Manual Enabling Rural Innovation (ERI)
Transcript of Manual Enabling Rural Innovation (ERI)
Enabling Rural Innovation (ERI)
Record book
Goals
Planning
Farm
experiments
Store
A Simplified Manual to Participatory Agro-Enterprise Development Through the ERI Approach
3
3
Publishers
www.horizont3000.atPlot 4775, Church Rd. Off Ggaba RoadPO Box 9719Kampala, Uganda
www.triasngo.orgKiwafu Road, KansangaP.O. Box 5617Kampala, Uganda
Responsible authors• PeterVanErum,Agro-EnterpriseCoordinator,TriasUganda
• LisaAigelsperger,TechnicalAdvisor,HORIZONT3000,EastAfrica
Acknowledgements/collaboratorsThedevelopmentofthismanualwouldnothavebeenpossiblewithoutthetremendousinputfromthefollowingorganisationsandpeople:
• Hoima,MasindiandMbararaDistrictFarmersAssociations(HODFA,MADFAandMBADIFA)
– Agriculturalfieldstaff:ElisaMuchwa,FatiaAtugonza,DeusMutabatiina,LydiaMuheirwe,BarungiEstherandWanzalaDavid
• YARD(YouthAssociationforRuralDevelopment)
– EdithSifuna,JoyceBirungi
• CIAT(InternationalCenterforTropicalAgriculture)
– AmosOwamani
4 5
• HORIZONT3000
– TechnicalAdvisor:LiloMassing
• TriasUganda:
– Agro-EnterpriseAdvisors:JuliusBarigyeandRichardNsamba– OrganisationalDevelopment–InstitutionalStrengtheningAdvisor:
MirjamSsenyonga
• Guide5.5,ContractManagementandBusinessPrincipleswasbasedonmaterialsdevelopedbythenowendedBusinessServicesMarketDevelopmentProjectUganda(BSMD)initiatedandfinancedbytheBritishDepartmentForInternationalDevelopment(DFID)andmanagedbytheInternationalLabourOrganisation(ILO).
FundersTheproductionofthismanualwasfundedby:
Agriterra,TheNetherlands(www.agri-terra.org)
BTC,BelgianDevelopmentAgency,Kampala,Uganda(www.btcctb.org)
DKA(Dreikönigsaktion),Austria(www.dka.at)
www.mangotreeuganda.org1479NaalyaRoad,Kiwatule,P.O. Box 25312, Kampala, Uganda
Layout, graphic design and materials
Thismanualcanonlybereproducedwiththepermissionofthepublishers.
Mango Tree
4 5
OverviewModule 1: Planning (Participatory Diagnosis - PD)• Session1.1-Gettingstarted
• Session1.2-Visioning
• Session1.3-Identifyingwhatwehave
• Session1.4-Actionplanning
Module 2: Checking our progress (Participatory Monitoring & Evaluation – PME)• Session2.1-Basicsofmonitoring&evaluation
• Session2.2-Designofmethodsandtools
• Session2.3-Analysingourresults
• Session2.4-Evaluatingourselves
Module 3: Learning about markets (Participatory Market Research – PMR)• Session3.1-Marketingbasics
• Session3.2-Preparingformarketvisits
• Session3.3-Analysisandpreparationforfeedbackfrommarketvisits
• Session3.4-Selectinganenterprise
• Session3.5-Preparationformarketchainanalysis
• Session3.6-Marketchainanalysis:Interviews
• Session3.7-Marketchainanalysis:Businessmeeting
• Session3.8–Marketchainanalysis:Preparationforfeedback
6 7
Module 4: Farming better (Farmer Participatory Research – FPR)• Session4.1-Basicsofsustainableagriculture
• Session4.2-Designingexperiments
• Session4.3-Developingdatacollectiontools
• Session4.4-Farmerfieldday
Module 5: Developing an enterprise(Enterprise Development – ED)• Session5.1-Post-harvesthandling
• Session5.2-Businessplanning
• Session5.3–MarketIntelligence
• Session5.4–Recordkeeping
• Session5.5–Contractmanagementandbusinessprinciples
6 7
Contents1. Why this manual? --------------------------------- 9 From subsistence farming to farming as a business -------- 9
Dissemination of the ERI approach ------------------------10
2. Who is this manual for? -------------------------- 10
3. How was the manual developed? ---------------- 11Joint initiative by Trias and HORIZONT3000 --------------11
Participation of development partners --------------- 11
4. How is the manual organised? ------------------- 12Five modules ------------------------------------------------12
Training guides ----------------------------------------------14
Icons for better orientation --------------------------------15
Training tools -----------------------------------------------17
The Agabas and Mugishas ----------------------------------18
5. How to use the manual --------------------------- 19ERI principles -----------------------------------------------19
Creativity ----------------------------------------------------20
Continuous coaching ----------------------------------------21
Country-neutral ---------------------------------------------21
6. What this manual cannot offer ------------------ 21A guide to make a perfect trainer --------------------------21
Cooking recipe ----------------------------------------------22
An approach fixed in stone ---------------------------------22
Topics not covered ------------------------------------------22
8 9
7. Some practical tips ------------------------------- 23Working in teams -------------------------------------------23
Documentation and learning --------------------------------24
Facilitation techniques --------------------------------------24
Coaching tools and tips -------------------------------------27
Coaching guiding questions ---------------------------------28
8 9
1. Why this manual?From subsistence farming to farming as a business• Therationalebehindthismanualistosupportfarmersandfarmer
groupsintheirtransitionfromsubsistencefarmingtofarmingasabusiness.Thisisinmostcasesalongjourney,andtheEnablingRuralInnovation(ERI)approachgivesfarmersguidanceinthatendeavour.
