Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
-
Upload
gabrielale -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
1/37
MOODS, MODALITYAND MODAL VERBS
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
2/37
Presentation plan
A. Definitions and distinctions (mood, modality)
B. Concepts of modality
C. Ways of expressing modalityD. Types of modality
E. Modal vers.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
3/37
Mood
formal category (expressed ! verinflections"a#xiliaries) ! $t%e vario#s &ays in &%ic%t%e action or t%e state is t%o#g%t of y t%e spea'er
(C#rme *+). syntacticastraction &%ose contentt%e
spea'er-s eval#ation of t%e event expressed y t%esentence ver (to e ! somet%ing real"fact#al or
desirale, conditioned, proale, possile,necessary, etc., i.e. disting#is%ing et&een t%eopposition /0 real).
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
4/37
A type of situation: real or
fact real1
T%e Dan#e flows into t%e Blac' 2ea.
3ala4i is situatedon t%e left an' of t%e Dan#e.
fact (involving a factual meaning)12eptim#s isin love. or 5t is la#g%ale t%at 2eptim#s is in love.
(6es, t%is is a fact1 %e is in love)
(example ! extracted from 7eec% 899+1 89)
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
5/37
A type of situation: unreal
supposition (involving a theoretical or non-factual meaning)1
reals#pposition (plan for t%e f#t#re)15t is proposed t%at t%e Assemly electa ne& Committee. (mandative
s#:#nctive)
unreals#pposition (referring to an imaginary"%ypot%etical state ofaffairs)15t is la#g%ale t%at 2eptim#s should bein love. (&%et%er %e isin love or not
is a different matter) analytical s#:#nctive0
hypothesis (involving somet%ing contrary to fact, i.e.,acounterfactual meaning)1
5t &o#ld e la#g%ale if 2eptim#s werein love. (#t act#ally %e is not in love)
(examples ! extracted from 7eec% 899+1 89)
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
6/37
Moods
Indicative ! t%e spea'er-s eval#ation of a state"event to e a fact orsomet%ing real.
T%ey &or' %ard for t%eir daily read.
Subjunctive ! t%e spea'er-s eval#ation of a state"event to e somet%ings#pposed to %appen in t%e f#t#re or s#pposed to %ave %appened int%e past, t%#s involving a t%eoretical or non!fact#al meaning.
;riends should bes#pportive and fran'.
Conditional ! a condition #nderlying t%e statement, t%#s emp%asi
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
7/37
Modality
() ?t%e spea'er-s relation to reality-
(8) ?t%e spea'er-s eval#ation of state!of!affairs-
(@) -t%e spea'er-s cognitive, emotive, or volitional
#alification of a state!of!affairs-.
Modality may refer to t%e speaker, to t%e eventor tot%eproposition. (ropositions are interpreted %ere
semantically, as sentences expressing a tr#t%, &%ic%is ovio#s ot% t%e spea'er and to t%e %earer). 5t may e &armer in t%e afternoon.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
8/37
Scale of certainty
5n an impersonaltone, in declarative sentences,spea'ers may express1(i) certainty1
e is certain to e t%ere.
5t is inevitale t%at t%erewill bea violent o#tcome.(ii) probability1
5t is likely thatt%e footaller &ill e ale t o play. eought to e ale to play.
(iii) possibility1
5t is possible t%at t%e train &ill e delayed. 5 am not certainto e t%ere.
(iv) nil certainty1 5t is not possiblefor Emily to go to college.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
9/37
Scale of certainty II
5n a personaltone, in declarative sentences, spea'ers mayexpress t%eir o&n1
(i) conviction(believe, be + convinced, positive, confident, sure,certain)1 5 am sure o#r footall team &ill &in tonig%t.
(ii) conjecture(think, presume, suppose, infer, daresay, expect,judge, conclude, trust, be of the opinion, assume, hold, suspect,subscribe to the view that, anticipate, foresee, predict, prophesy,consider, reckon, surmise, guess, imagine, conjecture)1 5 thinkt%ey &ill e %ere in time.
