Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q...

29

Transcript of Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q...

Page 1: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

��������������� � ���������� ��������������� �!�"� #$�!���� ����%�&�������!� �'���!(

)+*�,.-0/01325456873/09:25-<;=-84?>@/A;B/ CEDFCE-0/G2�H�10CI>J68K�/0>

L?M:NPOPQIRTS&U�OWVXRTYWZP[.\T]IY^U�S�_^Oa`�YbRTcdcd_eMbfB_eOPgFhTRi[d_^U�V._eU'cj_ec5V.\kQPUlV.U�[.S&_eOPUmOIRiV.NB[XRTYWcdNB]IcdUlV.cjnFoP\pcqUrS&\sQPNPYe_W_ec] \pNPOPQPU�Q0tmuvoPUwQP_yx&`'NPYyVzf�\pM0V.oP_^cmZP[.\T]IYeU'S{_^cmZERi[qV._bRTYeYef|S&U@RTcdNB[.U�Q!]Wf&V.oPU}] U�oIRJhs_^\pNB[v\pM0V.oPU`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY`'Y^RTcdck\pMjV.oPU�hiRi[._eU�Vzf~tvu�oB[.U�UaUl�BVd[dU'S&U�`'RTcdU'cRi[.U�U'cqZ U�`'_bRTYeYef�\pM�_eOWVdU�[.U'cqV'�rU'_eV.oPUl[kV.oPU�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY�`�YbRTcdck_ecRTS�ZIYeUT��V.oIRiV�_^c�V.oPU�hiRi[._eU�Vzf�_^c�\pMrgpU'OPU�[XRTY�VzfAZ UT�j\T[�V.oPU�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY�`'Y^RTcdc�_^c�Vd[._ehs_bRTY���M:\T[aUl�PRTS�ZIY^U|V.oPUhiRi[._^U�Vzf�_^c�RTO�Ri] U�Y^_bRTO"hTRi[._eU�Vzf�\T[��vRTYbRi]I_y���rRTN0�=\T[�S�_^OWNPc�V.oPU&`'RTOP\pOP_^`@RTY�`'YbRTcqc�_^c�RTS�ZIY^Ui�=V.oIRiV�_^cwV.oPUhiRi[._^U�Vzf!_^c���RTOP\Pt

� U�V�NPc|�P[.cqV|cdNBZPZ3\pcdU�V.oIRiV�V.oPU�hiRi[._^U�Vzf�_ec|cdS�\s\TV.o0t��zV�_^c�nrU'YeYm�BOP\JnFOGV.oIRiV�hTRi[d_^U�V._eU'c�\pMFgpU'OPU�[.RTYVzfsZ3U&QP\�OP\TVaM:\T[.S�R�]3\pNPOPQPU'QGM�RTS&_^Yyf"NPOPYeU'cdca\pOPU&�B�BU'cacd\pS&U|_^O~hTRi[._^RTOWVdc't��E\T[aUl�PRTS�ZIY^U�R�`'NB[dh~U�\pMgpU'OWNPcF��_eck\pM�gpU'OPU�[.RTY5VzfsZ3Ua_e�������st�u$fAZI_^`@RTYeYef�U�h~U'O�hTRi[d_^U�V._eU'cFn�_eV.o�Vq[._ehs_bRTY8`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY�`'Y^RTcdc}QP\�OP\TVM:\T[.S ]3\pNPOPQPU'Q<M�RTS�_^Y^_eU'c'¡�M:\T[�Ul�IRTS|ZIY^U&V.oPU�S&\AQPNPY^_$cqZERT`'U�\pMFRi]3U'Y^_^RTO�hTRi[d_^U�V._eU'c�oIRTca_^OB�IOP_yV.U'Yef�S�RTOWf`'\pS�Z3\pOPU'O~V.c�`'\T[q[.U'cqZ3\pOPQP_^OPg�V.\"VdoPU�VzfsZ U�\pMFZ \pY^Ri[._^cdRiV._^\pO0t?¢�h~U'O<V.oP\pNPgpo?VdoPU�c.RTS&U�_^c�Vd[.NPU�\pM}£�¤cdNB[.M�RT`�U'c'�sV.\wV.oPU�]3U'cqV$\pM3V.oPUFRTNBV.oP\T[@¥¦c§�BOP\Jn�Y^U'QPgpU�_eV$_^c�OP\TV��BOP\Jn�O|n�oPU�V.oPU�[mVdoPUFM�RTS&_eYefa\pM8�vRTYbRi]I_¨�©�mRTNV.oB[.U�U'M:\pY^QPck_ecF] \pNPOPQPU�Q0t�uvoPU�ZI_e`�V.NB[.U�M:\T[kcdS&\s\TVdo���RTOP\�hTRi[d_^U�V._eU'cFoP\JnrU�h~Ul[}_^c�S�NP`Xo�]P[._egpoWVdU�[@¡3_eOPQPU'U'QV.oPU�[dU&_^c�R�`'\pS�ZIYeU�V.U|`'YbRTcdcq_e�I`@RiV._e\pO�NBZ�V.\�QP_^S&U'OPcq_^\pO�V.oB[dU'UTt!ªsNP`Xo�R�`'Y^RTcdcd_e�I`'RiV._^\pO�_eO�gpU'OPU�[.RTY$cdU�U'SNPOPM:U@RTcd_y]IY^UT�E]INBVk\pO!V.oPU�\TV.oPUl[koIRTOPQ�_eVvnvRTc�ZP[.\Jh~U'Q�]Af!£w\pY^Y'«Ri[@�I¬�_yfWRT\T�TR|RTOPQ�¬�\T[._$­y®°¯+±8V.oIRiV�cdS&\A\TV.o��RTOP\|hiRi[._^U�Vd_^U'c�\pM5�B�BU'Q�QP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO�M:\T[.S�R�] \pNPOPQPU�Q�M�RTS&_^Yyf~t

² OPU�[.U@RTcd\pO�M:\T[�M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg�\pO�V.oPU�V.oB[dU'U&Ul�sVd[.U'S&U�`@RTcdU�ca_^c�VdoIRiV�[.\pNPgpoPYyf�cqZ3U@Ri�B_eOPg�_eV�_^c�U³�BZ U�`�V.U'QV.oIRiVNBZ�V.\�]I_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTY5U'´sNP_yhTRTYeU'OP`'UT�0RTO~f�hiRi[._^UlVµf�_^c}U'_yV.oPU�[\pM§gpU'OPU�[XRTY5VµfAZ Ua\T[wRTQPS&_yV.c}R��P]P[XRiVd_^\pO�V.\RTOP\TV.oPU�[whiRi[._^U�Vzf~�8nFoP\pcqU��P]P[.U�caRi[.U�U'_eV.oPUl[���RTOP\�\T[�oIRJh~U�Vd[._yhB_bRTY�`@RTOP\pOP_^`@RTY§`'Y^RTcdc't|¶}\°nrUlh~U�[�\pOPU|`@RTO\pOPYef"RT`XoP_^Ulh~U�V.oP_^c]I_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTY§M�RT`�V.\T[d_^c.RiV._e\pO�_eMm\pOPU&RTYeY^\JnFcwcd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eVd_^U'c't|��\T[�Ul�PRTS�ZIY^U�M:\T[aR�cqNB[.M�RT`'U

·3¸@¹iºd»�º½¼8¾@¸F¿BÀ�Á~Âb·+ðÄÅ

Page 2: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

\pMvgpU'OPU�[XRTY�VzfsZ U�\pOPU�OPU'U'QPcaV.\�`'\pO~Vd[XRT`�VaRTY^Y$VdoPU��k�°� `'NB[dh~U'c�\pO�V.oPU&cqNB[.M�RT`'U�V.\�S�Ri�~U�V.oPU�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTYQP_ehs_^cd\T[FRTS�ZIYeUTt

� OPM:\T[dV.NPOIRiVdU'Yef�_eV�_^c�OP\�Y^\pOPgpU�[�Vd[.NPU�V.oIRiV�cd_eOPgpNPYbRi[��3RTOP\�hiRi[._eU�V._^U�c�M:\T[.S R�] \pNPOPQPU�Q�M�RTS&_^Yyf~t|�E\T[Ul�PRTS�ZIY^U�`�\pOPU'c�\°h~Ul[!R�[XRiV._^\pOIRTY�OP\T[.S�RTY�`'NB[dh~U�\pMQPU'gT[.U�U���M:\T[.S RTO NPO~] \pNPOPQPU'Q M�RTS&_^YyfG\pMw��RTOP\cdNB[.M�RT`�U'c'¡5Vd\!M:\T[dS R�]3\pNPOPQPU'Q�M�RTS�_^Yef�\pOPU�OPU'U'QPcV.\�_^S�Z3\pcdUacd\pS&U�[.U�cqVd[._e`�V._^\pOPc\pO�V.oPU�cd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eVd_^U'c't² OPU|OIRiV.NB[.RTYj[.U'cqVd[d_^`�V._e\pO�Vd\!_eS�Z \pcqUa_^c}V.oIRiVwcd\pS&U��B�BU'Q"S�NPYyV._eZIYeUa\pM�V.oPU�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY�`'YbRTcqcw_ec���Ri[dVd_^U�[@tuvoPU|cdS&RTY^Y^U�cqVcdNP`Xo�Z \pcq_eV._yh~U�_eOWVdU'gpU�[wnrU�n�_^YeY�`@RTY^YjVdoPU�_eOPQPUl�0t����}\TVdU�V.oIRiVV.oPU|_eOPQPUl�"_^c�RTY^cd\!NPcdU'Q�V.\QPU'cd_egpOIRiV.U�\TV.oPU�[_eOWhiRi[._bRTO~V.c}_eO�V.oP_ec}`'\pO~V.Ul�BV'¡0NPOPM:\T[dV.NPOIRiV.U'Yyf�V.oPU�[.UaQP\AU'cOP\TVcdU'U'S Vd\�]3U�R�cqVXRTOPQIRi[.QOP\TVXRiV._e\pO0ta¶}\°nmU�h~U�[�U�h~U'O�V.oP_ec�_ec�OP\TV�U'OP\pNPgpo0�Icd_eOP`'U�`'\pOPU�cF\Jh~U�[FU�Y^Y^_yZPV._^``'NB[qh~U'cFoIR@h~U�_eOPQPUl��\pOPUT�Pf~U�VM:\T[.S�RTO�NPO~] \pNPOPQPU'Q�M�RTS&_eYef�\pM5�3RTOP\|cdNB[.M�RT`'U�c'�3cd_eS�ZIYef�hiRi[dfs_^OPg�V.oPU�QPU'gT[dU'U�RTcv] U'M:\T[dUTt

² OPUkOIRiV.NB[XRTY�`'YbRTcdc�\pM0cd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eV._eU'c$Vd\�nr\T[d��nF_yV.o�Ri[.U��TR@nvRTS�RiVXRwY^\pg�VdU�[.S&_eOIRTYEcq_^OPgpNPYbRi[d_eV._eU'c't�u�oPUlfM:\T[.S R&Y^Ri[.gpU�`'Y^RTcdck\pM§cd_eOPgpNPYbRi[._yV._^U'c�nFoP_e`³o�Ri[.U�`'Y^\pcdU�Q�NPOPQPUl[�S&RTOWf�cqVXRTOPQIRi[.Q�gpU'\pS�U�Vd[._e`�\TZ Ul[XRiV._^\pOPc�¡M:\T[�Ul�IRTS|ZIY^U&V.oPU��IOP_eVdU!´ANP\TV._^U�OWV�\T[�NPOB[XRTS&_y�IU'QG`'\°h~Ul[|\pM�RTO~f��TR@nvRTS�RiVXR�Ye\pg�V.U�[.S&_eOIRTYmcd_eOPgpNPYbRi[._yVµf_^ck�iR@nvRTS�RiVXR�Ye\pg&V.U�[.S�_^OIRTY©tF¬�\T[dU'\°h~Ul[}V.oPU�f�cdU�U'S V.\�] U�V.oPUaY^Ri[.gpU'cqV`�YbRTcdckn�oPU�[.U�\pOPUaS&_egpoWV}U³�BZ U�`�V] \pNPOPQPU�QPOPU'cdc'¡jM:\T[�Ul�PRTS�ZIY^Ua`'\pOPU�c�\Jh~U�[�RTO"U�Y^Y^_yZPV._^`�`'NB[qh~U|Ri[dU�Ye\pg�`'RTOP\pOP_^`@RTYj]INBVwOP\TV�TR@nvRTS�RiV.R�Ye\pgV.U�[dS&_^OIRTY�t���\T[dVdNPOIRiV.U'Yef�Vd\&RT`XoP_^U�h~UwV.oPUwM�RT`�V.\T[._ec.RiV._^\pO�RTY^YeNPQPU'Q�V.\|Ri] \Jh~Uw_eV�_^c�Ul�BZ3U'`�V.U'Q�V.oIRiV�\pOPU�\pOPYefOPU'U'QPc&Vd\�RTY^Y^\Jn{V.oPU�ZP[dU'cdU'OP`'U�\pM}`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTYFcq_^OPgpNPYbRi[d_eV._eU'c|n�oP_^`Xo Ri[.U�RTNBV.\pS&RiV._^`@RTYeYef��iR@nvRTS�RiVXR�Ye\pgV.U�[dS&_^OIRTY�t

�zV_^cwRTY^cq\�OIRiV.NB[.RTY�V.\!U'OPYbRi[.gpUaV.oPU�`@RiVdU'gp\T[df�nrU|Ri[.Uanr\T[d�s_^OPg�_^O"RTOPQ�_eOP`'Y^NPQPU|R&] \pNPOPQIRi[df�QP_yhB_^cq\T[n�_eV.o Mb[XRT`lV._^\pOIRTYk`�\sU�x�`'_^U'O~V.c't�uvoPU'cdU�RiZPZ3U@Ri[�OIRiV.NB[XRTYeYef<n�oPU'O \pOPU�VXRi�~U'c�R�´ANP\TV._^U'O~V�RTOPQ V.oPU�[.U�_ec[XRTS&_y�I`@RiV._e\pO�_^O�`'\AQP_^S&U'OPcq_^\pO�\pOPUa\T[kn�oPU'O�\pOPU�ZERTcdcdU'c}V.\�R�[.U�cd\pY^NBV._e\pO0tk�E\T[}Ul�IRTS|ZIY^U�cdNBZPZ3\pcdU�� _ecV.oPU}`'\pOPU\Jh~U�[�R�[XRiV._e\pOIRTY3OP\T[.S�RTY�`'NB[dh~U\pM8QPU'gT[.U'U �It�u�oPU'O�V.oPU}S&_eOP_^S�RTYI[.U'cq\pY^NBV._e\pO�� _^cr_ecd\pS&\T[dZIoP_e`V.\������PV.oPU�NPOP_e´sNPU ���d� ]INPOPQPY^U�\°h~U�[����Fn�_eVdo�R�cdU'`�V._e\pO�� \pM�cdU�Y^M^� _eOWVdU�[.cdU'`lV._^\pO�����RTOPQ�������� �! �� �_^c�RTS�ZIYeUTt�u�oPU�S&\T[dZIoP_^cqS"�#��$ �<cd_^S|ZIYef�`'\pO~Vd[XRT`�Vdc%��t

&�'�& ��(!)+*-,/.0,213* '54 Uwc.R@f�V.oIRiVvV.oPUwZERT_y[6��798;:��_ecFR=< 1�>@?-A�,2B _^MC7 _ecFR�OP\T[.S�RTY3hiRi[._eU�Vzf!RTOPQ9:�_^c�RD �zQP_ehs_^cd\T[�cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV��FEHGI:�_ec D �µ�vRi[dV._eU�[@t

J

Page 3: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

�µM��w��� � $ 7 _^c�R|S&\T[qZIoP_^cdS{V.oPU < 1�> ?�� < <�� A�� � \pM�:{_ec�QPUl�IOPU'Q�]Af!V.oPUwM:\T[.S�NPYbR

��� G ��� ��� � �FEHGI:���

4 U�c.R@f�VdoIRiV�: _^c�R�� � ����� 1��-*�� A B�� _^M�RTY^Y§\pM�_yV.c�`�\sU�x�`'_^U'O~V.c�Ri[.U�YeU'cdcV.oIRTO�\pOPUT¡j_eM�_eO�RTQPQP_eVd_^\pOV.oPU�`'\sU�x�`'_^U�OWV.c�\pM�:{Ri[.U�RTY^Y Z \pcq_eV._yh~UwV.oPU�O�nrUwc.RJf!V.oIRiV%:{_^c�R�� 1��-*�� A B�� t4 Uvc.R@f�V.oIRiV�V.oPUrZERT_y[ � 798;:�5_ec A���A! �A . A < 1�>�. (!B" @, * A <E_eM$# :�%k_^c§U'S�ZPVzf�RTOPQ�V.oPUvY^\pg}ZINPY^Yy]ERT`.�

_^c�R|cqNB]B� ] \pNPOPQIRi[qf~��M:\T[kRTOWf�]I_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTY0S&\T[qZIoP_^cdS�t

�zV�_ec�_eS�ZP[XRT`�V._e`@RTYrV.\�gp_yh~U�RTYeY�V.oPU�cqVXRTOPQIRi[.Q QPUl�IOP_eV._e\pOPc�RTOPQ?[.U'cdNPYyV.c�\pM}oP_egpoPU�[&QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pOIRTY�gpU³�\pS&U�Vq[df ¡PV.oPUw[.U@RTQPU�[}_ec�[.U�M:U�[d[.U'Q�Vd\�V.oPU�U³�P`'U'YeY^U'O~V}_eOWVd[d\sQPNP`�V._e\pO�\pMv­¨®�&+±5M:\T[FV.oP\pcdU�QPUl�IOP_eV._e\pOPcFnrU�oIR@h~U\pS&_yVdV.U'Q0t 4 Umnr\T[d��\°h~U�[�RTO|RTYegpU�]P[XRT_e`@RTY^Yyf�`�Y^\pcdU'Qa�IU'YeQ�\pME`XoIRi[XRT`lV.U�[._ecqV._^`('�U�[.\Pt 4 UmZP[d\°h~UmV.oPUrM:\pYeY^\JnF_eOPg`'\pO*)½U'`lV.NB[.U�\pM�+vRiVd[qf~U�h �

&�'-, �/. (!1 B0(0 '�1�2�3�46587�9 �;: 2=<-7�3>2@?A2�BDCFEHG�IJ2K763�I�2MLF5"NH<-OQPSR>LT5"OUOVOWR�?YX�5"<�BZC ��798;:� CD[!\DI�3�I0583

�½®0�7 I05"CT9"<-N]2K7JCD<^R*7 �`_� � ��6���FEIGH:� <UC/5"NaX�OW2 _�©¤ ��FE GI: <UCcb85"de5"N]5"3@5fOWR�?g3>2�BDNH<-7�5"O _ 5"7�9�ih 4 � �FEHGH:� <UCgjM5"BD3k<^2�B

<UC : R*[l7$9A2�9mE

L}c�Z3\p_^O~V.U'Q�\pNBV�Ri] \Jh~UT���½®pt � =_^OP`�Y^NPQPU'c§��RTOP\hiRi[._eU�V._^U�c�nF_yV.o�´sNP\TV._eU'O~V�cd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eVd_^U'c'tju�\kZP[.\Jh~U6�µ®pt � l�]Wf�Ra[.U'cqNPYeV�\pM�£w\pY^Y@«Ri[�­¨®p®'± �B_yVFcdNBx�`'U'c�V.\�]3\pNPOPQ�V.oPUV.\TZ�cdU'Y^M^� _^O~V.U�[.cqU'`�V._e\pO�\pM �6���FE GH:�³�BnFoP_e`³o�nrUn�_^Y^Y [dU'M:U�[FVd\&RTc�VdoPU�QPU'gT[dU'U �It�uvoWNPc5�½®pt � mM:\pYeY^\JnFc�Mb[.\pS

&�'on �/. (!1 B0(0 'p1�2�3�46587�9 �;: 2q<�7�3r2r?A2�BZCsEtG�IJ2�7 3�IJ2KB�2q<UC/5gB�2�58Ou7�[lN : 2�Bwv CD[!\DI�3�I0583M<xLqdy2cI05"z{2/5

OWR�?qX�5"<-B � 798;:� d�IJ2�BZ2

�½®0�7 I05"CT9"<-N]2K7JCD<^R*7 �`_� � ��6���FEIGH:� <UC : <W?f5"7�9f7$2�L _�©¤ ��FE GI: <UCcb85"de5"N]5"3@5fOWR�?g3>2�BDNH<-7�5"O _ 5"7�9�ih 4 � �FEHGH:� <UCgjM5"BD3k<^2�B _

|

Page 4: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

3iIJ2�7 ��� v E

² OPU}_^O~V.U�[.U'c½V._^OPg�M:[email protected][dU}\pM=cqS&\s\TV.o��3RTOP\�hiRi[._^UlV._^U'cr_ec�V.oIRiVmVdoPU�f�oIR@h~UkVd[._ehs_bRTYIM:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTY gT[d\pNBZ8tuvoPUwcdRTS&U}_^crVd[.NPU\pM=�3RTOP\�hiRi[._^U�Vd_^U'cmn�_eV.o��iRJnvRTS&RiVXR�Y^\pgaV.U�[dS&_^OIRTY�cd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eV._eU'cm]INBVFRT`�V.NIRTY^Yyf&_eO!V.oP_ec`@RTcdU�R�S&\T[.U�OIRiVdNB[XRTYFRTOPQ S&\T[dU�gpU'OPU�[.RTYF´sNPU�cqV._^\pO<_^c�V.\�`'\pOPcd_^QPUl[�V.oPU�M:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTYkgT[d\pNBZ \pMkV.oPU`'\pS�ZIYeU'S&U'O~Va\pMrV.oPU�cd_eOPgpNPYbRi[�Z3\p_^O~V.c't��µO�gpU'OPU�[XRTY$V.oP_^c�gT[d\pNBZ _ecaYbRi[.gpUl[�]INBV�_eV�_ec�] U'Ye_^U�h~U�Q�VdoIRiVaV.oPUM:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTY=gT[.\pNBZ�\pNPgpo~VkcqVd_^Y^Y0V.\�] Uw�IOP_eV.UTt$¬�\T[.U�gpU'OPUl[XRTY^Yyf�c½V._^YeY=_yVF_ecFU�h~U�O�S&\T[.UwOIRiV.NB[XRTY���RiV�Y^U'RTcqV_^O�VdoPU�`'\pOWVdUl�BVa\pMr\T[q]I_^M:\pY^QPc��jV.\�`'\pOPcd_eQPU�[aV.oPU&\T[d]I_eM:\pY^Q�M:NPOPQIRTS&U�OWVXRTY�gT[.\pNBZGRTOPQ�\T[d]I_^M:\pYeQ�RTY^gpU�]P[XRT_e`M:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTY=gT[.\pNBZ8t

