1 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAIBENCH AT AURANGABAD

ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO. 864 OF 2011

DISTRICT : - LATUR.

Vasudha d/w. Baburao Musale,Age: 26 Years, Occu: Education,R/o. Nagobanagar, Ahmedpur. .. APPLICANT.

V E R S U S

1. The State of Maharashtra,(Copy to be served on C.P.O.M.A.T. Bench at Aurangabad.)

2. The Dy. Secretary,Maharashtra Public Service Commission,Bank of India Building, 3rd floor,Mahatma Gandhi Road,Hutatma Chowk, Mumbai-400 001.

3. Sathe Tejaswini Gajanan,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Bld. No. 1, Flat No. 4, Saraswati Hsg,Maharashtranagar, Bhd Eden Wood,Pokharn Rd. No.2,Thane- W Maharashtra 400607.

4. Chougule Mahesh Nilkanth,Age: Major, Occu: EducationMr. Nilkanth Mahadev Chougule,At. Post- Tardal, Tq. Hatkanangale,Dist. Kolhapur-416121.

2 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

5. Wakchaure Santosh Uttam,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,At. Post, Kalas BK, Taluka-Akole,Dist. Ahmednagar-422603.

6. Nerurkar Smita Syamsundar,Age: Major, Occu. Education,B-34, B Wing, Room No. 404,R.M.M.S. Sector, Gokukdham, Goregaon,E-Mumbai 400063.

7. Shelke Sachin Karbhari,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At Hangewadi, Post. Malunja, Tq. Shrigonda,Dist.: Ahmednagar-422605.

8. Bhosale Rajendra Ashok,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At. Rajawadi, Post: Bijawadi,Tal. Man, Dist. Satara-415508.

9. Chattar Vikas Paraji,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Room No.-71, Shubhanmangal Boys Hostel,K.N.P. College of Veterinary Sciences, Shirwal,Tq. Khandala Dist. Satara-412801.

10. Aradhye Anuradha Gajanan,Age: Major, Occu.: EducationCo Sadashiv C Nair Flat No. 7,B1 Bandal Complex Paud Road Kothrud Depo.Pune-411038.

11. More Vidya Kashinath,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,

3 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

4, Shanti Niwas, Tembipada Gamdevi Road,Bhandup, Mumbai-400708.

12. Mirajkar Pallavi Prakash,Age: Major, Occu: EducationDr. Kore Kumar Baburao,Asst. Prof. Dept. of Animal NutritionCollege of Veterinary Science & AnimalHusbandry, Navsari Agricultural University,Navasari, Surat, Gujrat-396450.

13. Aher Amol Sharad,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Room No. 25, Boys PG Hostel,Bombay Veterinary College,Parel, Mumbai-400012.

14. Shejal Mahesh Ambadas,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At. Post Ale, Tal-Junnar,Dist. Pune-412411.

15. Mane Jyoti Babruvan,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Dr. Jyoti S. Koratkar,Madhuvishwa Flat No. E 306,Near Periwinkle English School,Bavdhan BK,Tq. Mulshi, Dist. Pune-411021.

16. Dhayagude Rohini Subhash,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,At Pehe, Post. Shevate,Tal. Pandharpur, Dist. Solapur-413315.

4 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

17. M A Majed M A Rasheed,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Quadrabad Plot, Raj Nagar,Near Dr. Umrikar Hospital,Parbhani-431401.

18. Thube Harshala Appasaheb,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,At.Post. Kanhur PatharAhamednagar, Maharashtra-414303.

19. Potey Dnyanesh Eknath,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At.Post. Balegaon, Tal. Akot,Dist. Akole-444117.

20. Ramane Sangram Pandit,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At. Satarade, Post. Padal, Tal. Panhala,Dist. Kolhapur-416205.

21. Deshmukh Shubha Vinodrao,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At.Post. Watfali, Tal. Ner,Dist. Yavatmal-445001.

22. Gajbhiye Abha Haridas,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,29 Milind Nagar, Khamla, Nagpur-25.

23. Gawade Lalita Babasaheb,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At Hunumantgaon, Post Pathare BK,Tal. Rahata, Dist. Ahmednagar-413721.

5 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

24. Yadav Manish Hansraj,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,At Post Khasapuri No.2, Tq. Paranda,Dist. Osmanabadd-413503.

25. Dhanawade Nirmala Bajeerao,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Plot No. 991, Vitthalnagar, Shirur,Tq. Shirur, Dist. Pune-412208.

26. Patil Rajashree Namdev,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Amar Maind Madhuvishwa, C-301,S. No. 13-2 13-3 14-3 D.P. Road,Near Perivinkal School Bavdhan BK,Tq. Mulshi Dist. Une-411021.

27. Magar Nitin Suddhakar,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At Post. Waghunde Khurde,Tal. Parner, Dist. Ahmednagar-414301.

