 1D

Ô�zx:m9Ô01 …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† 2D281 m: 5±Ù![2 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^893

Page 394: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

«!gâÞ4091Y~�áùƒð¶X Â×Ü]ŸÎj’^� )3(m46:)4(m08:ZDwÅÓx£?Æ]£tôp¸ZzgZkçA~ZDw»

xƒ@ìgØZvŒÛ7ÃzZîÅZÝßg]c�7g„X ¥ C1X ñ�{™Jå‚. è ¢�zx~¼��*zmZ]ZzgZDwƉèoÆ@�áï�Xø

Â"zS®»)©àZÈxHŠìÔOçWg^Ä6T”{Zkù´»ªCÙ~(Ì£g~zVàìX

ZDwÆëS /

D1C’kzVÃLL´)ZDwÐ Z 27~ ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜ‘Ën† Z*Zö*iä5‡ÂVÆjZáÐ*c[’k,óó)uzgt(Æîg67HìX1PZqÆÎZÔ:t5‡ÂVÅc��ZÇ�ÔZzg:LL*c[óóXÉLLÁc[óóÌ7ìXp}ÆMy~

Ða‰Zzg¼iâU Ú×Ëç¾^l �b‰$ó~ЪCÙì�‰p}Âú�ÂòÅŒÛdÆZ¶gZ]zg‚bÐ)Zzgt$ó~ic�{FUâ~�(XZkZ±gÐZ¹LL*c[

�LLZq»gz!g~óó¢zg]Æ� kÅDz+ ’k,óóŒÛZg�}™7™*5&ìXZìX ¿~ÑðˆìX%AzæÍyäZKDz8Љp}~sz'hÌÅ

Zk»¼z»^�cXxVaZ£Æ Zzg qZ£{VÆ*y»ÄZyÌ$w�c*yZyÅZ&bÐôpg;Xu†ZØ�gÆ*y è *y»ÄZyÌps™�c1Q

»ÄZys#Ö1Q6Z,Vä8`„�~ÔMy~’kÆ'»*x�g`7HX»[ú�Z£¸i~äZigZÓ�z„âZi~LLZLHxZzg³m�z„óóÅZk»zlÃ

ZO�r�g~ÑgƒäÆÑëóó)m9( è LLZD1CZ�[~Zqz¯ZŸ†óóZzgLL‡.ÞZ²7ÉZq è ªCù´Æîg6Ñë � ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜ‘Ën† ŒÛZg�cìX¿t�

Àòù”î0p}Æîg6ÌZk~Dz´Dq~yìXZDwÆëd /

6zW™'³gz~äZkù´~94gL(}Z,p}¦K�X,Æa5±ÙÔ![1:m12Ô22 1D

993�ª]Æù´

Page 395: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

~Ô}Á}ic�{ÔZDwÆ�ª]Ì�áï�XZyp}ÅâÎÌ7V7ìXZDwÐ5‡ÂVÅc��ZÇÔx@Z]Ô�ª]ZzgfZC@WZ]ªZDwÆTo]qäQyÐ�‹Ô�¬ZzgCkHÔZÐÈ™�cX5‡ÂVÆgz�Z�âÁV~¹Ð*xËg|Z])lZrŒ‹]ÔZÅÞZ`7g~Ô�iŒÔ�·†ZvÔeZË-Š@{VÔH]1zÔ†ZÓ]�gc!�~Ô´)·Z‡ZzgØgl»ª~(Æ‚B

aqÔZ}giZtÔqYu�Zg·Ô¦!��á{@Zzg·Z1kz){( ) ‰)czsßÍVÆp}Ì�áï�XÂ[ÆZq{~Më[ZDwÔ¡{ZzgZDwÅn{™*!!Æ@WZ]�K‰�X¸³äp}ÆZN[~tZßw7Ãg3�

]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä(]Îf^ÙÒ1 LLÃðZ+’k�áï:ÅYñ�'ZkâqÆ�vùúVÿ’kzV ‰ C1 þ~¬Ð�áïƒXóó)m8( ]µßç7ÒoÞ¿†Ún6 D aÜ‘Ën†(¡Úä]Îf^Ù

Åw�zegc0õ‚]S~¿FZØVÅìXÐÔ‰p}ÆMy~{àÇ%æFNň�1Zy~Ð9»m�ª]Ð7ìX

»[³gz~ätù·(~œZzg)Ð%AHìXìÒÀòtì�g‚bzÃÐp}Ü™Æc@Z™ÔZyÅFKÎðZzgZk6Zq�âpN7™p}»AÆjZá™�bXLLDz+óóåìX³gz~™räZkÆ'@Óx’kzVÃ7JÔZzg=ôÔQñgÅ¥ôÆaÔf~jZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]»ZÈxHXjZÙ~Z,V䉺ÔgzZc]6×zb™DƒñÇßg‹qw7ÅìX

� C2 -V�lz[Æ‚BÔZkù´ÅDz+~ÔïzW»KÌ»g�Ûâg;ìX2916Z,VäYmi%iZ»tZ½kÜHì:

�á²ÔCÙz‰Ü�á²7ƒ@Z%¬Ýìw~Zk»¦gCÙz‰ÜgLìZzgZkzzÐZkЉZz‡]Ðz¾dwQui�ƒC�XeZËZDw%jxÆ0ZqzZ§tì�z{ZqgZ]ZϬÝ~!CÙÐ=pÑñZzggZ5~Î!Mñ�YD„;BÅ

Ƹ5ä ¡Úä]Îf^Ù]µßç7ÒoÞ¿†Ún6 Zzg ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜ‘Ën† !]ì� Zµ t 1DZk§bÆËLLZßwóóÅ0È~Ã�gp§Z²7�X

Ôm51 ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜÞ�nà g<Z−+;×:�âp 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^004

Page 396: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

r~ZqÃä~gÅVÇXp�eg0ð64YîVÇXaèM\ZLìw~"¸ZzgtÌìwå�YD„r~ZqÃä~gÄ™p�eg0ð64YîVÇ1�4M\

#}~�Z4ƒñÔr~ÃÂeg0ð6�gZi™�cZzgp�Ãä~9}ƒ‰XZã~eZË%jxÃÌZK$jZÏ»ìwMc¹Ñq{ƒñXóó

è �V»ÂV�áï Àì�³gz~™räZDwÐ�[Zk"ã�]ÃF�h7ÅXZÍwÂtzZ§}ËÂ[cg‚á~èÃg7X Â[™1ZzgZkÅ

�zu}:i!ã¯òZk»)ß„�(Z[Z¥|-ãzg;ÆeZËuMYZ−+ŧsHY@ìXZDwÅi0ÏÆË�zg~ÃðZ+gzZe7Q�)ÔZ,LLÉ·óógZ]Ãr~á™!CÙtÆaäƒVXzZãîg6Z("ã�zZ§ÔÂ[~�áï™*„ßåzg:ÁZiÁZkÅF�h¢zg™ãec¶X

PZq©à�Ûz*ZÇZzgÌ�Ô}m9126Z½k¾»ì?Z½kÆ‚B*x7�cŠXz„Ðè¸ì:=ZögÝ»Xm442):�142(»Z½kLLF�gcóó»ìÔ1z„~tÐLL�!�˜i~óó»*xÉ�cìXm1716åezgkZ£

ÅZkgzZeÅF�hÅ¢zg]¶�zËZDwÅ‘�·ŒŒÛÙÔ©gM!�ÿ�Áþ‰ƒñ¸Xm6626åezgkZ£Ã¸³äeZË@|ÅZqð5Z�‚àCcìÔ��g„7Ôz){X

%AäMy~Z�ÔZâÁÔZ¶gZ]Ôg‚bÔÃÔZ�ZgzVÔñç¬]Zzgàâ‹ZDwÆZ�ágb�áï™Æù´ÐZ.�{™äzZßVÆaœªaZ™�~ìX

ZDw è WÖ /

�áùƒZÔT~ZDw Úr^Ö‹ô]Îf^Ù 2002Y~6zWQ�a»%û�ªCù·eÅZqZzgš~ìÔ �ªC Ð5‡ÂVÅc��Z¤V6�12p}¦K‰�Xt

~–w%A:LL9z{p}%AK‰�Ô�ZkЬM�ª]ÅË TA ~%A7ƒñXóóZ%LL�zp}Z,Ì�Ô�ZkЬÂ!ßg]~% Â[

ƒ`Ôpz;VZy»Q*åc*�g„ÖìXóó)m8(ZëF!]Âtì� Â

104�ª]Æù´

Page 397: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

p}ÅLL¡z�óó6{mÂz�~ìX�zx:â~»jZ!�cìX è äQ Íw:ñ³ Zp}6¥â]Z‚ÛZjZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]’kK�XXgx:*yógzVÆÎZ¤ è Îx:Q{ÆZzg¬gsÌ�áïÂ[™�b�XZypçVäù´ÃxZzgRw�~

ìZzgtZ%³ÅDz´Dq~6�ZwìÔ@ëZyÐZq¸g~auƒXZ,VäczsZDwÙk�iŒ)x:4791Y(»*yF¹IÕ�6zW�i@)x:

1C 4991(Ð�[™�cÔqÑè�Z½Þ�'Cg„��t�i@»*y7ìX*yógCD��$4è MGä´)ÃЬ5291Y~Zsð»Òуg~ }

�¬Zz{LLZsxZzgZ¿�óó6¼�¶ÆaWñZzg¼²á$4è MGäZL�z„*i·{VÆ‚BZyÆ.egzezZáky6QyÐ5‡]ÅXtz{iâ:åZ�i

@I¸i~7g-8~$™,ç E‚]‚wik½¸ZzgZ´)]ƒñÂz{Z[W!�»Ò~$™,ç E02‚wik½ÔZka*yógDîg6t�iŒ�Ô:��i@X

ðýýðýýð

5991Y( ~�áïìX)Z�Zg{c�ÇgÔ™Zc ÚÏ^ŸlôÚÛj^‡ t*y�áyZ/SÆ%ûù´ 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^204

Page 398: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âè ª]ÅDz+ � (`)*¸,]~�ª]ÆZùúV»Y{1ŠìXZyùúVÆ´z{

ZZZzÃ~¼�Z,p}Zzgr8/õEñ���q�lzZ~™Æ%AM\áV~M\mógzVÅZDwÐ Qg�z ™äÅ¢zg]ìX�,œ~ÅP

C1 5‡ÂV»f™MìXZy5‡ZVäZDwƹÐ�ª]ÌÜK�X�ª‹ZDwÆñ��z�ø[fí}Ãic�{xZzgRw�¶ÆaÔZk

~ Å5FKzDz+Zi'¢zg~ìX�ª]»¼zZg‚bzZZZzgºtùúVxìXQZq„gZz~ÅZgzZc]Zzg’k,�7IX'×h'WVgzZc]z�ª]~}}§�zÚÌMìX‰Zz‡]Zq„gzZeógä�zZgzZc]ÒyÅ�X}ZqgzZeógÔ�zu}gZz~ÅF�h™@ÃW@ì'VwÆîg6:

)LLÑñ]Æ�gzZi}6óó(~Ccì 2C )1(ÝxgÎw$äZLZq*y�ZDwÅzÃ]Å‘xV·ÃYzh2w~ñ��ÔgZYŒZºäÌ‘»

ZDwÅi!y6Yg~¶Ô1 3C 9zz�¦ZgZZzgzÃ]ÐÛ�IZqÃgÏg!¦ìX$™räZyÒ*]Ã)�p�Qy 4C eZˆZéxoäZyÐV!ÂVÅF�hÅ

Zg�cìX ŒÛ 5C ÅZK’kÅF�h™D�(LLRóó]ö…�æ�¸enjnç7Ún6 ,Æa�&À�/õ GG:·Zg”a�O~»Z*…ZD1]»ó£! 1D

Ô0002Ô´)ZDwZz6-ãzg;ÔZsxM!� ƒÒ†]Îf^Ùÿ‹]þ:m95@57 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

uz›gC!iWh�*h'Ô@ZÕX 3DÀì�eZˆZéx»tLLZÏsóó33 è :m171Ô271)@ëtZ%! ]Îf^Ù�…æáì^Þä D4

'ÎV)8391YD1791Y(JYVcZpZ~g;?(ÿZÍwþT1791Yþ:m61 ]Îf^Ù�…æáôì^Þä D5

304�ª]Æù´

Page 399: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)2(÷†Z+m°æ N�ÅgzZeÆ_.ZDwäCc�LL÷Z¸ð7Å541¹ÿ GHGZÐZq¯[~Q,Vä�«·ÃLLƒezn9WW 1 C1 jz[Æ�í~°uåóóÔ

CcìXtZ%sPZVZë:�Ô1ZkÐZgzZc]ÃïÅgzÝ 2C T~zg¾óó~�ÚZzgQyÅYy�Å¢zg]ªCÙƒCìX

)3(±Z®s@Æ_.ZDwä¹�Qg�z~Ìúi7|àYñÂÃðC3 w`7Ô1ZDwÅZK„Zq’kÐZkÅF�hƒCìX

ZqÐi·{VÆ_.ZDwäZ¹Ccå�6zWWg&Óå EHÅÃ@VÐZ¹!gCåEL )4(7ÔYè ZkgzZeÆܽzZ§ƒä~Ãðd->î IEX 4C ŒÛ\~úi7"ÅZYi]B¶X

Wg&Óå EHÔZDwÆ^ï6)†g~3391Y(Ь„)0391Y~(¯]ƒ`¸XzZc] ÿZÍwþÆzZu]z�ª]ÔZDwƉŒÛRZ•çEO{Åg ]Îf^Ù�…æáì^Þä )5(

Åã�6%AK‰�ÔXÆ!g}~ÝxgÎw$ä�ì�ZyLLÐic�{RZDwÆ'Z�giZ�}�ZÚiZ£ä)�p�¼��ª] 1 C5 ÒyZzgË»7ƒYóóX

ÆqgY]ÅF�hÅìÔ��: ]Îf^Ù�…æáôì^Þä ÆgZz~�(.eñÆ‚BÔSome of the statements of the book are factually incorrect, some are half truths and

some are Arabian Night Tales. If my uncle could somehow know of its contents in

his heavenly abode, he would cry out: "Save me from my friends.6C

ÃÔfíÒ�ª]»óZzgW~õ²*î è Zk§bƧ�Z]zÚ,]Æ7¢zg~ìX

fíÒ�ª]¦™ÆZqZqS»Y{1YñZzggzZc]z�ª]»�zCÙZ±gÐRZzgxƒZzgCÙ§bÆ�Z½zzZuC§�Ð0uƒÔQÐZµ™1YñÔ

QZÐZiuâ%AzæÍyHYñX

ÔZDw�ÔZÍw3791Y:m522 ‘vnËä 1DÔZÍw:m6 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 2D

»Y{ Ú×Ëç¾^l �&À�/õ GG:Zk![6Å�zu~)[(Æ� 3D:m333 ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä 4D

m61 Ô 1791Y ÔT ÿZÍwþ ]Îf^Ù�…æáôì^Þä 5DÔ†g~4791Y:m66 ]Îf^Ù C D6

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^404

Page 400: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ñµ è â~ÔZÍw:gzZeógzV»¿¬gsÔ�zx:â~Z]»jZ!ÔÎx:ø è Dz+¿jZÙz$›Ò3¨é G

GG]�áïKYNXqd/õ IG~»©jZßV»ZÈx̃nÂZkÐXi{ù”î0�ª]ÅŠgz7Zzg(|YñÏX�yfÆ;V

+B©3þGG

GL�ª]ÅLdgzZeñ��ìÔTÅæ�Ð�ª‹ZDwÅóDz+ic�{Â7X

�ª‹ZDwÆP™{!Ñ,·fí}Æ´z{Ô|‹´)ÆZg�á�Z]z�Ûñ�Z]»ZqzZ(ÌìÔ�r3û EEL’k~:WeXÒ¤CÙZ−+äZDwÃ.eŒÛd

Ð�¬Ô1QyÐÃðgzZec�ª]®w7X‰Zô[Ô��ª‹ZDwáƂBÈ™Æôp™äÅ&¢gnÔZk§s{§pZ{Âz:�}nÔZkÅúcVVwÝxgÎw$ÅìXZDwÅzÃ]ƈQ,Vä�å:

Z¤§‹»g!¹ìÔÂtZq¹(Z�Ûnì��¼ZKWçÐ'ÎV�¬ZzgZL»âVÐ'ÎV‹ÔQÐ�*JàcYñX%jxÆéÈ›ÅWl~T�wz�ârää!K'ko]qZ:6zgl0ðÔZkÆzZ�]¤ZV·�ZzgZyzZ�]

C1 ÅOWzg~~™IÃgZ{7ï$ËXºt�Ûâ›p}ÆÎZ$ ‰ 1t³xzZgZ�{z‰ÜÆ‚B‚Bâ07@ŠZzg

ÆÄZy ]Îf^Ön^l ™r¼:ÉnXZyÅzÃ]ÆÔZyÆdZëÐE~äkù´ ZX Ð$™rÅ]�ø[ZD1C’k,¦™Æ�áù™Zð�)8891Y(

P�ªCp}Ì�áï�X ~Q�ª]»Zqzz{ì�ZDwÅÄÐoƒäzZá‰Zô[ä

e C2 ZLgzi*òV~È™1XpZz†Zß©Ægzi*ô»Zqz�áùƒ[ìÔì´)ZDwÐ0ÔZk~'×hZ0gZY]Ìñ��ƒVXÝxgÎw$ÌZqiâä~ZKc��ZÇÈ™DgìÔ��:

gZ]Ã~Zzga�O~·@Zq�z]¢zgqwçEL}#ÖƒDÔ‰Zz‡]|]%jxÔZjÃ�™šf'~y(Â'¢zg~!'â^™©'WÅc��Z¤V

ÿ‹]þ:m95Ô06 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1DÔZDw�2:m083@124 ÞÏç� 2D

504�ª]Æù´

Page 401: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

C1 ~‰Zë)b»f™HìX÷ZZgZ�{ìt)b£Ñ]Å~%A™�zVXñÑ*$ÅP™{!Ñc��ZÇZzgZyÆgzi*ôÆZ0gZY]~i6�ÒØ~

�'Zϧb»Zqgzi*/a�O~·@Ì�gìÔTÆ!g}~eZËYzhZDw»Òyì:

62D5291Y~a�O~™rä´)Æ‚BZK5‡ÂVÅc��Z“Ì�ÑzqÅC2 ¶XZkc��Z“~�´ÔdZzgZ�!!ÂVÆ´z{‰!'{à�w8iï FF�X

ZkƈeZËYzhZDwäZkc��Z“ÐZqzZ§ÜHìXa�O~·oƒDz+ÆÔZygzi*òVà C3 @»tgzi*/Ì@qwwá�67WeX

�áù™äÅZÌZ•Òy7X|‹´)ÆZg�á�Z]z�Ûñ�Z]»tfí{xqª~ìXÀò_¬Ð

sÃÔZkfí}ÐdZ.�{ZÏz‰ÜeìÔZZk»ZqYìñç¬CZ�ágtÌ»gHYñXZkÆ%t¥x™*{™Âì�Ë{mñçqÆ!g}

~|‹´)ä¹V¹VZÖ§ìwHìZzg˺mZ%Ð0QyÅÃðgZ}ñ��Ììc7X

�ª‹ZDwÅFKzDz+ÔYy�Æ%7ƒãecX6�ëäT�zxÆ�âd~²nHåÔ�ª]6ïÅZqÃÒ¤@ZÑsäÅÔ1‹tzï~z{ñçqþ8ªîGOZK¤Ä~7ánX°Z"ÂtZqZd�gZ)}:8ZÝe~(Æó£á»ñçqìX

ðýýðýýð

:m743Ô843XZyÆgzi*ôÆPZ0gZY]ZyÆ"!!Ñù”î0 ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä D1~�áï�X ]Îf^Ön^l p}

:m991 Ú1ÿŸÖäÊ^Ý D2a�O~™rÆ7DU�%äèÃg{gzi*ôƉ{ZLZ*Z}Qg�zÆó D3

~�áïK�X ¡Úä]Îf^Ù]æ…2ç�â†pÚvÛ‚uŠnàE…æ]e¼D £á

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^604

Page 402: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:7 ![

�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

�ý�ý�ý�

704�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 403: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

!›ÐêO è ZDw¨ ( Z³ )Z*Z},»ZJy0k™äÆÖˆZDwZzg@»Òуg~.e²æ

gigHgƒñÔÂ�zu}�ÛZøÆ´z{ÔZÚzfZzg!ZzZsÅ)oVÅDgöÌZ¹Î{�XZk§bZyÅii0Ï»W¸i�gZqyƒZX½ã0õ'kJZzg@

»ÒZzgÍg»Òуg~Dg+�ÛZøZ�x�ïgìX-g\ÐzZ36Z¹'×h¼²áÆaÍg»Òуg~�»�gk�b7ZÔ15i#ÖÅ0ÈcVQyÅZë›

5i#Öîîg6Fu™�~X à 1C TÆÜs�ÔOçJ†g~1191Y�gkzDgöÐZDw»!Ÿ‚m»ƒ�Ô1½zpÐQy»!ßZôgZ‚'ŒÛZg

g;Xz{º[-ãzg;ÆZZ�ZgzVÆgÁgìZzg¢uÔZÚzfÔ!Z}ÔZ*Z}6pZzgðgìX«!g è ),ÔÃgÏÔ@gõ(ZsZs!ZzgÎwuzkZJ*]Æ%A

Q,Vä0091Y~�Î,)®ÆaÃgÏ»6p%AHåXt�zÃ]JYg~g;Xº[-ãzg;Æ´z{Ô‰�zu~Yç])Z[W!�ÔZ¥|z){(ÆZ 2C

ZJâV~ðÆ�ÛZøÌZ�x�bX´z{Zi,8191Y~Zsð»ÒуgÆC3 6zWJÅZe7zÃ]6ÔZDwä�zâ{JZ*Z},Ƥ9VÃ�gk�cX

Z ½zpZzg�gkzDgöÐZDwÅZkzZÕ»ZqUtÌì�Q,Vä]ö…�æ Æa 4C )oVÆaQg�zZzgÃgÏż�ÂÁ%AXÔçwÅegzV)oV

:m511 A History of Government College, Lahore 1DZDw�ZÍwÔm7791YÔ ÞÏç� ,Æa�&À�/õ GG:·ð�á@»*yLLZDwðóó 2D

m454D774Ô�zx:m37 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 3D

Zkiâä~ZÍw@Xgx)È6ZÎ~�gZ~ZzgQ@Û)Èçw�gZ~Ñg 4DƒC�X

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^804

Page 404: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)egÂÁ(œZ£¼q ]ö…�æÒç…Œ X �ñnßäÿÂrÜ Zzg¢uÆaÃgÏÂ[ Òç…Œy ZDwäp�„%AÅXtZDwÅ£?7ÔZ �ñnßäÿÂrÜ ÆZ·ZuÐ%AÅIXìX Å@c]�ÔOçikÃY{å™äÆaP™{!Ñ�gÏÂ1V6ZqÃeZÜ*¦k

�Ô‚Â,ZzgW^,)oVÆaQg�zÃgkÅ&ÂÁ4291Y~%AÅIXº[À,wÅLLQg�zƒwóóÆZ°k21B†g~5291Y~ZyZÖp~

ZyÂ1VÅàg~�~�:Urdu course for VI, VII and VIII classes by Dr. Sir Mohammad Iqbal M.A.

Ph.D., K.T., and Hakim Ahmad Shuja. (Gulab Chand Kapur and Sons,

Lahore) Reported upon by M. Mohammad Said, M.A., Lala Tej Ram, M.A.

and the Delhi Branch Sub-Committee.

