No. 20-10249-JJ, Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil ... · No. 20-10249-JJ, Huang v.Spector, et al....

Case Nos. 20-10249, 20-10610, 20-10611, 20-10612, 20-10613

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT

––––––––––––––––––––––––

SHIYANG HUANG, ET AL.,

Objectors-Appellants,

v.

BRIAN SPECTOR, ET AL.,

Plaintiffs-Appellees,

and

EQUIFAX INC., ET AL.,

Defendants-Appellees.

––––––––––––––––––––––––

On Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Northern District of Georgia, Civil Action No. 1:17-md-02800-TWT

––––––––––––––––––––––––

DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES’ RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR RELIEF UNDER

FED. R. APP. P. 10(e)(2)(C) BY APPELLANTS WATKINS AND FRANK

––––––––––––––––––––––––

David L. Balser

Phyllis B. Sumner

S. Stewart Haskins II

John C. Toro

Elizabeth D. Adler

Robert D. Griest

KING & SPALDING LLP

1180 Peachtree Street, N.E.

Atlanta, Georgia 30309

Case: 20-10249 Date Filed: 04/30/2020 Page: 1 of 139

No. 20-10249-JJ, Huang v. Spector, et al.

C-1 of 132

CERTIFICATE OF INTERESTED PERSONS

Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16.1 and Eleventh Circuit Rule 26.1, the

interested persons are as follows:

Abay, Jeremy E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Abbey Gardy, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Abbott Law Group, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Abbott, Donna, Plaintiff

Abbott, Melissa, Plaintiff

Abraham, Fruchter & Twersky, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Abraham, James, Plaintiff

Abraham, Jeffrey S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Abramowitz, Paige, Plaintiff

Abramson, Ashley, Plaintiff

Acklin-Davis, Cheyra, Plaintiff

Acosta, Russell, Plaintiff

Acosta-Smith, Katiushka Rebeca, Plaintiff

Adams, Christy, Plaintiff

Aday, Danika, Plaintiff

Adcock, Sean Knute, Plaintiff

Ademi & O'Reilly LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-2 of 132

Ademi, Shpetim, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Adler, Elizabeth Dees, counsel for Defendant(s)

Agnew, Christopher, Plaintiff

Agosto, Jackie L., Plaintiff

Ahdoot and Wolfson, APC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ahdoot and Wolfson, APC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ahdoot, Robert R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ahmed, Imran, Plaintiff

Ahmed, Salar Ali, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ahmed, Salar Ali, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Aidenbaum Schloff and Bloom, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Air Line Pilots Association, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Albrecht, Lawrence G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Alderman, Catherine, Plaintiff

Aldridge, Emily C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Alexander, Dan, Plaintiff

Alexander, John, Plaintiff

Alexander, Richard, Plaintiff

Alger Law LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Alger, Melody A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-3 of 132

Ali, Akbar, Plaintiff

Ali, Poonam, Plaintiff

Ali, Reesa, former Plaintiff

Ali, Reesa, Plaintiff

Allabaugh, Jaclyn, Plaintiff

Allabaugh, Jason, Plaintiff

Allanoff, Ben, Plaintiff

Allen, Gregory Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Allen, Jerry, Plaintiff

Allen, Teresa Denise, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Allison, Chris, Plaintiff

Almeida, Daniel E, Plaintiff

Almonrode, Sharon S. counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Alvarez, Kimberly Dawn, Plaintiff

Amadick, Margaret, Plaintiff

Amadick, Margaret, Plaintiff

Amador, Edwin Jeffrey, Plaintiff

Amir J. Goldstein, Esq., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Amjed, Naumon A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Amos, II, Charles Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-4 of 132

Ams, Jason T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Amsden, John L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Amuial, Adi, Plaintiff

Anderson, Christine, Plaintiff

Anderson, Christine, Plaintiff

Anderson, Jill, Plaintiff

Anderson, Keneil, Plaintiff

Anderson, Patrick, Plaintiff

Anderson, Rebekah Leann, Plaintiff

Anderson, Tracey, Plaintiff

Andrea S. Hirsch, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Andreica, Marius, Plaintiff

Andrews, Christopher, Objector

Andrews, James, Plaintiff

Andrews, Phyllis, Plaintiff

Annabelle Lee Patterson, PLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Annabelle Lee Patterson, PLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Anthony, Donald, Plaintiff

Antrim, Shawna Michelle, Plaintiff

Apathy, Justin, Plaintiff



C-5 of 132

Appel, Dawn, Plaintiff

Archambault, Michele Renee, Plaintiff

Areta, Ronnell, Plaintiff

Arisohn, Joshua D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Armstrong, Dean, Plaintiff

Armstrong, Steven Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Arnall Golden Gregory LLP-ATL, counsel for Defendant(s)

Arnall Golden Gregory LLP-ATL, counsel for Defendant(s)

Arnell, Chelsea, Plaintiff

Arnold M. Johnson Law Offices, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Arreaza, Alex, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Artino, Lynda L., Plaintiff

Artrip, Eric J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Arwood, David Russell, Plaintiff

Ash, Avery, Plaintiff

Ashford, Lakunta, Plaintiff

Ashley, Mark, Plaintiff

Asti, Gary, Plaintiff

Astor, Timothy, Plaintiff

Atiles, Jose, Plaintiff



C-6 of 132

Atkinson, Ashlie, Plaintiff

Atnip, III, Jack, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Aumais, Christopher T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Austin, Bradley, counsel for Defendant(s)

Austin, Michelle E., Plaintiff

Avise, Grant, former Plaintiff

Ayala, Love Morales, Plaintiff

Azocar, Adrian Michael, Plaintiff

Bacon, Adrian R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Baggett, Jeannie, Plaintiff

Bahnmaier, Mikayla Dawn, Plaintiff

Bailey & Galyen, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bailey & Glasser LLP-MA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bailey & Glasser LLP-MA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bailey, Benjamin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bailey, John Kennedy, Plaintiff

Bain, David Andrew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Baker, Jason, Plaintiff

Bakken, Keri, Plaintiff

Bakko, Justin, Plaintiff



C-7 of 132

Ball, Jeannie, Plaintiff

Ball, Jeannie, Plaintiff

Ball, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Ball, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Balser, David Lewis, counsel for Defendant(s)

Bandoh-Aidoo, Samuel, Plaintiff

Barber, Carol, Plaintiff

Barber, Eric, Plaintiff

Barbier, Cliff, Defendant

Barker, Patrick, former Plaintiff

Barker, Rita Bolt, counsel for Defendant(s)

Barlieb, Ethan J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Barnes, Roy E. CFP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Barnes, Roy E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Barnow & Associates, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Barnow, Ben, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Barone, John, Plaintiff

Barrack Rodos & Bacine, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-8 of 132

Barrett Law Group, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Barrett, John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Barrett, Sandra, Plaintiff

Barry, James A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Barry, Mike, Claimant

Basser, Stephen R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bassett, Alan B., Plaintiff

Bassett, Pamela R., Plaintiff

Baswell, Karen, Plaintiff

Batten, David, Plaintiff

Battle & Winn, LLP -B. AL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Battle & Winn, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Battle, Fleenor, Green, Winn & Clemmer, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Battle, Robert E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Baumgardner, Derek, Plaintiff

Baxter & Baxter, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Baxter, Justin M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Baxter, Patricia, Plaintiff

Beard, Leon, Plaintiff

Beasley Allen Crow Methvin Portis & Miles-AL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-9 of 132



Beck & Amsden, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Beck, Monte D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Becker, Carolyn, Plaintiff

Beekman, Bernadette, former Plaintiff

Belden, Matthew, Plaintiff

Belfon, Lawrence R., Plaintiff

Beligan, Jerusalem F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bell, Andrew P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Belland, Jaclyn, Plaintiff

Belong, Tyler Jay, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Belsky, Adam C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Benavidez, John, Plaintiff

Benavidez, Veronika, Plaintiff

Bench, Douglas J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bene, Devin Xavier, Plaintiff

Bene, Kristina Ruidas, Plaintiff

Benevento, Megan A. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Benne, Adam J., Plaintiff



C-10 of 132

Bennett, Corey Benjamin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bennett, Leonard A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bennett, Leonard A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Benson, Jamie, Plaintiff

Benson, Robert Todd, Plaintiff

Benson, Russ, Plaintiff

Benway, Patricia M., Plaintiff

Benz, Douglas, Plaintiff

Berezofsky Law Group, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Berezofsky Law Group, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Berezofsky, Esther Eva, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Berezofsky, Esther Eva, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Berezpfsky Law Group, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Berger & Montague, P.C. -MN, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Berger & Montague, P.C. -P.A, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Berger, David Michael, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bergquist, Karen, former Plaintiff

Berish, Joseph Michael, Plaintiff

Bethea, Candice, Plaintiff

Bevis, John Raymond CFP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-11 of 132

Bevis, John Raymond, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Beznoska, Bernice A., Plaintiff

Beznoska, Jr., Norman J., Plaintiff

Bickerton Dang, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bickerton, James J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bierstein, Andrea, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bigler, Debra, Plaintiff

Bigler, Emil, Plaintiff

Biles, Wayne, Plaintiff

Bingham Greenebaum Doll LLP - Lexington, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Biorn, Ron, Plaintiff

Bireda, Saba, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Birkett, Brenda, Plaintiff

Birkett, Brenda, Plaintiff

Biscup, Thomas Adam, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bishop, Michael, Plaintiff

Bishop, Paul W. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bishop, Paul William, Plaintiff

Bishop, Roy, former Plaintiff

Bishop, Roy, Plaintiff



C-12 of 132

Bisnar Chase LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bitton, Avi Joshua, Plaintiff

Black, James A., Plaintiff

Black, Petre Fiona, Plaintiff

Blake, Daniel, Plaintiff

Blakeman, J. Benjamin

Blakemore, Chevera, Plaintiff

Blanchfield, Jr., Garrett D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blankinship, Douglas Gregory, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blatt, Gayle M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blaudeau, Francois M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blauvelt, Christine L., Plaintiff

Bleckley, Jeanette Ann, Plaintiff

Bledsoe, Kathryn, Plaintiff

Bledsoe, Marilyn, Plaintiff

Bledsoe, Matthew, Plaintiff

Bleichmar Fonti & Auld LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Blieberg, Joseph Gershon, Plaintiff



C-13 of 132

Block, Carson., Plaintiff

Blood Hurst & O'Reardon, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blood Hurst & O'Reardon, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blood, Timothy G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blumenthal, Aaron, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Blythin, John D. counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bobbitt, Kristine, Plaintiff

Boehl Stopher & Graves, LLP - Paducah, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bolen, Earl, Plaintiff

Bologna, Sabina, Plaintiff

Bolton, Jordan S., counsel for Defendant(s)

Boodhoo, Gaitri, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Boothe, John M., Plaintiff

Borland, Tim, Plaintiff

Borrello, Robert John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bosak, Emily, Plaintiff

Bosak, Sean, Plaintiff

Boundy, Samuel, Plaintiff

Bourne, Joseph C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Boutin, Harold, Defendant



C-14 of 132

Boyer-Rainwater, Rodney, Plaintiff

Bozin, Daniel, Plaintiff

Brachat, William L., Plaintiff

Bradley, Alana M., Plaintiff

Bradley, Mary, Plaintiff

Bradley, Michael S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bradley, Sherri Vernetta, Plaintiff

Bradley, Valencia Vee, Plaintiff

Brammer, Jr., J. William, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Branch, Ebonie, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Branch, Michael, Plaintiff

Brandon, Judy Diane, Plaintiff

Brannan, Emily Smith, Plaintiff

Brannan, Samuel Tillman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Brannen, Jerad Russell, Plaintiff

Branstetter Stranch & Jennings PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Brashier, Andrew E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bratton, Barbara A., Plaintiff



C-15 of 132

Breen Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Breen, David H., Plaintiff

Breen, David Hart, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Breen, Mathew M., Plaintiff

Breen, Pamela A., Plaintiff

Brennan, Kenneth J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bressack, Darryl, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bressack, Darryl, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Brett H. Oppenheimer, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Brian D. Flick, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Brisini, Jr., John L., former Plaintiff

Briskin, Alan M., counsel for Defendant(s)

Briskin, Cross & Sanford, LLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Bristol, Jason Robert, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Broadhead, Desirae, Plaintiff

Broder, Laura, Plaintiff

Brody, Jay I., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Bronstein, Gewirtz & Grossman, ESQS., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-16 of 132

Bronstein, Peretz, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Broome, Christopher Justin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Broome, Christopher Justin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Brown, Chris, Plaintiff

Brown, Darlene, Plaintiff

Brown, Diane, Plaintiff

Brown, LaShawn, Plaintiff

Brown, Ronald, Plaintiff

Brumfield, Tyoka., Plaintiff

Brush, Frank J., Plaintiff

Buchanan, David R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Buckner & Miles, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Buckner, David Marc, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Budilov, Emil, Plaintiff

Buether Joe & Carpenter, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Buether, Eric W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Buhler, Patricia, Plaintiff

Burchett, Amy M. , Plaintiff

Burchette, Robert L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Burgess Law Firm, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-17 of 132