28. Mahajan Madhuvanti Vijaykumar,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Vardan Railway Station Road,Opposite. Jamhoor D.Ed. College,Udgir, Dist. Latur-413517.

29. Mahajan Namrata Anil,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,CO SR Pawar Ramchandra Qutr NO C3,Sudhir Colony, Akola, Dist. Akola-444002.

30. Chause Hussain Sayyed,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,

6 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Hussain Sayeed Chause,Bhoigalli Corner, Maulana Azad Road,Opposite. Dr. Hussaini Hospital Parbhani,Dist. Parbhani-431401.

31. Nakod Namrata Namdeorai,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Adv. Namdeo R. Nakod, Municipal Colony,Darga Road, Parbhani,Tq. & Dist. Parbhani-431401.

32. Patel Vaibhav Ramnath,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Vaibhav Ramnath Patel,At Post Ugwa, Tq. & Dist. Akola-444002.

33. Kad Suresh Dhondiba,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Room No.4, PG Hostel,Mumbai Veterinary College ParelMumbai-400012.

34. Rajgude Dhananjay RupchandAge: Major, Occu.: Education,At Taradgavhan PO. Manadavgan,Tq. Shrigonda,Dist. Ahmednagar-414101.

35. Tekade Vaijayanta Megharaj,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Shivaji Colony, At Post. Shirwal,Tq. Khandala, Dist. Satara-412801.

36. Kumbhar Ganesh Bhagvan,Age: Major, Occu: Education,

7 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Near Malojiraje Sheti Vidyalaya,Khumbaar wasti, At Post. Phaltan,Tq. Phaltan, Dist. Satara-415523.

37. Niture Ganesh Sidhappa,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Niture Nivas, Near Hawgi Swami College,Dam Road Udgir, Tq. Udgir, Dist. Latur-413517.

38. Ashwin Jayarajan,Age: Major, Occu: Education,12-1, Madhukung, Jaya Nagar, Dattapada Road,Borivli-E, Mumbai-400066.

39. Karle Anshuman SitaramAge: Major, Occu: Education,Plot No. 72, Janata Park-1, At Post Navapur,Tq. Navapur, Dist. Nandurbar-425418.

40. Biradar Bhaskar Pralhadrao,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Dr. Bhaskar Pralhadrao Biradar,Maharashtra Gramin Bank, Branch-Biloli,Tq. Biloli, Dist. Nanded-431710.

41. Arde Rohini Rajaram,Age: Major, Occu. Education,Rohini Sushil Gaikwad,B-8-3-13-14 Navratha Hsg, Sector-8,Sanpada, Dist. Thane 400705.

42. Zakher Ali Gafoor Ali,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Zaker Ali Gafoor Ali,Gulzar Colony, Dhar Road,

8 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Near Gulzar Masjid Parbhani,Parbhani. 431401.

43. Hatzade Ravindrakumar Imdeo,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Dr. Ravindrakumar Imdeo Hatzade,At Post Koka Jungle, Tq., Dist. Bhandara-441905.

44. Sabale Adinath Navanath,Age: Major, Occu: Education,At Watanwadi, Post Kada Sugar Factory,Ashti, Tq. Ashti, Dist. Beed-414202.

45. Jagtap Archana Bajirao,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Flat No.-3, Building No.-B-5, Shreeram Darshan,Phase I, Off Pune Satar Road, Near Snake Park,Katraj, Pune-411046.

46. Deshpande Raman Manikrao,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Nikhil Rasidency, Savaata Mali Chowk, BeedSahayog Nagar, East Beed,Tq. And Dist. Beed-431122.

47. Adlak Smita Ashokrao,Age: Major, Occu: Educatio,Dr. Adlak Smita Ashokrao, Alsi Plot,Near Vimalabai Alsi School Akola,Dist. Akola-444001.

48. Jadhav Ravindra Kaka,Age: Major, Occu: Educatin,At Post Wavarhire, Tq. Man,Dist. Satara-415001.

9 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

49. Chavhan Somanath Kundalik,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Dr. Chavhan Somanath Kundalik,Ram Nivas, At Post Bhavinimgaon,Tel. Shevgaon, Dist. Ahmednagar-414502.

50. Dige Mahesh Shivanand,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,At Deep Nagar, Purna Road, Nanded,Tq. And Dist. Nanded-431605.

51. Raghorte Yogesh Manik,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Budhwaripeth Near Gurudev Seva Ashram,Umrer,Tq. Umrer, Dist. Nagpur-441203.

52. Birajdar Vishnu Nananasaheb,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Birajdar Vihnu Nanasaheb,B-3, -32, New Green Valley CHS SECT-8B,CBD Belapur, Navi Mumbai-400614.

53. Kshirsagar Deepali Dattatraya,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,3590 Raul Colony, Barshi,Tq. Barshi, Dist. Solapur-413401.

