Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

127

Click here to load reader

description

A comprehensive overview of the payments space specifically mobile payments, and how macro trends are driving revolutionary changes in how consumers purchase and transact. Mobile Payments (mPayments) is rapidly becoming the payment vehicle of choice for consumers worldwide. The primary drivers that have influenced this growth include mobile banking, social media, enabling technology, “unbanked” communities, and consumer/retailer acceptance of mobile commerce. Growth in mobile and tablet sales is outpacing computers and in many markets now exceeds those of computers. Acceptance and usage of mobile/tablet banking, payments, money movement, and other financial transactions are growing rapidly. Mobile social media’s global exponential growth has become the primary channel for people to interact with friends and brands. Convergence of mobile/tablet usage combined with social media are evolving into new, dynamic interaction models and ecommerce opportunities. Financial service companies, most notable Banks, are faced with disintermediation and must rethink payment models and customer centric experiences.

Transcript of Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

Page 1: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 1!

Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

Jeff  Fleischman  CEO,  Blue  Panda  Interac9ve  

New  York,  NY  July  2012  

Page 2: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 2!

Page 3: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 3!

“The Mobile-Social Economy is the convergence of mobile and social media enabled by technology. Financial institutions stand on the threshold of a new paradigm in which payments, customer experience, and personalized offers will merge. Those firms that adapt will succeed and grow, those that don’t face an uncertain future.”!!

Jeffrey FleischmanCEO, Founder

Blue Panda Interactive!

Page 4: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 4!

Trends That Influence Mobile Payments (mPayments) Growth Summary ² mPayments is rapidly becoming the payment vehicle of choice for consumers

worldwide. The primary drivers that have influenced this growth include mobile banking, social media, enabling technology, “unbanked” communities, and consumer/retailer acceptance of mobile commerce.!

² Growth in mobile and tablet sales is outpacing computers and in many markets now exceeds those of computers.!

²  Acceptance and usage of mobile/tablet banking, payments, money movement, and other financial transactions are growing rapidly.!

² Mobile social media’s global exponential growth has become the primary channel for people to interact with friends and brands.!

²  Convergence of mobile/tablet usage combined with social media are evolving into new, dynamic interaction models and ecommerce opportunities.!

²  Financial service companies, most notable Banks, are faced with disintermediation and must rethink payment models and customer centric experiences.!

Page 5: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 5!

Drivers Of mPayment Growth

mPayments  Mobile  Banking  

Social  Media  

Technology  

Unbanked  

Consumer  &  Retailer  Acceptance  

There are several irreversible trends that will drive mPayment adoption and usage as the primary payment vehicle.!

Page 6: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 6!

Drivers Of mPayment Growth

mPayments  Mobile  Banking  

Social  Media  

Technology  

Unbanked  

Consumer  &  Retailer  Acceptance  

There are several irreversible trends that will drive mPayment adoption and usage as the primary payment vehicle.!

Page 7: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 7!

Mobile Banking The surge in mobile banking and cost dynamics are the main catalysts for the acceptance and usage of mPayments.!

² More than 40MM U.S. consumers will be using mobile banking by 2012.!

²  The cost of servicing for mobile transactions is relatively small compared to all other channels and reduces overall costs for banks.!

²  Banks are setting aside over one-third of their digital channel investments for mobile initiatives with a focus on alerts, remote deposit capture (RDC) and person-to-person payments.!

² Mobile applications and technology have created complete pricing transparency.!

²  In the U.S., 15% of online adults were active mobile bankers in 2011, up from 5% in 2008. In Canada, 20% of online adults are active mobile bankers, up from 8% in 2010.!

Source: Forrester; The Yankee Group

Page 8: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 8!

²  An average teller or phone transaction costs about $2.36 each, whereas an electronic transaction costs only about $0.10 each. !

² Mobile banking and payments such as SMS text messaging can reduce the burden on customer service and IT resources. !

²  Using secure and integrated messaging platforms reduces the costs and errors associated with paper-based payments.!

² Mobile banking provides the opportunity to capture greater level of detailed information on spend, payments, location for CRM activities.!

²  Additionally, this new channel gives the bank ability to cross-sell up-sell their other complex banking products and services such as vehicle loans, credit cards etc. !

SOURCE: Mobile Banking News

Drivers of mPayment Growth - Mobile Banking One of the biggest advantages that mobile banking offers to banks is that it drastically cuts down the costs of providing service to the customers. !

Page 9: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 9!

Mobile Banking – What Customer’s Want Mobile banking has had the highest usage rates among basic transactions and is now growing more rapidly for transfers, payments, and purchases.!

Source:  Berg  Insight  

What transactions customers are doing:!

²  Balance Inquiry: 74%!

²  Notifications: 73%!

²  Statements: 48% !

²  Notification of account limit: 47% !

²  Transfer funds between accounts: 35% !

²  Pay accounts: 28% !

² Make a purchase: 21% !

Page 10: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 10!

Mobile Banking – Remote Deposit The surge in U.S. mobile banking features such as online remote deposit capture (RDC) and mobile check deposit are a catalyst for the growth of mPayments.!

² RDC   can   dras@cally   reduce   the   @me   and  cost  of  deposi@ng  checks,  many  banks  are  now   offering   RDC   to   cater   to   new  customers   as   well   as   to   retain   exis@ng  ones.    

² RDC   has   shown   an   impressive   growth  rate  of  70%  from  2004  to  2008.  

² RDC  via   a  mobile  device   launched   in   the  U.S.   in   2009   and   has   quickly   been  adopted   by   many   large   US   banks   with  high  adop@on  rates.  

² Mobile   RDC   capture   will   eliminate   over  1.5B  check  deposit  transac@ons  from  U.S.  bank  branches  by  2014.  

Source: Market Research.com; Mercatus

Page 11: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 11!

Consumer Benefits!²  Reduce Visits to Branches !²  Reduce Calls to Contact Centers!²  Change Their Spending Patterns!²  Generate More Transactions!²  Become more aware of their money !²  Become more educated about money!!

Bank Benefits!²  Realize a Reduction in Costs!²  Be able to Generate More Loyalty!²  Be Able to Increase Their Customer Base!²  Create new mechanisms to stimulate impulse buying !²  Create new sales and marketing approaches!

SOURCE: MOBILE-FINANCIAL.com

Mobile Banking The surge in mobile banking is a catalyst for the acceptance and usage of mPayments and a means to build and protect customer relationships.!

Page 12: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 12!

Source: Tower Group Fiserv Mcom Data, 2009

Mobile Banking Is Dramatically Cheaper Than Other Channels As online and mobile continue to pick up share of volume, companies will see average cost to service decline.!

 $4.00    

 $3.75    

 $1.25    

 $0.85    

 $0.17    

 $0.08    

Call  Center  

Branch  

IVR  

ATM  

Online  

Mobile  

Page 13: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 13!

Drivers Of mPayment Growth

mPayments  Mobile  Banking  

Social  Media  

Technology  

Unbanked  

Consumer  &  Retailer  Acceptance  

There are several irreversible trends that will drive mPayment adoption and usage as the primary payment vehicle.!

Page 14: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 14!

²  Social networking accounted for 50% of all page views on mobile phones in 2011.!

²  Facebook mobile users quadrupled in 2 years from 50MM to 200MM.!

² More people access Twitter and Facebook on mobile devices than on desktop computers.!

²  There are 200MM mobile video playbacks from YouTube every day.!

²  There are 1.2B internet connected smartphones and 77% of individuals use mobile phones for search.!

²  Nearly 30% of consumers conduct product research on mobile devices.!

² Over 300,000 apps have been developed in the past 3 years and downloaded more than 10.9B times.!

SOURCE: Mobile Banking News

Drivers of mPayment Growth - Social Media Social media’s popularity, smart phone sales, and app proliferation have combined to create an organic and seismic shift in mobile-social media.!

Page 15: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 15!

U.S. Social Media Habits Are Similar To Other Markets

Facebook remains the premier social media platform eclipsing all other competitors combined.!

Source: comScore; Google; Statista; Nielsen

Time spent condensed to the equivalent of one hour !

Social networks/blogs grabbing a large share of consumers time online – expect mobile to become the primary channel for social media consumption.!

Page 16: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 16!

China’s Sina Has Become Immensely Popular In China Due To Its Microblogging Platform Known As Weibo With over 513MM netizens in China, Sina’s 50MM Sina Weiboers represents rapid growth in a relatively short period of time since it’s launching in 2010.!

Source:  Sina  Nov,  16,  2010  

Sina  Sta9s9cs:  ² Monthly   Increasing   Rate   of  

Registra@on:  33.8%  ²  Rate  of  Mobile  Blogging:  38%  ²  Blogs  per  Day:  25MM  ²  Number  of  Users  of  Sina  Weibo:  

50MM  (Oct,  20,  2010)  ²  Number  of  Partnered  Sites:  10M  ²  Total   Blogs:   200MM   (Nov,   7,  

2010)  ²  Blogs  per  Second:  785  ²  Daily   Traffic   that   Weibo   Brings:  

30MM  

Page 17: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 17!

Users Spend Well Over 8 Hours Per Month On Social Media Properties; Facebook Is The Predominant Leader

0:31

0:45

1:06

1:18

1:41

1:44

1:48

2:12

2:53

7:46

Amazon

Microsoft

Apple

Wikipedia

YouTube

MSN/Windows Live/Bing

Google

Yahoo

AOL Media

Facebook

Top 10 Web Brands by Time Spent Time per viewer, hh:mm, per month, August 2011 Source: The Nielsen Company

Top 10 Global Social Networks By unique visitors (000), June 2011 Source: comScore

734,240

144,441

119,467

84,356

74,821

71,526

66,073

61,035

51,754

37,600

Facebook

Twitter

Windows Live Profile

LinkedIn

QQ.com microblogging

MySpace

Renren

Vkontakte

Orkut

Yahoo Pulse

Page 18: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 18!

Mobile Access To Social Media Networks Has Grown Sharply Across All Age Demographics Social Network Growth, by Age, Ethnicity % change, Q3 2010 v. Q3 2011

16%

61% 68%

109%

67%

45% 41%

76%

44% 37%

70%

Source:  The  Nielsen  Company  

Page 19: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 19!

Females,18-34 Year Old, Are The Most Active On Social Networks U.S. Social Network Use by Age, Demographics Base: U.S. social media users, Q3 2011

96 103

88

108 104

98 91

100 101 94

103 102 101

Source:  The  Nielsen  Company  

Page 20: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 20!

Over 50% Of Online Consumers Expect Weekly or Monthly Updates Through Social Networks

3%

7% 6%

11%

26%

13%

28%

4% 2%

More than once a day

Once a day

Every other day

Twice a week

Once a week

Twice a month Once a month or less

Never Other

Marketing Contact via Social Networks % of respondents (n=2,997) June 2011

Source:  ROI  Research  and  Performics  

Page 21: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 21!

