m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13...

11
Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 1 Hervé Dole Institut d’Astrophysique Spatiale, Orsay Université Paris-Sud 11 et CNRS Institut Universitaire de France http://www.ias.u-psud.fr/dole/m2.php why is the night sky dark ? 1. why galaxy formation is a problem ? 2. how to adress these problems ? 3. overview of observation facts 4. overview of structure and galaxy formation 5. introduction to statistical tools: towards the power spectrum 6. introduction to the structured universe 1. why is the night sky dark ? Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 2 exercice 1 2. why galaxy formation is a(n interesting) problem ? Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 3 exercices 3 and 4 3. how to adress these problems ? ! 3.1 theory (lectures 5, 6, 7) ! how the sctructures can grow in an expanding Universe ? ! example ! 3.2 comparisons data vs models ! example: CMB ! example: statistical tools ! observations Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 4

Transcript of m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13...

Page 1: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

1 1

Hervé Dole Institut d’Astrophysique Spatiale, O

rsay Université Paris-Sud 11 et CNRS Institut Universitaire de France http://w

ww.ias.u-psud.fr/dole/m

2.php

why is the night sky dark ? 1.

why galaxy form

ation is a problem ? 2.

how to adress these problem

s ? 3. overview

of observation facts 4. overview

of structure and galaxy formation 5.

introduction to statistical tools: towards the pow

er spectrum 6.

introduction to the

structured universe

1. why is the night sky dark ?

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

2

exercice 1

2. why galaxy form

ation is a(n interesting) problem

?

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

3

exercices 3 and 4

3. how to adress these problem

s ?

! 3.1 theory (lectures 5, 6, 7) ! how

the sctructures can grow in an expanding Universe ?

! example

! 3.2 comparisons data vs m

odels ! exam

ple: CMB

! example: statistical tools

! observations

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

4

Page 2: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

3.1 need for theory

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

5

growth of perturbations

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

6

From N. Bavouzet’s PhD Thesis, http://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00363975 ;

from M

. Langer & H. Dole NPAC lectures, c2008

-> see M

ichael’s lectures for the dem

onstration

3.2 from m

aps to cosmological param

eters

7 Feb-2015

theory allow predictions and are

compared to observations

Hervé Dole, IAS - M2NPAC Advanced Cosm

ology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

3.2 between last scattering surfaces

Feb-2015 8

F. Noel – AAV 2010

Planck - thecmb.org

Planck+13

Ludwig+09

need for statistical

tools

Hervé Dole, IAS - M2NPAC Advanced Cosm

ology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

Page 3: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

3.3 history of the universe

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

9

Hu & White, 2004

? ? structure form

ation, galaxy evolution

redshifts of interest: 1090 to 0

but more im

portantly 10 to 0

Planck 15 mois

Planck Collaboration, 2013

4. overview of observation facts

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

10

! 4.1 CMB

4.2 extragalactic background light

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

11

EBL (Extragalactic Background Light) tells us about

the processes

involved in

galaxy form

ation & evolution (budget for radiation em

ission by nucleosynthesis & gravitation, presence of dust, …

). All fundamental forces

are at play.

CIB

(Cosm

ic In

frare

d B

ackg

round

) leve

l and

stru

ctu

re

dep

en

d

on

his

tory

of

en

erg

y p

rod

uc

tion

in

the

po

st-re

co

mb

ina

tion

Unive

rse [Kashlinsky, 2005]

cosmological backgrounds

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

12 D

ole et al., 2006 ; Dole 2010 H

DR

D

ole & B

éthermin in prep

Page 4: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

4.3 overview of observation facts

! spectrum of the CM

B ! large scale isotropy of the CM

B temperature

! small anisotropies of the CM

B temperature and polarization

! large-scale distribution of galaxies ! correlations (e.g. BAO

), redshifts, flux distribution etc.. ! galaxy clusters ! SN ! lensing on various tracors (CM

B, clusters, galaxies) ! quasars and absorption lines ! ...

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

13

scales of mass, dim

ension, d contrast

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

14

Yannick Mellier, IAP, 2002

Mass in Solar m

asses

Density contrast dρ/ρ"

photometric survey APM

, 1990

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

15

photometric near-infrared survey: 2M

ASS

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

16

Page 5: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

2MASS + redshifts: structures

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

17

spectroscopic surveys

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

18

Peacock, 2002

spectroscopic surveys

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

19

Peacock, 2002

spectroscopic surveys

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

20

adapted from Springel, 2006, YM

Page 6: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

spectroscopic survey VVDS

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

21

scales probed by SDSS

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

22 SDSS, D. Hogg

SDSS: - 8000 Sq. Deg. - 215e6 objets - 1e6 spectres - 15Tb de données en ligne

http://ww

w.sdss.org/dr8

strong & weak lensing

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

23

weak lensing -> DM

distribution

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

24

Page 7: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

simulations

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

25

z=6

z=2

z=0 V. Springel http://w

ww.m

pa-garching.mpg.de/galform

/data_vis/

100 h-1 M

pc

simulations

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

26

V. Springel - Code: Hydra http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/galform/data_vis/

matter pow

er spectrum P(k)

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

27

other facts and tracors ! ellipticals vs disk galaxies:

physics of cooling ! G

alaxy clusters ! high-z galaxies

! infrared & submillim

eter ! Lym

an-a related sources ! forest ! em

itters ! break ! ERO

, LRGs

! gamm

a ray bursts ! supernovae ! background em

issions

! Baryonic Acoustic O

scillations ! other statistical properties

of galaxies ! lum

inosity function, number

counts, colors, n(z)

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

28

Page 8: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

5. overview of structure and galaxy form

ation

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

29

structure and galaxy formation

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

30

Mo, van den Bosch, White fig 1.1

structure formation

galaxy form

ation

linear regime

non-linear regime

some tim

escales

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

31

Mo, van den Bosch, White sect 1.3

some tim

escales

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

32

Mo, van den Bosch, White sect 1.3

Page 9: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

mass-radius relationship

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

33

Padmanabhan, 1993, fig1.1

tcool=tgrav line

tcool = cooling time

tgrav = timescale for

gravitational collapse

GMmp/R: potential well m

ass-radius relationship

hierarchical formation

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

34

Mo, van den Bosch, White fig 1.3

6. introduction to statistical tools: towards

the power spectrum

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

35

what is a pow

er spectrum ?

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

36

Fourier analysis

Courtesy Marc-Antoine Miville-Deschênes

Espace direct: tim

e

Espace conjugué: fréquence tem

porelle

Page 10: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

37

Courtesy Marc-Antoine Miville-Deschênes

1 sine centered

2 sine centered

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

38

Courtesy Marc-Antoine Miville-Deschênes

n sinus décentrés

n sinus centrés

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

39

Courtesy Marc-Antoine Miville-Deschênes

n sine not

centred

autosimilar

form

(fractal)

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

40

Courtesy Marc-Antoine Miville-Deschênes

n sine not

centered

WM

AP 1 yr

Page 11: m2npac AdvancedCosmology201502 1ercours 2 obs hdole · AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer 13 15 scales of mass, dimension, d contrast Feb-2015 AC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

multipoles applied to the CM

B

Feb-2015 Hervé Dole, IAS - M

2NPAC Advanced Cosmology - Dole/Joyce/Langer

41

Hinshaw et al., 2007, W

MAP3

Ylm courtesy Benoit M

osser, LESIA

l=2

l=3

l=4

l=5

l=6