Malaysia Electronic Industry

download Malaysia Electronic Industry

of 24

Transcript of Malaysia Electronic Industry

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    1/24

    THE STUDY OF STRUCTURAL EFFECT ON EXPORT COMPETITIVENESS

    IN MALAYSIAN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC (E&E) SECTOR

    UNIVERSITI PENYELIDIKAN, PEMBANGUNAN DAN PENGKOMERSILAN

    UNIVERSITI TEKNOLOGI MARA

    40450 SHAH ALAM, SELANGOR

    MALAYSIA

    DISEDIAKAN OLEH:

    HASLINA BINTI CHE YAACOB

    DR. NIK MAHERAN BINTI NIK MUHAMMAD

    ZURINA BINTI ISMAIL

    OKTOBER 2007

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    2/24

    Surat KamiTarikh

    600-IRDC/SSP 5/3/137720 Disember 2004

    UNiVERsrn TEKNOLOGI MARAInstitut Penyelidikan, Pembangunan danPengkomersilan (IRDC)

    Institute of Research, Development andCommercialisation (IRDC)(Sebelum ini dikenali sebagm Biro Penyelidikan dan Perundingan)

    40450 Shah Alam, MalaysiaWebsite : h ttp/ /: wwwruitm.edu.my/brc

    Pengarah

    UiTM Cawangan KelantanKampus MachangBukit llmu18500 MachangKelantan

    Tuan/ Puan

    PERLANTIKAN BAGI MENJALANKAN PENYELIDIKAN

    Merujuk kepada perkara di atas, bersama-sama ini dimajukan salinan surat kelulusan

    menjalankan penyelidikan serta ringkasan kos perbelanjaan bagi penyelidikan yangdijalankan oleh pensyarah dari UiTM Cawangan Kelantan ;

    Tajuk Projek The Study of Structural on Export Competitiveness inMalaysian Electrical and Electronic (E&E) Sector.

    Ketua Projek : Puan Haslina Yaacob

    Kos Yang diluluskan : RM 19,880.41

    Jenis Geran : Geran Dalaman

    Sekian, terima kasih.

    Yang benar f

    KS-

    PROF IUIADYA DR ROSMIMAH RUOHD ROSLIN

    Ketua Penyelidikan (Sains Sosial dan Pengurusan)

    s.k: 1. Prof Madya Napisah Hj SafiiKoordinator URDCUiTM Cawangan Kelantan

    8. Puan Haslina YaacobKetua ProjekUiTM Cawangan Kelantan ,

    3. Encik Mohd Halil Marsuki

    Penolong AkauntanUnit Kewangan Zon 17(SHa haniarkan geran pcnye!h':!:an hix;i projek ini ke Kimpus Cawangzi)

    4

    axb Canselor (Penyelidikan):hdtka n (Sains Sosial da n Pengurusan)

    jlidiksji (Sains dan Teknologi)RSC

    idingan (Kewangan)

    03-55442094/5

    03-55442097

    03-55442091

    03-55442760

    03-55442090

    Ketua PerundinganKerua PengkomersilanKetua Harta IntelekPenolong Pendaftar

    Pegawai Sains

    03-55442100

    03-55442750

    03-55442753

    03-55447092

    03-55442098

    Pegawai Eksekutif

    PejabatAm

    FaxUnit Kewangan Zon 17Penolong Akauntan

    03-55442057

    03-55442093/2101

    03-55442096

    03-55443440

    03-55442099

    OKAS

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    3/24

    Tarikh : 31 Oktober 2007

    No. fail Projek : 600-IRDC/SSP 5/3/1377

    Penolong Naib Canselor (Penyelidikan)

    Institut Penyelidikan, Pembangunan dan Pengkomersilan

    Universiti Teknologi MAPvA

    40450 Shah Alam

    Ybg. Prof,

    LAPORAN AKHIR PENYELIDIKAN "THE STUDY OF STRUCTURAL

    EFFECT ON EXPORT COMPETITIVENESS IN MALAYSIAN ELECTRICAL

    AND ELECTRONIC (E&E) SECTOR"

    Merujuk kepada perkara di atas, bersama-sama ini disertakan 4 (empat) naskah Laporan

    Akhir Penyelidikan bertajuk "The Study Of Structural Effect On Export

    Competitiveness In Malaysian Electrical And Electronic (E&E) Sector" oleh kumpulan

    Penyelidik dari Fakulti Pengurusan Perniagaan untuk makluman pihak tuan.

    Sekian, terima kasih.

