Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications-Review

5
Overture PsycCRITIQUES !/<C/@G ,=: %= @B71:3 I ;3@71/< 'AG16=:=571/: AA=17/B7=< Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications (3D73E =4 Melodies of the Mind: Connections Between Psychoanalysis and Music 0G !C:73 !/4433 %/53: %3E .=@9 %. (=CB:3253*/G:=@ @/<17A @=C> >> )% >/>3@0/19 >/>3@0/19 6BB>2F2=7=@5/ (3D73E32 0G )6/@/ )/<2 !C:73 !/4433 %/53: 6/A E@7BB3< / A:7; >@=D=1/B7D3 D=:C;3 7< E6716 A63 3F/;7<3A ;CA71 B6@=C56 / >AG16=/</:GB71 :3<A /<2 B63< CA3A B6/B :3<A B= 3F/;7<3 1:7<71/: ;/B3@7/: )3D3@/: =4 B63 16/>B3@A /@3 0/A32 =< /@B71:3A >@3D7=CA:G >C0:7A632 0CB ;C16 =4 B63 ;/B3@7/: 7A <3E )63 3<5/53A 7< / A=>67AB71/B32 /<2 AGAB3;/B71 :/G3@7<5 =4 ;CA71 B63=@G /<2 >AG16=/</:GB71 B63=@G E3/D7<5 1:7<71/: 3F/;>:3A 7< 03BE33< B63 BE= B6CA 1@3/B7<5 / B756B:G 9<7B 1=;>=A7B7=< E/A 3F17B32 B= @3/2 /<2 @3D73E B67A 0==9 4=@ / <C;03@ =4 @3/A=<A 7@AB /A %/53: AB/B3A ;CA71 7A B63 <35:31B32 /@B 7< >AG16=/</:GA7A /<2 A31=<2 B63@3 /@3 A= 43E 1=<A3@D/B=@G B@/7<32 ;CA717/<A E6= /@3 /:A= >AG16=:=57ABA>AG16=/</:GABA A>3/9 4@=; / A7;7:/@ ;7<2 /A / 1=<A3@D/B=@GB@/7<32 B@=;0=<7AB /<2 / >AG16=/</:GB71/::G =@73<B32 >AG16=:=57AB *63@34=@3 7B 7A E7B6 C<7?C3 >:3/AC@3 B6/B 47<2 ;GA3:4 3<5/57<5 E7B6 %/53:NA 723/A 2= <=B 3F>3@73<13 B63 >3@>:3F32 @3/1B7=< B6/B A= ;/<G =B63@A 6/D3 B=E/@2 ;3 E63< E=<23@7<5 6=E 272 3D3@ 47<2 ;G E/G 4@=; ;CA71 B= >AG16=:=5G $G @3A>=<A3 7A /:E/GA B6/B B63G 0=B6 7<D=:D3 :7AB3<7<5 /<2 /< 3F?C7A7B3 /BBC<3;3<B B= B63 1=;;C<71/B7=< =4 =B63@A %/53: 1=<D3GA B67A A3<B7;3<B /A A63 23:D3A 7<B= B63 C<1=<A17=CA >@=13AA3A 7<D=:D32 7< B63 1=;;C<71/B7=< =4 E=@2A /<2 ;CA71 Melodies of the Mind: Connections Between Psychoanalysis and Music 7A =@5/<7H32 /<2 3F31CB32 ;C16 :793 / ;CA71/: 1=;>=A7B7=< 7B 7A 27D7232 7<B= B6@33 >/@BA A7;7:/@ B= / AG;>6=<GNA B6@33 ;=D3;3<BA *63 47@AB ;=D3;3<B 3F/;7<3A 3/@:G >AG16=/</:GB71 B63=@G 3A>317/::G @3C2NA /:;=AB/1B7D3 27A:793 =4 ;=AB ;CA71 E7B6 B63 3F13>B7=< =4 A=;3 =>3@/A *67A @3AC:B32 7< 67A :/19 =4 7<B3@3AB 7< 3F>:=@7<5 ;CA71 /</:GB71/::G /A 63 AB/B32

description

Crítica do aclamado livro Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications

Transcript of Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications-Review

Page 1: Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications-Review

Overture

PsycCRITIQUES!/<C/@G���� �����,=:�����%=�����@B71:3��

I� �����;3@71/<�'AG16=:=571/:��AA=17/B7=<

Musical Tonality and PsychoanalyticCommunications

��(3D73E�=4

Melodies of the Mind: Connections Between Psychoanalysis and

Music

0G !C:73�!/4433 %/53:

%3E�.=@9��%.��(=CB:3253*/G:=@����@/<17A��@=C>�� ��������>>

)�%������������� ������>/>3@0/19���������>/>3@0/19

6BB>�2F2=7=@5������/���� ��

(3D73E32�0G

)6/@/ )/<2

!C:73�!/4433�%/53:�6/A�E@7BB3<�/�A:7;��>@=D=1/B7D3�D=:C;3�7<�E6716�A63�3F/;7<3A�;CA71

B6@=C56�/�>AG16=/</:GB71�:3<A�/<2�B63<�CA3A�B6/B�:3<A�B=�3F/;7<3�1:7<71/:�;/B3@7/:�)3D3@/:

=4�B63�16/>B3@A�/@3�0/A32�=<�/@B71:3A�>@3D7=CA:G�>C0:7A632��0CB�;C16�=4�B63�;/B3@7/:�7A�<3E

)63�3<5/53A�7<�/�A=>67AB71/B32�/<2�AGAB3;/B71�:/G3@7<5�=4�;CA71�B63=@G�/<2�>AG16=/</:GB71

B63=@G��E3/D7<5�1:7<71/:�3F/;>:3A�7<�03BE33<�B63�BE=��B6CA�1@3/B7<5�/�B756B:G�9<7B

1=;>=A7B7=<

�E/A�3F17B32�B=�@3/2�/<2�@3D73E�B67A�0==9�4=@�/�<C;03@�=4�@3/A=<A��7@AB��/A�%/53:�AB/B3A�

;CA71�7A�B63�<35:31B32�/@B�7<�>AG16=/</:GA7A��/<2��A31=<2��B63@3�/@3�A=�43E�1=<A3@D/B=@G�

B@/7<32�;CA717/<A�E6=�/@3�/:A=�>AG16=:=57ABA>AG16=/</:GABA� �A>3/9�4@=;�/�A7;7:/@�;7<2�

/A�/�1=<A3@D/B=@G�B@/7<32�B@=;0=<7AB�/<2�/�>AG16=/</:GB71/::G�=@73<B32�>AG16=:=57AB

*63@34=@3�7B�7A�E7B6�C<7?C3�>:3/AC@3�B6/B� �47<2�;GA3:4�3<5/57<5�E7B6�%/53:NA�723/A� �2=�<=B

3F>3@73<13�B63�>3@>:3F32�@3/1B7=<�B6/B�A=�;/<G�=B63@A�6/D3�B=E/@2�;3�E63<�E=<23@7<5

6=E�272� �3D3@�47<2�;G�E/G�4@=;�;CA71�B=�>AG16=:=5G��$G�@3A>=<A3�7A�/:E/GA�B6/B�B63G�0=B6

7<D=:D3�:7AB3<7<5�/<2�/<�3F?C7A7B3�/BBC<3;3<B�B=�B63�1=;;C<71/B7=<�=4�=B63@A�%/53:

1=<D3GA�B67A�A3<B7;3<B�/A�A63�23:D3A�7<B=�B63�C<1=<A17=CA�>@=13AA3A�7<D=:D32�7<�B63

1=;;C<71/B7=<�=4�E=@2A�/<2�;CA71

Melodies of the Mind: Connections Between Psychoanalysis and Music 7A�=@5/<7H32�/<2

