) ) I ~

OBWHHA KA3AHAbK UJ1PEKUMJI YCfPORCTBO HATEPHTOPIDITA

[1 )0 A CKI1UA NlLvJ 1 Q OZ~ I590

1

amp Yperyrmpan (I1ergr~jmftlH ) n03~ ~HoJ~0K44f4BQ~ K~Jl paii~ampd -7f7i rp~~AnL~6middot middotmiddotba Ilnom Ha ~b1k 7pound12 M2 C06CTBeHO A1J1CTO B IHIOTaItz M2

I1llOTbT e 3anlicatf IH~ MIK=-AITltmkYAeP middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotlUbmiddot~~middotmiddotmiddot middot7middotmiddotmiddot middot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot~ 1101 axr N~ 154 T 11 neno 1220 OT (~cr

~~~middot~~middot~middotmiddotmmiddot~middot1middot~~~ middot68middotmiddotmiddotmiddot ~~

M~yen12fpoundYcA~qdmiddot~~b~~~t HOT aKT 1gt1(165 TtXV neno ~o OT7 ~r

HOT aKT N T ileno OT I

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot2--middotmiddotgX~~~~~ s o J)H~ e

TaKC3T3 OT lt1 l~a1hl~KB NiA5Y~~ CZQ 7 ()lt-gt

CKIIUITa we CJIYlKM JA middotr~= shyf 17 i

)-Ilnaa sa peryrnuas ~tQpp~ittlmiddot ~ _N ~4 OQ 06(

1 0 6 1 imiddot no peB nonp YCTp n~aH~ jisectjmiddotfimiddotX rp ~

Onofipen xanacrp aH middotX Df ~ ~ aA 3 r lt_fr 6~ _ _-

113-jepTa~ 12gt1 ~7- ( A bull~WoyA-n 1 A4~amp HJlHCTIi~ ~~XlX (

E)( t+-I llteuro-Ck-- rro tA~ATe V1 ~ Y ItYl - - Crescnepr Kp middotmiddot~fjpl ~

TIA ~A-cTr 4 bOlo 3AEEJIEJKKA JQt1XLk1 Y I2 K0a2~ 1(VfT ~ 112 H SllA A ri KJO~~ vi e~T1~~ B c YAmiddot L11 JA()T 1f1JMt

1 0 AA-AI d~middotftiPmiddoto nltAHA iI _Z)~AJAHt1 b Jltn ob ~ 4oK)c ~4 OJ -009i - cr- fAABEH APXHTEKT 11IrI

-I f bullII I ~ ( I

i

Peracrsp

KapTOTeKa

Aocne

3BH)( Ii OIIHCAHHE HA MMOTA

IHMenpe3HMe H 41sMHJ1HAI

3A

1 - 130

1 272

f

5rPAHHlIJI HA IIMOTA

17032009

tIll56 tIll2arrlT2 OT 30C

yperynapas II03eMJleH HMOT

( TPHCTa H cenesmecer KBM) 6C3 nocrpoeasrre ~pxy Hero lKHJlHWHH crpaaa

C ofiuia nnoui 37000 KBM

HMOlloT e orpeneu 3aHHllHBHlIYanHO lKHJlHUlHO crpovrencrao

~

06JlaCT Crapa 3aropa ofiUlHHa Ka3aHJl1gtK rptc) rpKasarersx

KO 82 YIIH XIX 3anooell pem4342006r Ha OGe

nn x 1444 MecTHoCT

1(1( YJI ITPEOEPA)I(EHHE

6n ox er anX

CeBepOH3TOK-YI1Jf V-1445 IOroH3TOK-YTIM XVIIImiddot 1447

IOr03anall-ynTIpeoGpagtKeHHe ceaeposanan-Yllld 1-1443 H II-1442

l---------+----~----~-----------------shy6UAHhIffiA OUEHKA HA 1282050 MOTA KbM MOMERTA HA YTBhPJKLABAHE HA AKTAf----------+--------------------------------shy7EIIBUJ COECTBEHIDlt 061111lHB KB3BHJIIoK HAHMOTA I

I L- --- ~ J

8CbCOIJCTBEHID(H

9HOMEP H lIATA HA CbCTABEHH nO-PARO AKTOBE

HJlMB

bull

HlIMB I

I I

I-------------L-------------------------------------ilOIIPElJOCTABEHH [(pABA 3A YIIPABJIEHHE I I I I

OCHOBaHHe naTa I i

Or KMeTlI ua 06WHHaTll HB OCHoBBHHe IiI12MS OT 3BKOHa 3B i 06WHHCKBTB co6CTIleHOCT

I

(AIO 38 npellOCT8BHHenp8S0cpOKnpHolipeT8TeJlH) I i

f----------------------------------~--------middot------middot-I

1lPA3IlOPEUHTEJIHH l(E~CTBWI C HMOTA (lIACT OT HMOTA)

nPABO HA CfPOE)K

38 Ha xorn OCHOBaHHe uaTa

)KHnHWHO crpowrencrsompI) CTBHIO H Cre$BHB lliHBeHKoBH THnOBilOrOBOp 29111954 Bb3MeIIlHO

(AIO 38 pUnOpelll8HeOnHC8HHenpH06peTaTeJlH) I

12AKTOCbCTABIITEJI ~I OJITaTeHeBa bo6qeBa - rneKCnepT -

I

(TpHTe HMeHa H )VIbjKHOCT) n (laquo IOllnHc bullbullbullbullbull

133AliEJIE)KKI1

I

------------------------------ JI

230l 2009

YllOCTOBEPEH~E

3A f~AHb4Hfl OlJEHKA flO 4Jl 264 OT AOfiK

~ HOCmiddotmiddot to YJgtcIBf~peiiIIE C8 H3paB HiJ )CH(a~HW3 ltIn ~~ CIT npVli1 01 JIl ~J PbM 3Mtrr jm6i sn 107i~rflilt HZ

OSl1lHA -KA3AHJTbK

8X

i 2J12050 ]lEI I1DBOIIoi --r bull bullbull _

i hfloY rjgt~~~Hlm~faHtiI iIlMOi e 30 oq6HlltJiSa~middotI~Hmiddot() Jel1tHO 1paBO 118 en OSCifJ

na Sal lVlpeantla IaCT Mr1M Kfi Ml 1)1 H~O

- ~

(noco-iaa ce CllllJUl J1~Iue1O IIMa I HflM21 HenOrllCeHI~ ~lH4HI4 ltliJPgt$1li8Hj1r)

l~ttl(~UypJi~HJ VtnAli ytIP6PtWJ~t1t0 H3 eelltHMnpaU Bbpxy Htltl1W)tfiIiMpound1 ~M()TM ~ HalCJltiACl~~tf1t IipUlFI(fiO)~JfiW

liifiulirj)(liM~ 1j~EiOT~to1n~ OOUV11t1 r1fHiillaO DIy HeMMMCllli KitTO H~nampPMIH miOClltfII ~l KilrWfHlfWl li~iI T~pfjttl1I

~PY~Ina en~cSatHHO Ha llncrreva liiTM oco6eH aCinar ee AOIljCKla iilKO npeXBbpJllUCnffr CbClilmHl(

1qp~II~~rrf ViHtrreKapl-U1ff( ~V1b)l(HlIK rilJ1M 3arJOfOAiITensn npeOCcTi36l11 AeKnapa4MSl e fiAlJfCl ltilIOr~gt(wmiddot bull

iOi)lgtl~ilmi~~ ida r~J~IYavrreJlHO t113r1hIlHeHllte ny6111111HIi AbP)I(iJElHIII III 06~IIIHClGl D3eMaHVl~~ u1264 ~niT

hmiddotmiddotjti~imiddotmiddot ~1 ~1Ar~~1Y flO f1t1EKlA ilO~lfisect1() Mc~Hm flI)(~

iii 11 r~)ryltifi~ np~~J HorAPIJIYC

C1CneU~a1111()T

) )

--9

06Jl1tHA KA3AHAbK lUiPEKUJUI YCTPOilCTBO HATEPMTOPIDITA

1( Jr(a QZ~- COQCKHUA 1fLiI ~ 1~

1amp Yperynapan (Ue1r)lllfffiH ) nOJ~ ~1yenoS~~4444BQ~ san pa~~amp~ -7tJj rpmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~fnimiddot~b-middot bir~ Ilnoui na~b1t lLf2 M- Cofcrseso MJlCTO B mIOTaILt Mshy