Mobile Is a Growing Access Point For Smartphone Owners Accounting For 51% Of Facebook And 12.5% Of Twitter Users Facebook, Twitter Reach among Smartphone Users 3-month average, ending June 2011

50.9%

31.7%

12.5%

7.4%

U.S. smartphone users European smartphone users

Facebook Twitter

Source:  Experian  Hitwise  

Page 22: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 22!

Approximately 39% Of Consumers Seek Purchase Advice For Financial Services Products

Social  Networks  as  a  Source  of  Purchasing  Advice  %  of  respondents  who  sought  advice,  June  2011  

46%

42% 39%

34% 33% 33% 31% 30%

28% 28% 26%

25% 24% 23% 22% 21% 19%

17%

Consumer Average 29%  

Source:  ROI  Research  and  Performics  

Page 23: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 23!

Globally, Chinese Internet Users Spend The Most Amount Of Their Leisure Time Online Displacing Traditional Media

44%  

40%  

38%  

31%  

30%  

29%  

29%  

28%  

28%  

28%  

23%  

22%  

19%  

18%  

15%  

14%  

China  

Sourth  Korea  

Japan  

Italy  

US  

Spain  

Austraiia  

Canada  

France  

UK  

Germany  

Norway  

Netherlands  

Sweden  

Finland  

Denmark  

Source:  TNS  “Digital  World,  Digital  Life”  December  2008  

²  In  Urban  areas  the  Web  will  soon  replace  newspapers  as  the  medium  with  the  second-­‐highest  daily  reach.  

²  Among  individuals  under  the  age  of  30,  the  Internet’s  penetra@on  is  almost  as  high  as  television’s.    

² Chinese  will  be  surfing  the  Web  more  oden  at  home  and  at  work  and  less  oden  at  Internet  cafes.  They  will  also  be  relying  on  their  mobile  phones.    

² In  2011,  69%  of  users  said  they  used  their  phones  to  access  the  Web—up  30  percentage  points  in  just  three  years.  The  share  of  hours  spent  accessing  the  Internet  on  mobile  devices  is  rising  rapidly  among  all  age  groups.    

Page 24: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 24!

There Is A Growing Shift In The Consumption Of Social Media On Mobile Phones

Mobile’s Growing Influence!

² Over 50% of Facebook and Twitter traffic!

² 200MM+ daily YouTube views !

² 86% of mobile internet users use their mobile phones while watching TV!

² Americans spend an average 2.7 hours socializing on their mobile phones!

² By 2014 mobile will surpass desktop usage!

² 70% of all mobile searches result in action within 1 hour!

² One half of all local searches are performed on mobile devices!

iPhone  Top  Mobile  Apps   Android  Top  Mobile  Apps  

YouTube   Google  Search  

Google  Maps   Gmail  

Facebook   Google  Maps  

Yahoo!  Weather   Facebook  

Pandora  Radio   Google  News  and  Weather  

Angry  Birds   YouTube  

Yahoo!  Stocks   Pandora  Radio  

ESPN  ScoreCenter   Angry  Birds  

The  Weather  Channel   Adobe  Reader  

Google  Search   Words  With  Friends  

Words  With  Friends   Twiker  

Nellix   Yahoo!  Messenger  

Fruit  Ninja   Amazon  Appstore  

Twiker   Yahoo!  Mail  

Movies  by  Flixster   Google  Talk  

Facebook  Messenger   The  Weather  Channel  Source:  comScore  Mobile  Metrix  2.0,  Beta  Data,  Dec-­‐2011,  U.S.,  Mobile  Marketer    

U.S.  Top  Mobile  Apps  for  iPhone  and  Android  by  Unique  Ac@ve  Users  (Age  18+)    

Page 25: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 25!

Case Study: American Express

Page 26: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 26!

Case Study: American Express The Emergence Of The Social eCommerce Model American Express is arguably one of the most innovative companies to generate engagement and sales from the integration of web, mobile, and social media.!

Page 27: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 27!

The Emergence Of Social eCommerce Model "Go Social" Tool for Small Business Merchants - Launched May 14, 2012 !

The "Go Social" offer tool is a virtual one-stop shop that allows American Express merchants to:!² Create and manage coupon-less

offers into digital channels such as Facebook and other platforms.!

²  Track offer campaign results across multiple social networks and locations.!

²  Help merchants to build their business and evaluate their social offer campaigns with detailed reports that they can access through their own secure dashboards.!

²  The platform is built upon American Express' Smart Offer API.!

Page 28: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 28!

The Emergence Of The Social eCommerce Model “Sync, Tweet, Save” Twitter Initiative – Launched March 2012 !

American Express turns twitter #hashtags into couponless national merchant offers and Cardmember savings using its smart offer APIs. API enable Amex to provide valuable merchant reporting about customers’ spending behaviors. Cardmembers can now sync their cards with Twitter, tweet, and save at national merchant partners including Best Buy®, McDonald’s, Whole Foods Market, Zappos.Com, and more. The campaign generated over US $12.8MM in it’s first two months.!

Page 29: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 29!

The Emergence Of The Social eCommerce Model “Link, Like, Love” Facebook Initiative Launched July 2011!

² On the American Express Facebook page, cardmembers can link their cards to the program and choose their favorite deals. !

² American Express will send statement credits to cardmembers' accounts as they shop online or in stores, without the need to pre-purchase anything, print out or show a coupon at the point of sale. !

² Delivers deals and offers based on cardmember Facebook activity, pages they like and share, as well as the activities of Facebook friends. !

² When the related transaction is made with the American Express card within a specific time period, the discount is credited to cardmember account. !

Page 30: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 30!

American Express Has Spent Years Developing The OPEN Small Business Network Community  

²  OPEN is American Express’ strategy to create market leadership and engagement beyond its customer base!

²  The OPEN Forum is a central location for the small business community!

²  OPEN Forum includes pertinent articles, blogs, and contributors!

²  Articles and content throughout OPEN Forum can be shared through Twitter, Facebook, Linkedin, emai, RSS, etc. !

!²  Mobile and tablet applications are being

introduced as additional distribution points!

OPEN  is  American  Express’  strategy  is  to  drive  higher  sales  and  share  of  wallet.  

Page 31: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 31!

Drivers Of mPayment Growth

mPayments  Mobile  Banking  

Social  Media  

Technology  

Unbanked  

Consumer  &  Retailer  Acceptance  

There are several underlying trends that will drive mPayment adoption and usage as the primary payment vehicle.!

Page 32: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 32!

²  3G networks have seen dramatic growth and we expect to see the same trajectory for next generation systems (e.g. 4G).!

² Mobile subscriptions surpassed the number of landlines in 2002 and is now is 3 times larger globally.!

²  Smartphone sales were up over 63% in 2011 from 2010 (488.5MM) and approximately 5.9B people use mobile phones globally!

²  iPad/tablets have the fastest adoption rate in history – outstripping iPhone adoption by over 3 times.!

²  Android-based devices continue to outpace iPhone sales and is the dominant mobile platform. The Google based system lags behind Apple app development but it is expected to narrow over the next 3 years.!

²  There are a number of disparate mobile platforms that companies must build their mPayment capabilities for as standards vary by region. !

SOURCE: Mobile Banking News

Drivers of mPayment Growth - Technology As carriers and telecomm companies have upgraded their infrastructure it has led to a corresponding increase in adoption and usage. This trend will bolster mPayments globally.!

Page 33: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 33!

Source:  Informa  WCIS+.  

        Q411  3G  Subscribers  

(MM)  

3G  Penetra@on  

3G  Subscribers  YoY  Growth  

        Q411  3G  Subscribers  

(MM)  

3G  Penetra@on  

3G  Subscribers  YoY  Growth  

1  USA     208   64%   31%   16  Canada   16   62%   34%  2  Japan   122   95%   9%   17  T  aiwan   14   48%   17%  3  China     57   6%   115%   18  South  Africa   13   21%   49%  4  Korea   45   85%   10%   19  Turkey   13   20%   62%  5  Italy   44   51%   25%   20  Portugal   13   78%   19%  6  UK   42   53%   25%   21  Vietnam   12   11%   358%  

7  Brazil   41   27%   99%   22  Mexico   11   11%   55%  8  India   39   4%   841%   23  Malaysia   10   27%   7%  

9  Germany   38   36%   23%   24  Sweden   10   73%   25%  10  Spain   33   57%   21%   25  Philippines   10   11%   45%  11  France   30   45%   35%   26  Saudi  Arabia   10   19%   17%  12  Indonesia   29   11%   27%   27  Netherlands   9   44%   34%  13  Poland   28   57%   17%   28  Egypt   8   10%   60%  14  Australia   22   76%   21%   29  Austria   7   58%   24%  15  Russia   17   8%   45%   30  Nigeria   6   6%   51%  

Global  3G  Stats:  Subscribers  =  1,098MM        Penetra@on  =  18%          Growth  =  37%    

In Q411 There Were 1.1B Global Mobile 3G Subscribers, Up 37% YoY With A 18% Share Of All Mobile Subscribers

Page 34: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 34!

In 2002 A Global Milestone Was Reached As Mobile Subscription Surpassed Landlines Mobile subscriber growth continues to grow rapidly while landlines are in a slow rate of decline!

Source: International Telecommunications Union

Global  Install  Base  MMs  

Page 35: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 35!

Apple Has Achieved Exponential Growth With Each Successive Product Launch

Source: KPCB; Apple

First 8 Quarters Cumulative Unit Shipments!

iPhone  vs.  iPod  =  20x  

iPad  vs.  iPhone  =  3x  iPad  vs.  iPod  =  60x  

Page 36: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 36!

The iPhone Sales Rate Has Been Eclipsed By The Android Platform And Continues To Outpace Apple

First 13 Quarters of Cumulative Unit Shipments!

Source: KPCB; Gartner; Morgan Stanely

Page 37: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 37!

Tablets And eReaders Are Growing Rapidly And Have Become A Third Screen For Consumers Tablets will play an increasingly integral role for digital consumers – banks and retailers will need to adjust their strategy and experiences specifically for them.!

*Estimate Source: Pew Research; Independent Research

0%  

10%  

20%  

30%  

40%  

50%  

60%  

2%   3%   4%   5%   6%  

14%   16%   18%  

29%  

55%*  

%  Ownership  US  Adults  With  A  Tablet  or  eReader  

Page 38: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 38!

Source: KPCB; internetworldstats.com

In 2011 There Were 2.3B Global Internet Users, Representing A 8% CAGR From 2008 Rank   Country   2008-­‐2011  New  

Internet  Users  (MMs)  2011  Internet  Users  (MMs)  

YoY  Growth  

Popula9on  Penetra9on  

1   China   215   513   12%   38%  

2   India   69   121   38%   10%  

3   Indonesia   37   55   22%   23%  

4   Philippines   28   34   44%   35%  

5   Nigeria   21   45   N/A   28%  

6   Mexico   19   42   19%   37%  

7   Russia   16   61   3%   43%  

8   USA   15   245   1%   79%  

9   Iran   14   37   N/A   48%  

10   Turkey   11   36   26%   49%  

Top  10   444   1189   12%   32%  

World   663   2250   8%   32%  

Page 39: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 39!

