Medical Education and Patient Safety

28
Medical Education and Patient Safety Professor David Black KSS Postgraduate Deanery

description

Medical Education and Patient Safety. Professor David Black KSS Postgraduate Deanery. Summary. 3 Stories Quality Management and PGME Trainee voice Frame this as one perspective on the Robert Francis Inquiry. A College visit in 2001. Pre 2005 the Colleges regulated PGME - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Medical Education and Patient Safety

Page 1: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Medical Education and Patient Safety

Professor David BlackKSS Postgraduate Deanery

Page 2: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Summary

• 3 Stories• Quality Management and PGME• Trainee voice• Frame this as one perspective on the

Robert Francis Inquiry

Page 3: Medical Education and Patient Safety

A College visit in 2001

• Pre 2005 the Colleges regulated PGME• All had regular visiting processes• RCS visiting emergency medicine in NW

– Previous visit issues not addressed– Very poor training– Wanted to remove recognition asap– Feared A&E would ‘need to close’– Big complaint to Alan Milburn

Page 4: Medical Education and Patient Safety

A case from mid -Staffs

• An accident on a bike

Page 5: Medical Education and Patient Safety

An Emergency Medicine Trainee

• A HST in EM• A response to a new Job Evaluation

Survey (JES) form introduced by the Deanery

• A simple yet forensic assessment of the situation and dangers

Page 6: Medical Education and Patient Safety

A bit of history about PMETB

“ Wherever possible autonomy should be given to Trust and LEPs to monitor there own performance…..visits should be advisory… kept to a minimum and have a clear an expressed purpose”

In reality most visiting stopped 2005-8

Page 7: Medical Education and Patient Safety

A bit more history about PMETB

• Deaneries held responsible for QM• Rely on self reporting, incidents, the

new PMETB survey• Distracted by the MTAS disaster –

recruitment was all• Sir John Tooke inquiry 2007

Page 8: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Recovery 2008-present

• Development of Schools – HoS jointly owned by Deanery and College

• Planned visiting process reinvented –but still mostly reactive not systematic

• GMC has become the competent authority

• Improvements in local processes of QC, the GMC survey and other tools

Page 9: Medical Education and Patient Safety

The Trainee voice (1)Visits: The best QM tool?

• High credibility with all clinicians• The ability to produce and evidence change• To test other sources (in KSS “The Bundle”)• To identify good and poor practice.• To allow ‘externality’• To manage ‘conflict’ situations• To assess small specialities• To deal with patient safety issues

Page 10: Medical Education and Patient Safety
Page 11: Medical Education and Patient Safety
Page 12: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Visiting Issues

Problem• Poor visitor behaviour• Looking at non-educational

issues• Too many visits-all

uncoordinated• To focused on technical

aspects, not patients• Unrealistic requirements

Mitigation• Set rules and train visitors• Stick to assessing GMC

standards• Plan and coordinate through

schools at a regional level• Lay and trainee involvement• Deanery (LETB) visit, with

college externality

Page 13: Medical Education and Patient Safety

A recent foundation visit….

• Massive surgical takes, multiple handovers, loss of continuity of care

• Leading to delayed discharge (e.g. a patient in 4 weeks with no plan)

• Consultants do not know trainees• F1 do not know who to contact when Reg in theatre • F1’s taking direct Urological referrals• ED: throughput prioritised over sick patients.

Foundations doctors pressurised to make admission decisions

Page 14: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Actions on patient safety-sharing is vital

• Do not go without talking to MD/CEO• Importance of lay involvement• Most issue involve and managed by the PGD• Involve the GMC• Involving SHA/PCT in current practice• Involve LETB/Clinical Commissioning Group/

Area Team of NCB?• Involve CQC

Page 15: Medical Education and Patient Safety

The Trainee Voice (2)

• know your GMC survey findings

Page 16: Medical Education and Patient Safety
Page 17: Medical Education and Patient Safety

The Trainee Voice (2)

