Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

41
MAC301 1

description

Updated lecture notes from last year's sessions on how the second GW was spun

Transcript of Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

Page 1: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

MAC301

1

Page 2: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Framing issues

• Mediatised conflict and strategies for information management

• Al-Jazeera as disruptive media

• Summary

2

Page 3: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Ray Heibert (1991) Public Relations Review

• Public relations and public communications would play an increasingly significant role in warfare

• The battle for public opinion would be as important as the engagement of soldiers on the front

3

Page 4: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Ray Heibert (2003) Public Relations Review

• We don’t think about facts but about the way those facts are framed

• Framing an issue becomes THE most powerful way to control our response to something.

4

Page 5: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

5

Page 6: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

6

Page 7: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• See Lakoff (2003)

• Classic narratives:– Self-defense story– Rescue story

7

Page 8: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Global audience = occasional language slip-ups

• “Crusade”

• “Axis of Evil”

• “Operation Enduring Freedom”

• “Coalition of the Willing”

• “Saddam’s Fedayeen”8

Page 9: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

9

Page 10: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• 600 based with troops

• Creates a sympathetic press

• Humanises the principal agents

10

Page 11: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• “The essential strategy for becoming the standard of truth when no one believes you is to open your operations to the kind of risk that no one would take if he were planning to lie. Spin is out of the question. Good or bad, the story is there for the reporter to see. In a company criticized for, say, global labor practices, this would mean opening overseas factories to unscheduled media visits. In this war, it means embedded reporters” – Clark S Judge, 2003,

http://www.whwg.com/thefirm/sample.php/54/Clark_S._Judge

11

Page 12: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

12

Page 13: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

13

Page 14: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

14

Page 15: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

Setting the stageSetting the stage

• “When Americans wake up in the morning, they will first hear from the [Persian Gulf] region, maybe from General Tommy Franks, then later in the day, they will hear from the Pentagon, then the State Department, then later on the White House will brief.” – Suzy DeFrances, President Bush’s deputy assistant

for communications cited in Douglas Quenqua, March 24th 2003, PR Week http://www.prweekus.com/White-House-prepares-to-feed-24-hour-news-cycle/article/46713/

15

Page 16: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

16

Page 17: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

17

Page 18: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

18

Page 19: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• “Photos of sleek fighter jets, rescued POWs, and smiling Iraqis cheering the arrival of U.S. troops are easy to find among Combat Camera’s public images. Photos of bombed-out Baghdad neighborhoods and so-called ‘collateral damage’ are not.” – cited in Heibert, 2003: 252

19

Page 20: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

20

Page 21: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

21

Page 22: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

22

Page 23: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• 'All the gadgets a reporter needs can be carried in a single suitcase that fits in the overhead compartment of most planes'. – (Peter Johnson, 'Media's war footing looks

solid', USA Today, 17 February 2003)

23

Page 24: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Launched in 1996 • Qatari capital of Doha• Estimated audience of 35

million regular viewers (Allan, 2004: 163)

• Biased?• Front for the CIA• ‘the mouthpiece for Osama bin

Laden’

24

Page 25: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• ‘The only crime Al-jazeera had committed was bearing witness to events the US would rather the rest of the world did not see’

• (Nik Gowing, BBC, 2002)

25

Page 26: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Iraq War (2003) presence:– Central Command (Centcom)– 4 embedded reporters with US & UK troops– Large unilateral reporting teams

26

Page 27: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• When Western journalists outside Basra were speculating about an uprising on the basis of coalition briefings, Al-Jazeera's correspondent inside the city was reporting first hand that “the streets are very calm and there are no indications of violence or riots”– Tarik Kafala, 2003,

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/2893689.stm

27

Page 28: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• ‘We and other broadcasters were not criticised for showing pictures of Iraqi dead and captured or those famous pictures from Guantanamo Bay’

– (Yosri Fouda cited in Kafala 2003)

28

Page 29: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• “Al-Jazeera” became one of the most searched for terms on the web

• ‘people branching out beyond their normal sources of news’– Karl Gregory, Director of Marketing at

AltaVista

29

Page 30: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Journalists ignored at Centcom• Financial reporters evicted from NYSE• Website hacked by pro-war groups• www.english.aljazeera.net DoS attack (March

2003)

30

Page 31: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

31

Page 32: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

32

Page 33: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

33

Page 34: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

34

Page 35: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

35

Page 36: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

36

Page 37: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• The US military played a fundamental role in shaping the perception people had of the war. Does this give PR a bad name?

