Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and...

64
Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY, USA Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY, USA Center for Accelerator Science and Education V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009 1

Transcript of Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and...

Page 1: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL:

eRHIC and MeRHICVladimir N. Litvinenko

Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY, USAStony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY, USACenter for Accelerator Science and Education

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

1

Page 2: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Inputs on Physics from BNL EIC task force lead by E.-C. Aschenauer, T. Ulrich http://www.eic.bnl.gov/taskforce.html, A.Cadwell, A.Deshpande,

R. Ent, T. Horn, H. Kowalsky, M. Lamont, T.W. Ludlam, R. Milner, B. Surrow, S.Vigdor, R. Venugopalan, W.Vogelsang, ….

www.bnl.gov/cad/eRhic/

Materials are from eRHIC R&D group and EIC task force

Inputs from A. Pendzick, A. Zaltsman, Y.R. Than, D. Gassner, X. Chang,

M.Minty, R. Lambiase, M.Mapes, C. Theisen, B. Oerter, J. Sandberg,

K. Mirabella, R. VanWormer

2

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 3: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

• Collider beam physics laws assert that with any given beam and IR parameters, a linac-ring collider outperforms a ring-ring collider

• We developed detailed technical design and cost estimate for the first stage of eRHIC, called MeRHIC

• We developed a clear staged pass toward full energy high luminosity eRHIC, based on the experience from hadron and lepton-hadron colliders

• eRHIC R&D is focused on:

• (a) Single cathode and Gatling polarized electron guns

• (b) Compact SRF linacs with HOM damping

• (c) Multi-pass high average current ERLs

• (e) Small gap magnets and vacuum chambers

• (f) Coherent electron cooling

3

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Conclusions first

Page 4: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

We prepared for tomorrow following topicson MeRHIC design

• MeRHIC design – Vadim Ptitsyn

• Beam dynamics – Yue Hao

• Engineering challenges and solutions – Andrew Burrill

4

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 5: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Content

• What is eRHIC

• eRHIC staging

• MeRHIC design

• IP developments

• R&D program for eRHIC

• Costs

5

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 6: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC Scope -QCD Factory

e-

e+

p

Unpolarized andpolarized leptons4-20 (30) GeV

Polarized light ions (He3) 215 GeV/u

Light ions (d,Si,Cu)Heavy ions (Au,U)50-100 (130) GeV/u

Polarized protons

25 50-250 (325) GeV

Electron accelerator RHIC

70% beam polarization goalPositrons at low intensities

Center mass energy range: 15-200 GeV

eA program for eRHIC needs as high as possible energies of electron beams even with a trade-off for the luminosity: 20 GeV is absolutely essential and 30 GeV is strongly desirable

e-

6

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 7: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

2007 Choosing the focus: ERL or ring for electrons?

• Two main design options for eRHIC:

– Ring-ring:

– Linac-ring:

RHIC

Electron storage ring

RHIC

Electron linear accelerator

Natural staging strategy

✔L x 10

L 4h e

rhre

he h

' e

' f

L h f Nh

hZh

h

*rh

7

e 1

e ~ 0.1

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 8: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

2008: Staging of eRHIC

• MeRHIC: Medium Energy eRHIC

– Both Accelerator and Detector are located at IP2 of RHIC

– 4 GeV e- x 250 GeV p (63 GeV c.m.), L ~ 1032-1033 cm-2 sec -1

– 90% of hardware will be used for HE eRHIC

• eRHIC, High energy and luminosity phase, inside RHIC tunnel

Full energy, nominal luminosity

– Polarized 20 GeV e- x 325 GeV p (160 GeV c.m), L ~ 1033-1034 cm-2 sec -1

– 30 GeV e x 120 GeV/n Au (120 GeV c.m.), ~1/5 of full luminosity

– and 20 GeV e x 120 GeV/n Au (120 GeV c.m.), full liminosity

• eRHIC up-grades – if needed

– Higher luminosity

– Higher hadron energy

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

8

Page 9: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

• MeRHIC: Medium Energy electron-Ion Collider

– > 90% of ERL hardware will be use for full energy eRHIC

– Possible use of the detector in eRHIC operation

• eRHIC – High energy and luminosity phase

– Based on present RHIC beam intensities

– With coherent electron cooling requirements on the electron beam current is 50 mA

– 20 GeV, 50 mA electron beam losses 4 MW total for synchrotron radiation.

