Nestle in the Pacific Northwest

download Nestle in the Pacific Northwest

of 4

Transcript of Nestle in the Pacific Northwest

  • 7/31/2019 Nestle in the Pacific Northwest

    1/4

    Page 2:

    Memo From the Chair

    ExCom Report Winter 2011-

    12 Earth Day Tree Planting

    Page 2:

    Portland Mayoral Debate

    on Environment Slated

    Free Documentary on

    Overpopulation

    Page 3:

    Upcoming Meetings

    Getaround For Sharing Your

    Own Idle Vehicle

    Page 4:

    Holiday Party/Alabarca

    Award photos U.S.A

    Forcing Coal On Kosovo?

    Explore, enjoy, and protect the planet

    A SIERRA CLUB publication from the Columbia Group of Oregon

    representing northwest Oregon including the Portland area

    Feb - apr 2012

    V 22, n 1

    by Joy Keen

    Did you know that Nestl, the largest foodand water company in the world, and the most

    boycotted, wants to build a water bottlingplant in the scenic Columbia River Gorge? It

    wants to bottle spring water from Oregonspublic lands and sell it for a 1000% prot. For

    over two years now, the Columbia Group water

    committee has been trying to stop this deplor-able plan. Nestl is not listed on any permit

    applications even though the City of CascadeLocks, where the plant would be located, and

    two separate state agencies have been working

    to make sure that the necessary water exchangehappens. Nestl has been greasing the skids

    with the state government agencies that havethe decision making power by paying to expe-

    dite permits and paying for all the necessaryenvironmental tests. Tis raises concerns overour states obligation to objectively review these

    permit applications and do whats best for thewater and wildlife of Oregon.

    Te Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife(ODFW) holds the water rights for Ox-

    bow Spring in the Columbia River Gorge,which it currently uses for a sh hatchery.

    o enable Nestl to bottle and sell the spring

    water, ODFW has proposed creating a waterexchange with the City of Cascade Locks:

    ODFW would get access to Cascade Locksmunicipal water (to use for its hatchery) and

    Cascade Locks would get access to the spring

    water which it would in turn sell to Nestl (at

    the municipal water rate). Nestl has oeredto pay for the necessary infrastructure to bringmunicipal water up to the hatchery. Tis water

    exchange is vital for Nestl being able to bottlespring water from Oxbow Springs. Nestl also

    plans to bottle Cascade Locks municipal water

    under its cheaper brand name, Pure Life.

    ODFWs water exchange permit proposal has

    to be approved by the Oregon Water Resources

    Department (OWRD) which has indicated

    it will make a decision any day now. Severalenvironmental organizations and thousands of

    concerned Oregonians have already contactedOWRD asking it to deny ODFWs water

    exchange application. Many have also askedGovernor Kitzhaber to direct both of these

    state agencies to stop this process. Tere is verylittle to gain for the State of Oregon and a lot

    to lose.

    Impacts to the state of Oregon, Cascade Locks

    and the Scenic Columbia River Gorge. Nestl

    acknowledges that the plant will create 200truck trips a day--or one every 8 minutes--

    right through the small downtown of CascadeLocks. Tese trucks will be driven on roads

    that were never designed to carry such heavyloads and Nestl refuses to pay for the neces-sary upgrades or damage to the roads, sticking

    ODO and the struggling city of CascadeLocks with the bill. Tere is concern about

    creating even more air pollution in the Gorgeand the harm it will do to the publics health

    and the areas tourism.

    Disposable water bottles are pollution. Bottled

    water wastes fossil fuels in production and

    transport. In 20 07, bottled water productionin the United States used the energy equiva-

    lent of 86 million barrels of oil to produce andtransport plastic bottles full of waterenough

    to fuel about 1.5 million cars for a year. Much

    of that water is water that people can get more

    easily, cheaply and quickly by just turning ontheir tap. Less than a 1/3 of the bottles are re-cycled so they end up in our landlls, lakes, and

    streams, where they may never fully decomposeand oen end up in Garbage Gyres in the

    oceans around the world.