~~~~~~~~~lllii~ot~~~~ 1I0T an N 64 T UI aeno lgt2Q aT l~cltr

~~~middot~middotN~middotlit5middotmiddotrmiddot~~~middotmiddotmiddotbSmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot ~1~

M~yenb~K~Bmiddot~bcent~~1 HOT alIT 1)(160 T )~XHC~eno tC oT11~r

HOT alIT 1f T neno aT r ~~

ltdtvmiddotjM-gt=middotmiddot-bull A ~ o ~lt lto)~ ~ ~L t ~eTaxcara OT d Jly ~Wi a c-middott~ KBNA5Y0~ 79 7 0

Cxuuara Ille cnYlKlI ~) middotZmiddot~middot ~r-e~middot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotUmiddot ~IlnauJaf lilY 1 = A 7C 06 0 t(perYjJ~UHSl IofptH c ~ ~ 1 -2 (gt1 6On06peH nonp YCTp N~aH Ie middot~ rp It~ ~middotmiddotJmiddotmiddotA middot On06peH xanacrp ~HX)~ W~ a~ l rmiddot

Q~ ~ - - _- - shy

~hl(epTan roJ --- ( e ~o~A J444 H)l(HCTHq ( w~ )

E) H-I tlt e-c kH rro tA ~A T e Vl ~ Y rL 11 XIX - II CT excnepr KP ~ ~

lA 3gtA-cp ~ bOlo 3AIiEJlE)((KA t1G1dXIk1 f 2 K0g2 ~ H gt11J A lpO M e ~ Yi e~T4~-Jpound LC YA lT (1MrT lf1J-lt WH =-(2

Ll A L~0b6no nAAtlA KAJAHIb Jlt 0 tlAA OT 1JGf3r ) I ~ I - 1 I 1-1 _( Ob~A ~ 4odeg(c J4 OJ -OOgr - cr- fAABEH APXMTEKT ~i~ imiddot(ijl lt

(1 i middotil bulli 1 l i

Peracrsp

KapTOTeKa

Aocne

3BH)( Ii OIIHCAHHE HA MMOTA

IHMenpe3HMe H 41sMHJ1HAI

3A

1 - 130

1 272

f

5rPAHHlIJI HA IIMOTA

17032009

tIll56 tIll2arrlT2 OT 30C

yperynapas II03eMJleH HMOT

( TPHCTa H cenesmecer KBM) 6C3 nocrpoeasrre ~pxy Hero lKHJlHWHH crpaaa

C ofiuia nnoui 37000 KBM

HMOlloT e orpeneu 3aHHllHBHlIYanHO lKHJlHUlHO crpovrencrao

~

06JlaCT Crapa 3aropa ofiUlHHa Ka3aHJl1gtK rptc) rpKasarersx

KO 82 YIIH XIX 3anooell pem4342006r Ha OGe

nn x 1444 MecTHoCT

1(1( YJI ITPEOEPA)I(EHHE

6n ox er anX

CeBepOH3TOK-YI1Jf V-1445 IOroH3TOK-YTIM XVIIImiddot 1447

IOr03anall-ynTIpeoGpagtKeHHe ceaeposanan-Yllld 1-1443 H II-1442

l---------+----~----~-----------------shy6UAHhIffiA OUEHKA HA 1282050 MOTA KbM MOMERTA HA YTBhPJKLABAHE HA AKTAf----------+--------------------------------shy7EIIBUJ COECTBEHIDlt 061111lHB KB3BHJIIoK HAHMOTA I

I L- --- ~ J

8CbCOIJCTBEHID(H

9HOMEP H lIATA HA CbCTABEHH nO-PARO AKTOBE

HJlMB

bull

HlIMB I

I I

I-------------L-------------------------------------ilOIIPElJOCTABEHH [(pABA 3A YIIPABJIEHHE I I I I

OCHOBaHHe naTa I i

Or KMeTlI ua 06WHHaTll HB OCHoBBHHe IiI12MS OT 3BKOHa 3B i 06WHHCKBTB co6CTIleHOCT

I

(AIO 38 npellOCT8BHHenp8S0cpOKnpHolipeT8TeJlH) I i

f----------------------------------~--------middot------middot-I

1lPA3IlOPEUHTEJIHH l(E~CTBWI C HMOTA (lIACT OT HMOTA)

nPABO HA CfPOE)K

38 Ha xorn OCHOBaHHe uaTa

)KHnHWHO crpowrencrsompI) CTBHIO H Cre$BHB lliHBeHKoBH THnOBilOrOBOp 29111954 Bb3MeIIlHO

(AIO 38 pUnOpelll8HeOnHC8HHenpH06peTaTeJlH) I

12AKTOCbCTABIITEJI ~I OJITaTeHeBa bo6qeBa - rneKCnepT -

I

(TpHTe HMeHa H )VIbjKHOCT) n (laquo IOllnHc bullbullbullbullbull

133AliEJIE)KKI1

I

------------------------------ JI

230l 2009

YllOCTOBEPEH~E

3A f~AHb4Hfl OlJEHKA flO 4Jl 264 OT AOfiK

~ HOCmiddotmiddot to YJgtcIBf~peiiIIE C8 H3paB HiJ )CH(a~HW3 ltIn ~~ CIT npVli1 01 JIl ~J PbM 3Mtrr jm6i sn 107i~rflilt HZ

OSl1lHA -KA3AHJTbK

8X

i 2J12050 ]lEI I1DBOIIoi --r bull bullbull _

i hfloY rjgt~~~Hlm~faHtiI iIlMOi e 30 oq6HlltJiSa~middotI~Hmiddot() Jel1tHO 1paBO 118 en OSCifJ

na Sal lVlpeantla IaCT Mr1M Kfi Ml 1)1 H~O

- ~

(noco-iaa ce CllllJUl J1~Iue1O IIMa I HflM21 HenOrllCeHI~ ~lH4HI4 ltliJPgt$1li8Hj1r)

l~ttl(~UypJi~HJ VtnAli ytIP6PtWJ~t1t0 H3 eelltHMnpaU Bbpxy Htltl1W)tfiIiMpound1 ~M()TM ~ HalCJltiACl~~tf1t IipUlFI(fiO)~JfiW

liifiulirj)(liM~ 1j~EiOT~to1n~ OOUV11t1 r1fHiillaO DIy HeMMMCllli KitTO H~nampPMIH miOClltfII ~l KilrWfHlfWl li~iI T~pfjttl1I

~PY~Ina en~cSatHHO Ha llncrreva liiTM oco6eH aCinar ee AOIljCKla iilKO npeXBbpJllUCnffr CbClilmHl(

1qp~II~~rrf ViHtrreKapl-U1ff( ~V1b)l(HlIK rilJ1M 3arJOfOAiITensn npeOCcTi36l11 AeKnapa4MSl e fiAlJfCl ltilIOr~gt(wmiddot bull

iOi)lgtl~ilmi~~ ida r~J~IYavrreJlHO t113r1hIlHeHllte ny6111111HIi AbP)I(iJElHIII III 06~IIIHClGl D3eMaHVl~~ u1264 ~niT

hmiddotmiddotjti~imiddotmiddot ~1 ~1Ar~~1Y flO f1t1EKlA ilO~lfisect1() Mc~Hm flI)(~

iii 11 r~)ryltifi~ np~~J HorAPIJIYC

C1CneU~a1111()T

) )

--9

06Jl1tHA KA3AHAbK lUiPEKUJUI YCTPOilCTBO HATEPMTOPIDITA

1( Jr(a QZ~- COQCKHUA 1fLiI ~ 1~

1amp Yperynapan (Ue1r)lllfffiH ) nOJ~ ~1yenoS~~4444BQ~ san pa~~amp~ -7tJj rpmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~fnimiddot~b-middot bir~ Ilnoui na~b1t lLf2 M- Cofcrseso MJlCTO B mIOTaILt Mshy

~~~~~~~~~lllii~ot~~~~ 1I0T an N 64 T UI aeno lgt2Q aT l~cltr

~~~middot~middotN~middotlit5middotmiddotrmiddot~~~middotmiddotmiddotbSmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot ~1~

M~yenb~K~Bmiddot~bcent~~1 HOT alIT 1)(160 T )~XHC~eno tC oT11~r

HOT alIT 1f T neno aT r ~~

ltdtvmiddotjM-gt=middotmiddot-bull A ~ o ~lt lto)~ ~ ~L t ~eTaxcara OT d Jly ~Wi a c-middott~ KBNA5Y0~ 79 7 0

Cxuuara Ille cnYlKlI ~) middotZmiddot~middot ~r-e~middot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotUmiddot ~IlnauJaf lilY 1 = A 7C 06 0 t(perYjJ~UHSl IofptH c ~ ~ 1 -2 (gt1 6On06peH nonp YCTp N~aH Ie middot~ rp It~ ~middotmiddotJmiddotmiddotA middot On06peH xanacrp ~HX)~ W~ a~ l rmiddot

Q~ ~ - - _- - shy

~hl(epTan roJ --- ( e ~o~A J444 H)l(HCTHq ( w~ )

E) H-I tlt e-c kH rro tA ~A T e Vl ~ Y rL 11 XIX - II CT excnepr KP ~ ~

lA 3gtA-cp ~ bOlo 3AIiEJlE)((KA t1G1dXIk1 f 2 K0g2 ~ H gt11J A lpO M e ~ Yi e~T4~-Jpound LC YA lT (1MrT lf1J-lt WH =-(2

Ll A L~0b6no nAAtlA KAJAHIb Jlt 0 tlAA OT 1JGf3r ) I ~ I - 1 I 1-1 _( Ob~A ~ 4odeg(c J4 OJ -OOgr - cr- fAABEH APXMTEKT ~i~ imiddot(ijl lt

(1 i middotil bulli 1 l i

8CbCOIJCTBEHID(H

9HOMEP H lIATA HA CbCTABEHH nO-PARO AKTOBE

HJlMB

bull

HlIMB I

I I

I-------------L-------------------------------------ilOIIPElJOCTABEHH [(pABA 3A YIIPABJIEHHE I I I I

OCHOBaHHe naTa I i

Or KMeTlI ua 06WHHaTll HB OCHoBBHHe IiI12MS OT 3BKOHa 3B i 06WHHCKBTB co6CTIleHOCT

I

(AIO 38 npellOCT8BHHenp8S0cpOKnpHolipeT8TeJlH) I i

f----------------------------------~--------middot------middot-I

1lPA3IlOPEUHTEJIHH l(E~CTBWI C HMOTA (lIACT OT HMOTA)

nPABO HA CfPOE)K

38 Ha xorn OCHOBaHHe uaTa

)KHnHWHO crpowrencrsompI) CTBHIO H Cre$BHB lliHBeHKoBH THnOBilOrOBOp 29111954 Bb3MeIIlHO

(AIO 38 pUnOpelll8HeOnHC8HHenpH06peTaTeJlH) I

12AKTOCbCTABIITEJI ~I OJITaTeHeBa bo6qeBa - rneKCnepT -

I

(TpHTe HMeHa H )VIbjKHOCT) n (laquo IOllnHc bullbullbullbullbull

133AliEJIE)KKI1

I

------------------------------ JI

230l 2009

YllOCTOBEPEH~E

3A f~AHb4Hfl OlJEHKA flO 4Jl 264 OT AOfiK

~ HOCmiddotmiddot to YJgtcIBf~peiiIIE C8 H3paB HiJ )CH(a~HW3 ltIn ~~ CIT npVli1 01 JIl ~J PbM 3Mtrr jm6i sn 107i~rflilt HZ

OSl1lHA -KA3AHJTbK

8X

i 2J12050 ]lEI I1DBOIIoi --r bull bullbull _

i hfloY rjgt~~~Hlm~faHtiI iIlMOi e 30 oq6HlltJiSa~middotI~Hmiddot() Jel1tHO 1paBO 118 en OSCifJ

na Sal lVlpeantla IaCT Mr1M Kfi Ml 1)1 H~O

- ~

(noco-iaa ce CllllJUl J1~Iue1O IIMa I HflM21 HenOrllCeHI~ ~lH4HI4 ltliJPgt$1li8Hj1r)

l~ttl(~UypJi~HJ VtnAli ytIP6PtWJ~t1t0 H3 eelltHMnpaU Bbpxy Htltl1W)tfiIiMpound1 ~M()TM ~ HalCJltiACl~~tf1t IipUlFI(fiO)~JfiW

liifiulirj)(liM~ 1j~EiOT~to1n~ OOUV11t1 r1fHiillaO DIy HeMMMCllli KitTO H~nampPMIH miOClltfII ~l KilrWfHlfWl li~iI T~pfjttl1I

~PY~Ina en~cSatHHO Ha llncrreva liiTM oco6eH aCinar ee AOIljCKla iilKO npeXBbpJllUCnffr CbClilmHl(

1qp~II~~rrf ViHtrreKapl-U1ff( ~V1b)l(HlIK rilJ1M 3arJOfOAiITensn npeOCcTi36l11 AeKnapa4MSl e fiAlJfCl ltilIOr~gt(wmiddot bull

iOi)lgtl~ilmi~~ ida r~J~IYavrreJlHO t113r1hIlHeHllte ny6111111HIi AbP)I(iJElHIII III 06~IIIHClGl D3eMaHVl~~ u1264 ~niT

hmiddotmiddotjti~imiddotmiddot ~1 ~1Ar~~1Y flO f1t1EKlA ilO~lfisect1() Mc~Hm flI)(~

iii 11 r~)ryltifi~ np~~J HorAPIJIYC

C1CneU~a1111()T

) )

--9

06Jl1tHA KA3AHAbK lUiPEKUJUI YCTPOilCTBO HATEPMTOPIDITA

1( Jr(a QZ~- COQCKHUA 1fLiI ~ 1~

1amp Yperynapan (Ue1r)lllfffiH ) nOJ~ ~1yenoS~~4444BQ~ san pa~~amp~ -7tJj rpmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~fnimiddot~b-middot bir~ Ilnoui na~b1t lLf2 M- Cofcrseso MJlCTO B mIOTaILt Mshy

