Networking the Failed State

7/27/2019 Networking the Failed State

1/48

"#$%&'()*+ $,# -.)/#0 1$.$# 2 3*.4$)*+ $,# 5)64)7/)*# &89*$#'*.$)&*./ :#/.$)&*6;,? @$/,()&= .,A$+($B CD7DE

78#$+14$9 F#,


2/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'5


3/48

B'$


4/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'E

H($-%)(/%J, '#, $4/, 43 (9'4$& ()< 5$(9'%9,&E F#%$F %&

%)'$4


5/48

B'$


6/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'K

!"# %&'()**)*+

F#,$, %& ( /(',)' ',)


7/48

B'$


8/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'M

9() $,5/(9, '#, 94H5/,0 $,/('%4)& ?#%9# ?4+/< #(I, ),,


9/48

B'$


10/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'TU

() d; +)%I,$&%'B= ()< '#, [4+$)(/ %& ,


11/48

B'$


12/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'T5

3(A$%9('%)- '#%& 94HH+)%'B %) &+9# ( ?(B= '#,B /(B '#, -$4+)< 34$ '#%& 94HH+)%'B '4 A,


13/48

B'$,'?4$1 '#,4$B (&&+H,&

'#(' (9'4$& #(I, ( &'(A/, %


14/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'TE

B,' $,/(',< I,$&%4)&= ()< ),'?4$1& F %& #4?,I,$ %'&,/3 ( I,$B #,',$4-,),4+& 94)-/4H,$(',=

$('#,$ '#() ()B'#%)- '#(' 9() A, -$(&5,< (& ( Z$,&,($9# 5$4-$(HQ= ( Z5($(F '4

&1,'9# #4? %' (F 54&'+/(',& ,&&,)'%(//B '#, 4554&%', '#() ),'?4$1 '#,4$%,&= ?#%9# '(1, (9'4$&%F $,/('%4)& ($, ?#(' 94)&'%'+',&'#, (9'4$&E7^"5E 8


15/48

B'$


16/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'TK

'#, &49%(/ &9%,)9,& +/< A, 5,$34$H,< %& ( 54/%'%9(/ a+,&'%4) '#(' 9())4' A, &,''/,< AB ()B

34$H 43 Z&9%,)'%3%9Q H,()&E i,'= '#,&, a+,&'%4)& 9() A, ,05/%9(',F $,&,($9#,$&= 4)'4/4-%,& ($, 5$,3,$(A/, %3 '#,B F 5$4I%F %) H4'%4)E :) '#, &+99%)9' &,9'%4) ?, (// F ()< '4 ($-+, '#(' %' &5+$& %)',$,&'%)- a+,&'%4)& 34$ (

&49%4/4-B 43 '#,


17/48

B'$


18/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'TM

"4)9,5'& ($, %) H()B ?(B& 9$+9%(/ 34$ 4$-()%J%)- (9(


19/48

B'$


20/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'5U

43 &+9# ( 9#($(9',$ 34$H ( /($-,$ 5('',$) ()< ($, %)


21/48

B'$; 43 '#, d;8 3$4H CDDCE 8& &'(',< '#,$,S f8H,$%9( %& )4? '#$,(',),< /,&& AB

94)a+,$%)- &'(',& '#() ?, ($, AB 3(%/%)- 4),&gMF#, K#%', `4+&, CDDCS 7NE

Y4$, '#() A,34$, '#, 3(%/,< &'(', ?(& 5$,L,+H(B,$ MCDD6NO P%(JJ( MCDD_NO P%(JJ( MCDD^NE


22/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'55

(/&4 ( -$4?%)- '$,)< '4?($


23/48

@.F/# &*#H I4$&' 3*'&/B#*$ J4?) %//+&'$('%4)KGL

UD8AA$,I%('%4)&S 2.:2 w dEeE 2,5($'H,)' 34$ :)',$)('%4)(/ 2,I,/45H,)'O *Yt w j,$H() .,


24/48

.4$ H('',$& 43 &%H5/%3%9('%4)= '#, (9'4$& ?, 94+/< % +/< $,&54)< '4 '#%& -$4?%)- '#$,('EUU;'+


25/48

B'$8F@ M>8F@ CDDUO ;9#,33,$ CDD^N ()< '#,

d)%',< >('%4)& Md>N Mb/%(&&4) CDDXO d> CDD\N &,' +5 ?4$1%)- -$4+5&= %)%'%('%I, ()< '(&1