Burgess, Mitchell L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Burgstahler, Jody, Plaintiff

Burgstahler, Kevin, Plaintiff

Burns Charest, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Burns, Megan Elizabeth, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Burns, Warren T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Burrows, Matthew Vernon, counsel for Defendant(s)

Bursor & Fisher, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Burt Langley, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Burt, Thomas H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Butler, II, George Edwin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Butler, Kathryn France, Plaintiff

Byas, Deidra, Plaintiff

Byrd, Courtenay, Plaintiff

Byrd, Evans, Plaintiff

Byrd, Gail, Plaintiff

Byrne Davis & Hicks, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cacioppo, Jayna Morse, counsel for Defendant(s)

Cadwallader, Brian A., Plaintiff

Cafferty Clobes Meriwether & Sprengel LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-18 of 132

Calderon, Jose, Plaintiff

Caldwell, Jr., Robert Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Callison Tighe and Robinson, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Campbell, Gary, Plaintiff

Campbell, Kody, Plaintiff

Campbell, Melissa Anne, counsel for Defendant(s)

Campbell, Robert Leonard, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Campbell, Tammy L., Plaintiff

Campbell, Timothy F., counsel for Defendant(s)

Campolo, Eric Andrew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Campolo, Paul E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Campos, Iris., Plaintiff

Canfield, Kenneth S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Canfield, Kenneth S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Caplan, David, Plaintiff

Cappio, Gretchen Freeman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carlin, Nicholas A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carlson, Charles, Plaintiff

Carlson, Clara, Plaintiff

Carney, Benjamin Howard, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-19 of 132

Carobene, Robert, Plaintiff

Carpenter, Brian Andrew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carpenter, Charles Henry, counsel for Defendant(s)

Carpenter, Dustin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carpenter, Dustin, Plaintiff

Carpenter, Dustin, Pro Se

Carr & Carr (Tulsa), counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carr and Weatherby, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carr, Maria, Plaintiff

Carr, Mark, Plaintiff

Carr, Patrick Eugene, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carr, W. Pitts, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carson, Shanon J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Carter, Shawnette, Plaintiff

Cary, III, Randolph Jefferson, Plaintiff

Casamayor, Rebecca Newman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Casey Gerry Reed & Schenk, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cashman, Michael Richard, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cashon, Ashley, former Plaintiff

Cashon, Ashley, Plaintiff



C-20 of 132

Cawley, Molly Renee Hamilton, counsel for Defendant(s)

Cederdahl, James A., Plaintiff

Cejas, Miriam, Plaintiff

Cento Law, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cento, G. John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chaffin, Christopher, Plaintiff

Chaiken, David M., counsel for Defendant(s)

Chakan, Elizabeth, Plaintiff

Chalmers, Dawn Lea, Plaintiff

Chambers, Alexia, Plaintiff

Chandler, Susan, Plaintiff

Chap, Amanda, Plaintiff

Chapel, Jr., Nimrod T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chapin, Edward Dewey, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Charest, Daniel H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Charles T. Lester, Jr., Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chase, Brian D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chase, Michael, Plaintiff

Chaselight, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chavez, Elizabeth Christine, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-21 of 132

Chavez, Kathleen Currie, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chehebar, Solomon, Plaintiff

Chekmazov, Val, Plaintiff

Chenault, Jasmine, Plaintiff

Cherney, Andrew, Plaintiff

Cherney, Jack, Plaintiff

Chilivis, Cochran, Larkins & Bever, LLP, counsel for Defendant(s)

Chimicles & Tikellis, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chimicles Schwartz Kriner & Donaldson-Smith LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Chinander, Marie, Plaintiff

Cho, Grace, Plaintiff

Chrisman, Ethan, Plaintiff

Chrisman, Tyler, Plaintiff

Christen, Peggy, Plaintiff

Christensen Young & Associates PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Christensen, Cameron, Plaintiff

Christensen, Jennifer J., Plaintiff

Christensen, Jennifer J., Plaintiff

Christensen, Steven A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Christensen, Zane L., Plaintiff



C-22 of 132

Church, Megan Cunniff, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ciampitti, Alene, Plaintiff

Cipollone, Pat, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cirsch, Lee A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clark Hill PLC -PA, counsel for Defendant(s)

Clark Hill PLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Clark Hill PLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Clark Hill, PLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Clark, Joseph, Plaintiff

Clark, LPN, Katherine, Plaintiff

Clark, Meghan, Plaintiff

Clark, Melissa Ryan, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clark, Miles N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clark, Miles N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clark, Robin Frazer, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clark, Thurman Bryan, Plaintiff

Clate, Anthony, Plaintiff

Clay, Jr., Charles L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clifford Law Offices, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clifford Law Offices, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-23 of 132

Clifford Law Offices, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clifford Law Offices, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clifford, Robert A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clifford, Robert A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clobes, Bryan L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Clore, Robert, counsel for Objector

Clough, Michael C., Plaintiff

Clouser, Jamie P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Coade-Wingate, Mona, Plaintiff

Coast Law Group, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cochran, Anthony L., counsel for Defendant(s)

Cochran, George W., Pro Se, Objector

Coe, Mathew Patterson, Plaintiff

Coffman, Richard L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Coggins, Jeffery Scott, Plaintiff

COHEN & MALAD LL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)P

Cohen & Malad, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cohen & Malad, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cohen Milstein Hausfeld & Toll, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC - DC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-24 of 132



Cohen Rosenthal & Kramer, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cohen, David Michael, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cohen, Rosenthal & Kramer, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Colchin, Angela, Plaintiff

Colchin, Angela, Plaintiff

Cole, Matthew, Plaintiff

Cole, Philip, Plaintiff, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cole, Scott Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cole, Shirley M., Plaintiff

Colley & Colley LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Colley Firm, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Colley, Jr., Paul, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Collins, Randall, Plaintiff

Collins, Robert L, Plaintiff

Colson Hicks Eidson, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Complex Law Group, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Conley Griggs Partin, LLP- GA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Conlin, Roxanne Barton, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-25 of 132

Connell, Justin Beecher, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Connick Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Connick Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Connick, Thomas J. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Connick, Thomas J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Conroy, Jayne, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Consumer Justice Center, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Consumer Law -PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Consumer Litigation Associates, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Consumer Litigation Associates, P.C.-NN VA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)





Coogle, Thomas Leslie, Plaintiff

Cook, Jeffrey Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cooke, Adam, counsel for Defendant(s)

Cooke, Peter, Plaintiff

Coombs, Leo Michael, Plaintiff

Coombs, Leo Michael, Plaintiff



C-26 of 132

Coomes, Andrew Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cooper & Kirk, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cooper, Corinne, Plaintiff

Cooper, Davis, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cooper, III, Paul Berry, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cope, Breanne Vandemeer, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Copeland, William Lloyd, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Corboy & Demetrio, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Corboy & Demetrio, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cordell, Donald A., former Plaintiff

Cornett, Robert, Plaintiff

Corona, John, former Plaintiff

Corsale, Peter, counsel for Defendant(s)

Cortez, Alejandrina, Plaintiff

Cortez, Elizabeth, Plaintiff

Cortez, Joaquin Antonio, Plaintiff

Cortez, Yulissa, Plaintiff, Plaintiff

Cotchett, Joseph W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-27 of 132

Cottle, Robert W. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Couch Law, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Couch, Nina B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Coughlin, Joseph T., Plaintiff

Cox, Brian, Plaintiff

Cox, Jessica, Plaintiff

Coyne, Mary, Plaintiff

Coyne, Tonya M., Plaintiff

Craig Kyle Hemphill Law Offices PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Craney, Bridget, Plaintiff

Cresswell, Deborah Louise, Plaintiff

Crockett, Denise B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Crockett, Jr., Robert F., Plaintiff

Crossett, James A., Plaintiff

Crow, Andrew, Plaintiff

Crowe, David, Plaintiff

Crumly, Tom, Plaintiff

Cuason, Maria Cristina, Plaintiff

Cuevas, Maricela, Plaintiff

Culver, Triel D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-28 of 132

Cunniff, John L., Plaintiff

Curran, Jr., Gary R., Plaintiff

Curtis, Brian, Plaintiff

Dahlstrom, Patrick V., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dalton, Brittany S., Plaintiff

Dalton, Daniel R., Plaintiff

D'Ancona, Joshua E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Daniel E. Morris Law Firm, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dann Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dann, Marc Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dann, Marc Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Danny Sheena, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Danzig, Aaron M., counsel for Defendant(s)

Daughtery, Cady, Plaintiff, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

David F. Miceli, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

David Hill Peck, Esq., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

David, Carl, Plaintiff

Davidson, Stuart A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Davis, Alex C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Davis, Germany, Plaintiff



C-29 of 132

Davis, Jeremy, Plaintiff

Davis, John W., Objector

Davis, John William, Objector

Davis, Leonard A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Davis, Olivia, Plaintiff

Davis, Patrick, Plaintiff

Davison, Laura J., Plaintiff

Davison, Terry, Plaintiff

Davitz, Dianna, Plaintiff

de Jesus, Peter, Plaintiff

De Ville, Tammy Tonette, Plaintiff

Dean, Kevin R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dearborn, Mark J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dearman, Mark, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Decker, Isabel Holguin, Plaintiff

DeConcini, Donna, Plaintiff

DeCosta, Christopher Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dees, Marshall P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dela Cruz, Monique, Plaintiff

DeMarco, Jennifer Pascucci, Plaintiff



C-30 of 132

DeMarco, Jr., Daniel, Plaintiff

Demetrio, Thomas A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dennis Corry Smith & Dixon, LLP- ATL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dennis, Jasmine, Plaintiff

Dennis, Jasmine, Pro Se

Dennis, Kaitlyn Leeann, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Derby, Melissa, Plaintiff

Derderian, Jaime Lea, Plaintiff

Derek G. Howard Law Firm, Inc., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Derek G. Howard Law Firm, Inc., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Derr, Charles, Plaintiff

Desiderato, Jerry, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

DeVore, Linda, Plaintiff

DeWoskin Law Firm, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

DeWoskin, Daniel Eliot, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dhuka, Imtiyaz, Plaintiff

Dhukka, Abuzar, Plaintiff

Diamand, Nicholas, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Diamond, Douglas, former Plaintiff

Diaz, Ernesto, Plaintiff



C-31 of 132

Diaz, Johann Manuel, Plaintiff

DiCello Levitt and Casey LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

DiCello Levitt Gutzler, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



DiCello, Mark A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dilworth Paxson - PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dilworth Paxson - PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dilworth Paxson LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

DiMichele, John A., Plaintiff

Dimmagio, Anthony, Plaintiff

Dixon, Brittany, Plaintiff

Dixon, Jeffrey Warren, former Plaintiff

Dodick, Dan, Plaintiff

Does 1 through 50, inclusive, Defendants

Doffermyre Shields Canfield & Knowles, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Doffermyre Shields Canfield & Knowles, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dominick, Keith W, Plaintiff.

Domino, Barbara J., Plaintiff

Donnelly, John, Plaintiff



C-32 of 132

Dooley, Robert S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Doolittle, Dennis, Plaintiff

Dorros Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dorros, Torin Aaron, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dorsey & Gates, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dorsey, Marilyn., Plaintiff

Dorsey, Trevor, Plaintiff

Dorssom, Elizabeth, former Plaintiff

Doss, Jason R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Doten, Eileen, Plaintiff

Douglas Leonard & Garvey PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Douglas, III, Charles G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dowgin, Maura, Plaintiff

Drake, E. Michelle, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dremak, Andrew, Plaintiff

Drobny, Stephen Paul, counsel for Defendant(s)

Drugan, Christopher S., Plaintiff

Drummer, K'acia, Plaintiff

Dublin, Nancy, Plaintiff

Dudas, Mark A., Plaintiff



C-33 of 132

Duenas, Heather, Plaintiff

Duke, Christian, former Plaintiff

Duncan Law Group, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Duncan, Debbie, Plaintiff

Duncan, Robert R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dunlap, Joe J., Plaintiff

Dunlap, Leigh., former Plaintiff

Dunleavy, Christopher P., Plaintiff

Duran, Franklin., Plaintiff

Duran, Roy, Plaintiff

Duran, Wendy, Plaintiff

Durham, Timothy, Plaintiff

Durrang, Joanne, Plaintiff

Dutton & Associates, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Dykes, Keisha, Plaintiff

Eames, William M., Plaintiff

Earl, Jonathon, Plaintiff

Eastman, John, Plaintiff

Edelsberg, Scott Adam, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Edelson & Associates, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-34 of 132

Edelson, Marc H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Edison, McDowell & Hetherington LLP -TX, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Edward B. Geller, Esq., P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Edwards Frickle & Culver, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Edwards, A. Clifford, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Edwards, Katherine, Plaintiff

Edwin, Atir, Plaintiff

Eggnatz, Joshua Harris, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Eidson, Jr., Lewis S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Eikost, Karl Gordon, Plaintiff

Elarbee, Thompson, Sapp & Wilson, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Eldridge, Mark A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ellenberg, Stanley, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Elliott, Abby, Plaintiff

Elliott, Maureen, Plaintiff

Els, Brian, Plaintiff

Emerson Firm, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Emerson, John G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Emert, Melissa Robin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