54. Patil Ashish Jayawant,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Primary Health Subcenter, Near Water Tank,Nagthane, TQ. Palus, Dist. Sangli-416313.

55. Padwal Navnath Popat,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Navnath Popat Padwal,

10 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

At Post. Golegaon, Tq. Shirur,Dist. Pune-412210.

56. Inamdar Arif Innus,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Varkute Malwadi, Tq. Man, (Dahiwadi),Dist. Satara-415509.

57. Sonone Swapnil Hiraman,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,45-C, Tapovan Complex, Somalwada,Wardha Road, Nagpur,Dist. Nagpur-440002.

58. Autade Deepak Prabhakar,Age: Major, Occu: Education,SO Autade Prabhakar,Teacher Colony, Laxmi Nagar,Near Bhoom Dudh Sang,Pardi Road, Bhoom,Tq. Bhoom, Dist. Osmanabad-143504.

59. Pange Avinash Dhuleshwar,Age: Major, Occu: Education,Pange Avinash Dhuleshwar,At Post. Shindewadi, Tq. Malshiras,Dist. Solapur-413109.

60. Rajput Nilesh Ganesh,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Rajput Nilesh Ganesh,At Post Raipur, Nandurbar,Dist. Nandurbar-425418.

11 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

61. Dharmadhikari Deepak Desai,Age: Major, Occu.: Education,Mangalya House No.-217,Sneh Nagar Vasmat Road, Parbhani,Dist. Parbhani-431401.

62. Kalaskar Pankaj SuryakantAge-major, Occ. EducationDr. Kalaskar Pankaj SuryakantAt post Kurhe Hardo, Tq. BodwadDist. Jalgaon – 425 105

63. Lokhande Shivaji DatatrayaAge___ major, Occ. EducationShubhmangal Boys Hostel,KNP College of Veterinary ScienceShirwal dist. Satara 412801.

64. Sarode Amol DattuAge __ major, Occ. EducationB-18 Shashi Sahakar SocietyNityanand Nagar, Ghatkopar,West, Mumbai-400086

65. Kadam Sagar NanasoAge ___ major, Occ. EducationC/o Vandana Nanaso KadamAt Post Yetgaon, Near Vita,Dist. SAngli-415311.

66. Satpute Ashlesha KrushnakumarB Vandana Apt. Pavanbhumi,Somalwada, Wardha Road, NagpurDist. Nagpur-25.

12 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

67. Raibole Dharmraj PurushottamAge __ major, Occ. EducationNear a block 368, Nagsen Nagar,Kansai Road, Subhash Tekdi,Ulhasnagar, Dist. Thane-421 001.

68. Raut Jaya DevidasAge ___ major, Occ. EducationSurbhi Nagar, Jivane Layout,Pimpalgaon Road, Yavatmal,Dist. Yavatmal-445003

69. Galakatu Shirish ShivajiraoAge___ major, Occu. EducationShivajirao A GalakatuSuyog Colony, Pati No. 2, ParbhaniDist. Parbhani-431401.

70. Deshmukh Nilesh DattatrayaAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Deshmukh Nilesh DattatryaAt Post Gour, Tq. Kallam,Dist. Osmanabad-413525

71. Tare AShwini BhupalAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post Alate, Tq. HatkanangleDist. Kolhapur-416109.

72. Kore Kumar BaburaoAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Kore Kumar Baburao,Asst. Prof. Dept. of Animal NutritionCollege of Veterinary Science & AnimalHusbandry, Navsari Agricultural University,

13 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Navasari, Surat, Gujrat-396450

73. Mulla Ahmad AbubakarAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post – Islampur, Tq. MalshirasDist. Solapur 413 107

74. Patil Prakash SubhashAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post – Mangle, Tq. Shirala,Ranjeet Chowk Dist. Sangli-415405.

75. Hagawane Sachin DinkarAge __ major, Occ. Education135, Hagawane Wastee, At post-Velang,Tq. Wai, Dist. Satara 412803.

76. Ambekar namrata NarayanraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationSmrutigandha Plot no. 110, Sec. 27AACNTDA Pune, Dist. Pune-411002.

77. Manjare Pramod TukaramAge __ major, Occ. EducationManjare Pramod TukaramNaikwadi Plot, Gandhinagar,Paranda road, Barshi.Tq. Barshi, Dist. Solapur-413401.

78. Katkar Shilpa MadhavAge __ major, Occ. Education165 mangalwar peth, At Post-Bhor,Tq. Bhor, Dist. Pune 412206

79. Jadhav Vinayak Laxmanrao

14 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Age __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post – Chikalthana BK Tq. SailuDist. Parbhani-431503.

80. Chukewar Atul BabanappaAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Chukewar Atul BabanappaAt Post-Ghatbori Tq. Mehkar,Dist. Buldhana-443301

81. Pandure Dinesh RameshAge __ major, Occ. EducationBazatal Lain Near Garute Photo Studio,Newasa Tal. NewasaDist. Ahmednagar-414603.

