Margin Enhancement Services to Healthcare Sector · 2020-05-15 · PKC Advisory 4 Planning and...
Transcript of Margin Enhancement Services to Healthcare Sector · 2020-05-15 · PKC Advisory 4 Planning and...
Confidential
Margin Enhancement Services to
Healthcare Sector
2PKC Advisory
Overview
Global health care expenditures continue
to escalate, shining a light on health
systems’ need to reduce costs and
increase efficiency
Global healthcare spending is
projected to increase at an annual rate of
5.4% during 2017–2022, from USD
$7.724 trillion to USD $10.059
trillion
Healthcare spending will likely be driven by
the shared factors of aging and
growing populations, developing
market expansion, clinical and
technology advances, and rising
labor costs
Healthcare spending in the Middle East
and Africa region is projected to
increase from USD $196 billion in
2017 to USD $279 billion in 2022
Current ScenarioWhy Healthcare
Advisory?
Key Challenges faced by Healthcare Sector
Recruiting, developing,
and retaining top talent
Creating financial
sustainability in an
uncertain health economy
Investing in digital
innovation and
transformation
Maintaining regulatory
compliance and
cybersecurityUsing new care delivery
models to improve
access & affordability and
reduce costs
Adapting to changing
consumer needs, demands,
and expectations
Our services to healthcare providers are aimed at assisting our clients to drive
continuous cost savings, streamlining activities, standardizing processes,
enhancing transparency and mitigating related risks
Source – Deloitte 2019 Global Health Care Outlook
3PKC Advisory
Our Service Offerings
Pool of
Subject Matter
Experts
Handholding
beyond
Delivery
Customer
Centric
Deep
Industry
Experience
Mix of
Offshore and
Onshore
Delivery Model
Tools and
Best
Practices
Our
Strengths
Our service offerings are designed to provide the most effective and tailored solutions to our healthcare clients driving
organizational development, reduction in costs and increase in profit margins.
Analyze spending and exploit cost saving
opportunities to drive sustainable and long
term savings
Planning and
Budgeting
Streamline planning and budgeting exercise
of the client to develop a comprehensive
business plan
Formulate pricing strategy and develop a
price and package master for the
services rendered
Price Master
Development
Cost AnalysisService
Offerings
4PKC Advisory
Planning and Budgeting Services
Our Impact StoriesWe understand the challenges faced by healthcare service providers in aligning their vision
with their business plan and budget. We assist them in developing a detailed business plan
and budget document to help them gain control of their finances.
Our Value
Proposition Developed capacity utilization strategy by
co-relating bed-nights with OT time. Resulted in
additional revenue of ~USD 18.8 million per
annum for a 300-bed hospital in India
Developed business plan and strategy for
opening interventional radiology to take advantage
of existing Cath lab facilities. Resulted in additional
revenues of ~USD 2.1 million per annum for a
500-bed hospital in India
Applied zero-based budgeting for rationalizing
consumables in cardio thoracic surgeries. Resulted
in saving of ~USD 142 thousand per annum for
a leading 300-bed heart specialty clinic in India
Developed strategy for home care facilities
and conducted detailed budgeting exercisefor a 900-bed medical college and hospital in India.