(iii) doubt(wonder, be + skeptical, doubtful, dubious)1 5 doubt &%et%er t%ere is any %ope for %im.(iv) disbelief(doubt, wonder, be +skeptical, doubtful, dubious +
negative)1 5 dont believein yo#r managerial s'ills.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
10/37
Semantic interpretation
Intellectivemodal concepts ! attit#des connected toreason or to t%e spea'er-s"listener-s po&er of:#dgment1 belief, conviction, skepticism, doubt, possibility, prediction,
logical necessity. Emotionalconcepts ! connected to vers of
(positive or negative) attit#de1 admiration, love, desire, hatred, regret, wish, hate,
appreciation, andanger or even(dis)approval.
Volitionalconcepts of modality ! spea'er-s act ofma'ing a c%oice or a decision1 firmness, order, necessity, reuest, application, obligation,
prohibitions, refusal, threat, determination, andwillingness.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
11/37
Means of expressingmodality rammatical 7exical Morp%ological
2yntactic
!hetorical
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
12/37
Lexical means of expressingmodali!
"roper namesinvolving a certain %#mo#r,or concealing e#p%emistic val#es, ('no&nmainly to native spea'ers)1
T%e Old Gentleman/old Gooseberry(2carao4c%i), Mrs Grundy(g#ra l#mii), and Joe Black(Doamna
c# coasa) John Barleycorn(personification of alco%olic
li#or) in1
5 %ave :#st r#n into the John Barleycorn of o#rfamily.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
13/37
Lexical means of expressingmodality
En#lish phrases&%ic% s#ggest1 doubt$ tell t%at to t%e marines disapproval$ to &as% one-s dirty linen in t%e
p#lic humouristic disapprovalto e a it on (a fi
af#mat) approval$
yo# may &ell say so irony$t%e devil-s o&n l#c'
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
14/37
Lexical means of expressingmodality"roverbs% ?modalled idioms and provers- (Croitor#
89981 FGH8>) 1
modalled idioms (i%e%& idioms 'ith a modal value)
!an a duck swim"(vrei cal#le ovI< ")
5t &ill %appen in a month of #undays(la 2fJnt#!aKteaptI)
proverbs
A ad t%ing never dies. (#r#iana rea n# piere)
A ad padloc' invites a pic'loc'. (pa
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
15/37
Morphological means(nominal constructions)
modal nouns1 possiility, proaility, c%ance,and li'eli%ood.
T%ere-s :#st a chancet%at %e may come.
modaladjectives1 possile, proale, li'ely. a) in impersonal constructions1
Its possible%e may %ave come
b) as part of a nominal group1 T%elikely&inner of t%is afternoon-s race or = t%e
mostprobableo#tcome of t%is trial...
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
16/37
Morphological means
modaladverbs1probably, possibly, surely,merely.
6o# &ere obviouslydelig%ted &it% yo#r ne& car.
Interjectionscover a large span of feelings1 oh! (s#rprise) ah! (satisfaction, recognition)
aha!(:#ilant satisfaction, recognition) yippee! (excitement, delig%t) ouch! / ow! / ooh! (pain) uh! (disg#st)
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
17/37
Morphological means(lexical er!s) leical verbsH t%e vers in t%is gro#p express s#c% notions as1 ?assertin- (believe, consider, think, reckon)
5 believe%e &ill e s#ccessf#l in %is career. ?evaluatin- (suspect, guess)
T%e detainees are suspectedto elong to terroristorgani
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
18/37
Morphological means (er!patterns) le#ico$modal au#iliariesormodal phrases(be have * adjective * infinitive$ be apt$able
to, be capable to, be bound to, be
sure$certain to, be possible$probable$likely to,
be liable to)(Croitor# 89981 F9!)
T%e protesters are sure to bearrested.
Lic'y is likely to&in t%e contest.
the use of remote past1
5 thou#ht5-d go along &it% yo#, if yo# don-t mind
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
19/37
Morphological means (modalpatterns) modal idioms1would rather, had better, would
sooner, would (just) as soon, had best (dreng%ea,GF)
5 would sooneryo# ass#med responsiilities. 5-m s#re t%ey would %ust as soonstay at %ome
We had bestforget &%at %appened. (N#ir' et al.*F>188G)
modal periphrases$have got to (gotta), be going to(gonna), be willing to, be inclined to, be about to, be
to, be capable of, be supposed$expected to, beallowed$permitted to, be in a position (determined bythe circumstances) to%
2%e was about toleave t%e room &%en t%e p%one rang.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
20/37
Morphological means (modaler!s)modal/pure/syntactic au#iliaries1can, could,
may, might, must, have to, shall, should, will,
would, ought to.
