Moon River Rehabilitation Summary Report

Moon River Walleye Spawning Bed Enhancement

Project Summary Report

Eric McIntyre, Coordinator, Eastern Georgian Bay Stewardship Council

November, 2008

1

Project Summary Report: Moon River Walleye Spawning Bed Enhancement Project

Executive Summary: After more than three years in the planning stages, the Moon River walleye spawning bed enhancement project began construction on September 24, 2008 and concluded on October 31st.

The project was awarded to WS Morgan Construction Co. of Parry Sound. Partners in the project included Rieger Construction and Red Rock Barging.

Over 1100 metric tons of rock was imported for the enhancement project. Enhancement work on the south shore comprised the installation of multiple boulder clusters top- dressed with granite cobble – providing optional substrate for walleye spawning and incubation processes. Enhancement work on the north shore comprised the construction of one boulder cluster and the deposition of over 500 metric tonnes of granite cobble.

The spawning beds have been designed to be functional throughout the wide range of projected flows down the Moon River during the walleye spawning and incubation period, in accordance with the Muskoka River Water Management Plan* (Acres International, 2006).

This project is the centre-piece of the Moon River Walleye Rehabilitation Plan (EGBSC- OMNR, 2007) and we are extremely optimistic it will have a marked beneficial impact on this population. Future assessment work is planned to evaluate the success of this project and to continue monitoring of this provincially significant fish population in accordance with the Rehabilitation Plan.

Background

The Moon River walleye spawning enhancement project is the center-piece component of the Moon River Walleye Rehabilitation Plan (EGBSC-OMNR, 2007).

Reliable, scientific data collection on the status of the Moon River walleye population commenced in the late 1960’s and has continued on an intermittent basis to present day. Data conclusively indicates a drastic reduction in spawning population over that time period. Factors contributing to the population decline are discussed in the Rehabilitation Plan (EGBSC-OMNR, 2007).

In 2005, the then North Channel and Eastern Georgian Bay Fisheries Stewardship Council in partnership with the Upper Great Lakes Management Unit – Lake Huron Office, of the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, commenced working towards a project to enhance walleye spawning habitat below Moon Falls on the Moon River. One of the drivers of this initiative was the Muskoka River Water Management Plan, which was being formulated concurrently.

* The Moon River is part of the Muskoka watershed and a component of the Muskoka River Water Management Plan.

2


The planning of a walleye spawning enhancement project at the Moon River in conjunction with the Muskoka River Water Management Plan was highly appropriate. In the Moon River Walleye Rehabilitation Plan (EGBSC-OMNR, 2007), the regulated flow regime down the Moon River during the walleye spawning and incubation periods was identified as a stressor on this population. Hence, the final design of the enhancement project was such that the spawning beds would remain functional throughout a flow regime of 14 – 100+ cubic meters per second (CMS). The lower limit matched the guaranteed minimum flow as per the Muskoka River Water Management Plan. The upper limit greatly exceeds the average flow in the Moon River during the walleye spawning and incubation periods.

In 2005, the Upper Great Lakes Management Unit commenced an intensive habitat inventory study that characterized the walleye spawning habitat below Moon Falls. This inventory documented spawning habitat substrate, river bed elevations and wetted perimeter at various flow regimes. This data was subsequently used by the Ministry of Natural Resources’ Northeast Science and Information Unit to formulate the final design of the spawning beds to be constructed. Three spawning bed enhancement options were proposed, of which two were adopted (Figure 1). The third option – a downstream riffle running shore to shore, was abandoned due to exorbitant cost and high biological uncertainties.

In November 2007 the Environmental Assessment for this project was commenced and subsequently completed in June, 2008. (EA available upon request from the EGBSC.)

The selection of a contractor to do the work was conducted in accordance with the Ministry of Natural Resources’ ‘Request for Proposal’ process. W.S. Morgan Construction of Parry Sound was awarded the contract in August of 2008 and work commenced on September 24th.

3


Figure 1. Proposed locations for walleye spawning bed enhancement options

Figure 2. Transformation of above enhancement areas on to aerial photo

Task #2b Task #1

Task #2a

Task # 2a

Task # 2b

Task #1

4


Construction Activities:

The design specifications for this project called for 3 tasks to be completed:

Task #1

Construction of 35 boulder clusters top-dressed with cobble/boulder mix throughout, on south shore as per diagram (see Figure 1)

Material Requirements: • 280 boulders (210 tonnes) of min. 800 mm dia. (31.5”) • 525 boulders (95 tonnes) of min. 500 mm dia. (20”) • 2450 boulders (56 tonnes) of min. 250 mm dia. (10”) • 70 cubic meters (101.5 tonnes) 50-250 mm dia. (2-10”) cobble • 100 cubic meters (145 tonnes) 100-400 mm dia. (4-16”) cobble/boulder

Task 2A Addition of rock cobble along north shore as per diagram (see Figure 1) consisting of: 360 cubic meters (522 tonnes) of 50-250 mm dia. (2-10”) cobble

Task 2B

Installation of 1 boulder cluster with cobble topdressing along north shore as per diagram (see Figure I) and consisting of

Material Requirements: • 8 boulders (6 tonnes) min. 800 mm dia. (31.5”) • 15 boulders (2.7 tonnes) min 500 mm dia. (20”) • 70 boulders (1.6 tonnes) min 250 mm dia. (10”) • 2 cubic meters (2.9 tonnes) 50-250 mm (2-10”) cobble

Documentary photos of the above work is provided in Appendix A.

