NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

25
LOGO Research Methods 2013 Assignment Group Members: Antonia Jakobi Willianne van Horssen Leon Visser Johannes Hesse Leonardo Stouffs Filipe Alarcon

description

Research method's task given from the NHTV SLM acadamy for the 2nd year IB students

Transcript of NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Page 1: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

LOGO

Research Methods 2013

Assignment

Group Members:Antonia JakobiWillianne van HorssenLeon VisserJohannes HesseLeonardo StouffsFilipe Alarcon

Page 2: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Contents

General Information

Conceptual Design

Research Technical Design

Measurements

Suggestions

Page 3: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

General Information

At the 22nd of January the group head out to the TOTAL petrol station at the Prinsenlaan 150 in Breda to measure the before decided activities.

The station area has 2 possibilities to enter (front and back) and 4 possibilities to park your car to get fuel. Furthermore it has 4 + 2 parking lots next to it and 2 possibilities to get air into the tires of the car. Besides that the station offers a food service called 'Coffe corner', as well as an option to use the car wash.

Source: https://maps.google.de/maps

Page 4: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

General Information

Source: http://www.outletfinder.rm.total.com/otfe/ficheDetail.do?reseauId=9&outletCode=NLTOT0000NN001575&lang=NL&mode=amode&otherparams#

Page 5: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Process Map

Page 6: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Conceptual Design (Step 1- 6)

Step 1: Orientation

• General situation sketch• Client• Assignment (client perspective)• Context  ´Step 2: Exploration of the problem

What is the problem? (actual situation complaints?)Out of complaints the problem that occurred is that there are customer waiting times from the customers perspective concerning payment. Who has the problem?The customers have to face the consequences of this problem. When did the problem arose?During rush hours (morning and evening) the problem is arising.  Why is it a problem / challenge? (losing customers)The owner is afraid of losing customers due to satisfaction. Where does the problem occur?The problem occurs in the shop at the counter.  

Page 7: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Conceptual Design (Step 1- 6)

Step 3: Research Objective (SMART) Specific: Improving a process or procedure at a petrol station  Measurable: To determine if the objective has been achieved a certain time frame for a process or procedure must be realized. Acceptable: As motorist need to fill up their gas tanks daily or weekly, many processes and procedure take place when this happens. Due to the fact that this is a weekly activity the research will be done to improve the time spent on one of the processes or procedures at the gas station, as this could improve customer satisfaction. Realistic: As the petrol station is accessible to the public, it is possible to conduct the research. Furthermore doing the measurements on the side without customers knowing that the research is taking place will aid in achieving real results.  Time: The research must be completed by week 11

Page 8: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Conceptual Design (Step 1- 6)

Step 4: Research model

Objective: Reducing the waiting time down to 10%. 

Implementation: Time checking / customer interviewing Choice: Implementing an electronic payment system at the pump Solutions: - Adding a new entrance which is related to the crossing (signing)

- Electronic payment system at the pump- Getting an extra cash register in the shop

 Possible problems: - entrance of the petrol station is not fitting in the infrastructure

- waiting time at the pump- waiting time for payment in the shop

Current situation: 6W’s

Page 9: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Conceptual Design (Step 1- 6)

Step 5: Research questions

Main: What is the percentage of people who need to wait for payment in the shop

Method: Time checking combined with a questionnaire

Research: How is the payment situation at petrol stations in the environment of the petrol station?

Page 10: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Conceptual Design (Step 1- 6)

Step 6: Terminology

Survey about the customer satisfaction with the current payment situation at petrol stationsAmount % Total amount of people asked: 89

Are you satisfied with the waiting time at the pump? YES 47 52,8 NO 42 47,2Are you satisfied with the waiting time for the payment in the shop? YES 43 48,3 NO 46 51,7Are you satisfied about the way of payment in petrol stations? YES 61 68,5 NO 28 31,5

As the regular customers of a petrol station are not always familiarized with the terminology used during a research of this type, the group decided to make the survey questions easier for them to understand and answer. Also not always they have the time to participate in a survey and the questions were built focusing in making it as fast as possible while getting the maximum information possible.

The first two questions are about the waiting time for the customers to have the services and the payment done. With these questions the group could make it clear whether the customers are satisfied with the issue or not.The third question was about the payment method in the station, which can be a really important in the satisfaction of the client in a petrol station. In this case, the customers need to go inside the shop and pay there what can make the waiting time bigger and also influence in the improvement of the market share.

The fourth and last question was concerning about customer's advices for improvements at the petrol station. This factor is really important to see the feedback of the clients, with that the group could focus in the right path to see which improvements were worth to pursue or not.

In summary of all the questions, the group tried to focus in the waiting time and also ways that the service of the station could improve for its market share. Easy and quick questions were made due to the climate of the petrol station.

Page 11: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Research technical Design (Step 7- 9)

Step 7: Research material

• IPhone timer• Questionnaire• Laptop (excel file)

Step 8: Research strategy

In order to achieve the pursued results of the assignment, it was really important to make the objectives and the research strategy clear for all the members. As the main task was to measure the processes in a petrol station and find out the bottlenecks of the system, a lot of information was needed about measurement and also about the station.

First of all, the group made a survey in the internet of how to measure in a proper way. The sources found were not always reliable. In this case they were evaluated to choose the ones with the best credibility. Also, the petrol station chosen was studied to point the different processes that are most important to measure. A talk with the owner was arranged for better explanation. With all these data, the objectives of the measurement and how to achieve them were well specified which gave the team a good path to achieve the expected results. The layout of the petrol station and the chosen activities are described later on this report.