3F31CB32�;C16�:793�/�;CA71/:�1=;>=A7B7=<��7B�7A�27D7232�7<B=�B6@33�>/@BA��A7;7:/@�B=�/

AG;>6=<GNA�B6@33�;=D3;3<BA�*63�47@AB�;=D3;3<B�3F/;7<3A�3/@:G�>AG16=/</:GB71�B63=@G�

3A>317/::G��@3C2NA�/:;=AB�/1B7D3�27A:793�=4�;=AB�;CA71��E7B6�B63�3F13>B7=<�=4�A=;3�=>3@/A

*67A�@3AC:B32�7<�67A�:/19�=4�7<B3@3AB�7<�3F>:=@7<5�;CA71�/</:GB71/::G��/A�63�AB/B32�

Page 2: Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications-Review

Act I

�A�4=@�7<AB/<13�E7B6�;CA71�� �/;�/:;=AB�7<1/>/0:3�=4�=0B/7<7<5�/<G�>:3/AC@3�)=;3

@/B7=</:7AB71��=@�>3@6/>A�/</:GB71��BC@<�=4�;7<2�7<�;3�@303:A�/5/7<AB�037<5�;=D32�0G�/

B67<5�E7B6=CB�9<=E7<5�E6G� �/;�B6CA�/4431B32�/<2�E6/B�7B�7A�B6/B�/4431BA�;3���@3C2�

����������>� ���

*63�0==9NA�A31=<2�;=D3;3<B�7A�/�B63;3�E7B6�D/@7/B7=<A�%/53:�>@3A3<BA�L1/A3�3BB3AM

�7443@3<B�>AG1671�>@=13AA3A�/<2�3;=B7=<A�/@3�7::CAB@/B32�B6@=C56�B63�;CA71/:�AB@C1BC@3�

B=</:7BG��=@163AB@/B7=<��E6716�7<AB@C;3<BA�>:/G�13@B/7<�>/@BA���/<2�0@734�1:7<71/:�D75<3BB3A

)63�1/<�234B:G�;=D3�4@=;�;CA71/:�/</:GA7A�B=�>AG16=:=571/:�/</:GA7A��3F>:71/B7<5

>AG16=/</:GB71�;/B3@7/:�/A�A63�23:D3A�7<B=�63@�>/B73<BAN�3;=B7=</:�:7D3A�*63�B67@2�;=D3;3<B

7A�/�@31/>7BC:/B7=<�=4�A=;3�=4�B63�B63;3A�4@=;�B63�47@AB�;=D3;3<B��/<2�3F/;7<3A�;CA71�

>AG16=/</:GB71�;3/<7<5A��/<2�B63�>=B3<B7/:�A=17/:�/<2�A=173B/:�7;>:71/B7=<A�E7B6=CB�B63

7<1:CA7=<�=4�/A�;C16�7<�23>B6�;CA71/:�/</:GA7A

*63�;CA71/:�/</:GA3A�/@3�B6=@=C56�/<2�E=C:2�;/93�/<G�;CA71=:=57AB�>@=C2��B6=C56� N;�4/@

3<=C56�/E/G�4@=;�;G�=E<�1=<A3@D/B=@G�2/GA�B6/B� �1/<NB�A/G�E63B63@�A63�6/A�CA32�/

)163<93@��"37:3@��������/</:GA7A��B6=C56�7B�A33;A�A63�6/A� �;3<B7=<�)163<93@�/</:GA7A��<=B

031/CA3� �B67<9�B63�;/8=@7BG�=4�/</:GABA�@3/27<5�B67A�@3D73E�E7::�9<=E�67A�E=@9�=<�;CA71��0CB

