Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013...

24
Workshop on High Resolu1on Proxies of Paleoclimate Madison, Wisconsin June 13, 2015 HiRes2015 J.W. Valley, HiRes2015 High Resolu1on Proxies of Paleoclimate, June 13, 2015, UWMadison

Transcript of Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013...

Page 1: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Workshop  on  High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate  Madison,  Wisconsin  June  1-­‐3,  2015  

HiRes2015

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 2: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

HiRes2013

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 3: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Lake  Mendota,  1979  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 4: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Pail  &  Shovel  Party    University  of  Wisconsin-­‐Madison  

First  day  of  classes    Sept.  1979      

Proposed  to  change  all  students'  names  to  Joe  Smith            so  that  professors  would  know  everyone  by  name.  Promised  to  order  all  campus  clocks  to  run  backwards          so  classes  would  be  over  before  they  could  begin.  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 5: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

1960                  1970                  1980                  1990                  2000                2010      2020                  2030                  2040                2050                  2060                  2070  

If  the  Pail  and  Shovel  Party  ran  climate  change.  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 6: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Predic1on  is  very  difficult,    especially  if  it’s  about  the  future.        

                 Niels  Bohr,  Piet  Hein,  Yogi  Berra  …..    

1979  2004  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 7: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

C.  R.  Van  Hise          President  UW-­‐Madison  1903-­‐1917  

1904  

CO2  3  GT/y  !  

ΔT=  8-­‐9oC  

Coal  

Chamberlin  Arrhenius  

USGS  Monograph  47,  1286  p.  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of        Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 8: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Speleothems

Ruddiman, 2001

Records of climate change

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 9: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

0 Ga4.6 Ga

Mars Sediment

What  are  the  new  opportuni1es  for  high-­‐resolu1on  study  of  paleoclimate  proxies?    

>4.4  byr  of  Paleoclimate  

Age:  Billion  Years  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 10: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

High-­‐Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate  Imaging  

 Sample  polish,  colloidal  alumina  or  silica    Op1cs:  visible,  reflected,  UV    SEM:  CL,  BSE,  SE,  EBSD    Laser  fluorescent  confocal  microscopy  

Electron  microprobe                  CAMECA  Users  Mee1ng,  Madison,  June  4-­‐5    SIMS:  isotopes,  trace  elements,  light  elements  Laser-­‐abla1on  ICP-­‐MS:  TOF,  quadrupole,                  magne1c  sector;  ns  and  fs  laser  Scanning  XRF  TEM  Synchrotron  Atom  probe              CAMECA  Users  Mee1ng,  Madison,  June  9-­‐12  Raman,  IR  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 11: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

“Tradi1onal  Uses”    

Petrology  Igneous  &  Metamorphic  minerals    Zircons,  Diamonds  &  inclusions  Ore  deposits  Diagene1c  cements      

 Astrobiology      Microfossils,  C-­‐isotopes,  TE’s  Sulfur  4-­‐isotopes    

 Meteorites/  Moon    

   Materials  Science  Thin  films,  depth  profiles  Trace  elements      

             

Ion  microprobe  =  SIMS      

 Biology  Biominerals  Single  bacteria  Tissue  Intracellular  material                Anthropology  &  Archeology    

 Paleoclimate  Proxies      Foraminifera,  Coral,  Sponges,  Mollusks,              Diatoms    Speleothems                Fish  otoliths              Tooth  enamel            Finely  layered  sediments    Pollen    

Isotopes,  Trace  elements,  Light  elements  Complements:  Electron  microprobe    (Major  and  minor  elements)   1-­‐10  μm  spots,  in  situ  

Small,      Precious    or  Zoned  

  J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 12: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Oct  31,  2011  

WiscSIMS Dept. of Geoscience

University of Wisconsin-Madison NSF-supported National Facility  

Kouki  Noriko  

Jim  Reinhard  

John  

Ian  

Travis  Brian  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 13: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

March  1,  2005,    Madison,        -­‐8oC  Instrument  accepted  Nov.  2005 J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 14: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Secondary  Ion  Mass  Spectrometer    SIMS  