– 30 GeV, 10 mA electron beam loses 4 MW for synchrotron radiation

– Power density is <2 kW/meter and is well within B-factory limits (8 kW/m)

• eRHIC upgrade(s) if needed

Staging of eRHIC: Re-use, Beams and Energetics

9

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 10: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

4 GeV e x 250 GeV p – 100 GeV/u Au

MeRHIC 2 x 60 m SRF linac3 passes, 1.3 GeV/pass

STAR

3 pass 4 GeV ERL

Polarized e-gun

Beamdump

10

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 11: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

10 to 20 GeV e x 325 GeV p – 130 GeV/u AueRHIC

STAR

2 x 200 m SRF linac4 (5) GeV per pass5 (4) passes

Polarized e-gun

Beamdump

4 to 5 vertically separatedrecirculatingpasses

Possibility of 30 GeV

low current operation

5 mm

5 mm

5 mm

5 mm

20 GeVe-beam

16 GeVe-beam

12 GeVe-beam

8 GeVe-beam

Com

mon

vac

uum

ch

amb

er

Gap 5 mm total0.3 T for 30 GeV

eRHICdetector

11

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 12: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Possible layout in RHIC IPof CeC driven by a single linac –

to boost polarized pp- luminosity

Gun 1Gun 2

Beam dump 1 Beam dump 2ERL dual-way electron linac

2 Standard MeRHIC modules

Ep, GeV Ee, MeV

100 106.58 54.46

250 266.45 136.15

325 346.38 177.00

Modulator for Blue Modulator for YellowFEL for Blue

FEL for Yellow

Kicker for BlueKicker for Yellow

Selectinggoals

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

12

Page 13: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

MeRHIC with 4 GeV ERL at 2 o’clock IR of RHIC

(April 09)

Linac 1

Linac 2

Linac 1

Lattice and IR by D.Trbojevic, D.Kayran

13

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 14: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

MeRHIC in IR 2: 3D layout

© J.C.Brutus, J. Tuozzolo, D. Trbojevic, G. Mahler, B. Parker, W. Meng

14

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 15: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Myriad of beam dynamics issues were studied for MeRHICNo show-stoppers !

Majority of these findings were reported at MAC meeting in March 2009Main finding – we could operate main SRF linacs without 3rd harmonics

15

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

2nd harmonic0.7 MV, 215 kW

fundamental6.5 MV, 325 kW

Page 16: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

dˆ s

dt

e

mcˆ s

g

21

1

B

1

g

21

ˆ ˆ B

g

2

1

E

Bargman, Mitchel,Telegdi equation

a

a g/21 1.1596521884 103

a i(2n 1) n(1 n 2(n 1)

i

f

1

2

ˆ g

2

e

mo

ˆ s 1 a e

mo

ˆ s ; spin a Ee

0.44065[GeV ]

Gun

ERL spin transparency at all energies

1

f

2

2

IPi

1Compton

polarimeter

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

5 6 7 8 9 10

E1, E2 for spin transparency

E1, GeV

E2, GeV

E

1,2

, G

eV

Energy in the IP, GeV

i 2 1 2 f

a i(2n 1) n(1 n 2(n 1) N

Total angle

Has solutionfor all

energies!

n passes

n=2

16

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 17: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Methods and solutions: asynchronous arcs

Dispersion function oscillates between ±1.8 m and the momentum compaction is adjustable:

Goals:-Have a good packing factor- ac=0 or M5,6=0- small dispersion- small betatron functions- reduce cost of civil construction

Dejan Trbojevic: EPAC 1990, pp. 1536:“Design Method for High energy Accelerators without Transition Energy.”

a 1

Co

D

ds 0

17

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 18: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

100 MeV Pre Accelerator ERL

Injector ParametersPolarized Gun (200kV)Cathode GaAs,Laser 780nm Emax= 10 MeV Iavr =50 mA, Q per bunch =5nC

Pre-accelerator ERL: One passEnergy gain 90 MeVEinj & Eextr=10 MeVEmax =100 MeV

eBeam parameters : E=100 MeVIavr=50 mAIpeak=500 AReprate = 9.8 MHzEmittance =70 mm-mradBanchlength = 3 mm dE/E = 1E-3

Gatling Gun (Ek=200keV)

