ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element...

87
Polynomial Form The polynomial representation of the field variable must contain the same number of terms as the number of nodal degrees of freedom. The polynomial representation for an Mdegree of freedom element should contain all powers of the independent variable up to and including M 1. If this is the case the polynomial is complete. In 2D and 3D, polynomial representations of the field variable satisfy the compatibility and completeness requirements if the polynomial exhibits the property known as geometric isotropy. A mathematical function satisfies geometric isotropy if the functional form does not change under a translation or rotation of coordinates.

Transcript of ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element...

Page 1: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Polynomial Form• The polynomial representation of the field variable must contain the same number of terms as the number of nodal degrees of freedom. 

• The polynomial representation for an M‐degree of freedom element should contain all powers of the independent variable up to and including M − 1.  If this is the case the polynomial is complete. 

• In 2D and 3D, polynomial representations of the field variable satisfy the compatibility and completeness requirements if the polynomial exhibits the property known as geometric isotropy.  A mathematical function satisfies geometric isotropy if 

the functional form does not change under a translation or rotation of coordinates. 

Page 2: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

An M order 2D polynomial is complete in the following form.

Where (2)N [(M 1)(M 2)] / 2t

Pascal triangle

A complete polynomial of order M must contain all terms shown above the horizontal line.

Page 3: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

This is represented by the dashed lines in the figure below.

One can use  complete polynomials, or incomplete polynomials if the incomplete polynomial is symmetric.  So the polynomial must contain all the terms above the straight lines or above the dashed lines.

Page 4: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

In 3D Pascal triangle is the Pascal Pyramid.

Page 5: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

In 3D Pascal triangle is the Pascal Pyramid.

Page 6: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Triangular Elements

Page 7: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Inverting the matrix and taking the dot product with the  vector gives.

Page 8: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

The shape function are.

where A is the area of the triangular element.

Page 9: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

The area can be restated as.

Given a coordinate system that is aligned with the triangle can simplify the shape function.

The shape functions become.

While simpler, all of these must be transformedinto an aligned global coordinate system.  This is many coordinate rotations. 

Page 10: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Complete interpolation function with 1 term

(x , y) = a0 + a1x + a2 y

The field variable  can take on a constant value, as required for completeness, and that the first partial derivatives with respect to the independent variables x and y are constants.

The three‐node triangular element is commonly known as a constant strain triangle.

The area coordinates of an arbitrary point P are:

Given:

Page 11: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

So a field variable may be expressed as:

Page 12: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Plane Stress

• The body is small in one coordinate direction in comparison to the other dimensions; the dimension in the z direction (the thickness) is either  uniform or symmetric about the xy plane;

• Thickness t, if in general, is less than one‐tenth of the smallest dimension in the xy plane, would qualify for “small.”

• The body is subjected to loading only in the xyplane.

• The material of the body is linearly elastic, isotropic, and homogeneous.

Page 13: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Plane Stress cont.

are non‐zero.

are zero.

The equilibrium equations are. 

The stress/strain relations are.

or 

Page 14: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Isoparametric Representation of the CST

u1

u3

u5

u2u4

u6

1

2

3

1 1 2 3 3 5

1 2 2 4 3 6

1

x

y

NNNu N u N u N uu N u N u N u

Page 15: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Isoparametric Representation of the CST

1

2

3

1 5 3 5 5

2 5 4 6 6

1 2 3

1 2 3

1( ) ( )( ) ( )

or

where0 0 0

N=0 0 0

x

y

NNNU u u u u u uU v u u u u u

U Nu

N N NN N N

Page 16: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

1 1 2 2 3 3

1 1 2 2 3 3

1 3 2 3 3

13 23 3

1 3 2 3 3

13 23 3

( ) ( )

( ) ( )

x N x N x N xy N y N y N xx x x x x xx x x xy y y y y yy y y y

Page 17: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Determine the shape functions at point P.

Solve for  and .

1 2 3

1 2 3

13 23 3

13 23 3

3.85 1.5 7 44.8 2 3.5 7

3.85 2.5 3 7

4.8 5 3.5 7

N N NN N N

x x x x

y y y y

2.5 3 0.155 3.5 2.2

0.30.2

0.30.20.5

Page 18: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Strains

1 5 3 5 5( ) ( )xU u u u u u u

u u x u yx y

u u x u yx y

u x y uxuu x yy

x y

x y

J

J is the Jacobian.

Page 19: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

13 13

23 23

x yx y

J

1

23 131

23 13

Where

1det

u uxuyy

uuxu yy

y yx x

J

J

JJ13 23 23 13det x y x y J

Page 20: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

1 det2

A J If points 1, 2 and 3 are ordered in a counter clockwise manner, thendet J is positive. 

Determine J.

13 13

23 23

2.5 5.03.0 3.5

det 2.5( 3.5) (3.0)( 5.0) 23.75

x yx y

J

J

Page 21: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

23 13

23 13

23 13

23 13

23 131

23 13

1det

1det

Where

1det

u uu y yxu u ux xy

v vv y yxv v vx xy

y yx x

J

J

JJ

Insert v for u.