Ion  Microprobe    

Sample  

 CAMECA  ims  1280  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 15: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 16: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Mon.  June  1  Room  A140,  Weeks  Hall    (Chair:  Ian  Orland)      9:00-­‐9:20    John  Valley    Welcome  and  Introduc1on  9:20-­‐10:20    Noriko  Kita  (Tutorial):  “SIMS  Basics”  10:20-­‐10:40  Ian  Orland  &  Kouki  Kitajima    “WiscSIMS  Live-­‐  Demonstra1on”  10:40-­‐11:00  Break  11:00-­‐12:00  John  Valley  (Tutorial):  “Accuracy  vs.  Precision”      12:00-­‐2:00              Group  photo  &  Lunch    ATernoon  Session  (Chair:  John  Valley)    2:00-­‐3:00  Richard  Alley  “Abrupt  climate  change:  An  update,  and  challenges  for  high-­‐resolu1on  sampling”  3:00-­‐3:20  Jack  Williams  “Extrinsic  and  intrinsic  causes  of  past  abrupt  changes  in  terrestrial  ecosystems”  3:20-­‐3:40  Break  3:40-­‐4:10  Margaret  Schoeninger  “Paleoclimate  and  tooth  enamel.  Where  do  we  go  from  here?”  4:10-­‐4:30  Melanie  Beasley  “SIMS  reveals  diagenesis  and  seasonal  paleoprecipita1on  at  Allia  Bay,  Kenya”  4:30-­‐4:50  Ian  Orland  &  Kouki  Kitajima  WiscSIMS-­‐Live  Part  2  4:50-­‐5:10  Jake  Cammack  “A  5  cm2  field  area:  QGIS  as  a  tool  for  the  integra1on  of  microanaly1cal  data”    Banquet  (Great  Hall  at  Memorial  Union)  6:00  PM    Cocktail  Hour  7:00-­‐9:00  PM  Dinner  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 17: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Mon.  June  1  Room  A140,  Weeks  Hall    (Chair:  Ian  Orland)      9:00-­‐9:20    John  Valley    Welcome  and  Introduc1on  9:20-­‐10:20    Noriko  Kita  (Tutorial):  “SIMS  Basics”  10:20-­‐10:40  Ian  Orland  &  Kouki  Kitajima    “WiscSIMS  Live-­‐  Demonstra1on”  10:40-­‐11:00  Break  11:00-­‐12:00  John  Valley  (Tutorial):  “Accuracy  vs.  Precision”      12:00-­‐2:00              Group  photo  &  Lunch    ATernoon  Session  (Chair:  John  Valley)    2:00-­‐3:00  Richard  Alley  “Abrupt  climate  change:  An  update,  and  challenges  for  high-­‐resolu1on  sampling”  3:00-­‐3:20  Jack  Williams  “Extrinsic  and  intrinsic  causes  of  past  abrupt  changes  in  terrestrial  ecosystems”  3:20-­‐3:40  Break  3:40-­‐4:10  Margaret  Schoeninger  “Paleoclimate  and  tooth  enamel.  Where  do  we  go  from  here?”  4:10-­‐4:30  Melanie  Beasley  “SIMS  reveals  diagenesis  and  seasonal  paleoprecipita1on  at  Allia  Bay,  Kenya”  4:30-­‐4:50  Ian  Orland  &  Kouki  Kitajima  WiscSIMS-­‐Live  Part  2  4:50-­‐5:10  Jake  Cammack  “A  5  cm2  field  area:  QGIS  as  a  tool  for  the  integra1on  of  microanaly1cal  data”    Banquet  (Great  Hall  at  Memorial  Union)  6:00  PM    Cocktail  Hour  7:00-­‐9:00  PM  Dinner  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 18: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Union  Terrace  Mon    June  1      9  PM      free  movie:    Speed  Wed    June  3      8-­‐11  PM  Open  Mic  Night    

           with  host,  Ben  Cameron  Thurs    June  4      5  PM    Bluegrass  Series-­‐  Cajun  Strangers  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 19: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Tue.  June  2  Room  A140,  Weeks  Hall  8:30-­‐9:00  AM  Light  Breakfast    

   Morning  Session  (Chair:  Reinhard  Kozdon)  9:00-­‐10:00      Ian  Orland:  “Developments  and  challenges  in  ion  microprobe  studies  of  speleothems  and  biocarbonates”  10:00-­‐10:20  Yongli  Gao  “High  resolu1on  paleoclimate  records  from  Yucatán  speleothems  spanning  the  past  2000  years”  10:20-­‐10:40  Mellissa  Cross  ”Records  of  paleoclimate  and  paleohydrology  from  slow-­‐growth  Great  Basin  Speleothems”  10:40-­‐11:00  Break  11:00-­‐11:30  Ronald  Amundson  “High  resolu1on  paleoclimate  records  from  laminated  carbonates  in  soils”  11:30-­‐11:50  Erik  Oerter  “Pedothem  carbonates  record  the  aridifica1on  of  the  Atacama  Desert”  11:50-­‐12:10  David  Fike  “The  Environmental  importance  of  microbial  sulfate  reduc1on  and  dispropor1ona1on:  Insights  from  SIMS-­‐based  δ34S  measurements”  

