Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

download Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

of 52

Transcript of Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    1/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    2/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    3/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    4/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    5/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    6/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    7/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    8/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    9/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    10/52

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    11/52

    - ' , , , - . - , . ' " - ;". , , , ; - " ".

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    12/52

    ", ' , : , , . - . - - " ". * - ' , , ' , ' . -

    - . - - , , - , , - . : , ' , - . ,

    , , - , .

    , . , - , " " " " . , , '

    . -

    . (. . . ).

    22

    ( " ", ) .. ' . - " ", - " ". , , , . . , - , , . , " - ", - - ". ' - , , - " " ' " ", , - ' '

    - . , , , . , . ; , - ' - ; . -

    23

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    13/52

    ' - , ' - , , - ' , , - . - - , - .

    1979

    24

    , *

    , , - , - , - , , ' -. .

    , . - ' - " " - - , , , , - , , , ' .

    , 0 - ' , - - .

    ,

    , . ( .. .).

    25

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    14/52

    - - , , - - . ' - " " , " " " " - ". , , " " " , - . - , , - , " , , " . , . . , - - , - - , -

    . " , -

    - ' , , , - - " ", , - . " - , -

    26

    r - . , - . " " , , - . - - , VE R S T E H EN ( ) - , -

    " " , " " . - , - . - ,

    " - r " - " - . , - , . , " " - ", - . , " - , . - , . : - ; - - ; " " ( -

    27

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    15/52

    - ) , - - , , - 1793 ; , , Rat e ( - ), - ; . ; ; ; ; - ; -

    - ' ;

    , - ri - . - , " " - . " , "." , - " " ' -

    . . :J:--.Q!! - Rg ; , OU K O-~riJ_~ &-._qy ~ ~"'ii 'J , fJJ_ ,l.!JL.!O !..... 1!!9_}\ElTOU Q.vOnou __ ._'i.. .,\!Q ,;r ~ ~ - - .. - - - - - . _ - - -;2. ' QOI5G.Qoav , , 3..Q ....JI~Q Q.~ !!l ~ -'{O\ cr v_I,J~~, , ~.'~~OJ1fu.l ~ -

    . ~~ QLJ,.J .&JQJu,o.Kq. q.,- . I p rc~I.!L UbL

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    16/52

    , -

    .9~:-:fg::~1~,~~~~.iI. 3'j~:ill KoJl1I9,~l~.s.!.:,~an- )5L .Lg,st ,",Q~Ys: , ";;'1,u. ~.QJ1lill_ry , ~ P K ~~~ ~OI3 " O !Q..:Ci W::: ; ~i ~:::~:~~ ~~:~} i.~~~W,.V lJ..... .. v-}

    - , . ..~ -l...9.... ~~ . 9 . L l"' Q . ! . . .Q , . QQ..u.,_,Q..J !1 9 ! -

    ~~~~~~ ,:~~~_q,~~ ~~.!f!,~~J?L q~~!JueY5 ~~~ "W~~Oo\ ,~ ..~. .2_.l!,_g> .~2.,9~.JQ ,~lLQ! .9..!!9~_~2~~.,~~~12-..

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    17/52

    ".6 , ' 1 " ", - " - " ( ).7

    ' , ' - - , ; ' . - ' '60, , - , . , , , - . - - . - - , , ' - .

    " " -

    " '" - " ' " " ' - '" " - " '60 , " - '" " " " - " - , - , " ... , ' '

    32

    ". , , " ' ". , , - " " " " " ( , , ) - " " - " " , - ."

    " " " " " " . g ei s t ( ) , , " " , - ' " ". , "

    " " " ( ) " " " . " " , , " " " " , " ", " ".? -

    33

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    18/52

    - " - ", " ", " " " " " - ".

