MIDDLE EAST

In association with

Home

UK

Africa

Asia

Europe

Latin America

Mid-East

US & Canada

Business

Health

Sci/Environment

Tech

Entertainment

Video

Advertisement

In association with

25 March 2014 Last updated at 01:34 GMT

Share this page Email Print

Share this page

Share Facebook Twitter

The deep discord bedevilling the Arab worldBy Gerald Butt Middle East analyst

Members of the Arab League have struggled to find a common direction for decades

Continue reading the main story

Related Stories

Gulf ambassadors pulled from Qatar Arab League sees stark differences in tourism Gulf states divided over Iran

The world has learned to expect rhetoric aplenty, but little of substance from Arab summits - and the one scheduled for Kuwait on 25-26 March will be no exception.

Indeed, expectations are, if anything, even lower than in the past.

This latest heads-of-state meeting, like all previous ones, is being convened by the Arab League, which was established nearly 70 years ago to foster mutual co-ordination in order to achieve "the close co-operation of the member-states".

In the euphoria of that post-colonial independence era much more than co-operation seemed possible.

Millions of Arabs dreamed of smashing down the border fences erected by the British and French colonists to achieve unity from Morocco in the west to the Gulf states in the east.

Continue reading the main story

“Start Quote

Once again, reality has fallen woefully below even the most modest expectations”

End Quote

All the ingredients seemed to be there as energetic young leaders took power: shared religion, language, history and culture - and a craving for a return of Arab self-esteem.

But surely today it can be no more than a handful of starry-eyed idealists who still cling to the dream of Arab unity.

Half a century or more of inter-government jealousy, rivalry and war have long buried that dream in the minds of most Arabs.

The start of the popular uprisings in 2011 - the Arab spring - raised expectations again, not of Arab unity, but of something that would still come close to meeting popular aspirations.

The overpowering urge to remove dictators from power was driven to a large extent by that same desire for dignity and self-esteem.

The Arab uprisings of recent years have not been the unifying force that many had hoped

The Syrian conflict has exacerbated divisions among Arab states

The new regimes, it was recognised, would not break down the colonial borders, it was too late for that.

But the hope was that they would at least work together in the common cause of facing shared regional challenges: Israel, the plight of Palestinians, inequality in wealth distribution, youth unemployment, failing education systems, paltry intra-Arab investment, and so on.

Continue reading the main story

Arab League

Founded: 1945 Headquarters: Cairo, Egypt Key players: Egypt, Saudi Arabia Members: 22 Population: 300 million (approx) Area: 5.25m sq miles

Profile: Arab League

Once again, reality has fallen woefully below even the most modest expectations.

In four decades of covering the Middle East I cannot remember the Arab world being as multilaterally fractured as it is today. Arabs are trapped under a dense and complex cat's cradle of ideological and sectarian differences.

Even in the one corner of the Middle East where there is a regional body, the Gulf Co-operation Council (GCC - comprising Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates), there are fresh challenges.

Formed in 1981 as Britain withdrew from the Gulf, the GCC has failed to achieve its most ambitious targets of economic integration and the establishment of a credible joint defence capability. But today it faces unprecedented discord:

Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Bahrain have withdrawn ambassadors from Qatar because of the latter's support for the Muslim Brotherhood (MB) in Egypt and elsewhere.

Kuwait and Oman have remained neutral in this dispute, so there are now three clearly different camps within the GCC on regional policy and support for the MB.

Saudi Arabia and Bahrain accuse Iran of meddling in their internal affairs by stoking unrest within their Shia communities, while Oman has recently hosted the Iranian foreign minister on an official visit. Oman also angered other GCC states by brokering secret talks between Iran and the United States on the nuclear issue.

Further afield, the list continues:

Iraq has accused Saudi Arabia and Qatar of seeking to destabilise the country. Relations between Egypt and Qatar are strained over the MB issue. Saudi Arabia has designated the MB a terrorist group.

Egypt has designated Hamas a terrorist group and is keeping Gaza isolated. Syria, embroiled in a civil war with outside backing, has accused Saudi Arabia and Qatar

of seeking to undermine the country. Saudi Arabia and Qatar are supporting different factions of the Syrian opposition. The Arab Gulf states, Egypt and Jordan accuse Iraq of acting as an agent of Shia Iran

and allowing Iranian arms to reach Syria - and of marginalising the Iraqi Sunni community.