Resulted in additional gross revenue and
EBIDA with same fixed expenses
Our Approach
Significant saving of management time
Intuitive data presentation
Improved resource allocation
Improved decision making
Increased transparency
Key Benefits
▪ Obtain detailed understanding
of the healthcare unit
▪ Collect data
Assessment
▪ Study the existing set-up
and capacity utilization
▪ Build suitable strategies
Analysis &
Estimation
▪ Develop a three year business
plan with estimates
▪ Prepare development plan for:
- specific medical specialties
-outreach centers
-home care centers
-diagnostic centers
Development of
Business Plan
▪ Deploy “Zero-Based
Budgeting” concept
▪ Develop the budget
document to include:
-Departmental budgets
-EBIDTA statements
-Cash flow statements
-MIS at hospital & dept. level
-Tool for variance analysis
Development
of Budget
▪ Deliver the business plan
and budget to the
management
▪ Train internal
resources for
future budget
preparations
Training &
Implementation
5PKC Advisory
Cost Analysis Services
Our Impact StoriesOur Value
PropositionWe assist our healthcare clients in developing management tools to identify cost saving
opportunities and design a dashboard for its continuous monitoring.Re-designed service prices based on capacity and cost analysis. Resulted in additional
contribution of USD 2.8 million per annum for a 350-bed hospital in India
Developed standard inventory packs for surgeries in
OT complex. Resulted in 5% savings (USD 1.3 million) for a leading hospital chain in India
Conducted cost analysis and suggestedoutsourcing of centralized lab of a 500-bed hospitalin India. Resulted in increase in net margin from
18% to 32%
Renegotiated with payers on high risk surgeries.Resulted in an increase in price and margin by
about 5% (approx. USD 2.1 million) for a500-bed hospital in India
Implemented consignment inventorymethod with vendors. Resulted in stock reduction
by 25% for a 900-bed medical college and hospitalin India
Assess
▪ Categorize costs using 3Me methodology
▪ Calculate Cost to Capacity for each
resource by applying Activity-based Costing
Enforce
▪ Develop monitoring benchmarks
▪ Help decide action plans
▪ Design dashboards
Discover
▪ Identify and map the clinical
processes and resources
▪ Identify costs at each level
Analyze
▪ Compare profitability
▪ Identify under-utilized resource capacity
Our Approach
Identify
▪ True margins
▪ Total costs of services
▪ Capacity utilization
▪ Recovery rates
▪ Volume levels to generate surplus
Analyze and Understand
▪ Cost reduction opportunities
▪ Package profitability
▪ Medical department wise profitability
▪ Consultant wise costs and surplus
Monitor and Decide
▪ A pricing strategy
▪ Benchmarks for monitoring
▪ Deviations from recovery rates
▪ Decision to outsource expenses
Key Benefits
6PKC Advisory
Price Master Development Services
Our Impact StoriesWe understand that for healthcare service providers revenue cycle management is bothcomplex and important. We assist our healthcare clients to design a price master suchthat same services can be rendered at multiple points at different prices.
Our Value
Proposition
Design
▪ Department-wise, Bed
Category-wise Price Master
▪ Premium & Package Pricing
including exclusions
▪ Category-wise variations
▪ Billing rules
Deliver and Implement
▪ Handover and training of
internal resources
▪ Implementation and
configuration support
▪ Discussion with key Head
of Departments and Senior
Management
▪ Review of relevant HMS
modules
Review and Analyze
Developed a pricing tool for a 500-bed hospital
in India. Resulted in savings of 8% of the gross
revenue through prevention of short billing and non-
billing
Enabled standardisation of package price.
Resulted in handling higher volume of patients
and higher utilisation of beds & OT for a 500-
bed hospital based in India
Developed Standardized price book that
enabled better negotiation, lower disallowances and
faster realisation from payers. Resulted in savings
of USD 1.4 million per annum for a 900-bed
medical college and hospital in India
Designed and implemented complete
automation of pricing of different services for
multiple hospital chains based in India. This resulted
in better realisation per unit service
Performed price adjustment for premium
services for a 500-bed Hospital
Structured pricing across healthcare units
Decline in potential revenue leakage
Increased control on prices
Simplified revenue management
Our Approach
Key Benefits
7PKC Advisory
Credentials
About PKC Advisory
Our Esteemed Clients
Case Studies
Team Profiles
8PKC Advisory
About PKC Advisory
9PKC Advisory
Our Esteemed Clients
10PKC Advisory
Case Studies
Performed Market Study and prepared Business Plan for hiving-off facility management division of a hospital chain
into a separate venture in India
▪ We carried out a comprehensive study of the following:
1) Expansion plans of the chain
2) Assessment of opportunities with existing hospitals in the region
3) Assessment of new hospital projects in the region
4) Extending house keeping and maintenance services to other industries
5) Creating a dedicated team and retaining
6) Bringing an international player as Joint Venture (JV) partner to maintain international standards
7) Consider listing the shares based on ROI and growth prospects
▪ Technology, Training, Compliance & Patient Safety (TTCP) were taken as core factors for the business model. A detailed gap
analysis was done in the market. Based on the gap analysis, we developed a business plan for spinning off the facility
management as a separate business venture, mapping market strategy, strategic roadmap, corporate structure, broad
implementation plan and financial projections.