    As climate change continues, fresh clean water

    is growing scarcer. It is important to preserve

    existing drinking water sources that may need

    to be used in the future as current municipal

    supplies face climate related impacts. Tere isno science to support the claim that bottled

    water is healthier and in fact, municipal wateris much more strictly regulated for safety. It

    takes 3 times more water than a plastic bottlewill hold to create one bottle of water. Nestl

    would be creating a wasteful and unnecessaryproduct while depleting the Gorges clean

    drinking water.

    Te Sierra Clubs guid ing principles on Water

    Commodication and Privatization are:

    Water is a public resource, not a commodity.

    Public policy must ensure the sustainability of

    safe water supplies for the b enet of all peopleand the natural environment.

    All water resources, including the oceans, must

    be protected as a public trust so that commer-

    cial use of water does not diminish public orecological benets.

    Access to clean, sucient and aordable drink-

    ing water is a human right necessary for humanhealth and survival. Tis right must be protect-

    ed by government policies and international

    agencies, consistent with ensuring access to safeand adequate quantities of water resources for

    all wildlife on the planet and sustainability ofthese resources.

    By allowing this water bottling plant to bebuilt, the state of Oregon would be violating

    these principles. If this disturbs you enough

    to get involved in this ght, please contact JoyKeen at 503-238-0442 x300 or email her at

    [email protected]

    Nestl: Out To Bottle The Columbia Gorge

    Oxbow Spring Water Diversion. Photo: Jim Lockhart

    Photos:NationalGeographicMagazine

  • 7/31/2019 Nestle in the Pacific Northwest

    2/4

    http://oregon.sierraclub.org/groups/columbia(503)238-0442 ext. 300 fax: (503)238-6281

    1821 SE Ankeny Street, Portland, OR 97214

    Looking for back issues? Visit http://oregon.sierraclub.org/groups/columbia/overlook/

    paGe 2 CUMbIa VerK

    EECTE COTTEE

    Chair Je Fryer [email protected]

    ice Chair Pat Nation [email protected]

    Secretary Samantha Lockhart [email protected]

    Treasurer Rhonda Diestel [email protected]

    At-Large Kendra Hodgson [email protected]

    Phaedra Booth [email protected]

    Dave Bybee [email protected]

    CONSEATON COTTEE

    Chair Scott Chapman [email protected]

    Land se/

    TransportationScott Chapman [email protected]

    ivers/Water Christine Lewis [email protected]

    Salmon Je Fryer [email protected]

    ANSTATE & POGA COONATOS

    Adopt-A-Trail Dave Bybee [email protected]

    Political/Legis. Nancy Hatch [email protected]

    Singles Group Dave Bybee [email protected]

    Outings Mike Newsham [email protected]

    OverlookEditor Je Fryer [email protected]

    Overlookesigner Samuel John Klein [email protected]

    Third Thursday Je Fryer [email protected]

    olunteer Phaedra Booth [email protected] Jim Maskus [email protected]

    Water Quality Nancy Hatch [email protected]

    CUMbIa GrUp eaDerSHIp DIreCTrY

    Columi Gou Cotct Ifomtio

    Fa 2012 Vol 22 no 1

    ExCom eport - Winter, 2011-12Contributed by Jef Fryer

    December: No meeting

    January:

    Te elections committee reported and the new Executive Committee was seated. New electedmembers are: Kendra Hodgson, Dave Bybee, Pat Nation, and Samantha Lockhart. Rhonda

    Diestel was appointed treasurer. Communications issues were discussed.