• know your GMC survey, findings including the specific patient safety concerns

• Inadequate staffing and supervision out of hours

• General service concerns

Page 18: Medical Education and Patient Safety

The Trainee Voice

• know your GMC survey findings– But well known problems

• meet your trainees – regularly• The key acute triumvirate:

-on take medical registrar-emergency medicine middle grade-the ITU registrar

Page 19: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Trainee engagement

• Highly idealistic and very intelligent workforce –use them do not ignore them

• Clinical leadership and change improvement projects

• Linking mangers and trainees in projects• Encourage exit surveys of educational

experience• Talk about education at the Trust board

Page 20: Medical Education and Patient Safety

On-going challenges

• Ensure confidence in raising concerns• How is the LETB/DEQ involved?• What about other professions?• What will these mean for compliance

with the EOF?

Page 21: Medical Education and Patient Safety

An Integrated Quality Dashboard for PGME

Page 22: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Events at Mid –Staffordshire Hospital

2009-2010 Independent Inquiry ‘what’2010-2011 Public Inquiry ‘why’

Public seminars 2012Report to ministers Jan 2013

Page 23: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Q: What themes from witnesses did the inquiry find?

• Bullying culture• Finance not patient drivers• Poor regulation• Poor management• Poor nursing• Redisorganisation• Failure to listen to patients or relatives

Page 24: Medical Education and Patient Safety

How did the inquiry end

“tide of public anger”

“can only be assuaged by the identification and implementation of measures which the patients and the public are satisfied have a good change of achieving this”

Page 25: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Seminars Oct-Nov 2011

• Regulation• Trust leaders• Information• Organisational culture• Nursing• Patient experience• Commissioning

Page 26: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Possible outputs

• Implications for many regulators• Focus on staff culture and older

peoples needs, especially in relation to nursing

• Openness, information and candour• Listening and peer review

Page 27: Medical Education and Patient Safety

Next steps

• Report will be sent to ministers in January

• Many fundamental recommendations• Listening to patients, relatives and staff• Peer review is powerful• But a lot will be up to you…..

Page 28: Medical Education and Patient Safety

My messages about trainees

• Embrace visiting as an opportunity to both improve education and patient safety

• Use your trainees as an improvement tool not just a transient workforce

• Ensure management talks to your trainees, your patients deserve it.


Patient Safety Curriculum in Medical Education · 환자안전 의학교육과정 ... 이 보고. Young-Mee Lee: Patient Safety Curriculum in Medical Education 220 Korean J Med Educ

Patient Safety Curriculum in Medical Education · 환자안전 의학교육과정 ... 이 보고. Young-Mee Lee: Patient Safety Curriculum in Medical Education 220 Korean J Med Educ

A Culture of “Surgical” Patient Safety · Medical Director of Patient Safety Medical Director of SICU and TICU Program Director –Surgical Critical Care Fellowship MetroHealth

A Culture of “Surgical” Patient Safety · Medical Director of Patient Safety Medical Director of SICU and TICU Program Director –Surgical Critical Care Fellowship MetroHealth

Patient Safety Regarding Medical Devices at ICUs in …659293/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Patient Safety Regarding Medical Devices at ICUs in Bangladesh Patientsäkerhet med avseende på medicinteknisk

Patient Safety Regarding Medical Devices at ICUs in …659293/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Patient Safety Regarding Medical Devices at ICUs in Bangladesh Patientsäkerhet med avseende på medicinteknisk

AHRQ Medical Office Survey on Patient Safety Culture

AHRQ Medical Office Survey on Patient Safety Culture

Patient Safety & Quality Improvement in Graduate Medical Education

Patient Safety & Quality Improvement in Graduate Medical Education

Longitudinal Evaluation of the Patient Safety and Medical ... · Aunon FM, Shaw R. Longitudinal Evaluation of the Patient Safety and Medical Liability Reform Demonstration Program:

Longitudinal Evaluation of the Patient Safety and Medical ... · Aunon FM, Shaw R. Longitudinal Evaluation of the Patient Safety and Medical Liability Reform Demonstration Program:

Patient Safety and Medical Errors

Patient Safety and Medical Errors

Purchasing and Design For Patient Safety Professor David Cousins Head of Patient Safety Medicines and Medical Devices National Patient Safety Agency London.

