Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

25
I Tamar Chachibaia, Tbilisi, Georgia, 2010

description

06 April 2010, Tamar Z. Chachibaia-Saginashvili. Georgian nanoscientists organise themselves Georgia is the first country in the history of the development of nanotechnologies in which the Georgian Orthodox and Apostolic Church ideologically supports its development. The NANO-2010 conference held 23-24 March 2010 was the 1st Nanochemistry & Nanotechnologies meeting conducted under the auspices of the Catholic Patriarch of All Georgia Ilia II. The conference was held and sponsored by the St. Andrew the First-Called Georgian University of the Patriarchy of Georgia in 23-24 March in Tbilisi. The organizing committee was headed by the rector of the University Dr. Parmen Margvelashvili. Committee members were Dr. David Jishiashvili, Dr. Shota Sidamonidze, Dr. A. Gerasimov, Dr. R. Chikovani and responsible secretary T. Napetvaridze. Scientists presented the results of their work undertaken during recent years. 56 reports were presented from the research groups. Some of them were collaborative investigations, most were original investigations. There is a high impact of patent applications, as well as a high publication rate. By the end of April the collection of publications is anticipated. During the conference colleagues proposed to consolidate joint efforts and intellectual resources of all scientists working in the Nanotechnology sphere in Georgia. The idea of initiation of activities through the establishment of the Initiative Group was announced and accepted during round table discussions. Short term goals were outlined. The most important was to achieve governmental support. The participants also acknowledged the preexisting Responsible Nanotechnology Center, established in 2005 and initiated by Tamar Z. Chachibaia-Saginashvili. More information:

Transcript of Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Page 1: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

I Tamar Chachibaia, Tbilisi, Georgia, 2010

Page 2: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

_________________________________________________________

Tamar Tamar ChachibaiaChachibaiaResponsible Nanotechnology Center

web-page: http://gnni.com.ge

E-mail: [email protected]

Presentation for the NAN0-2010 Conferencein in NanochemistryNanochemistry & Nanotechnologies& Nanotechnologies

In the St. Andrew the First-Called Georgian University

2323--24 March24 March

Page 3: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

AWARNESS OF THE FUTUREAWARNESS OF THE FUTURE

‘‘It is time that we educate ourselves about our possible It is time that we educate ourselves about our possible future and future and ‘‘the best way to predict the future is to the best way to predict the future is to create itcreate it’’

Alan Kay

Page 4: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Sustainability is based on the three core pillars of economy, ecology and social responsibility.

Sustainability means long-term far-sighted

economical success combined with protection of environment and being

socially responsible.

Page 5: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

2121stst Century Century -- New Era of Convergent New Era of Convergent TechnologiesTechnologies

Page 6: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Convergent Technologies of 21st Century

Cognitive Sciences

Biotechnology

Information Technology

Nanotechnology

Page 7: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Currently, Atomic Coup Goes BANG!the term “BANG” theory theory describes technological technological convergence ofBits, Atoms, Neurons and Genes -- to control all matter, life to control all matter, life and knowledge.and knowledge.

Convergent Technologies Convergent Technologies

INFOINFO

Information technology controls: Bits

Nanotechnology controls and manipulates:Atoms

Cognitive Neurosciences enables control of the mind by manipulating:

NeuronsBiotechnology controls and manipulates life by engineering:

Genes

BIOBIO

COGNOCOGNO

NANONANO

Page 8: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

We can look how publications and patents change recently according to certain technology. Patents and publications are two main domains of economic growth. Bibliometric analysis reflect rate of university inventions, while patent analysis is indicator of industrial activity.

State governments support and funding is also main indicator of excellence of technology.

BibliometricBibliometric & Patent Analysis& Patent Analysisreflecting university inventions rate and reflecting university inventions rate and

commercialization opportunitiescommercialization opportunities

Page 9: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Credit: IBM

Nobel Prize AwardsNobel Prize Awards19861986

IBM IBM -- BinnigBinnig & Rohrer& Rohrer19901990

EiglerEigler & Schweitzer& Schweitzer

Page 10: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

1996 1996 Nobel Price in ChemistryNobel Price in Chemistry

Robert F. Curl Jr. & Robert F. Curl Jr. & Richard E. Smalley Richard E. Smalley

&&Harold W. Harold W. KrotoKroto

for their discovery of for their discovery of buckminsterfullerene, buckminsterfullerene, the scientific name for the scientific name for

buckyballsbuckyballs

Page 11: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

As the US National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) is As the US National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) is commencing, there is a rare opportunity to commencing, there is a rare opportunity to integrate the societal studies and dialogues from integrate the societal studies and dialogues from the very beginning and to include societal studies the very beginning and to include societal studies as a core part of the NNI investment strategy. as a core part of the NNI investment strategy.