&�'�� ��( )+*-,/.0, 1 * ' � UlV���798;:��] U�R|Y^\pg�ZERT_e[FRTOPQ�Y^UlV�� ] UV.oPU�`�\pS�ZIY^U'S�U'OWV�\pM�VdoPU�cdNBZPZ3\T[dVk\pM�:!tuvoPU 1 B � ,�� 1 < � A < > ( � B A�,����r�-*`� A �( * . A < > B01�� ? ��� ���������� ��798;:�§_ec�]Af&QPU��IOP_eV._e\pO&V.oPU}´sNP\TVd_^U'O~Vr\pM

V.oPU�RTYegpU�]P[XRT_e`&M:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTY�gT[d\pNBZ � ������ ��� \pM�� `'\pOPcd_ecqV._eOPg�\pMvVdoP\pcdU��IOP_eVdU&`'\Jh~U�[.ct� � $ 7 cqNP`³oV.oIRiV�V.oPUwY^\pg|ZINPYeYe]ERT`.� � \pM�:{_^c�U�� U'`lV._eh~UTt�}\Jn cdNBZPZ3\pcdU�M:NB[dV.oPU�[�VdoIRiV ��798;:��_^c�Ye\pg�cdS&\A\TV.o0�mV.oIRiV�_ecF7 _^c�cdS&\A\TV.o RTOPQ V.oPU�cdNBZPZ3\T[dV�\pM

:�oIRTc&OP\T[.S�RTYv`�[.\pcqcd_^OPgpc't ªsNBZPZ3\pcdU�RTY^cq\�V.oIRiV�VdoPU�`'\AU�x&`'_eU'O~V.c&\pM :�oIRJh~U�VdoPU�M:\T[.S � �� t uvoPU'OV.oPU 1 B � ,�� 1 < ���r� *`� A! �( * . A < >�B 1� ? �������� ��798;:�m_^cvV.oPU�´ANP\TV._^U'O~Vk\pM=V.oPU�M:NPOPQIRTS�U'OWV.RTY5gT[.\pNBZ � � ��� \pM�� `'\T[d[dU'cqZ \pOPQP_eOPg�Vd\�V.oP\pcdU&V.\TZ3\pY^\pgp_^`'RTY��wRTY^\p_ec�`'\Jh~U�[.ct� � $ 7 nFoP\pcqU&[XRTS&_e�I`'RiV._^\pO�\Jh~U�[�U@RT`Xo`'\pS�Z3\pOPU'O~V�� \pM-:�QP_ehB_eQPU'c� ��PnFoPUl[.U�V.oPU�`'\sUlx&`'_eU'OWVF\pM! _^O�:�_^c�\pM�V.oPU�M:\T[dS � �� t

�zV�_ec�U@RTc½f"V.\�`³oPU�`X�"V.oIRiV�_eM�V.oPU�ZERT_y[���798;:�k_^c�Ye\pg�cdS&\A\TV.o�RTOPQ#"�_^c�R��IOP_eVdU�gT[.\pNBZ8��VdoPU'O$" _ecR&�IOP_eV.U�´ANP\TV._^U'O~V\pM§V.oPUa\T[d]I_^M:\pYeQ"M:NPOPQIRTS�U'OWV.RTYjgT[.\pNBZ"_e�$"�_ecR�´ANP\TV._^U�OWVw\pM�V.oPU�\T[d]I_^M:\pYeQ�RTY^gpU�]P[XRT_e`M:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTY=gT[.\pNBZ8t

&�'�% �& A! �? < ( ' ªsNBZPZ3\pcdU|VdoIRiV 7 � ����RTOPQ@: �('*) �,+ ��,+.-) tauvoPU'O"_eV_^c}nrU�Y^Yy�©�BOP\JnFO�[.U'cdNPYyVV.oIRiV

V.oPU�\T[d]I_^M:\pYeQ&M:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTYIgT[.\pNBZ�\pM3VdoPU�ZERT_e[ ��798;:��_ec$�IOP_yV.UF_y� '*) �,+ ��,+ � �st§uvoPUFY^RiVdV.U�[$`'\pOPQP_eVd_^\pO_^c�U'´ANP_ehiRTY^U'O~V�Vd\|V.oPU�`'\pOPQP_eV._e\pO�V.oIRiV �6���FEIGH:�v_ecFRTS|ZIY^UTt

� cd_eOPg �½®pt ¤ knrU�Ri[.U�Ri]IYeU&V.\�ZP[.\Jh~U&V.oIRiV�VdoPU�[.U&_ecaR�] \pNPOPQG\pO�V.oPU&S�R+�B_^S�NPS QPU'gT[.U'U�\pM�R��IOP_yV.U`'\Jh~U�[kcq\|V.oIRiVFRiVFYeU@RTcqV�V.oPUw\T[d]I_^M:\pYeQ�RTY^gpU�]P[.RT_^`M:NPOPQIRTS&U'O~VXRTY=gT[.\pNBZ�_^cv�IOP_eVdUTt

/

Page 5: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

&�'���� 1�B 1 <�< A B�� '�1V2�3 ��798;:�f: 2p5 b85"de5"N]5"3@56OWR�?63r2KBDNt<-7$5"O OWR�?gX�5"<�BHCD[!\DI 3�IJ5"3 �6���FE G :� <UC : <W?5"7�9]7$2�LFE

G�IJ2K763�I�2HR*B : <xLsR*O 9p5"O ?A2 : B�5"<^\ LD[�7�9m58N]2�7�3r5"O$?8B�R*[ X R>Lc3iIJ2 X�5"<-B � 798;:� <UC�� 7�<�3r2sE� 7/X�58BD3k<^\�[�O 5"B OW2�3 � : 2q5"7�PgRZX!2�7SCD[ : Cs2�3eR>L 7 d�I�R�Cs2c\DR*NaX�OW2�Nf2�7�3 <UCqR>Lc\ZRs9"<-Nf2�7JCD<^R"7 5"3�OW2�5"CD3�3id(R{E

G�IJ2K763�I�2t5"O ?A2 : B 5"<@\ LD[l7$9m5"N]2�7!3@5"Ou?"B�R"[sX R L � <UC�� 7!<-3r2 E

� [d\T]IY^U'S&c=`'U'O~V.U�[dU'Q�Ri[.\pNPOPQa] \pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cqc�\pMs�3RTOP\khiRi[._^UlV._^U'c5oIRJh~U$[.U'`'U'_yh~U'Qa`'\pOPcd_eQPU�[XRi]IYeUvRiVdV.U'O~V._^\pO0t�}_e�sNPY^_eO�­¦��i±WZP[.\Jh~U'Q��½®pt � 8_eOaQP_^S&U'OPcq_^\pO�Vznr\}RTOPQt+r\T[._ecd\Jh�­ hT±WZP[d\°h~U'Q��½®pt � 8_eO�QP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO�V.oB[.U'UTt��RTQPU�Y­y®�i±�ZP[.\°h~U�Q�V.oPUa]3\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cdc�\pM$cdS�\s\TV.o���RTOP\�hiRi[._eU�V._^U�cknF_yV.o � _^`@Ri[dQ�OWNPSa] U�[w\pOPUTt�L}ckZP[.U�hs_^\pNPcdYyfS&U'O~V._e\pOPU'Q�£�\pYeY@«Ri[@� ¬�_yfWRT\T�TR�RTOPQ�¬�\T[._r­¨®°¯+±�ZP[.\Jh~U'Q�V.oPUa] \pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cqc�\pM�cdS&\A\TV.o���RTOP\�hiRi[._eU�V._^U�c}_^OU�h~U�[qf�QP_^S&U�OPcd_^\pO0t ��U'`'U'O~V.Yef"�rY^U�S&U'OPcRTOPQ��kRTO<­¦�s®'±5ZP[.\°h~U�Q�V.oPU�]3\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cdc�\pM�R�[dU'cqVd[._e`�V.U'Q�`'Y^RTcdc\pM���RTOP\|hiRi[._eU�V._^U�c�n�_eV.o � _e`@Ri[.Q�OWNPSa] U�[F\pOPUTt

¬�\pcqV�ZP[d\s\pM:c�]3U'gp_^O?n�_eV.o?RTO _^QPU@R"VdoIRiV&gp\sU�c�]ERT`.� V.\��3RTOP\Pt �µMFV.oPU�QPU�gT[.U'U�_^c�h~U�[df YbRi[.gpU!V.oPU'O]Wf��F_eU'S�RTOPO��F\A`³o�M:\T[�RTO~f�Z \p_eOWV - ]3U'Y^\pOPgp_eOPg�Vd\�V.oPU�cdS&\A\TV.o�Y^\A`'NPc�nrU�S�R@f��IOPQ R D � QI_ehB_ecd\T[��D �zY^_eOPU@Ri[.Yyf�U'´ANP_ehiRTY^U'O~VFVd\����FE n�_eVdo�h~U�[df�oP_^gpo�S�NPYeVd_eZIY^_e`'_eVzf!RiV - tvu�oPU�´ANPU'cqV._e\pO�_^c�oP\°n V.\�NPcqU�V.oPUUl�B_^cqV.U�OP`'U�\pM�� V.\�\T]PV.RT_^O�R�`'\pO~Vd[XRTQP_^`lV._^\pO0t

­y®°¯+±kRTOPQ ­��i±}NPcdU�[.U'QPNP`lV._^\pO S&\sQPNPYe\ - V.\�ZP[.\AQPNP`'U�`³oIRT_eOPc�\pMw[XRiVd_^\pOIRTYk`'NB[qh~U'c�\pM�cdS&RTY^YFQPU�gT[.U'U`'\pOPOPU'`lV._^OPg�RTO~f�Vznr\|Z3\p_^O~V.c'tmuvoP_^c�U@RTcd_eYef�] \pNPOPQPc�V.oPU�S�NPYyV._eZIYe_^`'_yVµf&\pM���RTOPQ�oPU�OP`'U�V.oPUwQPU'gT[.U'Uit

+r\T[._^cq\°h�­ hT±=NPcdU�c}R�cd_eS&_^Y^Ri[kRi[.gpNPS�U'OWV't � OPM:\T[dV.NPOIRiV.U�Yef~�IQPNPU�V.\�VdoPU�ZP[.U'cdU�OP`'Ua\pMjcd_eOPgpNPYbRi[._yV._^U'c��EV.oP_ec_^c�Ul�sVd[.U'S&U�Yef�QPU'Ye_^`@RiV.U�RTOPQ�_yV�cqU'U'S&c�oIRi[.Q�V.\�gpU'OPU�[XRTYe_^cdUwV.oP_^c�S&U�VdoP\sQ�Vd\�oP_^gpoPUl[FQP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pOPc't

�RTQPU'Y�­y®�i±=NPcdU'c�V.oPU�M�RT`�VFV.oIRiVFV.oB[d\pNPgpo�RTOWf!Z \p_eOWVF\pM�7 V.oPU�[dU�_^cFR|[XRiV._e\pOIRTY=`�NB[dh~U�\pMjYe\°n QPU'gT[.U�UTt�µM�V.oP_ec�`'NB[dh~U!_^O~V.U�[.cdU�`�V.c�� RiV - VdoPU'O<_yV|S�NPcqV�Ye_^U�_^O���t�¶}U�V.oPU'OGZP[.\sQPNP`'U�c&R�`'\°h~Ul[._^OPg�M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pMhiRi[._^U�Vd_^U'c����vn�_eV.o�V.oPU�c.RTS&U�ZP[.\TZ3U�[dVzf~�8OIRTS&U'Yef�_^M$R�[XRiVd_^\pOIRTYj`'NB[qh~U|\pM�Y^\Jn QPU'gT[.U�U|S&U�U�V.c����vV.oPU'O"_^OM�RT`�V�_eV�S�NPcqV�Y^_^Uw_^O����.t§�zVF_ec�U@RTc½f!Vd\|cdU�U�V.oIRiV�V.oP_^c�`@RTOPOP\TV�oIRiZPZ U'O�nFoPU'O�V.oPU � _^`@Ri[dQ�OWNPS�]3U�[k_ec�\pOPUituvoPU�Y^\A`'NPc����m_ec�U'cqcdU'O~V._bRTYeYef�V.oPUwY^\s`�NPc�n�oPU�[.U�VdoPU�QP_yhB_^cq\T[�� oIRTc�V.oPUwc.RTS&UwoP_^gpo�S�NPYyV._eZIYe_^`'_yVµf~t

�rY^U'S&U�OPc�RTOPQ��FRTO ­¦�s®'±�cdoP\Jn VdoIRiV�`'U�[qVXRT_^O�cqoPU@RJh~U�ca\pMmQP_e�3U�[.U'O~V._bRTY�\TZ Ul[XRiV.\T[.c�Ri[.U�cdU�S&_y�©Z \pcd_yV._eh~UTt�}\TV.UrV.oIRiV�V.oPU�`'\pOPQP_eV._e\pO|V.oIRiV ��oIRTc$RiV$Y^U@RTcqV$Rwgp_eh~U'O|S�NPYyV._eZIYe_^`'_yVzfaRiV�RZ3\p_^O~V�_ec$U'´ANP_ehiRTY^U'O~V�V.\�cdRJfs_^OPg

!

Page 6: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

V.oIRiV|RTO~f�QPU�[._yhTRiV._yh~UT��\pMFR�Y^\A`@RTYmQPU��IOP_eOPg�U'´ANIRiV._^\pO0�§\pMF\T[dQPU�[�NBZ<V.\�V.oPU�S�NPYeV._yZIY^_e`'_eVzf�hiRTOP_^cqoPU'c't��V.oPU'O�`'\T[d[.U�cqZ \pOPQPcvV.\|R�´ANP\TV._^U'O~Vv\pM�OPU�g~RiV._eh~U}QPU'gT[dU'U�\pM5cd\pS&U}cdoPU'RTM�\pM=QP_e� Ul[.U'O~V._bRTY8\TZ Ul[XRiV.\T[.cv\pM=oP_^gpoQPU'gT[.U�U�\pO�R�gpU'OPU�[XRTY8`'NB[dh~UwZERTcdcd_eOPg�V.oB[.\pNPgpo - tmuvoP_^c�`'Y^U@Ri[dYef!`'\pO~Vd[XRTQP_^`lV.c�cqU'S&_y�©Z \pcd_yV._ehs_eVzf~t

4 UNPcdUU'O~V._e[dU'Yef�QP_y� U�[.U�OWV�_^QPU'RTc't�uvoPUS�RT_^O�_eQPU@RTcv\pM5\pNB[vZP[.\A\pM5Ri[dUwQPUl[._eh~U'Q!Mb[.\pS�V.oPU 7�� S�U�V.oP\sQ0�n�oP_^`Xo�nvRTc�QPU�h~U�Y^\TZ U�Q�Vd\�ZP[.\Jh~U�V.oPU��r\pOPU�uvoPU'\T[.U'S�t 4 U&S�Ri�~U�NPcqU&\pMrcd\pS&U|\pM�V.oPU&cd\TZIoP_ecqV._e`@RiV.U'Q_^QPU'RTck_^O~Vd[.\AQPNP`'U'Q0�3U�cqZ U'`�_bRTY^Yyf�]Wf�£�R@nvRTS�RiVXRB�I_eO�RTO�RiVdV.U'S|ZPV�V.\�cd\pYeh~U���N*)½_yVXRB¥¦c�`'\pO*)½U'`�V.NB[dUTt�L}OP\TVdoPU�[�~U�f�M:U@RiVdNB[.U|\pM$\pNB[�ZP[d\s\pM�_^cV.\�NPcqU�V.oPU�`'\pOPOPU'`lV.U'QPOPU'cdc�\pM$V.oPU�Y^\A`'NPcw\pM�Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY§cd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eVd_^U'c't�r\pOPOPU'`�V.U'QPOPU�cdc�\pMjVdoPU�Y^\A`'NPck\pM§Y^\pg&`'RTOP\pOP_^`@RTY5cd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eV._eU'cFnvRTc��P[.cqV}\T]IcdUl[dh~U'Q�]Af�ªsoP\T�BNB[.\Jh�_eO�V.oPU`@RTcdU�\pMkcdNB[.M�RT`'U�c't £�\pYeY@«Ri[�ZP[.\°h~U�Q?V.oIRiV�`�\pOPOPU'`�V.U'QPOPU�cdc�oP\pY^QPc&_eO?gpU'OPU�[XRTY�RTc&R"cdY^_e`X� RiZPZIYe_^`@RiV._e\pO?\pM£�RJnvRTS&RiVXR+���_eU'oWnmU'g|hiRTOP_^cdoP_eOPgPt�L}c�cdNP`Xo0�m)½NPcqVkRTc�n�_eV.o!V.oPU�ZP[d\s\pM�\pM��vYeU'S&U'OPc�RTOPQ��kRTO�­¦�s®'± �BnmU�QP\OP\TV$NPcdU�[.U�QPNP`�V._^\pO�S&\sQPNPYe\ - t��µO|ZERi[qV._^`'NPY^Ri[$nmU�gp_yh~U�V.oPUv�P[.cqV�ZP[.\A\pM3\pM3]3\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cdcm\pM3cdS&\s\TVdo���RTOP\hiRi[._^U�Vd_^U'cvnF_yV.oP\pNBV�NPcd_^OPg�[dU'QPNP`�V._e\pO�S&\sQPNPYe\ - t

�µOPcqV.U@RTQ"\pM$ZP[.\AQPNP`'_^OPg�`³oIRT_eOPc�\pM�[XRiV._e\pOIRTY�`'NB[dh~U'c�\pM�Y^\Jn QPU'gT[dU'UT�5nmU�ZP[.\AQPNP`'U�`�\°h~U�[d_^OPg�`XoIRT_eOPc�\pMZ \pcq_eV._yh~U�QP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pOIRTY���RTOP\�hTRi[._eU�V._eU'c � �}\pMrY^\Jn QPU'gT[dU'UTt � OPM:\T[dV.NPOIRiV.U'Yyf�nrU&Ri[.U&NPOIRi]IY^U&Vd\�cdS&\A\TV.oV.oPU'cqUmhTRi[._eU�V._eU'c'�pRTc5\pOPUr`@RTOacdS&\A\TV.o�`XoIRT_^OPc�\pMB[.RiV._^\pOIRTYW`'NB[dh~U'c��pcdU'UmM:\T[�U³�IRTS�ZIYeU}­y®°�+±©�TRTOPQ�V.oPU�cdUr`XoIRT_^OPc\pOPYef|Ul�B_^cqV�_^M V.oPUkQPU�gT[.U'U}_^c$cdNBx&`�_^U'O~V.Yef�YbRi[.gpUit�¬�\T[.U�\°h~U�[m_eVm_ecmM�Ri[rS&\T[dU�ZP[.\T]IYeU'S�RiV._e`�V.\�cdoP\°n QP_e[dU'`�V.YyfV.oIRiVjVdoPUm[.U'Y^UlhTRTO~V§_^O~V.U�[.cqU'`�V._e\pO|OWNPSa] U�[.c§Ri[dUm] \pNPOPQPU'Q0�WQPNPUmV.\}ZP[.\T]IY^U�S&cj\pMIUl�P`�U'cdc§_^O~V.U�[.cqU'`�V._e\pO�n�oP_^`XoQP\�OP\TVaRi[d_^cdU�nFoPU'O�\pOPU|_^O~V.U�[.cdU�`�V.c�R�QP_yhB_^cq\T[aRTOPQ�R�`'NB[qh~UTt ² O�V.oPU�\TV.oPU�[�oIRTOPQ�V.oPU�cdU&cdNB]WhTRi[d_^U�V._eU'cRi[.UkYe\pga`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY3`'U'O~Vd[.U�cr\pM5RiZPZP[d\TZP[._bRiV.UFY^\pgaQP_ehs_^cd\T[dcmRTOPQ!RTcmcdNP`Xo�V.oPU�f&oIR@h~UR�h~U�[df�[._e`³o�gpU'\pS�U�Vd[df~t¬�\T[.U�ZP[dU'`'_^cqU'Yef

&�'�� �/. (!1 B0(0 'p1�2�3 ��798;:�S: 2�5 OWR�?]X�5"<-Bfd IJ2�B�2 7 <UCqX�BZR��s2Z\�3k<-z82SR>LS9"<-N]2K7JCD<^R*7 ��� ®8_%: <UCS5"7

2� 2D\�3i<�z82T9"<-z <-CsR*BT587�9 �6���FEIGH:� <UC : <W?�5"7$9g7$2�LFE

�½®0 � L �� � ��� � 3iIJ2�7f3iIJ2�BZ2 <UCw5cCD[ : z"5"BD<@2�3iPtR>L(3�I�2� Y<�O : 2�BD3�Cs\DIJ2KN]2 R>L 7 CD[!\DIt3�IJ5"3�<xL�� ��� � $ �

<UCt3iIJ2�7$R"BDNg5"OQ<-CF5"3k<^R*7 R>Lt3iIJ2�[�7�<-z82KBZCF5"O0Ls5"Nt<-OQP65"7�9 ����� �3$ 7 <UCt3�I�2�7�5"3k[lB�5"O�N]R*B@XIA<UC�N _

3iIJ2�7 � <UC : <-B 5"3k<^R*7$5"O _ � <-C/5 \ZR*7�3kB 5A\K3i<^R"76N]R*B@XIA<UCDN 5"7�9�3iIJ2 � : B�2DCHR>L�� 58B�2���5"7$Rfz"5"B�<^2�3k<^2DC

5"7�9gCsRgB�5"3i<@R*7�5"OUOQPS\ZR*7!7$2Z\�3>2�9mE�

Page 7: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

� � � L LD[�BD3iIJ2�B �&� �©� � ��� � 3iIJ2�7�3�IJ2 � : BZ2DC/R>L � IJ5"z82/9A2r?"B�2Z2t5"3MNfR�CD3 � � ��� ��� � � E�©¤ � L 4 ���FEHGI:� <UC�je5"BD3k<^2�BMLsR*BcCsR*N]2(XR�CD<-3k<-z82c<-7!3r2@?l2�B 4 5"7�9

��� � � �C � �©� � 4 �����?®0 � ��� � ��3iIJ2�763iIJ2=OWRZ?cX�[�OUO : 5A\Db � R L : <UC/2� 2D\�3i<�z82c<-7 5f7$2�<W?*I : R*[�BZIJR R 9�R>Lc3iIJ2Y?A2K7$2�BD<@\�� : B�2�R>L � E

�ih � L �FEHGI: <UCYb{5"de5"Ng583@5fOWR�?]3>2�BDNH<-7�5"O`R LcOWR�?p98<UCs\�BZ2@X�5"7$\KP]5"3yOW2�5*C�3�g587�9�&� � � ��� � � � � 4 ����� ®0 � ��� � ��

3iIJ2�7 � <-CYCDNg5"OUOV<-7 5f7$2�<W?*I : R*[�BZIJR R 9�R>Lc3iIJ2Y?A2K7$2�BD<@\�� : B�2�R>L � E

L �~U�f�ZERi[dVa\pMmVdoPU�ZP[.\s\pMr\pM �µ®ptQ& }_^c�V.oIRiV�nrU�ZIY^RT`'U�RTY^S�\pcqV�OP\�[dU'cqVd[._e`�V._e\pOPc�\pO�V.oPU�VzfsZ3U&\pMmcd_eOs�gpNPYbRi[d_eV._eU'ck\pM�V.oPUaZERT_e[=� 798;:�ltk�ENB[dV.oPUl[.S&\T[.UT�3U�h~U'O�_^M§\pOPU�nrU�[.UaV.\�c½VXRi[dV}n�_eV.o�R�cdS&\A\TV.o�hiRi[._^U�Vzf 7G�n�_eV.o�U'S�ZPVzf�QP_yhB_ecd\T[�:!�BVdoPU'O�_eOPQPNP`�V._yh~U'Yef�\pOPUOPU'U�QPc�V.\�QPU@RTY�nF_yV.o�V.oPU`@RTcdU\pM�RTO!Ri[d]I_yVd[XRi[df&Y^\pg�ZERT_e['�cd\�nr\T[d�B_eOPg&RiV�V.oP_^c�Y^Ulh~U'Y8\pM�gpU'OPU�[.RTY^_eVzf!_^c�`�[.NP`�_bRTY8V.\�VdoPU�ZP[.\A\pM t

�zV}_^c}OP\TVcq\!oIRi[dQ�Vd\&ZP[.\°h~U��½®pt¦¤ �NPcd_eOPg��µ®ptQ& lt���\T[}U³�IRTS�ZIYeU�_eV_eckU@RTcqf�Vd\!NPcqU��½®ptQ& �Vd\�\T]PVXRT_^O�RTOUl�sZIY^_^`�_eVv] \pNPOPQ�\pO!V.oPU�QPU'gT[dU'U�n�oPU'O�V.oPU � _e`@Ri[.Q�OWNPSa] U�[�_^c�\pOPUTt

&�'�� � 1�B 1 <�< A B�� 'p1�2�3 ��798;:�H: 2H5fb85"dy5"Ng5"3r5pOWR�?f3>2�B�Nt<-7�5"O�OWR�?=X�5"<-BsE � L 7 <UC D�� LF5A\K3rR*B�<k5"O R>L�� <^\�58B 97�[�N : 2�BHR*7$2H5"7�9 � 4 ���FEHGI:� <UCHje5"BD3k<^2�Bt5"7�9�58NaX�OW2 _ 3�IJ2K7�3iIJ2/9A2@?8B�2Z2q<-CT5"3eN]R�CD3

�©� � 4 � � � � 4 ����� ®0 � ��� � �� ��FRTY^cd\!oP\TZ UaV.oIRiV��½®pt � �nF_eY^Y�]3UaV.oPUa�P[.cqV��©RTOPQ"h~Ul[df�cdS�RTYeY/�c½V.U�Z�Vd\°nvRi[dQPc�RTO�U�h~U'O~V.NIRTYjZP[.\A\pM$\pM$R

h~U�[df!_eOWV.Ul[.U'cqV._eOPg&`'\pO*)½U'`lV.NB[.UT�EQPNPU�_eOPQPU�Z U'OPQPU�OWV.Yyf�V.\|L}Y^Ul�BU'U�h�RTOPQ +r\T[._ecd\Jh �

&�'�� � 1 *�� (�� .�� B ( ' �M<��S5"7 <-7�3>2@?A2�B � 5"7�9�5qX!R�CD<�3i<-z{2cB�2�5"O�7�[lN : 2�B�*EG�IJ2K763�I�2MLF5"NH<-OQPSR>LT5"OUO z85"BD<^2K3i<^2�C 7 CD[!\DIS3iI05"3

�½®0 3iIJ2qOWR�?S9"<UCs\�BZ2@X�5"7u\�P�R L 7 <UCT583MOW2�5"CD3�g5"7�9� � ����FE <UCT5"NaX$OW2 _ �

Page 8: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

<UC : R*[l7$9A2�9mE

�µOPQPU'U'Q�]Wf �½®pt � r_eV�cdNBx&`�U'cFV.\�] \pNPOPQ�V.oPU�_^OPQPUl��\pM-�FE�t$�µO�M�RT`lVFS&\T[dU�_ec�Vd[.NPUi¡EV.oPUwZP[.\s\pM5\pM �½®pt¦¤ cdoP\JnFc$V.oIRiV�_eM+�½®pt �_ec$Vd[dNPUF_^O|QP_^S&U�OPcd_^\pO � ��®�V.oPU�O�V.oPUFQPU�gT[.U'Uk\pM-���FE _eO&QP_^S&U�OPcd_^\pO���_^c§] \pNPOPQPU'Q_^O�V.Ul[.S&c}\pM§V.oPU�Y^\pg�QP_^cq`�[.U�ZERTOP`�f~t�u�\�V.oPU�] U�cqVw\pM$Saf��sOP\°n�Y^U�QPgpUT� V.oP_^c_ec}_^O�M�RT`�V}V.oPUa�P[.cqVw`'\pOP`�[dU�V.UU�hs_^QPU'OP`'U�_^O�QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pO ���PM:\T[��½®pt �] Ulf~\pOPQ�V.oIRiV�\pM�V.oPU�U�hB_eQPU'OP`'U�\pM=V.\T[._e`whiRi[._^UlV._^U'c�t

L}Y^U³�PU'U�h�­¨®'±=ZP[d\°h~U'Q �µ®pt r_^O�QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pO�Vznr\�RTOPQ +r\T[._ecd\°h�RTOPQ +r\T[._ecd\°h�­ ¯+±=ZP[d\°h~U'Q �µ®pt rM:\T[FV.\T[._e`hiRi[._^U�Vd_^U'c't$£�R@nvRTS�RiV.R�­ &+±8ZP[.\Jh~U'Q �½®pt mM:\T[k��RTOP\�V.oB[.U'U�M:\pY^QPcFn�_eV.o � _e`@Ri[.Q�OWNPSa] U�[F\pOPU�RTOPQ�V.Ul[.S&_^OIRTYcd_eOPgpNPYbRi[._yV._^U'c�RTOPQ £�\pYeY@«Ri[@�§¬�_efWRT\T�iRB��¬�\T[._vRTOPQ ujRi�TRTgp_}­y®��i±�ZP[d\°h~U'QGV.oIRiV�RTY^Y��3RTOP\�V.oB[.U�U'M:\pY^QPc�nF_yV.o`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY8cd_^OPgpNPY^Ri[._eV._eU'c�Ri[.U}] \pNPOPQPU'Q0t��wU�cqZI_eV.UV.oP_ec6�µ®pt ¤ moIRTc�OP\TV�U�h~U�O�] U�U'O�[.U'cq\pYeh~U'Q�_^O!QP_^S&U'OPcq_^\pOV.oB[.U�UTt �zV�_ec�RTY^cd\�_^O~V.U�[dU'cqV._eOPgGV.\�OP\TV.U�VdoIRiV�[.U'`'U'O~V.Yyf � _eO oIRTc&ZP[.\Jh~U'Q V.oIRiV�\pOPU�`@RTOPOP\TV!QB[.\TZ V.oPU[.U'M:Ul[.U'OP`'U�V.\�V.oPU�Y^\pg�QP_^cd`l[.U�ZERTOP`�f _^O �½®pt �Ulh~U'O _eO V.oPU�`@RTcdU�nFoPU�[dU�\pOPU�[.UlZIYbRT`'U'c�] \pNPOPQPU�Q ]Wf]I_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTYeYef&]3\pNPOPQPU'Q0�3cdU�U�­y®��i±©t

�}\TV.U�VdoIRiVa_^M�R�V.oB[.U'U�M:\pY^Q 7 _ec�NPOP_e[dNPY^U'Q � V.oIRiVa_ec�7 _^ca`'\Jh~U�[.U'Q�]Wf�[XRiV._e\pOIRTY�`'NB[dh~U�c �V.oPU'O0��RTc�R`'\pOPcdU�´sNPU'OP`'Uw\pM8V.oPU¬�¬ � _eO�QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pO�V.oB[.U'UT� 7 _ecv]I_y[XRiV._e\pOIRTY�V.\�Ra¬�\T[._3�P]P[.UcqZERT`'Ui�J���!� �3$ �rt� NP_eV.U�cdNB[dZP[._ecd_^OPgpYyf�_yV�VdNB[.OPcF\pNBV�V.oIRiV�S�RTOWf!��RTOP\|hiRi[._^UlV._^U'c�Ri[.U]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY^Yyf�[._^gp_eQ�_eO�V.oPU�cdU'OPcdUwV.oIRiVV.oPU�[dU�_ec�\pOPYyf�\pOPUv¬�\T[d_B�P]P[.UFcqVq[.NP`�V.NB[.U �§�pNBZ�V.\]I_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTYBU�´sNP_ehiRTY^U�OP`'UTt��F¢$��¢ �F¢ �w�v¢mª����µO�oP_egpoPU�[QP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pOPckVdoPU�U³�P_^c½V.U'OP`'U�\pM§V.oPUa¬�¬ � oIRTcOP\TV}f~U�V}]3U'U'O�U'cqVXRi]IYe_^cdoPU�Q0t��E\T[}V.oP_^ck[.U'RTcd\pO0� nrU�RTQP\TZPVV.oPU�M:\pY^Y^\Jn�_^OPg|RTQ�oP\s`wQPU��IOP_eVd_^\pO�\pM=]I_e[XRiV._e\pOIRTY [._^gp_eQP_eVzf�_^O�V.oPU�gpU�OPU�[XRTY=`@RTcdUTt

&�'�&�� ��(!)+*-,/.0,213* '54 Urn�_^Y^Ysc.RJfaVdoIRiV�RhiRi[._^UlVµf 7�_ec�� , B0A .0, 1 * A < < � B , > ,�� _^MEM:\T[�RTO~f�]I_y[XRiV._^\pOIRTYsS&\sQPU'Y� \pM 7 RTOPQ�RTO~f�Vznr\�`�\°h~U�[d_^OPg�M�RTS�_^Y^_eU'c}\pM�`'NB[dh~U'c � ) \pO �&�0cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV=���FE � ) � �B� V.oPU�O�� � _ecOWNPS&U�[._e`@RTY^Yyf�U'´sNP_yhTRTYeU'OWV�V.\�R|S�NPYeV._yZIY^U\pM����it

�}\TV.UwV.oIRiVFV.oP_eckQPU��IOP_yV._^\pO�QP\AU'c}_^OPQPU'U�Q�_eS�ZIYef�V.oPU�S&\T[.U�NPcqNIRTY�\pOPUT�3RiV}Y^U@RTc½Vk_^O�QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pO�V.oB[.U'Ui�]Wf�R�[.U'cdNPYyVk\pM�+�RiVq[df~U�h"­ ¤i±�t 4 _yV.o�VdoP_^c�c.RT_^Q0� �½®pt & roIRTc�V.oPU�M:\pYeY^\JnF_eOPg|NPOPU³�BZ U�`�V.U'Q�`'\pOPcqU'´sNPU'OP`�U

&�'�&�& � 1�B 1 <�< A B�� 'p1�2�3 � 798;:�g: 2]5SOWR�?tX�5"<�B/d�IJ2�BZ2 7 <UCaX�B�R �s2Z\�3k<-z82]R>Lg9"<�N]2�7JCD<@R*7 � � ®8_ : <-Cg5"7

2� 2D\�3i<�z82T9"<-z <-CsR*BT587�9 �6���FEIGH:� <UC : <W?�5"7$9g7$2�LFE

Page 9: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

� L � � ����� � 3�I�2�7 7 <UCq7$R*3 : <-B�5"3i<@R*7�5"OUOQP]BD<o?"<k9mE

² OPU�nr\pOPQPU�[dcF_^M5V.oPU�[.U�_^c�RTO�U�h~U'O�cqVd[.\pOPgpU�[�[.U'cdNPYyV�VdoIRTO �½®pt^®p®0

&�'�&J,�� 1 *�� (0� .�� B0( ' �M<���5"7�<-7!3r2@?l2�B � EHGVIJ2�7�3iIJ2 Ls5"Nt<-OQPSR>LcOWRZ?cX�5"<�BZC ��798;:� CD[!\DIp3iI05"3

�½®0��FE GI: <UCcb85"de5"N]5"3@5fOWR�?g3>2�BDNH<-7�5"O _

� � ��6���FEIGH:� <UC/5"NaX�OW2 _ 5"7�9�©¤ �7 <UC : <-B 583i<^R"7�5"OUOQP]BD<W?8<k9

<UC : R*[l7$9A2�9mE

�½®pte®°� �ZP[.\°hs_^QPU'c�RTO�\T]WhB_^\pNPcwcqVd[.RiV.U'gTf�V.\�ZP[d\°h~U �½®pt ³t=�}\TVdU�RTYecd\�V.oIRiV �½®pte®°� }_ec�\pOPYyf�\pM�_^O~V.U�[dU'cqVn�oPU'O V.oPU � _^`'Ri[.Q OWNPSa] U�[�_^c�\pOPUit �zV�S�_^gpo~V�RTYecd\ ]3U"_eOWVdU�[.U'cqVd_^OPg<V.\ cqV.NPQBf `'\Jh~U�[._^OPg M�RTS&_^Ye_^U'c!\pMV._egpU�[.c�_^OG\TV.oPU�[�`'\pO~V.Ul�sV.c�U'cqZ U�`'_bRTYeYef�n�oPU'O VdoPU!QPU�gT[.U'U!_^c�OP\TV�OPU'`'U'cdcdRi[._^Yyf�YbRi[.gpUTt��µOPQPU'U'Q VdoPU�[.U�Ri[.US�RTO~f�RTOIRTY^\pgp_eU'c�]3U�VznrU'U'O|V.oPUFgpU'\pS�U�Vd[dfa\pM�`'\Jh~U�[._^OPg�M�RTS&_^Ye_^U'c§\pM�Vd_^gpU�[.c$RTOPQ|VdoPUFgpU'\pS&UlVd[dfa\pM `�\°h~U�[d_^OPgM�RTS&_eY^_^U�c�\pM5[XRiV._^\pOIRTY0`�NB[dh~U'c'�Ecd\pS&U\pM�n�oP_^`Xo�nrU�QB[XR@n�\pNBV�]3U'Y^\Jn�t$��_^OIRTYeYef�_eV�S&_egpoWVv]3U�\pMj_eOWV.Ul[.U'cqV�V.\Vd[df�V.\�`'\pOPOPU�`�V�´sNPU'c½V._^\pOPc�\pMr]3\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cdc�nF_yV.o�V.oPU&ZIoPU�OP\pS&U'OIR�\pMv¬�_e[d[.\T[�cqfBS&S�U�Vd[df~t�u�fsZI_^`'RTY^Yef¬�_e[d[d\T[�c½fBS&S&UlVd[df�RTcqcd\s`'_^RiV.U'c}V.\!\pOPU�S&\sQPNPYe_jcqZERT`'U�\pMm�vRTYbRi]I_¨�©�mRTNPcwRTOP\TV.oPU�[wcdNP`Xo�cqZERT`'Uita¶}\°nrUlh~U�[_^O cd\pS&U�QPU'gpU'OPUl[XRiV.U�`'RTcdU'c�_yV�c½nF_yV.`XoPU'c��vRTYbRi]I_¨�©�mRTNPc|RTOPQ �3RTOP\�hTRi[d_^U�V._eU'c't�¬�\T[.U'\Jh~U�[&S&RTOWf�\pM�V.oPU`'\pOPcqVq[.NP`�V._e\pOPcF\pMj¬�_e[q[.\T[Fc½fBS&S&UlVd[df�_eS�ZIY^_e`'_eV.Yyf&_eOWh~\pYyh~U���RTOP\|hiRi[._^UlV._^U'c�t

�(!.��*. 1 ��# B01 1 �61 ��� &�'on���� u5\!OIR@hB_eg~RiV.U�V.oB[d\pNPgpo�V.oPUaZP[.\A\pM �µ®pt ¤ l� YeU�VNPcNPcdUaV.oPU�Ul�IRTS|ZIY^Ua\pM`'\pOPU'c�\°h~Ul[}Ra[XRiV._^\pOIRTY8OP\T[.S&RTY `'NB[dh~U�\pMjQPU'gT[.U'U6�Et$uvoPUw�P[.c½VkcqV.UlZ�_^cvV.\|ZI_e`.��NBZ�R|`'\Jh~U�[._eOPg�M�RTS&_eYef�\pMV._egpU�[.c'�pcdU�U ) ¤Bt�L}cjZ3\p_^O~V.U'Q�\pNBV$Ri] \Jh~UmV.oP_^c§`'\T[d[dU'cqZ \pOPQPc§V.\}�IOPQP_^OPg�RQP_ehB_ecd\T[ :��wZERTcdcd_eOPgwVdoB[.\pNPgpo - \pMh~U�[df�Y^Ri[.gpUFS�NPYeVd_eZIY^_e`'_eVzf~t�u�oPU�nFoP\pYeU�Z3\p_^O~Vm\pM `'\Jh~U�[._eOPg�M�RTS&_eY^_^U�c�\pM�V._^gpU�[dc'�A_ec$V.oIRiV�nrU�\pOPYef�[.U@RTYeYef�OPU'U'QV.\�`'\pOPcd_eQPU�[wnFoIRiVwoIRiZPZ U�OPc�RiVwR�gpU'OPU�[XRTYjZ3\p_^O~V - \pM 7 ��cqU'U|M:\T[wUl�PRTS�ZIY^U���¤Bt � FRTOPQ"cd\!_^O�ZP[XRT`�V._e`'Un�oPU'O�nmU�OPU�U'Q"V.\!RiZPZIYyf�RTQ*)½NPOP`�V._e\pO"\T[_eOWh~U�[dcd_^\pO�\pM�RTQ*)½NPOP`lV._^\pO0� � ¯st � FRTOPQH� �Bt^®0�nrU�`@RTO�Vd[.U'RiV}V.oPUZERT_e[���798;:�rRTc�V.oP\pNPgpo�_eV�nrU�[dU�Y^\pg|cdS&\s\TVdo0t ��\pNPgpoPYef�cqZ U@Ri�s_^OPg�VdoPU�Y^\A`'NPc � �m_^c�nFoPUl[.U�: �moIRTc�h~U�[qfYbRi[dgpU�S�NPYeVd_eZIY^_e`'_eVzf~t=�½O�V.oP_^c$cdU'OPcdUFR�`'\Jh~U�[._eOPg�M�RTS&_eYefa\pM3Vd_^gpU�[.c ���5_^c�cd\pS&U�n�oIRiV$cd_^S&_eYbRi[�V.\wV.oPUF`�\°h~U�[d_^OPgM�RTS&_eYef�`'\pOPc½Vd[.NP`�V.U�Q�]Af��RTQPU'Y�t

Page 10: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

�µO�V.oPU�`@RTcdU�\pMjR|`�\pOPU�V.oPU�[dU�Ri[.UV.oB[.U'U�\T]Ahs_^\pNPc�`@RTOPQP_^QIRiVdU'c'�

�½®0�uvoPU�M�RTS&_eYef � ��\pMjYe_^OPU'c��In�oPU�[.U : � � ���.t� � !L Z U'OP`'_eY8\pMjoWfAZ U�[qZIYbRTOPU�cqU'`�V._e\pOPc����J�BnFoPU�[dU � � � ���°t�©¤ �uvoPU�M�RTS&_eYef�\pM=Z \p_eOWV.c -�� \pO9�v�Bn�oPU�[.U�� � � : �3G � �Jt

L}c ����� � ���%GG� : �.�BVdoPUnmU'_^gpo~V�\pM5V.oPU}�P[.cqV�M�RTS&_eYef&_ec��%GG��RTOPQ�RTc ����� � � �� ��V.oPUwnmU'_^gpo~V

\pM3V.oPU�cdU'`'\pOPQ�M�RTS&_^Yyf�_^c � �t§uvoPU�V.oP_y[.Q&M�RTS&_eYefaoIRTc�nrU'_egpoWV � �

� � �~V.oPU�oIRi[.S&\pOP_^`�cdNPS \pM3V.oPUv�P[.cqV$Vµnm\Pt

uvoPU}QP_^S&U'OPcq_^\pO�\pM=VdoPUk�P[.cqVvVznr\�M�RTS&_^Ye_^U'cm_ecv\T]Ahs_^\pNPcdYyf&\pOPUwRTOPQ�\pM0V.oPUY^RTcqV(''U�[d\Pt��µO�ZP[XRT`�V._e`'UkV.oPU'OnrU�OPU�h~U�[k`XoP\A\pcdU�V.oPUwcdU'`�\pOPQ�\T[�V.oP_y[.Q�M�RTS�_^Yef!RTcvV.oPU'_y[�nmU'_^gpo~V.ckRi[dU�OP\TV�YbRi[.gpUwU'OP\pNPgpo0t

uvoPU�OPUl�BVc½V.U�Z�_^cFVd\&[.U��IOPU�V.oPUa`'\Jh~U�[._eOPg�M�RTS&_^Yyf � �rcd\�V.oIRiV}_yV}M:\T[.S&cFR�]I_e[XRiV._e\pOIRTY�M�RTS&_eYef~�IcdU'U ) hPt�µO&V.oPUk`@RTcqUk\pM8R�`'\pOPUFV.oP_ecm_^c�RTNBV.\pS�RiV._e`Tt��µO&V.oPUkgpU�OPU�[XRTY3`'RTcdU}_eV�S&U@RTOPc$ZERTcqcd_^OPg�V.\�R�`'\°h~Ul[._^OPgaM�RTS&_eYef\pMjS�R+�B_^S�RTY3QP_^S&U'OPcq_^\pO0tvuvoPU�_^QPU@R|_^c�Vd\�RJh~Ul[XRTgpU�\Jh~U�[}RTYeY5QP_yhB_ecd\T[.c : ��ZERTcdcd_eOPg&V.oB[.\pNPgpo - �EcdU'U���hPt � ltuvoP_^c�_^c�cq\pS&U�n�oIRiV�RTOIRTY^\pgp\pNPc�V.\gT[.\Jn�_^OPg}`XoIRT_^OPc§\pMI[XRiV._^\pOIRTYA`'NB[dh~U'c�t§u�[email protected]�NBZ|cd\pS&U�\pMIVdoPUvnmU'_^gpo~VRTOPQ�nrUwU'OPQ�NBZ�nF_yV.o�R�]I_e[XRiV._e\pOIRTY8M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pM�S�NP`Xo�cdS�RTYeY^U�[vnrU�_^gpo~V@t

uvoPU�VdoP_e[.QGcqV.U�Z _^caV.\�QPU'`l[.U@RTcdU�V.oPU�QPU'gT[.U'U!\pM����.��cdU'U ) ¯st"L}g~RT_eO�_^O�V.oPU�`@RTcdU�\pMFR�`'\pOPU�V.oP_ec�_ecRTNBV.\pS�RiVd_^`Tt��½O�VdoPU�gpU'OPU�[.RTY�`@RTcdU�_eV�S&U@RTOPc�ZERTcqcd_^OPg�V.\�R�]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY§M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pMmS&_^OP_eS�RTY�QP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO0tuvoPU�_^QPU@R&_ec�V.oIRiVF_^MjV.oPU�QPU'gT[.U'U�\pM � �r_^c�h~U�[df�YbRi[.gpUwV.oPU'O�nrU�`@RTO�Ye_^MbVkR|]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY8M�RTS&_^Yyf!Mb[.\pS � ��V.\V.oPU�nFoP\pYeU|hiRi[._^U�Vzf~�=cdU'U�� ¯st ¤ lt|uvoP_^c�_ec�´ANP_eV.U�cd_^S�_^YbRi[V.\!] U'OPQ�RTOPQ"]P[.U@Ri�"M:\T[�`'NB[dh~U�c't�u�oP_ec�U'RiV.c�NBZS&\T[.U\pM�VdoPUwnrU�_^gpo~V}RTOPQ�nrUwU'OPQ�NBZ�nF_yV.o�R�]I_e[XRiV._e\pOIRTY0M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pM�cdS&RTY^Y^Ul[�nmU'_^gpo~VkcqVd_^Y^Y�t