• ERIisastrategicapproachthathelpssmallholderfarmerstobecomeempowered,self-reliantentrepreneurs.Basedonthemotto“producingwhatyoucansell,ratherthansellingwhatyouhaveproduced”,theapproachbalancesanincreasedmarketorientationwithinvestmentsintofoodsecurityandsustainablenaturalresourcemanagement.
• Thismanualspecificallyfocusesonparticipatoryagro-enterprisedevelopment1.OtheraspectsoftheERIapproach,suchasgroupstrengthening,foodsecurity,diversity(youth,gender,etc),HIV/AIDS,microfinance,mentoringandcoachingarenotcoveredinthismanual.Weneedtoemphasisethatthesetopicsarealsocrucialinthedevelopmentofstrongfarmergroupsandprofitableenterprises.Farmergrouptrainingsoutlinedinthismanualshouldthereforebeconductedconcurrentlywithtrainingsinthesecomplementarytopics.
• KeytotheERIapproachisthatitmotivatesfarmerstoorganisethemselvesintostronggroupsandworktowardcommongoals.Itempowersfarmerstomakeuseoftheirowncreativityandindependentlymakeinformeddecisionsonproduction,marketingandconsumption.Asmuchasthemanualisstructuredintrainingsessions,theaimofthemanualisthateventuallyfarmergroupsgothroughthesameprocessesindependentlywithouttheguidanceofafacilitator.Farmersaretrainedinenterpriseselectionandwillusethesameprincipleslongafterthefacilitatorhasleft.ERIwillhavechangedthefarmers’thinking.
1 BasedontheprinciplesandideasofEnablingRuralInnovationGuide2,AMarketFacilitator’sGuidetoParticipatoryAgro-EnterpriseDevelopment,CIAT,2006
10 11
2. Who is this manual for? • Themanualismeantforfacilitators,trainersordevelopmentworkers
workingwithruralfarmingcommunitiesthatwanttoengageinfarmingasabusinesssuccessfully.Inparticular,itaddressesfacilitatorswhohavenoorlimitedexperienceinERIbuthavebeenorarebeingtrainedinitsbasicconceptandprinciples.FacilitatorswillnotbecapabletousethemanualproperlyiftheyhavenoknowledgeatallaboutERI.FacilitatorswithalotofexperienceinERImightusethemanualasaguidingtool.
• Themanualdoesnotaddresstheneedsoffacilitatorswhoareinterestedinquicksolutions.Itrathercallsforfacilitatorswhohaveanauthenticinterestinparticipatoryapproaches,andwhotrulywanttocontributetodevelopingfarmers’capacityforself-help.
• ThemanualprovidesguidancetofacilitatorsmainlyintheimplementationandfacilitationofERIprocesses.Itdescribesprocessesthateventuallyactivatefarmerstomobilisetheirownstrengths,resourcesandopportunities.Themanualaddressesfacilitatorsasbothtechnicaladvisorsaswellascatalystsofprocesses.
Dissemination of the ERI approach• TheERIapproachhasbeendevelopedandtestedinEastAfricaover
severalyears2.AlthoughERIisnotasilverbullettoalldevelopmentchallenges,ithasproventobeapromisingstrategyfortheempowermentofruralfarmingcommunities.WeareconvincedthatthroughapplyingtheERIapproachandphilosophybehindit,wecanmakeadifferenceinruraldevelopment.
• Inthepastyears,awealthofpracticalexperiencesontheapplicationoftheERIapproachhasbeencollectedbymanydevelopmentpartners.Theseexperiences,however,havesofarnotbeendocumentedinasimple,structuredway.Thismanualisanattempttocaptureexperiencesfromthegroundandmaketheapproachmoreapplicableforabroaderrangeofdevelopmentorganisationswhodirectlyworkwithfarmers.
• Intheend,wehopetocontributetothedisseminationoftheERIapproachanditsunderlyingprinciplesoftruebottom-up,participatoryandsolution-focuseddevelopment.
2 Abroadrangeofdevelopmentpartnerswereinvolved,spearheadedbytheInternationalCentreforTropicalAgriculture(CIAT).
10 11
3. How was the manual developed? Joint initiative by Trias and HORIZONT3000• TriasandHORIZONT3000supportvariouspartnerorganisationsthat
alreadyapplyorwanttoapplytheERIapproach.BothorganisationsfacedthechallengethatnoproperdocumentationonERIprocesseswasavailable.TheythereforedecidedtocombineeffortsandcomeupwiththismanualthatwillhelptoscaleouttheERIapproachwithintheirnetworks,andtoshareexperiencesbeyond.