    Yang benar

    Ketua

    Projek Penyelidikan.

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    4/24

    KUMPULAN PENYELIDIK

    HASLINA BINTI CHE YAACOB

    KETUA PENYELIDIK

    DR. NIK MAHERAN BINTI NIK MUHAMMAD

    Ahli Kumpulan

    ZURINA BINTI ISMAIL

    Ahli Kumpulan

    ^yi^^

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    5/24

    PENGHARGAAN

    Setinggi-tinggi penghargaan dan terima kasih diucapkan kepada semua pihak yang terlibat

    secara langsung dan tidak langsung bagi membolehkan penyelidikan ini disiapkan dengan

    sempurna.

    Di antaranya:

    Dato' Professor Dr.Hussin @ Mohamed Ab. Rahman

    (Pengarah Kampus UiTM Kelantan)

    Prof. Madya Dr. Noormala Bt Amir Ishak

    (Dekan Fakulti Pengurusan Perniagaan)

    Nik Kamaruzaman bin Abdulatiff

    (Koordinator Penyelidikan, Pembangunan dan Pengkomersilan UiTMKK)

    Semua pensyarah yang telah memberikan kerjasama dan sokongan di dalam menjayakan

    penyelidikan ini.

    n

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    6/24

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Letter of transmittal

    Acknowledgement

    Table of content

    List of tablesList of figure

    Abstract

    Page

    ii

    iii

    viiviii

    ix

    CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION

    1.0 Introduction

    1.1 Background of the Study

    1.2 Term and definition.

    1.3 Problem Statement

    1.4 Objective of the Study

    1.5 Research Questions

    1.6 Significant of the Study

    1

    7

    8

    8

    11

    11

    12

    m

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    7/24

    CHAPTER 2 : LITERATURE REVIEW

    2.0 Introduction 13

    2.1 Economic Theory 13

    2.1.1 International Trade Theory And Comparative Advantage 14

    2.1.2 Evaluating Competitiveness And Comparative Advantage 15

    2.2 Competitiveness 17

    2.3 Export Competitiveness in Malaysia 19

    2.4 Export Competitiveness in the World Market 21

    2.5 Measuring Competitiveness 24

    2.6 Constant Market Share Model (CMS) 25

    2.7 Revealed Comparative Advantage Model (RCA) 28

    2.8 Conclusion 30

    CHAPTER 3 : RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

    3.0 Introduction 31

    3.1 Method 31

    3.1.1 Constant Market Share (CMS) 31

    3.1.2 Conceptual Framework 35

    3.1.3 The CMS Formula 35

    3.1.4 Sensitivity Analysis 37

    3.1.5 The RCA Model 38

    3.2 Data 40

    3.3 Conclusion 41

    IV

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    8/24

    CHAPTER 4 : FINDING AND ANALYSIS

    4.0 Introduction 43

    4.1 Constant Market Share (CMS) 43

    4.1.1 Change in Export Value 45

    4.1.2 Structural Effect 45

    4.1.3 Competitive Residual 47

    4.1.4 Second Order Effect 48

    4.1.5 Summary 49

    4.2 Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA) 50

    4.2.1 Export Performance Ratio of SITC 776 (Semiconductor) 50

    4.2.2 Export Performance Ratio of SITC 772 (electrical machinery, 60Apparatus, parts and necessary).

    4.2.3 Export Performance Ratio Of SITC 764

    (Telecommunication equipment) 68

    4.2.4 Export Performance Ratio of SITC 759(Printed circuit board) 81

    4.2.5 Export Performance Ratio of SITC 752

    (Disk drivers, printers and PCs) 90

    4.3 Conclusion 101

    v

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    9/24

    CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSIONS

    5.0 Introduction 104

    5.1 Recapitulation of Major 105

    5.2 Discussion 109

    5.2.1 Constant Market Share ( CMS ) 109

    5.2.2 Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA) 113

    5.3 Limitation of the Study 115

    5.4 Implication 116

    5.5 Recommendation 116

    5.6 Conclusion 166

    BIBLIOGRAPHY

    APPENDICES

    VI

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    10/24

    Table Description Page

    Table 1 Competitiveness Ranking For 2002 2002-2003 7

    Table 2 Gross Export of E & E manufacture in Malaysia 10

    Table 2.1 Desirable Characteristics on Competitiveness Measures and 25Methods

    Table 4.1 Result of Yearly Decomposition of Change in Malaysia Export 44Value of E & E products