�r\pS�ZERi[._^OPg!V.oPU��P[.c½VaM�RTS&_^Yyf�nF_yV.o�V.oPU�cdU�`'\pOPQ�_eV�]3U'`'\pS&U�c�`'YeU@Ri[.U�[an�oWf�nrU�ZP[dU'M:U�[�V.oPU��P[.c½V@¡�V.oPUQPU'gT[.U�U�\pM�� ��_^cv] \pNPOPQPU�Q�nFoP_eY^cqV�V.oPU�QPU�gT[.U'U�\pM�� �m_ecFRi[d]I_yVd[XRi[._eYef�Y^Ri[.gpUTt

L �~U�f�\T]IcqU�[dhiRiV._^\pO�_^cmVdoIRiVr_^O�V.oPU��RTOP\a`@RTcdU}V.oPU}M�RTS&_eYef|S�NPc½Vr] U}OP\pOs� Vq[._ehs_bRTY���V.oIRiVr_^c � �§_^crOP\TVv\pMQP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pOp''U�[d\ rZP[.\JhB_eQPU'Q�V.oPUnrU'_egpoWV�_^cvgT[.U'RiV.U�[�V.oIRTO�Vznr\P�PcdU�UF�©¤Bt h l¡sV.oP_ec�_ec�R�cd_^S|ZIY^U`'\pOPcdU'´ANPU'OP`'U\pMj`'\pOPOPU�`�V.U'QPOPU'cqc'tvu�oP_ecFM�RT`�VkRTOPQ�V.oPU�M�RT`�VFV.oIRiV�nrU�oIRJh~UwV.\|[.Ul�IOPU�\pNB[k`�\°h~U�[d_^OPg&M�RTS&_eYef�Vzn�_^`'Uw_^c�V.oPU[.U@RTcq\pO�M:\T[�VdoPU�[XRiV.oPUl[FY^Ri[.gpU�OWNPSa] U�[dc�V.oIRiVFRiZPZ U@Ri[F_^O��½®ptQ& lt

�µO�VdoPU��IOIRTY§cqV.UlZ�nrU�nvRTO~VwVd\�`'\pOPOPU�`�V�V.oPU�Y^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.U�ZERTOP`lf"V.\�V.oPU�QPU'gT[.U'U�\pM$VdoPU��P]P[.U�c'�5cqU'U ) �Btu�\�QP\�V.oP_^c�`'\pOPcd_eQPU�[�V.oPU|OIRiV.NB[XRTY�QP_bRTgT[XRTS QPU�V.Ul[.S&_^OPU�Q�]Af�R�`'\Jh~U�[._eOPg�M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pM�V._egpU�[.c��©¤Bt^®pte®0lt|�µO

Å �

Page 11: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

V.oPU�`@RTcdUw\pM�R|`'\pOPUwnrU�gpUlV

��� � � �� �-8

� � � � �

n�oPU�[.UF��_ec�_^cd\pS�\T[dZIoP_^`&V.\ � t�uvoPU��P]P[dU'c�\pM � Ri[dU�_^cd\pS&\T[qZIoP_^`�V.\ � �.t�u�oWNPcaV.oPU&�P]P[.U'c�\pM � Ri[.U\pM§] \pNPOPQPU'Q"QPU'gT[.U'UTt ² O"V.oPUa\TV.oPUl[�oIRTOPQ�_^M§nrUaZI_^`.��Vznr\��P]P[.U'c\pM � � � ��RTOPQ � ��V.oPU�O�V.oPUlf�Ri[.UaOP\TV`'\pOPOPU'`lV.U'Q�]INBVvV.oPU'_y[�_^S�RTgpU'cr_eO�7 Ri[.U`'\pOPOPU'`lV.U'Q0t�L}g~RT_eO�]Af�`'\pOPOPU�`�V.U'QPOPU'cqck_eVvM:\pYeY^\JnFcrV.oIRiVrV.oPUl[.U�_ecR&Y^\pg�`'RTOP\pOP_^`@RTY5`'U'O~Vd[.U�n�oP_^`Xo"`�\pOPOPU'`�V.ckV.oPU�S�t��µO�\pNB[`@RTcdU�VdoP_^ck_ecFV.oPUaUl�B`'U�ZPV._e\pOIRTY�QP_ehs_^cd\T[���\pM ��tL}ckV.oPU�Y^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.U�ZERTOP`lf�\pM � _^c���� ��_yV}M:\pY^Ye\°n�c}V.oIRiV}V.oPUa`'\AU�x&`'_eU'O~V�\pM�{nF_yV.o�[.U'cqZ3U'`�VV.\�: �CG : �_^c�RiV�Y^U@RTc½V}��� �I�BV.oIRiV�_^c'�P]Wf!cqfBS&S�U�Vd[df~�WV.oPU�`�\sU�x�`'_^U'O~Vk\pM� n�_eVdo![.U�cqZ U'`lVFV.\ : ��_ecFRiV�YeU@RTcqV�®�� �Et�� �µOM�RT`�Vr_yVm_ec�Ul�PRT`�V.Yef�®�� ��`'\T[d[dU'cqZ \pOPQP_eOPgaV.\�V.oPUkM�RT`lVmV.oIRiV ����G : ��G�: ��_^c�Ye\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY©t �uvoPUkgpU'OPU�[.RTY`@RTcdUi�En�oPU'O �"_^c�OP\TVkcdS�RTYeY©�B_ec�OP\TV�S�NP`Xo�oIRi[.QPU�[@�EcdU'U � �Bt � ³t

+mf�QPU��IOP_yV._^\pO�\pMPV.oPUrnrU'_egpoWV@�pnrUr`'RTO��IOPQ|R D � QP_ehB_ecd\T[ � ��� �6���FE�GF:�jcdNP`Xo|V.oIRiV�V.oPUr`�\sU�x�`'_^U'O~V\pM�� n�_eV.o�[.U'cqZ3U'`�VwV.\�� _^cwRiVwY^U@RTc½V���� �It �}\Jn�� _^c�R!cdU�`�V._^\pO"\pM � RTOPQ � � ���FE G ��F[.U�cqVd[._e`�V.c}V.\R�Vd[._ehs_bRTYjQP_yhB_ecd\T[w\pO�V.oPU�gpU'OPU�[.RTY§�P]P[dU|\pM � tau�oWNPc���� ������RTOPQ�cd\������ �Et��µO�V.NB[.O"VdoP_^c] \pNPOPQPcV.oPU�QPU'gT[.U'U�\pM �6���FE G :�lt?u�oP_ec&gp_eh~U'c�R"] \pNPOPQ \pO V.oPU�QPU'gT[dU'U�\pM � \pOPYefG_^O V.U�[.S&c|\pMFV.oPU�Ye\pgQP_^cq`�[.U�ZERTOP`�f~tk�µO�gpU'OPU�[.RTY�_^M ��_^cFOP\TVcdS�RTY^Y��3R&cq_^S&_eYbRi[FZP[d\s\pM§RiZPZIY^_eU'c'�0cdU�U�� �Bt h lt�uvoP_^c}`@RTcdUa_ec}cd_^S�_^YbRi[]INBV�S&\T[.UcdNB]PV.YeU�RTc�_^O�gpU'OPU�[XRTY0V.oPUwY^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY0`'U'O~Vd[.U�`�\pOPOPU'`�V._eOPg�� �kRTOPQ�����_eO � OPU'U'Q�OP\TVv] U�RQP_ehs_^cd\T['�PcdU'UF� �Bt ¯ lt�uvoP_^cF_ec�VdoPU�\pOPYyf!ZIY^RT`'U�n�oPU�[.UwV.oPU�Ri[.gpNPS&U'O~VF_ec�OP\TV�U��3U'`�V._yh~UTt

�/. A�*� �T���nr\pNPYeQ�Y^_y�~U�V.\�V.oIRTOB����Y^\T[._eO�L}Sa]P[.\�M:\T[aS&RTOWf"NPcdU'M:NPYr`'\pO~h~U�[.cdRiV._^\pOPc't��nr\pNPY^Q�RTYecd\Y^_y�~U�V.\�V.oIRTOB� � [.\pM:U'cqcd\T[|ªsoP\T�BNB[.\Jh�M:\T[�cd\pS�U&oPU'YeZIM:NPY�`'\pS&S&U'O~V.c't�u�oPU�S�R*)½\T[._yVzf"\pMrV.oP_ec�nr\T[d�"nvRTc`'\pS�ZIYeU�V.U'Q�n�oP_^Y^c½V}hB_^cq_eV._eOPg�u5\T�sf~\ � OP_eh~Ul[.cd_eVzf~t�Fnr\pNPYeQ�Ye_e�~U�V.\�V.oIRTOB� � [.\pM:U'cdcd\T[�£�RJnvRTS&RiVXR�M:\T[�oP_ecUl�sVd[.U'S&U�Yef��s_^OPQ�oP\pcqZI_yVXRTY^_yVµf�QPNB[._^OPg�Saf&cqV.RJf�_eO�u5\T�sf~\Pt§uvoP_^cmZERiZ Ul[�NPcqU'c�VdoPU}`'\pS&S�NBVXRiV._yh~UFQP_bRTgT[.RTSZERT`.�TRTgpUwn�[d_eVdV.U�O�_^O�u ¢�� ]Wf � RTNPY=ujR@fBYe\T[@t

ųÅ

Page 12: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

)����};=K~7 68KW68>|2�H�K~2�� 73;=-82�-89:73;=K�7 CI-0/010CI>

4 Uk[.U�M:U�[�VdoPU[dU@RTQPU�[vV.\�­y®shT±3M:\T[�VdoPUhiRi[._e\pNPcrOP\TV._^\pOPcr\pM=Y^\pgaV.U�[dS&_^OIRTY3RTOPQ�Ye\pga`@RTOP\pOP_^`@RTY�t 4 U�P[dcqV[.U'`'RTY^YEcd\pS&UFNPcqU'M:NPY QPU��IOP_yV._^\pOPcrQPNPUFVd\�£�R@nvRTS�RiV.R�­ �i±�RTOPQ�`'\pYeY^U'`�V�V.\pgpU�V.oPU�[�cd\pS&U��BOP\JnFO&[.U�cdNPYeV.c$V.oIRiVnrUw[.U'´sNP_y[.UwM:\T[FV.oPUZP[.\s\pM�\pM �½®pt � vRTOPQ@�½®ptQ& lt

,3'�& ��(!)�*-,2.0,21 * ' � U�V9��798;:��] U�R�Y^\pg�ZERT_y[@t?L cqNB]AhiRi[._^UlVµf � \pM 7 _ec�`@RTYeY^U'Q R�< 1�> � A�* 1 *-,i� A <� ( * . B0( _eM�_yV}_^c�V.oPU�_^S�RTgpU�\pM$R&QP_yhB_ecd\T[}\pM§Y^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.U�ZERTOP`lf�RiVS&\pcqV '�U�[.\Pt}L < 1 > � A�* 1 *-,�� A < ? < A!� (_^cwR�hTRTYeNIRiV._^\pO�`'\T[d[dU'cqZ \pOPQP_eOPg�V.\�R!QP_yhB_ecd\T[w\pM�Y^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.U�ZERTOP`lf�RiVwS&\pcqVY'�U�[.\Pt�uvoPU�< 1 > � A�* 1 *-,i� A << 1 �A� � �5� � ��798;:�j\pM3V.oPU�ZERT_e[ ��798;:��_^c§V.oPU�NPOP_^\pO&\pM3VdoPUFY^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTYE`�U'OWVq[.U'c't 4 U�n�_^YeYIc.RJf�V.oIRiV�RY^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY `'U�OWVd[dU�_ec ?`� B ( _^MC�FE G : _^cvY^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY0RiVrV.oPUgpU'OPUl[._^`Z \p_eOWVv\pM���t��µM=_^O!RTQPQP_eVd_^\pOV.oPU�[dU�_ec|R�NPOP_e´sNPU!Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTYmZIYbRT`'U�Yefs_^OPg�\°h~Ul[�VdoPU!gpU�OPU�[._^`�Z \p_eOWV�\pM�� nmU�n�_^YeYmc.R@f�V.oIRiV � _ec( &�� (!? .0, 1 * A <zt

� \pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY�`'U�OWVd[dU'c&U'O*)½\Jf?S�RTO~fGcqZ U�`'_bRTYvZP[.\TZ Ul[dV._^U�c't 4 U�`'\pYeY^U'`lV�V.\pgpU�VdoPU�[&cd_¨� \pMkV.oPU�S&\pc½V_^S|Z \T[dVXRTO~V�M:\T[FNPc�t

,3'-, � (� �A '��DjM5"OW\�[�OQ[AC�R>L 1�R�?S\Z5"7$R*7�<@\�5"OV\Z2�7�3kB�2�C�/1V2K3 ��798;:�T: 2/5]OWR�?qX�5"<-BsE�½®0 �ZjeR"7�7$2Z\�3>2�9"7u2DCZC� � L � ��7 ��$ <UCq5tNfR*B^XIl<UCDN d <-3iI�\ZR*7�7u2Z\�3>2�9 � : B�2DC CD[!\DI�3iI05"3 3iIJ2Y<-Ng5�?A2

R>L 2Kz82�BDPH\ZR*N X!R*7$2�7!3 R>L : d <-3�I�7$2@?m5"3k<-z82 \DR 2�� \�<^2�7�3V<UC R>LY\ZRs9"<-Nf2�7JCD<^R"7S5"3VOW2Z5*CD3`3id(R=<-7 587�9�6���FE@G@:� <UC : <W?]5"7�9H7$2iLqR"z82�B 3�I�2�7 3�IJ2Y<-7!3r2�BDCs2Z\�3k<^R*7�R>L �=� � ��798;:� d <-3iI�2�z82�B�P � : B�2Y<UC\ZR*7!7$2Z\�3>2�9mE

� � �=� � ��798;:� <-CT5 � 7�<�3r2q[�7�<^R"7 R>LcOWRZ?S\�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O�\Z2�7�3kB�2DCsE

�©¤ �ZjeR"7�z82 �{<�3iP � � L � <-Ct5pOWR�? \�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O�\Z2�7!3iBZ2�R>L �FE G :#G�)�� �

: ) _ 3�I�2�7 3�IJ2KB�2/<UCt587��qCD[!\DI3iI05"3 � <UCT5fOWR�?S\�587$R*7�<^\Z5"O�\Z2�7�3kB�2HR>L �FE GI: GH� : ) E

� R*d C�[sXmXR�Cs2S3iI05"3T<-7;5A9m9"<-3k<^R*7 : <UC62� 2Z\�3k<-z82 587�9 3iI05"3T3iIJ2�B�2�<UC 5 : R*[l7$9m5"BDP :�� � : CD[!\DI 3iI05"3�FE G :�� <UCSb{5"de5"Ng583@5 OWR�? 3>2�BDNt<�7�5"O��@3�Il<UC 5"OQdy5"P�C I�R*O 9*C=LsR*B 2 �l5"N X�OW2�<xL 7 <UC OWR�? 3r2KBDNt<-7$5"O 587�9

D�� Ls5A\�3>R*BD<k58O �{E�ih G�IJ2T<-7�3>2�BZC 2Z\�3k<^R*7 R>Lc3kdyR]OWR�?p\�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O�\Z2�7�3kB�2DCq<UCT5][�7�<^R"7 R>LcOWR�?�\�5"7$R"7�<^\�5"O�\D2�7�3kB�2DCFE

Å J

Page 13: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

� ¯ � L - <UC�5SXR*<-7�3gR>L �5� � ��798;:� 3iIJ2�7;3�IJ2KB�26<UC�5 [�7�<��K[!26Nt<-7�<�Ng5"O OWR�? \�5"7$R*7!<^\�5"Oc\Z2�7�3kB�2 �

\ZR*7!3@5"<�7�<-7�? - E� � �� [ XmX!R�C 2 � <UC/5TX�[�B�2/OWR�? \�5"7$R*7!<^\�5"O`\D2�7�3kB�2gR>L ��798;:� 5"7�9 � <UCt5 D � jM5"B�3i<^2KBS9"<-z <UC R*BtR Lq3iIJ2

LsR*B�N�� G �]_ d�IJ2KB�2�� <UC�5"N X�OW2g5"7�9 � <UC�2� 2D\�3i<�z82sE � L � <UCT7$R*3 \ZR*7�3r5"<-7$2Z9f<-7 3iIJ2/CD[sXAX!R*BD3

R>L �]_ 3iIJ2�7�LsR*BH5"OUO �CD[ � \K<^2�7�3kOQP]CDNg5"OUO _ 3iIJ2�BZ2H2 �{<-CD3�CH5 D � 9"<-z�<UCsR*B � � ��� � _ CD[!\DI�3iI05"3 � <UC

5"7 2 �{3iBZ2�Ng5"O�OWR�?S\�587$R*7�<^\Z5"OV\Z2�7�3kB�2tR L ��798;:#� � : � : �/ G � D_ d�IJ2KB�2 � 5ZXmX�BZRs5A\DI�2DC 2�BZR]5*Cg5ZXAX�B�Rs5l\DIJ2DC 2KB�R{E� B�R R>LsE �µ®0�M:\pY^Y^\Jn�cr_^S&S&U�QP_bRiV.U'Yyf�Mb[d\pS �½®�&st h $\pM$­¨®shT± t�� � �M:\pY^Ye\°n�cm]Wf&VXRi�B_eOPg�Ra[dU'cd\pY^NBVd_^\pO!\pM8VdoPUZERT_y[��798;:�§RTOPQ|\T]IcdU�[dhs_^OPg�VdoIRiV �=� � ��798;:��_ec�VdoPU�_eS�RTgpUv\pM3V.oPU�Ul�P`'UlZPV._^\pOIRTYIQP_ehs_^cd\T[dc$\pM�Y^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.UlZERTOP`�fY^U�cdc�V.oIRTO \T[�U'´sNIRTYV.\ '�U�[.\Pt"�}\TV.U"VdoIRiV�V.oPU"`'\pOWh~U³� Y^_eOPU@Ri[�`�\pS�]I_eOIRiV._^\pO \pMaQP_ehs_^cd\T[.c!nFoP_e`Xo�Ri[.U�iRJnvRTS&RiVXR�Ye\pg|V.Ul[.S&_^OIRTY=RiV�V.oPU�gpU�OPU�[._^`�Z \p_^O~V�\pM � _^cv�TR@nvRTS�RiV.R|Y^\pg�V.U�[.S�_^OIRTY8RiV�V.oPU�gpU'OPU�[d_^`�Z3\p_^O~V\pM���t§L}c ' : ) _^c�R�`'\pO~h~Ul��Y^_^OPU'Ri[�`�\pS�]I_eOIRiV._^\pO�\pM8V.oPUwQP_ehB_ecd\T[.c �!: ) �C�©¤ mM:\pY^Y^\Jn�c't��ih m_^c �½®pt ¯ �\pMr­ �i±RTOPQ � ¯ m_ec�_eS&S&U'QP_^RiV.U}Mb[.\pS �ih lt�� � r_^c�\T]IcdU�[dh~U'Q�_^O�­�i± t��

�µO�R�[.U'`'U'O~VFZP[dU�ZP[._^O~Vk\pM5L}Sa]P[.\�­ �+±8_eV�_^cvZP[.\Jh~U'Q�V.oIRiV � �st �st h mRTOPQ � �st �st ¯ �oP\pY^Q0�IU�h~U�O�nF_yV.oP\pNBV�V.oPUNPOPOIRiV.NB[XRTY=o~fsZ \TVdoPU'cd_^c�\pO�V.oPU�Ul�P_ecqV.U'OP`�U�\pM�: �©t

)� �2��5CI109:- � H�;=Dk9:K~9:CI>�25H�/09��jCI10>

n '�& ��( )+*-,/.0, 1 * ' � U�V9��798;:��]3U�R"Ye\pg"ZERT_y[@�$n�oPU�[.U�7 _^c�ZP[.\")½U'`�V._yh~UTt 4 U�c.R@f�V.oIRiV|ZERT_y[.c�\pM�V.oPUM:\T[.S � : � 8 � � �M:\T[.S R � 1���( B , * > � A! @, < � 1 � .0, >�( B � 1 �c�-,� �( * � , 1 * � A�*`� ��( , >. . � �(!A � � B (��A > A�, * � . � _^M

�½®0�uvoPU�[.Ua_eckR�ZP[.\")½U'`�Vd_eh~U�S&\T[qZIoP_^cdS � ��� � $ ��\pM§OP\T[.S�RTY0ZP[.\")½U'`�Vd_eh~U�hiRi[._^UlV._^U'ckRTOPQ�RTO�\TZ U'OcdNB]IcqU�V ��\pM � cdNP`Xo�VdoIRiV�V.oPUw�P]P[.U�\pMV��\Jh~U�[ � � � _ec�� �Xt

� � �uvoPU�[.U�_eckR�S&\T[dZIoP_^cqS�\pM � Vd\|V.oPU�¶}_eYe]3U�[dV�cd`XoPU'S&U�\pM�7 cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV ��_ec�V.oPU�OP\T[.S�RTY^_ec.RiV._e\pO\pM5_eV.c�_^S�RTgpUwRTOPQ � _^c�\T]PVXRT_^OPU�Q�]Wf�VXRi�s_^OPg�V.oPUwOP\T[.S�RTY^_ec.RiV._e\pO�\pM=V.oPU�NPOP_yh~U�[.c.RTY8M�RTS&_eYef~t

�©¤ ��µM �w�u� �3$ 7 _ec�V.oPU�OIRiVdNB[XRTY�S�\T[dZIoP_^cdS V.oPU'O � � � � �_ec&R�ZINB[.U�Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY�`'U'O~Vd[.U�\pM�FE GI: GI: �.t

Å |

Page 14: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

�ih p�"_^cFQP\pS�_^OIRTO~V@t� ¯ p�"_^c��IOP_yV.UTt� � � � ��� : �.�Pn�oPU�[.U : ��_ecFU��3U'`�V._yh~U�RTOPQ � _^cFR D �µ�vRi[dV._eU�[�QP_yhB_ecd\T[@t�^& �V.oPUwQP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO�\pM����$_^c � t4 UnF_eY^Y0c.R@f�V.oIRiV�V.oPU�M�RTS&_eYef�_ecFR�� , B0A .0, 1 * A < � A! @, < � 1 ��.0, >�( B ��_eM