82. Kadam Bramhanand AnkushAge __ major, Occ. EducationMahatma Gandhi Nagar Yedashi Road,Osmanabad, Dist. Osmanabad-413501.

83. Warhadpande Rahul MukundraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationR-144 A Reshimbag Layout NagpurDist. Nagpur-440005.

84. Murkikar Dhanraj NagoraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationNL6 Type Building No. 5, Flat No.13,Sector 10, Nerul, Navi Mumbai-400614.

85. Nagdive Anshuja ArunkumarAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Nagdive Anshuja Arunkumar583 Bezonbagh Housing Society

15 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Khadan Side, Bezonbagh, Nagpur,Dist. Nagpur-440004

86. Shinde Prakash RambhauAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Jawale Post NirgudsarTq. Ambegaon Dist. Pune 412406

87. Londhe Sharad PopatAge __ major, Occ. EducationDept. of Vet. MicrobiologyMumbai Veterinary college behind KEMHospital, Parel Mumbai-400012

88. Khose Kavita AshokAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Khose Kavita Ashok At postGunore, Tq. Parner,Dist. Ahmednagar-414306

89. Rakh Baliram JayramAge __ major, Occ. EducationC/o P.S. Kendre, 3 ekta nagar,Chaitanary nagar, Troda BK.Main Road, Nanded 431605

90. Kolekar Mahendra ApparaoAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Kolekar Mahendra Apparao845, hagre plot, krantisingh nagar,Uplai road, Barshi, Tq. Barshi,Dist. Solapur-413401

91. Pawar Shivraj AshokraoAge __ major, Occ. Education

16 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

At post Peth, Kumbhar galli,Tq. Walwa, Dist. Sangli-415407

92. Jaybhaye Ramdas SavleramAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt post Pimpalner, Tq. Shirur Kasar,Dist. Beed-431122

93. Bhole Gajanan ShriniwasAge __ major, Occ. EducationCo Dr. Shriniwas BholePost Shirdhone Tehsil MalkapurDist. Buldhana-443102

94. Mahalankar Swapnil SunilAge __ major, Occ. EducationMahalankar Sunil P, Prayag BhavanBhagirathi nagar, near Vitthal nagar,Gudadhi Road, GudadhiDist. Akola-444005

95. Sarode Irawati PoleshwarAge __ major, Occ. EducationIrawati poleshwar sarode 438,Sindhi colony, behind sindhi hindiSchool, Khamla Nagpur,Dist. Nagpur-400025

96. Karlewad Vaiju ShivajiAge __ major, Occ. EducationFlat No. B-4 Jai raj residencyMayureshwar raj park PriyadarashaniNagar, Old Sangvi Pune,Dist. Pune-411027

17 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

97. Jadhav Sandip RamchandraAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Jadhav SAndip Ramchandra86 Kesarkar Peth, near Hindvi PublicSchool, Satara Dist. Satara-415002.

98. Mundhe Bharat LimbajiAge __ major, Occ. EducationL.K. Mundhe, Jivandhara Niwas,Vikas Nagar, Karegaon Road,Near Deshmukh Hotel ParbhaniDist. Parbhani-431401

99. Deokar Shubhangi GautamAge __ major, Occ. EducationIrrigation Colony at post NateputeTq. Malshiras, Dist. Solapur-413107

100. Aware Swati ShivramAge __ major, Occ. EducationShri Shivram K AwareAnantkrupa, Near D. PharmacyInstitute, Umrer KothaTq. & Dist. Osmanabad-413501

101.Hadaoo Mohan KeshavAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt post Sangadi Tah. SakoliDist. Bhandara 441802

102. Borde Archana UttamraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationShri Shivram K AwareAashray N-7 K13 Jay Bajrang Colony,Cidco, Aurangabad, Dist. Aurangabad -431003.

18 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

103. Chimote Meena JanardhanAge __ major, Occ. EducationJanardhan hariji chimoteWard No. 3 Gadbuldi Mohpa Tq. KalmeshwarDist. Nagpur -441501.

104. Pendharkar Abhishek AnandAge __ major, Occ. EducationSmt. U.A. Pendharkar3 panchayat Samiti quarters, Sahada,Tq. Sahada, Dist. Nandurbar-425409

105.Bachanti Deepak RamraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationUrjanagar colony, qtr no. E5-4CSTPS, MSEB, Chandrapur,Dist. Chandrapur-442402

106. Gongale Madhavi AnandAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Gongale Madhavi Anand,Maharanapratap Ward,Near palli Buddha vihar BallarpurTq. Ballarpur Dist. Chandrapur 442701.

