Patent Trial and Appeal Board Boardside Chat: AIA Motions ...
Marvell Patent Appeal
of 18
-
Upload
jeffroberts881 -
Category
Documents
-
view
241 -
download
0
Transcript of Marvell Patent Appeal
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
1/46
!"#$%& ($)$%* +,-.$ ,/ 011%)2*
/,. $3% 4%&%.)2 +#.5-#$ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
#$%&'()' *'++,& -&).'%/)012 !"#$%&$''()**+""++
34
*$%.'++ 0'#5&,+,(1 (%,-62 +0742
*$%.'++ /'*)#,&7-#0,%2 )* ,+'+%-#%&.()**+""#%&. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"#$%&$%'" !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
())*+, -./0 12* 3451*6 71+1*8 9581.5:1 ;/*448?,@+45+ 54 A/B "C#'&:@#"'#&ADEF G
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
2/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"
+))*,,+418B (,8/ .*).*8*41*6 U? J9=(M9 GB 9JEM(A;KFGK7J>L WVRK=V;F VVVF ;RJR(A9 DB =JRYKAF VVX 737(A
M (;LJR J7YMV;LF WV;L(JR YLKW(7 OJRRJMF R/8 (4H*,*8F;(X N J[VA >BDB GKLA7KAF M*6S//6 72/.*8F ;(X 9JMJN
7L(EEJMF =+8254H1/4F 9;X MKT = (AZF W+.@*,, 7*05:/4&6+:P+.6 ;/0)+4?F =+?4*F >(F-/. +05:JYJMW(AF 9*,, V4:BF M/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
3/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`
(,8/ .*).*8*41*6 U? =VRRV(W WB G (T F =+8254H1/4F 9;X
9 ([V9 OVWWJMF 7+4 E.+4:58:/F ;(B
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
D*-/.* = (RR(;LF Y (M(AYKF +46 ;LJAF /$012$& 42-5+.6
Y (M(AYK7 /$012$& 42-5+6
;+.4*H5* W*,,/4 345@*.851? ab;W3cd 8
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
4/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%
*_1*41 /- f"gjF%#kF#%IBI# 54 )+81 ./?+,15*8 aI# :*418 -/.*+:2 /- 12* IIkFj$"F#'$ :25)8 12* e
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
5/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
I
65--*.8 -./0d 12* /.5*41+15/4 /- 12* 4*_1 0+H4*15: .*H5/454 ,54* +8 /4* 0/@*8 54 + )+.15:
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
6/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
k
:+41 S2*4 12* 85m* /- 12* 0+H4*15: .*H5/48 82.54P8 U*,/S:*.1+54 ,*@*,8B 8++ GB(B ""$# a85H4+, 6581/.15/4 /::
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
7/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
g
a$6+6F 5- 12* 8*]
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
8/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
j
/- 12* 0*12/6 0
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
9/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
'
%B ( 0*12/6 /- 6*1*.05454H U.+4:2 0*1.5: @+,
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
10/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$#
V4 "##'F ;W3 8
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
11/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$$
0*41 +8 + 0+11*. /- ,+S 6* 4/@/ +46 0
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
12/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$"
81.
