MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS...

49
MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Pork Lenders Meeting July 29, 2011 Dave Wright, D.V.M.

Transcript of MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS...

Page 1: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT

Pork Lenders Meeting July 29, 2011

Dave Wright, D.V.M.

Page 2: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Coordinator

Minnesota Voluntary Regional PRRS Elimination Project N212

Page 3: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Funding

•USDA – APHIS • PRRS CAP • AASV • NPB and MPB • BI PRRS Initiative • Swine Disease Eradication Center-U of M

Page 4: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Plan for Today

• PRRS Review—Crash Course

• What makes it so tough to control?

• Cost of PRRS

• Options for Control

• Voluntary Regional PRRS Elimination Project

• Message Points for Lenders

Page 5: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

CRASH COURSE ON PRRS

Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome

Page 6: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Studies

Condition Length of Survival

Frozen Years

Moist, Cold, Wet 11 days

700 F (210 C) 6 days

98.6 0 F (37o C) 24 hours

132o F (56o C) 20 minutes

Pitkin, Otake, Dee, “Biosecurity protocols for the prevention of spread of PRRSv”, Swine Disease Eradication Center, University of Minnesota

PRRS SURVIVABILITY STUDIES

Page 7: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

• Highly infectious-only small amount of virus necessary to infect a herd

• Persistent infection up to 200 days in some pigs--shedders

• Mutates easily-makes commercial vaccines effective inconsistently

• Simple blood tests cannot differentiate between field strain and vaccine strain of virus

Page 8: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Some good news: PRRSv only infects pigs—no other species can be

infected

Page 9: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

FINANCIAL IMPACT OF PRRS

U.S. SWINE INDUSTRY

$560 TO $760 MILLION --Neumann, JAVMA, 8-1-05

Page 10: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

FINANCIAL IMPACT OF PRRS

$225 to $300 Per Sow-Acute Infection

Over $100,000 per outbreak on 500 sow unit --Holck, Polson , 2009 PRRS Compendium

Page 11: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

FINANCIAL IMPACT OF PRRS

• Breeding/Farrowing: $74.16 per litter Reduction in pigs weaned & Reduced Farrowing Rate

• Nursery: $6.01 per pig

Increased Mortality; Reduced Feed Conversion; Reduced Average Daily Gain

• Grow/Finish: $7.67 per pig Increased Mortality; Reduced Feed Conversion; Reduced Average Daily Gain

--Neumann, JAVMA, 8-1-05

Page 12: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Impact: Change in nursery mortality pre- and post-filtration of study herds-Scott Dee Study

• Pre-filtration (PRRSV+)

• Flow 1

– 8.3%

• Flow 2

– 19.8%

• Flow 3

– 13.2%

• Post-filtration (PRRSV-)

• Flow 1

– 2.6%

• Flow 2

– 1.9%

• Flow 3

– 1.6%

Page 13: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

PRRS INTERVENTION STRATEGY

WITHIN HERD

• Stabilization

• Elimination

• Eradication

WITHIN AREA

• Control

• Elimination

• Eradication

Page 14: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

INTENSIFY BIOSECURITY

Page 15: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

OPTIONS FOR MANAGING HERD OUTBREAKS

• CONTROL THE IMPACT Live with it, but limit losses

• ELIMINATION OF THE VIRUS FROM HERD

Page 16: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

PRRS ELIMINATION TOOLS

• Whole Herd Depopulation and Repopulation

• Test and Removal

• All-in/All-out Pig Flow (AIAO)

• Herd stabilization: Load, Close, Expose Gilt acclimatization

• Partial Depopulation

• Herd Closure and Rollover

Page 17: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

PARTIAL BUDGET ANALYSIS

• Depopulation with Breeding Project

• Depopulation with No Breeding Project

• Closure of Herd with Off-Site Breeding Project

• Closure of Herd with Off-Site Gilt Development Unit

• Closure of Herd Alone -Paul Yeske, Swine Vet Center

Page 18: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

INCIDENCE OF NEW INFECTIONS

Depends on pig density in an area

Page 19: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Hog-Dense Area

“Clean pigs flowing to a hog-dense area will break with PRRS approximately 50% of the time.”