107. Deore Sandip NanabhauAge __ major, Occ. EducationDeore Sandip NanabhauAt post mukati Tq. And Dist. Dhule 424315

108. Kale Asaram KernathAge __ major, Occ. EducationRasal P.B., Swarajya Nagar,Balbhim Colony Beed,Tq. and Dist. Beed-431122

19 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

109. Walunj Uday DadabhauAge __ major, Occ. EducationSwami Samarth Nagar, Maldad road, SangamnerTq. Sangamner Dist. Ahmednagar-422605

110. Ghodake Prafulla SureshAge __ major, Occ. EducationNear Terna Engineering College,Tuljapur Road, OsmanabadTq. and Dist. Osmanabad-433501

111. Mohalkar Amol SudamAge __ major, Occ. EducationSudam Y MohalkarPlt no. 29, Shri krushn niwas sanskar colony,Jalna road, Beed, Dist. Beed -431122

112. Varma Trupti SureshAge __ major, Occ. EducationVanjari fail varma niwas sbi road, YavatmalDist. Yavatmal-445003

113. Rahangadale Santosh ParashramAge __ major, Occ. EducationNear jay kirana stores behind veterinary collegeSurendragadh seminary hills, NagpurDist. Nagpur-440006

114. Lakde Mahesh BapuraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationFront of sapna hotel,Jalna road BeedDist. Beed-431203

115. Tekale Ashish Anantrao

20 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Age __ major, Occ. EducationVilasrao Vasantrao Tekale,Near Dutt Mandir, Washi, Tq. Washi,Dist. Osmanabad 413503

116. Karale Pradeep VishnuAge __ major, Occ. EducationMN 617 Tambake Galli, Near Bhairoba MandirGram Nandani post Nandani Tq. Shirala,Dist. Solapur-416102.

117. Sawalkar Rajendranath SomanathAge __ major, Occ. EducationRakemdranath Somanath SawalkarAt Bhairawanathwadi, Post Tungat Tq. Pandharpur,Dist. Solapur-413304

118. Ghanvat Dipak PandurangAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post Morochi Tq. MalshirasDist. Solapur 413109

119. Ambalkar Gajendra BalabhauAge __ major, Occ. EducationAmbalkar Gajendra BalabhauAt post Keliveli Tah. AkotDist. Akola-444111

120. Kale Rushikesh PanandurangAge __ major, Occ. EducationRoom No. 25, Boys PG hostelMumbai Veterinary college behind KEM HospitalParel Mumbai -400012

121. Jadhav Sagar Ramchandra

21 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Age __ major, Occ. EducationRamchara Nagnath Jadhav,M.V. Seeds Company Nehru Chauk IndapurTq. Indapur Dist. Pune-413106

122. Rahane Sachin DagaduramAge __ major, Occ. EducationC/o Rahane Dagaduram Vitthal,Lohar Galli, Ap Vambori, Tq. Rahuri,Dist. Ahmednagar-413704.

123. Kharde Karan RajendraAge __ major, Occ. EducationKharde Karan RajendraD26 staff quarters pravara rural engg college,Loni, Dist. Ahmednagar

124. Kshirsagar Pravina MadhavraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationShiv shakti nagar, degloor road, UdgirTq. Udgir dist. Latur -413517

125. Parekar Sushant ShahajiAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Parkar Sushant ShahajiAt post ArewadiTq. Kavathe Mahakal, Dist. Sangli 416403

126. Mankar Dipika RamanAge __ major, Occ. EducationBiyabani Tq. Achalpur, Dist. Amravati-444806

127. Sankhe Rahul AshokAge __ major, Occ. EducationRoom No. 21, boys PG hostel,

22 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Mumbai veterinary college behind KEM HospitalParel Mumbai 400013

128. Waghmode Sarjerao ShahajiAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt 60 phata, post Malshira,Tq. Malshiras, Dist. Solapur-413107

129. Meshram Devendra JanardhanAge __ major, Occ. EducationRambai Ambedkar chouk,Vidya nagar bramhapuri,Dist. Chandrapur 441206

130. Adsul Navnath ShivajiAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Adsul Navnath ShivajiAt post kangaon Tq. Dound,Dist Pune-412219

131. Gavir Punam BhayyajiAge __ major, Occ. EducationNear new bus stop shakti nagar, ArmoriTq. Armori Dist. Gadchiroli-441208

132. Somwanshi Amarnath GorkhanathAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Somwanshi Amarnath GorkhanathAt Nideban, Tq. Udgir,Dist. Latur-413517.