The Sub-Committee decided to recommend the adoption of these books for

use in schools, provided that the price of the books are fixed at the rates which

the Text-Book Committee books are sold.1C

ZkÐZ0Zi{ƒ@ì�àg~ЬÂÁ)4291Y~(T™à��XaètÂÁ»[~�áï�ÔZka!g!g�áùÅIX!kxZqDÙZgÅ®Z�~Y8

2C YC�XÐVÂ1VÆuzgt6LLMZ�ÔóóÆZÖp�g`�XZyƒ~�âd»QZqìT~LLMZ�ÔóóÅZyÂ1VʼnZqÐi~S:]ŧs‡gMÃázH�ìXt�âpLL¸5óóŧsÐìX@ëtZ0Zi{Î*Â7��âp

åîg6cZk»ic�{FzZDw»’k™�{ìXZkŤ&ZDwÆZq*yЃCìÔ�Q,VäZK!›Ð)é:i0ÏÆZ’ZðZcx)1091Y( 3C LL”VŽzF�óó

~�åXZk*y~z{��:s79�/õ FGÂÓxò²z`ÅaÔ”VŽìXZ¤§$þGL½dQßßV6FƒÂðh}

a á~ÓxÕãDc]»¯gƒYN'Zy»ƒÐª�Ûntì��*Æ „²

XIqbal in Pictures @gz�Z�À,w˜!: 1D)m12D42(~®wìX ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù �âd»Q 2D

m1D9(X ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù †g~2091YÔ)˜!: Úíˆá 3D

904�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 405: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zk»z��i“»!ƒ'ZkÆCÙ÷~ZqnÅgz݃ÔTÅ™3ZzgzV67ÆÔZyÃ�c-�Zg~Zzg*»g~Æ‚Bi0Ϭ™ä»$�,XZkÅg�~»�Z]{�y$yzWƒ*ecÔ@�ZkÆ»~z{zÝaZƒÔ�gzbÆWNÐ

t]ZzgÂø]Æi8Ã�zg™ÆQÐNzœ™�îì'ÇZ+tì�ZyÃZL�ÛZøÐ7g~7g~WÇ„ƒ'»ïZy�Æa¢zg~ì�CÙZãaÅF�~t¾nÅpg¿Yz}ÔYèt¾wZܹ½zF�„Åz‚¦

Ðq݃YìÔ�ßv”VŽzF�Æ9ZzgdQßwÃ$åLOÃ7gnÔz{ZK*�ZãÐ΂ÌÆ£t6ZqªÓ:�„�gZi~™D�ÔT»³Z�ÛZ›Î‚Ì

ÆaZ•�gZ»µƒ@ì'Z*�Ãec�QÐÿaÃþg�~Æ0�{�{¹*V‹ñZzgc�™Zñ'!›Ð.ðV»�Ûnì�Z’ZЄa~Zܹ’rVÐ

C1 OWƒäŇ/aZ™äÅÃÒ™,Ô}Ñzq„ÐZyÃ^g�~™*2NXMZ�ÔÆ�âd~¹�ì�:

p}ic�{FZ,„ÉK��ÔX~i0Ï»gz×UHƒ@�¤DZk§]~ic�{Z4wÔic�{p��Zg~Zzg�c-�Zg~Ðz è Æ_¬Æˆ¤¿

áÃX|~Z�Ò]Ž»¸Ñƒ*ec�Z�!fztÅF�Æ‚B‚B¥ÅzWZ�~ZzgQyÆ�wz�ârÅYö›zú0ñ'ZkeÅÂ1V'ÿ~þZܹp}ÆZN[~ZkZ%ÃÅpg3�ì�Zy»Q|ƒÒyZ(ƒÔ�¤ÅïELDÃ$zgZzg)�w¯äÅO}(Zzg·�g¯ñZzgZkZ%»ÒpÂ!<mg3�

õZzgDzZ�[Å � ì�ÎÄz�6zƒ43ïEGG»g8¸ƒÔ@�¥Æ�ßV~ZܾC2 ^Æ�zgZy~ZLzíÅ�»0u_/ñbyƒX

ZyZ½‚]Æ_¬ÐzZãì�´)ZDwÆ4�qÎÄz�Z+ƒãecÔTÐ¥6ZܹZWZ]%AƒVZzgp}Ô¹EVZzgVÃ7|™QyÆ

ÃÔ^g�~Ôp��Zg~ÔnÔ·�g~Ô�c-�Zg~ÔZˆµ�ÛnZzgQyzgzÝ è �ßV~zÝÃgÄ™ÉÅ��XWÒ{ è Æ_!]aZƒVXÐVÂ1VÅóg�á]ZÏÑÃ7

,]~ZyÂ1V»¿Y{7HYg;ìX:m1Ô2Ô6Ô8 ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^Ù 1D

:m�Ô{X ]ö…�æÒç…Œ(2ã9oqÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 �âp 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^014

Page 406: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�gÏÂÁ ([)

g�zÃgkÔ�)®Æa Q /Ã9291Y»ZecìXuzgt è ªZec4291Y~�áùƒZXZkz‰Üøg}7

ZzgZkÅ1»�Ñg7H�Xz„p}Æ�z,]LLZ³Ô[óóZzg�âdÆeg,]:LL`Ô�Ô{ÔzóóÐÑgK��XQÂ[Ð,]»ÑgZiaçLâƒ@ìXWy

~)m222D052(Zq�Û}Ì�áïìXW¸iLL�¬óóÆÄZyÐZq£Ðƒ@ìXZkƈ�»Zq$ÔZqÄÔZq

¹ãZzgQZqÄ'7g~Â[~ŒÛdŒÛd¸ßg]'ŒÛZgìXªCÙ�~$ƈZqÄÔZk§bÂ[22VZzg42�0gzV6�ìX�0gzV~{™àqìÔ}:LL�*ÅW!�~óóZzgLLi}Åu*“óó»m'Z¢/õ EGÐZzgLL\§ZWóó

è ZzgLL!'»�óó»m@gõÐìXLL�Z-Zzg!wóóZzgLLÔÃZzgeñóó»ñçq¡¬)ìXi�n.ç IH»ª$ÔgZYCÙ÷PgÔ¾�Û±jè

YEÔgZYâc�ZkÔ(�wPZ�{Zzgå

Ë.ç LGM¹*V�XLL)~ZzgªVóóZzgLL%rZ§Zzgr5éGO�óóàx¹*V�X�cÄÔCÙ’k~Ãð:ÃðZ&kÑ©VìX�âd~LLZܾõóóÅ!]Å�ìÔ¥xƒ@ì¸5äZyp}zàâ]ÆZN[~ZkZ%»{mìwg3ì�¤DÆf‚6CÙ$ƵZܹZWZ]%¿ƒVX}}'ZÓgZ„ÌGz»�K�

�Ô1À�Ä~XCÙ$ÆbÎZÑ]~ZqW�|Z(ÎZw�áïìÔTФDÆZ0gZܹZˆkËZgƒXÂ[~¼�£zkÌ�áï�X

Ë*yÆ‚B*yógcÄÆ‚B�á²»*x7��Ôic�{F>Ô)@ëczsÄZÅPàâ]Ì�áï�Ô}:ZDwÅ Ô czsÄZÅ¥xƒC�

114�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 407: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

è LLNóó)ÜsegZÃg(qàÅLL6�öóóZzg�uPøzxÅLL»xóó'‰V)ui}yDyz*ã”V»�z){(»£gZY7ìXZkÂ[ÅÂ"zS®¹ZhìXgñ¯Zz‡sZzgZ²Z[»ZÈxÔW`ÀÅ»!Â1VÐ4ìXi!yzÒy

ÆZ±gÐñ��{�)®Æ¥ÃÔeìÔtÂ[ÂCkƒXuzgt6t„g]�g`ì:LLug_0î IG0½º[zßO]�{zZq©ægZkŧs

Ðàg”{óóXTci�ë)5491Y(Å„g]ËŠgZì:LLug;ñ½º[Ô�‹zæZgkŧsÐàg”{À,óóXg�zÃgkÔ‚Â,)®Æa Q /

]ö…�æÒç…Œ MZ�Ô»t�zuZzªCÙ~FKZzgÑ]ÅâÎÆZ±gÐÔz„p}Zzg�âp)8,](Æ�ZqÐ 1C 'Z}¼Æ_.ìXuzgt

Â[»W¸iƒ@ìXWy~Zq×�Û})m252D613(Ì�áïìX èQZòtÅÀ®Z�63ìÔX~Ûàâ]�Xø‚.Zy~àqìX�)®ÅÂ[~WZzgÄZÆ*x7�g`K�ÔZkÂ[~CÙ*yZzgÄÆ‚B'Zzg�á²»*x�»ZÈxH�ìXMZ�ÔÆ�âd~¸5��:

MZ�ÔÅFK~ZkZ%»{mîg6Òpg3�ì�6ZäZ‚EÒ®Æ}+÷JEL�

Æ‚B‚BiâUqwÆQyZ¶6�ZizVZzg�á²zVÆp}Äz�̤DÅÃЦg,Ô2VäQg�zÃZqZ+i!y¯äÆaZyëÃlÅ�Ô�ñ��{

C2X ¢zgc]Æ_.ZzgZ�Z}_6‡�gƒOçg@*Bu�ágÔ!ŒÛZ�Z*yÍÔ·@WiZ�Ôe÷2kZ£�Š~ÔpZzŒÂòÔ

�l u†ZØ�gÔ"n�á{Ô÷Z/ÔZºZ[W!�~Ô�uPøzxÔ6*PÔñÑ*;Z{VԯƂBÔ×ÁZzg)czs è ËgZ»'ZI 'W!�~ÔÎg3Zí$Zzgp�)ZDw�*x

Ô!W.Þm22 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù uzgtÆa5±Ù: è@ 1D:mLL`Ô�óóX ]ö…�æÒç…Œ‰^içm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 2D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^214

Page 408: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�V�±Z£¬ÔÔ±>Zg@ÔÔ´43ðEGg~Ô·¢y=wÔZÑs@Ô±gZs@ÔZÚi@ZzgZ=��Š~Å’k,Ì�áï�X´)ZDwÅÄLL÷ZzíóóÔ

~�áïLLyz*ã”V»¸ò�óóÅZ’Zðßg]ìXˆ~‰úV �…] è e^Þ-C1 ~FçÅ�ZzgWy~Èvs™�c�ìX

àâ]zp}~z„àqìÔT»f™�)®ÅÂ[ÆK~ƒ[ìXZk{Å’kzV~̸5»z„$©�î EG0ûg�ÛâÃW@ìÔT»ZÖg�âd~H�ìÔªt�Î’k,¥ÅZܹ½zF�~@zçzyƒÃX

g�zÃgkÔW^,)®Æa Q /MZ�ÔÅZk�~Â[~À23óg�á]�áï�Xàâ]Zzg�0gzVÅ

®Z�'Z'ìXZq*yLLi}Å�ÛÎ�ϪLLeJóó¬Zec)4291Y(~�áï:åÔ]ö…�æ zgz„»Z0Zi Z 2C ˆ~ZmZ�H�XZk§bB#Ö663,]ƒ�ìXuzgt

Æ_.ìX�âpÌ7VìÔZ%m26Â[ Òç…Œ(‰^içm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1~�áï‚]£zkÅz„Ì�~�ìXuzgt6t„g]�g`ì:LLug½º[zßO]�{ŧsÐàg”{À,óóX

]ö…�æÒç…Œ( Zk{Æ*yógzVZzgÄZ~9z„»g�áï�ÔX»f™ÆK~W[ìÔZ%u±Z£{VÔ7»4iï FEGÔpÙ·*øÔ± ‰^içm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1

Z£�Š~ÔnZºW!�~Zzg=�©gugxÅóg�á]ÌZk{~�áïÅ��X)czsZ�!zÄZÅ’k,×Á�XœZ£¼q»egZâLLuZrg‚VóóZzgZDwÅ�z

>LL*g{óóZzgLL)§gZz~óóÌ�áï�XLLe0Zzg*g}óóZôm~ÐFÀìÔ1áW»*x�g`7XQ|ƒ*yů6ªkì�tFÀœZ£¼q»ìXZqZzg

*yLL�csðóóÆ'»*xÌ�g`7ìX¸5ŧsÐ�b�¿jZÙÔp}~èÃg‰Z�z)bÅzŸs™D�X

)m421(~ñ��ìX ‰†æ�ô…Êjä ÷zsÈ 1D:!W.Þm32 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù @uzgtÆa5±ÙÔ 2D

314�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 409: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]»45ëGEY

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^414

Page 410: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

g�zÃgkÔ0v,)®Æa Q /~ñ��ìÔ ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù Zzg 1C MZ�ÔÅP™{!Ñ&Â1V»f™‰ÂÒ]

»f™ZDwÆËE™}ÔÎZö/~c ]ö…�æÒç…Œ(µ^Þ3çm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 pÂÒ]~7MX

!-B{}4èGE

GELZDwZkÂ[Åñ��ÏÐÑDgì�XZkZ±gÐt(tf™ƒ[ì�º[ Â[«!g”gs™ZðYg„ì)uzgt»@!W.ÞÔ6ì

À,wä†g~5291Y~MZ�ÔÅ&Â1V)'Z}¼ÔÞZzgÛ(Å�X %AH ~ 2C 8291Y Ôeg'kˆ ]ö…�æÒç…Œ àg~�~¶X0v,)®Æa

§Zi�: � tÂ[Ì´)ZDwZzgœZ£¼qÅœ�@;ìX¸5Ô�âd~g¶ZkЬ�Ô‚Â,ZzgW^,)®ÆaQg�zÃgk»gK�ÔXú[Ô

ßO]�{ZzgægZkÅÀ,�Väàg�ÛâcZzgæZgkÆ!›Ð)4èGEZzg¥äçIhÏ�¬XZkz‰ÜtÃgk¬xîg6y*ãæZgk~7JñYD�X}Z»]ì�tÃgkXQßßVÆâ�%AK�Ô‡&ÿELj,Z‚ÛZðU"ƒñXZ[

C3 @�*ø+ìX ]ö…�æÒç…Œ 0v,)®»ÍcMZ�ÔÅ&Â1VÅ=qÆÔ¸5ÃikÃÂ[ÅFKz@;

Ãè »ìwWcÔOçZNƒp}zàâ]ZzgFK~¸5äz„Z0ZizW}7g3ìÔ�‚—&Â1V~»g�ÛâåX�~p}Zzg¹*V׿�XÂ[~03

�0gzVÆ£«~32àâ]�áï�XW¸iÔ£)>ZyLL}ZÅŠg]óó(Ѓ@÷_Ô ìX�zZßV~‰*xËgZIe÷2kZ£Ô±Z£�Š~Ôu±Z£{VÔZ©

XA Bibliography of Iqbal )Z³( 1DÒj^en^lô]Îf^Ù )`( Òjg]Îf^Ön^l )[(

t$›4èG

GOE�á�ZVìZòÅZk@g+÷ GEL’k)9�y8291Y(Ѓ@ìÔ��~Tg>ZyLL*Zglóó 2D:m4(X ]ö…�æÒç…Œ(µ^Þ3çm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 ÿ˜Zþ6�g`ì)

:m2 ]ö…�æÒç…Œ(µ^Þ3çm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 3D

514�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 411: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

âZ[íZ<ÔqàÔg@*Bu�ágÔu†ZØ�gÔ·@WiZ�ÔnZºW!�~ÔŒÂòÔ6*PÔZºZ[W!�~Æ‚B‚B×6ZzgÁczsWÔ}:�uPøzxÔZW™-~ÔqæŒ÷_Ôq¬Ý²ÔZf÷_Zzg_œZgz~z){Ì�áï�X�z�0g}LLZ0SÔ¾~ZzgÍ�úg]óóZzgLL·g*y»WÂóóœZ£¼qÆ�X´)ZDwÅ

ÃðÄ�áï7XZq¹ãLLzÃ�ZgÝxóó6'»*x�g`7ìX$4èGELÂ[m9326‚.Wy~Zq×�Û})m042D172(�áïìX è »ƒ@ìXø

ZkÂ[»�âpMZ�ÔÅ&Â1VÐZìX¸5��:Zk~Zk!]»{mîg6ìwg3�ì�DzZ�[Æp}Zk§b¦KYN

�¥Ã5¥â]q݃äÆ‚B‚BÔQg�zi!yÐ�wÕaZƒZzgz{Z,Z0Z¯’kÐzZ�ƒYNÔ�ZÖ§_6qz~ƒXp}ÆZN[~iâUq¢{ÅÓx¢zgc]»ìwg3�ìZzgÃÒÅ�ì�p}Z,�w¿Zzg%æFNZWƒV�”VÅËZyŧsp�l�gZáƒXtp}”VÆ�w~â�§zíÅ�ÔZܹR]ZzgZ�!fztaZ™äÆaZI�XQyì�!›Ð)4èGEZyÃ7JDz‰ÜQyÓx_!‹¬DÃ¥Æ�wz�âr6î™äÅÃÒ™,ÐÔ�Zyp}ÅM

C1 ~ñby�XÃÔz„£œgì�Ô� è ÍcÔZkÂ[ÅFKz@;~ÌÔ¸5Æ7

«!g&Â1VÆZòtÉ™Dz‰ÜZyÆf‚~»g�ÛâÔªt�ZÍw:LLiâUÆ3C ŠÔ�zx:p}LLZ�!pÒVgpÆ!z��5¥â]óó Å 2C qwÆ_]]óó

qïƒVZzgÎx:Â[7|™LL¥Æ�ßV~ZܾõóóZzgDzZ�[ÅÆ‚BC4 ‚BZLzí»0u_/ñbyƒX

Z½këä*ZzgZt~ÜHåÔ ZDwÆ*yLL”VŽzF�óó»Zq

:m2Ô3 ]ö…�æÒç…Œ(µ^Þ3çm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 1D]ö…�æÒç…Œ(2ã9o(‰^içm6]æ…�:ãçm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 �âp: 2D

Zs 3DZs 1D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^614

Page 412: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

QkÅgzÝ~Ôikc�zâV�âaVÅ„g]Zzg|x6¨gHYñÔÂSy~ZqzZãs~Z·ZuúcVìXZk¯6gZ¶»ìwì�MZ�ÔÅZka¶Â[»�âpÌZDw„»’k™�{ìX

MZ�ÔÅZkÂ[»ZqúcVZÐZ�~Utì�¸5ÅpZé6Zzg@»ÒуgÆ6zW±ZzÑ�@�á�ZVìZòäZk»[Åi!y6¨¡z

Xñßs��: Å 1C ÃUãFç Zg�á�ÆaÔ˜V}=ZLìÑ]ÆñZ¬¥xƒZÔ~äšZqÐi èz

‰ ™�~Ôcâ^É�cX~ZkÂ[ÆCÙ*yƸ³Ã‡&ÿEL��&ƒVXC2 WŇ/!hÐêOy*yìX‚B„ZkÆÔ~cÃðæ}Æ~Ð{à7X

tÂ[ÌÔMZ�ÔÅ�zu~Â1Vŧb¼�!g�áùƒCg„X

cY M /´)ZDwä0091Y~«!gº[-ãzg;ÆZÚ÷ZJyÆaÃgÏ»6p

%AHXt�F‚wJYg~g;XQZ¹ZÚÔ!Z}ÃgÏZzgZ*Z}ÃgÏÆ6dÃgÏÆZZJ*]ÐM0g� C3 %A™äÅf)�Zg~ÌÎ{YäÐX

Æ:ÔZDwÆf‚~ZÚ÷ÆaZq]hÃgÏÃgk%A™ä»ìwaZƒZX«!gZk»ZÖg03B†g~2291YÆâ¯x·Zº¡~MìX[ZDZy�âVZkZy~}¸XZDwäZ¹�:

²áÐ÷ZZgZ�{ZqZÚ÷ÃgkÃgÏFK�¶»ìX]hÃgÏÄz�Ƽ�{Zzgï W‚y%äïYNÂ�VÆ¥Æa.eƃÇXZ¤W\ÃPZ+ÃÄz�~ YNÔÂ÷}ayh™³X>�gZ‚EÒqwŃVZzg(ZzgW‚y§¯]h

‹ìÔ ›^Öfo è�ƒVÂic�{oƒìX7Å541¹ÿ GHG¸VÅ¢zg]7XZqÂ[

:m4 ]ö…�æÒç…Œ(µ^Þ3çm6qÛ^ÂkÒ1Ön1 1DZs 2D

ÔZDw�ÔZÍw: ÞÏç� ðóó5±ÙX) è ,Æa·ð�á@»*yLLZDw¨ 3Dm454D774(

714�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 413: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¹ZhìÔ1y*y~�ø[7ƒðXtÂ[cÃðZzgÂ[ZknÅïYñÔÂp[ìX¾n�W\�VÆZÚ÷ƥŢzgc]Ãl!B�X÷Z°�tì

�ÃgÏÆfg)ÐÌ]hìÑ]ZzgZˆ‚]ƒÒ0îE0yJqXZôm~ÃgÎVC1 ~p}»àq.e�w8iï FFƒ@ìXZN[~z{ÌikÃgìX

ZkZ½kÐÔF"3ïGGELÂ[Æe~´)ZDwÅXi{Y6×gzÝ7CìXtÂ¥x7�[ZDäZDwÃÃð£/Â[½Åc7ÔpZDw»%û

Æ*xÐ�áùƒZXZkƼ�Zec�ø[�XZy �ñnßäÿÂrÜ »!ÃgkÔ6291Y~ƒ66291YƈÆ_54èEGELS®�g`�XZq°6‚ÁS®�g`7Ô¸�¸

6‡èah �†|ô�ñnßäÂrÜ »ç þ 6291Y ÿ ªZecìX¬ZecÆ‚ÁS®C2X ŽoÅ@gõ’k)7†g~7291Y(Ѓ@ì

6ÄZÈÂ[Å 3C ÃìXZkÆuzgt è »4391YZecøg}7 �ñnßäÂrÜÂ#„g]:LLZN!‹�z$Šê

EELÃgÏ'ZñCñ¢røóó�g`ìXuzgtƈ

LLz�óó»Zqzgt�g¡Ò3ï EGFÎcìX�zâVZzgZt6,]��g`7�Xz„

p})m1D2(ƈQ�ZqÐQÂ[»W¸iƒ@ìX7291YÆZec~8~î0�»¡Ò3ï E

GFÔz„ƈÎc�ìZzg9ßg]¸ìX8~î0�m876»ƒ@ìX8~î0Ä)m97D631(ÆWy~Zq�Û})m731D461(Ì�áïìXz�Zq

§i~(ÔZq 9b)Iz�zÅïGLZkZyZi±·Z)wiZ�{(ÔZqZYä)âƒÒ0îGZiú��á{†÷iZ(ZzgZq^*ó)(„*)ZiZ'Z�á(6�ìX *“ u egZó)

4C Zk§b%AäZy–q�0gzVÆfg)ÃgÏÆLL]hìÑ]zZˆ‚]óóÔ�zx:m061D161 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä 1D

Å'×h¤&ZkZ%Ð̃Cì�âà‚w72D6291Y~ZDw þ 6291Y ÿ ‚ÁZ�á® 2DÔZDw� ‘vnËä Æ*Ñ7PÁgZhÜÐgZ¦Å¼g¶zßwÅ)fZ!: �ñnßäÂrÜ ä�ñnßäÂrÜ „ÅgZ¦¶X7PÁgä �ñnßäÂrÜ ZÍwÔZÆ'3791YÔm42(Dîg6t

Y8¶Ô1z{0391Y~�áùƒðX Development Æ´z{ZDwÅÜsZqZzgÂ[Ô!W.Þm52 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù uzgtÆa5±Ù: è@ 3D

Ô�zx:m161 ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä ¯[ZDw¯x·Zº¡Ô 4D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^814

Page 414: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¥JàäÅÃÒÅìX8~î0Ä~gzòÔÄ~ÔDiZ»ãÔ@�ZøÔßZðÔ÷iZÔ÷+Ô*ÜÆzÔ�{}ZÔ�Û›èZi~Ô$Z$™öG�Ô<¾8k5é EGãÔ)wZ−+Z�ãÔÂòÔ¼g~ÔÓZvÔZ0¹ÔZâg~Ô‡WãÔZ�d™'Ôq��Ô�Û�zÏÔ;$§ö

GEZzg‹ð

Æ‚BZDwäZK>Ì�áïÅ�XZk§bŠ*¯Z�!%âVÆ‚B‚BQ,Vä]hÃgÏ�á²~ÃÌ»[~úÒÏ�~ìXZyÅZK>)`·gZzg$™*î EE0‚g!V(ÃgÏ~6454-ö XGJGŠ!]ÅVB�X�V~ic�{F©îZzg©~>�X

Åplâ+.e�{ìXZÖpÆ�gxyoƒìXplâ+ �ñnßäÂrÜÅZëp!tì�S²Z[»$g<îE0Z?ZÈxH�ìXZkzzФDÃ9ÈÆ‚B„g]7"~�‰Ü7ƒCX

g+÷ GELy @/

ZzgˆZiZVeg 2C ÆÔ�zÔ»�âp 1C 3191Y~�áùƒðXuzgt i^…mîaß‚,]Åz„)Itzñç¬](�~�ìX$4èGELÂ[ÆW¸iÐ,]»ZiaçLâÑgH�ìX

Z1Z[Å®Z�0õìXCÙ![f~”V~ËìX¬![)m1D26(»ÄZyì:LLyz�V»iâ:óóX�zu}Ô�}Zzga¸![)m26D981(~y*y~�âVÅWæZzgQyÆ�z§xZãÐcÅ�ìX0v,![)m091D873(»ñçq:LLZ3ÿXL�Û8ÅZ’Zð:q]óó�XWy~{~ZizgeÞÅ@`7Ù)3091Y(

M Æf™ÆˆZôm~Ó#ÖÅLL'»]óó6Ñge™iyÆZq)»Ü��c�ìXâÞ5091Y(6ƒ@ìXWy~�z<Zzg�z#-+õ GGO zZu]»{Ø�~Ñge�ÅWæ)71B

�áï�X¬<»ñçqì:LLŠ*Zzgqwű„Zzg�g@g]zZu]óóXZk~Zgc2VZzgß1VÐ0'Z5ð¥â]ZzgZOò¬]½Å��X

!W.Þm42 ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù uzgtÆa5±Ù: è@ 1D)m42D52(~®wìX ]Þç]…ô]Îf^Ù �âp 2D

914�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 415: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

èZ<ØÔ �zx~LLyÅqª2091Y~óóÆikÄZyy*yÅZYVÔi!âVÔ t.-*îE

G0½ÔigZ®ÔÅzwÄÔˆg]ZzggwV»-ÒyìX0ZÍw»ÄZyì:LL©]»DzZ�[óóZzg�zx»LL�âV»DzZ�[óó'Itzñç¬]ÅgzÝ~

Æ´It»YöÆ‚BZq©™C i^…mîaß‚ Oîg6¹YYì�tÂ[ìZzg�zÂzÐè�ìX

M±z©Z−+»Òyì�LLZkÂ[»Ü�Z%<ÆZqDä4191Y~~�c�ìXgZ¶Ã0ÎyÆË Iqbal in Picture kÆuzgt»@ Z C1 �áùHåóóX

êÃ{ä~ZkÜá»uZr75XÆ�âdÐè7¸�Â[¾�gZÆaè�Ô1M± i^…mîôaß‚

2C z©Z−+ä�ì:LLtÂ[41D3191Y~çwÅ)oV~7JðYC¶XóóZ¤pQ,Vä@G~ÃðjZ!7�cÔ@ëÂ[Åi!yZzgQ|[’kÐQyÅ!]