~~~~~~~~~lllii~ot~~~~ 1I0T an N 64 T UI aeno lgt2Q aT l~cltr

~~~middot~middotN~middotlit5middotmiddotrmiddot~~~middotmiddotmiddotbSmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot ~1~

M~yenb~K~Bmiddot~bcent~~1 HOT alIT 1)(160 T )~XHC~eno tC oT11~r

HOT alIT 1f T neno aT r ~~

ltdtvmiddotjM-gt=middotmiddot-bull A ~ o ~lt lto)~ ~ ~L t ~eTaxcara OT d Jly ~Wi a c-middott~ KBNA5Y0~ 79 7 0

Cxuuara Ille cnYlKlI ~) middotZmiddot~middot ~r-e~middot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotUmiddot ~IlnauJaf lilY 1 = A 7C 06 0 t(perYjJ~UHSl IofptH c ~ ~ 1 -2 (gt1 6On06peH nonp YCTp N~aH Ie middot~ rp It~ ~middotmiddotJmiddotmiddotA middot On06peH xanacrp ~HX)~ W~ a~ l rmiddot

Q~ ~ - - _- - shy

~hl(epTan roJ --- ( e ~o~A J444 H)l(HCTHq ( w~ )

E) H-I tlt e-c kH rro tA ~A T e Vl ~ Y rL 11 XIX - II CT excnepr KP ~ ~

lA 3gtA-cp ~ bOlo 3AIiEJlE)((KA t1G1dXIk1 f 2 K0g2 ~ H gt11J A lpO M e ~ Yi e~T4~-Jpound LC YA lT (1MrT lf1J-lt WH =-(2

Ll A L~0b6no nAAtlA KAJAHIb Jlt 0 tlAA OT 1JGf3r ) I ~ I - 1 I 1-1 _( Ob~A ~ 4odeg(c J4 OJ -OOgr - cr- fAABEH APXMTEKT ~i~ imiddot(ijl lt

(1 i middotil bulli 1 l i

230l 2009

YllOCTOBEPEH~E

3A f~AHb4Hfl OlJEHKA flO 4Jl 264 OT AOfiK

~ HOCmiddotmiddot to YJgtcIBf~peiiIIE C8 H3paB HiJ )CH(a~HW3 ltIn ~~ CIT npVli1 01 JIl ~J PbM 3Mtrr jm6i sn 107i~rflilt HZ

OSl1lHA -KA3AHJTbK

8X

i 2J12050 ]lEI I1DBOIIoi --r bull bullbull _

i hfloY rjgt~~~Hlm~faHtiI iIlMOi e 30 oq6HlltJiSa~middotI~Hmiddot() Jel1tHO 1paBO 118 en OSCifJ

na Sal lVlpeantla IaCT Mr1M Kfi Ml 1)1 H~O

- ~

(noco-iaa ce CllllJUl J1~Iue1O IIMa I HflM21 HenOrllCeHI~ ~lH4HI4 ltliJPgt$1li8Hj1r)

l~ttl(~UypJi~HJ VtnAli ytIP6PtWJ~t1t0 H3 eelltHMnpaU Bbpxy Htltl1W)tfiIiMpound1 ~M()TM ~ HalCJltiACl~~tf1t IipUlFI(fiO)~JfiW

liifiulirj)(liM~ 1j~EiOT~to1n~ OOUV11t1 r1fHiillaO DIy HeMMMCllli KitTO H~nampPMIH miOClltfII ~l KilrWfHlfWl li~iI T~pfjttl1I

~PY~Ina en~cSatHHO Ha llncrreva liiTM oco6eH aCinar ee AOIljCKla iilKO npeXBbpJllUCnffr CbClilmHl(

1qp~II~~rrf ViHtrreKapl-U1ff( ~V1b)l(HlIK rilJ1M 3arJOfOAiITensn npeOCcTi36l11 AeKnapa4MSl e fiAlJfCl ltilIOr~gt(wmiddot bull

iOi)lgtl~ilmi~~ ida r~J~IYavrreJlHO t113r1hIlHeHllte ny6111111HIi AbP)I(iJElHIII III 06~IIIHClGl D3eMaHVl~~ u1264 ~niT

hmiddotmiddotjti~imiddotmiddot ~1 ~1Ar~~1Y flO f1t1EKlA ilO~lfisect1() Mc~Hm flI)(~

iii 11 r~)ryltifi~ np~~J HorAPIJIYC

C1CneU~a1111()T

) )

--9

06Jl1tHA KA3AHAbK lUiPEKUJUI YCTPOilCTBO HATEPMTOPIDITA

1( Jr(a QZ~- COQCKHUA 1fLiI ~ 1~

1amp Yperynapan (Ue1r)lllfffiH ) nOJ~ ~1yenoS~~4444BQ~ san pa~~amp~ -7tJj rpmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~fnimiddot~b-middot bir~ Ilnoui na~b1t lLf2 M- Cofcrseso MJlCTO B mIOTaILt Mshy

~~~~~~~~~lllii~ot~~~~ 1I0T an N 64 T UI aeno lgt2Q aT l~cltr

~~~middot~middotN~middotlit5middotmiddotrmiddot~~~middotmiddotmiddotbSmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot ~1~

M~yenb~K~Bmiddot~bcent~~1 HOT alIT 1)(160 T )~XHC~eno tC oT11~r

HOT alIT 1f T neno aT r ~~

ltdtvmiddotjM-gt=middotmiddot-bull A ~ o ~lt lto)~ ~ ~L t ~eTaxcara OT d Jly ~Wi a c-middott~ KBNA5Y0~ 79 7 0

Cxuuara Ille cnYlKlI ~) middotZmiddot~middot ~r-e~middot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotUmiddot ~IlnauJaf lilY 1 = A 7C 06 0 t(perYjJ~UHSl IofptH c ~ ~ 1 -2 (gt1 6On06peH nonp YCTp N~aH Ie middot~ rp It~ ~middotmiddotJmiddotmiddotA middot On06peH xanacrp ~HX)~ W~ a~ l rmiddot

Q~ ~ - - _- - shy

~hl(epTan roJ --- ( e ~o~A J444 H)l(HCTHq ( w~ )

E) H-I tlt e-c kH rro tA ~A T e Vl ~ Y rL 11 XIX - II CT excnepr KP ~ ~

lA 3gtA-cp ~ bOlo 3AIiEJlE)((KA t1G1dXIk1 f 2 K0g2 ~ H gt11J A lpO M e ~ Yi e~T4~-Jpound LC YA lT (1MrT lf1J-lt WH =-(2

Ll A L~0b6no nAAtlA KAJAHIb Jlt 0 tlAA OT 1JGf3r ) I ~ I - 1 I 1-1 _( Ob~A ~ 4odeg(c J4 OJ -OOgr - cr- fAABEH APXMTEKT ~i~ imiddot(ijl lt

(1 i middotil bulli 1 l i

) )

--9

06Jl1tHA KA3AHAbK lUiPEKUJUI YCTPOilCTBO HATEPMTOPIDITA

1( Jr(a QZ~- COQCKHUA 1fLiI ~ 1~

1amp Yperynapan (Ue1r)lllfffiH ) nOJ~ ~1yenoS~~4444BQ~ san pa~~amp~ -7tJj rpmiddot~middotmiddotmiddot~fnimiddot~b-middot bir~ Ilnoui na~b1t lLf2 M- Cofcrseso MJlCTO B mIOTaILt Mshy

