Apr-2014164,417

Apr-2013182,100

%-10

Change-17,683

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The median sold price is down -10%Median Sold Price by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Median Sold Price by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The median sold price is down -10%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Sold Median Price Units Avg DOMTime Period

Apr-14 164,417 36 141

Mar-14 174,900 30 141

Feb-14 156,313 24 132

Jan-14 171,000 20 83

Dec-13 164,750 38 84

Nov-13 169,900 29 127

Oct-13 171,700 26 126

Sep-13 164,353 26 142

Aug-13 157,809 42 131

Jul-13 162,000 25 67

Jun-13 155,600 26 109

May-13 152,900 33 125

Apr-13 182,100 33 86

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The median price of for sale properties has not changed and the median price of sold properties is down -10%

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

169,900 0

William Cobb

169,900Apr-2014

Median For Sale vs Median Sold

ChangeApr-2013 %0

Apr-2013 Apr-2014 %182,100 -10

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

164,417Change-17,683

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Median For Sale vs Median SoldApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The median price of for sale properties has not changed and the median price of sold properties is down -10%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

For SaleMedian SoldMedianFor Sale # Properties # PropertiesSold Price Difference

Time Period

Apr-14 216 36169,900 164,417 -5,483Mar-14 215 30172,220 174,900 2,680Feb-14 195 24171,835 156,313 -15,522Jan-14 188 20169,900 171,000 1,100Dec-13 193 38168,500 164,750 -3,750Nov-13 215 29167,000 169,900 2,900Oct-13 221 26168,500 171,700 3,200Sep-13 208 26167,400 164,353 -3,047Aug-13 191 42164,500 157,809 -6,691Jul-13 174 25164,900 162,000 -2,900Jun-13 172 26169,900 155,600 -14,300May-13 157 33174,700 152,900 -21,800Apr-13 174 33169,900 182,100 12,200

Clarus MarketMetrics®Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

05/19/201422/

Apr-201436

Apr-201333

%9

Change3

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of Sold properties is up 9%Sold Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Sold Properties by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of Sold properties is up 9%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Time Period Units Median Price Avg DOM

Apr-14 164,41736 141Mar-14 174,90030 141Feb-14 156,31324 132Jan-14 171,00020 83Dec-13 164,75038 84Nov-13 169,90029 127Oct-13 171,70026 126Sep-13 164,35326 142Aug-13 157,80942 131Jul-13 162,00025 67Jun-13 155,60026 109May-13 152,90033 125Apr-13 182,10033 86

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

Apr-201457

Apr-201331

%84

Change26

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of Under Contract properties is up 84%Under Contract Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

AllBathrooms: SqFt:New

: Residential

All Square FootageConstruction Type: Lot Size:GBRAR

Livingston

Period: 1 Year MonthlyPrice:MLS:

All AllAll

Property Types:

Bedrooms:

County:

Under Contract Properties by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of Under Contract properties is up 84%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Units Avg DOMMedian PriceTime PeriodApr-14 169,90057 109Mar-14 171,83555 103Feb-14 149,90025 114Jan-14 168,00029 147Dec-13 164,40022 136Nov-13 174,90036 102Oct-13 172,50027 117Sep-13 167,45030 117Aug-13 162,62528 120Jul-13 161,00016 91Jun-13 164,90027 129May-13 155,10026 98Apr-13 161,20031 122

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

Apr-201460

Apr-201350

%20

Change10

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of New properties is up 20%New Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

New Properties by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of New properties is up 20%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Units Median PriceTime PeriodApr-14 159,90060Mar-14 171,45050Feb-14 173,50041Jan-14 171,83521Dec-13 177,50021Nov-13 175,26224Oct-13 170,95044Sep-13 169,95050Aug-13 159,90043Jul-13 161,45034Jun-13 147,90047May-13 172,90024Apr-13 170,17550

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

Apr-2014216

Apr-2013174

%24

Change42

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of For Sale properties is up 24%For Sale Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

William Cobb

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

For Sale Properties by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of For Sale properties is up 24%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Units Avg DOMMedian PriceTime Period