The objective of the assignment was to evaluate the profitability of hiving of facility management of the hospital chain across
India and present a business plan with milestones. Facility Management included: House Keeping & Infection Control, Security
Services and Maintenance Services including Bio-Medical Engineering ServicesOverview
Objective
Approach
Value Added
01
02
03
04
Case 1
Market Study
and Business
Plan
▪ The management was able to leverage the investment made in TTCP by serving the other players in the market. It was able to
unlock the value available within the group. The group turnover as well as the EBIDTA moved up substantially
▪ The hospital chain was able to bring an international partner. The increase in contribution to the bottom line due to higher
levels of efficiency in services was around 8-10%
▪ The business plan was the basis on which Client assessed the financial and operational viability of this venture
▪ Ultimately the otherwise high cost of bringing in an international training partner was saved in the form of a JV as well as the
cost of training could be defrayed among the clients outside of the chain too.
11PKC Advisory
Case Studies
Prepared Business Plan for separation of pharmacy business of a regional hospital chain with about 6 branches in
South India
▪ We carried out a financial assessment and prepared a detailed business plan with the following core objectives
1) Improving margins through aggregation
2) Expanding into retail pharmacy (Stand Alone Pharmacy (SAP)) - Direct Sale to Customers (D2C)
3) Retaining margin in existing B2B segment through outsourcing
4) Reduction in inventory levels, wastages and expiry drugs
5) Overall margin in Pharmacy turnover including SAPs to be achieved at 15% ROCE
6) SAP to give a margin of 3-4%
▪ The business plan had to include the details of year-wise plan for opening new stores with locations and time frame to become
a matured store with standard turnover and margin.
The client wanted to separate the pharmacy business to improve the margin and grow a retail chain of pharmaciesOverview
Objective
Approach
Value Added
01
02
03
04
Case 2
Business
Plan
▪ The management was provided with a road map to achieve following metrics in business:
1) Blueprint for expanding SAP location-wise and year-wise
2) Data driven store expansion resulting in fewer closures
3) Back-end supply chain with well established distribution network
4) Measure conversion of prescriptions
5) Promoting private labels wherever possible to improve margin without compromising on clinical quality (6-10% of turnover)
6) Close monitoring of progress of new stores to matured stores
7) Standard practices across stores resulting in ease of scaling up and control operations and finance
8) Integrated customer loyalty program
9) Year wise growth for 4 - 5 years in top line and bottom line after initial gestation period of 18 months.
12PKC Advisory
Case Studies
Performed Zero-Based Budgeting for a 500-bed super specialty hospital with multiple referral centers in India
▪ We carried out a financial assessment and interacted with all the departments and management to achieve the following
objectives:
1) Develop a vision and growth strategy by working with the management team. The major objective was to double the
revenues and achieve an EBIDTA of 22-26% in four years
2) Identify patient segments and launch digital relationship for improving brand recall as well as retail revenue
3) Differentiate services in to Premium, Normal and Standard. This helped to develop different strategies depending on
competitive landscape and set achievable goals for growth and plan resources accordingly
4) Develop overall hospital budget and medical department-wise budgets, estimating the revenues and expenses as if the
departments are launched afresh
5) Set up targets for top consultants in consultation with them according to the capacity and resources available/ required with/
by them
6) Rationalize material consumption and overheads according to the activity level
7) Plan marketing department targets, B2B network, referral centers, city centers and branch level plans
▪ The Zero Budget approach helped to relook at marketing and operations from ground level and connect to overall growth plans.