End, James P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-35 of 132

England, Cynthia Jane, Plaintiff

Englert, Gina, Plaintiff

English, Melissa L. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Enslow, Christopher, Plaintiff

Entsminger, Carrie L., former Plaintiff

Entsminger, Johnathan C., former Plaintiff

Eppy, Samuel, Plaintiff

Equifax Consumer Services, LLC also known as Equifax Personal Solutions also known

as PSOL, Defendant

Equifax Credit Information Services, Inc., Defendant

Equifax Health Services, Defendant

Equifax Information Services LLC, Defendant

Equifax Information Solutions, LLC, Defendant

Equifax, Inc., Defendant

Erickson, Michael, Plaintiff

Esades, Vincent J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Essary, Michelle, Plaintiff

Etten, Robert, Plaintiff

Evangelista Worley, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Evangelista, James M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-36 of 132

Evans, Dawn, Plaintiff

Evans, Douglas C., Plaintiff

Evans, Janet, Plaintiff

Evans, Kay., Plaintiff

Evans, Keymia, Plaintiff

Evans, McKean J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Everly, Valerie Anita, Plaintiff

Facinoli, Dr. John, Plaintiff

Fail, Jonathan, Plaintiff

Faillace, Ondrea, Plaintiff

Falco, Joe, Plaintiff

Falco, Maria, Plaintiff

Falcon, Richard V., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Falkenberg, Paul, Plaintiff

Faria, Brandee J.K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Faria, Brandee J.K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Farinella, Adolpho, Plaintiff

Farinella, Gus Michael, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Farris-Olsen, Robert, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Faruqi & Faruqi, LLP -Atl, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-37 of 132

Faruqi, Rahul, Plaintiff

Fausz, Ella J., Plaintiff

Federman & Sherwood, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Federman & Sherwood, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Federman, William B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fee, Smith, Sharp & Vitullo, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Feehrer, Wesley, Plaintiff

Feied, Malcolm B., Plaintiff

Feinstein Doyle, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Feldman, Lori G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ferrara, Susan, Plaintiff

Ferrel, Kayla, Plaintiff

Ferri, Daniel R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Finch, Courtney, Plaintiff

Finch, Michael, Plaintiff

Findlay, James, Plaintiff

Fink + Associates Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fink Associates Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)





C-38 of 132

Fink, David H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fink, Nathan J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fink, Nathan J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Finkelstein Thompson, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Finkelstein, Blankinship, Frei-Pearson & Garber, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Finley, James Benjamin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Finnerty, Robert William, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fiore, Justin, Plaintiff

First Albrecht & Blondis SC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fischman, Noam B., counsel for Defendant(s)

Fisher, Jr., David, Plaintiff

Fitzgerald, Jack, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fitzgerald, Jack, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Flanders, Kimbra, Plaintiff

Fleming Law Firm, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fleming, Catherine J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Flick, Brian D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Flitton, Cheminant M., Plaintiff



C-39 of 132

Flood, Kelly, Plaintiff

Flores, Shervon, Plaintiff

Flowers, Alice-Marie, Objector

Flowers, Jodi Westbrook, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Flowers, Jodi Westbrook, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Flynn, Trevor, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Foote, Mielke, Chavez & O'Neil, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Foote, Robert M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ford, Terry, Plaintiff

Fore, Lindsay Elisabeth, Plaintiff

Fossett, Tiffany, Plaintiff

Foster, Jason P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fraietta, Philip L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fralick, John, Plaintiff

Francis & Mailman, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Francis Mailman Soumilas, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Francis, James A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Frank, Larry, Plaintiff

Frank, Patricia, Plaintiff

Frank, Theodore H., Objector



C-40 of 132

Franklin, Karen, Plaintiff

Franklin, Michael, Plaintiff

Frazier, Tawanda, Plaintiff

Freeman, Randi, Plaintiff

Freeman-Hargis, James, former Plaintiff

Frei-Pearson, Jeremiah Lee, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fried, Albert Louis, Plaintiff

Friedland, Shelly L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Friedman, Andrea, Plaintiff

Friedman, Andrew N. counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Friedman, Todd M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Friedrich, Robert, Defendant

Froelich, Jr., Jerome, counsel for Objector

Fuhrman, Todd, Plaintiff

Fuller, Michael R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Fuschetti, Danielle Anne

Gainey, Richard, former Plaintiff

Gainey, Valerie, former Plaintiff

Gallagher Callahan & Gartrell PC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Gallant, Jr., Joseph, Plaintiff



C-41 of 132

Galligan & Reid PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Galligan, Brian P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gallo, Violet, Plaintiff

Galloway, Kristen, Plaintiff

Gallucci, Daniel N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Galpern, Andrew, Plaintiff

Galpern, Michael A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Galpin, Theresa M., Plaintiff

Gardner, Frederick, Plaintiff

Gardner, Nikki-Lynn, Plaintiff

Gardy and Notis, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gardy, Mark C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Garrett, Robert Walker, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Garrison, Jr., W. Lewis, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Garrity, James M., Plaintiff

Garthright, Blair, Plaintiff

Garvine, Brian M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gastel, Benjamin A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gastineau, Charles, Plaintiff

Gates, Matthew, Plaintiff



C-42 of 132

Gates, Sergeant James, Plaintiff

Gates, Tanisha M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gauger, Andrew, Plaintiff

Gauger, Nancy, former Plaintiff

Gauger, Nancy, Plaintiff

Gay, James A., Plaintiff

Gellar, Paul J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Geller, Andrew C., Plaintiff

Geller, Edward B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Geller, Jody L., Plaintiff

Gentile, Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gentile, Ryan L, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Geragos & Geragos, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Geragos & Geragos, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Geragos, Mark J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gerstein, Joshua, Plaintiff

Gersten, Ehud, Plaintiff

Gianola, Barnum & Wigal, LC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gianola, Barnum & Wigal, LC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gianola, James A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-43 of 132

Gianola, John Fulton, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Giatras, Troy N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gibbs Law Group LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gibbs Law Group LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gibbs, Eric H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gibbs, Eric H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gibbs, Robert, Plaintiff

Gibbs, William T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Giblin, Gwendolyn R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gibson, Robin, Plaintiff

Gibson, Troy K., Plaintiff

Giesler, Shea, Defendant

Gifford, Shenna, Plaintiff

Gilbert, Alicia Bliss, counsel for Defendant(s)

Gilbert, Robert Cecil, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gilchrist, Wesley B., counsel for Defendant(s)

Gilmore, Robert B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Girard Gibbs, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Girard Gibbs, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Girardi & Keese, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-44 of 132



Given, David M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gladwell, Lisa, Plaintiff

Glancy Prongay & Murray, LLP -CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Glancy, Lionel Z., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Glassman, Marisa Kendra CFP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Glassman, Marisa Kendra, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Godfrey & Kahn-WI, counsel for Defendant(s)

Godino, Marc L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Goldenberg Schneider LPA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Goldenberg, Jeffrey, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Goldman Scarlato & Penny, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Goldman, Mark S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Goldstein, Amir J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Goldstein, Jennifer S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Goldweber, Asha, Plaintiff

Gomez LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gomez, Julio C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gonzalez, Rosemary, Plaintiff



C-45 of 132

Goodale, Zachary, Plaintiff

Goode, Laura J. , Plaintiff

Goodman, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Gordon Shaw Law Group, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gordon, Richard S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gordon, Wolf & Carney, Chtd, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gori Julian & Associates, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gottesman, Michael, Plaintiff

Gottlieb, Mark, Plaintiff

Gower, C. Jacob, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grabar Law Office, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grabar, Joshua J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grady & Notis, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grafton, Nicole., Plaintiff

Graifman, Gary S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grajeda, Rueben, Plaintiff

Gray & White, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gray, Denise Carter, Plaintiff

Gray, Mark K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Green & Noblin, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-46 of 132

Green, Emily, Plaintiff

Green, Gary, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Green, John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Green, Latosha, Plaintiff

Green, Lillian Katherine, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Green, Robert S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Green, Sherry, Plaintiff

Greenlee, Mary, Plaintiff

Greenwald, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Greenwood, Thomas, Plaintiff

Greenwood, Thomas, Plaintiff

Gregory Law Firm, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gregory, Colton, Plaintiff

Gregory, Steven P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gresham, Dean, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Griest, Robert Douglas, counsel for Defendant(s)

Griffin & Strong, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Griffin, Eric, Plaintiff

Griffin, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Griggs, Lisa, Plaintiff



C-47 of 132

Grogen, Joyce M. , Plaintiff

Gross & Belsky, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gross, Terry, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grossberg, Josh, Plaintiff

Grossman Roth, PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grossman, Neil, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Grubb, II, Archie Irwin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gualandi, Evelyn, Plaintiff

Guess, Jasmine, Plaintiff

Guillory, Jacob, Plaintiff

Gulley, Roshunda, Plaintiff

Gurtis, Amanda, Plaintiff

Gustafson Gluek PLLC -MN, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gustafson, Daniel E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Gutierrez, Julia, Plaintiff

Guzman, Elio, Plaintiff

Haber Slade, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Haber Slade, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Haddon, Mallory E., Plaintiff

Haeggquist & Eck, LLP -CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-48 of 132

Haeggquist, Alreen, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro, LLP -WA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hagman, Nickolas, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Hagstrom, Richard M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hagstrom, Richard M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Haileselassie, Jade, former Plaintiff

Haileselassie, Jade, Plaintiff

Haines and Krieger, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Haines, George, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Haines, George, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hale, Ricky Lee, Plaintiff

Hall & Lampros, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hall, Angela Michelle, Plaintiff

Hall, Ashley Miranda, Plaintiff

Hall, Christopher Baker, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Halpin, Patrick, Plaintiff



C-49 of 132

Hamid, Nosheen T., Plaintiff

Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute, counsel for Objector

Hamilton, Donald, Plaintiff

Hamilton, Jesse, Plaintiff

Hamilton, Sarah, Plaintiff

Hammel, Douglas, Plaintiff

Hammond, Dennis, Plaintiff

Hammond, Terry, Plaintiff

Hamre, Angela, Plaintiff

Hand, Austin Bradley, Plaintiff

Handmaker, Sally M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Handrock, John, Plaintiff

Hanes, Elizabeth Wilson, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hanes, Elizabeth Wilson, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hannah, Kyle, Plaintiff

Hannan, Mary, Defendant

Hannon, Kevin S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hannon, Tom W., Plaintiff

Hannon, Tom W., Plaintiff

Hardy, Sarah L., former Plaintiff



C-50 of 132

Harris Lowry Manton, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)





Harris, Brian, Plaintiff

Harris, Earl, Plaintiff

Harris, Jasmine, Plaintiff

Harris, Jeffrey R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Harris, Jeffrey R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Harris, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Harris, Robert, Plaintiff

Harris, Vanuel, Plaintiff

Harte, Lilliana, Plaintiff

Hartheimer, David, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hartley Law Group, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hartley Law Group, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hartley, R. Dean, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hartman, Jared M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Haskins, II, Sidney Stewart, counsel for Defendant(s)



C-51 of 132

Hathaway, Christopher L. , Plaintiff

Haugen, Christopher J., counsel for Defendant(s)

Hausfeld, LLP - DC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)




Hayes, Renee, Plaintiff

Hayes, Windish & Badgewick, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Haylock, Darren, Plaintiff

Hebrlee, Craig, Plaintiff

Heck, Jeremiah E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hedlund, Daniel C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Heins Mills & Olson P.L.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Heisler, Jeremy, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hejny, Darlene, Plaintiff

Heller, Lisa L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hellmuth & Johnson PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hellmuth & Johnson PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hellmuth & Johnson, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hellmuth Johnson Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-52 of 132

Helton, Bob, Plaintiff

Hemphill, Craig Kyle, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Henderson, Joseph, Plaintiff

Henderson, Shon, Plaintiff

Hendricks, Deborah, Plaintiff



Heninger Garrison & Davis, LLC - AL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Henkel, Margaret, Plaintiff

Hensley, Barbara, Plaintiff

Hepburn, Alexander S., Plaintiff

Herman Gerel, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Herman Jones LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Herman, John C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Herman, Matthew J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Herman, Steven Alan, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hermina Law Group, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hermina, John W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hernandez, Amber, Plaintiff

Herrera, Daniel O., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-53 of 132

Herring, M. Stan, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Herrmann, Michael, Plaintiff

Hershkowitz, Kory, Plaintiff

Hesney, Solomon, Plaintiff

Hess-Mahan, Theodore M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hetherington, Thomas F.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Highfield, Christopher, Plaintiff

Hildenbrand, Zacariah, Plaintiff

Hill, Catrice, Plaintiff

Hill, Kazembe, Plaintiff

Hill, William, Plaintiff

Hilliard & Munoz, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hilliard, Robert C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hinck, Walter, Plaintiff

Hirsch, Andrea Solomon, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hirst, Nathan P., Plaintiff

Hobson, John A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hoerman, Timothy, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hoerman, Tor, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hoesly, Matthew Michael, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-54 of 132

Hogan Lovells, counsel for Defendant(s)