133. Mane Laxman ManikAge __ major, Occ. EducationAT post Khed bk. KatewadiTq. Khandala, Dist. Satara 415521

23 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

134. Gavade Vishal BalbhimAge __ major, Occ. Education1) C/o Balbhim Bhagwan Gavade Ap-BhoseTq. Miraj Dist. Sangli. 416422//2) C/o Balbhim Bhagwan Gavade Ap-BhoseTq. Khed Dist. Pune 410501//3) C/o Balbhim Bhagwan Gavade Ap-BhoseTq. Koregaon, Dist. Satara 415501

135. Vaidya Mangesh MahadeoAge __ major, Occ. EducationVaidya Mangesh MahadeoAt. Dadapur Post. Ramgad Tq. KurkhedaDist. Gadchiroli 441209

136. Kale Sneha AvinashAge __ major, Occ. EducationDhyaneshwari Care of Avinash DhamaleNear Gita Niwas, Next to shidhar apartment,Wghire colony no. 4, Pimpri gav,Pimpri Pune, Dist. Pune-411017

137. Dongardive Karuna MahadeoAge __ major, Occ. EducationM.R. Dongardive, H No. 13 72,Gautam Nagar, Ghati, Behind Vihar, AurangabadDist. Aurangabad 431001

138. Tembhurne Rohini DadabhaiAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Rohini D. Temdhurne, Plot No. 550,Indora math moholla post Benzanbagh,Nagpur-14, Dist. Nagpur 440002

24 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

139. Nagrale Deoyani GosaiAge __ major, Occ. EducationGosai kachruji nagarale Nehru Nagar,Ward No. 4, ChandrapurDist. Chandrapur-431402

140. Shendage Sanjay GanpatAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post Arun Tq. MadhaDist. Solapur 413301

141. Patil Dhanajirao ShrimantAge __ major, Occ. EducationCo Shrimant Dashrath PatilJijamata housing society plot no-9,Shymai bungalow varnali road,Vishrambagh SangliDist. Sangli-416416

142. Bhalerao Kapil PandurangraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationLaxminarayan Nagar,In Front of Hanuman TempleGate no. 02, Taroda bk NandedDist. Nanded-431605

143. Aghadate Satish KashinathAge __ major, Occ. EducationCo Uttam D Ghope jalambTq. Shegaon Dist. Buldhana 444303

144. Narwade Baban MadhavraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt post chuncha via HadgaonTQ. Kalamnuri Dist. Hingoli 431702

25 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

145. Jadhav Milind MohanAge __ major, Occ. EducationAshtavinayak cooperative housing society,2A flat no. 22, MMRDA colony, opp. Durga Nagar,Jogeshwari Vikroli link road,Andheri East, Mumbai 4000093

146. Shrisath Priti RajabhauAge __ major, Occ. Education774 near Buddha Mandir, Sadar BazarSadar Nagpur, Dist. Nagpur -440001

147. Khadiwale Mayadevi ShivajiraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Khadiwale Mayadevi ShivajiraoSugandhadeep bhagyan nagarShelhal road Udgir Tq. UdgirDist. Latur 413517

148. Bansod Snehal MurlidharraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Bansod Snehal MurlidharraoCo Bhanudasji Khandekar 22 Prajapati Nagar,Near Railway Crossing, Old Bhandara Road,Nagpur, Dist. Nagpur 440008

149. Dhamgunde Ajay SubhashraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationDeha raksha sadan house no. 1940Opp kalyan mandapamBehind jayakwadi workshopLokmanya nagar ParbhaniTq. And Dist. Parbhani-431101

26 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

150. Rathod Sanjay UttamAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Ananad Nagar Tanda post limbaTal. Pathri Dist. Parbhani-431541

151. Chavan Radheshyam MadhurkarAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt post Gawand goan tal. PaturDist. Akola 444501

152. Kale Komal VijayAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Kale Komal Vijay Nagpur Veterinary College,Girls Hostel Seminary hills NagpurDist. Nagpur 440006

153. Lahamte Chandrakant MarutiAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post Lavhali tal. Akole,Dist. Ahmednagar 433604

154. Puri Rangnath MarotiraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. R.M. Puri c/o M.R. PuriPSI Railway police StationNanded, Dist. Nanded -431601

155. Chavhan Sushil ShankarAge __ major, Occ. EducationProf. Shankar G. Chavhan Dubewar Layout PusadTq. Pusad, Dist. Yeotimal-445204

156. Gavit Yogesh TanajiAge __ major, Occ. EducationB.B. Tyade 15 Kalpataru Banglow

27 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Gosavi Nagar canal road Jail road,Nashik Road, Nashik,Dist. Nashik-422101

157. Warbhe Prashant VithalraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post Nagri tal. WaroraDist. Chandrapur -442907

158. Unaune Kiran PrabhakarAge __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Unaune Kiran Prabhakar,At. Post Mhaswad,Dist. Satara-415509

159. Bingewar Balaji ShamraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt. Dhanora Kp post KarkheliTal. Dharmabad Dist. Nanded-431808

160. Bawane Pradip VishwanathAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post Ramgad Tal. KurkhedaDist. Gadchiroli-441209

