Measuring the Environmental Dimension of...
Transcript of Measuring the Environmental Dimension of...
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 1
Measuring the Environmental Dimension of Globalisation
September 2007, DGINS: BudapestDiscussionPieter Everaers: Eurostat
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 2
Five papers
Statistics Estonia: Sustainability challenge: Global goods and values versus local priorities and practicesMinistry of Environment and Centre of Environmental Studies, Hungary: Globalisation and environment: targets and tools for measuring progressStatistics Netherlands: The challenges of globalisation from an environmental accounting perspectiveFederal Statistical Office, Germany: Environmental pressures from German imports and exportsEurostat, directorate E: Globalisation and environment: developments in Eurostat statistics
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 3
Categorisation of the papers
Why do we need harmonised (global / European) environmental statistics?The effectiveness of indicators and the interaction with policies?The value added of Integrated Economic and Environmental Accounting: some concrete examplesOverview of ongoing and planned actions in the field of environmental statistics and accounts (also) in the context of globalisation
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 4
globalisation Environment
Economic growthShifts production / consumption
Different elements (water, resources, air)
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 5
Statistics EstoniaSustainability challenge: Global goods and values versus local priorities and practices
Impact man on earth described from footprint perspective; environmental issues have multiple dimensions
Footprint and other composite indicators and environmental indices, maybe not robust but still a very valuable (and maybe currently the only useful) tool, for advocacy reasons (?) on a global scale
Work on sustainable indicators still poorly developed, we do not know enough on their impact and usefulness
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 6
Main conclusions
Relevant issues to tackle– Statistical products too far away to provide insight in
achieving the ‘’Great Transition’’ in consumption patternsto sustainable development, not enough insight on interrelations that characterizes globalisation
– The impact of Europe via trade on the global ecosystem: how big is the ecological cake, and who gets which piece?
– New eco / non-eco labelled trade classification neededOnly bits and pieces in place: the EU statistical system is not doing enough, much more is needed: Focus on data and knowledge development.
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 7
Ministry of Environment and Centre of Environmental Studies, HungaryGlobalisation and Environment: targets and tools for measuring progress
Process of selecting global quantitative key-indicators to set concrete policy targetsA scientific process in coordination with development in political commitmentThese indicators, well developed and accepted statistics , are helpful for setting targets and monitoring Three examples how this shows to be effective– Freon production - ozone depletion– Area of natural habitat - halting the loss of biological diversity– Surface temperature increase - greenhouse gasses and the
mitigation efforts
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 8
Main conclusions
Tackling global environmental problems requires global statistical data
Key indicators are very useful and effective
Adopting more specific and measurable targets means a stronger political commitment and a higher level of transparancy
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 9
Statistics NetherlandsThe challenges of globalisation from an Environmental accounting perspective
Environmental accounts: advantages– Consistent with the National Accounts– Environmental accounts can be linked to input-output tables
Kuznets Curve: U-shape relation between economic variables and environmental pressures : relevant to capture these relationships, as link with international tradeAbsolute decoupling GDP growth and CO2 emissions, to be analysed on the international level: test hypothesis on developed countries specialising in clean production and importing dirty products from developing countries
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 10
Main conclusions
Environmental accounting framework is useful to assess the influence of globalisation on the environmentNetherlands is not shifting its environmental burden abroad in the case of CO2 emissions Much further improvement needed on these type of analysis– Improve data sources of national accounts for measuring
globalisation– Investigate in calculation on environmental balance
indicators– Statistical coordination by Eurostat
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 11
Federal Statistical Office, GermanyEnvironmental pressures from German imports and exports.
