Medical Separation Medical Separation ProceduresProcedures

Presented by: Presented by: William A. McClureWilliam A. McClure

Chief Executive Office - Risk Chief Executive Office - Risk ManagementManagement

Workers’ Comp – Special ProjectsWorkers’ Comp – Special Projects(213) 738-2151(213) 738-2151

wmcclure@ceo.lacounty.govwmcclure@ceo.lacounty.gov

Topics CoveredTopics Covered

Overview Authority

• Rule 9.07• Rule 9.08

Med Sep: Non-Contributory Plan Members

Sample Letters Disability

Retirement: Contributory Plan Member

Med Sep: Contributory Plan Members

RULE 9.07RULE 9.07

The director of personnel may require a medical evaluation

An employee may request one

OR, a department, with the consent of the director of personnel, may require a medical re-evaluation

If the condition is work-related, the medical re-evaluation must be based on the medical evidence used by the WCAB

RULE 9.08

Is utilized when medical re-evaluation or other competent medical or legal evidence indicates employee is unable to return to their Usual & Customary Job

Interactive is conducted, and it is determined that employee is unable to be accommodated

Medical Separation vs. Disability Retirement

Medical Separation for Medical Separation for Employees in a Employees in a

Non-Contributory Plan Non-Contributory Plan

Review Civil Service Rule (CSR) 9.08 at Review Civil Service Rule (CSR) 9.08 at http://ordlink.com/codes/lacounty/_DATA/TITLE05/Appenhttp://ordlink.com/codes/lacounty/_DATA/TITLE05/Appendix_1.html#12dix_1.html#12Engage Employee in interactive process and ensure the Engage Employee in interactive process and ensure the alternatives listed in CSR 9.08 B.1. have been alternatives listed in CSR 9.08 B.1. have been exhausted.exhausted.Verify the employee is ineligible for LACERA disability Verify the employee is ineligible for LACERA disability retirement. Ineligible employees are those in Plan E and retirement. Ineligible employees are those in Plan E and those who have transferred into contributory plans, but those who have transferred into contributory plans, but have not met the disability retirement eligibility criteria. have not met the disability retirement eligibility criteria. Contact LACERA for details.Contact LACERA for details.Verify employee has been approved by VPA/Sedgwick Verify employee has been approved by VPA/Sedgwick CMS for LTD benefits to age 65 (obtain copy of the CMS for LTD benefits to age 65 (obtain copy of the approval letter).approval letter).Submit written request to CEO Risk Management Submit written request to CEO Risk Management Branch, ATTN: Charlene Abe, (See Sample Letter), Branch, ATTN: Charlene Abe, (See Sample Letter), attach supporting documentation including Sedgwick attach supporting documentation including Sedgwick CMS letter.CMS letter.Upon approval from CEO Risk Management Branch, Upon approval from CEO Risk Management Branch, provide written notification to the employee of the provide written notification to the employee of the Department’s intent to Medically Release them from Department’s intent to Medically Release them from County service (See Sample Letter). Consult County service (See Sample Letter). Consult departmental advocacy/performance management departmental advocacy/performance management staff…the notice must specify:staff…the notice must specify:– Effective date of the proposed releaseEffective date of the proposed release– Facts justifying the releaseFacts justifying the release– Timeframe within which the employee may respond orally or Timeframe within which the employee may respond orally or

in writing.in writing.

If departmental management confirms medical release is If departmental management confirms medical release is appropriate after considering the employee’s response, appropriate after considering the employee’s response, or if the employee fails to respond within the specified or if the employee fails to respond within the specified time frame, provide written notification to the employee of time frame, provide written notification to the employee of their release from County service (see sample letter). their release from County service (see sample letter). The notice must state:The notice must state:– Release is without prejudice (the employee is eligible for Release is without prejudice (the employee is eligible for

rehire if their condition improves)rehire if their condition improves)

– Employee has the right to appeal to the Civil Service Employee has the right to appeal to the Civil Service Commission within 15 business days of notice serviceCommission within 15 business days of notice service

The Department’s Human Resources Division will request that a check be issued to you from the Auditor-Controller for any accumulated benefits.

NOTE:NOTE:

– If the employee has an open workers’ compensation claim, If the employee has an open workers’ compensation claim, notify the Third-Party Administrator of the employee’s notify the Third-Party Administrator of the employee’s release from service.release from service.

– If the Civil Service Commission overturns the release, you If the Civil Service Commission overturns the release, you may need to reinstate the employee.may need to reinstate the employee.

