New Volume Therapy[1]

download New Volume Therapy[1]

of 66

Transcript of New Volume Therapy[1]

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    1/66

    VOLUME THERAPYVOLUME THERAPYDr. Monish RautDr. Monish Raut

    Dept of Cardiac AnaesthesiaDept of Cardiac AnaesthesiaSir Ganga Ram HospitalSir Ganga Ram Hospital

    New DelhiNew Delhi

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    2/66

    Fluid PhysiologyFluid Physiology

    Total Body Water 0.6 L/kg 2/3 Intracellular (ICF)

    1/3 Extracellular (ECF)

    ICF Volume (0.4 L/kg)ECF Volume (0.2 L/kg)

    Plasma Volume (0.05 L/kg)

    Interstitial Volume (0.15 /kg)

    Ratio of plasma volume to interstitialvolume is 1-to-3 [rationale for 3-to-1replacement of blood losses with crystalloid]

    Cells 28 LitresCells 28 Litres

    Blood volume 3.5Blood volume 3.5

    litreslitres

    Interstitial fluid 10.5 LitresInterstitial fluid 10.5 Litres

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    3/66

    Provide daily basal fluid requirementsMaintain or achieve normovolemia and haemodynamic

    stability

    Restitution of the fluid balance between the differentfluid compartments

    Maintain adequate plasma COP

    Enhance microvascular blood flow

    Prevent/moderate cascade system activation and trauma

    induced increased blood coagulability

    Normalization of oxygen delivery to tissue cells and

    cellular metabolism Int J Intensive Care, 1999; 6: 20Baillires Clin Anaesthesiol, 1997; 11: 49.

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    4/66

    Clinical Situations Often Requiring customizedClinical Situations Often Requiring customized

    Volume therapyVolume therapy

    Management of patients with hemorrhage (e.g., GI bleed, rupturedManagement of patients with hemorrhage (e.g., GI bleed, rupturedAAA, cardiac redo cases , IVC tear, SVC tear )AAA, cardiac redo cases , IVC tear, SVC tear )

    Surgery, especially with large blood losses or large third spaceSurgery, especially with large blood losses or large third spacelosses, such as liver transplantation or spinal correction surgerylosses, such as liver transplantation or spinal correction surgery

    Management of burn patientsManagement of burn patients

    Perioperative management of trauma patientsPerioperative management of trauma patients

    Management of cardiopulmonary bypassManagement of cardiopulmonary bypass

    Management of patients with sepsis syndromeManagement of patients with sepsis syndrome

    Complex situations: Acute Pancreatitis, DKA, Acute Renal FailureComplex situations: Acute Pancreatitis, DKA, Acute Renal Failure

    ALI/ ARDSALI/ ARDS

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    5/66

    Critically ill patients do often have complex

    hemodynamics (hypovolemia, myocardial depression

    or both).

    Only in rare case does the diagnosis tell you what is

    the main physiological disturbance.

    Co-morbidities often complicate the hemodynamic

    status.

    Critically ill patients often present us with therapeutic

    conflicts (e.g., hemodynamic instability and ARDS).

    Features unique to Critical

    Illness

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    6/66

    Early Optimization of HemodynamicsEarly Optimization of Hemodynamics

    improves outcomeimproves outcome

    Kern JW and Shoemaker WC

    Crit Care Med 30: 1686 1692, 2002

    Metaanalysis of hemodynamic optimizaton

    in high risk patients

    Rivers et al., N Engl J Med 345: 1368 1377,2001

    Early goal-directed therapy in the treatment

    of severe sepsis and septic shock

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    7/66

    Goals of hemodynamic ManagementGoals of hemodynamic Management

    Optimizing Stroke volume /CardiacOutput:

    Optimizing Preload:

    Avoiding Fluid Overload

    Measurement of Preload Assessing Fluid Responsiveness

    Measurement of SV/CO

    Assessing Pulmonary Edema

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    8/66

    Volume expansion is frequently used inVolume expansion is frequently used incritically ill patients to improvecritically ill patients to improvehemodynamics. Because of the positivehemodynamics. Because of the positiverelationship between ventricular end-diastolicrelationship between ventricular end-diastolicvolume and stroke volume, the expectedvolume and stroke volume, the expectedhemodynamic response to volume expansionhemodynamic response to volume expansionis an increase in right ventricular end-diastolicis an increase in right ventricular end-diastolicvolume (RVEDV), left ventricular end-diastolicvolume (RVEDV), left ventricular end-diastolicvolume, stroke volume, and cardiac output.volume, stroke volume, and cardiac output.