Hogan Lovells, US LLP-DC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Hogan, James, Plaintiff

Hoge, III, Arthur F., counsel for Defendant(s)

Hogencamp, Charles, Plaintiff

Hogue & Belong, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hogue, Jeffrey L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Holan, Mark, Plaintiff

Holen, Mary L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Holguin, Leonard Phillip, Plaintiff

Holley, Sonia, Plaintiff

Holloway, Angel, Plaintiff

Hollowell, Melvin B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Holly, Kathleen, Plaintiff

Holoman, M. Justin, Plaintiff

Holtz Mahshie DeCosta, PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Holyoak, Melissa, counsel for Objector

Holzer & Holzer, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Holzer, Corey Daniel, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Holzman, Steven C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-55 of 132

Honanian, Robert, Plaintiff

Hood, Christopher B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hood, II, Joseph Alexander, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hood, James Carroll, Plaintiff

Hood, Larry Bentley, Plaintiff

Hood, Neva Joyce, Plaintiff

Hootman, Dennis A., Plaintiff

Hopkins, Nathan W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Horne, David, Plaintiff

House, Aaron, Plaintiff

House, Jesse., Plaintiff

Hovsepyan, Hovsep, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Howard, Derek G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Howard, John, Plaintiff

Howard, Rickey L., Plaintiff

Howard-Vesci, Luke, Plaintiff

Huang, Shiyang, Pro Se, Movant, Appellant

Hudson & King, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hudson, Chanel, Plaintiff

Hudson, Joseph Shane, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-56 of 132

Huey, John, Plaintiff

Hughes, Brent, Plaintiff

Hughes, Emily E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hughes, John, Plaintiff

Hunt, Robert, Plaintiff

Hunter, Lola., former Plaintiff

Huppert, Richard, Plaintiff

Hussin Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hussin, Tammy Gruder, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hutchings, Barsamian, Cross and Mandelcorn LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Hutchinson, Christopher, Plaintiff

Hutz, Timothy, Plaintiff

Hyatt, JoAnn, Plaintiff

Ialacci, Nick, Plaintiff

Ingram, Tommie, Plaintiff

Irwin, Michael., Plaintiff

Isacoff, Mark, Plaintiff

Isacoff, Mark, Plaintiff

Isajiw, Peter, counsel for Defendant(s)

Issis. Odeh J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-57 of 132

Isso & Hughes Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Isso, Jennifer, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Itzhak, Krista, Plaintiff

J. Benjamin Blakeman, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jackson, Anthony F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jackson, Kashmir A. , Plaintiff

Jackson, Marlon, Plaintiff

Jacobson, Lawrence M., Pro Se, Movant

Jaetzold, Gary, Plaintiff

Jagadam, Vidya Sagar, Defendant

James G. Stranch, IV, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

James, II, Charles, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Janusz, Alexis Budinas, Plaintiff

Jaret & Jaret, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jaret, Robert S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jasinski, Mathew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jaspers, Glenn, Plaintiff

Jazlowiecki, Edward A. , Plaintiff

Jazlowiecki, Edward A., Pro Se

Jelli Donuts, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-58 of 132

Jenkins Mulligan & Gabriel, LLP -CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jenkins, Christian A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jensen, Benjamin C., counsel for Defendant(s)

Jett, Tammy, Plaintiff

Jimenez, Telesforo, Plaintiff

Joe, Christopher M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

John L. Green, CPA, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Johns, Benjamin F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Johns, Greg., former Plaintiff

Johnson, Aaron M., Plaintiff

Johnson, Angela Melton, Plaintiff

Johnson, Arnold Melvin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Johnson, Dawn, Plaintiff

Johnson, Elvis A., Plaintiff

Johnson, Ernestine, Plaintiff

Johnson, Jess Brandel, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Johnson, Jessica, Plaintiff

Johnson, Jonathan Wesley, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Johnson, Jonathan Wesley, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Johnson, Jr., Walter, former Plaintiff



C-59 of 132

Johnson, Lisa C., former Plaintiff

Johnson, Rodney H., Plaintiff

Johnston Allison & Hord, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Johnston, Heather, Plaintiff

Jonathan W. Johnson, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jonathan W. Johnson, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jonckheer, Willem Frans, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jones Walker LLP, counsel for Defendant(s)



Jones Walker, LLP-ATL, counsel for Defendant(s)

Jones Ward, PLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jones, Beronica, Plaintiff

Jones, Frances, Plaintiff

Jones, Lisa Niambi, Plaintiff

Joof, Henan Louis, Plaintiff

Joost, Jennifer L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Joost, Jennifer L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Jorge, Christine, Plaintiff

Josefsberg, Scott, Plaintiff



C-60 of 132

Joseph Greenwald and Laake, PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Joseph Greenwald and Laake, PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Joshpe Law Group LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Joshpe, Brett, Plaintiff

Judkins, John, Pro Se, Movant

Judkins, Susan, Pro Se, Movant

Jungali, David, Plaintiff

Just, Linda, Plaintiff

Kaass Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kabateck, Brian S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kabateck, Brown & Kellner, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kaczmarek, James M., Plaintiff

Kaczmarek, Kelly, Plaintiff

Kaden, Brian, Plaintiff

Kahler, Ray W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kalmick, Bruce, Plaintiff

Kamin, Correy A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kane, Julie Braman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kanterman, Jason Scott, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kantrowitz, Goldhamer & Graifman, P.C. -NY, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-61 of 132

Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer, LLP-CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kaplan Kilsheimer & Fox, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kaplan, Robert N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kartchner, Sr., Milo Gene, Plaintiff

Kartchner, Tamara Ann, Plaintiff, Plaintiff

Katona, Shanti Mulpuru, counsel for Defendant(s)

Katz, Benjamin, Plaintiff

Katz, Josef, Plaintiff

Katz, Leslie, Plaintiff

Katz, Marisa C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kauffman, Carol L., Plaintiff

Kauffman, Paul R., Plaintiff

Kaufman, Avi Robert, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kaufman, Simon, Plaintiff

Kealy, Victoria, Plaintiff

Keenan, Michael S., Plaintiff

Keller Rohrback, L.L.P, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Keller, Amy E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kelley Uustal, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kelly, Joseph Creed, Plaintiff



C-62 of 132

Kelston, Henry, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kemp, Greta L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kemp, Michael, Defendant

Kendall, Christopher John, Plaintiff

Kendrick, III, Hezzie, Plaintiff

Kenneth Metzger, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kenney, Joseph B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kent & Risley, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kent, Daniel Arthur, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kerkman Wagner & Dunn, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kert, David Earl, Plaintiff

Kesden, Gregory, Plaintiff

Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP -CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP-PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP-PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kessler, Adriane, Plaintiff

Kevin T. Moore, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Khaddar, Kamel., Plaintiff

Khalaf, Richard, Plaintiff

Khalil, Chantal, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-63 of 132

Khamvongsa, Khampha, Plaintiff

Kier, Aloha, former Plaintiff

Kier, Jackie L., former Plaintiff

Kilgore, Shelbi, Plaintiff

Killings, Carolyn, Plaintiff

Killorin, Robert W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

King & Spalding, counsel for Defendant(s)

King, Bradley K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

King, Brenda, Plaintiff

King, Justin, Plaintiff

King, Justin, Plaintiff

King, Laurence D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kingsland, Scott, Plaintiff

Kinsman, Robert, Plaintiff

Kiramijyan, Armen, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kishel, Timothy S., Plaintiff

Kisloff, I, Michelle Anne, counsel for Defendant(s)

Kitrick, Lewis & Harris Co. LPA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kittredge, William, Plaintiff

Kittrell, Daniel, Plaintiff



C-64 of 132

Kittrell, William Bradford, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kittrell, William Bradford, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kivlan, Walter, Plaintiff

Klavans, Jerry, Plaintiff

Klein, Michael J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Klein, Pamela, Plaintiff

Klein, Steve, Plaintiff

Klopfenstein, Brandon J, Plaintiff.

Kloss, Michael P., Plaintiff

Knebel, Lara, Plaintiff

Knepper & Clark LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Knepper & Clark, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Knepper & Clark, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Knepper, Matthew I., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Knepper, Matthew I., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Knepper, Terrance, Plaintiff

Knowles, Emily, Plaintiff

Knudsen, William, Plaintiff

Knudson, Amanda, Plaintiff

Kochanowski, Andrew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-65 of 132

Kocher, Charles, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kodroff, Jeffrey L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Koehler, Matthew, Plaintiff

Kohn Swift & Graf, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kohn Swift & Graf, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kohn, Joseph C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kohn, Robert, Plaintiff

Kohn, Robert, Plaintiff

Kohn, Susan, Plaintiff

Kohn, Susan, Plaintiff

Koller, A. Laurie, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Koller, Patricia A., Plaintiff

Koluncich, Nicholas, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Komperda, James, Plaintiff

Kopelowitz Ostrow Ferguson Weiselberg Gilbert, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kopelowitz Ostrow, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Koretsky, Crystal, Plaintiff

Koretsky, James, Plaintiff

Korsinsky, Eduard, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kosack, Karla, Plaintiff



C-66 of 132

Koskoff Koskoff Bieder, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Krachanus, Eric, Plaintiff

Kranstuber, Scott, Plaintiff

Kravec, Jr., Joseph N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Krawcyk, Jessica, Plaintiff

Krieger, David H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Krieger, David H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Krotine, Daniel John, Plaintiff

Krout, Angela M., Plaintiff

Kucerak, Olga, Plaintiff

Kuhns, Hampden, Plaintiff

Kula, Kenneth Paul, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kurtz, Orin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Kuss, Joseph M., former Plaintiff

Kutz, Christina, Plaintiff

Kutz, Kyle, Plaintiff

LaBreck, Peter J, Pro Se, Movant

LaBreck, Peter J., Movant

LaCien, Brian, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lacy Price & Wagner, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-67 of 132

Laforest, Sheneda, Plaintiff

LaGasse, Marc, Plaintiff

Laguardia Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

LaGuardia, Eric A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lajoie, Benjamin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lakeshore Law Center, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Laktonen, Douglas, Plaintiff

Lamb, Ellen, Plaintiff

Lamb, Owen, Plaintiff

Lambert, Meredith L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lambiras, Jon, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

LaMontagne, Michelle Marie, Plaintiff

Lampros, Peter Andrew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lang, Dan, former Plaintiff

Langley, Katherine, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Langston & Langston, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Langston, Rebecca McRae, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Langston, Shane Fredrick, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-68 of 132

Lanham, Michelle Elizabeth, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lanier, W. Mark, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lanigan, Michael R., Plaintiff

Lapter, Alain, Plaintiff

Lapter, Ana, Plaintiff

Larkin, Jr, Robert W., Plaintiff

Larkins, Debbie, Plaintiff

Larocchia, Lucia, Plaintiff

Larson, Dianna, Plaintiff

Laufenberg, Cari C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of A. Joseph Coomes, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Alex Arreaza, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Brian M. Garvine, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Gregory Joseph Allen, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Jamie P. Clouser, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of John Davis, counsel for Objector

Law Office of Nicholas F. Ortiz, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Rhine Law Firm, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Rick Morin, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Steven C. Holzman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-69 of 132

Law Office of Steven F. Samilow, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Office of Timothy Hoerman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Alexander M. Schack, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Charles James, II, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of David A. Bain, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Gary Green, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Geoffrey R. Romero, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Gerald S. Ohn APC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Gus Michael Farinella, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Gus Michael Farinella, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Kevin Rogers, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Maloney & Campolo, L.L.P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Maloney & Campolo, L.L.P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Maloney & Campolo, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Marc H. Richman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Murphy & Associates PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Nicholas Koluncich LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Paul C. Whalen, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Law Offices of Richard R. Rosenthal, PC

Law Offices of Timothy P. Rumberger, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-70 of 132

Law Offices of Todd M. Friedman, P.C , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lawless, Jr, John R., counsel for Defendant(s)

Lawson, Cheryl, Plaintiff

Lawver, Joseph W., counsel for Defendant(s)

Lawyer, Joan, Plaintiff

Lax Vaughn Fortson Rowe Threet P.A , counsel for Defendant(s)

Lax Vaughn Fortson Rowe Threet P.A., counsel for Defendant(s)



Le, David, Plaintiff

LeBow, James B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lechner, Jay P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lee Holen Law Office, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lee, Annie, Plaintiff

Lee, Ariel, Plaintiff

Lee, Debra, Plaintiff

Lee, Debra, Plaintiff

Leigh, Ralph, Plaintiff

Lemond, Jr., G. Franklin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lemond, Jr., G. Franklin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-71 of 132

Lenczewski, Daniel, Plaintiff

Lenczewski, Nancy G. , Plaintiff

Leon Storie, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Leoni, Robert Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lesowitz, Scott, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lester, Clarence, Plaintiff

Lester, JR., Charles T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lester, Karen, Plaintiff

Levi and Korsinsky, LLP- CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Levin Sedran & Berman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Levin, Arnold, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Levin, Daniel C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Levin, Irwin B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Levin, Jr., Edward, Plaintiff

Levine, Stephen M., Plaintiff

Levitt, Adam J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Levy, David, Plaintiff

