Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T...
Transcript of Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T...
![Page 1: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
UDTM
Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale Problem
Christopher J. Roberts, Ph.D.Associate Professor of Chemical Engineering
University of Delaware
![Page 2: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
UDTM
Students & Post-DocsPrateek Shah (Ph.D. `08) Jennifer (Andrews) Woods (Ph.D. `08)Yi Li (Ph.D. `09) Michelle Spatara (Ph.D. `09)Teresa Young (Ph.D. `09) William F. Weiss IV (Ph.D. `09)Rebecca Brummitt(Ph.D. `10) ErincSahin(Post-doc Res. Assoc.)Charles Woods Marco BlancoRon Maurer Andrew Kroetsch(BChE `10)Nayoung Kim
Current / Recent CollaboratorsAnne Robinson (UD) BramieLenhoff(UD)Erik Fernandez (UVA) Aming Zhang (UVA)TundeOgunnaike(UD) AdeolaGrillo (HGSI)Melissa D. Perkins (HGSI) Doug Nesta(GSK)Lucy Chang (GSK / PFZ) Alan Hunter (MedImmune)MagdaIvanova(UCLA) Tom Laue, Sue Chase (UNH)Richard Remmele(Amgen) Dean Liu (Amgen)Tapan Das (Pfizer) Kevin King (Pfizer)
Funding (current + previous)National Institutes of HealthMerck Research LaboratoriesNational Science Foundation Human Genome SciencesGlaxoSmithKline PfizerMedImmune AmgenBoehringer Ingelheim
Acknowledgements
![Page 3: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
UDTM
Dobson CM “Protein Folding and Misfolding” Nature (2003)
“Aggregation” occurs via competing contributions
![Page 4: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
UDTM
Unfolding-mediated Aggregation is Multi-Step:Product(s) Range from Oligomers to Visible
Particles
200 nm 200 nm50 nm
Weiss, Hodgdon, et al. Biophys. J. (2007)
Li et al., J. Pharm. Sci.(2010)
![Page 5: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
UDTM
Non-Native Agg’s are Typically Net “Irreversible”w/out Extreme T, p, [denaturant]
200 nm 200 nm50 nm
Weiss, Hodgdon, et al. Biophys. J. (2007)
High T (~ 100 C)High p (~ 103 bar)High [denaturant] (~ 4+ molar)
![Page 6: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
UDTM
Aggregation rates are very sensitive to temperature need (at least local) unfolding
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
3 3.2 3.4 3.6
bG-CSF shelf life (t90) vs. T, pH>4.5
Erroneous(Arrhenius)Prediction
1000 / T
log 1
0(ti
me
for 1
0% lo
ss)
pH 7.5
pH 4.8
1 year
1 mo.
1 day
1 hour
5 min.
LENPPrediction
5°C20°C30°C40°C
Roberts et al JPhSci (2003)
Hun ~ 102 kcal/mol at T ~ Tm
Hun ~ 0 kcal/mol at T ~ 10 - 20 oC
PBD 1BGC
![Page 7: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
UDTM
Small length scales: Inter-protein contacts can be only small segments of the entire protein
Zhang, Ivanova, Weiss, Roberts, Fernandez, Biochemistry (2010)
Akin to modified “domain swapping” model (e.g., Sambashivan et al., Nature (2005))
![Page 8: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
UDTM
Small length scales: Difficult to reliably predict (exposed) “hot spot” sequences in foldable proteins
Adapted from Roberts, Das, & Sahin Int. J. Pharm. (2011)
![Page 9: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
UDTM
Small length scales: single point mutations can greatly change kobs via “hot spots” a/o Gun
Roberts, Das, & Sahin Int. J. Pharm. (2011)Sahin, Jordan, Spatara, Naranjo, Robinson, Fernandez, Roberts Biochemistry (2011)
M69 S130
![Page 10: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
UDTM
Roberts, Das, & Sahin Int. J. Pharm. (2011)Sahin, Jordan, Spatara, Naranjo, Robinson, Fernandez, Roberts Biochemistry (2011)
M69 S130
Small length scales: single point mutations can greatly change kobs via “hot spots” a/o Gun
![Page 11: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
UDTM
Intermediate length scales: colloidal interactions & (near) neighbors
lim [protein] 0G22 = -2B22
Blanco, Das, and Roberts (in preparation)
S(q 0) [light / neutron scattering]
![Page 12: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
UDTM
Often, Gun (short L) wins out over B22(intermed. L) for agg’n of “monomers”
Tagg = temp. for t50 ~ 1 hourTm from DSCb2*= (B22-B22
HS) / B22HS
Roberts, Das, & Sahin Int. J. Pharm. (2011)Sahin, Grillo, Perkins, Roberts J. Pharm. Sci (2010)
![Page 13: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
UDTM
Brummitt et al JPhSci 100:2104 (2011)
Intermediate L: antibody “chain polymerization” (small oligomers)
Lumry-Eyring Nucleated-Polymerization (LENP)
mass action model
pH 4.5
![Page 14: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
UDTM
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
40 50 60 70 80
Excess Specific Heat C
apacity
(cal g
‐1K‐
1 )or
Mon
omer Fraction, m
(T)
Temperature / deg. C
Fab
CH2CH3
Local unfolding is (particuarly?) important for aggregation of large proteins
CH2CH3
FabTSML
DSC
![Page 15: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
UDTM
Initiation via irreversible dimerization of partially unfolded monomers
Nucleation: n ~ C01-x
Chain Growth: g ~ C0-1
Andrews & Roberts J Phys Chem B (2007); Weiss et al Biophys J (2007)Li & Roberts J Phys Chem B (2009); Li et al J PharmSci (2010)
Lumry-Eyring Nucleated-Polymerization (LENP)
mass action model
Brummitt et al JPhSci 100:2104 (2011)
Dimer…LargeSoluble /Insoluble Agg.