The client had a situation of flat revenue levels for the past three years and declining margins. The client wanted to identify
growth levers, set achievable targets for underperforming medical departments and consultants, identify underutilized medical
assets and rationalize costs at every departmentOverview
Objective
Approach
Value Added
01
02
03
04
Case 3
Planning and
Budgeting
▪ The management was provided with a detailed budget at hospital level, department level, fresh investments required and
release under utilized capacity as well as set efficiency norms for all expenses
1) An immediate growth of 20% was possible from revenues of USD 1.7 million to USD 2.1 million per month
2) Interventional radiology and liver transplant were established as premium services for 30% growth from second year
onwards. Both ICU and Cath lab could be utilized better
3) Material consumption was controlled in consultation with doctors and a saving of 12% on USD 0.6 million was achieved
4) Average Revenue per Operating Bed per day was increased from USD 195 per bed per day to USD 237 per bed per day.
13PKC Advisory
Case Studies
Performed Cost Analysis for a 300-bed Super Specialty hospital with multiple referral centers and an OT complex with
6 theaters including a dedicated Cardiac as well as Ophthalmology theater
▪ We carried out costing of services using Time Driven Activity-Based Costing (TDABC) method (endorsed by Harvard Business
School) to arrive at the cost of Inpatient, Outpatient and Day Care services in the hospital.
1) Develop a Detailed Template for capturing data for each department (both medical & non-medical) with all costs grouped in
to five drivers – Manpower, Materials, Machinery, Expenses and Utilities
2) Fix Capacity limits and Units of costs for various resources and arrive at standard time spent by the resources with each
clinical and non-clinical activities of the patient
3) Group all departments into medical support and service departments
4) Allocate Costs to all patient related activities based on the allocation parameters developed for each department whether
medical or support
5) Arrive at Cost per Surgery, Cost per day per bed for medical admissions, Cost per procedure and Cost per patient for
Outpatient Services
6) Fix Standard Recovery Rate for all key surgeries and procedures and arrive at cost per test/ procedure for lab and radiology
7) Fix inventory levels for the OT complex, reduce the cost of materials and develop inventory packages for surgeries
8) Rationalize manpower costs and increase manpower capacity by task shifting at all levels. This contributes to increase in
margin in fixed reimbursement tied to clinical outcomes.
The Ophthalmology Theater and three general theaters were operating at 40% capacity and bed utilization was at 57%. The
client wanted to understand cost of services including the cost per surgery department wise, OT utilization, material
consumption of surgeries, expense levels according to bed capacity utilizationOverview
Objective
Approach
Value Added
01
02
03
04
Case 4
Costing
▪ An immediate savings of 5% on revenue of base of USD 2.1 million per month due to savings in consumption of materials by
15%
▪ Ophthalmology OT capacity was increased with additional surgeries from 2 per day to 8 per day with fixed cost remaining the
same and revenue per surgery being reduced to generate demand. This led to an increase in revenue from USD 84 thousand
to USD 222 thousand per month based on 20 working days
▪ Higher utilization of other OT could be achieved with least increase in manpower cost with task shifting and training. This led to
a saving of 8% in manpower cost which was brought down from 28% to 22% of the revenue
▪ Break-even Point for number of beds to be occupied and number of surgeries per day for the theaters were identified.
14PKC Advisory
Case Studies
Carried out OT Costing for a 1400-bed Multi Specialty hospital attached to a medical collage hospital in Karnataka,
India
▪ We carried out costing of surgeries using Marginal Costing method to arrive at break-even point, capacity utilization and cost
per surgery for additional number of surgeries to fix a flexible pricing for additional number of surgeries
1) Average Revenue and Cost per surgery was arrived at
2) Based on detailed discussions with OT team as well as analysis of OT records, utilization of each theater was determined
3) Break Even Point in terms of number of surgeries was identified
4) Additional number of surgeries that could be done within the existing fixed cost structure was identified
5) Manpower utilization in step with OT utilization was identified with a clear finding that additional manpower was not needed
to increase the number of surgeries
6) Reasons for underutilization were also identified.