Lewis, John, Plaintiff

Lewis, Jon M., former Plaintiff

Lewis, Jordan M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-72 of 132

Lewis, Mark D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lewis, Richard, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Leyrer, Jennifer Louise, Plaintiff

Libasci, Barron A., Plaintiff

Lieberman, Jeremy A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein-CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Liftik, Michael E., counsel for Defendant(s)

Lightfoot Franklin & White, LLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Lightfoot Franklin & White, LLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Lindsay, Julia, Plaintiff

Linich, Margret, Plaintiff

Linker, David, Plaintiff

Lipchitz, Bryan, Plaintiff

Locks Law Firm, LLC - NJ, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Locks Law Firm, LLC - NJ, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Loeffel, Jay, Plaintiff

Loeser, Derek W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Loeser, Thomas E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Longman, Howard Theodore, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Longrich, Mark J. , Plaintiff



C-73 of 132

Lopez, Robert F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lots, Amanda, Plaintiff

Lowe, Yorkman., former Plaintiff

Lowry, Stephen G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lowry, Stephen G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lucero, Manuel, Plaintiff

Luckett Tyner Law Firm, P.A., counsel for Defendant(s)

Luckett, Jr., William O., counsel for Defendant(s)

Luftman & Heck and Associates, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lugrin, IV, George H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lumb, Kenneth Thomas, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lunkvitz, Terry, Plaintiff

Lynch, Alexandra Elizabeth, Plaintiff

Lynch, Alicia, Plaintiff

Lynch, Reagan, Plaintiff

Lynch, Travis Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lyons Law Firm, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lyons, Jr., Thomas J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Lyons, Kathleen, Plaintiff

Lyons, Thomas J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-74 of 132

Maar, Carl, Plaintiff

Macedonia, Jane Guzi, Plaintiff

MacInnis, John, Plaintiff

Mack, Tanya, Plaintiff

Mack, Timothy, former Plaintiff

Mackey, Belinda, Plaintiff

Mackleer, Jack, Plaintiff

MacPherson, Jennifer L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Maddox, Hargett & Caruso, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Maddox, Mark E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Madison, Steven G., counsel for Defendant(s)

Madsen, Ivy, Plaintiff

Madsen, Mike, Plaintiff

Maggiacomo, Patricia, Plaintiff

Magnanini, Robert A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mah, Rosanne L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Maher, David J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Maholm, Timothy, Plaintiff

Mahutga, Matthew Case, Plaintiff

Maizitis, Peter, Plaintiff



C-75 of 132

Mallahan, Kristopher A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mallh, Victor., Plaintiff

Malmstrom, Carl V., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Malone, Donald D. , Plaintiff

Malone, Keeya S. , Plaintiff

Malone, Thomas, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Maloney, Debra, Plaintiff

Maloney, Tim, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Maloney, Timothy F. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Malvasi, Peter, Plaintiff

Manaher, Alison, Plaintiff

Manco, Justin Edison, Plaintiff

Mann, Daniel J., Plaintiff

Manning, April, Plaintiff

Manning, Danielle Leigh, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Manning, Franklin, Plaintiff

Manning, Samiya, Plaintiff

Manopla, Abraham, Plaintiff

Manopla, Evelyn, Plaintiff

Manopla, Fortuna, Plaintiff



C-76 of 132

Manopla, Lilian, Plaintiff

Manton, Jed Davis, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Marchese, Joseph I., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Marchiando, Craig C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Marchiando, Craig C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Marcussen, Carin L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mardock, April, Plaintiff

Maredia, Imtiaz, Plaintiff

Maredia, Mumtaz, Plaintiff

Mares, Gary, Plaintiff

Marino, Lou, Plaintiff

Marion, Darin, Plaintiff

Markowitz, Stacy, former Plaintiff

Marrs, Paul, Plaintiff

Marrs, Tammy, Plaintiff

Marshall, Edward Alexander, counsel for Defendant(s)

Martell, Christina, Plaintiff

Martin White, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Martin, Daniel, Plaintiff

Martin, Drew, Plaintiff



C-77 of 132

Martin, James, Plaintiff

Martin, Jr., William Marvin, Plaintiff

Martin, Sean J., Plaintiff

Martin, Teresa Sue, Plaintiff

Martinez, Anna, Plaintiff

Martinez, Gary, former Plaintiff

Martinez, Jacqueline, former Plaintiff

Martinho, Carlos, Plaintiff

Mashburn, Dori M., former Plaintiff

Mason, Gary Edward, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mastando & Artrip, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mastando, Dennis A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mathews, D. Todd, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mattock, Bruce, former Plaintiff

Mattock, Bruce, Plaintiff

Matusko, Joanne E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mauldin, Susan, Defendant

Maxwell, Craig, Plaintiff

Maxwell, Stephen C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Maya, Theodore Walter, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-78 of 132

Mayerson & Hartheimer, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mayerson, Sandra E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mayweather, Paula, Plaintiff

Mcardle, Alyssa, Plaintiff

McBride, Blake, Plaintiff

McCable, Margaret, Plaintiff

McCaffrey, Meghan A., counsel for Defendant(s)

McCall, Richard, Plaintiff

McCalla, Alexander, Plaintiff

McCann, Antonietta, former Plaintiff

McCartney, Raymond, Plaintiff

McClung, Morgan, Plaintiff

McClure, Kyle, Plaintiff

McCune, Wright, Arevalo, LLP -PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McDonald, Wallace A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McDonough, III, James F. counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McDowell Hetherington, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McDowell, Andrew, Plaintiff

McEntyre, Zachary Andrew, counsel for Defendant(s)

McGonnigal, James, Plaintiff



C-79 of 132

McGowan Hood Felder & Johnson - Mt. SC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McGowan Hood Felder & Johnson - Mt. SC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McGrath, V. Brandon, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McGregor, Kristi Stahnke, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McGuire, Daniel D., counsel for Defendant(s)

McHenry, William Thomas, Plaintiff

McHill, Mary, Plaintiff

McKany, Steven M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McKenna Long & Aldridge, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McKenney & Froelich, counsel for Objector

McKinney, Maggie, Plaintiff

McKnight, H. Vincent, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McMullan, Jr., David Malcolm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McNabb Bragorgos & Burgess, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McNamara, Douglas J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McNamara, Douglas J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McNeeley, Madeline Elizabeth, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McNeeley, Madeline Elizabeth, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McNulty, Shannon, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

McNulty, Shannon, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-80 of 132

McShan, Edward Dean, former Plaintiff

McShan, II, Edward Dean, former Plaintiff

Meachum, Jennifer A., Plaintiff

Mead, Terry, Plaintiff

Meade, Suzanne, Plaintiff

Meadows, Christopher G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mee Mee Hoge & Epperson PLLP, counsel for Defendant(s)

Mee Mee Hoge & Epperson PLLP, counsel for Defendant(s)

Meiselas, Benjamin Jared, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Melegari, Lisa, Plaintiff

Melrath, Jason, Plaintiff

Melton, Jason M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Melzer, Andrew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mendoza, Julia, Plaintiff

Mendoza, Nicci, Plaintiff

Mendoza, Zandra, Plaintiff

Menzer, Allan, Plaintiff

Merino, Brooke, Plaintiff

Merino, Javier Luis, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mertlich, Jennifer, Plaintiff



C-81 of 132

Messer, David Mark, counsel for Defendant(s)

Messer, Jr., Clifton Ralph, Plaintiff

Messerli & Kramer, P.A., counsel for Defendant(s)

Messerli & Kramer, P.A., counsel for Defendant(s)

Metzgar, Geogory Michael, Plaintiff

Metzgar, Kimberly Joy C., Plaintiff

Metzger, Kenneth Albert, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Meyer & Nunez, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Meyers, Jody, Plaintiff

Meyers, Scott, Plaintiff

MHC Law, LLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Miceli, David F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Michaeli, Daniel, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Michel, Thristian, Plaintiff

Michelle E. Lanham Attorney at Law, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mickelsen Dalton LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mickelsen, Brian Christian, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Milberg Phillips Grossman LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Miles, III, W. Daniel, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Miles, Matthew, Plaintiff



C-82 of 132

Miles, Seth, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mille, Wakeelah, Plaintiff

Miller, Angela Lynn, Plaintiff

Miller, Bradley, Plaintiff

Miller, Cade, Plaintiff

Miller, Dale, former Plaintiff

Miller, David Waterstram, Plaintiff

Miller, E. Powell, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Miller, Jason Wallace, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Miller, Michael, Plaintiff

Miller, Mike, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Miller, Todd Michael, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Miller, Vess Allen, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Miner, Curtis B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Minka, Bryan, Plaintiff

Minka, Jacqueline, Plaintiff

Minnilo & Jenkins Co., LPA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mirarchi, Anthony, Plaintiff

Mitchel, Ernesto, Plaintiff

Mobbs, Robert, Plaintiff



C-83 of 132

Moellmer, Alison, Plaintiff

Mogelberg, Chris, Plaintiff

Mohamadi, Ashkahn, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mohamedali, Sakina, Plaintiff

Mollaie, Mahri, Plaintiff

Molo Lamken, LLP -DC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Molo Lamken, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Molo, Steven F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Molumphy, Mark Cotton, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Monday, Antonio Barsonda, Plaintiff

Moneypenny, Mary Hexter, Plaintiff

Moore, Brad J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Moore, Diane S. , Plaintiff

Moore, Hollie, former Plaintiff

Moore, Jimmie, Plaintiff

Moore, John Austin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Moore, Kevin Trent, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Moore, Michael, Plaintiff

Moore, Patrick B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Moore, Steven J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-84 of 132

Morgan & Morgan, P.A -T.FL CFP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morgan & Morgan, P.A. -T.FL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morgan & Morgan, P.A. -T.FL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morgan, Bridget Gallagher, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morgan, John, Plaintiff

Morgan, Julie, Plaintiff

Morgan, Sharon, Plaintiff

Moriarty, William, Plaintiff

Morin, Charles, Plaintiff

Morin, Richard John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morin, Susan, Plaintiff

Morris, Daniel Ellis, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morris, Grant E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morris, Jason, Plaintiff

Morrison, Sherwood, Wilson & Deola, PLLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Morvin, Bonnie, Plaintiff

Moscato, Beth, Pro Se, Movant

Mosley, Donna, Plaintiff

Motley Rice, LLC-SC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)




C-85 of 132



Muhammad, Gerald, Plaintiff

Mullen P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mullen, Wesley Martin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Mulligan, Daniel J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Murdock, Rochelle, Plaintiff

Murdock, Shawn, Plaintiff

Murphy & Associates PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Murphy & Falcon, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Murphy Falcon & Murphy, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Murphy, David M, counsel for Plaintiff(s).

Murphy, III, William H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Murphy, Jr., William Hughes, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Murphy, Kerri, Plaintiff

Murphy, Kerri, Plaintiff

Murphy, Leslie C., Plaintiff

Murray Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Myers, Sr., Terry, Plaintiff

Nabors, Jason L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-86 of 132

Nabors, Jason L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Naddeo, James A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nannis, Veronica Byam, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Napier, Barry, Plaintiff

Nast, Dianne M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nastlaw, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nastlaw, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nathan, II, Edward, Plaintiff

Nazario, Christina J. , Plaintiff

Nazrio, Mark A. , Plaintiff

Nealon, James E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Needleman, Joann, counsel for Defendant(s)

Nehring, Michael, Plaintiff

Neilan, Sean, Plaintiff

Neilan, Sean, Plaintiff

Nelson, Korey A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nelson, Pete, Plaintiff

Newcomer, Larry, former Plaintiff

Newkirk, Jeff, Plaintiff

Newsome, Linda, Plaintiff



C-87 of 132

Nguyen, Tien Phi, Plaintiff

Nielson, Jerry, Plaintiff

Nielson, Michelle, Plaintiff

Nixon Vogelman Barry Slawsky & Simoneau PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nixon, Leslie C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Noa, Guy Kamealoha, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Noblin, James Robert, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nocon, Shannon F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nolan, Glenntavius, Plaintiff

Normoyle, Dana James, Plaintiff

Normoyle, Sharon, Plaintiff

Norris, Destinni, Plaintiff

Norris, Michael, Plaintiff

Norris, Wayne, Plaintiff

Noster, Gloria, Plaintiff

Noster, Russell A., Plaintiff

Nowinsky, Craig, Plaintiff

Nunez, David Anthony, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Nuosci, Paul, Plaintiff

Nutt, Jerry, Plaintiff



C-88 of 132

Oberle, Bryan C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Oberst, Daniel E., Plaintiff

Obradovich, Hannah, Plaintiff

O'Brien Law Firm, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

O'Brien, Edward K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

O'Brien, Regional Manager Kevin, former Plaintiff

O'Brien, Sarah, former Plaintiff

O'Dell & O'Neal, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

O'Dell Properties, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

O'Dell, Justin, Plaintiff

Office of George E. Butler, II, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Office of Grant E. Morris, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ogburn, John, Plaintiff

Ogden, Pamela Sue, Plaintiff

Ohn, Gerald S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ojeda, Steve, Plaintiff

