Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

20
Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return Magnus Akke 2004-04-115 Industriell Elektroteknik och Automation [email protected]

description

Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return. Magnus Akke 200 4 -0 4 -1 15 Industriell Elektroteknik och Automation [email protected]. Outline. Introduction Measurements Comparison with models Discussion and conclusion. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

Page 1: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin

wire with ground return

Magnus Akke

2004-04-115Industriell Elektroteknik och Automation

[email protected]

Page 2: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

2

Outline

– Introduction – Measurements– Comparison with models– Discussion and

conclusion

Page 3: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

3

Motivation for measurements

• Relay testing

• Transient based fault location

• Insulation coordination

• Power line carrier

Page 4: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

4

Decouple 3-phase line

333231

232221

131211

phase

lll

lll

lll

L

minus

plus

zero

comp. sym.

00

00

00

l

l

l

L

321zero3 LLL IIII

3-phase line has one ground mode and two aerial modes. Focus on ground mode.

Page 5: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

5

Task 1: Measure impedance vs frequency for 1500 meter wire with ground return

ScopeChA

1

2

3

4

6

1500 m

5ChB

Task 2: Compare with models

Page 6: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

6

What to expect? Quick and dirty, use handbook TEFYMA

la

dL r

)ln(

40

Approximate inductance with two lines. Return line is the mirror image. Distance between wire and mirror image is 2 m. Resistance from DC-measurement.

Hz) 50at kmper ohm 1( mH 5

m 2 mm; 690 m; 1500

L

d.al

Page 7: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

7

TEFYMA model – Impedance vs Frequency

Page 8: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

8

Measurement setup

ScopeChA

1

2

3

4

6

1500 m

5ChB

Page 9: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

9

Measurement execution

Page 10: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

10

Measured and expected result

Page 11: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

11

Transmission line theory

References: Hallén, E., Elektricitetslära, Almqvist & Wiksells, 1953.

Claesson, I., et al, Analoga kretsar och signaler, Studentlitteratur, 1993.

xx x

),( txi xr xl

),( txv xg xc

),( txxi

),( txxv

),(),(

),(),( txxvt

txxixltxxixrtxv

),(),(

),(),( txxit

txvxctxvxgtxi

Page 12: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

12

Transmission line theory cont.

Re-write and let 0x

t

txvcvg

x

txi

t

txilir

x

txv

),(),(

),(),(

Calculation using Laplace gives

),0(

),0(

),(

),(

sI

sVK

sxI

sxV

)()( lsrcsg

where

)(

)(0 csg

lsrZ

)cosh()sinh(

)sinh()cosh(Kwith

0

1

0

xx

xZx

DC

BA

Z

Page 13: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

13

Transmission line with load

0x

),0( sI

),0( sV

Line model

DC

BAK

),( sdI

),( sdV

dx

LZ

DZC

BZA

sI

sVsZ

L

Lin

),0(

),0()(

Page 14: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

14

Transmission line model with fixed parameters

Page 15: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

15

Frequency dependent parameters

• Fixed parameters works well with metallic return, but fails when ground is used as the current’s return path.

• Carson (1926) used Maxwell’s equation to make a line model where the effect of ground losses and current distribution are embedded in frequency dependent line parameters R and L.

Page 16: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

16

Model with Carson’s frequency dependent parameters

Page 17: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

17

Frequency dependence by Carson and ad-hoc grounding model

Page 18: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

18

Discussion

• Model with lumped inductance and resistance is only valid at

• Transmission line model with fixed parameters is insufficient. Results in poor model and inefficient simulation

• Carson’s model is reasonable up to 100 kHz.

kHz 258

1

d

cf

Page 19: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

19

Relevance for typical transmission line?

Height=15 m, area=500mm2, length=300 km, R_flt=5 ohm

Page 20: Measurement of the frequency dependent impedance of a thin wire with ground return

20

Conclusion

• Theory and measurements are needed to verify and develop models.

• Measurement shows un-modeled dynamics.

• Further work– High frequency modeling of line– Include dynamics of connection between

line and ground, e.g, ground rod or fault– Bounded line length