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
13/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$`
15/4 .*]
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
14/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$%
4/58* 81+46+.6 6*@5+15/4Bc >-6 :/,B $#F ,54*8 I%nIkBabY.+48515/4c 2*.* .*-*.8 1/ + :2+4H* 54 0+H4*15: )/,+.51?F
+8 05H21 /::
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
15/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$I
12* -
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
16/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$k
aWA>d +46 J42+4:*6 W*65+ A/58* >./:*88/. aJWA>d6*85H48 54-.54H*8 ;W3h8 )+1*41 :,+508i)./6
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
17/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$g
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
18/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$j
-/. *@*.? U.+4:2 /- + 1.*,,58B A/. 58 12* *@56*4:* 0+6*548
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
19/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
$'
:+.*-
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
20/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"#
15/48 )./:*88 b6+1+ -5,*8 a:/)5*8 /- +:1
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
21/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"$
VV
W+.@*,,h8 .*0+5454H +.H
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
22/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
""
V1 -/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
23/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"`
:/4:,
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
24/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"%
EB`6 gg#F ggI aE*6B ;5.B $''Id aboYp2* 6581.5:1 :/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
25/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"I
8+0:.67 BB/ :6 /$&0$T 8O.67 >%16F gk' EB`6 $#g`F $#'#n'$aE*6B ;5.B "#$%dB D
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
26/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"k
)*.8 54 12*5. :25)8 +46 850
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
27/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"g
U#*"#%F gj' EB"6 $Ig%F $Iggngj aE*6B ;5.B $'jkdX )HHV$+>%16 :6 ?#&F$"-# K M+0+%1+ U+%%+-O >%.&6 9' GF+2D#&9"95O
M02.&F gk% EB`6 $`kkF $`g' aE*6B ;5.B "#$%dB Y2
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
28/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"j
4/@/ .*@5*S /- /Ue*:15@* .*+8/4+U,*4*88 +8 + ,*H+, 0+11*.
U+8*6 /4 %16 :6?+-&09%$1 89'#D90 ,#%+A7 >%16F Ikg EB`6 $`$%F $``k aE*6B
;5.B "##'dB
Y2* 6581.5:1 :/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
29/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
"'
658+H.**8B V- W+.@*,, 12/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
30/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`#
:/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
31/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`$
W8B R+S1/4 6/*8 4/1 2+@* + >2B9B /. + 1.+6515/4+, +:&
+6*05: +))/5410*41F U
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
32/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`"
:#%& F+0+ HO E$""$#D.9% :6 /$&0$T P%"$%+7 BB/ F A/B "#$`&$$`#F "#$I =R `kjg%I'F +1 sk aE*6B ;5.B G
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
33/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
``
:/4856*.54H 12* U*4*-518 51 S/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
34/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`%
1*.08F + )*.&
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
35/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`I
0*41 0*:2+4580 S51254 12* :/4-54*8 /- 12* 2?)/12*15:+,
4*H/15+15/4 2*.*B
Y2*.* +,8/ S+8 +0),* *@56*4:* 12+1 I# :*418 S+8 +4+))./).5+1* +0/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
36/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`k
1.5:1 :/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
37/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`g
/-1*4 05H21 U* +U,* 1/ +)),? 12*5. ,+S8 1/ :,/8*,? .*,+1*6+8)*:18 /- S2+1 +0/
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
38/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`j
548581 12+1 12* +:15/4 .*8)*:154H 12* )./6%16 :6 BN ="+1&09%$1.7>%16F II` 3B7B k$g a"##jd a+)),?54H *_2+
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
39/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
`'
).&0#W+%+1#F gj" EB`6 +1 $``%n`IX E#0.#Q P0&F9*+-$17>%16 :6 Z2V#.$:+7 >%16F ggj EB`6 $`kIF $`gg aE*6B ;5.B
"#$IdB D
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
40/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%#
3451*6 71+1*8Bc W+.@*,, K)*454H D.B I"X $-6 +1 II ab1/1+,8+,*8 +.* +4 50)*.05885U,* 0*+8
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
41/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%$
54:,
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
42/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%"
S512 12* +:15@515*8 12+1 /::
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
43/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%`
12+1 W+.@*,, U* 8*,*:1*6 +8 12* .*+6 :25) :2+44*, 8
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
44/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%%
:
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
45/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%I
.*@5*S 81+46+.68 1/ -546 12* /05885/4 *../4*/%16 :6 Z+Q [90A M$D+. /96F %"% EB`6 ``kF``'n%# a`6 ;5.B "##Id ab=2*.* + )+.1? -+5,8 1/ /Ue*:1)./)*.,?F S* 0+? .*@5*S -/. t),+54 *../. 54 12* 5481.
-
8/20/2019 Marvell Patent Appeal
46/46
;(MAJZVJ WJRRKA 3AV[JM7VYT @B W(M[JRR YJ;LAKRKZT
ZMK3>F RY9
%k
54H8 5- 12* *../. 81+468 -6 +1 `%#n%$ a54&1*.4+, ]