    Table 4.2 Export Performance Ratio of 776 or Semiconductor (1990-2004) 50-57fable 4.3~~ Export Performance Ratio of SITC 772 60-66

    fable 4.4 Export Performance Ratio of SITC 764 74-80

    Table 4.5 Export Performance Ratio of SITC 759" 81-86

    Table 4.6 Export Performance Ratio of SITC 752 90-96

    fable 4.7 Market Position of E & E Product by Destination 102-103

    vn

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    11/24

    LIST OF FIGURES

    Figure Description

    Figure 1 E & E Products' Share of National Exports

    Figure 3.1 Schematic Representation of the CMS model

    Figure 3.2 The Framework of these Decomposition Item

    Page

    7

    32

    35

    vm

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    12/24

    Abstract

    Malaysia is among the world's top 20 trading nations. This is due to the structural

    change in the Malaysian economy that turned the country from an exporter of primarycommodities into an exporter of high value-added manufactured products. In

    Malaysia, E&E forged a strong foundation over the 1 ast 3 decades, which provides

    new opportunities for such investments. This study analyses the structural effect on

    export competitiveness of Malaysian E&E products focusing on semiconductor (SITC

    776), Telecommunication product (SITC 764), Electrical machinery, Apparatus, Part

    and necessary (SITC 772), Printed Circuit Board (SITC 759) and Disk drives, printers

    and PCs (SITC 752). Furthermore, the study uses the Constant market share (CMS)

    and revealed comparative advantage (RCA) framework to analyze the extent of the

    export competition between Malaysia and other competitor economies. Overall, CMS

    result shows that in the first sub-period (1990-1994), Malaysia E&E export was

    competitive in the four markets studied, namely USA, Singapore, Japan and Hong

    Kong. However, in the second and third period, CMS result shows that Malaysia E&E

    export increased but not due to market competitiveness but due to the structural effect

    - that is due to an increased in the world import. In terms of export performance ratio,

    RCA results show that, Malaysia E&E product only performed was highly in the US

    market for almost all SITC. Indonesia has concurred the Singapore market and Hong

    Kong was concurred by China. However, Malaysia E&E export to the world generally

    has comparative advantage over other competitors namely Indonesia, Thailand and

    China. The study also revealed that Malaysia has higher export capacity to other

    countries besides USA, Singapore, Japan and Hong Kong. Therefore the argumentsaying that China will intensify the competitiveness of Malaysian E&E market is

    questionable since the study cannot reveal the comparative advantage hold by China.

    The study found that China only dominated the Hong Kong Market for almost all

    SITC studied.

    IX

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    13/24

    CHAPTER 1

    INTRODUCTION

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    14/24

    CHAPTER 1

    INTRODUCTION

    1.0 Introduction

    The electrical and electronic (E&E) industry is the leading industry within the

    manufacturing sector and is the largest contributor to output, export and employment

    opportunities in Malaysia. In 2004, Malaysia's exports of E&E products worth was

    RM241.48 billion (US$63.55 billion), which accounted for 50.2 per cent of total

    Malaysia's exports or 64.1 per cent of Malaysia's total exports of manufactured

    goods. Major export destinations were the US, Singapore, Hong Kong, Japan and

    China. As one of the leading exporters of electronics products in the world, Malaysia

    markets electronics components, consumer electronics and industrial electronics.

    The biggest export item is semiconductor devices used in a diverse range of

    industries, such as automotive and telecommunications. Malaysia's electrical

    products c omprise of household appliances, wires and cables, electrical industrial

    equipment, dry cells and batteries and other electrical apparatus and supplies

    (Matrade, 2005).

    1.0.1 Electrical Products

    A sophisticated range of electrical appliances are manufactured in

    Malaysia, including:

    Refrigerators, washing machines, vacum cleaners, electric fans,

    instant water heaters, rice cookers, blenders, microwave ovens and

    room air-conditioners.

    Wires and cables.

    1

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    15/24

    Electrical industrial equipment such as switchgears.

    Distribution transformers and electric motors.

    Dry cells, automotive batteries, incandescent lamps and fluorescent

    tubes.

    Major brands include Panasonic, Sony, Philips and Samsung. Home

    grown brands like T, 'Pensonic', 'Khind' and 'MEC have also made inroads

    into the export markets.

    1.0.2 Electronic Products

    Made-in-Malaysia electronics products are diverse and fall into 3

    categories - electronic components, consumer electronics and industrial

    electronics. These goods are sold globally, with semiconductor devices

    valued at RM89.30 billion (US$23.50 billion) accounting for more than 30 per

    cent of total E&E exports for 2004.