    February:

    Te new executive positions were elected with Je Fryer as the new chair, Pat Nation as vice-chair, and Samantha Lockhart as secretary. Te treasurers report was received. ExCom voted

    to allocate up to $20 0 for a potential appeal of an adverse Oregon Water Resources Departmentdecision on allowing Nestl to bottle water at Cascade Locks. ExCom voted to re-aliate withthe Coalition for a Livable Future. A budget committee was appointed. Meetings will be the

    second uesday of the month in 2012 beginning at 6:30 PM.

    emo from the Chairby Jef Fryer

    2012 is an election year, which once again means the Sierra Club oce will soon be busy withvolunteers interviewing ca ndidates vying for the coveted (at least in this area!) Club endorse-

    ment. Tis process is something that makes the Sierra Club unique for we are the only major

    environmental group that endorses candidates. Tis process oers volunteers rare insights intothe candidates that we are electing to oce. For instance, I was not surprised by the strange-

    ness of former Congressman Wu which in part led to his resignation for I have seen it myself inendorsement interviews over the years.

    Te endorsement process typically consists of sending out a questionnaire and then interviewingcandidates that return it. Based on both, as well as some other issues such as the viability of the

    candidate, we then decide who, if a nyone, to endorse. Te Columbia Group endorses local andstate candidates in its area, which runs from illamook to Arlington and south to McMinnville.

    Once we make endorsements, we will oen assist candidates in key races by phone banking and

    canvassing.

    If this sounds like fun, or to get more information, contact our Political Chair, Nancy Hatch [email protected].

    Film: other: Caring for 7 BillionHollywood Teater

    Monday, Februar y 20, 2012, 7:30pmFREE

    Mother, the lm, breaks a 40-year taboo by bringing to light an issue that silently fuels our larg-est environmental, humanitarian and social crises - population growth.

    Since the 1960s the world population has nearly doubled, adding more than 3 billion people. Atthe same time, talki ng about population has become politically incorrect because of the sensitiv-

    ity of the issues surrounding the topic religion, economics, family planning and gender inequal-ity.

    Te lm i llustrates both the over-consumption and the inequity side of t he population issue byfollowing Beth, a mother, a child-rights activist and the last sibling of a large American family

    of twelve, as she discovers the thorny complexities of the population dilemma and highlights a

    dierent path to solve it.

    All details on Facebook: http://pdx.be/7billion; the website: http://www.MothereFilm.com

    2012 Portland ayoral ebate onEnvironment Slated for AprilOn April 18, Portland mayoral candidates Eileen Brady, Charlie Hales, and Jeerson Smith will

    be asked to lay out their solutions for the challenges that face Portlands environment, publichealth, and natural resources.

    Te debate will be moderated by Oregon Public Broadcastings April Baer and will address arange of topics including climate change and clean energy, transportation, toxics and public

    health, and the management of Portlands special places.

    WHA:Portland Mayoral Debate on the Environment

    DEBAE MODERAOR: April Baer, Oregon Public Broadcasting

    WHEN: 6:30 p.m. to 8p.m., Wednesday, April 18, 2012. Te debate will begin promptly at

    6:30pm. Doors will open at 5:30pm.

    WHER E: Benson Polytechnic HS, Auditorium 546 NE 12th Avenue, Portland, OR

    CONAC: For questions about reservations or more information, contact Brian Pasko at

    503-238-0442 x301 or email at [email protected].

    TICKETS:Admissionisfeeochargebutreservationsmustbemadeinadvance.Seewebsiteat

    http://www.oregon.sierraclub.org/debateormoreinormation.

    The event is hosted by the Oregon Environmental Council, Oregon League of Conservation Voters, and the

    Oregon Chapter of the Sierra Club.

    Earth Day Tree PlantingCome join us on Saturday April 21st at Roster Rock State Park in the Columbia Gorge to celebrate

    the 42nd annual edition of Earth Day, as well as John Muirs birthdayrst president of the Sierra

    Club in 1892. Under direction of Oregon Parks & Recreations Glenn Littrell, this year well be plant-

    ing four dierent species of tree. Partnering with us again will be Safeway grocery stores, SOLV,

    Friends of the Historic Columbia River Highway and AANR. Bring your favorite gloves, shovel and wa-

    ter or use tools provided. Children are encouraged when they bring their parent or legal guardian.