EMPLOYEE RIGHTSEMPLOYEE RIGHTS

Civil Service Rules (CSR) give you the right to appeal this action and request a hearing before the Civil Service Commission (CSC). Your request must be in writing, must be signed by you or your representative, must give your mailing address, and must state in plain language the ruling or action you are appealing. Your petition should provide sufficient facts upon which your case is based in order to assist the CSC in determining whether to grant you a hearing. Please include any specific CSR violations if applicable. Written response and request for a hearing must be sent within fifteen (15) business days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays only, from the date on which this letter was mailed or given to you to: Civil Service Commission, 222 North Grand Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90012. A copy should also be sent to Mr./ Ms. Director of employee’s department.

To facilitate the processing of your last paycheck, please complete the enclosed Termination Clearance form and return it and any County property issued to you, including your department identification card, to your immediate supervisor who will forward the form to the Personnel Office.

All written materials and documents, upon which this action is based, were provided to you prior to or during the administrative interview and are attached for your review.

Request to Approve Request to Approve Medical Release – to CEOMedical Release – to CEO

(Sample Letter)(Sample Letter)

LETTERHEAD Date Ms. Charlene Abe Chief Administrative Office 3333 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 820 Los Angeles, CA 90010 Dear Ms. Abe: MEDICAL RELEASE OF (Employee’s Name) EMPLOYEE NUMBER: This is to request approval to medically separate (Employee’s Name) from County Service. The following is a summary of the facts:

(Employee’s Name) condition meets Social Security Disability criteria per VPA letter dated (Date), (Attachment).

(Employee’sd Name) is in Retirement Plan E (Employee’s Name) has been on medical leave from work since April 1994. Our department has recently attempted to interactive with employee, per certified

letter (date), and employee has indicated no interest in meeting/accommodation. (Employee’s Name)’s treating physician has indicated that he/she will probably

never be able to return to gainful employment. If you have any questions, please contact (Dept. RTW Contact Name), Return to Work Unit, at (555) 555-5555. Very truly yours, (DEPARTMENT HEAD NAME) (Title) (CHIEF NAME), Chief (Section Name) (Code) cc: (HR contact Name) csr:g:RTW101SampleLtrfor Req for Approval to Medically Release.2.09.word

Notice of Intent to Medically Notice of Intent to Medically SeparateSeparate Sample LetterSample Letter

LETTERHEAD CERTIFIED MAIL – RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED CONFIDENTIAL (Date) (Employee Name) (Address) Dear Ms./Mr. (Name): NOTICE OF INTENT TO MEDICALLY RELEASE This letter is to notify you of our intent to medically release you from your permanent position of (Position Title) with (Department Name) and from County service. The reasons for the proposed action are:

Medical Release without prejudice, under Civil Service rule 9.08 FACTS The specific facts supporting this proposed action are:

1. Our records indicate that you have been off work due to your disability since (Date).

2. There is no suitable position in which you can perform satisfactorily.

3. In a letter dated (Date), the County of Los Angeles Risk Management Branch of

the Chief Executive Office (CEO) concurred that your release is appropriate under provision of Civil Service Rule 9.08 (Exhibit A) based on the following:

It has been determined that you meet the Federal Social Security criteria

for total disability per the Sedgwick, CMS, letter dated (Date) (Exhibit B). You have been receiving Long Term disability (LTD) and will continue

receiving this benefit until age 65, as long as you continue to meet the plan requirements.

As a member of Retirement Plan E, you are ineligible for service-connected disability retirement (SCDR), but will receive service credit until age 65 as long as you are totally disabled and receiving LTD benefits.

CONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

In view of your incapacity to work and the (Date) letter of concurrence In view of your incapacity to work and the (Date) letter of concurrence from the County of Los Angeles Risk Management Branch of the CEO, from the County of Los Angeles Risk Management Branch of the CEO, the Department intends to medically release you from your position the Department intends to medically release you from your position without prejudice.without prejudice.

As a member of Retirement Plan E, you are ineligible for service-As a member of Retirement Plan E, you are ineligible for service-connected disability retirement. You may contact (Name) with connected disability retirement. You may contact (Name) with Sedgwick, CMS, at (555) 555-5555 or (888) 888-8888 regarding your Sedgwick, CMS, at (555) 555-5555 or (888) 888-8888 regarding your eligibility for LTD.eligibility for LTD.

RIGHT TO RESPONDRIGHT TO RESPOND

All written materials, reports, and documents upon which this action is All written materials, reports, and documents upon which this action is based are available for your review. If you wish to see them or obtain based are available for your review. If you wish to see them or obtain copies, please contact (Name), (Title) at (555)555-5555.copies, please contact (Name), (Title) at (555)555-5555.