    , __ \1 .Q . ~ ~ , - , , - , - , ., " " , , - - .~~LQQ .i.'!.~ .-!!~ , , gR(j . . ~~~K E ~oo x , :- ~~ ; -~ o- ;' ~

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    19/52

    , ' , " " " - " ( ; - ).13 ," - ", " ", , - , , - w " "- , ; '

    - . 2 g _l3~ ~ av.Q. ~ ~ - . , l1" , , , . - ' - - ,

    , -

    ' , - - - . - - , ' - . , . ::- o~ t Q-t-FJ~' W- -~@J- . ~ -.9JJl ._ _L-_u- ;:; UQU q[j : - ' - , - , , -

    36

    - . " , , ,

    , , - - , , , - . - , , - , " " ( ) , " " , , . ~b! 1! .Qt:lUJ.v: -,,: - ' , !3:u ~V o O_lJ=i- ~c: - !:! ~ S!.. '

    .1 '~ y~ clk !LXQ!} .QQt!!Y,i>~uwc;" " " ".14 ,

    , , ' , ' , ' ' . , ' . ' - , ,

    37

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    20/52

    . , - ; - ; , , - . ' ", - . - , ' '

    . ' - , ( ] - - - - . , - .

    ~ , ' . ' ; - ' -

    .

    ' . - , , , - - -n . - - - - , , - ,

    38

    ,

    . , , - .

    , " " , . - , " ", - - - - - . ' , - , " " " " . ' ,

    ' . ; " ": , w - . , ' - .

    . " " " ' , -. . '

    39

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    21/52

    , - ' - , - - . ' - , ' - - , , - , , , - , , ' " " - , ; " ; - " l , " , - ' , - ".

    , "Grund~i sse" , - , - - . , -

    , ' ," - , , , ., - ' - , ' - , - , - - , -

    40

    . ; ' ".lS

    " , , , , . " " , - - . , ' ' , " , - . , ; ~ , - , , ' . , , , , , ' ' , , ' ", , ;' - . . . , ,

    41

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    22/52

    " ' , , , , , ., ". "' , - ", - : " - - , , - - - ' ' - , - .:" 6 ! 7

    - , ; - ' - . , - - , . " - : "' - , - , - . - : - , - . : , - , , , , , . ' , - " ", , - ,

    4 2

    - , . , , - ."

    " ' " " " , - - ' . - - , " ; - . " " - , - , . ' - - :

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    23/52

    - . " - " - " " , - , , . , " - , - ;" - - - . " " '?'

    - ; , . ' , - ' , , " -

    " ; - ' , , - . ; - , . " " ' - - . - , - - " " ' - .!? - - , , . - - ' , ' , ' ,

    , - - , ; -

    44

    , . . - , .? . , , - , - ' - ; ; , ' , , ' . - .

    . ' ' . , " Jl -v.g.:w. ~4IK , - w:~../: . ' ; : ; , - , , , - , ." " ? "

    45

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    24/52

    ' - , - - .

    , - : , , .21 - " " - - - , ll _u -9 ' .J._.__..a... .r. ... illW_P..LQI:! Q._/.. ..l.Q.. ..Q.!L! }.9 u'- . , , - , , , , - ; ; n .

    - . ~lliL_QIQ.\L~ ...Q.,... L.. -9__ !S..Q ~Q1! - ~~~ y Ko :::: : KY lQWn . OK~- ~..q.c;- ~ . "6 , , .22 - , - - , - - . - , , - : - " " - .. - , , . -

    46

    - '' '', - ; - , . n , ' . - - .

    . .Qi ' - , lvwmou oT'TV'J'O- -fO --:-H~ - ~ .l:! .,9 ....

    _ . _ - - - -K~! ..!5.~b!.!.!5.Q!P.. 9.vl!S! i,.~Q....Il.. Q!JJillL'(_e.2.':P~"v t::i'O - I!.M.illJ QQ Q,irlQ.:J~Q.U-.Q :.tU)..s. m. :.~.::_L.~!.r} . . 0_~,y_~~.2 ...!:.!. O~.!!E~-u "-~ ill . : .. . .! 1 .