Drivers Of mPayment Growth

mPayments  Mobile  Banking  

Social  Media  

Technology  

Unbanked  

Consumer  &  Retailer  Acceptance  

There are several irreversible trends that will drive mPayment adoption and usage as the primary payment vehicle.!

Page 40: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 40!

²  There are over 2.5B unbanked people globally, many of which are in Africa, Asia, and Latin America.!

²  Because most of the unbanked currently own a mobile phone they are readily adopting mPayment based options.!

² Mobile payments are bringing disparate players together in collaboration to provide new payment options to the unbanked.!

²  The majority of mobile payments are focused on retail and person-to-person (P2P) payments.!

²  The ability to enhance the unbanked regions will vastly improve the flow of funds and ultimately spur economic growth that would otherwise be difficult to obtain.!

Source: Mobile Banking News

Drivers of mPayment Growth - Unbanked The worlds unbanked are rapidly adopting mPayments without the need for a bank. Banks will face stiff competition to win marketshare.!

Page 41: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 41!

SOURCE: Demirguc-Kunt and Klapper 2012

Many Parts Of The World Have A Large Percentage Of Unbanked Consumers mPayments will provide access to a more efficient and lower cost payment system fueling new economic prosperity for the world’s unbanked.!

89%  

55%  45%   39%   33%   24%   18%  

11%  

45%  55%   61%   67%   76%   82%  

High  Income  Economies  

East  Asia  &  Pacific  

Europe  &  Central  Asia  

La@n  America  &  Caribbean  

South  Asia   Sub-­‐Saharan  Africa  

Middle  East  &  North  Africa  

Unbanked   Banked  

Page 42: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 42!

Emerging Partnerships and Platforms In China – UMPay

²  According   to   UMPay,   e-­‐   and  mPayment  users  will  exceed  500MM  people   and   currently   has   100MM  mPayment   users.   Most   of   these  users  are  the  unbanked.  

²  The   greatest   growth   will   be   from  rural  farmers.    This  is  the  strategy  of  UMPay  today  -­‐   to  saturate  the  rural  loca@ons   with   UMPay   access  growing   to   half   a   billion   in   the   very  near  future  according  to  UMPay  CEO  Bin  Zhang.  

Launched  in  2003  It  provides  China  Mobile  users  with  a  comprehensive  mobile  payment  plalorm  and    mPayment  system  that  provides  mobile  wallets,  financial  message  services,  top-­‐ups  and  mobile  @cke@ng.    

Page 43: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 43!

India Is The World’s Second Most Populous Nation And Has Over 450MM Unbanked People In a country where cash is used in 65% of retail transactions and mobile phones are common, mPayments are poised to grow.!

India Facts & Figures!²  Mobile phone connections outnumber bank

accounts by more than a factor of three: 893MM mobile phone subscribers and 250MM bank accounts. !

²  The National Payment Council of India (NPCI) launched the Interbank Mobile Payment Service (IMPS). IMPS allows a person to pay/remit money to a merchant or an individual in real-time using a mobile phone number and a mobile phone identifier. !

²  M-commerce been gaining traction. India's leading m-commerce player, ngpay, has over 1.5 million registered users who can purchase products through their mobile phones. Their mobile mall has a daily volume of 40,000-50,000 unique users, with about 15% of those making purchases with an average transaction size of about Rs 700.!

Page 44: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 44!

Payments Using SMS And USSD Has Grown Exponentially in Certain Regions Will Expand Globally ²  Consumers in Africa, the Middle East, and India rely on telecoms including

Vodafone and MTN to provide mobile money options.!² Western Union has partnered with MTN in Uganda to launch a mobile-transfer

service. WU has agreements with 11 mobile operators and an additional 17 is in the works.!

Kenya  

M-Pesa Facts & Figures!² M-Pesa, Swahili for money!²  SMS based mobile money mPayment

launched in 2007!²  By 2011 68% of adults use mobile money!²  Average transaction size is $30!²  Users give cash to agent, money is loaded

onto account, payment made via SMS, confirm given to merchant via SMS!

Page 45: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 45!

Drivers Of mPayment Growth

mPayments  Mobile  Banking  

Social  Media  

Technology  

Unbanked  

Consumer  &  Retailer  Acceptance  

There are several irreversible trends that will drive mPayment adoption and usage as the primary payment vehicle.!

Page 46: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 46!

² Purchases from mobile devices is on the rise with consumers - 24% bought on a mobile website and 18% on a mobile app.!

² Mobile technology enables retailers to push local mobile offers, discounts, and rewards to incent in-store traffic. !

² Retailers have seen a substantial increase in online traffic and sales coming from tablets. !

² In the 2012 Shop.org/Forrester Research State of Retailing Online survey, 49% of retailers reported that the average order value via a tablet device is now higher than a smartphone or desktop. !

² Retailers with both tablets and smartphone apps, 45% of their total mobile web traffic for smartphones occur on the Web and 17% on apps. For tablets, 28% occur on the Web and 11% on apps.!

Source: Mobile Banking News

mPayments – Consumer & Retailer Acceptance The proliferation of digital technology and the rise of social media have contributed to a growing adoption and usage of mPayment services.!

Page 47: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 47!

The Emergence Of The Mobile Web As The Dominant Channel Of Choice – It’s Become Mainstream

Social networking accounted for of all page views on mobile phones in 2011!

Facebook mobile users have!

from 50MM in 2009 to 200MM in 2011!

There are mobile video playbacks from YouTube every day!

Over 300k apps have been developed in the

past 3 years and downloaded more than 10.9Btimes!

Nearly 30% of consumers conduct product research on mobile devices !

Twitter has over active users

sending over tweets a day!

86% of mobile internet users use their mobile phone while watching TV !

90% of the largest retailers have a mobile site or smartphone app!

Page 48: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 48!

Globally, Mobile Devices Are Increasing The Device Of Choice For A Variety Of Activities

Mobile’s Growing Influence!²  Overall Text messaging is highest with

Europeans preferring it the most at 84.4%. Japanese are much less likely in comparison at 44.4%!

²  Mobile social media and blogging are relatively new and North Americans have the highest rates above 30%. Expect these numbers to jump globally.!

²  Photos, and email rank consistently among the highest activities across all regions.!

²  Gaming is bigger in the US and Canada than other regions that may be influenced by popularity of the iPhone.!

²  Japanese are more likely to do email and, in general, access and search for content.!

²  Watching video from YouTube and proprietary content providers will continue to grow as smartphone ownership increases and content becomes available.!

US   EU5   Canada   Japan  

Sent  text  message   74.3%   84.4%   69.2%   44.4%  

Took  photos   60.3%   59.8%   55.1%   63.9%  

Used  email   40.8%   30.0%   35.9%   57.3%  

Accessed  Social  networks/blog  

35.3%   25.7%   31.2%   19.6%  

Accessed  weather   35.2%   23.2%   29.8%   35.1%  

Played  games   31.4%   27.5%   30.8%   15.3%  

Accessed  search   29.5%   20.4%   25.6%   30.8%  

Accessed  maps   26.5%   18.2%   21.65%   19.4%  

Accessed  news   25.5%   20.0%   20.1%   24.3%  

Listened  to  music   23.8%   27.4%   23.0%   13.3%  

Accessed  sports  info   21.8%   16.5%   16.0%   19.7%  

Accessed  financial  news  or  stock  quotes  

15.1%   11.3%   11.4%   17.9%  

Accessed  online  retail   12.2%   8.2%   6.1%   10.0%  

Source:  comScore  Mobile  Metrix  2.0,  Beta  Data,  Dec-­‐2011,  U.S.  

Mobile  Ac@vi@es  by  Share  of  Total  Mobile  Audience  

Page 49: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 49!

98%  89%  

79%   74%  64%  

At  Home   On  The  Go   Shopping   At  Work   Commu@ng  

Mobile Consumer Behavior Mobile devices have become an indispensible part of our lives……!

Over 300k apps have been developed in the past 3

years and downloaded more than 10.9B times!

……  And  are  used  universally  by  consumers  throughout  the  day  

Page 50: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 50!

Mobile Web Traffic Will Surpass Desktop Web Traffic By 2015 Tablet access to the web will gain a large foot hold as it’s growth is eclipsing desktop sales and growing at a faster rate than mobile.!

27%  

43%  

52%  

73%  

57%  

48%  

0%  

20%  

40%  

60%  

80%  

100%  

2007   2011   2015E  

Web  Surfing  By  Device  

Page 51: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 51!

Mobile Web Traffic Growth Global mobile traffic as a % of total web traffic has grown by a factor of 20 over the past 4 years. !

2011  Year  in  Review  and  Outlook  for  2012  ² Mobile   data   traffic  more   than  doubled  

in   2011.     Global   mobile   data   traffic  more   than   doubled   growing   133%   in  2011,  for  the  fourth  year  in  a  row.    

² Mobile  data   traffic  will  double  again   in  2012  

²  Cisco  es@mates  that   traffic   in  2012  will  grow  110%,  reflec@ng  a  con@nua@on  in  the  tapering  of  growth  rates.    

²  The   evolving   device   mix   and   the  migra@on   of   traffic   from   the   fixed   to  mobile   network   has   the   poten@al   to  bring  the  growth  rate  higher.  

Mobile  data  traffic  as  a  percent  of  total  web  traffic    

166%  CAGR  

Page 52: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 52!

China Has The Largest Online Population And By 2015 It Is Expected To Become The World’s  Largest Online Retail Market  

² By 2015, China will add nearly 200MM users, reaching an Internet population of more than 700MM users—double the combined number of Japan and the U.S. !

² In 2011, consumers spent 1.9B hours a day online— an increase of 60% from two years earlier. !

² Online buying and selling, including group purchasing, is the second fastest growing activity after micro blogging. !

² Chinese consumers are quickly adopting mobile usage that will be used as a primary access point and payment choice for the internet.!

² Users have not only adopted real-time mobile social networking at a growing rate they are also doing so with increasing frequency.!

Source:  Bain,  Nielsen  

China has become a major Internet market with increasingly sophisticated consumers. !

Page 53: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 53!

Internet Sales Have Taken Off As Online Retailers Gain Share, Mobile Will Become A Key Component Of This Growth

² Between 2011 and 2015, online retail sales will increase 300% to more than $360 billion. !

² China’s consumer behavior continues to evolve as they rapidly adopt a digital lifestyle. !² Half of Internet users say that the Internet is

their most trusted source of information, fol lowed by television at 30% and newspapers at 15%. !

² Between 2008 and 2011, the online share of consumer spending increased from 11.8% to 14.3%. Between 2011 and 2015, per capita online spending will likely rise by 15% annually. !

² Consumers research products online that they eventually buy in physical stores and 25% of consumers research online before buying offline – a trend consistent in other markets.!