~~~~~~~~~lllii~ot~~~~ 1I0T an N 64 T UI aeno lgt2Q aT l~cltr

~~~middot~middotN~middotlit5middotmiddotrmiddot~~~middotmiddotmiddotbSmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot ~1~

M~yenb~K~Bmiddot~bcent~~1 HOT alIT 1)(160 T )~XHC~eno tC oT11~r

HOT alIT 1f T neno aT r ~~

ltdtvmiddotjM-gt=middotmiddot-bull A ~ o ~lt lto)~ ~ ~L t ~eTaxcara OT d Jly ~Wi a c-middott~ KBNA5Y0~ 79 7 0

Cxuuara Ille cnYlKlI ~) middotZmiddot~middot ~r-e~middot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotUmiddot ~IlnauJaf lilY 1 = A 7C 06 0 t(perYjJ~UHSl IofptH c ~ ~ 1 -2 (gt1 6On06peH nonp YCTp N~aH Ie middot~ rp It~ ~middotmiddotJmiddotmiddotA middot On06peH xanacrp ~HX)~ W~ a~ l rmiddot

Q~ ~ - - _- - shy

~hl(epTan roJ --- ( e ~o~A J444 H)l(HCTHq ( w~ )

E) H-I tlt e-c kH rro tA ~A T e Vl ~ Y rL 11 XIX - II CT excnepr KP ~ ~

lA 3gtA-cp ~ bOlo 3AIiEJlE)((KA t1G1dXIk1 f 2 K0g2 ~ H gt11J A lpO M e ~ Yi e~T4~-Jpound LC YA lT (1MrT lf1J-lt WH =-(2

Ll A L~0b6no nAAtlA KAJAHIb Jlt 0 tlAA OT 1JGf3r ) I ~ I - 1 I 1-1 _( Ob~A ~ 4odeg(c J4 OJ -OOgr - cr- fAABEH APXMTEKT ~i~ imiddot(ijl lt

(1 i middotil bulli 1 l i

na3apHa OUeHKa -y n M N~XIXmiddot1444KB82 rpKa3aHnbK

M3X N~ 250204 2009 r

02042009 r rpKa3aHnbK

2 11

na3apHa oyeHKa -y n MN2XIX-1444KB82 rpKa3SHnbK

npeAMeT Ha 3aAaHMeTO Oueuxa na 06lltl1HCKI1 HeABI1gtKIIIM IIIMOT - 3eMSI Cnnoui OT 370 KBM B yperyJllllpaH n03eMJleH IIIMOT ynlllXIX-1444 B KB82 no nnaaa Ha rpKa3aHJlbK06JlCTapa 3aropaYJl npe06pagtKeHllle 2

Bb3J10gtKMTen 06U1MHa Ka3aHnbKAoroBop N2 AO 252703 2009r

1113nbllHMTen 6anKaHMHBecTEOOAKa3aHnbK 4pe3 eKllln C PbKOBOAI1TeJl I1HgtKTeMeHygtKKa 6l-1BaHoBa nparexaaaui nl1leH3 NQ714498 1113AaAeH OT An-CocPI1S1

06eKT Ha oueHKaTa 3eMR Cnnoui OT37000 KBM npencraanseauia 1acrHa 0611ll1HCKa c06CTBeHoCT CpeanM3MpaHo npaso Ha crpoexeea nocrpceaara B Hero crpaAa

Yen Ha oueHKaTaOnpeAeJlSlHe naaapaara CTO~HOCT Ha 06eKTa Cuen npoaaxtia

EcbeKTMBHa AaTa Ha oueHKaTa 02042009r

CPOK Ha BanMDHocr Ha oueHKaTaUJeCT MeCela OT ecPeKTIIIBHaTa nara Ha oueakara

1113non3BaHM MeTODM Ha oueHKa 1MeTOll no BJUCTaHOBHTeJlHa croHHOCT - TeKYl1ll1Te pa3XOAIII sa I1AeHTIII4HOTO Bb3np0l13BegtKAaHe Ha pasoeuieaoro 6bAelltO CTpOl1TeJlCTBO C OT411TaHe aa CbOTBeTHI1Te pa3XOAI1 sa TOBa 2MeTOR Ha na3apHHTe cpaBHeHHR - 6a311pa ce Ha peracrpapaaara IIIHcPopMalI1S1 sa 1113BbpWeHI1 npOAagtK6111 Ha IIIMOTI1 6Jllll3KI1 no Ka4eCTBa III napanerpa AO OleHSIBaHIIISI

npaBeH CTaJYT Ha o6eKTa OleHSlBaHI1S1T 06eKT e 3eMSI C nnoUl OT 370 KBM B ynl-1 XIX-1144KB82 no nnaua Ha rpKa3aHJlbK06lltl1Ha Ka3aHflbK- 1aCTHa 06U1MHcKa co6crBeHoCT csrnacao AKT NQ650 OT 17032009 rperl1cTbpl-130 xaprorexa 1 AOCI1e 272 06eKTa e c peanM3MpaHo npaeo Ha CTpOegtK csrnac-o lloroBop OT 1954rHoTaKT NQ682004 III NQ542006r Bb3JlOgtKI1TeJlSlT He e npeAOCTaBI1Jl AaHHI1 sa HaJll1411e Ha peCTIIITyl1II0HHI1 npeTeHlIII11 HaJlOgtKeHI1 Bb36paHIII IIIJlIII APyrl1 sel1lHI1 TegtKeCTI1 BbPXY OleHSlBaHI1S1 06eKT

0606U1eHO onMcaHMe Ha paHOHa

MecronOnOgtKeHMe Ha paHOHa HaCeJleHO MSiCTO rpaA Ka3aHnbK KB82 cDYHKlI1oHafleH TI1n BTOPM 30Ha BTOpa BIIIl Ha o6eKTa 3eMSI- c panM3MpaHO npaBO Ha CTpOegtK

aCT aHa aMOHa

1113BOAH 06eKTbT ce HaMlllpa Ha BTopocTeneHHa YJll1la B KBapTaJl C npe06JlaAaBal1ll1 gtKI1Jll1l1lHI1 napuena III gtKI1Jll1l1lHI1 6JlOKOBe Cnpoxapaua eononpoeonenaexpauaauepaaouuo OCBeTJleHI1e 11 KaHaJlIll3aLIIISI Ha paees repea C1113nbJlHeHa BepTI1KaJlHa nJlaHI1pOBKa 06eKTbT He nenana B pa~oH CBJlOWeHI1 eKOJlOrl14HI1 xapaKTepl1CTIIIKIII

OnMcaHHe Ha o6eKTa Ha oueHKaTa

3eMR 37000 KBM- yperyJll1paH n03eMJleH I1MOTynlll Nil XIX-1444 B KB82 no nnaaa Ha rpKa3aHJlbK06JlCT3aropa 6m 3aKOHHO nocrpoeaare C OTCTbneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK gtKMnHUlHa crpaAa co6CTBeHoCT Ha AHTOH BacHneB WHBeHKoB

3 na3apHa OUeHKa -y n ~ N2XIX-1444KB82 rpKa3ilHnbK

HaM-eepeKTMBHO Mo6po nOn3BaHe IlPIiI OlleHSIBaHeTO Ha HaH-eltpeKTIiIBHOTO iii A06po nOJl3BaHe CMe ce PbKOBOAliIl1li1 OT

C11eAHOTO lBb3MO)lHO 1i13n0Jl3BaHe(ltp1iI31i14eCKO) - napuerrsr e 3aCTpOeH C)IliIl1li1lJlHa crpaaa 2Pa3peWeHO n0Jl3BaHe(3aKOHHO) - IiIMOTa e yperyl1li1paH C npanoxeaa peryl1alllilSi iii

paspeiueao CTpOIiITel1CTBO Ha )IliIl1li1lJlHa crpaaarapax iii APn 3HaH-eltpeKTIiIBHO iii A06po nOJl3BaHe - sa )IliIl1li1lJlHIiI HygtKAIiI

Ha 06eKTa e HanpaBeH ornen Cbrl1aCHO yCTpoHCTBeHIiISI nl1aH B napuena e OCb~eCTBeHO OCHOBHOTO 3acrpoHBaHe - M3rpaeHa MaCMBHa elfHOeTagtKHa gtKMnM~Ha crpalfa Csrnacno yCTpoHcTBeHIiISI nnaa B napuena ce orpexaa nl1bTHOCT Ha 3aCTpOSIBaHe AO 60 1MaHKIiI B npeABIiIA reonerpavuara ltpopMa Ha napuenapaanepa iii nl101Jl iii 1i13XO)lAaHKIiI OT 1i131i1CKBaHIiISITa 3a OTCTOSlHIiISI OT OCHOBHOTO 3aCTpoSiBaHe AO CTpaHIiI4Ho peryl1alllilOHHIiITe 111i1HIiIIiI Ha napuena nplileMaMe Aonbl1HIiITel1HO 6bAelJl0 CTpoliITel1CTBo CbC 311 OT 220 M2 iii P31l- 340 M2

Ce6eCTOHHocna Ha IiIMOTa B T031i1 cl1Y4aH 61i1 61i111

- )f(liIl1li1lJlHa nnoui 30000 M2 X 4700011BM2 = 141 000 l1B - He)lliIl1li1l1lHa nnouirapax iii APn 4000 M2 X 2800011BM2 = 11 20011B-------==-==lt-=

061Jl0 15220011B CTOHHOCT Ha 3eMSlTa - Pearnpauia 3eMSI 22000 M2 x 1200011B = 26 400 l1B - He pe-rn-paura 3eMSI 15000 M2 x 1200011BX 50 = 9 000 l1B

061Jl0 35 400 l1B Ce6eCToHHocna Ha paspeuieaoro CTpoliITel1CTBo 152 200 fiB - 35 40011B = 116 800 l1B lJaHHIiI aa ce6eCToHHocna Ha 6bAelJlaTa crpourenaa npoAyKllliISI ca B3eTIiI OT Cnelllilal11i131i1paHIiITe 1i13AaHIiISI Ha Crpoaexcnepr - CEK COQgtIiISICTpoIiITel1eH 0630p KbM 2009 r iii CnpaB04HIiIK sa uesare ua CMP KaKTO iii c06CTBeHa IiIHltpopMaIlIilSi sa ueuare Ha KBaApaTeH MeTbp sacrpoena n1101Jl B ueuara Ha CMP e BKfl104eHa iii ne4a116aTa aa cTpoliITel1HIiISI npennpaeaa-i pasxozurre sa KOHTpOl1 iii npoexrvpaae pasxonraquo sa TaKCIiI iii

CbrnacyBaHIiISI iii APn Ilapuerrsr ce HaMlilpa BbB sropa crpoarensa 30Ha Ha rpaaa B xaapran C npeotinanaaauio HIiICKO iii cpeaao eraxao CTpoIiITel1CTBo1MaHKIiI B npeABIiIAMeCTOn0110)leHlileTO Ha 0lleHSIBaHIiISIT 06eKT iii HerOBIiISIT CTaTyT-3eMSI C peal11i131i1paHO CTpoliITel1cTBo onpeAel1S1Me 06elJleTeHlile n0l1Y4aBaHo Ha npliIHlllilna c06cTBeHocT BbPXY napuen cpeutv )IIiIIlIiIIJle He noae-e OT 15 1i1111i11i13pa3eHo B nesa 116 80011B x15 = 17 52011B - CTOHHOCT Ha napuena -MeTOAbT e cue-nca -ipea npsko cpaBHeHlile Ha pa3rne)lAaHIiISI IiIMOT C nOA06HIiI Ha Hero

KOIiITO ca 61i1111i1 npOAaAeHIiI ny6111i14HO KaTO lleHaTa ce onpeAel1S1 Bb3 OCHOBa Ha Te31i1 npeAIiIWHIiI CAeIlKIiI1MaHKIil B npeABIilA AaHHIilTe cb6paHIiI OT oueuarenare Iil IiIHTepBIOTaTa nposeneaa C areHllliI1iI sa HeABlil)llilMIiI IiIMOTIil sa IiIMOTIiI C na3apHIiI Iil CTpOIilTel1HIiI xapaKTeplilCTIilKIiI 6111i13KIil AO Te31i1 Ha olleHSIBaHIiISI IiIMOT-3eMH C peanM3MpaHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK ce OltPOPMIiI cpeaaa nasepaa uena - 8500nBM2

bull

CTOMHOCT Ha 3eMHTa 37000 KBM - 37000 KBM x 850011BM2 =31450 ns

4 na3apHa OUeHKa -y n M NXIX-1444KB82 rpKa3ilHnbK

MeTOA Ha o~eHKa CTOMHOcr nB

TernOBeH Koecb

npeTerneHa crOMHOcr

Bb3CTaHOBlITenHa CTOt1HOCT 17500 05 8750

na3apHlITe cpaBHeHlISI 31500 05 15750 CnpaBeA1IHBa nasapaa

crOMHOcr 061Jto 24500

H3BOAH npll onpeaenaaero Ha TernOBHlITe KoecPlIlIlIeHTlI oueaarenure ca lI3XOgtKAaJlll OT

cPaKTa4e o6eKTa e c peanH3HpaHo npaee Ha crpOegtK - aacrpoea C gtKHnHUlHa crpaAaKOSITO He e co6CTBeHOCT Ha 06lllIHaTaC Bb3MOgtKHOCT aa norrsnsauio CTpOllTenCTBO

lt13XOgtKpoundtat1KlI OT BClI4KO 113nOgtKeHO fJO TYK noeanarane ueaa aa npofJagtK6a Ha 3eMSI C

peanll3l1paHO npaso Ha CTpOegtK OT 24 500nB HnH 6622nBM2

KOMeHTap CbcTaBlITenl1Te Ha T03l1 AOKJIaA o6pbllaT BHlIMaHlIe BbPXY QgtaKTa 4e CbllI1S1T

e npenner Ha TbprOBCKa Ta~Ha lI KOHQgtlIAeHlIlIanHOCT npeAHa3Ha4eH e caMO aa cnygttlte6Ho

nOJl3BaHe OT 061JtHHa Ka3aHnbK lI 4e TOt1 e co6CTBeHoCT eAlIHCTBeHo Ha Bb3nOgtKHTeIIR Tot1 He MOgtKe Aa 6bAe KOnllpaH lI lI3nOn3BaH 3a KaKBlITO lI Aa e lIenll 6e3 nllCMeHOTO

paapeuieaae OT Bb3IIOgtKHTeIIR - 06U1HHa Ka38HnbK 11 6e3 csrnacnero Ha

CbcraBHTeIIR - 6anKaHHHBecrEOOAKa3aHnbK OlleHKaTa e 113BbpWeHa CbBeCTHO lI 06eKTlIBHO He3aBl1Cl1Ml1Te eKCnepTI1 C4l1TaT 4e He MoraT Aa 6bltaT nOCTaBeHI1 OrpaHlI4eHI1S1 B

113nOn3BaHeTO Ha APyrl1 TeXHlIKlI 3a aHanl13 lI OlleHKa B

HaCTOSlllI1S1 fJOKJIaA

CbTPyAHHK J(i A~onaKOBa

02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

Ilpu Bb3JUlfaHe H1 oueuxa e BClJlHLlefl

GlMQ OPl1fl1H3JlbT H3 T0311 lIoKi~1eHT

--_-__-----------------

N~7144 19 Mail 1998ronnna -

-

- lt

-

~

gt- AreH~HBTa aa npHBaTH3a~HH lt shylt ~- lt

~ 1 H3aaBa HaCTOJl~HJI JUUIeH3 _ I

-~~~~ gt~

~ Ha

i TEMEHY)I(KA EOPJ1COBi I1BAHOBA J1O cepas n N~ 2141310 1i3AaAeH aa 31081983 r OT

MBP-Pyce ErH 4403195510

33 OlJeHKa

aa HeJlBHAltHMH HMOTH

HU4eH3 b l17 e 6aAUOeH sa neonpeoesen CpOK

~

~ ~

( --12 (199)

hHUmCTEPCTBOffA HAPO)lllrA 1POCBEl A ---_--- ---_ --_ --_shy - bull - --__-~ - - -

Ill1 n J1 0 M A 3A 3ABbPIllEHO BHCUJE OEPAH7HAHVlE

i (CepUH HImiddot ivs ~

~

fJf _~lie~~T~fl~~~Har~~~1 7~II~~tlyen6~~~~a ~C~qvy~ ~ ~~~~~e~p~HRlt H(3 a~yenft4~ ~-~~~4~fK4q~

r 9HpbreJ~ ~ ~ i7~enoc-rbnf1rt R npea g61L ~1 3BbPW1 l fl cent

r~ ~ cfln - J~)u ~~~ji~JPe-T L u~ r nbflHVl5i KYI_IC He c7J(JlaquoJZshy