Dogs candisting#is% many odors.
pseudo / semi / "uasi modals$need, dare,be to, used to, have to%
2%eneednt
pay for t%at ill, 5 %ave already done it. &are%e steal%is rot%er-s moneyO
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
21/37
Syntactic means
If$clausesused to express doubt or uncertainty1
If yo# 'no& &%at 5 mean.
If yo# don-t mind my saying so.
'hat if %e-s %ad an accidentO
!hetorical +uestions(positive"negative)1
5s t%at a reason for despairO (Certainly, t%at is not=)
Didn-t 5 tell yo# &ere lyingO (6o# 'no&, 5 told=)
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
22/37
Syntactic means II
Eclamationsand exclamatory sentences1
!apital& 'ood of$for you&
Eclamatorysentences in t%ene#ative$
(asnts%e lost &eig%t (2%e %as lost &eig%t, %asn-t s%eO)
Eclamatory +uestions&it% a positive form1 id she look annoyed"
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
23/37
"hetorical means
!epetitions1 T%is car is far& fartoo expensive for #s
Emphatic means1 )ucha ea#tif#l girl
2%e treated t%emsocaref#lly 6o# doloo' nice today
,e#ative intensifiers1not(in t%e ver form) /at all 5 donot/dontli'e vegetalesat all*
t%e #se of non!assertive items, s#c% asany+ e-ll drin' any'ind of :#ice.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
24/37
#ypes of modality
To interpret modality, 7. orn (*8)proposes t%ree scales1
t%ey can e defined y () entailmentand
(8) +uantitativeconversational implicat#re1
lo#ical
epistemic
deontic
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
25/37
Logical scale
T%e lo#ical scalerelates1
necessity tr#t% possiility.
T%#s1
possibleis entailed y necessaryand itimplicatest%e negation of necessary, #tonly if it is regarded as a non!logical
relations%ip.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
26/37
$pistemic scale
epistemic scalerelates1 certainty proailitypossiility.
is car is near t%e garden, so %e muste at %ome no&. (certainty) T%ey should e ac' %ome in %alf an %o#r. (proaility) Pennifer is Qictor-s est friend, so s%e may'no& %is address. (possiility)
Epistemic modalities$prediction& (lo#ical) necessityand possibility.
T%e spea'er-s role1 to comment on t%e content of t%e cla#se, to ma'ereference to (lac' of) 'no&ledge or eval#ating an interpretation ofreality.
refers to t%e sentence sub%ect-s (lac' of) 'no&ledgeR it descries t%osemodalities revealing t%e val#e spea'ers attac% to t%eir #tterance
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
27/37
$pistemic scale II
"rediction! would(narratives) be apt to (repeatedstates"%appenings)1
T%e stage director noticed t%at Brad it was apt toplay complex c%aracters.
o#ical necessity-ased ! process of ded#ction1
! 6o#r moile p%one must e in yo#r ag (s#:ective1 5 'no& yo# 'eep it t%ere)! 6o#r moile p%one has toe in yo#r ag (more o:ective1 ladies 'eep it t%ere)
Epistemic possibility(possiility of somet%ing to e tr#e) ! negativecla#ses ! can1
Ta'e a very good loo' at t%em, t%ey cante real pearls.
Wit%in epistemic modality spea'ers eval#ate an interpretation of reality,and in so doing t%ey refer to (t%eir o&n) 'no&ledge.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
28/37
$pistemic scale III
is t%e modality of t%e propositions1 5t is possible for my da#g%ter to e at t%e lirary no&. My da#g%ter may e at t%e lirary no&. (strong possiility) My da#g%ter told me %er today-s planR s%e wille at t%e
lirary no&. (ass#mptive)
Modal certainty1prediction or loical necessity+&ill, m#st, e o#nd to1
T%e roadcast will e over y no&. (prediction, 5 'no& itfrom experience)
T%e roadcast must e over y no&. (logical necessity1t%e lig%ts are off)
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
29/37
Deonic scale
strong oligation (re+uest)&ea' oligation (su##estion)permission.