Page 22: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

23 1 5 13 3 5

23 2 6 13 4 6

23 1 5 13 3 5 23 2 6 13 4 6

23 1 31 3 12 5

32 2

( ) ( )1 ( ) ( )

det( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( )1 ( )

det

uu x

vxu yy u v

y x

y u u y u ux u u x u u

x u u x u u y u u y u u

y u y u y ux u

J

J 13 4 21 6

32 1 23 2 13 3 31 4 21 5 12 6

( ) ( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

x u x ux u y u x u y u x u y u

Page 23: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

23 13 12

23 13 21

32 23 13 31 21 12

0 0 01 0 0 0

det

y y yx x x

x y x y x y

ε BU

BJ

Page 24: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Find Be for each element using the local element numbering.=

Page 25: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Total Potential EnergyThe potential energy of the system is given by.

Page 26: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Element Stiffness

12 e

e

t dA T TU B DBU

12e e

e

U t dA T TU B DB U

12e eU t A T TU B DBU

12

eeU TU k U

Page 27: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Global Stiffness Matrix

12

12

ee

U

T

T

U k U

U KU

The total stiffness is the summation of each elements stiffness.

Page 28: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Force Terms

Page 29: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 30: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 31: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Traction Force

1 1 2 3

1 2 2 4

x

y

U N u N uU N u N u

Page 32: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

1 2

1 2 3 4, , , e

l

tdl u u u u

UT T

Page 33: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Force Example

Page 34: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 35: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 36: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

2 1 2i i i x i yu P U P U P

Page 37: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 38: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 39: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 40: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 41: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

The potential Energy is:

The work can be expressed as:

The force vector is:

Page 42: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Minimization of the potential energy.

Page 43: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Gives us:

Or

Where

Page 44: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

The shape function

Page 45: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

=y23/2A

=y12/2A

=y31/2A

=x32/2A

=x13/2A

=x21/2A

Page 46: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

23 31 12

32 13 21

32 13 21 23 31 12

0 0 01 0 0 0

2

y y yx x x

Ax x x y y y

Page 47: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

23 32

31 3223 31 12

12 2132 13 212

32 2332 13 21 23 31 12

13 31

21 12

00

1 0 0 0 00

1 0 0 0 004 (1 )

10 002

0

y xy x

y y yy xEtk x x x

x yAx x x y y y

x yx y

Page 48: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

2 223 32 23 31 32 13 23 12 32 21 23 32 23 13 31 32 23 21 12 32

2 231 13 31 12 13 21 31 32 23 13 31 13 31 21 12 13

2 2212 21 12 32 23 21 12 13 31 21 1

12

12

14 (1 ) 2

y Cx y y Cx x y y Cx x y x y x Cy x y x Cy x

y Cx y y Cx x y x Cy x y x y x Cy xEtk y Cx y x Cy x y x Cy x yA

2 21

2 232 32 32 13 23 31 32 21 23 12

2 213 31 13 21 31 12

2 221 12

x

x Cy x x Cy y x x Cy ySYM x Cy x x Cy x

x Cy

where C = (1 − )/2.

Page 49: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Work Equivalent loads for pressure p in direction n.

Page 50: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

with nx and ny corresponding to the components of the unit outward normal vector to edge 2‐3. Here, we use the notation p for such loadings, as the units are those of pressure.

The work being done the becomes.

Introducing the shape function definitions for u and v gives.

Page 51: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

So the total equivalent work becomes:

with

Page 52: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 53: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 54: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 55: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 56: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 57: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Body Forces

Page 58: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

In matrix format:

Page 59: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 60: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 61: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Gravity is in the negative y direction and is the only body force specified. 

Page 62: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Total FE Equation

Nodal force    Traction force              Body force 

Page 63: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 64: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 65: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 66: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 67: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 68: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 69: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

ke =

Page 70: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Global Stiffness Matrix

1

2

3

UUU

1

2

4 5 6 7, , ,U U U U8U

Page 71: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Example

Page 72: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 73: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 74: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 75: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 76: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

20 10 100

21

etAxA

t

Tk B DB

in2

in

Page 77: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Element k

Page 78: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Element 2

Page 79: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 80: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 81: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 82: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 83: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 84: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required
Page 85: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

For element 1.

Page 86: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

For element  2.

Page 87: ME 478 Introduction to Finite Element Analysisfaculty.washington.edu/averess/ME478/cst_lectures.pdf · 2014. 11. 13. · The field variable can take on a constant value, as required

Limitations to CST

• In bending problems, the mesh of CST elements will produce a model that is stiffer than the actual problem.

• A CST modeled beam subjected to pure bending will result in  afalse shear stress. 

• This spurious shear strain absorbs energy so some of the energy that should go into bending is lost. 

• The CST is then too stiff in bending, and the resulting deformation is smaller than actually should be.