Medium Density Fiber Report
-
Upload
bhartimahawar -
Category
Documents
-
view
29 -
download
10
description
Transcript of Medium Density Fiber Report
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
1, Krinkal Apartment, Mahalaxmi Society, Paldi Ahmedabad Gujarat 380007
Techno-Economic Feasibility Report of
Medium Density Fibre Board
January 2007
Mott MacDonald 501, Sakar II Ellisbridge Ahmedabad, Gujarat India 380001 Tel: +91-79-26575550
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Techno-Economic Feasibility Report of
Medium Density Fibre Board
This document has been prepared for the titled project or named part thereof and should not be relied upon or used for any other project without an independent check being carried out as to its suitability and prior written authority of Mott MacDonald being obtained. Mott MacDonald accepts no responsibility or liability for the consequence of this document being used for a purpose other than the purposes for which it was commissioned. Any person using or relying on the document for such other purpose agrees, and will by such use or reliance be taken to confirm his agreement to indemnify Mott MacDonald for all loss or damage resulting therefrom. Mott MacDonald accepts no responsibility or liability for this document to any party other than the person by whom it was commissioned.
To the extent that this report is based on information supplied by other parties, Mott MacDonald accepts no liability for any loss or damage suffered by the client, whether contractual or tortious, stemming from any conclusions based on data supplied by parties other than Mott MacDonald and used by Mott MacDonald in preparing this report.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
List of Contents Page
Executive Summary
Chapters and Appendices
1 Introduction 1
1.1 Study Background 1
1.2 Project Description 1
1.3 Background of the Firm 2
1.4 About the Promoters & Management 3
1.5 Consultants Background 4
1.6 The Scope of Work 6
1.7 Approach and Methodology 6
1.8 Caveats 9
2 Product Description 10
2.1 Medium Density Fibreboard 10
2.2 Prelam MDF Board 13
2.3 Laminate Flooring 14
2.4 Description of Substitutes 14
3 Market Study 20
3.1 Global Scenario for MDF 20
3.2 Laminate Flooring Market 24
3.3 Indian Market 27
3.4 Indian Scenario on Furniture 38
3.5 Other Relevant Issues 46
4 Raw Material Assessment 50
4.1 Raw material Types 50
4.2 Cotton Production 50
4.3 Cotton stalk 55
4.4 Bagasse as Alternate Raw Material 61
5 Technological Aspects 64
5.2 Manufacturing Process of Prelam Boards: 67
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
5.3 Manufacturing process of Laminated Flooring 67
5.4 Location Aspects 68
5.5 Machinery Details 71
6 Strategic Analysis of the Firm 77
6.1 SWOT Analysis 77
6.2 Five-Force Model Analysis 79
7 Marketing Strategy 82
7.1 Present Marketing Set Up 82
7.2 Formulation of Marketing Strategy 85
8 Financial Modelling & Analysis 88
8.1 Estimation of Capital Cost 88
8.2 Means of Finance 92
8.3 Assumptions 93
8.4 Cash flows& Profitability Statement 97
8.5 Financial Indicators- NPV, IRR, DSCR, Pay back 101
8.6 Sensitivity Analysis 101
9 Conclusion and Recommendations 102
Appendix A: Fixed Cost Allocation of Contingency and POP expenses 103
Appendix B: Working Capital Statement 104
Appendix C: Term Loan - Repayment & Interest 105
Appendix D: Unsecured Loan - Interest 106
Appendix E: SLM Depreciation 107
Appendix F: WDV Depreciation 108
Appendix G: Tax Statement 109
Appendix H: Debt Service Coverage Ratio 110
Appendix I: Pay Back Period & Internal Rate of Return 111
Appendix J: Availability of Bagasse 113
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
List of Figures
Figure 1.1: Approach and Methodology 8 Figure 2.1: Substitutes of MDF 15 Figure 3.1: MDF Consumption in China 21 Figure 3.2: Global MDF Demand Supply Balance 23 Figure 3.3: Global Particleboard Demand Supply Balance 23 Figure 3.4: World Production of Laminate Flooring 24 Figure 3.5: Production of Laminate Flooring in Europe 25 Figure 3.6: Market Volumes of Laminate Flooring in North America 26 Figure 3.7: Market Volumes of Laminate Flooring in Asia Pacific 26 Figure 3.8: Furniture Productions in Billion Euros 39 Figure 3.9: Raw material used in furniture 39 Figure 3.10: Furniture Production Break up 40 Figure 3.11: Import Export of Furniture in India 41 Figure 3.12: Country wise break up of export of Indian furniture 41 Figure 3.13: Product wise break up of Indian furniture export 42 Figure 3.14: Country wise break up of imported furniture in India 42 Figure 3.15: Product wise break up of imported furniture in India 43 Figure 3.16: Break up of the round wood consumption in India 44 Figure 3.17: Imports of Veneer & plywood in India (In US $ 000) 45 Figure 3.18: Import of MDF/HDF & Particle Board in India (In US $ 000) 46 Figure 4.1: Cotton Production area and yields of India and U.S. 50 Figure 4.2: Indias Cotton Production and Production area 51 Figure 4.3: Indias Cotton Production Yield 52 Figure 4.4: Gujarats Cotton Production Yield 53 Figure 4.5: CCS Centre Mechanism 60 Figure 5.1: Techno Economic parameter for machinery selection 71 Figure 6.1: SWOT Analysis 77 Figure 6.2: Wood Products & competitors life cycles 78 Figure 6.3: Five Force Model 79 Figure 7.1: Present Marketing Set up 82
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
List of Tables
Table 2.1: Classification of Board based on Density 10 Table 2.2: IS Specification of MDF Board 11 Table 2.3: Wood& Agro-based products and their application 17 Table 2.4: Characteristics comparison of different products 18 Table 3.1: Region wise MDF production 20 Table 3.2: Production and trade of MDF in the Middle East 22 Table 3.3: Indian log production, imports & apparent consumption, 2003 43 Table 3.4: Demand supply gap of wood 44 Table 3.5: Indian imports of wood products, 2002 -2003 44 Table 4.1: Cotton production 52 Table 4.2: District wise cotton production in Gujarat 54 Table 4.3: Cotton Productions in Surendranagar District 55 Table 4.4: Cotton Production in different talukas of Surendranagar 58 Table 4.5: CCS Centre locations 59 Table 4.6: Sugarcane Productions in Gujarat 62 Table 5.1: List of Imported Machinery 72 Table 5.2: List of Indigenous Machinery 72 Table 5.3: List of other plant and machinery 72 Table 7.1: The present marketing zones of RDPL in India 83 Table 7.2: The present marketing network of RDPL in world 84 Table 8.1: Building and Civil Work 88 Table 8.2: List of imported Machinery 89 Table 8.3: List of Indigenous machinery 89 Table 8.4: list of other plant and machinery 90 Table 8.5: Preoperative and Preliminary cost break up 91 Table 8.6: Inventory norms 91 Table 8.7: Total Cost of Project 92 Table 8.8: Means of finance 92 Table 8.9: Capacity Utilisation in phase 1 93 Table 8.10: Capacity Utilisation in phase 2 93 Table 8.11: Operating norms for Fibre Board manufacturing 95 Table 8.12: Operating norms for Prelam MDF Board manufacturing 95 Table 8.13: Operating Norms for Laminated HDF Flooring Manufacturing 95 Table 8.14: Repayment of Long Term Loan 96 Table 8.15: Profitability Statement 97 Table 8.16: Cash flow Statement 99 Table 8.17: Financial Indicators 101 Table 8.18: Sensitivity Analysis 101
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Executive Summary
Rushil Group (herein after referred to as client or RDPL) has a well established market in
the decorative laminate business in India and abroad. They are planning to make forays
into the manufacturing of MDF (Medium Density Fibreboard), laminate flooring and prelam
boards. This related diversification drive not only offers synergy in operation but also
provides a sea of opportunities in terms of value addition, import substitution, promotion
of rural economy, preservation of forests and employment generation.