You have the right to respond to this action, either orally, in writing, or You have the right to respond to this action, either orally, in writing, or both. If you choose to respond in writing, send your response to the both. If you choose to respond in writing, send your response to the facts contained in this letter to (Name), Deputy Director (Department facts contained in this letter to (Name), Deputy Director (Department Name) (Address). If you wish to respond personally, you and your Name) (Address). If you wish to respond personally, you and your representative, if you choose to be represented, may schedule a representative, if you choose to be represented, may schedule a meeting with (Name of last person above). For an appointment, call meeting with (Name of last person above). For an appointment, call (Name of person above secretary at(555) 555-5555.(Name of person above secretary at(555) 555-5555.

If you do not respond to this letter in writing by (Date) or arrange to If you do not respond to this letter in writing by (Date) or arrange to meet with (Name of above person), you will have waived your right to meet with (Name of above person), you will have waived your right to respond and the Department will proceed with the proposed action.respond and the Department will proceed with the proposed action.

If you have any questions, please contact (Name of contact above) If you have any questions, please contact (Name of contact above) secretary, at (555) 555-5555.secretary, at (555) 555-5555.

Very truly yours,Very truly yours, NAMENAME Director of (Department Name)Director of (Department Name) (NAME OF DEPARTMENT CHIEF)(NAME OF DEPARTMENT CHIEF) (Division Name)(Division Name) CodeCode Cc: Cc: HRHR Deputy aboveDeputy above

Notice of Medical Release Notice of Medical Release from Servicefrom Service

Sample LetterSample Letter

LETTERHEAD CERTIFIED MAIL – RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED CONFIDENTIAL (Date) (Employee Name) (Address) Dear Ms./Mr. (Name): NOTICE OF MEDICAL RELEASE FROM SERVICE This is to notify you of your medical release, effective (Date), from your permanent position of (Position Title) with (Department Name) and from County service. The reasons for the action are:

Medical Release without prejudice, under Civil Service rule 9.08 FACTS The specific facts supporting this proposed action are:

1. Our records indicate that you have been off work due to your disability since (Date).

2. There is no suitable position in which you can perform satisfactorily.

3. In a letter dated (Date), the County of Los Angeles Risk Management Branch of

the Chief Executive Office (CEO) concurred that your release is appropriate under provision of Civil Service Rule 9.08 (Exhibit A) based on the following:

It has been determined that you meet the Federal Social Security criteria

for total disability per the Sedgwick, CMS, letter dated (Date) (Exhibit B). You have been receiving Long Term disability (LTD) and will continue

receiving this benefit until age 65, as long as you continue to meet the plan requirements.

As a member of Retirement Plan E, you are ineligible for service-connected disability retirement (SCDR), but will receive service credit until age 65 as long as you are totally disabled and receiving LTD benefits.

4. On (date), we informed you of our intent to medically 4. On (date), we informed you of our intent to medically release you, of the specific grounds for the release, and of release you, of the specific grounds for the release, and of your right to obtain copies of the materials upon which this your right to obtain copies of the materials upon which this action is based. We also informed you of your right to action is based. We also informed you of your right to respond to the proposed medical release by (Date).respond to the proposed medical release by (Date).5. On (Date), at (time), you met with me and (Name), (Title) 5. On (Date), at (time), you met with me and (Name), (Title) (Discipline or other Section Name that handles your (Discipline or other Section Name that handles your department separation process), in the Skelly meeting for department separation process), in the Skelly meeting for this matter. During the meeting, you expressed concern this matter. During the meeting, you expressed concern regarding LTD and Retirement Allowance after the medical regarding LTD and Retirement Allowance after the medical release. I recommended that you schedule an appointment release. I recommended that you schedule an appointment with LACERA to discuss options for retirement and medical with LACERA to discuss options for retirement and medical insurance coverage.insurance coverage.

CONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

In view of your incapacity to work and the (Date), letter of In view of your incapacity to work and the (Date), letter of concurrence from the County of Los Angeles Risk concurrence from the County of Los Angeles Risk Management Branch of the Chief Executive Office, the Management Branch of the Chief Executive Office, the Department is medically releasing you from your position Department is medically releasing you from your position without prejudice. without prejudice.

As a member of Retirement Plan E, you are ineligible for service-As a member of Retirement Plan E, you are ineligible for service-connected disability retirement. You may contact (Name) connected disability retirement. You may contact (Name) with Sedgwick, CMS at (555)555-5555 or (888) 888-8888 with Sedgwick, CMS at (555)555-5555 or (888) 888-8888 regarding your eligibility for LTD.regarding your eligibility for LTD.