10 MeV Injector 90 MeV Linac

1.4, 2.7, 4 GeV

11 m 11 m10 MeV x 50 mA

0.5 MW Beam Dump

from MeRHICarcs

to MeRHIC vertical combiner

10 MeV Booster Linac

30 m

D. Kayran

18

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 19: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Gatling Gun*)

Parameter Value

Laser longitudinal distribution

Gaussian

Bunch length at cathode 0.5nS [FWHM]

Laser transverse distribution

Uniform

Laser spot diameter 8mm

Bunch charge 5nC

Accelerating voltage 200kV

Cathode-anode gap 3cm

Integrated solenoid field 2.1kG-cm

Dogleg funneling system is spin transparent

Electrostatic kicker

Rotating field kicker

~ 50 mA from injector is needed. State of the art electron polarized source is 1 mA.

The multi cathode to reduce load on a single cathode can be used

*) the Gatling gun is the first successful machine gun, invented by Dr. Richard Jordan Gatling.

Electrostatic kicker

Page 20: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Polarized e-beam injector20

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 21: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

MeRHIC Linac Design

703.75 MHz1.6 m long

Drift 1.5 m long

100 MeV 100 MeV4 GeV

65m total linac lengthAll cold: no warm-to-cold transition

E.Pozdeyev

Based on BNL SRF cavity with fully suppressed HOMsCritical for high current multi-pass ERL

21

I. Ben Zvi

Current breakdown of the linac

• N cavities = 6 (per module)

• N modules per linac = 6

• N linacs = 2

• L module = 9.6m

• L period = 10.6 m

• Ef = 18.0 MeV/m

• dE/ds = 10.2 MeV/m

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 22: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

TBBU stability (©E. Pozdeyev)

x

x

return

m11 m12

m21 m22

0

x

comming

Excitation process of transverse HOM

eRHIC

• HOMs based on R. Calaga’ssimulations/measurements • 70 dipole HOM’s to 2.7 GHz in each cavity• Polarization either 0 or 90°• 6 different random seeds • HOM Frequency spread 0-0.001

F (GHz) R/Q (Ω) Q (R/Q)Q

0.8892 57.2 600 3.4e4

0.8916 57.2 750 4.3e4

1.7773 3.4 7084 2.4e4

1.7774 3.4 7167 2.4e4

1.7827 1.7 9899 1.7e4

1.7828 1.7 8967 1.5e4

1.7847 5.1 4200 2.1e4

1.7848 5.1 4200 2.1e4

Threshold significantly exceeds the beam current,especially for the scaled gradient solution.

Simulated BBU threshold (GBBU)

vs. HOM frequency spread.

50 mA

22

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 23: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC IR developments• eRHIC IR lattice is design in direct communication with EIC task-force and with

inputs from EIC collaboration

• Main boundary conditions on present IR designs – our main priority

– There should be no magnetic elements (except dipole magnets used for EIC physics!) of both electron and hadron accelerators

– One of the golden measurements (diffraction) required

• A) very strong dipole next to the IP

• B) very long element-free straight sections for excellent energy resolution

• C) no – zilch! - hard X-rays in the detector

– No – Zilch! – hard X-ray in the detector chamber

• This limits choice of * to 40 cm without CeC and to 25 cm with CeC. We found solutions to all existing demands. Focusing is not a problem in all this scenario and excellent fits are found for all cases (Tepikian for RHIC, Trbojevic of ERL).

• Luminosity hungry experiments may require a dedicated IR, where accelerator elements are integrated into a detector (aka BarBar)

• CeC can compress hadron bunch lengths to few cm and * ~ 5 cm or even shorter are possible in such IR – few possible scenarios are under consideration. This IR can bring eRHIC luminosity well above 1034.

23

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 24: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Integrated IR des ignMeRHIC 4 GeV e x 250 GeV p/100 GeV Au

p, Au

e

Solenoid, 4 T

1T, 3m dipole

1T, 3m dipole

Remove DXes – 40 m to detect particles scattered at small angles

To provide effective SR protection:-soft bend (~0.05T) is used for final bending of electron beam

© J.Bebee-Wang

© E. Aschenauer

40 m

Softdipole

Softdipole

24

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 25: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Beam Disruptionprotons e

Interaction

Optimized

©Y. Hao

25

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 26: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Suppression of kink instability

