Financial Expert Witness Issues: How to Handle the Dangerous Financial Expert Witness
Litigation support and expert witness services
-
Upload
gelman-rosenberg-freedman-cpas -
Category
Documents
-
view
439 -
download
2
description
Transcript of Litigation support and expert witness services
Litigation Support and Expert Witness Services
January 22, 2013
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 2
More than 30 years of experience in fraud investigation
24 years as a special agent with the FBI 3½ years as a director of the forensic and dispute
services practice of Deloitte financial advisory services 3 years in private practice
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFEForensic and Dispute Services Principal
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 3
So Why Two Companies?
GRF CPAs is a highly respected accounting firm in Bethesda, MD.• More than 30 years of experience• Tax, Audit, and Accounting services, Forensic and Dispute
Services practice
Greystone is an investigative firm licensed in Maryland, Virginia and DC and is affiliated with GRF CPAs. • Maintains licenses and liability insurance to provide
investigative services to corporate and law firm clients.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 4
GRF Litigation Support Services
Forensic Accounting
Internal and External Fraud Investigations
Business Valuation
Fact and Expert Witness Testimony
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 5
Greystone Litigation Support Services Background, Due Diligence and Pre-employment
Background Investigations Locate Witnesses/Defendants Professional Witness Interviews Asset Tracing to Recover Court-Ordered Judgments Cause and Origin Fire Investigations and Testimony Recorded Conversations (where allowed by law) Surveillance and Photography Services GPS Tracking (with consent) Handwriting Expert Services National Network of Former FBI Agents
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 6
Financial Auditor v. Forensic Accountant
The Auditor: • Relies on statistical sampling to prove there are no irregular
transactions – numbers-focused with limited information.• “Don’t chase the shiny object.”
The Forensic Accountant: • Advised by the client of at least one irregular transaction.• Must develop methodologies to identify additional instances
of unauthorized activity and who the perpetrator is, how much is gone, how it was done, who else is involved.
• Information-focused – professional skepticism.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 7
Our Investigative Toolbox
INTERVIEWS - The Most Effective Tool People with knowledge about the event.
People working in the areas where the event occurred.
People with the authority or ability to cause the event to occur.
Suspects/Subjects – hope for a confession but at least get their story on the record and look for changes in the story as investigation progresses.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 8
Our Investigative Toolbox
PROPRIETARY DATABASES looking for bankruptcies, liens, judgments, foreclosures,
real estate owned, boats and airplanes owned, criminal convictions, address history, prior employers, sex offender registry, etc.
MVA For vehicles owned and driving record – Looking for
expensive vehicles, DUIs, suspended license, etc. (MD only)
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 9
Our Investigative Toolbox
EMAIL REVIEW (with employer or computer owner consent)
Once the list of suspects is narrowed down, review email for information concerning the event. Coordinate with IT shop to pull email. Use computer forensic expert to cull email down to manageable size using “key word” searches.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 10
Our Investigative Toolbox
COMPUTER HARD DRIVE/SHARED DRIVE REVIEW Only use credentialed computer forensic expert to extract
and recover deleted files and extract data using law enforcement approved protocols.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 11
Suggestions
Consult with us early in the case to:Assist counsel in formulating a strategy from an
investigative perspective.
Conduct due diligence investigations re: your new client, the adversarial parties, opposing counsel’s witnesses, your witnesses.
Assist with identifying relevant documents and people to be subpoenaed from an investigative perspective.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 12
Recent War Stories:
Civil fraud case – defendants used approximately 26 shell companies and 50 bank accounts. Our analysis identified multiple instances of embezzlement and money laundering. Also determined main defendant is a four- time convicted felon and served nine years in jail for similar schemes.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 13
Recent War Stories:
Plaintiff’s litigious history – wrongful termination suits, FCRA suits, topped off with a qui tam lawsuit against former employer. Plaintiff has brought over 30 actions over 10-year period, winning judgments in almost every case. Qui Tam was last straw for one employer.
Rick Potocek, CPA, MBA, CFE • [email protected] 14
Recent War Stories:
PNC Bank Wealth Management Employee 10-year trusted employee above reproach.
Bank Security identified $15K in unusual transactions in customer accounts to which employee admitted.
We were engaged to conduct a forensic accounting investigation and identified a total of approximately $400K embezzled from 86 customer accounts. Referred to FBI, defendant pled guilty, sentenced to two years in jail and restitution.
Rick Potocek, Forensic Accounting and Dispute Services Principal Email: [email protected] Telephone: (301) 951 – 9090Website: www.grfcpa.comVisit:
Connect with Us
4550 Montgomery Avenue, Suite 650N • Bethesda, MD 20814