Lebanon is divided between those for and against the Syrian government, and for and against Hezbollah's military support for Damascus.

Against this background it will be surprising if many Arab heads of state feel enthusiastic about attending the next summit in Kuwait (Syria is already suspended from the Arab League). An agenda that took into account even a fraction of the above grievances is unimaginable.

Unity has been off the table for many years. Today, meaningful intra-regional co-operation, too, is looking like a distant prospect.

This leaves individual Arab states to cope alone as best they can with the range of challenges facing the Middle East - that is when the regimes are not preoccupied with fighting for their interests in the maelstrom of regional disputes.

More on This StoryRelated Stories

Gulf ambassadors pulled from Qatar

05 MARCH 2014, MIDDLE EAST

Arab League sees stark differences in tourism

12 DECEMBER 2013, BUSINESS

Gulf states divided over Iran

13 JANUARY 2014, MIDDLE EAST

Gulf states at odds over Syria war

01 JULY 2013, MIDDLE EAST

Profile: Arab League

05 NOVEMBER 2013, MIDDLE EAST

Share this page

Share this page

Share

Facebook

Twitter

Email

Print

In association with

More Middle East stories

RSS

UN condemns Egypt death sentences

The UN condemns an Egyptian court's decision to sentence to death 528 supporters of ousted

President Mohammed Morsi, as another 683 go on trial.

Iraq's election commissioners resign

'Vulnerable' Syrians arrive in UK

Top Stories

China families vent plane fury

Ukraine far-right leader killed

Pistorius 'had loving relationship'

Obama: Pray for US mudslide victims

‘Scandal’ of liver disease inaction

Advertisement

Features & Analysis

Presumed dead

How do you mourn for someone when there's no body?

'I have been beaten'

Uzbek president's daughter smuggles a letter to the BBC

Saints and sailors

A guide to Russia's vision of Crimea

Best things ever

The 76 designs vying to be the greatest

Most Popular

Shared

1. 1: Thousands make selfie donation error

2. 2: The 76 best designs of the year

3. 3: Danish zoo kills four healthy lions

4. 4: Mass water supply fluoridation urged

5. 5: Japanese architect wins top prize

Read

1. 1: Ukraine far-right leader killed

2. 2: Danish zoo kills four healthy lions

3. 3: Gulnara Karimova: 'I have been beaten'

4. 4: Pistorius 'had loving relationship'

5. 5: Japanese architect wins top prize

6. 6: Mother's fatal bullet hit Kenya baby

7. 7: Thousands make selfie donation error

8. 8: Lithuania pleads for US gas supplies

9. 9: China families vent plane fury

10. 10: ‘Scandal’ of liver disease inaction

Video/Audio

1. 1: Jury sees video of Pistorius shop kiss Watch

2. 2: The technology that tracked MH370 Watch

3. 3: Daredevil balances over cliff edge Watch

4. 4: One-minute World News Watch

5. 5: 'Last photograph' of Titanic Watch

6. 6: Missing plane relatives Beijing protest Watch

7. 8: Pistorius 'is a broken man' Watch

8. 9: Sports star leaps off Mount Everest Watch

9. 10: How 'pings' helped track plane Watch

In association with

Elsewhere on the BBC

Unseen classics

Fascinating movies that never made it to the cinema

In association with

Advertising Partners

Programmes

HARDtalk Watch

The self-confessed workaholic and artistic director of the English National Ballet on the joy of the

dance

In association with

Advertisement feature by

What it takes to...

Diagnose through a laptop

Advertisement

Ads by Google

British Expat in Oman?

Avoid Losing 55% of Your UK Pension Download a Free Expat Pension Guide

www.forthcapital.com/QROPS

Expatriate In Oman?

£50k-£1m In Savings? Free Report To Get You The Best Interest Rates!

www.offshoresavingsdesigner.com

British Expat In Oman?

Avoid Losing 55% Of Your UK Pension Download A Free Expat Pension Guide

your.qropschoices.com/HMRC-listed

Services  Mobile  Connected TV  News feeds  Alerts  E-mail news

About BBC News Editors' blog BBC College of Journalism News sources Media Action Editorial Guidelines

BBC links

o Mobile siteo Terms of Useo About the BBCo Advertise With Uso Privacyo Accessibility Helpo Ad Choiceso Cookieso Contact the BBCo Parental Guidance

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.