~~~CoNor~~~~1f~iif~~U~7Z ~gt(~~n0 Ci1~Ul-1af1HOCTl a f~~~~yencd~laquoyen--~l~~~1~~f~C~bC cpen$ti~YCheXj3t-ITI-17~~iJnpea KypCa Ha CJleaS8H8TO - lJmiddotmiddot

~~~~~~kmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot~

AEKnAPAUMSI no amp 1T4 OT AonbllHMTenHMTe pa3nopeA6M OT

3aKOHa sa 06~MHCKaTa c06CTBeHOCT

110AnMcaHaTa MHgtKTeMeHYgtKKa 60pMCOBa MBaHOBa ErH 4403195510 aapec rpKa3aHllbKYll I1CllaBflHcKaI110 B Ka4eCTBOTO 01 Ha oueuaren Ha HeAB~)f~M ~MOT

3eMJI C nno~ OT 37000KBM npencrasnseaura ynM XIX-1444 KB82 no nnaHa Ha rpKa3aHnbK6e3 noctpoeaara BbPXV Hero crpaaa c OTClDneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK - aCTHa 06~HcKa c06cTBeHoCT

-

9 ~MaM 10 roA~H~ npocentgtec~oHalleH ornrr aa oueusaaae Ha ~MOT~

10He CbM 3a~HTepecoBaHa OT OT4ygtKUaBaHeTo ~Jl~ pasnopexaaaero He CbM pOAH~Ha no npaea l1~H~51 6e3 orpaH~4eH~51nO cspeepe-a l1~H~51 AO -rersspra crenen ~ no CBaTOBCTBO AO STopa crenes Ha CTpaH~Te no OT4ygtKUasaHeTO ~Jl~ paanopexnaaero

M3BeCTHa M e HaKa3aTenHaTa OTrOBopHOCTKOJITO HOCJI no n313 OT HK aa nOCOIIBaHe Ha HeBepH AaHH

shy02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

2 11

na3apHa oyeHKa -y n MN2XIX-1444KB82 rpKa3SHnbK

npeAMeT Ha 3aAaHMeTO Oueuxa na 06lltl1HCKI1 HeABI1gtKIIIM IIIMOT - 3eMSI Cnnoui OT 370 KBM B yperyJllllpaH n03eMJleH IIIMOT ynlllXIX-1444 B KB82 no nnaaa Ha rpKa3aHJlbK06JlCTapa 3aropaYJl npe06pagtKeHllle 2

Bb3J10gtKMTen 06U1MHa Ka3aHnbKAoroBop N2 AO 252703 2009r

1113nbllHMTen 6anKaHMHBecTEOOAKa3aHnbK 4pe3 eKllln C PbKOBOAI1TeJl I1HgtKTeMeHygtKKa 6l-1BaHoBa nparexaaaui nl1leH3 NQ714498 1113AaAeH OT An-CocPI1S1

06eKT Ha oueHKaTa 3eMR Cnnoui OT37000 KBM npencraanseauia 1acrHa 0611ll1HCKa c06CTBeHoCT CpeanM3MpaHo npaso Ha crpoexeea nocrpceaara B Hero crpaAa

Yen Ha oueHKaTaOnpeAeJlSlHe naaapaara CTO~HOCT Ha 06eKTa Cuen npoaaxtia

EcbeKTMBHa AaTa Ha oueHKaTa 02042009r

CPOK Ha BanMDHocr Ha oueHKaTaUJeCT MeCela OT ecPeKTIIIBHaTa nara Ha oueakara

1113non3BaHM MeTODM Ha oueHKa 1MeTOll no BJUCTaHOBHTeJlHa croHHOCT - TeKYl1ll1Te pa3XOAIII sa I1AeHTIII4HOTO Bb3np0l13BegtKAaHe Ha pasoeuieaoro 6bAelltO CTpOl1TeJlCTBO C OT411TaHe aa CbOTBeTHI1Te pa3XOAI1 sa TOBa 2MeTOR Ha na3apHHTe cpaBHeHHR - 6a311pa ce Ha peracrpapaaara IIIHcPopMalI1S1 sa 1113BbpWeHI1 npOAagtK6111 Ha IIIMOTI1 6Jllll3KI1 no Ka4eCTBa III napanerpa AO OleHSIBaHIIISI

npaBeH CTaJYT Ha o6eKTa OleHSlBaHI1S1T 06eKT e 3eMSI C nnoUl OT 370 KBM B ynl-1 XIX-1144KB82 no nnaua Ha rpKa3aHJlbK06lltl1Ha Ka3aHflbK- 1aCTHa 06U1MHcKa co6crBeHoCT csrnacao AKT NQ650 OT 17032009 rperl1cTbpl-130 xaprorexa 1 AOCI1e 272 06eKTa e c peanM3MpaHo npaeo Ha CTpOegtK csrnac-o lloroBop OT 1954rHoTaKT NQ682004 III NQ542006r Bb3JlOgtKI1TeJlSlT He e npeAOCTaBI1Jl AaHHI1 sa HaJll1411e Ha peCTIIITyl1II0HHI1 npeTeHlIII11 HaJlOgtKeHI1 Bb36paHIII IIIJlIII APyrl1 sel1lHI1 TegtKeCTI1 BbPXY OleHSlBaHI1S1 06eKT

0606U1eHO onMcaHMe Ha paHOHa

MecronOnOgtKeHMe Ha paHOHa HaCeJleHO MSiCTO rpaA Ka3aHnbK KB82 cDYHKlI1oHafleH TI1n BTOPM 30Ha BTOpa BIIIl Ha o6eKTa 3eMSI- c panM3MpaHO npaBO Ha CTpOegtK

aCT aHa aMOHa

1113BOAH 06eKTbT ce HaMlllpa Ha BTopocTeneHHa YJll1la B KBapTaJl C npe06JlaAaBal1ll1 gtKI1Jll1l1lHI1 napuena III gtKI1Jll1l1lHI1 6JlOKOBe Cnpoxapaua eononpoeonenaexpauaauepaaouuo OCBeTJleHI1e 11 KaHaJlIll3aLIIISI Ha paees repea C1113nbJlHeHa BepTI1KaJlHa nJlaHI1pOBKa 06eKTbT He nenana B pa~oH CBJlOWeHI1 eKOJlOrl14HI1 xapaKTepl1CTIIIKIII

OnMcaHHe Ha o6eKTa Ha oueHKaTa

3eMR 37000 KBM- yperyJll1paH n03eMJleH I1MOTynlll Nil XIX-1444 B KB82 no nnaaa Ha rpKa3aHJlbK06JlCT3aropa 6m 3aKOHHO nocrpoeaare C OTCTbneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK gtKMnHUlHa crpaAa co6CTBeHoCT Ha AHTOH BacHneB WHBeHKoB

3 na3apHa OUeHKa -y n ~ N2XIX-1444KB82 rpKa3ilHnbK

HaM-eepeKTMBHO Mo6po nOn3BaHe IlPIiI OlleHSIBaHeTO Ha HaH-eltpeKTIiIBHOTO iii A06po nOJl3BaHe CMe ce PbKOBOAliIl1li1 OT

C11eAHOTO lBb3MO)lHO 1i13n0Jl3BaHe(ltp1iI31i14eCKO) - napuerrsr e 3aCTpOeH C)IliIl1li1lJlHa crpaaa 2Pa3peWeHO n0Jl3BaHe(3aKOHHO) - IiIMOTa e yperyl1li1paH C npanoxeaa peryl1alllilSi iii

paspeiueao CTpOIiITel1CTBO Ha )IliIl1li1lJlHa crpaaarapax iii APn 3HaH-eltpeKTIiIBHO iii A06po nOJl3BaHe - sa )IliIl1li1lJlHIiI HygtKAIiI

Ha 06eKTa e HanpaBeH ornen Cbrl1aCHO yCTpoHCTBeHIiISI nl1aH B napuena e OCb~eCTBeHO OCHOBHOTO 3acrpoHBaHe - M3rpaeHa MaCMBHa elfHOeTagtKHa gtKMnM~Ha crpalfa Csrnacno yCTpoHcTBeHIiISI nnaa B napuena ce orpexaa nl1bTHOCT Ha 3aCTpOSIBaHe AO 60 1MaHKIiI B npeABIiIA reonerpavuara ltpopMa Ha napuenapaanepa iii nl101Jl iii 1i13XO)lAaHKIiI OT 1i131i1CKBaHIiISITa 3a OTCTOSlHIiISI OT OCHOBHOTO 3aCTpoSiBaHe AO CTpaHIiI4Ho peryl1alllilOHHIiITe 111i1HIiIIiI Ha napuena nplileMaMe Aonbl1HIiITel1HO 6bAelJl0 CTpoliITel1CTBo CbC 311 OT 220 M2 iii P31l- 340 M2

Ce6eCTOHHocna Ha IiIMOTa B T031i1 cl1Y4aH 61i1 61i111

- )f(liIl1li1lJlHa nnoui 30000 M2 X 4700011BM2 = 141 000 l1B - He)lliIl1li1l1lHa nnouirapax iii APn 4000 M2 X 2800011BM2 = 11 20011B-------==-==lt-=

061Jl0 15220011B CTOHHOCT Ha 3eMSlTa - Pearnpauia 3eMSI 22000 M2 x 1200011B = 26 400 l1B - He pe-rn-paura 3eMSI 15000 M2 x 1200011BX 50 = 9 000 l1B

061Jl0 35 400 l1B Ce6eCToHHocna Ha paspeuieaoro CTpoliITel1CTBo 152 200 fiB - 35 40011B = 116 800 l1B lJaHHIiI aa ce6eCToHHocna Ha 6bAelJlaTa crpourenaa npoAyKllliISI ca B3eTIiI OT Cnelllilal11i131i1paHIiITe 1i13AaHIiISI Ha Crpoaexcnepr - CEK COQgtIiISICTpoIiITel1eH 0630p KbM 2009 r iii CnpaB04HIiIK sa uesare ua CMP KaKTO iii c06CTBeHa IiIHltpopMaIlIilSi sa ueuare Ha KBaApaTeH MeTbp sacrpoena n1101Jl B ueuara Ha CMP e BKfl104eHa iii ne4a116aTa aa cTpoliITel1HIiISI npennpaeaa-i pasxozurre sa KOHTpOl1 iii npoexrvpaae pasxonraquo sa TaKCIiI iii

CbrnacyBaHIiISI iii APn Ilapuerrsr ce HaMlilpa BbB sropa crpoarensa 30Ha Ha rpaaa B xaapran C npeotinanaaauio HIiICKO iii cpeaao eraxao CTpoIiITel1CTBo1MaHKIiI B npeABIiIAMeCTOn0110)leHlileTO Ha 0lleHSIBaHIiISIT 06eKT iii HerOBIiISIT CTaTyT-3eMSI C peal11i131i1paHO CTpoliITel1cTBo onpeAel1S1Me 06elJleTeHlile n0l1Y4aBaHo Ha npliIHlllilna c06cTBeHocT BbPXY napuen cpeutv )IIiIIlIiIIJle He noae-e OT 15 1i1111i11i13pa3eHo B nesa 116 80011B x15 = 17 52011B - CTOHHOCT Ha napuena -MeTOAbT e cue-nca -ipea npsko cpaBHeHlile Ha pa3rne)lAaHIiISI IiIMOT C nOA06HIiI Ha Hero

KOIiITO ca 61i1111i1 npOAaAeHIiI ny6111i14HO KaTO lleHaTa ce onpeAel1S1 Bb3 OCHOBa Ha Te31i1 npeAIiIWHIiI CAeIlKIiI1MaHKIil B npeABIilA AaHHIilTe cb6paHIiI OT oueuarenare Iil IiIHTepBIOTaTa nposeneaa C areHllliI1iI sa HeABlil)llilMIiI IiIMOTIil sa IiIMOTIiI C na3apHIiI Iil CTpOIilTel1HIiI xapaKTeplilCTIilKIiI 6111i13KIil AO Te31i1 Ha olleHSIBaHIiISI IiIMOT-3eMH C peanM3MpaHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK ce OltPOPMIiI cpeaaa nasepaa uena - 8500nBM2

bull

CTOMHOCT Ha 3eMHTa 37000 KBM - 37000 KBM x 850011BM2 =31450 ns

4 na3apHa OUeHKa -y n M NXIX-1444KB82 rpKa3ilHnbK

MeTOA Ha o~eHKa CTOMHOcr nB

TernOBeH Koecb

npeTerneHa crOMHOcr

Bb3CTaHOBlITenHa CTOt1HOCT 17500 05 8750

na3apHlITe cpaBHeHlISI 31500 05 15750 CnpaBeA1IHBa nasapaa

crOMHOcr 061Jto 24500

H3BOAH npll onpeaenaaero Ha TernOBHlITe KoecPlIlIlIeHTlI oueaarenure ca lI3XOgtKAaJlll OT

cPaKTa4e o6eKTa e c peanH3HpaHo npaee Ha crpOegtK - aacrpoea C gtKHnHUlHa crpaAaKOSITO He e co6CTBeHOCT Ha 06lllIHaTaC Bb3MOgtKHOCT aa norrsnsauio CTpOllTenCTBO

lt13XOgtKpoundtat1KlI OT BClI4KO 113nOgtKeHO fJO TYK noeanarane ueaa aa npofJagtK6a Ha 3eMSI C

peanll3l1paHO npaso Ha CTpOegtK OT 24 500nB HnH 6622nBM2

KOMeHTap CbcTaBlITenl1Te Ha T03l1 AOKJIaA o6pbllaT BHlIMaHlIe BbPXY QgtaKTa 4e CbllI1S1T

e npenner Ha TbprOBCKa Ta~Ha lI KOHQgtlIAeHlIlIanHOCT npeAHa3Ha4eH e caMO aa cnygttlte6Ho

nOJl3BaHe OT 061JtHHa Ka3aHnbK lI 4e TOt1 e co6CTBeHoCT eAlIHCTBeHo Ha Bb3nOgtKHTeIIR Tot1 He MOgtKe Aa 6bAe KOnllpaH lI lI3nOn3BaH 3a KaKBlITO lI Aa e lIenll 6e3 nllCMeHOTO

paapeuieaae OT Bb3IIOgtKHTeIIR - 06U1HHa Ka38HnbK 11 6e3 csrnacnero Ha

CbcraBHTeIIR - 6anKaHHHBecrEOOAKa3aHnbK OlleHKaTa e 113BbpWeHa CbBeCTHO lI 06eKTlIBHO He3aBl1Cl1Ml1Te eKCnepTI1 C4l1TaT 4e He MoraT Aa 6bltaT nOCTaBeHI1 OrpaHlI4eHI1S1 B

113nOn3BaHeTO Ha APyrl1 TeXHlIKlI 3a aHanl13 lI OlleHKa B

HaCTOSlllI1S1 fJOKJIaA

CbTPyAHHK J(i A~onaKOBa

02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

Ilpu Bb3JUlfaHe H1 oueuxa e BClJlHLlefl

GlMQ OPl1fl1H3JlbT H3 T0311 lIoKi~1eHT

--_-__-----------------

N~7144 19 Mail 1998ronnna -

-

- lt

-

~

gt- AreH~HBTa aa npHBaTH3a~HH lt shylt ~- lt

~ 1 H3aaBa HaCTOJl~HJI JUUIeH3 _ I

-~~~~ gt~

~ Ha

i TEMEHY)I(KA EOPJ1COBi I1BAHOBA J1O cepas n N~ 2141310 1i3AaAeH aa 31081983 r OT

MBP-Pyce ErH 4403195510

33 OlJeHKa

aa HeJlBHAltHMH HMOTH

HU4eH3 b l17 e 6aAUOeH sa neonpeoesen CpOK

~

~ ~

( --12 (199)

hHUmCTEPCTBOffA HAPO)lllrA 1POCBEl A ---_--- ---_ --_ --_shy - bull - --__-~ - - -

Ill1 n J1 0 M A 3A 3ABbPIllEHO BHCUJE OEPAH7HAHVlE

i (CepUH HImiddot ivs ~

~

fJf _~lie~~T~fl~~~Har~~~1 7~II~~tlyen6~~~~a ~C~qvy~ ~ ~~~~~e~p~HRlt H(3 a~yenft4~ ~-~~~4~fK4q~

r 9HpbreJ~ ~ ~ i7~enoc-rbnf1rt R npea g61L ~1 3BbPW1 l fl cent

r~ ~ cfln - J~)u ~~~ji~JPe-T L u~ r nbflHVl5i KYI_IC He c7J(JlaquoJZshy