    Folks will assemble at 9 a.m. in the Rooster Rock parking lot just west of the park headquarters building

    located at the shore of the Columbia River. Work will last about four hours. Take highway I-84 east to

    exit 25 then under the highway to the end of the road. Carpooling will leave at 8:15 a.m. from the south

    entrance to the MAX Gateway Park & Ride parking structure located just east of I-205 at 1321 NE 99th

    Ave, 97220; between Halsey and Glisan. Volunteers frequently gather after work parties for camaraderie

    and a late lunch at McMenamins Edgeeld.

    For further information contact Dave Bybee at [email protected],

    360-993-4247. If youd like to be added to Daves private email list for timely news about our Adopt-

    A-Trail partnership for maintaining Latourell Falls Trail or work on Milepost 2016 for rebuilding the

    Historic Columbia River Highway into a bicycle/pedestrian route from Portland to

    The Dalles, send Dave a simple Latourell email.

    http://oregon.sierraclub.org/groups/columbia/overlook/http://www.oregon.sierraclub.org/debatemailto:DaveBybee%40oregon.sierraclub.org?subject=Earth%20Day%20Tree%20Planting%20Infomailto:DaveBybee%40oregon.sierraclub.org?subject=Earth%20Day%20Tree%20Planting%20Infohttp://www.oregon.sierraclub.org/debatehttp://oregon.sierraclub.org/groups/columbia/overlook/
  • 7/31/2019 Nestle in the Pacific Northwest

    3/4

    Fa 2012 Vol 22 no 1 CUMbIa VerK paGe 3

    Weekly Email Updates!For weekly updates on meetings, outings, and singles cl ub

    activites, go to:

    http://www.oregon.sierraclub.org/groups/columbia/

    then click on the sign-up page and fll in the web orm.

    Join Us or an exciting Pacifc Northwest

    Oregon Adventure!

    When you spend time in the outdoors, do you often choose a

    Sierra Club outing? The members of the Columbia Group Outings

    Committee hope so!

    or the latest trips and activities, visit:

    www.outingsnorthwest.org

    EETNGS CALENAAll meetings are at Columbia Group Oces

    unless otherwise noted1821 S.E. Ankeny St, Portland

    Feb

    Thu 16 Thid Thusdy, potluck t 6:30 .m., pogm t 7 .m .

    Cotct: J Fy,[email protected]

    St 25 iqud ntul Gs Wok Gou 10:00 .m.

    Cotct: Td Glichm, [email protected]

    Tu 28 byod Col Tskfoc 7:00 .m.Cotct: u Stvs [email protected]

    ar

    Wd 7 High Dst Committ 7 .m.

    Cotct: bod bck, [email protected]

    Tu 13 excutiv Committ 6:30 .m.

    Cotct: J Fy,[email protected]

    Thu 15 Thid Thusdy, potluck t 6:30 .m., pogm t 7 .m.

    Cotct: J Fy,[email protected] g

    St 24 iqud ntul Gs Wok Gou 10 m

    Cotct: Cotct: Td Glichm, [email protected]

    Tu 28 byod Col Tskfoc 7:00 .m.

    Cotct: u Stvs, [email protected]

    Apr

    Wd 4 High Dst Committ 7 .m.

    Cotct: bod bck, [email protected]

    Tu 10 excutiv Committ 6:30 .m.

    Cotct: J Fy,[email protected]

    Thu 19 Thid Thusdy, potluck t 6:30 .m., pogm t 7 .m.

    Cotct: J Fy,[email protected]

    St 21 iqud ntul Gs Wok Gou 10:00 .m.

    Cotct: Cotct: Td Glichm, [email protected]

    Tu 24 byod Col Tskfoc 7:00 .m.

    Cotct: u Stvs [email protected]

    Need help achieving your

    Earth Day resolution?

    Allow us to assist.

    Holistic Approach to

    EnergyEfciency&

    Renewable Energy

    CCB# 189156

    To learn how we help Oregonians achieve their Earth Day resolutions for

    energy efciency and renewable energy, call or visit us on the web.

    1339 SE 8th AvePortland, OR 97232(503) 227-2047www.solutions21st.com

    by Scott Chapman & Steve Gutmann

    Mount abor resident Peter Brown made an extra $250 last

    month by renting his car to his neighbors. Its amazing!