Participation of development partners• Thedevelopmentpartnersinvolvedintheproductionofthismanual
alreadyhadseveralyearsofexperienceintrainingfarmingcommunitiesintheERIapproach.DuringthattimetheywereguidedbyvariousERIguidesdevelopedbyCIATandbroughtintopracticewiththefacilitationofTriasandHORIZONT3000.
• Thedevelopmentprocessofthismanualstartedoffwithaseriesofformalandinformaldiscussionswithdevelopmentpartnersinvolvedinresearch,trainingandoutreach.Theoutcomeofthesediscussionsweretranslatedintoafirstconceptaboutthegoals,structureandcontentofthemanual.
• Inthenextstep,partnerswereinvitedtoneedsassessmentworkshops.Thepurposeoftheseworkshopswasto(1)sharepastexperienceswithERI,(2)agreeontheprocessandcontentwithineachofthefiveERImodules,and(3)toidentifychallengesthatfacilitatorsfaceintheERIimplementation.Thelatterweretranslatedintotheformulationofneedsthatfacilitatorshavetomoreeffectivelyworkandcommunicatewithfarmers.
• Themanualhasonlysometechnicalcontentthatiscrucialforincreasingfarmers’knowledgeandskillsinenterprisedevelopment,marketing,andsustainablenaturalresourcemanagement.Therefore,afacilitatorwhowantstoapplytheERIapproachshouldhaveprofoundknowledgeofenterprisedevelopment,marketing,sustainablenaturalresourcemanagementandagoodinsightintotheagriculturalsector.Thefacilitatoralsohasexcellentsoftskills,suchasteamworkabilities,groupcoachingandorganisingskills,respectandempathyforfarmers,amongothers.Foremost,thefacilitatorneedstohaveenthusiasmforhisorherworkwithruralfarmingcommunities.
12 13
• MangoTreewasconsultedtodirectlyaddressthoseneeds.TheycameupwithsuggestionsforimprovementssothatthemanualandtrainingmaterialscouldhelptoeffectivelyapplytheERIapproach.
• Throughnumerousdiscussions,meetings,consultationsandrevisionswithpartners,TriasandHORIZONT3000broughtthewealthofexperiencesintheERIapproachontopaper.
• Againwiththehelpofvariouspartners,alltrainingguidesandtrainingmaterialswerepre-testedinthefield.
• Themanualasitisnow,however,isnotyetthefinalversion.Experiencesinthecomingyearswillshowwhatworksandwhatdoesnotwork;itwillneedtoberevisedagainafterseveralyears.
4. How is the manual organised? Five modulesTheERIapproachintegratesawidespectrumofparticipatorymethodsintoaframeworkoffivecoremodules.Noneofthefivemodulesarenew,butlinkingthemintoastrategicandsystemicprocessforenablingruralinnovationisanovelty.
Particip
ator
yM
onito
ring
andEv
alua
tion
ParticipatoryMarketResearch
EnterpriseDevelopment
FarmerParticipatoryResearch
ParticipatoryDiagnosis
12 13
Themanualisorganisedintothosefivecoremodules.Foreasiercommunicationtofarmers,wedevelopedasimplifiednameforeachmoduleaswellasadistinctivedrawingthatfarmerscaneasilyremember.
1. ParticipatoryDiagnosis(Planning)
2. ParticipatoryMonitoringandEvaluation(Checkingourprogress)
Record book
GoalsPlanning
3. ParticipatoryMarketResearch(Learningaboutmarkets)
4. FarmerParticipatoryResearch(Farmingbetter)
5. EnterpriseDevelopment(Developinganenterprise)
Farm
experiments
Store
14 15
Training guides• Eachmoduleconsistsofastrategiccombinationoftrainingguides.Each
guide,inturn,comprisesasetofparticipatorymethodsandtoolstomakeeachtrainingsessionacaptivatinglearningeventforfarmers.
• Eachtrainingguideisstructuredintodifferentsections.Onthebottomofthefrontpageofeachtrainingguide,youseewhichERImodulethetrainingguidebelongsto,andwhichsession(accordingtotheoverview)it is.
ERImodule Mainmessage ProcessParticipatoryDiagnosis(PD)
Planning Farmergroupsassesswhichresourcesandopportunitiesareavailabletothem,andhowtheycanusethemtoachievetheirgoals
ParticipatoryMonitoringandEvaluation(PME)
Checkingourprogress Farmergroupskeeptrackoftheirprogresstowardachievingtheirgoalsandlearnfromsuccessesandmistakes
ParticipatoryMarketResearch(PMR)
Learningaboutmarkets Farmergroupsthemselvesconductmarketresearchtoidentifyandanalyseprofitablemarketsandenterprises
FarmerParticipatoryResearch(FPR)
Farmingbetter Farmergroupsexperimentontheirownfieldstotestwhichpractices,technologiesandvarietiesworkbestontheirfarms
EnterpriseDevelopment(ED)
Developinganenterprise Farmergroupsdevelopprofitableenterprisesandbuildsustainablebusinessrelationsbasedonthoroughbusinessplansandmarketintelligence
Module 1: PlanningSession 1 Session 3 Session 4Session 2
14 15
• The“schedule”intableformatthebeginningofeachtrainingguidegivesanoverviewofthesuggestedsectionsfortheparticulartraining.Italsoshowsanestimateofhowmuchtimegoingthrougheachsectiontakes,aswellastheoveralltimerequirementforeachsession.Pleasenotethatthesetimesareonlyestimates,andtheactualtimeyouwillneedinthefielddependsonmanyfactors(suchastheexperienceofthefacilitator,thelevelofactivityandcuriosityofparticipants,etc).