The hospital wanted to understand revenue & cost per surgery as well as break even point. The hospital also wanted to identify
underutilization and suggest ways for improving the utilization to increase the net revenueOverview
Objective
Approach
Value Added
01
02
03
04
Case 5
OT Costing
▪ Average OT utilization was at 57% with a scope to increase the number of surgeries by 4133 per annum. At average revenue
per surgery at USD 1123, scope to generate USD 4.6 million per annum was identified
▪ Staff and equipment capacity were available to perform the increased number
▪ Break-even point was identified at 3628 surgeries at current revenue per surgery and fixed costs
▪ Since fixed costs were not to increase, the additional contribution could be moderated to incentivize doctors from outside the
hospital to utilize the OT. This led to an increase in total revenue and margin
▪ Based on non-peak hour utilization, arrangements were made to bring in more surgeries without compromising clinical safety
and outcome.
15PKC Advisory
Case Studies
Performed Pricing for a 500-bed Super Specialty Hospital in India
▪ A complete Price Book was prepared containing prices for surgeries, procedures for Inpatient, Outpatient, Day Care &
Emergency and Trauma Care considering Premium, Standard and Normal category of medical services of the hospitals and a
comparative analysis within the competitive landscape was performed
1) Mapping different price points at multiple service points for different patient segments and payers
2) Define Surgical, diagnostic and medical package of services for different specialties in consultation with clinicians including
defining units of service for every component of service
3) Define inclusions and exclusions to packages including chargeability of use of certain equipment whether per hour or per
day
4) Defining Price Points (in consultation with clinicians) according to grades of medical event
5) Define Billing rules with levels of authorization for discounts and credits
6) Reasons for underutilization were also identified
7) Fixing categories of services in to Premium, Standard and Normal according to the strengths of the hospital in comparison
with competitors.
The Management wanted to create a proper price book covering all surgeries and procedures, package & open billing,
daycare, Trauma and Outpatient services. The management also wanted to frame billing rules and save leakages from top line
due to improper handling of pricing and billing process. Ultimately the Price Book had to be integrated into the hospital
management software
Overview
Objective
Approach
Value Added
01
02
03
04
Case 6
Pricing
▪ Revenue leakage of 6-7% due to improper billing was arrested
▪ Additional billing of exclusions brought in a revenue of 2-3%
▪ The Price Book helped in streamlining discounts saving about 2-3% of the revenue
▪ Bed Category wise Price Points for Cash/ Cashless/ Reimbursement (except for Bundled Payments) brought in additional
revenue of 5% on an average
▪ The total savings for the hospital at 450 operating beds and Average Revenue Per Operating Bed Per Day of USD 348
amounted to USD 0.6 million per month.
16PKC Advisory
Team Profiles
17PKC Advisory
S.Manivannan
Subject Matter Expert
Profile Brief
Manivannan has over 19 years of work experience in
providing healthcare management consulting and advisory
services in India.
He has worked with All India Institute of Medical Sciences
(AIIMS), Apollo Hospital Group, KLES, Belgaum, SRM
Medical College & Hospital and Star Health Insurance
Company and has done assignments related to management
audit, project review, budgeting and costing, operational and
financial review, hospital information system development and
legal compliance & reporting.
He is currently an advisor to Health Care Pricing Committee of
FICCI, New Delhi and a visiting faculty (cost accounting) at
Indian School Business (ISB), Mohali. He is also a knowledge
partner to Institute of Cost Accountants of India and Ministry of
Health in healthcare costing.