    Tere are lots of people who live nearby and either bike or ridetransit everywhere, and dont want to own a car. I usually ride

    riMet to work, so Im happy to earn some money by rentingout my Subaru, which would otherwise just sit in my driveway.

    Peters renter, Nathan Tomas, is equally happy. I sent a rentalrequest to Peter, he accepted via a text message, and half anhour later, I was using his Subaru to do transport my lmmak-

    ing equipment to do some work for a nonprot that I help outsometimes. It was one of the easiest, simplest, most communi-

    ty-centered experiences Ive had. I was completely stoked, andhave been telling all my friends about it ever since.

    Peter and Nathan shared Peters car through Getaround, a SanFrancisco-based peer-to-peer car sharing service that recently

    expanded into Portland. Peer-to-peer services allow the sharing

    of personal vehicles. Getaround already has hundreds of usersand 75 car owners signed up in Portland, and thousands more

    have been sharing hundreds of vehicles in the San FranciscoBay Area and San Diego since early 2011. And Getaround s

    Portland expansion is about to get a boost: in February the

    City of Portland and Getaround will use a $1.7 million federal

    grant to expand service and study the impact of peer to peercar sharing on people s transportation habits in low incomeneighborhoods.

    Getaround is one of several San Francisco-based personal carsharing companies that include RelayRides, JustShareIt and

    Wheels. Tese companies all see opportunity in the fact thatthere are more than 240 million vehicles in the U.S. (more than

    one for every licensed dr iver!), most of which are expensive to

    own and idle more than 90 percent of the time. Getaroundsmission is to end car overpopulation, and because a surprising

    number of vehicle owners appear open to renting out their carsto earn some extra money, theyre well on their way. Tousands

    of owners have already signed up in California and Oregon,

    and because ever more young urban residents are, like Nathan,abandoning car ownership to save money or live a greener

    lifestyle, theres increasing rental demand, too.Last summer, Oregon Governor John Kitzhaber signed a bill

    changing statewide insurance rules so that car owners can rentout their vehicles without being held l iable for accidents or

    jeopardizing their auto coverage. Getaround provides a com-mercial insurance policy that covers the driver and replaces the

    owners coverage during a vehicle s rental through their plat-

    form. Tey make money by charging a 40% commission, whichis used to cover insurance and other overhead costs. Available

    cars in Portland range from an older Honda Civic hybrid for$3 an hour ($15 a day) to a luxury SUV going for $40 an hour

    (with a two-hour minimum).

    Unlike eet-based car-sharing companies like Zipcar and its

    competitors, Getaround already operates not only in the urbancore but also in less dense communities like Beaverton, Hills-

    boro and Lake Oswego. With Getaround, a building contrac-tor could make money renting out his truck to a neighbor to

    make a Costco or IKEA run on a Saturday; a group of soccer

    moms could split the ownership costs of a minivan; or a com-muter to Intel or Nike could rent out her car to colleag ues from

    the company parking lot to colleagues who carpool, ride transitor bike to work, but sometimes need a car for errands, appoint-

    ments or meetings during the workday.

    Nathan paid nothing to sign up with Getaround, and Peter

    paid nothing to register his Subaru. Owners can approve ordecline any rental request, so trying the service is a breeze. Ge-

    taround uses Facebooks social media platform and other data

    points to verify renters identity and to prevent fraud. Tey alsocheck driving records and use an Ebay-like peer rating system to

    keep participants on their best behavior.

    Companies like Getaround oer multiple community benets:

    Environmental: According to published academic researchstudies, people who rent cars by t he hour (i.e. car-sharers like

    Nathan) plan out their driving and therefore drive signicantly

    less than car t, while riding transit, walking and biking more.One great example of the benets of car sharing is a 2010 reportby Frost and Sullivan that showed that car sharing diminished

    global carbon dioxide emissions by 482,170 ons (that s half

    the weight of the Golden Gate Bridge!) Also, Getaround has15 electric vehicles (EVs) and dozens of hybrids in its Cali for-

    nia network, plus one EV and well over a dozen hybrids in thePortland Area so far. Increasing the number of EVs in the Ge-

    taround system should help accelerate the use of lower emission

    EVs in two ways: 1) EV buyers can help defray the additionalcost of these vehicles by renting them out; and 2) potential buy-

    ers can address their concerns about owning and maintainingan EV by trying one out and talking to actual owners ahead of

    making up their minds about buying one.