• Mostofthetrainingguidescanbecarriedoutinoneday.Again,thisdependsonmanyfactors.Thetimeagroupallocatesforasessionneedstobenegotiated.Incaseatrainingguidecannotbeimplementedaccordingtoplan,facilitatorsneedtobeflexibleandsplititinameaningfulway.
ScheduleTopic Time
1 Introduction 15minutes2 Thefacilitatingorganisation 30minutes3 TheERIprogramme 30minutes4 TheERIprocess 30minutes5 Clarifyingexpectations 30minutes6 Sessionclosing 15minutes
TOTAL 2 hours, 30 minutes
Icons for better orientationToprovidemoreguidancetothefacilitator,thetrainingguidescontainfivedifferenticonsthatshowwhichkindofactivityisrecommended:
Thefacilitatorasksquestionstotheaudience,andprobesasmuchaspossible.Here,thefacilitatordoesusuallynotprovideanswersuntilparticipants’contributionsarefullyexhausted.
Ask
16 17
Thefacilitatorprovidesinformationonthegiventopictoparticipants.Althoughitisthefacilitatorwhohastheactivepart,participantsshouldbegiventhechancetocontribute,contradictoraskquestionsatanytime.
Thefacilitatorshowsacertaintrainingmaterialtoparticipants(thetrainingmaterialisshownintheiconitself).
Theparticipantsareaskedtosplitintogroupsanddoagroupassignment.Beforesplittingintogroups,thefacilitatorintroducesandexplainstheassignment.
Theparticipantsareaskedtodoaroleplayonacertaintopicordosomefieldworkwheretheyhavetointeractwitheachotherorotherpeople(e.g.marketvisits).
Explain
Show
Group work
Role play/Field work
16 17
Training tools• Themanualcomeswithasetoftrainingtoolsthathelptocommunicate
messagestofarmersmoreeffectivelyandwithmorefun.Thetoolshaveaslittletextaspossibleandthereforecanalsobeunderstoodbyilliteratefarmers.
Trainingmaterialsforthisguideinclude:
No. Title Trainingguidewherematerialisused
Goal
1 ERIsessionchart Throughout Providesanoverviewofthe5modulesandthesessionsundereachmodule
2 Levellingexpectationsstory
1.1 CommunicateswhichexpectationsfarmersshouldandshouldnothavewhenjoiningtheERIprogramme
3 M&Echart 2.1 Showstheimportanceofmonitoringandevaluation
4 Marketchaincards 3.1 Illustratethedifferentactorsinthevaluechain
5 4Pmarketingchartset 3.1 Explainswhatmarketinformationfarmersneedinordertoselectaprofitableenterprise(product,place,price,promotion)
6 Selectinganenterprisechart
3.4 Givesanideaofwhatfarmersneedtothinkaboutwhenselectinganenterprise
7 Howtogetmoreprofitchart
3.4 Illustrateshowfarmerscanearnmoreprofit
8 Cost-benefitanalysistool
3.4 Demonstrateshowtodoacost-benefitanalysis
9 Hippochart 3.53.8
Remindsfarmersthattheiractionscannegativelyimpactthemselvesandothers(e.g.inthemarketchain)
10 Sustainabilitychart 4.1 Communicatesthemeaningandimportanceofsustainability
11 Soilconservationmeasurescards
4.1 Showwhatfarmerscandotoconservesoilandwaterandimprovesoilfertility
12 Climatechangestory 4.1 Showstheimportanceofadaptingtochangingclimaticconditionsinthelongrun
13 Post-harvestlosscards 5.1 Showhowfarmerscanaddresschallengesinpost-harvesthandlinginordertobemoreprofitable
14 Businessplanningstory 5.2 Showstheimportanceofhavingawrittenbusinessplan
18 19
15 Marketintelligencestory
5.3 Showsthemeaningandimportanceofmarketintelligence
16 Contractstory 5.5 Showstheimportanceofhavingcontractsandgoodbusinessrelations
17 Tradingprinciplescards
5.5 Showdifferentprinciplesfarmershavetoconsiderwhendoingbusiness
The Agabas and MugishasMostofthetrainingmaterialsusetwocouplesasrecurringcharacters:theAgabasandtheMugishas.
The Agabas
TheAgabasrepresentthecouplethatshowsushowthingsareNOTsupposedtobedone.Theyarenotveryopen-minded,andsticktothewaysofdoingthingsjustliketheyhavealwaysbeendoingthem.TheAgabasarenotverystrongmembersintheirgroupandworkmostlyindividually.
18 19
The Mugishas
TheMugishasarethegoodexamples–orthe“ideal”farmersaswewouldwishtoseeallfarmersintheend.Theyareveryopen-minded,eagertolearnnewthings,andhard-working.Theyareveryactivemembersintheirgroupandimplementnewthingstheyhavelearntintrainingsrightaway.