![Page 16: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
UDTM
Brummitt et al JPhSci (2011b)
Large L: further aggregate growth via both monomer add’n & aggregate coalescence
![Page 17: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
UDTM
Aggregate growth mechanism ispH-dependent
pH 3.5Slow growthOnly soluble
aggregates
pH 4.5Rapid growthSoluble & “insoluble” aggregates
pH 5.5Rapid growthPrimarily “insoluble” aggregates
(macroscopic “particles”)
Brummitt et al JPhSci (2011b)
![Page 18: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
UDTM
200 nm 200 nm50 nm 50 nm
100nm
Aggregate growth mechanisms depend strongly on charge & salt effects
Weiss et al. (2007)
Globular, HMW,Soluble Agg.
Insoluble Agg. / Precip. / Particles
Linear, HMW,Soluble Agg.
R. Hepler
Li et al., J. Pharm. Sci.p. 645-662 (2010).
![Page 19: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
UDTM
B22 Surrogate for agg – agg interactions & particle formation
200 nm 50 nm
Li et al., J. Pharm. Sci. 99:645 (2010)
All T < ca.Tm
NOTE: similar result for some IgGs (Sahin et al. 2010)
![Page 20: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
UDTM
[sal
t] (a
ppro
x. Io
nic
Str.
)
pH
Nucleation (Monomers)&Mon-Agg Interactions
Nucleation / Seeding&Agg-Agg Interactions
[sal
t] (a
ppro
x. Io
nic
Str.
)pH
Small L (“local” structure)
Small & Large L
200 nm 200 nm50 nm 50 nm
![Page 21: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
UDTM
Students & Post-DocsPrateek Shah (Ph.D. `08) Jennifer (Andrews) Woods (Ph.D. `08)Yi Li (Ph.D. `09) Michelle Spatara (Ph.D. `09)Teresa Young (Ph.D. `09) William F. Weiss IV (Ph.D. `09)Rebecca Brummitt(Ph.D. `10) ErincSahin(Post-doc Res. Assoc.)Charles Woods Marco BlancoRon Maurer Andrew Kroetsch(BChE `10)Nayoung Kim
Current / Recent CollaboratorsAnne Robinson (UD) BramieLenhoff(UD)Erik Fernandez (UVA) Aming Zhang (UVA)TundeOgunnaike(UD) AdeolaGrillo (HGSI)Melissa D. Perkins (HGSI) Doug Nesta(GSK)Lucy Chang (GSK / PFZ) Alan Hunter (MedImmune)MagdaIvanova(UCLA) Tom Laue, Sue Chase (UNH)Richard Remmele(Amgen) Dean Liu (Amgen)Tapan Das (Pfizer) Kevin King (Pfizer)
Funding (current + previous)National Institutes of HealthMerck Research LaboratoriesNational Science Foundation Human Genome SciencesGlaxoSmithKline PfizerMedImmune AmgenBoehringer Ingelheim
Acknowledgements
![Page 22: Non-Native Aggregate Assembly and Structure: A Multi-Scale ... · (Arrhenius) Prediction 1000 / T log 10 (time for 10% loss) pH 7.5 pH 4.8 1 year 1 mo. 1 day 1 hour 5 min. LENP Prediction](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040700/5d553fb588c99367778b75cd/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
UDTM