Source:  The  Boston  Consul9ng  Group,  China’s  Digital  Genera9ons  3.0    

In  2010,  more  products  were  purchased  on  Taobao  than  at  China’s  top  five  brick-­‐and-­‐mortar  retailers  combined.    

Page 54: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 54!

Adoption Of Mobile Payments Has Accelerated in 2010 And Is Expected To Continue On An Upward Trajectory

31 Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.

Mobile Commerce = We Have Lift Off!

$0

$1

$2

$3

$4

$5

2009 2010 2011

Gro

ss M

obile

Sal

es o

r P

aym

ent

Volu

me

($B

)

eBay

PayPal

Target

Amazon.com

Square

Mobile Sales or Payment Volume – eBay / PayPal / Amazon.com / Target / Square, 2009-2011E

Note: Amazon.com disclosed 2010 mobile gross sale, 2009 / 2011 data are KPCB estimates. Source: eBay, Amazon.com, Target, Square.

Source:  KPCB  

Page 55: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 55!

Mobile Queries Are Growing Rapidly As Consumers Are Using Them Increasingly For Information and Transactions

19 Copyright 2011. All rights reserved.

Mobile Search – Growing Rapidly

19

Google US Mobile Queries (Indexed), 2007 – 2011

120

100

80

60

40

20

0

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

4x Growth in past years

Source: Google.

Source:  comScore,  KPCB  

Page 56: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 56!

Source:  comScore,  KPCB  

As US eCommerce Grows The Percent Of Mobile eCommerce Is Climbing, Reaching 8% in Q1 2012

Page 57: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 57!

Social Sites Are A Source For Information, Comparisons, And Ratings That Influences Buying Behavior Community,  Social  Tools  that  Impact  Buying  %  of  respondents,  June  2011  

59%

42%

26%

15%

13%

13%

9%

9%

User-generated product reviews

Online customer Q&A on product website

Community forums (conversations between

customers)

User-generated videos

Facebook company fan pages

Facebook newsfeed (friends talking about

products)

Mobile (iPhone app, text alerts)

Twitter (monitor, respond to, and post tweets)

Source:  e-­‐tailing  group,  PowerReviews  

Page 58: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 58!

Page 59: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 59!

“Give people more control over their banking and you’ll win their loyalty. That’s because mobile is not a channel so much as a way consumers live their lives and consequently, the way banks have to conduct their business.”! !

Douglas Brown!Senior VP Mobile Product Development!

Bank of America!

Page 60: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 60!

mPayments Summary

²  The Financial services industry has undergone a broad and rapid transformation over the past decade driven largely by technology and web based services!

² Mobile phone proliferation, development of mobile platforms, and capabilities have created a new dynamic paradigm in the payments industry!

²  Convenience and ease of use of mobile capabilities has created a seismic shift in the consumer mindset and acceptance of mPayments !

²  Social media coupled with mobile phones have been the catalyst to a growing opportunity to engage consumers and win share for companies!

² mPayments will grow rapidly as a percentage of total payments, however, banks risk disintermediation by non-bank competitors!

²  A big driver of mPayments will be the nearly 2.5B unbanked people in developing markets turning to non-bank mPayment options!

Page 61: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 61!

mPayment Roadmap For Banks – Creating Frictionless Finance Networks

²  Success will come from continued focus on building new distribution models and capabilities to enable mPayments.!

²  In order for the mobile wallet and payments to grow in adoption, it has to be simple, ubiquitous and have a compelling value to consumers.!

²  Prolific growth of smartphones and consumer acceptance is driving growth in mPayments.!

²  Banks must invest in several mPayment technologies as standardized platforms have yet to emerge and will likely vary across geographies.!

²  Banks must rethink their relationships with telecommunications companies and retailers to build and maintain market share and protect their payment marketshare form new competitors.!

Page 62: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 62!

History of Payments From Barter to Frictionless Finance There has been more transformation in the payments space in the past 5 years than the prior 2,500 years.!

BEFORE  600  BC  

CHECKS  PAPER  MONEY  

COINS   CREDIT  CARDS  

mPAYMENTS  

600BC  –  PRESENT  

BARTER/  TRADE  

806  –    PRESENT  

321BC  –    PRESENT  

1800s  –    PRESENT  

Source:  SapientNitro  

PRESENT  –  FUTURE  

Page 63: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 63!

Late  1970’s    –  Mid  1980’s   1994   1997   Today  

Evolution of Electronic Payments

Fric@onless  Finance  –  device,  currency  agnos@c  

Coinciding with the evolution of payments has been the development of technological advances that have created a frictionless, global ability to move money anywhere anytime.!

Rudimentary  Home  Banking  system  based  on  landlines  

Online  Banking  and  Bill  Pay.    Ability  to  access  accounts  any@me  

First  Mobile  Banking  service  

Page 64: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 64!

Mobile Users By % of Population

A f r i c a 5 3 %

A r a b S t a t e s 9 6 . 7 %

A m e r i c a s 1 0 3 . 3 % E u r o p e

1 1 9 . 5 % A s i a 7 3 . 9 %

Source:  KPCB  Internet  Trends,  Mary  Meeker  May  30,  2012    

C I S 1 4 . 3 %

30%  of  the  world’s  mobile  users  live  in  China  and  India  

87%  of  the  world’s  popula@on  have  a  mobile  phone  

Smartphone  sales  increased  63.1%  from  2010  to  2011  

Page 65: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 65!

Growth In mPayment Users 2010 – 2011: Use of mobile phone as payment device that is pre-loaded with funds.

9%   21%  6%   8%   9%   20%   10%   13%  1%   7%   16%   17%  10%   25%  USA   CHILE   BRAZIL   KENYA   SINGAPORE   HONG  KONG   CHINA  

Emerging markets have higher penetration and growth rates for mobile payments. !

Source:  NitroSapient  

Page 66: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 66!

The Growth Rate For mPayment Users By Region Mobile payment users had double digit growth across all markets from 2009 to 2010. !

Source:  Javelin  Strategy  2009  

Region   2009   2010   %  Change  

Asia  Pacific   41,865   62,  828   50.0%  

EMEA   16,823   27,091   61.0%  

La@n  America   5,131   8,010   56.1%  

Western  Europe   4,519   7,127   57.7%  

North  America   1,905   3,502   83.8%  

Total   70,243   108,558   54.5%  

Mobile  Payment  Users  By  Region  (000)  

Page 67: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 67!

Global mPayment Transaction Growth By Regions mPayments across all regions have experienced substantial growth from 2008 to 2012; rates will slow as markets reach saturation.!

Source:  Arthur  D.  Likle  

Page 68: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 68!

Electronic Payments In The US Grew By Over 82% In 2011 Mobile usage is growing rapidly for retail and payments creating an opportunity to gain share of wallet for ecommerce.!

134%  

87%  80%   82%  

77%   74%   74%   72%   70%   69%  

0%  

20%  

40%  

60%  

80%  

100%  

120%  

140%  

160%  

0  

5,000  

10,000  

15,000  

20,000  

25,000  

30,000  

35,000  

40,000  

Audien

ce  (0

00)  

Dec-­‐10   Dec-­‐11  

comScore  MobiLens,  3  month  average  ending  Dec.  2011  vs.  Dec.  2010,  US  

US  Top  Mobile  Categories  By  Growth  In  Audience  (000)  

Page 69: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 69!

mPayments In China 2010 - 2013

Payment growth will be fueled by:!

² The share of hours of internet access on mobile devices is rising rapidly among all age groups. !

² Growing usage of mobile apps.!

² Technology that increases the utility of mobile devices as a payment option.!

² Proliferation of mobile devices and mobile infrastructure.!

² Greater access to the web through mobile devices.!

² Convenience in researching product information and pricing transparency.!

19  48  

121  

219  

102  

191  

308  

481  

2010   2011E   2012E   2013E  

Mobile  Payments  (Billion  Yuan)  Mobile  Payment  Users  (MM)  

Source:  China  Internet  Watch  

² mPayments are expected to grow by 1132% and mobile payment users will increase by 472%. !

²  In 2011, 69% of users said they used their phones to access the Web—up 30 percentage points in just three years.!

Page 70: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 70!

The Players: Several Industry Groups Are Working On One or More mPayment Options The digital wallet is “owned” by several industry segments that each provide key components for mPayments and digital wallets.!

Financial  Ins@tu@ons  

Telecommunica@on  Companies  (1)  

Retailers  

(1)Telecommunica@on  companies  include  carriers,  handset  makers,  chip  makers,  OEMs  

Page 71: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 71!

The Players: Each Industry Group Has A Unique Role Within The mPayment Process Collectively mPayment players each provide key components for mPayments and digital wallets. They must work together to create end-to-end experiences.!

Financial  Ins@tu@ons  

Telecommunica@on  Companies(1)  

Retailers  

Banking  services  Loans  

Payment  Processing  Credit  Card  services  

Security  Infrastructure  

Wireless  Networks  Handsets  

Mobile  Apps  Mobile  Payment  Services  Mobile  Coupon  Services  Security  Infrastructure  

Loyalty  Programs  Merchandise  

Shopping  Experience  Consumer  Data  Point  of  Sale  

Security  Infrastructure  

(1)Telecommunica@on  companies  include  carriers,  handset  makers,  chip  makers,  OEMs  

Page 72: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 72!

The Players: Who Owns The Customer Relationship? The mPayment customer relationship is fragmented with each player having a unique role that will vary by market.!

Financial  Ins@tu@ons  

Financial  Rela@onship  

Telecommunica@on  Companies(1)  

Reliability  

Retailers  

Shopping  Experience  

(1)Telecommunica@on  companies  include  carriers,  handset  makers,  chip  makers,  OEMs  

Page 73: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 73!

Financial  Ins@tu@ons  

Telecommunica@on  Companies  (1)  

Retailers  ² Financial Institutions, Telecommunication Companies,

and Retailers need to collaborate and structure a revenue share model.!

² How businesses will get enough consumers to use the digital wallet and enough merchants to accept mobile payments.!

² Ensure that the end-to-end user experience is easy to use, intuitive, and seamless.!

² Focus on establishing global standards that can facilitate the growth of mPayments.!

To Establish A Mature mPayments Environment Key Issues Need To Be Addressed

(1)Telecommunica@on  companies  include  carriers,  handset  makers,  chip  makers,  OEMs  

Page 74: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 74!

KPMG 2011 mPayments Global Survey Highlights

²  Survey focused on projected success of the current and emerging mPayment methods, which were described in the survey as: !

Ø  M-wallet (mobile wallet): account and transaction info is stored on a SIM card; !

Ø  M-banking (mobile banking): direct access to the subscriber’s bank services and information via the mobile device; !

Ø  Contactless card systems: a short-range high frequency wireless communication technology which enables the exchange of data between devices; !

Ø  Specialist online payment systems: for example, Google checkout or PayPal; !

Ø  Carrier billing: for example, purchases are billed on the subscriber’s mobile phone bill. !