• What are the implications for the general public? Is globally produced news fit for purpose?

• Does the world need the likes of Al-Jazeera to counter the hegemonic versions of reality distributed by western backed media?

• Does new technology bring about a democratisation of the public?

37

Page 38: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• To what extent is it possible to separate the fact from the propaganda?

• How effective was the PR-inspired campaign?

• How complicit are journalists in this process?

• How might the demands for copy impact upon public knowledge?

38

Page 39: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• S. Allan, 2004, News Culture – 2nd edition, Berkshire: Open University Press.• Clar Byrne, 2003, ‘Sun brands Chirac “Saddam’s Whore”’, March 21st available at

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2003/mar/21/Iraqandthemedia.pressandpublishing#history-byline • Ray Eldon Hiebert, 1991, ‘Public relations as a weapon of modern warfare’, Public Relations Review 17(2)

(Summer), pp. 107–116. See also, Bradley S. Greenberg, Walter Ganz (Eds.), 1993, Desert Storm and the Mass Media, Hampton Press, Cresskill, NJ, pp. 29–36, and 1991, Ecquid Novi: Journal for Journalism in Southern Africa 12(1), pp. 93–105.

• Ray Eldon Hiebert, 2003, ‘Public relations and propaganda in framing the Iraq war: a preliminary review’ Public Relations Review, 29 (3), doi:10.1016/S0363-8111(03)00047-X    

• Clark S Judge, 2003, ‘P.R. lessons from the Pentagon’, The Wall Street Journal, April 1, p. B2. Available at http://www.whwg.com/thefirm/sample.php/54/Clark_S._Judge

• Tarik Kafala, 2003, Al-Jazeera: News channel in the news, BBC, 29 March http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/2893689.stm

• George Lakoff, 2002. Moral Politics: How Liberals and Conservatives Think, 2nd ed., University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

• George Lakoff, 2003, ‘Metaphor and War Again’, http://www.alternet.org/story/15414/?page=3 • N.A. Ostrom, 2003, ‘Net plays big role in war news, commentary’, The Mercury news, 28 February – at

http://www.altmuslim.com/press_more.php?id=1268_0_27_0_C • Douglas Quenqua, March 24th 2003, ‘White House prepares to feed 24-hour news cycle’ PR Week

http://www.prweekus.com/White-House-prepares-to-feed-24-hour-news-cycle/article/46713/)• Ariel Sabar, Military crews capture images from front line, The Baltimore Sun, April 18, 2003, p. A1.

39

Page 40: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

• Howard Tumber & Jerry Palmer, 2004, Media at War: the Iraq Crisis, London: Sage• Nick Davies, 2008, Flat Earth News: An Award-Winning Report Exposes Falsehood, Distortion and Propaganda

in the Global Media, London: Chatto & Windus• Simon Cottle, 2006, Mediatized Conflict, Maidenhead: Open University Press• Justin Lewis, Andrew Williams and Bob Franklin, 2008, “Four Rumours and an Explanation: A political economic

account of journalists’ changing newsgathering and reporting practices” in Journalism Practice, Vol 2 No 1.•  Stuart Allan, 2006, Online News, Maidenhead: Open University Press.• Stephen Reese, 2004, ‘Militarized Journalism: Framing Dissent in the Gulf Wars’ in Stuart Allan and Barbara

Zelizer (eds), Reporting War, London: Routledge.• Mark Deuze, 2003, “The Web and its Journalisms: Considering the Consequences of Different Types of

Newsmedia Online” in New Media and Society Vol 5 Iss 2.

40

Page 41: Mac301 Gw2 And Al Jazeera 2009 10 Sem1

Images used• #15: Scott Ableman, 2007: http://www.flickr.com/photos/ableman/351362491/

• #16: The U.S. Army, 2009: http://www.flickr.com/photos/soldiersmediacenter/4031630657/

• #17: US Dept. of Defense, 2008: http://www.defenselink.mil/multimedia/

• #18: Master Sgt Paul Gorman, US Dept. of Defense, 2009: http://www.defenselink.mil/multimedia/

• #19: The U.S. Army, 2007: http://www.flickr.com/photos/soldiersmediacenter/1890490856/

• #20: The U.S. Army, 2009: http://www.flickr.com/photos/soldiersmediacenter/3521609651/

• #21: The U.S. Army, 2009: http://www.flickr.com/photos/soldiersmediacenter/3974625233/

41