6o# mays%are yo#r room &it% yo#r co#sin. (permission) 6o# musts%are yo#r room &it% yo#r co#sin. (oligation) )hall5 #se my e!mail address for t%e conference correspondenceO
(offer)
may(permission) and must(oligation).shall (offer) deontic1 performatives, disco#rse! or spea'er!oriented
vers.
obliationsandpermissions. T%e spea'er-s role1 active one as (s)%e
intervenes in t%e speec% event and since (s)%e refers to oligation andpermission t%is may ring ao#t c%anges in t%e event.
6o# mustoserve t%e deadline or else yo# may miss t%e opport#nity.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
30/37
D!namic "ne#ral$a%le$a%ili!&modali!
orny (*G@188F)
() ability$p%ysical po&er or capacity, or from 'no&ledge or s'ill. T%is ox is very %eavy, canyo# lift itO
3rannie is over seventy #t s%e canstill read &it%o#t glasses.
!anyo# only #nderstand 2&edis% or canyo# spea' it as&ellO
(8) abilityres#lting from circ#mstances $e in a position to Can yo# come to t%e meeting tomorro&O (Are yo# free to do
so"in a position to do soO) Can yo# lend me five po#ndsO (Are yo# in a position to do
soO)
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
31/37
D!namic modali! II
detectale &%en canmeans ?possile for- and mustis #sed toindicate ?necessary for-.
T%e t#tor cangive yo# t%e rig%t ans&er. (meaning1 it is possile for%im to give yo# t%e rig%t ans&er).
6o# mustleave yo#r val#ales in t%e %otel safe eca#se &e do notfeel responsile for t%ings stolen from t%e %otel rooms. (meaning1 it isnecessary for yo# to =)
2#:ect!oriented dynamic modality1 can (aility) and will(&%eninvolving &illingness). 5t refers to t%e modality of events ! not
conditioned deontically. A s'illf#l professional li'e %im canfix yo#r oat in less t%at a &ee'. 5f only t%e %eadmaster willgive #s an intervie&
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
32/37
D!namic modali! III
Dynamic"aility modalities1physicalcapacity, skillor knowledeas &ell as &it% circumstances &%ic%enale s#:ects to carry o#t a partic#lar tas'.
T%is carpenter can ma'e a c%air and a stool a day.
T%e spea'er-s role1 attit#dinally ne#tral since (s)%eneit%er eval#ates, comments or interprets norintervenes in t%e proposition, #t only asserts or
in#ires ao#t t%e s#:ect-s capacity of performing atas'.
My private secretary cantype +9 &ords a min#te.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
33/37
An approach to modal er!s
(e%avio#r) divided into
(a) central$ can& could& may& mi#ht& must& () mar#inal$ used to& ou#ht to& need& dare
2%are morpholo#icaland syntactic
feat#res
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
34/37
Morphological features ofmodal er!s Canvs to can1
T%ey canplay in t%e sno&.
T%ey canm#s%rooms in t%is &or's%op.
T%ird person1 (e canplay in t%e sno& #t he maynot do it today.
forms1 May&e &ait for yo# %ere. Lo, yo# must not" yo# mustn/t.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
35/37
S!nacic fea#res' modali!and empo(aspec#ali!
6o# may smokein t%e %otel lo#nge.
T%ey may have hadan accident.
Actors can be rehearsinfor %o#rs.
2%e must have been watchintelevision for %o#rs t%atis &%y s%e loo's ex%a#sted.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
36/37
S!nacic fea#res' modali!and )e passi*e *oice
T%ey may be punishedfor t%eir mista'es.
T%e %ostages may have beenalready 'illed.
T%e prisoner m#st be bein interroatedno&.
-
8/10/2019 Moods, Modality and Modal Verbs
37/37
%onclusions
&%en not epistemic, modals may e eit%er subjector objectoriented.
canand willare s#:ect!oriented and refer to t%e aility or&illingness of t%e sentence s#:ect
may, shalland mustare disco#rse!oriented and t%ey relate tot%e spea'er-s action &%en giving permission, ma'ing a promiseor laying an oligation.
T%e syntagm ?disco#rse!oriented- ! meaningf#lly largerR it mayaccept not only t%e spea'er-s #t also t%e %earer-s intervention.
5n a #estion as *ay come in"&%ic% ill#strates an instance ofas'ing for permission, permission relates to t%e %earer and not tot%e spea'er.