� � p�w��� � $ 7 _^c�]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY©t

�ENB[dV.oPU�[�_^M

� � � � � ����� � �

V.oPU'O�nrU�n�_^YeY0c.RJf�V.oIRiV � : � 8 ��� rM:\T[.S&c�R � 1���( B ,�* > � A @, < �H1 �%.0, >�( B � 1 � < A B >�(6��( ,2>�. . t��_^OIRTYeYef�_eM

�½®�� ��� � � � �

RTOPQ�V.oPUM�RTS&_^Yyf�_ecm]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY�VdoPU'O!nmUknF_eY^Y3cdRJf&VdoIRiV � : � 8 � � $M:\T[.S&cvR/� ,2B0A .0,21 * A < � A! @, < � 1 � .0, >�( B �1 � < A�B0>�(���( , >. . t

uvoPU�M:\pYeY^\JnF_eOPg�`'\pS&S�NBVXRiVd_eh~U}QP_bRTgT[.RTS _ec�Z3U�[.oIRiZIc�nr\T[dV.o�R�`'\pNBZIY^U�\pM5nr\T[dQPc'�

�©¤Bte®pt^®0

��� � � �� 7 �

� � � �

�}\TV.U�V.oIRiV`�������W� � � � $ � � � � 5_ec5�IOP_eVdUrRTOPQ�]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY©t 4 U�n�_^YeYA\pMbV.U�O�Ri]INPcdUrOP\TVXRiV._e\pOaRTOPQa_^QPU'O~V._eMbf���rn�_eV.o�_yV.ck_eS�RTgpUTtF�vYeU@Ri[.Yef@�©¤Bt^®pt � �S�R@f!] U�[.U�n�[._yVdV.U'O�RTc : ����� �� ��tF�µO�ZERi[dV._e`'NPYbRi[kVdoPU�nrU'_^gpo~V\pMR�cdNPS \pM$QP_yhB_^cq\T[.c_^c}V.oPU�oIRi[.S&\pOP_e`acdNPS � V.oIRiV_^c}V.oPU�[.U'`�_eZP[.\A`@RTY�\pM�VdoPU�cqNPS%\pM§V.oPU�[.U'`'_yZP[.\s`'RTY^c k\pMV.oPUanrU'_egpoWVdc't�uvoPUanFoP\pYeU�Z \p_eOWVw\pM��©¤Bt^®0�_^c}V.oIRiV`'\Jh~U�[._eOPg!M�RTS�_^Yef�\pM�Vd_^gpU�[.c}U�O*)½\°f�cd\pS�U�h~U�[df�cqZ3U'`'_^RTY

Å /

Page 15: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

ZP[.\TZ3U�[dV._eU'c't 4 oPU'O�nrU�RiZPZIYyf@��¤Bt^®0l�InrU�n�_^YeY�RTYynvRJfsc�VXRi�~U � � �6���FE GI:�³t�L}c�V.oPUagpU'OPU�[XRTY5`@RTcdU�_ecOP\�oIRi[dQPU�[}RTOPQ�n�_eVdo�R�hs_^U�n Vd\°nvRi[dQPc�\TV.oPUl[FZ \pcqcd_e]IYeU�RiZPZIY^_e`@RiV._e\pOPc'�BnrU�V.Ri�~U � V.\|]3U�Ri[d]I_yVd[XRi[df~t

4 U��P[.cqVacdoP\Jn V.oIRiVa`'\Jh~U�[._eOPg�M�RTS&_^Ye_^U'c�\pM�V._egpU�[.c�Ul�B_^cqV�NPOPQPU�[anrU@Ri�"`'\pOPQP_yV._^\pOPcaRTOPQ�RiV�V.oPU&c.RTS�UV._eS&Ue)½NPcqV._^Mbf!V.oPUwOP\TVXRiV._e\pO�\pM ��¤Bt^®0lt�w_yh~U'O R�V.\TZ \pYe\pgp_^`@RTYvcqZERT`�U 7��rnrU�n�_^YeY�c.R@f?V.oIRiV�R�cdNB]IcdU�V�� _ec�`'\pNPO~VXRi]IYef QPU�OPcdU�_^M�� _ec&OP\TV

`'\pO~VXRT_^OPU�Q�_eO!V.oPU}NPOP_e\pO�\pM=`'\pNPO~VXRi]IYef&S�RTOWf&`'Y^\pcdU�Q�cdNB]IcqU�V.c�\pMC7�t+�}\TV.UkV.oIRiVv_eM0nrUQPU'`'\pS�Z3\pcdUwRTc��R|`�\pNPOWVXRi]IYeU�NPOP_e\pO

� � ������

� �

V.oPU'O�RiVFYeU@RTcqV�\pOPU�� � _^c�`'\pNPOWV.Ri]IYef�QPU'OPcdUTt

n '-, � (0 �A '�1�2�3 ��798;:�6: 2�5 OWR�?SX�5"<-B _ d�IJ2�BZ2 7 <UC/X�BZR��s2Z\K3i<-z{2 5"7�9 OW2�3 � : 2 5 : <W? D � jM5"B�3i<^2KB9"<-z�<UCsR*BsE 1V2�3 � 5�X!R*CD<-3k<-z82gB�5"3k<^R*7�5"OM7�[�N : 2�BsE61V2�3 � : 2p5 \ZR*[�7�3r5 : OQP 9l2�7JCs2]CD[ : Cs2�3=R>L 7 E � [ XmX!R*Cs2

3iI05"3VLsR*Bf2Kz82�BDPtX!R*<�7�3 - � � dy2�Ng58P��M7�9�5tX!5"<-B � : � 8 � �! C�[�\DI 3�I0583 - � � � 5"7�9 � � <UCg5tX�[�B�2]OWR�?

\�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O�\Z2�7�3kB�2tR L �FEHGH: GI: � d�I�2�B�2 : � ��� � � � � LsR"BYCsR*Nf2 � � � � EG�IJ2K76dy2=N]5"P�� 7�9S5S\ZR*z{2�BD<-70? LF5"Nt<-OQP�R Lc3i<o?A2�BZCtR>Lcdy2�<o?*IA3 � N]2�5*CD[�B�2Z9p5 ?m58<-7JCD3 � _ 3>R�?A2�3iIJ2�Bqd <-3iI

5S\DR*[l7!3@5 : OQP�9l2�7JCs2cC�[ : C 2�3 R L � C�[�\DI�3�IJ5"3�LsR*BT58OUO - � _�� � <UC/5 � : BZ2HR>L � E

� B�R R>LsE L}c ��_^c�]I_egP�j_eVa_ec�\pMmV.oPU&M:\T[dS � G � n�oPU�[.U � _^c�RTS�ZIY^U�RTOPQ � _^c�Ul� U'`�Vd_eh~UTt�+rfH� �st �st � l�Z \pcqcd_e]IYyf|ZERTcdcq_^OPg�V.\aR�cdNB]IcdU�Vv\pM��|�AnrUFS�RJf�RTcqcdNPS&UFV.oIRiV � ��_ecrRTO&Ul�B`'U�ZPV._e\pOIRTY�Ye\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY�`'U�OWVd[dUTtL}QPQP_^OPg|\pO�R|S�NPYyV._eZIYeUw\pM!��nrU�S�RJf!RTcqcdNPS&UV.oIRiV � � � ��t

4 U�S�R@f��IOPQ�RTO�_^O~V.U'gpU�[ cd\�V.oIRiV � � � _^c�_^O~V.U'gT[XRTY�t|¬�\T[.U�\°h~U�[�M:\T[�U@RT`Xo - � �{V.oPUl[.U�_ec�RTO_^O~V.U'gpUl[ �acdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV� �!: _ec�Y^_eOPU@Ri[.Yyf�U'´ANP_ehiRTY^U'O~V�Vd\ � � � ��t§¶}U'OP`'UFNPcd_^OPg�V.oPUF\T]IcdU�[dhiRiV._^\pO�Ri]3\°h~Ui�nrUmS&RJf�RTcdcdNPS&U$V.oPU�[.Ur_ec�RF`'\pNPO~VXRi]IYef�QPU'OPcdUvcdNB]IcdUlV \pM�� cdNP`XoaV.oIRiV�M:\T[�RTY^Y - � � �:�� � � � � � �¦t� U�V�� ] UaV.oPU�`'Ye\pcdNB[.U�_^OPcd_eQPU�VdoP_^cY^_eOPU@Ri[wcqfBcqVdU'S \pM�VdoPU�Z3\p_^O~V.c`'\T[d[.U'c½Z \pOPQP_^OPg!V.\ �:���M:\T[ - _eO t�FUlZIYbRT`'U�� ]Wf"RTO�_e[q[.U'QPNP`'_y]IY^U�`'\pS�Z \pOPU�OWVV.oIRiVw`'\pO~VXRT_^OPc�R�`'\pNPOWV.Ri]IYef�QPU'OPcdU|cdU�V�\pM�Z3\p_^O~V.c _eO 7RTOPQ�Y^U�V � �� �3$ � ]3U&V.oPU�NPOP_eh~Ul[.c.RTYmM�RTS&_eYef~t � _e`X��R�Y^\pg�[.U�cd\pY^NBV._e\pO�\pMrV.oPU�gpU'OPU�[._e`&�P]P[.U�\pMrV.oPUNPOP_eh~Ul[.c.RTY�M�RTS�_^Yef�RTOPQ�U³�BV.U'OPQ�VdoP_^c�V.\�RTO�U'Sa] U'QPQPU�Q�[dU'cd\pY^NBVd_^\pO�\Jh~U�[aRTO�\TZ3U'O�cdNB]IcdU�V ��\pM ��t�+rf

Å !

Page 16: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

RTcdcdNPS|ZPV._^\pO�V.oPUl[.Ua_^c}R&NPOP_e´sNPUaUl�B`'U�ZPV._e\pOIRTY�QP_yhB_^cq\T[}\pM�Y^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.U�ZERTOP`lf ''U�[.\�\Jh~U�[kV.oPUagpU�OPU�[._^`�Z3\p_^O~V`'\T[d[dU'cqZ \pOPQP_eOPg�V.\�V.oPU�Ye\pg|`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY8`'U'O~Vd[.U'c � �P�IM:\T[ - � t

uvoANPc�Z \pcdcd_y]IYef!VXRi�B_eOPg�R��IOP_eV.Uw`'\Jh~U�[k\pM � RTOPQ�ZERTcdcd_eOPg&V.\&RTO�\TZ U'O�cdNB]IcqU�Vk\pM ��nrU�S&RJf!RTcdcqNPS&UV.oIRiVaV.oPUl[.U�_^c�R�S&\T[dZIoP_^cqS � �$� �3$ � nFoP\pcqU��P]P[dU�� �w\Jh~U�[ � � ��_^c�R�Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTYr`'U'O~Vd[.U!\pM�FE G : G : �.t � \pcdcq_e]IYef�ZERTcdcd_^OPg�V.\!RTO�\TZ U'O�cdNB]IcdUlV�\pM � nrU�S�R@f�RTcqcdNPS&UaV.oIRiV � _^c��ERiV'�0cd\�V.oIRiV� S�RiZIcmV.\aV.oPU¶}_eYe] Ul[dVrcd`XoPU'S&Uit ��U�ZIYbRT`'_eOPg � ]Wf&V.oPUOP\T[.S�RTYe_^c.RiV._e\pO&\pM8V.oPU`'Y^\pcdNB[dUw\pM0V.oPU_eS�RTgpUk\pM��_^O�V.oPU�¶}_^Yy] U�[dV�cd`XoPU'S�UaRTOPQ � ]Wf!V.oPU�OP\T[.S&RTY^_^cdRiV._^\pO�\pM�V.oPUwZINPY^Yy]ERT`X�!\pM�VdoPU�NPOP_eh~Ul[.c.RTY=M�RTS&_^Yyf�nrUS�R@f�RTcdcqNPS&U�V.oIRiV=�©¤Bte®pt^®��z� �oP\pY^Q0tw�rNBVdV._eOPg�]Wf�o~fsZ3U�[dZIYbRTOPU�cw_eO � nrUaS&RJf�RTcdcdNPS&U�V.oIRiV � _eck�IOP_eV.UituvoPU�[.U'cqNPYeV�_^cFOP\Jn�`'YeU@Ri[@t �

4 UnF_eY^Y0NPcdU �©¤Bt � �[.UlZ [email protected]�QPYef~�I\pMbV.U'O�n�_eVdoP\pNBVF`'\pS�S&U'O~V@t

n 'on � (0 �A 'S1V2K3 � 798;:� : 265 OWR�?SX!5"<-B _ d�I�2�B�2 7 <UC 5SX�B�R �s2Z\�3k<-z82pz"58BD<^2�3kP R>L 98<-N]2�7JC�<^R*7 � 587�9

CD[ XmX!R�C 2 3iI05"3 � <UC : <W?]5"7$9/7$2iLFE(1V2�3 � : 2q5 X!R�CD<�3i<-z{2 B�5"3i<@R*7�5"O�7�[�N : 2�Bq5"7$9tOW2K3 - 5"7�9�� : 2Y3kdyRaX!R*<-7�3iCR>L 7 \ZR*7�3r5"<-7u2�9 <�7 3iIJ2fCDN]R�R*3�I OWR \K[AC R>L 7 : [�3c7$R*3t\ZR*7�3r5"<-7u2�9 <�7 5 \ZR"NaX!R*7$2K7�3TR>L : R>Lf7$2r?m5"3k<-z82

\ZR 2 � \�<@2�7�3rE(1V2�3 � : 2=3iIJ2/9A2@?8B�2Z2tR L � E

�½®0 � L � � � � �C � 3�IJ2K76dy2cNg5"P � 7�9p5"7 2� 2Z\K3i<-z{2T9"<-z <UC R*B � ��� � � � C�[�\DI�3iI05"3 �=� � ��798;: G � \ZR*7!3@5"<�7JC - E

� � � L � � � �%�C � 3iIJ2�7�d(2=Ng5"P�� 7$9�5S\ZR"z82�BD<�7�? LF5"Nt<�OQPpR Lq3k<W?A2�BDCTR>Lcdy2�<o?*IA3 � E�©¤ � L � � � � � ��� � 3�IJ2K7�dy2qN]5"P�� 7�9�5�\ZR*z82KBD<-7�? Ls5"Nt<-OQPSR>Lc3k<W?A2KBZC/R>LqO 5"B^?A2Tdy2�<W?"IA3@E

� R*d 5"CZCD[�N]2MLD[�BD3iIJ2�Bq3�IJ5"3 : <UCt2� 2Z\�3k<-z82t5"7�9g3iI05"3 �6���FEIGH:#G �� <UC : <W?p5"7�9g7$2iLFE

�ih � L � � �©� �C � 3iIJ2�7 3iIJ2�B�2/<UCH5"7 2� 2Z\�3k<-z82�9"<-z�<UCsR*B � � � � 587�9 5�\DIJ5"<-7 � � 8 � � 8s�s�s�;8 � � R>LTOWR�?

\�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O!\D2�7�3kB�2DC R>L �FE�G�:�G � CD[�\�IH3�IJ5"3 - � � � _ � � � � 5"7�9 � )�� � ) � ����� _ LsR*B � � � ��® E� B�R R>LsE �µ®0�_^c�nrU'YeYE�sOP\°n�O0�scdU�UkM:\T[rUl�PRTS�ZIY^U6�^&st^®0�\pM�­y®��i±EM:\T[vRwZP[.\s\pM t�� � �M:\pY^Ye\°n�cmMb[.\pS �½®0$RTOPQ ��¤Bt � lt�©¤ rM:\pY^Ye\°n�c�Mb[d\pS �©� lt+mfI�µ®0wnrU&S�R@f��IOPQ<R�QP_yhB_^cq\T[ � ����� � �p�@� [.U�cqZ U'`lV._eh~U'Yyf �� �cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV��FE G : G � ��_ec�OP\TV

�iRJnvRTS&RiVXR�Ye\pg�V.U�[dS&_^OIRTY8RiV - � [.U'c½Z U'`�Vd_eh~U'Yyf � lt � U�V � � � � G �� ��� ��tvuvoPU'O9�FEIGI:#G � _^c�OP\TVÅ �

Page 17: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

�iRJnvRTS&RiVXR�Y^\pg�V.U�[.S&_eOIRTY�RiV - RTOPQ � RTOPQ � � �FE G : G � �_ec�]I_^g�RTOPQ�OPU'M t@�ih wOP\Jn�M:\pYeY^\JnFc�Mb[d\pS� �st �st^®0lt��

n '�� � (� �A '�1V2�3 ��798;:�t: 2H5]OWR�?qX�5"<-B _ d�I�2�B�2 7 <UC(X$B�R��s2D\�3i<�z82T5"7�9 : <-Ct2� 2D\�3i<�z82/5"7�9fOW2�3 � : 2H5

D�� je5"BD3k<^2�Bf9"<-z <UC R*BaCD[�\�I�3�I0583 �6���FE G : G#�� <-C : <W?]5"7�9�7$2�LsE(1V2�3 � : � 8 ��� /: 2T5�\ZR"z82�BD<�7�?yLs5"Nt<-OQPpR>L3k<W?A2�BDC/R>Lcdy2K<W?*IA3 � ?"B�2Z5"3r2KBc3iI05"763kdyR{E

G�IJ2K7 � � � E� B�R R>LsE ªsNBZPZ3\pcdU�OP\TV't$uvoPU'O�M:\T[�gpU�OPU�[XRTY - � RTOPQ - �knrUS�R@f��IOPQ9: � RTOPQ : �}cdNP`Xo�VdoIRiV : ) � � � � �n�oPU�[.U -

) _^cRTO�Ul�P`�U�ZPV._^\pOIRTY�Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY�`'U'O~Vd[.U�\pM �FEIG : G : ) RTOPQ � � �stL}c - � RTOPQ - �aRi[.UgpU'OPU�[.RTY _eVrM:\pYeY^\JnFc$V.oIRiV�: �kQP\AU'crOP\TVr`'\pO~VXRT_^O - � t�uvoANPc - � _^cmRTO!U³�P`'U�ZPVd_^\pOIRTY Ye\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY `'U'O~Vd[.U\pM�FE G :#G : � G : ��RTOPQ�oPU'OP`'U �5� � ��798;:#GI: � GI: � �_^ckOP\TVk`'\pOPOPU'`�V.U�Q0t ² O�V.oPUa\TVdoPU�[}oIRTOPQ�RTc��� �s�C�6���FE GI: GI: � GH: � r_^cv]I_^g�RTOPQ�OPU'M t�u�oP_ec�`'\pO~Vd[XRTQP_e`�V.c � �st �ste®0 � \T[�_eOPQPU'U'Q �©¤Bt¦¤Bt h ³t �

)����2��5CI109:- � H�;=Dk9:K~9:CI>�25H�DF;��59:DF;=K�459:DkCI-8>J9:2�-

4 U�OPU�U'Q�RTO�U@RTcqf � U'S&S&R�V.oIRiV�] \pNPOPQPc'� ]3\TV.o�Mb[.\pS�]3U'Y^\Jn�RTOPQ�Ri] \Jh~UT��V.oPU�S�NPYyV._eZIYe_^`'_yVzf�\pM§R&Ye\pg`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY QP_ehs_^cd\T[rRiV�R�cdS&\s\TVdo&Z \p_^O~Vv\pM=R�hTRi[._eU�Vzf~t�¢$h~U'O�V.oP\pNPgpo�nrUwRi[.U}\pOPYyf&_eOWV.Ul[.U'cqV.U�Q�_eO�VdoPU}`@RTcdU\pM�Ul� U'`�Vd_eh~U�QP_yhB_ecd\T[.c'�IM:\T[�V.oPU�ZINB[dZ3\pcdU'ck\pM5_^OPQPNP`�Vd_^\pO�_yV�_ecFUl�sZ U'QP_eU'O~VFV.\|RTY^Ye\°n�OPU'g~RiVd_eh~Uw`'\sU�x�`'_^U�OWV.c�t

�C'�& � (� �A 'S1�2�3 7 : 2 5 CDN]R R*3iITz"5"BD<@2�3iP=R L(9"<-Nf2�7JCD<^R"7 � Ey1V2�3 � : 2w5 7$R"BDNg5"O!\�BZR�CZCD<-70?*Cy9"<-z�<UCsR*B _ OW2�3: : 2 5 : R*[�7�9m58BDPq5"7�9 � 5"7f2 � 2Z\�3k<-z82(98<-z <UCsR"BFE 1�2�3 : 2 5eX�[lBZ2eOWR�?T\�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O0\Z2�7�3kB�2wR>L �FE�G � G : � �R>Lw9"<-Nf2�7JCD<^R"7 � Ey1V2K3�� : 2 3�IJ2 Nt[�OQ3k< X�OQ<^\�<�3iPtR>L : 5"3 3iIJ2e?A2�7$2KBD<^\VX!R*<-7!3`R>L 587�9cOW2�3 ��: 2y3iIJ2 Ng5��{<�Nt[lN\ZR 2 � \�<@2�7�3(R L � E��YCZCD[�N]2T3�I0583 � � ® E

�½®0 � L � <-C/2�NaX�3kPf3iIJ2�7�� �I��� � E� � � � ®�� � E

� B�R R>LsE uvoPUa[.U'cdNPYyV_^c}Ye\s`@RTY�Ri] \pNBV}V.oPU�gpU'OPU�[d_^`�Z \p_eOWV\pM ��0RTOPQ�cd\�nrUaS�R@f�RTcknrU�Y^Y�RTcdcqNPS&U�V.oIRiV 7_^c�Rix&OPUTt!�rNBVdV._eOPg�]Wf�o~fsZ3U�[dZIY^RTOPU'c�_^O 7 nrU�S�R@f"RTcdcdNPS&U�V.oIRiV� _^c�R�Z \p_eOWV - t � UlVT�w�$� �3$ 7QPU'OP\TV.U�VdoPU�]IY^\Jn NBZ�\pM+7 RiV - n�_eVdo�Ul�P`'UlZPV._^\pOIRTYjQP_yhB_ecd\T[ ��tkuvoPU'O�V.oPUaY^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.UlZERTOP`�f�\pM ��nF_yV.o[.U'c½Z U'`�V�V.\��FE GI:�_^c���� � �Pn�oP_^`Xo�_ecFRiV�Y^U@RTc½Va''Ul[.\�RTc��FEHGI:�_^c�Y^\pg|`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY©t�¶}U'OP`'UF�µ®0lt

�

Page 18: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

² O�V.oPU�\TV.oPUl[�oIRTOPQ0�0]Wf�RTcdcdNPS|ZPV._^\pO�V.oPU�[dU|_ecRTO�RTYegpU�]P[XRT_^`�hiRTY^NIRiVd_^\pO���\pM�Y^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.U�ZERTOP`lf '�U�[.\n�_eV.o�[dU'cqZ U�`�VkV.\��FEIGI: � � t���QPU�V.U�[.S�_^OPU'cFR�cdU�[._eU'ck\pM�]IYe\°n�cFNBZIc��3U@RT`Xo�n�_eV.o�`'U'O~Vd[.U��3�EcdNP`Xo�V.oIRiVU�h~U'O~V.NIRTYeYef�V.oPU�`'U�OWVd[dU|\pM���_ecR�QP_ehB_ecd\T[@�0cdU�U�M:\T[wUl�PRTS�ZIY^UF� �st hW¯ �\pMF­y®�&+±©t�ªsNBZPZ \pcdU�V.oIRiV � � ® � ��t4 U�oIRJh~U

��� G � � G � � � � ���FE G ��CG�� �F8

n�oPU�[.U�� � _^crV.oPUcqVd[._e`�VrVd[XRTOPcqM:\T[.S \pM ��RTOPQ��}� ������� � � � �µ® ��� lt�uvoANPcvV.oPUY^\pg�QP_^cd`l[.U�ZERTOP`�f!\pM� nF_yV.o�[.U�cqZ U'`lVkV.\=�FEIG � GI: � � _^c�RiVFYeU@RTcqV

� �½® � � � � � ����� ®0 �½® � � m� �½®�� � D�

¬�\T[.U'\Jh~U�[�VdoPU&`'\sUlx&`'_eU'OWV�\pM � _ecwV.oPU�O�RiV�S&\pc½V �E�!� �� � cqVd_^Y^Y§oIRTc�OP\T[dS�RTY�`�[.\pcdcq_^OPgpc�_eO�R�OPU'_egpos�] \pNB[doP\s\sQ�\pM�V.oPU�gpU�OPU�[._^`�Z \p_^O~Vk\pM5V.oPU�`'U�OWVd[dU�\pM�3��RTOPQ�V.oPU�S�NPYeVd_eZIY^_e`'_eVzf�\pMjVdoPU�cqVd[d_^`�V�Vd[XRTOPcdM:\T[dS \pM:�_ec}RiVS&\pcqV�V.oPU�S�NPYyV._eZIYe_^`'_yVzf�\pM :�tY+rf�_^OPQPNP`�Vd_^\pO�\pO�V.oPUaOANPSa]3U�[\pM�]IY^\Jn NBZIc'�0_yV}M:\pY^Ye\°n�ckV.oIRiV��oIRTcFYe\pg|QP_ecd`�[.UlZERTOP`�f�RiV�Y^U'RTcqV�®�� ���ER�`'\pOWVq[XRTQP_^`�Vd_^\pO0t �

�C'-, � (0 �A 'S1V2K3 ��798;:� : 2Y5=OWR�? X�58<-B _ d�IJ2�BZ2 7 <UC 5=7uR*BDNg58O"X�B�R �s2Z\�3k<-z82 z"5"B�<^2�3kP/587�9=OW2�3 � : 2 5 : <W?