    Semiconductor devices produced include:

    o linear and digital integrated circuits;

    o memories and microprocessors;

    o opto-electronics;

    o discrete devices;

    o hybrids;

    o arrays; and

    o high-reliability military products.

    2

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    16/24

    Malaysia is among the world's top 20 trading nations. This is due to the

    structural change in the Malaysian economy that turned the country from an exporter

    of primary commodities into an exporter of high value-added manufactured products.

    The most significant change came during the late 1980's when the share of the

    manufacture exports doubled i n a s pan of five years (MITI: 2 002), particularly the

    Electrical and electronic (E&E) industry.

    Malaysia is now an export-oriented and it is a significant component of the

    Malaysian Economy. Electrical and electronics products accounted for RM189.49

    billion or 56.6 per cent of Malaysia's total exports and remained the largest

    contributors in 2001 and in the year 2002, it saw an increase of 4.5%. The largest

    export market for E&E products was the USA, valued at RM51 billion absorbing 26.9

    per cent of the total electrical and electronic exports in 2001 and it increased to

    RM55.66 (28.1 percent) in 2002. Other major export destinations were Singapore,

    RM35.9 billion (19 per cent) in 2001 which increased to RM37.79 billion (19.1

    percent) in 2002, Japan RM21.6 billion (11.4 per cent) in 2001 but decreased to RM

    17.87 billion (9 percent) in 2002, Hong Kong, RM14.52 (7.3 percent) in 2002, the

    Netherlands RM11.7 billion (6.2 per cent) in 2001 but decreased to RM8.75 billion

    (4.4 percent) in 2002 and China RM8.62 billion (4.4%) in 2002. In 2003, export sector

    in Malaysian E&E product made up to 52.9%.

    E&E valued at RM 85.18 billion (US$22.42) billion accounting for more than

    40% of total exports for 2003. In 2004, Malaysia's exports of E&E products was

    worth RM241.48 billion (US$63.55 billion), which accounted for 50.2 per cent of total

    Malaysia's exports or 64.1 per cent of Malaysia's total exports of manufactured goods

    (Maltrade,2005)

    3

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    17/24

    In Malaysia, E&E forged a strong foundation over the last 3 decades, which

    provides new opportunities for such investments. Many companies found Malaysia a

    competitive manufacturing, and export base nation, as they move up the

    manufacturing value chain, and produce higher end and high value added products.

    This is reflected in the continuing interest amongst investors, to establish new

    manufacturing operations in the E&E sector, as well as to expand and diversify

    existing operations in Malaysia

    For the period of 2000 to August 2003, 313 E&E projects were approved by

    the Malaysian government, encountered for RM 8.6986 billion total investment

    (67.8% foreign sources, that is RM5.9 billion, and 32.2% domestic sources, that is

    RM2.7968 billion).

    Within the electronics sector a lone, out of the 863 projects approved, with

    total capital investment of RM37.4 billion, between 1998 - August 2003, 426 projects

    were for the manufacture of electronic components, with the investment of RM25.5

    billion 251 projects were in the industrial electronics sector, with the investment of

    RM8.7 billion; and 186 projects were to manufacture consumer electronics products,

    with the investment of RM3.2 billion. Total employment provided by the 863 projects

    was 172,000.

    Malaysia markets electronics components, consumer electronics and

    industrial electronics to the world and the biggest export item is semiconductor

    devices used in a diverse range of industries, such as automotive and

    telecommunications.

    4

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    18/24

    In the consumer electronic sub-sector, it is seen that companies have shifted

    from the production of traditional products, such as VCRs, color TV sets, to higher

    added value products, such as digital audio-video equipment, multimedia speakers,

    TFT/Plasma TV sets and home theatres.

    In the area of E&E research and development (R&D), the Malaysian

    government continues to proactiveiy encourage the relevant R&D activities, through

    both fiscal and non-fiscal incentives. For example, under the Economic Stimulus

    Package announced on 21st May 2003, further incentives for R&D are provided, to

    enhance R&D activities in the country which include:

    1. approved R&D expenditure incurred during the Pioneer Status period, will

    be allowed to be accumulated, and brought forward, and be given another

    deduction after the Pioneer Status period;

    2. expenditure on R&D activities undertaken overseas, including the training

    of Malaysian staff, will be considered for double deduction, on a case-by-

    case basis;

    3. R&D companies will be given either second round Pioneer Status for

    another 5 years or Investment Tax allowance for a further of 10 years; and

    4. all value-added activities, including R&D will be designated as "prescribed

    activities" that can be undertaken in free industrial zones or licensed

    manufacturing warehouse.