êZiªk¥x7ƒCXuzgt6�gWLLeZË�·ZDw™róóZzgLLÑ!gZx6�á�Ôóó6zWØ~Ô

ZDwÆK~ikc è Íg»ÒуgóóÆ*x�g`�ÔZkaëZУ?Ñgì�Ôzg:qgY‹Â[ÆNg_¬ÐzZãƒ@ì�Â[Ñ!gZx6�á�Å’k™�{ìZzg´)ZDw»ÔSuzgtÆÔÂ[ÆItzqgY]м´‘7Xt!]'ÆQ|ƒ’kZzgzZu]ÆÒy~ZkÆ$©�î EG0ÃÐl!ÈVìXZkÅzŸsPVßVЃÏ:

�zu}![ÆÑzq~Cc�ì:LL²[~Zq*è<ØaZƒZXZkè<ØÆ!ã'C3 |]·å™r075Y~aZƒñX236Y~|]·å™rgZ„$ÓëL’ƒñóóå ZÍw:Q,VäW\ YV�Ô W8gåÆ!g}~tZ0Z¯Òy´)ZDw»7ƒY

E™{LL·å™róó¶î M™H » å LZk3^Z0Zi~7HÔ�zx:z{*I™D¸�W\ f™ »Ô�zx:m46 …æ‡+^…ôÊÏn† 1D

Zs 2D:m36 i^…mîôaß‚ 3D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^024

Page 416: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

YñXÝxgÎw$äîs²áJ´)ZDwÅÄQVðXZy»Òyì�Z¤ÃðZôm~i�{â�Zy—g-ZvmzÅ»f™LL·™róó¶î M™™@ÂM\¯gUZÐIu�ïZzg

C1X (~ñÐuiø™DZq(ZºZzgZzg8id»ñZi:™DƒñCc�ì�:

±ÆZ±gÐ�zâV(}»ïÔ1Zzg8idÕc�ÛdÐZCÈ èÅïmZzgådSDÛzVÃI™@åXZº(Z¬àj,Zzg�ÛZc�wZzguÑ÷LÀåXƒ

Æ‚B5èÐÿ˜Zþ'|Zzg¦[�Ô6Sîg3H™@åÔ1Zzg8id(ZïåX)è<ØÆßÍVÃZfeà@åXƒÅ§sÐ$ógLÔ¦1V6ñ

™@Zzg'~§b̼;B4ÔÂL:aÂåXaèZkÃË»Z±g:åÔZka:QkC2 Æ�wÃLuWgZx5Zzg:Ëî~!Ç»x!ƒðX

Zg ŒÛ 3C ó Wy,ó è8}Zg t!]êZiªkì�t„g]Zzg8idÃLLF±øILâ

�¶zZá¿ÆÐhƒX¬KÆ!g}~Z+!'!ÖºZDwÃðLLÃgfztóó„ÉYìXZqZzgVw�&À�/õ GGXÎyãuóÙÆWy~cÆ~ZômzVÐ'açL�gìXZkñµ6ÎyÅHª¶?'ä¤9VÃCcì�:

Z[ãÆZz‚yæƒñZzgpszCÙZk�w6YcXOç}ÂÃw[Z@ZzgHÂVæñVÐ7ØQ@Zzg}KzV~�¬NjZ@åZzgqgzV~7Y™zZ@å

ÿ�zxþÔm07 ]Îf^Ù�…æáì^Þä 1D:m341 i^…mîaß‚ D2

ÆPZÃg: e1ìç�p è …Úç‡ ¬KÆ!g}~ D3Z�ZÄÑ»9åZiz 0�ZsxV'FZiz

Wy, è âgZ}8 è F¿ �gxÈ»giZ§¬z�,\.üIL�,�gÀâ'�Ûz| ZÒ�Î| è '¾"3šø

GGEIyðZ�gZ¿Zz$k5é EIE745å EGE è zÝ Ãgfz‡V�Z*.‚745å EGE

Z0g,R:1� ð aV'Z� ^›Ïî I0©gZ6zZ:1�Zzg8id¬K6LLbÝÔ�Ô¼Zg~Zzg(Ï‚iØVóó»cyFZ¾zZßVÃÔZDwä

��: X ÆF)yóóŒÛZg�cì Western Interpreters of Indian History"The charges brought against him are based on a misinterpretation of contemporaryfacts and complete misunderstanding of the nature of social and political forceswhich were then working in the Muslim State. (The Muslim Community)

124�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 417: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zzgz{�yÈw�å�yz�VÃtt¾�~�ZzgZyÆqgzVÃUg™Zcå'Zkz‰Ü‚g}.È3{¤~ZzgÇzeyÆeàÈw�åÔÉZk~Zz‰�gZÅ

C1 =z�ZøÌ!¹7g„¶X~ZkÆ'@ZDwLLLZÈ�óóÆZkLLZâxóóÆ!g}~CD q^æm‚Þ^Úä

��z{:2C q�Äè~/Ziœ‚Á|

»‡båTä:�g˜VÕZVZ¤%�Z:ia

3C ¨%�ZVYy4�yi0µ4iï YGG

C4 »Và(0™ZKYyÔYyW�Û,Æ4�ÅXÅ’kz»g~~Ëîg´)ZDw i^…mîôaß‚ Zicì� Zk§btZky{g`

»Z·Zu�áïg;ƒXZz6ëäf™Hå�Â[Ñ!gZx6�á�Å’k™�{¥xƒCE™{Zzg‰zZu]Å,ÔZq{miZz�ÃÐ ì;Oç‰@g]�]»f™

7Å�ìÔ}:ú�çâ~Æ0�zZáÆ#Ö:_!]²z`6�Xë�:LLú�» )1(

yÅ�zª6Â�Z-å„Ô1‚B„tÌWgiz¶�(}(}!êgZ‡ÂVÃ�ZgÆ� Æ.VÆK~Cc ^™y*y6ú� ÐW C5 Zsx~�Z4™}óóX è izgÐ�+

:m172D272 i^…mîaß‚ 1D:m581 q^æm‚Þ^Úä 2D

ÔTÎx:m555(X e^În^lô]Îf^Ù ZDwÅZqázuÄLL�ÄLóó»Wy~Ä) 3D)m271(~ZDwägzòÅi!ãÔÎyãÃZyZÖp~yZ•o]7Hì: q^æm‚Þ^Úä 4D

W'z}yzuzgzxz�áx WVLZÈ�gZZâx{¿GlZiðzÂi0{F *êZipgæz)@È{FÂ0ZãYVp”‡:�Z�? GgZi}1�'õZ.�

:m07 i^…mîaß‚ 5D

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^224

Page 418: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zkä¼�¾ðVÅ"wäÅÔqgzVÃßNÔàzVðcÔyz�VÃ{~¯cZzg"Ñg�zªá™çãŧs%Z�Å)m17D27(X'×ht�z{gZ‡ÂVÃ)z§cZsx6Ñ*eLåóó)m38(X

)2(!'Æ!g}~Cc�ì�z{LLZL�7VÆ‚B(~"g·Ð7W@åóóX)m011(X

)3(Zzg8id¬KÆLLèI�óóÔZkÆLLbÝóóZzgyz�VÆÜsZkÅLLgVóó»"5¾æ EGZgf™H�ì)m141D241(X

)4(uZ`Z−z!ÃLL(ZªÝzÈlóóŒÛZg�ïƒñ'äCc�Zkäyz�V6LL.eJÕóóKZzg�zªqzVÃLLß^ß^™óóͯ�cX'×h'WVZkäeJÆÆwqÁgZ`¢Å�zª6LL�0ZÈÑ!Kóó)m612D712(XWÐ^™LL�ƒwóó»rÔZqÇzZîÆîg67H�ìX

ZyVßVÃ�Ùƒñ�âdÅZyTgÐZ·te7�:LLzZu‹@g]Å¡~¹Zôoлx1�ìóóX'×h'WV'ƺmiZz�ÃÐtªk¢~$wY@ì�Â[Æ'Ñ!gZx6�á��X

Z¤pt!]´)ZDwÅËZzg'×Z`Ð_“7gBÔ@ëgZ¶»ªkì�)ZDwäÂ[ÆqgY]Ã�A%ÔZigZÓzä�Zg~ÔÂ[6ZC*x�g`™ä

ÜÂ[Ô i^…mîaß‚ g]�̃;tZqZ\k*uZ%ì� ß 1C ÅZYi]�~ƒÏ´)ZDwÆ*xÐ�áùƒðÔTÆqgY]ÔZDwÆZ°gzìÑ]ÐzZãîg6

��zpÐ�XÐeì�Â[¾YäÆÔZDwÃZkt»ZˆkƒZƒÔOçÂ[»

ÃðZzgZec�ø[7X

eì�Z¹Â[»¼çz£Ì5ƒÔ1Zk»Ãðo]7MXZkiâä~ZyÅWæã 1DZâÁ¶�Zk6LzZZZÑ�Z7å'ZkaZDwÅ71D6191YЬÅZåLÃb

ñ��7ìX

324�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 419: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]»45ëGEY

1

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^424

Page 420: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÆË�zu}°Å�lÌg„XF‚wˆâ8Ã&Ïî HÆ i^…mîaß‚ gZ¶Z�zsûZq¯)=$g@î

EE0ñe(á™MñX~ä i^…mîaß‚ Zq™x�Ûâ·ñeZv™rZk»@Z1ÔZݯz{zZ:á�Xˆ~Z�zâV¶V»ñZi:HÂt�N

ìÔWÆ*xÌz„�ZzguzgtÌƒÉ i^…mîaß‚ ZÏsƒZ��zâV¶V»*xz(„ìÔ�zâV»�âpÌ!Ç7VìÔÉ�âdÆ�zâVÔZq„Â"ÐY9��ZzgZyÆ,]�)Z³Ô[(Ì7V�Ôp�zâVÂ1V»QÔZq�zu}ЬZìÔªZq*xÅt�zZÂÁ�X

-V¥xƒ@ì�tÂ[�z!gè�X$g@îEE0Z»�ò×-ìZzg$g@î

EE0ñe¿XZqÂ[Ã�zu~!gÔ6QÅßg]~Ô’kz"™äÅ¢zg] Šg}

ZkƉÒ*]ÅzzÐZÐZq»!Â[Æîg6 � YV7Mð?¸�Zkaàg7H�X)ìwgì�Zkiâä~ÂÁÔ,·ßg]~àg~Æa7ÅYC�X(OçÂ[»Zq*Q)=$g@î

EE0ñe(»gH�T~Zzg8id¬KÔãÎyZzguZ`Z−z!Æ!g}~MgZzÒ*]$g@î EE0Z»�ò~�áï‚—Ò*]

ЬZZzgù¦wе�X@GÆa$g@î EE0ñeÆÒ*])Z½‚](i^…mî )ZDwZ»�òуgÿ5002þ(~�áï*y:LL ]Îf^Ön^lViË`nÜæirˆmä gZ¶ÅÂ[

gZ¶äZk*y~tÌCcå�$g@îEE0ñe ÔP¥%]óó~�AYM�X aß‚

*³ZsyìXgZ¶Z�zsÃ$g@î

EE0ñeÆË�zu})�(°Å�l¶Xpl¬Ð¼²�¬ZkÆZqå°»uZr5X$g@î

EE0ñe�6536»ƒ@åXZ0Zi{å�aèWy~![)�32(�453ÐÑzqƒg;ìZkaz{�004J;ƒZƒÇÔ16å°»Q�

1C 7�X 8536»ƒY@ìXZk§bÍc$g@îEE0ñe~Üs�z,])753D853(ñ��

}}Z%sÌÃW@ì}: 1 2C $g@îEE0ñeZzg$g@î EE0¡7g„CÙ7V�

*å¯)=$g@îEE0¡7g(·Igu�á{�ãÆÃ{U¡7gÔgc„·zw7g~ñ��ìX 1D

ƒðX kÅaÜZLÃå�z„ohâZi{V1ciðÔIZSÅz‚¦ÐqÝ =Z,]~�zâVÆuzgVÆ@�bYgì�X {ÒW 2D

524�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 421: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]»45ëGEY

2

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^624

Page 422: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

@Ô¡7g

724�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 423: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

B8Wäè D ù¦Zq��Zzg�zâV67Ì°¢ è D�zâVÆuzgt¨ 1X ƒðìX1$g@î

EE0ñe~®Z›¢»f™7ìZ�$g@î EE0¡7g6®Z›¢�kDÙZg�g`ì2D$g@îEE0ñe6LL�iZÍwóóÆZÖpÃWD�Z�$g@î EE0¡7g6LL�i1óó�ƒZìX3D$g@î

EE0ñeÔ6�Zz6f™ƒZ*³ZsyìXp$g@îEE0¡7gåìZzgÂ[»

Q�8536僙»ƒ@ìX4D$g@îEE0¡7gŃÐZëqÂ[Æ!N§s�áïZôm~i!y~uzgt

ÆnZyZÖp» History of India ìXtZôm~uzgtZg�zuzgt»FÀìÔ@ëZg�zZzgZôm~ Completely revised and brought down to 1912 ZŸ†H�ìX

uzgV~ZqZzg�Ûttì�Zg�zuzgt6LLZ�åDióóÆZÖp�g`�Ô²ÆZÖp�ƒñ�X)Zôm~uzgt»@ Mufid-i-'Am Press Zôm~uzgt6

Ô6�&À�/õ GGX( W.Þ !�kDÙZgÅ®Z�~Â[)$g@î

EE0¡7g(ÅZ�á®Ðtªk™*Â7�ZÐ�g»!Â[àg™ÆjßV~7JcY@g;ƒÇX

ãÎy ÆFç”{Zec)$g@îEE0ñez¡(ЬKÔú�çâ~Ô i^…mîaß‚ Z¤p

Z‹Zn!'ïw�~��ÔZkÆ!z��ÔZk~ è ZzguZ`Z−z!Ð0¹Ï‡.ÞZ[Ìy*ãxZâVZzgZôm~Ó#ÖÐ0Z,Ò*]ñ���Ô�ZDwÆ

¦gZ]Zzg�Ð_“7gnX¯',tÎZwZ[ÌiÔì�ZkÆuzgtLL�·ZDwZ*Z}8ZÝe~Û7ZfÑóóÆZÖpYV�g`�?

ZDwÆ(¦gZ]Æe~¹Zë �ñnßäÿÂrÜ MZ�ÔÅegÂÁZzg�X½ÆZU�VÆ!g}~ZyÂ1VÐZDwÆZ0Z¯ÃÅzŸsƒC

��ÔZy~ZDw è 1C ìÔ1Àì�ZDwÆ(Z°g6Z[J�W~ÂÁZipZzÝxZÅk5åGO+X Iqbal's Educational Philosophy )Z³( 1D

Zi·Z£œjX ]Îf^ÙÒ1iÃ×nÛoÞ¿†m^l )[(Zi·Z£œjX ]Îf^ÙÒ^Ê׊ËäÿiÃ×nÜ )`(Zi·Z£{VX ]Îf^Ù]æ…ÚŠò×äÿiÃ×nÜ )�(

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^824

Page 424: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

History of India

924�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 425: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Å%ûÔZy»!Â1V»f™J7MXZyÆÃå¸5SyÐÑDÔcQZDwÆ(Z°g6cÆK~Q,VäSyÂ1VÃ)Zëìw™Dƒñ�gp§Z²7�?¢zg]ZkZ%Åì�ÓxZD1CZ�ZgzVZzgoÆZëÃ{âV~ikc»!Â1VÅaÝw½ÅYNÔ@�ZDw6ïÆe~ZyÐÃZ{QVcYnX

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^034

Page 426: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDw*)@134�gÏÂÁ � é� ZDwÅ%û

Page 427: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¯[¯xgZáZŒ)@(ñß~™Ô·)@( ¯[¯x

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^234

Page 428: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

<

1DÂÒCÃZµn^ÝÚ�†Ñ 2DZôm~Z�ágZ]l�âp

óó The Muslim Community 3DZDw»Zq*c[*yLL

334ÂÒCÃZ

Page 429: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÂÒCÃZ e1:¯ÄZDwÆ�¶V6Z0gZY]*å�Zzg�ÃZ�g„7XëäZfgZùÐæ�á�Ôlzg½oz�ÅÃÒÅìX

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^434

Page 430: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

534ÂÒCÃZ

Page 431: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^634

Page 432: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

734ÂÒCÃZ

Page 433: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^834

Page 434: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

934ÂÒCÃZ

Page 435: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^044

Page 436: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

144ÂÒCÃZ

Page 437: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^244

Page 438: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

344ÂÒCÃZ

Page 439: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^444

Page 440: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

544ÂÒCÃZ

Page 441: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^644

Page 442: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

744ÂÒCÃZ

Page 443: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^844

Page 444: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

944ÂÒCÃZ

Page 445: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^054

Page 446: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

154ÂÒCÃZ

Page 447: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^254

Page 448: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

354ÂÒCÃZ

Page 449: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^454

Page 450: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

554ÂÒCÃZ

Page 451: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^654

Page 452: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

754ÂÒCÃZ

Page 453: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^854

Page 454: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

954ÂÒCÃZ

Page 455: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^064

Page 456: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

164ÂÒCÃZ

Page 457: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^264

Page 458: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

364ÂÒCÃZ

Page 459: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^464

Page 460: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

564ÂÒCÃZ

Page 461: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^664

Page 462: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

764ÂÒCÃZ

Page 463: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^864

Page 464: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

964ÂÒCÃZ

Page 465: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^074

Page 466: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

174ÂÒCÃZ

Page 467: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^274

Page 468: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

374ÂÒCÃZ

Page 469: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^474

Page 470: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

574ÂÒCÃZ

Page 471: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ Zôm~Z�ágZ]Ôl�âp e2:)Zq),·�k(

ÎZi,]6�tZôm~Z�ágZ]z{Z�Zðï]�ÔXÅã�6�~ZDwqw @ »�âpÈHXZDwñi*Ñ�g~ôpZDwÅt�„â“�k µn^ÝÚ�†Ñ äz){ �g�XZDwÆZ5ZzgÓVÅ‚| Geothe ìXZk~Í,ÆX ),·!y ~�b�ZÖpZzg�gZ]ði (italics) Ã�V»ÂV'ŒÛZgg3�ìXFiNUì:( ~�ÔZy»Zôm~FÀqd/õ IG~�g`ìX)F3ÆagZ¶»[·»ò»Ny

Herder. Did not know Persian. But his didactic tendency made himinterested in Sa'di. He translated portions of Gulistan in his Blumen desParadieses1C . But hi eastern studies scarcely influenced his original poems.Unlike his contemporary Geothe he received no impulse from the East whichwould stimulate him to production. His didactic interest (one sided) renderedhim indifferent to Hafiz and caused him to proclaim Sa'di as a model worthyof imitation. It was Hafiz who fired the soul of Geothe and inspired him towrite the Diwan.

"An Hafiz Gesanges haben wir fast genng Sa'adi ist unslehrrichergewesen"2C .

Herder

Geothe Fired by Hafiz wrote the Diwan; he introduced the spirit Persian

poetry into German Lit. and introduced what is called the Oriental movement

Flowers of the paradise FÀ: 1DOn Hafiz's Odes we have almost we have almost enough; Sa'adi FÀ: 2D

has become instructive for us.

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^674

Page 472: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

in Gen. Lit. (Geothe's Faust-Prolo gue inspired by Kalidas). To the Orient

(i.e. Persia and Arabia-this was Geothe's Orient) he turned at the time of

Germany's deepest political degradation ; when she was overrun by foreign

invaders (the French). He shrank from the tumult and took refuge in the East.

The opening lines of the Diwan clearly show the object of this poetical. ó]In the Diwan however he preserves his poetical independence and does

not imitate the form of Persian poetry (Except twice when he imitates the

form of Ghazal). He remains a citizen of the west though he dwells in the

East for a time. He takes only what he finds congenial to his own nature as to

his attitude toward mysticism he had no love for it. It was incompatible with

his own habit of clear thinking. He says of Rumi, "I doubt if this poet could

give a clear account of his own doctrine (but his admiration for Spinoza :). He

knew that Hafiz was mystically interpreted in the East but he looked upon

Hafiz as a lyric poet only.

Thus Geothe brought in the Spirit of Pesian poetry ; it was reserved for

Ruckert and platen to bring in the form also.

The Oriental Movement started by Geothe was carried to perfection by

Rukert, Platen, Bodenstedt.

Schiller. He died before the Oriental movement in Germany had begun.

On him there is no Oriental influence except that his drama ÂgZy�| goes

back to persian source (ñ¢ÂòZY:�º0��á{Z¿Xgx( 8)�œ9)Ïî E0zÑegzk

1�à}$©5½ð EEGða²zkBut Schiller does not seem to be aware of the source. The scene is laid

in China names are Persirn.

Von Hammers' complete translation of Hafiz appeared in 1812 and

Geothe received the impulse to write the Diwan from this. It was not the

impulse only it was also the principal force from which the poet drew his

774Zôm~Z�ágZ]

Page 473: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

inspiration. A single verse of Hafiz often furnished a whole theme,

Sometimes his own poem could be a translation, Sometimes free paraphrase.

Other poets also furnished material e.g. Sa'di, Attar, Firdausi, Quran, Persian

sayings, anecdotes ete chosen from various sources.

Persian metaphors and simiiies copiously used in the Diwan CÙZÃgÔ¾ Í)(×ÇVÔZ§iÅýL¤êÔÉz�Ô{u�§cgÔÓz6zZ:(

Reference to Persian love tales -ŠilÔQ7V and a whole part

devoted to ‚¹ (called the book of Saqi). and Geothe does not shrink from

alluding to the subject of boy-love.

Platen. )ç1]( He imitated from the Persian poetry, also )‡Bzg�p(

even metrical rules. He studied Persian for this purpose. The books that gave

him impulse,

1. Hammer's translation of qƒ2. Geothe's Diwan

3. Ruckerts' Version of a portion of gzòIn 1821 appeared his ç1] and later @i{ç1]Wsqƒ etc. These are not

translations but origninal poems inspired by the reading of Hafiz. Persian

metaphors used ; Z'zñëaÔ²zµÉÔ�g°yÔiÅýLªÔÑ!±ZgÔhw etc.

Like a Geothe he ignores the mystic side of Hafiz.

The net result of Platen and Ruckerts' efforts_introduction of a new

poetic form. Besides çw Platen wrote g!¦ & �{ on Napoleon.

Ruckert

He knows Persian, Arabic and Sanskrit.

He is a devotee to the mystic poetry of Rumi and the joyous strain of Hafiz.

His ç1] ( æ¹Yw imitation of qƒ ) are mostly imitation of Rumi

Persian metaphors W>Z'Z�%�ÉÔyZ!]Ô%rgzb Ruckert's Sources:

&yZÑuZgÂòÔZ÷ÆzÔ8­xÔ·g*yYòÔÈg�ZøÔyZÅ�.çG«g and IÈÄ~

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^874

Page 474: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)oÜZ°g@( from which he takes several legends about Rumi). Also stories

from Pre-Islamic Persia �á{7gÔm��Ô¾ZxaÁ and Poems about Post Islamic

Persian kings ZÉ45»4è FGYGEz©[z‡1kÔÂxZ<ÔZ©ZgsyÔú�çâ~Ôúú�'Îo]·pZgix�á{ZzgZk»g°wZ−+zÎ:gÄ)yz*y( Whatever defects his poetry may have

Rukert's work is very important. He brought in new spirit and form.

Heine. His earlier poems show us Persian influence; but his later poems

(siene Gedichtes) show it unmistakably.

Called Sa'adi-Persian Geothe Imagined himself a Persian poet in exile

among the Germans-says-'O Firdausi, 0 Jami,

o Sa'adi, How miserable is your brother, how I yearn after the roses of

Shiraz.

But he held a poor opinion of German work Eastern Poetry (except

Geothe's Diwan). He never imitated this poetry. But his "Der Dichien

Firdausi" )ú�z�Û�zÏ»r( one of his best poems.

Yet Heine cannot be called a follower of the Oriental movement

originated by Geothe & others. He is in no sense an orientali sing poet.

Bodenstedt. Poems of Mirza à original poem, at first published

anonymously supposed to be translation.

Ran 140 editions in Germany Later he published ZÃg!iâ0{%iZÃ but

this was not much success.

Sources-Gulistan, Boostan, Jami and Firdausis' -Šil Ibn Yamin,

Sa'adi Baharistan.

Minor Poets

Loschke, Levitschnig, Wohl, Steiglitz, Hermanstahl, Daumer "Hafiz" a

collection of original poems in the manner of Hafiz. Lenthod ç1] like

Platen & Ruckert Von Schack (Scholar & poet like Ruckert). Influenced by

/ìx , Story of Z»sú�çâ~ Story of ;gz]âgz] . But the Hafizian movement

did not excite his enthusiasm even for Bodenstudts, poems by Mirza Shafi

974Zôm~Z�ágZ]

Page 475: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

had no great admiration.

(It is pity that ¤WBÔ¸Ô{y{*V(jãÔ²°Ôn~ etc never reached these

poets).

â^:´)ZDwÆ�„â“qgz!ÑZôm~Z�ágZ]»@�k·Z™Zx,ð)ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ0002Y(~�áï™1ìÔ Iqbal and Goethe @; äZK

m306@906X

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^084

Page 476: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

)l![5( 3e:ZDw»Zq*c[*y

The Muslim Community

A Sociological Study

tZk\»QìÔ�´)ZDwä1191Y~Z¥|Æ72;w~�cåX)ÑzZã(~�áï�ÔQg�z Speeches Zzg Thoughts ZkÆ�Z½‚]

èZDwÆËù´ è FÀÌ�ø[ìÔ1ZÝZôm~Qåßg]~�~�áï7ìXgZ¶Z�zsÃt),·)åßg]~(Zzg*c[[ÔZK

ïÆ�zgZyZDwñi*Ð�ø[�ZåÔ«!gZÐikÃeZËfÆ£áÆ‚B7H�X�ZiZVZÐZ*f~eZËz©ŒÛ7ÆZZ6Z-Å

)`3Ôl1ÔZÆ' Úr×ùäivÏnÐ Z�Zg]~�áù�äzZáóh}0891Y(~Zq¿¬g°â^Æ‚B�áù™Zc�XZ[JtìwHY@å�ZÝ[nzx�[ìXp�ZDwÆ0kÌZkÅ

�~Z¹}ÐZkÅZqÜ�ø[��ÔOçQ,Vä C1 Üôp:¶Ô\6ÃUã™D�ñZ�Zð!iðO�}~�FZçXZzgW¸i~ZqzŸ�•g{Ì�kHÔ�Zk\Æ:©6gzÝeZmìXt•g{ZDwÅZK�k~ìÔZÐfs~�g`HYg;ì)Zk»@ÔWÒ{Ô6�&À�/õ GG(:

ÔÑzZãÔm861( Speeches)"I have no copy of the lecture" ZDw: 1D

184The Muslim Community

Page 477: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

@�„â“ZDwÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^284

Page 478: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

The Muslim Community

A Sociological StudyThis lecture was delivered at Aligarh in 1911. The remark about the

Qadianis in this lecture must be revised in the light of the revelation of the

spirit of the movement since 1911. The Qadianis still appear to be Muslims in

externals. Indeed they are very particular in the matter of externals, but the

spirit of the movement as revealed often is wholly inimical to Islam.

