Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W....

39
Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu, F. Wolfs BSA Lecture Committee Particle Data Group http://ParticleAdventure.org/

Transcript of Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W....

Page 1: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

What have we learned from RHIC?

Mark D. BakerChemistry Department

Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo,

P. Steinberg, N. Xu, F. Wolfs BSA Lecture Committee

Particle Data Group http://ParticleAdventure.org/

Page 2: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Some of the people

Page 3: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Where they come from • BNL

– Chemistry, Collider-Accelerator, Physics

• >1000 people from around the world– Brazil, Canada, China, Croatia, Denmark, France,

Germany, India, Israel, Japan, Korea, Norway, Poland, Russia, Sweden, Taiwan, UK, US

Page 4: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

What is the universe made of?&

What holds it together?

Page 5: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

What is the universe made of?

Placeholder

Page 6: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

What holds it together?:The Fundamental Forces

Page 7: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Let’s smash some atoms!

+ -

-

u

u u u u u

d

u d u du du d

proton

proton

pion ()

uud

Page 8: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

If you can’t smash it, heat it!

Temperature

Plasma

+

---

-+

Pressure

Page 9: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Sideways slide - How much heat?

Placeholder

Page 10: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Heat is also a window back in time

Page 11: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

How do we get to 2 trillion oK?

Collide Gold nuclei at 99.99% of the speed of light

But: Will these fast violent collisions teach us anything?

10-23 seconds, 10-38 liters

Page 12: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

The plan of attack

• Collide gold nuclei at high energy– Collider, detectors, computers

• Understand the collision dynamics– Collective motion, equilibrium– Temperature, density

• Learn about the strong interaction– Quark-Gluon Plasma– Confinement

Page 13: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Where?

Page 14: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Inside the tunnel

Page 15: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

STARSTAR

Page 16: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

RHIC Computing Facility

The detectors can take 7 Gigabytes of data / minute!

Page 17: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

First Collisions

Page 18: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Timeline

CollisionsDelivered

Star & Phobos

Brahms & Phenix

|-----June------|-----July------|----August----|--September--|---October---|---November--| 2000

sNN = 130 GeV

Au-Au

|-December--|--January---|--February--|----March----|-----April-----|

(PHOBOS)

(STAR) (PHENIX)

1st Collisions

Papers (PHENIX)(BRAHMS)(PHOBOS)

(STAR)

Title:

Creator:qcdisplay2.2 Contact [email protected]:This EPS picture was not savedwith a preview included in it.Comment:This EPS picture will print to aPostScript printer, but not toother types of printers.

Papers

Page 19: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Looking for collective effects...

Is Gold+Gold > 197 * Proton+Proton?

Page 20: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

AuAu @ RHIC is something new!

PHOBOS

CERN/SPS

Energy/nucleon (GeV)

Produced Particles/Participating Nucleon Pair

ppPHENIX

BRAHMSprelim.

PRL 85 (2000) 3100

Page 21: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

How many produced particles?

Measured # in ahead-on collision:

4100±410

(Simulation)

PHOBOS Preliminary

Page 22: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Elliptic Flow: A collective effect

dN/d(R ) = N0 (1 + 2V1cos (R) + 2V2cos (2(R)) + ... )

Elliptic flow

Beam’s eye view of anon-central collision:

Asymmetric particle distribution:

Particles prefer to be “in-

plane”

Page 23: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Elliptic Flow Expectations

Hydrodynamic model

V2

Normalized Multiplicity

midrapidity : || < 1.0

Preliminary

Particle asymmetry

No collective motion

Hydrodynamic “Flow”

Page 24: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Elliptic Flow

Hydrodynamic model

V2

Normalized Multiplicity

midrapidity : || < 1.0

Preliminary

PRL 86 (2001) 402Particle asymmetry

Page 25: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Collective motion largest at RHIC

STAR, PRL 86 (2001) 402

Page 26: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

It even makes sense in detail

Huovinen, Kolb, Heinz

Particle asymmetry

Page 27: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Plan of attack - where are we?

• Collide gold nuclei at high energy– Collider, detectors, computers

• Understand the collision dynamics– Collective motion, equilibrium

– Temperature, density• Learn about the strong interaction

– Quark-Gluon Plasma

– Confinement

Page 28: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

We see the conditions at freezeout(a lower limit to the maximum Temperature)

FreezeoutHottest period

RT

1

Expansion cooling

Page 29: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Separating Temperature & Expansion

2

2

22

3

c

vmT

N

E

Compare produced particles with different masses!

2

2

. 3c

vmTTeff

Effective Temperature

mass

Page 30: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

1.7 1012 oK

RHIC shows rapid expansion& a high temperature

!3

2

c

vEffectiveTemperature(GeV)

CERN NA49

STAR Preliminary

Page 31: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Another thermometer

In an equilibrium system, twoparameters are sufficient to predict the “chemical” mix:

(# pions) / (# protons)(# kaons) / (# pions)(# anti-protons)/(# protons) et cetera.

Temperature (T)and “net amount of matter” (B)

Page 32: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Temperature from particle ratios

T = (2.2+0.2) 1012 oK-

STAR Preliminary

23

64

1,5,7

)/( 1. hhK

pp / 2.

KK / 4.

/ 3.

hK / 5. *0

/ 6./ 7. p

Page 33: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Temperature at Freezeout

• Chemical: T = (2.2+0.2) 1012 oK• Kinetic: T = (1.7+0.4) 1012 oK

• We did reach ~ 2 trillion K!

--

Page 34: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

The yields are compared to predictions by Hijing.The SPS data values from NA44, NA49 are plotted as reference.The ~3 measurement converted to y using the accepted mean pt.

Page 35: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

What happens before freeze-out?•Energetic particles come from quark or gluon “jets”.•They interact with the dense medium, but can’t thermalize.•Jet energy loss (“quenching”) is predicted.•Jet quenching measures the density early in the collision.

pion

Page 36: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Jet quenching at RHIC?

Neutral pionsCentral collisions

No quenching

Number

Transverse Momentum (GeV/c)

Neutral pions Peripheral collisions

Quenching

Transverse Momentum (GeV/c)

Preliminary

Page 37: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

More on jet quenching

Details need to be understood before conclusions can be drawn.

Page 38: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Summary

• We’ve learned a lot about the system– We have reached ~2 trillion degrees K– The system is expanding rapidly.– It was probably even hotter and denser

• Possible first evidence of jet quenching!– Should lead to a measure of the density

• No conclusions yet about the strong force.

Page 39: Mark D. Baker What have we learned from RHIC? Mark D. Baker Chemistry Department Thanks to: W. Busza, Axel Drees, J. Katzy, B. Lugo, P. Steinberg, N. Xu,

Mark D. Baker

Outlook

• More analysis• More data (x100 next run)

– Allows new early time probes

• More variety of data– Energy and species scan

• Detector Upgrades

It’s going to get even better!

Stay tuned for news about the strong force!