~~~CoNor~~~~1f~iif~~U~7Z ~gt(~~n0 Ci1~Ul-1af1HOCTl a f~~~~yencd~laquoyen--~l~~~1~~f~C~bC cpen$ti~YCheXj3t-ITI-17~~iJnpea KypCa Ha CJleaS8H8TO - lJmiddotmiddot

~~~~~~kmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot~

AEKnAPAUMSI no amp 1T4 OT AonbllHMTenHMTe pa3nopeA6M OT

3aKOHa sa 06~MHCKaTa c06CTBeHOCT

110AnMcaHaTa MHgtKTeMeHYgtKKa 60pMCOBa MBaHOBa ErH 4403195510 aapec rpKa3aHllbKYll I1CllaBflHcKaI110 B Ka4eCTBOTO 01 Ha oueuaren Ha HeAB~)f~M ~MOT

3eMJI C nno~ OT 37000KBM npencrasnseaura ynM XIX-1444 KB82 no nnaHa Ha rpKa3aHnbK6e3 noctpoeaara BbPXV Hero crpaaa c OTClDneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK - aCTHa 06~HcKa c06cTBeHoCT

-

9 ~MaM 10 roA~H~ npocentgtec~oHalleH ornrr aa oueusaaae Ha ~MOT~

10He CbM 3a~HTepecoBaHa OT OT4ygtKUaBaHeTo ~Jl~ pasnopexaaaero He CbM pOAH~Ha no npaea l1~H~51 6e3 orpaH~4eH~51nO cspeepe-a l1~H~51 AO -rersspra crenen ~ no CBaTOBCTBO AO STopa crenes Ha CTpaH~Te no OT4ygtKUasaHeTO ~Jl~ paanopexnaaero

M3BeCTHa M e HaKa3aTenHaTa OTrOBopHOCTKOJITO HOCJI no n313 OT HK aa nOCOIIBaHe Ha HeBepH AaHH

shy02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

3 na3apHa OUeHKa -y n ~ N2XIX-1444KB82 rpKa3ilHnbK

HaM-eepeKTMBHO Mo6po nOn3BaHe IlPIiI OlleHSIBaHeTO Ha HaH-eltpeKTIiIBHOTO iii A06po nOJl3BaHe CMe ce PbKOBOAliIl1li1 OT

C11eAHOTO lBb3MO)lHO 1i13n0Jl3BaHe(ltp1iI31i14eCKO) - napuerrsr e 3aCTpOeH C)IliIl1li1lJlHa crpaaa 2Pa3peWeHO n0Jl3BaHe(3aKOHHO) - IiIMOTa e yperyl1li1paH C npanoxeaa peryl1alllilSi iii

paspeiueao CTpOIiITel1CTBO Ha )IliIl1li1lJlHa crpaaarapax iii APn 3HaH-eltpeKTIiIBHO iii A06po nOJl3BaHe - sa )IliIl1li1lJlHIiI HygtKAIiI

Ha 06eKTa e HanpaBeH ornen Cbrl1aCHO yCTpoHCTBeHIiISI nl1aH B napuena e OCb~eCTBeHO OCHOBHOTO 3acrpoHBaHe - M3rpaeHa MaCMBHa elfHOeTagtKHa gtKMnM~Ha crpalfa Csrnacno yCTpoHcTBeHIiISI nnaa B napuena ce orpexaa nl1bTHOCT Ha 3aCTpOSIBaHe AO 60 1MaHKIiI B npeABIiIA reonerpavuara ltpopMa Ha napuenapaanepa iii nl101Jl iii 1i13XO)lAaHKIiI OT 1i131i1CKBaHIiISITa 3a OTCTOSlHIiISI OT OCHOBHOTO 3aCTpoSiBaHe AO CTpaHIiI4Ho peryl1alllilOHHIiITe 111i1HIiIIiI Ha napuena nplileMaMe Aonbl1HIiITel1HO 6bAelJl0 CTpoliITel1CTBo CbC 311 OT 220 M2 iii P31l- 340 M2

Ce6eCTOHHocna Ha IiIMOTa B T031i1 cl1Y4aH 61i1 61i111

- )f(liIl1li1lJlHa nnoui 30000 M2 X 4700011BM2 = 141 000 l1B - He)lliIl1li1l1lHa nnouirapax iii APn 4000 M2 X 2800011BM2 = 11 20011B-------==-==lt-=

061Jl0 15220011B CTOHHOCT Ha 3eMSlTa - Pearnpauia 3eMSI 22000 M2 x 1200011B = 26 400 l1B - He pe-rn-paura 3eMSI 15000 M2 x 1200011BX 50 = 9 000 l1B

061Jl0 35 400 l1B Ce6eCToHHocna Ha paspeuieaoro CTpoliITel1CTBo 152 200 fiB - 35 40011B = 116 800 l1B lJaHHIiI aa ce6eCToHHocna Ha 6bAelJlaTa crpourenaa npoAyKllliISI ca B3eTIiI OT Cnelllilal11i131i1paHIiITe 1i13AaHIiISI Ha Crpoaexcnepr - CEK COQgtIiISICTpoIiITel1eH 0630p KbM 2009 r iii CnpaB04HIiIK sa uesare ua CMP KaKTO iii c06CTBeHa IiIHltpopMaIlIilSi sa ueuare Ha KBaApaTeH MeTbp sacrpoena n1101Jl B ueuara Ha CMP e BKfl104eHa iii ne4a116aTa aa cTpoliITel1HIiISI npennpaeaa-i pasxozurre sa KOHTpOl1 iii npoexrvpaae pasxonraquo sa TaKCIiI iii

CbrnacyBaHIiISI iii APn Ilapuerrsr ce HaMlilpa BbB sropa crpoarensa 30Ha Ha rpaaa B xaapran C npeotinanaaauio HIiICKO iii cpeaao eraxao CTpoIiITel1CTBo1MaHKIiI B npeABIiIAMeCTOn0110)leHlileTO Ha 0lleHSIBaHIiISIT 06eKT iii HerOBIiISIT CTaTyT-3eMSI C peal11i131i1paHO CTpoliITel1cTBo onpeAel1S1Me 06elJleTeHlile n0l1Y4aBaHo Ha npliIHlllilna c06cTBeHocT BbPXY napuen cpeutv )IIiIIlIiIIJle He noae-e OT 15 1i1111i11i13pa3eHo B nesa 116 80011B x15 = 17 52011B - CTOHHOCT Ha napuena -MeTOAbT e cue-nca -ipea npsko cpaBHeHlile Ha pa3rne)lAaHIiISI IiIMOT C nOA06HIiI Ha Hero

KOIiITO ca 61i1111i1 npOAaAeHIiI ny6111i14HO KaTO lleHaTa ce onpeAel1S1 Bb3 OCHOBa Ha Te31i1 npeAIiIWHIiI CAeIlKIiI1MaHKIil B npeABIilA AaHHIilTe cb6paHIiI OT oueuarenare Iil IiIHTepBIOTaTa nposeneaa C areHllliI1iI sa HeABlil)llilMIiI IiIMOTIil sa IiIMOTIiI C na3apHIiI Iil CTpOIilTel1HIiI xapaKTeplilCTIilKIiI 6111i13KIil AO Te31i1 Ha olleHSIBaHIiISI IiIMOT-3eMH C peanM3MpaHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK ce OltPOPMIiI cpeaaa nasepaa uena - 8500nBM2

bull

CTOMHOCT Ha 3eMHTa 37000 KBM - 37000 KBM x 850011BM2 =31450 ns

4 na3apHa OUeHKa -y n M NXIX-1444KB82 rpKa3ilHnbK

MeTOA Ha o~eHKa CTOMHOcr nB

TernOBeH Koecb

npeTerneHa crOMHOcr

Bb3CTaHOBlITenHa CTOt1HOCT 17500 05 8750

na3apHlITe cpaBHeHlISI 31500 05 15750 CnpaBeA1IHBa nasapaa

crOMHOcr 061Jto 24500

H3BOAH npll onpeaenaaero Ha TernOBHlITe KoecPlIlIlIeHTlI oueaarenure ca lI3XOgtKAaJlll OT

cPaKTa4e o6eKTa e c peanH3HpaHo npaee Ha crpOegtK - aacrpoea C gtKHnHUlHa crpaAaKOSITO He e co6CTBeHOCT Ha 06lllIHaTaC Bb3MOgtKHOCT aa norrsnsauio CTpOllTenCTBO

lt13XOgtKpoundtat1KlI OT BClI4KO 113nOgtKeHO fJO TYK noeanarane ueaa aa npofJagtK6a Ha 3eMSI C

peanll3l1paHO npaso Ha CTpOegtK OT 24 500nB HnH 6622nBM2

KOMeHTap CbcTaBlITenl1Te Ha T03l1 AOKJIaA o6pbllaT BHlIMaHlIe BbPXY QgtaKTa 4e CbllI1S1T

e npenner Ha TbprOBCKa Ta~Ha lI KOHQgtlIAeHlIlIanHOCT npeAHa3Ha4eH e caMO aa cnygttlte6Ho

nOJl3BaHe OT 061JtHHa Ka3aHnbK lI 4e TOt1 e co6CTBeHoCT eAlIHCTBeHo Ha Bb3nOgtKHTeIIR Tot1 He MOgtKe Aa 6bAe KOnllpaH lI lI3nOn3BaH 3a KaKBlITO lI Aa e lIenll 6e3 nllCMeHOTO

paapeuieaae OT Bb3IIOgtKHTeIIR - 06U1HHa Ka38HnbK 11 6e3 csrnacnero Ha

CbcraBHTeIIR - 6anKaHHHBecrEOOAKa3aHnbK OlleHKaTa e 113BbpWeHa CbBeCTHO lI 06eKTlIBHO He3aBl1Cl1Ml1Te eKCnepTI1 C4l1TaT 4e He MoraT Aa 6bltaT nOCTaBeHI1 OrpaHlI4eHI1S1 B

113nOn3BaHeTO Ha APyrl1 TeXHlIKlI 3a aHanl13 lI OlleHKa B

HaCTOSlllI1S1 fJOKJIaA

CbTPyAHHK J(i A~onaKOBa

02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

Ilpu Bb3JUlfaHe H1 oueuxa e BClJlHLlefl

GlMQ OPl1fl1H3JlbT H3 T0311 lIoKi~1eHT

--_-__-----------------

N~7144 19 Mail 1998ronnna -

-

- lt

-

~

gt- AreH~HBTa aa npHBaTH3a~HH lt shylt ~- lt

~ 1 H3aaBa HaCTOJl~HJI JUUIeH3 _ I

-~~~~ gt~

~ Ha

i TEMEHY)I(KA EOPJ1COBi I1BAHOBA J1O cepas n N~ 2141310 1i3AaAeH aa 31081983 r OT

MBP-Pyce ErH 4403195510

33 OlJeHKa

aa HeJlBHAltHMH HMOTH

HU4eH3 b l17 e 6aAUOeH sa neonpeoesen CpOK

~

~ ~

( --12 (199)

hHUmCTEPCTBOffA HAPO)lllrA 1POCBEl A ---_--- ---_ --_ --_shy - bull - --__-~ - - -

Ill1 n J1 0 M A 3A 3ABbPIllEHO BHCUJE OEPAH7HAHVlE

i (CepUH HImiddot ivs ~

~

fJf _~lie~~T~fl~~~Har~~~1 7~II~~tlyen6~~~~a ~C~qvy~ ~ ~~~~~e~p~HRlt H(3 a~yenft4~ ~-~~~4~fK4q~

r 9HpbreJ~ ~ ~ i7~enoc-rbnf1rt R npea g61L ~1 3BbPW1 l fl cent

r~ ~ cfln - J~)u ~~~ji~JPe-T L u~ r nbflHVl5i KYI_IC He c7J(JlaquoJZshy