²  Opinions across geographies were remarkably consistent, while variation across industries was in some cases more pronounced. !

²  Only mBanking and online payment systems are seen as gaining traction in the short term. However, most respondents believe the mPayments will grow dramatically over the next 4 years. !

²  For the remaining solutions, respondents were most likely to say that it was still too early to predict whether or not the solution would be adopted widely. !

Page 75: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 75!

KPMG 2011 Mobile Payments Global Survey Highlights

ASPAC  EMEA  

Americas  

5%  6%  

5%  

39%  37%  

37%  

39%   39%   40%  

14%  15%  

5%  

2%  3%  

4%  

Mainstream  Today  

1-­‐2  Years  

3-­‐4  Years  

5-­‐10  Years  

10+  Years  

When asked respondents over 75% of those asked believe mobile payments will become mainstream in the next 4 years.!

Source:  KPMG  2011  Mobile  Payments  Global  Survey    

Global Sentiment Indicates Significant Growth In Mobile Payments Across All Regions.!

Page 76: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 76!

All  Retail  

Telecom  Fin.  Services  

Technology  

9%  9%  

7%   10%  

6%  

37%  40%   41%  

36%  

41%  37%  

34%  

39%  

37%   39%  

13%   14%  

10%   13%  12%  4%  

3%  

2%  3%  

2%  

Mainstream  Today  

1-­‐2  Years  

3-­‐4  Years  

5-­‐10  Years  

10+  Years  

KPMG 2011 Mobile Payments Global Survey Highlights

Source:  KPMG  2011  Mobile  Payments  Global  Survey    

75% of respondents believe mobile payments will become mainstream within the next 4 years.!

Global Sentiment Indicates Significant Growth In Mobile Payments Across All Industries.!

Page 77: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 77!

60% Of Companies Have A mPayments Strategy But Only 50% Offer A Service The number of companies that implement a mPayments service is expected to grow as equipment reaches the market and consumers continue to adopt mPayments.!

2011  KPMG  Mobile  Payments  Global  Survey    

26%  

29%  

27%  

32%  

38%  

38%  

24%  

29%  

30%  

33%  

32%  

31%  

33%  

36%  

34%  

29%  

31%  

29%  

27%  

26%  

21%  

15%  

30%  

29%  

13%  

10%  

14%  

13%  

8%  

10%  

11%  

13%  

Americas  

EMEA  

ASPAC  

Technology  

Financial  Services  

Telecom  

Retail  

All  

It  has  a  strategy  and  a  current  service   It  has  a  strategy  but  no  service  

It  has  no  service  and  no  plans  for  one  at  present   Don't  know  

Page 78: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 78!

71%  

57%  

38%  

33%  

32%  

29%  

26%  

21%  

6%  

Security  

Technology/Adop@on  

Privacy  

Regula@on/Legisla@on  

Cost  

Reliability  

Complexlty  

Availability  

Other  

Companies overwhelmingly believe that security concerns must be overcome to be successful in mobile payments

“What in your opinion are the main challenges companies face as they develop mobile payment strategies?”!

Source:  KPMG  2011  Mobile  Payment  Global  Survey  

Page 79: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 79!

Attitudes Towards Mobile Payments Are Consistent Across Asia And The West

0%  

20%  

40%  

60%  

80%  

Privacy  Issues   ID  Thed  &  Fraud  Concerns  

More  Convienent   Prefer  Most  Payments  are  Mobile    

Asia   Europe/US  

Source:  SapientNitro  

Respondents have concerns regarding privacy and ID theft although they are offset by consumer preference and convenience.!

Page 80: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 80!

Flexibility, Price Transparency, and Convenience Are The Main Drivers Consumers In China Shop Online !

² Online shops run business with a much cheaper cost and product prices are lower and a major factor for shopping online. !

² Faster and easier than going to retail stores rank the 3rd and the 4th respectively. !

² Convenience at anytime, anywhere is important to Chinese consumers.!

28%  

25%  

18%  

11%  

7%  

4%  

2%  

1%  

1%  

1%  

Shopping  Any@me  

Low  Price  

Faster  Than  Going  To  Store  

Easier  Than  Going  To  Store  

Easier  To  Compare  Prices  

More  Choices  

Ability  To  Find  Products  

Delivery  Service  

Detailed  Product  Info  

Easier  To  Find  Favorite  Brand  

Source:  DCCI,  China’s  Internet  Watch  

Reasons  Why  Consumers  Choose  To  Shop  Online  

The primary reasons why consumers shop online are consistent across markets. !

Page 81: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 81!

Drivers That Will Shape Mobile Payments (UK Survey)

87%  

67%  

67%  

37%  

35%  

29%  

17%  

14%  

4%  

3%  

Conveninece  to  pay  

Speed  of  paying  

Easier  to  pay  

Good  for  environment  

No  personal  info  on  receipt  

Track  spending  easily  

Fraud  less  likely  

Latest  technology  

Don't  know  

Other  

²  Respondents sited convenience and speed as the main drivers to adopt mPayments. These views are consistent across global markets and outweigh concerns about security. !

²  Security perception is improving because payment providers protect consumers against fraud and the implementation of authorization/verification processes.!

Page 82: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 82!

Barriers To Shopping on Smart Phones (UK Survey)

49%  

36%  

31%  

26%  

23%  

20%  

18%  

13%  

Awkward  shopping  experience  

Credit  card  security  

Slow  connec@on  

Screen  readability  

Not  easy  to  view  product  info  

Takes  too  long  

Limited  product  info  

Full  products  not  offered  

The largest barriers to conduct shopping on their mobile devices are ease of use, security, and performance concerns.!

Page 83: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 83!

Interest Among US Consumers In Using Mobile Wallet Technology To Pay For Merchandise In-Store Mobile wallets have uphill climb for consumer acceptance – this will occur as mobile payment systems gain traction and retailers integrate in-store terminals.!

Completely  Disinterested,  

41%  

Very  Interested,  

15%  

Somewhat  Interested,  

10%  

Neutral,  17%  

Not  Very  Interested,  

17%  

Source:  eMarketer;  Catapult,  Shopper  Lab,”  April  1,  2012  

²  25%  of  respondents  expressed  an  interest  in  using  mobile  wallets.  

²  17%  of  respondents  were  not  very  interested  and  41%  stated  they  had  no  interest  at  all  in  using  mobile  wallets.  

² While  the  numbers  of  those  not  interested  were  high  part  of  this  can  be  explained  by  the  wide  spread  acceptance  and  usage  of  cards.  

²  Looking  forward  these  opinions  will  change  as  retailers  offer  incen@ves  and  make  it  a  faster  and  more  convenient  payment  method.  

Page 84: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 84!

The Emergence Of The mPayment Ecosystem ² Mobile phones have become an indispensible tool for real time research and

purchasing behavior globally. !²  An increasing amount of purchases online and in-store are being driven from

mobile devices – regardless of mobile payment method.!

16%  

18%  

21%  

24%  

26%  

29%  

In-­‐Store  Price  Comparison  

Purchased  With  A  Mobile  App  

Researched  on  Mobile  and  Bought  Online  

Purchased  On  A  Mobile  Website  

Researched  on  Mobile  and  Bought  In-­‐Store  

Researched  Product  on  Mobile  

Javelin  Strategy  2009  

² Mobile  applica@ons  and  technology  have  created  complete  pricing  transparency.  

²  Nearly  30%  of  consumers  conduct  product  research  on  mobile  devices.  

²  Over  20%  that  do  research  on  a  mobile  device  will  buy  products  either  in-­‐store  (26%)  or  online  (21%).  

²  Purchases  from  mobile  devices  is  on  the  rise  with  consumers  -­‐  24%  bought  on  a  mobile  website  and  18%    on  a  mobile  app.  

Page 85: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 85!

Retailer-Based Loyalty/Rewards Mobile Applications

Currently  Have  

Within  12  Months  

12-­‐24  Months  

19%   29%   22%  

7%   41%   20%  

7%   25%   22%  

1%   16%   19%  

3%   7%   19%  

3%`   6%   10%  

The majority of North American retailers plans to use mobile barcode or coupon scanning within the next two years. NFC based loyalty functionality and payments will ramp up at an increasing rate as enabled phones and retailers install the needed hardware. !

SUPPORT  FOR  REGULAR  BARCODE  SCANNING  

COUPONS  ON  MOBILE  SCREEN  

SUPPORT  FOR  2-­‐D  BARCODE  

COUPONS  BY  NFC/RFID  LOYALTY  

SUPPORT  BY  NFC/RFID  FOR  PAYMENT  

CONSUMER  SELF-­‐CHECKOUT  

Source:  SapientNitro  

Page 86: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 86!

Current Providers Are Predicted To Remain The Dominant Players in Mobile Payments….

82%  

77%  

72%  

68%  

67%  

63%  

62%  

46%  

8%  

12%  

18%  

23%  

23%  

26%  

25%  

36%  

11%  

11%  

10%  

9%  

10%  

11%  

13%  

22%  

Banks    

Credit  Card  Companies  

Telcos  

Specialist  Web  Payment  Companies  

Online  Service  Provider  Giants  

Retailers/Merchants  

Technology  Companies  

Others  

 1-­‐4    5-­‐7    8-­‐10  

Source:  KPMG  2011  Mobile  Payments  Global  Survey    

10 point scale, 1-Most Important and 10 Least Important  

“What categories of players are going to have the most important roles in mobile payments?” !

Page 87: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 87!

….However, Opinions Vary When It Comes to Predicting Success of Specific Payment Types

15%  

8%  

39%  

24%  

41%  

32%  

28%  

29%  

51%  

40%  

51%  

26%  

51%  

15%  

3%  

10%  

7%  

20%  

mWallet  

mBanking  

Contactless  Card  Systems  

Specialist  Online  Systems  

Carrier  Billing  

Already  mainstream   Will  get  major  trac@on  in  my  market  

Early  days,  uncertain   Ulikely  to  do  well  

n=688!

n=690!

Source:  KPMG  2011  Mobile  Payments  Global  Survey    

n=709!

n=696!

n=687!

“What are the prospects for this mobile payment method in your country/region?”!

Page 88: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 88!

Core Mobile Financial Services 1.  Monetizing mobile!

2.  How banks are preserving their place in the payment value chain!

3.  July 2011!

4.  kpmg.com!