161. Rathod Sangita BaliramAge __ major, Occ. EducationB.H. Rathod Parvati NagarNear G.N. Azad college Pusad,Tq. Pusad Dist. Yeotmal-445204

162. Malgunde Smita AppasahebAge __ major, Occ. EducationBhind Surya Hospital lonand nira road lonand.Dist. Satar 415521

28 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

163. Chavhan Pawankumar HiramanAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt. Amdari post Plodi tal. ManoraDist. Washim 444403

164. Dandage Shashikant DamodharAge __ major, Occ. EducationDhad naka Dhandeleyout BuldhanaDist. Buldhana-443001

165. Rathod Govind RamaAge __ major, Occ. EducationAt Sonkhed Tanda post. Sonpeth Tal. SonpethDist. Parbhani -431516

166. Somwanshi Amarnath GorkhanathAge __ major, Occ. EducationMali Ravindra DinkarAt Post Kole tal. Karad, Dist. Satara-415103

167. Khodwe Prasad ManoharraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationNavijivan colony near Surdharshan BuildingDastur nagar Amravati, Dist. Amravati -444601

168. Ghawat Pankaj GaneshraoAge __ major, Occ. EducationNiwara Colony 1, Ramkrushnanagar,Near Shrma Kirana, AkolaDist. Akola-444002

169.Shinde Rajendra Kisan,Age __ major, Occ. EducationAt. Shrigonda Banker Mala NearTahsil Office, Tal. Shrigonda,

29 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

Dist. Ahmednagar-413701.

170. Kodamelwar Nageshwar Kishanrao,Age __ major, Occ. EducationNear Vitthal Mandir at Post Kinwat,Tq. Kinwat, Dist. Nanded-431804.

171.Rawalkar Meera Gangadharrao,Age __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Rawalkar Meera GangadharraoKrishnai Niwas Shastri Nagar,Bhavsar Chouk Malegaon Road,Nanded, Dist. Nanded-431605.

172. Kowachi Hemantkumar Deorao,Age __ major, Occ. EducationKowachi Hemantkumar DeoraoGhubade Home Neharu Ward No. 2Gadchiroli, Dist. Gadchiroli-431601.

173.Chavan Dipti Madan,Age __ major, Occ. EducationGopal Singh Guru Singh BisenMatoshri Guru Singh Bisen Marg,Behind Laxmi Talkies, Gadipura,Nanded, Dist. Nanded-431601.

174. Dawande Sandip Namdeorao,Age __ major, Occ. EducationAt Post Shendurjana Ghat Malkapur,Tq. Warud, Dist. Amrawati-444706.

175. Bhangare Rajaram Soma,Age __ major, Occ. EducationDr. Bhangare Rajaram Soma

30 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

At post Sakirwadi, Tq. Akole,Dist. Ahmednagar-422604.

176.Lekami Vijay Sharad,Age __ major, Occ. EducationGovt. S.T. Boys Hostel VidyanagariNear Somwari Quarter Hanumannagar,Nagpur, Dist. Nagpur-440002.

177.Hedaoo VAndana Ramesh,Age __ major, Occ. EducationPlot No. 187 Khat Road,Bhaiyyaji Nagar in front ofRajeshree Colony Bhandara,Dist. Bhandara-441904.

178.Wadje Santosh Ganpatrao,Age __ major, Occ. EducationDr. WAdje Santosh GanpatraoGanumpura Bhoigalli KarbalaRoad, Nanded,Dist. Nanded-431601.

179.Mahale Hemant Kashinath,Age __ major, Occ. EducationFlat No. 2 Shriram Apartment Shivaji Nagar,Dindori Road Mhasrul Tq. Dindori, Nashik,Dist. Nashik-422004.

180. Patil Shivali Rajesaheb,Age __ major, Occ. EducationVrandavan Girls Hostel,Behind Veterinary College, Parbhani,MAU Campus, Parbhani,Dist. Parbhani-431402. .. RESPONDENTS.

31 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

------------------------------------------------------------------------APPEARANCE : Shri S.K. Mathpati, learned Advocate

holding for Shri B.R. Kedar – learnedAdvocate for the Applicant.

: Smt. Sanjivani Deshmukh-Ghate –learned Presenting Officer for therespondents.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------CORAM : HON’BLE SHRI RAJIV AGARWAL,

VICE CHAIRMAN (A).AND

: HON’BLE SHRI B.P. PATIL,MEMBER (J)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------DATE : 13TH FEBRUARY, 2017.--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

J U D G M E N T[ Per : Hon’ble Shri Rajiv Agarwal, Vice Chairman (A)]

1. Heard Shri S.K. Mathpati, learned Advocate holding

for Shri B.R. Kedar – learned Advocate for the applicant

and Smt. Sanjivani Deshmukh-Ghate – learned Presenting

Officer for the respondents.