Oldja, Andrea, Plaintiff

Oldja, Paul, Plaintiff

Oleson, Dana, Plaintiff

Olin, Michael S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-89 of 132

Olivo, Lisa, Plaintiff

Olsen Daines PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Olsen, Aaron M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Olson, Dana, Plaintiff

Olson, Kyle, Plaintiff

One Cent Lane, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

O'Neal, Charles, Plaintiff

O'Neill, Kevin, former Plaintiff

O'Neill, Michelle, Plaintiff

Oppenheimer, Brett H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Orchard, III, Mel, Plaintiff

O'Reardon, Thomas J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Orloff, Michael Steven, Plaintiff

Ortiz, Nicholas F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Osborne, Edward, Plaintiff

Oselin, Sharon Suzanne, Plaintiff

Ostoya, Paul, Plaintiff

Ostrow, Jeffrey Miles, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Otsuka, Gregory S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Owens, Brian M., Plaintiff



C-90 of 132

Ozzello Practice PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ozzello, Mark A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pacelli, Robert, Plaintiff

Pacheco, Anna, Plaintiff

Pacheco, Juan, Plaintiff

Pagliarulo, John J., Plaintiff

Paik, Deanna, Plaintiff

Palmer, Tanya, Plaintiff

Paltzik, Edward Andrew, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Palumbo, Frank, Plaintiff

Palumbo, Jeanne, Plaintiff

Pang, Natalie S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pantaze, Nikolaos C, Plaintiff

Pantek, Russell, former Plaintiff

Parish Guy Castillo, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Parish, William H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Parker, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Parker, Ronald, Plaintiff

Parkhill, Anthony Lee, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Parkhill, Hayden D., Plaintiff



C-91 of 132

Parrott, Sean, Plaintiff

Parson, Dale, Plaintiff

Partin, Ranse M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Partridge, Barron, Plaintiff

Partridge, Tom, Plaintiff

Pascal, Bruce, Plaintiff

Pascucci, Michael James, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pate, Johnson & Church, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pate, Johnson & Church, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pate, Page Anthony, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Patrick, Stephanie, former Plaintiff

Patten, Jr., Marvin Allen, Plaintiff

Patterson Law Firm, LLP - IA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Patterson, Annabelle Lee, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Patterson, Annabelle Lee, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Patton, Bridget J. , Plaintiff

Paul W. Bishop, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Paul, Richard, Plaintiff

Pavesi, Jr., Charles, Plaintiff

Pavitt, Jodie, Plaintiff



C-92 of 132

Payne Law Firm, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Payne Law Firm, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Payne, Graeme, Defendant

Payne, Sean N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Payne, Sean N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Payne, William T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Payton, Rusty, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

PaytonDann, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Peacock, James, Plaintiff

Pearson Simon & Warshaw, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pearson Simon & Warshaw, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pearson, Lara, Defendant

Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Peay, Stewart O., counsel for Defendant(s)

Peck, David Hill, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pedroza, Richard, Plaintiff

Pellitteri, Carmen, Plaintiff

Peltier, Justin, Plaintiff

Penney, Brant D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pepper Hamilton-DC, counsel for Defendant(s)



C-93 of 132

Perez, Jose, Plaintiff

Perez, Oshik, Plaintiff

Perkin & Faria, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Perkin, John F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Perkins Thompson, PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Perkins, Dallas, Plaintiff

Perkins, Monica Rae, Plaintiff

Persinger, Melanie Rae, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Persinger, Melanie Rae, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Person, Deborah, Plaintiff

Person, Donald, Plaintiff

Pescia, Leslie L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pesek, Greg, Plaintiff

Peters, Christopher, Plaintiff

Peterson, Kenneth, Plaintiff

Petroplus, Parry, Plaintiff

Petrungaro, Andrea E., Plaintiff

Pettery, Melinda, Plaintiff



C-94 of 132

Pfaff, James A. , Plaintiff

Phalen, Ralph K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Phillips, Erlewine, Given & Carlin LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Phillips, Michelle, Plaintiff

Pierre, Alvin, Plaintiff

Pillette, Mercedes, Plaintiff

Pino, Krista, Plaintiff

Pippin, Jason, Plaintiff

Pitarra, Anthony Sabastian, former Plaintiff

Pitarra, Rita Joyce, former Plaintiff

Pittman, Dutton, Kirby & Hellums, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pivotal Law Group, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pizzirusso, James J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Placencia, III, Leo, Plaintiff

Plant, Adam P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Plante, Lorraine, former Plaintiff

Plante, Stephen, former Plaintiff

Platt, Christina, Plaintiff



C-95 of 132

Platts, Diane, Plaintiff

Pleasant, Thomas W., Plaintiff

Poarch, Justin, Plaintiff

Pobiner, Lori, Plaintiff

Podalsky, Gregg, Plaintiff

Podolny, James Henry, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Poligan, Richard, Plaintiff

Polischuk, Wesley K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Polk, Adam E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pollack, David, Plaintiff

Pollack, Janine L , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Polsinelli PC - DE, counsel for Defendant(s)

Polsinelli PC- DC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Polsinelli PC- MO, counsel for Defendant(s)

Polsinelli PC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Polsinelli PC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Pomerantz Haudek Block Grossman & Gross, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pomerantz, LLP -NY, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pomerantz, LLP -NY, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pontrelli, Paul Jay, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-96 of 132

Poole, Brandy, Plaintiff

Porter, Charles Millard, Plaintiff

Porter, Robin D., Plaintiff

Porter, William R, Plaintiff

Powell, Daniel, Plaintiff

Powers, Cassandra, Plaintiff

Powers, Douglas Ivan, Plaintiff

Powers, Gloria Jean, Plaintiff

Powers, Rogers & Smith, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Poynter, Scott E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Prater, IV, Harlan Irby, counsel for Defendant(s)

Pratt Clay, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pratt, Bradley W. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Prejean, Brett N.J., Plaintiff

Prescott, Steven Robert, Plaintiff

Preusch, Matthew J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Pryor, Jeffrey, Plaintiff

Pryor, Jr., Anthony E. , Plaintiff

Pugh, Michael, Plaintiff

Pugliese, Joseph, Plaintiff



C-97 of 132

Purnell-Reid, Chiaquitta, Plaintiff

Putegnat, Kevin, Plaintiff

Putegnat, Nydia, Plaintiff

Quagliani, Natalie, Plaintiff

Queenen, Barbara, Plaintiff

Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP-DC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Quinn, Connor, Weaver, Davies & Rouco LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Quinn, Connor, Weaver, Davies & Rouco, LLP - AL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Quirk, Michael J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Quirk, Michael J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ra, Laura, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rado, Andrei V., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rafco, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Raffin, Sheena, Plaintiff

Rainbolt, Kevin W. , Plaintiff

Raines Feldman, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rajkovich, Williams, Kilpatrick & True, PLLC, counsel for Defendant(s)

Rajput, Sanjay Kumar, Plaintiff

Ralph K. Phalen, Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ramey, Horace C., Plaintiff



C-98 of 132

Ramirez, Edith, counsel for Defendant(s)

Ramirez, Jonathan, Plaintiff

Ramsay, Mark, Plaintiff

Randall, Garry, Plaintiff

Rankin, Alexandria Patel, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Raynor, Joseph, Plaintiff

Reams Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Reams, Charles Austin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Reed, Claiborne, Plaintiff

Reid Collins & Tsai, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Reid, Kirkland E., counsel for Defendant(s)

Reid, Kirkland E., counsel for Defendant(s)

Reinert, Debbie, Plaintiff

Reinert, Randy, Plaintiff

Reinhard, Brook, Plaintiff

Reinhardt & Anderson, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Reinhardt, Mark, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Reinhardt, Wendorf & Blanchfield, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Reisman, Keith, Plaintiff

Ressetar, Nicholas, Plaintiff



C-99 of 132

Reyes, Alberto, Plaintiff

Reyes, Maribel X., Plaintiff

Reyes, Ruth, Plaintiff

Rhine, Joel R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rhodes, Rebekah, Plaintiff

Ribons, Michael, former Plaintiff

Rice, Cynthia, Plaintiff

Rice, Joseph F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rice-Wright, Anna, former Plaintiff

Rich, Ashley R., Plaintiff

Richardson, Julie, Plaintiff

Richman, Marc H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Richmond, Dan, Plaintiff

Richmond, Kimberly, Plaintiff

Rickard, Sarah L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rifkin, Ashley R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ritterbeck, Adam, Plaintiff

Rivas, Deborah, former Plaintiff

Rivas, Rosemary M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Robbins Arroyo, LLP-CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-100 of 132

Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd, LLP -FL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Robbins Ross Alloy Belinfante Littlefield, LLC -Atl, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Robbins, Brian J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Robbins, Cynthia, Plaintiff

Robello, Ronann Marie, Plaintiff

Robert J. Wagoner Co., L.L.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Roberts, Georgeanne, Plaintiff

Roberts, Mollie Marcia, Plaintiff

Roberts, Quentin A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Robin Frazer Clark, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Robinson & Cole, counsel for Defendant(s)

Robinson Calcagnie, Inc. -CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Robinson Calcagnie, Inc. -CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Robinson, Daniel S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Roda, Joseph N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Roda, Joseph N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Roddy, John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Roddy, Kevin Peter, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-101 of 132

Rodriguez, Nick, Plaintiff

Roehl, Robert, Plaintiff

Roehl, Robert, Plaintiff

Rogers, Kevin B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rogers, L. Kristine, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Romero, Ashley Marie, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Romero, Geoffrey R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Roofener, Chad, Plaintiff

Roofener, Corree, Plaintiff

Rosemore, Evan T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rosenthal, James B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rosenthal, Richard R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Roshto, Randall K., former Plaintiff

Roskovensky, Vincent M. , counsel for Defendant(s)

Roskovensky, Vincent M., counsel for Defendant(s)

Rothman, Justin, Plaintiff

Rothman, Michael, Plaintiff

Rotkis, Susan Mary, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rouco, Richard P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rowe, Roger D., counsel for Defendant(s)



C-102 of 132

Rowe, Roger D., counsel for Defendant(s)

Roxanne Conlin & Associates, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rozenzweig, Allan, Plaintiff

Rubio, Tanya Michelle, Plaintiff

Rudman, Samuel H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ruf, Kevin F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ruff, Tenku, Plaintiff

Ruiz, Aleida, Plaintiff

Rumberger, Timothy Paul, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rupnow, Josh, Plaintiff

Ruscitto, Albert, Plaintiff

Rusing Lopez & Lizardi PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rusing, Michael John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Russomanno & Borrello PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Russomanno, Herman Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rutherford, Morgan, Plaintiff

Ryan Bailey on behalf Frazier, Tawanda, Plaintiff

Ryan, Elizabeth A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Rybak, Matthew, Plaintiff

Saavedra, Jennifer, former Plaintiff



C-103 of 132

Saavedra, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Sacks Weston Diamond LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)




Sacks, Andrew B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sacks, Andrew B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Safford, II, Melvin, Plaintiff

Salinas, Alejandro, Plaintiff

Saltz, Mongeluzzi, Barrett & Bendesky, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Samilow, Steven Frederick, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Samini Scheinberg PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Samini, Bobby, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Samson, Nida, Plaintiff

Samuelson, Patricia, former Plaintiff

Sanchez, Gustavo Carlo, Plaintiff

Sander, Laura, Plaintiff

Sanders, Joe, Defendant

Sanford Heisler Kimpel LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sanford Heisler Sharp, LLP -CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-104 of 132

Sanford Heisler Sharp, LLP -DC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sanford Heisler Sharp, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)




Sanford Heisler Sharp, LLP-NY, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Santana, Alexandra, Plaintiff

Santello, Lea, Plaintiff

Santoli, Joseph R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Santomauro, Rodd, Plaintiff

Santomauro, Rodd, Plaintiff

Santos, Erik Dos, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sarko, Lynn Lincoln, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sarnelli, Jennifer, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sarraf Gentile LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sarraf Gentile LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sarraf, Ronen, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Saucier, Michael, Plaintiff

Sauder, Joseph G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Savell & Williams, counsel for Defendant(s)



C-105 of 132

Saveri & Saveri, Inc. - SF CA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Saveri, Richard Alexander, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Savett, Sherrie R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sawaya, Rose, McClure & Wilhite, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Schaber, Michael, Plaintiff

Schaffer, Charles E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Schelkopf, Matthew D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Scherer, Edward L., Plaintiff

Schifano, Maria, Plaintiff

Schneider, Tyler J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Schork, Erich Paul, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Schubert Jonckheer Kolbe & Kralowec LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Schubert, Noah M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Schubert, Robert C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Schumitsh, Jennifer C. , Plaintiff

Schur, Hong, Plaintiff

Schur, W. Craig, Plaintiff

Schwartz, Steven A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Scott Cole & Associates, APC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Scott Cole & Associates, APC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-106 of 132

Scott, Anthony, Plaintiff

Scott, III, Ralph Downing, counsel for Defendant(s)

Scott, III, Ralph Downing, counsel for Defendant(s)

Scullion, Jennifer R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Seeger Weiss, LLP - NJ, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Seeger, Christopher A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Seely, Kevin A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Segal, Scott S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Seiter, Jeff, Plaintiff