~~~CoNor~~~~1f~iif~~U~7Z ~gt(~~n0 Ci1~Ul-1af1HOCTl a f~~~~yencd~laquoyen--~l~~~1~~f~C~bC cpen$ti~YCheXj3t-ITI-17~~iJnpea KypCa Ha CJleaS8H8TO - lJmiddotmiddot

~~~~~~kmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot~

AEKnAPAUMSI no amp 1T4 OT AonbllHMTenHMTe pa3nopeA6M OT

3aKOHa sa 06~MHCKaTa c06CTBeHOCT

110AnMcaHaTa MHgtKTeMeHYgtKKa 60pMCOBa MBaHOBa ErH 4403195510 aapec rpKa3aHllbKYll I1CllaBflHcKaI110 B Ka4eCTBOTO 01 Ha oueuaren Ha HeAB~)f~M ~MOT

3eMJI C nno~ OT 37000KBM npencrasnseaura ynM XIX-1444 KB82 no nnaHa Ha rpKa3aHnbK6e3 noctpoeaara BbPXV Hero crpaaa c OTClDneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK - aCTHa 06~HcKa c06cTBeHoCT

-

9 ~MaM 10 roA~H~ npocentgtec~oHalleH ornrr aa oueusaaae Ha ~MOT~

10He CbM 3a~HTepecoBaHa OT OT4ygtKUaBaHeTo ~Jl~ pasnopexaaaero He CbM pOAH~Ha no npaea l1~H~51 6e3 orpaH~4eH~51nO cspeepe-a l1~H~51 AO -rersspra crenen ~ no CBaTOBCTBO AO STopa crenes Ha CTpaH~Te no OT4ygtKUasaHeTO ~Jl~ paanopexnaaero

M3BeCTHa M e HaKa3aTenHaTa OTrOBopHOCTKOJITO HOCJI no n313 OT HK aa nOCOIIBaHe Ha HeBepH AaHH

shy02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

4 na3apHa OUeHKa -y n M NXIX-1444KB82 rpKa3ilHnbK

MeTOA Ha o~eHKa CTOMHOcr nB

TernOBeH Koecb

npeTerneHa crOMHOcr

Bb3CTaHOBlITenHa CTOt1HOCT 17500 05 8750

na3apHlITe cpaBHeHlISI 31500 05 15750 CnpaBeA1IHBa nasapaa

crOMHOcr 061Jto 24500

H3BOAH npll onpeaenaaero Ha TernOBHlITe KoecPlIlIlIeHTlI oueaarenure ca lI3XOgtKAaJlll OT

cPaKTa4e o6eKTa e c peanH3HpaHo npaee Ha crpOegtK - aacrpoea C gtKHnHUlHa crpaAaKOSITO He e co6CTBeHOCT Ha 06lllIHaTaC Bb3MOgtKHOCT aa norrsnsauio CTpOllTenCTBO

lt13XOgtKpoundtat1KlI OT BClI4KO 113nOgtKeHO fJO TYK noeanarane ueaa aa npofJagtK6a Ha 3eMSI C

peanll3l1paHO npaso Ha CTpOegtK OT 24 500nB HnH 6622nBM2

KOMeHTap CbcTaBlITenl1Te Ha T03l1 AOKJIaA o6pbllaT BHlIMaHlIe BbPXY QgtaKTa 4e CbllI1S1T

e npenner Ha TbprOBCKa Ta~Ha lI KOHQgtlIAeHlIlIanHOCT npeAHa3Ha4eH e caMO aa cnygttlte6Ho

nOJl3BaHe OT 061JtHHa Ka3aHnbK lI 4e TOt1 e co6CTBeHoCT eAlIHCTBeHo Ha Bb3nOgtKHTeIIR Tot1 He MOgtKe Aa 6bAe KOnllpaH lI lI3nOn3BaH 3a KaKBlITO lI Aa e lIenll 6e3 nllCMeHOTO

paapeuieaae OT Bb3IIOgtKHTeIIR - 06U1HHa Ka38HnbK 11 6e3 csrnacnero Ha

CbcraBHTeIIR - 6anKaHHHBecrEOOAKa3aHnbK OlleHKaTa e 113BbpWeHa CbBeCTHO lI 06eKTlIBHO He3aBl1Cl1Ml1Te eKCnepTI1 C4l1TaT 4e He MoraT Aa 6bltaT nOCTaBeHI1 OrpaHlI4eHI1S1 B

113nOn3BaHeTO Ha APyrl1 TeXHlIKlI 3a aHanl13 lI OlleHKa B

HaCTOSlllI1S1 fJOKJIaA

CbTPyAHHK J(i A~onaKOBa

02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

Ilpu Bb3JUlfaHe H1 oueuxa e BClJlHLlefl

GlMQ OPl1fl1H3JlbT H3 T0311 lIoKi~1eHT

--_-__-----------------

N~7144 19 Mail 1998ronnna -

-

- lt

-

~

gt- AreH~HBTa aa npHBaTH3a~HH lt shylt ~- lt

~ 1 H3aaBa HaCTOJl~HJI JUUIeH3 _ I

-~~~~ gt~

~ Ha

i TEMEHY)I(KA EOPJ1COBi I1BAHOBA J1O cepas n N~ 2141310 1i3AaAeH aa 31081983 r OT

MBP-Pyce ErH 4403195510

33 OlJeHKa

aa HeJlBHAltHMH HMOTH

HU4eH3 b l17 e 6aAUOeH sa neonpeoesen CpOK

~

~ ~

( --12 (199)

hHUmCTEPCTBOffA HAPO)lllrA 1POCBEl A ---_--- ---_ --_ --_shy - bull - --__-~ - - -

Ill1 n J1 0 M A 3A 3ABbPIllEHO BHCUJE OEPAH7HAHVlE

i (CepUH HImiddot ivs ~

~

fJf _~lie~~T~fl~~~Har~~~1 7~II~~tlyen6~~~~a ~C~qvy~ ~ ~~~~~e~p~HRlt H(3 a~yenft4~ ~-~~~4~fK4q~

r 9HpbreJ~ ~ ~ i7~enoc-rbnf1rt R npea g61L ~1 3BbPW1 l fl cent

r~ ~ cfln - J~)u ~~~ji~JPe-T L u~ r nbflHVl5i KYI_IC He c7J(JlaquoJZshy