Nonlinear force model with Hourglass effectWith rms proton energy spread =1e-3

The optimum chromaticity is around = +4

Recent studies proved our early assumption that using simple feed-back on electron beam suppress kink instability

completely for all MeRHIC/eRHIC parameter ranges

© Y. Hao

26

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 27: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

MeRHIC eRHIC with CeC

p /A e p /A e

Energy, GeV 250/100 4 325/130 20

Number of bunches 111 105 nsec 166 74 nsec

Bunch intensity (u) , 1011 2.0 0.31 2.0 0.24

Bunch charge, nC 32 5 32 4

Beam current, mA 320 50 420 50

Normalized emittance, 1e-6 m, 95% for p / rms for e

15 73 1.2 25

Polarization, % 70 80 70 80

rms bunch length, cm 20 0.2 4.9 0.2

β*, cm 50 50 25 25

Luminosity, x 1033, cm-2s-1 0.1 -> 1 with CeC

2.8

eRHIC parameters

< Luminosity for 30 GeV e-beam operation will be at 20% level> 27

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 28: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Using only to of JLab assumptions for ELICmicro-beta*, traveling RF focusing ,

on a paper, brings eRHIC luminosity

to 1.4 x 1035 cm-2 sec-1

Reducing β* by a factor of 50 (from 25 cm to 0.5 cm)

boost luminosity by a factor of fifty28

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

L fc

NhNe

4*

Page 29: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC with CeC

p / A e

Energy, GeV 325 / 130 20

Number of bunches 166

Bunch intensity (u) , 1011 2.0 0.24

Bunch charge, nC 32 4

Beam current, mA 420 50

Normalized emittance, 1e-6 m, 95% for p / rms for e 1.2 2.5

Polarization, % 70 80

rms bunch length, cm 4.9 0.2

β*, cm 0.5 5

Luminosity, x 1035, cm-2s-11.4

29

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Parameters

Page 30: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC with CeC

p / A e

Energy, GeV 325 / 130 20

Number of bunches 166

Bunch intensity (u) , 1011 2.0 0.24

Bunch charge, nC 32 4

Beam current, mA 420 50

Normalized emittance, 1e-6 m, 95% for p / rms for e 1.2 25

Polarization, % 70 80

rms bunch length, cm 4.9 0.2

β*, cm 25 25

Luminosity, x 1035, cm-2s-10.028

30

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Parameters

Page 31: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC’s assumptions

are based on beam optics for HE hadron colliders

such as RHIC, HERA, Tevatron, LHC

We have potential for future up-grades beyond capabilities of present day colliders:

increase intensities of electron and proton bunches about 2 fold, the rep-rate 2 fold and

reduce beta* 5 fold – total up to 20 fold increase in luminosity.

31

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 32: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Challenges and Advantages

• Main Challenge – 50 mA polarized gun for e-p program

• Main advantage – RHIC

– Unique set of species from d to U

– The only high energy polarized proton collider

– Large size of RHIC tunnel (3.8 km)

• Main limitation

– Ion cloud limits the hadron beam intensity

32

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 33: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

0.5m0.7m 4m 0.5m

0.6mCathodes Combiner

Solenoids Spin rotator (Wien) Booster linac

(112MHz)

3rd

harmonic cavity

Bunching optics

DC gunwith 24 cathodes

Based on demonstratedcurrent technology developed at JLab

© E.Tsentalovich, MIT

Single cathode DC gun

© X.Chang

Main technical challenge is 50 mACW polarized gun: we are building it

33

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 34: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Coherent Electron Cooling (CeC)

Amplifier of the e-beam modulationin an FEL with gain GFEL~10

2-103

RD //,lab c

2 p

FEL

RD ce

p

vh

2 RD//

FEL

2 R

D

q Ze (1 cos1)

1 pl1 /c

qpeak 2Ze

FEL

LGo w

4 3

LG LGo(1 )

GFEL eLFEL / LG

LFEL

3LG

ct D o

o

; Dfree L

2; Dchicane lchicane

2.......

kFEL 2 /FEL ; kcm kFEL /2o

4en 0 cos kcmz r E

r ˆ z Eo X sin kcmz

namp Go nk cos kcmz

A

2n /o

qFEL (z)

0

FEL

cos kFEL z dz

k kq(1); nk k

2

Ez

Eh e Eo l2 sin kFEL DE Eo

Eo

sin2

2

sin

1

2

2

Z X; Eo 2Goeo /n

pt

q /Ze

FEL

E0

E < E0

E > E0

Modulator KickerDispersion section ( for hadrons)