031/CA3�/�)163<93@�/</:GA7A�7A�/�AC0831B7D3�=<3�@34:31B7<5�B63�;CA71/:�7<BC7B7=<A�=4�B63

:7AB3<3@/</:GAB�*63�/</:GA7A�@3>@3A3<BA�/�E/G�=4�63/@7<5��@3/27<5��/<2�C<23@AB/<27<5�/

>7313�=4�;CA71�B6/B�7A�1=;>:3F��23:D7<5�233>3@�B6/<�/�A7;>:3�B=</:�/</:GA7A

�A� �4=::=E32�%/53:NA�/ABCB3�/</:GA7A�=4�B63�B@7B=<3�7<��3@<AB37<NA�L�33��&44713@�"@C>93M�4@=;

West Side Story��;G�AB@C55:3�B=�63/@�B63�>7B163A�/<2�7<B3@D/:A�@3AC:B32�7<�C<1=;4=@B/0:3

/<2�4@CAB@/B7<5�/AA=17/B7=<A�B=�;CA71�B63=@G�1:/AA� �A/G�B67A�031/CA3�B63�;CA71/:�/</:GA7A

;/G�03�@/B63@�274471C:B�4=@�B6=A3�E7B6=CB�/<G�;CA71/:�B@/7<7<5�B=�C<23@AB/<2��=E3D3@��3D3<

4=@�=<3�E7B6=CB�;CA71/:�B@/7<7<5��B63�1:7<71/:�/</:GA7A�/<2�/A>31BA�=4�7<B3@</:�>AG1671�:743�/@3

/113AA70:3��/A�/@3�B63�27A1CAA7=<A�=4�B63�3;=B7=</:�B3<A7=<A�1@3/B32�7<�B63�;CA71�7BA3:4��3D3<

E7B6=CB�B63�B63=@3B71/:�C<23@AB/<27<5

�=@�B6=A3�<=E�E=<23@7<5�E6/B�/ tritone 7A�� N::�=443@�/�0@734�3F>:/</B7=<���B@7B=<3�7A�/

;CA71/:�7<B3@D/:�B6/B�1@3/B3A�/<�/C@/:�B3<A7=<�B6/B�035A�4=@�@3A=:CB7=<��@734:G��B63�;/7<AB/G

=4�;C16�=4�-3AB3@<�;CA71�7A�0/A32�=<�B63�6/@;=<71�A3@73A�CA32�2C@7<5�B63�>/AB����J���

G3/@A�&<�/�A3D3<�<=B3�A1/:3��B63�>@7;/@G�B=<3A�/@3�B63�47@AB������4=C@B6������/<2�474B6����

<=B3A�=4�B63�A1/:3���B@7B=<3�1/<�03�37B63@�/�A6/@>�����4=C@B6��/�6/:4�AB3>�/0=D3�B63�4=C@B6�

=@�/�4:/B������B6��/�6/:4�AB3>�03:=E�B63�474B6�*63�B@7B=<3NA�7<B3@D/:�1@3/B3A�/<�/C@/:�27A1=;4=@B

7<�B63�:7AB3<3@�/A�B63�3/@�G3/@<A�4=@�/�@3A=:CB7=<��37B63@�/�6/:4�AB3>�C>�B=�/�474B6�=@�/�6/:4�AB3>

2=E<�B=�/�4=C@B6

�=@�3F/;>:3��7<�/���;/8=@�A1/:3��������/<2���/@3�B63�=@5/<7H7<5�B=</:7B73A�*63�B@7B=<3

7<B3@D/:�E=C:2�03����=@�����E7B6�B63�@3A=:CB7=<�/�;=D3;3<B�B=�37B63@���=@���%/53:

7<B@=2C13A�63@�/</:GA7A�=4�B63�B@7B=<3�7<�L�33��&44713@�"@C>93M�0G�AB/B7<5�B6/B�7B�L@3>@3A3<BA�/

A=<71�;3B/>6=@�4=@�/;075C7BG��@3AB:3AA<3AA��/<2�7<AB/07:7BGM��>�����)63�3:/0=@/B3A�=<�B67A�

/@B71C:/B7<5�B6/B�B63�B@7B=<3�@3>@3A3<BA�B63�B3<A7=<�/<2�27A1=@2�03BE33<�B63�@/17/::G�/:75<32

5/<5A��B63�-67B3�!3BA�/<2�B63�'C3@B=�(71/<�)6/@9A�)63�7<B3@>@3BA��3@<AB37<NA�CA3�=4�B63

B@7B=<3�L/A�/<�7<B3@D/:��/A�/�;=2C:/B7=<�/<2�/A�/�B=</:�13<B3@�/B�B63�1=<1:CA7=<�=4�B67A

Page 3: Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications-Review

Act II

@=CA7<5�<C;03@����;CA71/::G�/97<�B=�E6/B�>AG16=/</:GABA�E=C:2�@343@�B=�/A

=D3@23B3@;7</B7=<��27A>:/13;3<B�/<2=@�;C:B7>:3�4C<1B7=<M��>�� �

4�B63�>@3D7=CA�BE=�>/@/5@/>6A�/@3�1=;>@363<A70:3��B63<�B67A�0==9�;/G�03�4=@�G=C� 4�/A�/

@3/23@��G=C�/@3�<=B�/0:3�B=�4=::=E�B63�;CA71�B63=@G�>@3A3<B32��G=C�;/G�6/D3�/�5@3/B�23/:�=4

274471C:BG�E7B6�%/53:NA�A31=<2�;=D3;3<B�&<�B63�=B63@�6/<2��B316<=:=5G�6/A�;/23�7B�D3@G

3/AG�B=�2=E<:=/2�/<�/>>:71/B7=<�4=@�/�93G0=/@2�=<�;=AB�A;/@B>6=<3A��;/97<5�7B�>=AA70:3�4=@

B6=A3�E7B6�/<�/07:7BG�B=�@3/2�;CA71�B=�6/D3�/<�/113AA70:3�E/G�=4�63/@7<5�63@�;CA71/:

/</:GA7A�+:B7;/B3:G�� �@3/2�B63�A31=<2�;=D3;3<B�E7B6�;G�93G0=/@2�/>>�/B�B63�@3/2G

%=<3B63:3AA��/A� �@3D73E32�=<3�;CA71/:�/</:GA7A�/4B3@�/<=B63@�� �6/2�B63�C<4=@BC</B3�433:7<5

B6/B�;CA71=:=57ABA�E6=�/@3�7<B3@3AB32�7<�B63�C<23@:G7<5�>AG16=:=571/:�7<4:C3<13A�=4�;CA71

;756B�6/D3�/<�3/A73@�B7;3�E7B6�B63�0==9�B6/<�E=C:2�>AG16=/</:GABA�*63�0@734�B67@2

;=D3;3<B�7A�;C16�;=@3�/113AA70:3�B6/<�B63�A31=<2

%/53:NA�4=1CA�7A�=<�;CA71�/A�B@/<A7B7=</:�=0831B�/<2�/�>/B6�B=�C<1=<A17=CA�>@=13AA�CA7<5�/

>@7;/@7:G��@3C27/<�>3@A>31B7D3��/:037B�/�;=23@<�=<3��BB3<B7=<�7A�>/72�B=�2@7D3�B63=@G��B63

C<1=<A17=CA��/<2�B63�35=��E6716�43:B�:793�B==�</@@=E�/�>AG16=/</:GB71�:3<A�4=@�;G�>3@A=</:

B/AB3��3@�070:7=5@/>6G�7A�?C7B3�7<1:CA7D3�/<2�@34:31BA�63@�1:/AA71/:�>AG16=/</:GB71�=@73<B/B7=<�

7<1:C27<5�B63�3/@:G�:7B3@/BC@3�=<�>AG16=/</:GA7A�/<2�;CA71�B6/B�E/A�AB33>32�7<�B63�2@7D3

B63=@G�=4�B63�2/G��"=6CB��������%=G��������)B3@0/��������/A�E3::�/A�;=23@<��@3C27/<

E@7B3@A�=<�B63�AC0831B��%/AA��������/A�17B32�7<��323@��"/@;3:����'=::=19�������

%3E�;=23:A�=4�>AG16=/</:GB71�B63=@G�/@3�<=B�7<B@=2C132�*63@3�/@3�<=�@343@3<13A�B=

"<=0:/C16NA�� �����@3:/B7=</:�E=@9�=<�8/HH�7;>@=D7A/B7=<�/<2�7BA�@3:/B7=<A67>�B=

>AG16=/</:GA7A��=@�B=�A3:4�>AG16=:=571/:�B63=@73A�B6/B�/19<=E:3253�B63�C<1=<A17=CA�;7@@=@7<5

/<2�BE7<A67>�4C<1B7=<A�=4�;CA71��"/7<3@��������)/<2���#3D7<����� ���7<�A>7B3�=4�63@�3/@:73@

@343@3<13A�B=�"=6CB�E63<�63�E@=B3�4@=;�/�;=@3��@3C27/<�>3@A>31B7D3�)7;7:/@:G��A63�2=3A

<=B�3F>:=@3�B63�>=E3@�=4�;CA71�B=�7<4:C3<13�C<1=<A17=CA�1=;;C<71/B7=<A�/<2�@3:/B7=</:

2G</;71A�@35/@27<5�A3FC/:7BG���7;3<��������)C163B���)/<2��������=@�7;>=@B/<B�1=5<7B7D3

/A>31BA�=4�;CA71/:�1=;;C<71/B7=<��!=<3A����=::3@/<����� ��)/19A�� ����

*63�;CA71/:�1=;>=A7B7=<A�16=A3<�4=@�/</:GA7A�/@3�47@;:G�5@=C<232�7<�B63�1:/AA71/:�/<2

@=;/<B71�>3@7=2A�=4�;CA71��E7B6�B63�3F13>B7=<�=4��3@<AB37<NA West Side Story 4@=;�����

�7D3<�%/53:NA�933<�AGAB3;/B71�A3<A707:7BG��0=B6�;CA71/::G�/<2�>AG16=/</:GB71/::G�� �E=C:2

6/D3�:7932�B=�63/@�E6/B�A63�E=C:2�A/G�/0=CB� �B6�13<BC@G�1:/AA71/:�1=;>=A7B7=<A�/<2�B637@

>AG16=/</:GB71�/<2�1:7<71/:�@3:3D/<13��4=@�3F/;>:3��/0=CB� 5=@�)B@/D7<A9GNA L’Histoire du

Soldat E@7BB3<�7<�������E6716�7A�/�1:3/@�1=;;3<B/@G�=<�-=@:2�-/@� �/<2�B63�;3B/>6=@71

�/CAB7/<�0/@5/7<A�AC16�1=<4:71BA�3<B/7:��=@�/0=CB��;7B@7�)6=AB/9=D716��B63�:/C232�)=D73B

1=;>=A3@�E6=�E/A�3D3<BC/::G�27A5@/132�0G�B63�)=D73B�5=D3@<;3<B��7A������)G;>6=<G���

E/A�A33<�/A�@3>@3A3<B7<5�A=17/:7AB�@3/:7A;��7A�)G;>6=<G������1=;>=A32�7<���� �4=@

=@163AB@/�/<2�16=@CA��E/A�0/<<32�0G�)=D73B�/CB6=@7B73A�4=@�7BA�CA3�=4�>=3;A�23<=C<17<5

/<B7�)3;7B7A;���CAB7<�������

)7;7:/@:G�� �E/<B32�B=�63/@�63@�>AG16=/</:GB71�7<B3@>@3B/B7=<A�=4�B63�/B=</:�;CA71�=4��@<=:2

)16=3<03@5�/<2��:0/<��3@5� �E/<B32�B=�9<=E�6=E�A63�E=C:2�:7<9�B63�1=;>:3F�/<2��B=

A=;3��B63�/0@/A7D3�A=C<2A��=4��::7=B��/@B3@�/<2��3=@53��@C;0�B=�>AG16=/</:GB71�/<2�1:7<71/:

1=<13>BA�'3@6/>A� �/;�<=B�037<5�4/7@�� �/;�/�4/<�=4� �B6�13<BC@G�;CA71��/A�E3::�/A�=4�;=@3

Page 4: Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications-Review

Finale

References

1=<B3;>=@/@G�>AG16=/</:GB71�B63=@73A� �7;/57<3�B6/B�%/53:�>@343@A�3/@:73@�>3@7=2A�=4�;CA71

/A�E3::�/A�=:23@�/</:GB71�B63=@73A�%=<3B63:3AA�� �B67<9�63@�/</:GA3A�=4�B63A3�1=;>=A3@A

E=C:2�03�4/A17</B7<5

%/53:�6/A�E@7BB3<�/�D3@G�1:3/@�/<2�B6=C56B4C:�/</:GA7A�=4�;CA71NA�7;>=@B/<B�G3B�<35:31B32

1=<<31B7=<�B=�>AG16=/</:GA7A��3@�;CA71/:�/</:GA3A�@3>@3A3<B�BE=�B67@2A�=4�B63�0==9� 4

@3/23@A�/@3�<=B�4/;7:7/@�E7B6�;CA71/:�/</:GA7A�/<2�;CA71�B63=@G��/A�E3::�/A�037<5�0:3AA32

E7B6�B63�/07:7BG�B=�63/@�;CA71/:�>7B163A�7<�B637@�63/2�E7B6=CB�B63�03<347B�=4�B63�/1BC/:�A=C<2�

B67A�0==9�;/G�<=B�03�4=@�B63;� 4�B63A3�B6@33�1=<27B7=<A�/@3�<=B�>@3A3<B��63@�A31=<2

;=D3;3<B�;/G�03�/�4@CAB@/B7<5�/<2�7<1=;>@363<A70:3�@3/2

�=E3D3@��74�=<3�>:/G32�/<�7<AB@C;3<B�4=@�/�43E�G3/@A�/A�/�167:2�=@�B33</53@�/<2�6/A�6/2�/

;CA71�/>>@317/B7=<�=@�;CA71�B63=@G�1:/AA��=<3�E7::�03�7<�4=@�/�B@3/B� <�1=<1:C27<5�� �;3<B7=<

B6/B�;G�4/D=@7B3�>/AA/53�7A�%/53:NA�7<1:CA7=<�=4�/�?C=B3�4@=;��3@<AB37<NA�/22@3AA��L*@CB6�7<

*7;3�=4�-/@�M�/B��/@D/@2�7<������E63<�B63�;CA717/<�/A�>67:=A=>63@�AB/B32�

�6/2�<3D3@�034=@3�033<�A=�/E/@3�=4�B63�;3B/>6=@71/:�037<5��*63��<3;G��0CB�B63�;=@3

>@=B31B7=<�=<3�6/A��B63�;=@3�2/<53@�7A�7;>:732��B63�AB@=<53@�B63�2343<A3��B63�5@3/B3@

;CAB�03�B63�B6@3/B��B�=<3�>=7<B� �AC223<:G�@3/:7H32�B6/B�B67A�7A�B63�E/G�B63�E=@:2

:7D3A��7A�>@/1B7132�7<�:7D7<5K3F7AB7<5�7<�B3@;A�=4�/<�3<3;G� BNA�3F/1B:G�B63�B/@53B�B6/B

!3ACA�/7;32�/B�/::�67A�:743��/<2��C226/�B==�/<2��@3C2��/<2��6/<27�/<2�$/@B7<�#CB63@

"7<5��B@G7<5�B=�;/93�B67A�7<D7A70:3�1@3/BC@3�C<<313AA/@G��&8/����=@=E7BH�� �����>����

�CAB7<� - ������ Music in the twentieth century: From Debussy through Stravinsky�%3E