    , , . ' , ' ' - ' - - " - " " " - . . - ,

    47

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    25/52

    " " - _ - , - - - , - - , - " ". - , -

    , - . - - - . - ' - . " ", " ", " " , .

    ' - ' : " " ' .

    - " " - Naf/ Inviicl1sigke it - - - : , - , , " " - - . - , - , . - - ' " -

    48

    , - - , - is.. .'5..q_ULiQ~9.. .1] 1] i.!J ave..eP_~.~.\~!:l.y -~ D.Q.!] " Q% ... l,J .l

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    26/52

    .

    " " ", , " - - ' ", " " - ' , ' ' , . " , - - , - ' - - " ". - " " ' . - , " " " " - - , , , , " ". - ' ' , ' ; , - " " " " . " " - ' - ' - '' '' . ,

    , / .c._@:n U l/_n. . _-'Lg_~V ~. qs : _ ~~2 . 9!L " " ?" w - cm n c :u . PIOU ~ '

    _. ' ' ~ "" .' '. 4 ;

    50

    \ .

    .!J.U~ x ' - -

    ~!JQ~~~!~_~9.!~ !2~. .!L:~~ T.21as, _){_t(Q: ..,.QQ . . ~ a Q, .."Q_Q:};.," ): ~

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    27/52

    ' - ; , " " - . , - ; ' , ; ; - , , - , ; , - , -

    , ; " ", - , ' , , .

    , - w - . . , - ." , - . ' , ' .. - , - . /l-. ..J.Q.L. ..'LQ 'l!l " ~" , ~ o .~y ~ o, : !.9__ .9-1...1,_V . " " l,! _JSQ.!Y.~ - -- ~ " w . -- .- ------

    ' ' , - " " . " " - " -

    52

    " , , - , . - .. ' ; , , - ' , - . q..q.lLOUs ..... fuJ.J

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    28/52

    S! .!Q ~~ .Q .!L Q .(u _ .1:... _ ,4 ..~" - _ o~/~~"P - ;Q...... .J;T_ELv.O-..o. n.o.Lo.u.QQ JJ.Q.J.f;... i!~O.u . .f.. 9.~~ _. -XPO _VQ!J ':~ " - ' ' , - ,

    5 4

    - , , ..." , " ' " " .?"

    1::I ~\Ol ..CLg vr : ....llLJi -l1J . .l9-:: . Q....QV .CL. .ou Q,._'{.\' .l l!9...99_ o~ ' - ~91J.Q1.

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    29/52

    " '" , " - ". ." , - ' ( - ) ( ) ". , Q ~Q-IL.-!S.QL... > .Q..Ll1JIl...-.(iC1-_~.. : QY, ' ,. - _ :' 9_ n ~ .2..f..2! '..2!J.Y- J ,-v.!Q;)l- JlQ,g Q~ avgYKn_yo o ~!)~ ." 3

    . ' -

    " " , ' - " - ". ' ," , ", - ' ' " ' - . , ' ... _ IJTQ.IJ.J; 5;, .,,3 2 " " , . - - " " , " " . 1::1 " ~..:: : . , , . ~'. .::: . . " " . .

    - " " - - . " - " ' " ov o" ; " -

    56

    ". ' , " g -.n. m , " ;.Q~_Q.s.. R , ~ " -~ - ;9 7~~ ~ " "Ou'~ 3 .Vn, t q,_m; ,J.

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    30/52

    ~ .-Lq ~ __l _( QD...lO.u ao:r~_1J..Ql.LKQc: - ,. w ~,::;g~ ~~:q9-~:q~-DQ~_~:.,\,k."Q:~l~. Ir:~~.f - c.. ,

    ~ .. .._ . , .._~- , . . ~. ~ . ,. c ' ~~ . .~,.W" :f;C - , ~ )f J J """~ "',r" ~ , ': _ ~"- -

    . ll:" ;.;rR - -yi~ ~, y ,~ v.q'l'!'!sW~Q ,b!wi:~= Jjiq ;:JS!i~~~ ". , ' " " - " - ''. , . , , .