Basic  Mobile  Banking     Enhanced  Mobile  Banking  And  Remote  Mobile  Payments    

Mobile  Payments  At  The  In-­‐store  POS    

Overview   The  basic  mobile  banking  market  consists  of  financial  ins@tu@ons  that  are  focused  on  developing  and  refining  their  mobile  banking  plalorm    

The  enhanced  mobile  banking  and  remote  payments  market  consists  of  players  with  mature  mobile  offerings,  healthy  adop@on  rates,  and  basic  remote  payment  services    

The  physical  POS  mobile  payments  marketplace  is  composed  of  tradi@onal  and  non-­‐tradi@onal  players  vying  for  early  market  share  of  mobile  payment  revenues    

Key  Features   Typically  includes  core  service  offerings  such  as  account  access,  balance  informa@on  and  internal  transfers  and  are  usually  on  1-­‐2  technology  plalorms  serviced  by  a  vendor  

Typically  consists  of  market  leading  mobile  banking  features  such  as  mobile  deposit  capture,  mobile  capture  and  bill  pay,  enhanced  enrollment  features,  and  some  remote  payment  offerings  such  as  person  to  person  (P2P)  payments    

Features  and  func@onality  widely  vary  depending  on  the  players  involved  and  geography  where  the  solu@on  is  being  launched      

Benefits   •  Enhanced  reputa@on  and  customer  service  •  Reduced  cost  to  serve  (and  therefore  more  flexible  capital)  •  Can  be  straighlorward  to  deploy  •  Easily  integrated  into  exis@ng  internet  banking  services  •  Demonstrates  innova@on  •  Creates  a  base  comfort  level  for  consumers  using  mobile  devices  •  Builds  in-­‐house  experience  and  skills  

•  Reduces  cost  to  serve  and  increases  available  capital  •  Streamlines  processes  and  reduces  manual  interven@on  •  Builds  in-­‐house  experience  and  skills  •  Capitalizes  on  ‘first-­‐to-­‐market’  opportuni@es  •  Provides  new  revenue  streams  

•  Protects  exis@ng  payments  revenues  •  Creates  new  revenue  opportuni@es  •  Responds  to  customer  demands  

Customer  Impact  

•  Unfekered  access  to  banking  informa@on  and  basic  transac@ons  •  Convenience  and  ease  of  use  •  Integrated  view  of  banking  informa@on  and  accounts  •  Higher  customer  loyalty  and  ‘s@ckiness’  

•  Reduces  branch  and  ATM  visits  •  Delivers  increased  flexibility  to  customers  •  Builds  comfort  and  acceptance  of  mobile  payment  solu@ons  •  Acts  as  a  stepping  stone  to  contactless  and  proximity  payments  

•  Convenience  and  ease  of  use,  par@cularly  for  low-­‐value  payments  •  Tighter  security  and  privacy  •  Replaces  tradi@onal  wallet  or  exis@ng  stored  value  accounts  and  electronic  purse  cards  

Key  Considera@ons  

•  What  is  our  mobile  channel  strategy?  •  What  is  our  mobile  commerce  strategy?  •  What  is  our  posi@on  on  mobile  payments?  •  What  are  our  current  mobile  banking  capabili@es?  

•  Who  is  our  mobile  service  vendor  and  are  their  capabili@es  sufficient?  •  What  are  leading  prac@ces  in  mobile  commerce?  •  What  should  our  mobile  payments  product  look  like?  •What  should  our  revenue  sharing  model  look  like?  

•  How  should  we  plan  for  enhancements  to  our  mobile  plalorm?  •  How  should  we  rollout  our  mobile  payments  pilot?  •  What  are  the  es@mated  costs  of  the  mobile  payments  ini@a@ve?  

Page 89: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 89!

Emerging Mobile Payment Categories

Source: KPMG, Monetizing mobile How banks are preserving their place in the payment value chain July 2011!

Mobile  bill  capture  and  pay    

P2P/Interna9onal  remifance    

Mobile  shopping     POS/Proximity  payments    

Overview:  Consumers  download  a  mobile  payments  applica@on  that  enables  users  to  pay  bills  simply  by  snapping  a  photo  of  a  paper  bill  or  invoice  with  their  smart  phone  camera  without  wri@ng  a  check  or  se�ng  up  a  template.      FI  Offerings:  Most  major  banks  offer  a  mobile  version  of  their  basic  online  bill  pay.  Chase  has  recently  partnered  with  Mitek  to  offer  mobile  bill  capture  &  pay  func@onality.      

Overview:  P2P  fund  transfers  allow  consumers  to  transfer  funds  to  each  other  using  an  email  address  or  phone  number  (no  account  details  required).  In  order  to  claim  funds,  users  must  register  and  verify  their  iden@fy  with  the  service  provider.      FI  Offerings:  Many  of  the  jumbo  banks  have  already  entered  the  P2P  market  with  solu@ons  @ed  to  their  mobile  banking  plalorm.      

Overview:  Consumer  uses  mobile  web  or  applica@on  to  search  for  and  purchase  goods  online;  similar  experience  to  online  shopping              FI  Offerings:  Many  major  e-­‐retailers  offer  mobile  versions  of  their  online  sites.  While  no  such  solu@on  is  has  been  launched  to  date,  FIs  may  be  able  to  leverage  this  channel  to  enable  credit  card  rewards  redemp@on  via  mobile.      

Overview:  “Wave  and  Pay”  or  “Tap  and  Go”  technology,  where  phones  are  embedded  with  NFC  technology  or  enabled  with  NFC  capabili@es  via  a  companion  device  and  waved  in  front  of  an  NFC-­‐compa@ble  terminal  for  payment.        FI  Offerings:  Visa  has  partnered  with  DeviceFidelity  to  offer  microSD  payment  technology  to  its  issuing  bank  partners.  The  microSD  cards  can  be  inserted  into  the  phone’s  memory  slot  to  enable  the  device  for  payment.  Contactless  s@ckers  and  NFC-­‐enabled  phone  covers  are  also  widely  available  and  being  tested  by  FIS.    

Page 90: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 90!

Three Core Types Of mPayments Have Emerged

mCommerce  Mobile  Web  Browser  (online  wallets,  web  ecommerce)  

mPayments  Uses  contactless,  mobile  

capabili@es  

mWallets  Virtual  Wallet  

How  It  Works  

Types  

1.  Add  items  to  Cart  2.  Fill  out  informa@on  3.  Purchase  and  

confirma@on  

1.  Add  items  to  Cart  2.  Click  to  buy  3.  Purchase  and  

confirma@on  

1.  Funds  loaded  on  device  e.g.  mobile  phone  

2.  Scan  barcode    3.  Purchase  made,  new  

account  balance  displayed  

1.  Credit  card  info  stored  on  phone  

2.  Enter  PIN  to  purchase  3.  Tap  your  phone  to  POS  ,  

authen@ca@on,  approval  Or  

1.  Money  loaded  into  account  2.  Purchase  made  via  SMS  3.  Purchase  and  confirma@on  to  

merchant  

Or  

Availability for specific mPayment type will vary based on cultural acceptance, technology, and financial provider access.!

Page 91: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 91!

Page 92: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 92!

“The era of mobile banking and payments is dawning. Around the world and across the banking value chain, everyone is waking up to the huge potential of a market that is emerging before their eyes and changing the way that customers interact with their financial institutions.” ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !KPMG! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!

Page 93: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 93!

mPayment Platform Summary

²  Although mPayments have seen significant growth, the market in terms of technology, standards, and payment providers vary widely by market!

²  The key players in the space are banks, financial service companies (e.g. credit card companies, telecoms, specialist web payment companies, online service providers, retailers/merchants, and technology companies.)!

²  Companies have created multiple partnerships/alliances and networks as they test and promote these platforms !

²  Although the market is nascent it is rapidly maturing and there will be an emergence of a few dominant players and platforms that will led to a few global platforms.!

² Over 2.5B adults are unbanked and using mPayment options from nonbanks will create disintermediation!

²  It is likely that multiple technologies will co-exist on mobile devices and cards which are being pushed by giants such as VISA and FeliCa!

Page 94: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 94!

The Growing Acceptance of mPayments

² While mobile payments are growing at a fast rate and will surpass US $172B in transaction values this year, NFC transactions are expected to remain relatively low through 2015.!

² The overall value of mPayment money volume is a growing number growing 61.9% over last year’s money volume. !

² The number of mobile payment users is also growing, Gartner Group predicts that the number of mobile payment users will reach 212MM in 2012, up from 161MM in 2011.!

² Growth is coming from almost all regions across globe and is expected to continue over the next 4 to 5 years. Through 2016 mobile transaction volume and value is expected to average 42% annual growth worldwide. !

² By 2015 global mobile payment transaction values will be exceed US $620B and the number of users will reach 450MM.!

!

Source:  Gartner  Group,  Mobile  Commerce  Daily  NFC  transac@ons  to  remain  low  through  2015:  study,  May  30,  2012  

Page 95: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 95!

mPayment Technologies

Source:  KPMG,  Mone@zing  mobile,  How  banks  are  preserving  their  place  in  the  payment  value  chain,  July  2011  

Descrip9on   Pros   Cons  

Contactless  (NFC)  

Set  of  standard  devices  to  establish  radio  communica@on  with  each  other  by  touching  them  or  bringing  them  into  close  proximity.  Components  include  s@ckers,  fobs,  microSD  cards,  etc.  

Leverages  exis@ng  contactless  card  standards,     Devices  oden  limited  to  a  single  

payment  account,  poten@ally  high  setup  complexity  for  user,  requires  distribu@on  and  cost  to  deploy.  

Embedded  NFC  

Uses  a  mobile  wallet  technology  on  an  embedded  NFC  chip  to  broaden  payment  op@ons  within  a  proximity  se�ng.    

Uses  exis@ng  contactless  card  standards,  enables  access  to  mul@ple  accounts  via  mobile  wallet,  provides  some  addi@onal  security  with  PIN  on  the  handset.    

Limited  availability  of  enabled  handsets  in  the  market,  Merchant  control  handset  inventory  and  distribu@on.      

SMS  Text          USSD    

Remote  payments,  primarily  for  digital  content      Similar  to  SMS  but  quicker  and  has  the  ability  to  invoke  commands  with  common  codes  rather  than  opening  a  messaging  applica@on.  

Ubiquitous  capability  available  on  the  vast  majority  of  handsets.  Enables  payments  in  developing  markets  with  low  access  to  banks.    

Message  length  limited,  high  cost  to  both  merchant  and  consumer.  

Voice/IVR   A  niche  technology  that  provides  mostly  account  servicing  and  bill  payments,  some  mobile  payment  authoriza@on  conducted  via  voice.    

Person  to  person  interac@on,  opportuni@es  for  dynamic  cross-­‐selling.      

High  cost  in  ‘live  agent’  situa@ons,  inefficient  data  communica@ons.      

Cloud  Based  Wallets  

The  user  downloads  an  applica@on  to  a  smartphone,  connects  a  credit  card  or  bank  account  to  the  app,  and  then  can  authorize  payment  to  par@cipa@ng  merchants  via  the  phone’s  Internet  connec@on.  

These  do  not  require  any  specific  hardware  like  NFC.  Uses  access  to  the  web,  no  special  hardware  e.g.  readers,  point-­‐of-­‐sale  (POS)  upgrades.  

Possible  connec@on  to  web  issues,  subject  to  site  availability.  

Page 96: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 96!