Sekiya, Julianne, Plaintiff

Selders, Derek, Plaintiff

Semnar & Hartman, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Semnar, Babak, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Serafine, Roberta, Plaintiff

Serino, Natasha N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Seror, Shimon, Plaintiff

Seymore, Angela, Plaintiff

Seymore, Omar, Plaintiff

Shafran, Andrea, former Plaintiff

Shafran, Barbara A., former Plaintiff



C-107 of 132

Shafran, Jr., Stephen M., former Plaintiff

Shanken, Richard, Plaintiff

Shanken, Tonya, Plaintiff

Shapiro, Terry, Plaintiff

Sharp, Kevin Hunter, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Sharpe, Miche', Plaintiff

Sharpe, Shayna, Plaintiff

Shaw, Amber Griffin, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Shearer, Donald K., Plaintiff

Sheena, Danny M. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Shell, Dori, Plaintiff

Shelsby & Leoni, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Shelsby, Gilbert F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Shepard, Sharon, Plaintiff

Shepard, Steven M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sheppe, Andrew, Plaintiff

Sherriff, Valerie Elizabeth, Plaintiff

Shevitz, Richard E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-108 of 132

Shub, Jonathan, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Shulman Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Shulman, Harry, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Shultz, Wesley, Plaintiff

Sidney, Ametrius V. , Plaintiff

Siegel, Norman E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Siegel, Norman E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sievers, Dustin, Plaintiff

Sigall, Herschel, Plaintiff

Sikes, Steven B., Plaintiff

Silverman, Jesse N., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Silvestre, Luisa, Plaintiff

Simmons Hanly Conroy LLC -NY, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Simmons Hanly Conroy, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Simmons, II, John W., Plaintiff

Simmons, Meghan, Plaintiff

Simons, Elizabeth M, Pro Se, Movant

Simons, Gregory A., Pro Se, Movant

Simons, Joshua D., Pro Se, Movant

Simpson, Amanda, Plaintiff



C-109 of 132

Sirolly, Benjamin T., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sisk, Trina Marie, Plaintiff

Sistek, Jeanne L. , Plaintiff

Skye, Kaethe, Plaintiff

Slade, Roger, Plaintiff

Slyne, Michael, Plaintiff

Slyne, Patrick, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Smart, Valorie Anne, Plaintiff

Smith Gildea and Schmidt LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Smith, Amie, Plaintiff

Smith, Courtney D., Plaintiff

Smith, Diana K., Plaintiff

Smith, J. Craig, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Smith, Jeremiah, Plaintiff

Smith, Jimmy, Plaintiff

Smith, Joshua, Plaintiff

Smith, Josie Lou, Plaintiff

Smith, LA' Sohn, Plaintiff

Smith, Michael Paul, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Smith, Phillips, Mitchell & Scott, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-110 of 132

Smith, Richard F., Defendant

Smith, Robin, Plaintiff

Smith, Samuel, Plaintiff

Smith, Seth Edward, Plaintiff

Smith, Todd A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Smith, Travis Quintin, Plaintiff

Smith. Phillips, Mitchell & Scott, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Smith-Norwood, Porsha, Plaintiff

Snell & Wilmer LLP, counsel for Defendant(s)

Snell & Wilmer, LLP, counsel for Defendant(s)

Snell, Matthew, Plaintiff

Sobol, Michael W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sogomonyan, Akop, Plaintiff

Solberg Stewart Miller & Johnson

Solberg Stewart Miller, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Solin, Lauren, Plaintiff

Solomon, Glenn Allen, Plaintiff

Solorio, Anna, Plaintiff

Sommers Schwartz, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Soumilas, John, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-111 of 132

Southern Institute for Medical & Legal Affairs, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Souza, Sharon, Plaintiff

Spahn, Brian C., counsel for Defendant(s)

Spanos, Theodore G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Spector Roseman & Kodroff, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Spector, Brian F., Plaintiff

Spellman, Joe, Plaintiff

Spencer, Andre, Plaintiff

Spicer, Mike, Plaintiff

Spicer, Richard, Plaintiff

Spicer, Richard, Plaintiff

Spiking, Ryan, Plaintiff

Spivak, Shayna, Plaintiff

Spositi, Melissa, Plaintiff

Spositi, Michael, Plaintiff

Sprecher, Taylor, Plaintiff

Squitieri & Fearon, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Squitieri, Olimpio Lee, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sroka, Scott, Plaintiff

St. Clair, Kurtis, Plaintiff



C-112 of 132

St. Luc, Reevney, Plaintiff

Stabell, Nancy, Plaintiff

Stabenow, Justin, Plaintiff

Stack, Brian J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stack, Fernandez & Harris, PA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Staker, Megan, Plaintiff

Stalpes, Justin P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Standish, Vera, Plaintiff

Stanfield, Tyler, Plaintiff

Stanojevich, Nicolas Miguel, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Starbuck, Summer Nicole, Plaintiff

Staun, Mark R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Steckler Gresham Cochran, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Steckler, Bruce W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Steel, Wright, Gray & Hutchinson, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Steel, Wright, Gray & Hutchinson, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stein Mitchell Muse Cipollone & Beato LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stein Mitchell Muse Cipollone & Beato LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stein, Steven B., former Plaintiff

Steinmetz, Eric L, Plaintiff



C-113 of 132

Stephan, Howard, Plaintiff

Stephen C Maxwell PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stephenson, Samuel, Plaintiff

Sternemann, Brian, Plaintiff

Sternemann, Phyllis, Plaintiff

Steufen, David, Plaintiff

Stewart, Daphne, Plaintiff

Stewart, II, Dale F., Plaintiff

Stewart, Leanne S. , Plaintiff

Stewart, Michael G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stiles, Brijit, Plaintiff

Stimac, Jr., Charles, Defendant

Stone & Magnanini LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stone, Davod S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stone, Jarrett, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stone, Patton, Kierce & Freeman, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stonebraker, Steven, Plaintiff

Stonebraker, Theresa, Plaintiff

Storch, Jenny, Plaintiff

Storie, Leon R., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-114 of 132

Stough, Tracey, Plaintiff

Stranch, IV, James G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Strauchman, Luke, Plaintiff

Strauss, Joel B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Streett Law Firm, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Streett Law Firm, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Streett, Alex G., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Streett, James A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Streisfeld, Jonathan Marc, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stritmatter, Kessler, Whelan, Koehler, Moore and Kahler, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Strong, Rodney K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Strutz, Victoria Lynn, former Plaintiff

Studer, Ryan Patrick, Plaintiff

Stueve Siegel Hanson, LLP -MO, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Stull Stull & Brody, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Stull Stull & Brody, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sturing, Sara Joy, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sullenger, D. Wes, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-115 of 132

Sullivan, Daniel P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sullivan, Robert B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sullivan, Thomas, Plaintiff

Suminski, Richard A. , Plaintiff

Summer, Alexandra P., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sumner, Phyllis Buchen, counsel for Defendant(s)

Super, Marty, Plaintiff

Susman Godfrey, LLP-TX, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Susman Godfrey, LLP-TX, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Susman Godfrey-TX, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Susman, Stephen D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Sutkaytis, Cheryl, Plaintiff

Sutkaytis, Steven, Plaintiff

Sutton, Mildred, Plaintiff

Swick, Randall Adam, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Syrowski, Michael J. , Plaintiff

Syverson, Erik Swen, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Syverson, Lesowitz & Gebelin LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Szekely, Elisabeta, Plaintiff

Tabish, Gene, Plaintiff



C-116 of 132

Tabish, Jan, Plaintiff

Tada, Caralyn, Plaintiff

Tadler Law LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Tadler, Ariana J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Tadros, Isaac, Plaintiff

Taenzer, York, Plaintiff

Tafas, Cheryl, Plaintiff

Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP (Indianapolis), counsel for Defendant(s)

Tama, Adam P. , Plaintiff

Tamburello, Christopher, Plaintiff

Tanks, Christopher, Plaintiff

Tate, Jeannie L., Plaintiff

Tate, Jr., George W., Plaintiff

Taubel, Eric S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Taylor Martino & Hedge, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Taylor Martino Zarzaur, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Taylor Martino, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Taylor, AmySue, Plaintiff

Taylor, Lauren Hoffman, former Plaintiff

Taylor, Robin L., Plaintiff



C-117 of 132

Taylor, Zachary L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Tepfenhart, Jason, Plaintiff

Tepfenhart, Nicholas, Plaintiff

Teppler, Steven W., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Teske, Katz, Kitzer & Rochel, PLLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Teske, Vildan A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Thayer, Christopher L. counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Barnes Law Group, LLC CFP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Barnes Law Group, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



The Brualdi Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Chapel Law Group LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Coffman Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Cottle Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Dann Law Firm Co. LPA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Dann Law Firm Co. LPA, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Doss Firm, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Eggnatz Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Finley Firm, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-118 of 132

The Giatras Law Firm, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Hannon Law Firm, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Lanier Law Firm - TX, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Law Office of Jack Fitzgerald, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)




The Law Offices of Steven E. Armstrong, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Malone Firm, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

The Miller Law Firm, P.C.

The Segal Law Firm, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Thomas A. Zimmerman, Jr. Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Thomas A. Zimmerman, Jr. Attorney at Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Thomas, Andrew W. , Plaintiff

Thomas, Emily, Plaintiff

Thomas, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Thomas, Rosalee B.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Thompson, Brian, Plaintiff

Thompson, David H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Thompson, Dwight, Plaintiff



C-119 of 132

Thomson, Clint, Plaintiff

Thrash, Jr., Hon. Thomas W., U.S. District Court Judge for the Northern District of

Georgia

Timmons, Katherine, Plaintiff

Tinen, Chris, Plaintiff

Tirelli, Linda, Plaintiff

Tischler, Eric, Plaintiff

Toft, Kent, Plaintiff

Tomas, Patrick, Plaintiff

Tomlin, Marilyn, Plaintiff

Tomlin, Michael W., Plaintiff

Tomlinson, Cole T., Plaintiff

Toops, Lynn A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

TorHoerman Law LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Toro, John Christopher, counsel for Defendant(s)

Torrey, Barbara, Plaintiff

Tortoreti, Phillip A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Tosco, Chris, Plaintiff

Toth, Ashley S. , Plaintiff

Toth, Cody, Plaintiff



C-120 of 132

Toubman, Jay L. , Plaintiff

Tracey, David H., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Tracy, Alison Suzanne, Plaintiff

Tracy, Sharon, Plaintiff

Treat, Ryan, former Plaintiff

Trevino, Barbara, Plaintiff

Tribble, James Cameron CFP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Tribble, James Cameron, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Trief and Olk, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Trief, Ted, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Triola, Devenn, Plaintiff

Troutman Sanders, LLP-ATL, counsel for Defendant(s)

Trusted ID, Inc., Defendant

Tuck, Marlo, Plaintiff

Tucker, Regina, Plaintiff

Tuel, Patricia, Plaintiff

Tundidor, Bert, Plaintiff

Turner, Nathan, Plaintiff

Turner, Trevor, Plaintiff

Turok, Paul, Plaintiff



C-121 of 132

Tweeddale, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Twitchell, Elizabeth, former Plaintiff

Tyree, Lisa, Plaintiff

Ullman, Stacey J. P, Plaintiff

Unsdorfer, Gary, Plaintiff

Unsdorfer, Jane, Plaintiff

Vahle, Barrett J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Vahle, Barrett J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Vancs, Steven M. , Plaintiff

Vasiliadis, Tom, Plaintiff

Vassil Gibson, MaryBeth, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Velasquez, Nicolas, Plaintiff

Vera, Kara, Plaintiff

Verrill Dana, LLP – MA, counsel for Defendant(s)

Vice, Mario, Plaintiff

Vickery, Abraham, Plaintiff

Vickery, Erica, Plaintiff

Vidmar, Joann H. , Plaintiff

Vilberg, Kaia, Plaintiff

Villines, Meredith, Plaintiff



C-122 of 132

Vita, Nancy M., Plaintiff

Vivanz, Michelle A., Plaintiff

Von Borke, Brett E., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

VonWiller, Krista, Plaintiff

Vullings Law, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Vullings, Brent F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

W. Pitts Carr and Associates, PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wade, James J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wagner, K. Scott, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wagoner, Robert J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Waitman, Dr. Heather, Plaintiff

Walker, Darryl W., Plaintiff

Walker, Nicole, Plaintiff

Walker, Patricia A. , Plaintiff

Walker, Retha Pearl, Plaintiff

Walsh, Ann Marie, Plaintiff

Walsh, Daniel, Plaintiff

Walters, James, Plaintiff

Ward, Bristol, Plaintiff

Ward, Craig, Plaintiff



C-123 of 132

Ward, IV, Jasper D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ward, Jr., James L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ward, Jr., James L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ward, Samuel M., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Ware, Christopher, Plaintiff

Ware, Oliver Jr. , Plaintiff

Warner, Jerome, Plaintiff

Warren, Allanna, Plaintiff

Warren, Mary, Plaintiff

Warren, Sharonda, Plaintiff

Warren, Tessa Addie-Lee, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Warren, Todd, Plaintiff