Every year, MDF worth US$ 67.5 million are being imported to India which meets almost
75-80% of the total domestic demand. Based on market information, the market for MDF is
growing at an impressive rate of 20-25% p.a. There are only two players in the domestic
market that manufactures MDF. In the light of the above facts, Rushil can look forward to
reap the benefits of early mover advantage. Further to this, a well-established distribution
channel will help the firm to push their new products into the market in a cost effective
way.
Manufacturing MDF from cotton stalks will be the first of its kind in India that will offer
cost advantages in terms of production. RDPL is planning to set up manufacturing unit at
Surendranagar, which is famous for cotton cultivation. Also the surrounding areas are
cotton-abundant. Alternatively, bagasse is being considered as the raw material for MDF
production; which can be easily procured from South Gujarat and Saurashtra.
The client also plans to grow ailanthus excelsa or other kind of soft wood tree near the
factory premises in a vast expanse of land so that the wood from the same can be used as
raw material for MDF. Ideally 850 to 870 saplings can be planted per acre of land and will
be ready for felling in a span of 4 years. The typical yield is 100 tons per hectare. On an
average, 1.55 tons of trees are needed to produce 1 cubic metre of MDF.
The technology and major machinery will be sourced from Germany and China. Parameters
such as contemporariness of technology, energy efficiency, post-sales customer support,
scalability, etc had been taken into account while choosing the technology.
The long-term relationship the client enjoys with many dealers in India and around the
globe, especially in Europe can be leveraged further to sell/export the products from
India. In this respect, the cost-competitiveness and the established brand equity will play a
vital role. RDPL is envisaged to export nearly 60% of the product to favourable market
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
destinations around the globe. The international marketing network of the RDPL is spread
in 34 countries including Canada, USA, Venezuela, Europe, Far East countries, Australia,
and Gulf countries with the strong brand name of Rushil Dcor.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
1
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
1 Introduction
1.1 Study Background
Since its inception in 1992, the Rushil Group of companies have created a niche for
themselves in the laminates business in India. Being a visionary company, it has tapped the
right opportunities so far in increasing the market share and the export volume, thereby
increasing the profits for the firm. At the same time, they have been continuously
innovating themselves in terms of product quality and services to the customers
worldwide, creating value for its stakeholders.
Indias impressive economic growth rate and the thrust on infrastructure development are
potential growth drivers for the construction materials in general and laminate in
particular. Rushil Group (herein after referred to as client or RDPL) is planning to make
forays into the manufacturing of MDF (Medium Density Fibreboard), laminate flooring and
prelam boards. This offers a sea of opportunities in terms of value addition, import
substitution, promotion of rural economy, preservation of forests, employment generation,
etc.
In the clients endeavour for related diversification into MDF manufacturing, Mott
MacDonald (herein after referred to as the consultant) would prepare a detailed techno-
economic feasibility report for the project. This study will focus on the issues of market
demand, raw material sourcing, technology selection, supply chain management, means of
finance, revenue modelling, risk management and strategy formulation.
1.2 Project Description
RDPL is planning to set up manufacturing unit of MDF and HDF board and their downstream
products like Prelam MDF board and Laminated HDF flooring.
The location identified for the project is Navalgarh village in Dhangadhra taluka of
Surendranagar district. The land acquisition process is finalized and RDPL has purchased 67
acres of land. RDPL has also finalized major machinery suppliers and purchase order has
been placed for MDF manufacturing plant, short cycle press, impregnation line and resin
plant. By considering the expertise of manufacturing machinery, quality and price
competitiveness, RDPL has selected foreign machinery suppliers for their requirement.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
2
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
The project will be implemented in two phases. In first phase, RDPL will manufacture
laminated flooring with imported High Density Fibre (HDF) board and in the second phase,
RDPL will manufacture Prelam MDF board and HDF laminated flooring with in-house
manufactured MDF and HDF board. The first phase will commence from October 2007,
while second phase is expected to be commissioned in October 2008.
The project has certain advantages due to its location and raw material used for
manufacturing Fibre board. The raw material selected for the project is agro waste like
cotton stalk and bagasse. RDPL is also considering social forestry route to meet its future
requirement of raw material. Due to the raw material selection, project come under the
agro industry and become eligible to get incentives from the Government of Gujarat.
1.3 Background of the Firm
Rushil Group of companies commenced operations in 1992, when Indian laminate industry
started serving to the global markets. Vir Laminate from the stable of Rushil Group is
one of best known brand in the laminate space and the company is one of Indias leading
decorative laminate manufacturing companies. Vir is a favourable brand for Indian
architects and interior designers. A large number of private & public sector corporate
companies spread across the length and breadth of the country are customers of the group.
Rushil pioneered Indian laminate industry into export market through the adoption of the
flexible global business practices that today enable the company to operate more
efficiently and to produce more value to its stakeholders. With a well-known product brand
Rushil dcor premium laminate, almost 34 countries are being served by our
comprehensive range of products as well as services.
The firm produces laminated sheets, prelam boards and door skins in their state-of-the-art
facilities at Mansa of Gandinagar District. The plant is capable of churning out 4.8 million
sheets per annum.
Milestones 1992 Rushil dcor Pvt. Ltd. (1st laminate manufacturing facility) established by
Mr. Ghanshyam Thakkar & his son Mr. Krupesh Thakkar
1992 - annual turnover of Rs. 2.5 crores in the first year
1993 - 100% increase in sales compared to the previous year
1994 companys first export to Bangladesh
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
3
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
1997 - Rushil International established for export business
1998 - Groups sales graph on the upswing by export & domestic sales
1999 - Mica Rushil Pvt. Ltd. (2nd laminate manufacturing facility) established.
2003 - Rushil H.P.L. (3rd laminate manufacturing facility) established.
2003 Production capacity of 300000 sheets per month.
2003 Companys export reached to 34 countries.
2004 Laxmi Pandit & Samir Khan as brand ambassadors.
2005 Erection of short cycle laminates plant (1st prelam manufacturing facility).
2005 - Production of Vir Prelam boards started.
2005 Sridevi as a brand ambassador for Vir Laminate.
2006 (4th laminate manufacturing facility) established.
2006 production capacity reaches 4,00,000 sheets per month
2007- 2nd manufacturing facility for prelam started (Vertex Laminate Private Ltd,
Mumbai).
2007 Reorganisation of management structure
1.4 About the Promoters & Management
The promoters of the firm are Mr. Krupeshbhai G. Thakkar and Mr. Ghanshyam Thakkar
who possess indomitable spirit of entrepreneurship. The former has nearly 20 years of
experience in laminate manufacturing industry by working in areas of production, product
and project development, exports and sales. Mr. Ghanshyam Thakkar is the founder of the
company who has 46 years of experience in plywood trading and 20 years of experience in
laminate manufacturing business. They are very upbeat about the laminate and flooring
business and are ready to tap the huge potential in this segment that will come as a
consequence of economic boom and the concomitant increased activities in infrastructure
(construction of shopping malls, multiplex, IT parks, offices, etc).