Facilitatorsshouldbeflexibletochangethenamesofthesecouples.Forexample,whensomeofthefarmersinthegrouphavetheabovenames(especiallytheAgabas),thefacilitatorwillhavetochooseanothercommonlyusednamethatdoesnotappearinthegroup.
5. How to use the manual ERI principlesInordertoincreasetheeffectivenessandefficiencyofthetrainingstherearesomeunderlyingprinciplesthatneedtobeadheredtowhileusingthisguide:
• Emphasis is on building on farmers’ existing capacity.Farmershaveawealthofknowledge.Beforebringingnewknowledge,farmers’
20 21
existingknowledgeisfirstexploredandexploited.Thisisgenerallydonebythequestionandanswertechnique.Forexample,whentalkingaboutsustainableagriculture,don’tstartoffbyexplainingsustainableproductiontechniques.Instead,firstaskfarmerswhattheythinkwhatsustainabilityis;thenaskwhattheythinkwhatsustainableagricultureis.Thereafteraskfarmerswhatsustainabletechniquestheyalreadyuse,andwhatotherstheyknow.Probeaslongastheirknowledgeisexploited,andonlyafterthatcomplementbyaddingnewknowledge. Byusingthistechniquetheknowledgeofthegroupissharedandvalidated.
• Farmers are in the driver’s seat.Nothingisdoneforthem,everythingisdonebyorwiththem.ThatiswhytheRiverCoderoleplay(explainedinguide1.2–Visioning)runsasaredthreadthroughoutmostoftheguides.Farmersneedtoberemindedcontinuouslythattheyarethemainagentsoftheirownchange.Thisisespeciallytrueinanenvironmentwheredonordependencyisstimulatedbyfreehandouts.
• In the same philosophy, no free handouts should be given to farmers. Instead,farmersaremadeawareofopportunitiesthatalreadyexistbutmaynothavebeenutilised.Sometimesitmaybenecessarytoprovideinputsforfarmers’experimentswhenfarmersarenotfullyconvincedyetaboutthebenefitsofanewtechnology,butthisshouldbeanexceptiononly.
• ERI is an approach that, when applied properly, can empower farmers economically as well as socially.Itisthereforeofcrucialimportancetoinvolveallmembersofafarmergroupandnotjustasmallgroupofmoreeducated,confidentfarmers.Bycarefullyinvolvingthelessconfidentmembers,theywillbecomemoreconfidentandthereforemoreempowered.Thisparticularlycountsfortheilliteratefarmers,womenandyouth.
CreativityJustlikewestimulatefarmerstobecomecreativeanddeveloptheirownideas,westimulateorganisationsandfacilitatorstomakeuseoftheirexperiencesandcreativity.Theprocessesdescribedinthismanualarejustonewayofdoingthings,butitmightnotbetheonlyorthebestway.Themoreexperienceafacilitatorgainsontheground,themoreheorshewilldevelopafeelingforwhatcanbedonetomakethingsworkevenbetter.
20 21
Continuous coachingTrainingsessionsontheirownasdescribedinthismanualarenotsufficienttoenablefarmerstomakechanges.Experiencehastaughtusthatcontinuouscoachingbyfacilitatorsbetweenthevarioustrainingsessionsiscrucialinordertoseeresults.Therefore,thetrainingorganisationshouldplanandbudgetforcoachingfarmergroupsonaregularbasis.
Coachingsessionsusuallyinvolveafacilitatorandsomeorallmembersofafarmergroup.
Usesolution-focusedguidingquestions,suchas:
• Whatwasthegoalyousetforyourselfandasagroup?
• Howfarareyouinreachingthisdesiredsituation?Whatprogressdidyoumake?
• Whatdoyouneedtodomore(ordifferently)sothatyoucomeclosertothedesiredsituation?
• Whatfurthersupportdoyouneed?
Moredetailedcoachingtipsandtoolscanbefoundinsection7.
Country-neutralAlthoughthemanualbuildsonexperiencesfromEastAfrica,itismeanttobecountryneutralandhasnogeographicalfocus.Insomecases,however,trainingcontentmightneedtobeadjustedtofitthelocalcontext(e.g.givingexamplesthataremoreappropriateforthegivenlocality,oradjustingstoriestofitthesocialandculturalcontext).
6. What this manual cannot offer A guide to make a perfect trainer• ThemanualisapracticalguidethroughtheERIimplementation
process.Itdoesnot,however,byanymeansreplacepracticaltrainings.IfafacilitatorwantstobecomeanexpertinERI,heorshehastogothroughseveraltheoreticalaswellaspracticaltrainingsinERI.ImplementingthecontentofthemanualwithoutmoreprofoundpracticaltraininginERIwillmostlikelynotleadtothedesiredsuccess.
22 23
Forthat,skilledfacilitatorsareneededwhonotonlyunderstandthedescribedprocesses,butalsohaveinternalisedtheprinciplesofandphilosophybehindERI.
Cooking recipe• Themanualwithitsmodulesandtrainingsessionscannotbe
implementedlikeastandardcookingrecipewherebyifallactivitiesareimplementedasdescribedinthemanual,thenwewillgetfarmerswhoarecompetententrepreneursintheend–thiswillnotwork!Participatoryempowermentprocessesarehighlychallenging.Besidestechnicalknowledgeandskills,theyrequireflexibility,alertness,intuitivefeeling,empathy–allofwhichthismanualcannotoffer.