Purchasing and Design For Patient Safety Professor David Cousins Head of Patient Safety Medicines and Medical Devices National Patient Safety Agency London.

MEDICAL ERRORS AND PATIENT SAFETY - University of …cores33webs.mede.uic.edu/uicpatientsafetyeducation... · New York Medical College MEDICAL ERRORS AND PATIENT SAFETY Chapter 8

MEDICAL ERRORS AND PATIENT SAFETY - University of …cores33webs.mede.uic.edu/uicpatientsafetyeducation... · New York Medical College MEDICAL ERRORS AND PATIENT SAFETY Chapter 8

Patient Safety Goals - University Malaya Medical Centre Safety Goals.pdfPATIENT SAFETY GOALS. ... PATIENT SAFETY COUNCIL MALAYSIA (PSCoM) 111Cl C iSfC1. 1.1. ... audit/statistic 2.Prevention

Patient Safety Goals - University Malaya Medical Centre Safety Goals.pdfPATIENT SAFETY GOALS. ... PATIENT SAFETY COUNCIL MALAYSIA (PSCoM) 111Cl C iSfC1. 1.1. ... audit/statistic 2.Prevention

Patient Safety, Medical Error and Tort Law: An ...

Patient Safety, Medical Error and Tort Law: An ...

Patient Safety and Graduate Medical Education February 2003 safety gme.pdf · Patient Safety and Graduate Medical Education Patient Safety and Graduate Medical Education February

Patient Safety and Graduate Medical Education February 2003 safety gme.pdf · Patient Safety and Graduate Medical Education Patient Safety and Graduate Medical Education February

Medical Professionalism in Relation to Safety -Junior · Medical Professionalism in Relation to Safety Junior Doctors Experiences in Practice Karen Egan, Patient Representative, Patient

Medical Professionalism in Relation to Safety -Junior · Medical Professionalism in Relation to Safety Junior Doctors Experiences in Practice Karen Egan, Patient Representative, Patient

MEDICAL SIMULATION IN IMPROVING PATIENT SAFETY

MEDICAL SIMULATION IN IMPROVING PATIENT SAFETY

The Patient Safety Challenge in the UK Dr Kevin Cleary Medical Director National Patient Safety Agency.

The Patient Safety Challenge in the UK Dr Kevin Cleary Medical Director National Patient Safety Agency.

Medical Technology Management and Patient Safety - Opencdn.intechopen.com/pdfs/37347.pdf · Medical Technology Management and Patient Safety 185 3. Sterilization Sterilization is

Medical Technology Management and Patient Safety - Opencdn.intechopen.com/pdfs/37347.pdf · Medical Technology Management and Patient Safety 185 3. Sterilization Sterilization is

Patient Safety: Medical Device Distribution Evaluation and ... · Patient Safety: Medical Device Distribution Evaluation and Sterile Barrier System Integrity Jan Gates, VP Client

Patient Safety: Medical Device Distribution Evaluation and ... · Patient Safety: Medical Device Distribution Evaluation and Sterile Barrier System Integrity Jan Gates, VP Client

Toward Patient Safety in Closed-Loop Medical Device Systems

Toward Patient Safety in Closed-Loop Medical Device Systems

1 Patient Safety 2013 Prevention of Medical Errors.

1 Patient Safety 2013 Prevention of Medical Errors.

Success Stories from the AHRQ Medical Office Survey … · Medical Office Survey on Patient Safety Culture Community Pharmacy Survey on Patient Safety Culture ... (patient-centered,

Success Stories from the AHRQ Medical Office Survey … · Medical Office Survey on Patient Safety Culture Community Pharmacy Survey on Patient Safety Culture ... (patient-centered,