No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not...

17
Christina Ndoh, MPA and Jennifer Kuzma, PhD NC State University, Public Administration Department & Genetics, Engineering and Society Center GET Conference, May 2014

Transcript of No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not...

Page 1: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

Christina Ndoh, MPA and Jennifer Kuzma, PhD NC State University, Public Administration Department & Genetics, Engineering and Society Center GET Conference, May 2014

Page 2: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

2

Page 3: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

3

No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”

Page 4: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

4

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Taxonomic designation provided for both the donor organism and recipient microorganism Phenotypic information which may include biochemical and physiological traits Genotypic information such as the introduced genetic material and the method used to construct the microorganism Signed statement certifying intent to manufacture R&D activities conducted to date Knowledge of related MO previously reviewed by EPA Major intended application Location and properties for area of environmental release (*TERA only)
Page 5: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

5

Page 6: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

6

2- Nod factor

production

3- recognition

by host

1- signaling

Image showing symbiosis from: http://www.glycoforum.gr.jp/science/word/saccharide/SA-A02E.html

(M. loti)

(rice crop)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
three possible pathways: 1) inserting the nif cluster directly into the target plant, with the plant’s chloroplast genome serving as the chassis; 2) inserting the cluster into the genetic structure of the plant’s root microbes, or endosymbionts, which live within a plant for at least part of its lifetime; or 3) inserting the gene cluster into soil microbes that surround the plant, such as pseudomonads.
Page 7: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

7

Page 8: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

8

GEM Application Number of TERAs

Bioluminescent detection of airborne chemicals 5

Enhanced RDX degredation in contaminated groundwater 2

Fecal contamination detection 1

Genetically modified microalgae 5

Land mine detection 6

Napthalene and methyl salicylate detection 1

Nitrogen fixation 6

Pierce's disease in grapes prevention 3

Page 9: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

9

BJ 5019 (R98-001) JH 359 (R98-002) TN 11912 (R98-003)

Parental Strain USDA 110 JH (USDA 110 selected for a spontaneous Rif-r)

USDA I 11o (a mannitol non-utilizing variant of USDA 110)

Phenotypic information

More nodules on soybean in presence of other strains

Higher symbiotic nitrogen-fixation with or without molybdenum

More nodules and higher nitrogen fixation

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Testing was to begin in April or May of 1998 and continue for 3 years.
Page 10: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

10

Page 11: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

11

Site Nearest occupied dwelling

Nearest human pop. density (pop.)

Nearest wooded area (major animals)

1 1700 ft. 2.5 mi (500) 1500 ft. (Deer, squirrels, raccoons)

2 800 ft. 1 mi (2000) 2000 ft. (Deer, squirrels, groundhogs)

3 1000 ft. Within city limits (12,000) 1 mi. (Deer, groundhogs)

4 1000 ft. > 5000 ft. (500) 500 ft. (Deer, squirrels, groundhogs)

5 1500 ft. 4 miles (750) 300 ft. (Deer, squirrels, groundhogs)

6 1000 ft. 4.5 miles (3500) 600 ft. (Deer, groundhogs, rabbits)

7 0.5 mi. Morrisonville (500) 0.5 mi. (Deer, squirrels)

8 0.5 mi. Morrisonville (500)

1 mi. (Deer, squirrels)

Site Specific Data (Sites 1-6 in OH, Sites 7&8 in WI)

Page 12: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

12

Page 13: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

13

Page 14: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

Preventative Precautionary Permissive Promotional

Intellectual Property No access to information

Highly restricted access to information

Largely open access to information

Open access to information

Biosecurity Control of information and tools by a few

Several have control of information and tools

Most have control of information and tools

Unrestricted access to information and tools

Biosafety Ban on usage of SB products

Stringent, mandatory government regulation of environmental health and safety

Voluntary or flexible mandatory programs and standards for environmental health and safety

No specific SB provisions or standards for environmental health and safety

Ethics Ban SB application with moral objection

Widespread dialogue and deliberation before SB deployed

Transparent decision-making with input from various non-expert stakeholders

Closed process with little input outside of SB scientific community and decision-makers

14

Preventative Precautionary Permissive Promotional

SB Regulation on an Oversight Approach Continuum

(table from Kuzma and Tanji, 2010)

Page 15: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

15

Page 16: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

16

Page 17: No “new risks”, no new laws needed, “product not process”conferences.asucollegeoflaw.com/emergingtechnologies2014/files/2014/07/... · 4 . Taxonomic designation provided for

17