    Michard F. Teboul JL. Predicting fluid responsiveness in ICUpatients: a critical analysis of the evidence.Chest. 121(6):2000-8, 2002 Jun.

    Plasma Volume Expansion

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    9/66

    Scenarios commonly

    encountered

    2- Patients with high suspicion of septic shock2- Patients with high suspicion of septic shock

    3- Patients in the ICU, already resuscitated for several hours or days3- Patients in the ICU, already resuscitated for several hours or days

    1- Patients with acute blood losses or body fluid losses1- Patients with acute blood losses or body fluid losses

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    10/66

    After how much & when ? TheAfter how much & when ? The

    question is which fluid ?question is which fluid ?

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    11/66

    The Ideal Plasma Volume ExpanderThe Ideal Plasma Volume Expander

    InexpensiveInexpensive

    No special storage problems; long shelfNo special storage problems; long shelflifelife

    Can be made in bulk using existingCan be made in bulk using existing

    industrial processesindustrial processesFree of pathogensFree of pathogens

    NontoxicNontoxic

    Crystalloid vs ColloidCrystalloid vs Colloid

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    12/66

    Fluid loading: which one ?Fluid loading: which one ?CrystalloidsCrystalloids

    greater volume is requiredgreater volume is required

    incidence of side effect is lowincidence of side effect is low

    Salt loading & hyperchloraemic acidosisSalt loading & hyperchloraemic acidosis

    ColloidsColloids

    First line product?First line product?

    RisksRisks

    allergyallergy

    HepatotoxicHepatotoxic

    CoagulopathyCoagulopathy

    Nephrotoxic ?Nephrotoxic ?

    TransfusionTransfusion

    Not for fluid loadingNot for fluid loading

    Restrictive strategy ((Hb 7-9 g%)Restrictive strategy ((Hb 7-9 g%)

    Task force of the ACCM_SCCM1999

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    13/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    14/66

    Time is organ function !!!Time is organ function !!!

    Start ofStart oftreatmenttreatmentICU

    Burden of organ dysfunction

    Prognosis

    Pre-hospital ED Ward

    Delay in diagnosis

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    15/66

    VOLUME EFFECT OF CRYSTALLOIDSVOLUME EFFECT OF CRYSTALLOIDS

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    16/66

    Crystalloid disadvantagesCrystalloid disadvantages

    Lowers plasma osmolalityLowers plasma osmolality

    Drive water into interstitial spaceDrive water into interstitial space

    Dilution of plasma proteinDilution of plasma proteinDecrease in colloidal osm pressureDecrease in colloidal osm pressure

    3 fold amount compared with colloid3 fold amount compared with colloid

    Hyperchloremic acidosisHyperchloremic acidosis

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    17/66

    Crystalloid disadvantagesCrystalloid disadvantages

    Post-op fluid overload increasesPost-op fluid overload increases

    morbidity significantlymorbidity significantly

    Post-op weight gainPost-op weight gainPost-op confusionPost-op confusion

    Increased duration of post-opIncreased duration of post-op

    ventilation/chest complicationsventilation/chest complications

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    18/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    19/66

    e.g. 0.9 % NaCl

    Ringers Lactate

    Colloids

    Naturalcolloids

    Gelatin

    Dextran

    HES

    Crystalloids

    Artificialcolloids

    Albumin

    Volume replacement - overview

    CrystalloidsBlood / plasma

    products

    Whole blood

    RBC

    FFP

    Plasma proteins

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    20/66

    Requirements of an ideal colloidRequirements of an ideal colloid

    No plasmaaccumulation

    Complete renalelimination

    Excellent safety profile

    No tissue storage

    Volume replacement - overview

    stable and reliable constant plateau effect

    be easily controllable

    Sufficient volume effect(efficacy and safety)