    ' - ; , " . , ] ,,1 O '{.~~.J,.~-,~ . . ' /- , 5. ]i,fel?iiV~~i!Jv;~:e.._!J_; .r:_ ili!J@ , .f . __J.2!. ~~~~~Q.~~i2.,._.l:!.!J ": .I:_. .._. , ..!L._. ,_ . .~ ;r ..q~ ,J_ .. ~~.~~::-::7a~_~ ~GI.r, g-_ .- _;.uu . -

    '~ .. . . JQr:....q..ll / . - ' -~- , / . , - , " ;" - " -. ".

    - ' , - " . ' . , , , , , - , ( ). " " - " m

    58

    " " . " " - - , . " , , " " , - . , - V .34

    _.~~"!"_6(:;JT9:/\ ,':0 gv .llQ ..~,cei!: _~ - ' Li":i04 ~i;:";1 )~:- i.~/\l,:'n:C,~_b'Q\lJ_'f,.yq_~'ou.,~ - ". " " ~ , " ( , - - . .) - ... " .35 , " " , . " , " . ."?6

    " " " " . f:i...u. Q 9.IQ,Id.~_ill>!J f? ~r.

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    31/52

    - " ". - " " - . - " " , , - , , , , " ; ", ; , , " "- ; - - . -

    - . - " " .

    ..f:,...m~Q.\U:..ql;._t .Q.Q!:l ~~ , ~~ -Q1.!lQJ.~/(,_Q- ~ ~"Q_ ..!9-. .!lW!1~.~~ ~~. ""- \\~'Jgn o.:!J~YAQIi~~q~IOV $O~

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    32/52

    . , - , . - ' " " " -;" - ' " " - . 40 , " - ".3 7 . '' '' - - . - , - . - - , " - ", " " " - " - , - , - " " .

    ' ; - . , , - - - ' ." ; , - , . - ", . " - , - : (Township), Q bLQJ;,..- .9,.~ +~r'-e'f'> ' l']~ U v., .,~ t,., , , G1 .-&-:::.v.,,(iQQIOU.JO E ~ : -

    62

    ~~~~~.::. s. ?~ s. ..9~J3i :!).5~

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    33/52

    , , - - , , - . w " " - , - - - . . " " ; - .40 -

    - - , , , , - . - " " " " " ", - . , - . , , ; - . w - - ' , - , _

    .

    , ' - , - ( , ) - , - . " - " - , - , - , - " " - . " -

    64

    , - .

    1978

    :

    1. . Albrecht Wel1mer: "Communications and Em an cipa tion: R ef le

    ctions the Linguistic Tum Critic a I Theory " O n C r ti c a I T heo ry,

    ed . Jo hn O 'N eill (S e abury Pres, 1976) , . 254.2. :'' " ( -

    " ").

    3. - . ( -

    . ).

    - / " . -

    - On Revolution (Vil ng

    Press, 1965) . 239- 40.

    4 . -

    ,

    ; ( CNT

    ), " "~ o-

    l:!- .. ri ...l ! )2 !1l . -

    p ~ ,-;;-~ ~ ;'~~ i"

    r; K ~ " :-;; ;;: ;;- ;;;

    ~ ~ -;; ~ ~ '~~ OKoo ~ 1936:"37,~-- --- ' ''''' '~ ''' : _-''''~--'~- ~~ oK~ . o ~ .:.~ ~ -

    ;; .

    5 . . Post-S c ar city A nar ch ism (B lac k R os e Bo oks , 1977 ),

    ., 15(}-S3.

    6 . ' ;

    ( . . ). "

    Authority , AnarchBm and Anar-

    c ho Sy nd ic al is m ( In te rn at io na 1 P ub li sh er s 1 97 2) , . 102.