A recent survey by the Carlisle & Gallagher Consulting Group on customers' preference on mobile concluded that banks are losing out to providers like PayPal and Google. Customers have voiced an overwhelming preference for these mobile-based payment solutions over those from their banks.  

Page 97: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 97!

Several Different mPayment Models Have Emerged And Are Competing To Gain Global Acceptance

Payment  Models  

CONTACTLESS  NFC,  RFID,  FeliCa  

MOBILE  APPS  Internet  

SMS    Text  

Messaging  

WEB    Mobile  Browser  

USSD    Similar  to  

SMS  

There  has  been  a  prolifera@on  in  proprietary  mPayment  offerings  that  vary  in  func@onality  and  standards.  

Page 98: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 98!

In The U.S. There Has Been A Proliferation Of Platforms And Partnerships In The mPayments Space ² Mobile payment platforms are shaping up along the lines of several associations and

partnerships.!² The space is continuing to evolve and expect to see a movement towards platform

consolidation and standardization.!

Partne

rs    

Plal

orm  

In  addi@on,  retail  giants  Wal-­‐Mart  and  Target  have  teamed  up  to  launch  their  own  mobile  wallet  and  Facebook  has  recently  announced  plans  to  create  person  to  person  (P2P)  payments.  

Tech   NFC   Web   Physical  

Reader  Web  

New  In  2012  

Web/Mobile  Web/Mobile  

Page 99: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 99!

There Has Been A Proliferation Of Platforms And Partnerships In The mPayments Space ² A handful of mobile payment platforms have emerged.!² The space is continuing to evolve and expect to see a movement towards

platform consolidation and standardization.!

Page 100: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 100!

Several Different mPayment Models Have Emerged And Are Competing To Gain Global Acceptance

Payment  Models  

CONTACTLESS  NFC,  RFID,  FeliCa  

MOBILE  APPS  Internet  

SMS    Text  

Messaging  

WEB    Mobile  Browser  

USSD    Similar  to  

SMS  

Page 101: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 101!

NFC-enabled Phone Sales And Usage Will Surge, Pushing Global mPayments Up 180% To US $620B By 2015

0  

100  

200  

300  

400  

500  

600  

2011   2014   2015  

93.2  

411.8  

544.7  

NFC-­‐Enabled  Mobile  Phone  Shipments  #MM  

2010   2011  

102  

141  

49  

86  

Global  mPayment  Users  and  Volume  

Users  MM  

Payments  $B  USD   $240B  

$620B  

2011   2015  

Source:  NitroSapient  

Page 102: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 102!

NFC Estimates - Key Statistics and Figures

²  Current barriers to growth include availability of NFC enable phones and POS terminals but both are expected to see strong through 2016.!

²  In 2011 there were 40-50 million NFC-enabled phones and will grow to 300 million or 20% of smartphones worldwide by 2014. This number will jump 53% to 863 million units in 2015.!

²  Global NFC mPayment transactions will reach US $50 billion worldwide by 2014 or 32.8% of the estimated US $1.13 trillion global mPayment.!

²  47 million Japanese have adopted tap-and-go phones in three years – making it one of the fastest roll outs of electronic products in human history. East Asia will see the fastest growth due in part to better cooperation between companies and governments.!

²  There will be 169 million users of mobile contactless payment in China in 2013. Total number of mPayment users will be 410 million, making China the world’s largest mPayments market.!

Source:  Mobile  Commerce  Daily;  CNET;    NitroSapient;  Juniper  Research,  April/June  2011;  Frost  &  Sullivan,  Feb  2011;  NFC  Times,  Oct,  2010;  IE  Market  Research,  July  2010;  Celent,  Nov  2010;  IDTechEx,  R&M,  Feb  2011  

Although  expert’s  opinions  vary,  all  agree  that  NFC  mPayments  will  become  a  major  source  of  transac@ons.      

Page 103: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 103!

Several Different mPayment Models Have Emerged And Are Competing To Gain Global Acceptance

Payment  Models  

CONTACTLESS  NFC,  RFID,  FeliCa  

MOBILE  APPS  Internet  

SMS    Text  

Messaging  

WEB    Mobile  Browser  

USSD    Similar  to  

SMS  

Page 104: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 104!

Starbucks Is A Retailing Pioneer In The mPayments Space

Starbucks Card Mobile App!

² Mobile bar codes that are delivered to the app and scanned at retail store!

² The mobile app is helping to relieve lengthy morning queues by speeding purchases!

² Less than a year after the mobile app launched Starbucks had 26 million transactions and has climbed to 42 million payments since inception!

² Starbucks has expanded it’s mobile payment app to Canada and the UK !

² The app also includes a store locator and its rewards program!

!

Mobile initiatives allow retailers to monitor and analyze purchase patterns, providing new insights to customer behavior. The ability to create highly personalized experiences will continue to drive retailers entry into the mobile space.!

Page 105: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 105!

Starbucks Is A Retailing Pioneer In The mPayments Space

The upside for mobile commerce and smart phone growth is enormous as all mobile phones will eventually become internet connected. That translates to over 4.7 billion smart phones that will  be sold and connected! How will your bank ready for the new mobile-social economy?!

Page 106: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 106!

PayPal Has Aggressively Forged Partnerships With Retailers And Point Of Sale Developers

²  First mobile payment partner, Home Depot, rolled out to 2,000 locations. Customers make purchases with their PayPal accounts by typing in their mobile phone number and PIN. Customer receives an electronic receipt on their mobile device after making a purchase.!

²  May 2012 announced additional 15 retail partners some of which include: Abercrombie & Fitch, Barnes & Noble, Foot Locker, JC Penney, Office Depot, and Toys "R" Us.!

²  Redesigned website has cross-sell space for promoting mobile payments. The site is also designed to be touch-friendly for use with tablets and smartphones. !

²  Signed deals with point of sale systems developers and point of sale terminal manufacturers. These partnerships give PayPal access to over 40 million payment terminals across the world.!

²  PayPal is also testing a new app in Britain that enables users to make purchases via a unique bar code linked to their account.!

²  Launched a joint venture in Japan and has plans to enter India, China and other global markets.!

PayPal Here  

PayPal is quickly becoming a formidable player in the payments industry and mobile is a major component of that strategy!

Source:  Mobileburn,  TechCrunch  

Page 107: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 107!

Retailer’s Will Expand Mobile Presence To Include Payment Oriented Mobile Applications

Currently  Have  

Within  12  Months  

12-­‐24  Months  

19%   29%   22%  

7%   41%   20%  

7%   25%   22%  

1%   16%   19%  

3%   7%   19%  

3%`   6%   10%  

The majority of North American retailers plan to use mobile barcode or coupon scanning within the next two years. NFC based loyalty functionality and payments will ramp up at an increasing rate as enabled phones and retailers install the needed hardware. !

SUPPORT  FOR  REGULAR  BARCODE  SCANNING  

COUPONS  ON  MOBILE  SCREEN  

SUPPORT  FOR  2-­‐D  BARCODE  

COUPONS  BY  NFC/RFID  LOYALTY  

SUPPORT  BY  NFC/RFID  FOR  PAYMENT  

CONSUMER  SELF-­‐CHECKOUT  

Source:  SapientNitro  November  2010  

Page 108: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 108!

Several Different mPayment Models Have Emerged And Are Competing To Gain Global Acceptance

Payment  Models  

CONTACTLESS  NFC,  RFID,  FeliCa  

MOBILE  APPS  Internet  

SMS    Text  

Messaging  

WEB    Mobile  Browser  

USSD    Similar  to  

SMS  

Page 109: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 109!

SMS And USSD Has Grown Exponentially in Certain Regions And Can Be Expected To Grow Globally

²  There are over 2.5B unbanked adults with the vast majority living in Asia, Africa, and Latin America that will use non-bank options for payments and money movement.!

²  Consumers in Africa, the Middle East, and India rely on telecoms including Vodafone and MTN to provide mobile money options.!

² Western Union has partnered with MTN in Uganda to launch a mobile-transfer service. WU has agreements with 11 mobile operators and an additional 17 are planned.!

²  In India, the National Payment Council (NPCI) launched the Interbank Mobile Payment Service (IMPS). IMPS allows a person to pay/remit money to a merchant or an individual in real-time using a mobile phone number and a mobile phone identifier. !

²  SMS payments went viral in the US for Haiti earthquake relief payments totaling over $US 30MM.!

Page 110: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 110!

SMS And USSD Kenya – M-Pesa

Kenya  

M-Pesa Facts & Figures!² M-Pesa, Swahili for money.!

²  Users give cash to agent, money is loaded onto account, payment made via SMS, confirm provided to merchant via SMS.!

²  SMS based mobile money mPayment launched in 2007.!

²  By 2011 68% of adults use mobile money.!

²  Average transaction size is $30.!

Page 111: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 111!

SMS And USSD Uganda – Western Union and MTN Group

Western Union/MTN Facts & Figures!²  Western Union (WU) and MTN Group launched a

mobile money transfer service in Uganda, allowing MTN customers to use mobile phones to send and receive money across borders.!

²  2 million customers of MTN’s Mobile Money will be able to add funds to their accounts. Customers can also send money internationally with WU directly, online, or from their Mobile Money accounts for cash payout at WU Agent locations or mobile phone partner subscribers.!

²  To gain traction, 9,000 branded mobile “Yellow Phones” were distributed to Ugandans. Customers who receive these devices must already have an active MTN Mobile Money account or sign up for one. !

²  MTN attracted 16% of its customers to its mobile money service in its initial 13 months, and approximately 60% of its transfers are to ‘unbanked’ customers in rural areas.!

Page 112: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 112!

Several Different mPayment Models Have Emerged And Are Competing To Gain Global Acceptance

Payment  Models  

CONTACTLESS  NFC,  RFID,  FeliCa  

MOBILE  APPS  Internet  

SMS    Text  

Messaging  

WEB    Mobile  Browser  

USSD    Similar  to  

SMS  

Page 113: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 113!

Web/Mobile Browser: Serve!² Launched by American Express in March 2011, Serve is

an online payment system similar to PayPal.!

²  Initially, for residents of the US, American Express announced in January 2012 the first global with Lianlian Group, one of China’s leading mobile payments providers. It has also signed deals with Verizon and Sprint to allow people to buy goods by entering in their phone number and PIN.!

² Serve allows users to buy things, withdraw cash from ATMs and make personal payments from their phone or computer using an account that is funded from a bank account or credit or debit card. !

² Serve is following PayPal’s to enable personal payments through Facebook with the launch of a Serve Facebook app, that allows users to pay each other back for free without leaving Facebook.!

² American Express is working with Payfone to support Serve checkout on Verizon devices. Payfone's back-end systems will help Verizon customers to make mobile payments simply and securely.!

Source: TechCrunch January 18, 2012; American Express!

Page 114: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 114!

Online Payment Comparison – Serve & PayPal ² Both services are becoming increasingly undifferentiated from each other – both provide

more functionality and flexibility compared to other payment methods.!² Both are planning to launch expanded functionality such as NFC, retailer alliances, and

loyalty/reward programs.!