They have a highly competent and forward looking team of professionals manning different
levels and functions. International Business Development is a thrust area that will help
RDPL to tide over any slack in domestic demand that may arise in future. Similarly it has an
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
4
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
IT-enabled office environment that continuously monitor the work flow in vital functions
such as Accounting& Finance, Sales, Production, Purchase& Inventory, etc.
The firm boasts of Sales& Marketing Offices spread throughout the country and an
extremely networked trade set up that export products to 34 countries worldwide.
The Organogram is given below:
Director
CEO
______________________________________________________________
Account Costing Finance Export Marketing & Project & Sales Development
Production HR Purchase IT
1.5 Consultants Background
Mott MacDonald Private Limited (IMM) is a leading multi-disciplinary management and
engineering consultancy based in India, with offices nationwide.
As part of the global Mott MacDonald Group headquartered in U.K., IMM is able to draw on
world-class technical and managerial resources comprising over 5000 staff in more than 50
strategic centres world-wide. IMM is engaged in planning and development touching many
aspects of everyday life from water, energy, industry, environment and transport to
building, healthcare, tourism and social development. Across these sectors IMM works for
national and local governments, public and private utilities, industrial and commercial
companies, investors, developers, banks and financial institutions, international and
bilateral funding agencies and private entrepreneurs. IMMs strengths enable our clients to
realize their projects optimally from concept to commissioning. With 750 professionals, we
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
5
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
take care of the entire process including providing advice on the best procurement route
and the optimum approach for maintaining the project once it enters service.
1.5.1 Services
(i) Management Consultancy IMM provides business planning and project management for a wide spectrum of clients in
industry, infrastructure and social development, including international development banks
and funding agencies. DMM also help clients such as accountancy practices, financial
institutions and industrial companies in making a realistic appraisal of their fixed assets,
and in preparing for disinvestment, mergers or de-mergers, acquisitions, takeovers,
insurance or liquidation, collaborations and joint ventures.
(ii) Social Solutions IMM has undertaken numerous studies and advisory roles for leading development banks
and funding agencies. Projects range from implementing vital AIDS eradication programmes
and pro-poor initiatives to studies for institutional strengthening, sector reform and impact
evaluation. DMM also offers specialist expertise in assisting with public consultation.
(iii) Engineering Services IMMs range of engineering services enables clients to realise optimal implementation of
projects. DMM takes care of every stage site evaluation, basic and detailed engineering,
contract preparation, project management, procurement, equipment inspection and
testing, site supervision and commissioning.
(iv) Infrastructure One of the key strengths of IMM lies in large-scale integrated urban infrastructure
development, encompassing water supply, drainage, solid waste, roads, sanitation, and
community buildings. Here our services range from planning and advisory assistance to
detailed engineering and construction management.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
6
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
(v) Industry IMMs skills and experience have earned it a leading reputation especially in chemicals,
textiles, oil and gas, agri& food processing and life sciences, as well as bulk drugs,
pharmaceuticals and biotechnology. DMM is known particularly for its expertise in process
engineering and licensing for speciality chemical production based on laboratory/pilot
plant know-how developed by R&D centres.
(vi) Buildings IMMs business covers all sectors from commercial and leisure to industry, education and
healthcare. DMM provides the full range of architectural, structural, mechanical and
electrical design skills, along with planning and project management expertise. Building
services are a special capability, notably building management systems, vertical
transportation, telecommunications and security.
1.6 The Scope of Work
The scope of work (SOW) includes-
Assessment of raw material availability to ensure sustained operation of the
plant.
Market assessment to justify project rationale from the market point of view.
Technology Evaluation.
Plant location analysis.
Assessment of project cost, operating cost and revenue estimates.
Working out detailed financial analysis as desired by the financial institutions.
Sensitivity analysis to identify factors crucial for the commercial viability of the
project.
1.7 Approach and Methodology
The entire work (study) will be broken down into individual sets of mutually-exclusive and
collectively-exhaustible issues addressing market demand, availability of raw material,
technology, location aspects, economic and financial feasibility, etc.
Market study will broadly cover the demand- supply scenario prevailing globally and locally
for MDF, its competing products (substitutes), end use pattern, drivers that could spur the
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
7
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
demand, etc. We would utilise our data bank and also refer to authentic and published
materials/literature etc for the purpose of collecting information on industry structure,
international demand-supply scenario, domestic and international prices and trends
thereof, price elasticity, past imports and exports from India, destinations and prices etc.
The availability and suitability of raw material (cotton stalk) for the production of MDF,
the sourcing of the same and related logistic issues will be covered in the next section.
Also contingency plans for alternative raw material (say, ailanthus and celsa) and the steps
to ensure hassle-free availability of the same will also be discussed.
Location Study will look into issues such as raw material availability, proximity to market,
availability of power, water, etc; and a host of other relevant issues like land, labour,
transportation, storage, etc.
Technology will cover the brief description of the process along with features such as
contemporariness of technology, local availability of plant and machinery, energy
efficiency of the process, ease of operation, modularity, scalability and flexibility in
technology/ operation, etc. The endeavour is to source the best available option in terms
of reliability and superiority of technology / plant and machinery.
The marketing strategy will look into the existing sales and marketing set up, need for re-
configuration if any, and addressing the issues holistically that goes beyond 4Ps.
The detailed revenue modelling will cover the means of finance, optimal debt-equity
structure, revenue streams, calculation of projected cash flows and the estimation of NPV,
IRR and debt service coverage ratio.
In addition, elaboration on certain strategic issues pertaining to the business will be
provided. This will throw light into the competitive landscape, the forces that act within
and outside, threats and opportunities, etc. Also specific strategies will be recommended
to tide over the challenges and surge ahead successfully.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
8
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Figure 1.1: Approach and Methodology
Source: MM Analysis
Market Study Demand vs. Supply
Growth Drivers
Substitutes
End Uses
Raw Material Assessment Major Raw Material Procurement
Contingency Options
Other Issues
Technological Aspects Track Record
Ease of Operation
Scalability/Modularity
Energy Efficiency
Flexible Line of Operation
Marketing Strategy Existing Setup
Distribution Channel
4Ps and Beyond
Revenue Models Means of Finance& Capital Structure
Revenue Streams& Cash Flow
Proj. Balance Sheet& Income Summary
NPV, IRR, DSCR, etc. Site Selection Proximity to RM/Market
Availability of Water, Power, etc
Logistics& Distribution Issues
Strategic Insights 5-Force Analysis
Competitive Strategy.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
9
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
1.8 Caveats
Since MDF market is a bit unorganised, it is very difficult to capture the exact under
currents in the market. Also a lot of these activities are not properly recorded. This poses
a lot of challenges for the consultant and the client alike. A judicious mix of desk research,
filed visits, interviewing of key personnel in the MDF/ related business and using some
clever conjectures based on our own experience was the method adopted to address this
issue.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
10
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
2 Product Description
2.1 Medium Density Fibreboard
Fibreboards are classified into low density, medium density and high density fibreboards
according to the density profile as shown below:
Table 2.1: Classification of Board based on Density
Fibreboard Typical Density Range (Kg/m3)
LDF (Low Density Fibreboard) 160-450
MDF (Medium Density Fibreboard) 500-800
HDF (High Density Fibreboard) 800& above
MDF is a panel product manufactured from lignocellulosic fibres combined with a synthetic
resin or other binders. The specific gravity varies from 0.5 to 0.88. MDF has a homogeneous
structure with no identifiable grain or no variations in surface hardness. It can easily be
edge-machined to into many different profiles ready for subsequent direct finishing due to
its relatively uniform thickness density profile. MDF has a good capacity to hold screws and
nails on surfaces and edges.
2.1.1 Features of MDF MDF is resistant to warping and compression. It has excellent screw-holding ability and
edge-finishing characteristics.