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    21/66

    ALBUMINALBUMIN

    5% Solution - 80% vol expansion5% Solution - 80% vol expansion

    25% Solution 200% vol expansion25% Solution 200% vol expansion

    Effect for 16-24 hrsEffect for 16-24 hrs

    Martino P. colloid and crystalloid resuscitationMartino P. colloid and crystalloid resuscitationThe ICU Book 3The ICU Book 3rdrd edit 2007edit 2007

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    22/66

    AdvantagesAdvantages

    Less anaphylactoid,coaguln abnormalitiesLess anaphylactoid,coaguln abnormalities

    Volume expansionVolume expansion

    AntioxidantAntioxidantInflences acid base statusInflences acid base status

    Barron ME : systemic review of comparative safety of colloidsBarron ME : systemic review of comparative safety of colloidsArch Surg 2004Arch Surg 2004

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    23/66

    DisadvantagesDisadvantages

    ExpensiveExpensive

    Interstitial Edema - Volume overloadInterstitial Edema - Volume overload

    Park G. Molecular mech of drug metabolism in criti illPark G. Molecular mech of drug metabolism in criti illBrit J. Anesth 1996Brit J. Anesth 1996

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    24/66

    DextranDextran

    Dextran 40 and Dextran 70Dextran 40 and Dextran 70

    Volume expansion 100 150%Volume expansion 100 150%Duration for 6 -12 hrsDuration for 6 -12 hrs

    Martino P. colloid and crystalloid resuscitationMartino P. colloid and crystalloid resuscitation

    The ICU Book 3The ICU Book 3rdrd edit 2007edit 2007

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    25/66

    DEXTRANSDEXTRANS

    6% dextran70

    10% dextran40

    Mean molecular weight

    (Dalton).

    70,000 40,000

    Volume effect (hours)(Approx.).

    5 3-4

    Volume efficacy(%)(Approx.).

    100 175-(200)

    Maximum daily

    dose(g/kg).

    1.5 1.5

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    26/66

    AdvAdv

    Vol expansion higher than HES and 5%Vol expansion higher than HES and 5%

    albuminalbumin

    Improve Microcirculation.Improve Microcirculation.

    by decreasing viscosityby decreasing viscosity

    by inhibiting RBCs aggregationby inhibiting RBCs aggregation

    Martino P. colloid and crystalloid resuscitationMartino P. colloid and crystalloid resuscitationThe ICU Book 3The ICU Book 3rdrd edit 2007edit 2007

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    27/66

    DisadvDisadv

    Anaphylactic reactionAnaphylactic reaction

    Coagulation abnormalitiesCoagulation abnormalities

    Interfer crossmatchInterfer crossmatchARFARF

    Barron ME : systemic review of comparative safety of colloidsBarron ME : systemic review of comparative safety of colloids

    Arch Surg 2004Arch Surg 2004

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    28/66

    GelatinsGelatins

    Succinylated gelatins (gelofusine)Succinylated gelatins (gelofusine)

    Urea crosslinked (haemacel)Urea crosslinked (haemacel)

    OxypolygelatinsOxypolygelatins

    Volume expansion 70 80 %Volume expansion 70 80 %

    Duration shorter than alb, HESDuration shorter than alb, HES

    Dubois MJ -Periope fluid therapy, 1Dubois MJ -Periope fluid therapy, 1 stst edition, 2007edition, 2007

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    29/66

    GELATINSGELATINS

    Urea-cross-linkedGelatin.