In this scenario of the assignment, it was time to measure the activities and properly store all the data. With the measurements of process once made, the group analysed the results and found out which activities could be optimised in order to reduce the waiting time for the customers and deliver them a better service.

Page 12: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Research technical Design (Step 7- 9)

Step 9: Research planning

Progressing:

Before the research could have taken place we needed to follow several steps. First of all we discovered an too often occurring problem in petrol stations. There is the possibility of a waiting line in the shop. This is making customers unsatisfied, because some people are in a hurry.

This is why we decided to do a research about the occurring problem at petrol stations. The objective of this examination obviously is to reduce waiting in the shops and to improve the customer service level. The real objective has been formulated SMART.

Once the objective and research questions were written out, the actual research started at the petrol station of Total at the Claudius Prinsenlaan in Breda. Thirty questions with several options set up in an excel file had to be answered per customer. We took place at a parking lot at the station in order to be able to answer the questions. We have done this research twice to be more accurate about the average customer. After the research all answers have been put together to find the percentage of waiting customers and other averages.

Page 13: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Measurements Day 1Measurement has been done at the petrol station, with the use of an IPhone timer, a questionnaire and a laptop with an Excel file. Two days of measuring are done, to get a ‘fair’ idea of the flows at the petrol station.

At first the time was checked when the customer arrived, also the leaving time was checked. Out of these times the total time at the petrol station is calculated. When the customer arrives, several questions are ‘answered’ for every customer. If the customer had to wait at the pump, in the shop, the mode of transport, gender, age and some other activities at the petrol station. These activities are measured, because expected is that there will be a bottleneck in one of the flows.

Page 14: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Measurements Day 2After the measurement all data was filled in the Excel file. There is data of 91 persons; 43 from day 1 and 48 from day 2.

The table is split up in 6 topics; waiting time, mode of transport, information about the customer, type of activity at the pump, activity in the shop and paying with PIN.

Out of the measurement came that some topics can cause some problems. These are highlighted in the next slights.

Page 15: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Measurements Comparison Waiting ‘yes/no’

YES14%

NO 86%

Waiting at the pump

YES30%

NO 70%

Waiting in the shop

YES15%

NO 85%

Waiting at the pump

YES35%

NO 65%

Waiting in the shop

1

2

These figures show that the amount of people that have to wait in the shop is pretty high, this need to be improved.

Also around 15% of the customers that get fuel have to wait at the pump. The aim is also to decrease this percentage.

Page 16: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Measurements Comparison Mode of transport

1

2

Car:84%

Motor-cycle/

Scooter:4%

Bike:7%

By foot: 5%

Car:86%

Mo-tor-

cycle/ Scoot

er:4%

Bike:6%

By foot: 4%

These figures show that the majority of the people come by car. This can be a reason for the waiting time at the pump, because it takes more time for cars to fill with gas, than for scooters for example. However this can not be reduced, because it is the customers choice.

Page 17: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Measurement form of payment and the waiting time

Average Payment with PIN

YES

NO

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243012345678

Average total time needed

minutes + seconds

Customer number

Tim

e

The figure on the left shows that most people pay with PIN. The people that not pay with PIN pay with cash. This is not an important fact for the waiting time, because the time needed for both payments is almost the same. However it does mean that most people go in the shop for a payment that also can be done without a person and this can reduce the waiting time.

The figure below shows the average waiting time per customer in minutes. There are some high and low ‘peaks’.

Page 18: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Reliability of the estimations regarding the times measured for each customer

Page 19: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Reliability of the estimations regarding the times measured for each customer

The same calculation was made also for the second day The size of the sample was 48 and the estimated reliability 80% Day 2: 2,4233- < 2,4233 Day 2: 2,2932 < < 2,5534 The calculation shows that it is 80% certain that the total time a customers

needed at the patrol station is between 2,3 and 2,6 minutes.

Page 20: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Reliability of the estimations regarding the times measured for each customer

By comparing these two results it shows that the on the second day 80% of the customers needed almost the same time at the patrol station, whether on the first day the interval is much wider.

Page 21: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Reliability of the estimations regarding the times measured for each customer

Confidence interval for the time needed to refuel the car The size of the sample was 43 and the estimated reliability 80% Day 1: 1,9318- < Day 1: 1,7986 < The calculation shows that it is 80% certain that the customers need

between 1,8 and 2,1 minutes to refuel their car.

Page 22: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Reliability of the estimations regarding the times measured for each customer

Again the same calculation were made for the second day The size of the sample was 48 and the estimated reliability 80% Day 2: 1,2396- < < 1,2396+ Day 1: 1,1621 < It is 80% certain that the time a customer needed to refill his car is between

1,2 and 1,4 minutes.

Page 23: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Reliability of the estimations regarding the times measured for each customer

Comparing these two outcomes it shows that on the second day again most of the customer needed the same amount of time. On the first day the time which was needed to get the petrol varied a little bit more.

Page 24: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

Suggestions

Possible solutions:

- Adding a new entrance which is related to the crossing (signing)

- Electronic payment system at the pump

- Getting an extra cash register in the shop

Problems:

- Entrance of the petrol station is not fitting in the infrastructure

- Waiting time at the pump

- Waiting time for payment in the shop

Page 25: NHTV 'Research Methods' Group Assignment Year 2

LOGOwww.themegallery.com