MDF is available in two grades, namely, interior grade and exterior grade and are available
in thicknesses ranging from 4mm to 50mm.The IS specifications are reproduced below:
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
11
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Table 2.2: IS Specification of MDF Board
Sr.
No. Specifications Unit Interior Grade Exterior Grade
1 Water Absorption
a) After 2 hours soaking % 9 6
b) After 24 hours soaking 18 12
2 Density Kg/m3 500-900 500-900
3 Moisture Content % 5.15 5.15
4 Linear Expansion (24
hours soaking)
a) General Absorption %
Thickness 7 4
Length 0.4 0.3
Width 0.4 0.3
5 Modulus of Rupture N/mm2
Upto 20mm 28 28
>20mm 25 25
6 Tensile Strength N/mm2
Upto 20mm 0.7 0.8
>20mm 0.6 0.7
7 Screw Withdrawal
Strength
N
Face 1500 1500
Edge 1250 1250
8 Dimensional Tolerance Mm
Length 3
Width 3
Thickness 0.3
MDF offers better quality than particle board. It has lower tendency compared to particle
board for fibre pop which comes from larger particles in the surface that swell more
than adjacent particles. Fibre pop occurs when the board is exposed to high humidity.
MDF has better strength and stability than veneered particle board. The internal bond
strength of MDF is about 50% higher than the corresponding value for veneered particle
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
12
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
board. MDF with a highly homogeneous construction and uniform density gradient does not
require a veneer overlay.
The distinct advantages of MDF are outlined below:
a) It does not delaminate
b) Excellent moulding abilities
c) It can be joined, riveted, tongued and grooved.
d) It can be calibrated and sanded on both sides.
e) Lathe work can be done easily.
f) It is free from overlays and gaps.
g) It possesses homogeneous strength.
h) It is free from knots and cracks.
i) Humidity-resistant.
j) It has low formaldehyde content.
k) Very good screw-holding and edge-finishing properties.
l) It needs no special tools or work methods.
m) All kinds of paints, lacquers, stains and varnishes can be used on MDF.
n) It is insect-resistant.
2.1.2 Applications MDF is being used in residential, commercial buildings for partitions, panelling, false
ceilings and furniture.
Thin MDF has applications in beds, cabinets, chairs, panelling, drawer bottoms and centre
panels in framed doors. It can also be used as skins for flush doors, partitioning, office
screens, lightweight doors and exhibition paneling.
Novel application avenues are in shoe making, motor vehicle interior parts, toys, printed
circuit board production and blades for electric fans. Due to its excellent acoustic
properties, MDF is also being successfully used in Hi-Fi equipment.
Moisture-resistant varieties are being developed that can be used for exterior applications.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
13
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Thick MDF boards can be used in buildings as columns and archways in place of solid wood
where the warp resistance, torsional stability, screw holding strength and edge finishing
characteristics are important. Thick MDF can be as a core substrate material for paneling
with veneers, printed surfaces, vinyl and low pressure laminates due to its dimensional
stability and smoothness. Thick MDF is also widely used as a base material for laminated
and veneered wood products for flooring and wall paneling and for foil wrapped mouldings.
It can also be used for a wide range of furniture such as tables, cabinets, windows, doors,
frames, handicraft items, display or exhibition stands and signs, ceiling, toys, carving,
partitions, maritime applications and educational equipment.
The entire versatility of MDF is yet to be utilised in a host of applications. In short, the
product has the potential to replace plastic, metals and wood in a wide variety of
applications which is only limited by our imagination.
2.2 Prelam MDF Board
To improve the aesthetic look and applicability, laminate paper is applied or fixed on the
fibre board with the help of a press. This board is known as pre laminated board or
prelam board. The prelam board has more than one paper on its surface like base paper
or balancing paper, decorative paper and other protective film. These papers help to
improve resistance to abrasion, temperature and water. As the prelam board is an
improved version of the MDF board, the specification of the Prelam board is completely
depend on the properties of the MDF board.
Prelam MDF board has certain distinct advantages, which are mentioned below:
Resistance to steam and stains
High abrasion resistance
Better strength for durability
Resistance to warping and sagging
Surface counter balanced for greater stability
Strong enough for load bearing applications
Termite, fungus & borer proof
Standard screw holding capacity
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
14
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Prelam MDF board used to manufacture the products mention below:
Cupboards, shutters & wardrobes.
Shelves
Table tops
Cabinets
Household & office furniture.
Computer furniture.
Panels in panel doors.
Beaded doors.
Partitions.
Precautions
2.3 Laminate Flooring
Laminate flooring is composed of several layers of impregnated paper and raw fibre board.
Papers are forming the surface layer of a core layer which stabilizes the floor. Flooring is
available in smaller size of planks. High density fibre board is preferred for core board of
the flooring as it has to bear the load. The basic properties of the laminate flooring are
depend on the properties of the HDF board and laminated papers.
The flooring can withstand with the normal load and provide good aesthetic load. It is not
100 % water-proof and scratch-proof but by using high grade quality paper water
absorption and scratch ability can be minimized to a great extent. Laminate flooring can
withstand the temperature variation and can be installed on any flooring like wood,
ceramic, concrete, particle board, vinyl, linoleum, etc.
2.4 Description of Substitutes
MDF closely competes with other product like plywood, hardboard, particle board and
plastic panels in a variety of applications. Apart from these products, chemically treated
wood, plantation timber, rubber wood, log wood and sawn wood find similar applications.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
15
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Figure 2.1: Substitutes of MDF
Source: MM analysis
Chosen Material
Wood or Wood Base Non Wood
Wood Based Panels
Timber
Timber Base Panels Reconstd Wood Panels
Ply Wood Block Board Particles Board MDF Fibre Board
Steel / Aluminium
Gyp-board
PVC Acrylic / Fibre glass etc.
Agro Waste Base
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
17
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Table 2.3: Wood& Agro-based products and their application
Wood Product Major Uses Substitute
(Wood& Agro waste
Types)
Substitute
(Non-wood Types)
Plywood& Veneer Construction-walls,
doors, decorative
panelling.
Packaging- crates,
boxes, tea chests.
Furniture.
Vehicles-boats,
caravans.
Misc.- Toys, etc.
Particle board
Fibreboard
Paper Overlay-
panelling& packaging.
Sawn wood.
Plastics (furniture&
packaging).
Fibreglass, concrete,
polyester overlay.
Sawn Wood Construction-flooring, walls, joinery, panelling& lining.
Engineering- railway sleepers, piling, wharves, bridges, mining timbers.
Furniture
Packaging-boxes, crates, pallets, etc.
Vehicles
Plywood, veneer, & MDF- panelling, furniture.
Fibreboard-packaging
Particle board.
Plastics (furniture& packaging).
Paper & paperboard (packaging).
Concrete, bricks, steel, aluminium.
Particle Board Construction-flooring, walls, under floor, panelling& building elements.
Plywood, veneer, & sawn wood- packaging, construction& furniture.
Fibreboard.
Steel& aluminium (furniture);
Plastics (furniture& packaging).
MDF Furniture, packaging, construction
(Flooring, walls, panelling, etc.)
Plywood, veneer, particle board& sawn wood.
Steel& aluminium (furniture);
Plastics (furniture& packaging).
Source: MM Analysis
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
18
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Table 2.4: Characteristics comparison of different products
Sr.
No.
