Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^...

22
*s 0 - - '2 ^ r * C-5 .2 =. O O *_ *f t S o o X U:r a o ' POW* ePM ct CO * M 234 w) ; s4 2<¢ < P -*i · , S, c .9 o.: ') a OL> I Q *W *a U Cpt *4 03 C. M) s= QV t;z w Or .- Mi U.g QE ; I 1. Q^ Ln cn ; u C 5 r" $ * ,6m (U ^ WI es;s . w~t 0.4 -0E C 9&ca

Transcript of Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^...

Page 1: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

*s

0- -

'2

^ r

* C-5

.2 =.

O O*_ *ft S

o o

X U:r

ao

'

POW*ePM

ctCO* M

234

w)

; s42<¢ <P

-*i

·, S,

c

.9o.:

') a

OL>

I Q*W *a

U Cpt*4 03

C. M) s=

QVt;z

wOr

.- Mi

U.g QE; I

1. Q^

Ln cn; u C 5r" $ *

,6m (U ^ WIes;s .w~t 0.4 -0E C

9&ca

Page 2: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

-c

F) e-^'"" 0^

P-j4.L,

,4-

CD

_I

t-0;. 4

C)

u

.

a rQW-.

Cl

A A A A A A A A A A

C0

;4;H

H4

r4

0H

H

*4

C

* -

4*Ct.

r3

r-

$:

t-U

4--

*)

cDu

v=

U

ri

.0

0

.>0

F ;

, /

mI

~

e-4

0

rd)

.;

C-

* _

F11

r)

I

0o4)

uC)

0(U

c5

*

o

r \

C,

0* _(

4-

I;E'OQ

cn

CDv

C)

5

V)

T)

U

*i-0

u

235

I

Page 3: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

0

0

a

o

-2

0

Hww0)

4^-

^^^^^

0

up*

*MrZ

id

*-P

P=^WwP=

-fl

eC

* -

wS

P=

236

I

Page 4: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

* *

&

G

(t

*S

onz

CA

w

MQet

5^

r

*E-

*5

P=

wi* m;0

S-

Q)

* -

U*

U

0V

* -

etf

1t

C -

U,

C

cn

P=

* -

Q)

'0

U,

* -CSO

* -

13

-

Qf

*p^0(w

wCCw

5S

A3

o

-

* -

0

Q

0 oMS

0

(U

w

-ila

*p

w2mcr

cnA

un

$soE

(mS43

a

W>

*E0

4

OPI

r-s-W00

237

)

A A A

Page 5: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

el0

* -

*-f

Pl

P3

-i

FA

E

o

(1)

O

CAc

*

-

Oj* -

;-

en Ccu

oaN

fm4

.

p0

imiPQ

Ur

ct

c~

&4

e,

rn

ftrj

*N

-mi4Qm

9,4

238

A A

Page 6: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

Wt

ri

0CSe(',ki

0 /-Cui)

CZ0 wfl3 T-3^

Q) fl /Oo !3~Od w z .

CL r \^ Au . LoW

0Pia-6=1rA0 11

1.,

s I'

O* ;

,b:'(n

Q

<_j

^ Cv\ C) d

*s*AS

.~ · Ll

§o al

W a PN

O 0 0 0 0 0

=S S =S : S S§~~~~~~~~~~~~omo M S S

A A A A A A

239

POW

0

0*

0

tr!*_

1-1

z

e

U.0

QWw=

C*M~

>-

*P*J

wt _

lq FC

- r-

Page 7: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

0 -

* - IW) >po no

M 1 m3

-al. r- cI)

§ 'S.a ,

o-S -( ,..4 .^ ,-*a ?^^ Pe^ o

*'-< S CQ CD .sv T fPE&E 3 *Po(* ;w *23ilo %~S

Pie Jsr) Jr) re C) ) P4 C)e§ 1 E t;Bs y gic 6s 4 gPSi22 0

A A A

240

EC)

F*

eslvill.4,i

063C4

r!

Q

CZi

0

:Q^a;

Page 8: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

CZ

Q

(Urs?-

e

Aeo:C)

"d

CZ

a

C

2du

13%

ru~

C

0)53sZem~

*3

-

es

a^

* -Sto

* -

C:

*O

-I

0

.aN

* o

C1a

4-405·

5P=r \

em

<S

;MO

aW

rst

C13

t t

z '

© mponOm

CZ1001czr 4

241

A

)

Page 9: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

* -

"e

&i)

e;

*

Ct

-lr

o=

eP

A

0

* Pe,

CS

-4-

CE

*t

A3

wo

es

*

C.

eA

.3

a

Ln

-o

C.P*-4-)0 M

;Zcwwu

C4

*mg0* -

G4;

242

c)

er9CZ

so

*Ni*r

!.)̂3r~rl

e3

adC%0

rrQ)

-wPo*PI

fZi

AL A A

v: 0

w

Ifl

-

S>-

w

0

Jni

Page 10: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

0

* o

SO

0

Q

o

w

0Iga

* -

.*P-

* -

0

z

ClPast

*PN(

+es,M

oeS

r^

C3-4C)

6.0

QtVB

w

*p*

I-<

wCf)

rA

d3CZ*-40CO)

M4

A

243

A

Page 11: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

0

Ue

PPIgsP"'

'. X~rsI a~~~a

Q

;w!C!*

·,

fte

r-~Iq

40,1

.F

%1W»MVRw

V!Q

Cub*W

*ftNOO

244

;-Gr'

Cel

r

r~~~~~~i ·

Off-

- -<yX-

rug

_ y -- _ :

,v» '' . ;ca ' /f

_/ /

W /0--- II -/

tf

-<f

-i

5S_^

)

* f

c;f

L

SuO

Page 12: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

0*a-

* -O*

ct

0h

V

C)IrW

0* -

gaO-

0 -P

0=0ft

A

245

Page 13: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

j)

-4

* -

za,

wr sPC

C

c?-

(Ue:V.(Z

9.0

* -

ws

O>F

* -

-4,mm

^2

Zj

* FM(;.