   Lunch  at  Steenbock’s  on  Orchard  (12:10PM-­‐1:40PM)      ATernoon  Session  (Chair:  Howard  Spero)  

1:40-­‐2:10    Kim  Cobb  “The  Toba  super-­‐erup1on:  Micro-­‐scale  traces  of  a  global-­‐scale  climate  event?”  2:10-­‐2:40    Reinhard  Kozdon  “Geyng  the  big  picture  from  a  small  spot:  Mul1-­‐proxy,  mul1-­‐instrument  in  situ  measurements  in  foraminifera”  2:40-­‐3:00    Samantha  Bova  “Assessing  the  natural  variability  of  the  deep  ocean  using  individual  benthic  foraminifera”  3:00-­‐3:30    Clay  Kelly  “Forams  Forever:  use  of  SIMS  δ18O  and  EPMA  Mg/Ca  analyses  of  plank1c  foraminiferal  shells  to  reconstruct  the  hydrological  cycle  during  past  climate  states“  

   Posters  (3:30PM-­‐5:30PM)    Beverages  and  Refreshments  will  be  provided      Dinner,  on  your  own,  State  St.,  Memorial  Union  Terrace…  ,  see  restaurant  map  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 20: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Wed.  June  3  Room  A140,  Weeks  Hall  8:30-­‐9:00  AM  Light  Breakfast        Morning  Session  (Chair:  Clay  Kelly)  9:00-­‐10:00  Howard  Spero  “Quan1fying  Isotopic  Varia1ons  in  Cultured  Plank1c  Foraminifera  

     at  the  Micron  Scale”  10:00-­‐10:20  Lael  Vecer  “Marsh  madness:  An  early  Holocene  sea-­‐level  record  from  peat  and  paleosols  in  southeastern  Louisiana”  10:20-­‐10:40  Jody  Wycech  “Calibra1on  of  in  situ  SIMS  δ18O  values  to  whole  shell  δ18O      

     composi1ons  using  Holocene  plank1c  foraminifera”  10:40-­‐11:00  Break  11:00-­‐11:30  Alexander  Gagnon  “The  Impact  of  Small-­‐Scale  Heterogeneity  on  Proxies  in    

     Biomineral  Archives”  11:30-­‐11:50  Ann  Russell  “Iden1fying  cultured  foraminiferal  calcite  for  geochemical      

     paleotemperatures  calibra1ons  using  87Sr”  11:50-­‐12:10  Hussein  Sayani  “Reliable  Sr/Ca  es1mates  from  Sclerac1nian  Corals  using  SIMS:  

     Challenges  and  implica1ons”      Lunch  at  Steenbock’s  on  Orchard  (12:10PM-­‐1:40PM)              

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 21: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

Loca1ons  of  stuff    Maps    WC,  turn  right    Lunch,  WID      Banquet,  Memorial  Union  

 WiFi:    PW  from  Union  South  

   UW  Net:  Use  “guest”      Ask  Jim    1  access  point  in  A140    Access  in  lobby  

 Upload  talks,  posters    

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 22: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

L.  Mendota  

L.  Menona  

Memorial  Union   WI  State  Capital  The  Terrace  

WiscSIMS  Weeks  Hall  Geoscience  

Union    South  

State  St.  

Lakeshore  Path  

WID  

Chazen  Art  Museum  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 23: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison  

Page 24: Madison,(Wisconsin(June(1>3,(2015( HiRes2015wiscsims/HiRes2015/pdfs/... · HiRes2013 J.W.(Valley,(HiRes2015>((High(Resolu1on(Proxies(of(Paleoclimate,(June(1>3,(2015,(UW>Madison

You  Are    Here  

(WID)  

J.W.  Valley,  HiRes2015-­‐    High  Resolu1on  Proxies  of  Paleoclimate,  June  1-­‐3,  2015,  UW-­‐Madison