Electrons

Hadrons

l2l1 High gain FEL (for electrons)

Eh

E < Eh

E > Eh

DispersionAt a half of plasma oscillation

Debay radii

RD RD //

p 4nee2 /ome

Density

pt

fel w 1r a w

2 /2o

2

r a w e

r A w /mc2

Eo 2Goo

e

n

X q/e Z(1 cos1) ~ Z

34

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 35: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Possible layout for Coherent Electron Coolingproof-of-principle experiment in RHIC IR

DXDX

19.6 m

Modulator, 4 mWiggler 7mKicker, 3 m

Parameter

Species in RHIC Au ions, 40 GeV/u

Electron energy 21.8 MeV

Charge per bunch 1 nC

Train 5 bunches

Rep-rate 78.3 kHz

e-beam current 0.39 mA

e-beam power 8.5 kW

35

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 36: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC

eRHIC loop magnets: LDRD project• Small gap provides for low current, low power consumption magnets

• -> low cost eRHIC• Dipole prototype is under tests• Quad and vacuum chamber are in advanced stage

25

cm

Gap 5 mm total0.3 T for 30 GeV

5 mm

20 GeV e-beam

16 GeV e-beam

12 GeVe-beam

8 GeV e-beam

Com

mon

vac

uum

cham

ber

0.00E+00

2.00E-02

4.00E-02

6.00E-02

8.00E-02

1.00E-01

1.20E-01

1.40E-01

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

Mag

net

ic F

ield

[Te

sla]

Longitudinal Position [mm]

At pole center, longitudinal scan

dx=0mm

0.11250.113

0.11350.114

0.11450.115

0.11550.116

0.11650.117

0.1175

30 32 34 36 38 40 42Ma

gne

tic

Fie

ld [

Te

sla

]

Transverse position [mm]

245Ampere, Transverse scan at center of the dipole

©, G. Mahler, W. Meng, A. Jain, P. He, Y.Hao

36

Page 37: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC37

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 38: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

© I. Ben Zvi

R&D ERL 38

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 39: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

• Collider beam physics laws assert that with any given beam and IR parameters, a linac-ring collider outperforms a ring-ring collider

• We developed detailed technical design and cost estimate for the first stage of eRHIC, called MeRHIC

• We developed a clear staged pass toward full energy high luminosity eRHIC, based on the experience from hadron and lepton-hadron colliders

• eRHIC R&D is focused on:

• (a) Single cathode and Gatling polarized electron guns

• (b) Compact SRF linacs with HOM damping

• (c) Multi-pass high average current ERLs

• (e) Small gap magnets and vacuum chambers

• (f) Coherent electron cooling

39

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Conclusions

Page 40: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

We prepared for tomorrow following topicson MeRHIC design

• MeRHIC design – Vadim Ptitsyn

• Beam dynamics – Yue Hao

• Engineering challenges and solutions – Andrew Burrill

40

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 41: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Back-up41

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 42: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC R&D (more in T.Roser’s presentation)

• Polarized gun for e-p program

• Development of compact recirculating loop magnets

• R&D ERL

• Compact eRHIC SRF with HOM damping

• Coherent Electron Cooling including PoP

• Polarized He3 source

Resources in FY 2009 • Administrative - 1

• Scientists (include. 2 PhD students) - 8

• Professionals – 3

• Technicians – 4

• Total - 16

42

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 43: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

eRHIC targeted LDRD-proposals• Accelerator:

– Proof of principle for a gatling gun polarized electron source

PI: Ilan Ben-Zvi

– laser development for polarized electron source

PI: Treveni Rao

– undulator development for coherent electron cooling

PI: Vladimir Litvinenko

– polarized 3He source development

PI: Anatoli Zelenski

43

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 44: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Progress with eRHIC• Continued:

– Development of R&D ERL– Small gap magnets– Understanding and suppression of kink instability– Simulation of electron beam disruption in the collision – Simulations of the beam-beam effects on hadron beam

• New developments– MeRHIC lattice and cost estimating– eRHIC staging and cost estimate– Coherent electron cooling for RHIC pp and eRHIC– Compact spreaders and combiner– Effects of wake-fields on beam energy loss and beam quality– Synchrotron radiation effects

• Publications on eRHIC-related accelerator R&D– About 25 papers in last year including one Phys. Rev . Lett.