.=@9��%.��%=@B=<

�7;3<� $ �������&<�L&C@�%/BC@3M��'@=:35=;3<=<�B=�/�@3:/B7=</:�>3@A>31B7D3�=<�A3FC/:7BG

< ( #3AA3@ � * �=;3<717 ��2A�� Disorienting sexualities �>>�� �J�� ��%3E�.=@9�

%.��(=CB:3253

�323@� )��� "/@;3:� (�#��� '=::=19� ��� ������ Psychoanalytic explorations in music

$/27A=<���*�� <B3@</B7=</:�+<7D3@A7B73A�'@3AA 'AG1 %�& ��@3C2� ) �������*63�$=A3A�=4�$7163:/<53:=� < ! )B@/163G ��2���*@/<A�� The standard

edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud �Vol. 13��>>� ��J ���

#=<2=<���<5:/<2���=5/@B6�'@3AA��&@757</:�E=@9�>C0:7A632������

!=<3A� $�(��� �=::3@/<� ) ��2A������ � Cognitive bases of musical communication

-/A67<5B=<�������;3@71/<�'AG16=:=571/:��AA=17/B7=< 6BB>�2F2=7=@5������

��������� 'AG1 %�& �"/7<3@� (���" �������*63�>@31C@A=@�/A�;3<B=@��B63�B63@/>7AB�/A�;CA3���@3/B7D7BG�/<2

A3:4=0831B�>63<=;3</� < � �=:203@5 ��2�� The realities of transference: Progress in

self psychology �Vol. 6��>>����J������7::A2/:3��%!���</:GB71�'@3AA

"37:3@� � �������*63�=@757<A�=4�)163<93@NA�B6=C56B���=E�;/<�7A�;CA71/: Journal of Music

Theory� 33� ��� ��J �� 6BB>�2F2=7=@5�� ���������

"<=0:/C16� ) � ���� The musical edge of therapeutic dialogue�%3E�.=@9��%.��(=CB:3253

'AG1 %�& �

Page 5: Musical Tonality and Psychoanalytic Communications-Review

"=6CB� � �������&0A3@D/B7=<A�=<�B63�>AG16=:=571/:�4C<1B7=<A�=4�;CA71 Journal of the

American Psychoanalytic Association� 5�����J��� 6BB>�2F2=7=@5������

������������������ 'AG1 %�& �%=G� ' �������*63�>AG16=2G</;71�;3/<7<5�=4�;CA71�� Journal of Music Therapy� 4�

�J � 'AG1 %�& �&8/� ���� �=@=E7BH� $ � ������CBC;<��)=;3B67<5�1/::32�B3@@=@7A; The American Scholar�

>>���J��

)/19A� & � ���� Musicophilia�%3E�.=@9��%.��"<=>4

)/<2� )��� #3D7<� ( ���� ��$CA71�/<2�7BA�@3:/B7=<A67>�B=�2@3/;A�/<2�B63�A3:4

Psychoanalysis and Contemporary Thought� 15�����J��� 'AG1 %�& �)B3@0/� ( �������*=E/@2�B63�>@=0:3;�=4�B63�;CA71/:�>@=13AA Psychoanalytic Review� 33�

��J�� 'AG1 %�& �)C163B� $��� )/<2� ) �������'3@4=@;7<5�23A7@3��$CA71/:�3F>@3AA7=<A�=4�43;/:3�A3FC/:7BG

Psychoanalysis and Contemporary Thought� 22�����J�� 'AG1 %�& �