• AlthoughtheERIapproachsuggestsacertainsequenceofactivities,theactivitiesasdescribedinthismanualarenotimplementedinalinearway.Someactivitiesmightbeimplementedinparallel,trainingguidesorcertainsectionsoftrainingguidesmightbeshiftedorevenleftoutcompletely,dependingonthesituation.Also,allmodulesandactivitiesareconnectedandbuildoneachother.
An approach fixed in stone• TheERIapproachisalivingapproach.Justasfarmersneedtoadaptto
ever-changingconditions,theERIapproachitselfisstillbeingfurtherdeveloped.Manythingswillworkthewaywewantthemtowork.Otherswillnotwork.TogetherwithpartnerswhohaveaninteresttofurtherimprovetheERIapproach,wewanttoidentifyexistinggaps,andjointlycomeupwithpotentialsolutions.
Topics not coveredAsexplainedabove,thismanualdoesnotcoverthecompleteERIapproachandsometopicsaremissing:
• Groupstrengthening(leadership,conflictresolution,teambuilding,groupconstitutions,etc.)
• Genderanddiversity
• Foodsecurity
• HIV/AIDS
• Micro-financeandsavingsandloans
22 23
• Mentoringandcoaching
Nevertheless,thesetopicsareverycrucialforthesuccessfuldevelopmentoffarmergroupsandtheirenterprises.
Whilewaitingforamorecomprehensivemanualontheabovetopics,facilitatorscanmakeuseofthewealthofmanualsavailablefromotherorganisations.Werecommendtomakeuseofsuchcomplementaryresourcedocumentsandtoflexiblyintegratethosetopicswithtrainingguidesproposedinthismanual.Themorefacilitatorsgainexperience,themoretheywilllearnhowtointegratethesetopics.
7. Some practical tips Working in teamsUsuallymanyfarmergroupsaretobetrainedandtherearemanytrainersinvolvedinsimilartrainings.Itisthereforeimportantthatthereisgoodteamwork.Thiswillincreasetheimpactandchanceofsuccess.Thefollowingneedstobetakencareofwhileworkinginteams:
• Makesureeachteammemberisgivenclearrolesandresponsibilitiesandthattheseareknownbyallgroupmembers.Forexample,atrainercanberesponsibleforacertainnumberofgroupsinageographicalarea.Successes(orfailures)withthesegroupscanthenbelinkedtothistrainer.Alternatively,atrainercanspecialiseincertaintopics.
• Iforganisationalresourcesallow,trainingsessionsshouldbedonebytwotrainers,onefacilitatingandtheothertakingrecords.Itshouldbeclearinadvancewhattheroleofeachtraineris.Lookfortrainerswhocomplimenteachother;combinelessexperiencedtrainerswithmoreexperiencedtrainers.
• Spendampletimeandplanforcommunication,(self)reflectionandfeedback.Forexample,afteratrainingsession,organiseasmallmeetingwiththetrainerstoreflectonhowthetrainingwasdone.Startwithselfreflectionfromthetrainer:
– WhathaveIdonewell?– HowcouldIdoitbetternexttime?– WhatfurthersupportdoIneed?
24 25
Afterthat,othertrainerswhoattendedthetraininggivefeedbacktothetrainerusingthesamequestions.Experienceshowsthatthisisaveryefficientwayoflearningtobecomeabettertrainer.
Documentation and learningNothingismorestimulatingthanseeingfarmergroupsachievesuccessesresultingfromthetrainingsandcoaching.Itisthereforeimportanttodocumentthesesuccesses.Thiscanbedoneintheformofphotographs,video,“mostsignificantchange”stories,copiesoftablesanddrawingsfromfarmergroups,etc.
Thiswillallowforfurtheranalysistoidentifysuccessfactorsthatthencanbeusedtoachievemoresuccessesinotherfarmergroups.Itisequallyimportanttodocumentlesssuccessfuloutcomesandtolearnhowtheycanbepreventedorreducedinthefuture.
Facilitation techniquesThefollowingisanon-exhaustivelistoftechniquesandtipstoconsiderwhentrainingorcoachingfarmersandfarmergroups:
• Preparewellinadvance.Taketimetogothroughthetrainingguides,studythetoolsandaskothertrainersformoreguidancewhensomethingisnotclear.Anticipatehowfarmersinyourenvironmentwillreactandfindaproperwaytorespondtoit.Doamocktrainingwithfellowtrainersifyouarenotconfidentenough.
• Itisadvisabletotrainfarmersinthelanguagetheyknowbest.Whenyouusealocallanguage,practiceinadvancehowyouwilltranslateeverything.Agreewithyourfellowtrainersabouttherightwordsinyourlocallanguage.Somehandoutsforfarmers(e.g.businessplantemplates)needtobetranslatedintolocallanguage.
• Givetherightexampletofarmers:comeontimeandbecommittedandactivewhiletraining.Showthatyouareconcernedabouttheirprogress.