2. The applicant has applied for the post of Live Stock

Development Officer, Group-A, pursuant to the

advertisement dated 18.11.2011 issued by the

Maharashtra Public Service Commission (M.P.S.C.), who is

32 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

the respondent No. 2 in this Original Application. The

main contention of the Applicant is that she had applied

for the post of Live Stock Development Officer, from Open

Category, for a post reserved horizontally for women. The

Respondent No. 2 did not recommend the Applicant and

wrongly recommended women candidates belonging to SC,

ST, NT(C) categories for Open-female vacancies. As per

Government Circular dated 16.3.1999 dealing with

horizontal reservation, horizontal reservation is

compartmentalized and candidates from one vertical

reservation category cannot be selected for the post

reserved for other vertical reservation category.

3. Learned Advocate for the Applicant argued that the

aforesaid Circular dated 16.3.1999 is issued as per law

laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Anil

Kumar Gupta Vs. State of U.P. & Others reported in

JT-1995(5) SC 505. Hon’ble Supreme Court has held

that O.C. Category (open competition) is also a vertical

reservation category for horizontal reservation and for

compartmentalized horizontal reservation, each vertical

33 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

reservation category is a water tight compartment and no

migration from one vertical reservation category to another

is allowed. This judgment is reiterated by Hon’ble

Supreme Court in the case of Rajesh Kumar Daria Vs.

Rajasthan Public Service Commission & Others

reported in AIR 2007 SC 3127(1).

4. This Tribunal has also held in the case of Irfan

Shaikh Vs. State that a vacancy for Open Home Guard

cannot be filled by a Home Guard candidate from other

vertical reservation category. This judgment was upheld

by Aurangabad Bench of Hon’ble High Court and also by

Hon’ble Supreme Court.

5. Learned Advocate for the Applicant argued that the

Applicant had applied from Open-female Category, though

she belongs to NT-(D) Category. In the merit list, she

should have been selected from Open-women category as

35 posts for reserved for Open-woman category and the

Respondent No. 2 has selected 7 candidates from SC, ST,

NT-C categories against Open-female posts.

34 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

6. We had asked the respondent No. 2 to place a copy of

the merit list for the aforesaid competitive examination on

record. The copy of the application form of the applicant

is also placed on record. There is no doubt that the

applicant had applied from Open-female category and

scored total of 58 marks. Last selected candidate from

Open-female category as per this list is at Sr. No. 124

(Ingle Smita Harishchandra), who scored 59 marks.

However, there are candidates of Sr. No. 76, 83, 94, who

belongs to NT-C, SC & ST categories and have been

selected from the Open-female categories. This is by way

of illustration as there are many more such candidates,

who have been selected from Open-female category though

they belong to SC/ST/NT-C categories. This is in violation

of law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Anil Kumar

Gupta (Supra) and Rajesh Kumar Daria (Supra).

7. The applicant has stated these facts in paragraph

XIX(iv) of the Original Application. In the affidavit in reply

dated 19.7.2013, the respondent No. 2 has stated : -

35 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

“3. -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --

-- -- -- -- --

With reference to the new Para XIX (iv& v) I say and submit that for any Open posteven if it is further reserved by way ofhorizontal reservation not only Opencategory candidates are considered but alsocandidates from all the other backwardcategories if they are higher in merit areconsidered.”

8. In fact, the respondent No. 2 has clearly admitted

that Female candidates from SC/ST/NT-C categories have

been selected against Open Female posts. This is clearly

against the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.

From the merit list, the applicant is at Sr. No. 145 and

last candidate from Open-female category (Open Female

35) is at Sr. No. 124. The candidates at Sr. No. 125, 127,

129, 133 & 139 also belong to Open-female category, but

have not been selected. Candidate at Sr. No. 14, 20, 76,

83, 94, 104 & 123 belongs to SC/ST/NT-C categories and

should have been adjusted against their respective vertical

36 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

reservation categories. The Applicant was eligible to be

selected from Open-female category.

9. Learned Advocate for the Applicant made a statement

that the Applicant was selected as Live Stock Development

Officer, Group-A in the selection for the year 2012 and she

is only seeking seniority from 2011 in this case.

Considering this fact, this Original Application is disposed

of with the following directions: -

(i) Though the Applicant is at Sr. No. 5 of the

Open-female candidates, who were eligible for the

selection, other candidates do not appear to have

approached Courts/Tribunals.

(ii) The Applicant is eligible to be given seniority

from 2011 on the basis of her place in the merit list,

but without any back-wages.

(iii) As the Applicant is held eligible for selection

from Open-female category, it will be presumed that

37 O.A. NO. 864 OF 2011

she has given-up her claim of NT-D category, if she

claims and accepts seniority from 2011.

(iv) Except for the case of the Applicant, we are not

unsetting the settled position.

There will be no order as to costs.

MEMBER (J) VICE CHAIRMAN (A)

O.A.NO.864-2011(hdd)-2016(DB)