Outwardly they look Muslims and anxious to look so; but inwardly their

whole mentality is Magian. It is probable that eventually the movement will

end in Bahaism from which it originally appears to have received inspiration.

M. lqbal

21st Oct: 1935

Z[ZÝ*y5±Ù:In the epic sweep of human history, there is nothing more

awe?inspiring, nothing more destructive of human ambition than the ruins of

bygone nations, empires and civilisations appearing and disappearing, during

the painful course of human evolution, like the scenes of a rapidly vanishing

dream. The forces of Nature appears to respect neither individuals nor

nations; her inexorable laws continue to work as if she has a far?off purpose

of her own, in no sense related to what may be the immediate interest or the

ultimate destiny of man. But man is a peculiar creature. Amidst the most

discouraging circumstances, his imagination, working under the control of his

understanding, gives him a more perfect vision of himself and impels him to

discover the means which would transform his brilliant dream of an idealised

self into a living actuality. An animal of inferior physical strength,

unequipped with natural weapons of defence, lacking the power of nocturnal

vision, keen scent, or fleetness of foot, man has, in search of a freer, ampler

life, always directed his indefatigable energy to discover the laws of nature,

384The Muslim Community

Page 479: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

understand their working, and thus gradually to become a determining factor

in his own evolution. By the great discovery of the law of Natural Selection

he has succeeded in reaching a rational conception of his own history which,

before long appeared to him to be nothing more than an inscrutable series of

events dropping out, one by one, from the mysterious womb of time, without

any inherent order or purpose. A still deeper insight into the meaning of this

law, and the discovery by Post?Darwinian thinkers, of other equally important

facts of collective life are calculated to work a complete revolution in man's

notions of group?life in its social, ethical economic and political aspects. It

has been brought to light by recent biological research that the individual as

such is a mere abstraction, a convenient expression for facility of social

reference, passing moment in the life of the group to which he happens to

belong. His thoughts, his aspirations, his ways of life, his entire mental and

physical outfit, the very number of days which he lives, are all determined by

the needs of the community of whose collective life he is only a partial

expression. The interests of society as a whole are fundamentally different

and even antagonistic to the interests of the individual whose activity is

nothing more than an unconscious performance of a particular function which

social economy has allotted to him. Society has a distinct life of its own,

irrespective of the life of its component units taken individually. And just as

an individual organism, in a state of organic disorder, sometimes

unconsciously sets up within itself, forces which tend to its health, so a social

organism under the corroding influence of destructive forces, may sometimes

call into being counteracting forces-such as the appearance of an inspiring

personality, the birth of a new ideal, or a universal religious reform-which

tend to restore its original vitality, and finally save the organism from

structural collapse by making the inward communal self to bring into

subjection all the insubordinate forces, and to throw off all that is inimical to

the health of its organic unity. Society has or rather tends to have a

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^484

Page 480: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

consciousness, a will, and an intellect of its own, though the stream of it

mentality has no other channel through which to flow than individual minds.

The expressions "Public Opinion, National Genuins", or what the Germans

happily phrase the "Zeitgeist" are only vague recognitions of this exceedingly

important fact of social Psychology. The crowd, the mass?meeting, the

corporation, the sect, and, finally the deliberative assembly are the various

means by which the body?social organises itself in order to secure the unity

of self-consciousness. It is not necessary that the social mind should be

conscious of all the various ideas that are, at a particular moment, working in

the individual minds. The individual mind is never completely aware of its

own states of Consciousness. In the case of the collective mind, too many

feelings, states and ideas remain below the threshold of social sensibility,

only a portion of the universal mental life crossing the border, and getting

into the clear daylight of social consciousness. This economical arrangement

saves from unnecessary expenditure, a great quantity of the energy of the

central organs which would otherwise be fruitlessly spent on details. It is,

therefore, clear that society has a life?stream of its own. The idea that it is

merely the sum of its existing individuals is essentially wrong and

consequently all projects of social and political reform, which proceed on this

assumption, must undergo a careful re?examination. Society is much more

than its existing individuals; it is in its nature infinite; it includes within its

contents, the innumerable unborn generations, which, though they ever lie

beyond the limits of immediate social vision, must be considered as the most

important portion of a living community. Recent biological research has

revealed that in the successful group?life it is the future which must always

control the present; to the species taken as a whole, its unborn members are

perhaps more real than its existing members whose immediate interests are

subordinated and even sacrificed to the future interests of that unborn infinity

which slowly discloses itself from generation to generation. To this

584The Muslim Community

Page 481: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

remarkable revelation of biological truth the social and political reformer

cannot afford to remain indifferent. Now it is from this standpoint-from the

standpoint of the future-that I wish to test the worth of our present social

activity. There is strictly speaking only one all-important problem before a

community-call it whatever you like, social, economic or political-and that is

the problem of a continuous national life. Extinction is as abhorrent to a race

as to an individual. The worth of all the various activities of a

community-intellectual or otherwise-ought always to be determined in

reference to this ultimate purpose. We must criticise our values, perhaps

trans-valuate them; and, if necessary, create new worths; since the

immortality of a people, as Nietzsche has so happily put, depends upon the

incessant creation of worths. Things certainly bear the stamp of divine

manufacture, but their meaning is through and through human. Before,

however, I proceed to this examination I wish to consider a few preliminary

points, the consideration of which, to my mind, is essential to arriving at any

definite conclusion concerning the Muslim Community. These points are:

(1) The general structure of the Muslim Community.

(2) The uniformity of Muslim Culture.

(3) The type of character essential to a continuous National life of the

Muslim Community.

I shall take these points in order.

(1) The essential difference between the Muslim Community and other

Communities of the world consists in our peculiar conception of nationality.

It is not the unity of language or country or the identity of economic interest

that constitutes the basic principle of our nationality. It is because we all

believe in a certain view of the universe, and participate in the same historical

tradition that we are members of the society founded by the Prophet of Islam.

Islam abhors all material limitations, and bases its nationality on a purely

abstract idea, objectified in a potentially expansive group of concrete

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^684

Page 482: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

personalities. It is not dependent for its life?principle on the character and

genius of a particular people; in its essence it is non?temporal, non?spatial.

The Arab Race, the original creation of Islam, was certainly a great

factor in its political expansion, but the enormous wealth of literature and

thought-manifestations of the higher life of the spirit-has been the work of

chiefly non-Arabian races. It seems as if the birth of Islam was only a

momentary flash of divine consciousness in the life?history of the Arab race;

the working of its spiritual potentialities was due to the genius of people

other than the Arabs. The essence of Islam, then, being purely ideal, it could

not accept any objective principle-such as country-as a principle of

nationality. The territorial conception of nationality, which has been so much

exaggerated in modern times, bears within itself the germs of its own

destruction. The idea of modern nationalism has certainly functioned usefully

in forming smaller political units, and creating a healthy rivalry among them,

which has contributed so much to the variety of modern civilisation. But the

idea is apt to be exaggerated, it has created a great deal of misunderstanding

of international motives; it has opened up a vast field for diplomatic intrigue,

and tends to ignore the broad human element in art and literature by

emphasising the peculiar traits and characteristics of particular peoples. To

my mind the feeling of patriotism, which the national idea evokes, is a kind

of deification of a material object, diametrically opposed to the essence of

Islam, which appeared as a protest against all the subtle and coarse forms of

idolatry. I do not, however, mean to condemn the feeling of Patriotism.

Peoples whose solidarity depends on a territorial basis are perfectly justified

in that feeling. But I certainly do mean to attack the conduct of those who,

while they recognise the great value of patriotic feeling in the formation of a

peoples' character, yet condemn our 'Asabiyyat which they miscall fanaticism.

We are as much justified in our 'Asabiyyat as they are in their Patriotism. For

what is 'Asabiyyat? Nothing but the principle of individuation working in the

784The Muslim Community

Page 483: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

case of a group. All forms of life are more or less fanatical, and ought to be

so, if they care for their individual or collective life. And as a matter of fact all

nations are fanatical. Criticise a Frenchman's religion; you do not very much

rouse his feelings; since your criticism does not touch the life?principle of his

nationality. But criticise his civilisation, his country or the corporate

behaviour of his nation in any sphere of political activity and you will bring

out his innate fanaticism. The reason is that his nationality does not depend

on his religious belief; it has a geographical basis-his country. His 'Asabiyyat

is then justly roused when you criticise the locality-which he has idealised as

the essential principle of his nationality. Our position however, is essentially

different. With us nationality is a pure idea; it has no objective basis. Our

only rallying?point, as a people, is a kind of purely subjective agreement in a

certain view of the world. If then our 'Asabiyyat is roused when our religion

is criticised, I think we are as much justified in it as a French?man is when

his country is denounced. The feeling in each case is the same though

associated with different objects. 'Asabiyyat is Patriotism for religion;

Patriotism 'Asabiyyat for country. 'Asabiyyat simply means a strong feeling

for one's own nationality and does not necessarily imply any feeling of hatred

against other nationalities. During my stay in England I found that whenever I

described any peculiarly Eastern custom or mode of thought to an English

lady or gentlemen, I, almost invariably, invoked the remark, "how funny", as

if any non?English mode of thought was absolutely inconceivable. I have the

highest admiration for this attitude; it does not indicate any want of

imagination; the country of Shakespeare, Shelley, Keats, Tennyson and

Swinburne cannot be wholly unimaginative; on the other hand it indicates

how deeply England's mode of thought and life, her institutions, her manners

and customs are rooted in the mind of her people.

The religious idea, then, without any theological centralisation, which

would unnecessarily limit the liberty of the individual, determines the

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^884

Page 484: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ultimate structure of the Muslim Community. In the case of no community

the words of Augustus Comte are so completely true as in the case of our

own. "Since Religion", says he, "embraces all our existence, its history must

be an epitome of the whole history of our development." It may, however, be

asked that if mere belief in certain prepositions of a Metaphysical import is

the only thing that ultimately determines the structures of the Muslim

Community, is it not an extremely unsafe basis especially before the advance

of modern knowledge, with its habits of Rationalism and criticism? This is

what the French Orientalist Renan thought; and entertained a veiled hope that

Islam would one day "lose the high intellectual and moral direction of an

important part of the universe." Nations, the basic principle of whose

collective life is territorial, need not be afraid of Rationalism, to us it is a

dangerous foe, since it aims at the very principle, which gives us a

communal?life, and alone makes our collective existence intelligible.

Rationalism is essentially analysis and consequently threatens to disintegrate

the communal synthesis achieved by the force of the religious idea. It is

undoubtedly true that we can meet Rationalism on its own ground. But the

point which I wish to impress on you is that the dogma i.e. the point of

universal agreement on which our communal solidarity depends, has

essentially a national rather than intellectual significance for us. To try to

convert religion into a system of speculative knowledge is, in my opinion,

absolutely useless, and even absurd, since the object of religion is not

thinking about life; its main purpose is to build up a coherent social whole for

the gradual elevation of life. Religion is itself metaphysics; in so far as it calls

up into being a new universe with a view to suggest a new type of character

tending to universalise itself in proportion to the force of the personality in

which it originally embodies itself. The point that I have tried to bring out in

the above remarks is that Islam has a far deeper significance for us than

merely religious; it has a peculiarly national meaning so that our communal

984The Muslim Community

Page 485: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

life is unthinkable without a firm grasp of the Islamic Principle. The idea of

Islam is, so to speak, our eternal home or country wherein we live, move and

have our being. To us it is above everything else, as England is above all to the

Englishman and "Deutschland uber alles" to the German. The moment our grasp

of the Islamic Principle is loosened that solidarity of our community is gone.

(2) Coming now to the second point: The uniformity of Muslim Culture.

The unity of religious belief on which our communal life depends, is

supplemented by the uniformity of Muslim culture. Mere belief in the Islamic

principle, though exceedingly important, is not sufficient. In order to

participate in the life of the communal self, the individual mind must undergo

a complete transformation, and this transformation is secured, externally by

the institutions of Islam, and internally by that uniform culture which the

intellectual energy of our forefathers has produced. The more you reflect on

the history of the Muslim Community the more wonderful does it appear

from the day of its foundation up to the beginning of the 16th century almost

a thousand years this energetic race was busy in the all?absorbing occupation

of political expansion. Yet in this storm of continuous activity the Muslim

world found time to unearth the treasures of ancient science, to make material

additions to them, to build a literature of unique character and above all to

develop a comprehensive system of law, probably the most valuable legacy

that Muslim civilisation has left us. Just as the Muslim Community does not

recognise any ethnological differences, and aims as the subsumption of all

races under the universal idea of humanity, so our culture is relatively

universal, and is not indebted for its life and growth to the genius of one

particular people. Persia is perhaps the principal factor in the making of this

culture. If you ask me what is the most important event in the history of

Islam, I shall immediately answer, the conquest of Persia. The battle of

Nehwand gave to the Arabs not only a beautiful country, but also an ancient

people who could construct a new civilisation out of the Semitic and the

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^094

Page 486: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Aryan material. Our Muslim civilisation is a product of the cross? fertilisation

of the Semitic and the Aryan ideas. It inherits the softness and refinement of

its Aryan mother and the sterling character of its Semitic father. The

Conquest of Persia gave to the Musalmans what the Conquest of Greece gave

to the Romans, but for Persia our culture would have been absolutely

one-sided. And the people whose contact transformed the Arabs and the

Mughals are not intellectually dead. Persia, whose existence as an

independent Political unit is threatened by the aggressive ambition of Russia,

is still a real centre of Muslim culture, and I can only hope that she still

continues to occupy the position that she has always occupied in the Muslim

world. To the Royal family of the Persia the loss of the Persia's political

independence would mean only a territorial loss, to the Muslim culture such

an event would be a blow much more serious than the Tartar invasion of the

13th century. But perhaps I am drifting into politics which it is not my present

object to discuss, all that I mean to establish is that in order to become a

living member of the Muslim Community, the individual, besides an

unconditional belief in the religious principle, must thoroughly assimilate the

culture of Islam. The object of this assimilation is to create a uniform mental

outlook, a peculiar way of looking at the world, a certain definite standpoint

from which to judge the value of things which sharply defines our

community, and transforms it into a corporate individual giving it a definite

purpose and ideal of its own.

(3) The third point need not detain us long. The above remarks indicate

the principal features of an essentially Muslim type of character. The various

types of character, however, that become popular in a community do not

appear haphazard. Modern Sociology teaches us that the moral experience of

nations obeys certain definite laws. In primitive societies where the struggle

for existence is extremely keen and draws more upon man's physical rather

than intellectual qualities it is the valiant man who becomes an object of

194The Muslim Community

Page 487: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

universal admiration and imitation. When, however, the struggle relaxes and

the peril is over, the valorous type is displaced, thought not altogether, by

what Giddings calls the convivial type, which takes a due share in all the

pleasures of life, and combines in itself the virtues of liberality, generosity

and good fellowship. But these two types of character have a tendency to

become reckless, and by way of reaction against them appears the third great

type which holds up the ideal of self?control, and is dominated by a more

serious view of life. In so far as the evolution of the Muslim Community in

India is concerned, Temur represented the first type, Babar combined the first

and the second, Jahangir embodied pre?eminently the second, while the third

type was foreshadowed in Alamgir whose life and activity forms, in my

opinion, the starting point in the growth of Muslim Nationality in India. To

those whose knowledge of Alamgir is derived from the Western interpreters

of Indian History, the name of Alamgir is associated with all sorts of cruelty,

intolerance, treachery and political intrigue. I shall be drifting away from the

main point of this lecture if I undertake to show, by a right interpretation of

contemporary history, the legitimacy of motives that guided Alamgir's

political life. A critical study of his life and times has convinced me that the

charges brought against him are based on a misinterpretation of contemporary

facts, and a complete misunderstanding of the nature of social and political

forces, which were then working in the Muslim State. To me the ideal of

character, foreshadowed by Alamgir is essentially the Muslim type of

character, and it must be the object of all our education to develop that type.

If it is our aim to secure a continuous life of the community, we must produce

a type of character, which at all costs, holds fast to its own, and while it

readily assimilates all that is good in other types, it carefully excludes from its

life all that is hostile to its cherished traditions and institutions. A careful

observation of the Muslim Community in India reveals the point on which the

various lines of moral experience of the community are now tending to

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^294

Page 488: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

converge. In the Punjab the essentially Muslim type of character has found a

powerful expression in the so?called Qadiani?sect; while in the United

Provinces, owing to a slightly different intellectual environment, the need of

such a type of character is loudly proclaimed by a great poetic voice. In his

light hearted humour Maulana Akbar of Allahabad, aptly called the tongue of

the times, conceals a keen perception of the nature of the forces that are at

present working in the Muslim Community. Do not be misled by the

half?serious tone of his utterances; he keeps his tears vieled in youthful

laughter, and will not admit you into his workshop until you come with a

keener glance to examine his wares. So deeply related are the currents of

thought and emotion in a homogeneous community that if one portion reveals

a certain organic craving the material to satisfy that craving is almost

simultaneously produced by the other.

Let me now precede a step further. In the foregoing discussion I have

tried to establish three propositions

1. That the religious idea constitutes the life-principle of the Muslim

Community. In order to maintain the health and vigour of such a community,

the development of all dissenting forces in it must be carefully watched and a

rapid influx of foreign elements must be checked or permitted to enter into

the social fabric very slowly, so that it may not bring on a collapse by making

too great a demand on the assimilative power of the social organism.

2. Secondly: the mental outfit of the individual belonging to the Muslim

Community must be mainly formed out of the material which the intellectual

energy of his forefathers has produced, so that he may be made to feel the

continuity of the present with the past and the future.

3. Thirdly: that he must possess particular type of character which I

have described as the Muslim type.

It is my object now to examine the value of the work that we have done

in the various spheres of activity. Now a thoroughgoing criticism of the work

394The Muslim Community

Page 489: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

of the Muslim world in the sphere of Politics, Religion, Literature and

Thought, Education, Journalism, Industry, Trade and Commerce will require

several volumes! The events, which are now happening in the Muslim World,

are extremely significant and a searching examination of them would be

exceedingly instructive; but the task is enormous, and I confess it is beyond

my power to undertake it. I shall, therefore, have to confine my observations

to the work that we have done in India, and here too I do not pretend to give

you any exhaustive treatment of the various problems now confronting us. I

shall consider only two points-Education and the improvement of the general

condition of the masses.

During the last fifty years or so, the work of Education has absorbed

almost all our energies. It is not improper to ask whether we have been

following any definite educational ideal, or only working for immediate ends

without giving a thought to the future. What kind of men have we turned out?

And is the quality of the output calculated to secure a continuous life of such

a peculiarly constructed community as our own? The answer to these

questions has been already indicated. The students of Psychology among you

know very well that the personal identity of the individual mind depends

upon the orderly succession of its mental states. When the continuity of the

stream of individual consciousness is disturbed there results Psychical ill

health which may, in course of time, lead on to a final dissolution of vital

forces. The same is the case with the life of the social mind whose continuity

is dependent on the orderly transmission of its collective experience from

generation to generation. The object of education is to secure this orderly

transmission and thus to give a unity of self?consciousness of personal

identity to the social mind. It is a deliberate effort to bring about a organic

relation between the individual and the body?politic to which he belongs. The

various portions of the collective tradition so transmitted by education,

permeate the entire social mind, and become objects of clear consciousness in

the minds of a few individuals only whose life and thought become

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^494

Page 490: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

specialised for the various purposes of the community. The legal, historical

and literary traditions of a community, for instance, are definitely present to

the consciousness of its lawyers, historians and literary writers, though the

community as a whole is only vaguely conscious of them. Now I wish you to

look at and judge the value of our educational achievement from this

standpoint. In the modern Muslim young man, we have produced a specimen

of character whose intellectual life has absolutely no background of Muslim

culture without which, in my opinion, he is only half a Muslim or even less

than that; provided his purely secular education has left his religious belief

unshaken. He has been allowed, I am afraid, to assimilate Western habits of

thought to an alarming extent, a constant study of Western literature, to the

entire neglect of the collective experience of his own community, has, I must

frankly say, thoroughly de?Muslimised his mental life. No community, I say

without any fear of contradiction, has produced so very noble type of

character as our own yet our young man who is deplorably ignorant of the

life?history of his own community, has to go to the great personalities of

Western history for admiration and guidance. Intellectually he is a slave to the

West, and consequently his soul is lacking in that healthy egoism which

comes from a study of ones own history and classics. In our educational

enterprise, we have hardly realised the truth, which experience is now forcing

upon us, that an undivided devotion to an alien culture is a kind of

imperceptible conversion to that culture, a conversion which may involve

much more serious consequences than conversion to a new religion. No

Muslim writer has expressed this truth more pointedly than the poet Akbar

who, after surveying the present intellectual life of the Muslim young man

cries out in despair

�%jx»¸wZ[=c�W@ì�w$wYNн$wYäÐ

We now see that the fears of the " �%jx ", the representative of the

essentially Muslim culture, who waged a bitter controversy with the late Sir

594The Muslim Community

Page 491: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Syyed Ahmad Khan on the question of Western Education, were not quite

groundless. Need I say that our educational product is a standing testimony to

the grain of truth contained in the Shaikh Marhum's contention? Gentlemen, I

hope you will excuse me for these straightforward remarks. Having been in

close touch with the student?life of today for the last ten or twelve years, and

teaching a subject closely related to religion, I think I have got some claim to

be heard on this point. It has been my painful experience that the Muslim

student, ignorant of the social, ethical and political ideals that have dominated

the mind of his continuity, is spiritually dead; and that if the present state of

affairs is permitted to continue for another twenty years, the Muslim spirit,

which is now kept alive by a few representations of the old Muslim culture,

will entirely disappear from the life of our community. Those who laid it

down as a fundamental principle that the education of the Muslim child must

begin with the study of the Qur'an-no matter whether he understands it or

not-were certainly much, more sensible of the nature of our community than

we claim to be. Economic considerations alone ought not to determine our

activity as a people, the preservation, of the unity of the community; its

continuous national life is a far higher ideal than the service of merely

immediate ends. To me a Muslim of scanty means who possesses a really

Muslim character is a much more valuable national asset than a high?salaried

free?thinking graduate with whom Islam, far from being a working principle

of life, is merely a convenient policy in order to secure a greater share in the

loaves and fishes of the country. These remarks need not lead you to think

that I mean to condemn Western culture. Every student of Muslim history

must recognise that it was the West, which originally shaped the course of

our intellectual activity. In the sphere of pure thought we are still perhaps

more Greek than Arab or Persian; Yet nobody can deny that we possess a

unique culture of our own, which no modern Muslim system of education can

afford to ignore without running the risk of denationalising those whose good

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^694

Page 492: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

it aims at securing. It is indeed a happy sign that the idea of a Muslim

University has dawned upon us. Considering the nature of our community the

necessity of such an institution cannot be doubted provided it is conducted on

strictly Islamic lines. No community can afford to break entirely with its past

and it is more emphatically true in the case of our community whose

collective tradition alone constitutes the principle of its vitality. The Muslim,

must of course, keep pace with the progress of modern ideas; but his culture

must, in the main, remain Muslim in character; and it is clear that such a

thing cannot be attained without a teaching university of our own. If you

produce young men, the groundwork of whose culture is not Muslim, you

will not be bringing up a Muslim community, you will be creating a totally

new community, which having no strong principle of cohesion may, at any

time lose its individuality in the individuality of any of the surrounding

communities, that may happen to possess a greater vitality than itself. But

there is, perhaps a still more important reason for the necessity of a Muslim

University in India. You know that the ethical training of the masses of our

community is principally in the hands of a very inefficient class of Moulvies

or public preachers, the range of whose knowledge of Muslim history and

literature is extremely limited. A modern public teacher of morality and

religion must be familiar with the great truths of history, economics and

sociology besides being thoroughly conversant with the literature and thought

of his own community. Such public teachers are the great need of the times.

The Nadwa, the Aligarh College, the theological Seminary of Dewband, and

other institutions of a similar type, working independently of one another,

cannot meet this pressing demand. All these scattered educational forces

should be organised into a central institution of a large purpose which may

afford opportunities not only for the development of special abilities, but may

also create the necessary type of culture for the modern Indian Muslim. A

purely Western ideal of education will be dangerous to the life of our

794The Muslim Community

Page 493: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

community if it is to continue as an essentially Muslim community. It is

therefore absolutely necessary to construct a fresh educational ideal in which

the elements of Muslim culture must find a prominent place, and past and the

present commingle in a happy union. The construction of such an ideal is not

an easy task; it requires a large imagination, a keen perception of the

tendencies of modern times, and a complete grasp of the meaning of Muslim

history and religion.

Before leaving this point, I think, I ought to say a few words on the

education of the Muslim woman. This is not a place to discuss the ideal of

womanhood in Islam. I must, however, frankly admit that I am not an

advocate of absolute equality between man and woman. It appears that Nature

has allotted different functions to them, and a right performance of these

functions is equally indispensable for the health and prosperity of the human

family. The so called "emancipation of the Western woman" necessitated by

Western individualism, and the peculiar economic situation produced by an

unhealthy competition, is an experiment, in my opinion, likely to fail, not

without doing incalculable harm, and creating extremely intricate social

problems. Nor is the higher education of women likely to lead to any

desirable consequences in so far as the birth rate of a community is

concerned. Experience has already shown that the economic emancipation of

women in the West has not, as was expected, materially extended the

production of wealth. On the other hand it has a tendency to break up the

unity of the family, which is an exceedingly important factor in the psychical

life of society. Now I am ready to recognise that the evolution of society by

resident forces alone is impossibility in modern times. The almost total

annihilation of space and time has produced a close contact among the

various communities of the world, a contact that is likely to affect the natural

orbit of some and to prove disastrous to others. What the larger economic,

social and political forces that are now working in the world will bring about,

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^894

Page 494: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

nobody can foretell; but we must remember that while it is advisable, and

even necessary for a healthy social change, to assimilate the elements of an

alien culture, a hasty injudicious jump to alien institutions may lead to most

abrupt structural disturbance in the body?social. There is an element of

universality in the culture of a people; their social and political institutions,

on the other hand, are more individual. They are determined by their peculiar

tradition and life-history, and cannot be easily adopted by a community

having a different tradition and life?history. Considering then the peculiar

nature of our community, the teaching of Islam, and the revelations of

Physiology and Biology on the subject, it is clear that the Muslim women

should continue to occupy the position in society which Islam has allotted to

her. And the position which has been allotted to her must determine the

nature of her education. I have tried to show above that the solidarity of our

community rests on our hold on the religion and culture of Islam. The woman

is the principal depositary of the religious idea. In the interests of a

continuous national life, therefore, it is extremely necessary to give her, in the

first place, a sound religious education. That must, however, be supplemented

by a general knowledge of Muslim-History, domestic economy, and hygiene.