    7 . , . 102.

    8. : - ( " ").

    9. :

    ( " ").

    65

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    34/52

    10. : .

    1 1. ' ,

    , -

    ~ ~ y o ~ -

    , ( " "

    . - . . .) -

    , .

    " "

    '' ",

    .

    12. , .

    13 . , . .14 .

    "-

    " .

    . , ,

    , " " -

    ,

    . , ,

    . -

    , " -

    " , -

    -

    . , , ' ,

    (" " " -

    " , " " " "),

    ."

    , , ,

    u -

    .

    15. ' (

    " ").

    16. Mutual Aid (Exte nding Hor zons Books , 1955)

    .179-80 -1 .

    17.

    c '

    -

    -

    / -

    " ;" ' -

    66

    , .

    , -

    ,

    1905

    , ' -

    ; , -

    , ;

    ,

    " " ,

    , -

    -

    ;

    , , -

    .

    o ~ / w -

    } / .J t ; i !U ~ o -

    , ic

    ~ e - . /l t . !U .

    18. Paths n Utopa (Beakon P r e ss , 1958) .

    19. , ' -

    . u -

    " "

    " " (Men-

    schen - ' nankind" McLellan, " hwnankind " -

    Nicolaus!), ,

    " u ,

    , ,

    " ,

    ,

    190 (Grundrisse, Random

    House, . 410' Nicolaus -

    '

    .

    ,

    ;

    . , ' -

    " -

    ", ' -

    67

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    35/52

    . Isaiah &--",, Franco Ventu , The RoI"'s Revolut ion (Grosse t & Dunlap,19(0) -

    , J;o

    ( . .. - ). "

    ' The 8pa-

    nish Anarchst (Free L fe Editions, 1977),

    (Harper & Row) .

    20 . . Post-S carsity Anarchism, . 65 .

    2 1 . . " "

    .

    ' - ; -

    1i , ; , ; -

    - -

    . 50,

    -

    -

    .

    ' "

    .

    ,

    50.

    " ,

    " , '

    , ;

    ,

    . , -

    ,

    " ". '

    -

    '

    ,

    , .

    22. Grundrsse (Random Houae, 1973), . 410.

    23 . J erem y S ha pir o : ' '' I1 te S li me History" On Critical Theory, . 147-48.

    24. , . 149.

    25. .

    ( ' ").

    68

    26. .1. Finley: Democmcy: Ancient and Modem (Rutgers University

    Press , 1973), . 18 .

    27. , , 29 -30.

    28 . : Considerations Representat ive Govemment

    (World Class ics Edi tion , 1948) , 196-98.

    29 . " ! ' :" Truth and PoIitics " P hi1 os op hy , Pol itics and 80-

    ci e ty ( " Peter Laslett and W .G. Run cim an (Blackwell

    & Co. , 1967) , . 115.

    30. . The Ea Theologcal W tngs (University ! Chicago

    Press , 1948) , . 304-5.

    31 . " , ,

    ' J;

    , .

    ,

    ' " " \

    ' ' .

    32 . " " , "Truth and Po1itics " , . 115.

    33.

    34. "

    Telos , -

    . , 1971

    '' " ( . ." -

    ; " " ).

    ,," " (. . . -

    " ") 1969.

    " ", " .

    " "

    -

    -

    .

    . ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    6 9

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    36/52

    " " " "

    .

    3 5 . ( " ")

    ' ; r 0-

    ( " ").

    36. . Th e E arly T h eol o gical Wr itings , . 81, 82 .

    37 . . ( -

    '' ".

    38 . : T he C ty Hs to ry (Harco u rt , Ba cee & W o rld,

    196 1) , . 3 32.

    39 . er Jense n : A m e can th e E ra the A rtc les of Co n fe d e rat on.40. . ( ' TV

    " ).

    70

    '

    - . , ' - ' ' - - - - , - ' ' . -

    , .

    , - . , ( , , .), " " - , .