Comparison
characteristics Plywood Particle Board MDF
1 Insects & Borers Attracts wood
borers
Does not attract
borers
Totally borer proof,
as only wood fibers
are bonded together
2 Machining, carving &
post forming Not Suitable
Suitable to a limited
extent
Highly suitable
3 Density of the Board Medium Low Medium and high
4 Edge cutting &
trimming
Suitable to a
limited extent
Suitable to a limited
extent Highly suitable
5 Nail & Screw holding
capacity Medium Low to Medium High
6 Board strength &
internal bond Medium Medium High
7 Structural strength
Low due to
wood layer
bonding
Low due to particle
bonding
High due to fiber
bonding
8 Moulding Not possible Not possible Excellent
9 Joining & riveting Not possible Suitable to a limited
extent Highly suitable
10 Surface finish Medium Low Excellent
11 Tensile strength Medium Low High
12 Raw materials 100% wood Agrowaste/wood Agrowaste/wood
13 Environmental
aspects
Dangerous to
forest
resources of
country
Boon for building
material industry due
to versatility of raw
materials usage like
agro waste & wood
waste.
Eco friendly product
Boon for building
material industry due
to versatility of raw
materials usage like
agro waste & wood
waste.
Eco friendly product
14 Value added products Plywood only Prelam boards, Prelam boards,
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
19
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
modular furniture modular furniture,
embossed doors,
carved surface doors,
painted boards
15 Product Specification G1 grade G2 grade G3 grade
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
20
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
3 Market Study
3.1 Global Scenario for MDF
In 2005, the global MDF production reached about 41 million m3, compared to 39 million in
2004. Large scale production facilities are concentrated in Asia, Europe and North
America.
Table 3.1: Region wise MDF production Region Production (000 m3)
Asia 18936
North America 5297.6
Europe 13300
Oceania (Australia and New Zealand) 1656
South America 1758
Total 40947.6 Source: Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) stats
The table explains the regional production in 2005. China has grown to become a dominant
producer (14.66 million m3), followed by Europe. Production in Europe rose to 13.3 million
m3, showing a growth of 7% as compared to 2004. The total consumption also rose by 7.6%
to 12 million m3.
From 2004 to 2005, North American MDF production rose from 5.1 to 5.3 million m3, with
70% of the production concentrated in the United States. MDF production in the U.S.
increased from 3.6 to 3.7 million m3, while the Canadian production increased from 1.5 to
1.6 million m3 in the above period. MDF imports to North America (procurement sources:
Brazil, Argentina, Chile and Venezuela and Oceania) declined by 10% in 2005, to 1.7 million
m3.
MDF production in New Zealand increased to 861000 m3 in 2005. The country also has the
highest per capita consumption of the product.
MDF consumption since the past decade has well penetrated markets other than furniture
industry. But, owing to an earlier establishment of particleboard as a product, its
consumption in most countries was more than MDF before.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
21
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
In countries like Japan and Korea, manufacturers are replacing particleboard; particularly
where MDF properties like smoothness of surface is required. This is expected to spread
worldwide, as furniture manufacturers seek cost effective methods of production.
However, with huge capacity inclusions in China, MDF consumption rose to 16 million m3,
driven by furniture industry growth (2004), compared to particleboard consumption of 4
million m3.
The figure below highlights the MDF consumption break up by segment in China:
Figure 3.1: MDF Consumption in China
Furniture78%
Decoration12%
Other10%
Source: China Academy of Forestry, China Wood
Continued innovations to customers need and to solve their problems, and the
development of Engineered Wood products lead to newer developments. Products like
Sawn wood and plywood are well past their prime, owing to these reasons.
Moreover, these products also compete with steel and other useful materials, widely used
in construction industry and furniture.
MDF Board Market in the Middle East The Middle East regions comprise of developing countries like Algeria, Bahrain, Egypt, Iran,
etc. with growing young population, which point towards growing consumption of wood
based panels.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
22
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
The major constraint to growth in MDF industry in the Middle East is the scarcity of raw
material. Almost 70% of the total production in the region in 2005 (54000 m3) was from
Iran. Trade statistics point towards the fact that majority of the consumption is met
through imports.
With growing demand of MDF in the region, the imports have risen from a mere 332,611 m3
in 2000 to about 2.2 million m3 in 2005.
Table 3.2: Production and trade of MDF in the Middle East
Year Production (m3) Import (m3) Export (m3)
2000 53000 279663 52
2001 14000 422631 139
2002 14000 566531 336
2003 14000 762661 144
2004 40300 1514209 913
2005 54000 2186581 1000 Source: Dieffenbacher Report
As evident from trade statistics, the export potential to Middle East region appears to be worth exploring.
Future Outlook
The Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Organization (Australia) predicts global MDF
demand to increase by 10% till 2010.
As per Jaakko Poyry Information Service, the demand for MDF in U.S., Europe, and Asian
countries (mainly China and South Korea) is expected to exceed the supply, driven by its
popularity in construction industry and furniture manufacturing in recent years. The figure
below shows region wise forecast of MDF surplus/deficits:
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
23
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Figure 3.2: Global MDF Demand Supply Balance
Source: Jaakko Poyry Information Service
Figure 3.3: Global Particleboard Demand Supply Balance
As evident from the figure above, particleboard deficits are anticipated in Europe, whereas
Asia, Oceania, South America are expected to have surplus capacities.
Global Particleboard Demand-Supply Balance
-7000
-6000
-5000
-4000
-3000
-2000
-1000
0
1000
2000
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 (F) 2015 (F)
Years
(1000 m3) North AmericaEurope AsiaOceaniaSouth AmericaAfrica
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 (F) 2015 (F)
Global MDF Demand-Supply Balance
-3500
-3000
-2500
-2000
-1500
-1000
-500
0
500
1000
1500
2000
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 (F) 2015 (F)
Years
(1000 m3) North AmericaEurope AsiaOceaniaSouth AmericaAfrica
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 (F) 2015 (F)
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
24
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Growth Drivers:
The demand of MDF is expected to show an upward trend, considering the following
macroeconomic factors:
1. Rapid economic growth at the world level (GDP growth rate - 4% till 2010).
2. Population growth and urbanization.
3. Trade and foreign investment deregulation.
4. Expanding wood processing capacity.
5. Anticipated growth in construction investment, furniture and decoration industry.
6. Increasing exterior use of wood based panels in European and American countries,
attributing to the suitability of climatic factors.
3.2 Laminate Flooring Market
The global production of laminate flooring from year 1990 to 2005 is depicted below.
Figure 3.4: World Production of Laminate Flooring
Source: Munksjo Paper The production of laminate flooring has steadily grown at a rate of 34.09 % CAGR in the
last 15 years and has reached 815 million m2 in the year 2005.
Europe is the major producer of laminate flooring in the world and is a net exporter for the
last 15 years. Europe accounts for 65 % of total production of laminate flooring in the
world (year 2005).
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Production in million m2
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
25
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
The production of laminate flooring in Europe is mentioned in the figure below:
Figure 3.5: Production of Laminate Flooring in Europe
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
in m
illio
n m
2
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Production for Europe Production for Exports
Source: Munksjo Paper Germany is the biggest producer of the laminate flooring and account for 28 to 33 % of
world production of laminate flooring in last 5 years. Other leading laminate flooring
manufacturing countries in Europe are France, Austria, Belgium, Poland, Switzerland, and
Great Britain.
In terms of import, North America is the leading continent to import the laminate flooring.
With the import, production of laminate flooring in America has also risen in the last 10
years.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
26
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Figure 3.6: Market Volumes of Laminate Flooring in North America
0
20
40
60
80100
120
140
160in
m
illio
n m
2
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Import Domestic Production
Source: Munksjo Paper The production of laminate flooring in Asia is constantly rising for the last 10 years until it
became net exporter in the year 2005.