If you have any questions, please contact (Name of contact above) If you have any questions, please contact (Name of contact above) secretary, at (555) 555-5555.secretary, at (555) 555-5555.

Very truly yours,Very truly yours,

NAMENAMEDirector of (Department Name)Director of (Department Name)

(NAME OF DEPARTMENT CHIEF)(NAME OF DEPARTMENT CHIEF)(Division Name)(Division Name)CodeCodeCc: Cc: HRHR

Deputy aboveDeputy above

Contributory Plan membersContributory Plan members – –

EligibleEligiblefor Disability Retirementfor Disability Retirement

Eligibility CriteriaEligibility Criteria

-Service Connected Disability (work related)-Service Connected Disability (work related)

-Non-Service Connected Disability: -Non-Service Connected Disability: after a after a minimum of 5 years employmentminimum of 5 years employment

--Transfers from Plan E to Contributory Plan:Transfers from Plan E to Contributory Plan: eligible after 2 years minimum, active serviceeligible after 2 years minimum, active service

If employee is eligible to apply, you cannot If employee is eligible to apply, you cannot medically separate, either EE or department medically separate, either EE or department can apply for Disability Retirement can apply for Disability Retirement

- California Government Code (CGC)

Section 31721

Contributory Plan Member; Contributory Plan Member; not eligible for Disability not eligible for Disability Retirement….Retirement….

Proceed with Medical Release Proceed with Medical Release procedures as indicated for procedures as indicated for Non-Contributory Plan Non-Contributory Plan membersmembers

If Disability Retirement is Denied; LACERA finds employee is not disabled, employer is obligated to return them to suitable work

-CGC Section 31725 as amended in 1970-Gladys McGriff Vs. County of Los Angeles (1973)

If employee is not disabled, but refuses to return to suitable work, they should be released for cause

Begin Skelly Process for Cause

Medical Separation for Medical Separation for Contributory Plan EmployeesContributory Plan Employees

Following are the circumstances under Following are the circumstances under which a department may consider which a department may consider medical release for a member of medical release for a member of Retirement Plan A through D as the Retirement Plan A through D as the only appropriate alternative;only appropriate alternative;

-The department has clear and -The department has clear and undisputed medical evidence that the undisputed medical evidence that the employee is permanently unable to employee is permanently unable to perform the essential duties of their perform the essential duties of their job.job.

-The department has complied with -The department has complied with Civil Service Rule 9.08 and has Civil Service Rule 9.08 and has

clear, convincing and complete clear, convincing and complete documentation that there is no documentation that there is no suitable, alternative or modified work suitable, alternative or modified work available that can be provided for the available that can be provided for the employee on a permanent basis.employee on a permanent basis.

-The department has filed an application -The department has filed an application for disability retirement on behalf of the for disability retirement on behalf of the employee because the employee is employee because the employee is unwilling or unable to file such unwilling or unable to file such application.application.-The department has received written -The department has received written notice from the Retirement Board that no notice from the Retirement Board that no decision on the retirement application decision on the retirement application can be made because the employee has can be made because the employee has refused to complete the required steps refused to complete the required steps of the disability retirement process.of the disability retirement process.-If all the above items are present the -If all the above items are present the department should request concurrence department should request concurrence from the CEO Risk Management Branch from the CEO Risk Management Branch that medical release is the only that medical release is the only appropriate, remaining alternative.appropriate, remaining alternative.-When written concurrence is received -When written concurrence is received the department may proceed with the the department may proceed with the medical release in accordance with Rule medical release in accordance with Rule 9.08 paragraph C. The following 9.08 paragraph C. The following elements form the basis of the elements form the basis of the separation;separation;

There is clear medical information that There is clear medical information that the employee is medically precluded on the employee is medically precluded on a permanent basis from performing the a permanent basis from performing the essential duties of their job.essential duties of their job.

No suitable alternate or modified No suitable alternate or modified permanent work is available.permanent work is available.

The department has filed an application The department has filed an application for disability retirement on the for disability retirement on the employee’s behalf in compliance with the employee’s behalf in compliance with the County Retirement Act (California County Retirement Act (California Government Code Section 31721).Government Code Section 31721).

The Retirement Board has notified the The Retirement Board has notified the department that because of the department that because of the employee’s refusal to cooperate in the employee’s refusal to cooperate in the required disability retirement process, required disability retirement process, the process has been suspended and no the process has been suspended and no decision can be made on the retirement decision can be made on the retirement application.application.

QUESTIONS??? QUESTIONS???