    With the realization of AFTA since January 2003, the ASEAN market should

    provide new opportunities for companies operating in Malaysia. For widely traded

    products, such as those in the E&E sector, this is supposed to be on-going efforts to

    spur the growth of a pan-ASEAN market.

    5

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    19/24

    At present, ASEAN has already completed the harmonization of standards

    for 20 priority product groups, which are widely traded in ASEAN, and which conform

    to 59 international standards of the ISO and the International Electro-technical

    Commission or I EC. Out of the 20-product group, 18 are in the Electrical and

    Electronic sector, ranging from refrigerators, air conditioners, television sets,

    capacitors to cathode ray tubes and loudspeakers and parts. The harmonization of

    these product standards, and the conformity to international standards, will facilitate

    greater intra-ASEAN market access, as well as access into the global market.

    However, China's robust economic growth and strong gravitational pull offoreign direct investments have been a serious threat to ASEAN countries,

    particularly to those countries which are highly dependent on the E&E sector for their

    export revenue (figure 2). However, although China's thriving semiconductor industry

    has been fuelled by its costs competitiveness; most MNCs are not in a hurry to invest

    in China. This is due to some distinct problems that have prevented them from

    making a premature leap on the Chinese bandwagon. China has a lack of qualitative

    factor such as conducive business environment, efficient infrastructure, and a sound-

    banking sector.

    China's burgeoning chip sector also appears to be a growing threat to

    Malaysia. A study by the World Economic forum has indicated otherwise. The report

    evaluates the economic competitiveness of a large sample of 102 countries in terms

    of growth, business environment and technology. However, Malaysia's

    competitiveness in 2002 and 2003 surpassed that of China and other ASEAN

    countries (except Singapore). This is due to China's poorer ranking and perceived

    deterioration related to its quality of public institutions, i.e. concerns about red tape,

    corruption, judicial independent, trade barriers and banking system (Global

    Competitiveness Report, World Economic Forum, 2003)

    6

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    20/24

    Figure 1: E&E Products' Share Of National Exports

    Malaysia - 53%

    Singapore -6 4%

    Sources: Asian Development Bank And Central Banks Of Various Countries

    TABLE 1: COMPETITIVENESS RANKINGS FOR 2002 AND 2003

    Gotiti^ v

    MalaysiaThailandChinaPhilippinesIndonesia

    200230373863

    69

    .. -

    . . :

    . . -.' :

    2932446672

    Busin^nv i rn r

    2002

    26

    35386164

    ^ w ,

    2631466560

    ..__ Technoloyy

    '009

    26416352

    65

    2039655678

    Note: Higher Rankings (I.E Smaller Numbers) Imply Better Competitive Position

    1.1 Background of the Study

    This study analyses the structural effect on export competitiveness of

    Malaysian E&E products focusing on semiconductor (SITC 776), Telecommunication

    product (SITC 764), Electrical Machinery, apparatus, parts and necessary (SITC

    772), Printed Circuit Board (SITC 759) and Disk drives, printers and PCs (SITC 752).

    Furthermore, the study uses the Constant market share and revealed comparative

    advantage framework to analyse the extent of the export competition between

    Malaysia and other World economies. It was argued that the emergence of other low

    cost producers such as China and ASEAN Free Trade Area (AFTA) will intensify the

    competitiveness of Malaysian E&E market.

    7

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    21/24

    Many studies have assessed the competitiveness of Malaysian commodity

    exports, namely Palm Oil (Fatimah and Roslan, 1988, Mohamad, Fatimah, Abdul

    Aziz, 1992), Cocoa and rubber (Md Nasir, Mohd Ghazali, Othman, 1993). Amir

    (2000) on the other hand provides in-depth research on competitiveness of all

    Malaysian manufacturing and factors that influence Malaysia's export

    competitiveness.

    Fatimah and Alias (1997) study on export performance of selected E&E

    products, which is similar to this study. The present study however, extend the

    research area by comparing the performance of Malaysia E&E market and their

    competitiveness with three other countries namely Indonesia, Thailand and China

    from the year 1990 to 2004. Even though a country's competitiveness is affected by

    both price and non-price factors (e.g. product, quality, delivery service, business

    environment and technology) this study has focused on identifying m easures and

    determinants of Malaysian competitiveness in specific E &E s ector using Constant

    Market Share (CMS) approach and Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA)

    approach. CMS decomposes of four components of actual growth of country's

    exports: namely world trade, commodity composition, market distribution and

    (residual) competitiveness. CMS identifies factors that contribute to the export gain

    or loss in the world market - structural and competitiveness and the RCA analysis

    provides a rough indicator of the strength of a product in terms of its comparative

    advantage in the world export market relative to others (Fatimah and Alias, 1997).