    Economic: Nathan doesnt have car payments, insurance pay-

    ments or maintenance and repair costs, and since he generally

    relies on his bikes or public transit, he has full control overmuch he spends on driving. According to TeDailyGreen.com,

    people generally spend only about $600 per year on car shar-ing, as opposed to an average of nearly $9,000 annually to own

    a car, per AAA.

    Social: Communities benet not only by reducing unneces-

    sary driving, reducing parking demand and recycling localdollars, but also by creating closer ties between neighbors. One

    Getaround member summed it up nicely:

    Want To ake oney And Share Your dle Car?aybe ts Time To Getaround!

    please see Getaround, Page 4

    PhotosCourtesyScottChapman

    mailto:[email protected]:?subject=tedgleichman%40mac.commailto:?subject=tedgleichman%40mac.comhttp://email.powweb.com/sqmail/src/[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:?subject=tedgleichman%40mac.comhttp://email.powweb.com/sqmail/src/[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:?subject=tedgleichman%40mac.comhttp://email.powweb.com/sqmail/src/[email protected]://email.powweb.com/sqmail/src/[email protected]:?subject=tedgleichman%40mac.commailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]://email.powweb.com/sqmail/src/[email protected]:?subject=tedgleichman%40mac.commailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]://email.powweb.com/sqmail/src/[email protected]:?subject=tedgleichman%40mac.commailto:[email protected]
  • 7/31/2019 Nestle in the Pacific Northwest

    4/4

    Fa 2012 Vol 22 no 1CUMbIa VerKpaGe 4

    ColumbiaOverlook

    SiClu,

    ColumiGou

    1821S.e.

    akyStt

    potld,

    r,

    97214

    nnprFITrG

    USpSTaGe

    paID

    prTanDr

    perMIT1090

    Since 1987, Moving Portland andBeyond to an Environmentally

    Sustainable Future.

    Grid-tied Photovoltaics &Solar Water Heating.

    www.solarenegyoregon.com

    503-238-4502

    Colum

    bia

    Overlook

    F-ail2012

    Vol22num1

    InTHISISSUe:

    neSTTbTTeTHeG

    rGe

    FreeVerppUaTIn

    DCUMenTarY

    CarSHarInGYUrWn

    Car

    MaYraenVIrnMen

    TDebaTe

    If Getaround disappeared tomorrow, I would

    also miss the feeling of community connec-tion I have experienced from renting my ca r to

    people in my neighborhood. Ive met friendly,

    interesting people, all of whom have been grate-ful for my willingness to rent to them and who

    have treated me and my car with respect. Itsounds cheesy, but getting to meet and rent my

    car to some of the strangers I would otherwisepass on the street every day makes me feel

    more connected to my neighborhood and less

    anonymous in this big city. Oering my vehicleto a stranger is an act of trust and sharing, and

    when the individual reciprocates by behaving asa friendly and responsible borrower, it validates

    that trust and builds social capital.

    by Justin Guay and Mary Anne Hitt

    Tats the question we have been asking the

    U.S. G overnment over and over, aer discover-

    ing their steadfast support for plans to build anextremely expensive, extremely dirty coal plant

    in Kosovo. We rst sounded the alarm overthis project months ago and despite essentially

    admitting that our concerns are valid, the State

    Department and the World Bank are recklesslypushing forward a plan to leave the tiny coun-

    try saddled with a heavily polluting new coalplant along with unsustainable levels of debt at

    a time when the EUs debt crisis threatens theglobal economy.