Increasing International relationships in trade, import and export, increased global responsibilitiesDemand for systematic statistical monitoring of environmental pressures emerged, especially embodied energy and carbon dioxide emissions: EU wide monitoring system neededIntegrated economic and environmental accounts Product and consumption view, imports and exports
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 12
Main conclusions
Relocation hypothesis (export of dirty production, import of dirty products) not supported for Germany. Strong increase of energy prices an important explanatory factor
Systematic statistical approach on a regular base needed to monitor embodied environmental pressures
Comparable EU wide data needed and System of Economic and Environmental Accounts and Input Output Tables
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 13
Eurostat, directorate EGlobalisation and Environment: developments in Eurostat statistics
Globalisation in environment follows economic developments; environmental statistics integrated with other statistical domainsA plea for integrated economic and environmental accountingChallenges for environment statistics and accounts for the ESS (see next slide)
Strategies to meet the challenges (see next slide)
Priorities in Environmental accounting
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 14
Challenges for environmental statistics
Further develop integrated economic and environmental accountingRaise awareness in other statistical domains on relations with environmental statisticsUse statistics already available in other domainsResources to be reserved for environmental statisticsRespond on need for composite indicatorsInformation on river and sub basin level
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 15
Codes: 1 = data availability and use; 2 = implementation; 3 = inactivity
Member States
Air emissions
Water accounting
Economy-wide
material flow
Environmental protection
expenditure
Environmental taxes
Forest and land accounts
Subsoil asset
accountsBelgium 1 2 1 1 1 1 3Denmark 1 2 1 1 1 1 1Germany 1 1 1 1 1 1 3Greece 1 2 1 1 1 1 3Spain 2 2 3 1 1 2 3France 1 2 3 1 1 1 1Ireland 1 2 3 1 1 3 3Italy 1 2 1 1 1 2 2Luxembourg 2 3 3 1 1 3 3Netherlands 1 2 2 1 1 3 1Austria 1 2 1 1 1 1 1Portugal 2 3 2 1 1 3 3Finland 2 1 1 1 1 1 1Sweden 1 1 2 1 1 2 3United Kingdom 1 2 1 1 1 2 1Norway 1 1 2 1 1 2 1
Area of work
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 16
Strategies to meet these challenges
Emphasis on further develop Integrated Economic and Environmental accounting
Support and promote Environmental accounting
Strengthen cooperation between main European actors in Environment statistics (example Go4)
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 17
Relations with other statistics
Environmental statistics and globalisation is very strongly linked to many issues in economic and social statistics. Sharing of data should be further developed (material flows, waste etc).
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 18
TradeProduction/consumptionEnergy useTransport flowsEconomic globalisation
Social globalisationTourismMigrationConsumption patterns
Environmental globalisation
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 19
Three approaches
Key sets of indicators
Composite indicators
Multiple indicator systems (integrated Economic and Environmental Accounting)
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 20
Integrated accounting
Key indicators
Regional stats
Global statist.
Composite indicators
Advocacy
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 21
Questions (I)
Is it relevant to discuss globalisation and environmental statistics on itself or should it be considered part of the discussion in economic and/or social statistics as there are so many indications that globalisation in environmental statistics directly follows the other domains?
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 22
Questions (II)
Do indicators work and more specific is there a role for statisticians for developing key (policy) indicators as suggested in the Hungarian paper?
The development of key indicators, is this a short term or long term perspective?
How to proceed in a dialogue between statistics and environmental policies on the right way to develop indicators?
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 23
Questions (Continued III)
How to organise further harmonisation and primary data collection on environmental issues?
How to relate data from other statistical domains to the field of environmental statistics? Think about variables, classifications, geo references
Can new data collections on environmental issues be justified from the point of view of response and administrative burden?
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 24
Questions (Continued IV)
Integrated Economic and Environmental Accounting, is this the right way, even when it is long and complex?
What to think about the examples discussed?
Do we need to develop EU regulations on this issue to facilitate the development and implementation?
What are the priorities in environmental accounting, eg. focus on depletion or on pressures?
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 25
Questions (Continued V)
Are the Data Centres the best (and maybe only) solution for setting up and efficient system providing information at one hand and facilitating conceptual and analytical work?
21-mars-07 NOM DE LA PRÉSENTATION 26
Thank you for your attention