Apr-14 169,900216 127Mar-14 172,220215 136Feb-14 171,835195 144Jan-14 169,900188 154Dec-13 168,500193 147Nov-13 167,000215 129Oct-13 168,500221 119Sep-13 167,400208 120Aug-13 164,500191 127Jul-13 164,900174 140Jun-13 169,900172 142May-13 174,700157 153Apr-13 169,900174 147

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

Apr-20142

Apr-201310

%-80

Change-8

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of Expired properties is down -80%Expired Properties by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

William Cobb

05/19/2014Clarus MarketMetrics® 1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Expired Properties by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of Expired properties is down -80%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

Avg DOMUnits Median PriceApr-14 156,9152 261Mar-14 182,4504 164Feb-14 215,0005 203Jan-14 155,9005 185Dec-13 202,4504 374Nov-13 147,9007 188Oct-13 173,9003 289Sep-13 149,9001 736Aug-13 144,9005 244Jul-13 203,40010 335Jun-13 203,4005 198May-13 197,2506 191Apr-13 173,90010 187

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of for sale properties is up 24% and the number of sold properties is up 9%

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

174 24

William Cobb

216Apr-2014

Supply & Demand by Month

ChangeApr-2013 %42

Apr-2013 Apr-2014 %33 9

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

36Change

3

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Supply & Demand by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The number of for sale properties is up 24% and the number of sold properties is up 9%

William Cobb Accurate Valuations Group

For Sale Sold# Properties

Avg DOM Avg DOM# Properties

Time Period

Apr-14 127 141216 36Mar-14 136 141215 30Feb-14 144 132195 24Jan-14 154 83188 20Dec-13 147 84193 38Nov-13 129 127215 29Oct-13 119 126221 26Sep-13 120 142208 26Aug-13 127 131191 42Jul-13 140 67174 25Jun-13 142 109172 26May-13 153 125157 33Apr-13 147 86174 33

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/

Apr-2014109

Apr-2013122

%-11

Change-13

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The average days on market is down -11%The Average Days on Market by Month

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

William Cobb

LivingstonAll 1 Year Monthly

County:Period:Price:

Property Types: : Residential

05/19/20141/2Clarus MarketMetrics®

All Square FootageBedrooms: All AllSqFt:

All Lot Size:Bathrooms:NewConstruction Type:MLS: GBRAR

The Average Days on Market by MonthApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The average days on market is down -11%

Accurate Valuations GroupWilliam Cobb

# UC UnitsAvg DOMTime PeriodApr-14 57109Mar-14 55103Feb-14 25114Jan-14 29147Dec-13 22136Nov-13 36102Oct-13 27117Sep-13 30117Aug-13 28120Jul-13 1691Jun-13 27129May-13 2698Apr-13 31122

Clarus MarketMetrics® 2/2 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

Apr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The average months supply of inventory is down -36%

Accurate Valuations Group

Apr-2013 vs. Apr-2014

4.3 -36

William Cobb

2.8Apr-2014

Months Supply of Inventory

ChangeApr-2013 %-1.5

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

1/2

MLS: GBRAR Bedrooms:AllAll

Construction Type:All1 Year Monthly SqFt:

Bathrooms: Lot Size:New All Square FootagePeriod:All

County:Property Types: : Residential

LivingstonPrice:

Months Supply of InventoryApr-2013 vs Apr-2014: The average months supply of inventory is down -36%

William Cobb Accurate Valuations Group

During MonthLast Day of Month MSI# Units For Sale # UC Units

UC Avg DOMTime Period

Apr-14 57 109157 2.8Mar-14 55 103156 2.8Feb-14 25 114165 6.6Jan-14 29 147154 5.3Dec-13 22 136167 7.6Nov-13 36 102172 4.8Oct-13 27 117191 7.1Sep-13 30 117177 5.9Aug-13 28 120158 5.6Jul-13 16 91148 9.2Jun-13 27 129140 5.2May-13 26 98125 4.8Apr-13 31 122133 4.3

Clarus MarketMetrics® 05/19/2014Information not guaranteed. © 2014 - 2015 Terradatum and its suppliers and licensors (www.terradatum.com/about/licensors.td).

22/