Page 115: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 115!

Web/Mobile Browser: Google Wallet

²  The Google Wallet online service stores your credit cards in the cloud and are all managed with a single password. When you checkout at online merchants that accept Google Wallet, you can quickly pay by signing into your Google Wallet account.!

²  Like other competitors fraud protection policy covers users against unauthorized purchases made through Google Wallet, and payment information is securely encrypted and stored. !

²  The Google Wallet expanded to a mobile app in 2011 that stores your credit cards and offers on your phone. When you check out at brick-and-mortar stores that accept Google Wallet, you can pay and redeem offers quickly just by tapping your phone at the point of sale.!

²  Google has partnered with Sprint which has preloaded the Google Wallet on many of their handset devices.!

²  Last year Google announced its NFC-based Google Wallet mobile payment service, with backing from a number of retail and financial partners including Subway, Macy's, Walgreens, Toys 'R Us, First Data, Citibank and MasterCard and Sprint on the carrier side. A Citi MasterCard or Google Prepaid Card is required with the service, although the latter can be funded from any other card.!

²  The partnership with MasterCard means Google Wallet will be fully compatible with the PayPass contactless payment system that's widely in place today. Google may use NFC stickers for phones without built-in NFC.!

Source:  Google;  Engadget  

Page 116: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 116!

NFC Case Study – FeliCa

Page 117: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 117!

²  The name derives from the word "felicity," suggesting convenience, was introduced in Japan, FeliCa is a technology developed by Sony in which a microchip, embedded in a card or electronic device, combines processing, storage, and communications functions. Over 100MM chips have been shipped and there are more than 70 million NFC enabled devices in Japan.!

²  The FeliCa chip can be used in portable digital devices such as cell phone sets, handheld computers, wristwatches, and calculators. This makes it possible for the portable device to contain multiple forms of data including personal or business identification (ID) information, bank account numbers and balances, medical information, credit account data, transportation passes, and authorization codes!

²  Mobile FeliCa a subsidiary company of both NTT DoCoMo and Sony. DoCoMo has developed a mobile wallet, Osaifu-Ketai, literally meaning "Wallet Mobile”, refers to mobile phones that integrate Mobile FeliCa ICs, as well as to services provided by applications of these phones. Mobile FeliCa has a wide network of partnerships and business models. au (KDDI,) SoftBank, Samsung, Gemalto and others have partnered or licensed mobile FeliCa from FeliCa Networks.!

²  Although it was developed by NTT DoCoMo, the system is also supported by other mobile phone operators, making it the de facto standard mobile payment system in Japan. Osaifu-Keitai services include electronic money, identity card, loyalty card, fare collection of public transits (including railways, buses, and airplanes), or credit card.!

²  In 2002 Visa International announced the establishment of a joint working relationship with Sony Corporation and Infineon Technologies for the joint development and promotion of a single-chip Global Platform multi-application chip product that supports Visa Smart Debit/Credit (VSDC) payment and contactless applications based on FeliCa. !

Overview of FeliCa

Source:  Miscellaneous,  Adver@sing  Age  June  11,  2012  

Page 118: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 118!

FeliCa Products and Applications

Source:  Wikipedia  and  NitroSapient  

²  The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ: ”Super IC Card” !The “Super IC Card” rolled out by the Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ is a dual-interface (contact and contactless), 3-in-l IC card designed for the utmost in security, flexibility and customer convenience. With a choice from prepaid (“Edy” e-money), debit (cash card) and charge (credit card) payments, cardholders can use the card for a variety of purposes.!

  !²  Wallet Phones !

FeliCa compatible wallet phones, referred to as “Osaifu-Keitai” and marketed by NTT DoCoMo, KDDI and Softbank Mobile, are used increasingly in Japan for a wide variety of applications including e-money, credit cards, payments. Additional companies are adopting usage of FeliCa based payment products.!

²  Non-Financial Applications!e-tickets, membership IDs, airline tickets, airport check in, entertainment, loyalty programs, reward membership, pc/online encryption, home security. New functionality is continuously being added to the FeliCa platform!

Page 119: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 119!

FeliCa Functionality Has Become Ubiquitous in Japan and is Spreading Globally 50% of Japanese mobile users have a FeliCa phone and 20% of users have used a mobile wallet to make a purchase Mobile.!

Source:  Wikipedia,  SONY,  Smartnfc  

Boarding  Pass  

Consumer  Electronics  

Transit  Ticket  

IC  Card  

Vending  Machine  

Access  Control  

Internet  Credit  Service  

Retailers  

ID  Card  

eTicket  

Page 120: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 120!

FeliCa Has Expanded Throughout Asia

Source:  Wikipedia  and  NitroSapient  

1997  Hong  Kong  Octopus  Card  on  95%  of  phones.    Also  on  wristwatches,  phones,  keyholders.    Used  for  transporta@on  systems,  convenience  stores,  coffee  shops,  supermarkets,  vending  machines      

2002  Singapore  EZ-­‐link  system  (defunct)  train  @ckets,  emoney,  student  military  ID  cards  

2004  Shenzhen  Buses  and  subway  networks  

2004    Bangkok  Thailand  Subway  @cke@ng  system  

2002  India  Train  @cke@ng  system  

Japan  –  Founded    IC  Cards  and  wallets  for  transporta@on,  emoney  (vending  machines,  amusement  centers,  baseball  @ckets,  retail),  airport  check-­‐in  and  rewards,  home  access  key,  PKI  network  authen@ca@on,  email  encryp@on,  wireless  LAN  communica@ons,  FeliCa  Pockets  (membership  cards,  promo@onal  coupons,  customer  loyalty  point  cards)  2004  Edy  prepaid  emoney    service  launches.    15mm+  cards,  27k  par@cipa@ng  merchants/shops  2004  Launch  of  mobile  wallet  phones  2004  Internet  based  credit  card,  eLIO,  used  with  personal  computer  via  a  embedded  or  tethered  port    

Page 121: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 121!

FeliCa NFC-enabled subway straps were activated last May 21st and has been serving ads for a travel agency called HIS. The straps let commuters with compatible phones retrieve an embedded URL that redirects their mobile browsers to an advertising website. No personal information is required or transmitted in the process.!

Page 122: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 122!

FeliCa Sample Usage

FeliCa based payments are used:!²  Yahoo Dome Baseball Park to purchase

tickets!²  Sega Amusement Centers, ANA airline

tickets!²  Kesaka System offers a keyless entry

system enabling residents to lock or unlock doors using FeliCa cards or mobile phones. !

²  At some Tipness fitness clubs in Japan, members wear FeliCa-equipped wristbands called TIP GEAR to check in, open lockers, and pay for purchases with Edy e-money.!

²  In Finland, 20 universities and colleges use FeliCa ID cards for cashless payment at cafeterias on campus and access control.!

Users can upload digital cash from a credit card to a cell phone, pass a wristwatch near a scanning device at a department store checkout station, use a calculator as a virtual train ticket, or use a FeliCa card to log on to a computer at an Internet kiosk.!

Page 123: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 123!

“We are approaching a new age of synthesis. Knowledge cannot be merely a degree or a skill... it demands a broader vision, capabilities in critical thinking and logical deduction without which we cannot have constructive progress.”!!

Li Ka Shing!Chairman, Hutchison Whampoa Limited!

Page 124: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 124!

Q&A  

Page 125: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 125!

Glossary Of Terms ²  Embedded NFC: By including a microchip in mobile device hardware, manufacturers are able to add

NFC capabilities to handsets, effectively turning mobile devices into contactless payment solutions.!

²  EMV/Chip and Pin: EMV is a global standard that uses integrated circuit cards to enable the authentication of credit and debit card transactions (also known as Chip and PIN cards in Europe).!

²  iOS/Android: Most mobile devices are powered by one of a handful of mobile operating systems such as iOS (developed by Apple) or Android (developed by Google).!

²  App: Short and common name for mobile applications, apps provide proprietary services through a secure and easy to use program. Low-value Payments: While there is no formally set definition of what constitutes a low-value payment, the level tends to represent a nominal amount according to the spending trends within each jurisdiction.!

²  MicroSD Card: Secure Digital cards, and their MicroSD counterparts act in a similar fashion to SIM Cards by storing a mobile users data and information in a secure format.!

²  MNO: Mobile network operators are telecom companies with the proper radio spectrum licences and infrastructure to deliver robust services to mobile phone subscribers.!

²  Mobile Banking: Platforms that enable customers to access financial services (such as transfers, bill payments, balance information and investment options).!

²  Mobile Payments: The process of using a hand-held device to pay for a product or service at a point-of-sale.!

²  NFC: Near Field Communications is a set of short-range wireless technologies that supports two-way communication of data such as banking information across short proximities.!

Page 126: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 126!

Glossary Of Terms ²  NFC companion device: Companion devices enable users to add NFC capabilities onto mobile

devices that do not contain embedded NFC. These usually take the form of stickers, dongles or fobs.!

²  Proximity Payments: Using a device or card with an integrated circuit chip, payment is made by bringing the device within 3 inches of an enabled POS terminal.!

²  SIM Card: A subscriber identity module (SIM) is an integrated circuit which stores subscriber information and mobile device identities in a secure and removable format.!

²  Smart phone/device: The integration of mobile phones with sophisticated computing abilities to emulate the computing power and functionality of handheld computers.!

²  SMS Text/Text Codes: Standing for Short Message Service, SMS has been used by merchants and banks since the 1980s to exchange information and make purchases using text codes (a 160 character or less code that generates an automated response from the recipient).!

²  TSM: Specific to mobile payments, Trusted Service Managers work with banks and MNOs to bridge multiple banks and operators to ensure a interoperable and secure system.!

²  USSD: Unstructured Supplementary Service Data (USSD) is a protocol used by GSM cellular telephones to provide services such as WAP browsing and mobile-money services.!

²  WAP/Mobile Browser: Wireless Applications Protocol (or WAP) is a technology standard that enables mobile devices to view and interact with web-based programs and services.!

Page 127: Mobile Payments in The Financial Services Industry

© 2011 Blue Panda Interactive. Proprietary And Confidential.! 127!

Blue   Panda   Interac@ve   [Digital   Consultancy   +   Crea@ve   Agency]:  Merging   the  brains  of  a  strategic  consultancy  and  the  innova@ve  approach  of  an  agency  to  transform  customer  experiences.    We  focus  on  digital  strategy,  media,  and  analy@cs  to  connect  brands  with  their  customers.  We  leverage  innova@ve  ideas  that  are  based  on  business  goals  and  customer   needs   to   execute   winning   strategies.   We   believe   integrated  marke@ng  and  content  are  key   ingredients   to  connect  and  engage  with  your  customers   and   fans.   We   share   a   passion   to   drive   business   outcomes   and  delight  customers.    If  you  would  like  to  learn  more  about  how  we  can  partner  with  you  please  contact  us  at  info@[email protected]