~~~CoNor~~~~1f~iif~~U~7Z ~gt(~~n0 Ci1~Ul-1af1HOCTl a f~~~~yencd~laquoyen--~l~~~1~~f~C~bC cpen$ti~YCheXj3t-ITI-17~~iJnpea KypCa Ha CJleaS8H8TO - lJmiddotmiddot

~~~~~~kmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot~

AEKnAPAUMSI no amp 1T4 OT AonbllHMTenHMTe pa3nopeA6M OT

3aKOHa sa 06~MHCKaTa c06CTBeHOCT

110AnMcaHaTa MHgtKTeMeHYgtKKa 60pMCOBa MBaHOBa ErH 4403195510 aapec rpKa3aHllbKYll I1CllaBflHcKaI110 B Ka4eCTBOTO 01 Ha oueuaren Ha HeAB~)f~M ~MOT

3eMJI C nno~ OT 37000KBM npencrasnseaura ynM XIX-1444 KB82 no nnaHa Ha rpKa3aHnbK6e3 noctpoeaara BbPXV Hero crpaaa c OTClDneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK - aCTHa 06~HcKa c06cTBeHoCT

-

9 ~MaM 10 roA~H~ npocentgtec~oHalleH ornrr aa oueusaaae Ha ~MOT~

10He CbM 3a~HTepecoBaHa OT OT4ygtKUaBaHeTo ~Jl~ pasnopexaaaero He CbM pOAH~Ha no npaea l1~H~51 6e3 orpaH~4eH~51nO cspeepe-a l1~H~51 AO -rersspra crenen ~ no CBaTOBCTBO AO STopa crenes Ha CTpaH~Te no OT4ygtKUasaHeTO ~Jl~ paanopexnaaero

M3BeCTHa M e HaKa3aTenHaTa OTrOBopHOCTKOJITO HOCJI no n313 OT HK aa nOCOIIBaHe Ha HeBepH AaHH

shy02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

Ilpu Bb3JUlfaHe H1 oueuxa e BClJlHLlefl

GlMQ OPl1fl1H3JlbT H3 T0311 lIoKi~1eHT

--_-__-----------------

N~7144 19 Mail 1998ronnna -

-

- lt

-

~

gt- AreH~HBTa aa npHBaTH3a~HH lt shylt ~- lt

~ 1 H3aaBa HaCTOJl~HJI JUUIeH3 _ I

-~~~~ gt~

~ Ha

i TEMEHY)I(KA EOPJ1COBi I1BAHOBA J1O cepas n N~ 2141310 1i3AaAeH aa 31081983 r OT

MBP-Pyce ErH 4403195510

33 OlJeHKa

aa HeJlBHAltHMH HMOTH

HU4eH3 b l17 e 6aAUOeH sa neonpeoesen CpOK

~

~ ~

( --12 (199)

hHUmCTEPCTBOffA HAPO)lllrA 1POCBEl A ---_--- ---_ --_ --_shy - bull - --__-~ - - -

Ill1 n J1 0 M A 3A 3ABbPIllEHO BHCUJE OEPAH7HAHVlE

i (CepUH HImiddot ivs ~

~

fJf _~lie~~T~fl~~~Har~~~1 7~II~~tlyen6~~~~a ~C~qvy~ ~ ~~~~~e~p~HRlt H(3 a~yenft4~ ~-~~~4~fK4q~

r 9HpbreJ~ ~ ~ i7~enoc-rbnf1rt R npea g61L ~1 3BbPW1 l fl cent

r~ ~ cfln - J~)u ~~~ji~JPe-T L u~ r nbflHVl5i KYI_IC He c7J(JlaquoJZshy

~~~CoNor~~~~1f~iif~~U~7Z ~gt(~~n0 Ci1~Ul-1af1HOCTl a f~~~~yencd~laquoyen--~l~~~1~~f~C~bC cpen$ti~YCheXj3t-ITI-17~~iJnpea KypCa Ha CJleaS8H8TO - lJmiddotmiddot

~~~~~~kmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot~

AEKnAPAUMSI no amp 1T4 OT AonbllHMTenHMTe pa3nopeA6M OT

3aKOHa sa 06~MHCKaTa c06CTBeHOCT

110AnMcaHaTa MHgtKTeMeHYgtKKa 60pMCOBa MBaHOBa ErH 4403195510 aapec rpKa3aHllbKYll I1CllaBflHcKaI110 B Ka4eCTBOTO 01 Ha oueuaren Ha HeAB~)f~M ~MOT

3eMJI C nno~ OT 37000KBM npencrasnseaura ynM XIX-1444 KB82 no nnaHa Ha rpKa3aHnbK6e3 noctpoeaara BbPXV Hero crpaaa c OTClDneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK - aCTHa 06~HcKa c06cTBeHoCT

-

9 ~MaM 10 roA~H~ npocentgtec~oHalleH ornrr aa oueusaaae Ha ~MOT~

10He CbM 3a~HTepecoBaHa OT OT4ygtKUaBaHeTo ~Jl~ pasnopexaaaero He CbM pOAH~Ha no npaea l1~H~51 6e3 orpaH~4eH~51nO cspeepe-a l1~H~51 AO -rersspra crenen ~ no CBaTOBCTBO AO STopa crenes Ha CTpaH~Te no OT4ygtKUasaHeTO ~Jl~ paanopexnaaero

M3BeCTHa M e HaKa3aTenHaTa OTrOBopHOCTKOJITO HOCJI no n313 OT HK aa nOCOIIBaHe Ha HeBepH AaHH

shy02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

~

~ ~

( --12 (199)

hHUmCTEPCTBOffA HAPO)lllrA 1POCBEl A ---_--- ---_ --_ --_shy - bull - --__-~ - - -

Ill1 n J1 0 M A 3A 3ABbPIllEHO BHCUJE OEPAH7HAHVlE

i (CepUH HImiddot ivs ~

~

fJf _~lie~~T~fl~~~Har~~~1 7~II~~tlyen6~~~~a ~C~qvy~ ~ ~~~~~e~p~HRlt H(3 a~yenft4~ ~-~~~4~fK4q~

r 9HpbreJ~ ~ ~ i7~enoc-rbnf1rt R npea g61L ~1 3BbPW1 l fl cent

r~ ~ cfln - J~)u ~~~ji~JPe-T L u~ r nbflHVl5i KYI_IC He c7J(JlaquoJZshy

~~~CoNor~~~~1f~iif~~U~7Z ~gt(~~n0 Ci1~Ul-1af1HOCTl a f~~~~yencd~laquoyen--~l~~~1~~f~C~bC cpen$ti~YCheXj3t-ITI-17~~iJnpea KypCa Ha CJleaS8H8TO - lJmiddotmiddot

~~~~~~kmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot~

AEKnAPAUMSI no amp 1T4 OT AonbllHMTenHMTe pa3nopeA6M OT

3aKOHa sa 06~MHCKaTa c06CTBeHOCT

110AnMcaHaTa MHgtKTeMeHYgtKKa 60pMCOBa MBaHOBa ErH 4403195510 aapec rpKa3aHllbKYll I1CllaBflHcKaI110 B Ka4eCTBOTO 01 Ha oueuaren Ha HeAB~)f~M ~MOT

3eMJI C nno~ OT 37000KBM npencrasnseaura ynM XIX-1444 KB82 no nnaHa Ha rpKa3aHnbK6e3 noctpoeaara BbPXV Hero crpaaa c OTClDneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK - aCTHa 06~HcKa c06cTBeHoCT

-

9 ~MaM 10 roA~H~ npocentgtec~oHalleH ornrr aa oueusaaae Ha ~MOT~

10He CbM 3a~HTepecoBaHa OT OT4ygtKUaBaHeTo ~Jl~ pasnopexaaaero He CbM pOAH~Ha no npaea l1~H~51 6e3 orpaH~4eH~51nO cspeepe-a l1~H~51 AO -rersspra crenen ~ no CBaTOBCTBO AO STopa crenes Ha CTpaH~Te no OT4ygtKUasaHeTO ~Jl~ paanopexnaaero

M3BeCTHa M e HaKa3aTenHaTa OTrOBopHOCTKOJITO HOCJI no n313 OT HK aa nOCOIIBaHe Ha HeBepH AaHH

shy02042009r rpKa3aHnbK

AEKnAPAUMSI no amp 1T4 OT AonbllHMTenHMTe pa3nopeA6M OT

3aKOHa sa 06~MHCKaTa c06CTBeHOCT

110AnMcaHaTa MHgtKTeMeHYgtKKa 60pMCOBa MBaHOBa ErH 4403195510 aapec rpKa3aHllbKYll I1CllaBflHcKaI110 B Ka4eCTBOTO 01 Ha oueuaren Ha HeAB~)f~M ~MOT

3eMJI C nno~ OT 37000KBM npencrasnseaura ynM XIX-1444 KB82 no nnaHa Ha rpKa3aHnbK6e3 noctpoeaara BbPXV Hero crpaaa c OTClDneHO npaeo Ha CTpOegtK - aCTHa 06~HcKa c06cTBeHoCT

-

9 ~MaM 10 roA~H~ npocentgtec~oHalleH ornrr aa oueusaaae Ha ~MOT~

10He CbM 3a~HTepecoBaHa OT OT4ygtKUaBaHeTo ~Jl~ pasnopexaaaero He CbM pOAH~Ha no npaea l1~H~51 6e3 orpaH~4eH~51nO cspeepe-a l1~H~51 AO -rersspra crenen ~ no CBaTOBCTBO AO STopa crenes Ha CTpaH~Te no OT4ygtKUasaHeTO ~Jl~ paanopexnaaero

M3BeCTHa M e HaKa3aTenHaTa OTrOBopHOCTKOJITO HOCJI no n313 OT HK aa nOCOIIBaHe Ha HeBepH AaHH

shy02042009r rpKa3aHnbK