    8

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    22/24

    1.2 Terms And Definition

    "Competitiveness" in this study was defined as any changes in the export

    value measured by only microeconomic factor such as price factor (i.e cost of the

    product).

    "Specialization" was defined as producing a product which has a niche

    market and high value added.

    1.3 Problem Statement

    The Malaysian economy has experienced a rapid economic growth during the

    past three decades. The manufacturing sector has played a decisive role in

    Malaysian economic success, contributing significantly to output, investment,

    employment, and exports. Although the export sector particularly E&E has been at

    the forefront in transforming the Malaysian economy, it has also made the country

    highly dependent on the buoyancy of the external sector such as those mentioned

    above.

    The E&E sector as a major contributor to Malaysian export and accounting for

    more than half of the country's export revenue has been sliding since the tech

    meltdown in 2000. The past two decades or so have s een s ubstantial changing

    patterns of export share and export merchandise in Malaysia. There is a very strong

    belief that fast-growing China is overtaking the ASEAN-2 countries, in international

    trade arena especially with the accession to the WTO of China. ASEAN particularly

    Malaysia is facing the challenge of a rapidly industrializing China, not only China's

    flooding its low-priced manufactured products, but competing indirectly in a third

    country market, which is a more serious treat to ASEAN (Wong, 1984 in Wen, 2001).

    9

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    23/24

    The local E&E industry has shown mixed performance across its various sub-

    sector (table 1) while exports of lower-end product suffered declines. Even though

    semiconductor sales had instead strengthened in 2003, amid the increasingly keen

    competition and pressure to cut costs, Multinational Corporations (MNCs) are shifting

    their manufacturing bases to lower-cost countries, mainly China. Declining exports

    has also been more pronounced for labor-intensive and lower-value-added products

    that is the most vulnerable to competition from China, such as television, air-

    conditioners, electrical apparatus and refrigerators. The cost skilled labor in Malaysia

    is estimated to be 2 times more expensive than in China (Ram 2003).

    Table 2: Gross Exports 01Exports

    Semiconductors

    Electronic components andparts

    Industrial equipment &machinery

    Electrical appliances(consumer product)Total E&E exports

    Share of total export (%)

    E&E Manufacuturers In IV2000

    (RM mil)

    71,16995,662

    36,182

    26,463

    229,476

    62%

    2001

    (RM mil)

    60,774

    79,082

    35,980

    24,714

    200,550

    60%

    alaysia.2002

    (RM mil)

    72,522

    81,742

    32,315

    22,482

    209,061

    59%

    2003

    (RM mil)

    77,985

    69,196

    33,465

    21,810

    202,456

    53%

    Increase

    Decrease

    Decrease

    Decrease

    Decrease

    decrease

    Sources: DOS

    China's robust economic growth and strong gravitational pull of foreign direct

    investments have been serious threats to ASEAN countries, particularly those which

    are highly dependent on the E&E sector for their export revenue (figure 1). Does this

    then imply doom and gloom for Malaysia?

    Therefore, this study is interested to investigate the performance of Malaysian

    E&E exports and their competitiveness as compared to other competitors.

    10

  • 8/2/2019 Malaysia Electronic Industry

    24/24

    1.4 Objective Of The Study

    The objective of the study is:

    1. To analyze the market share of Malaysia E&E exports using constant

    Market Share (CMS) approach in order to assess its competitiveness in

    the world market.

    2. To identify the Malaysian competitive position in E&E exports to the world

    market from 1990-2004.

    3. To examine whether the decline in Malaysia E&E export performance

    over 1990 -2004 is associated with the decline in Malaysian

    Competitiveness.

    1.5 Research Questions

    Based on the above problem statement and research objectives, the basic questions

    that need to be addressed here are:

    1. Does Malaysia E&E product have the comparative advantage in the world

    market?

    2. How competitive are these exports?

    3. As compared to the selected countries, which competitive position

    Malaysia is in E&E export, to the world market from 1990-2004?

    4. Is the decline in Malaysia E&E export performance over 1990 -2004 is

    associated with the decline in Malaysian Competitiveness?

    5. Where are the potential markets for these products?

    11