34$9,&= #,/< 94)3,$,)9,& ()< H,,'%)-& ()< 5+A/%,< $,54$'& ()< &'$(',-BL5(5,$& '4

(


26/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'5K

H(1,$& ()< :@& ,)',$,< '#, ),'?4$1= &,9+$%'BL4$%,)',< (& ?,// (&


27/48

B'$


28/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'5M

&%-)%3%9()'/B %)9$,(&,< M94H5($,< '4 '#, ,($/%,$ 349+& 4) -4I,$)()9, ()< ,94)4H%9

%&&+,&NE\X

8 &,94)< %)&'()9, 43 '$()&/('%4) %& '#, K4$/< *()1E 8& ?, ($-+,< '#, K4$/< *()1 ?(&

,)$4/,< %) '#, ),'?4$1 ($4+)< CDDCE .(%/,< &'(',& 5$4I%


29/48

B'$


30/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'6U

%)',$,&' ()< %


31/48

B'$


32/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'65

!I_# +*.' %" $@' "'$'# +, .4.0#B)4 7>F/)4.$)&*QL

F#%& &+--,&'& +& '#(' :G %& '#, H([4$ 94)'$%A+'4$ '4 '#, 9%$9+/('%4) 43 '#, 94)9,5'E F#,

5%9'+$,= '#4+-# ',//%)-= %& #4?,I,$ 5$4A/,H('%9 (& %' $,/%,& 4) '#, 9/+&',$%)- 43 '#, ;;": 43

?#,'#,$ ( 94)'$%A+'%4) %& :G 4$ A,/4)-& &4H,?#,$, ,/&,E :) 4'#,$ ?4$'*./ "'= &8 .'$)4/#6

8'&B $&7 ?LQ


33/48

B'$


34/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'6E

Y(//(AB= ; "4+)9%/ 43 .4$,%-) G,/('%4) K(%)-'4)= 2"=d;8

Y(J$+%= 88 ;+)B *%)-#(H'4)= :)&' j/4A(/ "+/'+$(/ ;'+('%4)&= j,),I(= ;?%'J,$/()4#'

":.PT .$(-%/%'B :)


38/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'6M

fF#, .(%/,< ;'(',& :)


39/48

B'$


40/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'EU

O= 3*.4$)*+ . 0)64)7/)*#; I"@ .*0 $,# 6&4)&/&+P &8 $,# 0)64)7/)*#

F#, 5$%H($B 4A[,9'%I, 43 '#%& ($'%9/, ?(& '4 54)F %& () ('',H5' '4 +)$(I,/ #4?

&9#4/($& M$,LN3(A$%9(', /($-,$ -/4A(/ &'$+9'+$,&E j/4A(/ &'$+9'+$,&= &+9# (& :G ($, #4?,I,$

)4' ),9,&&($%/B &'(A/, H(9$4 &'$+9'+$,&= A+' 9() A, &,,) (& -/4A(/ H%9$4&'$+9'+$,& 4$

&'$+9'+$,& 43 ( H4$, 3/+%< 9#($(9',$E :) %'& 54&'L5/+$(/%&' (''%'+F 433,$& ( 5,$&5,9'%I, %)

?#%9# ?, 9() &'+F %& (

'#,4$B 43 5,$34$H('%I%'BE F#, (%H %& )4' 4)/B '4 A, $,3/,9'%I, '4?($


41/48

B'$


42/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'E5

*$,%',)A(+9#= ,)$%1= ()< 8)('%4)(/ ;,9+$%'B ;'$(',-B 43 '#, d)%',< e%)-,4LF$+&',,%5S F#, h%H%'& '4 ;4/I%)- '#, P$4A/,H 43VP$,9($%4+& ;'(',#44 $@' >1/ 8'$,? i4$1S G4+'/,


43/48

B'$" 7))1%+# CM6NS UC]\\E"$491,$= "#,&',$ 8E CDDUAE b)-(-%)- .(%/,< ;'(',&E :)S C*+'%>" 7))1%+# ^C M6N= ;E UCL\\E"J($)%(?&1(= *($A($(E CDDÊ V@$-()%J%)-S #4? '4 &'+ I%#A 7##'##0'"$ 1"2 O+%#%# P1+.;

J1+"%"> D;#$'0#E h()#(H= @034$#E Y9h,()S ;9%,)9,855/%9('%4)& :)',$)('%4)(/ "4$54$('%4)E

b&'B= 2()%,/ "E= c(91 8E j4/9 a*-'+"1"4' 1"2 J*+.2 G+2'+ %" $@' Y" 3*.%4; M7\WN= ;E 6XLX6E

.+)< 34$ P,(9,E CDDXE F#, .(%/,< ;'(',& :)" 3*.%4; M7X7N= ;E 6\LXUE

.+)< 34$ P,(9,E CDDÊ F#, .(%/,< ;'(',& :)" 3*.%4; M7_UN= ;E DLÛEj(FEV D4%'"4'S Y'4@"*.*>; ?