In addition to the foregoing, it was necessary to excavate a portion of a cobble, limestone, rock shoal formerly constructed approximately half a mile downstream of our work site. In the 1980s this shoal was constructed by the Ministry of Natural Resources – Parry Sound District, as an alternate walleye spawning site, which has proved unsuccessful. Cobble and boulders were removed to permit access past this location and then repositioned upon completion of the upstream work.

Note: The above specifications called for a total of 1,142.7 tonnes of rock. Documentation was submitted by Rieger Contracting indicating the delivery of 1,167.8 tonnes of material.

5


Acknowledgements: This project was a collaborative effort between the Eastern Georgian Bay Stewardship Council, Provincial Government (Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources) and Federal Government (Dept. of Fisheries and Oceans) and was primarily funded under the Canada-Ontario Agreement (COA). Project coordination was conducted by the Eastern Georgian Bay Stewardship Council, a member of OMNR’s Ontario Stewardship Network. The successful completion of this project is a sterling example of the tangible biological and social benefits that the Ontario Stewardship model has produced since its inception in 1996.

This COA project was initiated by the Upper Great Lakes Management Unit – Lake Huron Office. Other significant sources of funding included: Ontario Power Generation – Evergreen Energy; OMNR Parry Sound District; and several generous private donations to the Eastern Georgian Bay Stewardship Council habitat enhancement fund. We also wish to acknowledge the supporting role played by the Georgian Bay Land Trust and Georgian Bay Biosphere Reserve with respect to raising awareness and promoting private donations.

Limestone shoal

Figure 3. ‘Cabin Narrows’ with limestone shoal repositioned to facilitate barge transport.

6


We greatly acknowledge the following significant contributors to this project: OMNR – Upper Great Lakes Management Unit – Lake Huron Office staff: This project

could not have taken place without their sound baseline data collection, tireless promotion, MNR coordination and funding support. In particular we thank Dave Gonder for his key role in bringing this project to fruition.

OMNR – Northeast Science and Information Unit (Timmins): For computer modelling

designing various enhancement options. Special thanks to Scott Finucan for his dedication to this project, vis-à-vis: modelling, project design, on-site supervision and subsequent flow testing.

OMNR – Parry Sound District Office: For project support including: supplemental

funding, assistance with the Environmental Assessment process and unfailing encouragement to get the job done. In particular, special thanks to Steve Taylor for encouragement and financial support as well as flow manipulations to facilitate construction activities.

Ontario Power Generation – Evergreen Energy: For their generous donation of $40k

towards the project; and especially Bob McEwen for making this happen. Ministry of Government Services: Special thanks to Andrej Baca, (Ontario Shared

Services Procurement Officer) who lead us through the morass of government purchasing in the shortest time possible to conduct this project in the fall of 2008. Andrej’s sage advice and guidance was much appreciated and helpful.

We would also like to thank and acknowledge the Georgian Bay Land Trust and Great

Lakes Conservancy in providing us with key partner support in our fundraising efforts for this and other spawning habitat enhancement projects. We are likewise very appreciative of the many generous donors who contributed financially as well as their time and efforts towards the project.

Construction consortium of WS Morgan, Red Rock Barging and Rieger

Contracting. We were very pleased with the conscientious and cooperative manner in which construction activities were conducted. The contractors made every effort to follow direction and were very amenable to suggestions and modifications. Construction work was effectively supervised by John Mintz of Red Rock Barging.

And last, but not least, we wish to recognize the coordination efforts of the Eastern

Georgian Bay Stewardship Council. Key members of the Council who were instrumental in bringing this project to fruition: Bill McRobb, owner of Moon River Cottages for his tireless efforts, sometimes at

considerable personal expense, at providing on-site assistance in numerous instances throughout the planning and construction of the project.

Ray Hachigian for spearheading the fundraising committee and his efforts at fundraising for this and similar habitat enhancement projects.

Terry Crawford, EGBSC Chairperson, and tireless project supporter. Eric McIntyre, EGBSC Coordinator and project coordinator.

7


Appendix A - Photo documentary of enhancement work

Boulder cluster being constructed on south shore (Task #1). Bobcat on barge deposits rock at the base of barge ramp which is subsequently picked up and specifically placed by excavator with bucket and ‘thumb.’

Overview of Project Cobble deposited here – Task 2a. (Not completed at time of photo although cobble stockpiles evident.)

Task #1 – Boulder Clusters adjacent to south shore.

8


Lateral view - completed boulder clusters adjacent to south shore – Task #1.

Aerial view - completed boulder clusters adjacent to south shore – Task #1

9


Single boulder cluster location on north shore (Task 2b)

Cobble being redistributed to final location along north shore – Task 2a.

10


East facing aerial view of near completed project. Moon Falls evident at top of photo.

Zone of rock cobble distribution along north shore (Task 2a). Not completed at time of photo although cobble stockpiles evident.

South view of near-completed project

11


Moon River Rehabilitation Summary Report

Documents

Transcript of Moon River Rehabilitation Summary Report