    71

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    37/52

    - , - , , - - - , - - ,

    , - , -

    - " - " , ' (; , ) , ; ( , -), ( ), , ' , ' - ' - - ,

    - , - , , , , , , , - , - , , . ' - - , - ,

    ,

    72

    , - - , ' ; ' - ; , - . , , , - . ; - ( ) '

    . : ; , ' ; . ' , ' - . 0-

    ; ' , - , .

    , ~ ' - - . . . - , " " , . " - " , - . ' - " ;" - , , " " " ".

    ' n " "

    73

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    38/52

    . " " ( " "]. , . - , ' - , , ' - . - , ' . - . , , , , " " . " "- , 0 - - .. " ", - , - - . - ' , - , " ", - " ; , - -

    ' - " ( . . .).

    , , - , - , " " ; ; . " ", ' - - . -

    74

    , , - . - - . - , - , - . " " , , " " - ", , - . , " " - " * " - ". , - " " " ", - . - " - , , "

    - " ". - - " - " 0- , - , . , , . -

    . ( .. .).

    7 5

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    39/52

    , - - " ;" .

    ' , " " , - "' - ' ;". - ; " ", .

    ' - ' ' , - - , ; - ; , " " . - ; ( - ) , . , , ; ' - , - , ; . - , - - . - - " " " " " " - - . . , - C; ,

    76

    , " - " " " - .

    ' , - : " ;'. " " oc; ; " ; , - ' ; ' " ;" - : ' - . " ; " -

    ; ( " ;"}, - , , - , - ;

    ' - " " - . , , - , - . ; ; , , ' " ", , - , . - - ; , . , ~,h!Q.~ -~.~.e; udQ..i].i .L,lg. .c.--.L1'-'2 Y_Ls... il~-ci1A I-!J ... K C; ...us.. Q.L..S.Q.L ..u..~. - " " , -

    77

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    40/52

    . ' ; " - ", - , , , ~~Q.. \,_JLQ.9 nQ " " , C!.L!l._Q l ;J.Q. ., o ~~. - ~ . . . ....J__e )' -

    , ~ -~Y. 9~~!] "' J~ii:J~ 9i2 iQ ) .- - - ..Qe. f~ 9~ ( - ; tr: _.(U:!'!Q ~Il!._!S ( ). ~o - , ....o~ D. J :!lt. ,_ . .u_.._....9_~QQ Q6._-6 Q lL ...: .L ...Il._ - - OC~..._~_Q_ .. . .:. _q- _:._ -~ " .. " ' , - ' ".' , - , - . . ~...LL~..iJ. ...e:- .J:.L LL. 'll!lI KU ill.w.f;. -} \ , ~ Mo . . T!.Jo191 1 ~ - . Q.....:.~_ Q ... /L.Q.\l Q.. . .....~ . .:.I.Q....... .!J.JSL i!.(\ .

    E .M.''~, _:.... __-F>~~~_._~.9 - ~.~IJ ..I_.H -J !J Q..Q...I.L.K _ JJ_)2 .... - ~ ....f-__~ ..~Q--_:.._u... _~_-~ -_4. . _ ~. _~. . - - , ' , " - " , - . " " . , - , - .

    . , " "

    78

    . - , ' - , . - . . - - . .. - .

    ; " " " " , , ' ' , , ' . , . ; . ( , , - , ,

    ) , . - " " , : . - .

    "

    79

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    41/52

    " : " " . , , - ; - " - " ( , , - ), " " - , , " - ", , - , " -" , ' ,

    . ' ; - - . . , - , , - .

    ; - : "' !" " - " " ( - ' : " -;" '' '' ' -..) - , - , , - - , ; ". ' - " " , , : " , " - - " (. ,

    /

    8 0

    , 1848) " ( ). ' , , , - , ' .

    . -- , . , - , " " , "" . , ' _ [;....QY ~~, . " Q " O (i"( 'O'"jj"X x o;~'~ ;~; K7;'-'-(A .) - - . " - " , , ( : - ) ; - - , - ' , . " "; ; .