Figure 3.7: Market Volumes of Laminate Flooring in Asia Pacific
0
50
100
150
200
250
in m
illio
n m
2
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Domestic Production Net Import Net Export
Source: Munksjo Paper The continuous increasing production of laminate flooring in China is the major reason
behind the spurt in Asian production of laminate flooring. From 11 % of production share of
total world production of laminate flooring in year 2001, China reached at 23 % of
production share in the year 2005, which is next to Germany only.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
27
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
3.3 Indian Market
3.3.1 Market Survey
The market study was carried out in various segments which influence the demand for
MDF. They were divided on the basis of similarity in response pattern and the factors
affecting the demand for MDF.
Competitors (including substitute products), institutional buyers, architects & interior
decorators, industrial buyers & converters and wholesalers & distributors were contacted
during the survey. Additionally, some actual users of MDF were also contacted. The study
was conducted in Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Calcutta, Chennai, Delhi, Hyderabad, Jaipur and
Kochi.
a) Competitors:
They are the manufacturers of MDF and its substitutes. The substitutes are plywood,
particle board, hard board, etc. The regional offices and head offices of these
manufacturers were contacted during the survey.
(b) Institutional Buyers:
They are the large buyers of MDF and its substitutes, with having fairly uniform application
areas and the quantity used being substantial. For example CPWD, where the requirement
is mainly of doors & windows but quantity being used is substantial. Large construction
companies also fit into this category. These are bodies where procedures for introducing a
new product are elaborate but volume of sales justifies it.
(c) Architects & Interior Decorators:
This category represents the users of these products for a variety of applications. They are
also the innovators in finding new application areas for various products. This segment do
not form big market by them but help it grow.
(d) Industrial Buyers / Converters:
This segment consists of the converters who use MDF and its substitutes for large scale
manufacture of end use products. They may be T.V. cabinet makers, flush door and knock-
ed down furniture makers etc. Users of this segment have specific requirement and use
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
28
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
various substitute products according to the requirement of end product and the cost of
alternative products.
(e) Wholesalers / Distributors:
This is the most significant segment as they form a link between manufacturing company
and the actual end users. They are the members of distribution channel for various
substitute products (like plywood, particle boards etc.) and very often influence the end
users decision.
(f) End users:
They are both actual buyers and users of MDF. They have used MDF in a particular
application and were contacted to know their views on MDF.
3.3.2 Summary of Findings
(i) Plywood and Block board Plywood and Block board collectively constitute a major segment of wood panel
market.
Plywood possesses good strength and mechanical properties, as well as firm,
easy nailing/screwing ability has given the product very good market
acceptance over the years.
Small scale manufacturers in unorganised sector constitute the major chunk of
the total plywood manufacturing. As these units do not pay any excise duty and
evade other local taxes, they give a tough fight to organised sector plywood
manufacturers.
This industry uses premium timber log veneers as input, which is in short supply.
Construction, furniture and packaging industries are the biggest end-users of
this product.
Plywood is considered first choice for the household furniture in India, but in
foreign countries where ready made and flexible furniture demand is increased
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
29
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
in last decade, there preference gradually moves to other available alternate
products.
Plywood and Block board are available with phenol & urea formaldehyde
bonding for exterior and internal application.
Block boards are available in a density of 750 - 900kg/m3 and thickness varies
from 10 mm to 40mm.
Plywood offers several superior properties like bending, termite resistance,
ability to withstand varying conditions, etc. which makes it non-substitutable by
other wood panel products for some applications.
Most of the sale is on credit. The credit period varies between 30 - 60 days
Source: Capital Market
Marketing of these products is generally through the normal distribution channel
of company -> wholesalers/stockists -> dealers -> consumer. However,
sometimes the dealers purchase directly from the company.
Typically the Plywood is available in panel lengths of 5, 6, 7 & 8 ft., width of 3
and 4 ft. and thickness of 4, 6, 9 and 16 mm.
Fast moving size of Plywood and Block board is 8'x4'.
Prices of plywood have moved upwards at a rate of 10-15% in the last few years.
This can be primarily attributed to increased prices of raw materials.
Some plywood companies are also offering panel doors, flush doors, ceiling tiles
and Plywood with very distinctive and unorthodox surface veneers.
Plywood shuttering is preferred over wooden or steel shuttering because it is
lighter to handle, can be bent and finish is smooth, thus saving plastering cost.
Manufacturer Installed capacity Unit
Greenply Industries (plywood/particle board) 1,18,50,000 M3
Kitply industries (plywood and boards) 14,750,000 M2
National Plywood Industries (plywood / block
board) 4 mm basis 11,350,000 M2
Century ply boards (plywood) 25200 M3
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
30
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Particle Board
The market size for PB in India is roughly US$110 million, with a year-on-year
growth rate of 20%. Almost 90% of the demand is met by domestic production
and the rest is imported. Imports are chiefly from Nepal, Bhutan and Sri Lanka.
Particle boards are mainly used for partition/panelling and in the manufacture
of doors (as inserts in frame) and rarely used for table tops. Ready made
furniture manufacturer prefer particle board as main raw material.
PB suffers from the poor edge machinability, poor tensile strength and poor
screw/nail holding strength.
A substantial portion of particle board (around 65%) being marketed is
laminated and the remaining 35% are in the form of plain& veneer boards.
Industry uses a variety of raw material for the manufacture of particle board,
such as bagasse, wood chips, rice husk, etc. Wood accounts for 87% of the raw
material used in the manufacture of PB.
Standard sizes of particle board panels are 8' x 4', 9' x 4' & 10' x 4' and the
thickness ranging from 9 mm to 35 mm. 12 mm thickness particle board is used
as inserts in door frames, 18mm for modular furniture. The other sizes
commonly used are 15 and 25 mm sheets.
At present there are 15-16 players of particle board and the demand for the
same is nearly 2.55 lakh tons per annum.
Bhutan Board unit in Bhutan with an installed capacity of 21000 TPA has been
performing at 70% capacity utilisation. The unit is located in Bhutan. It markets
around 50% of its production in India.
Novopan is the market leader of particle board followed by Bhutan Board.
Novopan has two manufacturing units with capacities of 50,000 and 75,000
cubic m/year respectively.
Ecoboard, Vision Boards, Aurobindo Laminates and Trimurti used to
manufacture particle board using bagasse as raw material.
Nepal Boards, Bhutan Boards, Mysore Chip Boards, Uro, Decoboard (Bakelite
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
31
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Hylam) and Novopan manufactures PB from wood.
Medium Density Fibre (MDF) Board
MDF worth US$ 67.5 million are being imported to India every year that meets
almost 75-80% of the total domestic demand. Based on market information, the
market for MDF is growing at an impressive rate of 20-25% p.a.
There are two manufacturers of MDF in India. These are Mangalam Timber
Products Ltd. and Nuchem Ltd. The trade name of Mangalam's product is "DURA
TUFF" and that of Nuchem Ltd. is "NUWUD".
The plant capacity of Mangalam Timber is 57000 cubic m/year and that of
Nuchem Ltd. is 60000 cubic m/year (45,000 MTPA).
Duratuff is available in interior and exterior grade and also in pre-laminated
form whereas NUWUD does not have pre laminated boards.
Plywood is considered first choice for the household furniture in India, but in
foreign countries where ready made and flexible furniture demand is increased
in last decade, there preference gradually moves to other available alternate
products.
Pre-laminated boards of DURATUFF are preferred in the Southern and Western
regions, whereas the plain boards are dominant in Northern India. MDF market
in the Eastern region is negligible because of the easier & cheaper availability of
non-teak wood.