44

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 45: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

X x

xo

; S s

so

2

E

sE

2

;

dX

dt

1

IBS

1

X 3 / 2S1/ 2

CeC

1

S;

dS

dt

1

IBS //

1

X 3 / 2Y

1 2

CeC

1

X;

xn 0 2m; s0 13 cm; 0 4 104

IBS 4.6 hrs; IBS // 1.6 hrs;

IBS in RHIC foreRHIC, 250 GeV, Np=2.1011

Beta-cool, A.Fedotov

x n 0.2m; s 4.9 cm

This allowsa) keep the luminosity as it is b) reduce polarized beam current down to 25

mA (5 mA for e-I)c) increase electron beam energy to 20 GeV

(30 GeV for e-I)d) increase luminosity by reducing * from 25

cm down to 5 cm

Dynamics:Takes 12 minsto reach stationarypoint

X CeC

IBS // IBS

1

12 ; S

CeC

IBS //

IBS

IBS //

12 3

Gains from coherent e-cooling: Coherent Electron Cooling vs. IBS

45

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 46: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

4 GeV e x 250 GeV p – 100 GeV/u Au

MeRHIC

120m SRF linac3 passes, 1.3 GeV/pass

46

STAR

3 pass 4 GeV ERL

Polarized e-gun

Beamdump

M/eRHICdetector

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 47: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

47

STAR

Polarized e-gun

Beamdump

10 to 20 GeV e x 325 GeV p – 130 GeV/u AueRHIC

47

2 x 200 m SRF linac4 (5) GeV per pass5 (4) passes

4 to 5 vertically separatedrecirculatingpasses

Possibility of 30 GeV

low current operation

5 mm

5 mm

5 mm

5 mm

20 GeVe-beam

16 GeVe-beam

12 GeVe-beam

8 GeVe-beam

Com

mon

vac

uum

ch

amb

er

Gap 5 mm total0.3 T for 30 GeV

eRHICdetector

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 48: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

30 GeV e x 800 GeV p – 320 GeV/u U

eRHIC II 3 x 200 m SRF linac6 GeV per pass5 passes

48

(e)STAR

Yellow ring serves as200 GeV injector into upgradedBlue ring

4 to 5 vertically separatedrecirculatingpasses

Up-grade:New LHC-class

SC magnets in Blue ring

5 mm

5 mm

5 mm

5 mm

20 GeVe-beam

16 GeVe-beam

12 GeVe-beam

8 GeVe-beam

Com

mon

vac

uum

ch

amb

er

Polarized e-gun

Beamdump

eRHICdetector

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 49: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

MeRHIC eRHIC with CeCeRHIC II 8T RHIC

p /A e p /A e p / A e

Energy, GeV 250/100 4 325 / 125 20 800 / 300 20

Number of bunches 111 166 166

Bunch intensity (u) , 1011 2.0 0.31 2.0 0.24 3.0 0.24

Bunch charge, nC 32 5 32 4 32 4

Beam current, mA 320 50 420 50 630 50

Normalized emittance, 1e-6 m, 95% for p / rms for e

15 73 1.2 25 1 10

Polarization, % 70 80 70 80 70 (?) 80

rms bunch length, cm 20 0.2 4.9 0.2 4.5 0.2

β*, cm 50 50 25 (5) 25 (5) 25 (5) 25 (5)

Luminosity, x 1033, cm-

2s-10.1 -> 1 with

CeC2.8 (14) 17 (85)

eRHIC parameters

49

< Luminosity for 30 GeV e-beam operation will be at 20% level>

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 50: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

MeRHIC parameters for e-p collisions

not cooled With cooling

p e p e

Energy, GeV 250 4 250 4

Number of bunches 111 111

Bunch intensity, 1011 2.0 0.31 2.0 0.31

Bunch charge/current, nC/mA 32/320 5/50 32/320 5/50

Normalized emittance, 1e-6 m, 95% for p / rms for e

15 73 1.5 7.3

rms emittance, nm 9.4 9.4 0.94 0.94

beta*, cm 50 50 50 50

rms bunch length, cm 20 0.2 5 0.2

beam-beam for p /disruption for e 1.5e-3 3.1 0.015 7.7

Peak Luminosity, 1e32, cm-2s-10.93 9.3

50

© V.Ptitsyn

Luminosity for light and heavy ionsis the same as for e-p if measured per nucleon!