• Facilitatorstendtowritealotonflipchartswhiletraining.Thistakesalotoftimeandpeoplemightnotunderstand(certainlywhenthewritingisinEnglish).Thisisonlyusefulincertaincircumstances(e.g.whensummarisingtherolesofacommittee).
• Praisefarmerswhentheymakeacontribution(e.g.“Welldone!”;“Thatisanexcellentcontribution!”;“Thatisverycleverofyou,Ineverthought
24 25
aboutthat”).Thiswillmakelessconfidentmembersmoreconfidentandtheywillcontributemore.
• Similarly,letfarmersknowthatallanswersandquestionsareright.Ifanincorrectanswerisgiven,praisethemforthecontributionandexplainthatyouhaveadifferentview.Thenaskotherfarmersiftheyhaveadifferentviewaswell.
• Youdon’tneedtoanswerallquestionsfarmersask.Certainlydon’tstartaone-to-onedialoguewithonefarmeronly.Alwaysinvolveotherfarmers.Whenfarmersaskquestions,askotherfarmerswhethertheyknowtheanswer.Firstexhausttheknowledgeofthefarmersbeforeaddingknowledgefromyourside.
• Alwayscheckifallfarmershaveunderstood.Don’tjustask,“Haveyouunderstood?”Asksomefarmerstorepeatorsummarisewhatyouhavementioned.Whentheyfail,asksomeonewhohasunderstood.Then,correctwhereneeded.Nevermoveontothenexttopicifyouarenotsurethatallhaveunderstood.Ifneeded,repeatthetraininganothertimeorplanforaspecialcoachingsession.
• Neverarrangeseatsinaclassroomsetting.Youneedmaximumparticipation,sothearrangementofchairs,benchesormatsisveryimportant.Don’tallowfarmerstohidebehindothers.Thisoftenhastodowithlackofconfidence.Itisyourtaskasafacilitatortoincreasethatconfidence.Onceshyfarmersarepraisedfortheirlittlecontributions,theywillgraduallycontributemoreandbecomemoreactive.Thisisthestartoffarmers’empowerment!
• Makesureallfarmerscontribute.Themanualhasplentyoftoolsthatallowparticipationfromeventheilliterate.Chartsandstoriesespeciallyevokeparticipationfromthelessactive.Usethesetoolstoawakenthelessactive.
• Atrainingisaboutthefarmers,notaboutyou.Don’tpreach,don’tdoaone(wo)manshow!Beafacilitator:letthefarmerscontributeandcriticallyanalysewhatyousay.Continuouslyaskquestions!
26 27
• Avoidclosedquestionslike:
• Usefarmers’answersandquestionstoaskmorequestionsandgetanswersfromfarmersthemselves.Exhaustfarmers’knowledgebeforeaddingyourknowledge.
• Listeningskillsforafacilitatorareasimportantasquestioningskills:listenverywelltowhatfarmerssayanduseittoprobemoreandgettothecoreofthetopic.
• Usecreativityandalotofvarietywhentrainingfarmers.Forexample,theintroductiondoesn’tneedtoalwaysbethesame(eachstandupandintroducethemselves).Usesomevarietyandrememberthatanintroductioncanalsobeusedtobreaktheice,tomakefarmerscomfortable.Standinguponebyoneisveryscaryforsomefarmers.
• Ifthesessiontakestoolongandfarmersaretired,continuenexttime,ascloselyaspossibleaftertheunfinishedsession.Haveaproperendingandwhencontinuing,haveaproperreflectionaboutthefirstpartofthesession.
• Stimulatefeedback,self-reflectionandcriticalthinking.Followingguidingquestionsmightbehelpful:
– Isitreallytruethatthesoilisbad?Whydoyouthinkso?Haveyoudoneresearchonthis?
– Whatdidthemarketingcommitteedowell?Howcouldtheydoitbetternexttime?
– WhatprogresshaveyoumadesincethelasttimeIvisited?Whatshouldyoudotomakeevenmoreprogress?
– Whatwasgoodaboutthechairman’spresentation?Howcouldheevendobetternexttime?Whatcanyoudotohelphim?
Don’task InsteadaskDon’tyouthinkaskingforfreehandoutsisbad?
Whatwillhappenifyouaskforhandouts?Whatshouldyoudoinstead?
Andwhenfarmerschecktheircrops,wecallitwhat?Wecallitmonitoring.
Whatcouldbethemeaningofmonitoring?
Istheroleofthemonitoringcommitteetocheckeverymember’sprogress?
Whatcouldbetheroleofthemonitoringcommittee?
Isn’tthatagoodquestion?Theansweristhatweneedtolookatprofitability,productionandmarket.
Isn’tthatagoodquestion?Whatdoothersthinkaboutthat?Whatcouldbetheanswer?
26 27
• Showthatyouareahumbleandlearningpersonyourself.Askforfeedbackfromthefarmers.WhatdidIdowell?HowshouldIdoitbetternexttime?Tellthemthatyoualsomakemistakesbutthatyoulearnfromthemtodobetternexttime.
• Continuouslyremindfarmersthattheyhavecontrolovertheirownchange.Whenfarmerswanttoexpresstheirproblemstoyou,firstletthemventforawhile.Thenask:
– Whatshouldbedoneinstead?– Whatcouldyouhavedonetopreventthis?– Whatcanyoudotomakeitbetternexttime?