    ( Hemaccel)

    Cross linkedGelatin

    SuccinylatedGelatin(Gelofusine )

    Concentration (%)3.5 5.5 4.0

    Mean moleculareight(Dalton)

    35000 30000 30000

    olumeeffect(hours)(approx)

    1-3 1-3 1-3

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    30/66

    HemacelHemacel

    Na 145Na 145

    K 5.1K 5.1

    Ca 6.25Ca 6.25

    Cl 145Cl 145

    GelofusineGelofusine

    Na 154Na 154

    K 0.4K 0.4

    Ca 0.4Ca 0.4

    Cl 120Cl 120

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    31/66

    AdvAdv

    CheaperCheaper

    No limit of infusionNo limit of infusion

    Less renal effect.Less renal effect.

    Barron ME : systemic review of comparative safety of colloidsBarron ME : systemic review of comparative safety of colloids

    Arch Surg 2004Arch Surg 2004

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    32/66

    DisadvDisadv

    Anaphylactoid reactionAnaphylactoid reaction

    Effect on coagulationEffect on coagulation

    Circulatory dysfunctionCirculatory dysfunction

    Tabuchi N. gelatin impair platelet adhesion in cardiac sxTabuchi N. gelatin impair platelet adhesion in cardiac sx

    Thromb Haemost 1995Thromb Haemost 1995

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    33/66

    Allergic reactions after applicationAllergic reactions after applicationof colloids (%)of colloids (%)

    Allergic reactions after applicationAllergic reactions after applicationof colloids (%)of colloids (%)

    prospective multicenter studie (~20.000 patients)prospective multicenter studie (~20.000 patients)

    GelatinsGelatins DextransDextrans AlbuminAlbumin HESHES

    0,40,4

    0,20,2

    00

    (Laxenaire et al., 1994)(Laxenaire et al., 1994)

    Allergicr e

    actions

    (%)

    Allergicr e

    actions(%)

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    34/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    35/66

    Parameters of HES

    Pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic of HES iscontrolled by:

    Molar substitution

    C2/C6Substitution pattern

    Molecular weight

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    36/66

    Volume EffectsVolume Effects

    The performance of 6% HES as a plasmaThe performance of 6% HES as a plasma

    volume expander is very similar to 5%volume expander is very similar to 5%albumin.albumin.

    The oncotic pressure (30 mm Hg) isThe oncotic pressure (30 mm Hg) is

    higher than 5% albumin (20 mm Hg)higher than 5% albumin (20 mm Hg)the increment in plasma volume can bethe increment in plasma volume can be

    slightly higher as wellslightly higher as well

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    37/66

    VoluvenVoluvenThe ThirdThe Third

    Generation HESGeneration HES

    Licensed for up to

    50ml/kgbw/day

    Only starch approved for

    use in pediatrics

    Only starch approved for

    use in renal failure patients

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    38/66

    VOLUVEN - Less chemicalmodification

    ... compared to conventional starches (HES 200/0.5) Voluven has a

    reduced degree of substitution (by approx. 20 %)

    improved substitution pattern (C2 /C6 ratio)

    Both modifications together ensure a constant renal excretion andavoid plasma accumulation, even after repeated doses

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    39/66

    Safety of high dosevolume replacement

    Influence on haemostasis

    and coagulation

    Tissue storage

    Influence on kidneyfunction

    Incidence of anaphylactoid

    reactions

    HES in children

    Influence on oxygen tension& inflammatory response

    Hot topics with HES

    Original Study with Voluven

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    40/66

    Volume effect of 6% HES 130/0.4(Waitzinger et al., 1998)

    Study results

    Volume effect ~100%

    Plateau effect ~ 4 hours

    Volume effect up to 6 hours

    hours

    Volume effect of 6% HES 130/

    0.4

    Original Study with Voluven

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    41/66

    Study results

    Administered :- 6% HES 130/0.4

    (Voluven)

    - Ringer`s Lactate

    Tissue oxygen tension:

    - 59% increase with HES

    130/0.4 (Voluven)

    - 23% decrease with RL

    LMW HES and tissue oxygenationLMW HES and tissue oxygenation

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    42/66

    CanJ Anesth 2003; 50 (10): 1009-1016

    Intravascular volume replacementIntravascular volume replacementwith HES 130/0.4 may reducewith HES 130/0.4 may reduceinflammatory responseinflammatory response

    This is most likely due to an improvedThis is most likely due to an improvedmicrocirculation with reducedmicrocirculation with reducedendothelial activation and lessendothelial activation and less

    endothelial damageendothelial damage

    SIRS

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    43/66

    High dosage data with VoluvenHigh dosage data with Voluven

    High dose volume replacement using HES 130/0.4 during major urologicHigh dose volume replacement using HES 130/0.4 during major urologic

    surgery does not alter coagulation (Ellger et al.)surgery does not alter coagulation (Ellger et al.)