    So how do we k now the project is so bad? Wecommissioned expert analysis from a former

    chief Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

    enforcement ocer who found glaring aws(check out our initial analysis at http://action.si-

    erraclub.org/site/DocServer/Review_of _TOR_

    Final.pdf?doc ID=8341) in the project design.

    First and foremost he found that the plant willlikely cost 2-3 times what project proponents

    claim. Tese costs would be borne by a countrystruggling to rebuild aer years of war and

    would take the form of foreign debt that will

    have to be repaid by raising rates on averagecitizens. Tis is eerily similar to what hap-

    pened with the World Banks last coal loan toEskom and has led the nations leading nightly

    news program to ask probing questions about a

    European Eskom.

    Even worse, he found that Kosovo doesnt evenneed the power they simply dont have enoughbase load demand to justify such a large power

    project. In fact the project would lead to a gen-erating capacity that is three times higher than

    existing demand and four times higher whencorrected for avoidable losses.

    Tis means Kosovo consumers (or the govern-ment) would have to service over a bil lion

    euro in debt at a time instead of investing in

    what Kosovo does need an upgrade of its

    leaky electricity g rid (an ancient relic le over

    from the soviet era that loses up to 40% of its

    supplies) and new f orms of peak power (juiceto power the lights when people wake up andwhen they come home from work). Reducing

    the losses from this leaky bucket, combined

    with job creating energy eciency programs,completely eliminates the need for a dirty,

    expensive new coal plant.

    So how did State Department and the World

    Bank respond? Just months aer we sent t hemour ndings, the World Bank released a new

    report that supported our conclusions: a newcoal plant will cost twice as much as they

    rst estimated, and the country does indeed

    have signicant clean energy potential. But,their central conclusion remained unchanged:

    Kosovo simply must have an expensive, un-needed, dirty new coal plant (you can see our

    rebuttal rearming that Kosovo doesnt need a

    new coal plant here).

    Given this response, it is clear that exploring

    alternative energy options th at dont threatenpeoples health, raise their rates, or threaten

    unsustainable levels of debt are simply not inthe cards at t he State Department or the World

    Bank. As a result the country has become anepicenter of a struggle between local communi-

    ties and powerful international players over the

    future direction of their young country.

    Our members are standing rm with the citi-

    zens of Kosovo demanding the State Depart-

    ment relinquish support for this dirty new coalplant.

    Tis project would rob a young generation of

    Kosovo citizens of the clean, healthy futurethey deserve. Join us in telling the State De-

    partment No Coal in Kosovo.

    Justin Guay works with the Sie rra Club Interna-tional Campaign. Mary Anne Hitt is Directorof the Sierra Club Beyond Coal Campaign. is

    article originally appeard in the Sierra ClubInsider newsletter of Feb. 7th, 2012.

    Getaround,continued from page 3

    .S. Pushing Coal on Kosovo?

    2010 Holiday Party / Alabarca Award Event

    Aboe right: Christine Le wis (r) presents Emma Newman (r) with the Adam Alabarca award

    at this years Columbia Group Holiday E vent. Aboe le : Ann Grin of Inner Cit y Outings

    speaks at the eve nt. Photos courtesy o f Je Fryer.

    Below: Participants in the 2011 Earth Day Tree planting event enjoy ne weather and fellow-

    ship in preserving, protec ting and enjoying contribut ing to our enironmental qual ity. Another

    outing is slated for this coming April 21st. For details, see the article on Page 2.

    Photos courtesy: Dave Bybee .

    OxbowSpringPhotoGaryBraasch

    UsedwithPermission

    http://action.sierraclub.org/site/DocServer/Review_of_TOR_Final.pdf?docID=8341http://action.sierraclub.org/site/DocServer/Review_of_TOR_Final.pdf?docID=8341http://action.sierraclub.org/site/DocServer/Review_of_TOR_Final.pdf?docID=8341http://action.sierraclub.org/site/DocServer/Review_of_TOR_Final.pdf?docID=8341http://action.sierraclub.org/site/DocServer/Review_of_TOR_Final.pdf?docID=8341http://action.sierraclub.org/site/DocServer/Review_of_TOR_Final.pdf?docID=8341