This will enable her to give a degree of intellectual companionship to her

husband and to successfully do the duties of motherhood, which, in my

opinion, is the principal function of the woman. All subjects which have a

tendency to de?womanise and to de?Muslmise her, must be carefully

excluded from her education. But our educationists are still groping in the

dark. They have not yet been able to prescribe a definite course of study for

our girls; and some of them are, unfortunately too much dazzled by the

glamour of Western ideals to realise the difference between Islam which

constructs nationality out of a purely abstract idea, i.e. religion, and

Westernism which builds nationality on an objective basis i.e. country.

I shall now proceed to offer a few remarks on the improvement of the

994The Muslim Community

Page 495: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

general condition of the masses of our community. And in this connection the

first point of importance is the economic condition of the average Muslim. I

am sure nobody will deny that the economic condition of the average Muslim

is extremely deplorable. His small wage, dirty house and under?fed children

are a matter of common observation in the towns where the population is

mostly Muslim. Pass through a Muslim street in Lahore; what do you find?

An old silent gloomy street whose mournful quite is relieved by the shrieks of

ill?clad bony children or by the subdued entreaties of an old woman in Pardah

spreading out her skinny hand for alms. This is not all. Inside these unhappy

dwellings there are hundreds of men and women whose fathers have seen

better days, but who are now compelled to starve without ever opening their

lips for appeals to charity. It is really this poverty of the lower strata of our

community and not the Pardah system, as our young protagonists of social

reform sometimes contend, that is reacting on the general physique of our

community. Besides this class there is the absolutely incapable who brings

into the world children as incapable as himself, and by surrendering himself

to laziness and crime spreads the contagion of these vices to others. Have we

ever given a thought to these aspects of the social problem? Have we ever

realised that the duty of our Anjumans and leagues is to work for the

elevation of the masses and not to push up the individuals? The most

important problem before the Muslim public worker is how to improve the

economic conditions of his community. It is his duty to make a careful study

of the general economic situation in India and the causes, which have brought

it about. How much of this situation is due to the larger economic forces that

are working in the modern world, how much to the historical antecedents,

customs, prejudices and ethical short comings of the people of this land, how

much, if at all, to the policy of the Government; these are the questions

which, in preference to other questions, must occupy his brains. The problem

will, of course, have to be approached in a broad impartial non?sectarian

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^005

Page 496: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

spirit; since the economic forces affect all communities alike. The

ever?increasing land?revenue, the importation of foreign drink into country,

or the rise of prices, whether it is due to a wrong currency policy or the

establishment of free?trade between an agricultural country and a

manufacturing country or to any other cause-these things affect the economic

condition of Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs and Parsees all alike, and loudly

proclaim that the public workers of all the various communities can, at least,

meet on the common ground of economic discussion. The Muslim public

worker however has hitherto concentrated almost all his energies on the point

of securing our due share in Government Service. The effort is certainly

laudable, and he must continue to work until we have achieved our object.

But he must remember that Government Service as a field for the production

of wealth is extremely limited. It offers prospects of economic elevation only

to a few individuals; the general health of a community depends largely on its

economic independence. There is no doubt that a few individuals in the

higher branches of Government Service give a tone of honour and

self?respect to the whole community; but it is equally true that there are other

spheres of economic activity which are equally important and more profitable.

The process of change and adjustment to an economic ideal is certainly

painful to a people whose tradition have been in the main, military, yet in

view of the change that is coming over the communities of Asia, principally

through the economic energy of western nations, the ordeal must be gone

through. Besides working for the removal of economic disabilities, if any, we

must have a system of technical education, which is, in my opinion, even

more important, than higher education. The former touches the general

economic condition of the masses which form the back bone of a community,

the latter only a few individuals who happens to possess more than average

intellectual energy. The charity of the wealthier classes among us must be so

organised as to afford opportunities of a cheap technical education to the

105The Muslim Community

Page 497: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

children of the community. But industrial and commercial training alone is

not sufficient. In economic competition the ethical factor plays an equally

important part. The virtues of thrift, mutual trust, honesty, punctuality and

co?operation are as much valuable economic assets as professional skill. How

many economic undertakings have failed in India through want of mutual

trust and a proper spirit of co?operation. If we want to turn out good working

men, good shopkeepers, good artisans and above all good citizens, we must

first make them good Muslims.

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^205

Page 498: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÂÒ]ÂÁ Z³:

g‚bzZ¶gZ] [:

!iðO�Z]ZzgNÒu4è EG `:

),·èoZzgc��Z/ �:),·ó£á {:

305ÂÒ]

Page 499: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^405

Page 500: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

1C ÂÁ : Z³

Ô%A:Ýx��gæXZ�Zg{Z�á®Qg�z©gW!��ÁÔ4491Y �$^…ô]Îf^Ù m

Ô�zx:eZË·!ŒÛX)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ8891YX ]uç]Ùæ�$^…ô]Îf^Ù m

F¹Z�[Ñ�gÔ7691Y è :eZ˱†ZvX> ]�en^lôÊ^…‰oÚn6aß‚æ¨7Ò^u’ä m

:gæ�{VXDZ»�ò�‹Ô4791Y ]ö…�æ]Ú¡ m

:º[-ãzg;Ñ�gÔ8691Y ¢3 ]ö…�æ�]ñ†åÚÃ^…Íô]‰¡Únä m

:gæ�{VX�Ye�5�‹Ô5791Y ]ö…�æÒnŠ1ÖÓãn6 m

:eZËZ1GâgZ−+XZDwZ»�ò0Îy™ZcÔ9591Y ]‰¡Úoi’çÍ]æ…]Îf^Ù m

:eZË·œ&(XÂ[%œßW!�Ô7791Y )Qg�z( ]�^…mäÒ¡Ý]Îf^Ù m

Ô%A:·aZ/�’~X��+z�Zø!é7gÔ0591Y ]‘¡u^lô]Îf^Ù m

:eZËàkZ£E~X£Qg�z�à-ãzg;�‹ ]ö‘çÙivÏnÐæi†ingÚjà m

:Zi¾HÔáW:MYZ−+Z£'ãXZDwZ»�ò™ZcÔ6591Y ]Îf^Ù m

:ñß~Z£�+XZsðZM6öÑ�gÔ6291Y ]Îf^Ù m

:eZË·dZ−+XZDwZ»�ò0Îy™Zc ]Îf^Ù]Ò^�Úo(Ò^…+ˆ]…p]æ…Úß’çe1 m

:~*BWiZ�XZ�Zg{Z/Qg�zZ[W!�Ô0691Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…]ŒÒ^Â`‚ m

:·ð�á@XÃ{:Z³×eZsxÑ�gÔ6791Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…]ÞrÛàuÛ^mk]‰¡Ý m

:4©~XZDwZ»�ò0Îy™ZcÔ3791Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…eãçµ^Ù m

:·ð�á@X�ig,Ñ�gÔ7791Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…µßr^hÒçÞŠØ m

:eZË�i�X>F¹Z�[Ñ�gÔ3791Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…Âf‚]ÖvÐ m

´)ZDwÅ£?Å]Z�áoVÅ,e�1~�~Yg�ìÔZka<~èÃg 1DÂÁikÃÂÒ]~�áï7ÅIX

505ÂÒ]

Page 501: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:eZË·gcnXZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7791Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…Ê^…‰o�Æ] m

:·Z£{VXZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7791Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…ÚŠò×äiÃ×nÜ m

:~*BWiZ�X�YeÔ5�‹Ô5791Y ]Îf^Ù]æ…ÚdžeoÚËÓ†mà m

:eZËpZz†Z?²ÃãXZDwZ»�ò0Îy™ZcÔ7591Y ]m†]Þnç7ÒoÞ¿†Ún6 D ]Îf^Ù m

:Y'Z¦X)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ5891Y ]mÔÚ_^ÖÃä D ]Îf^Ù m

Ô%A:·†ZvŒÛ7X)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ6891Y ]Îf^Ùeß^Ý�^� m

:PœjX�YeÔ5�‹Ô0891Y q^�æ+†aß‚pÞ0]� D ]Îf^Ù m

¤�m~Di™ZcÔ3891Y X %A:·�ÛhZ/ q`^áô�m,† D ]Îf^Ù m

ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7991Y X :eZËd�ÛZ¹ 2ß‚Þò1Úf^u& D ]Îf^Ù m

·ð�á@X�éÑ�gÔ5791Y Ô%A: 2ç�â†pÚvÛ‚uŠnàÒoÞ¿†Ún6 D ]Îf^Ù m

�‹ X :«Z%z�~ ìç]inàÒoÞ¿†Ún6 D ]Îf^Ù m

ÿZÍwþ:{−nß°X)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ1791Y �…æáôì^Þä D ]Îf^Ù m

:eZË�Ûâyì7g~XQg�zZ»�ò�|™ZcÔ8791Y ‰gÒ1Ön1 D ]Îf^Ù m

%A:ZºgZ�X)ÄZDwÔÑ�gÔ8791Y ‰nù‚‰×nÛ^áÞ‚æpÒoÞ¿†Ún6( D ]Îf^Ù m

:eZËÝx@fzZ3gX�ì!ÈZ�[Ñ�gÔ8791Y ]Îf^ÙÒ^ƒaßo]…iÏ^ m

:eZË·�+@|Ô%A:ZahŒÛÙX¶XÅÑ�gÔ7791Y ]Îf^ÙÒ^ÊÓ†æÊà m

:·Z£œjX™Zc,v™ZcÔky ]Îf^ÙÒ^Ê׊ËäÿiÃ×nÜ m

�ZgZ¢ZW¥|Ô8491Y X :†Z?x0z~ ]Îf^ÙÒ^ÚØ m

F¹Z�[Ñ�gÔ7791Y è :eZË„�]'w~X> ]Îf^ÙÒo]ö…�æÞ%† m

:eZËpDZ»g~X¢z6ì6ö�Ô8791Y ]Îf^ÙÒoi¡�Ún6 m

:eZË·†Zv,ðX>F¹Z�[Ñ�gÔ7791Y ]Îf^ÙÒo‘vfkÚn6 m

7791Y ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ X eZˆZ,gZ� : ]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰o�^†pÒ^ißÏn‚pq^ñˆå m

:eZˆZ/XNh7gÔTàÔ�y7gÔ9691Y ]Îf^ÙÒ1]ej‚]ño]ÊÓ^… m

:¬Ô@Jß~XZDwZ»�ò0Îy™ZcÔ1691Y ]Îf^ÙÒ1�ì†p�æ‰^Ù m

:·Z£œjXWw0ÎyZ�å»Ð÷™ZcÔ5691Y ]Îf^ÙÒ1iÃ×nÛoÞ¿†m^l m

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^605

Page 502: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:±zikZd¬$~XZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7791Y ]Îf^ÙÒ1�ÆpÚ«ì„ m

Ô%A:‡èZahŒÛÙX�ú�tÑ�gÔ8791Y ]Îf^ÙÒ1ÚÛ‚æ|Â×Û^ð m

:ZöZ**iX�ÝxZZhÜÑ�gÔÿ7791Yþ ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜ‘Ën† m

Ô%A:™'³gz~X�2Ñ�gÔ5891Y ]Îf^ÙÒ1aÜÞ�nà m

Ô%A:lZr��]X@`v�ÔÑ�gÔky ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä m

ÿq¢~Z�á®þ:�«YZvXZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�g5002Y ]Îf^ÙÞ^Úä m

6002Y %A:eZËZÜtZWX¤gtXÅÔÈ0wÔ1891YÔ�zx:0991YÔÎx: ]Îf^ÙÞ^Ú1( m

:ÝxgÎw$)%A:ZëÐE~(Ô$ÜÑ�gÔ8891Y ]Îf^Ön^l m

:‡èZ£xVZº�*¥SXZDwZ»�ò0Îy™ZcÔ5691Y ]Îf^Ön^lÒ^ißÏn‚pq^ñˆå m

Z�ZXÅÑ�gÔ2991Y X :eZËg<Z−+;× ]Îf^Ön^io]�hÒ1inà‰^Ù m

‰[DiÔÑ�gÔ0991Y X :g<Z−+;× ]Îf^Ön^ioq^ñˆc m

:eZËGZº�gZãX9ziÜÑ�gÔ9991Y ]Îf^Ùmç…¸Ún6 m

:eZËÝx@fzZ3gX�¬DÑ�gÔ7791Y ]Òf†]æ…]Îf^Ù m

:{y·�g%iZÎyZ£X%[ZàÑ�gÔ9191Y ]Öß¿† m

:M±z©Z−+XÑíWg^6ö™Zc ]ÞrÛà m

%A:g°j�á�XZsîXÅÔÑ�gÔ5791Y ]æ…]Ñô+Ü+�jä( m

:·ëgXZ-ZÈZ�[™ZcÔ7791Y ]mÏ^áô]Îf^Ù m

ZDw™ZcÔ1591Y è Ô%A:±†ZßZugX> e^În^lô]Îf^Ù m

:±†ZßZugÔ·†ZvŒÛ7XWsZ�[Ñ�gÔ8791Y "54èGEGE%Ô e^În^lô]Îf^Ù m

:eZËz©ŒÛ7XZ�åZ'.3ð GFg*Ñ�gÔ2891Y µ^ÒŠj^áÒoÞ¿†m^ioeßn^�m6 m

:eZËÝx@fzZ3gX]hQg�zNU6öÑ�gÔ2691Y i^…mî]æ…mß9ØÒ^Ös m

:¬Ô@Jß~XWcZ�[Ñ�gÔ9691Y 2ß‚m^�m62ß‚iª$†]l m

:eZË-Š@{VX¸ZOa�‹Ô7791Y u^ÊÀ]æ…]Îf^Ù m

ÔáW:"Z£ÑzZãXZ*zYZv{VÑ�g u†Íô]Îf^Ù m

:·†ZvŒÛ7X)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ1891Y un^l]Îf^ÙÒo+Ü�‚åÒ<m^7 m

705ÂÒ]

Page 503: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:ÿlZr��]þ@`v�Ñ�gÔÿ8391Yþ un^lô]Îf^Ù m

:·¢yX�]hÑ�gÔ5791Y un^lô]Îf^ÙÒ^]mÔq„e^io�æ… m

:´)ZDwÔáW:a�O~·@X;'Z�giÑ�gÔ3291Y ì¡Êkô]‰¡Únä m

:�Z£¼qX@`vÑ�gÔ3491Y ÔzZÍw ìç7e`^ m

:†ZØ‚´X)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ5591Y ƒÒ†ô]Îf^Ù m

:eZË·†Zv,ðX>F¹Z�[Ñ�gÔ7791Y …æ]m^lô]Îf^Ù m

:%û·†ZvŒÛ7XZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7791Y …æ|ÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ù m

:M¦z©Z−+XÑíMg6ö™ZcÔÑ�gÔTZÍw:âÞ4691YÔT�zx:Z~5691Y …æ‡+^…ÊÏn† m

:eZˆZ?²ÃãX»âÈcÄéZyÔÿ3591Yþ …æÚoôÂ’† m

:ÿZÍwþYzhZDwX�ÝxZZhÜÑ�gÔ9791Y ‡Þ‚å…æ� m

:ÿ�zxþYzhZDwX�ÝxZZhÜÑ�gÔ1891Y ‡Þ‚å…æ� m

:eZˆZ?xpgæXZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7791Y ‰†+„�k]Îf^Ù m

591Y X�ÝxZZhÜÑ�gÔ9 :ÝxgÎw$Ô™�tZ�Ñzg~ "54èGEGE%Ô :´)ZDw ‰†æ�ô…Êjä m

:Ú{Ãgz¹X�£g™ZcÔ3791Y ‰Ë†Þ^Úäÿ]Îf^Ù m

:±Ñy0z~X%Z»�ò©gW!��ÁÔ7491Y ‰n†]ÊÇ^ÞŠj^á m

:·¤CÙÃgz¹XòÃ{:Ñ�gÔ9391YÔ4491YÔ9491YÔ8791Y ‰n†lô]Îf^Ù m

2791Y F¹Z�[Ñ�gÔ è ´)ZDwÔáW:eZËZ�gZ£œjX> : �„…]lôÊÓ†]Îf^Ù m

:ñß~·lZrXZsðM6öÑ�gÔÿ7291Yþ �†|�ñnßäÿÂrÜ m

:´)ZDwX%[ZàÑ�gÔky �Óçå m

ß°†Z°æE™ZcÔ3791Y X :±�x@Q~ �Óçå]Îf^Ù]æ…]ŒÒo‘‚]ce^‡+�k m

:ciZ�{·†Z+mX�Z*cZ`Z−+Z£Z%<Ô5191Y „…ô�Óçå m

Ô%A:IbZ/œjX�ÛqyDiÑ�gÔ7791Y ]µßç7ÒoÞ¿†Ún6 D ¡Úä]Îf^Ù m

:·ëgXZ-ZÈQg�z™ZcÔ7791Y ¡Úä]Îf^ÙÒoÊ^…‰oƈ٠m

Ô%A:†Z°[ŒÛ7X"5½è EGE�Ñ�gÔ0002Y �^åÒ^…ì_ç½ 101 ¡Úä]Îf^ÙÒ1 m

:цZÔX)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ7591Y ÊÓ†ô]Îf^Ù m

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^805

Page 504: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:Z1·�X_5ëEYLéXÅÑ�gÔ9691Y Ά�á]æ…]Îf^Ù m

:´)ZDwXWsZ�[Ñ�gÔ0791Y ÎçÚo‡Þ‚+o]æ…Ú×kôen–^µ†]mÔÂÛ†]ÞoÞ¿† m

Ô%A:g<Z−+;×XZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7791Y Òj^en^lô]Îf^Ù m

î� è Z_gZ�%œ X :eZËœ&(ÔeZË·gcn "54èGEGE%Ô Ò�Ì]Ÿen^l]Îf^Ù m

ÃgÏÔZsxW!�Ô7791Y:eZËz©ŒÛ7X�Z�[]hÑ�gÔ3791Y Ò¡‰nÓo]�hÒ^ivÏnÏoÚ_^ÖÃä m

:Z�å,;îkÔZ¥|Ô5791Y Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù]ö…�æ m

Ô%A:Z£uzlXÂ[{:‹ðéZyÔT�zxÔ3791Y Ò×n^lô]Îf^ÙÊ^…‰o m

Ô%A:ñß~·†Z°iZtXq�6ö©gW!��ÁÔÿ4291Yþ Ò×n^lô]Îf^Ù m

%A:¡@'ãXQg�zZ»�ò�‹ÔZÍw@XgxXZ�á® Ò×n^lôÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ù( m

ZZnK:9891YÔ1991YÔ3991YÔ8991YXÔ%A:2kZ£XQg�zZ»�ò·zw7gÔÿ3691Yþ Ò×n‚ô]Îf^Ù m

:ñÑ*�9ziZ−+Z£&ZðXÒñÑjVZ%<Ôky ÖŠ^á]ÖÇng m

:ÒZ°ÝÃgz¹XZ³F¹Qg�zy5�‹Ô3002Y ÖÇ^lô…æ‡Ú†å m

Ô%A:eZ˱†ZvXZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ7791Y ÚjÃ×Ï^lôì_f^lô]Îf^Ù m

:{y·�gciZ�{¡Z£�Xa@-hà�‹Ô8191Y Ú%ßçp…]‡ôe1ìç�p m

:eZË¥Z−+ÕX-ŠzÑ™ZcÔ2691Y Ú%ßçp‰†ù]Ÿ‰†]… m

eZË‚]Zv�X=wZOaÑ�gÔ9791Y 1Z¹gÔ%A: Ú%ßçpÚÆæÍeä+Øæe×fØ m

:aZvgŸXZ³gzZ*�Û°ZkZyz0ÎyÔéZyÔ3791Y ÚvÛ‚]Îf^Ù m

:ÝxgÎw$X�ÝxZZhÜÔÑ�gÔ9691Y Ú_^Ög]‰†]…æ…Úç‡ m

:·†ZvŒÛ7X>F¹Z�[Ñ�gÔ7791Y ]Îf^ÙÒoÞ¿†Ún6 D ÚÃ^‘†mà m

±†ZßZug+·†ZvŒÛ7XMsZ�[Ñ�gÔT�zxÔ8891Y "54èGEGEÊ ´)ZDwÔ% ÚÏ^Ÿlô]Îf^ÙV m

:ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔT�zxÔ6891YÔTÎx:)Ä ÚÓ^ing]Îf^Ùeß^Ýì^áÞn^‡]Ö‚màì^7 m

ZDwÑ�gÔ5991YXTXgxÔ%A:†Zv�á{;×XZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÑ�gÔ6002YÔ%A:Zg”ú�*�á�XZ�Ò]Ñ�gÔ9002Y ÚÓ^ing…�n‚uŠàì^7eß^Ý…ÊnÄ]Ö‚màa^�Ûo m

905ÂÒ]

Page 505: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

%A:.gç~XZ�Zg{î� ÚÓ^ing‰†ÚvÛ‚]Îf^Ùeß^ÝÚçŸÞ^‰nù‚‰×nÛ^áÞ‚æp( m

Z°gz�k�ç™ZcÔ2991YÔ%A:U�%XZ߇gXÅÑ�gÔ8991Y ÚÓjçe^lô]Îf^Ùeß^Ý2ç�â†pÚvÛ‚uŠnà m

:)ÄZDwÑ�gÔky Úß�ç…]l]Îf^Ù m

eZËÔgŸX±îZ−+©gW!� : un^l]æ…]�eoì‚Ú^l D Ú`^…]q^‰†Ò�െ�^��^� m

�ÁÔ8791Y:6zW·ëgX-ãzg;,e7Ñ�gÔ2791Y Únˆ]áô]Îf^Ù m

:eZËYzhZDwX�ÝxZZhÜÑ�gÔ2791Y Ú1ÿŸÖäÊ^Ý m

)Zi�u†ZØ�g(Ô%A:·ð�á@X)ÄZDwÑ�gÔ2791Y Þ„…ô]Îf^Ù m

Ô%A:¤t@@`XZ£t6ö©gW!��ÁÔ8391Y 0191Y Þ¿Ü]Îf^Ù(‰Ë†un‚…�e^��Òà m

:eZËzikW¸X�÷~Ñ$k~Ñ�gÔ4791Y Þ¿Üq‚m‚ÒoÒ†æ:n6 m

8391Y Ô%A:¤t@@`XZ³Z�á®Qg�z©gW!��ÁÔ Þ¿Ü‰¶^Œqß^h]Ún†]æ…�扆pÞ¿Ûn6 m

:oZºM!�~X�Ye�‹Ô3591YX ÞÏ‚ô]Îf^Ù m

:±†ZßZugXWsZ�[Ñ�gÔ9691Y ÞÏ�ô]Îf^Ù m

:†ZØ‚´X�"yÑ�gÔ5591Y m^…]áôÒ`à m

Ô%A:Ýx@™ÄAö´òXX{,¬C«ðéZyÔ0691Y mÔ2Ûàô+Ø m

ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔÑ�gÔ6891Y X :g<Z−+;× Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 5891Y m

ZDwZ»�ò0ÎyÔÑ�gÔ8891Y X :g<Z−+;× Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 6891Y m

m A Bibliography of Iqbal: K.A. Waheed, Iqbal Academy Karachi, 1965.m A History of Government College Lahore, 1864-1964: Garette and Abdul

Hamid, Lahore, 1964.m Bibliography of Iqbal: Abdul Ghani and Nur Ilahi, Bazm-i-Iqbal, Lahore, 1954.m Dictionary of National Biography: Vol: 30, Oxford Universty Press, 1937.m Discourses of Iqbal: Edited by Shahid Hussain Razzaqi, Iqbal Academy ,

Lahore 1979.m Iqbal: Attiya Begum, Aaeena-i-Adab, Lahore, 1969.m Iqbal in Pictures: Faqir Sayed Waheed-ud-Din, Lion Art Press Karachi, 1965.

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^015

Page 506: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

m Iqbal's Educational Philosophy: K.G. Sayyedain, Sh. Mohammad Ashraf,Lahore, n.d.

m Islam as an Ethical and Political Ideal: Edited by Dr. S. Y. Hashmy,Islamic Book Service Lahore, 1977.

m Mohammedan Theories of Finance: Nicholas P. Aghindes, ColumbiaUniversity, New York, 1910.

m My Reminiscences: M.S. Toosy, Karachi, 1976.m Persian Psalms: Arthur J. Arbery, Muhammad Ashraf Lahore, 1948.m Quaid-i-Azam as Seen by His Contemporaries: Compiled by Jamil-ud-Din

Ahmad, Publishers, United Lahore, 1966.m Stray Reflections: Allama Muhammad Iqbal, Edited by: Javid Iqbal, Sh.

Ghulam Ali, Lahore, 1987. Iqbal Academy Pakistan, Lahore, 1992.Revised and Annotated By: Khuram Ali Shafique, Iqbal AcademyPakistan, Lahore, 2006.

m The Reconstruction of Religious thought in Islam: Allam MuhammadIqbal, Edited and Annotated by: M. Saeed Shiekh, Iqbal AcademyPakistan+ Institute of Islamic Culture, Lahore, 1986.

m The Sword and Sceptre: Edited by Dr. Riffat Hassan, Iqbal AcademyLahore, 1977.

m Tributes to Iqbal: Edited by Muhammad Hanif Shahid, Sang-i-MeelPublications, Lahore, 1977.