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 51: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

• 40 cm * and 40 m element free space

• Integrated 5.8 m long 4 T solenoid

• First indication that it is good layout for diffraction physics

• There is enough flexibility in the layout to accommodate main detector needs

IR without DXes: 5-fold flexibility for hadron energyJ. Beebe-Wang, E.-C. Aschenauer

51

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 52: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

RHIC lattice modification – Steven Tepikian

=0.4 m

52

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 53: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Methods and solutions: construction of the asynchronous arcs:53

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 54: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Switchyard at the linac

4GeV

0.1GeV

1.4GeV

2.7GeV

0.2

45

8 m

2.8423 m

1.25 m

0.55 m

0.1

6 m

0.1

6 m

1.866 m

0.7

02

m

0.1

36

m

54

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 55: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Vertical splitters –3.35 GeV, 2.05 GeV, and 0.75 GeV

© Nicholaus Tsoupas

55

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 56: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Caesiation x 6HV feedthrough

Laser windows

Laser

Laser mirrors

Electron Beams

56

V.N. Litvinenko, EIC AC meeting, TJNAF, November 2-3, 2009

Page 57: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Linac design with const. grad quads (current baseline)

• Einj/Emax = 100MeV / 4GeV

• 3 acc./decel. passes

• N cavities = 72 (total)

• L module/period = 9.6 / 11.1m

• Ef = 18.0 MeV/m

• dE/ds = 10.2 MeV/m

Cavity: 703.75 MHz, 1.6 m with dampers

Constant gradient quads: L=20 cm, G~100 Gauss/cm

4GeV

100MeV 100MeV

Page 58: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Scaled gradient solution

Scaling gradient with energy produces more focusing and increases BBU threshold

Gmax ~ 500 G/cm

Matching scaled linacto arcs is in the works

Quad strengthGmin ~ 100 G/cm

Page 59: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

BBU simulations• HOMs based on R. Calaga’ssimulations/measurements • 70 dipole HOM’s to 2.7 GHz in each cavity• Polarization either 0 or 90°• 6 different random seeds • HOM Frequency spread 0-0.001

Simulated BBU threshold (GBBU) vs. HOM frequency spread.

Beam current 50 mA

Threshold significantly exceeds the beam current,especially for the scaled gradient solution.

F (GHz) R/Q (Ω) Q (R/Q)Q

0.8892 57.2 600 3.4e4

0.8916 57.2 750 4.3e4

1.7773 3.4 7084 2.4e4

1.7774 3.4 7167 2.4e4

1.7827 1.7 9899 1.7e4

1.7828 1.7 8967 1.5e4

1.7847 5.1 4200 2.1e4

1.7848 5.1 4200 2.1e4

Page 60: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Energy loss and its compensation

• Energy loss– Linac cavities: 0.54 MeV/linac.

(6.5 MeV total)– Synch. radiation: 8.8 MeV total – CSR: negligible

• Total power loss: 765 kW• Energy difference in arcs

(max)– Before compensation: 2%– After compensation: 0.06%

σz = 2 mmqb = 5 nC

2nd harmonic0.7 MV, 215 kW

fundamental6.5 MV, 325 kW

Page 61: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Energy spread and its compensation

δE (MeV)

RF 0.17%

Cavity Wakes 8.9

Synch. Rad. (4rms) 1.35

Resistive Wall small

CSR small

Total 10.25

Dog-leg with M56=15 cm, M566=125 cm2

Energy spread vs. Arc #

Energy spread compensation

10 MeV -> 1.6 MeV

to MeRHIC vertical combiner

Page 62: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Beam losses: Touschek

Not a large problem but not negligible

Total beam loss beyond given energy aperture

Page 63: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Beam losses: Collisions with residual gasScattering

Losses beyond aperture at 100 MeV

Small, can be neglected

Bremsstrahlung

Losses beyond energy aperture

Small, can be neglected

Page 64: Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC … AC meeting... · Machine Design Progress and Options at BNL: eRHIC and MeRHIC Vladimir N. Litvinenko Brookhaven National Laboratory,

Energy spread compensation

Smal d, Large dE

Large d, fits the RF wave -> small dE

0.75

2.05

1.42.74.0

0.1

RF

b

i

f

i

i

f

lE

E

10 MV -> 1.6 MV

m56 15 cm

m566 ?