    50 ml/kg50 ml/kg

    Advantages of Voluven at repitive high dose levels in patients with severeAdvantages of Voluven at repitive high dose levels in patients with severe

    craniocerebral trauma (Neff et al.)craniocerebral trauma (Neff et al.) 70 ml/kg70 ml/kg during several daysduring several days

    Safety of High Dose volume substitution with 6%HES 130/0.4 in cardiacSafety of High Dose volume substitution with 6%HES 130/0.4 in cardiac

    surgery (surgery (Frey et al.)Frey et al.)

    48 ml/kg48 ml/kg

    Large-dose hydroxyethyl starch (HES) 130/0.4 in elective coronary arteryLarge-dose hydroxyethyl starch (HES) 130/0.4 in elective coronary arterybypass surgery (Kasper et al.)bypass surgery (Kasper et al.)

    50 ml/Kg50 ml/Kg

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    44/66

    Sticky issues with starchSticky issues with starch

    bleeding tendencybleeding tendency caused by inhibition of factor VII andcaused by inhibition of factor VII andvon Willebrand factor and impaired platelet adhesiveness.von Willebrand factor and impaired platelet adhesiveness.

    This effect is seen predominantly with high MW hetastarch, is lessThis effect is seen predominantly with high MW hetastarch, is lesspronounced with medium MW hetastarch, and is absent with lowpronounced with medium MW hetastarch, and is absent with low

    MW hetastarch.MW hetastarch.

    The coagulation defect is pronounced when more than 1,500 mLThe coagulation defect is pronounced when more than 1,500 mLhetastarch is infused within a 24 hr period. can be minimized byhetastarch is infused within a 24 hr period. can be minimized bylimiting the infusion volume to less than 1,500 mL in 24 hours andlimiting the infusion volume to less than 1,500 mL in 24 hours and

    by avoiding the use of hetastarch in patients with an underlyingby avoiding the use of hetastarch in patients with an underlyingcoagulopathy, particularly von Willebrand's disease.coagulopathy, particularly von Willebrand's disease.

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    45/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    46/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    47/66

    Acid-base equilibriumAcid-base equilibrium after administrationafter administration

    of large volumes of an unbalanced solutionof large volumes of an unbalanced solution

    HCO3

    Cations

    Anions

    Na+

    Cl

    PO43

    Alb

    Lactat

    e

    SO42, OH

    etc.

    K+

    H+

    Ca2+

    Mg2+

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    48/66

    Hyperchloremic acidosisHyperchloremic acidosis

    Nausea vomitingNausea vomiting

    HeadacheHeadache

    Delayed first urinationDelayed first urinationDisturbed blood coagulationDisturbed blood coagulation

    Impaired cardiac functionImpaired cardiac function

    Reduced cardiac outputReduced cardiac output

    Malperfusion of kidneys & gutMalperfusion of kidneys & gut

    Inactivation of calcium channels in cell membranesInactivation of calcium channels in cell membranes

    Inhibition of noradrenaline releaseInhibition of noradrenaline release

    B l d 6% HES 130/0 4

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    49/66

    Balanced 6% HES 130/0.4Balanced 6% HES 130/0.4

    AdvantagesAdvantages

    Due to the same active ingredient as Voluven

    the samebeneficial effects for the patients

    Balanced electrolyte solution, close to human plasma

    Lower chloride content than saline based solutions

    Lowest chloride content as compared to all other balancedsolutions

    With acetate /Malate as a precursor of bicarbonate in order to

    counteract development of hyperchloraemic metabolic acidosis

    Carrier solution without Ca2+ ions in order to exclude the risk ofcomplexation of Ca2+ ions with certain anions

    Disadvantages?Disadvantages?