5"7�9]7$2�L=9"<-z�<UCsR*BsE(1V2�3 � : � 8 ��� /: 2T5p\ZR*z82KBD<-7�? Ls5"Nt<-OQPpR>LY3k<W?A2�BDCTR>Lcdy2�<o?*IA3 OW2�CZCc3iI05"7 � 5"7�9�98<-N]2�7JC�<^R*7� E� L � : � 8 ��� <-Ct7$R*3 : <-B 583i<^R"7�5"O�3iIJ2�7 dy2gNg5"P � 7�965 \ZR*z82�B�<-7�?YLF5"NH<-OQP R>Lt3i<o?A2�BZC � � � 8 ���; R>L�dy2�<W?*Il3

��� ����� � 5"7�9�98<-N]2�7JC�<^R*7 � _ d�IJ2�BZ2t2�<-3iIJ2�B�½®0 � � � _ R*B� � � � � 5"7�9 � � � 8 ��� <-CT5 : <�B 5"3k<^R*7�58O8LF5"Nt<-OQPmE

� B�R R>LsE � U�V ��] U�VdoPUaQPU'gT[.U'Ua\pM��§tw+rf�RTcdcdNPS�ZPVd_^\pO � � ®pt � _^`.��RTO�\TZ3U'O�cdNB]IcdU�V � � 7�`'\pOWV.RT_^OPU'Q_^O�V.oPU}cdS�\s\TV.o�Y^\A`'NPcv\pM 7 RTOPQ�V.oPU`'\pS�ZIYeU'S&U'O~Vv\pM=VdoPUwcqNBZPZ \T[dV�\pM : cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiVvM:\T[�RTYeY - � ��VdoPU�[.UUl�B_^cqV � � 8 � �08s�s�s� 8 � Z3\p_^O~V.cF\pM � cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV - � ���m_y� � � �

) � � � ® �s�s� �EtmªsU�V : ) � : � + RTOPQ � ) � � � + t� U�V�" � ' : ) RTOPQ�ZI_e`.����cdNP`Xo"V.oIRiV �FE G : G�� "�_ec}S�R+�P_eS�RTY^Yyf�Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY§RiV - tL}c - _^cRcdS&\A\TV.o�Z \p_^O~V�\pM-7��B]Af �ihPte®0mnmU�oIR@h~U

��� � � � ����� "6 � � �)� ��� : ) r� ���V�

Å

Page 19: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

� U�V � ] UaV.oPUaNPOP_e´sNPU�S&_eOP_^S�RTY8Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTYj`'U�OWVd[dU|\pM+�FE G : G � "�`'\pO~VXRT_eOP_^OPg - twu�oPU�[dU�_ecRTOG\TZ U'OGcdNB]IcdU�V�\pM�� � � � � � � � cdNP`XoGV.oIRiV�RTcanrU�hTRi[df - _eO�V.oP_^c�cdU�V'� � QP\AU'c�OP\TV�`XoIRTOPgpUTtuvoANPc�nrU�S&RJf�RTcqcdNPS&U � � � � � � � � � � t��µM�nrUwoIRJh~UwU'´sNIRTYe_eVzf&V.oPU�O�]Af �©¤Bt � $V.oPU�[.Uw_^c�R|cqS�RTY^YZ Ul[dV.NB[d]ERiV._e\pO � \pM� " cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV � � � 8 ���;vM:\T[.S�cFR�`�\°h~U�[d_^OPg�M�RTS�_^Yef�\pM5nrU'_^gpo~V�� � ����� � ³�In�oP_^`Xo�_ec\T]WhB_^\pNPcqYef�]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY©t

uvoANPc�nrU�S�R@f�RTcdcqNPS&U�V.oIRiV � � � � tM+mf�cqfBS�S&U�Vd[df�RTOPQ � �st �st¦¤ � _^ckR�Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY=`�U'OWVq[.U�\pM�FE�G�� � : � t � _^`.��� � � �|cd\}V.oIRiV � _^c§RFZINB[.UrYe\pg}`@RTOP\pOP_^`@RTYA`'U'O~Vd[.Uv\pM �FE�G�:�G��3: � t��}\Jn hiRi[dfB_eOPg

- � � � _yV}M:\pY^Ye\°n�cFV.oIRiV}V.oPUl[.Ua_^cRTO�_e[q[.U'QPNP`'_y]IY^Ua`'\pS�Z3\pOPU'O~V\pM �=� � ��798;:#G��3: � �V.oIRiV}`'\pO~VXRT_eOPc � �RTcaR�ZP[.\TZ3U�[�cdNB]IcdU�V't +mf � �st �st � l�=nrU�S�R@f�RTcdcqNPS&U�V.oIRiV � � _^c�R�ZP[.\TZ3U�[�cdNB]IcdUlV�\pM�R�Ye\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY`'U'O~Vd[.U � � \pM �5� � ��798;:IG��3: � lt��µVvM:\pYeY^\JnFcm]Wf �©¤Bt � �V.oIRiVrV.oPUl[.U_^cvRacdS�RTYeYEZ3U�[dV.NB[d]ERiVd_^\pO � \pM��3: � �cd\�V.oIRiV�� � � 8 ��� r_^c�R|`�\°h~U�[d_^OPg�M�RTS�_^Yef�\pM=V._^gpUl[.c�\pM5nrU'_^gpo~V ��� ����� � �RTOPQ�gT[[email protected]�[�QP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO0t �

�C'on � (0 �A 'S1V2�3 ��798;:� : 2 5 OWR�?�X!5"<-B _ d�IJ2�BZ2 7 <UCS5 7$R*B�Ng5"OVX�BZR��s2Z\K3i<-z{2fz85"BD<^2K3iPmE 1�2�3 � : 2 5: <W? 587�9�7$2�Lg98<-z <UCsR"BFEg1V2�3 � : � 8 ��� f: 2]5�\ZR*z82KBD<-7�?cLs5"Nt<-OQP�R>Lt3k<W?A2�BDC]R>LtO 5"B^?l2�dy2�<W?"IA3 � 5"7�9 Ng5��{<-N]5"O9"<-Nf2�7JCD<^R"7 � E

G�IJ2K7 2�<-3iIJ2�B

�½®0�� : � 8 ��� <UCT5 : <-B 5"3k<^R*7$5"O8LF5"Nt<�OQPpR Lc3i<o?A2�BZCtR>LcO 5"B@?A2qdy2�<o?*IA3 _ R*B� � 3iIJ2�B�2=<UCT5 : <-B 5"3k<^R*7$5"O"LF5"Nt<-OQP � � �08 ���; R>Lc3k<W?A2KBZC/R>LqO 5"B^?A2Tdy2�<W?"IA3(587�9�CDNg58OUOW2�BH9"<-N]2�7�CD<^R*7�E

� B�R R>LsE +mf�RTcqcdNPS�ZPV._e\pO � � � � ��� � � �m��� � � � t��µM � : � 8 ��� �_ec�R�]I_e[XRiV._e\pOIRTY�M�RTS&_eYef"\pM�Vd_^gpU�[.c��µ®0oP\pY^QPc�RTOPQ�V.oPUl[.U|_ec�OP\TVdoP_^OPg�Vd\�ZP[.\Jh~UTt ² VdoPU�[dn�_^cdU�]AfH�ihPt � �VdoPU�[.U�_ec�R�`'\Jh~U�[._eOPg�M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pM$Vd_^gpU�[.cw\pMnrU'_egpoWV�� ��� � � � �9� � � ®0 �et�uvoPU�QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pO�\pM�V.oP_ec�M�RTS�_^Yef�`'RTOPOP\TV�] U|YbRi[.gpUl[�V.oIRTO � ��\TV.oPU�[qnF_ecdU� � �08 ���;nm\pNPY^Q�] U�R�`'\Jh~U�[._^OPg�M�RTS&_^YyfH� � � 8 ��� \pM�V._egpU�[.c�\pMmY^Ri[.gpU|nmU'_^gpo~V�RTOPQ�gT[.U@RiVdU�[aQP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO0�n�oP_^`Xo&`'\pO~Vd[XRTQP_e`�V.c§V.oPUFS�R+�B_^S�RTYe_eVzf�\pM�� : � 8 ��� lt +mf��ihPt � �V.oPU�\pOPYyf�\TV.oPU�[�Z \pcdcd_y]I_^Ye_eVzf�_^c§V.oIRiV � � � 8 ���;_^c�R�]I_y[XRiV._e\pOIRTY0M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pM5V._egpU�[.c�\pMjYbRi[.gpUnrU'_egpoWVFRTOPQ�cdS&RTY^Y^Ul[�QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pO�RTOPQ!nrU�oIR@h~UF� � ³t �

)���9:1 ;s/09:2�-0;=K� 3;=Dk9:K~9:CI>�25H�Dk9:-89:DF;=K�459:DFCE-8>J9:2�-

4 UaOPU'U�Q�R�M:\T[.S \pM�RTQ*)½NPOP`�V._e\pO�RTOPQ�_^O~h~U�[.cd_e\pO"\pM�RTQ*)½NPOP`�V._e\pO0ta�r\pO*)½U'`�V.NB[.RTY^Yef�V.oPU�[.U�\pNPgpo~VwVd\�]3UÅ �

Page 20: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

R�cqVd[d\pOPg�M:\T[dS \pM�RTQ*)½NPOP`�V._^\pO�M:\T[aV.oPU�OP\T[dS�RTY^_ec.RiV._^\pO�\pM�RTO~f�Ye\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTYm`'U'O~Vd[.UTt � OPM:\T[qV.NPOIRiV.U'Yyf_^O~h~U�[.cq_^\pO�\pM8RTQ*)½NPOP`�V._e\pO�_^c�\pOPYyf|�sOP\°n�O�M:\T[rQP_yhB_^cq\T[.cmRTOPQ�RTQ*)½NPOP`�Vd_^\pO�_^c$\pOPYef��BOP\JnFO�M:\T[rcq\pS&UFcqZ3U'`'_^RTY`'U'O~Vd[.U�c���M:\T[jUl�PRTS�ZIY^U$S&_^OP_eS�RTY/³�°cqU'U­ i±sRTOPQ!­¦�+±©t��E\T[dV.NPOIRiV.U�YefnrUm\pOPYyf�OPU'U�Q|RTQ*)½NPOP`lV._^\pO�RTOPQ�_eOWh~U�[dcd_^\pO\pMmRTQ*)½NPOP`lV._^\pO�_eO"h~U�[df�cqZ3U'`'_^RTY�`'RTcdU'c't 4 U|c½VXRiV.U�\pOPU�M:\T[.S \pMmRTQ*)½NPOP`lV._^\pO�V.\!QP\�n�_eV.o"Y^\pg!`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY`'U'O~Vd[.U�ckoPU�[.UTt�u�oPUw\TV.oPU�[FM:\T[.S `'\pOP`'U�[dOPcF]I_e[XRiVd_^\pOIRTY0M�RTS&_eY^_^U�c'�PcdU'U � �Bt^®0lt

%3'�& � (0 �A 'S1V2�3 �w��� � $ 7 : 2 5cCDN]R R"3�ItN]R"B^XIA<-CDN R>L(CDN]R�R*3�Itz85"BD<^2K3i<^2�CFEM1�2�3 : � : 2 5 D � 9"<-z <UC R*BR*7 7 5"7�9fOW2�3 � � : 2=3iIJ2wX�[lOUO : 5A\DbSR>L : � 3>R � E 1V2�3 � ��: 2H5 : R*[�7�9m58BDP�R*7 �g_ CD[!\DIS3iI05"3(3iIJ2=CD[sXAX!R*BD3� R>L � � 9AR"Nt<-7�5"3>2DC 7 5"7�9 � � � <UCYCDNfR R*3iI0E

G�IJ2K7 ��798;:� <UCTOWR�? \�5"7$R*7!<^\�5"O �@B�2DC@X!2Z\�3k<-z82�OQP]b{5"de5"Ng583@5pOWR�?p3>2�BDNt<�7�5"O _ 2�3>\sE � < � �i� 8 � � � � G � � <UCcOWRZ?S\�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O �@B�2DC@X!2Z\�3k<-z82�OQPHb85"de58Ng5"3r5]OWR�?f3r2�B�Nt<-7�58O _ 2�3>\sE �{E

� B�R R>LsE uvoPUkZP[.\TZ3U�[dVzf&\pM ]3U'_^OPgaYe\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY3_^c$Y^\A`@RTY�_eO&V.oPU}RTOIRTYyfsV._e`�V.\TZ3\pY^\pgTf~t ² O&V.oPUk\TV.oPUl[roIRTOPQ0�Y^\A`@RTY^Yyf!_^O�V.oPU�RTOIRTYefsVd_^`V.\TZ \pYe\pgTf~�� _^ckR�ZP[.\sQPNP`�V 7 ��� 7 �+��n�oPU�[.U67 � _eck_^cq\pS&\T[dZIoP_^`V.\ 7 RTOPQ � �

_^c�V.oPU�ZINPY^Yy]ERT`.��\pM§R&QP_ehs_^cd\T[ : ��n�oP\pcdU�cdNBZPZ3\T[dV_^ckcqS&\s\TV.o0�Ecd\&V.oIRiV � � � ��� 7 � GH7 ��� � �itw+rNBVV.oPUw[.U'cdNPYyVF_ec�U@RTc½f�_eO�V.oP_ec�`@RTcqUT��cqU'U�M:\T[�Ul�IRTS|ZIY^U�� �Bt �s®0m\pMv­¨®J¤i± t��

%3'-, � (0 �A 'S1V2�3 ��798;:�q: 2q5�OWRZ? X�5"<-B d�I�2�B�2 7 <UCMX�B�R �s2Z\�3k<-z82c5"7�9 : <UC=2�Y2Z\�3k<-z82sE � [ XmX!R*Cs2Y3�I0583 �

<UCc5"7 2 ��\Z2rX�3i<@R*7�5"O�OWR�?f\�5"7$R"7�<^\�5"O�\Z2�7!3iBZ2qR>L �FE�G : EHG�I�2�7 3�IJ2KB�2 <UCq5"7 R�X!2�7�CD[ : Cs2�3 � R>L 3�I�2 C�N]R R*3iI

OWR \�[lCtR L � d <-3iIp3iIJ2ML R*OUOWR*d <-70?cX�BZR�X!2�B�3iP��

�VR"B/5"OUO�9"<-z <-CsR*BZC � R*7 7 _ d�Il<^\DI 9AR]7$R*3w\ZR*7!3@5"<�763�I�2Y?A2�7u2�BD<^\ X!R*<-7�3 R>L � 5"7�9]CD[ : z"5"BD<@2�3i<@2DC � R>L� C�[�\DI 3iI05"3 � ��� <UCf5gX�[�B�2fOWR�? \�5"7$R*7!<^\�5"Oy\D2�7�3kB�2pR L �� G � �� 3iIJ2�7 � <UCf5gX�[�B�2fOWR�? \�5"7$R*7!<^\�5"O

\Z2�7!3iBZ2tR>L �FEIGH: G � E

� B�R R>LsE uvoP_^cr[.U�cdNPYeVv_ecrY^\s`'RTY Ri] \pNBVrVdoPUwgpU�OPU�[._^`}Z3\p_^O~Vv\pM�� cd\anrUwRi[.U}Mb[.U�UVd\�[dU�ZIYbRT`'U 7 ]Wf�RTOWf&\TZ U'OcdU�V�V.oIRiVr`'\pO~VXRT_^OPc$V.oPU}gpU'OPU�[._e`FZ \p_eOWVm\pM���t�uvoPUk_^QPU'R�_^c�V.\�[dU'QPNP`'UkV.\�V.oPUF`@RTcdU}\pM8R�QP_ehs_^cd\T['�An�oPU'O�V.oPU[.U'cqNPYeV§] U'`�\pS&U'c�RTO|U'RTcqf�`'\pOPcdU'´ANPU'OP`'U�\pM�_eOWh~U�[dcd_^\pO�\pM3RTQ*)½NPOP`lV._^\pO0t � _e`.��RYe\pgw[dU'cd\pY^NBVd_^\pOt���!� � $ 7\pMjV.oPUwZERT_e[5� 798;:�vRTOPQ�Y^U�V � ]3U�V.oPU�Ye\pg�ZINPY^Yy]ERT`.��\pM :�t +rf�RTcdcqNPS�ZPV._^\pO�V.oPU�[.U�_ec}R�NPOP_e´sNPU�QP_yhB_^cq\T[� Yefs_^OPg�\°h~Ul[�� \pM5Ye\pg�QP_^cd`�[dU�ZERTOP`�fp''U�[.\Pt � U�V � � � � $ � ] U}V.oPU[.U'cqVq[._^`�Vd_^\pO!\pMV��V.\ ��t �FU�ZIY^RT`'_^OPg

J �

Page 21: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

7 ]Wf�RTO&\TZ3U'O�cdNB]IcdUlV@�AnrUFS�RJf|RTcdcqNPS&U�V.oIRiV � RTOPQ ��Ri[dU�] \TVdo&cdS&\A\TV.o0�sRTOPQ|V.oIRiV � �GRTOPQ �FE G :Ri[.U D � Y^_eOPU@Ri[.Yef�U'´ANP_ehiRTY^U'O~VFVd\�''Ul[.\Pty+mf!RTQ*)½NPOP`�V._e\pO�nrU�S�RJf�n�[._yV.U

� ��� G � �� � � ��� G��F8

M:\T[mcq\pS&U�Ul� U'`�Vd_eh~UFQP_yhB_ecd\T[ ���~nFoPUl[.U�]3\TV.o&cd_eQPU'cmRi[.U D � Y^_eOPU@Ri[.Yef!U'´ANP_ehiRTY^U'O~V�Vd\=''U�[d\Pt � \pcqcd_e]IYyf�ZERTcqcd_^OPgV.\�R|cdS�RTY^YeU�[�\TZ U'O�cqU�VknrU�S�RJf�RTcdcqNPS&U�V.oIRiVFU�h~U�[df�`'\pS�Z3\pOPU'O~V}\pM ��QP\pS&_eOIRiV.U'c���RTOPQ�V.oIRiV � � � _eccdS&\A\TV.o0t�u�oPU�O

���9G � � ����� G � ���� � ��� ���FE GH:����� � � � � � �FEHGI:����� ��� � � ��� � ��

ªsNBZPZ \pcqU&V.oIRiV � _^caR�ZINB[dU�Y^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY�`�U'OWVq[.U�\pM � �@G � ����t�ªsU�V � � � � � �at�L}c �{QP\sU�c�OP\TV`'\pO~VXRT_^O!V.oPU�gpU�OPU�[._^`wZ \p_eOWV�\pM���� � _ec�OP\TVkR|`'\pS|Z \pOPU'O~VF\pM�� �©�Ecq\|V.oIRiV ��� � � ��� � � � ���vt��zV�M:\pY^Ye\°n�c]Wf�� ¯st^®0$V.oIRiV � � � � r_ec�R�ZINB[.UwY^\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY0`'U'O~Vd[.Uw\pMC��� G � � ���vt$uvoPU[.U'cdNPYyV�OP\Jn�M:\pY^Ye\°n�c�RTcv_^OV.oPUwZP[.\s\pM5\pM �½®�&ste®pt^®0l� �µ®�&st � rRTOPQ �½®�&st & r\pMm­y®shT±©t �

%3'on � (0 �A '�1�2�3 ��798;:�p: 2p5�OWR�?]X�5"<�B�587�9 OW2K3 � : 2S5 9"<-z�<UCsR*BSR>L]3�I�2aLsR"BDN � G � d�IJ2�BZ2 � <UC

5"NaX$OW2p5"7$9 � <-C�2� 2D\�3i<�z82sE�1V2�3 � : � 8 � � p: 2S5 \DR*z82�B�<-7�?=Ls5"Nt<-OQP R>Lg3i<o?A2�BZCpR>L�d(2�<W?*IA3 ?"BZ2�5"3>2�Bg3�I0587 �

5"7�9 9"<�N]2�7JCD<@R*7 � E=1�2�3 � �H: 2t3iIJ2tB�2DCD3kBD<@\�3i<@R*7 R L � 3>R ��� E � [ XmX!R�C 2/3iI05"3w3�I�2�B�2t<UCH5"7 R�X!2K7 C 2�3 R>L �

CD[!\DIp3iI05"3!LsR*BT58OUO � � � dy2=Ng5"P � 7�9�5p\DR*z82�B�<-7�? LF5"Nt<�OQP�R>LY3k<W?A2KBZC � � ��� 8 � �

��; R*7 ��� R>LYdy2K<W?*IA3 _ d <-3iI

B�2�C^X!2Z\�3e3>R � � _ ?"BZ2�5"3>2�Bc3iI05"7 � � EG�IJ2K76dy2=N]5"P�� 7�9p5S\ZR*z82�B�<-7�?wLs5"Nt<-OQPSR>Lc3k<W?A2KBZC � � � 8 ���; R>LT98<-N]2�7JC�<^R*7 OW2DCZC=3�IJ5"7 � 5"7$9gdy2�<W?"IA3

� � � � ®� G

®� � �

��� �� G � � �

�$[�BD3iIJ2�B=<xL : R*3�I � : � 8 ��� 587�9 � � ��� 8 � �

�� 58B�2 : <�B 5"3k<^R*7�58O8LF5"Nt<-OQ<@2DCc3iIJ2�7 CsR]<UC � � � 8 ���; E� B�R R>LsE � _^`.� 4 cd\�V.oIRiV 4 � _ecv�vRi[dV._^Ul[rRTOPQ�Y^U�V�� ��� E�� 4 � j] UkV.oPUF`'\T[d[.U'c½Z \pOPQP_^OPg�Ye_^OPU�]INPOPQPYeUTt �}\TV.U

V.oIRiV]Wf"ªsU�[d[.U�hTRTOP_ecdoP_^OPg� �0��798� ����� � � �!M:\T[ YbRi[dgpU�U�OP\pNPgpo0t�¶}U�OP`'U�nmU|S�R@f�Ye_^MbV � ����V.\

R D �zQP_yhB_ecd\T[ � ����\pO 7 D � Y^_^OPU'Ri[.YefGU'´ANP_ehiRTY^U'O~V�Vd\�V.oPU�c.RTS&U�S�NPYeV._yZIY^U�\pM � t�L}QPQP_^OPg�\pO�R�S�NPYyV._eZIYeU

\pM � nmU�S�R@f"RTcdcdNPS&U�V.oIRiV � ���a_^c�_eO�M�RT`�V�R!S�NPYeV._yZIY^U�\pM���t�u�oWNPc�]WfI� ¯st � wRTOPQ ��¤Bt � RiZPZIY^_^U�Q�V.\

� : ��G � ���08 � �

�� �nrU!S�R@f��IOPQ?R�`'\°h~Ul[._^OPg�M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pMvV._^gpU�[dc � � � 8 ��� �\pM�nrU'_^gpo~V � � � t�uvoPU![.U�cqV�_ec

`'YeU@Ri[@t �

J@Å

Page 22: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

%3'�� � (� �A 'p1�2�3 ��798;:�S: 2�5 OWR�?fX�58<-BS5"7�9�OW2�3 � : 2S5 : <W? 5"7�9�7$2�LS9"<-z�<UCsR*BsE 1�2�3 � : � 8 � � : 2�5: <-B�5"3k<^R*7�5"O8Ls5"Nt<-OQPSR>Lc3k<W?A2KBZC/R>LqO 5"B^?A2=dy2�<W?*Il3Md <�3�I�Nt<-7�<-N]5"O�9"<-Nf2�7JCD<^R"7 � E

G�IJ2K7 � � ���� <UCT5"3yN]R*CD3 �©� � � � � � � E� B�R R>LsE ªsNBZPZ3\pcdU�V.oIRiV � � ��� � � � � � � � � � t�ªs_^OP`'U � _^ck]I_eg�nrU�S�RJf�n�[d_eV.U � � � � G ����n�oPU�[.U �_^ckRTS�ZIY^UaRTOPQ �{_eckU�� U�`�V._eh~Uit +mf�£wY^U'_eS�RTO0¥¦ck`l[._eV.Ul[._bR&M:\T[wRTS�ZIYeU'OPU'cdc��0RTc�� _^ckOPU�M � � � �{_^cRTS�ZIYeUM:\T[�RTO~f�� � � ®pt uvoANPc�nmU�S�R@fGRTcdcdNPS&U!V.oIRiV � � � � � � � � � � � � � t ªsU�V � � � � �����³t uvoPU'O�½®��p� � � � � �©� � � � � tw+mf��ihPt � mV.oPU�[dUa_^ckR�]I_y[XRiV._e\pOIRTY=M�RTS�_^Yef!\pMjV._egpU�[.c5� � �

�� 8 � �

��;�\pMjnmU'_^gpo~V}gT[.U@RiVdU�[

V.oIRTO�� � M:\T[ � ��� G � �rRTOPQ�®��p� � �q�EV.oIRiV�_^c�\pM�nrU'_egpoWVkgT[[email protected]�[�V.oIRTO�� � � �kM:\T[ � �.t(+mf � ¯st ¤ r_eV�M:\pY^Ye\°n�cV.oIRiV}V.oPUl[.Ua_^cR&]I_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTY=M�RTS&_^Yyf�\pM§V._egpU�[.c5� � �08 ��� �\pM§QP_eS&U'OPcd_e\pO�YeU'cdc}V.oIRTO � RTOPQ�nrU'_^gpo~VgT[.U@RiVdU�[V.oIRTO�� � �PV.oIRiVF_ec�\pM�YbRi[.gpU}nrU'_egpoWV'�En�oP_^`Xo�`'\pO~Vd[XRTQP_e`�V.cvV.oPU�S�_^OP_^S&RTY^_eVzf�\pM � : � 8 ��� lt �

)������32568-=4<HW251G/��=C�4=C ��10CEC�2�H�;��39:1 ;B/ 9:2�-0;=KH�;=Dk9:K� 9:-�/0CI10Dk>�25H�/�8C"K~2�� 4=9:>J7 10C��i;=-=7�

¶}U�[.Uw_^cvV.oPU�\TV.oPU�[�h~U�[.cd_e\pO�\pMjRTQ*)½NPOP`�Vd_^\pO�nrUwcdoIRTY^Y8OPU'U�Q0��S&U�OWV._e\pOPU'Q�_eO ) ¯st

� '�& � (� �A '�1V2�3 7 : 2q5wX�BZR��s2Z\K3i<-z{2wz"5"B�<^2�3kP�5"7�9/CD[sXAX!R�Cs2 dy2q5"B�2w?"<-z82K7 5tCD[ : z"5"B�<^2�3kPHR La3iIJ2 Y<�O : 2�BD3

Cs\DI�2�N]2TR>L 7 C�[�\DIf3iI05"3M<xL�� �� �3$ � <UC 3�I�2 7uR*BDNg58OQ<UCF5"3k<^R*7 R>L 3iIJ2Y[l7�<�z82�BZCs5"O�Ls5"Nt<-OQPg587�9 �w�!� � $7 <UCg3iIJ2�7�5"3k[�B 5"OyN]R*B@XIA<UC�N _ 3�I�2�7 � <UC : <-B�5"3k<^R*7�5"O E 1V2K3 : : 2S5 D�� 9"<-z�<UCsR*B�CD[!\DI 3�IJ5"3 �FE G : <UC

D�� je5"BD3k<^2�BsEG�IJ2K7S3iIJ2�BZ2 <-CY5"7�R�X!2K7SC�[ : C 2�3 � � � CD[!\DIf3�I05830LsR*Bq5"OUO � � �/_ 3iIJ2�� : B�2 ��� R>L � R"z82�B � <UCwC�N]R R*3iI

<-7 \DRs9"<-N]2K7JCD<^R*7 R"7$2t5"7$9gdy2=N]5"P�� 7�9 � � CD[!\DIS3iI05"3

� �FEHGI:������� � � � � G � �Z�

R*B�2DR*z82�Bq3�IJ2 X�5"<-B � ��� 8 � � I05"Cc3�I�2MLsR*OUOWR"d <-7�?YX$B�R�X!2KBD3k<^2DCFE

�½®0 � � <UCf2� 2D\�3i<�z82�< � 3iIJ2]OWR�?HX�[�OUO : 5A\�b � R>L : <UCf2�Y2Z\�3k<-z82�<-7 5 7$2�<o?*I : R*[�BZI�R Rs96R>LH3iIJ2H?A2�7$2�B�<^\

� : BZ2tR>L � E

� � � L � <UC]2�Y2Z\�3k<-z82t<-7 5�7$2K<W?*I : R"[lBDIJR Rs9 R>Lt3iIJ2/?A2K7$2�BD<@\ � : B�2fR>L � 5"7$9 �FE G : <UC/b85"dy5"Ng5"3r5

OWR�?f3r2�B�Nt<-7�58O 3�I�2�7 ��� <UCc7$R"BDNg5"O EJ;J

Page 23: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

�©¤ G�IJ2TOWR�?�9"<-Cs\�B�2rX�5"7$\�PpR>L � ��� 8 � � <UCT583MOW2�5"CD3y3�IJ2=OWR�?p9"<-Cs\�B�2rX�5"7$\�PpR>L ��798;:� E

� B�R R>LsE �zV}cqNBx&`'U'c}V.\�QPUl�IOPU � �vRTOPQ�V.\&ZP[.\Jh~U��½®��z¤ v\pO��&�3_^O�R&OPU'_egpoW]3\pNB[.oP\s\AQ�\pMjV.oPUagpU'OPU�[._e`��P]P[.U\pM � t

uvoPU�gpU'OPU�[._e`��P]P[dU�\pM � _^c�`�U�[dVXRT_eOPYef cdS�\s\TV.o _eO `�\sQP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO \pOPU�RTOPQ cd\�V.oPU��P]P[.U'c!\pM � Ri[.U`'U�[qVXRT_^OPYyf cqS&\s\TV.o _^O?`�\sQP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO<\pOPU�\Jh~U�[�RTO?\TZ3U'O cdNB]IcdUlV@t u�oWNPc&\Jh~U�[�VdoPU�c.RTS&U!\TZ U'O cqNB]IcdU�V�FE ����� � � � �rRTOPQ�cq\|nrU�`@RTO�QPU��IOPU � ��Vd\|cd_eS�ZIYef�]3U�V.oPU[.U'c½Vd[._^`lV._^\pO�\pM � V.\ � �.t �µ®0v_ec�V.oPU�O�`'Y^U'Ri[@t

�µM � �$RTOPQ��FE G : _ecv�iR@nvRTS�RiVXR�Ye\pg�VdU�[.S&_eOIRTY3_eVvM:\pYeY^\JnFcrV.oIRiV ����G � _^cm�iRJnrRTS�RiVXR�Y^\pgaV.Ul[.S&_^OIRTY\pMvY^\pg�QP_ecd`�[.UlZERTOP`�fGRiVaY^U'RTcqV�V.oPU�Ye\pg�QP_^cd`l[.U�ZERTOP`�f�\pM �FE G :%_eO R�OPU�_^gpo~] \pNB[.oP\A\sQ�\pMrV.oPU&gpU'OPU�[d_^`�P]P[.U�\pM � t§�½O!ZERi[dV._e`'NPYbRi[�_eV�M:\pY^Ye\°n�cvV.oIRiV � _^c��r\poPU'O�¬�RT`@RTNPYbR@f!_^O�R|OPU'_egpoW]3\pNB[.oP\s\AQ�\pM5V.oPUwgpU'OPU�[d_^`�P]P[.U|\pM � RTOPQ�cd\�V.oPU��P]P[.U'c�\pM � Ri[dU��r\poPU'O�¬�RT`@RTNPYbR@f�\°h~Ul[�RTO"\TZ U'O�cqNB]IcdU�V@t��½O"ZERi[dV._^`�NPYbRi[ ���F_ecOP\T[.S�RTY�t§¶}U'OP`'UF�©� lt� _e`.�B_^OPg�Rw[dU'cd\pY^NBVd_^\pO�\pMEV.oPU�gpU'OPU�[._e`��P]P[.UFRTOPQ�Z \pcdcq_e]IYefaZERTcqcd_^OPg�Vd\�RcdS�RTY^YeU�[�\TZ U'O�cdU�V@�3�©¤ jM:\pY^Ye\°n�c

U@RTcd_eYef~t��

� '-, � (0 �A 'S1V2�3 ��798;:�H: 2�5pOWR�?TX�5"<-B _ d IJ2�B�2 7 <UC X�B�R�� 2Z\�3k<-z82sEY1�2�3 � : 2g5"7�P D � jM5"B�3i<^2KBS9"<-z <UC R*B5"7�9 � : � 8 ��� 5 : <-B�5"3i<@R*7�5"O8LF58Nt<-OQPSR>Lc3k<W?A2�BDCFE � 2�3 � � � � � : � E

G�IJ2K7 3iIJ2�BZ2�<UC�5"7 R�X!2�7 CD[ : Cs2�3 � R>L � C�[�\DI 3iI05"3/<xL � � � 3�I�2�7 2Kz82�BDP \DR*NaX!R*7u2�7�3 R LS3iIJ2� � 2 ��\Z2@X�3k<^R*7$5"OOWR�\�[ACqd�IA<^\DI�9lR*Nt<-7�583r2DC � <-C=5�OWR�?p\�5"7uR*7�<^\�58O�\D2�7�3kB�2/R>L �FE G � G<� � � E � 7gX�5"B�3i<@\�[lO 58B2�z82KBDP � � 2 �0\Z2@X�3k<^R*7�58O 98<-z <UCsR"B I05*CcOWRZ?p9"<UC \�B�2@X!5"7$\�Pf5"3yN]R�CD3 2�BZR�d <-3iIpBZ2DC^X!2Z\K3M3>R �FEIG � G � � � E

� B�R R>LsE � _^`.��� �� ��� ��tau�oPU�O�� ��RTOPQ ���FRi[.U�Y^\pg!`@RTOP\pOP_^`@RTY�`�U'OWVq[.U'c�\pM ���@G � G � � G � �.t�u�oWNPc� �st �st^®0�_eS�ZIY^_eU'cFV.oPUl[.U�_^c}cd\pS&UaYe\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTYj`'U'O~Vd[.U �

��v`'\pO~VXRT_^OPU'Q�_eO �V.oIRiV}`�\pOPOPU'`�V.c � ��RTOPQ � �.t

+mf�cqfsS&S&U�Vq[df�RTOPQ �©�st �st ¤ rnrUaS�R@f��IOPQ"RTO�\TZ U'O�cdNB]IcdUlV � � �{cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV ���r_^ckR�Ye\pg�`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTY

`'U'O~Vd[.U\pM ����G � G�� � �.t��mRi[qfB_^OPg��~� ����c½nrU'U�ZIcv\pNBV RTOPQ�cd\a]Af � �st �st � §_yVrM:\pY^Ye\°n�cmV.oIRiV _^cmR�Ye\pg

`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY8`'U'O~Vd[.U�\pM ����G � G?� � �Xt �

� 'on � (0 �A 'S1V2�3 7 : 2f5�Cs\�IJ2�N]2SR>L X�[�B�2p9"<-N]2�7�CD<^R*7 � 5"7�9�OW2�3 � : 2f5"7 5"NaX�OW2 D � 9"<�z <UCsR*BpCD[!\DI3iI05"3 � � 4 � <UCpjM58BD3k<^2�BFE � [ XmX!R*Cs2H3�IJ5"3w3iIJ2�BZ2]5"B�2f2 � 2Z\�3k<-z82 D�� 9"<-z <UC R*BZC � 5"7$9�� _ d�I�2�B�2 � �� � <UC

JZ|

Page 24: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

<-7�3>2@?"B�5"OV5"7�9 � � � ��� � � G � L R*BYCsR"N]2H\ZR"7JCD3r5"7�3 � E

G�IJ2K7

� � � ���4 �! � �

� B�R R>LsE �µOPQPU'U�Q4 � � � � � � �! � � � �5� � � � � � G � � � � m� ��� 8

n�oPU�[.U�nmU�NPcdU'Q�V.oPU�M�RT`�V�V.oIRiV � � � �� ��®pt �

� '�� � (0 �A ' � [ XmX!R*Cs2c3�IJ5"3 �FE G : <UC b85"de58Ng5"3r5gOWR�?g3>2�BDNH<-7�5"O�R>LYOWRZ?�9"<UCs\KB�2@X�587$\�P]583MOW2�5"CD3 � ��_

�6���FE G :� <UC : <W?f587�9g7$2�L _ d IJ2�B�2 : <UC=5"7 2 � 2Z\�3k<-z82 D � 9"<-z <UC R*BFE � [ XmX!R*Cs2c3�IJ5"3M3iIJ2T9"<�N]2�7JCD<@R*7 R>L 7<UC � 587�9]3iI05"3�4 � �FE GI:� <UCHje5"BD3k<^2�BMLsR*BcCsR*N]2T<-7�3>2@?A2�B(4!E �YCZCD[�N]2T3�I0583e3iIJ2/9l2@?"B�2D2q<UCT5"3yOW2�5"CD3

� � �C � � � � 4 � ��� ®0 � ��� �! ��5"7�9 OW2�3 �w��� � $ 7 : 263�IJ2 : <-B 5"3k<^R*7$5"O N]R"B^XIA<-CDN 9A2�3>2�BDNH<-7$2�9 : P 5 : <-B 5"3k<^R*7$5"O LF58Nt<-OQP R L 3k<W?A2KBZC

R>LfO 5"B@?A2�dy2�<W?*Il3=5"7�9�Nt<-7!<-Ng5"O 9"<-N]2K7JCD<^R*7 _ d�IJR�Cs2 2 �m<UCD3>2�7$\Z2f<UCH?"[J58B 5"7�3>2Z2�9 : P ���lE�� ���^I�2�B�2fdy2�3@5"b{2� � �6���FEHGH:� �{E��t2 � 7u2 � 3rR : 2=3iIJ2qOWR�?qX�[lOUO : 5A\Db�R L : 5"7�9p9l2 � 7$2 � � 5*Cc<�7 ���8E�� �{E

�½®0 � <UC/2� 2D\�3i<�z82c<-7 5f7$2�<W?*I : R*[�BZIJR R 9�R>Lc3iIJ2Y?A2K7$2�BD<@\�� : B�2�R>L � E� � G�IJ2KB�2�<-C 5"7 RZX!2�7 C�[ : C 2�3 � � � CD[!\DI 3iI05"3 � � � G � � <UCSb85"de58Ng5"3r5 OWR�? 3r2KBDNt<-7$5"O R>L�OWR�?

9"<UC \�B�2@X!5"7$\�Pf5"3yOW2�5*CD3� _ LsR"BT5"OUO ��� � E�©¤ � Lc3�I�2t9A2@?8B�2Z2q<-CT5"3eOW2�5*CD3

� � � � � ��� � 4 ����� ®0 � ��� � ��3iIJ2�7 � <-CYCDNg5"OUOV<-7 5f7$2�<W?*I : R*[�BZIJR R 9�R>Lc3iIJ2Y?A2K7$2�BD<@\�� : B�2�R>L � E

� B�R R>LsE �©� vM:\pYeY^\JnFc�Mb[.\pS �½®0vRTOPQ � �Bt^®0³t§u�oWNPck_eV�cdNBx�`'U'cFVd\|ZP[.\Jh~UF�½®0rRTOPQ ��¤ lt� U�V�� � 8 � � 8s�s�s�;8 � � ]3U�V.oPU�Ul�B`'U�ZPV._e\pOIRTY�QP_ehs_^cd\T[.c\pMM� n�oP_^`Xo�QP\pS&_eOIRiV.U ��t/+mf � �Bt � � ) oIRTc�Ye\pg

QP_^cq`�[.U�ZERTOP`�f Y^U�cdcaV.oIRTO<\T[�U'´ANIRTYmV.\ '�U�[.\"n�_eVdoG[.U�cqZ U'`lV|V.\ �FE G#: G�� : �.t�uvoWNPc|_eM� ) _ecaV.oPU�Ye\pgJ /

Page 25: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

QP_^cq`�[.U�ZERTOP`�f�\pM � ) nF_yV.o�[.U'c½Z U'`�V�V.\��FE G : VdoPU'O�V.oPU�`�\sU�x�`'_^U'O~Va\pM � ) n�_eV.o�[dU'cqZ U�`�V�V.\ : �k_^c�RiVY^U'RTcqV� ) �p�st +mf � �Bt ¤ �V.oPUwQPU'gT[.U'U�\pM �6��� � � G � � r_^c�RiVFYeU@RTcqV

��� )� 4 � �

² O�V.oPUw\TV.oPU�[koIRTOPQ�]Af � ¯st h mVdoPU�QPU'gT[.U�U�\pM �6��� ��� G � � r_^c�RiV�S&\pcqV � � � � � � � � t$u�oWNPc� � � 4 � �0� � � � � � � �

� ) �

+mf��©¤Bt ¤Bt � m_eV�M:\pY^Ye\°n�c�V.oIRiV

� � � �%�C � � � � � 4 � �0� � � � � � � �� ) � � � � � �

� ) � � �©� � 4 ����� ®0 � ��� � �� ��}\TV.U�VdoIRiV}_^M � _^ckOP\TVUl� U'`�Vd_eh~U�V.oPU�O�VdoPU�[.UaUl�B_^cqV.c � cdNP`Xo�VdoIRiV � ) � ®�RTOPQ�M:\T[RTY^Y � nrUaoIR@h~U � ) � t�½®0vRTOPQ@�©¤ rM:\pY^Ye\°n�_eS&S&U'QP_^RiV.U'Yyf~t �� B�R R>LTR L�� �{E � �mE �µ®ptQ&st^®0�M:\pYeY^\JnFcvMb[.\pS �©¤Bt¦¤Bt � l� �ihPt � mRTOPQ��©¤Bt h ³t��½®ptQ&st � �M:\pY^Y^\Jn�c�Mb[d\pS ��hPt ¤ mRTOPQ@�©¯st h lt�½®pt &st ¤ mRTOPQ �½®pt &st h mM:\pY^Ye\°n Mb[.\pS � �Bt h lt��� B�R R>LTR L � �{E � � �{E �µS&S&U'QP_^RiV.U}Mb[.\pS �½®ptQ&ste®0lt �� B�R R>L�R>L � �mE����{E ªsNBZPZ \pcdU�OP\TV@t�u�oPU�O�]Wf �½®ptQ& vV.oPU�[.U�_^cwR&]I_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTY5S&\T[dZIoP_^cqS ���� � $ 7 RTOPQ"R`'\pO~Vd[XRT`�Vd_^\pO�S&\T[dZIoP_^cqS � �$� � $ � cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV�� RTOPQ"V.oPU�gpU'OPU�[d_^`��P]P[.U|oIR@h~U�Z \pcd_yV._eh~U�QP_^S�U'OPcd_^\pO0t¬�\T[.U'\Jh~U�[Y��_^ckcqS�RTY^Y=_^O�R&OPU'_egpoW]3\pNB[.oP\s\AQ"\pMjVdoPUagpU'OPU�[._e`��P]P[.U�\pM � t � U�V �] U�V.oPU�ZINPYeYe]ERT`.��\pM�RTORTS�ZIYeU�QP_yhB_^cq\T[m\pO � RTOPQ�YeU�V "�] U�V.oPUFZINPcdoPM:\T[dnrRi[.Q�\pM Gt§uvoPU'O." _^c D �z��Ri[dVd_^U�[RTc 7 _^c D � M�RT`�V.\T[._^RTYRTOPQ�cd\6� � " � G � nFoPUl[.U � _^caUl�B`'U�ZPV._e\pOIRTYmRTOPQ�QP\sU'c�OP\TVaQP\pS�_^OIRiV.U ��t�uvoWNPc "�_^caOP\TV�]I_egP�n�oP_^`Xo�`'\pO~Vd[XRTQP_e`�V.c�VdoPU�M�RT`�V�V.oIRiV�7 oIRTc � _^`@Ri[dQ�OWNPS�]3U�[k\pOPUit �

� '�% � (0 �A 'S1V2K3 ���!� � $ � : 2T5 : R*[�7�9A2Z9 LF5"Nt<-OQP _ d�Il<^\DIqX�5"B�5"N]2�3kBD<UC 2DC 3iB�< X�OW2DC ��798 �%8 �=Z_ d�IJ2�BZ27 <UCq5YX�BZR��s2Z\K3i<-z{2 z"58BD<^2�3kP _ � <UC=5�OQ<-7u2 : [l7$9�OW2tR*7 7 5"7$9 � <-C=5 D � 9"<�z <UCsR*BsE �M<��p5"7 <-7!3r2@?l2�B(4 587�9f5

X!R�C�<-3i<�z82cB�2�58O 7�[�N : 2�B�*EG�IJ2K763�I�2�B�2q<-CT5S\ZR"7JCD3r5"7�3 ��� CD[!\DIp3iI05"3�LsR*Bt2�z82�B�P]3iB�< X�OW2 ��798;:�8 � d�IJ2�BZ2

�½®0�: <UC=5gC�[ : : R*[l7$9m5"BDPgCD[!\DI�3�I0583 : G � <UCt2� 2Z\�3k<-z82 EJ !