Warshaw, Daniel, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Washburn, John, Plaintiff

Waszkelewicz, Paul, Plaintiff

Watkins, David R., Objector

Watson, Jessica, Plaintiff

Watson, Nicholas, Plaintiff

Watts & Herring,LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weatherby, Alexander Dewitt, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-124 of 132

Weatherly, Teri, Plaintiff

Weaver, Lesley A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weaver, Robert Moore, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weaver, Terra, Plaintiff

Webb, Edward Adam, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Webb, Edward Adam, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Webb, Klase & Lemond, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weiler, Matthew S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weinberg Wheeler Hudgins Gunn & Dial, LLC-Atl, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weiner, Justin B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weiner, Melissa S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weist, Roger, Plaintiff

Wells, Joshua D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weloth, David, Plaintiff

Weltchek Mallahan and Weltchek, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weltchek, Nolan J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weltchek, Robert J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wertheimer, Rachel M., counsel for Defendant(s)

West, Mikell, Objector

Westbrook, Barbara, Plaintiff



C-125 of 132

Westerman Law Corp., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Westerman, Jeff S., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Westmoreland Hall PC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weston, John K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Weston, John K., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wetzel, Joseph Richard, counsel for Defendant(s)

Wetzel, Joseph Richard, counsel for Defendant(s)

Whalen, Paul C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Whipper, Leslie, Plaintiff

Whitcomb, Kaitlin, Plaintiff

White, Amanda Janaye, Plaintiff

White, Carolyn, Plaintiff

White, David, Plaintiff

White, Martin L., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Whitfield Bryson & Mason, LLP - DC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Whitfill, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Whittel & Melton, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Whitten, Austin B., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Whittington, Richard, Plaintiff

Wickens, Robert, Plaintiff



C-126 of 132

Wiggins, Williams & Wiggins, counsel for Defendant(s)

Wiggins, Williams & Wiggins, counsel for Defendant(s)

Wilens, Gary, Plaintiff

Wilens, Jeffrey, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wilentz, Goldman & Spitzer, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wiley, Debbie, Plaintiff

Wilhite, Erin, Plaintiff

Wilhite, George W. , Plaintiff

Wilhite, Jay Travis, Plaintiff

Wilhite, Todd R. , Plaintiff

Wilkerson-Klopfenstein, Sara E. , Plaintiff

Wilkins, Kirby, Plaintiff

Williams, Alfredo, Plaintiff

Williams, Carl, Plaintiff

Williams, Cherie, Plaintiff

Williams, Chris, Plaintiff

Williams, Elexis, Plaintiff

Williams, III, David Reece, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Williams, John M., counsel for Defendant(s)

Williams, John M., counsel for Defendant(s)



C-127 of 132

Williams, Julia A., former Plaintiff

Williams, Justin, Plaintiff

Williams, Kellie, Plaintiff

Williams, Martin, Plaintiff

Williams, Michael Jay, Plaintiff

Williams, Patricia, counsel for Defendant(s)

Williams, Patricia, counsel for Defendant(s)

Williams, Phillip, former Plaintiff

Williams, Rodney, Plaintiff

Williams, Thomas A., Plaintiff

Williamson, Fontenot, Campbell & Whittington, LLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wilson, Cory Eugene, Plaintiff

Wilson, Danial, Plaintiff

Wilson, Scot D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wilson, Stanford Glenn, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wiltz, Juliette Ann, former Plaintiff

Windish, Richard J., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wing, Joshua Iron, Plaintiff

Wininger, Steven, Plaintiff

Winn, III, Harlan F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-128 of 132

Wise, Jennifer, Plaintiff

Wites & Kapetan, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wites, Marc A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Withers Bergman, LLP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wittenberg, Richard, Plaintiff

Wizig, Diane Sharon, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman & Herz, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wolf, Martin Eugene, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wolf, Michael, Plaintiff

Wolfe, Kim, Plaintiff

Wolff, George, Plaintiff

Wolfson, Tina, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wolson, Joshua D., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wong, Stephanie L., Plaintiff

Wood, Cassey-Jo, Plaintiff

Wood, David, Plaintiff

Woods, Joshua, Plaintiff

Woods, Samantha, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Woods, Samantha, Plaintiff

Worley, David James, counsel for Plaintiff(s)



C-129 of 132

Wright, James R., former Plaintiff

Wright, Marshall Alan, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wright, Valencia, Plaintiff

Wright, William L., Plaintiff

Wyatt, Mitchell, Plaintiff

Wyche P.A., counsel for Defendant(s)

Wyckoff, Rae, Plaintiff

Wygal, Brenda Kay, Plaintiff

Wygal, Edward, Plaintiff

Wyly Rommel, PLLC, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Wyly, Jim, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Yamamoto, Kyoko, Plaintiff

Yanchunis, John A. CFP, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Yanchunis, John A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Yearout Myers & Traylor, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Yearout, J. Gusty, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Yoder, David H., Plaintiff

Yoder, Joe, Plaintiff

Yoeckel, Kenneth, Plaintiff

Young, Bridgette, Plaintiff



C-130 of 132

Young, Donald, Plaintiff

Young, Kelly E., Plaintiff

Youngstrom, Scott, Plaintiff

Yunker & Schneider, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Yunker, Stephen F., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zadrozny, Sarah A. , counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zager, Joseph, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zagerlaw, P.A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zaletel, Susan, Plaintiff

Zamora, Martin, Plaintiff

Zamora, Victor, Plaintiff

Zarpas, Christopher, Plaintiff

Zarzaur Law PA- FL, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zarzaur, Jr, Joseph A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zasada, Constance, Plaintiff

Zasada, Constance, Plaintiff

Zasada, Theodore, Plaintiff

Zasada, Theodore, Plaintiff

Zaugg, Brooke, Plaintiff

Zaugg, Jared, Plaintiff



C-131 of 132

Zebrowski Law, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zebrowski, Paul Alphonsus, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zelakowski, Mark, Plaintiff

Zeldes, Helen I., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zeleznick, Mark, Plaintiff

Zeleznick, Nicole, Plaintiff

Zeman, Amy Marie, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zende, Kurt, Plaintiff

Zerbe, Rodney Mark, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zhou, Lily, Plaintiff

Zimmerman Law Offices, P.C., counsel for Plaintiff(s)



Zimmerman Levi & Korsinsky, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zimmerman, Jr., Thomas A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zimmerman, Jr., Thomas A., counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zirpoli, Cadio, counsel for Plaintiff(s)

Zorogastua, G. Gabriel, counsel for Defendant(s)

Zribi, Mary L., Plaintiff



C-132 of 132

Zweig, Bernard J., Plaintiff

Zweig, Marc, former Plaintiff

Dated: April 30, 2020.

/s/ David L. Balser

David L. Balser

Counsel for Defendants-Appellees


1

DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES’ RESPONSE TO

MOTION FOR RELIEF UNDER FED. R. APP. P. 10(e)(2)(C) BY

APPELLANTS WATKINS AND FRANK

Appellants Watkins and Frank move to supplement the appellate record with

the proposed final approval order provided to the District Court as Chief Judge

Thrash directed at the December 19, 2019 fairness hearing in In re Equifax Inc.

Customer Data Security Breach Litigation, Case No. 1:17-md-02800-TWT (N.D.

Ga.). Defendants-Appellees Equifax Inc., Equifax Information Services LLC, and

Equifax Consumer Services LLC (together, “Equifax”) take no position on the relief

requested in Appellants’ motion. Equifax, however, takes issue with Appellants’

mischaracterization of the proceedings in the District Court and their incorrect

suggestion that Judge Thrash’s final approval of the settlement was anything other

than proper.

Appellants are wrong that Judge Thrash’s final approval of the settlement was

procedurally flawed. For starters, Appellants’ argument that the District Court’s

Local Rule 5.1(A)(1) required the proposed order to be filed on the docket lacks

merit. That rule applies only to proposed orders filed in connection with a motion

or other request for relief, not to a proposed order submitted at the court’s direction

following an oral ruling at a hearing.

Appellants’ attack on the routine practice of counsel preparing a proposed

order at the direction of the court is likewise misplaced. After hearing argument at


2

the December 19, 2019 fairness hearing—where Appellants’ counsel presented their

objection to the settlement—Judge Thrash announced a detailed ruling approving

the settlement and overruling all objections. (Dec. 19, 2019 Hr’g Tr. at 113-122).

The Court then directed Class Counsel to prepare a written order “summarize[ing

its] rulings on the motions and [its] adoption basically of the arguments that have

been made by the Plaintiffs and by Equifax in the hearing.” (Id. at 122). Consistent

with the Court’s instructions, Class Counsel prepared a proposed order, obtained

Equifax’s approval as to form, and submitted it for the Court’s consideration. The

Court then entered its order granting final approval of the settlement on January 13,

2020. See Dkt. 956 (amended on March 17, 2020 at Dkt. 1029).

There was nothing improper about Class Counsel’s submission of the

proposed order. The authorities Appellants rely on are readily distinguishable. For

example, Chudasama v. Mazda Motor Corp., 123 F.3d 1353 (11th Cir. 1997)

involved a situation—unlike here—where the court failed to make its own findings

and instead “delegat[ed] the task of drafting sensitive, dispositive orders to plaintiffs’

counsel.” Id. at 1373. On appeal, this Court found the district court’s delegation of

the entire decision-making process to counsel improper, stressing “the court’s abuse

of discretion in managing the case,” an “utter lack of an appearance of impartiality

in the text of the proposed orders,” and “the fact that one of the [proposed] orders

imposed sanctions against the opposing party and counsel” that were “severe” and


3

“clearly excessive.” Id. at 1373 n.46, 1372. And while Appellants quote language

in In re Colony Square Company, 819 F.2d 272 (11th Cir. 1987) disapproving of

counsel-prepared orders under certain circumstances, that case confirms there is

nothing improper about counsel submitting a proposed order after the court

“reache[s] a firm decision” following a hearing, at least where the court gives

counsel direction as to the “particular result” and “specific points” to be addressed

in the order. Id. at 276. Here, Judge Thrash made specific findings on the record

following a nearly four-hour fairness hearing and then directed Class Counsel to

prepare a proposed order that “summarize[ed the Court’s] rulings.” (Dec. 19, 2019

Hr’g Tr. at 122). There was nothing improper about this process—which courts

routinely employ—and Appellants’ cited authorities do not hold otherwise.

In all events, the proposed order is immaterial to this appeal. See Fed. R. App.

P. 10(e)(2) (allowing supplementation of record “[i]f anything material . . . is

omitted from or misstated in the record”) (emphasis added). Judge Thrash’s 122-

page final order approved the settlement and overruled all objections, including that

of Appellants. See Dkt. 1029 at 37-82. The final approval order specifically

overruled Appellants’ argument regarding purported intra-class conflicts based on

differences in state-specific legal remedies (see id. at 58-65), which is the sole

argument Appellants propose to raise in this appeal (see Appellants’ Civil Appeal


4

Statement, March 12, 2020). The proposed order is unnecessary to address that

issue, and Appellants do not contend otherwise.

Respectfully submitted this 30th day of April, 2020.

/s/ David L. Balser

David L. Balser

Phyllis B. Sumner

S. Stewart Haskins II

John C. Toro

Elizabeth D. Adler

Robert D. Griest

KING & SPALDING LLP

1180 Peachtree Street, N.E.

Atlanta, Georgia 30309

Telephone: (404) 572-4600

Facsimile: (404) 572-5100

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]


Equifax Inc., Equifax Information

Services LLC, and Equifax Consumer

Services LLC


1

CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE

Under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure Rule 32(g), I certify that this brief

complies with the length limits set forth in Fed. R. App. P. 27(d)(2)(A), because it

contains 728 words, as counted by Microsoft Word, excluding the items that may be

exempted under Fed. R. App. P. 32(f).

I also certify that this brief complies with the typeface requirements of Fed.

R. App. P. 32(a)(5) and the type style requirements of Fed. R. App. P. 32 (a)(6), as

it has been prepared in a proportionally spaced typeface using Microsoft Word in

14-point Times New Roman font.

/s/ David L. Balser

David L. Balser



1

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I certify that, on April 30, 2020, I electronically filed Defendants-Appellees’

Response to Motion for Relief Under Fed. R. App. P. 10(e)(2)(C) by Appellants

Watkins and Frank with the Clerk of Court using the Court’s CM/ECF system,

which will automatically send email notification of such filing to registered CM/ECF

users.

I also certify that copies of the foregoing were served upon the following pro

se Objector-Appellants via U.S. Mail:

George Willard Cochran, Jr.

1981 Crossfield Circle

Kent, Ohio 44240

Shiyang Huang

2800 SW Angler Court

Topeka, Kansas 66614

Christopher Andrews

P.O. Box 530394

Livonia, Michigan 48153

Alice-Marie Flowers

P.O. Box 2322

Anderson, Indiana 46108

/s/ David L. Balser

David L. Balser



No. 20-10249-JJ, Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil ... · No. 20-10249-JJ, Huang v.Spector, et al....

Documents

Transcript of No. 20-10249-JJ, Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil ... · No. 20-10249-JJ, Huang v.Spector, et al....