Specializations
▪ Healthcare Strategy and Management Consulting
▪ Healthcare Costing, Budgeting & Pricing
▪ Operations Management
▪ Healthcare Technology Solutions & Digital Platform
▪ Implementation Solutions
Education and Certifications
▪ Chartered Accountant, Institute of Chartered Accountants of
India
Representative experience
▪ Published a Research Paper on Healthcare Costing as knowledge partner to Federation of Indian Chamberof Commerce & Industries, New Delhi
▪ Selected more than 12 hospitals across India and adopted “Time Driven Activity-Based Costing” Modelendorsed by Harvard Business School
▪ Provided support as a knowledge partner to Institute of Cost and Works Accountants of India in releasingIndia’s first Costing Manual for Hospitals
▪ Established Costing System and Price Tool for a well known 300-bed Multi Specialty Hospital in Tamil Nadu,India
▪ Developed Zero-Based Budget for a 300-Bed hospital with budget for various medical specialties and targetsfor marketing department
▪ Developed Price Book and Standard Package Template for more than 1500 surgeries and proceduresacross 30 medical specialties for a super specialty, 500-Bed corporate hospital including Liver and RenalTransplant departments
▪ Designed, developed and implemented Hospital Management System for a 1000-bed Medical Collage andHospital based in India
▪ Carried out financial and operational reporting review of a Regional Hospital Chain based out of Tamil Nadu,India
▪ Acted as a Domain Expert to support IT solution development of a Regional Hospital Chain based out ofTamil Nadu, India
▪ Managed 800-bed Medical College and Hospital as well as its performance reporting to Board of Trustees inKarnataka, India
▪ Acted as a Chief Advisor to a leading (4th largest in India) Medical Lab Chain covering Finance, Costing,Budgeting, Supply Chain, Franchisee Management and Quality Review
▪ Worked with a leading Ophthalmology Chain in India for their first phase of expansion across South of India
▪ Conducted risk-based audits for a 400-bed Heart Specialty Centre at Mumbai, India
▪ Performed costing of Asia’s largest Trauma Care Centre based in India
18PKC Advisory
Rupesh Srivastava
Director
Profile Brief
Rupesh has a total work experience of over 15 years in
providing risk and business solutions in India and Middle East.
Prior to PKC Advisory, he has worked with KPMG in their
Governance Risk and Compliance Services Practice wherein
the work required extensive project management and
execution of risk-based assignments combining multi-
disciplinary backgrounds. His experience spans across a
spectrum of verticals including Healthcare, Hospitality,
Manufacturing, Metal & Mining, Real Estate, Retail, Insurance
and Financial Services Industry.
Rupesh leads the Process & IT Consulting practice at PKC
Advisory. He is actively involved in business development and
in managing client relationships and is also responsible for
quality review and overall delivery of the engagements.
Specializations
▪ Risk-Based Internal Audits
▪ Process Risk Consulting
▪ Model Business Processes
▪ Enterprise Risk Management
▪ Corporate Governance Solutions
Education and Certifications
▪ Chartered Accountant, The Institute of Chartered
Accountants of India
▪ MBA (Finance), NMIMS, Mumbai, India
Representative experience
▪ Led risk-based Internal Audit of Billing & Collections function covering Admission, Cancellation, Refunds,
Collections, Charge Capture, Bank-in & Sales Reconciliation, and Tariff Master Management processes for
IPD as well as OPD areas of a leading private sector healthcare chain based out of India
▪ Managed Internal Audit of Medical Records Management function of a multinational group of hospitals based
out of India
▪ Supervised process review of Sales & Marketing, and Third Party Administration functions of a leading
private sector hospital group based out of India
▪ Led Physical Verification of key assets and inventory of a leading retail pharmaceutical chain of Asia
▪ Managed process review of end-to-end Blood Bank operations for a large hospital chain of Asia covering
processes like Blood Sourcing, Screening and Quality Control, Blood Storage & Segregation, Blood
Requisition & Issuance, Consent Management, Recordkeeping, and Regulatory Compliance
▪ Handled review of operational and regulatory requirements for Narcotics Management for multiple units of a
leading healthcare service provider of Asia
▪ Led process review of Bio Medical Waste Management process for one of the leading group of hospitals in
India
▪ Managed internal audit of Housekeeping & Laundry and Food & Beverage processes for a leading hospital
chain based out of India
▪ Supervised controls testing of Finance & Accounts, HR & Admin, Engineering and Security functions for
multiple hospitals in India
▪ Led Internal Audit for end-to-end Procurement and Inventory Management function of a leading multinational
healthcare chain of Asia covering processes like Purchase Requisitioning & Ordering, Physical Storage &
Safeguarding of Stock, Handling of Regulated Stock and Vendor Managed Inventory (VMI), Inventory levels
monitoring, Receipts & Issuance, and Vendor & Item Master Management
Email : [email protected] Website : www.pkcadvisory.com