ðýýðýýð

g‚bzZ¶gZ] :[

:22BZ6s5591Y ¡W!� �‡]�Ò�Ûn† m

:Z6s5691Y Ñ�g �ñnßä m

:ZDw�Ô¢2ÔÑg{11ÿ8791Yþ ?zg ]uŠ^Œ m

:�ÑðZÆ'0691YÔZDw�ÔTÎx7791Y ™Zc ]ö…�æ m

:�c8791Y Ñ�g ]ö…�æJ]ñrŠ8 m

115ÂÒ]

Page 507: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:âga2891Y Zc™ ]ÊÓ^… m

:ZDw�2Ô7791Y ·zw7g ]Öˆen† m

:ZÆ'3591YÔZ6s4591YÔZÆ'5591YÔZÆ'7591YÔ�g~8691YÔ�Ñð Ñ�g ]Îf^Ù m

m1791YÔ�g~4791YZcÔÑ�g:�Ñð1691YÔ�Ñð2691YÔ�g~4691YÔ�g~9691YÔ�g~ ™ ]Îf^Ù…mçmçV m

6791YÔZDw��ÑðÔZÆ'7791YÔ�Ñð8791YÔ�Ñð9791Y:22Z6s9491Y Ñ�g ]Ú†æ‡ m

:7291YZzg2391YƼ�Ñg} Ñ�g ]ÞÏ¡h m

:ZDw�7791YÔZDw�1891Y Ñ�g ]æ…mß9ØÒ^ÖsÚn,ˆmà m

:ZDw�7791Y ™Zc e†.ô+Ø m

:�c0691Y �‹ e†a^á m

1D :¢ZÍwÔÑg{2 YxØgz �|-ãzg; ivÏnÐ m

:ZDwZec2791YÔZ6s3791Y gZzf~ qß- m

:ZDwZecZ6s4791YÔZDwZecâÞ7791Y ™Zc qß- m

:02�g~7791YÔ02m7791YÔ22�y8791Y ßy qß- m

:�121Ôm0002YÔ ` ì‚]eí�q†ÞØ m

:ZDw�4791Y Ñ�g …]æp m

:3291YZzg7291YƼ�Ñg} Ñ�g ‡Únß‚]… m

:�g~@âga8791Y Ñ�g ‰çm†] m

:ZÆ'âÞ4891YÔZDw�2991Y Ñ�g ‰n^…å m

:ZDw�Ñg{3Ô4Ô5Ô6 u~ô �n†]‡å m

:ZDw�ZÍwÔZÆ'3791YÔ�zxâÞ�c7791YÔ�g~�Ûzg~8791Y Ñ�g ‘vnËä m

:ZDw�3791Y uÍ�J •n^e^… m

:Z6s5791YÔâÞ7791YÔZ6s0891Y Ñ�g •n^cu†Ý m

:Z6s3591Y ™Zc Ê^…]á m

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^215

Page 508: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

:ZDw��c7791Y Ñ�g Êßçá m

:ZDw��g~8791Y gZzf~ Ên˜]Ÿ‰¡Ý m

:âÞ8791Y Ñ�g ÎçÚoJ]ñrŠ8 m

:Z6s5791YÔZ6s9791Y ™Zc ÎçÚo‡e^á m

:Z6s#3691Y �~ Ò†�]…Þç m

:ZDw�Z6s0791Y Ñ�g Ú^åôÞç m

:¢1ÔÑg{1Ô2 Ñ�g Úr×ùäivÏnÐ m

:m2091YÔZÆ'3091YÔ�c4091YÔ�g~5091YÔâga5091Y Ñ�g Úíˆá m

:Z~8391YÔm8391Y ZW¥| ÚÃ^…Í m

:�y0591Y �‹ Úß^�p m

:m7691YÔèo�ZÍwÔZ6s#8691YÔZDw�1Ôm7791YÔZDw�2 Ñ�g ÞÏç� m

�c7791YÔÑg{�041ÿ3991Yþ:ZDw�2591Y uÍ�J Þçm‚‘fx m

:ZDw�âÞ�c7791Y Ñ�g aÜ…]‡ m

m Islamic Education, Lahore: Jan. Feb. 1975.m Journal of Research, P.U. Lahore: Jan 1976, July 1977, Jan. 1978.m Journal of Research Society of Pakistan, Lahore: October 1977.

ðýýðýýð

!iðO�Z]ZzgNÒu4è EG )`(

¢�)ZDwñi*Ñ�gÅ�àâ] •†hôÒ×nÜ A/M- 1977-193 )1(Òn�Ôå e^Ùôqf†mØ A/M- 1977- 118 )2(!iðO�{�

ºtQg�zZzgÃgϯx A/M- 1977- 195 )3(Òn�]‰†]…ôìç�p Z’Zð!iðO�{ A/M- 1977- 198 )4(Òn�

315ÂÒ]

Page 509: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

…Úç‡ôe1ìç�p !iðO�{ A/M- 1977- 199 )5(Òn�µ‹2äe^m‚Ò†� !iðO�{ A/M- 1977- 200 )6(!iðO�{�

ÚŠ^ʆ Zzg ‡eç…ôÂrÜ Ô e^Ùôqf†mØ Ô e^Þ-ô�…]Ð µn^ÝôÚ�†Ñ źtàâ]Ô�âp

0Zôm~Z�ágZ]

A/M- 1977- 201 )7(Òn�

]‰†]…ôìç�p åz�{ A/M- 1977- 203 )8(z�{�»ºt¯x e^Ùôqf†mØ Zzg e^Þ-ô�…] )9(Òn6��g`7

źtàâ] e^Þ-ô�…] )01(Òn6��g`7‰†]…ôìç�p ] å!iðO�{ )11(!iðO�{6��g`7

The Muslim Community A/M- 1977- 208 )21(!iðO�{�

),·èoZzgc��ZÇ :z

´)ZDwƼ�),·èo )Z³(aZ£eZgÔ�·ZÑsÔ±2k*i~ÔeZË·†Zv,ðÔ·†ZvŒÛ7Zzg )[(

"Z£ÑzZãƼ�èoÔ¯xg<Z−+;×X±2k*i~Ô�·ZÑsÔeZË·†Zv,ðZzg�*iZ£Ð5‡ÂVÅfZCc��ZÇX )`(

),·ó£á :{

'Z} :$�Ò3¨éG

GG]jZÙZi·œ&;ÿsi~þÔ E]ö…�æ)]Þ,†mˆpD ]Îf^ÙIq`^áô�m,† )1(Z*…ZD1]Ô´)ZDwZz6-ãzg;ÔZsxM!�Ôÿ6991Yþ

:U�%Ô'Z}Z*Z}Qg�zÔ Â¡Úä]Îf^Ù]æ…2ç�â†pÚvÛ‚uŠnàE…æ]e¼D )2(Zzg@»ÒÔÑ�gÔ3891YX

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^415

Page 510: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Z�ágt%A:‡Ìú�Z£

1DtZ�ágt™31@924Ã�ìXZk~¼*Ô&�âaVZzgQÂ[ìjZÙz$�Ò3¨é G

GG]ÆjZá�áï�X2DZ�ágb~Z�}gYwÔÃÔg‚bzZ¶gZ]ÔZâÁZzg(ÔdÔóZzgZ�á�Z�ZgzVÆjZá�áïK��X

Z�ágt7H�X è ´)ZDw»*x½ãCÙÔ6Wg;ì®ZZk»jZ!�U�áï 3D4D�VZzgaÝwÆjZá�áï7K�X

515ÂÒ]

Page 511: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Z¾mW�ôP:141Ô341Ô981Wg'~Ô6zW:001Wg&Óå EHÔ6zW:54Ô84Ô35Ô501Ô542Ô292Ô

692Ô403Ô603Ô703Ô013Ô404WiZ�ÔZ1Zæx:413WiZ�Ô·@:214Ô614Wig:27Ô911Ô151Ô161Ô561Ô771Ô881Ô981Ô

191Ô591Ô012Wë[Z£{VÔ™ñZ�{:732Wë[ZûÔeZË:43Wë[ZDw:71Ô81Ô004Wí6í:112Ô'×h�&À�/õ GGZ&4k54è GEIGGE

Z'Z�á:814Z'Z�ðÔ|]:56Ô021Ô731Ô124Z'Z�ð:213Z'Z�÷(ÈK:19Z+:37Ô371

ºzy:913 è Z0g”:913 è Z0

¹:914 è Z0Z1ZÎœj:293Ô493Z1ZMgx:�&À�/õ GG·†Z?xÐZ1fgñ:231Z1;†ZßZu:91Z1�:381Z1·�:822

Z�âgCÙz~:912Z£@{VÔ{y:44Ô54Z£{VÔu�Zg÷:952Z£�+zVÔñß~;44Ô55Z£Ôu�ZgZ*!:732Z£uzl:602Z£¼q0�áÔ�:33Ô14Ô34Ô54Ô05Ô35Ô

904ÔÔ314Ô514Ô614Z£�:622Z£¬Ô±:314Z£xVZº�*¥S:392Z£âZio:563ZºZûY:453Ô183ZºgZ„:43Ô671Ô922Ô572ZºèZã:732ZºÔâ7:62

572 D ZÜtZW:71Ô62Ô06Ô922Ô372Z�d™':914Zg”ÍgÇãÔ%iZ:34Ô44Ô493Z‡Mã:19

56Ô58 ð: ZuZ>ÿ9»*xþ:38 ð ZuZL

ZÅÞZ`7g~:473Ô004Z�³÷_:514ZÑs@:314ZÑsZ{VÔ™riZ�{÷:222ZûZgzkÔñÑ*:44Ô413Zׄk:842Ô352

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^615

Page 512: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

93Ô 81Ô93Ô15Ô812Ô032Ô172Ô7 ZÚiZ£Ô�:893Ô404

ZÚiJß~:182ZÚi@:314ZW™-~:614

ÔæÑk8:413 i Z‘45å EEGZŒgZ£œjÔeZË:43Ô273ZŒgZ−+Z£Ô{y:042ZŒgZ−+ÔM±:44Zf÷_:614ZahŒÛÙÔ‡è:43Ô373Ô083Z#îy:701Ô711Ô031Zºÿ÷{þ:124ZºZ[W!�~:15Ô201Ô801Ô351Ô522Ô652Ô

852Ô214Ô614Zº©g~:71Ô81Ô55Ô842Zº©g~»ª~ÔeZË:692Zºg×ã:62Ô542ZºZ{V²ÙiZ�{:922Z™ZxÔeZËZöZ*:962ZÑÑZ¹:313ZÄB5Ðö EG:�&À�/õ GG†ZÆ*Z

ÄB5Ðö EGZÓkg¶:�&À�/õ GG·œ&ÿZÓkg¶þZ®s@Ô±:293Ô404Zâx!!:301Ô293Z!5ÿG:172ZqÐi·{y:404ZëÐE~:504

ZëZÔ±:583Ô793Z÷jÔpZz:44Z÷jÔ÷:621Z÷Æz:99Z÷�:52Ô112Z÷çztñ:223Z}Z−+Ô�:44Zy�áYZv{VÔñß~:732Ô062Ô782Ô043ZâgZDwŒÛ7:992ZâZgZ/Ô?:472Zâg‡h:43Zâg�á{ÔñÑ*:432Zâg~:914Zâg~H:262Z/�á{�ã:02Z/Ô÷:214Zzg8id¬Ý�ÿ÷{þ:793Ô124Ô324Ô

424Ô824ZizgeÞ:914Z*ZÅ:982Ô583Z\Í:74Z&4k54è GEIGGE:112Ô'×h�&À�/õ GGWí6í!'ÿ÷{þ:114!��á{@Ô±:004!ŒÛZ�Z*yÍ:214!mh:92Ô56$Z$™öG�:914'Z.Ô6zWWg:703

715Z�ágt

Page 513: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

'ZîyÔ6zW:251'Zî):74'µÔYy:523'}V:862Ô573'ãÔ±¡@:71Ô72Ô472Ô082Ô182'iá:051

aZ£:61aZ£eZg:43Ô622Ô742Ô842Ô252Ô352Ô

83 962Ô172Ô392Ô0 D 362Ô462Ô762aZ£ÔxV:362Ô583Ô093Ô393Ô9931Z#:66Ô38Ô9021Z¹g:38Ô201·�gcgkÔâZ[:352Ô452Ô863èZ�:48ËwÔ†ZØ�g:99Ô573Ô493HWg&Óå EH:762Ô272H™/È0w:06Ô56H�«·:93HñÑ*¤Zò:251Ô351Ô062Ô162Hø-V%iZ:872"n�á{:2146z,g¶Ô†ZØ:36Ô76Ô96Ô97Ô321Ô241Ô

861Ô371Ô671Ô081 D 151Ô161Ô261Ô4616*P:214Ô614Bk:902

¡:�&À�/õ GGpZz¥Z−+² ècsy:58Ô'×h�&À�/õ GG©ØP èc

@|ÔeZË·�+:14Ô822Ô052Ô763Ô583Ô093Ô104

@gZP:252+:�&À�/õ GGß°Ýx!{‹§ö

EW+

d�Û¹ÔeZË:12Ô62Ô72Ô932Ô042Ô182Ô282Ô603Ô073Ô573

¤t@@`:732Ô872Ô333Ô043i�á{Ô±:93�uPøzx:452Ô214Ô614àkg¶ÔÕZ£ŒÛ7:52Ô571

×»‰:252Ô452g�:582 èW

ÂÅh4ðG~:112Ô'×h�&À�/õ GGN&ðåé¤}:74å\:952å\ÔZpeÚ603N&ð:112

ãÎy:762Ô793Ô124Ô224Ô424Ô824�Í:74UÜ»y7g~:842Ô352U�%:62Ô362Ô604Y'Z±:121YòÔñÑ*:99Ô203Ymi%iZ:004YzhZDwÿ=)g(þ:72Ô92Ô85Ô17Ô27Ô

47Ô67Ô97Ô08Ô48Ô441Ô571Ô581Ô681Ô781Ô702Ô912Ô062Ô182Ô692Ô

83Ô 303Ô403Ô503Ô733Ô173Ô373Ô0683Ô783Ô293Ô793Ô304Ô604

YzhÜ:182

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^815

Page 514: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

�sð:37<¾8k5é EGã:914Q�aÔ6zW:02Ô783Ô104°wZ−+Ô%iZ:583Ô093

YŠzZð:132)wZ−+Zjã:493)wZ−+Z�ã:914

Âÿ!��á{þ:651Ô851Ô012ÂZgZg:19ÕÔ·:962Õgç~:43ÕŒÛ7:�&À�/õ GGàkg¶¡:92Ô56Ô012�l'W!�~214:�V�z„:001�$ÿ÷{þ:58�$¬Ý:462

¾�Û±jèY

E:114egÖZzw:373lZr��]:481Ô433Ô0047»4iï FEG:314

5ä:58Ô902Ô012qƒèZi~:19Ô49Ô69D99Ô701Ô111Ô711qàÔñÑ*Z®s@:74Ô15Ô822Ô952Ô

214Ô614qæ�÷_:614qæZ{V:27Ô08

ÔZ°×yÑzZã:�&À�/õ GG·ÔZ°×yÑzZã

ÔZ°×y−·â~:413Ô´43ðEGg~:314�]:�&À�/õ GGlZr��]�]ñ;ã:863�ZºÔgZY:304�ZºÔo:82�Z−+Ô÷:732Ô452Ô872Ô113Ô333�cgkÔâZ[:562Ô662@Z£ÿæãþ:96Ô07Ô381Ô983@ñÔZâx:31Ô46Ô56Ô48@8Œ4-öE

GEÔeZË:101@�Zø:914ïƒâg7g~:Ô583hâZi{Vo:02Ô12Ô424�*Ó:172qZ£{VÔ6zW:04Ô27Ô08Ô583Ô093Ô

293Ô393Ô993qZv�á{;×:752Ô062q¬Ý²:614©g™Zgñ:56Ô231Ô471Ô691{−nß°:512Ô193{yZŒgZ−+{V:�&À�/õ GGZŒgZ−+Z£Ô{y{y·�gciZ�{¡Z£˜ŒÛ7œj

&~Wù:801yxZb:373

åð:58åÑ:093цZÔ:49Ô79

915Z�ágt

Page 515: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ÜZÜ:51Ô61ÔÔ6432;×:503Ô603

pZz�Âò:74Ô401Ô412Ô842Ô872Ô303Ô473Ô083Ô214Ô614

pZz™rÿ¸�pZz�Âòþ:632pZz·i™cÔeZË:43Ô182

¡:012 è pZz¥Z−+²ÔcpgæZ£:992pgæZ£Ô6zW:623pgæZ£÷:252Ô452pgægç~:43pÙ·*ø:582Ô314�Zr�Š~:14Ô24Ô44�w·ÔpZz:493�{}Z:914�+·Ô�:072�e:19eZgÔ!Z}:�&À�/õ GGaZ£eZgeZg#Ôu!5ÓÀê G:932Ô513ezgkZ£:912Ô104fZ™@ÔeZË:65fzZ¥îx:012fzZ3gZ£:52fzZ3gZ{VÔâZ[:74Ô652fzZ;gk‚ÑgÔâZ[:871gZ`¢:324gZs@Ô¦:314gZi~:421Ô931Ô491

gZk&�Ôu:86Ô871Ô822Ô922Ô032Ô132Ô232Ô932Ô962Ô472

gZáZ�:52Ô532Ô262Ô272Ô972gZx6�á�ÔÑ!:024Ô224Ô324gZxPgY:58g[âZi{VÔu�Zg:942Ô352g@*Bu�ág:214Ô614g×yÔ=ZöZ}:042Ô142Ô242Ô562Ô

662Ô104gØZvŒÛ7:893Ô993g°jÔpZz:44g°j�á�:152Ô763giZtÔZ}:004g0:831gËÔ'Rh:523gæZ£œj:252Ô452gæ�{V:31D61Ô12Ô42Ô52Ô602Ô112gæŒÛ7:222g<Z−+;×:61Ô02D42Ô62Ô82D03Ô23Ô

53Ô14Ô26Ô36Ô56Ô96Ô07Ô27Ô47Ô08Ô78Ô621Ô241Ô351Ô961Ô371Ô891Ô122Ô222Ô232Ô142Ô542Ô352Ô652Ô472Ô082Ô182Ô782Ô092Ô392Ô003Ô103Ô503Ô703Ô013Ô513Ô713Ô943Ô253Ô263D463Ô873Ô883Ô004Ô424

gzòÔñÑ*:19Ô69Ô89Ô99Ô211Ô821Ô921Ô041Ô451Ô523Ô914

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^025

Page 516: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

gîs0�áÔ¸i~:542gcnZdÔeZË:952izg:�&À�/õ GG[Z−+‡�g~izgidZûY:62Ô82Ô282i+Z°$+ñ:302i+Z°$+Ô%�á{:83‚]a:53‚´:�&À�/õ GG†ZØ‚´_541ºÎæ FGE:393

7ZH:272]45å HEHw:48u±Z£{V:782Ô314Ô514uZ`Z−z!:324Ô424uZ`Z−+Ò:64Ô29Ô252Ô452ÿu�ZgHþ:172

u�ZgQ~ÔZ:35u�Zg·ÔqY:004u�Zg·Ô�:552uzÂ*àz:493u~gZxÔÑ!:44Ä~:65Ô99Ô914GZ#èEEL":421Ô721

D GZº�gZã:81Ô22Ô62Ô72Ô43Ô912Ô303503Ô703Ô013Ô713

\§ZW:28Ô851Ô114sbZ−+·Z1k'ã:792sxÔZ*Z}:203s#ÖZv�á{:342

Îyú�Ô‡è:83Ðÿ¢ã�ÛâVgzZþ:58Ñy0z~Ô±:05Ô69Ô151Ô671Ô522Ô

922Ô332Ô152Ô972Ô413Ô513Ô073ÐDÙZgz~:842‹ðçâ~Ô�:16Ô914�!�si~:104ÎZògZx¾B:64Îg`3Zí$:214

¢/Ô·:22Ô182Ô573ùzuÔZÝ:303±Z£�Š~:314Ô514±i:432_œZgz~:614J�áwÔ�ÛZA:562Ô503�á�ZVìZòÔ±ZzÑ�@:714�á�Ô'gZY¨6�á�:201Ô301Ô501Ô051Ô122Ô

432Ô972Ô792Ô113�á§ægZÏ:19Ô432�áC:753Ô363Ô463Ô663X'×h�&À�/õ GG

"Z£ÑzZã�áyZ/S:182Ô204�á@@giZ¹:863Ô073�á@ð:22

(�ã:74Ô692¼qZ−+·Ô�:34ÑgÔ†Z>:373ÑpÔZ*Z*:272Ô213

125Z�ágt

Page 517: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

-:58ˮZv{V:352

.gç~:572Ã�Zî�~:262Ô472OZ£Ô±:71Ô672ÒZ°×yÃgz¹:822\)ÿI

ÔeZËZ+÷~:013Øgl»ª~:004Øt�w~:842Þ[Z−+Ôu:44Ô54×i�+Ô�:44Ô54h:74

462Ô 22Ô 82Ô43Ô6 D 61Ô91Ô62 ™'³gz~:104 D 182Ô473Ô783Ô993

™�tZ�Ñzg~:47™Ô·Ôñß~:632œ&ñÿZ1–þ:321Ô421Ô931œ&YzhÔ6zW:542(gú�ÔeZË:25&bZ−+Z£:793ß°Ýx½+:882Ô493

762 D MYZ−+Z£'ã:562MYZ−+Ôu:104¤gt:�&À�/õ GG†Z°×y¤gt¤@ZÑs:82Ô604¤Ù·Ôñß~:732¤CÙZ−+ÔÒ:461Ô912Ô782¤CÙ²cVÔ!!:99

¤CÙÃgz¹:392Ô613d~ÔZâx:653³Ô±:413îÏÿ¸�ÂxZ<þ:113îÏÔ·Ñp:�&À�/õ GG·ÑpîÏZ»g~:16 Dp;Z£œj:452;ZdÔeZË:91;Zv{VÔu:513;si~Ô�&À�/õ GG:·œ&;;Z{VÔñÑ*:Ô433Ô833Ô933Ô463Ô

214¼gZ−+{g:032¼g~:914¬$@ÔeZ˱:071¬$gŸËZgÔeZË152¬$Z¬$Ô±:093¬${Î:ÔPZ�~:56Ô871¬Ô@Jß~ÔeZË:65¬Ýp0÷~:35ÿ¬Ý�á{ŒÛ7þ:53

„�]'w~ÔeZË:782Ô433Ô833†Z]‰ÔeZË:56†Z(g�á™:43†Z/ÔeZËñß~:632Ô882†ZÔ¯âg~ÔñÑ*:44Ô54†Z?Ôc:53Ô171†Z?ÔpZz:Ô583Ô783Ô593Ô693

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^225

Page 518: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

†Z°[ŒÛ7:572†Z°[¼:882†Z°9.è WELg~:021Ô121†Z°Ý¤gt:07†Z°Ý¤gtÿáWþ:063Ô663Ô763Ô073†Z°iZtgZ”Ôñß~:55Ô333†Z°æ¤gt:973Ô583Ô093†Z°æÔxV:842

13 †Z?xpgæÔeZË:301Ô051Ô332Ô392Ô6†Z?x0z~:613Ô693†Z,gZ�ÔeZË:99Ô001†Z+m:121†Z+m™�Ô÷:404†Z+mâßZe{:81Ô39Ô59Ô672†ZBgO:443Ô643†ZDÃgzt:43†ZDÔ±:342Ô252Ô392†ZØ�guzg~:44†ZØ�gÔ�u:14Ô24Ô44Ô54Ô84Ô65Ô58Ô

09Ô29Ô39Ô401Ô512Ô932Ô652Ô592Ô413Ô583Ô093Ô393Ô993Ô214Ô614

†ZÁ~Ãã842Ô372†ZéxoÔeZË:304†ZÆ*Z

ÄB5Ðö EG:313Ô133Ô663†Z�Ô±:91†Zv,ð:�&À�/õ GG·†Zv,ð

33 †ZvÔeZ˱·:141Ô752Ô682Ô782Ô7†Zv�á{;×:71Ô62Ô53Ô242Ô342

†Zvq�~:91†ZvŒÛ7:�&À�/õ GG·†ZvŒÛ7†Zv-ŠZÔ´):493†ZÓ]�gc!�~:05Ô004†ZØ‚´:64Ô25Ô901Ô051Ô251Ô351Ô

392Ô613Ô583Ô893†ZØ�S:263†ZØÔxV:973†ZßZuZ*Z}:093

33Ô †ZßZug:25Ô55Ô822Ô352Ô733Ô8143Ô243Ô443Ô063Ô263Ô363Ô963Ô093

†Zß©ÔpZz:94Ô07Ô942Ô052Ô352Ô862Ô392Ô973Ô093Ô504

DiZ»ã:914¢y"ñ:48Ô231²ÙiZ�{:�&À�/õ GGZºZ{V²°:19Ô99³m©~ÔpZz:301‚]g×ã:032Ô152Ô872Ô173

ÓZv:914«·Ô�:81Ô93Ô742Ô403Ô793Ô404«g:99«YZvÔ�:86Ô522Ô622Ô722Ô822Ô332Ô

432Ô832Ô732Ô542Ô842Ô452Ô472¾Hë:94Ô35Ô65Ô39Ô49Ô201Ô022Ô

432Ô832Ô562Ô662Ô762Ô962Ô172Ô272Ô692Ô403Ô503Ô273

325Z�ágt

Page 519: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

xZvÔ�:062FÔeZË¥Z−+:43>Zg@Ô±:314ZZâxÔu±:29Ô901Zj:512Ô612Ô432Ô172Ô504ZìZòÔ±:562ZÒ]:573Z=��Š~:314Zu�ZgQ~:�&À�/õ GGu�ZgQ~q��:914/§]g~Ô6zW:07ÁeZv:621ÁeZvzZgO:53¸Ô%iZ:24Ô65Ô99çZàÔZâx:46Ô113ÝxZ£{g:842Ô452ÝxZÅk5åGO+:824Ýx�.8:24Ô512Ô092Ô613Ô583Ýx�Ôñß~:101Ýx@fzZ3gÔeZË:62Ô64Ô15Ô051Ô612Ô

922Ô432Ô242Ô652Ô852Ô972Ô682Ô782Ô192ÔÔ292Ô592

Ýx@™ÄAöÔ´ò:101Ýx��gæ:91Ô782Ô333ÝxgÎw:462Ô862Ýx[Z−+:171Ýx%”ÔñÑ*:413ÝxÑ:53

"»ª~:58ÃgCÙÍÔé:953Ô263Ô463ÃgztZºÎ:43Ô53ÃgztZWñ:53Æ:192Ãy™\:523�ÛZ%i:001�Ûs:53�Ûc�Z*w:22Ô53�Û�zÏ:914�Û›èZi~:914�ÛzrZ£ÿ6zWþ:062�Û;�:58