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    50/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    51/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    52/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    53/66

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    54/66

    when it comes to selecting the resuscitation fluid doctors are faced with a

    range of options. At the most basic level the choice is between a colloid or

    crystalloid

    solution.

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    55/66

    N Engl J Med 2004;350:2247-56

    use of 4 percent albumin or normal saline for intravascular volumeresuscitation in a heterogeneous population of patients in the ICU

    Requirements for mechanical ventilation and renal-replacementtherapy, time spent in the ICU and in the hospital during the 28-day study period, and the time until death (among the patientswho died) were also equivalent. The proportion of patients in thetwo groups in whom new singleorgan or multiple-organ failure

    developed were similar.

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    56/66

    Crystalloid/Colloid DebateCrystalloid/Colloid Debate

    Are colloid more effective than crystalloid?Are colloid more effective than crystalloid?

    Are synthetic colloid equally effective &Are synthetic colloid equally effective &

    safe as human albumin?safe as human albumin?

    Do HES have the best risk/benefit profileDo HES have the best risk/benefit profile

    among all colloids?among all colloids?

    Is third generations HES safer thanIs third generations HES safer than

    olders?olders?

    A ll id ff ti thA ll id ff ti th

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    57/66

    Are colloid more effective thanAre colloid more effective than

    crystalloid?crystalloid?

    Hemodynamics changes by colloids areHemodynamics changes by colloids are

    immediate effects and do not lead toimmediate effects and do not lead to

    improved clinical outcomes in comparisonimproved clinical outcomes in comparison

    with crystalloidswith crystalloids Finfer S. SAFE Trial, NEJM 2004Finfer S. SAFE Trial, NEJM 2004

    Brunkhorst FM. VISEP Trial, NEJM 2008Brunkhorst FM. VISEP Trial, NEJM 2008

    Wills BA.Comparison of 3 fluids for resuscitation in DSS, NEJM 2005Wills BA.Comparison of 3 fluids for resuscitation in DSS, NEJM 2005Upadhyay M. crystalloid and colloid resuscitation in ped septic shock,Upadhyay M. crystalloid and colloid resuscitation in ped septic shock,

    Indian Pediatri 2005Indian Pediatri 2005

    A th ti ll id llAre s nthetic colloid eq all

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    58/66

    Are synthetic colloid equallyAre synthetic colloid equally

    effective & safe as human albumin?effective & safe as human albumin?

    Starches can easily replace albumins as volStarches can easily replace albumins as vol

    expander because they are equally safe but lessexpander because they are equally safe but less

    expensive.expensive.

    Boldt J. albumin based IV volume replacement in elderly pts undergoingBoldt J. albumin based IV volume replacement in elderly pts undergoingabd sx. Anesth Analg 2007abd sx. Anesth Analg 2007

    Recent metaanalysis failed to find mortality benefitRecent metaanalysis failed to find mortality benefit

    of any type colloid in critically ill.of any type colloid in critically ill.

    Perel P. colloid vs crystalloids in critically ill, Cochrane data base ReviewPerel P. colloid vs crystalloids in critically ill, Cochrane data base Review20092009

    Bunn F. colloid solutions for resuscitation, Cochrane data base ReviewBunn F. colloid solutions for resuscitation, Cochrane data base Review

    20082008

    D HES h th b t i k/b fitDo HES have the best risk/benefit

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    59/66

    Do HES have the best risk/benefitDo HES have the best risk/benefit

    profile among all colloids?profile among all colloids?

    Dextran associated with anaphylacticDextran associated with anaphylactic

    reactions,coaguln abnormalities, interfersreactions,coaguln abnormalities, interfers

    crossmatch, ARF.crossmatch, ARF.