--Tim Loula, National Hog Farmer 6-15-11

Page 20: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Hog-Dense Area

PRRS struck four times in four years (2004 to 2007) in Wakefield Pork, Inc. case reported in National Hog Farmer.

--National Hog Farmer 6-15-11

Page 21: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

SOW FILTRATION STUDY Scott Dee

Identified 20 herds for his study that became infected every 12.8 to 13.1

months.

Page 22: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Regional PRRS Elimination

Project North of 212 MN

Montse Torremorell, Dave Wright,

Scott Dee, Peter Davies, Bob Morrison,

&

Swine Health Center, Morris Vet Clinic, Nate

Winkelman, Swine Vet Center, Neil DeBuse, Fairmont

Vet Clinic

University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN USA

Page 23: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

REGIONAL PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT

A voluntary, producer-led, coordinated, regional disease control

program

Page 24: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

BACKGROUND

• Stevens County regional elimination project started in 2004

• Project expanded to 6 surrounding counties in 2009

• In 2010, project expanded again to include the greater region of N-212

Page 25: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Expansion

Page 26: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

GOALS OF REGIONAL ELIMINATION PROJECT

• Identify the swine herds in the area

• Invite participation by signing participation agreement

• Determine PRRS status of each herd

• Encourage elimination if herd is positive

• Encourage improved biosecutiry if herd is negative

Page 27: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Note the verbs “Invite” and “Encourage”

• Program is voluntary

• Relies on producer and veterinarian participation and communication

• Communication is key

Page 28: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Stevens County 2004

Page 29: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Stevens Co., May, 2011

Page 30: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Seven County Region

Page 31: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Maps

May 2011

Page 32: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

PLEASED WITH PROGRESS

• More sites have been identified

• Fewer positive sites in region—reduced prevalence of PRRS

• Demonstrates the advantage of cooperative effort among producers, veterinarians, community suppliers and industry to eliminate PRRS

N212 MN sow herd status

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

2010 Q2 2010 Q3 2010 Q4 2011 Q1 2011 Q2

Negative

Negative provisional

Positive stable

Positive

Unknown

Page 33: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

2011

Page 34: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

STUDIES UNDERWAY TO CALCULATE BENEFIT OF REGIONAL ELIMINATION

PROJECTS

Presentations at Lehman Conference

Page 35: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

HOW PORK LENDERS CAN BECOME INVOLVED

Page 36: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

DISCUSS PRRS WITH CUSTOMERS

Inquire about risk and management of PRRS on farms that you serve

Page 37: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

ENCOURAGE MULTI-SITE PRODUCTION IF EXPANDING

DISCOURAGE CONTINUOUS FLOW IF EXPANDING

Page 38: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

If producer is planning to expand, consider PRRS elimination as well.

Page 39: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

INVEST IN BIOSECURITY

Page 40: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Bench “Danish” Entry

Bench

Page 41: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Dedicated Trailers

Page 42: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Clean-up

Equipment

Page 43: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Establish “Clean/Dirty” Line for Transport on Farms

Page 44: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

EXPANDED FEED STORAGE

Minimum one-week supply to allow flexible, non-emergency

delivery

Page 45: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Air filtration in studs and sow farms

2009

Page 46: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

MERV 16 (EU 9)

95 % DOP @ ≥ 0.3 microns

Air filtration Dee, 2005

Page 47: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

SUMMARY

• PRRS is a nasty bug

• It’s really costly

• We have tools to control and eliminate it from herds and regions

• Voluntary regional elimination projects show promise for assisting swine producers in managing PRRS

Page 48: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

THANKS FOR THE INVITATION

MN Pork Board MN Pork Producers Association

Page 49: MINNESOTA VOLUNTARY PRRS ELIMINATION PROJECT Elimination... · Plan for Today •PRRS Review—Crash Course •What makes it so tough to control? •Cost of PRRS •Options for Control

Dave Wright, D.V.M. 763-242-7535

[email protected]