¹Zv»‰:473a@:801

@+:43 èaa@Ôu:962

hÔ‡è:814 èaq:004 èa

jãÔ!!:99MÔ±z©Z−+:35Ô671Ô783Ô693Ô024M·²ÂòÔ�:501Ô2219ziZ−+Z£&ZðZ%<~Ô�:801

;Ô;Z£:693ëg8-.èGE:562Ô662

‡Wã:914‡Ìú�Z£:22‡ZZW:�&À�/õ GG·Z»b

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^425

Page 520: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Šg]ZvÔ÷:621�:48

"Ç è "+CÐöGEOOÔ[ è »gwâg¾:58Ô'×h�&À�/õ GGæ

™iyÔÑge:914™xZÞÔñß~::842™*jÔpZz:44™*!!ÿnÒZDwþ:004¤s:28æZv:48Ô58æ"+CÐö

GEO:58Ô'×h�&À�/õ GG:»gwâg¾Ô!o-÷GL"Ç

¾wZ£œjÔeZË:62¾wZ−+¡~:012

å8:114Ã$Ö:523Çg‚V�@Ï:493Ç0S:163

01Ô ¤Zòÿ�Ýx‡�gþÔñÑ*:94Ô05Ô49Ô59Ô3401Ô121Ô221Ô031Ô461Ô142Ô552Ô262

�[P:904�[�+Ô�:44ÍCÙ~ÔZ*!:083ÍM:112X'×h�&À�/õ GGÍaÍ,:451Ô112Ô523Ô373Ñ8S:74

963Ô Z£ÑzZã:43Ô753Ô263D563Ô "073Ô'×h�&À�/õ GG:�áC

�©gW!�~)„kZ{V(:62Ô522Ô722Ô822Ô932Ô472

ßZð:914ß�+ÔÑge:023ßweÔ!!:83

b:75Ô57321ÔÔ541Ô641Ô741âg:523âÊ-�øG

:523â&45½ð EHGY

=Ôu:713âã:313âc�ZkÔgZY:114

Igu�á{�ã:424IguZÔ�:26Ô161Ô822ë�Z³Uã:83�ÔZ}:862�o:842Ô5538[¬ÝÔÒ:64

íZ<ÔâZ[:614)gÎwZv(:23Ô58Ô421Ô821Ô921Ô "# ·431Ô931Ô541Ô871Ô381Ô291Ô391Ô302Ô402Ô812Ô822Ô632Ô942Ô223Ô433D633Ô833D043Ô743Ô653Ô024Ô124

·Z'Z�:53·Z'Z�Ôa�O~:53·Z£ÔqY:842·Z£œj:824·Z�gö:842·Zg”Ôa�O~:304·Z‡Ô´):004

525Z�ágt

Page 521: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

·ZÑsÔ�:43Ô232Ô332Ô323·Zº�á{{VÎW!�~:772·Zº¡:832Ô714Ô814·Z™Zx,ð:182·Z1k:004·Z}iÛ~:872·Z}−·â~:413·!ŒÛÔeZË:292·aZ/�’~:55·aa�O~:82·Õ:071Ô671·Õ{V:613·ÔZ°9.è WEÑzZã:05Ô69Ô303Ô133Ô

433Ô833·�:241·�YßO~Ôñß~:44Ô54·�ŒÛÙÔ�:293Ô104·@Ôa�O~:62Ô35Ô85Ô95Ô26Ô36Ô

76Ô86Ô07Ô641Ô261Ô661Ô071Ô371Ô081Ô381Ô232Ô332Ô362Ô833Ô873Ô973Ô583Ô504Ô604

·@²Ù:583Ô093Ô393·Ú{Ãgz¹:692Ô183·ð�á@:121Ô083Ô804Ô714·�+¯t:44Ô84Ô25Ô822Ô032Ô732Ô

842Ô052Ô252Ô452Ô062Ô392Ô592Ô043Ô553

·g=Za:253Ô453

·gpy:452·gpyÔ�:83·gcnÔeZË:82Ô92Ô43Ô99Ô301Ô891·i™cÔeZËpZz:�&À�/õ GGpZz·i™c·GZ−+Q~:461Ô152Ô413·G{VÔÆ:922Ô762·G�Ô6zW:72Ô323Ô523Ô623·GÔ%iZ:272·�á{zVÔ±:44·ÑpîÏ:362·-ŒÛ7:472·ÃÔxV:912Ô583Ô683Ô304·œ&ÿZÓkg¶þ:241Ô461·œ&;ÿsi~þ:62Ô262

(:142 ÞÏç� ·Ü)æk·†Z?xÐÔZ1ZMgx:352·†ZvIé:44Ô54·†Zv,ð:43Ô64Ô26Ô07Ô512Ô912Ô

432Ô732Ô513Ô583·†ZvÔ�:004·†ZvŒÛ7:52Ô43Ô34Ô44Ô801Ô051Ô

422Ô522Ô032Ô252Ô452D652Ô262Ô372Ô443Ô363Ô083

·¢yÔ6zW:032Ô682Ô892Ô992·¢y=w:314·²Ãy{V:252Ô452·Z)wiZ�{:814·Z»bÔ‡ZZW:432Ô732Ô932Ô362Ô

462Ô862Ô863

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^625

Page 522: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

·Z{VoÔ™ñZ�{÷:222Ô822·�ÛhZ/:52·‡�g~aZgÔxVo:801·»ò:43·ñeZv:424Ô824·š:161·dZ−+:43Ô871·&��á{{V:792·ëg�á{{V:792·ëgÔ6zW:79Ô99Ô001Ô142·�y:062·©[:513·©[ÔxV:53·-÷�]Ô6zW:38ú�Z£¸i~:993ú�Zvœj:841Ô071Ô471Ô281ú�èZã:732Ô452ú�çâ~:224Ô824ú�Âò:783Ô093Ô393Ô493Ô993ú�§i~:814[Z−+‡�g~izgÔeZË:122Ô422Ô522UgZ£Ô�:81UgH:301Ug&�:71Ô822Ô932Ô992%$|öGD

Z£{Vo:452%[g¶ÔÒaZÞ:501

"i è "Ç:58Ô�&À�/õ GG:»gwâg¾Zzgæ è[&�ZdÅ7:43

zh:793Ô893˜Z[:653

”t:25ÀpZz:43Ô621Ô222Ô182Ô792Ô523

862 ZiCÙþ:752Ô062Ô è !{‹§öEWZÔZ©Ô´)ÿ�à:36c~ÔZ1ZY:16Ô77

¥Z−+ÕÔeZË:801¥Z−+F:�&À�/õ GGF¥Z°9.è WEÔeZ˱:43g:�&À�/õ GG†ZßZugo+:35�ge:023�i�:912Ô632Ô742Ô552Ô672Ô392Ô

992Ô703Ô893Ô004Ô204�i@:204Ny�{V:62Ô912Ô472�ÔÑge:914µg'`:473¡�:703¡{:733Ô004

Ô|]:66Ô67Ô48Ô811Ô231Ô041Ô ð� ñ.341Ô291Ô012

ñÑjV:801ñøÔeZË:703$ÔÝxgÎw:92Ô03Ô05Ô27Ô47Ô08Ô901Ô

141Ô 511Ô711Ô721D031Ô231Ô431Ô D 311541Ô281Ô481Ô681Ô512Ô942Ô252Ô

652Ô583Ô304D604Ô124 D 452

725Z�ágt

Page 523: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

93 ÷�Ô´)±:93Ô04Ô75Ô19Ô39Ô89Ô7÷+:914

oZºW!�~:822å&¾æ HY

^:172Ô303Ô953Ô163Ô263Ô463Ðz&Óå EH:523!5ÓÀê GeZg#Ôu:�&À�/õ GGeZg#*�g»Ãgz~:64*iÔZöZ*:993*ÜÆz:914*ò@©~:44�gZ£Ãgz¹:182ÜZDgZx7g~:8422kZ£:3922kZ£�Š~Ôe÷:64Ô74Ô5142k*i~Ô±:43Ô93Ô95Ô06Ô26Ô161Ô661Ô

071Ô671Ô771Ô381Ô712Ô912Ô432Ô83Ô 342D542Ô613Ô713Ô023Ô973Ô4

583Ô783Ô883Ô214¾Z−+Ô!!:83Ô952Z−+:952Z−+;×:872Ô÷iZ:914ÂxZ−+Zz1:83ÂxZ−+ÔÑ:44ÂxZ−+ÔxV:74Ô35Ô251Ô461Âò:19Ô914

nZºW!�~:314Ô614n~:99Ô211

242 D %Z−+Z£Ô{y:042%g¶Ô±:53

Õ�©gW!�~Ô6zW:692$¹ÒjèE

EÔ6zW:623Ô433Ô963i æÑk8Z‘45å EEGi:�&À�/õ GGZ‘45åEEG

1zÔH]:853Ô004âZ[™rÈ0w:86Ô96Ô132Ô232Ô152Ô472âgZÞÔpZz:392âg·Ô�:81Ô83Ô93Ô201Ô941Ô251*iZ£Ô�:43Ô26Ô27D47*iZ−+{VÔ{y:801Ô461Ô412Ô432Ô042Ô

242Ô152Ô113Ô473*i·{V::204"54fõ EGHI:46Ô48Ô851Ô112Ô713Ô'×h�&À�/õ GG��:112Ô'×h�&À�/õ GG"54fõ

EGHI

zZ]ZÔ÷:571zZuÔZöZ}:�&À�/õ GG†ZßZuÔ±zZ™:192zZíFZ!Ô%iZ;�~Zá:27Ô08Ô891Ô502

352Ô D þ:201Ô032Ô152 ÞÏng £ÿæk z©Z872Ô173

z©Z−+Ô±:783z©‚]ÔeZË:62z©ŒÛ7ÔeZË:43Ô53Ô44Ô94Ô571Ô182Ô

192Ô292Ô873zgeizgB:74Ô84zikW¸:84zikZd¬$~Ô±:89zÝìZò:052Ô352

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^825

Page 524: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

zàZ−+ÔpZz:842zàZvZPW!�~Ô÷:622z@8-,ç EGE:523z@Ã6:74zw*†ÔZZ:81Ô62Ô912Ô672Ô503;gzyð:012;gzyZ°æ:431;×ÔeZËZözZð:563CÙ÷Pg:114DÙ�Ôu�ÛZ1j:853Ô263ƒ1ëÔeZËÿ·Zâyþ:62ƒïÔeZË:013‹yÔ6zW�ÛZ:562

JÔ6zW:804¬:451

i�n.ç IH:114sV è ©ØPÔ|]:58Ô'×h�&À�/õ GGc

ugxÿ=�©gþ:062Ô314-Š0@1:36-Š@{VÔeZË:49Ô79Ô004-ŠÐ²:793-÷�]:�&À�/õ GG·-÷�]

Azad:372

Goethe:373

Hakim Ahmad Shuja:409

Lala Tej Ram:409

Lessing:372

Mohammad Said, M.:409

Shamloo: �&À�/õ GG"Z£ÑzZãKýKýK

ÃWU§ZDw:49Ô59Ô403Ô153WcY:904Ô714D914Ô824ZjZwzWU§ZDwÔ�zx:292Z�Ò‹ÃgÏ~yzîV»z:83

ZDw:304 è Qg�zW\áV~f™Qg�zZ5:18Ô602Qg�z�Z]{çg½Zsð:74Ô623Qg�zÃgkÔW^,)®Æa:804Ô904Ô

314Ô61414D714 Qg�zÃgkÔ0v,)®Æa:33Ô5

Qg�zÃgkÔ�)®Æa:804D214Ô614Qg�zÃgkÔ‚Â,)®Æa:804Ô904Ô

214Ô314Ô614ZgèÈsi:52Ô15Ô86D07Ô27D47Ô77Ô

08Ô281D481Ô681Ô191Ô791Ô502Ô983Ô893

01D221Ô 33Ô05Ô35Ô09Ô49Ô59Ô69Ô2 ZuZ§p�~:521D051Ô782Ô203Ô133Ô233Ô533Ô733Ô043Ô243Ô743Ô943Ô053Ô

553Ô473Ô893 153Ô21D841Ô ZuZgzgñi:31Ô03Ô43Ô99Ô501Ô021Ô5902Ô012 581Ô681Ô881Ô291Ô891Ô

ZDw:91 è Z�ágtkKZ&q‹ZDw:33Ô55

603 D ZDw)Zi¾H(:562D762Ô403ZDw)Ziñß~Z£�+(:55

925Z�ágt

Page 525: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

g¦Zg~Zzgµ":871 »D ZDwZ»�òZDwZzgZ³×eèZsx:64Ô062Ô513ZDwZzgÈ0w:871Ô152ZDwZzg†Z/:632Ô672Ô393ZDwZzgÃgÏÄZ:09Ô69Ô99Ô301ZDwZzg¡Òiªî EE0½:824ZDwZzg!hÏî 00½:824

Zqó_·:82 D ZDwZq_·:121 D ZDw

¯x�á�:52Ô522 D ZDwy~5Z�:24 è Y�z¤ D ZDw

�È�v:52Ô62Ô262Ô272Ô472Ô672 D ZDw�È�v:$›Ò3¨é G

GG]zjZÙ:262 D ZDwP6It:72Ô282 D ZDwa�O~·@ÅÃ~:071 D ZDwpZ&ÅÃ~:872 D ZDw�gzÈ{::93Ô512Ô193Ô604Ô124 D ZDw�gzÈ{:ÿZzwþ:304Ô404 D ZDw

ƒÆa:09Ô99 D ZDw±Ñy0z~ÅÃ~:922 D ZDw

ZDw»f6Zg»:051ZDw»(Ï:183ZDw»„z®:822Ô583ZDw»¡Òiªî EE0½:824ZDÁ»ï:693

82Ô ZDwÅQg�z�)idZûY(:62Ô82Ô282Ô7433Ô833

33 ZDwÅQg�z�)„�]'w~(:782Ô433Ô8

ZDwÅ�l~:26ZDwÅ,Zzg�á²~:04Ô05ZDwÅÄ~:64Ô35Ô612Ô022Ô432Ô

532Ô732Ô413Ô613ZDwÅÃgÏ�á²~»W~Y{:99Ô001ZDwÆWy~�z‚w:462Ô772ZDwÆ(Ãc]:824ZDwÆP�ZCÙgm}:783Ô593Ô693

983 D ZDwÆ�g:381Ô583Ô683ZDwÆÄ~–~Ô�~gzò~:89ZDwÆ@zbf:4Ô801Ô432ZDwÆ�~Z°g:733Ô543Ô643Ô053ZDwÆëS:02Ô993Ô004ZDwÆëd:02Ô82Ô783Ô993D104ZDw*)ÿ�]þ:481Ô983Ô304Ô504ZDw*))�«YZvDq¢~(:71Ô822Ô

932D142Ô572Ô983ZDw*)ÔZzw:62Ô05Ô35Ô86Ô19D39Ô69Ô

99Ô301Ô801Ô021Ô121Ô521Ô941Ô171Ô912Ô022Ô522D332Ô732Ô832Ô342Ô152Ô252Ô452Ô552Ô062Ô762Ô472Ô772D082Ô882D092Ô792Ô413D613Ô023Ô433Ô943Ô073Ô173Ô473Ô404D604

41Ô ZDw*)Ô�zx:56Ô89Ô201Ô401Ô121Ô521Ô9632Ô D 251Ô071Ô171Ô812Ô622Ô33203Ô 452Ô062Ô762Ô172Ô472Ô872Ô882Ô3

083Ô804Ô824 413Ô513Ô843Ô263Ô

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^035

Page 526: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZDw*ó:71Ô06Ô56Ô032Ô132Ô232Ô932Ô572Ô772 D 172Ô372

ZDwÔ5ï:81ZDwÔ-g\~:81Ô62Ô72Ô501Ô251Ô912Ô

762Ô272Ô603Ô713ZD1]ÿ$þ:504Ô604ZD1]Ô�z‹t:51Ô02Ô78Ô424ZD1‹pZz:07ZD1]»W~Y{:392ZD1CZ�[Æ&‚w7891YD9891Y:91Ô

42Ô82Ô182ZD1CY}:81Ô82Ô362ZºZzgZDw:54Ô15ZJy~0kƒäƤ:043Z³:501Zð³bcWsZsx)Ñày(:623ZâZ§ZDw:62Ô83Ô25Ô55Ô59Ô201Ô501Ô

912Ô822Ô542Ô D 801Ô111Ô941Ô251Ô71292Ô 742D452Ô062Ô762Ô872Ô972Ô353Ô 592Ô113Ô213Ô833Ô643D943Ô1

553Ô653Ô173Ô183Ô904Ô214Ô314Ô514Ô814Ô914

13Ô 35Ô251Ô461Ô032Ô152Ô982Ô4 ZzgZ¾ËX:743Ô253Ô763Ô083Ô004Ô404Ô604

!ª‹ZDw:33Ô25Ô55Ô65Ô351Ô381Ô363Ô224

!Á�s:51Ô61Ô52Ô92Ô03Ô15Ô95D56Ô17Ô37D57Ô77Ô87Ô08Ô78Ô671

�gZ:61Ô42Ô52Ô92Ô03Ô33Ô43Ô04D24Ô è !874Ô84Ô15Ô25D06Ô17Ô37Ô57Ô67Ô87Ô08Ô68Ô09Ô29Ô39Ô59Ô621Ô562Ô314�gZå:61 è !8

'»‹ZDw:92'ÀÉ:381*y:19·§Y:690ÎyÅÃcCã�,:94

Ô 781 D �:95Ô671Ô871D281Ô481 :p!h™791Ô402Ô822

\Äæt:33Ô43Ô05Ô95Ô09Ô79D99Ô001Ô621Ô841D361Ô581Ô981Ô491Ô002Ô112Ô922Ô652Ô533Ô043Ô743Ô373

@g+÷ GELZzg@»Òуg:272@g+÷ GELZZÄò:83@g+÷ GEL¦s:72Ô473@g+÷ GELy:02Ô914D924r»‹ZDw:33Dz+ÔïZzggzZe:42

ZDw:02Ô082 è £?Yzh*):53Ô95Ô09Ô89Ô99Ô071D571Ô

581Ô781Ô091Ô691Ô302Ô152Ô393Ô224

Pc�,ÔP@WZ]:65Ô121qƒZzgZDw:49Ô69Ô79Ô101w½ZDw:843Ô053

135Z�ágt

Page 527: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Zsx:043 è we§‹ZDw»Zq_!C�zg:682Ô033§‹ZDwÅË”{šcV:121§‹ZDwÆP�ÍÚ:183

D è¹ZDw:62Ô55Ô56Ô19Ô801Ô871Ô612912Ô822Ô732Ô752D062Ô962Ô172Ô372Ô672Ô972Ô082Ô782Ô303Ô123Ô743Ô863Ô473

è¹ZDw¯xH¤Zò:97Ô351Ô752Ô062D262Ô672

Ü¢ïEGLZsð:833pV·:04Ô34Ô54�Z*}gZi:93�-ZÈqƒ:04Ô19Ô79�-Zȸ:75�-ZȤZò:351f°æLZDw:14Ô64Ô501Ô901Ô051Ô251Ô392Ô

893gZ¯"p�~:801g‚!‘ÐêLZOÄæy:792gñ¯"p�~:33Ô05Ô35Ô09Ô021D841Ô

782Ô233Ô533Ô043Ô743Ô153Ô793Ô124

gzZc‹ZDw:93Ô04Ô34Ô19gz—k"3ïGGELZDw:452Ô372gziǧMÿZzwþ:783Ô393Ô693D893gziǧMÿ�zxþ:93Ô25Ô55Ô801Ô901Ô743Ô

783Ô393Ô893Ô024

gz&öL):101gzhZ�,ƒZV‚Ñ:*Z³×eZsx:74

61D271Ô 05Ô95Ô09Ô79Ô99Ô001Ô241Ô3 i1§Y:781Ô091Ô591Ô202Ô902 D 571Ô481

i1§]h:461Ô152503Ô413 D i0{gz�:83Ô401Ô692Ô303

ZDw:54Ô301Ô051Ô392 è u*“511Ô D 311 uz›gC:33Ô43Ô14Ô29Ô901Ô111Ô

711Ô721Ô821Ô031Ô131Ô231Ô431Ô351Ô352Ô893Ô314

\g*)Âò:04Ô19ÎZö´)†ZÔ(wÃK:043±Ñy0z~ZDwÅÃ~:572Zjjy:16Ô671 觧‹ZDw:392�á�ZDw:52Ô121Ô221Ô521Ô051Ô122D522Ô

432Ô872Ô972Ô792Ô113Ô733•gZ‹¡¾æ

ELZDw:273

ÑbWsY:814D 47Ô67 D ¢ƒæ:71Ô52Ô15Ô56D96Ô27

87Ô481¤w:714´)ZDwZJVÅÃ~:583Ô004´)ZDwZzga�O~·@)gzZ*(:362Ô604´)ZDwÅÃgÏçw:79Ô99Ô001´)ZDwÅ»!Ã:Zq‹t:82´)ZDwÆ101�á‚gèo:572DZÑO�:91Ô482Ô682D882Ô192D303Ô

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^235

Page 528: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

113Ô423D723Ô033Ô643Ô993ÃgÏ�~:801

8mZÇ:893¡¾æELZDw:35Ô49Ô79¡ÒiªîEE0Y:732Ô333

ŒÛWy:28Ô89Ô521Ô131Ô231Ô391Ô002Ô132Ô352Ô523Ô443Ô353Ô193

ŒÛWyZzgZDw:822²°:04Ô19 è ŸZ

Â[ZÅ.›4iïGIG:792ÂÒ‹ZDw::392Ô514µ3ïGELZD1]:514¯Z�[»ó_·:192Ô292à‹ZDw)�Á(:65Ô333Ô843

52Ô92Ô03Ô55Ô D à‹ZDwÔQg�z:51Ô32581D781Ô 65Ô85Ô56Ô86Ô17D78Ô

602Ô702Ô182Ô98311Ô à‹ZDwÔÃgÏ:71Ô32Ô52Ô92Ô03Ô211Ô3

51D651Ô 711Ô821Ô921Ô131Ô431Ô141Ô841Ô4951Ô071Ô471Ô281Ô581D112Ô793

ZDw:61 è à‹!ª‹Ä72D282 ZDw:4Ô71Ô62Ô72Ô472Ô6 è à‹kK

ZDw:392 èã%§ZDw:49Ô062Ô513Ô643Ô743Ô

253D653Ô263Ô763Ô183%§ZDw:Q»ó_·:82Ô452Iy:801—yZØ:801

¸‹gzi%{:822O»�g�:452�~uZÑuZg:801�~ñÑ*gzx:04Ô19Ô89Ô99

ZDw:02Ô783Ô104 è WÖ·ZDw:99%¢üGL,ð:433Ô943)�Û:95Ô09Ô671D281Ô581Ô861Ô781Ô

191Ô791Ô502Dµqà:54

43D153Ô ZDw:381Ô782Ô233D143Ô3 è p}553Ô753ZuZgzgñi:03Ô141Ô541 è _!Á�s:03 è _

�gZ:92 è !8 è __·ZDwÔ'}VÅÃ~:72

Z06;ð'±ið YV:573 è _·ZDw�g6¤xZDw:81Ô672£Ñ‹ZDw:69Ô79Ô901Ô211Ô721Ô141Ô682Ô

733D943Ô153Ô553Ô753Ô563Ô893Ô904Ô014

£Ñ‹�i:204ZDw¯xH¤Zò:752 è kKZDw¯x¤Zò:05Ô97Ô79Ô001Ô301Ô è kK

231941Ô051Ô D 401Ô121Ô221Ô521Ô031461Ô761Ô552Ô652Ô262Ô872Ô973ZDw¯x*i:71Ô62Ô35Ô55Ô801Ô è kK

42D342Ô 221Ô251Ô461Ô412Ô712Ô532Ô0

335Z�ágt

Page 529: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

152Ô872Ô482Ô113Ô473gæ�{V¯xg<Z−+;×:112 è kKu·ZDw¯x±Ñy0z~:572 è kK

¯!‹ZDw:75Ô95Ô06Ô26Ô251Ô161Ô661Ô071Ô671Ô712Ô532Ô342D642Ô252Ô362Ô872Ô613Ô713Ô023Ô123Ô973

¯!‹ZDw¯xa�O~·@:62Ô362Ô672

�ª]ZDw:ïz‹t:82D �ª]:912Ô973Ô483Ô683Ô783Ô093

393Ô993Ô404493Ô993 D �ª‹ZDw:483Ô293

'gZY¨6�á��á�Ô§]ZzgZ�!}â]:122óÑ!Ãx:6042§ZDw:512¶È2w:06

©gW!��Á~:333 è ZDwÔ èÄ3k»ƒZ÷Zzg�zu~>:333 èÄ]hÅ™z�:84 èÄZDw:822 è×ZDw:25Ô55Ô822 èî

óg�á‹ZDw:82ú÷*):962Ô072âZ�gZ]:91âZ�§ZDw:33Ô443Ô543

‹zZg_�á{:04c�ǧ¸:822Ô204cgZÈ@:25

É:101 è qm5891Y»ZD1CZ�[:81Ô91Ô826891Y»ZD1CZ�[:91Ô72Ô82Ô522Ô323

A Bibliography of Iqbal:293, 338, 415

A His tor y of Gover nmet Col legeLahore:408

Arabian Night Tales:404

Bedil in the Light of Bergson :375

Bibliography of Iqbal:293, 338

Development: 19, 26, 27, 93, 286,

288.303-313, 319, 324, 326, 327,

331, 333, 366, , 398, 418

Dictionary of National Biography:245

Discourses of Iqbal:368-370

Faust: 371

History of India :428

íIndian Art and Letters:359

Iqbal in Pictures:53, 122, 176, 218, 271,

296, 304, 307, 409, 420

Iqbal:220, 265

Iqbal's Educational Philosophy:428

Iqbal's Letters to Attiya Begum:265, 266, 269Letters of Iqbal:170, 176, 218, 219, 226,