    Barron ME : systemic review of comparativeBarron ME : systemic review of comparativesafety of colloid , Arch Surg 2004safety of colloid , Arch Surg 2004

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    60/66

    Gelatins impair platelet function andGelatins impair platelet function and

    reduce vWf and coagulation factor VIII:creduce vWf and coagulation factor VIII:c

    Tomi T.,Gelatin and Hydroxyethyl Starch, but Not Albumin, Impair

    Hemostasis After Cardiac Surgery.Anesth Analg 2006Anesth Analg 2006.

    Gelatins impair renal function similar to

    HES 200/0.6 in cardiac surgery.

    Boldt J.,Comparison of the effects of gelatin and a modern

    hydroxyethyl starch solution on renal function and inflammatory

    response in elderly cardiac surgery patients. Brit J Anesth 2008Brit J Anesth 2008.

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    61/66

    HES 450/0.7 and HES 200/0.5 increasesHES 450/0.7 and HES 200/0.5 increases

    bleeding in cardiac surgerybleeding in cardiac surgeryHaynes GR.,Fluid management in cardiac surgery. J.CardiothoracicHaynes GR.,Fluid management in cardiac surgery. J.Cardiothoracic

    Vasc Anesth 2006.Vasc Anesth 2006.

    HES 250/0.45 associated with increasedHES 250/0.45 associated with increased

    AKI in cardiac surgery.AKI in cardiac surgery.Rioux JP.,Pentastarch 10% risk factor of AKI following cardiacRioux JP.,Pentastarch 10% risk factor of AKI following cardiacsurgery. Criti Care Med 2009.surgery. Criti Care Med 2009.

    Is third generations HES safer thanIs third generations HES safer than

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    62/66

    Is third generations HES safer thanIs third generations HES safer than

    older generations ?older generations ?

    HES 130/0.4 associated with significantHES 130/0.4 associated with significantreduction in perioperative blood lossreduction in perioperative blood lossKozek , effects of HES on blood loss in major sx, analysis of RCT,Kozek , effects of HES on blood loss in major sx, analysis of RCT,

    Anesth Analg 2008Anesth Analg 2008

    Tetrastarches associated with 15%Tetrastarches associated with 15%reduction in blood loss compared toreduction in blood loss compared to

    gelatin and pentastarches.gelatin and pentastarches. Chang D., colloid for periop plasma expansion: syst review TransfChang D., colloid for periop plasma expansion: syst review TransfMed 2007Med 2007

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    63/66

    HES 130/0.4 no reported adv effect onHES 130/0.4 no reported adv effect on

    renal function.renal function.Boldt J.,influence of vol therapy with modern HES on kidneyBoldt J.,influence of vol therapy with modern HES on kidney

    function Crit Care Med 2007.function Crit Care Med 2007.

    HES 130/0.4 not an independent riskHES 130/0.4 not an independent risk

    factor for adv effect on renal function.factor for adv effect on renal function.SOAP Trial,.Brit J. Anesth 2007.SOAP Trial,.Brit J. Anesth 2007.

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    64/66

    9 clinical trials on renal function9 clinical trials on renal function

    demonstrate safety of waxy maize deriveddemonstrate safety of waxy maize derived

    HES 130/0.4 and, 2 recently publishedHES 130/0.4 and, 2 recently published

    trials confirm that potato derived HEStrials confirm that potato derived HES

    130/0.42 has no adv effects on renal130/0.42 has no adv effects on renal

    function.function.

    Westphal M, HES diff products diff effects, Anesthesiology 2009.Westphal M, HES diff products diff effects, Anesthesiology 2009.

    James MFM, tetrastarches in periop setting, Current opin inJames MFM, tetrastarches in periop setting, Current opin inAnesthes 2008.Anesthes 2008.

    NO MAGIC BULLET

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    65/66

    Hemodynamic TruthsHemodynamic Truths

    Tachycardia is never a good thingTachycardia is never a good thing

    Hypotension is always pathologicalHypotension is always pathological

    CVP is only elevated in diseaseCVP is only elevated in disease

    Volume therapy should always be customized according to the

    underlying pathophysiology

  • 8/6/2019 New Volume Therapy[1]

    66/66

    THANK YOUTHANK YOU