Page 26: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

� � ��FE GI: <UCcb85"de5"N]5"3@5fOWR�?g3>2�BDNH<-7�5"O`R LcOWR�?p98<UCs\�BZ2@X�5"7$\KPf5"3eOW2�5*C�3 � � E�©¤ � E�� 4 ���FEHG :� � � E�ih ��FE GI: G � <UCc7uR*3 b{5"de5"Ng583@5fOWR�?]3>2�BDNH<-7�5"O E� ¯ � ��� � � �

G�IJ2K7 � � � � E

� B�R R>LsE �}\TVdU�V.oIRiV}QP_yhB_^cq\T[.c :�c.RiVd_^cdMbfs_^OPg �½®0z� �©¤ �M:\T[dS R�] \pNPOPQPU'Q�M�RTS&_eYef~t�u�oWNPc}Z \pcdcq_e]IYef�U'OPYbRi[dgp_^OPg� nmU|S�R@f�RTcdcqNPS&UaV.oIRiV�� ZERi[XRTS&UlVd[._^cqU'c}Vd[._eZIYeU'c���798 �%8;:�lt �}\TVdU�VdoIRiVwnmU�Ri[.U�Mb[.U'U�V.\�RTQPQ�R�]ERTcdUZ \p_eOWV�Mb[.U'U|Y^_eOPU�]INPOPQPYeU|V.\ �Ft�L}QPQP_^OPg�\pO�R�cqNBx&`'_eU'OWVdYef"RTS�ZIY^U�Ye_^OPU�]INPOPQPY^U|Vd\ � RTOPQ"ZERTcdcq_^OPg�V.\�RZ \JnrU�[F\pM � nrU�S�RJf�VdoPU�[.U'M:\T[.U�RTcdcdNPS&UwV.oIRiV � _^c�h~Ul[df�RTS�ZIY^UTt

+mf@�}\sUlV.oPU�[._^RTO _eOPQPNP`�V._^\pOGnrU!S�RJf�RTcdcdNPS&U�V.oIRiV���_ec�_y[d[.U'QPNP`�_e]IY^U�RTOPQ<_yV�cdNBx&`'U�c|V.\�Ul�PoP_y]I_eV|ROP\pOs� U�S�ZPVzf<\TZ3U'O?cdNB]IcdUlV�\pM ��n�_eV.oGV.oPU�gp_yh~U'O<ZP[.\TZ3U�[dVzf~t � _^`.�B_eOPg�R�[.U'cd\pYeNBV._^\pO?\pM�V.oPU�gpU'\pS�U�Vd[._e`gpU'OPU�[d_^`}�P]P[.UwRTOPQ�ZERTcdcd_^OPg�V.\�RTO�\TZ U�O�cdNB]IcqU�VvnrU}S�R@f�V.oPU�[dU'M:\T[.UwRTcdcdNPS&UkVdoIRiV ��_ecrcdS&\A\TV.o�RTOPQ�V.oIRiVV.oPUacdNBZPZ3\T[dV\pM :�oIRTc}gpY^\T]ERTY5OP\T[.S�RTY=`�[.\pcdcq_^OPgpc't}L}cknrU�Ri[dUaRTcdcdNPS&_eOPg�V.oIRiVkV.oPUaYe\pg�QP_^cd`�[dU�ZERTOP`�f�\pM�FE GI:{_eckRiV�Y^U'RTcqV _eV�M:\pY^Y^\Jn�c�V.oIRiV�U�h~U�[qf�`�\pS�Z \pOPU'O~V�\pM�:{oIRTc�`'\AU�x&`�_^U'O~V}RiV�S&\pcqVw®�� t

L}c+�FE�G�: G � _^c�OP\TV§�TR@nvRTS�RiV.RYe\pg}V.U�[.S&_eOIRTY �ihPte®pt � 5_eS�ZIY^_eU'cjV.oIRiV�V.oPU�[dU�_ec$R`'U'O~Vd[.U \pM 7 nF_yV.oS�NPYeV._yZIY^_e`'_eVzf�RiV�YeU@RTcqV _eO � t�uvoWNPc�nrU&`@RTO��IOPQ�QP_yhB_^cq\T[.c � 8 � 8s�s�s�;8 � ] U'Ye\pOPgp_^OPg�V.\ � � �In�oP\pcdU_^O~V.U�[dcdU'`�V._e\pO&nF_yV.o _^cmRw�IOP_eV.U�cdU�Vm\pM�Z \p_^O~V.c'�WnFoPUl[.U � _ec$V.oPU�QP_^S&U�OPcd_^\pO&\pM �t �}\Jn ZI_^`.��R�Z \p_eOWV - \pMV.oP_ec��IOP_eVdU�cdU�V}RTOPQ�`XoP\s\pcdUaR|M:NB[dV.oPU�[}cqU�[._^U�c ��� � 8s�s�s� ��! � \pM�U'Y^U'S�U'OWVdck\pM � V.oIRiVk`�\pOWVXRT_eO - n�oP\pcdU_^O~V.U�[dcdU'`�V._e\pO�n�_eV.o � _^ckR��IOP_eV.UwcdU�VF\pM5Z3\p_^O~V.c't

uvoPU'O

� � � �5� � � 8�s�s� �� � � r� � 8cd\�V.oIRiV

��� � � �n�_^Y^Y0QP\Pt �

J �

Page 27: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

� B�R R>LTR L � �{E ���{E 4 UwS�R@f!RTc�nrU'YeY8cdNBZPZ \pcdUwV.oIRiV�V.oPU�QPU'gT[dU'U�\pM � ���FEHGI:�r_^c�RiVFYeU@RTcqV

� � �C � � � � 4 ����� ®0 � ��� � �� �uvoANPc�]Af��½®ptQ& �V.oPUl[.UF_ec�R]I_e[XRiV._e\pOIRTYIS&\T[dZIoP_^cqS ���!� �3$ 7 RTOPQ�Rw`'\pO~Vd[XRT`�V._e\pO&S&\T[dZIoP_ecdS � �!� � $�%n�oPU�[.U�V.oPU��P]P[.U'c|\pM � oIRJh~U!QPU'gT[.U�U�RiV�S&\pcqV � � ��� � � � � t�L�`'\pYeY^U'`lV._^\pOG\pM�hiRi[._^UlV._^U'c�\pMv] \pNPOPQPU'QQPU'gT[.U�U�M:\T[.S&c�R�] \pNPOPQPU'Q�M�RTS�_^Yef�RTOPQ�cd\�V.oPUw�P]P[dU'cF\pM � ] U�Y^\pOPg�V.\&Ra] \pNPOPQPU'Q�M�RTS�_^Yef~t�¬�\T[dU'\°h~Ul[F]Wf� �Bt h v_eM � _^c�VdoPU�Y^\pg|ZINPY^Ye]ERT`.��\pM+: RTOPQ � �mVdoPU�[.U'c½Vd[._^`lV._^\pO�\pM � Vd\�����VdoPU'O�nrU�oIR@h~U�V.oIRiV�� ���CG � �

_^cv�iRJnvRTS&RiVXR�Ye\pg�VdU�[.S&_eOIRTY0\pMjY^\pg�QP_^cd`l[.U�ZERTOP`�f�RiV�YeU@RTcqV M:\T[ ��� � RTO�\TZ U'O�cdNB]IcdU�Vk\pM���tªsU�V � �

�� � � � : � �����³t�uvoPU'O&]Af9� �Bt^®pt¦¤ +� ��� G � �!G � �

���_^c�OP\TVm�TR@nvRTS�RiV.R�Y^\pg�V.U�[.S&_eOIRTY©�WM:\T[rgpU'OPU�[d_^`

`XoP\p_^`'U|\pM �&RTOPQ � t�+mf � �Bt ¯ k_eVwM:\pYeY^\JnFcV.oIRiVwV.oPU�[.U|_^c�R�`'\pOPcqV.RTOWV�� ��cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV�� � ���Tt�uvoWNPc�]Wf�©¤Bt¦¤ mVdoPU�QPU'gT[.U�U�\pM �6���FEHGI:�r_^c�RiVFS&\pc½V � � � �C � t �� B�R R>L R L�� �{E � �{E +mf�V.oPU�S�RT_eO?uvoPU'\T[.U'S \pM�­y®p®'±�gp_yh~U'OH� RTOPQ 4 V.oPU�[dU�_^c�R"�B�PU�Q _^O~V.U'gpU�[ v cqNP`³oV.oIRiV � � � v ���FE G :�}_ecwh~Ul[df"RTS�ZIY^UTt�uvoWNPc�V.\!ZP[.\°h~U �½®pt � }_yVwcdNBx&`'U�c�V.\!] \pNPOPQ�V.oPU�QPU'gT[.U�U�\pM�6���FEIGH:��RTOPQ�nrU�S�R@f!RiZPZIYef �½®pt¦¤ lt��� B�R R>LqR>L � �{E � �{E ªsNBZPZ \pcqUVdoIRiV �FE�G�: _^c$�TR@nvRTS�RiVXR�Y^\pg�V.U�[dS&_^OIRTY�RTOPQ�V.oIRiV �6���FE�G�:��_ec�]I_^g�RTOPQOPU'M t � U�V 4 ]3U�RTO~f�Z3\pcd_eVd_eh~Uw_^O~V.U'gpU�[FcdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV 4 ���FEIG :��_eck�vRi[dV._eU�[@te+rf �½®pt¦¤ �V.oPU�[.U�_^ckR�`'\pOPcqVXRTO~Vv cdNP`Xo�V.oIRiV%� � v M:\T[kRTYeY8ZERT_y[.c6��798;:�mc.RiV._ecdMbfB_eOPg9�½®pt¦¤Bt^®��^h lt

ªsNBZPZ \pcqUkV.oIRiV�V.oPUF\T[d]I_^M:\pYeQ�RTY^gpU�]P[XRT_e`FM:NPOPQIRTS&U�OWVXRTY�gT[.\pNBZ�oIRTcm`@Ri[dQP_^OIRTY^_yVzf&RiV�Y^U@RTcqV � t�u�oPU'O&VdoPU�[.U_^c�Rk�IOP_eVdU�`�\°h~U�[ �w�!� � $ 7 \pM 7 \pMI\T[.QPU�[�RiV§Y^U'RTcqV � cqNP`³o�V.oIRiV§V.oPUvY^\pg}ZINPY^Yy]ERT`.� � \pM :�_^c§U�� U�`�V._eh~UituvoANPcFVdoPU�ZERT_e[ �k� 8 � mc.RiV._ecq�IU'c5�½®pt¦¤Bt^®��^h lt§¬�\T[dU'\°h~Ul[FV.oPU�QPU'gT[.U'U�\pM � � ��� G � v_ecFU'´ANIRTY0V.\ � � V._^S&U�cV.oPU�QPU'gT[.U'U�\pM � ���FEHGI:�ltmu�oWNPc � _ec�OP\&S�\T[.UwVdoIRTO�V.oPU � V.o![.\s\TV�\pM v QP_ehs_^QPU'Q�]Wf!V.oPU�QPU'gT[dU'U�\pM�6���FEIGH:�lt$u�oP_ecFgp_eh~U�c�V.oPU�P[.cqVFcqVXRiV.U�S&U'O~V@t�E\T[$V.oPU�cdU'`'\pOPQ�c½VXRiV.U'S&U�OWV@�~OP\TV.U�V.oIRiV$_^M$��_ec�«U�V.RTY^U�_^O&`'\AQP_^S&U�OPcd_^\pO|\pOPUT�AV.oPU�O&_eV$_^c$RTNBV.\pS�RiV._e`rV.oIRiV

V.oPU�Y^\pg�ZINPY^Ye]ERT`.��\pM�:�_^c�U��3U'`�V._yh~UTt �

�w9 �3K~9:2���1 ; ���

­y®'± ��t~L}Y^Ul�BU'U�h3t +v\pNPOPQPU�QPOPU'cdcvRTOPQF� � M:\T[mYe\pg�cdNB[.M�RT`�U'c't � 7�3>2�BD7$5"3i<@R*7�5"O���E 583�I0E �s¯s�Q&{&�� �B®��B�P®� 8hPtJ�

Page 28: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

­¦�+±��rtIL}Sa]P[.\Pt �wU'OPU�[.RTY^_W'�U'Q�Y^\pg�hTRi[d_^U�V._eU'c'�IRi[ � _yh � S�RiV.o0t¦L�����B®p®°�p� �~�st

­ ¤i± ��t�+vRiVµfA[.U�h3t�u�oPU�`'\pOPU&\pMmU��3U'`�V._yh~U&QP_ehs_^cd\T[dc�\pM�V.oB[dU'U'M:\pY^QPc�t��µO �(BZR \sE � 7�3kO E jeR"7sLFEwR"7 �aO ?A2 : B 5 �ZERTgpU'cF¤p¤m& �s¤~¯p�s� ®� � Bt

­ hT±�Lat!+r\T[._^cd\Jh t +r\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cqc}\pM��§RTOP\�V.oB[dU'U'M:\pY^QPc�nF_yV.o�Ye\pgi� V.U�[dS&_^OIRTY cq_^OPgpNPYbRi[d_eV._eU'c�\pM�gp_eh~U'O�_^OPQPUl� t��E 583�I0E � \�<kE���7�<�z"E G�R�b�PAR � � � � l�¦¤~���s¤8hW�s�P�� �B®pt

­¦¯+±�Lat~Latm+r\T[._^cd\Jh|RTOPQ � tWLatA+r\T[._ecd\°h3t0ªs_eOPgpNPYbRi[�Vd\T[._^`��§RTOP\�V.oB[dU'Ul� M:\pYeQPc't 5"3rE �$: E �P®��p¤ � � ³�^®J¤8h ��®shP®p�®� ~�st

­ �i±��rtI�vRTS�ZERTOIRBt§�r\pOPOPUl�P_yVs«U}[XRiV._e\pOPOPU'Y^YeU}QPU'c�hiRi[._³«U�Vs«U'cvQPU�§RTOP\Pt �a7!7�E � \�<kE��� \ZR*OW2 � R*B�NgE � [ X E ��� � ��p¯ � ¯ l� ¯T¤ ��B¯"hW¯s�3®� ~�st

­ &+±��tI£�R@nvRTS�RiV.RBte+r\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cqc}\pM D �z�§RTOP\�V.oB[.U�U'M:\pY^QPc't jeR*7�3>2�NaX E 5"3�IJE _ �a5"BD3 � _ �aN]2�BsE 5"3iI0E� R \ E �0®J¤B®p�0®� ~�st

­ �i±��t�£�R@nvRTS�RiVXRBt ² O �EN*)½_eVXRB¥ c�Mb[.U'U'OPU'cqc `'\pO*)½U�`�V.NB[.U M:\T[G¤+� M:\pYeQPc�RTOPQ hi� M:\pY^QPc't 5"3iI0E �a7�7�E �¤ � � �©¤ l� h B® �B¯�~¯s�3®� m&st

­ i±��tp£�RJnvRTS&RiVXRBt ªsNB]ERTQ*)½NPOP`lV._^\pO&\pM�Y^\pgw`@RTOP\pOP_^`'RTYEQP_yhB_ecd\T[.c'tT�z�³t �aN]2�BsE �0E 5"3�IJE �P®°�� � ¯ ³� � p¤�� � B�®� �Bt

­y®��i±�ª3t~£�U�U'Y3RTOPQPtW¬��.£wU�[.OIRTO0t �kRiVd_^\pOIRTYI`'NB[dh~U'c$\pO�´ANIRTcd_y�©ZP[.\")½U'`�V._yh~U�cdNB[dM�RT`'U'c't 2�NgE �aN]2�BsE 5"3iI0E

� R \ E �0®sh � � � � ³� hB_e_^_ G�®°¯T¤B�E®� Bt

­y®p®'±�PtI£�\pYeY@«Ri[@t§¢$�3U'`�V._yh~Uw]ERTcqU�Z \p_eOWV�Mb[.U'U�OPU'cdc't 5"3�IJE �a7�7�E ��� � �ih ³� ¯~¯ � � �~¯s�3®� p¤Bt

­y®°�+±�PtA£w\pY^Y'«Ri[@t� 5"3i<@R*7�5"O�j�[lB�z82DCqR*7��aO ?A2 : B�5"<^\���5"B�<^2�3k<^2DC �Th~\pY^NPS&UF¤~��\pM � B@?A2 : 7!<UCZCs2 9l2�B 583�IJ2KNg5"3k<Ub[�7�9]<UIlB�2�B� B�2K7��?A2 : <^2�3>2 t�ªAZP[._eOPgpU�[@�=®� �Bt

­y®J¤i±�Pt3£w\pY^Y'«Ri[@t�ªs_^OPgpNPYbRi[d_eV._eU'ck\pMjZERT_e[dc't��µO �aO ?A2 : B 5"<^\q?A2ZR"N]2�3kBDP�� � 5"7!3@5�j�BD[ ������� �IZERTgpU'cw�p�s® �B� �m&stL}S&U�['tP¬"RiVdo0t3ªs\A`Tt^� � [.\°hs_^QPU'OP`�UT� ���³�8®� m&st

­y®shT±�PtI£�\pYeY@«Ri[�U�VkRTY�t§��Y^_eZIc�RTOPQ�Ri]INPOPQIRTOP`'U�M:\T[}RTY^gpUl]P[XRT_^`V.oB[.U'U�M:\pY^QPc't �YCD3 �2�B�<UC �K[!2 �E�s®p®p�0®� ~�stJ

Page 29: Ptmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/tigers.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · RTOP\|hiRi[._^U Vd_^U'c \pM5 B BU'Q QP_^SU'OPcd_^\pOM:\T[.S R ] \pNPOPQPU QM RTS&_^Yyf~t ² OPU[.U@RTcd\pO M:\T[ M:\s`'NPcd_eOPg\pO

­y®°¯+±�Ptm£w\pY^Y@«Ri['�$��tm¬�_efWRT\T�iRB�mRTOPQ ª3tm¬�\T[._©t �kRiV._e\pOIRTYF`'\pOPOPU�`�V.U'QPOPU'cqc�RTOPQ ]3\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cdc�\pM���RTOP\S�RTOP_eM:\pY^QPc't ��E �q< � E � 2ZR*NgE �I¤ �B� &�~¯ �0&{&B� ®� ~�st

­y®��i±�Pt�£w\pY^Y'«Ri[@�P��t�¬�_efWRT\T�iRB�3ª3t�¬�\T[._��3RTOPQ�¶at�ujRi�TRTgp_�t(+r\pNPOPQPU'QPOPU'cdc\pM�`@RTOP\pOP_e`@RTY � � �§RTOP\�¤+� M:\pY^QPc�t� B�R \sE �05ZX�5"7 � \�5m9mE � 2KBFE � 5"3iI0E � \�<kE �!&� � ¯ l� &T¤��0&{&s�P�� � �Bt

­y®�&+±�PtB£w\pY^Y@«Ri[rRTOPQ�ª3tB¬�\T[._�t�� <-B�5"3i<@R*7�5"O�?A2ZR*Nf2�3iB�PfR>Lq5"O ?l2 : B 58<^\Yz"5"BD<@2�3i<@2DC �~h~\pY^NPS&U�®J¤8h�\pM jM5"N : BD<k9�?A23kB 5A\�3iCc<-7�Ng5"3iIJ2�Ng5"3k<^\DC t��vRTS�]P[d_^QPgpU � OP_eh~U�[.cq_eVzf � [.U�cdc'�=®� �Bt

­y®��i±�Pt � _eO0te+r_e[.RiV._^\pOIRTY NPO~] \pNPOPQPU�QPOPU'cdc\pM D � �3RTOP\�V.oB[.U�U'M:\pY^QPc'�3Ri[ � _eh3�¦S�RiVdo0t¦L����� �B®p®°�"hW�st

­y®�i±�Lat �RTQPU'Y�t§u�oPU] \pNPOPQPU'QPOPU�cdck\pM=QPU'gT[.U'U�\pM5�§RTOP\�hTRi[._eU�V._eU'crnF_yV.o � _^`@Ri[dQ�OWNPSa] U�[�\pOPUTt �0E �aN]2�BsE 5"3iI0E � R \ E �Jh��ih ³� � �B® � � ~�s� ®� B®pt

­¦��i± ��tC�}_e�BNPYe_^O0t�QPU'Y � UF'F''\�cqNB[.M�RT`'U'can�_eV.o�Ye\pgi� V.U�[dS&_^OIRTY§cd_eOPgpNPYbRi[._yV._^U'c�t 583@E �$: E �$®�� � � � ³� �p����B�"h~¤B�¤ �8hP�0®� � Bt

­¦�s®'±��jt �FRTO�RTOPQ�¶at8�rY^U'S�U'OPc't}L OPU�n S�U�V.oP\sQ�_eO��§RTOP\!gpU�\pS&U�Vd[df~t � 7�3>2�BD7�583@E 5"3iI0E 2�CFE � R*3k<^\Z2DC ��½®�� l� ¯p�{& �B¯"h B�P�� � �Bt

������ ���������������������������! "��#�� %$'&(���# ")���*�# "+-,� /.102�"+43'���" 5+6 879$&;:<�=/+>&!$'���"+6�?�# A@8���� B�?CD��"EF��G�H.

@8���� B�ICD��"EF��G�H.J:DKML�N"O/PFQ

RTSVUXWZY-[\WB]B]Z^`_�aba/ced�fhgBi/jhk#lhkBm�d#l�npoHqsr�f!t�uHqvi/w�r

J �