• Ifyouhavedominantparticipants,don’tallowthemtocontrolthetraining.Thiswillcauselessparticipationfromotherfarmers.Adominantparticipantcanbehandledbypraisinghim/herforhisactivecontributionsandcleverinsightsandtellhim/herthatyoufirstwanttoknowfromotherparticipantshowtheythinkaboutit.
• Neverblamelessactivefarmersfornotparticipatingwell!Thiswillmakethemevenlessconfident!Instead,keeponaskingthemquestions,simplifythequestionsoraskthemtodosomethingtheyknow.
• Trytomainstreamgenderthroughalltrainingandcoachingsessions.Thisshouldbedonebyaskingreflectionquestions.Forexample:
– Howmanyfarmerscamewiththeirwifeorhusband?– Whydidyoubringyourwife?Whatarethepositiveeffectsofthis?– Whatcanyouadviseotherfarmerstodo?– Howdidyouinvolveyourwifeandchildreninthebusiness
planning?Howwasthisexperiencecomparedtodoingitalone?
Coaching tools and tipsInordertoachievepositiveresultsitisnecessarytoorganisecoachingsessionsbetweentheformaltrainingsessions.Coachingcanbedonebyoneormorefacilitators(thosethatdidthetrainings)forsomefarmers(e.g.marketingcommittee)orallgroupmembers.
28
Thefollowingareexamplesofsomecoachingquestionsthatcanbeusedduringacoachingsession:
Coaching guiding questions1. Whatneedstohappenduringmyvisitsothatitisusefultoyou?
2. Whatwasthegoalyousetyourselfandasagroup?Whatisthesituationthatyoudesire3?
– Howwillyoubedifferentwhenyouhavereachedthedesiredsituation?
– Howwilltheothergroupmembersseethatyouhavereachedthedesiredsituation?
– Howwillothers(e.g.traders/buyers)seethatyouhavereachedthedesiredsituation?
3. Onascalefrom1to10,howfarareyouinreachingthisdesiredsituation?(10beingthedesiredsituationand1havingachievednothing).Whatprogressdidyoumake?Howdidyoudothat?Whatelsedidyoudotomakethishappen?
4. Whatdoyouneedtodomoreordifferentlysothatyoucomeclosertothedesiredsituationandscorehigheronthescale?
5. Whatfurthersupportdoyouneed(e.g.recordkeeping,marketlinkage)?
– Isthereanyfarmerwhoknowshowtoimproveit?– Doyourememberhowthiswasdone/explainedinthetrainings?
6. Howwillyouseethatyouhavecomeclosertothedesiredsituation?HowwillIseethiswhenIcometovisityounexttime?
7. Howusefulwasmyvisittoyoutoday?HowcanIoryouimproveitnexttime?
8. Whataresomeoftheactionsyouaregoingtodobecauseofthisvisit?
3 Refertotheindicatorsthatfarmersagreedupon,suchashavingrecords,calculatingprofits,doingmarketresearch,havingmarketaccess,generatingprofits,doingcollectivemarketingandimprovingproductivity.
28
Whenapplyingthetool,takethefollowingtipsintoconsideration:
• Alwaysstartwiththegroup’sprogressandhowtheymanagedtodoit.Whathasgonebettersincelasttime?Howdidyoudothat?
• Don’ttellfarmerswhattheycanknowthemselves:stimulatefarmers’criticalthinking!Firststimulatethemtofindsolutionsthemselves(eveniftheyspecificallyaskforadvice)andthenaddonyourknowledge.
• Askquestions!(e.g.Whydoyoulikethis?Howdidyoudoit?Howdoyouthinkcoulditbedonebetter?Doyourememberwhatwassuggestedinthetrainings?)
• Appreciateandpraisetheprogress!
• Showinterestinwhatfarmersdo(e.g.byrememberingtheirsuccessandproblemsduringthelastvisit).
• Don’ttalktoomuch:listenandtrytounderstandbeforetalking.Bepatient.Givefarmersampletimetothinkaboutyourquestions.
• Beopenforlearning.Yourwayisnotnecessarilythebestforthefarmergroup.
• Nobodyfailsalways:focusonthesuccessesandaskhowtheydidit.Askfarmerswhodobettertoexplaintotheonesthathavechallenges.
• Focusonthesolutions,nottheproblems.Ask:whatcanyou/theydoinstead?
• Usefarmers’ownmaterials(e.g.businessplans,records)anddiscussandpracticehowtoimprovethem.
• Beconsistentinyourcommunicationandthatwithinyourteam.
• Makesurethatyouknowenoughaboutthetopicandaboutthebackgroundofthefarmergroup(previouswork,achievements,training,indicators).
• Youcan’tknoweverything:behonestandhumbleifyoudon’tknowandexplorethesolutionswithfarmers.
• Evaluatehowusefulyourcoachingwasforthefarmers.Askthemhowitcouldbeimprovednexttime.
30 31
30 31
1479 Naalya Road, Kiwatule, P.O. Box 25312, Kampala, UgandaTel: 256-312-263-263, Email: [email protected]
www.mangotreeuganda.org
Mango Tree