;1

;0-4a

0

Q)

0a)

11(Z

A

246

*t

w

CAC3

;0-

S9

wed

erWw

.4Czc

El

cZ

*FI

"3ec

L

e=

0

*-

411

A

Page 14: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

aWAwMd

-

C.:Ss

4014

^ _3

tw4-d C,-*

3 ;>*

0y Poo

-5s e

o

-; I K -

= **' So=- , r3

_*- i /' - ,\OS C3

^ t ~lA" uO CQO '. w5rt ',>

B~§ ,l

~~~s-<

Ct 9

o

> ,S0

AA

247

* -(

CZ&t0J-411

bCU.

.ALo(ne

oz

Ct

0

;sl

00

0-0

4;0*

;0,

0o -* P*(S^

N\I

flsl1-

00

' .

<'d·**»- S3 - '

.. ^-- -- ;' - * i" -,

$- - -

-^ -

- ^- --

-.. &

q1

vpm

0M=

^",~ · ·;

A

<^,pt -

-*

i-.-3 -<

PM"

-&

mmy-17

.^ --- '-

Cpl.W :I;.aP

* -

a

0Wa

CU

CV)44m

O-

- -

i

Page 15: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

O^t·Sr

;0-

^

*PP*

rf

-a

S1Z

v:-»

v3

F=O*!

Po~

a P

?>-0A*

.

* -^

&o

-

a

s

;*-

0)

*-

0

Vo*p*

A

0rAcw

et

ws&PN(

*5

'bl0Exi

C:A

Mw

0^6

<u, ;4

c4^

*^

I(

P%

rA

a

ciqIr=

img

w8>ff

ICI<ycl~

w

CZ^0

0

,p \

abTo

4)

PaM-

-933~bd

W

cl~

Wa1* P*

248

A

Page 16: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

csLO*64

M

&.4

¢11=0a<;.3

Q)

Cd0=P*

596O"<V

. ^ (- Wi~

Cd t

lim

P '

PEW ,

E S g-? cCS 2 sS- <S3 0

rp 3 , Q e

0 a^ >4q

._ 0f s

*»-( g. i"< ̂

E r* S

o Q13.

Q ft Cg *ll > S _ ._

G Vi

oa s

v *a M) <. so <

S3 Q) C HtE

»*

0 O

MAt>

C)

^* c E.^ §n *-s W3 Q

§, ^

_ *3S»^ V f

>rt01erv «4Ec

A

249

f

I >

i »?EM

! C4

CAQ

* 2:3

s

BA

;2w

. ;O

^-

w

W

W

0-d

yc

-6^86yP~

r^

* -

W.

.50Q«

St

op"

4)

CO48

.'r

,IN

cc

owlsy

:CP-4

*A.* a

. 0 PK\

cLt

f31i

w

^<p^)* spa

ir ?

I

Page 17: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

Poe&̂9

0w

. l

X-X

a 4

00

ZA

A A

250

C)-

* -el40

*3

0 00M5

s

* MO

i

.a

O

IiiI

PXa

i G-»w

* ;0-- Ij >~~,

NW

x wr-1 ^

re) } w~~;9

Page 18: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

= wjB^A.* .S. fX .-^ ? * - u i

5s L - E *a-S S r as

91 ci V *r c ^

3L gCd +M? 2 P

~s Icriw It~CO"0

-0 w ,

251

dlven~

* *

w

PsO

a3

»in

^A

rAI

0 PN

W))C

>Poo*W!

W

a'

Qop"

I

cWCZIIM

Id i

4

e3mi

<!

"**

;t

Qat

· c1 4

3Q

a->0"SCa.

<

E-- I ~5 cri ~ ~ ~8

Page 19: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

c ,-

rmA

ti -e

Pt

co'LflMpj

/

252

L)CA

I

\I-

Page 20: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

e* -

o 0Q w

A A /1^~~~, i

I,^

I I

t ,

\I\ ~/i .

~, /'/'

253

* «

'"CQ

riM

* S

C0)

'oV

cm3c;

Ww wra^r~Q ^Ws rQ

wS3;

=r.

Page 21: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

* -

tP

-S

o

*0

* -

Q

Q)

z

z

sdlr dC/IGJt

Ma

et

C!W*w

P=

254

II

IIl

Page 22: Mr. Robert Ayers, Department of Defense, Vulnerabilities and … · 1996. 2. 23. · ^t·Sr;0-^ *PP* rf a-S1 Z v:-» v3 F=O*! Po~ a P 0 ?>-A*. * - ^ &o-a s;*-0) *-0 Vo *p* A 0

OSS '96: THE CONFERENCE Proceedings, 1996 Volume II, Fifth Internatinal

Symposium Global Security & Global Competitiveess: Open - Link PagePrevious Mr. Robert Hutchinson, Publisher, Jane's Information Group, The Secret Parts of Fortune: The Role of Sources in

Open Intelligence

Next Mr. Robert Steele, Information Peacekeeping -- Open Source Intelligence as a Policy Option and OperationalAlternative

Return to Electronic Index Page