MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING...

24
© 2019 ideas42 1 MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING ECONOMIC MOBILITY Matthew Darling, ideas42 Policy Institute for Governors’ Human Services Advisors 9/12/2019

Transcript of MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING...

Page 1: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 1

MAKING WORK COUNT:

STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING ECONOMIC MOBILITY

Matthew Darling, ideas42Policy Institute for Governors’ Human Services Advisors

9/12/2019

Page 2: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 2

A STORY…

Page 3: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 3

Page 4: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 4

Page 5: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 55

Page 6: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 6

CONTEXT MATTERS

FIX THE CONTEXTNOT THE PERSON

Page 7: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 7

THE STANDARD MODEL

DECISIONS ACTIONS OUTCOME

yes

no

A

B

yes

no

benefits >

costs?

we decide “yes” if benefits > costs

action naturally follows from decision

Page 8: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 8

ACTUAL BEHAVIORAL MODEL

DECISIONS ACTIONS OUTCOME

Yes

No

I don’t know ?

?

?How difficult is it?

Will it take long?

What’s everyone else doing?

Can I just do it tomorrow?

Was I already “good” today?

Page 9: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 9

BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS AND POVERTY

Page 10: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 10

Page 11: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 11

POVERTY INTERRUPTED: DESIGNING FOR SCARCITY

3 design principles and

15 recommendationsfor reducing the bandwidth

tax and addressing the

context of poverty

Page 12: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 12

THE DESIGN PRINCIPLES

Cut the costs Create slack Reframe and empower

Page 13: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 13

DESIGN PRINCIPLE 1: CUT THE COSTS

Well-meaning programs increase these costs unintentionally

Page 14: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 14

Poverty Interrupted white paper.

CREATING SYNERGIES

Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100%

of college aged student received the scholarship because the

sign-up was integrated into the standard housing application.

Page 15: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 15

DESIGN PRINCIPLE 2: CREATE SLACK

Poverty is unforgiving, leaving no room for error or risk.

Even minor unanticipated “shocks” can be catastrophic for families.

Building resilience to these shocks to support families.

Page 16: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 16

Poverty Interrupted white paper.

offers “stackable” trainings, each of which leads to a workplace credential,

so participants get credit even if they can’t complete the whole program.

BUILDING BACKSTOPS

Page 17: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 17

Living in poverty carries a powerful social stigma.

Many systems and programs unintentionally reinforce this stigma rather than affirm

autonomy and dignity.

DESIGN PRINCIPLE 3: REFRAME & EMPOWER

Page 18: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 18

Poverty Interrupted white paper.

invites successful participants back

to work with younger students and hires from within the community

BUILDING PLAUSIBLE PATHS TO SUCCESS

Page 19: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 19

POLICY IMPLICATION:WORK REQUIREMENTS

Page 20: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 20

Page 21: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 21

WORK REQUIREMENTS…

INCREASE COSTS

ELIMINATE SLACK

MALIGN AND

DISEMPOWER

Page 22: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 22

Page 23: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 23

Page 24: MAKING WORK COUNT: STRATEGIES FOR PROMOTING … · Poverty Interrupted white paper. CREATING SYNERGIES Among families Tacoma Housing Authority worked with, 100% of college aged student

© 2019 ideas42 24