    " ; - " " - " , " " - . -

    81

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    42/52

    " " , : . " " , - . , ' .

    , ' - " ", -.

    ".... ", . , "" , , , . "" : ; " '

    : - ; ; ; ; ; ; , -

    82

    . , , ' , .

    7 , . ' "", . , ,

    . , , : " " " ". ", , ".

    ' . , " "( ;) . , . "" , " " ( Grundrisse ), . , " " - , - " " .

    (. , Grundrisse, ), ' : " " , , -, " " . , , " "

    83

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    43/52

    " " . ' , - : . - - . , , " " " ".

    , - . ' -, ' . - - , - , , , - - ' . , ' ' , - " -" - " ". , , .

    "- " . , . - - " " ' , - ' . - , ' .

    84

    ' " ", - " ". " " - , ' - - .

    ,

    , ; . , , , - " " " " , ' , ' ", " " " - " , " " " " - ' , . , Mqp- - , - , ' - - ~ " " - i:oJ. ro u , - ) '' o ~.~ : -

    " " , ; , -

    85

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    44/52

    " " - , - . , " " , " , " ( - ), - " - ' " " , - ". (

    ). ; " "

    Ql;o::OliX,!Qef-! v-:.:..9 - v W- :l. ~u. i- _O MqRL.YJQ...Id_lO~I2Id!JVEia QI ~ !] Q!L !] - . -

    ~~JillQ.lI_:' .! 9.Q::. .. - !] " " - . , " " X"v

    ' ~-i'o't ' " ", , - , - , . - , , , - . ' - - _ ; " " . ' , - ; , - . - . - ; " " ;( ), " " " " - - , " ;" - " " " ;" . - " " ' - - .

    86

    . . - - ; - . , " ", , " ", ; " " " ;" . - - " - " -

    ' . - , ' ( ; }, - , ; - ; . " " " " - - , , " " , - , , - " " .?

    , - ; . , - , - , " ; " ( - - " ; "] ; ' - -

    87

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    45/52

    . - , , , - . ' 0 - " " - , - .

    . -, , - ' . . , - , " "

    ' . ,':'0-_ __.(.L~;~ ~_ ~'I:S.!',;.... . -.YK,~Y-!Q"tLea. ~!!iili.l.Y.9....fntKOl .Q~L _~.Q.J.. ;" ( , , ) - .

    - . , " " . :

    : " ' " ( . 16). : ' , - . , , ' .

    : ( , - )" ( . 17) . : ( . 9), " - " " ".

    88

    " " " - " " " - ' ;":

    : " - ' " ( . 20) . : - , - - . - , , . " ", - ' .

    " ( ! . .) " - ' - - , , . ( 15 ) - ' - - ' . , . . - , - .

    : " "20). : " (. ). , , .

    : " , , - ... " ( . 22) . : ! - - , , " ", . - - ,

    89

  • 8/6/2019 Murray Bookchin O Marxismos San Astiki Koinwniologia

    46/52

    ... : "' , (!)

    , - (. 25) ... - (. 27) ... ( . 27) ... " . , ; - . : 6 - ' . , , ;

    . - , -

    . . ' - ' : " " " , , ' . " " , '20 '60, , - , ' ~o ..J;; y ~ ...Qb! . ,.J; .. &\l->@l:I-:'r: - ,t ff'W.. \l...U.- c [J~,.g.. .i]..ILU Q.. ,

    9..J.Q..V_r~ . , - ( , , - ), - 1925 , 1950 '80, - , , l nd G s Journ l " " - , ' " - " , 72 .

    230 - , 1950 , - 1950 , - .

    . , , , , , , ' , - , , , - , - ,

    . , ' , - , , . , - ' - - - . , , - ' . , , - ,

    ' , - . - - " ". " " " " , ' ." ; " " " " , , - .