Greenply, one of the major players in plywood, particle board and decorative
veneer board manufacturer, is also entering in MDF market with pre laminated
boards, branded as Greenlam. Although Greenply not manufacturing MDF
board at present, it purchases MDF from outside and get it laminated in its unit.
Majority of sale is of 8 ft x 4 ft. panels and thickness prefer-red are 6, 12 and 18
mm.
MDF initially was not accepted positively by traditional carpenter because of
slightly different work practices requirement. However, at present the
carpenters find it easy to work with MDF.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
32
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
MDF manufacturers are trying to push the product directly to the institutional
buyers who are the large consumers. Company plays a promotional role only.
Manufacturers of MDF claimed that they are making exterior grade conforming
to international MDF specifications. They use Phenol Formaldehyde resins for
making exterior grade MDF.
MDF has been accepted by institutions like IOC, CPWD, DDA, HVDCO, IAAI, ITC
Ltd., Ministry of External Affairs, State Housing Boards, State PWDs, Taj Group
of Hotel, etc.
The major demand of MDF board in recent years created by the new emerged
industries in India like software, BPO, retail and banking. Corporate sector
prefers MDF because it provides good aesthetic look and fast erection of
furniture in office.
Plywood is considered first choice for the household furniture in India, but
gradually this preference is shifting towards ready made and flexible furniture,
which is made up of MDF board. The furniture industry, valued at almost INR
30,000 crores, is expected to witness a robust growth in the wade of upswing of
purchasing power of more than 400 million middle class populations.
The growth in furniture consumption has been attributed mainly to
unprecedented growth witnessed in construction and residential real estate
markets. The short term growth is anticipated at 7% - 8%.
Much of the domestic demand for furniture (65%) is from ten major cities viz.
Mumbai, New Delhi, Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Ahmedabad, Pune, Surat,
Kanpur and Jaipur.
With the rising income of middle class and willingness to change furniture often,
will also perk up the demand for MDF board.
Poor awareness about MDF board has been a deterrent, but this can overcome
by educating carpenters and the end user.
MDF is also being sold to original equipment manufacturers like Videocon, BPL &
Philips. These companies use MDF in the manufacture of speaker cabinets.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
33
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Nuchem has a variety of downstream products of MDF like doors, windows,
mouldings, etc. These downstream products are manufactured by Nuchem on
contractual basis.
However, most people related to MDF expect it to perform better in panels and
doors compared to furniture. This is in contradiction with the international
trend, where majority of MDF is being used in furniture making only.
Manufacturers are quite optimistic about increase in share of MDF in the total
panel product markets and particularly plywood. Moreover, they expect it to
perform same function of timber in the manufacture of doors. They expect a
penetration level of over 30% of total panel product market in the future.
Others (Plastic Panels, Cement Bonded Particle Boards, etc.)
The plastic panels are made of PVC which is relatively costlier vis--vis the
other panel products. Thus, the acceptance level is low.
Sintex, the largest manufacturer of PVC panels, are focussing on direct
marketing to the end-users. Marketing through architects was not very
successful because of their high price.
These panels look very attractive, but over a period they fade due to
environmental effects.
Gujarat Synthwood claims to be making a scratch resistant product with integral
skin and appearance similar to wood.
The plastic panels are not very strong, thus, not suitable for use in external uses
like doors & windows.
Uses of plastic panels are limited to door & window frames, doors, windows and
partitions in commercial buildings.
Because of excellent water resistance properties these panels surpass all the
other similar products in performance. These products need no painting,
polishing, varnishing etc. because they are pre-finished on both the surfaces.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
34
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Doors of PVC panels do not find easy acceptance because of psychological
preference for wooden door. Customer accepts frames and windows of material
other than timber more readily but customers still prefer wood or something
similar in appearance and texture.
The manufacturing companies have focussed on institutional markets where
volume is high and product requirement is standardised.
Gujarat Synthwood is trying to promote the product in household and residential
applications to expand the market. Because of its high price & preference for
wood or something similar to wood for doors and windows the penetration of
PVC panels in the total panel product market is quite low.
These products are also relatively new and are still trying to carve out a market
niche for themselves.
The major manufacturers of PVC panels are Sintex, Uniplas, Gujarat Synthwood,
Caprihans & Fixopan Industries. Jain Group manufactures polystyrene (trade
name "TIMBRON") 'based panel products.
Cement bonded particle boards are mainly used for flooring, ceilings and
partitions. The market for these is slowly developing. Cement bonded
particleboard at present is manufactured by NCL Industries (Bison Panel) in
India.
Laminated Flooring
Laminated flooring is widely used in household, corporate offices, restaurant,
hotels, and entertainment complexes. But still granite, marble, kota and
ceramics are the most preferred flooring for house flooring market in India.
Wooden flooring also getting acceptance slowly in Indian houses because of the
availability of the laminated wooden flooring.
Laminate floors are made up of a thin, transparent upper crust that is resistant
to wear and tear, and of high density fibre board inside. Laminate floor cheaper
than the real and hard wooden floor. Laminate floors available at Rs 200-300
per sq feet.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
35
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Laminated floor provides good aesthetic look. It is available in different colours
and designs, which depends on the paper used in the surface of the wooden
floor.
At present, demand of the wooden flooring in India is 90 % met by import only.
More than 20 brands are selling in the Indian market presently. A large number
of these are importers. Amongst the well-known brands, there are Pergo (a
Swedish brand), Krono (a German brand), Eggar, Floormaster, etc.
Laminated floor can be installed on existing flooring of wood, ceramic,
concrete, particle board, vinyl, linoleum, etc.
The surface layer of laminate flooring is hard, compact and autistatic, so dirt
and dust do not adhere to it easily. It makes floor cleaning easy.
Laminate floor are less vulnerable than pure wooden flooring from water and
dust, but they also require great care to maintain sustainable life. Due to
improvement in technology, laminated flooring is available in market with the
warranty up to 50 years.
Technology has change laminate flooring from glue joints to mechanical click
joints; almost all laminate floors are glue-free today.
The Indian flooring market has witnessed a lot of changes in the last 50 years.
From the traditional stone flooring, people have moved to granite, ceramic,
marble and now its laminates flooring.
3.3.3 Institutional Buyers for MDF
A SHIPPING INDUSTRY
MDF / Particle board can be used in the manufacture of furniture in ships for which at
present plywood is used. Currently marine plywood is used in this application.
B. RAILWAYS
Research Design & Standards Organization (RDSO) is the research wing of Railways. They
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
36
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
promote the use of newer materials in coach building. New class of material is tested and
certified by them. This is communicated to all the nine zones of Railways so that field staff
can use them.
The two major coach factories namely Integral Coach Factory (ICF), Perambur and Railway
Coach Factory (RCF), Kapurthala opined that approval of RDSO is needed for using any new
material. At present MDF is not used in such building.
c. SURFACE TRANSPORT
(i) Presently wood, plywood and block board are being used in bus and truck body
building.
(ii) Some bus/truck body manufacturers said that they do not know anything about MDF
and nobody has approached them for such a product.
(iii) Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation tried MDF for passenger seats by
replacing plywood which was being used earlier. But the results of this experiment were
not satisfactory. However, the trials are still on.
D. STATE AGENCIES
(i) Central Public Works Department (CPWD) is quite favourable to the product. Their
Technology Application & Development Cell (TADC) has approved the material and they are
still conducting some tests on the product. For experimentation/trial purpose they have
used it in some of the construction and are observing its performance.
