New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

12
New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

description

My lightning talk at WMF All Hands 2011 on trending and semi-protected Wikipedia articles that are mostly read-only (or hard to edit) for anonymous users

Transcript of New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Page 1: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

New editors not welcome:!When Wikipedia articles trend

Page 2: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

User experience with trending articles

Engaging with readers of trending articles

Supporting editor activity with trending articles

Page 3: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Daily page views for semi-protected articles

10. 100. 1000. 10 000. 100 000.Views

100

200

300

400N

Semipr Random

total 6 378 092 109 107

median 565 6

semi-protected

random

Page 4: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Daily page views for semi-protected articles

total page views median page views

semi-protected 6.4M 565!

random sample 109K 6

India: 7.8M Australia: 7.3M!

Wikimedia Traffic Analysis Report for period April 2010 - March 2011

Page 5: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend
Page 6: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Erik Zachte, Edit and revert trends, 2010

Page 7: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Article Feedback: Semi-protection of frequently rated articles

31% "

among top rated

60% "

among lowest rated

Data collected: 2011-10-12

(10+ ratings per day)

46% "

of frequently rated articles

Page 8: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

1.8% "

edits by new registered users

7.4% "

edits by new anonymous users

all trending articles unprotected trending articles

3.5% "

edits by new registered users

15.6% "

edits by new anonymous users

Yusuke Matsubara, Trending articles and new editors, 2011

4x more edits "

to unprotected trending articles than to semi-protected trending articles

Semi-protection of trending articles (3x hourly views increase)

Page 9: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Coordination in high-traffic articles on rapidly changing events

B. Keegan, N. Contractor (2011) Hot off the Wiki: Dynamics, Practices, and Structures in Wikipedia’s Coverage of the Tohoku Catastrophes

2011 To hoku earthquake and tsunami!

533,700 page views in 1 day

Higher probability of locks/conflicts!

Ineffective on-site coordination Migration to IRC

Success of encapsulated contributions! 208 edits to casualty count template

Page 10: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend
Page 11: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Engaging with readers of high-traffic articles

Edit article

Edit encapsulated sections of an article

Edit article with curation mechanism (flagged revisions?)

Rate article

Provide constructive feedback

Contribute sources/citations

Subscribe by email

Help perform general maintenance tasks

Learn that articles are not static (even when they cannot be edited)

A trending/high-traffic article API to enable reader engagement features? !

Page 12: New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend

Image credits

Kittens and Flowers for the Ewoks CC BY-NC-SA image by Stéphan http://www.flickr.com/photos/st3f4n/4100711403

Darth Vader is watching you CC BY-NC-SA image by Stéphan http://www.flickr.com/photos/st3f4n/4020408210

Dario Taraborelli. New editors not welcome: When Wikipedia articles trend !http://nitens.org/docs/slides/wmf-allhands-2011.pdf!