229, 230, 237, 264, 265, 268, 271,272, 276, 305, 306, 316, 334, 368, 380

Letters and Writings of Iqbal:266-268

Letters of Iqbal to Jinnah:263, 269

Letters to Atiya :53, 93, 94, 102, 104,

238, 271, 272, 296, 304, 305

Mohammedan Theoris of Finance:314

Mementos of Iqbal:269, 304, 362, 367,

368, 392

Monograph of Atiya Begum on Iqbal :266

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^435

Page 530: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

My Reminiscences:263

Persian Psalms:100

Political Economy(Fawcett):291

Political Economy(Walker):291

Principles of Economics:325

Q u a i d - e - Aza m a s Se e n b y H i sContemporaries: 263, 264

Reconstruction:27, 33, 34, 98, 286, 288,

314, 317, 320-325, 338

Speeches )ÑzZã( :303, 331,334, 355-358,

360-363, 365, 366, 369, 370, 378

Speeches )¤gt( :360,366,367369, 370

Speeches )ÑzZãÔZÍw( :355-358, 367

Speeches )ÑzZãÔ�zx( :359, 360, 363, 364, 366

Songs of Modern David:164, 251

Stray Reflections:19, 48, 97, 288, 364,

370-374, 380

Thoughts )zZu( :338, 360, 362-366, 369,

370, 373

Tributes to Iqbal:121

KýKýK

g‚bzZ¶gZ]WiZ�ò:942Ô352WÃt:432Ws:83Z�k:703Z�y:452Ô133Ô343Ô853Z�!�*:94Qg�z:18Ô792Ô523

Qg�zeZó:891Ô702Z°g:703ZDw:24D54Ô512Ô392Ô404ZDwg--Ôуg:54Ô94Ô07Ô671Ô281Ô032Ô

92Ô 8 252Ô352Ô062Ô472Ô872Ô692Ô992Ô083

ZDwg--)©gW!�(:71Ô91Ô54Ô672ZD1]:91Z,r:862Z²Û:93Z:183Z%zi:19Ô432D632Ô342Zz[:461Ô352Ô253D453Ô083Ô183Zzg@»Ò�+:542';y:872

�™Zo:163#-@î FEE0¯Ñ�:84

�Z¶g:792©:401

k:97Ô022Ô422Ô542Ô642Ô352Ô972Ô503Ô393 D 303

lZ¼gZ{:352}ZjÑ$k~9Ô:542

Ã:24 è }8�Ág--:692gZz~:44i!y:14iâ::643

535Z�ágt

Page 531: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

i�Zg:461Ô252Ô352Ô513Ô083Ô183633Ô933 D *gÒð:433 ]454g)4è

HGHGE:853ÎgZä:553ÎwZhT~¦^:753Ô853(g{:42Ô72Ô92Ô07Ô332³ƒQg�z:54اS:54

�:52Ô83Ô25Ô201Ô301Ô601Ô801Ô021Ô121Ô161Ô422Ô232Ô962Ô083Ô404Ô814

ÃgZy:522.y:342Ô762Ô563¸òeZó:973¸òi!y:132Ô462

™�Z§â:842ò~¦^:043ò~�+:052Ô252

ÑV:753âÓâ:82Ô14Ô942Ô052Ô352&CÏî E0ï:612Ô922Ô432Ô652Ô852Ô082

&y:64D84Ô25Ô58Ô29Ô452Ô482Ô592Ô692Ô892Ô992Ô033Ô133Ô533Ô933Ô143Ô343Ô153Ô904

%µ:052çgs:593f!0Îy:083o�~:401öZy:963

Ýl:34Ô54Ô15Ô39Ô49Ô712Ô022Ô142Ô252Ô352D552Ô862Ô962Ô072Ô

33Ô 872Ô182Ô692Ô413Ô613Ô533Ô6183Ô683Ô783Ô504Ô804Ô714�:032Ô152Ô252

âZ�g:81âZ}z‰Ü:432â&åGLð:022

ìw:262 è .8.�y:032zí:802Ô043zV:133Ô933

Civil and Military Gazette:364

East and West:121

Indian Antiquary:331

Iqbal Review:375

Islam:334

Islamic Education:234, 367

Journal of Research: 46, 286, 287, 291, 295

Light:367

Muslim Outlook:338

New Era:334, 339, 371, 372

Oriental College Magazine:218

The Hindustan Review:338, 388

The Muslim Revival:359, 361

The Orient:373The Pakistan Times:269The Socialogical Review:32, 338

KýKýK

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^635

Page 532: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZâÁWzZyÑp:83ZS:02Ô424ZO:253Ô793ZuZL:38Ze:36Zjjy:671Z[W!�:262Ô933Ô753Ô204Ô804Z%<:801Ô024Z*g:94Z0zg:472

49Ô982Ô503Ô603Ô023Ô D Zày:09Ô29253Ô083

ZkZy:71Ô52Ô001Ô602Ô802Ô113Ô814!iZ§¦V:34Ô54$Z-V:152'Þ:75Ô251Ô503

�ZøqZV:042 èÂ�:732Ô562Ô133Cg:513@�÷:52Ô602·g:1821y:603Ô703·zw7g:424¸K�gzZi{:94¸g]:71Ô52Ô53Ô08Ô78Ô602Ô462Ô

323Ô573È0w:871Ô132Ô232Ô152Ô372Ô472

0Îy:71Ô22Ô52Ô78Ô602Ô262Ô323Ô863Ô573

º[:83Ô74Ô611Ô711Ô533Ô214cið:02Ô424ck:48Ô052rm:902éZy:602ÆcV¸¿cV:54YßO:042Yzh2w:873Ô683Ô883Ô304]{:48*:81Ô94Ô48Ô251Ô451Ô403D703�!y:253YZ:66Ô67Ô87Ô191�VW!�:48

y:801tV:48auäуg:241

u:38si:58Ô99

672Ô792Ô , ©gW!��Á:71Ô91Ô35Ô55513Ô863Ô104

6:38�‹:61Ô42Ô14Ô44Ô55Ô28Ô48Ô801Ô161Ô

812Ô062Ô172Ô443Ô214�‹�gzZi{:252��[:26Ô48gZzwH~:74gZz~:48

735Z�ágt

Page 533: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

gcn2w:48gzx:58jz[:404uóÙ:124]Ò‹3ïEGL¢6:201

¡7g:424Ô824(wÃ^:34Ô101Ô412Ô732�áÑâg:48�áx:58:

Hâ·g:151èZi:511èg2w:503

êû:48¤`:371Ô091

13Ô Z¥|:23Ô33Ô08Ô48Ô932Ô442Ô613Ô704 663Ô073Ô8 D 833Ô933Ô443Ô463

¸i~7gÔ-8:204çã:324�ÛZ]:48

¦:463ßW!�:062

ŒÛ\:26Ô28Ô48Ô793Ô404».Þ:732™Zc:52Ô801Ô022Ô522Ô132Ô742Ô562

ò:83ÃZegyƒ9:24Æ:48

‰`:94Ô562Ô982Ô303Ô713Ô723Ô043

|Z]:83I:48уg:42Ô52Ô82Ô92Ô43Ô83Ô24D54Ô94Ô

55Ô06Ô97Ô49Ô301Ô311Ô141Ô241Ô051Ô161571Ô871Ô412Ô812Ô122Ô432Ô732Ô042Ô052Ô252Ô652Ô562D762Ô172Ô272Ô572Ô672Ô182Ô692Ô203Ô703Ô413Ô323Ô043Ô553Ô753Ô063Ô883Ô093

Ñày:603−·::652Ô413

~:44Ô301Ô433LÑ`:54Ô94

603Ô213Ô913Ô023Ô D ßy:23Ô052Ô303833Ô653Ô953

â8Ã&Ïî H:424ægZk:513Ô613Ô214æÜ:48%¼+:001ñc�уg:583÷J:401�g:513.egze:204

*gz}:161E›Nîy:182zÑeÿ-g\þ:35;C:603;àw'v:94Ô503Ô723

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^835

Page 534: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

CÙc::182ï6:36Ô37Ô793Ô893Ô404y*y:692Ô023Ô814Ô914Ô224ƒâg7g:39-g\:84Ô94Ô28Ô39Ô101Ô822Ô052Ô582Ô

982Ô503Ô343Ô353Ô583Ô804Delhi:409

Hotel Luletia:250

Queen Ann's Mansion:250

KýKýK

Z�Zg}WwZ&c›>:433WsZ�[уg:662Ô203

Zsðуg:81 è Z�Zg{pÄQg�z)Äx²{:34Ô44ZgT¤A΂Ì:023Zsò-ãzg;:743Ô943Zsð»Òуg:74Ô29Ô204Ô804ZDwZOòÿgZáZ�»Xi{Z�Zg{þ262ZDwZ»�ò0Îy™Zc:871Ô142Ô342Ô742Ô

552Ô992ZDwZ»�ò0Îyуg:51Ô61Ô91D22Ô42Ô

42Ô 242Ô642Ô7 D 62Ô53Ô78Ô571Ô042652Ô182Ô282Ô203Ô703Ô963Ô373Ô573Ô183Ô424

ZDwZ»�òÿуgþÑ$k~:43ZDwñi*уg:91Ô72Ô43Ô06Ô401Ô501Ô

121Ô941Ô051Ô102Ô032Ô942Ô452Ô

552Ô703Ô463Ô073Ô473Ô573ZZÄ�{:112

Z�!».Þ:533Ô043Ô843 è Z³Qg�zуg:18 è F¹ è Z³Qg�zy�‹:822Ô643Ô253 è F¹ è Z³

Zsxуg:54D94Ô15Ô25Ô121Ô è ×e è Z³582Ô513Ô043

Z³}ZxZ−+:432Z³ò~�*y:94

Z��:34Ô44 è Z³º[:34Ô84 è Z³

Zzg@»Òуg:03Ô53Ô54Ô101Ô192Ô292Ô592Ô804Ô714

Zz±i«çEe-ãzg;:023Zz±i«çEe-ãzg;6ö:023'wÔZ~Z:603Ô703'Ñ-ãzg;Ñ$k~:603)ÄZDwуg:522Ô042Ô213Ô183Né�ÿR-wZÐþ:952R‹»Ò‰`:052Ô303Ô403R‹»ÒÑ$k~:713?zg-ãzg;Ñ$k~:43Ô622º[-ãzg;уg:72Ô13Ô64Ô282Ô192Ô

703Ô623Ô804Ô714º[-ãzg;Ñ$k~:43Ô703ckZOò::623@`vуg:06Ô26YeZiCÙÿþ:752YeZsð�‹:95Ô06Ô161Ô542

935Z�ágt

Page 535: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¯;wуg:4137ÒªîG0×zÃ:093×"ìGGLZsx6öуg:53©gW!�;ðÃg^:792Ô113{�xZ³M6öуg:792�*XÅ�‹:61�+·~6öуg:332gZbZ¨S΂Ì:603g^a΂ÌWs0Îy:183ga΂ÌWs0ÎyÑ$k~:43Ô353Ô183

72;wÔZ¥|:613\g]{U0ÎyÔ*:603

£@gõÔ™Zc-ãzg;:172;'Z�gkуg:833ÚTyуg:91

7PÁgZhÜ:814´)ZDwZz6-ãzg;ZsxW!�:304Z¥|-ãzg;:613Ô104�Ûh,e7�‹:573

Ã{:ƒ»Zsxуg:771™Zc-ãzg;:952Ô072Ô172™a6öуg:621ÃW6W6ì6öÔzí¤8уg:332

‰`-ãzg;:48Ô403Ô713‰`-ãzg;Ñ$k~:501Íg»Òуg:24Ô74Ô48Ô412Ô512Ô

912Ô982Ô292Ô592Ô703Ô804Ô024ßiZuZhvßy:603Ô313Å5¿.ç EEESy:303Ô403

âg'v-ãzg;Ñ$k~:703{s;îkуg:812Ô172{s;îk�‹:172

ZZx:112 è>‡ây‚iº[:063Ô363 è>

tyZ�å»Ð÷:043K!¼�Û�zk:562KLm:983

ŒÛ\:793Ô404 èK›Z�åZÁÏZcWs‡gyZ&c:513

æX6�÷Qg�zZ»�aÈ0w:472%[Zàуg:55

-šà�‹:801-YeZsð�‹:161Ô671-»zcã'Þ:251�ZÄBk5éE]gZx7gÔ-8:573

Z+уg:473 è �y�Ye�‹:822ñà-ãzg;:403Ô603Ô013

Dñi*™Zc:873zZ]‘Ô.çGE�уg:571

Z³:442 Anti-GodAllah Diya and Sons Lahore and Delhi: 55Gulab Chand Kapoor and Sons:409 League of Nations:211United Nations:2111

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^045

Page 536: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]Z zg&éGMW Z gZ PW ZDw6 è £?eZË�Zh:

eZËg<Z−+;×)£Qg�zÔ-ãzg;Zzg@»ÒÔÑ�g(âCÙ+ZD1]Æ�gxyZq»�z�i£xgn�XQ,VäZD1]Æe~FKzïÆz¯

Zy»@i{F+»g*)ìÔZzg:Üst�Zy i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^Ù »g*óZ�x�b�XikÃÆÔƒ»ñV6ÔÉZD1]~ÌZqz¯ZŸ†ìXZke~;×™rÅ�lz[ZzgDzFK�zâVÅ�Z��´7CìX

ZkÂ[Ń(~p!tì�ZkÐZDwƾÑ]ÅzÝ»Z0Zi{�@ìÔZka�Zk~Óx£?ZDw»Zq©H�ìZzg�*ƃÐ(}�á²2)q¢ÆZqxF+®ÅCÙnÅ�kzVZzg½kzV6gzÝeZà�ìXZke~�Ë”{c)czsqzVÅ�gcÄÆ‚B‚B7gz>ż�!Vcß�V»SiZ!H�ìX

CÙ![ÆÑzq~;×™rä¬g°*yÉ™ñçqÆ´ï]z�Z]Ì7K�ZzgZkçA~IÆ�v�zZßVÆÒ*]ÅYõ7@wÌÅìXZk§b;×™rÅçV~ZqóYöÆ‚BW~ù]ÌaZ��ìX

ZD1]6Zq"Vwd�*zmìÔTÐ: i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^Ù ù¦zÀòîg6Üs¥z‡gMÉfzâCÙ+̹¼Z.�{™M�XZ+Zq�*zm~@;Å¢zg]æ]ÐCkÅYg�¶Ô&/�zp!7gZ™ÆÔeZËg<Z−+;×™räZDwƯxz\xÆízZ�á®ÅZq}#ÖZ�x�~ìX

Ô�g~@Z~9991Y( Ú†mî )âx)

345]Z zg&éGMW Z gZ ZDw6PW è £?

Page 537: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

eZËZ0�Ûh:ZqZëZzg*‡.Þ�ÛZñlÂ[ìX i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^ÙÒ^ivÏnÏoæiç•nvoÚ_^ÖÃä

ZD1]~ZkÅwjZ!YCÂ[ÅìXZkÐZ.�{K%ZDwÅ�zÄÆ9Q»_·e:�ÇX~eZË;×ÃIg·�7™@�V�Q,VäZDw6¹(Z»x™�3cìZzgz{Ì8ZÝDe~Æ£áÅ~X

Z¥|ÔmÔZÆ'Ô3891Y( ]ÖË^Á )

: gcnZ£ZKâÎÅQg�z~tZq»�Â[ìTÃ�ñ�zZx��ÇÔSîSy

sV~�Z¤WÒ{ËïÄZDw»ÃðRZic7™äÅX�]��ðÂz{ÃgÄ™ZL è ˬÝÆik!g�äÐÅ�YñÇXÜsZqZkÂ[Ã7

Ñ~»x[�YñÇX( Ñ�gÔ�g~3002YÔm122 e^‡m^Êk )

eZËZâg‡h:6»x™äÆaZqZ‚Ï�*zmìXZkÅ�gc©eZË;× ]Îf^Ön^l tÂ[

ÅZDw�z4»4+x�ZzgZ[ZkÂ[Åçz-ÐZDwÆfí{Äz�áƂB%A™*W‚y��ìX

Ñ�gÔ#�y3891Y( ]æ…]Ñ )

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^445

Page 538: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZD1]6¸³Å£?z@c]5891 X Ñ�g4791YX1891Y )Wz�t( ]Îf^ÙÒo›çmØÞ¿Ûn6 1D

3991YX8991YX4002Y5791Y )¿"5Òð EE¤Z°( Òjg]Îf^Ön^l 2DÑ�g6791YX��7791Y )ïzDz+( ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 3DÑ�g7791YX3002YXZ¥|2891YX6991 )FKzDz+( ]Îf^Ùevn%nk�^† 4DÑ�g7791YX2002Y )×"5Òð EE¤Z°( Òj^en^lô]Îf^Ù 5DÑ�g2891YX2002YÔ0102Y )ï( i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^ÙÒ^ivÏnÏoæiç•nvoÚ_^ÖÃä 6DÑ�g6891Y )¬gsz�t( QTUMðÒ^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 7DÑ�g8891Y )¬gsz�t( Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 6891Y 8DÑ�g9891Y )FK( ]Îf^Ù�ß^‰o]æ…q†ÞØ…mŠ†5 9DÑ�g9891Y )FK( ]Îf^Ù�ß^‰o]æ…Úvç… 01DÑ�g0991Y )ózW~p}( ]Îf^Ön^ioq^ñˆc 11DZsxW!�3991Y )ÉÂÒ]( ¡Úä]Îf^Ù 21DÑ�g2991Y 7891Y@9891Y)¬gsz�t( ]Îf^Ön^lÒ1inà‰^Ù 31DÑ�g4991Y )�tzW( ¡Úä]Îf^Ù]æ…Ún†ur^‡@ 41DZsxW!�4991Y )Ñq'( ]Îf^Ùe3ç7]æ…Þçqç]Þç7Ò1Ön1 51DÑ�g6991Y )ï( ivÏnÐ]Îf^Ön^lÒ1Ú^ì„ 61DZsxW!�2002YX9002Y )Ñq'( ]Îf^Ön^lÒ1‰ç‰^Ù 71D

545]Z zg&éGMW Z gZ ZDw6PW è £?

Page 539: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ñ�g5002YX0102Y ]Îf^Ön^lViË`nÜæirˆmä 1D 8ZsxW!�8002YX0102Y þ ¡Úä]Îf^ÙV�í’nk]æ…ÊÓ†æÊà 1D 9Ñ�g9002Y µ^ÒŠj^áÚn6]Îf^Ön^io]�h D 02

ðýýðýýð

ZkÂ[Æ�SZzg_FZWÌ�áù�`�X /

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^645

Page 540: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

]Z zg&éGMW Z gZ PW ZDw6 è £?eZË�Zh:

eZËg<Z−+;×)£Qg�zÔ-ãzg;Zzg@»ÒÔÑ�g(âCÙ+ZD1]Æ�gxyZq»�z�i£xgn�XQ,VäZD1]Æe~FKzïÆz¯

Zy»@i{F+»g*)ìÔZzg:Üst�Zy i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^Ù »g*óZ�x�b�XikÃÆÔƒ»ñV6ÔÉZD1]~ÌZqz¯ZŸ†ìXZke~;×™rÅ�lz[ZzgDzFK�zâVÅ�Z��´7CìX

ZkÂ[Ń(~p!tì�ZkÐZDwƾÑ]ÅzÝ»Z0Zi{�@ìÔZka�Zk~Óx£?ZDw»Zq©H�ìZzg�*ƃÐ(}�á²2)q¢ÆZqxF+®ÅCÙnÅ�kzVZzg½kzV6gzÝeZà�ìXZke~�Ë”{c)czsqzVÅ�gcÄÆ‚B‚B7gz>ż�!Vcß�V»SiZ!H�ìX

CÙ![ÆÑzq~;×™rä¬g°*yÉ™ñçqÆ´ï]z�Z]Ì7K�ZzgZkçA~IÆ�v�zZßVÆÒ*]ÅYõ7@wÌÅìXZk§b;×™rÅçV~ZqóYöÆ‚BW~ù]ÌaZ��ìX

ZD1]6Zq"Vwd�*zmìÔTÐ: i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^Ù ù¦zÀòîg6Üs¥z‡gMÉfzâCÙ+̹¼Z.�{™M�XZ+Zq�*zm~@;Å¢zg]æ]ÐCkÅYg�¶Ô&/�zp!7gZ™ÆÔeZËg<Z−+;×™räZDwƯxz\xÆízZ�á®ÅZq}#ÖZ�x�~ìX

Ô�g~@Z~9991Y( Ú†mî )âx)

345]Z zg&éGMW Z gZ ZDw6PW è £?

Page 541: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

eZËZ0�Ûh:ZqZëZzg*‡.Þ�ÛZñlÂ[ìX i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^ÙÒ^ivÏnÏoæiç•nvoÚ_^ÖÃä

ZD1]~ZkÅwjZ!YCÂ[ÅìXZkÐZ.�{K%ZDwÅ�zÄÆ9Q»_·e:�ÇX~eZË;×ÃIg·�7™@�V�Q,VäZDw6¹(Z»x™�3cìZzgz{Ì8ZÝDe~Æ£áÅ~X

Z¥|ÔmÔZÆ'Ô3891Y( ]ÖË^Á )

: gcnZ£ZKâÎÅQg�z~tZq»�Â[ìTÃ�ñ�zZx��ÇÔSîSy

sV~�Z¤WÒ{ËïÄZDw»ÃðRZic7™äÅX�]��ðÂz{ÃgÄ™ZL è ˬÝÆik!g�äÐÅ�YñÇXÜsZqZkÂ[Ã7

Ñ~»x[�YñÇX( Ñ�gÔ�g~3002YÔm122 e^‡m^Êk )

eZËZâg‡h:6»x™äÆaZqZ‚Ï�*zmìXZkÅ�gc©eZË;× ]Îf^Ön^l tÂ[

ÅZDw�z4»4+x�ZzgZ[ZkÂ[Åçz-ÐZDwÆfí{Äz�áƂB%A™*W‚y��ìX

Ñ�gÔ#�y3891Y( ]æ…]Ñ )

ðýýðýýð

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^445

Page 542: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

ZD1]6¸³Å£?z@c]5891 X Ñ�g4791YX1891Y )Wz�t( ]Îf^ÙÒo›çmØÞ¿Ûn6 1D

3991YX8991YX4002Y5791Y )¿"5Òð EE¤Z°( Òjg]Îf^Ön^l 2DÑ�g6791YX��7791Y )ïzDz+( ì_ç½ô]Îf^Ù 3DÑ�g7791YX3002YXZ¥|2891YX6991 )FKzDz+( ]Îf^Ùevn%nk�^† 4DÑ�g7791YX2002Y )×"5Òð EE¤Z°( Òj^en^lô]Îf^Ù 5DÑ�g2891YX2002YÔ0102Y )ï( i’^ÞnÌ]Îf^ÙÒ^ivÏnÏoæiç•nvoÚ_^ÖÃä 6DÑ�g6891Y )¬gsz�t( QTUMðÒ^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 7DÑ�g8891Y )¬gsz�t( Ò^]Îf^Ön^io]�h 6891Y 8DÑ�g9891Y )FK( ]Îf^Ù�ß^‰o]æ…q†ÞØ…mŠ†5 9DÑ�g9891Y )FK( ]Îf^Ù�ß^‰o]æ…Úvç… 01DÑ�g0991Y )ózW~p}( ]Îf^Ön^ioq^ñˆc 11DZsxW!�3991Y )ÉÂÒ]( ¡Úä]Îf^Ù 21DÑ�g2991Y 7891Y@9891Y)¬gsz�t( ]Îf^Ön^lÒ1inà‰^Ù 31DÑ�g4991Y )�tzW( ¡Úä]Îf^Ù]æ…Ún†ur^‡@ 41DZsxW!�4991Y )Ñq'( ]Îf^Ùe3ç7]æ…Þçqç]Þç7Ò1Ön1 51DÑ�g6991Y )ï( ivÏnÐ]Îf^Ön^lÒ1Ú^ì„ 61DZsxW!�2002YX9002Y )Ñq'( ]Îf^Ön^lÒ1‰ç‰^Ù 71D

545]Z zg&éGMW Z gZ ZDw6PW è £?

Page 543: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

Ñ�g5002YX0102Y ]Îf^Ön^lViË`nÜæirˆmä 1D 8ZsxW!�8002YX0102Y þ ¡Úä]Îf^ÙV�í’nk]æ…ÊÓ†æÊà 1D 9Ñ�g9002Y µ^ÒŠj^áÚn6]Îf^Ön^io]�h D 02

ðýýðýýð

ZkÂ[Æ�SZzg_FZWÌ�áù�`�X /

ÖÃä Ú_^ �nvo æiç ivÏnÏo ÒÙ i�^ÞnÌô]Îf^645

Page 544: ø xflz−gQ wDZŁ? - iqbalcyberlibrary.net · 375 Y1988ÔBedil in the Light of Bergson 377 âŁ+ zD ¯Vzg0 ”t” ...

¡*)9 ß S �903 D 803 213Ô313 1 11�é�à &B©ýEO 9 03m38 m32 qí4ÔS3 06@zV kzV 4 811

]o8 ]o8 My~ 731[] +] 81 27186'k 04'k 5 422

71t4491Y~�áù�ZXZk 7XZk 2 622ZÍwÆZq°Ð�Cì� ZÍw»Zqì� 3 622

�6~ �1~ My~ 332C5 �`¸X C4 �`¸X 71 432

]Îf^Ùeß^Ý�^� �^�]Îf^Ù 12 432Ãè� é���Ü Ã~ � é���Ü 41 242

62D162 m0 062 D m952 2 752�èo 26èo 4 862ZZz�] ZdZz�] 8 682ÎZÎ ZqÎ 21 882

ZDwÆ�zg{ ZDwä�zg{ 02 253zg Z m632 gz m632 51 393

m25Ô55 m12Ô22 My~ 993æZgk ægZk 5 214

1ºt�~ù´

\\Dataserver\shared\Publications\Urdu Books\Tasanif-e-Iqbal Final Setting\New Folder\Seht Namah