For the first time in the history happens that For the first time in the history happens that social scientists have such a participatory social scientists have such a participatory role in a nanotechnology development.role in a nanotechnology development.

Realistic approach to the development of NT Realistic approach to the development of NT is characteristic for US government. Most is characteristic for US government. Most scientist share similar reasonable responsive scientist share similar reasonable responsive attitude.attitude.

Page 12: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

President George W. Bush signed into law the “21st Century Nanotechnology Research and Development Act” - 3rd of

December, 2003

In the January 2000

President Clinton’s program speech

on establishing

National Nanotechnolo

gy Initiative (NNI) at Caltech.

Page 13: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

NANONANO--201020102323--24 March 24 March

1st Conference in 1st Conference in NanochemistryNanochemistry & Nanotechnologies & Nanotechnologies In the St. Andrew the FirstIn the St. Andrew the First--Called Georgian UniversityCalled Georgian University

For the first time in the history of the

development of nanotechnologies Georgia is the first country in which

Georgian Orthodox and Apostolic Church

supports its development.

Page 14: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

During conference During conference NANONANO--2010,2010, which was the 1st which was the 1st NanochemistryNanochemistry & & Nanotechnologies meeting organized by the Patriarchy of Georgia Nanotechnologies meeting organized by the Patriarchy of Georgia in in 2323--24 March in Tbilisi in the St. Andrew the First24 March in Tbilisi in the St. Andrew the First--Called Georgian Called Georgian University.University. www.sangu.ge.Colleagues proposed to consolidate joint effort and intellectualColleagues proposed to consolidate joint effort and intellectualresources of all scientists working in Nanotechnology sphere in resources of all scientists working in Nanotechnology sphere in Georgia. Georgia. The idea of initiation of activities through establishment of thThe idea of initiation of activities through establishment of the Initiative e Initiative Group was announced and accepted during round table discussions.Group was announced and accepted during round table discussions.Short term goals were outlined, out of them most important to acShort term goals were outlined, out of them most important to achieve hieve governmental support.governmental support.

Page 15: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies
Page 16: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

From the moment of its foundation From the moment of its foundation nanotechnology was unequivocally considered nanotechnology was unequivocally considered from the multi dimensional perspective.from the multi dimensional perspective.General public, as well as scientists are split in General public, as well as scientists are split in distinctive successors, on the one hand, distinctive successors, on the one hand, nanonanoradicalsradicals, with optimistic, almost futuristic beliefs , with optimistic, almost futuristic beliefs in nanotechnology, on the other hand, in nanotechnology, on the other hand, nanonanoskepticsskeptics, with their prominent , with their prominent nanophobicnanophobicprecautionsprecautions…… and in fine, and in fine, nanonano realistsrealists, with , with clear materialistic attitude to this emerging clear materialistic attitude to this emerging technology like US government. technology like US government.

Page 17: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Nano Optimism, Realism &Pessimism

• Eric Drexler• Ray Kurzweil• Michel Roco & • W. Bainbridge• Transhumanists• Futurists• Robert A. Freitas Jr.

•• Bill Joy Bill Joy •• Prince of Wales Prince of Wales

Charles Charles •• Michael CrichtonMichael Crichton•• President's Council President's Council

on Bioethicson Bioethics•• ETC Group ETC Group •• Friends of the EarthFriends of the Earth

Page 18: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Blue for those that are neutral or mixed.

Green for nanotechnology development that are bening and good.

Red, for things that need to be thought about

Page 19: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

For the first time in the history of technology

development NT is governed in most responsible way

from the very beginning.

Technology should be ever greener then could be imagined.

Page 20: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

• Moreover David Rejeskienvisioned development of green NT in 3 main directions.

• Dark Green: Nanotechnology is applied directly to solve environmental problems.

• Light Green: Nanotechnology provides environmental benefits for other applications.

• Right Green: Nano-based processes and products are designed to be environmentally low-impact (life-cycle analysis,design for environment, etc.).

Nanotech: Rolling to MarketDavid Rejeski, Director

Project on Emerging NanotechnologiesEPA Grantees Meeting

October 26, 2005

Page 21: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Why is crucial Innovation

management in the period of technology

revolution?

How to perform timely the Innovation?

Page 22: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Innovator - you are willing to try unproven results / be an initiator for R&D in the field;Early adopter - you aim to be among the first to market products with new technologies;Late adopter - you introduce new technologies only after they have been widely popularized;Late follower - you introduce new technologies only when current solutions become obsolete.

Adoption of new technologies

Page 23: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

We should know about steps of technology development

• Technology trigger.

• Peak of inflated expectations.

• Trough of disillusionment.

• Slope of enlightenment.

• Plateau of productivity.

Page 24: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Thank you for your time

Page 25: Nano 2010 ELSI for Resposible Development of Nanotechnologies

Questions?