(ii) Main use for CPWD is in door shutters followed by windows and frames. But the
Department is quite stringent on the Boiling Water Proof (BWP) grade product. They would
also prefer a pigmented exterior grade for easier identification.
(iii) They find that exterior grade MDF is not easily available in the market
(iv) Housing & Urban Development Corporation (HUDCO) another central government
body in housing is also giving MDF a trial by using it in some of the construction activity.
HUDCO has used MDF in its Type IV flats at Khelgaon Marg, New Delhi for joinery and
various interior
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
37
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
E. PRIVATE BUILDERS
(i) Private Builders see a great possibility of MDF application in door shutters. For
frames, steel or aluminium is used and in windows steel, aluminium and PVC are preferred.
Door shutters traditionally have been of wood and they would continue to be made up of
similar material.
(ii) Price-wise MDF is either on a bit higher side or equivalent to other material in their
assessment.
(iii) Users have found availability of MDF as a constraint.
Points (ii) & (iii) are not weaknesses per se, but opportunities. RDPL can look forward to
leveraging the advantages arising out of domestic production at economies of scale.
3.3.4 Architects & Interior Decorators
(i) Positive attitude about the product is reflected by various architects & interior decorators contacted.
(ii) MDF is recommended in the furniture which is painted for use. However, in the
cases where polishing arid teak ply lamination is required, MDF is not preferred
because of its poor adhesive properties compared to plywood and blockboard.
(iii) Modular furniture is a new concept. It will be preferred by the people who want
economical stuff but for the class which believes in exclusiveness it is a preferred
material.
(iv) Short supply of MDF especially NUWUD has also been reported by few.
(v) MDF is preferred because of its appearance, price and versatility. Higher use of MDF
and other panel products is reported in the western and southern India.
(vi) According to majority of respondents in this category, MDF is a success abroad and
in India direct marketing and promotion through architects is required. But
carpenters or workmen need to be educated about the product for better
penetration.
(vii) Availability of larger sizes of MDF like 8'x6' (which is available in particle board) is
desired by some interior decorators.
(viii) Everybody agrees that price, performance and awareness about the product will
influence the choice of customer and the penetration is expected to increase in the
future to over 30 to 35% of the panel product market.
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
38
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
3.3.5 Industrial Buyers/Converters
(i) Respondents of this group have been using plywood and particle board till now.
(ii) As the modular furniture in India is not very popular, the use of MDF is very less.
(iii) Until now furniture manufacturers have been using other panel products like
plywood, blackboard etc. Although MDF is cheaper than plywood, most furniture
makers have not given it a try as it, is a relatively new product. However, in places
like Muzaffarnagar, U.P., which is known for its furniture made from Sheesham
wood, demand for NUWUD based furniture, is picking up. Furniture (from NUWUD
includes tables, chairs, cabinets, 0 wardrobes, racks with very good design creativity.
Cost of MDF is less than sheesham and teak wood.
(iv) Handrails and margins (mouldings) made from MDF in a wide variety of designs are
gaining popularity. These are traditionally made from teak wood. A few furniture
makers, who have replaced particle board with MDF find this uneconomical.
However, the cost-benefit is not weighed in terms of MDF's durability, strength etc.
(v) For simpler applications like TV trolleys, cabinets etc., particle board being a
cheaper product, is preferred. Also acoustic properties of particle board fit into the
requirement.
(vi) In furniture making, requirement of moulded/carved edges can be easily met with
MDF, but users have minor worries about screwing properties on the edges of MDF.
(vii) MDF is being used by ancillary units of some audio/video electronic equipments
manufacturing companies.
Some of regular users have complained about poor availability, which is forcing them to
use other panel products again. They make products on time bound order, so cannot afford
to wait.
3.4 Indian Scenario on Furniture
The Indian furniture industry is fragmented and 85 % of the furniture produced is by
handicraft. The contribution of the sector to the GDP is approximately 0.5 % only.
The furniture production trend in India is depicted below:
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
39
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Figure 3.8: Furniture Productions in Billion Euros
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation The industry grew almost 3% per annum annual growth rate in year 1996 to 1999 and then
slowed down by 10 % in year 1999. The slow down was the result of the cyclical situation of
the economy. Furniture sector recovered from the 1999 crisis and attained a 3 % growth
rate in the year 2000 and 2001.
The wood-based furniture ruled the Indian furniture industry with 65 % share, while metal
is accounted for 25% and plastic is accounted for 10 %.
Figure 3.9: Raw material used in furniture
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation
1998 2000
2016
2067
2130
1913
1986 2026
1800 1850
1900 1950
2000 2050
2100 2150
1996 1997 1999 2001
65%
10%
25%Wood
Metal
Plastic
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
40
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
The household furniture is the major segment of the total furniture production, which
accounts for 65% of the production value.
Figure 3.10: Furniture Production Break up
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation The household segment covers the upholstered furniture, bedroom, kitchen, and dining
rooms furniture. The upholstered furniture accounts for the 30 %, bedroom 20 %, and
kitchen and dining rooms furniture for the 7.5 % each. The second major segments in the
furniture industry are corporate/office and hotel furniture with the share of 15 % each.
Other furniture holds remaining 5 % share.
The office furniture segment is the one that boasts the most important companies, both
from the point of view of size and of the technological innovation of the production.
Import Export
The import and export of the furniture is given as exhibit below:
8% 8%5%
15%
15% 29%
20%
Upholstery Bedroom Furniture Dining room Furniture Kitchen Furniture
Other Furniture Corporate/Office Hotel/contract
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
41
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Figure 3.11: Import Export of Furniture in India
020406080
100120140160
1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
in m
illio
n Eu
ros
Import Export
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation The exports of Indian furniture are ten times higher than imports of the furniture in India.
The exports are more in the form of cheap varieties at affordable costs whereas the
imports cater to the elite class who wants to own the best brands available in the market.
Export of Indian furniture
The United States is the biggest consumer of the Indian furniture outside India and
accounts for 24% of total export of the Indian furniture. After US, United Kingdom and
Germany are the biggest export destinations for the furniture with 14% share each.
Figure 3.12: Country wise break up of export of Indian furniture
4%
2%
24%
14%
14%5%
2%
15%
5% 10%
5%
United States Germany United kingdom FranceItaly Denmark Canada Greeceothers Belgium Netherlands
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
42
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
The indicative break up of export share of the furniture products is given below:
Figure 3.13: Product wise break up of Indian furniture export
1%
1%
8%
4%
5%8%
31%
42%
Other Wooden Furniture Office Furniture other Furniture & PartsKitchen Furniture Seating & Parts Plastic FurnitureOther Metal Furniture Bedrooms
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation
Import of the furniture
Indian consumer prefers stylish and western furniture. The biggest import source of
furniture in India is Germany which account for the 16 % of total import of the furniture.
Germany followed by the Italy with 12 % and Korea with 10 % of import share.
Figure 3.14: Country wise break up of imported furniture in India
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation The indicative break up of import share of the furniture products is given below:
20% 3% 16%12%
7%
9%
4% 5% 7%7%
10%
GermanyItalyKorea United KingdomUnited StatesIrish RepublicFranceJapan Poland others Switzerland
-
Techno-Economic Feasibility report of Mott MacDonald Medium Density Fibre Board Rushil Dcor Pvt Ltd.
43
P:\Ahmedabad\AMC\USERS\PROJECTS\230431-Rushil -MDF -Feasibility\report\Final Report - Amended 26th Nov 2007.doc/
Figure 3.15: Product wise break up of imported furniture in India
Source: European Furniture Manufacturer Federation
Indian wood scenario
India meets its wood required by natural production, plantatio