\&01" d1.&'#U6M7NS 66L^DEj(&5,$= 2,&E CDD6E V;,9+$%)- +H()%'BS ;%'+('%)- r`+(H) ;,9+$%'Br (& "4)9,5' ()< 2%&94+$&,EVQ*&+"1. *) \&01"

,'-'.*/0'"$XMCNS CC7LC\6Ej,$H() .,


44/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'EE

j4/#E Y9h,()S ;9%,)9, 855/%9('%4)& :)',$)('%4)(/ "4$54$('%4)E

j4$2 "4$54$('%4)E`(H,%$%= ;#(#($E CDD_E .(%/,< ;'(',& 4$ ( .(%/,< P($('0'"$ 1"2

3'14' D4%'"4' C6 M\N= ;E U76LUU7Ec(91&4)= P('$%91 F#(


45/48

B'$0 )*+ ,'-'.*/0'"$E K,&'54$'S P$(,-,$ ;,9+$%'B:)',$)('%4)(/E

e,4#(),= G4A,$' @?,) CDDUE P4/%'%9(/ (+'#4$%'B (3',$ %)',$I,)'%4)S -$(" 7))1%+# ^\ M\N= ;E 76UL7XUEe$(0A,$-,$= *E YE CDD_E .(%/,< &'(',&S ',H54$($B 4A&'(9/,& '4 ,?

.4$,%-) P4/%9B %) '#, P(9%3%9 G,-%4)S "4)3,$,)9, $,54$' 43 '#, j,$H() P(9%3%9 >,'?4$1= CXLC_>4I,HA,$ CDD\= d)%I,$&%'B 43 `(HA+$-E >,+,),'?4$1 F#,4$B()< (3',$E @034$,? i4$1S G4+'/,E +)< cE ;E Y4$$%&4)E CDD\(E F#, ',$$4$%&' '#$,(' %) 83$%9(E :)S C*+'%>" 7))1%+# ^U M7N= ;E _6L}EhBH()= P$%)9,'4) >E +)< cE ;',5#,) Y4$$%&4)E CDD\AE F#, F,$$4$%&' F#$,(' %) 83$%9(E :)S C*+'%>" 7))1%+# ^U M7N= ;E

_6L^XEY(/,1E CDDXE ;'(', .(%/+$, %) '#, ;4+'# "(+9(&+&S P$454&(/& 34$ () 8)(/B'%9(/ .$(H,?4$1E :)S Y+1"#%$%*" D$&2%'#

I'-%'


46/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'EK

Y())= Y%9#(,/E 7W^Ê D$1$'#S J1+ 1"2 O1/%$1.%#0E >,? i4$1S */(91?,//EY($(//= Y4)'B jE +)< *EGE "4/,E CDDÊ j/4A(/ G,54$' 4) "4)3/%9'= j4I,$)()9,= ()< ;'(', .$(-%/%'B CDDÊ :)S

C*+'%>" 3*.%4; =&..'$%" 7^ M7N= ;E ULC7EY($(//= Y4)'B jE +)< c(91 j4/('%4)& 2,I,/45H,)' P$4-$(HH, Md>2PNE

Y,)1#(+&= e,)E 7WWÊ ;4H(/%(S P4/%'%9(/ @$Ê >,?

i4$1S G4+'/,,+H(B,$= bE CDD6E *4-+& $,3+-,,&k F#, ,?H()= b


47/48

B'$,? >('+$, 43 >('%4)L;'(', .(%/+$,E :)S J1#@%">$*" &1+$'+.; C6 MUN= ;E ^6LWXEG4'A,$-= G4A,$' :E= M`-EN= CDDU= D$1$' C1%.&+' 1"2 D$1$' J'1A"'## %" 1 Y%0' *) Y'++*+E K(%)-'4)S *$441%)-&

:)&'%'+'%4) P$,&&EG4'A,$-= G4A,$' :E= M`-EN= CDD\= J@'" D$1$'# C1%.9 O1'# 1"2 O*"#'h&'"4'#E P$%)9,'4)S P$%)9,'4) d)%I,$&%'B

P$,&&EG4'#9#%/(4H% "#(J()= M`-EN= 7W^^= Y@' 3+'41+%* =1.1"4'9 D$1$' 1"2 D*4%'$; %" 7)+%41E *4+/,? i4$1S "4$),//

d)%I,$&%'B P$,&&E;9#,33,$= c((5 8F@S F#, >,0' 2,9(


48/48

=&'>'+ ? ='$@A'EM

t($'H()= :EKE M,

Networking the Failed State

Documents

Transcript of Networking the Failed State